Functional Brain SPECT: The Emergence of A Powerful Clinical Method
Functional Brain SPECT: The Emergence of A Powerful Clinical Method
Functional Brain SPECT: The Emergence of A Powerful Clinical Method
Department ofRadiology, Harvard Medical School and Brigham and Women ‘s Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts and
Department ofRadiology, University ofTexas Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas, Texas
..,.......
!•
•S •,@S S S SS FIGURE 1. High-resolution
simultaneously by dual-isotope
1•1••Ii••• acquisitionof the two radiotra
cars injected sequentially. A
128 x 128 acquisitionmatrix
was employed using a high
resolution(7—8
mm)fanbeam
collimatorand a three-headed
SPECT system. Note similar
POST 1* posT image resolution for both brain
bloodflowtracers.
@ I—
@M.PAO
@ 3, t@ t@\j@
FIGURE4. Three-dimensionalsurface-renderedimages
showing a right frontopanetal resting rCBF deficit with expansion
following vasodilation with Diamox in a stroke patient. The differ
ence in affected areas in the resting and vasodilated studies
@.
representstheareaof failedvasodilatoryreserve.
@ DEMENTIA t@ p
Alzheimer'sDisease
Approximately halfofthe patients presenting with early FIGURE 5. Technetium-99m-HMPAO
SPECT usingthe high
resolution
ASPECTsystem.Bilateral
temporoparietal
perfusion
clinical symptoms of dementia cannot be accurately diag defects in a patient with Alzheimer's disease. Axial(A)and sagittal
nosed by clinical criteria. Early diagnosis is important (B) planes.
because dementia-like symptoms may mask reversible
conditions, such as depression, or treatable diseases, such
as vascular dementia. Furthermore, early diagnosis of Alz While bilateral posterior cortical defects are highly pre
heimer's disease can avoid the financial and emotional dictive in Alzheimer's disease, this scintigraphic pattern
drain that often occurs if the time to final diagnosis is has also been described in patients with vascular dementia
needlessly delayed. (91), Parkinson's disease (94,95), mitochondrial ence
Brain perfusion SPECT is useful in the diagnostic eval phalomyopathy (96), hypoglycemia (97) and carbon mon
uation of patients with memory and cognitive abnormali oxide poisoning (97). The scintigraphic pattern of Parkin
ties (79). Initial clinical studies comparing patients with son's disease with dementia cannot be distinguished from
Alzheimer's disease and normal control subjects (80—87) that of Alzheimer's disease by visual assessment alone.
or patients with multi-infarct dementia (88—91)found that While Parkinson's disease patients with dementia have a
SPECT is highly accurate. In severely impaired patients, variety of scintigraphic patterns, the most common in
sensitivity is 95% or greater ( 79,83). The sensitivity of volves the temporoparietal cortex (94,95).
SPECT in the classification of mildly impaired patients is The reduced tracer uptake in the posterior association
also high, with rates reported between 80% and 87% (79, cortex in patients with Alzheimer's disease is probably due
86,92). to multiple factors, including reduced rCBF, decreased
The predominant finding ofbilateral posterior temporal cortical thickness in the temporoparietal cortex (98) and
and parietal perfusion defects in these patients is highly a reduced number of neurons in the affected areas (99).
predictive of Alzheimer's disease (Fig. 5). In a prospective Most of the reduced tracer activity is due to reduced
study of over 100 patients with memory loss, bilateral regional blood flow, however, particularly in early disease
posterior association cortex defects were detected with (100). In any case, the combined effect of flow reduction
99mTcHMPAO SPECT in 65% of the patients with Alz and atrophy serve to increase the diagnostic sensitivity of
heimer's disease (93). This pattern, with or without addi the test, and atrophy corrections are probably not war
tional association cortex defects, has a predictive value of ranted for routine applications.
over 80% for the diagnosis of Alzheimer's disease. Patients with Alzheimer's disease can present with other
scintigraphic patterns, although they are less frequent than AIDS Dementia Complex
bilateral posterior cortical defects (93). Unilateral tempo The early clinical signs of AIDS dementia complex
roparietal defects are not predictive either for or against (ADC) or HIV encephalopathy are often subtle and may
Alzheimer's disease. With 99mTc@HMPAO,unilateral pos be indistinguishable from depression, psychosis or focal
tenor defects are seen in 15%—20%of patients with Alz neurologic disease. Since treatment such as zidovudine
heimer's disease (93), significantly more than with [1231] (AZT) can improve cognitive function in ADC, its early
IMP (80). Consequently, vascular dementia involving the detection is important. Computed tomography (CT) and
posterior branches of the middle cerebral artery may re magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) play a role in diagnos
semble Alzheimer's disease when the latter presents as a ing focal neurologic disease, such as infection or tumor,
unilateral pattern. but are nonspecific for ADC. Brain perfusion SPECT is
Some investigators recognize dementia of the frontal highly sensitive for the detection ofADC (102—104).Early
type as an entity separate from Alzheimer's disease (92), disease is easily separated from normal subjects and non
with the former presenting with personality and behavioral HIV psychoses (105—106).The perfusion pattern is usually
changes and with less severe memory deficits. These in described as multifocal or patchy cortical and subcortical
vestigators find that the two dementias can be distin hypoperfusion. With high-resolution SPECT, we found a
guished scintigraphically, with bilateral frontal or fronto high incidence of cortical defects in ADC, which are most
temporal deficits characteristic of frontal lobe dementia. frequent in the frontal, temporal and parietal lobes (107)
Frontal dementia is considered by many to be a subset of (Fig. 6). Background activity is high, involving more than
Alzheimer's disease. In either case, bilateral frontal deficits halfofthe patients in our series. Basal ganglia involvement
by themselves are not diagnostic and are seen in patients is also frequent. A high number of patients have focal
with schizophrenia, depression, progressive supranuclear areas of increased activity as well. The perfusion pattern
palsy (usually with basal ganglia involvement) and Pick's improves with ADC therapy (105). Brain perfusion
disease as well as in Alzheimer's disease and/or frontal SPECT should be applied cautiously in patients with sus
lobe dementia. pected ADC because an identical brain perfusion pattern
The probability of Alzheimer's disease with normal is seen among chronic cocaine polydrug users (107). It is
perfusion or with perfusion defects outside the temporo also not clear whether the perfusion pattern is limited to
parietal cortex is low. The predictive value of a normal ADC or may be seen with nonspecific changes such as
scan depends on the clinical setting. When patients are white matter pallor, astrocytic proliferation and mononu
well screened before referral for SPECT, few of them will clear infiltration which are present in almost all AIDS
be without central nervous system disease. In our experi patients. It may not matter since SPECT imaging may
ence, when patients are screened by a memory disorder prove to be an indicator ofthe severity ofbrain dysfunction
clinic, the negative predictive value of a normal study is and therefore may be quite useful in planning therapy and
about 80%. The predictive value will increase as more in evaluating its effectiveness.
normal patients are included in the population.
EPILEPSY
VascularDementia Functional brain imaging with either SPECT or PET is
Vascular dementia is related to a number of distinct now a well-established technique to localize the epileptic
underlying diseases (101). Binswanger's disease or subcor focus in patients with refractory complex partial seizures
tical atherosclerotic encephalopathy involves the microcir
culation, presents as white matter disease and is attributed
@ to atherosclerosis of penetrating cerebral arteries. Multi ‘.@4 s@
infarct dementia involves the large vessels and results from
large cerebral infarcts. A third disease, a form of multi
infarct dementia but not usually involving large-vessel
occlusion, results from multiple small, deep, subcortical
lacunar and pericapsular infarctions. Mixed forms of these
three vascular diseases often occur. Technetium-99m-
HMPAO SPECT appears reasonably accurate for distin
guishing vascular dementia from Alzheimer's disease when
bilateral temporoparietal defects are present (82,83). The
scintigraphic pattern of multi-infarct dementia is usually
described as multiple asymmetrical perfusion defects, often
involving the primary cortex and deep structures. Vascular
dementias which involve the subcortical structure are as FIGURE6. Technetium-99m-HMPAO
SPECT(axialplanes).
sociated with patchy or diffuse patterns of blood flow Multiple small perfusion defects throughout the cerebral cortex
reduction. in a patient with AIDS dementia complex.
Functional
BrainSPECT•
HolmanandDevous 1895
lism declines rapidly (118). In addition, secondary gener functional brain imaging. By far, the most common path
alization may occur. Ictal studies with iodinated agents ologic finding is mesial temporal sclerosis, which is thought
have been more successfulin identifying seizurefoci than to be the consequence of an older lesion now manifested
interictal studies (126,128,129,134). Unfortunately, true as a gliotic scar (143). A review ofSPECT and PET studies
ictal studieswith HMPAO are nearly impossibleto obtain demonstrates a 34% incidenceof focalMRI abnormalities
because this compound is unstable in vitro, leading to and a 17% incidence on CT. This is contrasted to a 71%
delays between seizure onset and injection of 5—20mm. incidence of focal EEG changes and a 59% incidence of
In the study by Rowe et a!., 22/30 patients with focal EEG focal abnormalities on interictal functional imaging meas
findings showed increased postictal HMPAO uptake at the ures (108). A few studies demonstrate a close relationship
site of the EEG focus (133). These data suggest that early between the severity of interictal ICBF reductions and
postictal studies (within 5 mm) may be as effective as true eitherclinicalsymptomatologyor cognitiveimpairment
ictal injections. (144). Homan et al. compared SPECT and neuropsycho
In a recent review, the combination ofall EEG data was logical assessments in 50 patients with partial seizures
localizing in 71 % of the patients (108). By contrast, func (145). Even though rCBF and neuropsychological deficits
tional imaging (SPECT or PET) was localizing in 59% of were relatively mild in many patients, at least one low
the interictal studies and 65% of ictal studies. These data flow region matched an area of neuropsychologically im
suggest that ofthe patients with EEG-localized seizure foci, paired function in 43 ofSO patients. There was a significant
79% were equally well localized by functional brain im correlation between areas of visually identified hypoper
aging. It is interesting to note that the localizing power of fusion and neuropsychological impairment (p < 0.001).
interictal functional imaging is not substantially different Stepwise discriminate function analyses revealed predic
between SPECT and PET, nor is it significantly different tive relationships between deficits on specific neuropsy
between IMP, HIPDM and HMPAO. chological tests and visually identified hypoperfusion, par
ticularly in the left and right temporal regions. Similar
PrimaryGeneralizedSeizures
data were reported by Berent et al. (146).
There are few data concerning functional abnormalities
in generalized seizures (12,136—138). These results are Pediatric Studies
consistent with the failure of surface or depth EEG or Seizures in children may result from a variety of under
structural imaging modalities such as CT and MRI to lying pathologies. There may be no relationship between
definea specificanatomicregionof seizureoriginin these clinical symptoms and either electrographic or radio
patients (139). Leroy et al. did not detect quantitative graphic findings, and the patients often have unpredictable
asymmetries in rCBF (137) and Theodore et al. found no courses. Functional brain imaging could be useful in un
significant differences in glucose metabolic rates (136). derstanding clinical pleomorphisms associated with partic
ular diseases, or as a device for subcategorizations useful
FrontalLobe Seizures
in predicting progression. Unfortunately, there are only
In recent years, there has been increased interest in
seven published studies concerning functional brain im
partial seizures originating from areas other than the tem
aging in pediatric epilepsy, excluding case reports and
poral lobe (140). Frontal lobe seizures have been difficult
abstracts. Six of these involve PET (147—152)and one is
to localize using standard EEG technique, and stereotactic
an IMP SPECT study (153). The only clear conclusion
depth electrodes have not proven to be as beneficial for
that may be drawn is that more work needs to be done. It
localizing the site of the seizure origin as in temporal lobe
is likely, given the adult experience and the limited pedi
seizures. The results ofsurgical treatment of extratemporal
atric results, that functional brain imaging abnormalities
partial seizures has been disappointing in comparison to
will precede structural signs in infants and will likely
the results of temporal lobe surgery. Functional imaging
provide an insight into observed seizure activity. The
holds promise for localization of the site of extratemporal
limited studies available for review suggest of a prognostic
seizures, but limited data currently exist. It appears that
as well as a diagnostic role for functional brain imaging in
60%—70%of subjects with proven extratemporal seizures
pediatric patients, but such a role is not yet established.
demonstrate hypometabolism interictally (141). These hy
pometabolic areas appear widespread and are less localized PRIMARY BRAIN TUMORS
than in temporal lobe seizures.
Malignant gliomas carry a dismal prognosis due to their
Structural,Clinicaland CognitiveCorrelations aggressive biological behavior. Newer treatment modali
Patients with partial and secondarily generalized sei ties, however, including radiosurgery and brachytherapy,
zures are much more likely to have structural abnormali have resulted in increased local control and survival rates
ties observable on CT or MRI than patients with primary (154). With aggressive treatment, an increasing number of
generalized tonic-clonic seizures or absence attacks (142). patients will present with symptoms and signs that may
It is not always true that abnormalities detected on struc be secondary to recurrent tumor or to radiation changes
tural imaging studies are correlated with the seizure focus alone. Establishing the cause of clinical deterioration in
defined by clinical or EEG criteria or, for that matter, with malignant glioma patients treated with high dose radiation
(@@_) mal controls and that these regional effects existed sepa
rately from global alterations (181 ). Also, Devous et al.
recently compared ‘33Xe SPECT in rCBF in 48 sympto
matic MDD patients (13 nonendogenous, 24 endogenous
(. I •@
(‘ (.-@ :‘ and 11 psychotic) to 48 age- and gender-matched normal
controls (188). Results revealed a significant age-by-de
@ [email protected] t\11@@1_) @: _@ pressive subtype interaction for gCBF and for rCBF ratios.
Age effects on rCBF differed not only by region but also
FIGURE 9. Thallium-201SPECT (axial planes).Horseshoe among the three diagnostic subtypes. These findings of age
shapedregionof high20111 uptakein a patientwith a recurrent
glioblastoma in the right temporal lobe following surgery and effects among depressive subgroups are only one indication
brachytherapy. ofthe heterogenous nature ofthe population. For example,
FunctionalBrainSPECT •
Holmanand Devous 1897
the notion of global reductions in cerebral blood flow in Technetium-99m-HMPAO SPECT has been shown to be
depression has been both supported and opposed. Such a more sensitive than CT in detecting abnormalities in pa
diversity of results may be explained by examining the tients with a history oftraumatic brain injury, particularly
endogenous/nonendogenous and psychotic/nonpsychotic in the minor head injury group (223). Thus, 42 patients
patient mixtures in each study. (80%)showed
rCBFdeficits
withSPECT
compared
with
29 patients (55%) with CT. In addition to its higher
ObsessiveCompulsiveDisorder sensitivity, SPECT reflects changes in perfusion at an
PET studies have revealed abnormalities in glucose met earlier time than CT (224). In a preliminary study, patients
abolic rates in obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD) pa
with large lesions, multiple defects and lesions involving
tients, but the implicated areas vary from study to study.
the brain stem appeared to have a worse prognosis than
Baxter et al. have found increased metabolism in the those patients with nonfocal, small lesions, particularly if
caudate nuclei, orbital gyri, hemispheres and orbital gyrus
they involved frontal or occipital lobes. SPECT may also
to-hemisphere ratio bilaterally ( 190, 191 ). Nordahl et al.
predict the degree ofpermanent damage and those patients
did not report global, hemispheric or caudate abnormali
who will develop post-traumatic headache (225). Roper et
ties, but did find increased orbital frontal metabolism
al. has shown that with HMPAO SPECT some patients
bilaterally and decreased right parietal and left parieto
with traumatic brain injury may have cerebral blood flow
occipital metabolism in OCD as compared to normals
equal to that of surrounding brain (226). This informa
(192). Another conflicting study reports increased metab
tion may be of prognostic value or may simply indicate
olism in the right prefrontal cortex and in the left anterior
luxury perfusion with disassociation between metabolism
cingulate (193). A 33Xe SPECT study in 14 OCD patients
and flow. At this point, the number of studies of SPECT
found significantly lower mean blood flow, but no regional
and traumatic brain injury are small and involve only a
differences between OCD and matched normals (194).
few patients, but this application appears promising.
Similarly, Nordahl et al. found lower glucose metabolic
rates in OCD than in normal controls in most brain
regions. NEURORECEPTOR IMAGING
Neuroreceptor imaging now plays a very limited role in
Schizophrenia clinical practice. Early clinical trials and the much larger
Recent reviews suggest that SPECT and PET, as well as PET experience suggest that useful applications will
the nonimaging ‘33Xe
inhalation probe technique, provideemerge and that a wide spectrum of radioligands will
evidencefor frontallobedysfunctionin certainsubtypes become available. SPECT ligands have been developed for
ofschizophrenia (195,196). While hypofrontality has been muscarinic cholinergic receptors (‘231-3-quinuclidinyl-4-
reportedfrequently(197—200), not all investigators
have iodobenzilate, IQNB), the dopamine D-2 receptors ([1231]
observed it (201—203). Inconsistent findings have been iodobenzamide, IBZM), the serotonin-2 receptor ([123!]
attributed to variability in study populations with regard iodoketanserin) and the benzodiazepine receptor (‘23I-Ro
to age, duration of disease, clinical state, subtyping (espe 16-0154m, lomazenil).
cially along the paranoid/nonparanoid dimension) and The dopaminergic system plays an important role in
medication status (204-208). Frontal lobe dysfunction the coordination ofnormal brain function and is a primary
may be more evident during the performance of cognitive action site for neuroleptic drugs for treating schizophrenia
tasks designed for frontal lobe activation (197,199,207, and Parkinson's disease. Furthermore, a number of central
209—213). Hypofrontality also appears to be associated nervous system diseases, including schizophrenia, tardive
with the negative symptoms of schizophrenia (195,199). dyskinesia, Parkinson's disease and Huntington's chorea,
Temporal lobe abnormalities have also been reported (199, are associated with changes in dopamine receptor density
209,214). The combination ofboth anterior and posterior in the brain. Iodine-l23-IBZM has been imaged in humans
functional alterations is often expressed as an abnormality and has a distribution similar to that of positron-labeled
in the anterior/posterior gradient. Buchsbaum et al. and D-2 receptor antagonists with localization primarily in the
others have also reported subcortical abnormalities, partic basal ganglia (227).
ularly on the left side (198,203,21 7—221).Generalized left lomazenil is a specific ligand for benzodiazepine recep
hemispheric dysfunction (laterality) has also been reported tors in the human brain (228). The highest concentration
(195,203,204,222). ofthis receptor antagonist is in the medial occipital cortex.
lomazenil distribution is altered in partial epilepsy and, in
HEAD INJURY early qualitative imaging studies, appears to be abnormal
Traumatic brain injury has an overall incidence similar even when perfusion studies are normal.
to that of stroke, with a particularly high mortality in the Iodine-l23-IQNB studies of muscarinic acetylcholine
first 48 hr post-trauma (223). Proper management of these receptor binding in patients with Alzheimer's disease result
patients requires an accurate assessment of underlying in images which are similar or less abnormal than images
brain function and, consequently, emission computed to of perfusion in the same patients with Alzheimer's disease
mography has been investigated as a possible monitor. (229,230). Studies of the muscarinic acetylcholine system
FunctionalBrainSPECT•
HolmanandDevous 1903
ophrenia. Arch Gen Psychiatry l982;39:25 1—259. 225. Abdel-Dayem HM, Sadek SA, Kouris K, et al. Changes in cerebral
218. Buchsbaum MS. Wu JC, DeLisi LE, et al. Positron emission tomography perfusion after acute head injury: comparison of CT with Ic-99m HM
studiesofbasal gangliaand somatosensorycortexneurolepticdrugeffects: PAO SPECT. Radiology 1987:165:221—226.
differencesbetween normal controls and schizophrenic patients. Biol 226. Roper SN, lsmael MI, King WA, et al. An analysis ofcerebral blood flow
Psi'chiatri' 1987:22:479—494. in acute closed-head injury using Tc-99m-HMPAO SPECT in computed
2 19. Early TS, Reiman EM, Raichle ME, Spitznagel EL. Left globus pallidus tomography.JNuclMed 1991:32:684—687.
abnormality in never-medicated patients with schizophrenia. Proc Nail 227. Kung HF, Alavi A, Chang W, et al. In vivo SPECT imaging ofCNS D-2
AcadSciUSA 1987:84:561—563. dopamine receptors: initial studies with iodine-l23-IBZM in humans. I
220. Resnick SM, Our RE, Alavi A, Our RC, Reivich M. Positron emission Nuc/Med 1990:31:573—579.
tomography and subcortical glucose metabolism in schizophrenia. Psy 228. Schubiger PA, Hasler PH, Beer-Wohlfahrt H, et al. Evaluation of multi
chiairvRes 1987:24:1—Il. centre studywith iomazenil:a benzodiazepinereceptorligand.Nuc/Med
221. Van Heertum RL, O'Connell RA. Functional brain imaging in the Commun 1991:12:569—582.
evaluation ofpsychiatric illness. Semin Nuc/Med 199l;2l:24—39. 229. Holman BL Gibson RE, Hill IC, Eckelman WC, Albert M, Reba RC.
222. Our RE, Resnick SM, Our RC. Laterality and frontality ofcerebral blood Muscarinicacetylcholinereceptorsin Alzheimer'sdisease:in vivoimaging
flow and metabolism in schizophrenia: relationship to symptom specific with iodine-l23-labeled 3-quinuclidinyl-4-iodobenzilate and emission to
ity. Psi'chiatrv Res 1989:27:325—334. mography. JAMA 1985:254:3063.
223. Gray SO, Ichise M, Chung D-G, Kirsh iC, Franks W. Technetium-99m- 230. Weinberger DR, Gibson R, Coppola R, et al. The distribution of cerebral
HMPAO SPECT in the evaluation of patients with a remote history of muscarinicacetylcholinereceptorsin vivo in patients with dementia. A
traumatic brain injury: a comparison with x-ray computed tomography. controlled study with ‘23IQNB
and single photon emission computed
J N,iclMed 1992:33:52—58. tomography. Arch Neuro/ 199 l;48(2):169—176.
224. Reid RH, Gulenchyn KY, Ballinger JR. Venturey RA, ECG. Cerebral 231. Innis RB, Al-Tikriti MS. Zoghbi SS, et al. SPECT imaging ofthe benzo
perfusion imaging with technetium-99m HMPAO following cerebral diazepine receptor: feasibility of in vivo potency measurements from
trauma: initial experience. C/in Nuc/ Med 1990:15:383—388. stepwise displacement curves. I NuclMed 1991:32:1754—1761.
1904