Optimization of Grinding Parameters for Minimum Surface Roughness by

Taguchi Parametric Optimization Technique
 
Deepak Pal, Ajay Bangar, Rajan Sharma, Ashish Yadav

Student of M.E. (PIS), Mechanical Engineering, Maharana Pratap College of Technology,

Gwalior, Madhya Pradesh, India.
E-mail: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected]

___________________________________________________________________________________________________

ABSTRACT

Cylindrical grinding is one of the important metal cutting processes used extensively in the finishing operations. Surface
finish is the important output responses in the production with respect to quantity and quality respectively. The
Experiments are conducted on universal tool and cutter grinding machine with L9 Orthogonal array with input
machining variables as work speed, grinding wheel grades and hardness of material. The developed model can be used by
the different manufacturing firms to select right combination of machining parameters to achieve an optimal surface
roughness (Ra).The results reveals surface roughness (Ra).The predicted optimal values for Ra for Cylindrical grinding
process is 1.07 Ra respectively. The results are further confirmed by conducting confirmation experiments.
Key worlds - Grinding, Taguchi, hardness Roughness, S/N ratio, Regression

_______________________________________________________________________________________

1. Introduction engineering knowledge. In parameter design,

Cylindrical grinding is an essential process for final independent process parameter values will be
machining of components requiring smooth surfaces optimized and where as in tolerance design,
and precise tolerances. As compared with other tolerances will be determined and analysed for
machining processes, Grindings costly operation that optimal values set by parameter design. Taguchi
should be utilized under optimal conditions. Although method is a powerful design of experiments (DOE)
widely used in industry, grinding remains perhaps the tool for optimization of engineering processes.
least understood of all machining processes.

The present paper takes the following input processes

parameters namely material hardness, work piece
speed and grinding wheel grain’s . The main
objective of this paper is to show how our knowledge
on grinding process can be utilized to predict the
grinding behavior and achieve optimal operating
processes parameters. The knowledge is mainly in the
form of physical and empirical models which
describe various aspects of grinding process. The
main objective in any machining process is to
minimize the surface roughness (Ra).In order to
optimize these values taguchi method, is used.

Figure 1 Steps of taguchi method

2. Taguchi Method
3. Experimental Setup and Cutting Conditions
Taguchi method is the process of engineering
3.1 Work piece material
optimization in a three step approach namely system
The work piece material selected for investigation is
design, parameter design and tolerance design. In the
EN 24, EN31 and Die steel. This steel can be
system design, a basic functional prototype design
hardened and tempered to provide a greater strength
will be produced by applying scientific and
____________________________________________________________________________________________________

International Journal of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering (IJMIE), ISSN No. 2231 –6477, Volume-1, Issue-3, 2012
74
 Optimization of Grinding Parameters for Minimum Surface Roughness by Taguchi Parametric Optimization Technique
__________________________________________________________________________________ 

and wear resistance in comparison of low carbon steels. The work piece used for experiment
is round bar with 30 mm diameter and 75 mm length. for the present work is the aluminum oxide abrasive
with verified bond with constant speed of 2850 RPM.
3.2 Machining Process The jobs have undergone turning and hardening
The cutting tests were performed on universal tool processes before grinding. Hardening is done for
and cutter grinding machine and Aluminum oxide better output response and the HRC is maintained. 
white grinding wheel. The experiments were  
conducted as per the orthogonal array and roughness Table3.3 consolidated design of experiment table
for various combinations of parameters was measured Experiment Combination Output
using Deviate DH 5 tester. of input Response
factors (Roughness)
3.3 Plan of Experiment 1 H1W1G1 2.20
The experiment was planned using Taguchi’s
2 H1W2G2 1.65
orthogonal array in the design of experiments, which
help in reducing the number of experiments. The L9 3 H1W3G3 1.10
orthogonal array. 
4 H2W1G3 1.59
Table3.1 parameters and their levels for experiment
5 H2W2G1 1.90
Level Material Workpiece Grinding
6 H2W3G2 1.07
hardness speed wheel
(HRC) (r.p.m) (grains) 7 H3W1G2 1.31
H W G
8 H3W2G3 1.46
1 50 100 G46
9 H3W3G1 2.11
2 55 160 G60

3 60 200 G80 Lower is better S/N =-10 log [1/n (Σyi2)] ---- “Eq.
  (1)”

Table 3.2 L9 orthogonal array Table 3.4 S/N ratio summary sheet
Experiment P1 P2 P3 Experiment S/N ratio
1 1 1 1 No.
2 1 2 2 1 -6.85
3 1 3 3 2 -4.35
4 2 1 3 3 -0.83
5 2 2 1 4 -4.03
6 2 3 2 5 -5.58
7 3 1 2
6 -0.59
8 3 2 3
7 -2.35
9 3 3 1
8 -3.29
9 -6.49
3.4 Experimental Details
A set of experiments were conducted on tool and Average of S/N Ratio = -3.82 dB
cutter grinding machine on different alloy steel of
different hardness material to determine effect of
parameters namely),Work speed (rpm),material
hardness and grinding wheel on surface roughness Average S/N ratio for each parameter at three
Ra(μm). Three levels and three factors L9 Orthogonal level
array used to design the orthogonal array by using
design of experiments (DOE) .Grinding wheel used
____________________________________________________________________________________________________

International Journal of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering (IJMIE), ISSN No. 2231 –6477, Volume-1, Issue-3, 2012
75
 Optimization of Grinding Parameters for Minimum Surface Roughness by Taguchi Parametric Optimization Technique
__________________________________________________________________________________ 

Table 3.5 S/N ratio table for surface roughness

S. No Parameter S/N ratio value for
Low Medium High
Surface roughness
Material
H -4.01 -3.4 -4.04
Hardness (sH)

Workpiece
W -4.41 -4.41 -2.64
speed (sW)

Grinding
G -6.31 -2.43 -2.72
wheel (sG)

Average Roughness for each parameter at three

levels
Tabl 3.6 mean response table for surface roughness
S. No Parameter Surface roughness
Fig 4.1. Effect of process parameter on Roughness
Low Medium High
Material
H Hardness 1.65 1.52 1.63 4.2Response Graphs for S/N values for Surface
(HRC) Roughness
Wokpiece
W speed 1.70 1.67 1.43 (a)Level II for Hardness, sH2 = -3.4 dB indicated
(RPM) as the optimum situation in terms of S/N values.
Grinding
G 2.07 1.34 1.38 (b)Level III for work piece speed, sW3 = -2.64 dB
wheel (G) indicated as the optimum situation in terms of S/N
values.

The optimum level for a factor is the level that (c) Level II for Grain’s, sC2 = -2.43 dB indicated
gives the highest value of parameter in each level as the optimum situation in terms of S/N values.
in the experimental region denoted by bold letter.
The estimated main effects can be used for this
purpose.

4. Main Effects
Main effects plots for the experiments have been
given below.

4.1 Response Graphs for Means

1. Level II for Hardness, H2 = 1.52 Ra indicated as

the optimum situation in terms of Surface
Roughness values.
Fig4.2 Main effect for S/N ratio .
2. Level III for Cutting Speed, W3 = 1.43Ra
5.1Results
indicated as the optimum situation in terms of From main effects plotted, it is observed that there
Surface Roughness values. is decreases surface roughness as material hardness
increased. The roughness decreases when speed is
3. Level II for Grain’s, G2 = 1.34Ra indicated as changed from 100 to 160 rpm and again decreases
the optimum situation in terms of Surface when speed changed to 200 rpm, similarly when
Roughness values grinding wheel grain’s change from G46 to G60

____________________________________________________________________________________________________

International Journal of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering (IJMIE), ISSN No. 2231 –6477, Volume-1, Issue-3, 2012
76
 Optimization of Grinding Parameters for Minimum Surface Roughness by Taguchi Parametric Optimization Technique
__________________________________________________________________________________ 

surface roughness decreases, but as again change to 5.2 Conformation of Experiment

G80 roughness increase considerably. To validate the optimum grinding conditions (H2,
W3, G2) the combination of Medium Hardness
(H2), Larger Wokpiece speed (W3) and Medium Acknowledgement
Grain’s (G2) , then the Surface Roughness is We gratefully acknowledge the inspiration provided
minimum obtained by Dr. V. M. Sahai, (Principal), Professor G.S.Tomar
(Advisor), Professor Sanjay Goyal, and Professor
Table 5.1 conformation of experiment A.K. Saxena, Professor Ashish Sastri, Professor S.G.
Mishra of M.P.C.T. Gwalior to complete this
Surface Roughness S/N ratio research. At last but not least we are very thankful to
( Ra ) (dB ) God who has blessed us to accomplish this work.

1.07 -0.59

5.3 Mathematical regression Modelling

For the combination of parameters, roughness value References

is tabulated. Empirical formula has fined out by using
regression modeling. 1.E.Brinksmeimer, H.K.Tonshoff , C.Czenkusch and
C.Heinzel(1998) “Modelling and Optimization of grinding
process”. Journal of Intelligent Mnufacturing pp303-314.
Modelling of parameters
To generalize the results, the Modeling of input 2.A.J. Shih, M.B. Grant, and T.M. Yonushonis (1998)“Vitreous
parameters (Hardness, work piece speed, grain’s) and bond CBN wheel for high speed grinding of zirconia and M2 Tool
steel”. Transaction of NAMRI/SME vol 26.
output parameter (Roughness) is done using
REGRESSION MODELLING and MATLAB 3.Davim J.P. 2001. “A note on the determination of optimal cutting
Software R2011b. conditions for surface roughness obtained in turning using design
of experiments.” Journal of material processing technology. Vol
116, pp 305-308.

4.M.kiyak ,O.Cakir ,E.Altan(2003) “A Study on Surface Roughness

Ra = 105.90 (Hardness)0.0078 * (Work piece Speed) - in External Cylindrical grinding” Achievements in mechanical &
0.2492
* (Grinding wheel)-0.7340 Material engineering AMME. Pp 459-462.

5.L’ubica ELEKOVA , Zdenko LIPA ,(2009) “Comparison of

conventional and structured abrasive” Research Papers faculty
5.4Comparison of Result material science and technology in Tranava.pp 21-27.

6.Sijo M.T and Biju N, 2010, “Taguchi method for optimization of

cutting parameters in Turning Operations” AMAE.2010.01.536
pp-103-105.

7.M.Janardhan and Dr. A. Gopala Krishna (2011)“Determination

and optimization of cylindrical grinding process parameters using
Taguchi method and Regression Analysis” International Journal of
Engineering Science and Technology.ISSN : 0975-5462

8.Samuel Karanja Kabini, Dr.Barnard Wamuti Ikua, Dr.George

Nyakoe (2011)“Dynamic Modelling of Chatter Vibration in
cylindrical Plunge Grinding Process” Innovative systems design
and Engineering. ISSN:2222-1727

9.K. Venkatesh, M.S. Bobji, and S.K. Biswas (1999)“Power spectra

of roughness caused by grinding of metals” Journals of Material
Research vol.14 pp 319-322.

Fig 5.1 comparison of results 10G.Akhyar ,C.H. Haron , J.A. Ghani(2008) “Application of
Taguchi method in Optimization of Turning parameter for surface

____________________________________________________________________________________________________

International Journal of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering (IJMIE), ISSN No. 2231 –6477, Volume-1, Issue-3, 2012
77
 Optimization of Grinding Parameters for Minimum Surface Roughness by Taguchi Parametric Optimization Technique
__________________________________________________________________________________ 

roughness” Internatinal Journal of Science engineering and

Technology”ISSN 1985-3785 pp60-66.

11.Resit Unal Edwin B. Dean (1991) “ Taguchi approach to design

optimization for quality and cost”. Annual Conference of the
International Society of Parametric Analysts. Pp -1-10

12.Yang W.H. and Y.S. Tarang 1998. “Design optimization of

cutting parameters for turning operations based on Taguchi
method.” Journal of material processing technology. Volume 84,
pp 122-129

”””

____________________________________________________________________________________________________

International Journal of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering (IJMIE), ISSN No. 2231 –6477, Volume-1, Issue-3, 2012
78