Meaning and Relevance of History: College of Allied Health Sciences Batch 2024
Meaning and Relevance of History: College of Allied Health Sciences Batch 2024
COURSE OUTLINE
Additional notes
1. Meaning and Relevance of History -Every historian must strive at understanding the origins of
2. Content and Contextual Analysis
the sources and must also compare one source or
3. Teachings of the Katipunan of the Sons of the
People account with another.
4. Antonio Pigafetta. First Voyage Around the World -No historian is ever infallible but weighing all sources
5. Customs of the Tagalogs By Fray Juan de allows him to reach a conclusion that is true and objective.
Plasencia
6. Act of Declaration of Philippine Independence
7. A Glance at Selected Philippine Political INTRODUCTION: What are “History” and
Caricature in Alfred McCoy’s Philippine Cartoons: “Historical Sources”? By Louis Gottschalk
Political Caricature of the American Era
(1900-1941)
The Meaning of “History”
1 I MADE BY VIDAD
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY-ANDREWS CAMPUS
COLLEGE OF ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCES BATCH 2024
READINGS IN PHILIPPINE HISTORY
PROF. LORETA CADATAL
ADAPTED FROM: POWERPOINT/LECTURE
● HISTORY-AS-ACTUALITY
-Knowledge may be acquired, however, by an impartial o the whole history of the past
and judicially detached investigation of mental images,
processes, concepts, and precepts that are one or more ● HISTORY-AS-RECORD
steps removed from objective reality o can be known to him only through the
surviving record of it.
o is only the surviving part of the recorded
Artifacts as Sources of History part of the remembered part of the
observed past of that whole.
ARTIFACTS
2 I MADE BY VIDAD
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY-ANDREWS CAMPUS
COLLEGE OF ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCES BATCH 2024
READINGS IN PHILIPPINE HISTORY
PROF. LORETA CADATAL
ADAPTED FROM: POWERPOINT/LECTURE
o (2) that his own experience is both like and ● For the past conceived of as something that
unlike other men’s. It is not alone his own “actually occurred” places obvious limits upon the
memories interpreted in the light of his own kinds of record and of imagination that he may use.
experience that he must try to apply to the
understanding of historical survivals; it is the Imagination in Historiography
memories of many other people as well, but
one’s own memories are abstract images, not ● The historian is not permitted to imagine things that
realities, and one’s reconstructions of others’ could not reasonably have happened. He is
memories, even when reinforced by frequently required to imagine things that must have
contemporary records and relics, are likely to be happened.
even more abstract.
o For example, it is a platitude that the
historian who knows contemporary life
best will understand past life best.
Additional notes
-Historian’s aim is verisimilitude with regard to a perished
Additional notes
past – a subjective process – rather than experimental
-Unfortunately, no platitude tells how to acquire a wide
certainty with regard to objective reality.
range of those desirable qualities and knowledge or
how to transfer them to an understanding of the past.
-He tries to get as close an approximation to the truth
over a greater distance, it has a much thicker (more
about the past as constant correction of his mental images
muscular) wall.
will allow, at the same time recognizing that the truth has
in fact eluded him forever.
History of Historical Method
-history has only detached and scattered objects to study
(documents and relics) that do not together make up the ● For our purposes these methods will be considered
under four headings:
total object that the historian is studying – the past of
mankind – and that object, has largely disappeared, exists
3 I MADE BY VIDAD
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY-ANDREWS CAMPUS
COLLEGE OF ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCES BATCH 2024
READINGS IN PHILIPPINE HISTORY
PROF. LORETA CADATAL
ADAPTED FROM: POWERPOINT/LECTURE
-Where they are official records, he may have to search for Primary Particulars Rather than Whole Primary
them. Sources Sought
● Sources, in other words, whether primary or
-The more precise his delimitations of persons, area, time, secondary, are important to the historian
and function, the more relevant his sources are likely to be because they contain primary particulars (or at
least suggest leads to primary particulars).
The Distinction between Primary and Other
Original Sources o The particulars they furnish are
● PRIMARY SOURCE trustworthy not because of the book or
o is the testimony of an eyewitness, or of a article or report they are in, but because of
witness by any other of the senses, or of a the reliability of the narrator as a witness of
mechanical device like the dictaphone – those particulars
that is, of one who or that which was
present at the events of which he or it tells ● THE DOCUMENT
(called simply eyewitness). o The word document (from docere, to
o It must thus have been produced by a teach) used to mean a written source of
contemporary of the events it narrates. historical information as contrasted with
oral testimony or with artifacts, pictorial
● SECONDARY SOURCE survivals, and archeological remains.
o is the testimony of anyone who is not an o It is sometimes reserved for only official
eyewitness – that is, of one who was not and state papers such as treatises, laws,
present at the events of which he tells. grants, deeds, etc.
4 I MADE BY VIDAD
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY-ANDREWS CAMPUS
COLLEGE OF ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCES BATCH 2024
READINGS IN PHILIPPINE HISTORY
PROF. LORETA CADATAL
ADAPTED FROM: POWERPOINT/LECTURE
-To both sociologists and psychologists it is the degree of PROBLEM 1: Forged or Misleading Documents
subjectivity in these documents that distinguishes them ● “Historical documents” are fabricated for several
reasons:
from other documents.
o Sometimes they are used to bolster a false
claim or title.
-To the historian the difference between first-person and
third-person documents is not of major significance. That o Sometimes fabrication is due to less
is true for at least three reasons: mercenary considerations.
(1) Often an apparently third-person document is in fact o Sometimes quite genuine documents are
first-person intended to mislead certain
contemporaries and hence have misled
(2) Genuinely third-person documents in so far as they are subsequent historians.
“historicable” must ultimately rest on first-hand observation
o Occasionally misrepresentations of the
(whether by the author or by someone consulted by the nature of printed works result from the
author). editor’s tricks.
(3) Every document, no matter how thoroughly the author o The circumstances of the forgery or
misrepresentation of historical documents
strove to be impartial and detached, must exhibit to a
may often themselves reveal important
greater or lesser extent the author’s philosophies and political, cultural, and biographical
emphases, likes and dislikes, and hence betrays the information – but not about the same
author’s inner personality. events or persons as if they were genuine.
5 I MADE BY VIDAD
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY-ANDREWS CAMPUS
COLLEGE OF ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCES BATCH 2024
READINGS IN PHILIPPINE HISTORY
PROF. LORETA CADATAL
ADAPTED FROM: POWERPOINT/LECTURE
● Seals have been the subject of special study by ● If the members of the same family are largely
sigillographers, and experts can detect faked copied from each other, as this arrangement in
ones. families frequently shows, the oldest one in all
probability (but not necessarily) the one nearest the
● Anachronistic style (idiom, orthography, or original.
punctuation) can be detected by specialists who are
familiar with contemporary writing (e.g. wrong ● When the copy nearest the original in each family is
spelling, signatures, proper names). discovered, a comparison of all of these “father”
copies will usually then reveal words and passages
PROBLEM 3: Garbled Documents that are in some but not in others
● A document that in its entirety or in large part is
the result of a deliberate effort to deceive may PROBLEM 5: Identification of Author and of Date
often be hard to evaluate. ● Some guess of the approximate date of the
o not of studied falsehood, but of document and some identification of its supposed
unintentional error. author
● To answer that question it is necessary to divide the o Putting the hypothesis in interrogative
available copies into one or more “families” – that is, form is more judicious than putting it in
groups of texts which closely resemble each other declarative form
and therefore seem to be derived, directly or
indirectly, from the same master copy. PROBLEM 3: The Quest for Particular Details of
Testimony
● Then by a comparison of the texts within each ● Every historical subject has four aspects – the
family, an effort is made to establish the biographical, the geographical, the
comparative age of each in relation to the others. chronological, and the occupational or functional.
6 I MADE BY VIDAD
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY-ANDREWS CAMPUS
COLLEGE OF ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCES BATCH 2024
READINGS IN PHILIPPINE HISTORY
PROF. LORETA CADATAL
ADAPTED FROM: POWERPOINT/LECTURE
7 I MADE BY VIDAD
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY-ANDREWS CAMPUS
COLLEGE OF ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCES BATCH 2024
READINGS IN PHILIPPINE HISTORY
PROF. LORETA CADATAL
ADAPTED FROM: POWERPOINT/LECTURE
Teachings of the Katipunan of the (An intelligent man is he who takes care in everything he
says and keeps quiet about what must be kept secret.)
Sons of the People 10. Sa daang matinik ng kabuhayan, lalaki ay siyang
patnugot ng asawa’t mga anak; kung ang umaakay ay tungo
UNIT 3 sa sama, ang patutunguhan ng iaakay ay kasamaan din.
1.Ang kabuhayang hindi ginugugol sa isang malaki at banal (Along the thorny path of life, the man leads the way and his
na kadahilanan ay kahoy na walang lilim, kundi damong wife and children follow. If the leader goes the way of
makamandag. perdition, then so do those who are led.)
(A life that is not dedicated to a great and sacred cause is 11. Ang babae ay huag mong tignang isang bagay na
like a tree without a shade, or a poisonous weed.) libangan lamang, kundi isang katuang at karamay sa mga
2. Ang gawang magaling na nagbubuhat sa pagpipita sa kahirapan nitong kabuhayan; gamitan mo ng buong
sarili, at hindi sa talagang nasang gumawa ng kagalingan, ay pagpipitagan ang kaniyang kahinaan, at alalahanin ang
di kabaitan. inang pinagbuhata’t nagiwi sa iyong kasangulan.
(A good deed lacks virtue if it springs from a desire for (Do not regard a woman as a mere plaything, but as
personal profit and not from a sincere desire to do good.) helpmate and partner in the hardships of this existence.
Have due regard to her weakness, and remember the
3. Ang tunay na kabanalan ay ang pagkakawang gawa, ang mother who brought you into this world and nurtured you in
pagibig sa kapua at ang isukat ang bawat kilos, gawa’t your infancy.)
pangungusap sa talagang Katuiran
12. Ang di mo ibig na gawin sa asawa mo, anak at kapatid,
(True charity resides in acts of compulsion, in love for one’s ay huag mong gagawin sa asawa, anak, at kapatid ng iba.
fellow men, and in making true Reason the measure of every
move, deed, and word.) (What you would not want done to your wife, daughter, and
sister, do not do to the wife, daughter, and sister of another.)
4. Maitim man at maputi ang kulay ng balat, lahat ng tao’y
magkakapantay; mangyayaring ang isa’y higtan sa dunong, 13. Ang kamahalan ng tao’y wala sa pagkahari, wala sa
sa yaman, sa ganda…; ngunit di mahihigtan sa pagkatao. tangus ng ilong at puti ng mukha, wala sa pagkaparing
kahalili ng Dios wala sa mataas na kalagayan sa balat ng
(Be their skin dark or pale, all men are equal. One can be lupa; wagas at tunay na mahal na tao, kahit laking gubat at
superior to another in knowledge, wealth, and beauty... but walang nababatid kundi ang sariling wika, yaong may
not in being.) magandang asal, may isang pangungusap, may dangal at
puri; yaong di napaaapi’t di nakikiapi; yaong marunong
5. Ang may mataas na kalooban inuuna ang puri sa magdamdam at marunong lumingap sa bayang tinubuan.
pagpipita sa sarili; ang may hamak na kalooban inuuna ang
pagpipita sa sarili sa puri. (A man’s worth does not come from him being a king, or in
the height of his nose and the whiteness of his fac, or in him
(A person with a noble character values honor aboce being priest, a REPRESENTATIVE OF GOD, or his exalted
self-interest, while a person with an ignoble character values position on the face of this earth. Pure and truly noble is he
self-interest above honor.) who, though born in the forest and able to speak only his
own tongue, behaves decently, is true to his word, has
6. Sa taong may hiya, salita’y panunumpa dignity and honor, who is not an oppressor and does not abet
oppressors, who knows how to cherish and look after the
(An honorable man’s word is his bond.) land of his birth.)
7.Huwag mong sasayangin ang panahun; ang yamang 14. Paglaganap ng mga aral na ito at maningning na sumikat
nawala’y magyayaring magbalik; nguni’t panahong nagdaan ang araw ng mahal na Kalayaan dito sa kaabaabang
na’y di na muli pang magdadaan. Sangkalupuan, at sabugan ng matamis niyang liwanag ang
nangagkaisang magkalahi’t magkakapatid ng ligaya ng
(Don’t waste time; lost wealth may be recovered, but time walang katapusan, ang mga ginugol na buhay, pagud, at
lost is lost forever.) mga tiniis na kahirapa’y labis nang natumbasan. Kung lahat
ng ito’y mataruk na ng nagiibig pumasuk at inaakala niyang
8. Ipagtanggol mo ang inaapi, at kabakahin ang umaapi. matutupad ang mga tutungkulin, maitatala ang kaniyang
ninanasa sa kasunod nito.
(Defend the oppressed and fight the oppressor.)
(When these doctrines have spread and the brilliant sun of
9. Ang taong matalino’y ang may pagiingat sa bawat beloved liberty shines on these poor Islands, and sheds its
sasabihin, at matutong ipaglihim ang dapat ipaglihim. sweet light upon a united race, a people in everlasting
happiness, then the lives lost, the struggle and the suffering
will have been more than recompensed.)
8 I MADE BY VIDAD
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY-ANDREWS CAMPUS
COLLEGE OF ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCES BATCH 2024
READINGS IN PHILIPPINE HISTORY
PROF. LORETA CADATAL
ADAPTED FROM: POWERPOINT/LECTURE
● The numerous economic benefits it gave to About the book: The First Voyage around the world
Portugal made other monarchs envious and
prompted them to search for a new trade route to
Asia. Take Note:
● This led to the discovery of many territories ● Pigafetta kept a detailed journal of what happened
previously unknown to the Europeans, through to them from the time they left Seville in 1519 until
inhabited already and known to other races. they returned to Spain three years after.
● The marriage of Queen Isabella of Castile and King ● When he returned to Italy, many of his associates
Ferdinand II of Aragon (1469) couple resulted in asked him to write a formal account of the Magellan
the rise of Spain as a world power. expedition and have it published.
● Spain started to explore their economic options ● He presented his draft to Pope Clement VII,
outside the Iberian Peninsula. Philippe de Villiers L’Isle-Adam (grandmaster of the
Knights of Rodes) and to Lious of Savoy (mother of
● Inspired by the success of Portugal, they aspired to King Francis I of France), hoping that they would
have a fair share in the spice trade. They financed help him finance its publication.
the trans-Atlantic voyages of Christopher Columbus
(1942 to 1502) which resulted to the discovery of ● Unfortunately, he was unable to find a financier
the territories on the other side of the Atlantic who would pay the deposit required by the
Ocean. printer because by that time, the accounts of
Maximillianus Transylvanus and Peter Martyr were
● Decades later, the Spanish monarch also already out and interest on the Magellan expedition
supported the plan of Ferdinand Magellan to go had died down.
to the East by sailing westward, a proposal that
Portugal refused to finance.
9 I MADE BY VIDAD
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY-ANDREWS CAMPUS
COLLEGE OF ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCES BATCH 2024
READINGS IN PHILIPPINE HISTORY
PROF. LORETA CADATAL
ADAPTED FROM: POWERPOINT/LECTURE
● Three of them were in French and two were kept in -In Pigafetta’s account, their fleet reached what we called
Bibliotheque Nationale in Paris. the Ladrones Islands or the “Islands of the Thieves.” He
recounted “These people have no arms, but use sticks,
● The third one was originally owned by British
which have a fish boneat the end. They are poor, but
collector Sir Thomas Phillipps.
ingenious and great thieves, and for the sake of that we
● The fourth copy was written in mixed Italian, called these three islands the Ladrones Islands.”
Spanish, and Venetian languages and could be
found in the Ambrosian Library in Milan. -Ladrones island is presently known as the Marianas
● In 1800, Carlo Amoretti published an Italian Islands.
version and the following year a French version
came out in Paris.
Events happened in Ladrones Islands
● An English version was published in 1819.
10 I MADE BY VIDAD
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY-ANDREWS CAMPUS
COLLEGE OF ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCES BATCH 2024
READINGS IN PHILIPPINE HISTORY
PROF. LORETA CADATAL
ADAPTED FROM: POWERPOINT/LECTURE
-They went to this island and Pigafetta reported that they Additional notes
saw mines of gold
-Magellan spoke before the people of Cebu about peace
and God. Pigafetta reported that the people took pleasure
-Pigafetta described this king as the most handsome
on Magellan’s speech.
of all the men that he saw in this place.
-Pigafetta also related how the people talked about, how at
-This king was named Raia Calambu, king of Zuluan old age, parents were no longer taken into account and
and Calagan (Butuan and Caragua), and the first king had to follow orders from their children as the new leaders
of the land. Magellan responded to this by saying that his
was Raia Siagu. faith entailed children to render honor and obedience to
their parents.
11 I MADE BY VIDAD
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY-ANDREWS CAMPUS
COLLEGE OF ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCES BATCH 2024
READINGS IN PHILIPPINE HISTORY
PROF. LORETA CADATAL
ADAPTED FROM: POWERPOINT/LECTURE
● Magellan reiterated that all of the newly baptized ● The natives had slain all of the men except the
Christians need to burn their idols but the native interpreter and Juan Serrano who was already
gave excuses telling Magellan that they needed the wounded.
idols to heal a sick man who was relative to the
king. ● The fleet abandoned Serrano. They left Cebu and
continued their journey around the world.
● They went to the sick man and baptized him. After
the baptismal, Pigafetta recorded that the man was ANALYSIS OF PIGAFETTA’S CHRONICLE
able to speak again. He called this a miracle. ● The chronicle of Pigafetta was one of the most
cited documents by historians who wished to
● April 26- Zula, a principal man from the island of study the precolonial Philippine.
Matan (Mactan) went out to see Magellan and
asked him for a boat full of men so that he would be ● Pigafetta was seen as a credible source for the
able to fight the chief named SIlapulapu (Lapulapu). period, which was prior unchronicled and
● Magellan offered three boats instead and expressed undocumented.
his desire to go to Mactan himself to fight the said ● Pigafetta’s writings account for the “purest”
chief. precolonial society.
● They numbered 49 in total and the islanders of ● The reader needs to understand that he was a
Mactan were estimated to number 1,500. The battle chronicler commissioned by the King of Spain to
began. accompany and document a voyage intended to
expand the Spain empire.
● Magellan died in that battle.
● Pigafettas’s attributes influenced his narrative, his
Additional notes selection of details to be included in the text, his
characterization of the people and of the species
that he encountered, and his interpretation and
-Magellan was pierced with a poisoned arrow in his right retelling of the events. Being a scholar of
leg. cartography and geography,
-Seeing that the captain has already deteriorated, more ● Pigafetta was able to give details on geography and
natives came to attack him climate of the spices that their voyage had reached.
-Pigafetta also said that the king of Cebu who has baptized ● In reading Pigafetta’s description of the people, one
could have sent help but Magellan instructed him not to has to keep in mind that he was coming from the
join the battle and stay in the balangay so that he would sixteenth century European perspective. Hence, the
see how they fought. reader might notice from a sixteenth century
European perspective.
12 I MADE BY VIDAD
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY-ANDREWS CAMPUS
COLLEGE OF ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCES BATCH 2024
READINGS IN PHILIPPINE HISTORY
PROF. LORETA CADATAL
ADAPTED FROM: POWERPOINT/LECTURE
2. Credit must be 2. Source of historical ● Hence, the friars ended up performing the
given to Magellan information about the administrative duties of colonial officials.
expedition for proving beginning of
that the world is not Christianity in the ● The friars became the most knowledgeable and
flat but an oblate Philippines, the First influential figure in the pueblo.
sphere and they Mass and the
demolished the myth conversion of Rajah ● Plasencia’s Relacion de las Costumbres de Los
that there is boiling Humabon and his wife Tagalogs (Customs of the Tagalogs, 1589)- is an
water at the equator. and the story of the example of this kind of work.
image of the Sto. Nino. o It contains numerous information that
historians could use in reconstructing the
3. Magellan and his 3. Numerous accounts political and socio-cultural history of the
men completed the about the Filipinos Tagalog region.
circumnavigation of when they met the
the world. Spaniards. Some o -His work is a primary source because he
Filipinos were easily personally witnessed the events and his
befriended while account contained his observations.
others refused to
interact and trade with Additional notes
them.
5. They brought to the -His continuous interaction with the people he converted
attention of the to Christianity enables him to write a work titled Reacion
13 I MADE BY VIDAD
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY-ANDREWS CAMPUS
COLLEGE OF ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCES BATCH 2024
READINGS IN PHILIPPINE HISTORY
PROF. LORETA CADATAL
ADAPTED FROM: POWERPOINT/LECTURE
MODE OF DRESSING
RELEVANCE ● IN MALE
● It covers numerous topics that are relevant in may o Headgear is called Putong (symbolizes
disciplines such as politics. It contains information the number of persons the wearer had
about the social classes, political stratifications and killed)
legal system of the Tagalog region. o (Upper) a jacket with short sleeves called
kanggan.
● It preserves and popularizes the unwritten customs, o (Lower) bahag
traditions and religious and superstitious of the
Filipinos. ● IN FEMALE
o (Upper) Baro or Camisa
● His writings about the Customs of the Tagalogs o (Lower) Saya
helped the priests and missionaries to become
effective evangelizers. GOVERNMENT
● The unit of government is called BARANGAY ruled
● Disprove the claim of some Spaniards that when by a chieftain, and consist of 30 to 100 families
they arrived in the Philippines, Filipinos were still together with their relatives and slaves
uncivilized and lacking in culture. According to
Plasencia, Filipinos were already politically and ● Administration of justice
economically organized. They had a functioning o The chieftain’s executive function includes
government, tax system, set of laws, criminal justice implementing laws, ensuring order and
system, indigenous calendar and long-standing giving protection to his subject.
customs and traditions. They had concept of
Supreme Being (Bathala), practiced burial customs o Disputes between individuals were settled
and believed in life after death. Lastly, the people he by a court made up of the chieftain and
met were wearing garments and gold ornaments council of elders.
and their houses were decorated with idols.
INHERITANCE
Las Costumbres de los Indios Tagalos de Filipinas ● The 1st son of the barangay chieftain inherits his
By Juan de Plasencia father’s position; if the 1st son dies, the 2nd son
succeeds their father; in the absence of male heirs,
SOCIAL CLASS it is the eldest daughter that becomes the chieftain.
● Chieftain (Datu)
o chief, captain of wars, whom governed, MARRIAGE CUSTOMS
obeyed and reverenced ● Men were in general, monogamous; while their
wives are called Asawa.
● Nobles (Maharlika)
o Free-born, they do not pay taxes. ● Courtship begins with Paninilbihan
● Commoners (Aliping Namamahay) ● Prior to marriage the man requires to give a dowry:
o They live in their own houses and lords of o Bigay- kaya (a piece of land or gold);
their property and gold
14 I MADE BY VIDAD
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY-ANDREWS CAMPUS
COLLEGE OF ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCES BATCH 2024
READINGS IN PHILIPPINE HISTORY
PROF. LORETA CADATAL
ADAPTED FROM: POWERPOINT/LECTURE
o Panghihimuyat (a gift for the brides o They used tap trees as ink and pointed
parents); stick as pencil.
o Bigay-suso (for brides wet nurse).
● Marriage between couples belonging to different o They wrote on large plant leaves, bark of a
social classes were not common. tree or bamboo tubes
15 I MADE BY VIDAD
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY-ANDREWS CAMPUS
COLLEGE OF ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCES BATCH 2024
READINGS IN PHILIPPINE HISTORY
PROF. LORETA CADATAL
ADAPTED FROM: POWERPOINT/LECTURE
-born on December 17, 1830 in Biñan, Laguna ● Later research by historian=writer Jim Richardson
placed the total number of the signees at 177.
-Parents: Gregorio Enriquez Bautista and Silvestra
Altamira. Analysis of the “Declaration of Philippine
Independence”
-He studied Law at the University of Sto. Tomas and ● A re-examination of the document on the
earned his degree in 1865 (at 35 years old). declaration of independence can reveal some often
overlooked historical truths about this important
-He solicited funds to finance the campaign for reforms in event in Philippine history.
the Philippines and became member of the La Liga
● The document reflects the general revolutionary
Filipina, Cuerpode Compromisarios, and La Propaganda. sentiment of that period. (e.g. the abuses
specifically mentioned in the proclamation like friar
-He was arrested and imprisoned in Fort Santiago by the abuse, racial discrimination, and inequality before
Spaniards as he was suspected of being involved in the the law reflect the most compelling sentiments
represented by revolutionary leadership.)
Philippine Revolution but managed to defend himself and
was eventually released. ● no mention was made about the more serious
problem that affected the masses more profoundly
-He became the first adviser of President Emilio Aguinaldo (e.g., the land and agrarian crisis felt by the
in 1898 numerous Filipino peasants in the 19th century)
16 I MADE BY VIDAD
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY-ANDREWS CAMPUS
COLLEGE OF ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCES BATCH 2024
READINGS IN PHILIPPINE HISTORY
PROF. LORETA CADATAL
ADAPTED FROM: POWERPOINT/LECTURE
Buencamino, or were intentionally left out because ● However, the transition to the American colonial
they were landholders themselves. period provided leeway in the publication of
independent newspapers. Initially, newspapers
● The proclamation also gives us the impression on were scrutinized by the government to ensure that
how the victorious revolutionary government of they did not contain anti-American sentiments which
Aguinaldo historicized the struggle for were branded as subversive and were confiscated.
independence.
● However, the Katipunan as the pioneer of the ● The four decades of the American colonial rule
revolutionary movement was only mentioned once became a formative period in Philippine history.
toward the end of the document.
● Censorship was loosened when a civil government
● There was no mention of the Katipunans was established in 1901.
foundation.
● This gave the Filipinos the right to published without
● Bonifacio and his co-founders were also left out. prior censorship of the government.
● It can be argued, thus, that the way of historical ● After censorship was removed, Rafael Palma
narration found in the document also reflects the launched El Renacimiento (Rebirth) which became
politics of the victors. the most influential of the early nationalist
newspapers campaigning for the right to free press.
● The point is even official records and documents
like the proclamation of independence, while truthful ● Whenever the Americans left offended with any
most of the time, still exudes the politics and biases publication, they used libel and sedition laws to
of whoever is in power. This manifests in the obstruct the developing hostilities.
selectiveness of the information that can be found in
these records. ● After facing two libel suits, El Renacimiento had to
discontinue.
● It is the task of the historian, thus, to analyze the
content of these documents in relation to the ABOUT THE AUTHOR
dominant politics and the contexts of the people and Alfred McCoy
the institutions surrounding it.
● born on June 8, 1945 in Massachusetts USA.
● This tells us a lesson on taking primary sources like
official government records within the ● He earned hi BA in European Studies from
circumstances of this production. Columbia College in 1968
● Studying one historical subject, thus, entails looking ● He studied Philippine political caricatures to
at multi primary sources and pieces of historical understand the social and political context of the
evidences in order to have a more nuanced and Philippines during American period and later
contextual analysis of our past. worked with Alfredo Roces, his co-author of
Philippine Cartoons: Political Caricatures of the
A GLANCE AT SELECTED PHILIPPINE American Era.
POLITICAL CARICATURE IN ALFRED ● Though McCoy did not create any political
caricatures, his interest in them urged him to
MCCOY’S PHILIPPINE CARTOONS: compile such caricatures from various sources to
produce a single collection.
POLITICAL CARICATURE OF THE
AMERICAN ERA (1900-1941) Alfredo Reyes Roces
17 I MADE BY VIDAD
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY-ANDREWS CAMPUS
COLLEGE OF ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCES BATCH 2024
READINGS IN PHILIPPINE HISTORY
PROF. LORETA CADATAL
ADAPTED FROM: POWERPOINT/LECTURE
ABOUT THE TEXT huge warehouses containing bulks of rice, milk and
grocery products.
● Political cartoons and caricature are rather recent
art form, which veered away from the classical art
by exaggerating human features and poking fun as
its subjects.
LIST OF CARICATURES
● The first example shown above was published in
The Independent on May 20, 1916.
● The cartoon shows a politician from Tondo , named
Dr. Santos, passing his crown to his brother-in-law,
Dr. Barcelona. A Filipino guy (as depicted wearing
salakot and barong tagalog) was trying to stop
Santos, telling the latter to stop giving Barcelona the
crown because it is not his to begin with.
18 I MADE BY VIDAD
CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY-ANDREWS CAMPUS
COLLEGE OF ALLIED HEALTH SCIENCES BATCH 2024
READINGS IN PHILIPPINE HISTORY
PROF. LORETA CADATAL
ADAPTED FROM: POWERPOINT/LECTURE
● The next cartoon was published by The ● One example is the unprecedented increase of
Independent on November 27, 1915. motorized vehicles in the city. Automobiles became
● Here, we see the caricature of Uncle Sam riding a popular mode of transportation in the city and led
chariot pulled by Filipinos wearing school uniforms. the emergence of taxis. However, laws and policy of
The Filipino boys were carrying American objects implementation was mediocre. This resulted in the
like baseball bats, whiskey and boxing gloves. increasing colorum and unlicensed vehicles
McCoy, in his caption to the said cartoon, says that transporting people around the city.
this cartoon was based on an event in 1907 when
William Howard Taft was brought to the Manila pier ● Another sample is what McCoy called the “sexual
riding a chariot pulled by students of Liceo de revolution” that occurred in the 1930s. Young
Manila. Such was condemned by the nationalist at people, as early as that period disturbed
that time. conservative Filipino mindset by engaging in daring
sexual activities in public places like cinemas. Here,
we can see how that period was the meeting point
between the conservative past and the liberated
future of the Philippines.
19 I MADE BY VIDAD