0% found this document useful (0 votes)
70 views44 pages

Instrumentation and Process Control: Lecture-30:Second Order Systems

The document discusses second order systems and their characteristics. It covers: 1) Second order systems can be represented by a linear second order differential equation. The general form includes terms for acceleration, velocity, position, and input. 2) The step response of a second order system depends on the damping ratio ζ. An underdamped response (0<ζ<1) involves oscillations that decay over time, while an overdamped response (ζ>1) is non-oscillatory and becomes more sluggish as ζ increases. 3) Other topics covered include the characteristics of underdamped response, damped vibrators, U-tube manometers, first order systems

Uploaded by

Kshitij Soni
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
70 views44 pages

Instrumentation and Process Control: Lecture-30:Second Order Systems

The document discusses second order systems and their characteristics. It covers: 1) Second order systems can be represented by a linear second order differential equation. The general form includes terms for acceleration, velocity, position, and input. 2) The step response of a second order system depends on the damping ratio ζ. An underdamped response (0<ζ<1) involves oscillations that decay over time, while an overdamped response (ζ>1) is non-oscillatory and becomes more sluggish as ζ increases. 3) Other topics covered include the characteristics of underdamped response, damped vibrators, U-tube manometers, first order systems

Uploaded by

Kshitij Soni
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 44

Second Order

systems

Instrumentation and Process Control Characteristics


of Underdamped
response
Lecture-30:Second order systems
Damped
vibrator

U-tube
manometer
Dr. Hemanth Kumar Tanneru
First Order
systems in series
Department of Chemical Engineering
Non-interacting
Indian Institute of Petroleum and Energy Visakhapatnam systems

Interacting
systems
Table of Contents

1 Second Order systems


Second Order
systems

2 Characteristics of Underdamped response Characteristics


of Underdamped
response
3 Damped vibrator Damped
vibrator

U-tube
4 U-tube manometer manometer

First Order
systems in series
5 First Order systems in series
Non-interacting
systems
6 Non-interacting systems Interacting
systems

7 Interacting systems
Learning Objectives

Second Order
systems

Characteristics
of Underdamped
1 Understand the Second order systems response

2 Predict how a second order systems respond to step input Damped


vibrator
3 Analyze the different types of second order responses U-tube
manometer
4 Understand the behaviour of underdamped response First Order
systems in series
5 Derive transfer function model for second order systems
Non-interacting
systems

Interacting
systems
Table of Contents

1 Second Order systems


Second Order
systems

2 Characteristics of Underdamped response Characteristics


of Underdamped
response
3 Damped vibrator Damped
vibrator

U-tube
4 U-tube manometer manometer

First Order
systems in series
5 First Order systems in series
Non-interacting
systems
6 Non-interacting systems Interacting
systems

7 Interacting systems
Second Order systems
• A system which can be represented by a linear second order differential
equation is called second order system
• The general form of second order system Second Order
systems

d 2y dy Characteristics
a2 + a1 + a0 y = b0 u(t) (1) of Underdamped
dy dt response

Damped
a2 d 2 y a1 dy b0 vibrator
+ + y = u(t) (2) U-tube
a0 dy a0 dt a0 manometer

• Laplace transform with all initial conditions as zeros First Order


systems in series

τ 2 s 2 Y (s) + 2ζτ sY (s) + Y (s) = Kp U(s) (3) Non-interacting


systems

• On rearranging Interacting
systems
Y (s) Kp
G (s) = = 2 2 (4)
U(s) τ s + 2ζτ s + 1
a2 a1 b0
where, τ 2 = a0 , 2ζτ = a0 and Kp = a0
Step response of a second Order system
• If the forcing function is a unit-step function
1
U(s) = (5) Second Order
s systems

• Output Y(s) can be written as Characteristics


of Underdamped
response
Kp
Y (s) = (6) Damped
s (s 2 + 2ζτ s + 1) vibrator

U-tube
• Factored into two linear terms that contain the roots manometer
p p First Order
ζ ζ2 − 1 ζ ζ2 − 1 systems in series
s1 = − + ; s2 = − − (7)
τ τ τ τ Non-interacting
systems

Interacting
Case ζ Nature of roots (s1 & s2 ) Type of response systems

Case 1 >1 Two distinct real roots Overdamped


Case 2 =1 Two equal real roots Critically damped
Case 3 0<1 Two complex conjugate roots Underdamped
Step response for overdamped system

• Step response of the overdamped system can be given as


" # Second Order
p t ζ p t systems
Y (t) = 1 − e −ζt/τ cosh ζ 2 − 1 + p sinh ζ2 − 1 (8) Characteristics
τ ζ2 − 1 τ of Underdamped
response

Damped
vibrator

U-tube
manometer

First Order
Inference: systems in series

• Response is non-oscillatory Non-interacting


systems

• Becomes more sluggish as ζ increases Interacting


systems
Step response for underdamped system

• Step response of the underdamped system can be given as


" p p !# Second Order
1 − ζ 2 1 − ζ 2 systems
Y (t) = 1 − e −ζt/τ sin + tan−1 (9) Characteristics
τ ζ2 of Underdamped
response

Damped
vibrator

U-tube
manometer

Inference: First Order


systems in series
• Response is oscillatory Non-interacting
systems
• Oscillations decreases with increase in Interacting
time systems
Step response for critically damped system

• Step response of the underdamped system can be given as


Second Order
h ti systems
Y (t) = 1 − e −ζt/τ 1 + (10) Characteristics
τ of Underdamped
response

Damped
vibrator

U-tube
manometer

Inference: First Order


systems in series
• Response is non oscillatory and Non-interacting
systems
approaches to 1
Interacting
systems
Comparison

Second Order
systems

Characteristics
of Underdamped
response

Damped
vibrator

U-tube
manometer

First Order
systems in series

Non-interacting
systems

Interacting
systems
Table of Contents

1 Second Order systems


Second Order
systems

2 Characteristics of Underdamped response Characteristics


of Underdamped
response
3 Damped vibrator Damped
vibrator

U-tube
4 U-tube manometer manometer

First Order
systems in series
5 First Order systems in series
Non-interacting
systems
6 Non-interacting systems Interacting
systems

7 Interacting systems
Characteristics of Underdamped response

• Rise Time: Time required for the


response to to first reach its ultimate Second Order
systems
value Characteristics
of Underdamped
• Response Time: Time required for the response

response to come within ±5 percent of Damped


vibrator
its ultimate value and remain there.
U-tube
• Period of Oscillation: Time between manometer
• Overshoot: A measure of how two successive peaks or two successive First Order
systems in series
much the response exceeds the valleys of the response. Non-interacting
ultimate value following a step systems
• Natural period of Oscillation: If the
change and is expressed as the Interacting
damping is eliminated from system i.e., systems
ratio A/B in Figure.
ζ = 0, then the system will oscillate
• Decay ratio: Ratio of the sizes continuously without any change in the
of successive peaks and is given amplitude of oscillations.
by C/A in Figure.
Formulas for finding terms of underdamped response
1 Overshoot
!
−πζ
Overshoot = exp p (11) Second Order
systems
1 − ζ2
Characteristics
of Underdamped
2 Decay ratio response
! Damped
−2πζ vibrator
Decay ratio = exp p (12)
1 − ζ2 U-tube
manometer

First Order
3 Rise Time systems in series
q 
τ −1 2
Non-interacting
tr = − p tan (1 − ζ )/ζ (13) systems
1 − ζ2 Interacting
systems
4 Period of Oscillation
2πτ
T =p (14)
1 − ζ2
Contd..

Second Order
systems

Characteristics
• Examples of second order systems are: of Underdamped
response
• U-tube manometer Damped
• Damped vibrator vibrator

• Second order systems can arise from several physical situations such as U-tube
manometer
• multi capacity processes First Order
• inherently second order systems systems in series

Non-interacting
systems

Interacting
systems
Table of Contents

1 Second Order systems


Second Order
systems

2 Characteristics of Underdamped response Characteristics


of Underdamped
response
3 Damped vibrator Damped
vibrator

U-tube
4 U-tube manometer manometer

First Order
systems in series
5 First Order systems in series
Non-interacting
systems
6 Non-interacting systems Interacting
systems

7 Interacting systems
Damped vibrator
Assumptions:
• A1. System is free to oscillate
horizontally under the influence of a Second Order
systems
forcing function F(t).
Characteristics
• A2. The origin of the coordinate system of Underdamped
response
is taken as the right edge of the block Damped
when the spring is in the relaxed vibrator

U-tube
• A3. Initially, no force is applied manometer

First Order
systems in series
Goal: To find a transfer function that relates
Non-interacting
Y to F (t) systems

Interacting
The different forces acting on block: systems

• The force exerted by the spring (-KY, towards left)


• The viscous friction force (−C dY
dt , towards left)
• The external force (F(t), towards right)
Balance equation
• Newton’s law of motion: Sum of all forces acting on the mass is equal to the
rate of change of momentum
Second Order
d 2Y dY systems
W 2 = −KY − C + F (t) Characteristics
dt dt of Underdamped
response
• On rearranging
Damped
vibrator
d 2Y dY
W +C + KY = F (t) (15) U-tube
dt 2 dt manometer

• Dividing K on both sides First Order


systems in series

W d 2Y C dY F (t) Non-interacting
systems
2
+ +Y = (16)
K dt K dt K Interacting
systems
• Standard form
Y (s) 1
= 2 2 (17)
U(s) τ s + 2ζτ s + 1
Contd...

Second Order
systems

Characteristics
of Underdamped
response

Damped
W C F (t)
• Here, τ 2 = K , 2ζτ = K, and U(t) = K
vibrator

U-tube
manometer

First Order
systems in series

Non-interacting
systems

Interacting
systems
Table of Contents

1 Second Order systems


Second Order
systems

2 Characteristics of Underdamped response Characteristics


of Underdamped
response
3 Damped vibrator Damped
vibrator

U-tube
4 U-tube manometer manometer

First Order
systems in series
5 First Order systems in series
Non-interacting
systems
6 Non-interacting systems Interacting
systems

7 Interacting systems
U-tube manometer

Assumptions:
• A1. Flow in the manometer is laminar Second Order
systems
• A2. The density of the fluid above the
Characteristics
manometric fluid is negligible of Underdamped
response
• A3. Velocity profile is flat. Each Damped
vibrator
molecule moved with same velocity
U-tube
manometer
Goal: To find a transfer function that relates First Order
H to P, that is, H(s)/P(s). systems in series

Non-interacting
systems

The different forces acting on manometric fluid: Interacting


systems
• Force due to differential pressure
• Force due to gravity
• Frictional drag force
Balance equation

• Momentum balance on the fluid in the manometer Second Order


systems

Characteristics
Sum of forces causing fluid to move = Rate of change of momentum of fluid of Underdamped
response

• Sum of forces causing fluid to move Damped


vibrator

U-tube
Unbalanced pressure forces causing motion − Frictional forces opposing motion(18)
manometer

First Order
systems in series
• Unbalanced pressure forces causing motion
Non-interacting
systems
πD 2 πD 2 Interacting
Unbalanced pressure forces causing motion = (P1 − P2 ) − ρgh systems
4 4
Contd...

• Frictional forces opposing motion can be calculated as skin friction at wall


Second Order
Frictional forces opposing motion = Skin friction at wall systems

Characteristics
• Skin friction at wall of Underdamped
response

Damped
= (Shear stress at wall) × (Area in contact with wall) vibrator
    U-tube
= τwall (πDL) = 8µDV̄ (πDL) = 8µ 1 dh

D 2 dt (πDL) manometer

First Order
systems in series
• The rate of change of momentum of the fluid
Non-interacting
systems
d
= (mass × velocity × momentum correction factor) Interacting
systems
dt 
πD 2 πD 2 1 dh2
    
d V̄
= ρ L (β) = ρ L (β)
4 dt 4 2 dt
Contd...

• Force balance equation for the manometer Second Order


systems

Characteristics
πD 2 1 dh2 πD 2 πD 2
!  !
4 8µ 1 dh
  
ρ L = (P1 − P2 ) − ρgh − (πDL) (19) of Underdamped
4 3 2 dt 2 4 4 D 2 dt response

Damped
vibrator
πD 2 1 dh2 πD 2 πD 2
!  !
4 8µ 1 dh
  
U-tube
ρ L + (πDL) + ρgh = (P1 − P2 )
4 3 2 dt 2 D 2 dt 4 4 manometer

First Order
• Dividing both sides by ρg (πD 2 /4) systems in series

Non-interacting
2L d 2 h 16µL dh P1 − P2 ∆P systems
+ +h = =
3g dt 2 ρD 2 g dt ρg ρg Interacting
systems
Contd...

• Expressed in standard form


Second Order

d 2Y dY systems

τ 2 2 + 2ζτ + Y = U(t) (20) Characteristics


dt dt of Underdamped
response
• Applying Laplace transform Damped
vibrator

τ 2 s 2 Y (s) + 2ζτ sY (s) + Y (s) = U(s)


U-tube
(21) manometer

First Order
• Transfer function systems in series

Non-interacting
systems
Y (s) 1
= 2 2 (22) Interacting
U(s) τ s + 2ζτ s + 1 systems

• Here, τ 2 = 2L 16µL ∆P
3g , 2ζτ = ρD 2 g
, U(t) = ρg and Y = h
Table of Contents

1 Second Order systems


Second Order
systems

2 Characteristics of Underdamped response Characteristics


of Underdamped
response
3 Damped vibrator Damped
vibrator

U-tube
4 U-tube manometer manometer

First Order
systems in series
5 First Order systems in series
Non-interacting
systems
6 Non-interacting systems Interacting
systems

7 Interacting systems
First Order systems in series

• Consider a process with several input variables and several output variables.
Second Order
systems

Characteristics
of Underdamped
response

Damped
vibrator

U-tube
manometer

First Order
systems in series

Non-interacting
systems

Interacting
systems
Figure: Two-tank liquid-level system: (left) Noninteracting; (right) interacting
Table of Contents

1 Second Order systems


Second Order
systems

2 Characteristics of Underdamped response Characteristics


of Underdamped
response
3 Damped vibrator Damped
vibrator

U-tube
4 U-tube manometer manometer

First Order
systems in series
5 First Order systems in series
Non-interacting
systems
6 Non-interacting systems Interacting
systems

7 Interacting systems
Non-interacting systems

Assumptions:
• A1. liquid to be of constant density Second Order
systems
• A2. tanks to have uniform Characteristics
of Underdamped
cross-sectional area response

• A3. the flow resistances to be linear Damped


vibrator

U-tube
Goal: Our problem is to find a transfer manometer

function that relates h2 to q, that is, First Order


systems in series
H2 (s)/Q(s).
Non-interacting
systems
Approach:
Interacting
• Obtain a transfer function for each tank, Q1 (s)/Q(s) and H2 (s)/Q1 (s) systems

• Combined these transfer functions to eliminate the intermediate flow Q1 (s)


and produce the desired transfer function
Derivation
• A mass balance over tank 1:
dh1
q − q1 = A1 (23) Second Order
dt systems
• Valve relation: Characteristics
of Underdamped
h1 response
q1 = (24)
R1 Damped
vibrator
• Substituting Eqn. 24 into 23 eliminates q1 U-tube
manometer
h1 dh1 First Order
q− = A1 (25) systems in series
R1 dt
Non-interacting
• Putting Eqn 24 and 25 into deviation variable form gives systems

Interacting
H1 dH1 systems
Q− = A1 (26)
R1 dt
H1
Q1 = (27)
R1
Contd...
• The transfer function relating to is found by transforming Eqn 26 and
rearranging to obtain
Second Order
H1 (s) R1 K1 systems
= = (28)
Q(s) A1 R1 s + 1 τ1 s + 1 Characteristics
of Underdamped
• Similarly, the transfer function relating to s obtained by transforming Eqn 27. response

Damped
Q1 (s) 1 1 vibrator
= = (29) U-tube
H1 (s) R1 K1 manometer

• The same procedure leads to the corresponding transfer functions for Tank 2 First Order
systems in series

H2 (s) R2 K2 Non-interacting
= = (30) systems
Q2 (s) A2 R2 s + 1 τ2 s + 1 Interacting
systems

Q2 (s) 1 1
= = (31)
H2 (s) R2 K2
• Here, Kp1 = R1 , Kp2 = R2 , τ1 = A1 R1 & τ2 = A2 R2
Transfer function for Noninteracting Tanks
• The transfer function relating the outflow from Tank 2 to the inflow to Tank
1 can be derived by forming the product of Eqn 28 through 31.
Second Order
Q2 (s) H1 (s) Q1 (s) H2 (s) Q2 (s) systems
= × × × (32)
Q(s) Q(s) H1 (s) Q1 (s) H2 (s) Characteristics
of Underdamped
• On substitution response
     Damped
Q2 (s) K1 1 K2 1 vibrator
= (33)
Q(s) τ1 s + 1 K1 τ2 s + 1 K2 U-tube
manometer
• On simplification First Order
systems in series
Q2 (s) 1 Non-interacting
= (34) systems
Q(s) (τ1 s + 1)(τ2 s + 1)
Interacting
systems
Contd...

• Overall transfer function H2 (s)/Q(s) by multiplying Eqns. 28, 29 and 30 to


eliminate Q1 (s) and H1 (s): Second Order
systems

H2 (s) H1 (s) Q1 (s) H2 (s) Characteristics


= × × (35) of Underdamped
Q(s) Q(s) H1 (s) Q1 (s) response

Damped
• On substitution vibrator

U-tube
manometer
   
H2 (s) K1 1 K2
= (36) First Order
Q(s) τ1 s + 1 K1 τ2 s + 1 systems in series

Non-interacting
• On simplification systems

Interacting
systems
H2 (s) K2
= (37)
Q(s) (τ1 s + 1)(τ2 s + 1)
Table of Contents

1 Second Order systems


Second Order
systems

2 Characteristics of Underdamped response Characteristics


of Underdamped
response
3 Damped vibrator Damped
vibrator

U-tube
4 U-tube manometer manometer

First Order
systems in series
5 First Order systems in series
Non-interacting
systems
6 Non-interacting systems Interacting
systems

7 Interacting systems
Interacting systems
Assumptions:
• A1. Liquid to be of constant density
• A2. Tanks to have uniform Second Order
systems
cross-sectional area Characteristics
of Underdamped
• A3. The flow resistances to be linear response

• A4. The resistance for liquid flow is the Damped


vibrator
change in the level difference necessary U-tube
to cause a change inflow rate. manometer

First Order
systems in series
Goal: Our problem is to find a transfer Non-interacting
function that relates h2 to q, that is, systems

H2 (s)/Q(s). Interacting
systems
Approach:
• Obtain a transfer function for each tank, Q1 (s)/Q(s) and H2 (s)/Q1 (s)
• Combined these transfer functions to eliminate the intermediate flow Q1 (s)
and produce the desired transfer function
Transfer Function of Interacting systems
• The balance over tanks 1 & tank 2:
dh1
q − q1 = A1 (38)
dt Second Order
systems
dh2
q1 − q2 = A2 (39) Characteristics
dt of Underdamped
response
• At steady state, Damped
vibrator
qs − q1s = 0 (40) U-tube
manometer
q1s − q2s = 0 (41)
First Order
(42) systems in series

Non-interacting
• Subtracting unsteady state Eqn from steady state and introducing deviation systems

variables give Interacting


systems
dH1
Q(s) − Q1 (s) = A1 (43)
dt
dH2
Q1 (s) − Q2 (s) = A2 (44)
dt
Contd...
• Valve relation:
h1 − h2
q1 = (45) Second Order
R1 systems

h2 Characteristics
q2 = (46) of Underdamped
R2 response

Damped
• Writing in deviation variables gives vibrator

H 1 − H2 H2 U-tube
manometer
Q1 = and Q2 = (47)
R1 R2 First Order
systems in series
• Laplace Transform Non-interacting
systems
Q(s) − Q1 (s) = A1 sH1 (s) (48) Interacting
systems
Q1 (s) − Q2 (s) = A2 sH2 (s) (49)
R1 Q1 (s) = H1 (s) − H2 (s) (50)
R2 Q2 (s) = H2 (s) (51)
Contd...

Second Order
systems
• These equations may be combined to eliminate Q1 , Q2 , and H1 and to arrive
Characteristics
at the desired transfer function: of Underdamped
response

Damped
H2 (s) R2 vibrator
= (52)
Q(s) τ1 τ2 s 2 + (τ1 + τ2 + A1 R2 )s + 1 U-tube
manometer

First Order
• Here, τ1 = A1 R1 and τ2 = A2 R2 systems in series

• Deviation variables: Q = q − qs , Q1 = q1 − q1s , Q2 = q2 − q2s , Non-interacting


systems
H1 = h1 − h1s and H2 = h2 − h2s , Interacting
systems
Model Comparison

Second Order
1 Noninteracting system systems

Characteristics
of Underdamped
H2 (s) R2 response
= (53)
Q(s) (τ1 s + 1)(τ2 s + 1) Damped
vibrator

2 Interacting system U-tube


manometer

First Order
H2 (s) R2 systems in series
= 2
(54)
Q(s) τ1 τ2 s + (τ1 + τ2 + A1 R2 )s + 1 Non-interacting
systems

Interacting
• Difference: Presence of the cross product term A1 R2 in the coefficient of s systems
Step response of non-interacting system
• Transfer function of two tank non-interacting system in series
H2 (s) R2
= (55) Second Order
Q(s) (τ1 s + 1)(τ2 s + 2) systems

• Assumption: τ1 = τ2 = τ Characteristics
of Underdamped
response
H2 (s) R2
= (56) Damped
Q(s) (τ s + 1)(τ s + 2) vibrator

• For a unit step change in input U-tube


manometer

1 First Order
Q(t) = 1; Q(s) = (57) systems in series
s Non-interacting
• Response in level systems

Interacting
R2 systems
H2 (s) = (58)
s(τ s + 1)(τ s + 2)

R2 /τ 2 C1 C2 C3
H2 (s) = = + + (59)
s(τ s + 1)(τ s + 2) s (s + 1/τ ) (s + 1/τ )2
Contd...
• The constants C1 , C2 and C3 are determined as
C1 = R 2 ; C2 = −R2 ; C3 = −R2 /τ (60)
Second Order
• The expression for H2 (t) systems

Characteristics
of Underdamped

−t/τ t 
H2 (t) = R2 1 − e − e −t/τ (61) response
τ Damped
vibrator

U-tube
manometer

First Order
systems in series

Non-interacting
systems

Interacting
systems
Step response of interacting systems
• Transfer function of two tank non-interacting system in series
H2 (s) R2
= (62) Second Order
Q(s) τ1 τ2 s 2 + (τ1 + τ2 + A1 R2 )s + 1 systems

• Assumption: τ1 = τ2 = τ Characteristics
of Underdamped
response
H2 (s) R2
= 2 2 (63) Damped
Q(s) τ s + 3τ s + 1 vibrator

• For a unit step change in input U-tube


manometer

1 First Order
Q(t) = 1; Q(s) = systems in series
s Non-interacting
• Response in level systems

Interacting
R2 systems
H2 (s) = 2 2
(64)
s(τ s + 3τ s + 1)
R2
H2 (s) = (65)
s(0.382τ s + 1)(2.618τ s + 1)
Contd...

R2 /τ 2 C1 C2 C3
H2 (s) = = + + Second Order
s(0.382τ s + 1)(2.618τ s + 1) s (s + 2.618/τ ) (s + 0.382/τ ) systems

Characteristics
• The constants C1 , C2 and C3 are determined as follows of Underdamped
response

C1 = R2 ; C2 = −1.171R2 ; C3 = −0.171R2 Damped


vibrator

U-tube
 t 
H2 (t) = R2 1 + 0.171e −2.618t/τ − 1.171 e −0.382t/τ manometer

τ First Order
systems in series

Non-interacting
systems

Interacting
systems
Effect of interaction on step response

Second Order
systems

Characteristics
of Underdamped
response

Damped
vibrator

U-tube
manometer

First Order
systems in series

Non-interacting
systems

Interacting
systems
Figure: Response comparison plot

• Interacting system is more sluggish than non-interacting


Second Order
systems

Characteristics
of Underdamped
response

Damped
Thank You vibrator

U-tube
manometer

First Order
systems in series

Non-interacting
systems

Interacting
systems

You might also like