Damage To Engine Bearings - 861097
Damage To Engine Bearings - 861097
Damage To Engine Bearings - 861097
The Motorservice Group is the sales organisation for the worldwide aftermarket activities
of R
heinmetall Automotive. It is a leading supplier of engine components for the
independent aftermarket. With the premium brands K
olbenschmidt, Pierburg,
TRW Engine Components and the BF brand, Motorservice offers its customers a wide
and comprehensive range of top quality products from a single source. As a problem
solver for trade and repair shops, the corporation also offers an extensive service
package. M
otorservice customers benefit from the combined technical know-how of a
large international automotive supplier.
RHEINMETALL AUTOMOTIVE
RENOWNED SUPPLIER TO THE INTERNATIONAL AUTOMOTIVE INDUSTRY
Published by:
© MS Motorservice International GmbH
CONTENTS 2 | 3
CONTENTS PAGE
1. BASIC INFORMATION 5
1.1 Bearing positions in the engine 5
1.2 Main bearings and connecting rod bearings in the crank mechanism 6
1.3 Functions of engine bearings 7
1.4 Structure of engine bearings 8
1.5 Removal of engine bearings in the event of damage 10
Removal of engine bearings in the event of damage
5. FATIGUE DAMAGE 52
5.1 Introduction 52
5.2 Cracks and nicks to the sliding layer 54
5.3 Cracks and nicks to the bearing metal 55
6. OVERHEATING DAMAGE 56
6.1 Introduction 56
6.2 Heat cracks 57
6.3 Fusing of the sliding layer 58
6.4 Discolouration of the sliding layer and / or the back of the bearing 59
7. CORROSION 60
7.1 Frictional corrosion / Contact corrosion 61
7.2 Chemical corrosion 62
9. GLOSSARY 66
ABOUT THIS BROCHURE
This brochure provides an overview of the different types of Even though the bearing generally suffers the greatest damage,
damage in engine half shell bearings and thrust washers. It also the replacement alone of the damaged bearing often does not
supports experts with diagnostics and determining the cause of rectify the cause of damage.
damage.
During professional engine reconditioning, the actual cause of
The process of assessing engine damage always requires an the damage must therefore first of all be determined to then be
all-encompassing approach to identify the causes, which may able to take the suitable repair measures.
not always be clear. Following engine repair, failures may often
occur again. This is because damaged components may have For each case of damage shown, the characteristic damage
been replaced, but the cause of damage has not been rectified. symptoms are demonstrated using suitable bearing shells. It should
be noted that different damage symptoms may arise for different
Due to the high level of complexity of the interaction between the materials. Due to the different characteristics of damage symptoms,
individual components of a bearing inside the engine, the cause there may be deviations from the images shown in the brochure.
of damage is generally not easy to recognise. This is frequently
not to be found in the bearing itself, but in the surroundings of
the bearing.
02
02 Shaft journals:
• Material (e.g. cast or steel shaft)
• Rigidity (elasticity and strength)
04
• Thermal distortion
• Oberflächengüte
• Manufacturing tolerances
• Surface quality
03 Lubrication:
• Lubricant (viscosity, additives)
• Oil supply (oil level, oil pressure,
oil pump, oil lines, oil filter)
• Level of contamination
03
04 Bearing shell:
• Material (resistance, wear resistance,
dry-running behaviour, embedding
properties)
• Manufacturing tolerances
• Surface quality
1.1 BEARING POSITIONS IN THE ENGINE 4 | 5
1. BASIC INFORMATION
1.1 BEARING POSITIONS IN THE ENGINE
The image of the six-cylinder engine shows the bearing positions
in the engine. Seven main bearings are installed, one of which is
designed as a thrust bearing. Between each of the main bearings
you can find the connecting rod bearings – one connecting rod
bearing per cylinder.
This brochure focuses on the half shell bearings which are used
as bearings for the connecting rod and crankshaft in the crank
mechanism.
04
01 02 03
The bearings of the crankshaft are main bearings. Here, the bearing
is also divided into an upper and lower bearing shell. For the
main bearings, the lower bearing shell is subject to a higher
strain by absorbing the ignition forces. The forces transferred
from a connecting rod to the crankshaft are absorbed by several
main bearings, meaning that these are subject to a lower strain
than the conrod bearing shells on the rod side. The upper main
bearing shell contains an oil groove which conveys the oil to the
connecting rod bearings via bores in the crankshaft.
01 02 04
Coefficient of friction μ
01
03
02
0 nü Speed n
Stribeck curve:
Relationship between friction and speed (constant load)
The main function of engine bearings is to absorb and transmit At low speeds, the hydrodynamic lift is not enough to keep the
forces between components which are moving in relation to one surfaces completely separate from one another. This results in
another. Friction should also be minimised, thereby enabling a partial contact between the sliding surfaces, creating the risk of
practically wear-free rotary motion. During operation, frictional bearing damage. It is only when the speed increases that the
forces are generated in every bearing which counteract the rotary frictional forces are reduced and a permanent lubrication film
motion and thereby generate heat. In order to reduce these forces is formed. Liquid friction/fluid friction is generated, whereby both
and to dissipate the frictional heat, it is necessary to have a the sliding surfaces are completely separate from one another. So
lubricating film between the bearing and the shaft journals. that the reliable functioning of the bearing can be ensured, the
Without this lubricating film, direct contact causes dry friction, resulting lubricant pressure in the bearing gap must be large
which in turn causes wear and abrasion on the bearing. enough to absorb the forces acting on the bearing without contact
of the sliding surfaces. This is the ideal operating point for engine
Hydrodynamic engine bearings, in which a stable lubricating film bearings. But this form of friction also generates heat, meaning
forms through the relative movement between the bearing shell that sufficient lubrication is also required for heat dissipation.
and journal alone, pass through a mixed friction range up to a
particular transition speed.
1.4 STRUCTURE OF ENGINE BEARINGS
In accordance with the standard DIN 50282 („The Tribological Image of bearing structure
Behaviour of Metallic Antifriction Materials – Significant
Definitions“), the tribological behaviour of an anti-friction material
01
can be characterised by terms such as running-in behaviour,
embedding properties, dry-running behaviour, wear resistance
02
and adaptability. The requirements made of the engine bearing
are therefore crucial when it comes to the choice of material.
03
TWO-COMPONENT BEARINGS
• Steel-aluminium composites
01 Steel back
02 Intermediate layer (if required)
03 Bearing material
Steel-aluminium
Bearing material: Bronze Bearing material: Aluminium or bronze Bearing material: Brass or bronze
Intermediate layer Sliding layer: Bonded Intermediate layer (for bronze)
Sliding layer: Galvanic Sliding layer: Sputter
1.5 REMOVAL OF ENGINE BEARINGS IN THE EVENT
OF DAMAGE
The following should be noted during the removal of bearing • Issues with other engine components, for example the
shells in the event of damage: crankshaft, must also be documented. In the majority of
• The bearing shells should be labelled according to seat and cases, damage to the interacting sliding partner of the
position in the main bearing centre line so that the events engine bearing can be recognised. Often, damage to the
leading to the damage can be better understood. In addition bearing is also the result of damage to other engine
to the appearance of the bearing, the seat can often provide components.
information on the events leading to the damage. In the event • In order to allow subsequent analyses, a sample should be
of bending of the crankshaft, above all the first and last taken of the oil used and the oil filter retained. Particle
main bearing along the centre line demonstrate one-sided residues can be documented and analysed, providing
wear marks, for example. information about possible causes of damage.
• Operating conditions (duration, type of stress) and other • The torques required to loosen the engine bolts must be
influences, such as the oil used, must be documented so documented. If the bolts are not fastened with the right
that it is possible to have a better assessment of the torque, relative movement between the bearing shell and
damage. the housing bore may be the result.
01 02 03
This is the case, for example, each time the engine is started
and stopped. Between standstill and the transition speed of the
shaft, the bearings used pass through the mixed friction range. In
this range, the load bearing capacity of the lubricating film is not
always sufficient to completely separate the interacting sliding
parts from each other (see chapter: „1.3 Functions of engine
bearings“). Especially for vehicles with start / stop function,
wear-resistant materials therefore play an important role. At low
speeds and high stress, it may also occur that liquid friction is
not achieved and the bearing is worn. Deviations in terms of
geometry due to installation errors or the deformation of journals
and the bearing line may also cause wear.
ASSESSMENT
ASSESSMENT
Initial rubbing marks may result from run-in marks if the effect of If the mixed friction state is continued, the initial rubbing marks
mixed friction intensifies. If this is a temporary state, these may are strengthened and scoring at the journal may occur.
be levelled out again; the functionality of the bearing is not The result is seizure at the affected bearing shells, whereby the
further impaired. Assessing this is very difficult, however. bearing shell welds with the journal due to thermal stress.
POSSIBLE CAUSES
• Oil bores not free: the reason may be the incorrect • Blocked oil filter
installation of the bearing shells or blockage of the oil bores • Defective oil pump
– the latter is often the case when biological fuels are used • Leak in the oil lines
• The lubrication gap is too small, meaning that a stable • Overstressing of the bearings: the strain is higher than the
lubrication film cannot be formed – cause: form and bearing is designed for – causes are chip tuning or piston
geometry deviations of the shaft or journal, or bending of seizure, for example
the crankshaft • Effect of particles: particles find their way into the bearing
• The lubrication gap is too large, meaning that the gap, causing initial rubbing marks on the journal and
hydrodynamic pressure required for the formation of the bearing. In the event of embedding or scoring, edges are
stable lubricating film is not achieved created, resulting in greatly increased mixed friction
• Oil level or oil pressure too low
REMEDY
Initial rubbing marks may continue to develop into seizure of the • Check the oil pump is functioning
bearings. It is therefore important to replace the bearings and to • Check the oil lines for any leaks
rectify the cause: • Check the stress of individual bearings
• Check that all of the oil bores are free and that there is no • Check the entire bearing set for the embedding of particles
blockage or grooves. If present, the influence of particles may have
• Check the actual bearing clearance: if it is not within the caused the formation of the initial rubbing marks (see
tolerance range, form and geometry errors are often the chapter: „3. Damage due to the influence of particles“)
cause (see chapter: „2.5 Special cases“)
• Check the functioning of the oil filter and always change the
oil filter and oil according to the manufacturer‘s instructions
• Check the oil level and oil pressure and readjust if necessary
2.4 SEIZURE
DESCRIPTION
ASSESSMENT
High temperatures in the area of high mixed friction cause localised Damage due to the influence of particles or initial rubbing marks
welding between the journal and bearing. These welded areas may occur at adjacent bearings due to the deposits from abrasion
break up again, whereby the bearing material – which is softer brought in through the lubricant circuit.
compared to the crankshaft – is torn off. An acute lack of lubricant Initial rubbing marks are the preliminary stages of bearing
is the cause here. The temperature development caused by this seizure.
causes overheating damage – a common side effect of bearing
seizure.
POSSIBLE CAUSES
• Oil bores not free: the reason may be the incorrect installation • Blocked oil filter
of the bearing shells or blockage of the oil bores – the latter • Defective oil pump
is often the case when biological fuels are used • Leak in the oil lines
• The lubrication gap is too small, meaning that a stable • Overstressing of the bearings: the strain is higher than the
lubrication film cannot be formed – cause: form and geometry bearing is designed for – causes are chip tuning or piston
deviations of the shaft or journal, or bending of the crankshaft seizure, for example
• The lubrication gap is too large, meaning that the • Effect of particles: particles find their way into the bearing
hydrodynamic pressure required for the formation of the gap, causing initial rubbing marks on the journal and
stable lubricating film is not achieved bearing. In the event of embedding or scoring, edges are
• Oil level or oil pressure too low created, resulting in greatly increased mixed friction
REMEDY
Seizure is amongst the most serious types of bearing damage. • Check the oil pump is functioning
The bearing is destroyed and has to be replaced. If use of the • Check the oil lines for any leaks
bearing is continued, other engine components may be damaged. • Check the stress of individual bearings
• Check that all of the oil bores are free and that there is no • Check the entire bearing set for the embedding of particles or
blockage grooves. If present, the influence of particles may have
• Check the actual bearing clearance: if it is not within the caused the formation of the initial rubbing marks (see
tolerance range, form and geometry errors are often the chapter: „3. Damage due to the influence of particles“)
cause (see chapter: „2.5 Special cases“)
• Check the functioning of the oil filter and always change the
oil filter and oil according to the manufacturer‘s instructions
• Check the oil level and oil pressure and readjust if necessary
2.5 SPECIAL CASES
There are some cases where the Lower Upper
bearing shells display a special bearing shell bearing shell Chapter
wear pattern. The following 2.5.1
damage pictogram can be used One-sided edge wear
to assign possible damage • On the upper and lower shell, on the same side
symptoms to a type of damage. in each case
2.5.2
One-sided alternate edge wear
• On the upper and lower shell, diagonally
opposed
• Different areas may be pronounced to
differing degrees
2.5.3
Two-sided edge wear
• On the upper and lower shell on both sides
2.5.4
Wide wear marks in the centre of the bearing
• Generally pronounced to the same extent on the
upper and lower shell
• No pronounced wear pattern for main bearing
shells in the upper bearing shell due to oil
groove
2.5.5
Stripe-like wear in the centre of the bearing
• Generally pronounced to the same extent on the
upper and lower shell
• No pronounced wear pattern for upper main
bearing shells with oil groove
2.5 SPECIAL CASES 18 | 19
Lower Upper
bearing shell bearing shell Chapter
2.5.6
Wear on opposing areas of the separation planes
2.5.7
Two-sided wear on areas of the separation planes
2.5.8
Narrow zone of wear in the crown of the bearing shell
2.5.9
Narrow wear-free strips at the edges of the bearings
• May occur on one edge or both edges
2.5.1 ONE-SIDED EDGE WEAR
DESCRIPTION
• Bright, light stripes of wear on one side at the edge of the bearing
• Identifiable signs of material fatigue or initial rubbing marks
possible in the area of the edge wear in severe cases
• Overheating phenomena such as discolouration due to thermal
stress or carbon deposits in the area of the edge wear on the
bearing back
ASSESSMENT
The lubrication gap at the bearing edge is too low, meaning that Depending on the intensity of the wear at the bearing edges, this
the lubricating film is not fully stable and mixed friction occurs can be considered as completely normal. During operation, the
locally. If the shortage of lubrication continues, the temperature crankshaft is subject to bending, which above all has an effect on
increases due to the frictional heat that results. This could result the outer main bearings. The outer bearings therefore
in overheating damage such as dark discolouration of the demonstrate more pronounced edge wear.
bearing back. The shortage of lubrication continues to intensify
due to the increasing temperature level and the process
reinforces itself until the first initial rubbing marks occur and
fatigue damage occurs due to increased surface pressure.
POSSIBLE CAUSES
• Tapered ground journal (Fig. 1) • Bearing bore which is not aligned due to bolts with the
• Tapered bearing bore (Fig. 2) incorrect tightening torque during the assembly of the
• Rounding radius too large on one side (Fig. 3) engine or excessive distortion of the main bearing centre
• Bending of the crankshaft: during installation, the line due to temperature development during operation
crankshaft was not balanced or is deformed due to • Axial shell misalignment
mechanical strain during operation
Fig. 1: Tapered ground journal Fig. 2: Tapered bearing bore Fig. 3: Rounding radius too large on one side
REMEDY
Bearings that exhibit edge wear can continue to be used • Check alignment of the main bearing bore: during assembly
depending on their wear condition. of an engine, always make sure to use the specified
If these damage symptoms intensify after a few hours of tightening torques and bolt tightening sequence – the
operation, measures to determine the cause should be taken: engine must be sufficiently cooled during operation as
• Check for correct geometry of the crankshaft: Dimensions, deformations may also occur due to temperatures that are
roundness, cylindricity, ripple, surface roughness too high
• Check the bearing line bore is correct: Dimensions, • Check connecting rods for angularity before installation
roundness, cylindricity, surface
• Balance crankshaft during installation and check strain on
the shaft
2.5.2 ONE-SIDED ALTERNATE EDGE WEAR
DESCRIPTION
ASSESSMENT
The lubrication gap at the bearing edge is too low, meaning that The shortage of lubrication continues to intensify due to the
the lubricating film is not fully stable and mixed friction occurs increasing temperature level and the process reinforces itself
locally. If the shortage of lubrication continues, the temperature until the first initial rubbing marks occur and fatigue damage
increases due to the frictional heat that results. This could occurs due to increased surface pressure.
result in overheating damage such as dark discolouration of the
bearing back.
POSSIBLE CAUSES
REMEDY
Bearings that exhibit edge wear can continue to be used • Check alignment of the main bearing bore: during assembly
depending on their wear condition. of an engine, always make sure to use the specified
If these damage symptoms intensify after a few hours of tightening torques and bolt tightening sequence – the
operation, measures to determine the cause should be taken: engine must be sufficiently cooled during operation as
• Check for correct geometry of the crankshaft: Dimensions, deformations may also occur due to temperatures that are
roundness, cylindricity, ripple, surface roughness too high
• Check the bearing line bore is correct: Dimensions, • Check connecting rods for angularity before installation
roundness, cylindricity, surface
• Balance crankshaft during installation and check strain on
the shaft
2.5.3 TWO-SIDED EDGE WEAR
DESCRIPTION
ASSESSMENT
The lubrication gap at the bearing edge is too low, meaning that until the first initial rubbing marks occur and fatigue damage
the lubricating film is not fully stable and mixed friction occurs occurs in this area due to increased surface pressure.
locally. If the shortage of lubrication continues, the temperature Two-sided edge wear occurs very often in the main load area of a
increases due to the frictional heat that results. This could result bearing. Depending on the intensity of the wear, this can be
in overheating damage such as dark discolouration of the bearing considered normal, and does not impair the functioning.
back. The shortage of lubrication continues to intensify due to
the increasing temperature level and the process reinforces itself
POSSIBLE CAUSES
• Concave journal form (Fig. 1) • Too large an axial clearance, maladjustment of the
• Concave bearing bore (Fig. 2) connecting rod
• Too large a rounding radius between the journal and crank • Journal ground at an angle (Fig. 4)
web (Fig. 3)
Fig. 1: Concave journal form Fig. 2: Concave bearing bore Fig. 3: Too large a rounding Fig. 4: Journal ground at an
radius angle
REMEDY
Bearings that exhibit edge wear can continue to be used depending the shaft
on their wear condition. • Check alignment of the main bearing bore: during assembly
If these damage symptoms intensify after a few hours of of an engine, always make sure to use the specified
operation, measures to determine the cause should be taken: tightening torques and bolt tightening sequence – the
• Check for correct geometry of the crankshaft: Dimensions, engine must be sufficiently cooled during operation as
roundness, cylindricity, ripple, surface roughness deformations may also occur due to temperatures that are
• Check the bearing line bore is correct: Dimensions, too high
roundness, cylindricity, surface • Check connecting rods for angularity before installation
• Balance crankshaft during installation and check strain on
2.5.4 WIDE WEAR MARKS IN THE CENTRE OF THE BEARING IN THE
CIRCUMFERENTIAL DIRECTION
DESCRIPTION
ASSESSMENT
The lubrication gap in the centre of the bearing is too low, The shortage of lubrication continues to intensify due to the
meaning that the lubricating film is not fully stable and mixed increasing temperature level. This process reinforces itself until
friction occurs locally. If the shortage of lubrication continues, the first initial rubbing marks and fatigue damage occur in this
the temperature increases due to the frictional heat that results. area due to increased surface pressure.
POSSIBLE CAUSES
Fig. 1: Journal shape that is too strongly Fig. 2: Convex bearing bore
convex
REMEDY
The bearings can continue to be used depending on their wear • Check alignment of the main bearing bore: during assembly
condition. They should be replaced as soon as initial rubbing of an engine, always make sure to use the specified
marks develop or indicators of material fatigue become visible tightening torques and bolt tightening sequence – the
and measures to determine the cause should be taken: engine must be sufficiently cooled during operation as
• Check for correct geometry of the crankshaft: Dimensions, deformations may also occur due to temperatures that are
roundness, cylindricity, ripple, surface roughness too high
• Check the bearing line bore is correct: Dimensions, • Check connecting rods for angularity before installation
roundness, cylindricity, surface • Check lubrication system (see chapter: „2.3 Initial rubbing
• Balance crankshaft during installation and check strain on mark“)
the shaft
2.5.5 STRIPE-LIKE WEAR IN THE CENTRE OF THE BEARING
DESCRIPTION
ASSESSMENT
This type of wear may be due to a lacking or insufficiently rounded Since there is no metallic contact between the journal and
oil bore (Fig. 1). With this in mind, the wear in the lower bearing bearing due to the oil groove, no material removal takes place
shell in main bearings or in both bearing shells in connecting rod and a ridge forms on the journal. This ridges leads to stripe-like
bearings is very pronounced in the area of the oil bore on the wear in the bearing shell without an oil groove.
journal. Both processes can lead to initial rubbing marks and fatigue
A second way in which wear arises that can lead to the same damage.
damage symptoms is ridge wear (Fig. 2). This results from the
lower journal wear in the area of the oil groove.
2.5 SPECIAL CASES 28 | 29
POSSIBLE CAUSES
(1) There is no metallic contact in the (2) A very small ridge can form due to the (3) In the lower main bearing that
area of the oil groove in the upper main reduced journal wear in the area of the oil does not have an oil groove, this ridge
bearing shell. The journal wear is lower groove (shown exaggerated here to aid causes increased wear in the centre of
than in the areas in contact with the understanding). the bearing. This leads to the typical
bearing surface. stripe-like wear pattern in ridge wear.
REMEDY
DESCRIPTION
ASSESSMENT
If the bearing shells in this area carry weight, the fault is severe. The shortage of lubrication continues to intensify due to the
Misalignment of the bearing shells to one another due to an increasing temperature level and the process reinforces itself
installation error can be the cause for the wear that occurs. until the first initial rubbing marks occur and fatigue damage
The bearing clearance is too low locally due to the cover offset, occurs due to increased surface pressure.
meaning that the lubricating film is not fully stable and mixed
friction occurs in places. If the shortage of lubrication continues,
the temperature increases due to the frictional heat that results.
POSSIBLE CAUSES
REMEDY
DESCRIPTION
ASSESSMENT
If the bearing shells in this area carry weight, the fault is severe. The shortage of lubrication continues to intensify due to the
This appearance can be caused by a vertical oval bore. increasing temperature level and the process reinforces itself
This reduces the bearing clearance in the area of the parting face until the first initial rubbing marks occur and fatigue damage
meaning that the lubricating film is not fully stable and mixed occurs in this area due to increased surface pressure.
friction occurs in the reliefs. If the shortage of lubrication
continues, the temperature increases due to the frictional heat
that results.
POSSIBLE CAUSES
REMEDY
DESCRIPTION
ASSESSMENT
This appearance is caused by a horizontal oval bore. This reduces The shortage of lubrication continues to intensify due to the
the bearing clearance in the crown meaning that the lubricating increasing temperature level and the process reinforces itself
film is not fully stable and mixed friction occurs in places. If the until the first initial rubbing marks occur and fatigue damage
shortage of lubrication continues, the temperature increases due occurs in this area due to increased surface pressure.
to the frictional heat that results.
POSSIBLE CAUSES
REMEDY
DESCRIPTION
ASSESSMENT
POSSIBLE CAUSES
REMEDY
01
04
02
03
01 Steel back
02 Oil film
03 Shaft
04 Particle
3. DAMAGE DUE TO THE INFLUENCE OF PARTICLES 38 | 39
To gain an insight into where the particles have come from, it may be useful to analyse the bearing and a sample of the oil.
POSSIBLE CAUSES
• Mounting was not clean: due to carelessness or inadequate • Cavitation: particles are broken off of the bearing material
cleaning of the engine components during mounting, dirt and carried on by the oil – depending on the size, these may
may enter the engine block cause scoring or fine embedding in the bearing or in the
• Residues such as metal chips or residual blasting agent adjacent bearing
from production or reconditioning may form deposits in the • Seizure: seized engine components (pistons, bearing
engine block which then come away during operation – shells) cause numerous particles to enter the lubricant
often these are also deposits from attachments, such as the circuit, which in turn can cause damage to other components
oil cooler, which were not cleaned adequately during the • Fatigue damage: if material has broken off of engine
engine reconditioning components, this broken-off material can be further carried
• Damage to the seals in the area of the engine: if a seal is by the oil into the bearings and can cause damage here
excessively stressed or damaged during installation, it no
longer fulfils its function and particles can enter the system
• Lack of maintenance of the lubricant system: inspection
intervals that have been exceeded or blocked oil filters may
cause an increase in dirt in the oil
REMEDY
Generally, despite scoring or embedded particles, bearings can • Filtering of the intake air: service the filters regularly;
still be used. This depends on the extent of the damage, replace if necessary
however. If, for example, there are numerous large indents from • Check other engine components for damage such as
particles with initial marks of mixed friction due to material cavitation, fatigue or seizure – engine bearing damage due
accumulation, it is advisable to replace the bearing. Fine particle to the influence of particles is often consequential damage
indents do not impair the function of the bearing. In both cases, • If the influence of particles cannot be ascertained, the
the cause should be clarified in any case: analysis of damaged bearing shells and an oil sample may
• Cleaning of all components before mounting: it is important provide an insight: if particles are still embedded in the
to rinse out all of the oil bores in the shaft and housing bearing or present in the oil, their chemical composition can
before initial start-up. It is also important that the bearing be determined – if it is a case of material from the
seats are cleaned so that small chips and particles from crankshaft, for example, a more precise check for damage
production and / or reconditioning are removed – the oil can be carried out here
channels of attachments, such as oil cooler and
turbocharger, must also be thoroughly cleaned
• Check the seals for functionality
• Always replace the oil filter and oil according to the
manufacturer‘s specifications: ensure that the inspection
intervals are complied with and only oil and oil filters to the
right standard are used
3.2 SCORING
DESCRIPTION
ASSESSMENT
Particles which find their way into the lubricant gap and are not This often leads to initial rubbing marks and seizure.
embedded into the bearing material are repeatedly forced through The scoring may also be the result of the influence of mixed
the gap, causing grooves in the process. Depending on the friction. Here, the grooves are fine and formed on the surface,
thickness of the edges created, these cannot be flattened during however, and appear at both interacting sliding parts.
further operation and, due to increased mixed friction, there is an
increase in temperature in the event of shaft contact.
REMEDY
• Scarred surface
• Particle imprints (still containing particles in places),
surrounded by material accumulation which is visible as a
light shining point due to wear
• Often in conjunction with scoring in the journal and bearing
• In severe cases, initial rubbing marks from the embedding
are visible
ASSESSMENT
Particles which find their way into the lubricant gap may become Due to the material accumulations at the edges or protrusions
embedded in the bearing material. Depending on the thickness from particles which are not completely embedded, the formation
of the sliding layer, we can differentiate between deep and shallow of the lubricant film is disrupted, and mixed friction conditions
embedding. In the case of deep embedding, the particles are may be created. So-called „wire-wool“ wear is a possible
completely integrated into the sliding layer. This is only possible consequence. Here the embedded particles cut into the surface
when the particle is smaller than the thickness of the layer. of the shaft and remove material (chipping wool). The particles
The material accumulation created during the embedding is that break away, which are then embedded again, accelerate the
flattened during the subsequent contact with the shaft due to wear. bearing damage, and often complete failure of the journal and
Shallow embedding takes place when the size of the particle is bearing cannot be avoided.
greater than the thickness of the layer. The particles are not
completely embedded and protrude from the bearing surface. Initial rubbing marks and seizure can therefore result from
They cause wear and scoring on the journal surface. particle embedding.
REMEDY
ASSESSMENT
Very large and hard particles which find their way into the
lubricant gap cannot become embedded in the bearing material.
They are forced through the lubricating gap, but then always
become stuck again. Frequently, the pattern appears from oil
grooves or oil bores as the particles were introduced here.
Pronounced material accumulation along the progression track
causes initial rubbing marks and seizure.
REMEDY
ASSESSMENT
01 Housing
02 Shaft
03 Particle
REMEDY
ASSESSMENT
Erosion is a form of abrasive material removal, caused by the flow The integrity of the material is also influenced negatively as the
forces of the oil. This effect is reinforced by the smallest particles fissures on the surface can cause cracks. Damage caused by
in the oil, such as carbon deposits or deposits from abrasion. fatigue is the result.
Erosion is also often the result of cavitation, as here particles
from the material are broken off and enter into the lubrication Due to the use of thin oils, erosion is occurring more and more
system. frequently.
Erosion attacks the material surface and activates it chemically,
accelerating the initial corrosion.
POSSIBLE CAUSES
• High speeds and low bearing clearance • Smallest particles in the oil flow: particles may come from
• Use of incorrect engine oils with, for example, the incorrect different areas of the engine and may have been caused by
additives or without additives at all incomplete combustion or cavitation, for example
REMEDY
4.2 CAVITATION
Cavitation is caused by the flow of the lubricant through the Despite the different ways in which they are created, for some
bearing gap. The vapour pressure of the oil used plays a crucial damage symptoms it can be difficult to differentiate between
role here. cavitation, erosion and corrosion. Often, complex transitional
forms also appear such as cavitation erosion or erosion corrosion.
Seen correctly, cavitation is merely the physical process of the This can be explained by the fact that both cavitation and erosion
fuel vapour lock of a liquid, which in itself does not cause any attack anti-corrosion layers, activate these chemically, resulting
damage to the bearing. The corresponding damage symptoms in corrosion.
describe cavitation erosion through the material removal typical
for this, as a result of the implosion of the vapour bubbles in
areas below the vapour pressure (cavitation <–> cavitation erosion).
CAVITATION
If the vapour pressure of the oil used is not reached, gas and
vapour bubbles form which are transported further by the flow.
This is known as cavitation. When the static pressure continues
to increase, these bubbles collapse like an implosion, resulting
in strong pressure surges – so-called microjets – as well as high
temperatures. The pressure surges cause the material to break off
and cause material removal, i.e. cavitation erosion.
Cavitation bubble is formed Implosion begins Microjet is formed Microjet breaks through
and grows the cavitation bubble and hits
the surface
DESCRIPTION
• Cavitation in the relief: pointed or mushroom-shaped nick Cavitation may also occur in other areas of the bearing, such as
in the relief towards the parting face. The area is clearly in the crown. These forms are, however, much harder to
roughened and matte differentiate from erosion and corrosion. Generally, you do not
• Cavitation in the run-out of the oil groove: mushroom- find material nicks such as with the forms mentioned above, but
shaped nick in the run-out of the oil groove, roughened instead matte, slightly roughened areas which could also be the
and matte area result of erosion or corrosion.
ASSESSMENT
3D measurement – cavitation
POSSIBLE CAUSES
High temperatures and low-boiling impurities may advance Vibration or suction cavitation:
cavitation. • Lubrication gap is too large, causing the hydrodynamic
• Impurities in the oil: water, fuel or deposits from abrasion pressure in the bearing gap to fall
and dirt • Crankshaft vibration: Journal movement causes a reduction
• Oil pressure that is too low: unforeseen loss of pressure in pressure on one side due to resulting suction effect
(for example due to defective oil pump) is present or the oil • Vibration in the bearing bore (generally for connecting rod
pressure is set too low eyes) due to deformation or bending – resulting in
• The vapour pressure of the oil used is too low a reduction in pressure in the oil film
• Increase in temperature in the bearing (for example due to a
lack of oil) Flow cavitation:
• Oils with low viscosity increase the risk of cavitation • Breaks in the surface (oil bores, oil grooves) and diversion
• Hollow areas / foreign particles (for example carbon of the oil flow may cause a reduction in pressure
deposits) at the back of the bearing may cause vibration of
the bearing shell, resulting in cavitation
REMEDY
Bearings which demonstrate cavitation do not need to be • Check the lubricating gap and readjust bearing clearance
replaced. Depending on the extent of the cavitation, the service if necessary
life may be reduced due to the influence on the dynamics of the • Check the engine for vibration stress
bearing. Complete failure is not a concern, however. • Check the oil for fuel dilution
• Use quality oils and replace the oil and filter regularly in
accordance with the manufacturer‘s specifications
• Check the oil pressure and readjust if necessary
• Use an oil with a higher vapour pressure: The oil must be
compatible with all engine components, however. Consult
the manufacturer for advice if necessary
5. FATIGUE DAMAGE
5.1 INTRODUCTION
If the integrity of the material is exceeded locally, fatigue occurs.
The first cracks form (Fig. 1), which continue to grow due to notch
effect and a network of cracks develops (Fig. 2). In addition, nicks
occur (Fig. 3) in the bearing metal. The network of cracks and the
nicks reduce the strength of the bearing, meaning a fatigue
fracture can be caused in the event of stress. The engine bearing
has then lost its ability to function and complete failure occurs.
Particles enter the lubrication system due to the material
breaking off.
This can result in scoring or the embedding of particles in the
same or adjacent bearing shells. Initial rubbing marks and
seizure can also be caused in the same or adjacent bearings. Fig. 1: First cracks
Fig. 3: Nicks
5. FATIGUE DAMAGE 52 | 53
POSSIBLE CAUSES
Signs of fatigue, such as cracks and nicks on the bearing metal, • Poor oil quality or oil ageing: if unsuitable oil is used or the
are caused by dynamic overstrain. This can have various causes: oil is not of a sufficient quality due to ageing, this can impair
• Overstressing: if forces larger than the design allows for the formation of the lubricating film
affect the bearing, material fatigue occurs – combustion • Vibrations: if the bearing is subject to alternating tensions
defaults, such as knocking, increase the pressure on the due to vibrations, the risk of material fatigue increases
piston and therefore also on the connecting rod bearing • High temperatures: material fatigue is accelerated by high
• Lubrication gap dimensioned too small – a stable temperatures since they reduce the strength of the bearing
lubricating film cannot form: the lubricating film pressure material
rises in these locations and the surface pressure increases
– this can be caused by misalignment, formal errors, errors
in geometry or installation errors (see chapter: „2.5 Special
cases“) – inspection of the adjacent bearing can provide
more information
REMEDY
• Check stress of the bearings – if necessary, a bearing that is • Check connecting rods for angularity before installation
more resistant to fatigue must be used • Balance crankshaft during installation
• Check for correct geometry of the crankshaft: Dimensions, • Only use oil recommended by the manufacturer and observe
roundness, cylindricity, ripple, surface roughness oil change intervals
• Check the bearing line bore is correct: Dimensions, • Ensure sufficient engine cooling
roundness, cylindricity, surface
• Check the alignment of the main bearing bore (observe
specified tightening torque of the bolts, cool engine
sufficiently)
5.2 CRACKS AND NICKS TO THE SLIDING LAYER
This type of damage only occurs with engine bearings with a sliding layer made of polymer / bonded, galvanic or sputter coating.
DESCRIPTION
POSSIBLE CAUSES
• Consequential damage due to increasing temperature • Insufficient heat dissipation provided by the lubricant
development as a result of initial rubbing marks, seizure or (see chapter: „2.3 Initial rubbing marks“)
edge wear
REMEDY
If overheating damage occurs, the bearing must be replaced and If no further damage to the bearing is visible, the lubricant circuit
the causes investigated. In the event of consequential damage, (see chapter: „2.3 Initial rubbing mark“) and the stress on the
the cause of the primary damage must be rectified. bearing must be checked.
6.2 HEAT CRACKS 56 | 57
DESCRIPTION
ASSESSMENT
If the bearing shell is not sitting correctly in the bearing block, The surrounding medium can penetrate into the surface (which is
frictional corrosion is caused due to the resulting relative already roughened and chemically activated) and accelerate the
movement (micro sliding movements). The frictional heat corrosion.
generated by the movement of the bearing cannot be dissipated Frictional corrosion reduces the integrity of the material, as the
by the lubricant as in the inside of the bearing, but instead formation of micro cracks is facilitated. Fatigue damage with
causes local overheating of the steel back. The overheating consequences such as cracks or fatigue fractures can be the
causes fusing and the scarred surface typical of this. There is a result.
transfer of material between the back of the bearing and the
bore.
POSSIBLE CAUSES
• Insufficient preloading due to bore being too large or • Bending of the crankshaft: the bending of the crankshaft
bearing shell being too small leaves a particular wear pattern on the sliding surface of the
• Bearing shell protrusion too small: the protrusion of the bearing (see chapter: „2.5 Special cases“)
bearing shell guarantees the reliable fit through sufficient • Insufficiently tightened bolts
press fitting • Vibrations from the housing or the crankshaft which cause
• Housing deformation: for crankcases made from aluminium, micro-movements (vibration may also be caused by foreign
the housing and bearing shell can deform differently under particles and / or hollow areas)
the effect of extreme temperatures, whereby the reliable fit
of the bearing may no longer be sufficient
REMEDY
When the signs of contact corrosion are recognisable, the • Check the locating hole and housing for possible deformation
bearing must be replaced as the integrity may already be • Balance crankshaft during installation and check strain on
reduced. the shaft
• Locating hole and bearing shell outer diameter must be • Tighten bolts in accordance with the manufacturer‘s
within the tolerance range so that the specified bearing specifications with regard to tightening torques and the
clearance can be met tightening sequence
• Protrusion: in order to create the desired press fit for the • Check engine for vibration during operation
reliable fit, the bearing shell must have a sufficient
protrusion
7.2 CHEMICAL CORROSION
DESCRIPTION
ASSESSMENT
Chemical corrosion is caused by reactions between the bearing The integrity of the material is adversely affected by the chemical
shell and engine oil. Triggers for the chemical reaction are attack, meaning that fatigue damage is accelerated, even with
aggressive additives in the oil or oil contamination during low stress.
operation.
POSSIBLE CAUSES
• Wear, cavitation and erosion can assist corrosion since they • Contamination of the oil with water or antifreeze
attack the material surface and activate it chemically • High operating temperatures accelerate chemical processes
• Formation of acids and metal salts as a result of oil ageing such as oil ageing
• Impermissible, aggressive oil additives
• Aggressive products from combustion (sulphur, hydrogen
sulphide)
REMEDY
POSSIBLE CAUSES
• Axial clearance too low, meaning that the thrust washer is • Sustained axial stress
pressed against the interacting sliding parts • Shaft flange too rough
• Axial stress too high
REMEDY
• Check the axial clearance of the crankshaft and keep to the • Check the axial stress on the thrust washer
specified tolerance range – if necessary use a thrust washer
with undersize grade
8. DAMAGE TO THRUST WASHERS 64 | 65
Sliding wear
Wear marks are visible on the sliding surface of the thrust washer New state before use
Seizure
Areas of torn-out material and pronounced scoring; oil grooves
are no longer visible
Complete failure
9. GLOSSARY
TECHNICAL NAMES AND NAMES ON THE ENGINE BEARING
01 02
01 02
03
03
06 08
05 07 04
04
09 05 09 10
06 07
04 08
02
01
01 Locking lug
02 Oil groove
9. GLOSSAR 66 | 67
Transition speed
Describes the transition point – the area in which the transition
from mixed friction to liquid friction takes place due to the
higher sliding speed. In hydrodynamic engine bearings – as
used in combustion engines – the thin lubricating film only
forms at higher sliding speeds. At lower sliding speeds, these
engine bearings have to withstand mixed friction with high
proportions of dry friction. For this reason, we always strive to
keep operation with mixed friction as short as possible.
Wall thickness
The bearing clearance is determined by the wall thickness of
the engine bearing. As the outer diameter is specified by the
press fitting, the bearing clearance relative to the shaft
diameter can be adjusted by varying the wall thickness.
For reconditioned shafts, there are engine bearings with
different oversize grades (larger wall thicknesses).
KNOW-HOW TRANSFER
PROFESSIONAL KNOWLEDGE FROM THE EXPERTS
TECHNICAL VIDEOS
Knowledge transfer via video TECHNIPEDIA
Our videos provide you with useful information on our Technical information on all aspects of the engine
products, such as hands-on fitting instructions and system We share our know-how with you in our Technipedia. You can
descriptions. get professional knowledge direct from experts here.
MOTORSERVICE APP
PRODUCTS IN FOCUS ONLINE Access technical know-how on the move
Our solutions explained clearly Here, you will find the latest information and services relating
Interactive elements, animations and video clips provide to our products quickly and easily.
interesting information about our products in and around the
engine. SOCIAL MEDIA
Always up to date
ONLINESHOP
Your direct access to our products
Order at any time. Quick availability check. Extensive product
search by engine, vehicle, dimensions etc.
www.ms-motorservice.com
70 | 71
HEADQUARTERS:
MS Motorservice International GmbH
Wilhelm-Maybach-Straße 14–18
74196 Neuenstadt, Germany
www.ms-motorservice.com
www.ms-motorservice.com
© MS Motorservice International GmbH – 50003 859-02 – EN – 05/17 (092020)