Sme Financing: Ipo Issue and Post-Ipo Analysis: Prashant Gupta, Associate Professor at IMI, Delhi, Prashantgupta@imi - Edu
Sme Financing: Ipo Issue and Post-Ipo Analysis: Prashant Gupta, Associate Professor at IMI, Delhi, Prashantgupta@imi - Edu
Effulgence
Vol. 16 (Special Issue)
January - June, 2018
Rukmini Devi Institute of Advanced Studies
E-mail : [email protected], Website : www.rdias.ac.in
http://effulgence.rdias.ac.in/user/default.aspx
https://dx.doi.org/10.33601/effulgence.rdias/v16/iSpl1/2018/article0.8
ABSTRACT
Small Medium Enterprises (SMEs) are an engine of growth for any nation in the world. As per estimates of
World Bank, 45% of total employment is created by formal SMEs and approximately up to 33% of national
income (GDP) in emerging economies. This calculation may further inflate if contribution of informal SMEs is
included. As per estimates ~600 million jobs will be required in the coming 15 years to provide employment to
the growing manpower worldwide, primarily in Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa. In emerging markets, SMEs
provide most of the formal jobs. Therefore, access to finance is a key constraint to SME growth; without it,
many SMEs suffer and stagnate.
Recently, an initiative has been taken for the capital financing of SMEs via IPOs, wherein the response has been
very good and encouraging. Also, the performance of secondary market of SME IPOs has been very good. But
the low level of liquidity and turnover makes the whole process risky for investors. This is why SEBI (market
regulator in India) has issued directives that while investing in SME IPOs, small investors should be kept away.
SEBI further reiterates that merchant bankers should act as investors in such companies for at least three years.
On the flipside, if these three years goes on in only settling the whole business, the interest of these shareholders
may vanish and they may withdraw their investment. This will lead to liquidity crunch again. This paper focuses
on measuring the effectiveness of SME financing through IPO and analysing how successful companies have
been after raising finance through this route. Also, examining how the involvement of stock exchanges, where
these companies are listed, may provide sustained support to the managements of these companies.
Keywords: BSE SME IPO, SME Exchange, SME Employment, SME growth
1
recently launched SME platforms and a financial
overview of listed companies. Keshab Das (2007) has studied that in spite of
descriptive and active policy framework in India,
LITERATURE REVIEW the growth of SMEs continues to be slowed down
by fundamental problems such as poor availability
One of the interesting phenomena in SME of funds, low levels or obsolete technology, which
financing is the role of IPO and its effect on affects the quality of product and hence lesser
companies’ performance. Since SME’s role has exports. He stressed on the fact that it would be too
been accepted worldwide by various countries as a early to judge the effectiveness of new policies. He
reason of boost to economy and trade, a lot of says that much of the potential of small firms to
research and whitepapers have been written in this grow and develop innovativeness is formed by the
field. In the opinion of C B Bhave (2010) (speech type of infrastructure, both physical and economic,
delivered at FICCI), SMEs are a catalyst in the available and can be accessed at reasonable costs.
majority of the economies and form a significant The MSMED ACT gives more importance to
part of industrial activity. He further reiterates that networking with stakeholders both upstream and
since SMEs in most of the cases come across downstream in the entire global value chain,
financial crisis, therefore, he anticipates that the starting from obtaining of raw material,
formation of SME Exchange will be an important handling/production to marketing and customer
step to provide support in terms of capital, services.
enhanced credibility and other benefits.
Bhatendra Kumar Gupta (2008) and Tarak Shah
Review of literature explains that banks are the (2011), in their research study, said that after
primary source of capital for SMEs in both agriculture, the SME sector is the second largest
developed and developing countries (Vera & Onji, employer in India. For making anything successful,
2010; Ono & Uesugi, 2009; Zhou, 2009; Wu et al., the role of financing or funding is eminent and this
2008; Carey & Flynn, 2005; Cole & Wolken 1995). calls for a need of a dedicated stock exchange for
Also, everybody had been focussing on the concern the MSME sector to cater to their requirements.
that similar to large corporations, SMEs should be This problem of insufficient financing to SMEs
promoted as an active participant in IPO to ease needs serious attention amongst the others to
availability of finance. ensure adequate credit delivery to SMEs, better risk
management, and technological up gradation. The
R. K. Jain, Avdhesh Kumar Shukla and Kaushiki SMEs sector is considered to be an unexploited
Singh (2013), in a whitepaper at RBI, have market for financial organizations in India. The
analysed the importance of IPO and some of the only way out of the mire is that the Indian
financial attributes of listed companies. While manufacturing sector could be supported by the
measuring the performance of companies after IPO, current rural systems and by making them self-
most of the research carried out harmonizes with sufficient. This is only possible by helping small &
research in the US by Moonchul and Ritter (1999) medium enterprises and the rural artisans (people
that after IPO, companies performance generally with innate skills and talents) in becoming effective
either remains stagnant or underperform in terms of and competitive enough to face the future. A
revenue and market capitalisation in the market. number of problems and business practices of
However, Loughran and Ritter (1995) presents a global players and markets can be witnessed, learnt
different picture that underperformance is not and adjusted for ensuring the competitiveness of
something that is inherent post-IPO, there have Indian SMEs.
been instances when their market capitalisation has
shown consistent Compounded annual growth RESEARCH PROBLEM
(CAGR) viz-a-viz net income.
It was observed that there is a body of literature in
While citing the importance of SMEs Y.Srinivas the SME financing through IPO in foreign markets
(2005), mentioned in an article in ICAI journal that and their effects on companies. However, it
SMEs play an important role in the economy remains unknown the extent to which these
bringing parity between balanced and sustainable initiatives are beneficial in Indian scenario and how
growth, employment generation, entrepreneurial this route has succeeded in addressing the needs of
skills development and contribution to export funding and enhanced visibility of companies listed
earnings. However, in spite of their significance to on these exchanges. Through this paper, we aim to
the economy, most SMEs face the brunt of understand the benefits of launching SME
globalisation, primarily due to problems in the area exchanges and how companies are reaping
of financing. He further emphasized that since advantages of this initiative. Hence, this research is
globalisation in 1991, it has become very important useful in understanding the importance of SME
to smoothen up the flow of credit to this sector.
2
exchanges, and measuring the effect of IPO on 1) Alternative Investment Market – AIM (London
SMEs. Stock Exchange, London): Established in 1995 as a
sub-market of the London Stock Exchange. Over
METHODOLOGY 3,600 companies have chosen to join AIM since
inception. It helps companies from Canadian oil
The research conducted is descriptive in nature. explorers to Chinese tech start-ups. Also, a number
From a total of 207 companies listed as of 19 flexibility is provided in this exchange such as no
October 2017 on BSE SME exchange, financial minimum size requirements for listing and shares
data of at least last three financial years for only can be traded in any freely-available currency, etc.
169 companies was available. The probable reason 2) NASDAQ OMX First North (NASDAQ OMX
could be that either few companies have stopped Group): Designed for small and growing
trading or migrated to main exchange or listed at a companies, where every company has a Certified
later date. BSE SME exchange was started in Jul Adviser, who is responsible for carrying out the
2012. In the initial years, there was only handful of whole process of listing. This exchange is very
companies which were listed and data availability much suitable for small, young or growth
was scarce. Therefore, data of 169 companies has companies. NASDAQ OMX First North integrates
been used throughout the paper. On the other side, the advantage of becoming public without any
~88 companies are listed at NSE Emerge, therefore, hassle and is mainly considered as the first step
volatility at NSE Emerge is less than BSE SME. In towards the main market. (NASDAQ OMX
this case, an index having high volatility makes website).
more sense to be taken for study.
3) NYSE Alternext (NYSE-Euronext Group):
To carry out the study, data has been collected from Formed in 2005 by Euronext to meet the needs of
annual reports of listed companies, journals, and small and midsized companies. Here the rules are
different stock exchange websites. as easy with a minimum free float requirement of
€2.5m only for IPO. On the other side, for a private
SME FINANCING CONCERNS placement, the company can apply for listing on
Alternext and must prove that they have placed at
In a discussion paper by SEBI, several factors have least €5m with five or more investors.
been identified which highlight the need for SME
financing rising role of an exchange as under: 4) Euro MTF (The Luxembourg Stock Exchange,
Luxembourg): Acts as a major listing centre of
• High cost of raising capital international bonds, equities, and other funds. The
• As compared to large corporations, SMEs Luxembourg Stock Exchange functions through
do not have access to funds from angel two markets: European regulated market (opened in
investors, VCs, and PE players May 1929) and Euro MTF (opened in July 2005
• In case of smaller issues, the costs of and is a multilateral trading facility regulated by the
raising capital as per current guidelines are exchange itself.
fixed, which become troublesome for
smaller issues (SMEs) 5) Mothers (Tokyo Stock Exchange, Tokyo):
• A strong framework is required for SMEs Established in 1999 under Mothers name (market
to fasten the process of raising capital at a of the high-growth and emerging stocks), to meet
low cost early stage funding requirements of venture
• Due to small size and less affordability, companies and offer investors with more
the eligibility norms, listing requirements, diversified investment products. Here the lead-
corporate governance norms and other underwriter submits a written, TSE-designated
formalities may need to be relaxed for format statement, to TSE called ‘Sponsor’s Letter
SMEs of Recommendation’ on behalf of an applicant,
stating the fact or reason as to why the applicant
INTERNATIONAL SCENARIO meets the eligibility criteria of strong growth
potential and in which of its primary field of
Globally, separate exchanges have been established business such high growth potential is observed.
to cater to the needs of SMEs and facilitate their
growth and funding requirements. From a total of 6) TSX Venture Exchange (TMX Group, Canada):
192 countries known globally, 149 have their own This exchange was formed to provide public
stock exchange. And among those countries venture capital to expedite the growth process of
roughly 57 have an alternative markets for SME new ventures. Listing in the current exchange
companies to raise funds. Some of the examples opens up the opportunity to access larger pools of
are: capital.
3
7) The Alternative Exchange (Johannesburg Stock Indonext: BSE IndoNext was established in
Exchange, South Africa): Caters to the January 2005 to benefit small & medium size
requirements of a large number of companies in all companies, the investors in these companies & the
sectors including young & fast-growing businesses capital market as a whole. Basic features are as
(such as start-ups) and family-owned businesses. follows:
• The concept is based on the Euronext
8) Growth Enterprise Market (Hong Kong, China): exchange, which was formed in 1999 by
The Growth Enterprise Market does not require merging the Paris, Amsterdam, Lisbon &
growth companies to fulfil the requirements to have Brussels stock exchanges
achieved the minimum profit levels as a condition • Investors & the companies, which are
of listing. listed only on Regional Stock Exchanges
(RSEs) have been impacted severely, as
If we look at the listing requirements of SME the volatility at RSEs is very low and they
exchanges, almost all the markets adopt an easy record insignificant trading volumes.
process of listing and maintenance requirements Investors who make investments in such
than the main market, in terms of various small & medium companies feel helpless
parameters: operating history, the minimum to take their money out due to less
number of shareholders, past financial performance volatility & unable to realize the fair value
and number of free-float shares, etc. To maintain of their investments.
sufficient liquidity, many exchanges have put • The companies listed only at RSEs face
across alternative arrangements such as market difficulty in raising finance from the
makers for liquidity. While making policies related capital markets due to improper price
to the SME Exchange in India, several of the global discovery of securities in the secondary
practices have been adopted. market. New small & medium enterprises
(SMEs) have not been able to use the
DOMESTIC SCENARIO markets to fund their plans.
4
Basis of Difference BSE SME Exchange BSE Main Board
Post-issue paid up capital Minimum post issue capital of 1 crore Minimum post issue paid up capital of 10
(face value) and maximum 25 crores crores
Minimum Allottees in IPO 50 1000
There are two important distinguishing attributes BENCHMARK: SME IPOS PERFORMANCE
between OTCEI and present SME exchanges: IN THE SECONDARY MARKET
1) Unlike OTCEI, which was standalone, now
SME exchanges are completely integrated with a Along with SME platform, BSE has set up a
particular exchange and allow easy migration from barometer index under the name BSE SME IPO to
the SME platform to the primary exchange keep a track on the performance of SME IPOs in
2) There is a 100% provision for underwriting of the secondary market. The BSE SME IPO Index is
the issue and market maker for three years after the calculated with free float methodology in line with
listing to provide liquidity (SME World 2014). other BSE indices. The number of scrips included
in the index is variable. However, at any point of
SEBI has worked hard to decide upon relaxed time, a minimum of 10 companies should be
norms regarding listing on the SME Exchange such maintained in the index. All newly listed
as issuers need not have a track record of companies are incorporated in the index and a
distributable profits. As of now, the present company which has completed three years after
procedures set up by SEBI is based on following listing is automatically excluded from it. The index
objectives: a) to protect investor’s interest by was launched on 14 December 2012 and started
keeping larger lots, to limit the participation only to trading on 18 Jan 2013. From a period of trading
informed investors, b) maintaining sufficient till 19 Oct 2017, the BSE SME index witnessed a
liquidity by provision of market making and c) huge rally of about 1085.2% which is significantly
involving a merchant banker to file red herring higher than gains in other stock indices in India.
prospectus (RHP) with due diligence certificate The performance of BSE SME Index can be seen in
with the exchange, this will reduce the time Figure 1 below, showing comparison with and
involved in the processing of issue (BSE 2011). primary index BSE Sensex:
5
Figure 1: BSE SME IPO Performance
Approximately there is a list of 207 companies’ scrips available on BSE SME website (as of 19 Oct 2017). A
snapshot of company details is available below:
Since the opening of BSE SME and NSE Emerge listed firms is important from the risk management
exchanges, BSE SME has been able to establish point of view of SME platforms as well as for
itself as a preferred platform for listing. Below investors.
graph shows the sector wise breakup of companies
listed at BSE SME. Sectoral distribution of 207 The volatility is more at BSE SME than NSE
companies reveals that primarily financial Emerge. Only half of the companies have been
companies (16, including other financial services listed at NSE Emerge till now. Here for the purpose
companies), Textiles (11) and Comm. Trading & of analysis, companies at BSE SME have been
Distribution (10) have shown interests to mobilize taken. From a total of 207 companies, ~169
resource from the market. Further, a most of the companies have been taken for the purpose of
companies belong to the services sectors which are financial analysis because the financial data of only
considerably diversified. This diversification of 169 companies for four years was available.
6
Figure 2: Sector-wise Distribution of Listed Companies
Following are the primary financial attributes which have been analysed for companies listed in BSE SME:
1. Market Capitalisation: Since these companies operate at a small level, market capitalisation
stands at an average of Rs.676m with highest being Rs.10,232m. Around 24 companies had a
market capitalization between Rs.1,000-10,500m, constituting ~14% of the total companies under
consideration. The large market cap is an indication of the size of the company. Companies with
large market capitalization usually have more assets, capital and higher revenues than those having
smaller market capitalization. Top five companies with highest market capitalisation have been
shown below:
2. Price-earnings ratio (P/E): A comparison of the P/E ratio of SME companies as on 19 Oct 2017,
24 companies had P/E ratio of greater than 100, which is an average of all companies. Investors are
generally willing to pay a higher P/E for companies whom they think will be growing at a higher
rate than the normal growth. High P/E ratio of these companies shows confidence in the investors
that these companies are on the verge of growth. Top 24 companies having high P/E ratio are:
7
Prime Customer Services Ltd 165
Suncare Traders Ltd 160
R&B Denims Ltd 159
Veeram Ornaments Ltd 157
Unishire Urban Infra Ltd 156
Relicab Cable Manufacturing Ltd 150
O. P. Chains Ltd 148
Amrapali Fincap Ltd 137
VMV Holidays Ltd 131
Karnimata Cold Storage Ltd 127
Amrapali Capital and Finance Services Ltd 126
Captain Pipes Ltd 117
Zeal Aqua Ltd 117
Poojawestern Metaliks Ltd 116
B.C. Power Controls Ltd 115
Jet Infraventure Ltd 111
Vaksons Automobiles Ltd 110
Aditya Consumer Marketing Ltd 107
Polymac Thermoformers Ltd 101
3. Revenue growth: For a number of companies listed in last three years (i.e. 2017, 2016 & 2015),
average growth in revenue from the time of listing till 2017 had been tremendous.
Listing Year No. of Companies Average Growth in Revenue
2015 32 2,088%
2016 43 1,326%
2017 44 352%
The above analysis clearly shows that post-IPO, the majority of the companies have witnessed
unprecedented growth in revenue. Difference between is a maximum of three years and such a drastic
growth is spectacular for all companies. It means that by raising finance through IPO, they have been
able to see a significant rise in their revenue. It is also an evidence of the fact that post-IPO, the
companies gain visibility in the eyes of consumers too.
4. Institutional Holdings: Mostly in 58% of sampled companies, the promoters have held more than 50%
stake in their companies. A major holding by financial institutions confirms good governance and
greater answerability, which was primarily absent in most of the enterprises. Involvement of
institutional investors, who usually take investment decisions after carefully analysing the feasibility of
business prospects of the issuers, will propel more retail investors to come and invest in SME issues
with confidence.
Net Income CAGR of ~119 companies The above analysis of publicly available financial
witnessed an average growth of 467%. attributes emphasizes the fact that there has been a
This implies that SMEs have more significant effect of IPO on companies’
opportunity with them to expand further. performance. Most of the players had sought
finance for meeting working capital requirements.
8
Here the role of exchange increases in terms of research support in partnership with various
transparency. Exchanges may also provide brokerage houses on the financial attributes of
handholding to the companies listed with them. these companies on a regular basis which will
They may also provide fundamental and technical reduce information irregularity about them.
9
Asia and Globalization, ERIA Research n%20Conceptual%20Framework%20of%
Project Report 2007-5, pp.69-97. 20Lending%20Technologies%20for%20F
Available at: inancing%20of%20Small%20and%20Me
http://www.eria.org/SMEs%20in%20India dium%20Enterprises%20by%20Indian%2
_Issues%20and%20Possibilities%20in%2 0Overseas%20Bank.pdf
0Times%20of%20Globalisation.pdf 20) Srinivas, Y. (2005, September). Bank
7) Growth Enterprise Market Hong Kong Finance to the SME Sector– Issues And
Market. (2016, May 06). Retrieved from Perspectives. Retrieved from
www.hkgem.com/ http://www.icaiejournal.org/Journal/1134_
8) Jain, R. K., Shukla, A., & Singh, K. 2005_9.pdf
(2013). SME Financing through IPOs – 21) Stock Exchange of Hong Kong. (2016,
An Overview. Reserve Bank of India May 06). Retrieved from
Occasional Papers. Vol. 34, # 1 & 2. http://www.hkgem.com/aboutgem/e_defau
Retrieved from lt.htm?ref=7%3A .
https://www.rbi.org.in/scripts/bs_viewcont 22) The Alternative Exchange, Johannesburg
ent.aspx?Id=3055 Stock Exchange, South Africa. (2016,
9) Junjie Wu, Jining Song, Catherine Zeng, May 06). Retrieved from
(2008) "An empirical evidence of small https://www.jse.co.za/capital/altx
business financing in China", 23) Tokyo Stock Exchange. (2016, May 06).
Management Research News, Vol. 31 Iss: Retrieved from
12, pp.959 - 975 http://www.tse.or.jp/english/rules/mothers
10) List of scrips and index prices. (2016, May 24) TSX Venture Exchange, TMX Group,
06). Retrieved from Canada. (2016, May 06). Retrieved from
http://www.bsesme.com/listing.aspx https://www.tmx.com/
11) Loughran, T. and Ritter, J.R. (2002), “Why 25) Vera, D., & Onji, K. (2010). Changes in
don't issuers get upset about leaving the Banking System and Small Business
money on the table in IPOs?”, Review of Lending. Small Business Economics,
Accounting Studies, Vol. 15 No. 4, 34(3), 293-308.
pp. 413‐43. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s11187-008-
12) Mothers, Tokyo Stock Exchange, Tokyo. 9119-9
(2016, May 06). Retrieved from 26) Wang, S., & Zhou, H. (2004). Staged
www.jpx.co.jp/english/equities/products/f Financing in Venture Capital: Moral
oreign/mothers/ Hazard and Risks. Journal of Corporate
13) NASDAQ OMX. (2016, May 06). Finance, 10(1), 131-155.
Retrieved from www.nasdaq.com http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0929-
14) NYSE Alternext. (2016, May 06). 1199(02)00045-7
Retrieved from https://www.euronext.com
15) Ono, A., & Uesugi, I. (2009). Role of
Collateral and Personal Guarantees in
Relationship Lending: Evidence from
Japan's SME Loan Market. Journal of
Money, Credit and Banking, 41(5), 935-
960. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1538-
4616.2009.00239.x
16) OTCEI. (2016, May 06). Retrieved from
www.otcei.net/
17) Prospectus of listed at BSE SME. (2016,
May 06). Retrieved from
www.bsesme.com.
18) SEBI. (2016, May 06). Retrieved from
http://www.sebi.gov.in/commreport/sme.p
df
19) Shukla, T. N., & Pattanaik, D. (2015,
October). A Case Study on Conceptual
Framework of Lending Technologies for
Financing of Small and Medium
Enterprises. Indian Overseas Bank.
Retrieved from
http://ijemr.in/A%20Case%20Study%20o
10