Chapter 3 Making Schools Inclusive
Chapter 3 Making Schools Inclusive
Introduction
Previously, you learned about the history, context, and foundations of special
needs and inclusive education. By understanding the role that disability frameworks
play, we can now move on to finding out how to implement inclusive practices in the
classroom. This chapter shall provide insights and practical tips on cultivating
inclusive habits and implementing such practices in the classroom effectively. It is
entirely based on the Booth and Ainscow (2002) framework to help schools
determine their next steps in shifting to a more inclusive setting.
1. Diversity is the new "normal."
Competencies
Additional needs, and the ability to create safe, inclusive, and culturally
responsive learning environments for students with additional needs.
A UNIFYING FRAMEWORK
In 2002, Booth and Ainscow came up with an Index for Inclusion, which aims to
direct educational institutions toward developing their own next steps and action
plans if they want to restructure into becoming more inclusive. "It takes on the social
model of disability as its starting point, builds on good practice, and then organizes
the index work around a cycle of activities which guide schools through stages of
preparation, investigation, development, and review" (UNESCO 2005:30). A three-
dimensional framework was created (see Figure 3.1).
Evolving inclusiveProducing
practices inclusive practices
(Source: The Dimensions and Sections in the Index of Inclusion. Adapted from Booth
& Ainscow, 2002:8)
I. CREATING INCLUSIVE CULTURES
In educational reform, stakeholders are those who are "invested in the welfare
and success of a school and its students" (www.edglossary.org). In other words,
these are the teachers, administrators, school staff, officials and other workers, the
parents and their families, the community, and the government. They may also be
collective entities like local businesses, advocacy groups the media, sociocultural
institutions, and other organizations that may be directly or indirectly involved in
education. Stakeholders are important because they play a major role in "connecting
what is being taught in a school to its surrounding community" (www.edglossary.org),
In 2017, UNESCO reported that there has been significant global improvement in
accessing education, specifically in the primary level for the last 15 years. However,
its 2016 Global Education Monitoring Report reveals: that there are still an estimated
263 million children and youth aged 6 to 17 all around the world who are still not in
school at this time. The report also confirmed the continuous plight of women against
gender discrimination, among others. With increasing globalization and international
migration, the problem pertaining to inclusive education and how it affects PWDs
could not be more real.
Build key people. The government recognizes the need for teacher training, both in
the special needs education and general education levels. It also pushes for the
use of evidence-based teaching frameworks, provision of student assistance, and
access to instructional materials. Most importantly, calls are made for continuing
research and forming of policies to be initiated by agencies such as the Department
of Education so as to further refine the inclusive process and have it tailored to fit to
the needs of children with additional needs. This is an important factor that every
nation has to constantly revisit as the needs of students across continents, though
similar, would have nuances depending on where they reside. Educational
frameworks cannot just be lifted and “copy-pasted” with the expectation that what
worked for one country will work for another. UNESCO (2005) states that clarity of
purpose, realistic goals, motivation, support, resources, and an evaluation of
policies and practices all contribute to a successful shift toward inclusion.
Identify and eradicate barriers. UNESCO’s Guide for Inclusion (2005) advocates
for the identification and removal of obstacles that have to do with transforming
prevailing attitudes and values on a systemic level. The Philippine government
seems to be in consonance with this aspect in the light of its existing legislative
policies that ground the undeniable importance of inclusion. It is also continuously
reorganizing structures in education and implementing programs that highlight the
need for primary stakeholders like the school, the parents, and other policy makers,
to acquire more understanding and capacity-building to manage an inclusive
environment.
Attitudes, values systems, misconceptions, and societal norms - can lead to prejudices and/or
actual resistance to implement inclusive practices (UNESCO 2005).
Physical barriers - the lack of building, facility, transportation, or road accessibility are types of
physical barriers that can literally affect one's mobility.
Curriculum - a rigid "one size fits all" type of curriculum that does not allow room for individual
differences can significantly stunt one's learning and opportunity for growth.
Lack of teacher training and low teacher efficacy- whether training in teaching strategies, using
curriculum frameworks, or behavior and classroom management, lack of training as well as low
confidence in one's own skills can directly affect how inclusive practices are implemented.
Poor language and communication - language barriers may also directly have implications on
how well inclusive practices are implemented.
● Lack of funding - enough funding can allow for training more teachers as well as
coming up with more appropriate programs, instructional materials, or facilities:
lack of funds can be limiting and debilitating to schools.
Lack of policies - policies have the ability to unify beliefs and mobilize resources;
unfortunately, lack of it can become a convenient justification for inaction.
Selected learners
are included in a
Student who are All same-aged general education
not part of the peers/learners are class based on
Learners classroom norm in one class their readiness
regardless of ability instead of their
age.
Mostly strengths-
based but is
Assessment and sometimes is also Both norm-
Evaluation standard-based referenced and
Norm-referenced strength-based
Recognize the shift in roles of the teachers. With the shift to inclusive
education, the role of special education (SPED) teachers suddenly seems to
be reduced to only "as needed." As a result, the SPED teacher's role no
longer becomes that of an implementer but that of a consultative nature
instead. It also becomes the responsibility of the general education teacher
to know what to do when faced with a learner with additional needs in his or
her classroom. The SPED teachers' role-their trainings, their insights, and
their skills as a supposed prime mover in the inclusive education framework-
must neither be diminished nor disregarded. Instead, these must be used to
ensure a good inclusive program is provided to children with additional
needs. Conversely. general education teachers must go through skills
training and capacity building workshops to ensure that they are supporting
all types of learners in their classrooms appropriately
Booth and Ainscow (2002) recommend that schools reflect on their current
policies and practices to check their readiness for an inclusive set-up. They also
devised a questionnaire that would help administrators, faculty and other
stakeholders comprehensively gather baseline data. A move that would greatly help
in informing policy would be to examine different aspects of the school and the
delivery of its services. Specifically, schools may look at the following:
Student admissions
Accessibility to utilities and facilities
Learner accommodations
Allow technology as
needed
Establish strong
home school
partnerships
Classroom check-
ins and check-outs
Principle 9: Inclusive Inclusive practices are Make students
Environment designed to foster aware of and
acceptance and a sense of comfortable with
belongingness for all. diversity
Emphasize social
roles in the
classroom: (e.g.,
that we students
are there to teach
each other and
learn from each
other.)
Allow bonding
activities
Do team-building
exercises regularly
and integrate
lessons in such
activities
2. Differentiated Instruction
All learners are unique and have varying interests, talents, strength as well as
needs. Hence, it is essential that teaching and learning experience reflect this
diversity. To ensure engaged, successful, and flourishing learners, teaching and
learning experiences need to be designed in a way that provide opportunities for
students to learn and demonstrate their understanding in varied ways. Thus,
Differentiating Instruction (D1) helps ensure that learners are engaged in respectful
tasks and provide diverse means of learning that reflect their strengths and address
their needs simultaneously.
How Is Instruction Differentiated?
Bender in 2002 (as cited by Gentry et al. 2013) identified elements of the
curriculum that can be differentiated: (1) content, (2) process. (3) product, and (4)
learning environment in response to the students' characteristics interests,
readiness, and learning profile. As an overview, differentiation is achieved by
providing materials and tasks:
As teachers, you must know your curriculum. You are suggested to revisit or
identify which are non-negotiable and negotiable learning objectives and tasks. You
are also expected to know your students' interests, readiness level (based on
diagnostic data), and learning styles/profile (strengths and needs). You may create a
class profile to provide an overview of the class's characteristics and needs. Next,
you have to identify and plan what and how to differentiate your material. The goal is
to start small and take simple steps toward differentiating instruction. Table 3.3
provides a guide on how to effectively differentiate in the classroom.
Answer interest)
instruction
•Jigsaw (expert
groups)
•Cooperative
learning activities
•Teams, Games
and Activities
•Cubing
•Learning contracts
1. Explain to the students the reason for differentiation. Make sure this is understood
by all.
2. Use "anchor activities" which students can automatically work on when completing
assigned tasks to maintain a productive work environment and maximize
instructional time. Examples of anchor activities are reading chosen book (e.g.,
for book report), journal writing based on a prompt, skill practice (spelling, math),
use of manipulative objects, etc.
a. Facilitator
b. Recorder
c. Summarizer/Timekeeper
d. Presenter
e. Errand monitor
c. Have a plan for when to ask for help (role of the errand monitor)
Anchor Activity Options
References:
Booth, T. and Ainscow, M. (2002). Index for Inclusion: Developing learning and
participation in schools. Bristol: Centre for Studies on Inclusive Education
Read Write Think (2004). Cooperative Group Role Lands. IRA/NTC. Retrieved from
https://www.readwritethink.org/files/resources/ lesson_images/lesson
227/cooperative.pdf.
UN General Assembly.(2015). " Transforming our world: the 2030 agenda for
Sustainable development, "A/ RES/70/1. Retrieved from https://
www.sustainabledevelopment.org
Van den Brule-Balescut, J. & Sandkull, O. (2005). " Putting the convention into
practice: ensuring education for all. Rights-based approach to education
programming. Proceeding of the 6th Ad Hoe Committee Session, UN HQ,
New York. Retrieved from https://slidespalyer.com/slide/5883978/