See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/287301623

Rubber dam in endodontics: An overview of recent advances

Article  in  International Journal of Clinical Dentistry · January 2013

CITATIONS READS
5 28,878

3 authors, including:

Vasudev Ballal
Manipal Academy of Higher Education
91 PUBLICATIONS   821 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Root canal irrigants and Endodontic Biomaterials View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Nidambur Vasudev Ballal on 21 December 2015.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.

International Journal of Clinical Dentistry ISSN: 1939-5833
Volume 6, Number 4 © Nova Science Publishers, Inc.

RUBBER DAM IN ENDODONTICS - AN OVERVIEW

OF RECENT ADVANCES

Nidambur Vasudev Ballal, BDS, MDS, PhD,

Deepika Khandelwal, BDS
and Muliya Vidya Saraswathi, BDS, MDS
Department of Conservative Dentistry and Endodontics,
Manipal College of Dental Sciences, Manipal University,
Manipal, Karnataka, India

ABSTRACT
The rubber dam has been introduced to endodontics over past 120 years. It is
obligatory in endodontics, so much so that endodontics should not be performed without
a rubber dam. However, its use in endodontics has been unfortunately rejected by many
in the profession. Many unfounded reasons for its use like, time for its placement, cost of
equipment and materials, difficulty in use and patient acceptance are given by the dental
practioner‘s. However, recently by the introduction of many newer variations, its use in
endodontics has been made easy. The purpose of this paper is to review the advances in
rubber dam materials and discuss their possibilities to use in endodontics.

INTRODUCTION
The need to work under dry conditions, free of saliva, has been recognized for centuries,
and the idea of using a sheet of rubber to isolate the tooth dates almost 120 years. Its
introduction is attributed to Dr. Sanford Christie Barnum, who in March 1864 demonstrated
for the first time, the advantages of isolating the tooth with a rubber sheet [1]. It is surprising
that even today the use of rubber dam for endodontics among general dental practioners is
low. Many reasons such as, time for rubber dam placement, cost of equipment and materials,
difficulty in use and patient acceptance are some of the disincentives to rubber dam use given
by the dentists [2]. The majority of these disincentives is based on unfound myths rather than


Address for correspondence: Dr. N. Vasudev Ballal, BDS, MDS, PhD, Professor, Department of Conservative
Dentistry & Endodontics, Manipal College of Dental Sciences, Manipal University, Manipal – 576 104,
Karnataka, India, E-mail: [email protected] or [email protected], Fax : 90-0820-2570061, Phone:
+91 9880626167
320 Nidambur Vasudev Ballal, Deepika Khandelwal and Muliya Vidya Saraswathi

evidenced based reasoning. It is worth spending a few seconds to organizing rubber dam for
use in endodontic procedures and thus improve the entire treatment.
Advantages of using rubber dam during endodontic procedures:

1. Provides dry and clean operating field.

2. Enhanced access and visibility to the working area.
3. Protects patients from possible aspiration or swallowing of endodontic instruments,
medicaments, irrigating solutions and debris [3].
4. Retracts and protects the soft tissues (gingival tissues, tongue, lips and cheeks)
against possible trauma from rotary and hand instruments and endodontic
medicaments [3, 4].
5. Significantly reduces the microbial content of air turbine aerosols produced during
endodontic procedures, thereby reducing the risk of cross-infection [5, 6].
6. Improves the properties of dental materials by preventing the moisture contamination
of restorative materials.
7. Enhances operating efficiency and increased productivity. Patient management is
simplified by avoiding need to rinse the mouth of debris.
8. Protects dentists and dental assistants against infections which can be transmitted by
the patient‘s saliva [6].
9. Minimizes patients conversation during root canal treatment and encourages them to
open their mouth [3, 4, 7].
10. Eliminates need for repeated change of cotton rolls due to flooding of saliva or root
canal irrigants.

Contraindication to the use of the rubber dam includes:

1. Asthmatic patients
2. Patients with latex allergy
3. Psychological reasons

Recent Advances in Rubber Dam

Rubber Dam Sheets

 Hygenic dental dam (Coltène/Whaledent, OH, USA) – It is a non-latex rubber dam

for patients with latex allergies. This powder-free, synthetic dam comes in one size
(6 × 6 inches) and in one thickness (medium gauge). It has a shelf life of 3 years and
has the same tensile strength of a latex dam.
 Derma dam (Ultradent Products. Inc, USA) - It is also a nonlatex and powder-free
rubber dam which removes the possibility of latex reactions. It has a low content of
surface proteins and has an advantage of having low dermatitis potential, reduced
allergic reactions and greater tear resistance
 Flexi dam (Coltène/Whaledent)- It is an elastic nonlatex dental dam made from an
elastic plastomer and can be elongated more than 1000 % before tearing. It is more
tenacious than latex dam and is simple to place. It needs to be stretched before use.
 Rubber dam in Endodontics- an Overview of Recent Advances 321

The punched hole should be 1 or 2 sizes smaller than normally used for latex dam.
As the dam is nonlatex and powder free, there are reduced chances of allergic
reactions. It adapts extremely well around the cervix of tooth for effective isolation
and an absolutely dry working area. It is available in blue and violet colour. These
colours provide a good contrast to the working area and may have a calming effect
on the user. This has an advantage while performing aesthetic treatment procedures.

Rubber Dam Frames

The older frames have numerous disadvantages such as, requiring more time for
positioning, they completely cover the patient‘s nose and mouth, giving the patient unpleasant
sensation of suffocation and they do not cause retraction of the lips or cheeks. Recently newer
frames have been marketed into endodontic practice which has many added advantages.

a) Articulated frame
The articulated rubber dam frame (IRED, France) is made of non-irritant plastic material
(polysulfone) currently used in the agro alimentary industry and has the following features
(Figure 1).

 A double hinge situated in the vertical axis of the frame, which allows it to be folded
in half in the vertical direction.
 A brace situated at the bottom of the frame allows turning the dam sheet back on
itself creating a reservoir into which compresses or an aspiration device may be
placed.

Figure 1. Articulated frame.

Figure 2. Safe T frame

322 Nidambur Vasudev Ballal, Deepika Khandelwal and Muliya Vidya Saraswathi

The articulated frame has an advantage in providing access to the buccal half of the
cavity. This accessibility facilitates proper positioning of the radiographic film, administration
of additional local anesthetic, and evacuation of therapeutic liquids, which may have
accidentally entered the buccal cavity [8]. In addition to this, it has an reservoir at the bottom
of the frame that allows the placement of gauze to compress and an aspiration canula to avoid
leakage of fluids such as sodium hypochlorite onto the patient's clothing.

b) Safe T- frame
The Safe-T-frame (Sigma Dental Systems) is composed of two hinged frame members
whose snap-shut locking mechanism securely clamps the rubber dam sheet in place (Figure
2). This concept also makes it possible to retain the traditional U-formed frame geometry and
dimensions and offers a secure fit without-stretching the rubber dam sheet. It also has a
further advantage of, raised edges of the frame which provide a barrier around the sheet
preventing fluids from escaping on to the patient. This contributes to greater patient comfort.

Pre-Framed Dental Dams

a) Insti dam (Zirc)

It has an in-built flexible radiolucent nylon frame eliminating the need for a separate one.
It is made of translucent natural latex that is very stretchable, tear-resistant and provides easy
visibility. There is an off-center pre-punched hole which customizes fit to any quadrant
(Figure 3). More holes can be added if desired. Its compact design is just the right size to fit
outside the patient‘s lips. It has the following advantages.

 Built-in flexible frame which eliminates the use of separate frame.

 Pre-punched hole helps eliminate tearing.
 Radiographs may be taken by bending the frame without removing the dam.
 Minimal pull on clamp.
 Single-use and hence eliminates the need for sterilization.

Figure 3. Insti dam.

b) Handi dam (Aseptico)

It is a pre-framed rubber dam which eliminates the need for traditional frames (Figure 4).
It is quick and easy to place. It allows easy access to oral cavity during the root canal
procedure.

c) Dry dam
It is an alternative type of rubber dam which does not require a frame. It consists of a
small rubber sheet set in the center of an absorbent paper with light elastics on either side to
 Rubber dam in Endodontics- an Overview of Recent Advances 323

pass over the ears (Figure 5). It fits like a face mask with an absorbent lining to give patient
comfort and reduced risk of allergic reaction. It is available in medium and thin varieties. It is
useful for quickly isolating anterior teeth but it is not useful for isolation of posterior teeth. It
has an added disadvantage of not being useful in a bleaching procedure due to the absorbent
nature of the paper surrounding it.

d) Framed Flexi Dam (Coltène/Whaledent)

The Hygenic non-latex flexi dam is also available with an convenient, built-in-frame
(Figure 6). The flexible frame is designed with a convenient working size of 100 mm x 105
mm to ensure easy placement without limiting access. The dam has good tear resistance and
is latex allergy free and odorless. The smooth surface of the plastic frame helps to maximize
patient comfort when positioned against their skin.

Figure 4. Handi dam.

Figure 5. Dry dam.

Figure 6. Framed flexi dam.

e) Opti Dam (Kerr)

Opti Dam is the first rubber dam with 3-dimensional shape and nipple design (Figure 7).
The 3-dimensional shape of OptiDam and the anatomical frame shape match the contours of
the mouth. This allows greater access and improved visibility to the working area. This also
allows reduced tension resulting in easier rubber dam application and low risk of clamp
displacement. Opti Dam is available in two versions: anterior and posterior. Opti Dam
involves much less preparatory work than for conventional rubber dams. i.e. no marking of
324 Nidambur Vasudev Ballal, Deepika Khandelwal and Muliya Vidya Saraswathi

the tooth position because of outward oriented nipples and no hole-punching procedures as
the nipples are easily cut. It offers maximum patient comfort and allows them to breath with
no pressure around the nasal area.

Figure 7. Opti dam.

Figure 8. Optra dam.

f) Optra Dam (Ivoclar Vivadent, USA)

Optra dam represents the next generation of rubber dams, combining the benefits of a lip
and cheek retractor (Optra Gate), with the total isolation of a rubber dam (Figure 8). The
anatomical shape, high flexibility and patented inner-ring design allows it to be placed
without the need for clamps. Additionally, there is no need for a separate rubber dam frame
making it even more time and cost efficient. It is available in both regular and small sizes.
The soft flexible material allows patients to maintain full mobility of their jaw along with
added comfort throughout the procedure. It provides optimum isolation as well as it is
comfortable for the patient. Due to the enhanced flexibility of the plastic rings, it can be
placed more easily in the patient's mouth. Its anatomical shape helps to create a considerably
larger treatment field and complete isolation of both arches can be achieved at the same time.
 Rubber dam in Endodontics- an Overview of Recent Advances 325

Rubber Dam Clamps

a) Clamp with long guard extension

These clamps retract and protect the cheek and tongue along with isolation. They can be
used with gauze or cotton rolls just for the retraction of tongue and cheek. The larger wing of
the clamp is used for the retraction of the tongue (Figure 9).

Figure 9. Long guard extension clamp.

b) Tiger clamp
These are the clamps with serrated jaws (Figure 10). These serrations will increase the
stabilization of the clamp on the partially erupted or broken down teeth.

c) S-G (Silker-Glickman) clamp

This is a clamp with anterior extension which allows for retraction of the dam around a
severely broken-down tooth, and the clamp itself is placed on a tooth proximal to the one
being treated (Figure 11). It is made from durable cast stainless steel, which is autoclavable,
corrosion-resistant, flexible and long lasting. It is ideal clamp for molar isolation. Its extended
wings allows for rubber dam placement around the teeth with minimal tooth structure.

d) Super Clamp (Dent Corp Research and Development, NY, USA)

This new product facilitates the isolation of an individual tooth without covering the
patient‘s whole mouth and nose [9]. It protects the tongue and cheeks while helping the
patient and the dentist feel more comfortable. The tongue need not be protected with the
mouth mirror and hence it gives total security for treatment with the rotary instrument. The
device consists of a specially designed clamp with an added ―wing extension‖ to retract the
cheeks and the tongue (Figure 12).

Figure 10. Tiger clamp.

326 Nidambur Vasudev Ballal, Deepika Khandelwal and Muliya Vidya Saraswathi

Figure 11. Silker Glickman clamp.

This system comes with pre-cut rubber dam material designed to fit the clamp. It is very
simple to use, quick and easy to place. It allows for easy evacuation of oral fluids with a
saliva ejector or a high-volume evacuator, and also can be used without the rubber dam to
protect only the tongue and soft tissues. The clamp is made out of thin, flexible stainless steel.
It can be sterilized by autoclave, chemiclave or even dry heat. However, it has one
disadvantage that, it cannot be used for anterior teeth. It comes in three sizes: L- large clamp
for molars, M- medium clamp which can also be used for molars and S- small clamp which
can be used for premolars.

Figure 12. Super clamp.

e) Gold colored clamps

These clamps have diamond grit on their jaw to improve the retention of the clamp
(Figure 13).

Recent alternatives to Rubber Dam

1. Kool dam (Pulpdent Corporation)

It is a light cured material applied on the gingiva or tooth surfaces prior to power
bleaching, sand blasting or other procedures requiring intraoral protection or isolation. It is
also used to block out undercuts prior to taking impressions. Also called as liquid rubber dam
 Rubber dam in Endodontics- an Overview of Recent Advances 327

(Figure 14). Because of its low exothermic reaction, it eliminates burning and pain, thus
assuring patient comfort.

Figure 13. Gold colored clamp.

Figure 14. Kool dam.

It remains flexible after curing and has good tear resistance. It stacks on itself smoothly
and evenly and is easy to remove. It is moisture friendly and works well in the oral
environment and is a rubber dam substitute. A similar resin product called as OpalDam is
manufactured by Ultradent Incorporation. It has two disadvantages. Firstly, being resin based,
it produces heat when cured, and can thus cause discomfort or pain to the patient. Secondly,
some of these products tend to displace and not stay where they are placed.
328 Nidambur Vasudev Ballal, Deepika Khandelwal and Muliya Vidya Saraswathi

2. Fast dam
Anatomically-shaped fast dam is designed to provide a superior means of maintaining a
dry quadrant field (Figure 15). It can be used in place of cotton rolls to retract the cheek and
tongue while maintaining a dry field. Continuous aspiration is achieved by means of 17
suction holes along the perimeter, eliminating the need to change saturated cotton rolls while
retracting the cheek and tongue. Fast dam fits into the valve of all standard saliva ejectors.
Fast dam is also suitable when conventional rubber dam is too cumbersome.

Figure 15. Fast dam.

3. Isolite
The Isolite is a new dental device that simultaneously delivers continuous throat
protection, illumination, retraction and isolation (Figure 16). It has a unique soft, flexible
mouthpiece which isolates maxillary and mandibular quadrants simultaneously, retracts and
protects the soft tissues from accidental damage from high speed turbines, delivers shadow
less illumination and continuously aspirates fluids and prevents the aspiration of foreign
objects. It can be particularly useful in young people with incompletely erupted teeth. Using
Isolite, a core buildup during endodontic treatment can be done immediately by placing a
matrix or core-former, and thus completing the process in one step. This reduces the amount
of time and number of steps needed as compared to conventional rubber dam.

Figure 16. Isolite system.

 Rubber dam in Endodontics- an Overview of Recent Advances 329

A similar device, Isodry, is also available which performs the same function, but requires
external lighting. It has the following disadvantages: (a) It is significantly more expensive
than the rubber dam. (b) It does not provide the color contrast with the teeth that some
practitioners find helpful when using rubber dam. (c) It may cause damage to the gingiva,
since Isolite does not seal the gingiva from irrigants or intra canal medicaments.

Recent Accessory to Rubber Dam

1. Cushees
These are soft thermoplastic cashew shaped nodules which are grooved on their inner
surface and act as rubber dam clamp cushions (Figure 17). It is slipped over the tooth
attachment blade of clamp prior to clamp application. It increases patient comfort through
elimination of contact of steel clamp with gingiva or tooth enamel, and thus helps to protect
the natural tooth structure and costly restorations. It also enhances rubber dam seal to limit
leaking from above or below the dam and reduces clamp slippage. They are sterilizable and
reusable. It can be applied to one or both the jaws of rubber dam clamps. They are available
in two sizes: yellow for anterior and bicuspid clamps and blue for molar clamps.

Figure 17. Cushees.

Figure 18. Wedjets.

 330 Nidambur Vasudev Ballal, Deepika Khandelwal and Muliya Vidya Saraswathi

2. Wedjets (Hygenic)
These are stretchable elastic stabilizing cords made from natural latex rubber and used as
a rubber dam retainer (Figure 18). These are a faster and easier method of retaining the rubber
dam than using conventional clamps. It is placed like dental floss over the rubber dam in the
interproximal areas of the teeth, holding the rubber dam in position. It is available in extra
small, small and large sizes. It reduces patient trauma and discomfort caused by metal clamps.
They are especially used in the isolation of anterior teeth.

REFERENCES
[1] Elderton RJ. A modern approach to use of rubber dam. Dent. Pract. Dent. Record
1971;21:21, 187–193, 226–232, 267–273.
[2] Ahmad IA. Rubber dam usage for endodontic treatment: a review. Int. Endod. J.
2009;42:963-972.
[3] Glickman GM, Pettiette MT. Preparation for treatment. In: Cohen S, Hargreaves KM,
Keiser K, eds. Pathways of the Pulp, 9th edn. St. Louis, MO: Mosby, 2006, pp. 120-132.
[4] Ingle JI, Walton RE, Malamed SF et al. Preparation for endodontic treatment. In: Ingle
JI, Bakland LK, eds. Endodontics, 5th edn. Hamilton: BC Decker Inc, 2002, pp.
394-403.
[5] Cochran MA, Miller CH, Sheldrake MA. The efficacy of the rubber dam as a barrier to
the spread of microorganisms during dental treatment. J. Am. Dent. Assoc.
1989;119:141-144.
[6] Harrel SK, Molinari J. Aerosols and splatter in dentistry: a brief review of the literature
and infection control implications. J. Am. Dent. Assoc. 2004;135:429-437.
[7] Bhuva B, Chong BS, Patel S. Rubber dam in clinical practice. Endo: Endo Pract Today
2008;2:131-141.
[8] Sauveur G. Improvement of the rubber dam frame. J. Endod. 1997;23:765-767.
[9] de la Vega E. The Super Clamp- An innovative isolation barrier. Inside Dent 2008;4(1).
[10] Scardina, G.A. Editorial: Critical reading of a scientific article: Scientific validity
(2009) International Journal of Clinical Dentistry, 2 (4), pp. 205-206.

View publication stats