Slow Steaming Practices in The Global Shipping Industry: /pages 8-9
Slow Steaming Practices in The Global Shipping Industry: /pages 8-9
delivery in June 2013, the engine gine – rated at 31,150 kW – as “a To this end, a prototype was re- is mandatory to observe the new pact system using high-tem-
is bound for a 319,000-dwt, ABS new, green, marine diesel engine cently fitted to an MAN B&W NOx regulations, and any negative perature and high-pressure
class VLCC (Very Large Crude with an ultra-long-stroke and lower 6S46MC-C engine aboard a gen- effect on fuel consumption and gas, and de-NO x efficiency is
Carrier) to be built by Shanghai speed that follow the design prin- eral cargo newbuilding for Nissho running costs is a major concern improved
Waigaoqiao Shipbuilding Co., Ltd. ciples of the Mark 9 engine series.” Shipping. for ship operators. it is possible to maintain the
(SWS) for Maran Tankers of Greece. He further stated: “The G-type en- engine’s running perform-
The G-series engine is hallmarked gine is a realisation of the most ad- NOx regulation De-NOx technology for Tier III ance whether the SCR system
by its SFOC, energy efficiency and vanced technology, offering advan- The regulation of air pollution stem- Realistically, SCR and EGR (Ex- is running or not and with no
ability to meet all Tier II criteria. tages in fuel consumption, exhaust ming directly from diesel engines haust Gas Recirculation) are the harm to the engine
The ceremony was held at the emission and energy efficiency.” is among the IMO regulations cov- two main techniques that can help Hitachi Zosen is a total solu-
CMD factory in Lingang, Shanghai. He ended his speech by stating ering hazardous waste from ships. engines meet Tier III NO x regula- tion provider of marine SCR
It was attended by a large audience that the order for the... The first NOx regulation was intro- tions, based on the service experi- systems.
of CMD staff and partners, includ- duced in 2000 (Tier I), with Tier II ence from power plants and cars,
ing representatives from Shanghai Continued on page 2 coming into force in 2011 and Tier respectively. Continued on page 3
MAN Diesel & Turbo Bigger Compressor Trains First Sale of Uprated A Real Powerhouse
Acquires Kappel For PTA Plants L23/30H Announced of a Solution
Takeover strengthens Major supplier in rapidly Strategic internal Otto 20V35/44G engine to
propeller portfolio expanding market repositioning for GenSet meet future power needs
2
2
SCR on test-bed:
1
1 SCR catalyst
3 Engine
1 3
Continued from previous page level to avoid ammonia slip. enge air pressure were also stable. Normal loading condition sions are continuously maintained
After closing the SCR bypass, With this system, the engine can Here, the engine was loaded grad- at a low level. The engine system
Figure 6 shows the result of SCR the urea was controlled in this way, be accelerated as normal. Howev- ually from half-speed to 90% load was stable and, with normal load-
performance measurements. The and NOx emissions at the SCR out- er, such a quick loading is unusual in 15 minutes. The SCR bypass is ing, no bypass valve control is nec-
set value for the automatic de-NOx let were maintained at a stable, low and normally only happens in an unused and the urea flow rate is essary for the system to remain
control was an 80% reduction. As level – 80% de-NOx was achieved. emergency situation. Normally, ac- controlled according to the load stable.
a result, the de-NOx ratio was 80% The turbocharger speed and scav- celeration takes about 30 minutes. increase. Accordingly, NO x emis-
at every E3 mode point with SCR Fast unloading
and bypass modes performing Here, the engine speed was de-
similarly. Other points of interest Almost same performance between SCR and bypass creased suddenly and as quick-
include: ly as possible – in a few seconds
High cylinder outlet gas tem- High cylinder outlet gas temperature at low load due to CBV from 90% load to half. The EGB
perature at low load due to 500 and CBV are both opened and the
CBV gas temperature maintained above
The graph shows that the E3-
450 300°C. NOx is controlled at a low
cycle value was 3.1 g, which level and the engine system was
was less than the 3.4 g stipu- 400 Exh. Gas Temp. (°C) stable.
lated for the IMO limit
At every E3 mode point, the Conclusions
350
NOx emission level was lower Hitachi Zosen and MAN Diesel &
than the NTE line of IMO Turbo now have a Tier-III-compli-
300
The gas temperature was main- ant, large, two-stroke diesel engine
tained automatically above with SCR and know that the follow-
250
300°C at low loads. ing parameters must be controlled.
From an engine point of view:
Transient response 200 the SCR needs to be placed
Fast loading before the turbine
During acceleration, the SCR by- the gas temperature must be
pass (V1) was opened and kept 0 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ( x 1000) controlled correctly
1
open until the gas temperature be- an appropriate engine control
Power (kW)
fore the turbine came up, and the system is necessary
urea flow rate was controlled at low Figure 5: Engine performance with and without SCR (Source: Hitachi) engine performance with and
without SCR is almost the
same.
From an SCR point of view:
450 good urea injection and good
DeNOX control setting = 80% ammonia mixing are necessary
400 an appropriate SCR catalyst is
Gas temp degC
6 100
5 NOX g/kWh
80
NOX g/kWh
4
60
DeNOX %
2 40 DeNOX %
1 20
0
0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Engine load %
Engine load %
Figure 6: Performance of SCR system (Source: Hitachi) Figure 7: NOX certificate from NKK
DIESELFACTS 2/2012 PAGE 5
MAN Alpha Kappel tip-fin design features and benefits: tip vortices are formed
due to the difference in pressure between the pressure and suction side of
the propeller as water moves from the region of high pressure to that of low
pressure. The pressure on both sides near the tip will therefore equalise and
the efficiency of the tip region decreases. The Kappel design minimises the flow
over the tip, and the outer region of the Kappel propeller therefore retains a high MAN Alpha propellers (FPP scale 1:28 models shown) with four-bladed conventional blade design (left) and five-bladed
efficiency increasing the total efficiency of the Kappel propeller compared to with Kappel tip fin design (right). As with the CPP range, the MAN Alpha FPPs also cover a power range of 4-40 MW, cor-
conventional designs responding to, for example, MAN B&W low-speed engines up to the G80ME-C9 series
res
Automatically updated so you stay in the know. f e atu
g
Or read DieselFacts on the go.
x c itin ee!
,e fr
Newnd it’s
–a
Come into DieselFact’s world: large-bore diesel engines, turbomachinery, marine and stationary appli-
cations, design, licensees, power outputs, gas turbines, steam turbines, compressors, turbocharg-
ers, propellers, gas engines, complete marine propulsion systems, turnkey power plants, market
segments, process industry, PrimeServ after-sales, global network, research & development.
PAGE 6 DIESELFACTS 2/2012
Terephthalic Acid Plant with blue-coloured MAN integrally geared compressor (Source: MAN Diesel & Turbo)
Following a general trend aimed lion to 1.1 million tonnes/yr). these plants is still on the rise. ly recovers power by expanding If the process supplies off-gas
toward economy of scale, the size This is a big step when com- The architecture of MAN’s PTA the off-gas supplied by the proc- at high pressure and temperature,
of purified terephthalic acid (PTA) pared with the previous size of compressor trains follows the ess. The steam turbine is directly a separate four- to eight-stage in-
plants has continued to grow. 826,700 tons/yr (750,000 tonnes/ standard design, adopted in the connected to the integrally geared line machine (similar in design to
yr). However, the German compa- early 1980s. It consists of a main process air compressor via a sep- a steam turbine) can be a better,
MAN Diesel & Turbo is one of the ny said it has received multiple or- integrally geared process air cen- arate pinion drive. more efficient solution. In this case,
major suppliers of compressor ders for PTA plants with a capacity trifugal compressor driven during While the main air compressor the turboexpander is connected to
trains for such applications. It has of 1.3 million to 1.4 million tons/yr the start-up phase by an electric may be defined as a standard ma- the turbomachinery train through
installed several plants from 1.1 (1.2 million to 1.3 million tonnes/yr) motor/generator, a steam turbine chine with four to six stages, de- an auxiliary gearbox.
million to 1.2 million tons/yr (1.0 mil- — showing that the average size of and a turboexpander that active- pending on the PTA process the Once the PTA process has
customer has chosen, the other reached full load, the process
machines are specifically designed steam and the power recovered
for PTA plants. by the off-gas turboexpander ex-
The steam turbine has to handle ceeds the power needed to drive
low-pressure live steam and fea- the main air compressor, and the
tures a very large casing with two surplus power is fed to the electric
additional admissions to make the motor, which is then turned into a
best use of the process steam generator and supplies power to
available. The frame size of this the grid.
machine is very large when com- For synchronous reasons, the
pared with its power output, but whole train needs to run at fixed
that size is imposed by the proc- speed.
ess conditions. The demand for large PTA plants
The turboexpander has to be is mainly concentrated in China, In-
constructed with the use of special dia and the Middle East.
materials to safely handle the off- MAN technology has been
gas that, in spite of being ‘cleaned’ adapted to follow both the market
prior to the turboexpander inlet, is trends as well as the latest design
still very aggressive. criteria.
These turboexpanders can ei- Large MAN PTA compressor
ther be of the integrally geared trains of 40,200 to 67,000 hp (30 to
type, or with an inline configuration, 50 MW) are the result of several
depending on the process condi- years of experience, which has
tions and parameters. been transferred to the trains that
When a single- or two-stage ex- will serve the new 1.3 million to 1.4
pander is requested, an additional million tons/yr (1.2 million to 1.3 mil-
pinion can be mounted on the air lion tonne/yr) -sized plants.
Picture of an integrally geared compressor such as those used in PTA plants (Source: MAN Diesel & Turbo) compressor casing.
DIESELFACTS 2/2012 PAGE 7
Main engine
SMCR power kW
40,000
Potential fuel savings of 4-7%
Lower
8 cyl.
-C9
.2
8 cyl. rpm
9. 2 ME
E- C S80
M
30,000 G80
M E-
C9.2 Larger
G 70 8 cyl.
S 70 M
E-C8
.2 Propeller
20,000 8 cyl.
C9.2
G60ME- 8 cyl.
C8.2
S60ME- Higher
8 cyl.
S50ME-B9.3
8 cyl. Efficiency
G50ME-B9.3
10,000 8 cyl.
G45ME-B9.3
8 cyl.
G40ME-B9.3
(Above) The G-type engine series has already revolutionised ship design and MAN Diesel & Turbo reports that more efficient hulls are now designed to take advantage of the incoming orders for G-engines;
(right) the entry for the S30ME-B9 engine in MAN Diesel & Turbo’s latest marine engine programme
Developing trend
Generally speaking, customers
reacted positively to slow steam-
ing and were much less con-
cerned with schedules and plan-
ning. There were also signs of a
trend among shipping companies
to use the financial gains from slow
steaming as a competition param-
eter. In this respect, the shipping
lines that decided to invest in so-
lutions that could further optimise
their returns from slow steaming
stood to gain an advantage.
Environmental compliance
Compliance with local environmen-
tal relations is also important for
shipping lines requiring access to
certain countries and ports. There
was a significant difference in ap-
proach to this question by those
who had already implemented en-
gine retrofits compared with those
who had not. Those who had im-
An MAN PrimeServ service engineer pictured during the retrofit of a turbocharger cut-out system plemented engine retrofits were
more inclined to address environ-
In late 2011, MAN Diesel & Turbo Apart from running at part-load, one or more of these measures Lower fuel consumption also mental compliance by investing
conducted a web survey among there are a number of other ways to declared themselves pleased with means fewer emissions, a valu- in mechanical solutions that were
more than 200 representatives of the further increase the financial return the results. able side-effect in a world of ever certain to deliver the necessary ad-
global container and bulk shipping from slow steaming. These include These measures enable a more stricter environmental regulations. vantages within a reasonable pay-
industry. Of these, 149 had imple- the use of slide fuel-valves, turbo- efficient consumption of fuel and Survey respondents that had im- back time.
mented ‘slow steaming’, that is, low- charger cut-out solutions, the up- lubricating oil as well as an im- plemented engine upgrades rated You can download the entire sur-
or part-load operation. grading of lubrication-oil systems proved engine performance, add- factors such as the fouling of the vey and see the short film – Slide
(see text boxes), engine de-rating ing significant further gains to the exhaust-gas boiler, the presence of Fuel Valves – making slow steam-
The purpose of the survey was to and propeller upgrading. Survey annual savings of millions of dollars soot deposits in moving parts and ing possible – at:
investigate the approach of con- respondents that had adopted achieved by slow steaming itself. having the correct lubrication as far www.manslowsteaming.com
tainer lines as well as bulk and
tanker operators to slow steaming, 1
the retrofit, de-rating and upgrade Slow Steaming Kit: Alpha Lubricator Upgrade
measures they had taken to max-
imise their return on slow steaming,
and how they evaluated the results A consequence of substantial over-lubrication at low load is the gen- Alpha Lubricator Layout – Lubrication algorithm
of these measures. eration of deposits on the piston crown and rings, increasing the risk
of damage to the cylinder liners. Over-lubrication represents a waste Cylinder oil feed rate
Slow steaming of resources. The Alpha Lubricator Upgrade offers lubrication optimi-
Specific feed rate [g/kWh]
2.00
Reduction factor [-]
1.0
Since its initial introduction in 2007, sation at all engine loads. 1.80 0.9
High load breakpoint
the slow steaming concept has 1.60 25% load breakpoint 0.8
world’s shipping community. As Cylinder lubrication oil savings of 20-50% at low load 1.20 0.6
such, the engines in the world’s More accurate feed-rate control at all engine loads 1.00 0.5
fleet are designed to run constantly Minimal over-lubrication at low load, reducing deposits and improv- 0.80 0.4
at full load, a situation that is typi- ing cylinder condition
0.60 0.3
cally not the optimal operational Implementation of latest design features
0.40 0.2
pattern today. This accordingly Upgraded interface by latest software version. Breakpoint at 15 revolution/injection
corresponding to ~35% engine load
0.20 0.1
sets challenges for operators in The Alpha Lubricator Upgrade is recommended for all large-bore MC ~10% Engine load ~25% Engine load
0.00 0.0
terms of how to maximise perform- engines (70-98 bore) and older installations in small-bore engines. 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75 80 85 90 95 100
Engine rpm (of MCR) [%]
ance and competitiveness under
these new operating conditions.
The slow steaming phenomenon 12K98MC-C example The new lubricator layout reduces the engine power level at which the
has its origins in fuel costs; the vast algorithm, controlling the cylinder oil feed rate, changes. The ‘breakpoint’ is
A useful example of the savings the Alpha Lubricator Upgrade can offer
moved to the left. The Alpha Lubricator Upgrade enables the cylinder oil feed
majority of questionnaire respond- can be taken from a 12K98MC-C engine operating at 10% load. MAN rate to follow a lower curve. The marked area in the figure above corre-
ents – both those who had and Diesel & Turbo measured a lube-oil consumption of 240 l/day prior sponds to the potential lubrication oil savings from upgrading the system.
those who had not implemented to the upgrade and 100 l/day afterwards. At 6,000 h/year and 1,200
engine retrofits – agreed that the EUR/t, this represents yearly savings of 42,000 EUR.
price of fuel was the overriding rea-
son for adopting slow steaming.
DIESELFACTS 2/2012 PAGE 9
2 3
Slow Steaming and SFOC Reductions: Turbocharger Cut-Out SFOC reductions recorded in service with a 12K98ME Slide Fuel-Valves
Of a ship’s total operational costs, fuel accounts for by far 185 Engines that are not fitted with slide fuel valves
the greatest proportion. By installing a Turbocharger Cut- are difficult to operate at low-load on account of
180
Out System, an operator gains the option of disabling one soot formation. Such engines have to be regu-
of the turbochargers during low-load operation. This, in turn, 175 larly driven at high revolutions to clean the ex-
g/kWh
Panorama view of the new MAN PrimeServ Academy in Frederikshavn, Denmark in its location on the harbour waterfront as part of the MAN PrimeServ Frederikshavn Service Centre
www.mandieselturbo.com MAN Diesel & Turbo stics of each individual project, especially specific site and operational conditions.