Developing Computational Proficiency With Multiplication and Division
Developing Computational Proficiency With Multiplication and Division
In its May 2015 Vol. 21, No. 9 publication, Teaching Children Mathematics, the National Council
of Teachers of Mathematics (NCTM) suggests a similar sequence, but adds square products as
foundational facts to be learned early. See Table 1.
Note: There are many interpretations of 3 x 2. In this document the supporting examples will
reference it as 3 groups of 2.
EduGAINS Mathematics K-12 Page 1 of 10
Knowing the foundational facts, along with properties and strategies, allows students to reason
the facts for 3, 4, 6, 7, 8, and 9. What follows is designed to support the teaching and learning of
foundational facts and computational strategies.
Establishing 1s and 0s
a)Multiplying by 1
Once students are comfortable with interpreting 2 x 4 as 2 groups of 4, 5 x 3 as 5 groups of 3, etc.,
they can be led to interpret 1 x 2 as 1 group of 2, and 1 x 5 as 1 group of 5. After students have
worked with enough examples, support students in explicitly understanding multiplying any number
by 1 yields a product equal to the original number (i.e., a number keeps its original identity when
multiplied by 1). Hence, 1 is called the Multiplicative Identity.
b) Multiplying by Zero
Students can think of 0 x 3 = 0 or 3 x 0 as “no groups of 3” as well as “addition of 3 zeros” to generate
products of 0. They may even extend the product pattern.
Example:
4x3 3x3 2x3 1x3 0x3
= 12 =9 =6 =3 =0
c) Dividing by 1
Students who have had experience with the unknowns being written in all three of the possible
locations in a x b = c will appreciate that 2 ÷ 1 = ? means the same as 2 = 1 x ?. Their understanding
of the multiplicative identity, tells them that ? = 2. Like multiplication by 1, division by 1 also leaves a
number unchanged (e.g., 2 ÷ 1 = 2, 99 ÷ 1 = 99).
d) Divisions Involving 0
Students can reason about 0 ÷ 2 = ? by asking themselves, “How many groups of 2 yield a total of
0?” This quotative division question is answered by 0 since it takes zero groups of 2 to yield a total
of 0. If students ask the partitive division question, “2 groups of how many yield a total of 0?”, they
again, answer 0. Similarly, 0 divided by any number other than 0 yields a quotient of 0.
Some students may be curious about division by zero. Guide them to reason that 2 ÷ 0 = ? can be
a partitive division where the quantity per part is unknown. In that case, ask “Zero groups of what
quantity yield a total of 2?” Since this question does not define any number, we say that 2 ÷ 0 is
undefined. If 2 ÷ 0 is a quotative division, then 2 ÷ 0 = ? asks, “How many groups of 0 are in a total of
2?”. Again, this question does not define any number, so 2 ÷ 0 is undefined. Any number other than 0
can replace 2 in the argument above.
A few students may be curious about 0 ÷ 0 = ? By changing this division question to the equivalent
multiplication question, 0 = 0 x ?, students can reason that ? can be 1, or ? can be 2, or ? can be 99.
In fact, ? can be any number. Since the value for ? cannot be determined without further information
0 ÷ 0 is said to be indeterminate.
2s, 5s, and 10s Using Commutative Property 2s, 5s, 10s, 0s, 1s and using
Examples: 2 x 3, 5 x 4 for 2s, 5s, and 10s the Commutative Property
altogether
Model of 2 x 6 Model of 6 x 2
Using the Commutative Property of Multiplication can reduce the cognitive load for students by
taking advantage of multiplication facts already mastered when learning a new multiplication fact.
For example, students typically learn certain facts before others (e.g., 2-times, and 3-times before
6-times). The models above convince students that 6 x 2 (a new fact) yields the same product as
2 x 6 (a known fact). Similarly, if the student knows 3 x 6 = 18, they can reason that 6 x 3 = 18. By
applying the Commutative Property to known facts, students can reduce the number of new facts they
need to learn.
It should be noted that the Commutative Property does not apply to division (e.g., 10 ÷ 2 does not
have the same value as 2 ÷ 10).
For more detail about the Distributive Property and visual justification for using this strategy, see
Pictorial Strategy for Multiplying All Types of Numbers on page 9.
Being flexible in using strategies is a great skill. Many computational strategies depend on breaking
larger numbers down to smaller or friendly numbers (decomposing the number), then applying the
Distributive or the Associative Property. Which particular strategy a student chooses will depend on
which particular facts the student has already mastered. The best strategy for decomposing factors
depends on which number facts the student knows. The following chart illustrates that multiple
strategies can be used for the same product.
Decompose = (5 + 1) x 7 = 6 x (6 + 1) = (7 – 1) x 7 = 6 x (5 + 2) =3x7x2
Visual summaries of the various decomposing strategies are shown below and illustrate the fact that
more than one strategy can be used for some of the facts. If the Commutative Property was used as
well, the first and third charts will have more facts filled in.
2s, 5s, or 10s Anchor Square Product 2s 5s, or 10s Anchor Half
plus or minus Anchor plus or minus plus or minus then Double
1 group 1 group 2 groups
Gap Closing J/I Representing and Renaming Whole Numbers Student Book p.18
Using trading of units and flexibility in renaming numbers, students can make sense of multiplication
and division by 10, 100, and 1000.
52 tens
52 x 10 can mean 52 tens can be written as 520 so the answer is 520
The following strategies are related to strategies shown earlier for single-digit multiplication. Again,
several strategies can be used for the same fact.
*Many steps are included for understanding but these steps do not have to be written. Students may
use less formal notation.
Strategy Examples* Additional Information
14 x 25
= 14 x (20 + 5)
Decompose to Use Known = 14 x 20 + 14 x 5 Use a known multiplier as an anchor then
Facts = 280 + 70 use the distributive property.
= 350
14 x 25
“Quadruple then Quarter” and “Half then
= 14 x 100 ÷ 4
Double” strategies are both based on
Scaling Up and Scaling Down = 1400 ÷ 4
keeping equivalence while using numbers
= 350
that are easier to work with mentally.
The following chart contains examples of how an open partitioned array can be used to find a product
by decomposing larger whole numbers, decimals, fractions, and algebraic expressions.
Many steps are included for understanding but these steps do not have to be written
Use an open
array
Determine
partial
products
2 1/4 x 3 1/2
= 9/4 x 7/2
= 63/8
= 7 7/8