Cornejo 2019 Sex Cord Stromal Tumors of The Test
Cornejo 2019 Sex Cord Stromal Tumors of The Test
Cornejo 2019 Sex Cord Stromal Tumors of The Test
Sex cord-stromal tumors female examples. Pure stromal tumors of the testis are much less
common than similar tumors in the ovary and the well-known thecoma
of the testis is remarkably rare in the testis. Fibromas of stromal derivation in the
testis should be distinguished from fibromas that originate from the
tunica albuginea and from examples of the non-neoplastic process
Kristine M Cornejo nodular pseudotumor.
Robert H Young Keywords adult granulosa cell tumor; fibroma; juvenile granulosa
cell tumor; Leydig cell tumor; myoid gonadal stromal tumor; Peutz-
Jeghers syndrome; Sertoli cell tumor; sex cord-stromal tumor; testis
Abstract
Testicular tumors apart from those in the germ cell family are uncom-
mon and are mostly sex cord-stromal tumors and may pose a major Introduction
diagnostic challenge. This review focuses on the clinicopathologic fea- Non-germ cell tumors of the testis are much less common than
tures of these uncommon neoplasms, pertinent differential diagnoses, germ cell tumors, and may pose a major diagnostic challenge,
relevant immunohistochemical and molecular findings as well as the particularly for general pathologists. However, even patholo-
recent updates proposed by the World Health Organization (WHO). gists with special interest in urologic pathology may be chal-
Contrast between these neoplasms as seen in the male and female lenged by these cases because of their relative rarity. Our
gonad will also be made when warranted. The commonest sex cord- current knowledge of sex cord-stromal tumors of the testis is
stromal tumor of the testis is the Leydig cell tumor which, when based on work of many prior investigators but it should be
seen in children, is often associated with sexual precocity. The histo- noted that two of the giants of gonadal pathology Dr. Gunnar
logic features are generally those of an easily recognized oxyphilic Teilum1 and Dr. Robert E. Scully2 have probably contributed
neoplasm but various peculiarities such as microcysts and spindling more than most.3 The former was likely the first to focus on the
of the tumor cells may case diagnostic difficulty on occasion. In the interesting similarities and yet differences between these tu-
male, in contrast to the female, the most common sex cord-stromal mors in the male and female. The latter, based on his own
tumor of epithelial nature is the Sertoli cell tumor. Most of these fall writings and availability of cases sent to him in consultation for
in the not otherwise specified category and are usually characterized study by others, contributed greatly to our knowledge of these
by a diagnostically helpful at least focal hollow or solid tubular pattern. tumors and our debt to these great prior investigators is
Occasional malignant Sertoli cell tumors have a predominantly diffuse acknowledged here. The contributions of British investigators,
pattern sometimes interrupted by septa with a lymphocytic infiltrate particularly those on the British testicular panel of several de-
that can cause seminoma to be mimicked. Rare Sertoli cell tumors cades ago, culminating in an outstanding work published in
are associated with marked sclerosis. The so-called large cell calci- 1964, and also in the meritorious book edited by Dr. R.C.B.
fying Sertoli cell tumor, may be sporadic or associated with manifes- Pugh, published 12 years later, should also not be forgotten.3e5
tations of the Carney syndrome. A distinctive entity referred to as Amongst other things Drs D.H. Collins and T. Symington of that
intratubular hyalinizing Sertoli cell neoplasia occurs in the testis of group were the first to comment on the differential between
young boys with Peutz-Jeghers syndrome. It is often bilateral, micro- Sertoli cell tumor and seminoma.3
scopic and associated with gynecomastia. Testicular granulosa cell Sex cord-stromal tumors are overall infrequent, but are the
tumors are much rarer than their ovarian counterparts but can be simi- second most common testicular tumor after germ cell tumors and
larly subdivided into adult and juvenile forms. In the male, the juvenile are relatively more commonly identified in children (in whom
granulosa cell tumor has a particularly striking tendency to occur in the germ cell tumors are rare), comprising approximately 25% of all
first 6 months of life. The primitive appearance of the nuclei and brisk testicular neoplasms, in contrast to only 2e5% of testicular tu-
mitotic activity of the juvenile granulosa cell tumor may result in a mors in adults.6 Most of the tumors are clinically benign, with
misdiagnosis of a more malignant neoplasm. The histologic spectrum only a small subset (5%) being malignant. Many are non-
of the adult granulosa cell tumor is as seen in the more common functional, but a minority may be associated with isosexual
pseudoprecocity or feminization and/or a genetic or clinical
syndrome.6 We begin by considering by far the most common,
the Leydig cell tumor.
DIAGNOSTIC HISTOPATHOLOGY 25:10 398 Ó 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
MINI-SYMPOSIUM: NEPHROUROLOGY
DIAGNOSTIC HISTOPATHOLOGY 25:10 399 Ó 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
MINI-SYMPOSIUM: NEPHROUROLOGY
mesothelioma, exemplifies the importance of being aware where which encodes the b-catenin protein, in a significant proportion
an intrascrotal neoplasm is predominantly located when exam- of NOS and sclerosing SCTs.6,18,19 The lipid-rich variant is no
ining testicular and paratesticular neoplasms. Malignant LCTs longer considered a separate entity as many SCTs contain lipid
may be spindled and extend beyond the testis and conversely and vacuolization, and it is rare to find a purely lipid-rich SCT.
malignant mesotheliomas may be spindled and involve the testis. Uncommonly, metastases develop, usually involving lymph
Careful gross evaluation should suggest the likely correct diag- nodes, with occasional instances of hematogenous spread to lung
nosis in such cases but if needed immunohistochemistry with and bone.20
inhibin and other markers will be helpful. Grossly, the neoplasms usually measure 2e5 cm and are well-
circumscribed, firm, tan-white to gray or rarely yellow, with a
minor cystic component occurring in a third of cases.6,20 Areas of
hemorrhage and necrosis are uncommon. Tumors with promi-
nent stromal sclerosis are typically smaller (<2 cm) and lack cyst
Practice points formation.6,21,22 Microscopically, they display some tubular dif-
ferentiation, at least focally, often in a nodular pattern separated
C Leydig cell tumors are the most common sex cord-stromal tumor.
by fibrovascular and occasionally myxoid stroma (Figure 3).16
C May be associated with HLRCC and Klinefelter syndrome.
The tubules can be hollow/round to elongated and solid,
C Diffuse growth composed of round/polygonal cells with eosino-
showing various amounts of cystic dilation (Figure 4).6,16 A
philic cytoplasm and small nucleoli.
diffuse growth of cells may rarely be seen, often traversed by
C Subset contain Reinke crystals and lipofuscin pigment.
fibrous stroma and sometimes associated with an inflammatory
C Differential diagnosis includes Leydig cell hyperplasia (<0.5 cm;
cell infiltrate. Rarely a retiform pattern is seen.6,16 The cells often
multifocal), testicular tumors of the adrenogenital syndrome
contain clear or pale to eosinophilic cytoplasm and may display
(bilateral; multifocal; androgen receptor negative; CD56/syn-
lipid or vacuoles, but usually only focally (Figure 5).6,16 Mitotic
aptophysin positive), malakoplakia (Michaelis-Gutmann bodies,
activity and cytological atypia is typically absent to minimal, but
involvement of interstitium and seminiferous tubules), yolk sac
may occur in a small subset, especially those displaying diffuse
tumor (AFP positive; inhibin negative), Sertoli cell tumors (tubular
growth.6,16 A subset of tumors contain prominent hypocellular
differentiation; nuclear b-catenin) and mesothelioma (gross ex-
hyalinized stroma and when it constitutes 50% of the tumor, is
amination/dominantly paratesticular; inhibin negative).
designated the sclerosing variant of SCT, NOS (Figure 6).6,22
Identifying this variant is important as it correlates with better
outcome and a lower risk of metastasis.21,22
Sertoli cell tumors Metastasis occurs in 5% of tumors and features of malignancy
Sertoli cell tumors, not otherwise specified (NOS) include size >5 cm, extratesticular spread, moderate to severe
Sertoli cell tumors (SCTs) occur at all ages, but most commonly cytological atypia, >5 mitoses/10 HPFs, lymphovascular inva-
in adults and comprise <1% of testicular neoplasms.6,7 Most sion and necrosis.6,20 Immunohistochemically, the tumor ex-
present after 30 years of age (mean age 45 years), but they presses nuclear b-catenin in 60e70% of cases.18,19,23
nonetheless account for a higher percentage of testicular tumors Additionally, they are often positive for inhibin (50% of cases),
in children due to the rarity of germ cell neoplasms before 15 Melan-A, WT-1, calretinin, synaptophysin, chromogranin, SOX9,
years of age. They present with a slow-growing, unilateral SF1, PAX2/PAX8, epithelial membrane antigen (EMA) and
testicular mass, usually without hormonal manifestations.6,16 pancytokeratin.6,20,24
Lipid-rich and sclerosing variants are now classified as SCT, The histologic differential includes Sertoli cell nodules, LCT,
not otherwise specified (NOS) (Table 1).6,17 The latest WHO seminoma, adenomatoid tumor and rete cystadenoma. Sertoli
classification of urologic tumors (2016) reflects this new classi- cell nodules occur in cryptorchid or undescended testis and are
fication based upon identification of CTNNB1 gene mutations, usually microscopic (<1 cm), although rarely mass-forming
nodules have been reported, comprised of aggregates of non-
neoplastic immature Sertoli cells within seminiferous tu-
bules.20,25 Helpful clues include an association with scattered
Classification of sertoli cell tumors
spermatogonia, lack of stromal invasion and rounded aggregates
Tumor type Genetic characteristic/ of hyaline material, while SCTs are often mass-forming (>1 cm)
syndrome with stromal invasion.16,20 SCTs may display diffuse growth with
abundant eosinophilic cytoplasm and resemble LCTs. However,
Sertoli cell tumor, not otherwise CTNNB1 gene mutation identifying Reinke crystals in LCTs and tubular differentiation in
specified (NOS) SCTs helps to separate the two entities, although a pseudotubular
- Sclerosing variant pattern may rarely be seen in LCTs.16,20 Immunohistochemistry
Large cell calcifying PRKAR1A gene mutation/ will also help as LCTs are often strongly positive for inhibin,
sertoli cell tumor deletion while SCTs are positive for b-catenin, pancytokeratin and var-
Carney complex iably for inhibin.19,20 Therefore, a negative inhibin stain would
Intratubular large cell STK11 gene mutation support an SCT.
hyalinizing sertoli cell neoplasia Peutz-Jeghers syndrome SCTs may occasionally display a diffuse pattern with inflam-
mation and a seminoma may be considered.16 Additionally,
Table 1
seminomas may show tubular morphology, mimicking SCTs.
DIAGNOSTIC HISTOPATHOLOGY 25:10 400 Ó 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
MINI-SYMPOSIUM: NEPHROUROLOGY
Figure 3 Sertoli cell tumor, NOS. Small to medium sized hollow tu- Figure 6 Sertoli cell tumor, sclerosing variant. Abundant collagen be-
bules separated by myxoid stroma. tween compressed cords and tubules.
Practice points
DIAGNOSTIC HISTOPATHOLOGY 25:10 401 Ó 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
MINI-SYMPOSIUM: NEPHROUROLOGY
DIAGNOSTIC HISTOPATHOLOGY 25:10 402 Ó 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
MINI-SYMPOSIUM: NEPHROUROLOGY
Practice points
DIAGNOSTIC HISTOPATHOLOGY 25:10 403 Ó 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
MINI-SYMPOSIUM: NEPHROUROLOGY
Practice points
Juvenile granulosa cell tumor 1, WT1 and calretinin with more variable staining for cytokeratin
The majority of juvenile granulosa cell tumors (JGCT) occur in and SOX9, and with negative staining for SALL4.41
the first 6 months of life, with only 10% occurring after that age JGCTs are benign with indolent behavior and are typically
in our case series (range: 30 weeks gestational age to 10 years), treated with surgical resection.41 Despite a subset containing a
with a report of a case occurring in a 27 year old.41,42 Most high proliferative index (>40 mitoses/10 HPFs), none had evi-
present with a unilateral testicular mass or enlargement and dence of disease with follow-up.41
rarely with endocrine manifestations.41 Occasionally, tumors The histologic differential includes YST as both may occur in
arise in boys with cryptorchid testes or gonadal dysgenesis and the young. The age of the patient is helpful as JGCT occur in
karyotypic abnormalities.41,43 A FOX2L gene mutation has not those <6 months of age, whereas most children with YST are
been identified in JGCT, but only a rare case has been tested.40 older (mean 20.7 months; range 5e71 months).41,44 JGCTs
Grossly, the tumors measure up to 5 cm (mean 1.7 cm; range display follicular differentiation, which is not a feature of YSTs,
0.5e5.0 cm), and are tan-yellow to gray and contain a cystic albeit the polyvesicular vitelline variant with cysts may mimic
component, often with a mucoid or watery fluid-like sub- follicles, and both may contain solid growth.16,41,44,45 Immuno-
stance.36,41 Histologically, JGCTs usually display a lobular ar- histochemistry is also helpful as YSTs are positive for SALL4,
chitecture containing follicles of varying size and shape with glypican-3 and AFP, while JGCTs are highlighted by sex cord
basophilic and/or eosinophilic material (Figure 12).41 The -tromal tumor markers such as inhibin, calretinin and WT-
stroma is often fibromyxoid or fibrous and the cells which often 1.41,44,46
line the follicles in single or multiple layers, contain round to Other entities to consider in the differential include SCTs,
ovoid nuclei with pale to eosinophilic cytoplasm and inconspic- sarcoma and AGCTs. SCTs show tubular differentiation rather
uous nucleoli (Figure 13).41,43 Longitudinal grooves are infre- than follicular differentiation, and age is helpful in separating
quent and abundant mitoses defined as 10 mitoses/10 HPFs are these two entities. The follicles of JGCTs are typically larger than
identified in approximately 40% of cases.41 Immunohis- the tubules of SCTs, often with multilayering of cells which may
tochemically, the tumors are highlighted by inhibin, FOXL2, SF- be mitotically active and nodular in appearance with a myxoid or
DIAGNOSTIC HISTOPATHOLOGY 25:10 404 Ó 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
MINI-SYMPOSIUM: NEPHROUROLOGY
fibromyxoid stroma.41 Occasionally, JGCTs display a significant cord component, a reticulin stain may be helpful.48 Fibrous
spindled component and a sarcoma, such as embryonal rhab- pseudotumors may also be considered as it similarly presents as
domyosarcoma may be considered. However, other typical a well-circumscribed white-tan or yellow mass with a whorled or
components of JGCTs are present such as follicle formation and bulging cut surface.49,50 Histologically, it is composed of uniform
the location may be a helpful clue as sarcomas are typically spindled cells arranged in whorls with a myxoid or collagenous
paratesticular.7,36,41 AGCTs may also enter the differential, but stroma and small vessels, often with inflammation.49e51 The
JGCTs occur in a much younger age group and typically lack the helpful clue is the predominant paratesticular location, typically
conspicuous longitudinal grooves.41 Although both granulosa with attachment to the tunica.49 Immunostains for S100 and
cell tumors express FOX2L, as mentioned previously, immuno- inhibin may be helpful as they are usually negative in fibrous
reactivity has been identified in other sex cord-stromal tumors pseudotumor, while variably positive in fibroma.49,50 Lastly,
and it is not specific. myoid gonadal stromal tumors (MGSTs) may also be considered
as it is also comprised purely of spindled cells forming fascicles.
Immunohistochemistry may be helpful as MGSTs are typically
Practice points negative for inhibin, SOX9 and calretinin, while often positive in
fibroma.52
C Juvenile granulosa cell tumors are not associated with FOX2L
gene mutations.
C More common than adult granulosa cell tumors in the testis and Practice points
occur in the first 6 months of life.
C Solid and cystic neoplasm comprised of varying sized follicles, C Fibromas are composed of spindled cells in a storiform or
with round to ovoid cells, inconspicuous nucleoli and uncom- fascicular pattern with variable amounts of collagen.
monly display nuclear grooves. C Differential diagnosis includes unclassified sex cord-stromal
C Differential diagnosis includes yolk sac tumor (SALL4/glypican-3/ tumor (reticulin stain highlights nests of cells), fibrous pseudo-
AFP positive), Sertoli cell tumors (tubular differentiation; no tumor (paratesticular; S100/inhibin negative) and myoid gonadal
multilayering of cells) and sarcoma (paratesticular; lack follicle stromal tumor (inhibin/SOX9/calretinin negative).
formation). C Thecoma of the testis using ovarian criteria is exceptionally rare.
DIAGNOSTIC HISTOPATHOLOGY 25:10 405 Ó 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
MINI-SYMPOSIUM: NEPHROUROLOGY
DIAGNOSTIC HISTOPATHOLOGY 25:10 406 Ó 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
MINI-SYMPOSIUM: NEPHROUROLOGY
29 Goode B, Joseph NM, Stevers M, et al. Adenomatoid tumors of 41 Kao CS, Cornejo KM, Ulbright TM, Young RH. Juvenile granulosa
the male and female genital tract are defined by TRAF7 mutations cell tumors of the testis: a clinicopathologic study of 70 cases with
that drive aberrant NF-kB pathway activation. Mod Pathol 2018; emphasis on its wide morphologic spectrum. Am J Surg Pathol
31: 660e73. 2015; 39: 1159e69.
30 Jones MA, Young RH. Sertoliform cystadenoma of the rete testis: 42 Lin KH, Lin SE, Lee LM. Juvenile granulosa cell tumor of adult
a report of two cases. J Urol Pathol 1997; 7: 47e53. testis: a case report. Urology 2008; 72: 230 e11e3.
31 Paluru S, Ulbright TM, Amin M, Montironi R, Epstein JI. The 43 Lawrence WD, Young RH, Scully RE. Juvenile granulosa cell
morphologic spectrum of sertoliform cystadenoma of the rete tumor of the infantile testis. A report of 14 cases. Am J Surg
testis: a series of 15 cases. Am J Surg Pathol 2018; 42: 141e9. Pathol 1985; 9: 87e94.
32 Proppe KH, Scully RE. Large-cell calcifying Sertoli cell tumor of 44 Cornejo KM, Frazier L, Lee RS, Kozakewich HP, Young RH. Yolk
the testis. Am J Clin Pathol 1980; 74: 607e19. sac tumor of the testis in infants and children: a clinicopathologic
33 Kratzer SS, Ulbright TM, Talerman A, et al. Large cell calcifying analysis of 33 cases. Am J Surg Pathol 2015; 39: 1121e31.
Sertoli cell tumor of the testis: contrasting features of six malig- 45 Young RH, Ulbright TM, Policarpio-Nicolas ML. Yolk sac tumor
nant and six benign tumors and a review of the literature. Am J with a prominent polyvesicular vitelline pattern: a report of three
Surg Pathol 1997; 21: 1271e80. cases. Am J Surg Pathol 2013; 37: 393e8.
34 Petersson F, Bulimbasic S, Sima R, et al. Large cell calcifying 46 Kao CS, Idrees MT, Young RH, Ulbright TM. Solid pattern yolk sac
Sertoli cell tumor: a clinicopathologic study of 1 malignant and 3 tumor: a morphologic and immunohistochemical study of 52
benign tumors using histomorphology, immunohistochemistry, cases. Am J Surg Pathol 2012; 36: 360e7.
ultrastructure, comparative genomic hybridization, and polymer- 47 Burandt E, Young RH. Thecoma of the ovary: a report of 70 cases
ase chain reaction analysis of the PRKAR1A gene. Hum Pathol emphasizing aspects of its histopathology different from those
2010; 41: 552e9. often portrayed and its differential diagnosis. Am J Surg Pathol
35 Gourgari E, Saloustros E, Stratakis CA. Large-cell calcifying Ser- 2014; 38: 1023e32.
toli cell tumors of the testes in pediatrics. Curr Opin Pediatr 2012; 48 Zhang M, Kao CS, Ulbright TM, Epstein JI. Testicular fibrothe-
24: 518e22. coma: a morphologic and immunohistochemical study of 16
36 Ulbright TM, Young RH. Testicular and paratesticular tumors and cases. Am J Surg Pathol 2013; 37: 1208e14.
tumor-like lesions in the first 2 decades. Semin Diagn Pathol 2014; 49 Jones MA, Young RH, Scully RE. Benign fibromatous tumors of
31: 323e81. the testis and paratesticular region: a report of 9 cases with a
37 Tanaka Y, Carney JA, Ijiri R, et al. Utility of immunostaining for S- proposed classification of fibromatous tumors and tumor-like le-
100 protein subunits in gonadal sex cord-stromal tumors, with sions. Am J Surg Pathol 1997; 21: 296e305.
emphasis on the large-cell calcifying Sertoli cell tumor of the 50 Miyamoto H, Montgomery EA, Epstein JI. Paratesticular fibrous
testis. Hum Pathol 2002; 33: 285e9. pseudotumor: a morphologic and immunohistochemical study of
38 Ulbright TM, Amin MB, Young RH. Intratubular large cell hyali- 13 cases. Am J Surg Pathol 2010; 34: 569e74.
nizing sertoli cell neoplasia of the testis: a report of 8 cases of a 51 Oliva E, Young RH. Paratesticular tumor-like lesions. Semin Diagn
distinctive lesion of the Peutz-Jeghers syndrome. Am J Surg Pathol 2000; 17: 340e58.
Pathol 2007; 31: 827e35. 52 Kao CS, Ulbright TM. Myoid gonadal stromal tumor: a clinico-
39 Cornejo KM, Young RH. Adult granulosa cell tumors of the testis: pathologic study of three cases of a distinctive testicular tumor.
a report of 32 cases. Am J Surg Pathol 2014; 38: 1242e50. Am J Clin Pathol 2014; 142: 675e82.
40 Lima JF, Jin L, de Araujo AR, et al. FOXL2 mutations in granulosa 53 Du S, Powell J, Hii A, Weidner N. Myoid gonadal stromal tumor: a
cell tumors occurring in males. Arch Pathol Lab Med 2012; 136: distinct testicular tumor with peritubular myoid cell differentiation.
825e8. Hum Pathol 2012; 43: 144e9.
DIAGNOSTIC HISTOPATHOLOGY 25:10 407 Ó 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.