Guidance For Deconstruction of Tower Blocks Floor by Floor/piecemeal
Guidance For Deconstruction of Tower Blocks Floor by Floor/piecemeal
Guidance For Deconstruction of Tower Blocks Floor by Floor/piecemeal
The National Federation of Demolition Contractors The principles and procedures in the guidance notes are
(NFDC) is represented on the British Standards Sub- based on the practices recommended by the Demolition
Committee, which prepares the Code of Practice for Code of Practice [BS6187] and Guidance Notes prepared
Demolition [BS6187], and is, along with The Institute of by the Health and Safety Executive.
Demolition Engineers, the voice of the UK demolition
industry. The National Federation of Demolition Contractors is
very grateful for the assistance and advice given by the
Founded in 1941 to help spearhead London’s post-Blitz Health and Safety Executive in the preparation of this
clear-up campaign, the NFDC’s corporate members are guidance.
responsible for more than 90% of all demolition that
takes place in the UK. The guidance is advisory, and it is based upon the
combined practical experience of Members of the Sub-
Today, the NFDC is committed to establishing safe Committee during the past 30 years.
working practices for its members, and to represent
National Federation of Demolition Contractors
The voice of the UK Demolition Industry
their interests in areas such as training, safety, the It is to be remembered that Clients, CDM Co-ordinators
environment, waste management, industry guidance, and Contractors, must be flexible in their approach in
legislative changes and relevant codes of practice. the light of all the circumstances including the many
variations that can be encountered as a result of the
As a result of growing concern, in respect of design, construction and materials used in multi storey
demolishing multi storey structures of 18 metres and buildings. The guidance is not prescriptive and discretion
above, the Federation has established a Sub-Committee in the application of the Demolition Code of Practice
to produce appropriate guidance for demolition remains with those concerned with each specific
methodology entailing the demolition and/or dismantling project. Accordingly, neither the National Federation of
on a floor by floor/piece meal basis. Demolition Contractors nor the Members of the Drafting
Sub-Committee, individually or collectively, accept any
The Federation have previously published guidance for liability whatsoever for any loss, injury or damage
use of High Reach Demolition Rigs and will consider howsoever caused to any property or person as a result
additional guidance for alternative methods of of the deconstruction of any tower block, nor for any
demolition in the future. errors or omissions that the guidance may contain.
[email protected]
Contents 3
Section 1 - General
1.1 – Scope of Guidance 5
1.2 – Objectives of Guidance 6
1.3 – Responsibilities 7
1.4 – Health and Safety Legislation 8
Section 4 – Legislation 39
4.1 – Acts of Parliament 39
4.2 – Regulations 40
4.3 – British Standards 41
Definitions
Nature, applicability and status of
guidance
Limitations of good practice
guidance
The scope of this guidance is to define the roles, This guide cannot deal with every eventuality and
safe working practices and acceptable levels of site condition. A formulation of good practice can
control needed to carry out only be of value where it is applied with careful
deconstruction/demolition of buildings over 18m. planning, competent supervision, control and
monitoring of the works under appropriate
As such, this document should be used purely as a
contractual arrangements. All stakeholders should
guide to the works and is not intended to be a
exercise their own knowledge, experience and
specific method statement and risk assessment for
judgement in all matters.
any particular works. A contract specific method
statement and relevant risk assessment must be Other methods that should be considered when
produced to take account of all of the issues raised choosing the appropriate demolition
within this document as well as the prevailing site, methodology include the use of high reach
environmental and regulatory conditions including mechanical demolition techniques and the
BS6187 Code of Practice for Demolition. controlled use of explosives. These methods are
covered in separate guidance and therefore will
The guidance has sought to avoid being over
not be included in this document.
prescriptive as this might limit the scope for
innovation and the development of cost-effective This guidance note has no specific
solutions. Furthermore, this guide is an enabling recommendations on the type of structures that can
document and does not form a code of practice. or cannot be demolished using the methods
The guidance does not in any way limit the described within this document.
responsibilities and statutory duties of those parties
involved in the design, specification and
deconstruction/demolition processes.
1 General 6
1.3 Responsibilities
The Client (usually the building owner) has a duty Duties on clients do not apply to domestic
to appoint a team of consultants one of which will householders when they have construction
be the CDM Co-ordinator. Demolition contractors work carried out.
can be appointed directly by the client or via a
The designer: should ensure that structures are
main contractor. The demolition contractor or the
designed to avoid, or where that is not possible
main contractor can also be the Principal
to minimise, risks to health and safety while
Contractor.
they are being built, maintained, used and
It is important that contractual arrangements and eventually demolished Where risks cannot be
the respective roles of the various parties should be avoided, adequate information should be
clearly understood with the responsibilities and provided to enable other designers, the CDM
liabilities of all parties clearly defined and coordinator and contractors to be aware of
recorded in the relevant contract conditions. This those risks and to take account of them.
guide does not extend or affect such Design will also include the preparation of
responsibilities and liabilities. specifications – it is not limited to drawings.
Construction (Design & Management) The CDM co-ordinator: has overall
Regulations 2007 (CDM2007) responsibility for co-ordinating the health and
These regulations provide a framework within safety aspects of the design and planning
which the management and co-ordination of phase. They should identify and collect pre-
health, safety and welfare is planned for all stages construction information, advise the client on
of a construction project, including design, the suitability of the principal contactors
construction, in service maintenance, alteration construction phase health and safety plan and
and demolition. produce or update the health and safety file at
the end of a project.
The Regulations apply to all demolition work and it
is anticipated that the “Construction Phase Health The principal contractor: should take account
and Safety Plan,” developed by the Principal of health and safety issues when
Contractor, will become the main tool in the preparing and presenting tenders, method
planning and management of any demolition project. statements, risk assessments or similar
documents. The principal contractor also has
The principle duties of each of the main parties to develop the construction phase health and
named in these Regulations are summarised below: safety plan and co-ordinate the activities of all
The client: should ensure that only competent contractors to ensure they comply with health
people are appointed as CDM Co-ordinator and safety legislation and site rules. Principal
and principal contractor. This also applies contractors have duties to check on the
when making arrangements for the provision of information and training for
appointment of designers and other employees and for consulting with employees
contractors. They should also ensure that and the self-employed on health and safety
sufficient resources, including time, will be issues relevant to the project.
allocated to enable the project to be carried out
safely.
1 General 8
Contractors and the self-employed: should co- The deconstruction/demolition works must be carried
operate with the principal contractor and out in accordance with all relevant and current
National Federation of Demolition Contractors
The voice of the UK Demolition Industry
provide relevant information on the health and legislation. As legislation is subject to change this
safety risks created by their work or others and guidance refers to current legislation at the time of
how they will be controlled. Contractors and printing. A summary of which can be found in
the self employed also have duties to plan, Appendix “A”.
manage and monitor their own work to make
Health and Safety Regulations, including the Health
sure that workers under their control are safe
and Safety at Work etc Act 1974, Construction Design
from the start of their work on site. They
and Management Regulations 2007, Control of
should satisfy themselves that they and anyone
Asbestos Regulations 2006 and BS6187: in particular,
they employ or engage are competent and
apply to all aspects of demolition work and are
adequately resourced.
recognised in the applied methodology within this
guidance note.
2 Project Planning 9
It is recommended that the following minimum level It is essential that works of this kind be undertaken by
of information is included in any pre-tender stage only competent and suitably experienced contractors
health and safety information which the CDM Co- and personnel.
ordinator should ensure is prepared.
Competent contractors must be able to demonstrate
Description of the works. sufficient knowledge, skill, practical experience and
training.
Programme restraints and requirements.
A competent person may be defined as:
Contractual requirements.
‘A person who can demonstrate sufficient knowledge,
Contractor Pre-Qualification and Competence
skill and practical experience and has received
Details of Structure to be demolished adequate and relative training.’
Details of existing Services and Utilities It is recommended that only specialist demolition
Details of Previous Uses of the Building and contractors who are able to demonstrate suitable
Site technical competence and experience be invited to
tender for high rise deconstruction works.
Details of Asbestos and Other Hazardous
Materials Factors to be considered for pre-qualification include:
Sufficient information should be provided to allow All existing services should be clearly identified
a contractor to develop a suitable demolition including building operation and maintenance
National Federation of Demolition Contractors
The voice of the UK Demolition Industry
method. This should include: manuals (O&M’s) and;
Original construction drawings that identify Electricity; underground cables, overhead
the structural form of the building, detailing lines, building supply, meters, ancillary
the nature of the building frame, including equipment and transformer rooms.
any special forms of construction – e.g.
Gas mains and meters
cantilevered elements/pre-stressed/pre/post
tensioned elements, type of roof and Oil and other fuel lines
cladding systems. Hydraulic pressure mains and district
How overall structural stability is heating systems
maintained [e.g. shear walls, braced bays Foul and storm water services including
and shear cores]. drainage
Evidence of any gross structural defects in Telecommunications equipment and fibre
the building or known major alterations optic cables
since construction.
Radio and TV cables.
2 Project Planning 11
Identify any previous use of the Where potential ordnance hazards have been
building/site, that may indicate any existing identified, sufficient investigations should be
hazards e.g. contamination, underground undertaken so that tenderer's can be suitably
cellars or voids, tunnels or underpasses. informed of the risks.
Surveys should be carried out to identify Emergency lighting systems (acid battery’s)
hazardous materials, these may include, but are not and smoke detectors (radioactive)
National Federation of Demolition Contractors
limited to, the following;
The voice of the UK Demolition Industry
Any such hazards should be identified by survey.
Asbestos Only suitably trained and competent personnel
Lagging to pipes and boilers should undertake this survey work which should
be completed prior to any other investigations in
Fire insulation order to minimise the risk of accidental exposure.
Wall boards and partitions The removal of such materials should, where
Insulation under window sills appropriate, be undertaken in advance of and in
isolation from, any deconstruction operations, with
Linings to ducts and airing cupboards.
adequate time allowed for removal.
In room heaters
Floor and ceiling tiles
‘Dry riser’ water pipes
Insulation within curtain wall cladding
Hazardous Materials
Chlorofluorocarbon (CFC)
Pentachlorophenol (PCP)
Polychlorinated Biphenyls (PCB)
Man made Mineral Fibre (MMMF)
Fluorescent tubes & bulbs
Lead paint
Others:
Used syringes and hypodermic needles
Pigeon droppings
Rodent infestation
Human excrement
Contamination of air conditioning tanks –
Legionnaires disease.
Ozone depleting substances
2 Project Planning 13
Under the CDM Regulations 2007 the principal The HSE are required to be notified of the project
contractor will be responsible for the development works, via form F10, signed by the client. A copy
National Federation of Demolition Contractors
The voice of the UK Demolition Industry
of the Construction Phase Plan. of the F10 is required to be clearly displayed on
site.
The Plan will include comprehensive risk
assessments together with detailed method Other notifications will/may include;
statements and programme of works.
Local Authority – Section 80(2) Notice and
Prior to commencement on site adequate welfare Section 81(2) response from the local authority
facilities must be provided. Building/Demolition Warrant for Scotland.
Dependant on the size and complexity of the Any adjoining/adjacent buildings will require
project it is recommended that the contractor notification under the Party Wall Etc Act
receive a minimum of six weeks lead in time. legislation.
Other interested stakeholders may include;
Utilities
Police/Fire
Underground/Rail Networks
Environment Agency/Scottish Environment
Protection Agency
British Waterways
Holders of Wayleaves
Emergency Services
Natural England and English Heritage
Further guidance may be obtained from the NFDC
web site ‘clients guide’
2.2 Post contract award 15
Method statements should be prepared for all The National Federation of Demolition
works following completion of an initial risk Contractors strongly recommends that all
assessment and should form part of the demolition operatives engaged in work covered by
Construction Phase Plan. these guidance notes should have, or be under
training to obtain as appropriate.
Method statements and risk assessments should be
communicated to all site personnel as part of a i. CSCS/NDTG/CCDO Certificate of
structured induction process. Photographs, Competence - Demolition
pictorials and drawings can also be an effective Operatives/Supervisors;
way of communicating the safe method of work to
ii. CSCS/CPCS Certificate of Training
the site personnel.
Achievement – Plant Operatives;
It is imperative that all persons receiving an
iii. NDTG Cerificate of Training Achievement
induction to safe working should acknowledge
– Plant Operatives
understanding of the whole process and that this
communication is recorded and retained on site. iiii. NVQ Level 2/3 – Demolition
No deviation from the method statement should Induction training specific to that project must be
occur unless such a change has been amended and given to all personnel before the commencement
agreed by the author or other authorised person. of work on site.
Method statements should take into consideration All demolition plant opertives should be trained
all aspects described in section 2.2 of this and experienced, particularly with regard to the
guidance. application of skid steer loaders and mini breakers
Effective means of communication with foreign working at height.
workers must be implemented. It is recommended that only trained and
experienced operatives undertake
demolition/deconstruction of high rise buildings.
2.2 Post contract award 16
2.2.5 Structural
Survey/Temporary
Propping and Shoring
Structural survey and design works should be Where assessment is required by a structural
undertaken by a suitably qualified and experienced engineer for the design of a temporary propping
National Federation of Demolition Contractors
The voice of the UK Demolition Industry
temporary works engineer and or an experienced and shoring system to the building floors and or
structural engineer. walls it will be necessary to take account of the
following;
The survey will supplement, confirm and extend
the information given at Pre-Tender stage and Plant and equipment loads on floors
based on direct observation, testing and
Debris loads on floors or against any wall,
examination of existing drawings, it will be
including perimeter.
required to:
Arrangement of the structure and its safe
Confirm the form of construction.
load capacity.
Confirm the existing condition of the
Changing structural form, i.e. from original
structure, including identification of
load path design to one of temporary
vandalism, damage, corrosion, condition of
support, could affect the safe loading
special elements such as pre-stressed/post
capacity of floors.
tensioned elements and changes to the
structure during its lifetime The structure should be subject to
continuous monitoring during the
Provide information on the floor loading, to
demolition process to ascertain that load
include debris, plant and other, which may
transfer is occurring as designed and that
be safely carried by the existing structure so
vibration from the works is having no
that any propping arrangements may be
significant effect upon floors below the
designed
working floor or on neighbouring or
Confirm the size of all elements to adjacent properties.
determine craneage requirements.
Where lift shafts are used for rubble
Provide sufficient information to ensure that removal, determination of the need to
the structural integrity of the building is provide external support to the shear walls
maintained in order to prevent an against bulging or fracture should be made
unplanned collapse during the sequence of by the structural engineer
demolition.
Provide information on the structural
integrity of party walls to determine if
structural support is required to those walls
during the demolition.
Core tests may be required by the structural
engineer to provide information of the
quality of concrete on the floors and walls
as well as reinforcing arrangement.
2.2 Post contract award 17
The design programme should take into All design details should be passed to site in easily
consideration: understood and clear form (e.g. annotated
drawings) and a feed-back system must be
The form and condition of the structure.
established to ensure that any deviations found to
That due care is taken to ensure that no any designs, plans and calculations are passed to
components are unsupported during or in the Structural Engineer so a reassessment can be
advance of demolition/dismantling or undertaken.
deconstruction.
The presence of post-tensioned concrete
and the possible structural effects
of cutting the stressing tendons e.g. ejection
of tension bolts or anchor blocks
2.2 Post contract award 18
2.2.6 Environmental
Considerations
Prior to demolition a ‘refurbishment and A survey should be undertaken where practical to:
demolition’ survey must be undertaken to identify
Verify the information given at Pre-Tender
all asbestos materials within the building.
Stage.
Asbestos materials will either be notifiable
(requiring a licensed contractor) or non-notifiable Physically check and locate the routes of all
(not requiring a licensed contractor). In all cases a notified incoming services to the site.
method statement and plan of work is required by Physically, check that no unidentified
law and this must be specific and current. Where services remain in the building or cross the
the asbestos is notifiable form ASB(5) must be site.
completed by the licensed contractor and
Understand the sequences and time scales
submitted to the HSE 14 days prior to
required to safely plan and programme the
commencement of any works.
works (these may include notification and
Other hazardous materials may include chemicals, payment to the utility companies).
pigeon guano, PCB’s, PCP’s, gases in refrigeration
Any live services that are to remain should be
and air conditioning systems (cfc’s), lead and 2
accurately located, marked and protected or
pack paint and galvanised steel. Although these
diverted as necessary.
are not notifiable to the HSE appropriate safe
systems of work and disposal must be prepared to Provision should also be made for temporary
deal with their removal. power supply to the site for the duration of the
works.
This may also include health monitoring for
persons directly involved in the operation e.g
blood lead testing for operative hot cutting steel
covered in lead based paints.
2.2 Post contract award 20
Scaffolding and protection is a critical part of the All scaffolds should be designed by
deconstruction of high rise buildings. Careful competent/qualified scaffold designers who
National Federation of Demolition Contractors
The voice of the UK Demolition Industry
consideration must be given to the following: will provide scaffold drawings and
Intended method of deconstruction. calculations. The design will incorporate
(Elevations requiring scaffold and the width suitable and sufficient ties back to the main
of those scaffolds). structure in accordance with the current
British and European Standards and
Whether or not external access is required legislation. It is recommended that
at each working level (e.g. to demolish demolition scaffolds should contain
external brick wall panels). additional scaffold ties to ensure that the
The risk presented by falling debris to site scaffold is always tied to the remaining
personnel and the general public. should be structure during deconstruction/demolition
controlled by ensuring the lifts are close process. This will require liaison, planning
boarded to prevent any debris falling down and co-ordination with the scaffold designer
the face of the building. In addition, the and installer. Should banners be required
installation of scaffold fans or protection on the scaffold the scaffold designer is to
gantries should be considered. confirm that the wind loading is acceptable.
Measures, which can be put in place to Where scaffold protection fans are used all
control dust and noise such as appropriate boards should be securely fixed down and
sheeting to the scaffold with acoustic any materials on the fans should be cleared
treatments to reduce noise. progressively.
Scaffolds may include emergency escape The erection and dismantling of all
provision such as external ladder access to scaffolds (including ladder access) should
all levels. be carried out by a competent scaffolding
contractor and will be subject to continuous
Provision of protection to exposed leading
inspection throughout the works.
edges during partial demolition of sections
Scaffold tagging systems should be used.
to the building/structure.
In virtually all cases the Health and Safety
Provision of boarding up external openings
risks, will dictate the use of scaffolding
in order to contain dust and debris.
with sheeting prior to and during
The design of exclusion zones to areas deconstruction/demolition. If a total
where large plant are operating is sufficient enclosure of the scaffold is not to be
to allow the safe operation of that plant. employed, careful planning and execution
of the works will be required to ensecure
Edge protection around openings created
safe edge protection is fitted and effective
during demolition such as drop zones, well
at all times. Neither, personnel, tools, or
holes, lift shafts, stairwells and the like.
materials should be at risk of falling.
2.2 Post contract award 21
Crane types can vary from telescopic, crawler and Where telescopic and crawler cranes are used the
tower and a project may require the use of more ground conditions must be suitable to remain
National Federation of Demolition Contractors
The voice of the UK Demolition Industry
than one type of crane. All craneage works are stable during the works. This may include
subject to LOLER Regulations and as such all lifts designed extra strengthening to distribute the load
have to be planned and the lift plan produced by a which must be checked by a structural engineer.
suitably qualified Appointed Person. All slinging Particular consideration must be given to
must be carried out by trained, competent and underground services, voids, basements and the
authorised slingers experienced in the type of like.
lifting operation required. Emergency procedures
Consideration must be given to the lifting capacity
must be in place prior to any lift taking place.
of the crane to prevent potential overturn and
Crane selection will take account of the location, collapse. Account must be given to the lifting
lifting radii, size and centre of gravity of the load, hook and chain etc as this must be included in the
adjacent buildings, proximity hazards and others. weight to be lifted.
It is recommended that crane specialists are
The height of the crane must allow for the safe
consulted during this process.
clearance of loads over the structure and
Where tower cranes are used the base of the crane scaffolding above the working floor level and the
should be designed by a structural engineer and clearance for slings/chains etc beneath the hook.
constructed to the engineer’s specifications to
ensure stability of the crane at all times. On no
account should old tower crane bases be used
unless they have been checked and approved by a
structural engineer.
2.2 Post contract award 23
Restrictions should be placed on jib lengths to When cutting and lifting during demolition the
prevent loads being moved over public highways centre of gravity must be correctly ascertained and
or adjacent properties. Effective communication the weight of the item to be lifted must be within
between crane driver and the slinger/signaller is the lifting capacity of the crane. To prevent
imperative and it is recommended that a dedicated overturn and collapse of the crane it is considered
crane co-ordinator is employed. Handset radio reasonably practicable to allow spare capacity
communication is recommended in preference to when lifting to allow for errors in underestimating
hand signals. weights. An estimated weight and the actual
weight could be some way apart.
Where more than one crane is employed it is
essential that co-ordination is established and Therefore it must be recognised that if there is an
monitored to avoid crane collision. element of doubt a factor of safety of twice the
estimated load should be allowed for all lifts.
All cranes and associated equipment are subject to
Account must also be made for the lifting hook
regular inspection and testing in accordance with
and chain weight etc.
the manufacturers recommendations and UK
workplace regulations. It is important to establish the position of cranes to
ensure safe working loads are not exceeded.
When cranes are not in use suitable measures must
Frequently, tower cranes are preferred for work on
be taken to prevent any unauthorised access.
high rise buildings particularly in urban and
confined city areas.
2.2 Post contract award 24
Site security must be considered on an individual Exclusion zones should be established on site to
basis and is subject to risk assessment. The ensure the public and personnel are protected from
following aspects are recommended to be falling debris. There may be several changes to
considered: the exclusion zones as work progresses which will
form part of the detailed method statement for the
Site Boundary. Unless the site is secured
works.
by existing structures e.g. boundary walls.
Secure fencing/hoarding not less than 2 An exclusion zone should be established around
metres high is generally required. The the structure: this is the space encompassing the
fencing/hoarding should enclose all demolition/dismantling activity from which all
demolition/dismantling operations with persons, except essential persons directly involved
appropriate secure entrances to prevent in the demolition, are to be excluded. The size of
unauthorised entry to the site. Suitable the area will depend on the method selected, the
statutory safety signs and notices must be risk of collapse and the risk posed by falling debris
prominently displayed. In addition, it is in relation to the predicted debris area. This last
prudent to consider the following; point may be of particular importance where a
sheeted scaffold enclosure is not to be used.
Security of building/structure out of
working hours.
Provision of security personnel included out
of hours.
Entrance gate(s) security.
Reporting arrangements for visitors.
Immobilising plant when not in use.
Provision of CCTV.
Prevention of unauthorised access to tower
cranes hoists and other plant.
Scaffold alarm systems.
Site lighting.
2.2 Post contract award 26
Safe access/egress should always be maintained, Precautions should be taken to prevent the risk of
using the existing facilities whenever possible. fire and explosion caused by gas, combustible dust
National Federation of Demolition Contractors
The voice of the UK Demolition Industry
Materials should not impede safe access and or vapour. The following items should be
egress to all floor levels, including the floor being considered by the contractor and appropriate
dismantled. An alternative safe means of access emergency procedures established and included in
and egress must be maintained at all times for the Health and Safety Plan:
emergency use. A traffic management plan must
Establish fire assembly points and escape
be created to ensure that pedestrians and moving
routes.
plant and vehicles are segregated throughout the
works. Means of emergency escape from working Provision of fire fighting equipment at
areas to a safe point should be kept clear of critical locations (appropriate number and
materials progressively. type of fire extinguishers inc’ maintenance
regime)
Adequately trained personnel.
Means of raising alarm.
Evacuation plan.
Establish correct hot work procedures
including a permit to work system
Provision of a dedicated mains water
supply where possible.
Maintenance of the high rise water supply
during any prolonged period of cutting with
gas/oxygen cutting equipment.
Provision for early removal of flammable
material.
Falling sparks, from hot cutting, to floors
below and onto debris sheeting
Floors with little or no natural light may
require emergency lighting.
Materials likely to release toxic fumes in a
fire should not be overlooked.
These plans would be brought to the attention of all
persons on site via site induction and or toolbox
talks and must be clearly displayed on site.
Directions to the nearest Hospital A&E Department
should be displayed on the site notice board.
2.2 Post contract award 27
2.2.17 Weather
3.1.1 General
The use of large precast concrete wall and floor were non existant. The second largest cause was a
units were employed in the construction of high failure of the propping systems either through
rise buildings during the 1960’s and 1970’s. The insufficient props or the inadequacy of their fixings.
system was particularly prevalent in high rise The third largest cause was a failure of the various
blocks designed for domestic dwelling components of lifting equipment, including the
developments. This type of construction used the lifting eyes which were built into the panels.
reinforcement in the connections and cross walls When, floor by floor dismantling procedures are
for framing support. The structures were built on adopted, the afore mentioned factors will clearly
a floor by floor basis and assembled using need to be addressed within the safety method
appropriate craneage. Shear loadings were applied statement to describe the process needed to
via the reinforced in-situ concrete stairs and lift prevent accidents occurring.
cores. Structural integrity depended upon the
panels being joined and secured by bolted and In general, the original lifting eyes and bolts are
concrete grout infill connections which, over the likely to be damaged or corroded and should be
years, have been found to be inconsistent in terms considered unsuitable for re-use. In addition, it is
of quality and must not be relied upon during unlikely that any of the original drawings detailing
deconstruction/demolition. these lifting points will be available for examination.
Therefore, design and positioning of new lifting
The process of floor by floor erection entailed points will be necessary for panel removal.
lifting each unit by the in-built lifting eyes and
bolts. Propping of wall panels was necessary to It is important that an accurate assessment of the
stabilise them in position before bolting and weight of all component panels and of the design
infilling with concrete was completed. of their reinforcement is necessary to ensure that
the design of any lifting equipment and crane
The simple multi-box structure was brought under capacity is adequate for the task.
official and professional engineering scrutiny by
the collapse of a high rise block at Ronan Point,
London. A local gas explosion, within one of the
flats, blew out the walls of the flat thus removing
support for the upper storeys causing a progressive
collapse. As a result of the ensuing enquiry, many
similar buildings were structurally reinforced but
some have remained unaltered. Information
regarding any such reinforcing on subsequent
projects of this nature will need to be ascertained
before work commences.
Numerous serious accidents occurred during the
erection of the structures of which three causes in
particular have been identified. The prime cause of
injuries was as a result of persons falling from
edges where guard rails and toe board protection
3 Deconstruction Process 30
The arrangement and design of propping for lateral Where there is uncertainty regarding the structural
support must take into account the floor panels. integrity of the floor and walls immediately below
National Federation of Demolition Contractors
The voice of the UK Demolition Industry
The latter require support during pneumatic the operational level, it is recommended that at
breaking out from their wall supports. Similarly, least two or more floor levels should be propped
each wall panel should have a minimum of two (structural engineer to advise). During the
points of propping to prevent sudden collapse by breaking back of the upper floor level, edge
twisting or buckling. The props and fixings for protection for the prevention of falls will need to
wall units must be capable of resisting push/pull be considered. The work should be planned in
forces, which occur during breaking out. Diagonal such a manner that no “free” walls are left
props to wall panels are particularly advantageous. standing. Where this is not practical or possible,
additional propping should be provided to ensure
The proposed floor loading calculations by a
stability for prolonged periods or overnight.
structural engineer should take into account the
loading likely to be imposed by plant equipment
and demolition debris and it is recommended that
back propping be provided as appropriate.
3 Deconstruction Process 31
3.1.3 Sequence
One complete storey should be removed at a time Installation of push/pull ropes or diagonal
if and where possible. However, there may be braces to vertical panels prior to chasing of
occasions when the floor removal will need to be joints
staggered to aid demolition. All work at that level
Removal of panels in sequence working
should be completed before moving on to the next.
towards the stair/lift core (edge protection
This will certainly apply to all precast elements.
must be provided in these areas)
Where cast in-situ areas are established, such as
stair and lift cores, the order of work must be It is recommended that all structural demolition, so
arranged to ensure that edge barriers are far as is reasonably practicable, should be carried
maintained around the areas at floor levels under out by demolition machines working adjacent to
demolition. Typically, works to ready the panels the floor being demolished and with a demarcation
for lifting using mini demolition plant will involve line clearly marked.
the following;
Removal of complete floor and repeat the
Remove roof process down to the required level.
Chase panels to free holding bolts Areas of floor remote from the cores, at the next
level below, may commence whilst work on the ‘in
Forming holes for lifting
situ’ elements above is being carried out to
The practice of lifting concrete walls and floor completion.
panels by slings and the positioning of lifting
points should be carefully considered in relation to
the original design of the lifting points. The old
lifting points should not be used as their integrity
cannot be guaranteed. The exact positioning of the
new lifting points in the panels and the method of
slinging should be clearly shown in the safety
method statement. Particular attention should be
paid to panels, which have door or window
openings.
3 Deconstruction Process 32
Framed systems can be constructed of steel or Stability depends upon individual elements
reinforced concrete. These may have infill panels consisting of steel or concrete beams and columns
National Federation of Demolition Contractors
The voice of the UK Demolition Industry
of brickwork, blockwork, no fines concrete or pre- with fixed end connections. Concrete beam and
cast concrete cladding. columns may be pre-tensioned, connected either
by pre-stressing steel or structurally bolted/welded
connections.
Alternatively, the design may depend upon a
concrete or steel core in the centre of the building.
Structural beams extend from the core to the
external columns. The core incorporates lift
shafts, staircases and service risers. Floor
construction and external cladding will vary in
their design.
Floors can be of in situ reinforced concrete, infill
clinker, hollow pot, composite units or precast
concrete units with concrete infill at joints.
External walls usually consist of infill curtain
walling systems. Less frequently, they consist of
concrete panels with window openings
incorporated. Occasionally, some may be of low-
density (no fines) concrete or infill brickwork.
3 Deconstruction Process 33
3.2.2 Sequence
Demolition of the lower storeys of the structure The following are indicative of the common items
will usually be carried out by mechanical means. of plant and equipment used for
National Federation of Demolition Contractors
The voice of the UK Demolition Industry
The level at which the change to mechanical demolition/dismantling of high rise structures;
demolition takes place will be based on an
Mini demolition machines (including
assessment of:
remote controlled)
The reach, capacity and operating
Large demolition machines
limitations of the plant proposed. (See
NFDC guidance on use of high reach Skid steer loaders
demolition rigs). Cranes (tower, luffing, crawler and mobile)
The exclusion zone required for safe Compressors (breakers, drills etc)
containment of debris.
Generators (lighting, small tools power etc)
The proximity of any live or occupied areas
This equipment should only be operated in
around the site previously protected by the
accordance with the manufacturers
scaffold system. The contractor must also
recommendations, by trained and competent
demonstrate an ability to adequately control
operators experienced in demolition operations.
dust emissions.
It is essential that plant and equipment is carefully
selected, of suitable size when working on the
floors and is suitable for the nature of work to be
carried out. The appropriate PPE and RPE should
be worn by all operatives. Careful consideration
should be given to live loads placed on the
structure during the deconstruction process,
particularly where floor integrity may be affected
by the induced weight and movement of plant and
machinery. An appropriate risk assessment must
be undertaken before work commences. Control
measures put into place as a result of any risk
assessment process must be monitored regularly
for their continued effectiveness.
3 Deconstruction Process 35
The choice of cranes available to dismantle any Stationary and rail mounted tower cranes offer the
high structure is wide. The shape, height and greatest control when dismantling. The operator
design of the structure, site constraints and can usually see the load being lifted and can react
economics ultimately drive the decision on the use to hand signals as well as radio directions. The
of a particular type. All crane operations used in choice of jib type, either luffing, swan neck or
the deconstruction should be controlled by a crane conventional saddle may be decided by site
coordinator working with an experienced constraints or contractor preference. Wherever
banksmen and slinger. The transfer of plant from possible, it is recommended that the lowering/set
floor to floor should be undertaken by crane or down area be in clear view of the crane operator at
prefabricated ramps, that a competent engineer has all times. The estimated maximum loads and radii
approved the design of. The use of ramps to be encountered should be calculated and
constructed by debris is not considered best considered when specifying the suitability of any
practice. crane.
One of the most important factors to be considered
in the selection of tower cranes is the construction
of the building and whether it is capable of
offering any support to the mast of the tower
crane. It is generally recommended that cranes
should not be tied into a structure but it is accepted
that in some cases there may be no alternative.
A structural engineer should be employed to
produce a suitable foundation design for the tower
crane. Old tower crane bases, used to construct
the building, should not be used to support further
cranes for the demolition element.
The tower crane will usually be powered by 3
phase electricity and sufficient time should be
allowed to obtain this supply from the electricity
suppliers or a suitably sized generator will be
required.
3 Deconstruction Process 36
Conventional or tower rigged crawler cranes are Mini demolition machines equipped with hydraulic
extremely flexible where site conditions permit. breakers or shears are generally the most widely
National Federation of Demolition Contractors
The voice of the UK Demolition Industry
However, it is considered that they may be less accepted item of plant utilised when dismantling
appropriate for deconstruction of tower blocks. any high-rise structure employing the floor-by-
Any crane working at the base of any structure floor method. Pulverizing attachments mounted
should have a Falling Object Protection System on mini machines can be useful where noise
(FOPS) Cab. restrictions apply, but can be relatively slower in
operation than the mini/hydraulic breaker
combination. The weight and use of any such
equipment will be determined by the calculated
floor loadings of the structure.
Remote controlled demolition machines, equipped
with breakers or shears, are used extensively in
work of this type as they generally have a greater
break out force than a comparable mini excavator
of the same weight. They also have an ability to
remove the operator from the immediate vicinity
of the machine and work face, thus reducing the
risk to the operator.
Adequate and usually extensive back propping of
floors immediately below the working level will
enable the use of larger equipment, but such
methods must be supported by the necessary
calculations (See Propping).
3 Deconstruction Process 37
The permissible size of such equipment is again These types of hand held tool are generally used
dependent upon the structure to be demolished and when working from external scaffolds and at
the necessary back propping. Skid steers are used particularly difficult locations. Consideration
to clear broken debris from floors, either into should be given to ensure the appropriate weight
skips, purpose made discharge chutes or existing of breaker is employed for the task being
discharge chutes, e.g. lift shafts etc. The means to undertaken. Breaker types should be assessed for
prevent machines falling over a leading edge or their ability to reduce exposure to Hand Arm and
into discharge chutes must be addressed. Baulk Whole Body Vibration to the user.
timbers on the floor together with hand rails or
purpose made steel frames with handrail are two
such systems.
3 Deconstruction Process 38
This Section lists the principle legislation, British Health and Safety at Work etc Act 1974
and European standards applicable to demolition
Environmental Protection Act 1990
operations as this document went to press. It is
recommended that contractors ensure they are
aware of any updates that may have followed
publication on this document. More detailed
information on key issues regarding health and
safety legislation for persons planning demolition
work can be found in the Health & Safety
Executive’s (HSG150) Health and Safety in
Construction guidance.
4. Legislation, British and European Standards
and Health & Safety Executive 40
4.2 Regulations
Scope of works
Description of existing structures with
existing drawings
National Federation of Demolition Contractors
The voice of the UK Demolition Industry