Whistleblowing Program IIA
Whistleblowing Program IIA
White paper
Whistleblowing
Programs
Updated 2020
Level 7, 133 Castlereagh Street, Sydney NSW 2000 | PO Box A2311, Sydney South NSW 1235
T +61 2 9267 9155 F +61 2 9264 9240 E [email protected] www.iia.org.au
Whistleblowing Programs
› Empowering employees by giving them a path to disclose The various state and commonwealth acts make a serious
wrongdoing. attempt to address integrity and accountability in the public
sector in their respective jurisdictions, with the primary
› Protecting and enhancing an organisation’s reputation objective being the provision of safe means to make
which can be irrevocably damaged by a whistleblowing disclosures and protect whistleblowers. However, they are not
issue covered by the media. without their shortcomings. Critics note that:
› Positively impacting on organisation culture – › Reportable wrongdoing is ill-defined and differs between
whistleblowing calls out poor culture and practices and jurisdictions.
offers an improvement opportunity.
› Anonymous complaints are not always protected.
Whistleblowing can also help meet an organisation’s
workplace safety and legal obligations to employees. Left › It is not clear who will be protected and how.
unchecked, misconduct or wrongdoing may in some cases › Obligations on organisations differs and is unclear.
compromise and endanger wellbeing of employees.
› Absence of an oversight agency responsible for
Most people want misconduct exposed and addressed, but whistleblower protection.
not everyone feels safe reporting it. Most people will only
do so if they can feel safe from reprisals. A well-constructed
for an entity to enable its whistleblower protection officer and In addition to the release of RG 270, ASIC granted relief to
whistleblower investigation officer (or equivalent), to exercise public companies that are not‑for‑profits or charities with
independent judgement and have a mechanism through which annual revenue of less than $1 million from the requirement
they can escalate problems directly to the entity’s board.” to have a whistleblower policy. All companies are however
bound by the whistleblower protections in the Corporations
c. Upfront and ongoing education and training
Act from 1 July 2019, regardless of whether they are required
ASIC Good practice tip 15 says “Demonstrate the entity’s to have a whistleblower policy.
commitment to the policy by promoting it actively and
regularly. We encourage an entity’s management to actively Roles and Responsibilities
and regularly promote the entity’s whistleblower policy. This Role of internal auditors
may help demonstrate the entity’s commitment to protect and
support disclosers, and to identify and address wrongdoing Internal auditors are now ‘eligible recipients’ under the
promptly.” Under RG 270.131 ASIC says “An entity should Corporations Act and whistleblowers may disclose a
conduct upfront and ongoing education and training regarding whistleblower matter to an internal auditor or external auditor,
its whistleblower policy, processes and procedures. The including a member of an audit team conducting an audit. As
training should be provided to every employee.” a result, internal auditors need to understand their obligations
when receiving a whistleblowing disclosure to ensure they do
ASIC also outlines specific topics that should be covered in not breach personal or corporate obligations.
training for all staff, and those with specific roles under the
whistleblower policy. Internal auditors have two clear roles they can play. One is
optional and the other is not.
d. Ensuring the privacy and security of personal information
One imposes a legal obligation to receive disclosures made
Under RG 270.147 ASIC says “It is good practice for an entity to them under the law. This role is not optional. Auditors must,
to have appropriate information technology resources and in the first instance, receive a disclosure if it is made to them
organisational measures for securing the personal information while performing an audit for a client, whether it be made
they receive, handle and record as part of their whistleblower openly or anonymously.
policy. Due to the sensitivity of the information, any leaks
or unauthorised disclosure (including from malicious cyber The reason is simple; the law appoints auditors as eligible
activity) may have adverse consequences for the disclosers, recipients or persons to whom a disclosure may be made. The
the individuals who are the subject of disclosures and the law does not require auditors to carry out a role beyond that
entity. It is important for the entity to consult the Australian unless they wish or are required by the organisation to do
Privacy Principles and other relevant industry, government and so. They merely have to ensure the disclosure made to and
technology-specific standards, guidance and frameworks on received by them is forwarded to a person legally authorised
data security to help safeguard their information.” to deal with the disclosure in accordance with the legislation.
Auditors must however receive the whistlelbower’s consent
e. Monitoring and reporting effectiveness of the policy to forward on a report to the next appropriate person at the
Under RG 270.150 ASIC says “It is important for an entity to organisation. If the auditor does not receive consent from the
have mechanisms in place for monitoring the effectiveness of whistleblower they may face criminal and civil penalties.
its whistleblower policy and ensuring compliance with its legal To comply with this and any other extended obligation
obligations. It is good practice for an entity to provide periodic imposed on them, auditors need to receive a sufficient level of
reports to the entity’s board or the audit or risk committee. training.
An entity could also monitor and measure its employees’
understanding of the entity’s whistleblower policy, processes Another role which auditors are best placed to deliver is that
and procedures on a periodic basis. This may help the entity of ‘auditing’ the organisation’s whistleblowing framework to
to determine where there are gaps in their employees’ check for and ensure compliance with the law.
understanding. It may also help the entity to enhance and This role is optional. Miss this opportunity and the organisation
improve its ongoing education, training and communication misses the benefit of the sharp mind of auditors attuned to
about the policy.” compliance.
f. Reviewing and updating the policy The law is more than substantially prescriptive. Hefty
Under RG 270.158 ASIC says “It is good practice for an entity penalties, including jail, may follow non-compliance with this
to review its whistleblower policy, processes and procedures new and technical whistleblowing framework. An audit (the
on a periodic basis (e.g. every two years). It is also good new law calls it a review) of past disclosures offers assurance
practice to rectify any issues identified in the review in a timely of compliance, an opportunity to detect breaches, and for the
manner.” audit to make recommendations for improvement.
An audit should examine procedures concerning such as: › Making an immediate assessment of the welfare and
protection needs of a whistleblower
› Receipt of disclosures.
› Remaining alert to any intimidation or detrimental acts of
› Acknowledging and recording disclosures.
omissions and taking appropriate action if need be
› Secure storage of information and communications.
› Informing the whistleblower how the organisation will
› Confidential and private communications. deal with intimidation, victimisation or detrimental action.
› Authorisation and accessibility of information. Among other things a whistleblower protection officer needs
to be:
› Legal processes carried out within required timeframe.
› Trustworthy.
Who more capable than an auditor to monitor and assure
effectiveness of an organisation’s whistleblower policy and › Impartial (independent from the allegations raised in the
framework for legal compliance. whistleblower’s report).
Internal auditors also have a role in supporting a successful › Capable of building rapport and confidence with others.
whistleblowing program, including:
› Discreet.
› Providing independent and objective monitoring and
› Capable of addressing concerns or reports of intimidation
testing.
or victimisation.
› Providing assurance to the board of directors and
A whistleblower protection officer should be given direct
management the program meets good practice.
access to human resources and legal advisors. Where
› Conducting risk assessments. necessary in serious matters, they should have direct access
to the audit committee, chief executive officer or other senior
› Establishing internal controls to mitigate risks.
executive.
› Triaging significant issues with the benefit of their
Role of investigator
thoughts and suggestions.
Disclosures that qualify for protection are usually investigated
› In some cases, receiving disclosures.
to determine whether the disclosure is proven or not, and
› Liaising with the risk management team. accordingly decide an appropriate response.
› Understanding and interpreting misconduct trends. An investigation should be carried out by an investigator
appointed under the whistleblower policy and in the manner
› Providing regular reports to the board of directors.
set out in the policy; by law the policy must outline key steps
Role of whistleblower protection officer of the investigation process.
Whistleblowers often need support and protection in what can To be sure, the investigator should, in the first instance, satisfy
be a traumatic and confronting experience. themselves the ‘disclosure’ qualifies as a protected disclosure
as a pre-requisite to the investigation.
A whistleblower protection officer is appointed by an
organisation for that purpose; to support and protect a In accordance with good practice tips provided by ASIC, an
whistleblower, if necessary, from detrimental action. A person investigation should focus on the substance, rather than the
from within or external to the organisation may be appointed. motive, of disclosures and ensure the investigation follows
good practice and good governance. The investigator must
This role should enlighten the whistleblower of critical ensure confidentiality requirements under the Corporations
information contained in the organisation whistleblower policy Act are met during the investigation or they may face criminal
about the protections available to them, including protections and civil penalties.
under the Corporations Act.
The organisation should provide an avenue for review of the
They play a critical role in: investigation should a party to the disclosure challenge the
› Making the whistleblower aware of support and findings.
protection available including identity protection Role of employees
(anonymity and confidentiality) if they have asked to
remain anonymous. Employees are key players in a whistleblowing program, with
a key role to:
› Fostering a supportive work environment.
› Keep on the alert for misconduct.