The Arup Journal Issue 2 2005 Comp

2/2005
The Arup Journal

CCTV Headquarters, Beijing ,
China: Structural engineering
design and approvals
Chris Carroll, Paul Cross,
Xiaonian Duan, Craig Gibbons,
Goman Ho, Michael Kwok,
Richard Lawson, Alexis Lee,
Andrew Luong, Rory McGowan,
Chas Pope
The Scottish Parliament

Building, Edinburgh
David Hadden, Don Henning,
Patricia Johnstone, David Lewis,
Duncan Richards, Alan Tweedie,
Simon Webster. Robin Wilkinson
Constitutional Court,
Johannesburg
Altstair Avern-Taplin
'The Hub ' Community

Resource Centre, London
Chris Trott
Making knowledge work

Dominique Poole, Tony Sheehan
Plantation Place development,

City of London
35 Plantation Place
Mick Brundle
39 Plantation Lane
Lee Hosking, Dec/an O'Carro/1
41 Plantation Place South

Graham Goymour
Miami Airport QTA:

ri sk-informed performance-
based fire protection
Richard Custer. Matthew Johann
Brian McLaughlin,
Brian Meacham, Jeffrey Tubbs,
Christopher Wood, Eileen Wood
Designing buildings for a

wireless world
Bob Cather. Alan Newbold,
Edwin Stokes
Caltrans District 7
Headquarters, Los Angeles
Eugene Desouza, Andy Howard,
Teena Videriksen
CClV Headquarters, Beijing China:
Structural engineering design and approvals
Chris Carroll Paul Cross Xiaonian Duan Craig Gibbons

Goman Ho Michael Kwok Richard Lawson
Alexis Lee Andrew Luong Rory McGowan Chas Pope
Introduction
Growth in China is happening at an historically unparalleled rate. China Central
Television (CCTV), the principal state-run broadcaster, currently has 13 channels,
but by 2008 it plans to be operating over 200 channels and competing successfully
with CNN , NBC, Sky, and the BBC in the global market. To enable this expansion,
and to place CCTV firmly on the global map, a new headquarters facility was
needed , with the entire television -making process housed in one location within
Beijing's newly-designated Central Business District (Fig 1).
In early 2002 , CCTV organized an international design competition, which
attracted some of the biggest names in architecture. After much effort it was won in 1. CCTV in the new Beijing CBD.
August 2002 by Rem Koolhaas's practice Office for Metropolitan Architecture
(OMA), based in Rotterdam , working with Arup. To secure the project, OMA formed
an alliance with the East China Architecture and Design Institute (ECADI) , which Architectural concept
would act as the local design institute (LOI) of record for both architecture and The client stipulated in the competition brief that the
engineering. Working with an LOI is a statutory stipulation for all projects in China, facility should all be housed on one site , but not
and the LOI 's local knowledge and contacts can make the relationship necessarily constrained to one building . In his
very beneficial. architectural response, however, OMA decided that
by doing just this, it should be possible to break
down the 'ghettoes' that tend to form in a complex
and compartmentalized process like the making of
'Who says that structure should not be reinvented? TV programmes and create a building whose layout
... Who says that reinventing structure cannot be in three dimensions would force all those involved -
creative?' the creative people, the producers, the technicians ,
the administrators - to mix and produce a better
Rem Koolhaas, from a discussion at Tsinghua University, 5 August 2003.
end-product more economically and efficiently.
The winning design thus combines administration
and offices, news and broadcasting , programme
production and services - the entire process - in a
The design team
single loop of interconnected activities. The
When the SD (scheme design) started , the authorities and the client , and offered specialist
project was divided between Arup offices In input such as wind and fire engineering. As the specifics of the structure evolved in tandem with the
Hong Kong and London. The core team, design progressed, additional input was received specifics of the building as they in turn evolved , a
including six staff seconded from Hong Kong from Arup offices in Beijing and Shenzhen. notable example being the placement of double-
and one from Beijing , was located in London to
This close co-operation proved invaluable in height studios within the Towers and Base, which
work closely with OMA in Rotterdam. Given the
delivering a scheme design within four months
many engineering disciplines involved, and the significantly influenced the structural form.
and the EPD and EPR (expert panel review)
need for dedicated project teams for each of the The public facilities included in the project are
approvals within a further six.
three buildings on the site, Arup had a near-
permanent presence In OMA's offices. Four of Arup provided engineering and consultancy input located in a second building , the Television Cultural
ECADl 's engineers joined the Arup team in for structural, building services , geotechnlcal, Centre (TVCC) ; both buildings are serviced from a
London for most of the EPD (extended fire, communications, and security design, single support building which houses major plant as
preliminary design) phase, while their leading the engineering design through SO, EPD
well as the site security.
architectural colleagues worked alongside OMA including the associated approvals processes to
in Rotterdam . tender, working with ECADI engineers. ECADI
Another Arup team In Hong Kong provided currently leads the production of the final
information and guidance on Chinese design and construction information and is to provide site
procedures, maintained contact with local assistance with support from Arup.
The Arup Journal 2/2005 3

Progress to construction
Given the challenging and unprecedented nature of the winning design, the
competition was followed by a further period of justification and persuasion, during
which Arup applied considerable effort at substantial risk. During the next four Express
elevators
months, feasibility studies were made and two key proof-of-concept meetings held
between the client 's technical advisors and key members of the Arup team. These
primarily addressed the safety, buildability, and overall cost of the scheme, and Tower Tower
lobby lobby
concluded that though there was no precedent for such a building , it could be
achieved . Once the client was convinced of this, contracts were signed and the
experienced international design team required to deliver the project was mobilized .
The official ground-breaking ceremony took place on 22 September 2004, but
although construction started relatively recently, it is felt that rather than wait more
than three years until completion, the fantastic story of the realization of CCTV
should start to be told now. This first article is principally a description of the
structural design , analysis, and approvals process for the main CCTV building.
Subsequent editions of The Arup Journal will contain episodes on the building
services and security engineering for the main building , on the TVCC and support Public space and ci rculation
buildings, and on the construction process to completion and opening.
The new CCTV headquarters development

The entire CCTV development has a site area of 187 OOOm 2 and will provide a total
of 550 OOOm 2 gross floor area. The estimated construction cost is around 5bn RMB
(or $US600M) , and the project as a whole (Fig 2) includes:
• the China Central Television headquarters building (CCTV building)
• the Television Cultural Centre (TVCC)
• a service and security building
• a landscaped media park with external features.
The 450 000m 2 , 234m tall (Fig 3), CCTV building consists of a nine-storey 'Base'
and three-storey basement, two leaning Towers that slope at 6° in each direction,
and a nine to 13-storey 'Overhang ', suspended 36 storeys in the air, all combining
to form a 'continuous tube ' . Viewed in other terms.the total building form can be
seen as four distinct volumes, each approximately the size of One Canada Square
in London 's Canary Wharf, two of them leaning towards each other from opposite
corners of the site, and joined at the top and bottom by the other two, both
horizontal and with opposite 90' angles in their middles.
Stud io and broad cast
400m
Jin Mao CJ Administration VIP
lounge
Tower
(420m)
Eiffel
Tower
CJ Multlbusiness
300
(320m) CCTV
Building
CJ News and broadcasting
234m CJ Broadcasting transmission
VIP
lounge
200 CJ Production
CJ Hotel
100
CJ Public facilities
CJ Service building
Canteen - + - - ' - -!!,+
VIP
CCTV
CJ Special vehicle park lobby
CJ Guards accommodation
CJ Mediapark
Central kitchen
Staff canteen
Gym
Staff and VIP facilities
2. The site layout, showing programme distribution. 3. The functions and layout within the CCTV building .
4 The Arup Journal 2/2005

Structural form
Superstructure - the 'continuous tube '

Early on, the team determined that the only way to
deliver the desired architectural form of the CCTV
building was to engage the entire fac;:ade structure,
creating in essence an external continuous tube
system. Adopting this approach gave proportions
that could resist the huge forces generated by the
cranked and leaning form, as well as extreme
seismic and wind events. 4.
This 'tube' is formed by fully bracing all sides of Principles of the tube structure: regular grid of columns and edge beams
+ patterned diagonal bracing = braced tube system.
the fac;:ade (Fig 4). The planes of bracing are
continuous through the building volume in order to
reinforce and stiffen the corners. The continuous The braced tube structure gives the leaning Towers ample stiffness during
tube system is ideally suited to deal with the nature construction, allowing them to be built safely within tight tolerances before they are
and intensity of permanent and temporary loading connected and propped off each other. The tube system also suits the construction
on the building, and is a versatile, efficient structure of the Overhang, as its two halves will cantilever temporarily from the Towers.
which can bridge in bending and torsion between
the Towers, provide enough strength and stiffness in Robustness
the Towers to deliver loads to the Base, and stiffen The continuous tube has a high degree of inherent robustness and redundancy, and
up the Base to reinforce the lower Tower levels and offers the potential for adopting alternative load paths in the unlikely event that key
deliver loads to the foundations in the most elements are removed. This was studied in detail and provides the building with a
favourable possible distribution, given the geometry. further level of safety.
Vertical cores housing lifts, stairs, and risers are
oriented and stepped so that they always sit within Substructure and foundations
the footprint of the sloping Towers. Sloping cores, The main Towers stand on piled raft foundations. The piles are typically 1 .2m in
to allow consistency of floor plate layout, were diameter, and about 52m long. Given the magnitude and distribution of the forces
considered but ruled out due to constraints on the to be transferred to the ground, the raft is up to 7.5m thick in places and extends
procurement of the lift systems. beyond the footprint of the Towers to act as a toe, distributing forces more
In addition to the cores, the floor plates of the favourably into the ground. The foundation system is arranged so that the centre of
Towers take support from many vertical columns. the raft is close to the centre of load at the bottom of each Tower, and no
Given the nature of the sloping Towers it is not permanent tension is allowed in the piles. Limited tensions in some piles are only
possible to continue vertical column lines from top permitted in major seismic events.
to bottom , so a two-storey deep system of transfer For the Base plus three-storey basement, a traditional raft foundation is used ,
trusses is used at approximately mid-height. The with tension piles between column locations to resist uplift from water pressure
floor plates of the Overhang are also supported acting on the deep basement. 15-20m long, 600mm diameter tension piles will be
by vertical columns that are transferred to the arranged under the raft with additional 1 .2m diameter piles under secondary cores
external tube structure via a two-storey deep and columns supporting large transfer trusses from the studio areas (Fig 6) .
transfer deck (Fig 5).
The continuous tube structure has behind its
final irregular arrangement a regular base pattern of
perimeter steel or steel-reinforced concrete (SRC)
columns, perimeter beams, and diagonal steel
braces set out on a typically two-storey module.
The regular base pattern was tuned or optimized by
adding or removing diagonals and changing brace
plate thickness to match the strength and stiffness
requirements of the design.
The two-storey base pattern was chosen to
coincide with the location of several two-storey high
studios within the Towers. A stiff floor plate
diaphragm can only be relied on every two storeys, 5. 6.
(a) Internal columns starting (b) Internal columns supported The foundation system.
hence lateral loads from intermediate levels are
from pilecap level. on transfer structures.
transferred back to the principal diaphragm levels
via the internal core and the columns.

A performance-based design approach
Chinese approvals p rocess

The legal framework in China governing building
design practice is similar to those of Japan and
some continental European countries where the
design codes are legal documents published and
enforced by the state government. Design
engineers must comply with the codes when
designing buildings and structures covered by their
scope, but equally the codes provide legal
protection to the design engineers who are relieved
of any legal responsibilities by virtue of compliance.
The Chinese code for seismic design of buildings
(GB50011 - 2001), sets out its own scope of
applicability, limiting the height of various systems
and the degree of plan and vertical irregularities.
Design of buildings exceeding the code must go
through a project-specific seismic design expert
panel review (EPA) and approval process as set out
by the Ministry of Construction .
Although the 234m height of the CCTV building
is within the code's height limit of 260m for steel
tubular structural systems (framed-tube, tube-in-
tube, truss-tube, etc) in Beijing , its geometry is non-
compliant. The Seismic Administration Office of the
Beijing Municipal Government appointed an expert
panel of 12 eminent Chinese engineers and
academics to closely examine the structural design,
focusing on its seismic resistance, seismic structural
damage control , and life safety aspects.
Arup realised the importance of engaging the
expert panel early in the design process, and three
informal meetings were held to solicit feedback and
Developing and optimizing the bracing pattern gain trust before the final formal presentation. The
panel was under enormous public and state
The diagonal braces within the appropriately. The distribution Changes in stiffness also
continuous tube structure of forces within the braces was changed the dynamic scrutiny to closely examine Arup's design , the
visually express the pattern of then investigated, and the behaviour of the structure and rigorous nature of which - aided by successful
forces wtthin the structure and results categorized into three hence the seismic forces that collaboration with ECADI - was of vital importance.
are an important aesthetic groups with an appropriate are attracted. Patterning
aspect of the cladding system. action applied to the braces became an extremely involved From day one the building received wide publicity in
The bracing pattern was within a particular group: iterative process. China, and concerns were voiced by both the
determined through an intense • density the mesh by adding An unfolded stress pattern general public and the government over the safety
iterative analysis and in close braces; 'doubling' view of the structure was
collaboration with the architect. of the adventurous design - indeed it came to be
• keep the same developed (Fig 8) to clearly
The principal structure of the display the results of the whole referred to by the public and the media as 'Wei
building was modelled in Oasys • rarefy the mesh by removing building in one view, or Fang ' (the dangerous building) : an indicator of the
GSA and representative braces: 'halving'. alternatively folded up into a scrutiny the project and hence Arup were under.
loading applied, including a The structure is highly 3-D model (Fig 9). This enabled
static equivalent load for a level indeterminate, so changing the the design team to visually
1 earthquake. Initially, a uniform bracing pattern resulted in a process the results quickly, Seismic requirements
bracing pattern (Fig 7) was new distribution of forces while keeping the architect As the seismic design lay outside the scope of the
adopted, and the SRC and within the columns, braces, up-to-date and involved in the
steel columns sized and edge-beams. development of the pattern. prescriptive Chinese codes of practice, Arup
proposed a performance-based design approach
from the outset, adopting first principles and state-
of-the-art methods and guidelines to achieve set
performance targets at different levels of seismic
event. Explicit and quantitative design checks using
appropriate linear and non-linear seismic analysis
were made to verify the performance for all three
levels of design earthquake.
The criteria for this performance-based design are Software
beyond those usually applied to such buildings in Many software packages Oasys GSRaft: iterative non-
China, and were set by the Arup design team in were used to deliver the linear soil-structure interaction
CC1V structural design, some analysis
consultation with the expert panel to reflect the
developed in house by Arup: Oasys Compos: composite
importance of the building both to the client and to
CSI SAP2000: limited non- steel beam and concrete slab
the Chinese Government. The basic qualitative linear structural analysis and analysis and design
performance objectives were: design with static, dynamic Oasys Adsec: composite
and push-over capability (SRC) cross-section analysis
• no structural damage when subjected to a level
Oasys LS-DYNA Environment: Oasys ADC : reinforced
1 earthquake with an average return period of
non-linear explicit time history concrete design package
50 years (63% probability of exceedance in analysis
Xtract : non-linear large strain
50 years) Oasys GSA: linear structural composite (SRC) cross-
• repairable structural damage when subjected to analysis with static and section analysis
response spectrum analysis
a level 2 earthquake with an average return MSC/Nastran: heavy duty
dynamic capability
period of 475 years (10% probability of finite element analysis
Oasys Vdisp: plug-in for GSA package
exceedance in 50 years) to analyze non -linear soil
Xsteel: 3-D CAD package.
• severe structural damage permitted but collapse stiffness
prevented when subjected to a level 3

earthquake with an average return period of 10. Non-linear finite element simulation model showing local buckling of a typical steel brace.
2500 years (2% probability of exceedance in
50 years)
For the CCTV development site, the peak horizontal The post-processor provided a revised element list which was imported back into
ground acceleration values associated with the SAP2000, and the analysis and post-processing repeated until all the design criteria
three levels of design earthquake are 7%, 20% and were met. As the structure is highly indeterminate and the load paths are heavily
40% of gravity respectively. influenced by stiffness, each small change in element property moves load around
locally. Optimizing the elements only for capacity would result in the entire load
Elastic superstructure design gradually being attracted to the inside corner columns, making them prohibitively
With the bracing pattern determined from the initial large, so careful control had to be made of when an element's section size could be
concept work, a full set of linear elastic verification reduced and when there was a minimum size required to maintain the stiffness of
analyses were performed , covering all loading the tube at the back face.
combinations including level 1 seismic loading , for To further validate the multi-directional modal response spectrum analyses,
which modal response spectrum analyses were level 1 time-history checks were also made using real and artificially-generated
used . All individual elements were extensively seismic records.
checked and the building 's global performance
Non-linear superstructure seismic design and performance verification
verified . Selected elements were also initially
assessed under a level 2 earthquake by elastic For the performance-based design , a set of project-specific 'design rules ' were
analysis, thus ensuring key elements such as proposed by the design team and reviewed and approved by the expert panel ,
columns remained elastic . creating a 'road map' to achieve the stated seismic performance objectives.
The elastic analysis and design was principally Appropriate linear and non-linear seismic response simulation methods were
performed using SAP2000 and a custom -written selected to verify the performance of the building under all three levels of design
Chinese steelwork code post-processor, which earthquake. Seismic force and deformation demands were compared with the
automatically took the individual load cases applied acceptance limits established earlier to rigorously demonstrate that all three
to the building and combined them for the limit qualitative performance objectives were achieved .
state design . Capacity ratios were then visually Inelastic deformation acceptance limits for the key structural brace members in
displayed , allowing detailed inspection of the critical the continuous tube were determined by non-linear numerical simulation of the
cases for each member. Due to the vast number of post-buckling behaviour. LS-DYNA, commonly used to simulate car crash
elements in the model - 10 060 elements behaviour, was used for this work. The braces are critical to both the lateral as well
representing nearly 90 OOOm of steel and SRC as the gravity systems of the building and are also the primary sources of ductility
sections - and the multitude of load cases, four and seismic energy dissipation. Non-linear numerical simulation of the braces was
post-processors were run in parallel , one for steel needed to establish the post-buckling axial force/axial deformation degradation
columns, one for SRC columns, one for braces, and relationsh ip to be used in the global 3-D non-linear simulation model. It was also
another for the edge beams that together form the used to determine the inelastic deformation (axial shortening) acceptance limit in
continuous tube. The SRC columns used a modified relation to the stated performance criteria. Post-buckling inelastic degradation
post-processor to account for the differences relationship curves illustrate the strength degradation as the axial shortening
between the steel and SRC codes; section increases under cyclic axial displacement time history loading. The acceptable
properties of these columns were determined using inelastic deformation was then determined from the strength degradation
XTract, which also computed the properties for the 'backbone' curve to ensure that there was sufficient residual strength to support
subsequent non-linear analyses. the gravity loads after a severe earthquake event.

5 x Sm raft Foundation design
springs
The design of the foundations required that the applied superstructure loads be
redistributed across the pilecap (raft) so as to engage enough piles to provide
adequate strength and stiffness. To validate the load spread to the pile group, a
complex iterative analysis process was used adopting a non-linear soil model.
51.Sm long,
1.2m diameter The superstructure loads were applied to a discrete model of the piled raft
piles. Load
transferred to system. Several hundred directional load case combinations were automated in a
soil at 46.Sm
below base spreadsheet controlling the GSRaft soil-structure interaction solver (Fig 11 ).
of raft
This procedure iteratively changed the input data in response to the analysis results
to model the redistribution of load between piles when their safe working load was
reached . The analysis was then repeated until the results converged and all piles
were within the allowable capacities. The envelope of these several-hundred
11 . GSRaft model of the piled foundation. analyses was then used to design the reinforcement in the raft itself.
Connections
Having established the inelastic global structure and The force from the braces and edge-beams must be transferred through and into
local member deformation acceptance limits, the the column sections with minimal disruption to the stresses already present in the
next step was to carry out non-linear numerical column . The connection is formed by replacing the flanges of the steel column with
seismic response simulation of the entire 3-0 large 'butterfly' plates, which pass through the face of the column and then
building subjected to level 2 and level 3 design connect with the braces and the edge-beams. No connection is made to the web
earthquakes. Both the non-linear static pushover of the column to simplify the detailing and construction of the concrete around the
analysis method and the non-linear dynamic time steel section.
history analysis method were used to determine the The joints are required to behave with the braces, beams, and columns as
seismic deformation demands in terms of the 'strong joint/weak component' . The connections must resist the maximum probable
maximum inelastic inter-storey drifts and the load delivered to them from the braces with minimal yielding and a relatively low
maximum inelastic member deformation. These degree of stress concentration. High stress concentrations could lead to brittle
deformation demands were compared against the fracture at the welds under cyclic seismic loading, a common cause of failure in
structure's deformation capacities storey-by-storey connections observed after the 1994 Northridge earthquake in Los Angeles. Two
and member-by-member to verify the seismic connections, representing the typical and the largest cases, were modelled from the
performance of the entire building . All global and original AutoCAD drawings using MSC/ NASTRAN. The models were analyzed ,
local seismic deformation demands were shown to subjected to the full range of forces that can be developed before the braces
be within their respective acceptance limits, buckle or yield - assuming the maximum probable material properties - to evaluate
demonstrating that the building achieves the the stress magnitude and degree of stress concentration in the joints. The shape of
quantitative and hence qualitative performance the butterfly plate was then adapted by smoothing out corners and notches until
objectives when subjected to level 2 or level 3 potential regions of yielding were minimized and the degree of stress concentration
earthquakes. reduced to levels typically permitted in civil and mechanical engineering practice.
CAD files of the resulting geometry of the joints were exported from the finite
element models and used for further drawing production (Fig 12).
MPa
0 Transfer structures
100 Whilst the external tube structure slopes to give the unique geometry, the internal
200
steel columns and cores are kept straight for functional layout and to house lift and
services shafts. This resulted in a different configuration for every floor - the spans
300
from core to fac;:ade , and internal column to fac;:ade , change on each. Consequently,
400 internal columns can be removed where the floor span decreases sufficiently on
500 one side of the core. Similarly, additional columns are needed up the building height
where the floor spans increase significantly on the other side of the core. Transfer
600
trusses support these additional columns, spanning between the internal core and
the external tube structure. They are typically two storeys deep and located in plant
floors so as to be hidden from view and to minimize the impact on floor planning.
The sizes of the transfer trusses mean that they could potentially act as
outriggers linking the external tube to the internal steel cores - undesirable as this
12. would introduce seismic forces into the relatively slender internal cores. The design
The von Mises stress distribution of a large connection plate
under the most unfavourable loading combination . preference is to keep all the seismic forces in the more robust diagrid framing of the
continuous tube. The transfer trusses are thus connected to the internal cores and
the external columns at singular 'pin-joint' locations only. Detailed analyses were
made to ascertain that no outrigger effects result from the transfer truss geometry.

13. One of several construction seq uence loading arrangements considered .
The floors cantilevered from the two leaning Towers to form the Overhang are Conclusion
enclosed by the continuous tube structure on the outside. This supports a two-way The structural design of CC1V posed many
transfer deck in the bottom two storeys of the Overhang , carrying the columns for technical challenges to the large international team .
the floors above. They were successfully overcome, within a very tight
The Base also contains major transfer trusses, spanning over the principal programme. Arup 's unique global depth of
studios to support the columns and floors above. experience and knowledge made this possible,
enabling the right people to be involved at the right
Construction issues
stages of the project . The Arup team delivered the
The building 's unique form necessitated careful consideration of the construction design through a seamless global collaboration ,
method throughout the design process. Both the method and sequencing of the transcending time zones, physical distance,
works (Fig 13) will affect the permanent distribution of dead load through the cultures, cost centres, and even the SARS
continuous tube. outbreak. Foremost in the team's collective mind
To allow the contractor some flexibility in method and programme, upper and was the need to deliver the complex design on time
lower bound analyses were performed, using staged construction and loading to for the client and in so doing win the approval of
build up the final dead load incrementally. The lowest bound of loading when the the Chinese Ministry of Construction expert panel.
two Towers are connected puts the highest stresses into the Overhang structure
since it acts as a prop between the Towers, while the upper bound puts the largest
stresses into the Towers since they carry more of the load in bending as a
cantilever. Between these two extremes there is scope for the contractor to choose Credits
his programme, and to propose alternative erection procedures. Client: China Central Television Architect: OMA
Stedebouw BV Geotechnical , structural, MEP. fire,
The timing of the connection between the Towers is also important, so as to and security consultant: Arup - Abdel Ahmed, Chuan-
minimize the relative movement between them from thermal and wind effects. It is Zhi Bai, Cecil Balmond, Carolina Bartram, Chris Carroll,
also important to minimize future thermal movements between the Towers that Wayne Chan. Mark Choi, Dean Clabrough, Paul Cross,
Roy Denoon. Omar Diallo, Mimmy Dino, Xiaonian Duan.
could put large stresses into the Overhang where it is restrained by the Towers. Gary Ge, Craig Gibbons, Sam Hatch, Guo-Bo He,
Xue-Mei He, Colin Ho, Goman Ho, Yi Jin, Jonathan
Kerry, Michael Kwok, Francis Lam, Peter Lam, Richard
Lawson, Alexis Lee. Jing-Yu Li, Zhao-Fan Li, Ge-Qing
14. Site work begins, September 2004.
Liu, Peng Liu, Quan Liu, Pierre Lui, Man-Kit Luk,
Andrew Luong, John McArthur. Rory McGowan,
Hamish Nevile, Gordon Ng, Xiao-Chao Pang, Jack
Pappin, Steve Peet, Bill Peng, Dan Pook, Chas Pope,
Oun Shi, Andrew Smith, Stuart Smith, Derek So.
G Y Sun, George Thimont, Alex To. Fei Tong,
Paul Tonkin, Ben Urick, Bai-Qian Wan, Yang Wang,
Will Whitby, Robin Wilkinson. Michael Willford, Michelle
Wong, Stella Wong, Eric Wu, Jian-Feng Yao. Angela
Yeung, Kenneth Yeung, Terence Yip, George Zhao,
Julian Zheng (analysis, geotechnical, structural)
Illustrations: 1, 9 COMA; 2 Nigel Whale; 3 -14 Arup
The nex1 article in this series, discussing the building

services design of the CCTV development, will appear
in The Arup Joumal 3/2005.
The Arvp Journal 212005 9

The Scottish Parliament
Building, Edinburgh
David Hadden Don Henning Patricia Johnstone
David Lewis Duncan Richards Alan Tweedie
Simon Webster Robin Wilkinson
From the contemplative seating in the fa9ade to the

innovative shape of the debating chamber, this is a
building for the people.
2 . Window seat in MSP 's office.
Project background
HM The Queen officially opened the Scottish
Parliament Building (SPB) in October 2004 after six
years ' design , construction, and debate - principally
about time and cost. The end result has received
much acclaim from critics and journalists, as well as
many thousands of visitors, supporting the intention
for the SPB to be a building for the people. From
the innovative shape of the main debating chamber
(Fig 1) to the contemplative seating in the fac;:ade of
the MSPs ' (Members of the Scottish Parliament)
offices (Fig 2), the vision of the Spanish architect
Enric Miralles has been realized , despite his
untimely death.
Located at the opposite end of the Royal Mile
from Edinburgh Castle, and close to Holyrood
Palace, the site encompasses an area of 1.45ha
within the old road boundaries that houses the new
buildings, plus a further 1.86ha of new landscaping .
It also contains the listed Category A Queensberry
House, where the original 1706 articles of the Union
between England and Scotland were established. It
is poignant that self-determination for Scotland has
now been established and will be practised here,
within an ensemble of individual buildings (Figs 4 &
5) that contain offices and support for the MSPs,
committee rooms, media facilities, and the debating
chamber, all above a common basement area.
In a referendum on 11 September 1997, almost
75% of Scottish voters agreed that there should
be a Scottish Parliament, and this result led to
the search for a permanent home. Holyrood
was selected , and an international competition
launched by the UK government Scottish Office on
1 . The debating chamber.

26 January 1998 to select a design team. From over 70 expressions of interest, five
were short-listed and asked to produce indicative design ideas. The contenders
were Rafael Vinoly, Michael Wilford, Richard Meier and Keppie Design, Glass
Murray & Denton Corker Marshall International, and Ernie Miralles Benedetta
Tagliabue (EMBT). On 6 July 1998 the team headed by the latter was chosen. Later,
after the Scottish Parliamentary elections, the Parliament itself became the client.
After the initial competition rounds, the architectural practice RMJM joined EMBT
in a joint venture to provide local expertise. Arup supported EMBT/ RMJM
throughout the competition and was appointed as structural engineer. Later, this
was supplemented by additional consultancy commissions in blast , well water
studies, fac;;ade engineering, and civil engineering/landscaping. In January 1999,
Bovis Lendlease was appointed as construction manager.
4. Computer image of main buildings.
Bagpipes Galore
Workin g partnerships
Press Tower
A joint venture company was formed between Arup's Edinburgh office and a London group
EMBT and RMJM in Edinburgh, with the collaborated closely on the structural design.
intention of carrying out the design in The former was mainly responsible for the
Edinburgh, but in practice Miralles created it geotechnical work and basement design, the
from his studio in Barcelona. Throughout the refurbishment of Queensberry House, 'Bagpipes
first year, Arup team members travelled regularly Galore' (a former shop whose retained fai;;ade
to Barcelona to visit him and discuss the would front a new building behind), and the
structural designs. His chosen way of working, roads and landscaping. The London group
which suited the complex shapes he was intent designed the superstructure for the new
on creating, was to produce physical models, buildings - The MSP office building, the
ranging from the whole site at small scale In Assembly buildings, the debating chamber, a
pclystyrene to large-scale details in balsa wood. further new building along Canongate, the road
Although frustratingly difficult to pin down, Enric that bounds the site to the north, and the
Miralles was a very charming man, who decorative canopies, as well as the scheme
constantly sought to improve his designs design for the glazed MSPs' foyer linking the
despite programme pressures. It was with great buildings (Fig 3). Both teams also liaised closely
shock that the team learnt of his death from a with Arup Security Consulting.
• MSPs D Clerks , chief executive and presiding officer
brain tumour in summer 2000. By then he had Whilst London staff travelled to Edinburgh for
• Administration, finance and personnel • Distinguished visitors
established the arrangements, the massing, and scheduled meetings and day-long design
the feel of the buildings - the use of fair-faced sessions, it was of great value that the
Ancillary accommodation D Circulation
concrete throughout, the carefully configured Edinburgh office and the resident engineer 5 . Site plan.
sightlines through the seemingly complex could cover all other meetings, on site or with
arrangements - and Joan Callis, his right-hand the architects, and deal with site and design
man, defended these principles throughout the issues at short notice.
remainder of the project.
The site
3. Architect's image of the MSPs' foyer.
Site history
Prior to the SPB, the site was divided into two
distinct areas, the Scottish & Newcastle Brewery to
the east and Queensberry House and its gardens to
the west. The east area had long been associated
with brewing, with William Younger II purchasing
part it in 1825 for £5000. By the late 1870s five
wells were extracting groundwater for brewing, and
records indicate that water was pumped at a rate of
4000 -14 OOO litres/ hour in 1938. Extraction ceased
in the 1960s. Queensberry House itself was built
around 1670. After a series of alterations and
changes of ownership it was bought in 1801 by
William Aitchison , who stripped it of its fittings and
fixtures. Two years later it was sold to the Board of
Ordnance and the site was developed as a barracks
and hospital block with a parade ground on the site
of the former garden. It was then that another
storey was added.

Existing and new wells
Out of 20 wells found on the main brewery site (Fig 6), six main ones, up to 3m in
diameter, had shafts up to 44m deep with bores up to 100m deep. To enhance
water extraction rates for brewing, these wells were connected to each other,
36
mostly by headers (horizontal culverts) 6m deep, though two were linked by
34 horizontal mines at 18m and 2:1m depth respectively. As they were concentrated
beneath the new debating chamber, great care was taken to expose and infill the
wells and co-ordinate foundations to avoid them .
Given the site's successful extraction history, Arup proposed to the client that
- Groundwater level
well water might provide a sustainable supply for the SPB. The firm was appointed
• Existing well to produce a feasibility study and hydrogeology report to assess the viability of this
proposal, and analyze the impact of any groundwater extraction on the surrounding
6. Conjectured rockhead levels, groundwater levels,
area. As a result, two new boreholes were sunk which yield around 5000 litres/ hour
and existing wells across the site.
each . Together with a buffer tank, they provide cooling water and grey water for
building services.
From 1815 onwards it was successively a public Basement and foundation con struction
hospital , a House of Refuge, and a geriatric hospital This involved excavation to depths of around 4m in the west and 7m in the east,
until it was finally closed in 1996 and bought by where the plantroom areas below the debating chamber and Assembly towers are
Scottish & Newcastle Breweries. Its varied life had a located . A hard/ soft secant piled wall was used for much of the excavation
significant impact on the building fabric 's structural perimeter to minimize movement felt by surrounding structures and to prevent
integrity, and it was in poor condition when handed groundwater entering. To the east, an open battered excavation sufficed , as
over to the Parliament. In 1997 Scottish & groundwater levels are lower and there are no adjacent structures.
Newcastle made Queensberry House and the land Piled walls retaining Queensberry House were designed to limit movement
to the east available for the new SPB. behind to 1Omm horizontally and 5mm vertically, due to the listed building's
sensitivity. During excavation a programme of regular monitoring was established to
Site geology and groundwater
record any movements.
The site stratigraphy comprises drift deposits (sand, The foundations are typically pad footings, bearing on rock exposed during
gravel , silt) above rock; to the west lies sandstone excavation . Where rock levels lie up to 2m below the underside of the pad
and to the east volcanic basalt. Rockhead levels foundations , mass concrete was infilled between pad and rock. Only in the south-
generally fall from Canongate to Holyrood Road, west corner were piles used, due to the low rockhead level (Fig 7) .
and particularly significant for the foundation design The basements, which lie beilow the water table, are defined in the client brief as
was the sharp dip in rockhead level in the south- a Grade 2 (better utility) space, in line with 8$8102. This requires no water
west corner, down to 6m below foundation level. penetration and to achieve this, the basement slabs were designed as a watertight
Conjectured groundwater levels were plotted and concrete structure with crack widths limited to <0.2mm. The external retaining walls
taken as the base values for design and are not designed as watertight concrete but as a drained cavity wall.
construction . During the site investigation ,
groundwater levels were recorded and subsequently
confirmed during regular monitoring of water levels 8. Stairs leading down to the MSPs' foyer.
within standpipes located strategically throughout
the site. Design groundwater levels are taken in the
long term to be 2m above the current measured
values to allow a factor of safety against future rises
in groundwater level ; the high levels in parts of the
site influenced the structural design, in particular
requiring the use of tension piles where buoyancy
exceeded the applied dead loads.
7. Foundation strategy.
Water
table
Mlnlpiles
600mm piles
Rockhead
1 2 The Arup Journal 2/2005

I j
9. Computer model of the debating chamber roof. 11. Committee room.
The debating chamber (Fig 1), some 49m long and 25m maximum width, is
The new buildings immediately above the public foyer. The floor is a major steel grillage that both acts
as a transfer structure to cope with the variable column positions above and below
The public entrance and debating chamber
this level, and allows the chamber to cantilever beyond the ground floor structure
The main public foyer is on the east side, opposite and support the heavy fa9ade and its finishes , designed to withstand terrorist
Holyrood Palace, and contains an exhibition, action. This floor is stepped and integrates the supply air systems and complex
information facilities, and a retail outlet. As the electrical installations within its depth , as well as supporting various mezzanine
'parliament of the people', the SPB opened its levels and the public galleries. All finishes are in oak and this theme is extended
public areas in September 2004, complete with upwards to the roof structure and ceiling arrangements.
guided tours. By the end of November more than Spanning across the entire space is a roof supported on major three-
130 OOO people had visited the building, making it a dimensional timber trusses with stainless steel ties and connections (Fig 9). This
considerable tourist attraction in its own right. structure is entirely sculptured and its geometry required unique nodes and bracing
The foyer is characterized by its high quality fair- systems. The roof extends further skyward on its western boundary, forming large
faced concrete finishes and , in particular, three in roof-lights that allow in considerable natural daylight. In keeping with Parliamentary
situ reinforced concrete vaults with random saltire strength and longevity, the roof materials are of the highest quality - European oak
crosses and irregular light wells, each having an for the glu-lam compression members, and stainless steel for all other elements.
individual geometry with a tapered plan section, The roof geometry coheres with the chamber shape by having the trusses
making it unique in construction terms. They form a arranged in three distinct groups, separated by discontinuity zones with changes of
dramatic ceiling (Fig 14), and contrast with the light ceiling level. This ceiling level is set above the trusses, with a steel purlin roof again
and airy spaces beyond. The vaults rest on three above, carrying the final roof finishes. The trusses are supported on a tri-girder at
main steel beams supported by high quality precast the rear of the chamber and on external concrete-clad steel columns at the inner
columns, also of unique shape and form , which fa9ade. These columns extend like cathedral buttresses from the bottom of a
required them to be cast offsite and upside down. basement light well to the top of the structure. The combination of exposed
All the concrete, whether precast or in situ , was structure and high quality finishes forms a dramatic space for the Parliament to
produced from consistent materials to ensure a conduct its business publicly and openly.
correct colour match.
Assembly buildings
10. Model of the Assembly buildings. The Assembly buildings (Fig 10) accommodate the committee rooms and support
facilities where most Parliamentary business is carried out - an ensemble through
which the MSPs pass at first floor level from their garden to the debating chamber.
Miralles likened the Assembly buildings' external appearance to upturned boats on
a Scottish shore; their geometry and interaction with each other is subtly complex
and the roofs especially so, with stepped double curvatures, achieved by structural
steelwork, reflected in the internal ceilings to give an ecclesiastical ambience
(Fig 11). These spaces contribute to encouraging collaboration rather than
confrontation.
The buildings are designed in post-tensioned reinforced concrete, principally to
achieve clear spans of up to 14m with structural depths of 350mm , thus providing
column-free spaces with minimum floor heights allowing integration of the building
services. The leading points of the buildings are truncated at the lower levels and
cantilever significantly from the main body. The floor structures and shear walls act
together to achieve these cantilevers, which enhance the spaces thus formed at
the ground floor.

The office structure comprises in situ reinforced
concrete portal frames supporting precast concrete
vault units that form the ceilings and support the
floor finishes . Alternate portal frame beams
cantilever beyond the office columns by up to 3.5m
to support the 300mm deep in situ reinforced
concrete corridor slab. The vault cross-section has
surface recesses for services distribution and soffit
recesses at the bearings, to achieve the architect's
desired effect of the vault seeming to hang in mid-
air rather than bear onto its supports.
The client preferred in situ concrete to precast
for a more robust building , so the precast vault
details include an in situ stitch allowing full
anchorage and ties, so as to achieve the necessary
robustness. The south core is close to the road ,
exposed to the risk of blast, and designed for lateral
forces far greater than normal , with the outer wall
specially reinforced to prevent a local breaching.
12. Entrance to the Canongate building showing the first floor cantilever and the Zen Garden.
Blast also influenced the design of the western
fac;;ade's precast backing panels, which needed
The Canongate buildings careful reinforcement detailing to achieve the
The Canongate buildings abut the formal entrance that allows the public to view the required degree of blast resistance in thin panels
buildings and look into the MSPs' foyer, and complete the perimeter of the northern with a large irregular opening .
boundary. The wall is of precast concrete elements embodying several scribed
panels. masonry units from the original buildings, and a reproduction of a drawing
of Edinburgh Old Town made by Miralles during his first visit to the city.
Above the entrance the building cantilevers by up to 14m, achieved by
integrating a double-storey height vierendeel truss on both sides into the fac;;ades .
The trusses are in steel to minimize creep deflections, and also support secondary
steel beams spanning between them to provide column-free space inside. The steel
I-sections forming the trusses have concrete cast into and between their flanges to
create a high quality exposed finish between the windows on the interior side,
consistent with the concrete finishes throughout the rest of the Parliament. Post-
tensioned anchorages secure the steel structure to the reinforced frame behind ,
controlling deflection and dynamic movement. The roof comprises steel beams,
close-centred purlins, and profiled metal decking designed for blast protection.
13. Computer-generated view of an MSP's office.
At first floor level on the Canongate side, a balcony known as the Zen Garden is
supported by steel beams cantilevering from the north vierendeel, with posts for the
balcony wall in turn cantilevering vertically.
The Canongate building is directly adjacent to the road and has therefore been
designed for bomb-resistance. Arup Security Consulting provided equivalent static
forces for the design after assessing the building's stiffness. The forces are resisted
by plate action of the slab , and thick reinforced concrete core walls. The building is
founded on large pad foundations bearing directly on rock, and under the cores,
the mass of concrete has been increased to resist uplift from high lateral loads.
The MSP building

The 129 MSPs work in a six-storey linear building parallel to Reid 's Close along the
site's western edge. Their cell -like offices (Fig 13), each with a protruding window
seat, are along the western fac;;ade , and corridors along the eastern edge, with
views of the garden and the MSPs' foyer, connect them to cores at each end of the
building . An additional escape stair, cantilevering from the building side at its
midpoint, links the top three floors to an escape corridor at the third floor
connecting to the south core. The cores also give access to the garden level and
the basement car park below.
14. The public foyer concrete vault seems to hang in mid-air.

- -- -- -
15. Upper and lower pergolas and the north-east canopy.

- -
Canopies and pergolas The architect required the canopy and the lower
The main public entrance is framed by a complex of three structures. the upper and pergola to have exposed concrete to all faces.
lower pergolas and the north-east canopy (Fig 15). Both pergolas are supported by This had to be considered in conjunction with the
conical 'flame-shaped ' columns that match others in the SPB . Their stocky forms requirement for a 100-year design life, and
act as cantilevers and resist moments from the upper pergola. The columns are concerns about the long-term appearance of the
carried on pad footings designed to resist overturning moments. concrete when viewed from overlooking windows
The upper pergola is a 58m x 9m grillage of stainless steel hollow sections finally led the architect to agree to cladding the
covered by a random arrangement of 'bamboo' (actually Scottish oak), suspended upper surface of the canopy. For the lower pergola
6m - 8m above ground by raking stainless steel hollow sections . The pergola acts beams stainless steel reinforcement was specified ,
as a vierendeel on plan to take the horizontal forces to the flame-shaped columns to reduce the risk of unsightly staining in this highly
and the raking props cast into them . Ties from the tips of the flame-shaped visible structure.
columns to the tips of the raking columns were introduced to control the deflections
at the extreme ends of the pergola, where the cantilever length is around 9m.
The 'lower pergola' is a grillage of fair-faced concrete beams running along the
whole east fa9ade of the SPB , approximately 5m above ground level. This was
designed to be constructed in situ but was re-designed in conjunction with the
contractor as precast beams.
The north-east canopy is a concrete slab, curved in section and cantilevering up
to 9m from the building, taking its principal support by hanging from the pergola
above it and with its backspan disappearing into the main building . It is further
complicated by the presence of an opening , through which one of the flame-
shaped columns passes, thus preventing the canopy taking direct support
from the column (Fig 16).
Although the canopy would deflect significantly under dead load, this was not
seen as a problem as no partitions, cladding , or other fittings were affected , and
the already curved shape made the deflection visually insignificant. The canopy was
designed for a live load of 1.5kN/ m2, with a deflection limit of span/ 500 in case of 16. 'Flame-shaped ' column passing through canopy opening.
unintentional pedestrian loading , perhaps from political protesters!

Fac;ades
Introduction
Arup Fac;;ade Engineering (AFE) was initially
appointed for three months to support
EMBT/ RMJM on two critical cladding packages,
the foyer roof and the specialist glazing , but its
involvement grew into other areas of the project.
Ultimately three separate teams were contracted for
the MSP building elevations, the precast concrete
elements, and the next phase of the specialist
glazing and foyer roof packages.
Foyer roof
Previous work on Portcullis House, Westminster,
with its many similarities in design life requirements
and bomb blast protection , was extremely valuable,
whilst designs developed for the 'lens' at City Hall,
18. Feature panels on the fac;ade of the Assembly tower.
London , also proved useful in achieving the required
flush outer glazed face that would also deliver good
panel retention against lateral loads. The design Specialist glazing
principles progressed through workshops with
This had a much wider scope than the foyer roof package, including glazing to the
Mero, the specialist glazing subcontractor, and were
debating chamber, the bridge that links it with the Assembly towers, and the
then developed through detailed design with Arup
complex shapes enclosing the public stair from the foyer to the end of the bridge.
Security Consulting. The installed cladding (Fig 17)
In addition to specific blast requirements for the specialist glazing , the walls and
is largely unchanged from these initial principles.
rooflights to the debating chamber also had very onerous acoustic performance
criteria to limit road noise penetration . The eventual design employed double-glazed
units, with acoustic damping and blast protection performance, built into the
17. External view of foyer roof.
laminated unit construction , combined with acoustically enhanced curtain-walling
profiles. This system is one of the best performing double-glazed walls yet
developed , and was empirically tested prior to manufacture, to demonstrate
performance in practice.
MSP building
Originally tendered as one package, the east and west fac;;ades were repackaged
into different elements including the timber windows, structural steelwork, stainless
steel , concrete mullions, timber louvres, and stone. Interfaces between the
packages and the wide palette of materials were further complicated by variations
in detailing throughout the fac;;ade, which affected the weathering line of the
envelope. Combining the demanding bomb blast requirements with effective
thermal performance involved extensive use of condensation risk analysis. The team
also advised on other features , including rooflights and the tower windows.
Precast concrete
The cladding to the debating chamber, press tower, and boundary walls was
technically very challenging , and required AFE involvement throughout. A key issue
was its behaviour in the event of a blast - the panels have to stay on the building!
Others included the complex geometry, fixing , buildability (and handling) , and many
intricate interfaces with other fac;;ade elements. Aspects considered in the designs
included durability, robustness, weathertightness and interface with the weathering
envelope, and thermal performance. The cladding also includes fenestration
elements such as large feature panels (3.5m to 5.5m high) of granite and oak louvre
grills (Fig 18), and bamboo panels fixed onto steel carrier frames that stand proud
of the precast cladding (Fig 19). Bespoke concealed brackets and fixings were
designed and fabricated to accommodate the different tolerance requirements,

Blast consultancy
Introduction
In December 1998 a meeting took place between
the architect, Arup's structural team, and the
Government Buildings Counter-Terrorist Protection
Advisor to discuss how protection against terrorist
bomb attack could be incorporated into the design.
The need to add a blast consultant to the project
team was subsequently agreed with the client, who
noted Arup 's capability in this field and asked for a
proposal to advise the design team.
In March 1999 a two-stage blast consultancy
appointment was added to Arup's involvement.
Initially this work was centred in another of the
London groups , where experience of blast effects
had been enhanced by extensive involvement in the
aftermath of the city's major vehicle bomb attacks
19. The complex fa<;:ade assemblies dramatically contrast with the rugged natural backdrop.
of the early 1990s1 . The later stages of the blast
consultancy were conducted under the banner of
dimensional variations, and movements between the precast and steel elements. Arup Security Consulting (ASC) , formally launched
Other features include cast -in natural stone, and intricate architectural face in July 2001 .
mouldings, formed with rubber mats. AFE worked closely with the architects in The initial blast consultancy scope included:
assisting to review the sub-contractors' design development, production, • liaison with Government security advisers
installation and quality control , all aiming to achieve a high quality, architectural • outline guidance to the design team on blast-
precast cladding envelope. resistant design
• review of scheme design proposals with respect
Canongate walls to blast protection
At several places in the Canongate boundary walls, the architect designed panels • working sessions with the design team on blast-
of natural stone inset, and in places recessed, into the precast faces. Some were related issues
cast in , which required care to avoid blemishes. The other method was to post-fix • advice on blast-resistant design for incorporation
the stones into cast recesses, where the challenge was to ensure secure and into the architect's design intent drawings and
robust fixings. Many of the natural stones were hand-carved with inscriptions or specifications for elements of the fa9ade.
patterns (Fig 20), and the Canongate boundary walls as a whole, with these Subsequently the following were added :
intricately shaped and sculpted inserts, required complex structural support and • ongoing reviews of the design team 's developing
casting techniques. design and tender documentation
• review of tenderers ' and contractors'
submissions with respect to blast issues
20. The Canongate boundary wall. • site inspection of selected elements of the
building envelope with respect to blast
protection.
In due course ASC's involvement extended to
include regular onsite workshops with the architect,
construction manager, and subcontractors whose
work packages included blast protection measures.
Application of blast protection measures

Government security advisors identified zones of the
complex in which 'standard measures' for blast
would apply and others where 'enhanced
measures' were deemed necessary. In the former,
the initial approach was to adopt, where possible,
relatively straightforward design rules for structures
and fa9ades without the need for complex blast
analyses. In 'enhanced measures ' areas, these

Windows
In buildings for which blast protection is a design criterion , glazing is often the most
critical issue in mitigating potential hazard to occupants. At distances from an
explosion where human bodies may survive airblast effects without serious harm ,
glass fragments can cause seveire, even lethal injuries. The value of laminated glass
in mitigating fragmentation is well established and its use in the innermost leaf of all
external windows is now mandatory for new UK Government buildings. A library of
proven blast-resistant glazing configurations exists for conventional fixed windows
over a limited range of sizes, but: the challenge at SPB was to achieve similar levels
of performance in windows with unique geometries or which used natural materials
and in some cases had to be openable for maintenance or to provide natural
ventilation. Through close collaboration with the architect, trade contractors and
AFE, solutions were developed to match these apparently conflicting requirements
21 . Test arrangement for MSP building west elevation window. with EMBT/RMJM's aesthetic objectives.
Conceptually, openable windows seem contradictory to blast protection.
However, as natural ventilation was fundamental to the design of certain parts of
design rules were to be augmented by explicit the building, workable solutions had to be found . 'Slam-shut' windows, which can
analysis of structures and fac;:ades under blast be opened outwards a limited amount for ventilation, were developed in which the
loading , which itself was to be derived from a openable casement would be forced to close by the blast shockfront. Leakage
specified weight of explosive material and a stand- studies were made of the likely internal pressures from the external design
off distance appropriate to the element under explosion should the casement somehow be prevented from closing. These
consideration . While for a more conventional showed that although internal pressures immediately inside the windows would
building the prescriptive 'standard measures' inevitably be high , they would quickly fall to values below the recognized threshold
approach might ensure an acceptable degree of for eardrum rupture. In the few locations where this criterion could not be achieved ,
occupant protection, the challenging geometry and mechanical ventilation was introduced.
palette of materials of the SPB meant that a more
rigorous approach was often necessary, and not Blast testing of windows
only in the 'enhanced measures' zones. Designs for many of the windows and other glazed elements of the building
To evaluate the intense but very short-lived envelope were developed with confidence in their performance under blast loading.
airblast pressures created by a high explosive In certain cases, for example windows with irregular glazing shapes or timber
detonation, extensive use was made of ConWep 2 , a frames or 'slam-shut' configuration, full-scale physical trials were carried out to
US military program to which ASC has access prove their blast resistance.
through its involvement in UK Government projects.
ConWep's blast pressure time-histories were used
to analyze dynamically the global behaviour of
complete structures, or local effects on individual
building elements or areas.
The approach was not to seek to avoid damage
entirely under these extreme conditions, but to
ensure that it was within acceptable limits that
would still provide appropriate protection to building
occupants. The analysis and design of structural
elements in steel and concrete was based on
US methods3, while assessment of glazing
behaviour under blast load drew on the analytical
procedures and extensive database of test results
built up by the UK Government's own explosion
protection team.
22. MSP building west elevation winalow.

The arrangements generally adopted for such range
tests involve attaching the test sample to the open
front of a closed cubicle to prevent the blast wave
from wrapping around the target and applying a
relieving load on its rear face (Fig 21). The SPB
trials, which ASC supervised , identified weaknesses
in certain localized details but ultimately through
successful tests proved the 'blastworthiness' of the
final designs (Fig 22).
9/11 and The Holyrood Inquiry

The attacks on the World Trade Center and the
Pentagon on 11 September 2001 were undeniably
defining moments in the history of terrorism . They,
and subsequent world events, have profoundly
influenced perceptions of risk and concerns about
security. The UK has a lengthy history of terrorist
attacks, not least against government-related
facilities and, as noted earlier, the requirement to
24. Queensberry House after refurbishment.
provide blast protection was included in the 1998
brief for SPB and the blast consultant's role was
established well before 9/ 11 . After it, the principles
of occupant protection against terrorist attack
Refurbishment and landscaping
remained fundamentally unchanged - a point
Queensberry House
recognized by Lord Fraser in his lnquiry4 : ' .. . I am
persuaded by the evidence that the events of 11 Because of the age and history of Queensberry House, Historic Scotland wished to
September 2001 were not the catalyst to a retain and incorporate as many existing floors and joists in the refurbishment as
wholesale review of the security requirements on possible. However, its poor condition, the many alterations, and the need to carry
the site nor were they responsible for an escalation modern office loads and provide blast resistance, resulted in just two timber floor
in the standards of protection required to meet a areas being retained . All others were replaced with a modern concrete and steel
previously unforeseen terrorist threat.' floor system, as thin as possible to allow finished floors to match existing door
In his Inquiry Lord Fraser decided to consider thresholds and stairs without the ceiling dropping below the tops of the windows.
security issues but elected to do so by taking Holes in the beam web allow service ducts and pipes to pass through to avoid
evidence in camera from those most closely providing a separate service zone beneath . The new floors provide robustness and
involved in this aspect of the project, including ASC. diaphragm action as well as acoustic and fire separation, and add strength ,
Commenting on how the blast consultant's task durability, and dynamic performance.
was fulfilled, Lord Fraser was 'satisfied as to the The walls within Queensberry House are generally stone-built , rubble-filled , and
thoroughness and professionalism with which this up to 700mm thick, but in many places alterations had resulted in brick and
work was undertaken by those involved'. blockwork being introduced as new openings were formed or existing ones closed
off. This also led to a variety of lintels, with precast concrete or steel joists alongside
the original timber ones, or openings without lintels at all. Cracks became evident
once plaster and finishes were removed . Some had formed during earlier additions,
Sock expansions
into soft fabric core and unbridged butt joints had opened up due to settlement and movement.
Major remedial works were needed. The outer and inner wall leaves were tied
Anchor body
together with special grouted anchors for local strengthening, and wall panels were
dependent on load similarly connected into return walls to ensure overall stability. The latter was mostly
but normally 15mm,
20mm, or 30mm where later extensions were built with no ties to the original frame ; the new anchors
square hollow
section bridge the old butt joints , tying the various elements together (Fig 23) .
Such major works on Queensberry House were not originally intended, and
additionally the team was instructed fairly late to design the new/old roof (Fig 24) .
The final appearance of the roof was based on a contemporary sketch of the
Edinburgh skyline discovered after extensive archaeological research, together
with other old artworks, further buildings of the era by the same architect, and
anecdotal evidence.
23. Wall stitching with grouted anchors: length, number,

and position dependent on structural condition .

25. The SPB in its setting of new landscaping.
Landscaping
Conclusion
Landscaping spills out from the built area of the site
into the park south of Holyrood Road. As well as These fascinating and highly varied buildings are characterized by two common
roadworks within the park, upgrading two themes: high quality, fair-faced concrete and complex geometrical shapes, both in
roundabouts and Queens Drive to cater for the overall building outlines and in individual elements such as the 'flame-shaped'
increased traffic flow once Holyrood Road was columns and the boundary wall.
closed to public traffic, significant earthworks were Already popular with visitors and set to become a major landmark in Edinburgh,
needed to establish new topography south of the the Scottish Parliament was a major challenge for Arup in its complexity, its scale,
site and east of the neighbouring Dynamic Earth and its ever-changing requirements. The firm helped to deliver a unique project that
building. The result is publicly accessible landscape, includes 11 buildings - each with its own individual character - contains more than
with embankments, canopies, water features, cycle three times the area compared with the competition, and was presided over by five
paths, footpaths, hard areas, newly-planted trees, different clients during the six years since it was won. The same period also saw
and indigenous flora (Fig 25). the untimely death of the Scottish leader Donald Dewar, very much a driving force
Level differences within the new landscaped behind the Parliament, as well as Enric Miralles. It is hoped that both would have
areas were of paramount architectural importance been satisfied with the reality of their vision.
and were achieved using stone encased behind a
steel mesh. Corrosion, weathering, durability, and
structural stability all had to be addressed in
Credits
developing a solution for the Scottish climate.
Architect: EMBT/RMJM Construction manager: Bovis Lendlease Quantity surveyor: Davis
Dressed stone in properly designed, specified, and Langdon Structural, civil, fa9ade, geotechnical , blast and landscaping engineer: Arup -
constructed gabion baskets met all the design Joan Anderson , Francis Archer, Tom Barr, Monika Beyersdorff, Daniele Bosia, Mark Bowman,
Geoffrey Burns, Sam Cook, Rob Davis, Brian Edie, David Guild, Tony Gulston, Arjan Habraken,
criteria for retaining purposes.
David Hadden, Don Henning, Graeme Herd, Mark Holst, Fred llidio, Patricia Johnstone,
Hiroshi Kawamura, Gavin Kerr, Rob Kinch. Ken Knowles, David Lewis, Joan Lindsay, John
McDonald, Andrew Millar, Stewart Millar, Astrid Muenzinger, Hamish Nevile, Steve Peet, Chas
Pope, Stephen Ratchye, Mark Reed, Duncan Richards. Volker Schmid , Annalisa Simonella,
David C Smith, Peter Stevenson, Alan Tweedie, Simon Webster. Gary Wilkie, Robin Wilkinson
Building services engineer: RMJM Specialist glazing subcontractor: Mero Structures Inc
Illustrations: 1, 2, 11 , 18, 19 Arup/Adam Elder/ Scottish Parliamentary corporate body; 3, 4, 10,
13 EMBT/ RMJM ; 5-7, 23 Arup/ Nigel Whale; 8, 12, 20, 25, 26 Arup/ Roland Halbe; 9 Cowley
Structural Timberwork; 14, 16 Arup/ Peter Cook/VIEW; 15 Arup/Paul RafteryNIEW; 17 Arup;
21 David Hadden/Arup; 22 Don Henning/Arup; 24 Ken Knowles/Arup
References
(1) HADDEN , D. Building in blast protection. The Arup Journal, 33(3), pp20-23, 1998.
(2) HYDE, OW. ConWep Version 2. 1.0. 1. USAE Engineer Research & Development Center, Vicksburg ,
Mississippi.
(3) US DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY. Technical Manual TM5-1300 . Design of structures to resist the
effects of accidental explosions. Washington DC, 1990.
26. The garden landscape. (4) LORD FRASER OF CARMYLLIE, The Rt Hon, QC. The Holyrood Inquiry. Scottish Parliamentary
Corporate Body, 2004.

Constitutional Court, Johannesburg
1.
Alistair Avern-Taplin new democratic institution. The brief was to develop
Looking south-east: The
the entire precinct of the chosen site as library's precast fac;;ade is on
'Constitutional Hill' - a public space for the city and the left, and the Rex Welsh
Library tower prominent in the
On 21 March 2004 South Africa a symbolic place for the nation where the foreground . The Great African
Stairs rise towards
Constitutional Court and various other aligned
celebrated 10 years of democracy, institutions such as the Human Rights Commission
Constitutional Square
and the Court entrance, with
and to mark the occasion would be accommodated alongside museums, the exhibition Gallery to their
left and Sections 4 and 5 on
President Thabo Mbeki officially appropriate retail, and residential accommodation, the right. On the far left is
Hillbrow Tower, an Arup
some of which would be accommodated in the
opened the new Constitutional historic prison buildings. While the competition
project from the 1960s.
Court in Johannesburg. focused on the Court building , an appropriate

setting for the new elements within the entire site
was also called for.
Introduction The winner, a joint venture between OMM Design
The Constitution of the Republic of South Africa is Workshop and Urban Solutions, was announced in
the new democracy's supreme authority, and April 1998. They were asked to recommend the
passed into law in 1996. It includes a Bill of Rights remainder of the professional team and chose Arup
and serves to ensure that political powers are as civil , structural , and mechanical engineer. Key
exercised within a framework of constitutional reasons were Arup 's reputation for innovative
constraints, irrespective of what might be intended structural design and experience in sustainable
by the Parliament. To safeguard the Constitution , building ; the Zimbabwe practice was to fulfil a key
widely considered the most progressive in the role in designing a passive cooling system . Arup
world, 11 judges were sworn in. was also appointed as project manager to provide
The process to construct the Court started in strategic advice to the client only, and subsequently
late 1997 when the Department of Public Works the firm was engaged for the full project
launched an open international design competition management and civil and structural engineering
for an appropriate architectural expression of the roles for the entire Constitutional Hill precinct.

The historical area
The precinct contains several historically significant
buildings, including The Fort and ramparts, The
_\L The Women's Gaol
In 1909, a new Women's Gaol was built directly east of
The Fort, the handsome red brick building that remains
today. It held both black and white women, but in
Awaiting Trial Block, Sections 4 and 5 'Number Four', separate sections. The vast majority of inmates were
and the Women 's Goal. Constitutional neither murderers nor freedom fighters. but ordinary
Court Hill brow women arrested mainly for pass offences or for making
~u
The Fort and ramparts
At the centre of Constitution Hill is The Fort surrounded
by its ramparts , originally built between 1896 and 1899
by the Boer president. Paul Kruger, as an act of defiance
.:r£rr _\n lfr:o
Four'
Tower
0
an independent income from beer brewing - illegal
because the state controlled the sale of liquor to blacks
through its beer halls. Sometimes they had small
children or babies with them. This was especially true
against the might of imperial Britain, and a way to keep
during the late 1950s, when black women were arrested
watch over the uitlanders {foreigners) in the mining Awaiting .............. ,
Trial ____.::"· : in large numbers when they deliberately presented
~ =--c:-in~---,:~? nj
village of Johannesburg, who were plotting an overthrow Block :.......... .. ..... themselves to the police without passes.
of the Boers. In 1900, during the Anglo-Boer War, the The Fort
British took Johannesburg, and imprisoned Boer soldiers The Commission on Gender Equality, an official body
in The Fort. A group of Cape Afrikaners who had fought that looks after the rights of women , took offices in the
l
on the side of the Boers were executed at The Fort,
killings that marked the beginning of its long history as a e-=
~~~~===~ Women's Gaol in 2003. An exhibition detailing the lives
and experiences of three very different women who were
place of punishment, confinement and abuse, and incarcerated in the gaol is on display in the oval atrium
Johannesburg's main place of incarceration for eight that is at the centre of the building.
decades. \ ~ Orn
The Fort is entered from the south through a set of huge
doors that lead through a tunnel. Prisoners passed into Constitution Hill in a nutshell
Section 4 and 5 'Number Four'
a reception area and were then sent to a 'delousing
room' where they were stripped and sprayed with cold Most South Africans know the whole prison complex The old Fort area bordered by Sam Hancock, Hospital,
water, before being moved to the Awaiting Trail Block. simply as 'Number Four', a term which symbolized Kotze and Joubert streets will become an anchor and a
Once convicted , they were incarcerated in The Fort if courage and fear, the cruelties and indignities of symbol of Johannesburg's inner city regeneration. Apart
they were white men, in the Native Gaol if they were colonialism and apartheid, and the prison system in from the Constitutional Court, the new precinct will also
black men , and in the Women's Gaol if they were female. general. In 1902, Section 4 and 5 of the prison replaced house statutory bodies and a thriving complex of
the native gaol built in 1893. 'Number Four' is to the heritage sites and museums, exhibition and performance
The Awaiting Trial Block north of the ramparts and west of the new Constitutional spaces, offices, shops, restaurants and other tourist
All prisoners went through the Awaiting Trial Block. For Court. It contained the general cells for black male facilities. It will be an engine of growth and
two weeks, the 156 Treason Trialists of 1956, led by prisoners where violent criminals, pass-offenders and transformation for downtown Johannesburg - and a
Nelson Mandela, were held there, as were the scores of political prisoners were incarcerated side-by-side. At the place where visitors can feel safely the heartbeat of this
activists held for three months during the 1960 State of extreme north of Number 4 are 24 punishment cells, vibrant city. The precinct will also be home to one of
Emergency, and hundreds of teenagers held after the which contained men who had committed an offence South Africa's major public art collections. To this end an
Soweto Uprising of 1976. All these groups were kept in inside the prison such as trying to escape. These cells Artworks Project for acquisition of art for the Court and
special communal cells. In these horribly overcrowded also held men with infectious diseases like smallpox, public environment has been initiated.
cells for common criminals, new inmates were inducted juveniles, and men with mental illnesses.
The entire precinct will , in fact, become a 'living '
into the brutal life of prison. They were often robbed, Section 4 and 5 is in a state of extreme disrepair, the museum. Visitors will be able to visit The Fort. At the
attacked and even raped by members of the 'Numbers' paint peeling off its walls, and its courtyards covered in entrance, off Kotze Street , one exhibition already being
gangs who exist to this day. A visitors' room was elephant grass and weeds. It forms a vital heritage staged depicts a short history of the prison complex,
connected to the Awaiting Trial Block, the only place of component of Constitution Hill, and will not be tampered whilst another shows a society in transition , looking
comfort for the prisoners. This has also been dismantled with or renovated. It is the dark heart of the precinct, back at the difficulties of the past and the possibilities
to make way for Constitution Square, but will be rebuilt , giving visitors a salutary sense of what prison life must of the future.
perhaps as a visitors' centre for the precinct. have been like.
A law library with IT links to the world

The Constitutional Court library of 40 OOO books is set to
grow by 10 OOO a year until it reaches 400 OOO volumes,
making it Africa's most important law reference site, and
one of the most significant in the world . It has also
launched the most comprehensive legal virtual library in
Africa. which will carry the full text of every major court in
South Africa and later all courts in sub-Saharan Africa
that carry the electronic text of court judgements.
The library subscribes to all major English law reports,
and to those of the German Constitutional Court, three
of the German Federal Supreme Courts, and certain
French public law reports. The court holds 130 different
law report series.
The virtual library has an Internet portal that provides a
single point of access to the library's resources. Materials
can be searched for and viewed online, and printed or
downloaded.
3.
The library, showing its ramped floors ; the entire
structure is suspended from a portal at roof level to
avoid columns in the basement.

4.
The stairs in the exhibition gallery, leading to the foyer in the
distance. The Great African Stairs are outside the glass doors on
the right and the administration area to the left behind the wall.
Site selection and history The Fort was thus an ideally symbolic site for the
All 11 Constitutional Court judges were from the start actively involved in the site Constitutional Court. To transform the prison would
selection. Enabling the eventual building users to choose its location was an act of physically and visually dramatize the contrast
empowerment, and contributed greatly towards feelings of inclusivity and between a past of 'untold suffering and injustice'
ownership. The judges warmed to the opportunity and considered several potential and the future of 'democracy and peaceful co-
sites. in Pretoria and Midrand as well as Johannesburg, but eventually settled on existence' , as the postamble to the Constitution
the run-down The Fort precinct on the northern face of Braamfontein ridge in puts it. More importantly, the decision to house the
Johannesburg, the apex of the Witwatersrand region and bordered by the inner-city Court in inner-city Johannesburg also signifies
neighbourhoods of Hillbrow and Johannesburg. confidence in the idea of a truly shared democratic
How the site was chosen set the tone for the whole project. The judges would public space arising in urban post-apartheid
be actively involved throughout, and the design team welcomed this. As the project South Africa.
unfolded, the design's success rested less and less on pure technical ability and After the site was selected and secured , it was
increasingly on responsive relationships established across professional and decided that a public competition would be the
disciplinary boundaries. Thus South Africa 's most prominent symbol of democracy most appropriate and democratic way of choosing
was born out of a largely democratic process. a design; after negotiations, The Fort precinct was
The 12.5ha site is physically accessible and prominently situated, and was seen donated by the Greater Johannesburg Metropolitan
to have the potential to catalyze the regeneration of Johannesburg's central Council to the Department of Public Works.
business district, but the judges selected it above all because of its rich symbolism. Constitutional Hill will also house the Museum of the
Originally built in 1893 as a military defence outpost, it developed into a penal Constitution, a constitutional library, and various
institution - significantly designed by Sytze Wierda, official architect of the South democratic institutions like the Human Right
African Republic, who also designed the parliament and supreme court building on Commission , the Gender Commission , and the
Church Square, Pretoria. Over the years, many of those fighting political and social Public Protector. In accordance with mixed use
oppression were incarcerated in the The Fort prison, the history of political struggle design principles, Constitution Hill will also include
bestowing on it the doubtful honour of being the only prison in the world in which market, work, and living spaces.
both Ghandi and Mandela were locked up.

Existing 4 & 5 gaols 8 Internal walkway
2 Great African Stairs 9 Foyer
3 Exhibition arcade 10 Court

4 Rex Welsh collection 11 Reference library
5 Public auditorium 12 Judges' chambers
6 Administration 13 Existing sub-station
7 Council robing and 14 Judges' lounge, conference

meeting rooms and comitee room
6.
The winning concept

Though right in the heart of the city, from its inception the site had been insular and
deliberately inaccessible, so it had to be connected to the neighbouring precincts,
with emphasis on pedestrian movement. Another priority was to design a building
that would benefit from the rich and complex legacy of the site, and also important
was the notion that in a democratic society civic buildings 'can either gain their
symbolic value by expressing the openness they present' or they can be 'alienating
monuments' (SA Architect, August 1998). OMM Design Workshop and Urban
Solutions sought 'the power of a pre-eminent building , without monumentality'.
The result was a series of terraces stepping down the steeply-falling site, facing
due north and thus misaligned with both the Fort and the other prison buildings.
The topography and the misalignment generate the 'Great African Stairs', which
taper as they ascend southward to the foyer and Court at the head of the complex,
aligned parallel to the Fort. Paved with bricks from the demolished Awaiting Trial
Block, the Stairs are like a stitched seam between the new Court building and
Sections 4 and 5 of the old prison to the west.To fulfil the architects' own objective
of interweaving past with future, stair towers of the former prison buildings were
retained and incorporated in the new complex, and materials like bricks were
retrieved and recycled. This approach is echoed in the principles for energy
conservation, whereby interior comfort in the building is largely achieved by
harnessing the advantages of the high diurnal range experienced in Johannesburg. 5. 7.
Apart from the Court chamber. which is air-conditioned, an internal summer Detail of artwork screens on Looking east on the north
the exhibition gallery side of the site, with the
temperature no higher than 26°C is achieved, 6- ?°C below the ambient elevation, by the top of the library on the right behind its
temperature. Similarly the Court is designed not to need acoustic amplification. Great African Stairs; precast fa~ade, and the first
Constitutional Square and of the judges chambers
The public faces of the building engage with passers-by through the various the Court entrance are wings on the left. Between
artworks and mosaic cladding. Sun-baffles and screens too are endowed immediately ahead, and is the link between the
Sections 4 and 5 on the left. administration building and
artistically, and shelter is provided by indigenous trees. the library.
24 The Arup Journal 212005

The Constitutional Court building
8.
The building has six main zones: The Court chamber: a
• the Court foyer - the public entrance into the glazed acoustic reflector is
suspended over the judges'
building and an extension of the most public and counsel benches. The
area of the site, Constitution Square bricks forming the dry-
stack wall were salvaged
• the Court chamber, where the judges sit, and from the demolished
judicial debate is conducted in public Awaiting Trial Block.
• the Judges' chambers, the private area where 9.
the judges, their secretaries and researchers From The Fort's ramparts:
In the foreground is the
have their offices; these areas are in a cloistered foyer, with the 'light tower'
courtyard, not accessible to the public built over a staircase
retained from the Awaiting
• the administration wing, where most of the Court Trial Bock. The Court
staff work chamber is right of the
foyer.
• the library, where most of the Court's research is
undertaken in what will be the most advanced
and largest collection of human rights material on The administration wing links the foyer, Court chamber and library on a north-south
the African continent axis. The exhibition gallery doubles as an internal public walkway that parallels this
• the exhibition gallery, where permanent and wing immediately to the west. It is enclosed but largely transparent internally to the
temporary art exhibitions will be on display in an administration offices and externally to the Great African Stairs.
extension of the public areas of the building. The Judges 'chambers are east of the administration wing in a series of office
The Court chamber and foyer, in the south wing , are suites on three floor levels. All north-facing and overlooking a courtyard to the east
directly accessible to the public from Constitution (which is framed by the Court building and the Hillbrow substation on the eastern
Square, whilst the library, forming the north wing , is boundary of the site) , these suites are separated from the administration wing by an
also partly open to the public. The two most public inner walkway, a light, triple-height space with timber decked bridges at different
functions are therefore the most visible, and located floor levels that afford the judges private access to each other's rooms and to the
to enable easy access. Court chamber and the library.

10. completely open and undivided, using changes in floor level to define the areas for
The entrance foyer to the Court, showing sloping columns,
'bar code' openings in the roof slab, and the curved the judges, counsel, and the public - on open terraced seating. Galleries are also
concrete wall with triangular openings, all in off-shutter provided for the press and for visiting judges. The enclosing walls are substantial
concrete.
and, towards the south-east corner where the first of the old Awaiting Trial Block
stair towers shapes the chamber, are packed with bricks removed from this
Language demolished building and set aside for reuse. At the street level of Constitution
In the Court building the architects sought to Square externally, a narrow ribbon of glass, about 30mm high, is inserted into the
communicate through the language of its form what south and east walls of the chamber.
it is about. And this expression shifts, with the The people of the Court can be seen going about their business from both the
different functions accommodated. internal public walkway/gallery along the western edge of the building and the Great
The timber entrance doors to the foyer of the African Stairs outside. A ramped pathway set within the Stairs zigzags between the
court building stand 8m high. The space is formed contours of the site - a meandering but easier alternative walk. Celtis africana is
in concrete, though largely transparent to the being planted along the pathway to shade people on the Stairs. The internal
exterior, populated by slanting columns, and alert to walkway/gallery is also ramped in part, and stepped, to negotiate the gradient of
the movement of the sun with skylights cast as the site. The entire west fa9ade is glazed, and protected by steel screens, with
slots at various angles into the concrete roof slab doorways all along it. People can choose to walk outside or to go in to shelter from
and closed by projecting glass boxes externally. the weather or to view the art.
One of the stairwells of the old Awaiting Trial Block The twin-roofed north wing, which houses the library, is expressed as 'a box of
projects into the space, unrestored and a direct filtered light' . With its concrete screened fa9ade, modulated by vertical timber-clad
reminder of what this place used to be. A small area bays, and rising three storeys internally - though standing five storeys high from
of the basement level of the old building is exposed ground level at this point on the site - it is the most visible component of the Court
below the foyer floor level. building from the north. The library symbolizes knowledge, wisdom and
A second set of tall timber double-doors, enlightenment , and this idea is emphasized in the 'tower of light' that forms its
detailed with hand-worked brass inlays, lead to the north-west corner, where the Rex Welsh Library of antiquarian law books will be
Court chamber. Here the internal space is housed.
The judges' chambers, by contrast, are on a domestic scale. Each suite includes
office space for the judge, a secretary, and two legal clerks.

Sustainability Materials
The architectural concept is expressed both through
the structure and deliberate choice and use of
n I
n materials. With extensive use of off-shutter concrete
in slabs, soffits and columns (a choice initiated by
Passively Daytime heat is Night air flushes
cooled and purged from through building the mechanical requirement that almost all surfaces
filtered fresh rock with cool cooling room
air to building night air surfaces be radiant so as to contribute to thermal storage)
particular attention was paid to the quality of
i=====::i I I shuttering and consistency of concrete. There is
also a good deal of exposed timber and steel, in the
form of composite roof trusses and suspended
walkways and decks. Merbau timber was chosen
as it is the world's only commercially grown and
harvested hardwood with the required coloration. It
Fresh air Fresh air
intake intake is used not only as a finish for floors , handrails and
Cooling mode Sam - 2.30pm Summer night flush mode 11 pm - 6am ceilings, but also as a composite member of the
roof timbers and walkway support structure.
Extensive glazing maintains a sense of openness
and transparency, a special system being
Air receives developed where bespoke extruded glazed
preheat from
previous aluminium frames are bolted to galvanized structural
afternoon's heat steel members. Bricks from the demolished
within rocks
structures were used both for dry pack and
, ~---~ I I Fresh air straight-jointed panels, and black African slate floors
combines with
recirculated warm were installed in homage to the many other
air from building
to save on winter government buildings that have over the years used
heat bills
the same material for this purpose.
Cooling mode 2.30pm - 6pm Winter morning preheat mode Sam - 11 am Credits
Client: South Africa Department of Public Works Client
project manager: Johannesburg Development Agency
11 . Rockstore operation modes.
Arch itects: OMM Design Workshop and Urban Solutions
Multidisciplinary engineer and project manager: Arup -
While the north/ south orientation of the main along the library wing also contribute (minimally) Alistair Avern-Taplin, Peter Basson, Colin Chanraya, Trevor
public spaces of the Court building and of the to cooling the intake air. Mechanical fans drive Chetty, Errol Davison , Safiya Desai , Shaun Dixon, Anthea
judges' chambers is most appropriate for cooler air in summer or warmer air in winter du Preez, Nicholas Featherston, Clive Fick, Ingrid Gardner,
passive or low energy climate controls , the from the rock chambers through channels in the Krish Govender, Lee-Zane Greyling , Roger Hayim, Andy
easVwest orientation of the administration wing floor plenum to floor-mounted outlet vents, to Howard, Jack Jaza, Roy Jones. Kim Leach, Rob Leach,
(which suited the urban design requirement for a moderate the internal temperature . The system Roy Morris, Ephraim Mzimase, Linda Ness, Jayanti
perimeter building) necessitated some climate works in conjunction with steel ventilation Odhav, Michelle Pakes, Ash Parshotam , Mike Rainbow,
mitigation. This is evident in the screens to the chimneys on the roof of the administration wing. Martin Schindler, James Senior, Errol Shak, Rael Smith,
glazed west fac;:ade, and in the layering of the These ex1ract hot air from the interior by natural Con Strydom, Liesl Strydom, Elvira Tessa
internal space that sets the administration stack effect, and are fitted with fans to Quantity surveyor: Hamlyn Gebhardt, Koor Dindar
services back from the west wall, inside the accelerate its release. (The internal ventilation Main contractor: Wilson Bayly Holmes (PTY) Ltd,
temperature mediating zone of the public shafts also house rainwater downpipes and Rainbow Construction Structural engineer: Sibanye
walkway. electrical cabling.) Consulting Engineers Mechanical engineer: Toon
Herman Associates Electrical engineer: Van Der Walt
In consultation with the mechanical engineers
and the client, it was decided that a rock store
r
The rock store system can take 6- off the
Barry Wet services: DSB Consulting Civil Engineer
extremes of outdoor temperatures to create a
system should be used to provide a low energy Acoustic consultant: Acuslov Landscape architect :
more moderate interior climate. Internal
means to control the building 's interior climate. African Environmental Design Fire consultant: LJK Fire
temperatures are then generally within the 26'C
In principle, this increases a building 's thermal Engineering Consultants Illustrations: 1, 3, 5 , 8
maximum defined by international office
storage capacity, enabling it to store coolness Hi Shots ; 2, 6, 11 Nigel Whale; 4, 7, 9, 10
standards; commonly remaining at around 23·c.
(absorbed from the cold night air in summer) or Angela Buckland
heat (from warm day air in winter), which can It should be noted that some supplementary
then be transferred to the interior spaces. It provisions were required. Conventional
mechanical air-conditioning services the
relies on a climate which has a high diurnal
temperature range - as exists in the Highveld. basement archives (to ensure a stable
environment for archival material) as well as the
About 55Qm3 of packed rocks are held in 14 court chamber, auditorium, and training room .
separate subterranean systems extending 200m These latter spaces are designed for gatherings
along two sides of the basement car-park of people and a passive climate control system
perimeter. Shallow ponds outside the judges' would be inadequate to manage the physical
chambers and a wider, deeper water trough body heat generated by such numbers.
The Arup Journal 212005 27

1. 'The Hub' in its urban South London setting.
'The Hub' Community The client's brief required that the

building should be inviting, user-
Resource Centre, friendly, with universal appeal to

help create vitality in its function.
London Chris Trott
Introduction Team response

'New Deal for Communities' (NDC) is a UK Government programme designed to The first thing was to hold a socially inclusive public
tackle social exclusion and renew some of the country's poorest and most deprived consultation , which identified the needs to be
neighbourhoods. A central feature of the plan is to put communities themselves at fulfilled . The resulting programme focused on
the heart of decision-making, and to this end 39 NDC partnerships have been providing space to support the economic situation
established in England, 10 of them in London. One of these, in the borough of and community facilities in the area, and the
Newham, is the West Ham and Plaistow NDC, and an early outcome of its delivery subsequent conceptual design prioritized the
plan was to identify the need for three new community resource centres (CRCs). project's environmental responsiveness. In parallel ,
Arup has been engaged for all three. 'The Hub' in Eastlea is the first; it opened the team evolved a business plan to ensure
in October 2004 , with Woodlands CRC following in mid-2005. The third is intended that 'The Hub' remains economically viable
for North Plaistow. For 'The Hub' Arup was appointed as business planning , throughout its life.
structural, building services and building physics consultant. working with
Eger Architects. Building form and layout
The projects are all strongly community-oriented and designed on sustainable The site is some 1OOm long by 20m wide. The need
principles. They are innovative and , together with the other elements of their for an appropriate scale to the building in the
delivery plan , have helped this particular NDC to become one of the most highly- context of the surrounding residential area. together
rated of the 39. with a 'right to light' envelope, constrained its
height. This proved quite challenging, particularly in
The brief view of the amount of new accommodation that
The client wanted the design to 'be of a high quality standard , inviting and user- was required. The site had previously
friendly, with universal appeal to help create vitality in its function . The design accommodated garages which, together with their
should include the following elements as a guideline: hard-standings, were removed, as was an existing
• be an imaginative landmark scheme derelict house.
• be innovative in types of materials used The building form was also driven by the need
• include energy efficiency in terms of external and internal design functions for significant and very diverse areas to
• use materials for self-sufficient energy and/or to sell on energy accommodate business start-up units (BSUs) , a
• have flexible and spacious internal floor space standards cafe, a pharmacy, a nursery, and a multi-purpose
• embody internal and external security measures. ' community hall , as well as being significantly
influenced by energy and renewable materials
considerations.

Carbon optimization of form Rainwater storage Opening rooflights
collects from roof
Skylights
Early in the design , studies were made of how this
l
Wintergarden (not
could be constructed as an environmentally Planted heated generally)
sunscreens
responsive, carbon-optimized building. This process
Exposed concrete soffit
addressed the simultaneous beneficial use of providing thermal mass Natural and intermittent
mechanical ventilation
daylight and solar gain to warm the building by
Condensing boiler
using well-positioned windows, glazed elements, for additional heat
and wintergarden zones. The analysis led to Planted

Fa~ade: sunscreens
recommendations for the orientation and size of integrated
PV cells
windows, and setting appropriate levels of insulation
Natural ventilation
to minimize carbon impact.
Harvested rainwater
This allowed the form, orientation, and overall
mass of the building to be developed within a
-Jw- Renewable electricity
'Ground-coupled '
rigorous conceptual framework designed to ensure Piled foundations used to minimize heat transfer loop
'excavated' material and temporary
optimum user comfort, excellent daylight, and works due to high water table ....... Heat storage and
recovery
minimized energy use. The resulting design gives
Local underfloor heating
high levels of insulation to the permanently
occupied accommodation, which surrounds a 2. Energy-saving structural and services concepts .
transiently occupied wintergarden that is partially
heated in winter. An ETFE (ethylene
tetrafluoroethylene) roof covering to the Structural systems
wintergarden was felt to be justified because the After considering the merits of a concrete structure with thermal storage properties
space below is not heated fully and because the that could have provided further passive cooling and heating, and which would
material used is fully recyclable. have been designed for extended life, the team decided that the nature of the site
and the building required a more lightweight treatment. A structure that could be
Choice of structural and services systems demounted and reused (or recycled) was therefore adopted , though it was
Having ensured that the building 's passive design recognized that the potential for reuse elsewhere (or if this proves not possible,
was optimized , the building systems were then reuse of parts or recycling) was only possible for the superstructure.
chosen with the aim of further reducing As the site was overlain by 2.5m to 3m of moderately contaminated fill , the safe
carbon impact, via both carbon in use and working practice of capping and leaving in situ was adopted . Methane was
embodied carbon . detected during the site investigation, and this required mitigation through suitable
ground slab design and following the best practice guidance in CIR/A Report 149 1•
A pile solution was adopted, which allowed all the fill material on site to be
3. Upper level walkway and offices beneath skylights.
retained and avoided the environmental penalties of considerable muck-shift and
the associated embodiment of carbon in the sub-structure. Should the site again be
redeveloped , the piles could be reused for residential or similar buildings. The
ground-bearing slabs contain 30% of cement replacement material to reduce the
quantity of cement required .
The structural frame is in steel , with suspended slabs of precast concrete;
encased floor beams were avoided, and a minimal concrete cover to the precast
slabs was used to simplify future dismantling. The steelwork is punched with its
designated size and grade, and jointed by bolting to allow it to be easily identified
and dismantled in the future.
Services systems
The ventilation is mixed mode. When weather permits, occupants can use natural
ventilation , drawn in through the external windows and passing via internal windows
to the wintergarden , from which it exits at high level. At other times modest levels of
fresh air are introduced via heat pumps.
As well as having windows, the south fac;:ade is clad with photovoltaic (PV)
elements. This has several merits. It provides a renewable electrical supply to the
ground-coupled heat pumps, nominally sufficient for their annual supply, and also
acts as a rainscreen with a cavity behind, allowing air to be drawn into the heat
pumps in cold weather, having recovered waste heat from the PV elements. In
addition, it provides shade in summer to the business start-up units. The windows
have retractable shades so that the occupants can harvest useful solar gain in
winter when the sun is low.

Optimum Worst Case
4. The public face of 'The Hub ': street entrance to the cafe. 5. SPeAR diagram showing 'The Hub's 'green credentials' .
Because the BSUs were developed to allow for a high degree of cellularization , and Sustainability assessment
IT-intensive users were expected , a modest level of cooling was deemed In support of the PV funding application, a
appropriate in those areas, albeit only to limit internal temperatures to a maximum sustainability assessment was carried out , using
28?C on design days. Various heating and cooling systems were considered , Arup 's SPeAR~ methodology to demonstrate its
and a ground-coupled heat pump system was chosen as it offered minimum sustainable credentials. The building 's primary foci
carbon impact and also allows the BSUs to be heated as required. Eight 150mm on strengthening the local community's economic
ground bores along the northern border of the site were drilled 80m deep to take base through the provision of business start-up
heat from and discharge to the surrounding ground. opportunities and providing a wide range of services
The remaining areas of the building have no mechanical cooling, and are to the community are clearly evident from the
heated either by radiators, or in the case of the partially-heated wintergarden, assessment, where the socio-economic indicators
via underfloor units in the cafe 's seated area. A condensing boiler provides boost demonstrate that the project priorities have been
and back-up heating. successfully met.
Water conservation features include low consumption fixtures and fittings in toilet
areas, with a root irrigation system for the planted walls. A rainwater storage tank is Summary
provided below the children 's external play area to the nursery and is expected to 'The Hub' began with a clear vision, and the brief
contribute to a saving in mains water of around 50% pa. Harvested rainwater is and design process flowed directly from that. It
used for toilet flushing and plant irrigation. opened to the public in October 2004 , following
Electrical systems include the PV arrays on the south fac;:ade, which feed the four months of fitting out by various tenants. It is
building 's main distribution board with power, offsetting around 20% of the total operating successfully and its design and
demand. Metering arrangements allow for export of power to the local grid development have produced useful feedback for the
when demand is below the building 's requirements. Low-energy luminaires are subsequent CRCs in the delivery plan.
used throughout.
Business planning and photovoltaic funding application

The functional planning was informed by a business plan which Arup developed to Cred it s
ensure that 'The Hub' has a sustainable future post-handover. By an iterative Client: New Deal for Communities Architect : Eger Architects
Multidisciplinary engineer: Arup - Simon Bourne, Dave Clarke,
process, spatial planning focused on maximizing the higher-value areas of the Ed Clarke, Ulrike Elbers , Andrew Fraser, Lesley Graham,
project. Capital costs, rental incomes, operating costs, and consumables costs, Richard Harpin, lnka Heile, Stephen Hill, Carole Large,
together with appropriate risk profiling, were built into the business plan at concept Wolfgang Muller, Vicky Potts, Les Stokes, Gareth Thyer, Cyrus
Toms. Chris Trott. Julie Wood Illustrations: 1 , 3, 4 Arup/
sign-off stage, after which the client took over detailed development of the business Dennis GilbertNIEW; 2, 5 Lesley Graham
planning framework directly.
The building systems design described above contributed to making the
business plan sustainable, and it is anticipated that energy and water consumption Reference
costs will be reduced by around 50% as a result. (1) CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY RESEARCH AND
INFORMATION ASSOCIATION . Report R149. Protecting
On behalf of the client , Arup also compiled the funding application for the PV development from methane, by GB Card. CIRIA, 1996.
installation to the UK Department of Trade and Industry-funded major PV grant
scheme. The project was awarded the maximum possible grant of 70%.

Making 'Mistakes are valuable guides,
they should not be forgotten or concealed.
knowledge work Rocks and reefs are charted on maps

as a warning to sailors,
shouldn't we do the same
with our mistakes and failures?'
Dominique Poole Tony Sheehan Ove Arup, Doodles & Doggerel
Introduction Approaches to managing knowledge

Managing knowledge within organizations has Knowledge Management (KM) requires the integration of expertise in people,
become increasingly difficult in recent years. process and technology to create business benefit. It applies skills drawn from
Decisions must now be made at greater speed, areas as diverse as business strategy, IT, information science and organizational
against more aggressive global competitors, and in effectiveness. As a result successful KM is difficult to achieve. Many organizations
the face of greater volumes of information than ever have struggled with the selection of appropriate KM tactics amidst a maze of
before. In this context, appropriate knowledge must potential solutions.
be applied consistently, to avoid the increasing In practice, the choice is relatively straightforward: Firms seeking to innovate will
threat of litigation and to deliver increased value to focus more on KM techniques that support creativity by creating strong networks
clients. The potential rewards are considerable; between people, whilst firms seeking to deliver standardized products will tend to
when knowledge is managed successfully, focus more on systems and processes (Fig 1).
organizations create value in the market-place At Caunton Engineering , a UK-based steelwork fabricator, managing knowledge
through their ability to deliver the best of the firm , through strong adherence to procedure enabled by technology enables good
drawing on the most appropriate skills. productivity. By contrast, the US-based design consultancy IDEO has a culture of
'If I have seen further it is by standing on the freedom and empowerment which allows individuals to apply their knowledge as
shoulders of Giants' , wrote Isaac Newton to fellow effectively as possible in order to support innovation with minimal constraint by
scientist Robert Hooke in 1676. What Newton procedure. Arup combines both approaches to ensure that knowledge
meant was that his own scientific and mathematical which supports both innovation and standardization processes is shared and
advances owed much to the knowledge and reused effectively.
discoveries that had been made by others before
him. The challenge is not to repeat, but to learn
from the past and to improve on it with each Standardization
iteration. The same is true for today's organization,
where one key resource is derived from an ability to
learn from one project to the next. At the same
time, organizations must offer something extra, and
People to people
I People to process
must develop new solutions faster than competitors Communities Project teams
so as to innovate from a position of confidence and Creativity Efficiency
informed judgement.
1. Innovation vs stand ardization.
Within Arup, the goal of mobilizing expert knowledge occurs in Types of knowledge
two ways:
• Individual experts can be found through 'Arup People,' an When managing knowledge, a distinction is commonly drawn between knowledge
award-winning tool which provides access to the declared that is tacit (associated with skills and experience in people's heads) and that which
expertise of individuals together with documents such as is explicit (in documents or databases). Both must be managed if organizations are
their CV.
to be successful, but the emphasis will vary according to the business focus.
• Networks and communities of experts in various fields help to
provide a focus, sharing knowledge and responding to Explicit knowledge to support standardization needs to be captured , articulated ,
questions in a range of technical areas, and helping to ensure documented, and stored in electronic databases for reuse at a later date. Tacit
that knowledge flows readily across the firm.
knowledge, by contrast, is highly personal; it is the skills and expertise acquired
through experience, and thus is strongly linked to the context in which the
knowledge exists. It is difficult, if not impossible to capture and reuse tacit
knowledge, but using it effectively is nevertheless essential for companies seeking
to maintain a competitive edge.

In Arup the challenge of storing and accessing basic data Many people have become too busy to reflect, overloaded with information to the
about its ever-growing number of projects has been met for extent that they are forced to rely instead on the information at hand (Fig 2).
decades by a searchable project records system, initially
founded in the 1960s using physical methods like edge- This gap must be closed if people are to work more effectively and deliver their
punched cards. This system has subsequently employed ever- full potential. To thrive, organizations must combine three key activities in a way that
more sophisticated computerized techniques to keep pace supports business needs:
with user needs and demands, which now enable it to
embrace a far wider range of explicit knowledge about the • embed explicit knowledge into processes
firm 's projects by integrating existing systems such as the • mobilize tacit knowledge through people finders, networks , and communities
image library. • create the right environment for decision-making through effective team -building ,
decision support tools, and training.
Embedding explicit knowledge into processes recognizes that , to be competitive,
organizations must deliver good practice and comply with certain basic procedures.
To emphasize the greater potential value of tacit versus explicit In some cases these procedures can also be a legal requirement - compliance with
knowledge, consider a recent study of a firm of 6000 people. health and safety and other legal obHgations, for example. Capturing and
The storage capacity of the firm's databases amounted to embedding such explicit knowledge can be achieved by various methods - for
some 40TB {terabytes) of explicit knowledge: data and
information {1TB = 1000GB). By contrast, the storage capacity example, through Word macros, letter templates and standard letters of
of an individual's brain exceeds 4TB of tacit knowledge with appointment - all requiring expert knowledge to be translated into rules and
context . Effectively the information and data stored in the firm 's procedures that can be applied across organizations. Technical knowledge can be
database is equivalent to only 10 people, illustrating the
potential power of an organization that can fully mobilize its integrated into processes through calculation plans, standard details or
tacit knowledge in practice. spreadsheets - a simple example in the corrosion protection field is the translation
of a 30-page British Standard into a two-line interactive spreadsheet. This
translation allows a less-experienced engineer to benefit from the knowledge of an
2 expert, minimizing the chances for mistakes on a project, and enabling people to
The effect of information growth on reuse templates, sound in the knowl!edge that they are building on past experience
our capacity and desire to learn. Information
overload rather than reinventing the wheel.
Whilst application of standardized knowledge is valuable, mobilizing tacit
knowledge is essential for more innovative projects and organizations to ensure that
creativity is not curtailed. In today's increasingly dispersed organizations, it is
Capacity and
desire to learn essential to network effectively to ensure that clients receive the best knowledge of
the firm, rather than the best available in a given location. This may be by finding
Time
experts or by networking people together by communities of practice; groups of
individuals working on separate projects but united by common interests. The
The combination of explicit knowledge in potential value of communities is immense, as they provide a powerful means of
databases, and the recruitment of the best staff knowledge exchange, allowing people to ask questions, search for answers, and
with exceptional tacit knowledge, are both key KM receive training from experts in their chosen field.
goals. The additional challenge for any organization Having created a knowledge base, the challenge is then to create the right
seeking to manage knowledge effectively is to environment to ensure consistent and appropriate application of this knowledge .
ensure consistent application of the right knowledge How do we encourage individuals to make the right decisions at the right place and
at the right time in a way that creates value for time? The answer ultimately lies in such factors as an organization's culture, its
clients. It is about making knowledge work; enabling ways of working , and knowledge sharing. In many ways, this requires attention to
people to make the right decisions, combining the factors that are rooted in the past; mentoring, coaching, teaching and learning.
best of their own knowledge with the best
knowledge of the organization and wider industry at
any given time.
Working effectively
Whilst the goal of knowledge work seems relatively
simple, increasing pressure on individuals has made
the effectiveness of today's knowledge worker
questionable.
A key skill for designers has always been the
need to balance urgency in decision-making with
the ability to pause, reflect, consult, and deliver the
best possible quality of response to clients. Perhaps
the greatest challenge to effectiveness in this type
of work is that the rapid growth of information in
recent years has started to exceed the capacity -
and indeed the desire - of individuals to learn.

Individual Organization encourage creative thought and knowledge
• Work/Life • Increased productivity
exchange. The metaphor of the mediaeval
• Stress management • Agility monastery is a good example of customized space,
• Interesting work • Differentiation providing a variety of environments for different
knowledge needs. Cloisters were spaces geared to
accidental contact, and certain conventions were
adopted in their use. For example, monks would
walk in pairs to discuss issues, but an individual
walking alone holding an open breviary was
understood by others to be meditating. Similarly the
UK Government Communications Headquarters
(GCHQ) building in Cheltenham, England , has been
designed to promote the exchange of knowledge to
aid the global 'war against terrorism ' . The threats of
terrorism require different ways of working , with a
new emphasis on knowledge sharing and the ability
Young engineers working alongside their more experienced peers need the to create serendipitous links and to form
opportunity to learn by observing, by listening. By doing this, they can acquire multidisciplinary quick-response teams. Open-plan
valuable skills, such as managing risk and learning from failure , progressive offices , hot desking , spaces with comfortable sofas,
problem-solving, self-organization , and interpersonal skills. In the present economic artwork, and statues have all been incorporated to
environment all this is becoming harder to achieve, as increasing workloads and stimulate creative thinking and encourage open talk.
tighter budgets drive many firms towards ways of optimizing performance,
increasing productivity, and eliminating unnecessary activities. There is a danger Conclusion
that increasing workloads prevent senior staff from devoting sufficient time to junior Successful organizations of the future will make
staff. In the short term , this may achieve cost savings and improve efficiency, but knowledge work for their clients better than ever
the long-term consequences are alarming - lack of knowledge transfer runs the risk before. Clients will come to organizations
of repeating mistakes that are well known to experienced staff. demanding access to the best experience rather
than merely the best available. They will expect
Looking to th e future people to deliver current good practice through
Effective KM demands that organizations consider: appropriate processes, supplementing this with an
• how best to recruit, develop, and retain the best people ethos of improvement and innovation . Client
• how best to combine the skills of individuals expectations will continue to rise, and organizations
• how to create distinct capabilities in an increasingly competitive business that fail to match these standards will not survive.
environment To thrive in the future , organizations must
• how to create value for clients and communicate it effectively. manage knowledge strategically, developing an
Recruiting the best people is essential to sustain competitive advantage, yet ability to recognize and exploit new market needs
remains a particular challenge in the engineering sector where increasingly talented through effective combinations of skills and
individuals are being lured into purely commercial and financial firms where better- interests. Arup, for example, has already applied
paid careers may be on offer. In the face of such competition for talent, expertise developed in the germ warfare sector to
organizations must recognize the need to engage individuals, recognize their needs, address the spread of disease in hospitals, and
and respond to these to ensure people are happy to work for the organization finite element analysis developed in the building
rather than merely being employed to do so. In recent years, the difficulty in sector to car design. The key challenge will be
recruiting good staff has put individuals in a much stronger position. People are responsiveness , and the ability to combine existing
now more likely to hire organizations than vice versa. skills and interests from unexpected sources in
People expect to be involved in interesting work, to achieve an appropriate ways that create client value . Knowledge will still
balance between work and home life, and to be treated fairly in terms of rewards of have to be managed - not just to solve today's
recognition. Ultimately a split has emerged between individual and organizational business problems, but to ensure that organizations
priorities resulting in the need to strike a balance. continue to generate new capabilities for the future.
The future will see people as increasingly key to effective KM and business
performance. Organizational pressures to achieve increased productivity, greater
agility, and competitiveness in the marketplace can only be achieved if knowledge is Credits
Tony Sheehan is Group Knowledge Manager for Arup.
managed and applied in ways that complement the needs of the individual. The
Dominique Poole is Knowledge Project Manager at Arup.
knowledge challenge is to successfully achieve this balance between organizational Illustrations: 1, 2 Nigel Whale; 3 Ng Choon Boon;
needs and individual motivations (Fig 3). 4 Philippe Pellerin
Organizations must , therefore, consider how to get the best from the people
they recruit , addressing such diverse issues as culture, motivation , and the
workplace itself. The physical space in which people work offers opportunities to

Plantation Place
development,
City of London
Plantation
Lane
Plantation
Place
Plantation Place
South
1. 2. Plantation Place and St Margaret Pattens viewed from

Id Eastcheap.
One of the largest new projects in the heart of the City The development also incorporates a new
pedestrian route, Plantation Lane, which cuts east-
offers over 100 ooom2 of internal floor space and yet
west from Wren 's church to Mincing Lane. The
avoids overwhelming the adjacent historical buildings. creation of this route - a combination of art,
architecture and urban design - embeds the new
building into the grain of the ancient city and
enhances the urban context. One side is marked by
Plantation Place, designed by Arup Associates for the British Land Company, is one an integrated artwork, also designed by Arup
of the largest new projects in the heart of the City. Comprising almost an entire Associates in collaboration with artist Simon
block, the 1ha site is bounded by Fenchurch Street (north), Mincing Lane (east) , Patterson , depicting the surface of the moon, while
Rood Lane (west) and Eastcheap/ Great Tower Street (south). Christopher Wren's the natural stone pavement is inscribed with text.
grade 1 listed church of St Margaret Pattens occupies the south-west corner, This newly-created route acknowledges the City of
together with an 18th century town house now used as an office. Another office London 's rich historic fabric , reflecting the medieval
building , 51 Eastcheap, remains on this part of the site, adjacent to the church . street pattern.
The Plantation Place development comprises two buildings. The larger, itself The proximity of the site to the River Thames and
known as Plantation Place, and built along Fenchurch Street, has 15 storeys plus its location outside the City's cluster of tall buildings
three basement levels, giving a total of 78 300m 2 gross internal area above ground, set the maximum height. This, coupled with various
including 2300m 2 of net retail at ground level. It has various floor plate sizes and view studies and rights of light agreements, defined
uses ; levels 2 and 3 may be fitted out as trading floors providing 490Qm2 net of the envelope profile of both buildings. Of special
contiguous office area on each floor. The second building , Plantation Place South, concern were the close views of the tower and spire
is 10 storeys high and provides some 22 500m 2 gross internal area. of St Margaret Pattens from Great Tower Street.
Here the upper mass of the building is set back and
this, together with the glass cladding reflecting the
sky, avoids overwhelming Wren's design.

Plantation Place
Mick Brundle
The overall form

The overall architectural form developed in response
to the site's complex constraints, but was also
conceived as a positive contribution to the civic
realm in this part of the City. Through a series of
adjustments in plan, angled cuts and set-backs, the
building transforms itself from the street-defining
base and reinvents and fragments its form as it
ascends, culminating in a pair of glass cube forms
in the skyline. The resulting composition , while
accommodating the very considerable programme,
disseminates its volume into its immediate
surroundings. It is seen from the surrounding streets
not as a single object but a series of vignettes.
The stratification of the building vertically, into
street architecture below and deep setback terraces
of smaller office floors above, suggests two fa<;ade
types and provides the opportunity for opening
windows for fresh air and garden terraces at the
upper levels.
4. The Plantation Place atrium.
3. Plantation Place building anatomy.
The internal anatomy

The Fenchurch Street entrance is defined by a change of alignment of the existing
street pattern , which together with the recycled and critically-acclaimed Marketing
Suite Beacon ', establishes the building 's presence when viewed from the
Gracechurch and Lombard Street part of the City.
A pair of Jura limestone-clad towers framing the glass entrance screen provide a
cordon sanitaire between the office entrance and retail areas, which occupy most of
the ground plan . A double-height entrance hall leads via a wide Jura limestone
staircase to a 43m high central atrium . A dematerialized glass bridge connects
together the first floor levels and provides a dramatic threshold before entering the
atrium interior.
The offices are on either side of the atrium , with two cores to each side
containing lifts that serve all floors and escalators at the rear to the lower levels. The
cores also contain services risers. staircases and washrooms, and allow easy
access to all parts, particularly the larger floors , so walking distances are minimized.
In section the atrium is stepped towards the south on the upper levels, bringing
daylight and sunlight deep into the lower level. This configuration provides a more
usable contiguous floor plate arrangement at the upper levels; the atrium forms the
centre of a U-shaped office floor at levels 7 to 9 and is bridged over completely at
levels 10 to 14.
Service access for both buildings is from a vehicle entrance in Rood Lane. A
two-way ramp provides access to an upper basement level with head clearance for
large trucks and refuse vehicles. There is parking for 46 cars at this level. Two
further basement levels, the middle and lower basements, contain plantrooms and
tenant storage. An additional plant room is provided at level 15.

~
The fa9ades
' ···-
The cladding design represents a long-standing interest by Arup Associates in
.. ..
environmental design, occupant comfort, and a 'layered' approach to architectural
far;:ades. The two main types described combine these aspects, incorporating
... ...
various passive and active solar control devices and simultaneously creating a
Double
distinct architecture. The far;:ades have high thermal performance, exceeding the glazed Cast
unit aluminium
requirements of the new part ' L' of the Building Regulations , with solar shading and component
Glazed
high insulation standards increasing comfort levels and minimizing energy spandrel •
consumption . A balance between highly insulated cladding and high performance panel
glass maintains internal comfort conditions.

The street base responds in height and fa9ade treatment to the character of the
surrounding City buildings. As the streets here are narrow, the fa9ades are
designed for oblique viewing . Heavy modelling in stone, glass and metalwork
maximizes the effects of light and shade and provides an urbane presence, while
maintaining a fully glazed perimeter to the deep floors.
The upper-level floors are smaller, and enjoy enhanced daylight, a more open
aspect , panoramic views of the City, and fresh air. Innovative technology can
enhance the workplace environment; the whole building offers a high quality, fully
air-conditioned environment but the environmental solution also goes much further.
The upper levels can be partly operated without air-conditioning. The air at this level Aluminium
grill
is less polluted , giving the opportunity to naturally ventilate the offices from opening
windows in the fa9ades , in conjunction with air-conditioning when required. I
Aluminium
CHS
Aluminium
flat bar
5. The atrium concept. 6. Upper level double-skin cladding.
West
Upper level double-skin cladding
A double skin of glass, the outer a wind and rain
screen of frameless clear tiles tilted at 3°, acts as an
open-jointed thermal flue, rain screen, and wind
baffle. The inner skin of high performance glass
cladding, with opening windows and heavily
insulated glass spandrels, allows occupiers the
choice of natural ventilation or air-conditioning for
East much of the year. Both skins were based on a 1.5m
Stone services wide module and assembled on site as a series of
core 600mm deep prefabricated cassettes , complete
with blinds, glazing , and maintenance walkways.
The zone between the skins contains active solar
blinds on the outside of the inner cladding while
Glass
High deep maintenance walkways act as passive solar
level
entrance
fresh shading, reducing the need for descending blinds
on sunny days. These walkways provide maximum
access to the cladding and blinds without disturbing
the office activity within , essential for a typical
densely-occupied City floor plate.
Sensors mounted on the inner far;:ade for every
tenancy zone detect solar conditions for that part of
the building, while controllers inside raise and lower
the blinds accordingly. The far;:ade thus responds
East lift cores locally to solar conditions. The outer skin allows
windows to be opened for ventilation in rainy and
windy conditions, and protects the solar control
Entrance lobby blinds from wind damage when deployed in all but
extreme situations.

7. The atrium at podium level.
The architectural expression of the upper building massing provides a distinctive

silhouette on the City skyline. This, in combination with the layered fa9ade of the
reflective glass tiles, active solar blinds and metal filigree, enhances the skyline
Stainless steel
presence and positively locates the development in the City context. fabricated
clamp bracket
Lower level cladding

As the lower floors , with their deep-plan offices, are large and close to noise and
pollution from vehicles, natural ventilation is not appropriate. Instead a curtain of
linked Jura limestone fins on a 3m horizontal module 600mm deep orthogonal to
the fa9ade replaces the outer glass screen of the upper level cladding .
The reason for this is part contextual and part environmental. The building
replaced a collection of stone buildings including the neoclassical commodity
trading building Plantation House. Although none were of great architectural merit, it
was a condition of planning that the new building should present itself to the City as
one clad largely in stone.
The stone fins form a three-dimensional curtain which, together with horizontal Smoke
clea ring
fixed metal louvres and heavily insulated glass spandrels, provides sun shading to vent
the office floors and a suitable architectural composition to the urban setting.
Though the fa9ades are fully glazed , the mostly oblique views from the narrow
Double
streets show the fins closing up to conceal the glass and forming a more solid glazed unit
elevational expression . This also benefits occupiers, as the fin screen and glass
Lateral
insulated spandrel provide an element of privacy in the manner of an Ottoman restra int
jalousie, whilst the fins themselves, similar to a conventional stone reveal , act as Jura
limestone
light reflectors into the interior. Stainless
steel rod
To maximize the street retail presence around most of the building, the stone Aluminium
brlse solell
curtain stops at first floor level , the ground plane with the exception of the main and
service entrances being expressed as metal clad columns with glass shop windows 8. The lower level cladding .
and entrance screens between.

The atrium cladding
Atrium glass bridge
The skin defining the atrium 's spatial envelope
continues the theme of manipulating light. ·-
Resonating with the principle of the external curtain The client required the first floor plates bisected
of stone fins , the atrium cladding is designed as a by the atrium to be linked by a bridge, which
series of projecting vertical glass fins on a 750mm Arup Associates desired to be as light and
ephemeral as possible. It was thus built
horizontal module within the atrium supporting the substantially of glass. the glazed floor providing
glass perimeter cladding . The layer of fins forms a both visual lightness and significant lateral
screen between the occupiers of the office floors , stability. The spanning elements are integrated
with the floor structure above and are not visible
allowing some privacy and visually defining the in the finished enclosure.
seven-storey atrium as a large 'room'. A ladder chassis of stainless steel flats is 10. The glass bridge interior.
The fins are fabricated from shattered toughened suspended by stainless steel rods attached to
the floor beams above. The interaction between The laminated glass wall panels are supported
glass, encapsulated between two sheets of low iron via neoprene pads on these brackets and
the suspending and suspended structures was
glass. They transform ambient light from various checked for overall dynamic performance. restrained laterally at their corners using EPDM
natural and artificial sources into coruscating light, Laminated glass floor panels were laid laterally shims to avoid glass-to-metal contact. There is
with a continuous silicone seal into the ladder an allowance for vertical alignment at either end
an optical device similar to a cut glass chandelier. of the tie rods, and the structure is restrained
structure using an EPDM separating strip. This
Stainless steel 'shoes' spanning between floor ensured that they contribute to the lateral longitudinally by connection to the floor structure
levels continuously support the fins, which are stiffness of the frame over the full 18m span. at one end only.
edge-bonded to the atrium glass cladding with The critical structural element is the coupling The ladder chassis came to site as one piece
piece that connects the ladder chassis to the and was slid into position on a moving platform.
structural silicone, providing stiffness and reduced The rods were then attached and adjusted for
suspension rods. This element supports the
glass thickness to the whole cladding assembly. glass wall panels via cantilevered brackets and alignment and subsequently for load
With the varying external light entering from the resists the lateral balustrade and kick rail loads. equalization prior to glass installation.
southern sky, a dramatic and ever-changing interior

is created at the heart of the building .
9. The atrium cladding. 11 . The atrium cladding: corner detail.
~
. . '
Fritted
glass
spandrel
~
Slab
fixing
bracket Projector • less steel
light support shoes
Encapsulated
crackled
glass fin

'Time and Tide'
artwork:
Plantation Lane
Lee Hosking Declan O'Carroll
Artistic vision
This close collaboration between the artist Simon
Patterson and Arup Associates, funded by
developers British Land , is part of an initiative to
'put something back' into the City of London. The
artwork is integral to Arup Associates ' public realm
concept, and crucially was developed hand-in-hand
with the design of the new public space, rather than
commissioned separately.
The work, 41 m long and 6m high , was
conceived to suggest constancy during times of
change, and Patterson also devised a collection of
texts to be inset into the stone of the new
12. Level 10 garden terrace. pavement. The text sits along a series of great arcs,
which appear to slide underneath the mass of the
13. Level 10 garden concept.
new buildings. Each curve of text represents a
different timeline, beginning with Roman gods and
goddesses, and moving through miscellaneous
information such as the City Guilds, the Livery
Companies and the different membership degrees
of the Freemasons. 'The visitor can either follow a
particular timeline, or choose a more random but
equally fascinating reading by cross-referencing the
different timelines ', says art critic Andrea Schlieker2 .
14. Plantation Lane looking west.
The garden terraces

The step between the upper and lower atrium chambers occurs at level 7,
corresponding to a garden terrace level. A south-facing wintergarden on the floor of
the upper atrium has direct access to the outside garden terrace. As the building
steps back, other terraces are formed, culminating in the main large garden terrace
at level 10 with direct access for occupiers from the two main lift cores through the
upper fac;:ades.
This garden was designed as a series of arboreal chambers of soft and hard
landscape linked to a main pedestrian route around the building perimeter, giving
occupiers a sheltered , private and attractive amenity. A maintenance railway for
cleaning cranes occupies the inner part of the terrace. By designing the rails flush
with the hard paving and providing parking alongside the two cores for the cranes,
the sense of 'garden ' is maintained when viewed from the level 10 occupied floors .
The terraces are linked to the south by a vertiginous bridge over the glass roof of
the atrium , which allows a 360° promenade around the building with exceptional
views of the Thames and the City. The gardens have happily provided a habitat for
insect and bird life, which surprisingly proliferate at this level in the City, when given
the opportunity.

15. The illuminated Moon screen: orthogonal projections.
Patterson settled on an image of the Moon to column sections supports the glass screen, and provides the first level of vertical
counterpoint the difficult, rapid and often violent adjustment. These arms are in turn supported by threaded diagonal tension rods
changes that have imposed themselves on the that carry the glass dead load, and also provide further adjustment. Cruciform
people of London across the ages. Londinium's stainless steel clamping brackets with no visible external fixings are fixed into
Roman inhabitants used the Moon's cycles to threaded ends of these arms. This allows horizontal adjustment to maintain the
underpin their calendar, and today it is a symbol of screen curvature. The glass itself is 1.5m x 2.4m modules in landscape orientation.
scientific progress. The glass and artwork were prototyped in a series of 1m square samples,
'As the same hemisphere of the Moon always inspected in a purpose-built lightbox. In all, 24 samples were examined before the
faces the Earth, people will have witnessed the final glass build-up and printing technique was chosen. Multiple procedures were
identical sight in the night sky throughout history, involved, including several different methods of ink-jet printing onto both glass and
from the first settlers in Londinium to today's City laminate material.
bankers', says Schlieker. 'The image of the Moon is The final glass build-up is a laminate of two sheets of 12mm low iron glass with
particularly rich in associations, within the field of an anti-reflective acid-etched finish to the outer visible surface. This was to avoid
pagan and sacred symbolism , as ubiquitous symbol reflections in the surface when viewed obliquely - an important consideration, as
in legends and myths, as locus for romantic the approach is always at an angle along the narrow Lane. The rear of the inner
yearning, but also as incarnation of scientific glass pane is covered with a 100% ceramic white frit, which diffuses the light
progress in the 20th century. Patterson wants to source and eliminates views inside the screen through the 'white' areas of the
allude to all of these different concepts with this monochromatic image. The final artwork was produced photographically and
mysterious and emblematic image.' laminated with a clear pvb interlayer to complete the sandwich . The completed
image can be viewed in daylight as well as by artificial light.
Engineering The glass panel installation is finished with a clear silicone joint to reduce particle
The screen foundations were cast well in advance migration inside the screen, and to minimize maintenance needs. The back of the
of the final geometry being resolved . An oversized screen is powder-coated aluminium panels, attached by 'hook-on' cladding
1200 x 650mm deep supporting reinforced technology, which can be removed for maintenance. The joints between them are
concrete beam was necessary to give flexibility for sealed with gaskets to eliminate light leakage, which would have been a distraction
the artistic vision, leaving room for some minor to the offices behind the screen.
deviation in the plan geometry and size. Color Kinetics Co/orB/ast LED fittings supply the illumination in rows at the top
In its final resolution, the curved geometry of the and bottom of the light box at 800mm centres, fed from two separate control
screen lines the middle of Plantation Lane's south boxes at each end of the screen. The software-controlled lighting enables a
edge, set out easl/west using a 2.4m x 750mm constantly changing colour rendering behind the glass. The top row of light fittings
module along a radial geometry. The steel frame of is accessed externally via a discreet glazed hinged lid complete with gas struts to
the giant light box comprises a series of structural allow safe maintenance, and restraining clasps to avoid wind uplift.
UC sections 6m tall at 2.4m centres, positioned at
its rear and attached and levelled to the concrete
below by baseplates, with post-drilled bolts.
To maintain the clarity and simplicity of the 16. The Moon screen: colour variations.
design vision, the support system had to minimize
shadowing inside the screen when illuminated and
be positioned far enough behind the artwork to not
show through immediately behind the glass. As the
structure was never designed to be visible, the
lightness of the members was entirely a
consequence of the lighting performance.
A simple system of horizontal arms bolted to the

The building's massing responds to its prominent
Plantation Place South corner location with set-backs at upper levels to
create sympathetic relationships with adjoining
Graham Goymour buildings and to reinforce the sense of architectural
order in the fac;:ade, arranged in three tiers. At
ground level a double-height colonnade supports
Overall form the main body of five floors, whose plates extend to
As a discreet element in the development, Plantation Place South adheres to many the site boundaries to reinforce the surrounding
of the design principles developed for the site as a whole, while establishing a clear urban pattern and correspond with adjoining
identity for itself on the southeast corner. It is designed around a central core, with parapets and setbacks. Above this, three upper
principal south and east-facing frontages onto Great Tower Street and Mincing levels are set back in two stages to create terraces
Lane. It connects at basement level to share servicing facilities with the overall and to break down the building's massing.
development.
Entry sequence and integration into
urban context
17. Plantation Place South from the junction of Mincing Lane and Great Tower Street. To further augment the public realm on the site, the
design of Plantation Place South incorporates its
own route at ground level linking Great Tower Street
to the new pedestrian route, Plantation Lane. This
internal link is designed as part of the building's
entry sequence, which takes visitors through an
external arcaded space into a large, double-height
entrance hall. This leads directly to the ground level
lift lobby and is extended northwards, via a gradual
incline, to Plantation Place. The entire sequence of
spaces is lined on one side by the broad sweep of
a curved chain mail screen that finally connects to
the external illuminated screen in Plantation Lane.
The intention behind this internal route is to
encourage cross-movement though the entire site
to the benefit of the greater development and the
building itself, which is served by a secondary
entrance from Plantation Lane.
Fac;:ade design: loadbearing stone

With its proximity to the conservation area, the
Wren church and indeed , Plantation Place, the
building's architectural identity appropriately relies to
a large extent on the use of natural stone. At the
same time, compliance with Building Regulations
suggested a very deliberate approach to limiting the
amount of glass. These considerations led to the
evolution of a fac;:ade where stone transcends its
common use as a cladding material to one in which
structural, architectural, and environmental
concerns could find a common expression.
The fac;:ade design for Plantation Place South
also evolved from patterns established in the first
phase of the project, particularly the use of
suspended stone fins. A Jurassic limestone from
Bavaria was chosen for its excellent weathering
properties and high compressive strength, and in
Plantation Place South these properties are utilized
in a loadbearing construction.

Structural design
Precast spandrel
As well as satisfying the normal functional aspects,
the structural design aimed to enhance project
delivery and value. The key concepts, which define
Stainless steel the approach taken , are as follows:
bracket connection
Primary steel
• Arrange the layout to mitigate site constraints in
floor beam Stainless steel post- advance of construction .
tensioned MacAlloy bars
• Configure the substructure to give an early gain
300 x 900mm
Floorplate limestone fin on critical path activity.
composite
metal deck/
• Optimise the structural frame system for
lightweight slab efficiency and buildability
• Use an innovative passive approach to the fire
300 x 1500mm
protection of structural steelwork.
panel • Develop a creative and integrated fa9ade design
to add character and value.
Bounded by Underground tunnels, highways, and a
nearby building on shallow foundations , the site 's
existing perimeter retaining walls surrounded a zone
Window
of undisturbed archaeology. The basement was
therefore sited centrally, clear of these constraints to
mitigate obstruction disturbance and minimize the
effects of excavation ground movements. A central
core and the principal columns were arranged to be
in this clear zone with only light perimeter loading.
18. Elements of the fa<,ade design. Secant walling and foundation piling progressed
unobstructed in the central zone. The outer zone
was slabbed over the undisturbed archaeology, and
Instead of cladding components being clipped to the outside of a structural frame,
this formed a stiff perimeter waling ring to enable
a masonry wall was erected , with openings formed to receive window components
open central zone basement excavation . The
in a separate installation. This traditional approach of wall and window construction
avoidance of substructure temporary works allowed
suggested an economic benefit through greater market competition than the more
a slipformed core to spring directly from the lower
usual curtainwall solutions.
basement level. This gave the earliest start to core
A modular approach with a 3m grid was adopted , with three basic structural
construction , including prefabricated services risers,
components: a stone fin , a stone wall panel , and a horizontal spandrel panel, each
lifts, and toilet finishes - the critical path activities in
arranged in repetitive bays in a staggere1d pattern with glazed window openings.
a commercial shell-and-core office building .
The base pattern on the east elevation places the larger window openings north
of the projecting fins to maximize self· s~1ading , which is also enhanced by the deep
reveal nature of the fa9ade. Window framing is also hidden behind the masonry 19. View from office floor south towards The Monument.
panels to minimize heat loss. The fin/ panel/ window pattern is staggered from floor
to floor so that there is always a structural overlap between panels and fins from
one floor to the next. Spandrel beams are arranged in 6m lengths, so that perpend
joints always occur at the centreline of a wall panel below.
On the south elevation , which receivEis more direct sun , the arrangement of
stone changes so that some fins are turned through 90° to become in-plane panels,
thus further limiting the amount of glass on the fa9ade, while still conforming to the
established structural module with vertical load paths repeated every 3m .
A giant order at ground level collects this loadbearing construction through a
transfer spandrel bearing onto columns at 6m centres around the building's
periphery that also form arcaded spaces for the building's main entrance as well as
a retail unit alongside Plantation Lane. Between these, office space pushes out to
meet perimeter columns in the form of large bay windows.
Finite element analysis of the stone elements. scale load testing , and prototype
panel construction all assured the integrity and buildability of the system .
By contrast , the building 's upper leve·ls are clad in a unitized system combining
glazed and opaque units that maintain the same proportion of clear glass as below
for a consistent internal appearance. This lightweight cladding also reinforces the
sense of contrast between lower and upper levels.
42 The Arup Journal 212005

Credits
Client : The British Land Company PLC Architect , structural ,
and M&E engineer: Arup Associates - Nicola Adams , Gert
Andresen, Mark Arkinstall, Rachel Atthis, Simon Barden ,
Graham Bardsley-Smith , Mike Beaven , George Bowman,
James Bown , Mark Boyle, Anita Bramlitt, Paul Brislin , Tony
Broomhead, Mick Brundle, Peter Caller. Glen Carney, Jason
Clark, Steve Clarke, Peter Connell, Chris Cowell , Paul
Dickenson , John Edgar, Geoff Farnham, Paul Felix, Kevin
Fellingham , Martin Finch, Richard Gargaro, Matt Gilliver,
Maureen Godbold, Darren Goodman, Graham Goymour, Ian
Hazzard, Matthew Higgs. Ed Hoare, Tony Hoban, Lee Hosking,
David Hymas, Jacqueline Jiang-Haines. Lindsay Johnston.
20. The reception hall.
Mario Kaiser, Jackie Keegan-Warg, Dan Kelly, Caroline King.
Mike King , Mike Kinney, Joanne Larmour, Andrew Lawrence,
Pablo Lazo, David Lee, Tommy Lee, Steve Leonard, Benjamin
Optimizing the structural frame Lim. Sean Macintosh, Teresa Marshall. Luke McAdam, Barry
McAulliffe, Richard McCarthy, Daryl McClure, Abi McGillivray,
The building's planning and floor plate efficiency suited a central core with clear Will McLardy, John E Miles, Cathy Milligan , Marek
floor spans to the perimeter, and alternative floor framing systems were compared. Monczakowski, Terry Moody, Andrea Nanni, Declan O'Carroll,
The normal efficiency of multi-bay concrete construction was eroded without the Jane O'Connor, Mark Oxbrough , David Pearce, Annelise
Penton, Lizzie Pomeroy, Robert Pugh , Carolyn Quinn , Terry
repetitive bay continuity for the building layout considered here. Additionally, elastic Raggett , Steve Ratchye, Graham Redman, James Reed ,
redistribution of two-bay continuous concrete increases load on the central column. Patrick Regan, Roland Reinardy, John Roberts, Davina Rooney,
but pattern loading still requires the edge columns to carry a full bay reaction. This George Scott , Stephen Setford , Caroline Sohie, Lexy Stevens,
Nick Suslak, Matt Vaudin , Malcom Wallace, Jim Warren, Gary
means that foundations for concrete need to be designed for more than the Webb, Mark Winter, Ken Wiseman, Roger Wood , Jo Wolbers,
building actually weighs, with significant impact on foundation cost. Tim Worsfold Controls, fa~ad es, fire, transportation,
A steel frame, on the other hand, ideally suits simple bay spans, so the chosen acoustics , geotechnical , archaeolog ical, materials , security,
water and planning consultant: Arup - Darren Anderson ,
approach was UC sections for secondary beams, acting compositely with the Simon Barden, Simon Barnes, Simon Brimble, Graham Dodd,
lightweight concrete metal deck slab to reduce overall structural depth, and Nathan Hewitt, Richard Hughes, Susan Lamont, Barbara Lane,
services duct distribution running freely below. Services cross-overs and core Pein Lee, Tom Linder. Nicola Masters, Silole Menezes, Bruno
Miglio, Zedi Nyirenda, Dinesh Patel , Joe Pavely, Jeffrey Pereira,
entries were organized in the spaces between beams, which meant that, within the Haico Schepers, Matthew Shinkel, Cyrus Toms, Stephan Von
same overall floor depth, services space and distribution flexibility actually exceeded Roon, Simon Webster, Darren Wright , Malcolm Wright , Roddy
the comparable thinnest prestressed concrete flat slab option. Wykes, Jason Zawadzki Project manager: M3 Consulting
Quantity surveyor: Gardiner & Theobald Construction
manager: Bovis Lend Lease Planning: Montagu Evans Rights
Passive fire protection of light: Anstey Horne Party wall surveyor: Dron & Wright
An outstanding feature of the structural design is the use of state-of-the-art thermo- [Plantation Lane] Artist : Simon Patterson Artist's visualization :
mechanical analysis to establish an economical approach to the fire protection of Stephen Kirby Architectural metalwork & glass balustrades:
Glazzard Stone flooring : Gabriel Engineering; Miller Druck
structural steelwork, and determine the strengths and weaknesses of the building International Stone supplier: ltalmarble Pocai , Neumeyer and
structure so that mitigating measures could enhance robustness in the fire limit Brigl Illuminated screen & glass gates: Josef Gartner Printed
state. This resulted in the first approved use of this approach for a City of London interlayer processing : Concepta Colourglass Glass supplier:
Eckelt Stainless steel gates: Kimber Engineering Floor
building . Additionally, the development of specific construction details to help limit lighting: Zumtobel Illuminated screen lighting: Lighting
the impact of fire on the final structural design provides an additional level of safety. Technology Projects
This approach comes from extensive research carried out with the University of Illustrations: 1, 3, 5, 6, 8, 9, 13, 15, 18, 21 Arup Associates;
Edinburgh, validated on the Cardington Large Building Test Frame Program. 2, 4, 7, 10, 11 , 14, 16, 17, 19, 20 Christian Richters;
12 Richard Bryant
After agreement on the approach was obtained from the client. his insurer, and
the local authorities, the fire team developed the design basis fires for input to the
structural models with the City of London. the London Fire and Emergency
Planning Authority, and a third-party reviewer. Following detailed and extensive non-
linear finite element analysis of the composite steel frame structure in the various
References
agreed design fires , the team undertook a comprehensive review of the structural
(1) BRUNDLE, M. A beacon
fire responses. for the City o f London .
This demonstrated what structural elements required fireproofing to ensure a The Arup Journal, 35(2),
major load-carrying mechanism in fire could take place - tensile membrane action. pp1 6- 17, issue 2/ 2000.
In addition, various changes to the cold temperature design were made including (2) BRISLIN , P, Editor.
Plantation Lane: Time and
redirecting the rebar within the concrete core to limit heat transfer to this anchoring Tide. RIBA Enterprises
mechanism, and providing specific fireproofing to key connections. Progressive Publishing , 2005.
collapse checks in the fire limit state were carried out on the basis of the ISBN: 1-85946- 173-5
recommendations in Part A of the Building Regulations.

As severe fires were assumed , on the basis of total sprinkler failure and full floor
engulfment in fire , plus multiple areas of broken glazing for venting in the design
fires, no limits were required to be placed on the building design for future changes.
This approach has been nominated for the Structural Steel Design Award 2005.

1. The rental car facility from the south-west, with the quick turnaround building in the foreground.
Miami Airport OTA: risk-informed

performance-based fire protection
Risk assessment and performance-based fire Richard Custer Matthew Johann
engineering met the challenge of designing a facility Brian McLaughlin Brian Meacham
with 120 fuel dispensing stations for the rental car area Jeffrey Tubbs Christopher Wood
at Miami Airport's multi-modal transportation hub. Eileen Wood
Introduction The OTA

Miami International Airport (MIA) is one of the busiest in the USA, ranking third by Typically, QTAs are isolated, on grade facilities.
passenger numbers in 2003 after New York's JFK and Los Angeles' LAX. A long- However, the constrained MIA site has led to the
term masterplan for comprehensive improvements has been under way since the unprecedented step of making this QTA a multi-level
mid-1990s and, in addition to extended and enhanced terminal facilities and a facility, rather than the conventional grade level or
fourth runway, the current $4 .8bn Capital Improvement Program includes a major ground floor location. Thus it is essentially an
upgrade to the landside transportation system. immense reinforced concrete parking garage,
Part of this upgrade is the Miami lntermodal Center (MIC), a transportation hub comprising four storeys each 660ft x 320ft (201 .2m
to facilitate connections and transfers between air, rail, and ground transportation . x 97.5m), with 16ft (4.9m) floor-to-floor height. As
Its first phase is a five-year programme comprising, firstly, improvements to the conceived, the first three levels will contain fuel
currently congested highway system, and secondly, construction of the first phase dispensing (120 stations, 40 on each level), fluid
of the MIC 'core' and of the MIC/MIA Connector, an automated people mover filling (oil and windshield washer), tyre air filling , and
system that will link the MIC with the airport. washing areas. The fourth floor will be used for
The programme's third element is the consolidated rental car facility (RCF), which additional vehicle storage.
will occupy slightly more than half of the 53 acre (21.5ha) MIC site. The RCF will Two fuel farms and storage areas for the QTA
house the operations of all rental car companies at the airport and serve as the liquids (windshield wiper fluid, oil, detergent, etc) will
transportation core for intercity and local buses, heavy rail, retail outlets, and be nearby, with the storage tanks for the gasoline
passenger services, with provision for future developments. Within the RCF, a key built underground. The gasoline piping to the QTA
element is the quick turnaround (QTA) facility, which will be used for vehicle fuelling, will be contained within a vertical concrete
cleaning, and light servicing . construction, with entry onto each level.

Unlike the rest of the ACF, the OTA operations present unique hazards and risks.
Specifically, the number of gasoline dispensing stations planned in the building What is performance-based design?
greatly exceeds what is allowed by the governing regulations (NFPA 11 and In contrast to the prescriptive approach which only
specifies methods and systems without identifying how
NFPA 30A2) , which also do not allow multi-level indoor fuelling, and only permit these achieve the desired safety goal, performance-
indoor fuelling on the ground level within 50ft (18m) of an exterior wall. based design in the case of fire protection uses an
The refuelling configuration poses a number of hazards, including : eng1neenng approach based on established fire safety
objectives, analysis of fire scenarios, and assessment
• a larger uncontrolled fuel release in one place than would occur at a smaller, of design alternatives against the obiectives. This
independent facility, due to increased fuel release rate and/or spill duration allows for more design flexibility and innovation in
• more sources of potential ignition from the many fuel dispensing stations construction techniques and materials, gives equal or
better fire safety, and maximizes the cosVbenefit ratio
• greater challenges in fire detection, suppression, and/ or egress than in a during design and construction .
smaller facility
• the potential for explosions from the formation of fuel vapour-air mixtures
• more significant spray fires as a result of the higher pressure in fuel supply lines
to multiple levels stations in the OTA's three levels will provide
• fuel fires flowing from a higher to a lower level, due to the elevated fuel sufficient protection for any hazards from them.)
dispensing Thirdly, the performance-based fire protection
• increased risks to occupants and responding emergency personnel from multi- report gave an overview of the fire protection
level fires and/or explosions. systems and features proposed for the OTA, using
• increased challenges in fire suppression associated with multi-level fuelling . 'performance language' to describe the overall
approach to active and passive fire protection
A risk-informed performance-based approach features in the facility, critical features , and design
In October 2000 a workshop was held to discuss the fire and life safety issues options for these features.
associated with the RCF's conceptual design. The workshop determined that. given Finally, explosion hazard for gasoline fuel spills
the overall scale of the facility, a performance-based approach would be the most within the OTA was further reviewed, and
appropriate, informed by a system safety assessment and risk analysis . documented in the gasoline vapour dispersion and
This was made possible by the existence of regulatory clauses that allow the use overpressures report. This three-part analysis
of alternative methods and materials to those specified by the regulations. The (vapour development, vapour dispersion, and
Miami Dade Aviation Department Aviation Life Safety Bureau thus allowed for a deflagration overpressure estimation) concluded that
performance-based approach as appropriate for the facility, given its uniqueness significant structural damage was unlikely, but as
and incompatibility with prescriptive code requirements. with large spills in on-grade, open-air gasoline
refuelling , persons in the vapour cloud could be
Fire and life safety analyses seriously injured or killed . Specific recommendations
As part of a design development team that also includes EarthTech Consulting Inc and critical management procedures have thus
(project manager), HNTB Architects Engineers Planners (architect), Wallberg Alvarez been developed to address staff and other
(MEP engineer) , and Burns & McDonnell (fuel system design) , Arup was engaged in occupant safety.
2000 as risk and fire protection consultant.
Design solution
As discussed and agreed at the October 2000 workshop, the overall approach
addressed the hazards associated with the refuelling stations in two parts - Based on the performance-based analyses
assessing fire and explosion hazards, and assessing the overall risks associated developed for the OTA, the Arup team defined many
with hazards in the OTA - and following the design and analysis process outlined in critical features as being necessary for a successful
the SFPE Guide3. design. First of all , the overall maintenance and
The first step required a Fire Protection Engineering Design Brief (FP Design operations requirements included the need for a
BrieQ report to be submitted to the stakeholders. In general, this sets forth the comprehensive training and maintenance plan ,
scope of the analysis and details the overall performance-based process used , together with an overall security plan to address
allowing stakeholder and authority input into the process before the bulk of the deliberate events like arson or terrorism .
analysis is performed . This further allows for specific review and approval of the Beyond these, the team produced detailed sets
overall level of safety necessary for the facility. of design characteristics that addressed overall fire
The next step was to quantity the fire scenarios identified in the FP Design Brief and life safety issues; emergency fuel shut-off; the
in engineering terms. Firstly, the system safety assessment for gasoline used risk delivery, dispensing , and storage of fuel , windshield
and failure analysis techniques to determine the significant scenarios that would washing fluid , and lube oil ; and control room panel
need to be addressed through the fire and explosion hazard analyses, and features. These are all detailed overleaf.
estimated the frequency and sizes of spills .
Secondly, this was updated to include additional fuel island systems deemed
necessary by the design/ owner team. These were the lubricating oil , windshield
washer fluid, and compressed air systems, and the updated system safety
assessment outlined and summarized the risks posed by them . (The results
concluded that the safety features specified for the refuelling islands for the 120

Critical design features Fuel pumping
• dedicated tank-mounted vertical turbine pumps
for each of the six dedicated piping sections
Fire and life safety • pumps sized to provide maximum flow 200gpm
• four-hour rated vertical chases and concrete piping trenches (15 litres/sec) (20 positions at 1Ogpm each)
• fuel island retention area sized to accommodate a 100-gallon (455 litre) spill • pumps to start on signal from one dispenser and
• combination ultraviolet and infrared (UV/IR) sensors to detect flame in the fuel time-out after 10 minutes if no additional signals
dispensing areas and initiate automatic fire suppression received
• 212°F (100°C) heat detectors over fuel dispensing areas to back up • hydraulic control/ pressure reducing valves at
UV/IR sensors each service level at QTA entrance for each set
• overhead and floor-level alcohol-resistant foam system at the fuel dispensing of 20 fuelling positions
stations to suppress and control fires in the retention area • control/ pressure reducing valves to fail in closed
• automatic sprinkler protection throughout, except directly over the retention position ; to modulate to limit pipe pressure
basins at the fuel dispensing areas regardless of inlet pressure; to shut off upon
• water curtain that won't spray into retention basin at the 20ft (6.1m) clear zone excess flow, leak detection alarm , emergency
• water curtains at the QTNRCF interface fuel shut-off alarm, or tank low level alarm
• manual fire alarm stations throughout • automatic recirculation valves at the pump
• standpipe and hose stations at egress stairs and as necessary throughout discharge to recirculate approximately 30% of
• voice communication devices throughout the design flow back to the tank to prevent the
• visual alarms where required by code or due to ambient noise pump from operating at no flow conditions
• four-hour fire resistance rating for all floor-ceiling assemblies, columns, and other • thermal relief valves located within each piping
structural components, with tested fire-resistive protection to floors and ceilings segment, actuating to protect each segment
directly above the fuel dispensing areas from over-pressurization from thermal heat gain ,
• properly fire-rated expansion joints and discharging into a gravity system that drains
• access for tenant spaces from refuelling1areas through a corridor open at the top back to the underground storage tanks
• drains for the retention to be raised, like a roof drain, to reduce potential • service level high pressure switches downstream
blockage of the control/ pressure reducing valves at each
• minimum 3ft (900mm) free area above the tenant spaces to allow a substantial service level
path for explosion venting . • pumps provided with a shut-down feature if
service level high pressure switch increases to
Fuel delivery and storage set maximum pressure.
• fuel delivery within a dedicated unloading area having a containment area sized
to hold the entire contents of a tanker truck (8000 gallons/36 400 litres) Emergency fuel shut-off
• containment areas having dedicated drainage to an oil/ water separator • stations at each dispenser island and at remote
• fill connections located within spill containment pads draining to concrete locations within 20ft (6.1 m) and 1OOft (30m) of
containment area the dispensers
• integral overfill valves within the tank drop tube • stations to shut off the following components on
• double-wall steel fuel storage tanks a 'per-floor' basis: all fuel pumps, all fuel
• tanks provided with integral automatic gauging and leak detection systems, with dispensers, all control/ pressure reducing valves,
control panels in the fire command room and all lube oil and windshield washer systems
• tank gauging system to monitor total product level , product temperature, and • system to shut down upon receipt of alarm from
water level , designed to alarm at high-leivel and low level conditions an emergency fuel shut-off station or from the
• monitoring system for tank interstitial space (leak detection) and pump sensors. voice communication and fire detection system .
Fuel piping
2.
• double-wall welded carbon steel piping, and welded carbon steel containment Computer simulation of the explosive range zone of a gasoline
piping , with 100% radiographic inspection of welds leak from a fuelling station after 120 seconds.
• nitrogen-filled double-wall interstitial space, with leak detection monitoring

• separate dedicated systems for each of the six piping sections (two per floor, 20
fuelling positions per section)
• systems velocities below recommended maximum to minimize static charge
generation
• pipe grounding to provide path for rapid dissipation of static charge
• supply piping drain to low point connections , and gravity discharge, to
completely drain system for maintenance.

Windshield washing fluid and lube oil : dispensing, piping , and pumping
• dispensing through a spring return hose-reel at each fuelling island
• each dispensing location controlled by a normally-closed, fluid line solenoid valve
Parking • normally-closed, fluid line solenoid valves to close when any fire detection
(two levels)
system device or emergency fuel shut-off station is activated
• dispensing reel hoses limited to 30ft (9m), with an aluminum gooseneck, manual
fill, hose end control
• washing fluid piping to be 1 .5in (38mm) stainless steel tubing
• lube oil piping specified as Schedule 40 carbon steel
• lube oil joints to be weld connections, except at connections to equipment
• separate pumps for each zone on each floor, each pump serving 20 servicing
positions
• washing fluid pump valves to shut down when any fire detection systems device
or emergency shut-off station is activated.
Control room panel features

• two separate programmable logic controllers for increased reliability, both to
operate in parallel or with one in 'hot-standby' mode (ie where one unit controls
the operations while the other is kept updated and ready to control operations
should the first unit fail)
• programmable logic controller for all fuel systems operations, interacting with the
voice communication and fire detection system, emergency fuel shut-off system,
leak detection system, and low product level alarm
• fuel delivery systems only to operate when the voice communication and fire
detection system is operating and functioning properly, the emergency fuel shut-
off and leak detection systems are not in alarm, and the automatic tank gauging
system is not in low product level alarm
• programmable logic controllers designed to include an interface panel to display
alarms and system information
.· • control panel designed to alarm if high pressure switch increases to set
..·· maximum pressure .
·. ·. ....···· Conclusion
··. ...·· w
Flame
detectors w w
The Arup team 's analysis was peer-reviewed and has been ultimately accepted by
3. the authorities. Construction of the OTA and RCF is expected to commence later
Top: plan of RCF and OTA showing the constraints on site this year, with the whole facility scheduled to open for use in 2007 . Arup provided
area by highw ays and rail lines.
Above: layout option for UV/ IR flame detectors at fu elling significant value by demonstrating that this structure could be designed and built
island s, confi gured to prevent fi res bei ng hidden from safely at an overall reduced operating cost, which made the analysis and protection
detector view by parked vehicles w ith doors, hood and
trun k open or closed . features well worth the cost.
Windshield washing fluid and lube oil

Credits
delivery/storage Project owner: Miami International Airport Client and project manager: EarthTech Consulting
• washing fluid stored in two 2000 gallon (9 100 Inc Design architect: HNTB Architects Engineers Planners Architect of record : Sequeira &
Gavarrete Design MEP engineer: Wolfberg Alvarez Design fuel system : Burns & McDonnell
litre). vertical, flat bottom polyethylene, above- Fire engineer: Arup - Richard Custer, Matthew Johann. Brian Mclaughlin, Brian Meacham,
ground tanks in the fluids storage rooms Jeff Tubbs, Christopher Wood, Eileen Wood Illustrations: 1 EarthTech; 2 Arup; 3 Nigel Whale
• lube oil stored in two 1OOO gallon (4550 litre).
horizontal, cylindrical, above-ground tanks in the
fluids storage rooms
References
• delivery through a locked pedestal-mounted spill
{1) NATIONAL FIRE PROTECTION ASSOCIATION and WESTERN FIRE CHIEFS ASSOCIATION.
containment box outside fluids storage rooms
NFPA 1: Uniform fire code. NFPA, 2003.
• integral pressure-rated overfill prevention valve in
(2) NATIONAL FIRE PROTECTION ASSOCIATION . NFPA 30A: Motor fuel dispensing facilities and
the fill drop tube to close, and the high-high level repair garages. NFPA, 2003.
alarm to alarm, when high-high fluid level is (3) SOCIElY OF FIRE PROTECTION ENGINEERS. Engineering guide to performance-based fire
reached within storage tanks. protection analysis and design of buildings . SFPE, 2000.

Can buildings be engineered to
allow desired wireless frequencies
to enter whilst deflecting others
for privacy or security?
Frequency selective surfaces
(FSS) may be the answer.
Designing
buildings for a
wireless world
Alan Newbold
Introduction Research on FSS for Ofcom

People at work want both universal access to information, increasingly through In a team that also included Culham
mobile communications, and security and privacy for their communications. Electromagnetics and Lightning (project managers),
The challenge is to meet both requirements simultaneously in the workplace. the National Physical Laboratory, and Warwick
Currently mobile communications infrastructure and systems are designed on the University, Arup Communications and Arup
basis of detailed analysis of radio frequency (RF) coverage and capacity Materials Consulting recently took part in a project
requirements. Security and privacy needs can be met through good design, but for the UK regulatory body Ofcom (Office of
eavesdropping remains an issue. How can building design and fitout aid the design Communications) to research the practical potential
of wireless communications systems, and reduce the problems of eavesdropping , of FSS in a real office environment to aid in
by using frequency selective surfaces (FSS) and attenuating materials? spectrum efficiency. The specific aim was to
Demand for spectrum continues to grow, and hence propagation characteristics demonstrate the possibility of reducing the
within buildings are becoming a more important consideration. Generally, as the coverage area of a wireless system through the use
frequencies of operation rise from 450MHz, 900MHz, and 1.8GHz, to 2.4GHz and of FSS and attenuating materials. This would then
5.2GHz, the ability to penetrate building materials reduces significantly. allow the radio channels to be reused over a shorter
As new wireless systems with limits to the number of available channels and distance and result in a more spectrum-efficient
operating at higher frequencies are installed in buildings, it is time to consider system through increasing capacity per m 2 .
selecting different types of material for use in construction, based on their RF
characteristics. For example, reflecting material could be used to prevent signals
2. A 5.2GHz bandstop FSS.
from propagating into rooms; RF-attenuating film could be added to double-glazed
windows; and FSS could be deployed to allow certain frequencies to propagate
into a room while reflecting other frequencies.
One of the hardest challenges designers face is to predict the frequencies that
will be used in the future , as wireless technologies develop and users demand ever-
increasing bandwidth . Buildings are constructed to last many years and internal fit-
outs occur every few years, but new wireless standards are developed every few
months; a detailed understanding of the latest developments in wireless
communications standards and products, and an appreciation of the characteristics
of the frequencies they use, are required.

A 63m 2 demonstrator facility was constructed to simulate an office environment, The 2.4GHz and 5.2GHz bands are categorized as
and then partitioned into three electrically isolated areas and equipped with both licence-exempt industrial , scientific and medical
IEEE802.11 b (2.4GHz) and IEEE802.11 a (5.2GHz) wireless local area network {ISM) bands and are becoming more heavily utilized.
(WLAN) systems. This particular construction was lined with a reflective material These bands are self-regulated and hence any
that provided approximately 60dB of attenuation throughout the facility, which interference between systems needs to be resolved
allowed the team to benchmark the capability of the FSS. by users. This will become much more of an issue
with heavier use of these areas of spectrum. For
Defining FSS frequency requirements example, some major hospitals have started to have
Before constructing the FSS panels, the attenuation characteristics and target problems with some of their medical equipment due
frequencies were defined. To determine these characteristics, the team analyzed to utilization of the ISM band, and in some cases
the main in-building requirements for wireless communications, covering wide area agreements have been reached to move medical
network (WAN), local area network (LAN) and personal area network (PAN). In the electronics away from the ISM band and into a
wide area, the ability to access mobile cellular networks is fundamental for any dedicated band.
organization and so coverage into the building is needed at frequencies between
900MHz - 2.2GHz.
In addition, and particularly due to some recent highly publicized problems, the
10
requirement to allow TETRA (terrestrial trunked radio) frequencies into a building for
the emergency services is critical, as is allowing PMR (private mobile radio) services
to operate for specific client requirements, including IT and security departments. Power
8 (dBm)
Hence coverage needs to be available from 350-4 ?OM Hz and from 870-900MHz in
a building. -100
-105
For most organizations, the use of personal wireless communications is 6
-110
assumed to occur within a relatively short distance (<10m) and hence when
-115
considering the propagation of radio waves the signals are assumed to work within
-120
a restricted area and not as part of LAN or WAN systems.
-125
The main RF requirement affected by building design and fit-out today is the -130
deployment of LAN systems, including those developed under the IEEE802.11 b/g -135
2
and IEEE802.11 a/h standards at 2.4GHz and 5.2GHz. Most users of the former -140
standard are accustomed to the concept of a wi-fi hotspot, where coverage is -145
provided in a particular predicted high-use area. However with new applications like 0
wireless voice over IP, the ability to achieve roaming coverage, where users can
walk from area to area without dropping the connection, will become a minimum 0 2 6 8
requirement in offices. 3.
Software modelling results: GSM signals from outside
In the local area, wireless IEEE802.11 b systems use the 2.4GHz band with the building .
22MHz channels, limiting the system to three non-overlapping channels, each
providing up to about 11 Mbps raw data throughput or 5.5Mbps shared data
throughput to the users covered by the access point. Where many users are
located in a small area, like an airport departure lounge, coverage is often
overlapped to provide a higher aggregated throughput. Also, where in the event of
an access point failure a minimum level of RF coverage is required, coverage is
overlapped to provide resilience. To ensure provision of aggregated throughput and
RF resilience the RF design can become very complex and in some cases
impossible without some level of inter-access point interference.
New wireless standards and systems are continually being developed to improve
performance within these constraints. The ratified IEEE802.11 g standard increases
the overall throughput up to about 20Mbps. However it still offers only a limited
number of non-overlapping channels. Although the IEEE802.11 a/h systems aid this
particular problem through the provision of eight non-overlapping channels, the
2.4GHz systems are still increasing in popularity and applications like voice have 4.
not yet been developed at the 5.2GHz frequency. This will probably result in two The Ofcom test installation: the dielectric cladding was
polyethylene, the FSS substrate was polyester, and the core
radio systems being required for use in buildings, operating at 2.4GHz and 5.2GHz. was extruded polystyrene.
Alongside frequency management problems, the security of wireless systems,
particularly wi-fi , is poor. Many of the security risks that have been highlighted can
be mitigated through careful design, but the radio link will always remain vulnerable
as it is difficult to place boundaries on RF transmission. There have been many
documented cases of potential hackers eavesdropping open networks from outside
the building.

Given the limited number of non-overlapping
channels in the IEEE802 .11 a/b/g/h systeims, it was
felt that if a cost-effective FSS could be designed to Choice of FSS materials
selectively reflect certain frequencies in the 2.4GHz
or 5.2Ghz bands, then buildings could be designed Bob Cather Edwin Stokes
to aid in the efficient use of these frequencies and
hence aid RF design. Although research carried out The practical issues around incorporating FSS fuels (though not to alkalis), low flammability,
materials in a real office/building environment good high temperature stability, and can be
on another Ofcom project shows that it i s had to be considered - issues of both the readily shaped and formed.
theoretically possible to achieve the required results, inherent suitability of candidate materials and Styrofoam extruded polystyrene foam is widely
to design a practical example will be very their interaction with construction and building used in buildings for thermal insulation in roofs
operation. For this project, two general forms of and wall cavities. It is very flammable and has
challenging . construction were considered as the base. limitations on mechanical damage compared to
The next desirable objective is to design an FSS Office buildings are constructed either the other candidate materials. It has good acid
able to stop or pass 2.4GHz and 5.2GH.z bands in traditionally, with brick structural walls and and alkali resistance but poor solvent
lightweight concrete partitions within, or in the resistance.
their entirety. This would allow an organization to more modern combination of concrete and/or
The various service requirements and the
selectively prevent the 5.2GHz band used by staff steel-framed structure, with lightweight timber
or plasterboard partitions. Most prestige City materials properties were compared, to draw
or operations from being transmitted across a tentative conclusions on the most appropriate
offices are of 'modern' construction, though
physical boundary and into a common area, but due to increased desire to reuse or refurbish
basis for further development. Incorporated
within the building structure and fabric , the FSS
allow the common-use 2.4GHz band to pass across existing buildings, a significant and possibly
increasing number may be of the 'traditional' will be impractical to inspect. modify or replace.
the boundary unaffected and maintain public or so it must be robust enough to tolerate site
methods and materials.
voice communications. conditions and have confident long-term
The Arup Materials Consulting team analyzed performance. In interior fit-out, aesthetics, UV,
Due to the separation between target the constraints and requirements arising from abrasion, fire spread and reaction to cleaning
frequencies, it is relatively easy to provide about building regulations, the compatibility with regimes are all important issues; whilst when
45d8 attenuation in the stop band, with only 2-3d8 adjoining materials, and the practicalities of FSS are incorporated into local workstations,
installation and maintenance. When locating aesthetics and unit cost come to the fore. The
attenuation in the pass band . Software propagation FSS within partition walls, these factors include material needs to be unobtrusive, and
modelling showed that a relatively small FSS panel compatibility with adjoining components workstation configurations may change many
could be used to provide sufficient signal strength including junctions and joints, health and safety times in the life of a building.
considerations, acoustic properties, fire
into the appropriate room from the transmitting AP. performance, the nature of any applied finishes,
With every issue weighed in the balance, the
team concluded that though Styrofoam is a
The FSS were made from two layers, each using a and durability and maintenance. When
viable and cost-effective option for internal
dielectric core of extruded polystyrene SE3parated by incorporated in the fa9ade, there are additional
partitions, it would need to be encased to meet
issues of continuity of weathertightness and
a spacer. The total thickness of the structure was fa9ade thermal and comfort perfonmance, and the fire performance regulations and was too
open to damage, so Rohacell would probably
about 30mm and the outside of each FSS was clad accommodation of movement and deflections.
be the most appropriate due to its robustness,
with a dielectric material. With all these factors in mind, as well as versatility and fire performance. For fa9ade use,
The project demonstrated that an FSS could considerations of in-service modification, Melinex PET is probably the best option
replacement and maintenance, the next task because of its flexibility and UV resistance.
allow a 5.2GHz signal to propagate through it whilst was to determine the suitability of candidate
preventing a 2.4GHz signal from passing. This substrate materials proposed by project
meant that through a combination of the partners for installed FSSs. Five materials were
proposed: PET (Melinex), polyimide (Kapton),
appropriate shielding and FSS it is possilble to GRP laminate (/so/a), polymethacrylimide
isolate 2.4GHz signals from one room to another (Rohacet~. and extruded polystyrene foam
(Styrofoam).
whilst allowing a 5.2GHz signal to pass into both
Melinex PET is a clear thermoplastic film
rooms. The reverse of this was also demonstrated.
commonly used as protective film on glazing. It
To show that it was possible to meet the is flexible but vulnerable to tear, and is
requirements of allowing mobile cellular and inherently flammable. However, it has good UV
resistance, with typically a 10-year service life
emergency communications into a building whilst
exposed on glazing.
preventing all higher frequencies from paissing, a
Kapton is a translucent yellow thermoset film,
low pass FSS was constructed. This proved that typically used in the electronics industry as a
signals up to 1GHz could be allowed to pass into a flexible substrate. Like Melinex PET it is flexible
and vulnerable to tear, but it is far less
building, hence allowing TETRA emergency
flammable. It has excellent chemical resistance
services, PMR signals or 0.9GHz GSM signals in. but absorbs moisture easily.
Currently it is not possible to design an affordable Isola is a thin and rigid glassfibre reinforced
FSS to permit 1.8GHz to pass whilst preventing the plastic (GRP) laminate, typically used as a
substrate of printed circuit boards. Like Kapton
transmission of 2.4GHz.
it has good fire resistance and chemical
resistance, but its susceptibility to moisture
absorption can lead to delamination.
Rohacell is a polymethacrylimide (PMI) foam,
and comes in two grades: A (aircraft structural
grade) and HF (high frequency antenna grade). 5. A more familiar use for PET.
It has good resistance to most solvents and

6. Terminal 5 at London Heathrow Airport will use the latest technologies to tailor its wireless infrastructure.
Applications in buildings Conclusion

Most of today's landmark buildings, including airport terminals, major stations and In the future , construction firms, landlords, and
corporate headquarters, use glass fa9ades and are fitted out as open plan office or tenants should take closer interest in RF
public spaces. This in itself creates enormous challenges for designers of wireless propagation as wireless communications become
systems, particularly in resolving coverage vs. capacity, and addressing the issues more and more critical to business. Consultants and
of frequency management. One of the main security problems for these buildings is designers will also need to use the building
preventing unauthorized users from eavesdropping on their wireless networks from materials, fit-out materials, RF materials, FSS,
outside the building perimeter, but the distance from which a potential intelligent antennas, and wireless systems in a
eavesdropper can 'sniff' a wireless network can be greatly reduced through the combination of ways to achieve the desired results.
appropriate selection of building materials. It is possible today to procure glass with Though an FSS really needs to be able to
a significant level of attenuation built into it so that it will reduce the leakage of the differentiate cost-effectively between individual
radio signal outside the building. When supplemented with special screening channels in the 2.4GHz frequency band , the current
material that can be fitted to the inside of windows, this could bring the distance of developments in this technology have many
leaked signal to within the physical perimeter of the site. potential applications in industry.
A screening solution will also attenuate mobile cellular, PMR and TETRA signals, The project was one of 10 funded by Ofcom as
but by adding a low pass FSS into the walls at appropriate points it is possible to part of the Spectrum Efficiency Schemes 2003-
allow the required signals to propagate into the building . These principles can be 2004 . The detailed results and findings will be
applied in airports, major stations and trains, and theatres and auditoria as well published on the OFcom website,
as offices . http://www.ofcom .org .uk/research/ industry_market_
Airports and major stations have many tenants with independent wireless research/ technology_research/ses/ses2003-04.
communications requirements. In areas where there are physical boundaries
between adjacent tenants it may be possible to physical separate the tenant This feature is based in part on the article
systems using FSS combined with reflective screening . This would allow the 'Designing buildings for the wireless age ' in IEE
landlord systems to function as normal. Communications Engineer, June/July 2004.
One interesting problem for train operators is ensuring the propagation of
mobile cellular signals into the new carriages made with metalized windows,
where signal strengths are varied at best. Using a FSS designed for train carriage
Credits
operation it would be possible to allow the mobile cellular frequencies to propagate
Client: Ofcom Team members: Culham Electromagnetics
into the carriage. and Lightning : National Physical Laboratory; Warwick
Increasingly clients are requesting that some or all wireless communication is University; Arup - Bob Cather, Ken Kilfedder, Bruce
prevented within a specific space, eg operating theatres, auditoria, lecture theatres, Laidlaw, Alan Newbold, Edwin Stokes Illustrations:
1 Tim Pohl; 2 Ofcom ; 3, 4 Arup; 5 Todd Smith ; 6 Richard
and some meeting rooms. Through a combination of careful building planning and Rogers Partnership
the use of special materials it is possible to achieve up to 120dB of attenuation,
which could therefore have the desired effect.

Introduction
The Caltrar1s In March 2005, Thom Mayne of Morphosis was

awarded the 2005 Laureate of the prestigious
District 7 H,aadquarters, Pritzker Prize for architecture. The Caltrans District

7 Headquarters, Mayne's most recently completed
project, was described as one of his more important
Los Angeles projects: 'The design of this building goes beyond

merely providing functional spaces. It seeks in every
way to actively engage the city and people while
blurring the distinction between outside and inside,
with the objective of creating a government bureau
Eugene Desouza Andy Howard Teena Videriksen that works as a truly public building.'
The California Department of Transportation is, in
its own words, 'undergoing a transformation from a
Taking advantage of the prevailing climate of transportation bureaucracy to a mobility company'.
Southern California, the new headquarters - opened on Historically responsible for operating the labyrinth of
freeways and highways in California, its scope of
time and on budget - achie~ves high standards of responsibility now extends to other transport modes
energy-efficiency and sustainability. including rail and mass transit, and embraces issues
of appropriate land use and environmental
responsibility.
1. North-west view from City Hall, featuring tho light bar and the Eli & Edythe Broad Plaza.

District 7 is one of the more complex of the 12
districts which Caltrans oversees. Serving the City
of Los Angeles as well as the greater Los Angeles
and Ventura counties, District 7 sustains a
population of 11 M. Its existing headquarters
building was over 50 years old and, apart from
being too small and obsolete for the evolving
functions and aspirations of Caltrans, it carried a
visible legacy of damage from the January 1994
Northridge earthquake.
The challenge
In 2000 the State of California initiated a
competition for a new headquarters building that
would incorporate 'world-class design excellence,
sustainability, integration of art and architecture, and
contribute to the revitalization of the civic center'.
The delivery method was 'modified design/ build' ,
in which entrants are initially provided with more
detailed information about the proposed project
2. Plaza view from entry canopy looking north toward City Hall.
than in a conventional design/build approach.
The initial 11 developer/ contractor-driven teams
were reduced to a shortlist of three: Thomas the District 7 Headquarters, were instrumental in developing the 10 minute
Properties/Morley Construction/NBBJ , with OMA Diamond plan for the City of Los Angeles. Sadly Ira Yellin died during the course of
(Rem Koolhaas); Urban Partners/Clark the project, but its completion stands as a fitting symbol of his contribution to
Construction/Gruen , with Morphosis (Thom Mayne); downtown Los Angeles.
and Koll Construction/Langdon Wilson, with Miralles The architectural goals of the project were ambitious, and no less so were its
Tagliabue (Benedetta Tagliabue) . Arup contributed aspirations for sustainability: the building is expected to achieve the US Green
to all three teams. Building Council LEED™ (Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design)
The Urban Partners/Clark Construction/ Gruen/ Silver Rating.
Morphosis entry won, with Arup providing Upon receiving Notice to Proceed , a formidable project team was immediately
mechanical, electrical, plumbing, and mobilized. The architects and contractor established a joint project office where
telecommunications engineering, as well as teams of engineers and specialists camped during the hectic early weeks of the
sustainability advice. The team was commissioned schedule. Through close collaboration and a tremendous team spirit, the design
in February 2002. The design created 700 000ft 2 was developed rapidly to meet the critical structural steel mill order date, only four
(65 000m 2) of useable area, in a 10-storey tower on months into the design process. At this early stage the MEP design had to be
top of a three-storey podium, together with a sufficiently developed and detailed in order to commit to equipment room locations ,
350 000ft 2 (32 500m 2), four-level, subterranean equipment sizes and loads, and structural beam penetrations. This early critical
parking garage. The project budget was fixed at a milestone demanded tight discipline from the design team and a streamlined and
very competitive $17 4M against an aggressive linear design process.
30-month schedule. Although Arup was originally contracted to provide schematic and detailed
The challenge was to design and build over design services only, with construction documents being prepared by the trade
1Mft2 (100 000m 2) with full tenant improvement, on subcontractors, the modified design/ build contract included a rigorous submission ,
a city centre site that was not only restricted but review, and approval process to ensure design compliance with the bid documents.
architecturally sensitive. It lies opposite the lofty art Based on the value Arup provided in the negotiation of bid alternates and bid
deco splendours of Los Angeles' City Hall, which clarification requests, and to maintain consistency of the design intent, the general
has dominated the area since it was opened in contractor expanded Arup's role.
1928. Also nearby is the Cathedral of Our Lady of During the period when design was being transitioned from the design team to
the Angels , as well as the city's most striking new the trade subcontractors, and the project was already in construction, MEP
public building, the Walt Disney Concert Hall. equipment ordering became critical to the project schedule. Interaction between
In addition, the site lies within the '10 minute designers and builders became intense as the team worked to resolve detailed
Diamond' - a plan originally initiated some 20 years specification interpretation issues that stalled the ordering of major air-handling and
ago to restore downtown Los Angeles. By creating cooling equipment. It was at this particularly demanding stage that the mechanical
an accessible and attractive urban environment, the subcontractor declared bankruptcy, forcing the appointment of a replacement.
plan is intended to draw people back downtown to
both live and work. Dan Rosenfeld and Ira Yellin of
Urban Partners, who led the winning consortium for

The design/build process against such an aggressive schedule demanded that cost
and value engineering be strong and continual components of the design process.
The fa<;:ades became the focus of detailed costing, value, and constructability
review early in the process. Arup developed fa9ade modelling using ROOM and
NATFAC to determine the thermal performance and internal comfort conditions
produced by a range of fa9ade options. ROOM is part of the E+ TA (environmental
and thermal analysis) software suite developed by OASYS, Arup's software
development and sales company. The team selected for detailed evaluation, a
semi-active solution incorporating an exterior 'scrim' of perforated sheet metal.
The lifecycle value of the fa9ade was then assessed and compared with other
more traditional solutions. The modelling demonstrated capital cost savings
derived from reduction in the HVAC system capacity and , more importantly to
Caltrans, a significant lifecycle benefit that helped gain support for the
unconventional approach .
The scrim comprises framed aluminum panels punched with holes of varying
sizes to provide 48% openness, and allow for clear vision and natural light. The
scrim acts as a second skin 1Oin (250mm) away from the inner fa9ade, while also
3. Interior view from office of scrim pneumatic actuators.
contributing significantly to the character of the building and its presence on the LA
skyline. In addition to its clean, hi-tech aesthetic, the scrim reduces energy
Arup 's role was immediately expanded to ensure consumption effectively while maintaining a bright working environment and
progress of the construction documents, and providing views of the city. It also acts as a shade, reducing solar heat gains and
provide daily site presence to aid in the rapid limiting infiltration of unconditioned outside air by reducing wind pressure on the
orientation of the new mechanical subcontractor. inner fa9ade .
Ultimately Arup's involvement on the project
increased to 50% more than originally anticipated.
The general contractor and entire team 4. Detail of photovoltaic panels and south escape stairway.
collaborated in an intense effort to overcome the
setback caused by the loss of this key trade
subcontractor. Incredibly the project schedule was
recovered , and the completed building was handed
over to a very happy client at the end of the
programmed 30-month concurrent design/
build period .
Energy efficiency
The building orientation evolved in response to
functional requirements and the surrounding urban
environment, and the resulting form presented
extensive east , south, and west fa9ades on a
narrow plan designed to maximize occupant views
and the use of daylight.
The thermal performance of the fa9ade was
identified as critical to achieving the aggressive
energy conservation targets set forth in the
design/build brief. The client specified that the
measured building performance should better the
energy efficiency requirements of the California
Energy Commission Title 24 by 20%. This equated
to about a 30% improvement on ASHRAE 90. 1,
which is adopted in many states as an energy
usage benchmark. The team exceeded this goal by
documenting 30% savings on Title 24 (equating to
40% improvement on ASHRAE 90.1).

To further reduce heat gain , the east and west Savings by Design
fa9ades have been designed as thermal flues , using This programme, funded by California utility
the building height and hot sun on the external face customers under the auspices of the Public
Utilities Commission and administered through
of the scrim to generate high air change rates four utilities - the Pacific Gas and Electric
between the outer and inner fa9ades. This serves to Company (PG&E), San Diego Gas and Electric
keep the driver of conductive heat exchange close (SDG&E}, Southern California Edison Company
(Edison or SCE} and Southern California Gas
to the ambient air temperature. Many of the scrim Company (SoCal Gas} - exists to encourage
panels are powered to open automatically in high-performance non-residential building
response to the position of the sun , playfully design and construction .
punctuating the otherwise clean lines and flat Financial incentives are available to owners
when a new building's efficiency exceeds the
planes of the building's outer skin . minimum Savings by Design thresholds,
Balancing cost and fa9ade performance was a generally 10% better than Title 24 standards.
continual challenge, particularly as the team These incentives encourage owners to make
energy efficiency a major goal in their new
explored options for some form of protection for the buildings, and help to defray some of the costs 5. View from behind photovoltaic panels .
south elevation that would provide contrast with the of energy-efficient building components .
east and west fa9ades . A range of solutions that To supper! the extra effort for integrated energy of the building compared to the Title 24
design and to reward exceptional design baseline. The design team qualifies for
met the architectural objectives and engineering
accomplishments, Savings by Design also offers incentives when the building design saves
performance criteria was quickly developed , financial incentives to design teams. In its at least 15%.
however delivering these solutions within the Whole Building Approach, a computer
simulation model calculates the energy savings http://www.savingsbydesign .com
contractor's budget demanded a more innovative
approach to design and procurement. Ultimately,
the team went up-market for a cheaper solution,
leveraging the financial incentives offered by the
State and utility providers to promote alternative Through extensive computational modeling of the sun path across the annual cycle,
energy generation . a balance was struck between the BIPV summer and winter applications. This
On the south fa9ade the aluminum scrim is resulted in a panel angle of 50° off the horizontal and a spacing between panels of
replaced with an open lattice framework that 5ft (1 .5m) .
supports a vision glass wall incorporating a The design/ build team was able to reduce the cost of the unique multifunctional
14 000ft 2 (1300m 2) array of 895 building integrated fa9ade system by securing $800 OOO in rebates from Savings by Design , the
photovoltaic (BIPV) panels. The panels harvest solar Southern California Gas Company, and the Los Angeles Department of Water
energy and convert it to electricity during peak and Power.
hours when cooling demands are at their highest, In addition to the effective performance of the composite fa9ade, the energy
providing significant energy savings due to the conservation target was exceeded through a combination of measures including :
punitive peak demand energy tariff structure. The • control of minimum outside air supply using C02 measurement
direct current power generated by the BIPV cells (demand ventilation)
flows through power conversion equipment and into • premium efficiency motors for all equipment
the building's electrical distribution system , • extensive use of variable speed drives interfacing with the building
contributing 92kW of peak power. management system (BMS)
In addition to its energy saving properties, the • variable volume pumping
south fa9ade behaves similarly to the east and • increased chiller efficiency
west, reducing the heat load by shading from the • equipment sizing to maintain efficiency at actual operating points
opaque, monocrystalline BIPV cells. reducing (ie high peak and part load efficiencies)
infiltration , and promoting natural ventilation • improved control system accuracy and performance
between the two vertical layers of fa9ade . • the building control and automation systems
Detailed sunpath studies were undertaken to • system commissioning
determine: • appropriate minimum thicknesses for pipe and duct insulation
• the optimum power output angle of the panels • optimized thermal insulation performance for building envelope
• their vertical spacing to prevent self-shading • use of dual-pane, low-E, and low solar heat gain coefficient glazing
• the optimum cell density in the panels to achieve • external environmental control in the form of the scrim on the east and
the required output and maximize natural light in west fa9ades
the offices • angled photovoltaic panels over the entire south fa9ade fenestration.
• their positioning relative to each other in order
to balance aesthetic with the occupant lines
of sight.

The control parameters are as follows:
• occupancy sensors
• light level sensors to optimize the use of
daylighting
• free cooling, ventilation, cooling tower
economizer cycles
• energy and demand monitoring
• C0 2 monitoring for demand ventilation
• CO monitoring for car park exhaust
• chiller optimization
• boiler optimization.
Mechanical systems
The building is cooled by three water-cooled VFD
centrifugal chillers, utilizing non-HCFC refrigerant;
one sized to handle the base cooling load, while the
other two are each sized to handle 50% of the peak
cooling load. They provide a total cooling capacity
of 1800 tons of refrigeration (6.33MW) - 120% of
peak load - and are in a basement mechanical
equipment room, served by four open-cell, induced-
draft cooling towers of equal size for heat rejection .
The cooling towers were selected to cool 120%
6. View of maintenance walkway on the south fa9ade between glazing and photovoltaic panels. of the peak chiller capacity, equating to 144% of the
peak design load. A constant volume primary and
variable flow secondary chilled water system is
Energy modelling shows the envelope performance to be very good; overall the provided. Part of the cooling system can operate
system was designed to achieve approximately 1 ton of refrigeration per 400ft 2 on emergency power, providing 350 tons of
(94.6W/m 2) in the hot southern California climate. refrigeration (1.2MW) under standby power
The chiller plant was designed to operate with an annual energy efficiency of no scenario.
more than 0.55kWh of energy consumec! per ton-hour (0.156kW per kWh) of Three equal-sized natural gas-fired boilers
cooling capacity delivered to the air distribution system. This includes the chillers, located in a basement level mechanical equipment
chilled water pumps, condenser water pumps, and the cooling tower fans. In room discharge flue gases into a common header
practice, the variable frequency drive (VFD) centrifugal chillers have a full load flue that runs up a dedicated riser shaft to vent at
efficiency of <0.5kW/ton and part load e'fficiency of <0.36kW per ton.
Similarly, the air distribution system was designed to deliver air at an annual
energy consumption of no greater than 0.40kWh of power consumed per ton-hour 7. View of south-east corner from Second Street,
incorporating photovoltaic panels.
(0.114kW per kWh) of cooling delivered.
All major HVAC equipment and drivin1~ motor efficiencies were selected to
minimize effective operating costs. California Energy Commission standards were
used to determine the minimum acceptable level of efficiency for analysis.
Bu ild ing automation

A comprehensive DOC (direct digital control) BMS serves the building, based on
individual microprocessor-based controls for separate subsystems such as the
lighting and mechanical controls.
The control parameters are presented on a conventional PC workstation allowing
monitoring and adjustment of all building environmental functions. This allows the
client to provide a comprehensive 'help desk' type of service for responding to staff
problems or equipment failures. The automatic controls establish and monitor the
principal environmental control criteria, while still allowing for a degree of user
control over their local environments. Th13 control system is optimized for energy
conservation , utilizing free energy, such as economizer cycle cool air and daylight
whenever available.

roof level, 14 floors up. These boilers supply 150%
of the building heating load required by the client, ie
50% standby/redundancy. The total installed
heating capacity is 8925MBH (2.6MW).
Eight exterior AHUs, each supplying about
45 000ft3/min (21 m 3/sec) of air, are at upper roof
level and serve levels 4-13. Seven more AHUs in
basement mechanical equipment rooms, and on
the lower roof, serve all spaces from ground level
to level 3. All AHUs serving office areas are
equipped with airside economizers controlled on
dry bulb temperature.
The mechanical rooms are strategically located
to take into account the wind direction around the
building and to ensure that the intake louvres, for
the full outside air economizers, avoid excessive
wind pressures, entrainment of noxious pollutants,
toilet exhaust fan discharge, and discharge effluent
from the cooling tower systems. A combination of
smaller AHUs and fan coil units (FCUs) serve the
elevator machine rooms and electrical closets,
which contain transformers and communication
closets on each floor. The AHUs can supply up to
523 OOOft 3/min (246m3/sec) of air into the building.
The AHUs are sized to optimize the air velocity
through the filters and over the cooling coils,
thereby optimizing the system static pressure
requirements. Belt-driven plenum (plug) fans are
used to achieve the most effective fan selection to
satisfy the system characteristics, and to provide
optimum acoustic performance. Each AHU has the
capability for full airside economizer operation, using
the return fan as exhaust fans in this application,
through the articulation of the damper systems.
8. View of plaza featuring plaza artwork and signage.
The turndown operating characteristics of the
individual AHUs has been evaluated to ensure
acceptable performance at lower air flow quantities. architectural structures. A common header connects the air inlet points to the top
Kitchenettes and core toilets are connected to of each supply air dropper.
the general exhaust air system within the two On the south fa9ade , a plenum tower discharges exhaust air more than 15ft
common risers, extending through the building core. (4.5m) above ground via external louvres, and away from populated areas such as
In the event of a fire , this riser doubles for smoke the sidewalk, open plaza and exterior playground. Sensors control variable speed
exhaust, drawing air off the fire floor and negatively supply and exhaust fans to maintain acceptable levels of CO within the parking
pressurizing the space. garage. Utilizing VFDs ensures that substantial energy is saved when operating the
In the data centre, close control CRAC garage ventilation system . The exhaust fans are rated to work at 250°F as they also
(computer room air-conditioning) units with filters, serve as smoke exhaust fans for the parking levels. Up to 623 OOOft3/min
chilled water coil and electric steam humidifiers, (294m 3/ sec) of air is exhausted from the parking garage.
meet the room loads. These units, together with Telephone services and communication rooms housing sensitive electronic
part of the chilled water system, operate on components are conditioned by ceiling -mounted chilled water FCUs, served by part
emergency power to maintain conditions if the main of the building's 24/ 7 air-conditioning system .
power fails. The design includes an additional 10% capacity for future use on all the building
The four basement levels of parking are systems, including but not limited to all of the air systems and the chilled water and
ventilated by a mechanically-driven push-pull heating hot water systems. All equipment, ducting and piping meets this
system, in which supply shafts drop down at the requirement by being sized to accommodate this future load . The equipment sizes
north end of the parking levels and exhaust shafts were determined based on the highest air flow rate obtained from computer-
rise up at the south end. Fans are located at each generated heat gain calculations to offset each room 's load at the time of the
of these riser shafts, and supply air is brought in via building's peak block load.
elevated external air intake openings within

The indirect lighting provides general ambient lighting and is controlled through the
building automation system . The direct lighting is primarily used to enhance the
working environment for staff and their performance. The luminaries at each
workstation are equipped with integral occupancy sensors that control the
operation of direct lighting component to reduce the amount of energy wasted .
The perimeter fixtures are furnished with integral photocell/occupancy sensors,
which automatically dim when there is sufficient natural daylight available or
when someone leaves the space, thereby creating a functional and energy
efficient environment.
Communications
The data communications cabling infrastructure is supported by two completely
redundant incoming service routes. One is designed to support local service
providers and the Caltrans fibre optic ring, while the second supports other tenants,
and serves as the building's redundant pathway to the outside world . The pathways
for incoming services are designed to support current cabling infrastructure with an
allowance of 25% for future expansion. Both routes serve the main incoming
9. Aerial view from the north-west.
service room (MPOE) . Through various pathways (conduit and cable tray) , the
MPOE is connected to the main distribution frame (MDF) .
Fire engineering The 900ft 2 (84m 2) main computer room, or data centre, is adjacent to the MDF.
The high rise smoke management is provided by Two sets of telecom rooms. vertically stacked , are designed to provide riser
rated exhaust fans on the upper roof. There are two pathways to connect all 14 floors to the MDF and data centre. A fully redundant
fans at the top of two dedicated riser shafts, one fibre optic ring connects all telecom rooms to the data centre.
per full building height core, and each sized at a The data cabling system comprises a network of copper cable supported by
capacity of 35 OOOft 3/ min (16.5m 3/ sec). Fire-rated fibre optic cable. The data centre houses the electronics that support a network of
shafts extend down the full building height. Under a cameras throughout the Los Angeles metropolitan area, as well as Caltrans data
fire scenario, the smoke dampers off these rising and voice networks. Multiple radio systems are installed in this building to
shafts will open on the fire floor and the fans on the communicate with incoming helicopters. various Caltrans departments, police and
roof will ramp up as required for the particular Caltrans satellite offices.
smoke/ fire zone. These smoke exhaust fans are
State raises the bar
provided with emergency power from thE3
emergency generators for this purpose. Fire Through a design/build process that promoted and placed emphasis on design
fighting/escape stairwells are provided with stairwell excellence through the unique bidding procedure. the State of California has
pressurization systems, with the ability to procured an outstanding piece of urban architecture within an aggressive budget
introduce 12 00Qft3/min (5 .6m 3/ sec) of outside air and to an ambitious schedule. The project has already won several awards and is
into the stairwells, distributed over the fuill height expected to receive the US Green Building Council's LEED™ Silver Rating for its
of the building. demonstrable achievement of exemplary sustainability goals. The building is a
credit to those involved and raises the bar for future public projects in the City
Lighting of Los Angeles.
The open office spaces are illuminated by pendant
direct/indirect three-lamp fluorescent luminaries with
state-of-the-art control to create a visually dynamic
Cred its
environment. The fixtures are unique in that they are
Owner: Department of General Services, California; User: District 7, California Department of
provided with digital addressable ballasts and are Transportation; Design/build team : Main and First Design/Build Associates. Inc .. which
controlled both via a network lighting control system consists of: Urban Partners. LLC (Developer); The Clark Construction Group, Inc. (General
and locally. These ballasts are based on the DALi Contractor); Morphosis (Design Architect); and Gruen Associates (Executive Architect);
Mechanical , electrical, plumbing and telecommunications engineers: Arup - Peter Alspach ,
(digital addressable lighting interface) Robert Buckley, Joe Ceballos . Susan Chen , Vahik Davoudi , Eugene de Souza. Steve Done,
communication protocol and are compa1tible with Keith Franklin, Kathleen Hannon. Andy Howard, Rick Lasser, Craig Macadang, Julian Mamro,
other open protocols used in building automation Anait Manjikian. Vahan Margaryan, Maurya McClintock. Bruce McKinlay, lldiko Mezei, Josef
Nejat, Morad Pajouhan, Jonathan Phillips, Fernando Rivas. Jerry Rodriguez. Lisamarie Roed,
systems, thus presenting opportunities for total Massoud Safaee, Helen Sinanyan, Raymond Tam, Armen Topakian; Construction manager:
building system integration. O'Brien Kreitzberg/URS Corporation; Structural engineer: John A. Martin Associates, Inc
Illustrations: 1, 7, 10 John Linden; 2, Benny Chan/Fotoworks; 3. 6. 8, 9, Roland Halbe;
4, 5 Jim Sinsheimer

'The new Caltrans District 7 Headquarters
is the fastest, most affordable, and most
innovative public building ever developed
in California, and Arup's contribution to this
project was significant. They were able to
maintain their creativity, while working
within tight budget and schedule
restraints, and with a demanding client.'
Dan Rosenfeld, Principal, Urban Partners LLC
The Arup Journal Vol.40 No .2 (2/2005) Arup is a global organization of designers. It has a
ARUP Editor: David J Brown Designer: Nigel Whale
Editorial: Tel: +1 508 616 9990
Fax: +1 508 616 9991
constantly evolving skills base, and works for local and
international clients throughout the world.
E-mail: [email protected] w.ar p.com
Published by Corporate Communications Group,
Arup, 13 Fitzroy Street, London W1T 480, UK.
Tel: +44 (0)20 7636 1531 Fax: +44 (0)20 7580 3924
E-mail: [email protected]
Illustrations: 1. M,ami AlrPort OTA: performance-based fire protectoo: Arup: 2. 'The Hub' Community Resource Centre, London: Arup/Oenn,s G,lberWIEW:
Front cover. 3. 4, 5. Plantahon Place development Chnst,an R,chters: 6. Makong knowledge work: Ng Choon Boon: 7 Constotut,onal Court. Johannesburg: Angela Buckland:
8. Des,gn,ng bu,ld,ngs lor a wireless world: N,gel Whale; 9 The Scottosh Parliament Bu,ld,ng. Edinburgh: Peter Cook/V,ew; 10. Caltrans D1stroct 7 Headquarters. Lus Angeles:
Roland Halbe t t, Inside front cover. CClV Headquarters, Be11,ng, China: OMA
Pnnted 1n England by Beaccn Press using their pureprlnf environmental pr,nt technotogy. The pnnt1ng inks are made from vegetable based Olis and 95% of cleaning solvents ara
recycled lor further use. All electnc1ty was generated lrom renewable sources and on average 88% ol any waste assoc,ated with th,s product will be recycled. Beacon Press 1s a
Carbon Neutral'" company and has planted 3000 trees to offset its carbon emissions, and ,s registered to environmental standards 14001 and EMAS.

The Arup Journal Issue 2 2005 Comp

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

The Arup Journal Issue 2 2005 Comp

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

The Arup Journal Issue 2 2005 Comp

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

2/2005

The Arup Journal

The Scottish Parliament

'The Hub ' Community

Making knowledge work

Plantation Place development,

41 Plantation Place South

Miami Airport QTA:

Designing buildings for a

Chris Carroll Paul Cross Xiaonian Duan Craig Gibbons

The Arup Journal 2/2005 3

buildings, and on the construction process to completion and opening.

The new CCTV headquarters development

4 The Arup Journal 2/2005

Superstructure - the 'continuous tube '

The Arup Journal 2/2005 5

Chinese approvals p rocess

prevented when subjected to a level 3

The Arup Journal 2/2005 7

8 The Arup Journal 2/2005

The nex1 article in this series, discussing the building

The Arvp Journal 212005 9

From the contemplative seating in the fa9ade to the

2 . Window seat in MSP 's office.

10 The Arup Journal 2/2005

4. Computer image of main buildings.

The Arup Journal 2/2005 11

1 2 The Arup Journal 2/2005

9. Computer model of the debating chamber roof. 11. Committee room.

The Arup Journal 2/2005 13

The MSP building

14 The Arup Journal 2/2005

15. Upper and lower pergolas and the north-east canopy.

The Arup Journal 2/2005 15

16 The Arup Journal 2/2005

Application of blast protection measures

The Arup Journal 2/2005 17

22. MSP building west elevation winalow.

18 The Arup Journal 2/2005

9/11 and The Holyrood Inquiry

23. Wall stitching with grouted anchors: length, number,

The Arup Journal 2/2005 19

20 The Arup Journal 2/2005

Court in Johannesburg. focused on the Court building , an appropriate

The Arup Journal 2/2005 21

A law library with IT links to the world

22 The Arup Journal 2/2005

The Arup Journal 2/2005 23

2 Great African Stairs 9 Foyer

3 Exhibition arcade 10 Court

5 Public auditorium 12 Judges' chambers

6 Administration 13 Existing sub-station

7 Council robing and 14 Judges' lounge, conference

The winning concept

24 The Arup Journal 212005

The Arup Journal 2/2005 25

26 The Arup Journal 2/2005

The Arup Journal 212005 27

'The Hub' Community The client's brief required that the