State of ModelOps 2021
State of ModelOps 2021
ModelOps 2021
How 100 AI-Focused Executives from Top
Global Financial Services Companies are
Developing Practices to Ensure Excellence
as They Govern and Scale AI Initiatives
State of ModelOps 2021
Contents
Click below to navigate
3 Executive
Summary
4 Methodology
5 Foreword
6 Enterprise AI is
Driving the Rise of
ModelOps
9 Enterprises are
Investing in Their
ModelOps Functions
10 Why ModelOps is an
Enterprise Concern
16 AI has an
Operationalization
Problem
17 Who Should Be
Responsible for
ModelOps
19 Conclusion
2
State of ModelOps 2021
Executive Summary
M
odelOps is a must-have capability ModelOps functions to automate and
for enterprises seeking to streamline their existing processes.
operationalize AI, and this has Most AI-focused executives feel that
become apparent in 2021. Enterprises standardizing ModelOps practices across
are investing in their ModelOps functions the enterprise is essential for managing the
and developing processes for governing, operational challenges and risk that come
monitoring and managing AI models at scale. with AI deployment at scale.
This report summarizes the first Models are not like conventional software.
ever research into the state of model As enterprises increasingly recognize this,
operationalization. Our survey of 100 they are creating new roles, such as the
executives from top global financial ‘model operator’. These will bring focus,
services companies provides a unique flexibility and operational excellence
snapshot of the practices large enterprises to managing models, in the same way
are using to govern and scale mission- that DevOps , ITOps and SecOps do for
critical AI initiatives. conventional software.
Our findings show that AI is already Alongside the survey results, we present
widely deployed in many large highlights from several top executives who
enterprises. To address the operational shared their views regarding the extent of
and compliance challenges that comes the enterprise AI operationalization problem
with this, organizations are investing in and how they’re addressing it.
Key Takeaways
270
is the average number
80%
say difficulty managing risk and
of models respondents’ ensuring compliance is a barrier
enterprises have in production to AI adoption for their enterprise
5-7
is the average number of tools
25%
say their existing processes
respondents’ enterprises use for for inventorying models in
developing AI models production are ‘very effective’
90%
of survey respondents expect
69%
say improving the enforcement of AI
to have a dedicated ModelOps governance processes is a key reason
budget within 12 months to invest in a ModelOps platform
3
State of ModelOps 2021
Methodology
T
his representative survey of of Department, and include VPs
100 AI-focused leaders from of Data Science, Global Heads of
the financial services sector Risk, Heads of AI and other AI-
was conducted in February and focused executives.
March, 2021. We asked them 19 questions
Respondents were selected from about their organizations’ AI
the 100 largest financial services maturity and ModelOps capabilities,
companies in North America and as well as the obstacles to model
Europe, respectively. Of these, 84% operationalization facing their
are from Global 500 or Fortune companies and where they’re
500 organizations, including investing to overcome them.
Charles Schwab, Citigroup, Morgan Then, we combined our findings
Stanley, American Express and with commentary from seven industry
JPMorgan Chase. experts to put these unique insights
They have job titles ranging from into the state of enterprise model
C-level to Directors, VPs or Heads operationalization into context.
Contributors
Stu Bailey
Co-Founder and Chief Skip McCormick
Enterprise AI Architect, Data Science Fellow,
ModelOp BNY Mellon
Glenn Hofmann
Chief Analytics Officer, Scott Zoldi
New York Life Chief Analytics Officer,
Insurance Company FICO
Patricia Flynn
VP, Information
Governance and
Solution Delivery,
State Street
4
State of ModelOps 2021
Foreword
W
e’re delighted to be the sponsor of this first
annual State of ModelOps survey. The very
fact that we have such a survey speaks to the
speed at which our industry is moving in 2021.
ModelOp was founded five years ago with a sole
focus on ModelOps. But even a year or so ago
the notion of ‘ModelOps’ still wasn’t recognized or
understood by many AI practitioners.
That’s changed as the barriers to gaining value from
AI have shifted from creating models to operating them
in production with full efficiency, visibility, compliance
and fairness, as well as within risk limits.
In recent months, there’s been a rapid increase in
attention paid to the critical role of ModelOps as a core
capability, especially for Fortune 500 and Global 500
enterprises. We’re pleased to have been at the forefront
of this effort and excited to serve our customers’ needs.
I want to thank Corinium Intelligence for their
excellent work, and especially thank the 100 senior
leaders who responded to the survey and the seven
executives who agreed to go ‘on the record’ and
provide candid interviews.
This report reflects the challenges real businesses are
facing today and how they’re addressing them in their own
words. I hope that they, and all readers, find it valuable.
Stu Bailey
Co-Founder and Chief
Enterprise AI Architect,
ModelOp
5
State of ModelOps 2021
Enterprise AI is Driving
the Rise of ModelOps
KEY FINDING
M
odelOps is becoming a
critical business function
as more enterprises
successfully deploy and scale their
use of AI models. learning and AI, it’s not really clear Enterprises are Now
Our survey of 100 AI-focused that our existing process works.” Scaling AI Capabilities
leaders from top financial services The term ‘ModelOps’ generally refers When it comes to AI initiatives,
companies shows that these to the enterprise capability focused on where is your company?
enterprises currently have 270 models governance and lifecycle management
All business
in production each, on average. One of all types of decision models, such units using 19%
in five report that all business units in as traditional statistical models, as AI regularly
their organizations use AI regularly, well as AI models. ModelOps touches
while a further 60% report that at least everything that happens with a model Some business
some business units do so. from the point at which its released units using 60%
AI regularly
This is not entirely surprising, as the into production until (and beyond) its
organizations we surveyed are highly ultimate retirement.
Pilot AI
advanced in their use of AI. However, AI models have unique initiatives and/ 21%
the growing number of models at use characteristics and cannot be or experiments
in these enterprises is creating new managed and governed in the same
challenges for AI-focused executives. way as conventional software. So,
270
“For straight transactional while the enterprises we surveyed
processing, I think the model that have decades of experience with
we have works very well,” says models, the growing number of AI The average number of models
Patricia Flynn, VP, Information models at use in these enterprises our respondents’ companies
Governance and Solution Delivery is placing new strains on their typically have in production
at State Street. “For machine business processes. Source: Corinium Intelligence, 2021
6
State of ModelOps 2021
7
State of ModelOps 2021
8
State of ModelOps 2021
Already is integrated
Inventorying models
that are deployed Should be integrated
Maintaining a
compliance audit trail
30% 70%
Risk management
application
Model governance
38% 62%
Monitoring of models Business
applications
Standardizing
model operations
41% 59%
42% 58%
IT service
management
ModelOps is Seen as a Key Business Capability
Does your company have a dedicated budget for model operations?
46% 54%
DevOps
tools
53% 37% 10%
50% 50%
Data science
Yes No, but we will No, and that will not change development tools,
within 12 months in the foreseeable future frameworks or platforms
9
State of ModelOps 2021
Why ModelOps is an
Enterprise Concern
KEY FINDING
A
I tech stacks are constantly premises, 58% execute models “On the production side, we’ve
evolving. Data scientists want to using AWS, 58% do so using Google mostly standardized to one platform,”
be able to use the best tools for Cloud, 27% deploy on Microsoft reports Glenn Hofmann, Chief
the job and enterprises are generally Azure and 12% use other cloud- Analytics Officer at New York Life
happy to accommodate this. As a result, based services. A full 94% use at Insurance Company. “All the models
the ecosystems emerging to develop, least two deployment environments. get deployed on that platform. They
deploy and manage AI in enterprise There are also multiple data science can be consumed by any production
settings have become complex. tools in use at the vast majority of system in the company via an API.”
Our research suggests that multiple companies – 81% use at least two data He adds: “We still have a few
teams are now actively deploying science tools to develop AI models, legacy models on other platforms.
AI models in most large enterprises. with 43% reporting that they use more Maintenance of those gets
Of the 100 AI-focused executives than five. increasingly difficult.”
we surveyed, 81% report that their
organizations have more than five
teams deploying AI models, and 29%
say they have more than 10.
There’s a great variety in production
“We still have a few legacy models
environments, with models deployed on other platforms. Maintenance
across a mix of on-premises and
cloud environments.
of those gets increasingly difficult”
While 48% of respondents say Glenn Hofmann
their models are executed on- Chief Analytics Officer, New York Life Insurance Company
10
State of ModelOps 2021
11
State of ModelOps 2021
With many teams executing different types of AI in a range of environments and using
multiple data science tools, standardized processes are needed to tame enterprise ModelOps
Multiple Teams Deploy AI Across an Enterprise Data Science Staff Generally Use a Range of Tools
How many different teams are deploying models in your Across all business units, how many different data science
entire company? tools does your company use for developing models?
15+ 1% 7+ 4%
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60%
67%
Machine learning models
AWS 58%
54%
Rule-based or heuristic models
12
State of ModelOps 2021
Emerging Trends
in ModelOps
Optimization
KEY FINDING
U
ntil fairly recently, companies have focused on
arming data scientists with the tools they need
for rapid AI development.
But with model development capabilities starting to
scale, a new hurdle has emerged. Enterprises are now
targeting their investments toward getting models into
production in an efficient, compliant and transparent
manner, while maintaining their efficacy and value.
“It’s been a common problem for a while now for “It’s been a common
analytics teams to build models that then sit on a shelf
and never actually get deployed into production,” notes problem for a while now
Glenn Hofmann, Chief Analytics Officer at New York Life
Insurance Company. “We’ve now largely resolved that.
for analytics teams to
But I think it’s a relatively recent phenomenon that this is
getting easier to resolve.”
build models that then
Our research shows that managing risk and ensuring sit on a shelf and never
regulatory compliance is the top barrier to model
operationalization in business today. The 100 AI-focused actually get deployed”
executives we surveyed also cite reducing the cost of Glenn Hofmann
ModelOps and improving model governance as the top Chief Analytics Officer,
two benefits of investing in the function. New York Life Insurance Company
13
State of ModelOps 2021
ability to automate and streamline Crucial Very important Fairly important Not very important Not important
processes so that AI systems can 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
be deployed, scaled, monitored
Improved enforcement of
and maintained. governance and compliance rules
Our research shows that executives
Model operationalization
are becoming aware of the benefits cost reductions
of investing in technology to help
Better visibility into the state
automate and standardize ModelOps and status of models
practices.
Improved collaboration across
One key focus is integrating their data, analytics and AI teams
ModelOps systems with their current
Enhanced ability to measure
software stacks. Of the 100 executives model revenue contributions
we surveyed, 70% say their enterprise
Better model auditability
has integrated data from its risk
and audit reporting
management applications with its
ModelOps processes. Meanwhile, Ability to automate and scale
operationalization process
62% say they’ve integrated data from
their business applications and 59% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
report doing the same with IT and Source: Corinium Intelligence, 2021
But we think it’s necessary to Zhao adds. “On the annual basis,
I also have the ‘algo attestation’.
keep us within the accepted For that, I create a list of things like,
‘What’s the algorithm inventory?
risk parameters” What’s the model inventory? What’s
Kathryn Zhao the algorithm performance quality?
Global Head of Electronic Trading, Cantor Fitzgerald And, are there any red flags?”
14
State of ModelOps 2021
15
State of ModelOps 2021
Enterprises are racing down the path to AI maturity. But there’s no consensus around
who’s responsible for managing and monitoring models once they’re in production
RESPONDENTS
Model
Operators 63% 71% 71% 60% 50%
or Model
RESPONSES
Engineers
Data
52% 79% 21% 80% 60%
Scientists
16
State of ModelOps 2021
T
he ModelOps function is
underdeveloped in many
enterprises because it
has initially fallen to established
organizations such as DevOps.
This arrangement is not ideal,
due to factors including the unique
characteristics of models compared
with conventional software, the
internal and external compliance
and regulatory requirements around
AI models and the need to support There are many differing views as
many stakeholders and teams. to where responsibility for ModelOps
“You never let the
Enterprises often lack a dedicated should live. Perhaps not surprisingly, data scientists
team with the knowledge, remit or respondents in IT functions are
authority to orchestrate ModelOps as the least likely to say that they feel create their own
a cross-functional capability. Some
say that data science teams should
responsible for ModelOps. Executives
in these roles believe data scientists,
paper because
be responsible, but others feel that model operators or model engineers they’re too close
this isn’t the way to go. should have this responsibility.
“You have to have this third-party However, some experts suggest to the problem”
that knows what they’re looking that people skilled in ITOps have Skip McCormick
at and knows how to measure it,” a strong foundation for ModelOps Data Science Fellow,
argues BNY Mellon Data Science and may be best positioned to BNY Mellon
Fellow Skip McCormick. “You never become model operators, as they
let the data scientists create their have deep experience keeping
own paper because they’re too close production systems running ‘round
to the problem.” the clock’.
17
State of ModelOps 2021
60%
“In the past that was often true, and
it was not effective.”
Model operators or model engineers Today, 40% of enterprises still
lack dedicated model operators
26% to handle day-to-day ModelOps
tasks. But if current trends
DevOps
continue, this should be expected
Source: Corinium Intelligence, 2021 to decrease.
18
State of ModelOps 2021
Conclusion
KEY FINDING
A
cross many industries extract the full value from their AI
and companies, the investments while limiting risk and
strategic power of AI has maintaining efficacy, transparency
been established thoroughly. and compliance.
This has led to a surge in model Organizations are creating
creation. But investments in the dedicated model operator or model
people, processes and tools for engineer roles to take on day-to-day
operationalizing models – i.e. ModelOps duties.
ModelOps – has lagged behind. On the other hand, fewer
That’s now starting to change. organizations are placing ModelOps
More than half of the enterprises in the DevOps organization.
we surveyed now have a dedicated Meanwhile, our expert contributors
ModelOps budget, and that figure is generally agree that data scientists
set to rise to 90% within 12 months. have highly specialized, valuable
The key drivers for this increased skills and are not best suited
investment are managing risk, or positioned to manage the
reducing costs through automation operationalization of their models.
and providing visibility through In 2021, the state of ModelOps
improved monitoring. is encouraging. There’s a growing
AI-focused executives in recognition of the function, the
financial services, an industry that problems that it addresses, the
is relatively mature in its use of opportunities it creates and the
traditional and AI models, report investments that need to be made
confidence in the effectiveness to support it. Like DevOps, ITOps
of their ModelOps functions. But and SecOps before it, ModelOps
they face challenges and see looks set to grow into a core
significant room for improvement. business function in its own right as
They also understand that these global AI use matures. But there is
challenges limit their ability to still a long way to go.
19
Get Essential Data and Analytics
Insights Direct to Your Inbox
As anyone who has attended our global conferences or
events will know, our 300,000-strong network of data
and analytics leaders boasts many of the most forward-
thinking minds in the business world.
SUBSCRIBE NOW
About ModelOp
ModelOp is a pioneer of ModelOps software. The company enables
large enterprises to address the critical governance and scale challenges
necessary to fully unlock the transformational value of enterprise AI and
machine learning investments.
Core to any AI orchestration platform, Global 2000 companies use
ModelOp Center to govern, monitor and orchestrate models across the
enterprise and deliver reliable, compliant and scalable AI initiatives.