Dangling Modifiers - Exercise 1: Wording May Vary. Below Are Suggested Corrections
Dangling Modifiers - Exercise 1: Wording May Vary. Below Are Suggested Corrections
http://www.bristol.ac.uk/arts/exercises/grammar/grammar_tutorial/page_41.h
tm
For help with any item below, refer to the dangling modifiers page.
1. Writing carefully, the student finished the essay in time to hand in.
Because the student wrote carefully, the essay was finished in time to hand in.
Your answer: I wrote the essay carefully, it was finished in time to hand in.
Your answer: Good grades are essential for you to do well in college.
Your answer: The car was crowded, so the trip was uncomfortable.
7. After John had done calculus problems for hours, his foot went to sleep.
After doing calculus problems for hours, John noticed his foot went to sleep.
Your answer: After John had done calculus problems for hours, John's foot went to
sleep.
8. When we drove over the hill, the ocean came into view.
Driving over the hill, we saw the ocean come into view.
Your answer: When we drove over the hill, the ocean came into view.
Because we were confused by the complicated wording, the contract made no sense.
Your answer: Because the contract was confused by complicated wording, it made no
sense.
10. After Joe cleared his throat, his voice sounded much better to me.
Your answer: After his throat was clearly, his voice sounded much better to me.
For help with any of the items below, refer to the dangling modifiers page.
The children were pleased when some fireworks were set off early.
Your answer: Some fireworks were set off early to please the children
5. Because I took good care of myself, the flu never kept me from work this winter.
By taking good care of myself, I never had to take off work for the flu this winter.
Your answer: Because I took good care of myself, the flu never kept me from work this
winter.
Because he budgeted his money carefully, his debts were finally paid.
Your answer: Because he budgeted his money carefully, his debts were finally paid.
Your answer: Fatty foods should be avoided from her to lose weight.
When they dug new test wells, new oil sources were located.
Your answer: They digged test wells, so new oil sources were located.
9. Dropped in the bushes, the missing keys were found by the child.
The child found the missing keys that were dropped in the bushes.
Your answer: The child found the missing keys dropped in the bushes,
10. Carrying a heavy pile of books, she caught her foot on the step.
When she was carrying a heavy pile of books, her foot caught on the step.
Your answer: When she carried a heavy pile of books, her foot caught on the step.
Read each sentence carefully. If the sentence is correct, write C on the line to the
right. If the sentence contains a misplaced modifier, write MM and correct the sentence.
If the sentence contains a dangling modifier, write DM and correct the sentence.
1. When jumping the fence, the rider was thrown by his horse. ___
2. Please give the desk to Mrs. Wooten with the brass inlaid figures.
___
3. The team with the highest number of wins will capture the championship.
___
4. Diets are painful ordeals which help you lose weight. ___
5. Doctors and lawyers with white hospital coats are well- respected.
___
6. Designer jeans which cost a lot of money are worth the price because they last
forever, or at least until styles change. ___
9. An army which lacks proper equipment will not be an effective fighting force.
___
10. To enter the Olympics, an athlete must compete very hard. ___
13. Never buy a car from a dealer with a broken odometer. ___
15. American writers who live in Europe gain new perspectives on culture.
___
16. The car was parked on the edge of a cliff which was rusty. ___
17. Country music is loved by many people because it praises simple virtues.
___
18. College students succeed in every aspect who work hard. ___
19. Hitting the tin roof, my sleep was disturbed by the rain. ___
20. Houses provide comfort for people with central air conditioning.
___
Edit the following essay for dangling and misplaced modifiers. If you see an error,
use the appropriate editing symbol (either DM or MM) to label it. Then correct the
error.
(1) I think you should meet my friends Ted and Fred someday.
(2) They are a very unusual pair.
(3) Let me illustrate what I mean.
(4) One day I decided to stop by their apartment.
(5) Ted answered the doorbell dressed in a cowboy suit and invited me in.
(6) Fred explained that their costumes were intended to help them enjoy a spaghetti-
western fully.
(7) You can imagine my chagrin when I noticed they were wearing genuine .357
Magnums.
(8) As I looked around the room, I saw clay targets broken on the floor.
(9) At that point, I began to worry about Ted and Fred.
(10) Watching the movie, I observed them very carefully.
(11) Their reactions were quite different to the western.
(12) Engrossed in the fight scenes, Ted was oblivious to his surroundings totally.
(13) Fred, on the other hand, fidgeted in his seat until the violence subsided.
(14) I started getting nervous and decided to leave.
(15) Ted, Fred, and I parted company after that day.
(16) Rumor has it that Ted tried to shoot his way out of a paper bag and that Fred
organized a posse to catch a marauding rat.
Sentence Structure: Misplaced and Dangling Modifiers
(Exercise B)
Read each sentence carefully. If the sentence is correct, write C on the line to the
right. If the sentence contains a misplaced modifier, write MM and correct the sentence.
If the sentence contains a dangling modifier, write DM and correct the sentence.
1. Please give this watch with the brown stripes to the man wearing a shirt.
___
2. When diving into the water, a raft was hit by Jerry. ___
3. The car was bought from a dealer with shifty eyes. ___
5. Because of his ability in math, the position of Chief Accountant was awarded to Jerry.
___
7. Science has brought us many miracles which make our lives easier.
___
10. Foods which are low in calories often do not taste as good as foods which contain
more calories. ___
11. Avarice is one of the seven deadly sins which is greed. ___
12. We drove our car into a service station with a flat tire. ___
14. Terry bought a bike from Mrs. Smith with broken gears. ___
15. British writers gain new perspectives who live in America. ___
16. To swim the English Channel, endurance and strength are required.
___
Modifier Placement
Basic Principle: Modifiers are like teenagers: they fall in love with whatever they're next
to. Make sure they're next to something they ought to modify!
A participial phrase followed by a Passive Verb is also apt to be a dangler because the
real actor of the sentence will be disguised.
An infinitive phrase can also "dangle." The infinitive phrase below should probably
modify the person(s) who set up the exercise program.
Directions: Rewrite each of the following sentences to correct the dangling participles.
1. Blown away by the storm, the family could not find the roof to their house.
2. Climbing to the top of the hill, the view was spectacular.
3. Saddened by the news, a condolence card was sent to Fatima by her co- workers.
4. Rushing to get to the bank before 6pm, the right tire on Tom’s car blew out.
5. Sleeping with the window open, my throat was sore the next day.
6. Arguing with the teacher, the test was failed by Carol.
7. Beaten down by the weather, the farmer could not save his crops.
8. Painting by the morning light, the masterpiece was completed in record time.
9. Grading the exams, my vision became to blurry.
10. Walking through the hot desert, a new and unusual cave was found by the
explorer.
11. Searching under her bed for her term paper, an old piece of pizza was found by
Clara.
12. Talking on her cell phone and driving at the same time, the cop gave Joi a ticket.
13. Warned about the bad weather conditions, the honeymoon cruise was planned
anyway by the stubborn couple.
14. Annoyed with her little brother’s constant teasing, the door to her room was
barricading so Roli could not enter.
15. Visiting her grandmother, Dulce’s favorite brownies were waiting for her on the
kitchen table.
Practice Exercises 1
Correct the following sentences by using the rules discussed above. Possible answers
appear on
the last page of this handout.
1. Maintaining a daily exercise program, my weight seemed to decrease faster than usual.
3. While studying for my college exam, my daughter interrupted me and wanted to play
4. Drawing quite a crowd, the auditorium was packed with Garth Brooks fans.
5. Running around the block, the sidewalk seemed slicker than usual.
6. While changing the baby's diaper, the powder fell on the floor.
7. Even as an athlete who has competed in the 5k run, the dog was able to run faster than
me.
8. Carrying the groceries to the car, my foot got stuck in a pot hole.
9. Taking the chance that she might win, the lottery ticket seemed a small price to pay.
10. Having recognized the mistake, the problem seemed much easier to fix.
11. As a traveling businessman, my mom didn't get to see my dad very often.
12. While learning how to ride a bike, my knees got skinned up quite a bit.
13. Carrying the clubs for the golfers, the tees got lost by the caddy.
14. Removing the tag from the pillow, the pillowcase seemed to fit better.
15. Upon sitting down at the bar, the beer was waiting for us.
16. After removing the old songs from the jukebox, the music seemed to get better.
18. In sending the flowers to that address, the wrong house received the delivery.
19. Sparkling with flames, the water was used to extinguish the fire.
20. As a member of the school board, children are my dad's favorite topic.
21. Coloring the pages with neon crayons, the pictures seemed to come alive on the
paper.
22. Removing her hat before entering the church, the priest nodded for her to sit on the
third row.
23. Explaining the format for completing the form, the document shouldn't take too long
to fill out.
24. As a manager of a major league baseball team, my six-year-old daughter would like
to see one of our games.
25. To score a hole in one, the golf club must be just right.
Practice Exercise 1 Answers
The following revisions are just some of the options for eliminating the dangling
modifiers in each sentence. If you have different options you’re not sure of, ask a tutor to
go over them with you.
Directions: Revise the following sentences to eliminate dangling modifiers. Circle the
number of the sentence if no change is needed.
2. Baked fresh every morning, we couldn’t resist trying the bakery’s cookies.
4. Wearing a neatly pressed suit, Jim was ready for his interview.
8. The party was very fun, laughing and talking all night.
10. Listening carefully, I still could not understand what the teacher was saying.
MISPLACED AND DANGLING MODIFIERS
I. A MISPLACED MODIFIER--is misplaced when it modifies, or appears to modify,
the wrong word or phrase. The best general rule for avoiding misplaced modifiers is to
place modifiers as close as possible to the words they are intended to modify.
A. MISPLACED WORDS:
Adverbs are especially likely to be misplaced because they can appear in several
positions within a sentence.
B. MISPLACED PHRASES:
To avoid confusion, place phrases near the words they modify. Note the two
meanings when the phrase is shifted in the following sentences.
The equipment without the accessories sold the best. (Different types of equipment
were available, some with and some without accessories.)
The equipment sold the best without the accessories. (One type of equipment was
available, and the accessories were optional).
C. MISPLACED CLAUSES:
To avoid confusion, clauses should be placed as close as possible to the words they
modify.
Original: We sent the brochure to four local firms that had three-color illustrations.
Revision: We sent the brochure that had three-color illustrations to four local firms.
Another way to correct a dangling gerund phrase is to make the phrase a clause.
A participle is a word that ends in "ing" or "ed" and looks like a verb; yet it
actually is an adjective that must modify a specific noun or pronoun. If it doesn't, it is
called a dangling participle.
The three most common forms of dangling participles are caused by the writer not
observing the following rules.
1. The participle should be placed closed to the word to which it refers, and there
should be no intervening noun to which the participle might seem to refer.
Revision: Our branch office submitted a complete report, giving details about
this transaction.
CLUE: Sometimes changing the sentence from the passive to active voice will
correct the modification problem.
Original: Working at full speed every morning, fatigue overtakes many of the
employees in the afternoon.
Revision: Working a full speed every morning, many of the employees become
tired in the afternoon.
3. A participle following the main clause should refer to a definite noun, not to the
general thought expressed by the clause.
Original: These accounts disappeared from the vault, thus causing us very much
worry. (Instead of modifying a particular word, "causing" modifies the entire clause that
appears before the comma.)
Many times the idea conveyed in the dangling participial phrase should be
emphasized rather than subordinated in a modifying phrase. In order to emphasize the
idea and to get rid of the dangling modifier, the writer should transform the participial
phrase into an independent clause--
Revision: Because the accounts disappeared from the vault, we are very
worried.
Correct a dangling infinitive phrase by supplying the missing noun or pronoun that
provides the subject of the infinitive phrase.
Original: To evaluate the feasibility of the project, the centralized plan will be
compared with the present system of dispersing facility sites.
Revision: To evaluate the feasibility of the project, the committee will compare the
centralized plan with the present system of dispersing facility sites.
Occasionally a subject and verb are omitted from a dependent clause, forming what
is known as an elliptical clause. If the omitted subject of the elliptical clause is not the
same as the subject of the main clause, the construction dangles. Simply adding the
subject and verb to the elliptical clause solves the problem.
Original: When ten years old, his father started the company.
Revision: When Bill Krebs was ten years old, his father started the company.
Exercise 1: In the following sentences underline the modifying phrases and/or
subordinate clauses, and indicate whether the sentence is correct (C), or whether the
sentence contains a misplaced (M) or dangling (D) modifier.
Sample: __M__ Being an old customer, we know that you are familiar with our
Christmas displays.
1. _____ The check arrived six days late, causing me to write a collection letter.
2. _____ Realizing our mistake, we immediately sent a new one to replace the first
check.
3. _____ Please go down to the main office, and lying on the manager's desk you will
find a copy of the latest report.
5. _____ Being a savings association, our customers do not have checking accounts here.
6. _____ When changing monthly loan payments, it will be necessary to get approval
from the loan department.
7. _____ To improve product appeal, the sales staff decided to use blister packaging.
2. Your new account has been approved after viewing your personal background and
excellent reputation. To familiarize you with our billing process, you will receive an
itemized bill the first of each month.
8. Those files are incomplete, causing the confusion in our personnel department.
1. The students packed donations of food and delivered them to the elderly who
lived locally in hampers.
The students packed donations of food in hampers and delivered them to the
elderly who lived locally.
3. Convicted of murdering his wife, the judge sentenced him to life imprisonment.
6. Previously viewed as an exploration of the unconscious, critics now also see Alice
in Wonderland as social and political satire.
7. Standing at the hotel window, the yachts with their colourful spinnakers raced
across the bay.
8. Vacations abroad are very inexpensive when working for a hotel chain.
10. There was a discussion yesterday on the incidence of suicide among students in
the Dean’s office.
Answer Key
2. He had almost lost all the buttons off his coat. (original)
He had lost almost all the buttons off his coat. (correction)
3. Convicted of murdering his wife, the judge sentenced him to life imprisonment.
Convicted of murdering his wife, he was sentenced by the judge to life
imprisonment.
6. Previously viewed as an exploration of the unconscious, critics now also see Alice
in Wonderland as social and political satire.
Previously viewed as an exploration of the unconscious, Alice in Wonderland is
now also seen by critics as social and political satire.
7. Standing at the hotel window, the yachts with their colourful spinnakers raced
across the bay.
Standing at the hotel window, I could see the yachts with their colourful
spinnakers racing across the bay.
8. Vacations abroad are very inexpensive when working for a hotel chain
Vacations abroad are very inexpensive when one works for a hotel chain.
Or
As I descended the fire escape, I saw a policeman.
10. There was a discussion yesterday on the incidence of suicide among students in
the Dean’s office.
There was a discussion in the Dean’s office yesterday on the incidence of suicide
among students.
1. Flying over the countryside, the cars and houses looked like toys.
2. The messenger spoke to the receptionist who delivered the package.
3. The golfer made a hole-in-one with the green-and-white umbrella.
4. Without thinking what might be on the menu, Hugh told his hostess that he hated
broccoli.
5. After studying hard, the test was a breeze.
6. With my small allowance, the tickets were too expensive.
7. The right belongs to every American to vote in elections.
8. The house was rebuilt by the new owners destroyed by the fire.
9. At camp, home seemed very far away.
10. After finishing the dishes, we were ready to relax for the evening.
Stan is a successful architect and interior designer whose custom-built homes stagger
the imagination. Priced beyond what the average person can afford, his unique inspiration
can be seen in the house on the corner. The front of the house is made entirely of glass.
Extended outward from the second floor, eight vertical steel pillars support a balcony.
Within the center of the house, a huge tropical aquarium rests on a marble floor five feet
in diameter. A wrought iron staircase winds its way around the aquarium connecting the
first and second stories. Recessed in the ceilings, each room is softly lit by fluorescent
lights. To enjoy music in any location, there is a dial on the wall next to the thermostat. In
the winter, fireplaces provide warmth; in the summer, cool air is circulated by fans. By
closing your eyes and dreaming, the house can become yours.