Level of Satisfaction of Grade 12 Studen

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 77

POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 1

Chapter 1

The Problem and Its Background

The K-12 program was implemented for Filipino graduates to adopt the education

standards that are needed worldwide. It was implemented through the Enhanced Basic

Education Act of 2013. This new curriculum lengthens our basic schooling adding 2 years

from 10-year basic education and started to introduce the Senior High School (Grade 11 and

12) which cover two years of specialized upper secondary education where students may

choose a specialization based on their aptitude and interests. Each student in Senior High

School can choose among four tracks namely: Academic; Technical-Vocational and

Livelihood; Arts and Design and Sports. The Academic track includes four strands namely as

Accountancy, Business, and Management (ABM); Humanities and Social Sciences (HUMSS);

and Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) and lastly, General

Academic Strand (GAS). The choice of career track will define the content of the subjects a

student will take in Grades 11 and 12 (Official Gazette, 2012). However, after 2 years of its

official operation some minor and major problem emerged. First, there are no sufficient

teachers, classrooms, facilities, laboratories, and other instructional and teaching materials

that will aid the technological-vocational track. Several schools double or even triple shifts in

classes to cover these problems due to the sudden increase of population of senior high

school students. Second, the over-congested curriculum also became a problem, the K-12

curriculum has total of 31 subjects required for senior high school, 15 of which were core

subjects and 16 which were the track subjects, then latter broken down into 7 contextualized
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 2

subjects and 9 specialization subjects and all in all each subject will have 80 hours per

semester only. The unforeseen problems through this implementation might affect the

satisfaction of the student’s academics or their interest in pursuing their desired course in

college.

The research was conducted at Central Colleges of the Philippines. Students in CCP

go through a core curriculum and specialized subjects under a track or strand of their choice.

CCP offers the four strands under academic track with almost 1,000 students for Grade 11

and 12.

Theoretical Framework

Several theories and study have been analyzed to understand the dimension that will

influence student’s satisfaction. First, Clemes (2008) also developed a three-factor theory with

different sub-factors which includes quality of the teaching staff, administrative staff, outcome

quality (learning assessment), and good physical environment. Fourth, is the Investment

model theory explaining the relationship between student satisfaction and academic

performance. Satisfaction increases when the rewards of study increase (higher grades).

When costs like financial and time constraints are lower and alternate options are low,

satisfaction was lower (Hatcher, Kryter, Prus, & Fitzgerald, 1992). Continuing learning

intention or a specific desire on the part of the learner to learn, is related to learning experience

and to the content and completion of a learning session. Zhou (2016) on her study of

“Empirical Study on University Curriculum Satisfaction of University Graduates” states that

curricula in universities should meet the needs of society and occupations. Curriculum settings

should depend on students’ abilities; Secondly, curriculum content should reflect the new
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 3

knowledge and technological innovations quickly. The curriculum content should reflect the

frontier dynamic and aim to meet students’ needs about the latest. It is necessary to increase

the interdisciplinary curricula and theories, which aims to broaden the students’ visions. At the

same time, the sharing of resources in different disciplines and institutions is also very

essential. Next is the customer satisfaction theory according to Kottler (2009), satisfaction is

a person’s feelings of pleasure or disappointment resulting from comparing a product

perceived performance or outcomes in relation to his or her expectations. It means if the

performance matches the expectation, the customer will be satisfied. Lastly is Gottfredson’s

theory (1981) of occupational aspirations are reflection of one’s self-concept, his theory

describes that students are attracted to certain specialization because of their self-concept or

how they perceived their selves in the future using interest, attitudes, and skills that are

strongly influenced by our shared environment (e.g. family, peers, school, and community).

However, continuing learning intentions to take up future learning are strongly and

consistently related to current or recent experiences of learning and student’s satisfaction.


POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 4

Conceptual Framework

The framework below gives researchers the paradigm on how the research work and

perceived in the study in the light of the above theories with corresponding application in this

study.

Figure 1. Dimensions that influences the student satisfaction

INPUT PROCESS OUTPUT

➢ Profile of the
respondents

Dimensions of Student’s satisfaction


student satisfaction Student assessment in their chosen track
➢ Teacher’s through questionnaire
Credibility
➢ Learning Facilities
➢ School
administration
➢ Learning
experience
➢ Curriculum
➢ Personal
satisfaction of
student

FEEDBACK
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 5

Statement of the Problem

This study sought to determine the Level of satisfaction of Grade 12 students of

Central Colleges of the Philippines and to determine if the following dimensions will affect their

choice of course in college aligned to their present strand. Specifically, it seeks to answer the

following questions:

1. What is the profile of the student-respondents in terms of:

1.1 Age;

1.2 Sex;

1.3 Religion;

1.4. City Address;

1.5. Parents Monthly Income;

1.6. Parents Educational Attainment;

1.7. Academic track and strand?

2. What is the level of satisfaction of Grade 12 students in terms of:

2.1 Teacher’s Credibility;

2.2 Learning Facilities;

2.3 School Administration;

2.4. Curriculum;

2.5. Learning Experiences;

2.6. Personal Satisfaction of the Students?

3. Is there a relationship between the academic track/strand of the students and their level

of satisfaction?
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 6

Hypothesis

This study aims to explore the Level of satisfaction of Grade 12 students in their

chosen Academic Track in Central Colleges of the Philippines and the null hypotheses to be

tested are:

1. There is no significant relationship between the profile of the student and their level of

satisfaction in terms of:

3.1. Teacher’s credibility;

3.2. Learning Facilities;

3.3. School administration;

3.4. Curriculum;

3.5. Learning Experiences;

3.6. Personal Satisfaction of the students.

Scope and Limitations

The study covers all the academic track/strand of Senior High School at Central

Colleges of the Philippines. The respondent of the study was composed of 267 students and

was conducted during the second semester of School year 2017-2018.


POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 7

Significance of the Study

This study sought to explore the Level of satisfaction of Grade 12 students in their

chosen academic track. This study will benefit the following:

Department of Education. This study will benefit not just the Higher education sectors

but also the Basic Education sector, they will gain knowledge about the effectiveness of the

K-12 curriculum being implemented in the Private sectors and how the present curriculum

affects student’s satisfaction.

Educational Institutions. The findings of this study will benefit the educational

institutions in the country by helping them to identify the problems in different aspects that

affects student satisfaction and help them to improve the quality of services they offered.

Teachers. This study will help the educator in identifying the factors that mostly affects

the student satisfaction specifically as to what the best learning experience they want that

strikes their interest the most inside the classroom.

Students. This study provides guidance to the incoming senior high school students

who will choose academic track/strand.

Future Researchers. This study will be an effective tool and reference for the future

researchers who would intend to make any further relevant study about student satisfaction

of senior high school students in their chosen track.


POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 8

Definitions of Terms

Academic Track. Choosing this track means the students are looking forward going

to college. This track will help the students prepare their selves for the subject specialization

of the college course they will take in the future. This track has four strands namely as ABM,

STEM, HUMSS, and GAS (Edukasyon.ph, 2017).

Credibility. According to Wikipedia (2018), credibility has two key components:

trustworthiness and expertise, which both have objective and subjective components.

Trustworthiness is based more on subjective factors but can include objective measurements

such as established reliability. Expertise can be similarly subjectively perceived, but also

includes relatively objective characteristics of the source or message (e.g., credentials,

certification or information quality). Secondary components of credibility include source

dynamism (charisma) and physical attractiveness.

Curriculum. According to Wikipedia (2018), curriculum is broadly defined as the

totality of student experiences that occur in the educational process. The term often refers

specifically to a planned sequence of instruction, or to a view of the student's experiences in

terms of the educator's or schools’ instructional goals.

Dimensions. According to Webster (2018) it is defined as the amount or number of

things that something affects or influences.

Learning Experience. Wikipedia (2018) refers to it as any interaction, curse, program,

or other experience in which learning takes place. It occurs whether in traditional academic

setting (schools, classrooms) or nontraditional settings (outside-of-school) locations.


POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 9

Facilities. Wikipedia (2018) state that facilities is an installation, contrivance, or other

things which facilitates something; a place for doing something

Satisfaction. Satisfaction is a feeling of happiness that obtain when a person fulfilled

his or her needs and desires. It is a state felt by a person who has experienced performance

or an outcome that fulfilled his or her expectations (Ilyas, M. & Arif, S., 2013, pp. 282-298).
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 10

Chapter 2

REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE

This chapter includes the review of the related literature and studies which the

researcher has examined to shed light on the topic under study.

Education is one of the key drivers of economic growth and student satisfaction is an

important component. As defined by Kotler (2017) satisfaction is the fulfillment of need or

desire, the pleasure obtained by a product’s perceived performances (outcomes) in relation

to his or her expectation. If the performance fails, the customer is not satisfied and when the

performance is good it will result to satisfaction. Below are the related literatures that describes

the dimensions used in this study.

The university is an educational as well as a service setting, where the service is often

produced and consumed simultaneously (Childers et al., 2014). One way that educational

institutions may consider enhancing service quality in the university is by considering how the

students’ connection to the university campus and their willingness to benefit from all the

services may influence their level of satisfaction. According to Chang and Fisher (2003) the

level of a student’s satisfaction in a lesson is a very important component for them to acquire

the knowledge or skill. A student can be satisfied if he feels that the lesson meets his needs

and expectations. This can motivate the student to put more efforts on learning, increase

his/her positive attitude towards the lesson, and to attend other courses in future (Gecer,

2013)
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 11

Personal Satisfaction of Students

According to Richard Herdlein, Emily Zurner (2015) in their article “Student

Satisfaction, Needs, and Learning Outcomes”, discussed that European universities in

general and the higher education system in Western Europe have paid little attention to

approaching student learning with an emphasis on activities that occur outside the classroom.

The idea of “holistic” education is more closely related to the American tradition that places

significant emphasis on “student learning and development” outside the classroom. Students

throughout the world spend find ways to spend their time outside of class in activities that

complement the formal academic curriculum as well as the mission and goals of the university.

Student unions, associations, clubs, and organizations have a long history of providing some

outlet for the student need to socialize, organize recreate, volunteer, and sometimes worship

together.

Maintaining and improving students’ satisfaction has been considered an important

goal of education and universities (Orpen, 1990), with the assumption that student satisfaction

is indicative of institutional effectiveness (Barton, 1978). A key factor of student satisfaction is

the quality of the teaching staff. As a result, the use of student rating scales as an evaluative

component of their teaching system has increased. The majority, if not all, teaching staff at

most universities have been required or expected to administer some type of teaching

evaluation form to their students during each course offering for some time (Seldin, 1993).

Mai (2005) studied the student satisfaction in higher education and its influential

factors. It was found that the overall impression of the school, overall impression of the quality

of the education, teacher’s expertise and their interest in their subject, the quality and

accessibility of IT facilities and prospects of the degree furthering students careers were the
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 12

most influential predictors of the student’s satisfaction. Similarly, Deshields et al. (2005) used

a satisfaction model and Herzberg’s two factor theory to examine the determinants of student

satisfaction with education. They found that faculty performance and classes were the key

factors which determined the quality of college experience of students which in turn led to

satisfaction. All this studies emphasis on certain factors of education offerings which

determines the students’ satisfaction with education and in turn loyalty to the institution.

Guise and Cote (2000) said that satisfaction is a summary, affective and variable

intensity response centered on specific aspects of acquisition and/ or consumption and which

takes place at the precise moment when the individual evaluates the objectives. In several

universities around the world, student satisfaction surveys are carried out yearly. The

revolving philosophy points to the belief that successful institutions have three basic attributes:

they focus on the needs of the students; they continually improve the quality of the educational

experience; and they use student satisfaction data to shape their future directions Mancao

(2005). Unlike other service industries, which hold satisfaction as a goal in and of itself,

colleges and universities typically perceive satisfaction as means to an end. Higher education

tends to care about student satisfaction because of its potential impact in student motivation,

retention, recruitment efforts and fund raising (Schreiner 2009).

According to Salinda Weerasinghe, R. Lalitha and S. Fernando in their journal entitled

“American Journal of Educational Research” (2017) Students’ satisfaction can be defined as

a short-term attitude resulting from an evaluation of students’ educational experience,

services and facilities. Earlier it was measured by common satisfaction frameworks, but later

higher education specifies satisfaction models were developed. The objective of this review

is to render all available constructive literature about students’ satisfaction with a sound

theoretical and empirical background. Data were collected from refereed journals and
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 13

conference papers and are constructively analyzed from different point of views to filter a

sound background for future studies. The first section of the paper discusses students’

satisfaction, satisfaction models and frameworks used by previous researchers around the

world and second section explain the empirical findings of previous studies in real world

context.

In the study proposed by Wiers-Jenssen (2002) he found out that quality of teaching

is an important dimension of student satisfaction while emphasizing the need to a good

physical environment and the quality of services from the school’s administrative staff, these

factors should not be overlooked when an institution is considering the impacts of student’s

satisfaction in their academic performance. Second, Elliot and Healy (2001) examined some

dimensions of a university student satisfaction, based on their study the consistent factors that

tend to emerge are the performance of the academic personnel that affect their learning

experiences and complete access to facilities and resources of the campus.

Teacher’s Credibility

According to the research study of John Hattie (2016), teacher credibility is vital to

learning, and students are very perceptive about knowing which teachers can make a

difference. There are four key factors of credibility: trust, competence, dynamism and

immediacy. There are four key dimensions that lead to credible teaching which provide a

useful framework and guide for teachers to master credibility. The first is trust. Teachers need

to show that they trust their pupils and genuinely care about their personal and academic

development. Teachers who show fairness and treat everyone in the same way will gain

respect and trust from their pupils.


POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 14

The next key dimension is competence. Students need confidence in the teacher’s ability

to deliver compelling and engaging information. Teachers who are organized and structured

when presenting a subject and answering questions will gain credibility. Next is dynamism;

teachers need to present material with energy and enthusiasm to engage their students. If

pupils can see that their teacher has genuine passion for a subject, they will instantly feel

more excited and engaged. Finally, immediacy is the other key dimension of credible teaching.

This examines ways that teachers can break down barriers between themselves and their

pupils by increasing eye contact, reducing the distance between teacher and students or

rearranging chairs into a circle. This will help students to feel part of a collective group and

will promote the idea that the teacher is on their side and committed to helping them learn.

According to the research study of Donna Fong-Yee and Anthony H. Normore of

Florida International University, USA, entitled “The Impact of Quality Teachers on Student

Achievement” (2013) Education leaders, policymakers and educators need to invest in critical

areas that impact the quality of teacher and the quality of teaching. While it is no secret that

better teachers produce better learning, educational reform must work toward restructuring

and reinventing teacher preparation and professional development by connecting clinical work

in schools with knowledge about what works for teaching and subject-matter knowledge. If we

are going to hold students to standards, we need to be able to ensure that the teachers who

work with them will also be able to teach to those standards. Teachers do matter, and their

cognitive ability and knowledge of the subject matter and of teaching and learning, licensure,

and teaching behaviors in the classroom are related to teacher quality. Major changes in the

areas of recruitment, preparation, licensing, teacher support and opportunities for professional

growth need to occur for teaching to improve, thus inevitably and positively affecting the most
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 15

important variable of all, the student. Based on the article, “Too many teachers teaching

outside their area of expertise”

The Conversation (2015) by Linda Hobbs “Out-of-field” teaching - teaching a subject

without specific training in that subject - has for many years been a taboo practice that all

teachers know of, many have experienced, but few have spoken up about due to its ubiquity.

Little attention had been given to the effects of out-of-field teaching on teacher well-being and

retention, and on student attainment and participation. Also neglected were the effects on

discipline leaders and mentors who devote time and energy to support the teachers, the

broader school culture and the teaching profession generally when teachers leave out of

stress and disenchantment. Despite no consistent relationship between student achievement

and teacher qualifications, research has shown that highly effective teachers have a deep

understanding of the subjects they teach. They value both the subject and students engaging

with the subject at a deep level.

Learning Facilities

According to Dr. Bruce Baker (2015) in his article “The importance of School Facilities

in Improving Student outcomes”, discussed that the school facilities can have a profound

impact on both teacher and student outcomes. With respect to teachers, school facilities affect

teacher recruitment, retention, commitment, and effort. With respect to students, school

facilities affect health, behavior, engagement learning, and growth in achievement. Thus,

researcher generally concludes that without adequate facilities and resources, it is extremely

difficult to serve large numbers of children with complex needs.

Scheneider (2002) states in his study “Do School Facilities Affect Academic

Outcomes?” that school facilities affect learning. Spatial configurations, noise, heat, cold,

light, and air quality obviously bear on students' and teachers' ability to perform. Empirical
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 16

studies will continue, focusing on fine-tuning the acceptable ranges of these variables for

optimal academic outcomes. But we already know what is needed: clean air, good light, and

a quiet, comfortable, and safe learning environment. This can be and generally has been

achieved within the limits of existing knowledge, technology, and materials. It simply requires

adequate funding and competent design, construction, and maintenance.

School Administration

Kamal and Ramzi (2002) looked at the administrative side of higher education by

measuring student perception of registration and academic / career advice across different

facilities and other administrative services to assure positive quality of courses and teaching

(Athiyaman, 1997; Cheng & Tam, 1997; Soutar and McNeil, 1996). However, Kamal and

Ramzi (2002) looked at the administrative side of higher education by measuring student

perception of registration and academic / career advice across different faculties and other

administrative services to assure positive quality service that compliments the academic

services.

Issues such as privatization and increased competition among higher learning

institutions are now common in most countries. Hill (1995), states that higher education is a

service industry and that service quality is a critical determinant of the success of higher

learning institutions (Landrum, Prybutok & Zhang, 2007).

To succeed in today’s competitive higher education sector, service quality is of

essence to any institution of higher learning (Sandhu & Bala, 2011). In view of this, higher

education institutions must assess the quality of their services since outstanding service

quality can provide them with competitive advantage (Albretch, 1991). If the higher education

institutions provide quality service which meet or exceed that expectations of their students,
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 17

their services will be evaluated as high-quality service and if not, the services will be judged

as poor (Zammuto et al, 1996)

According to Parasuraman, Zeithaml and Berry (1990), consumer perceptions of

service quality results from comparing expectations prior to receiving the service and the

actual experience of the service. In higher education institutions, perceived service quality can

be the product of evaluating several service encounters for a student and these could range

from encounters with administrative staff, to encounters with lecturers, librarian and security

staff. If an institution consistency provides services at a level that exceeds customer

expectations, the services will be evaluated as high quality but if the services fail to meet

customer expectations, the services will be judged as poor quality (Zammuto et al, 1996)

According to Schmoker (2006), School administrators must be visible, student and

teacher centered, and willing to tackle issues for which there are no easy answers. The shift

in educational leadership has gone from instructional leader to the more appropriate term of

“learning leader”. In the past, a principal or school administrator worked in isolation and was

predominantly concerned with personal autonomy and the top down approach. This type of

leadership practice will no longer work if schools are to create an effective environment for

student learning and achievement. Schmoker (2006) asserts that schools will not improve until

the building leader begins to work cooperatively with teachers.

Jurkowitsch, et al., developed a framework to assess students’ satisfaction and its

impact, in higher education. In this framework service performance, university performance,

relationships with student, university standing works as antecedents of satisfaction and

promotion works the successor. Later, Alves and Raposo developed a conceptual model to

assess students’ satisfaction in 2010. According to the model student’s satisfaction in higher

education is determined by institute’s image, student expectations, perceived technical


POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 18

quality, functional quality and perceived value. These influences can be identified directly or

indirectly through other variables. The model further illustrated student loyalty and word of

mouth as the main successors of satisfaction. When student satisfaction upsurges, he will

psychologically bind with university and its activities. That represent level of loyalty he or she

has. Consequences will be spread among friends, relatives, prospect students and interested

parties then and there as word of mouth. The main criticism for the model is that it has largely

ignored main functions of a university; teaching and learning in measuring satisfaction of

students but it has been developed adding two successors of satisfaction as loyalty and word

of mouth.

Learning Experiences

According to Zenawi Zerihun, Jos Beishuize, and Willem Van Os (2012) on their article

entitled “Student Learning Experience as Indicator of Teaching Quality” Learning is less likely

to occur because of what is presented by teachers. Rather, it is an activity that is accomplished

by students, of course with the guidance and facilitation from teachers. Students must be the

major players in creating meaning out of their experiences. Some studies emphasize that

student engagement in the learning process is more important for learning (e.g., Biggs 1999;

Chickering and Gamson 1987; Shuell 1986). In the same vein, the students’ engagement in

the process should be the focus of assessing the effectiveness of teaching. Considering this,

it may be difficult to evaluate teacher performance in terms of its impact on student learning if

the emphasis continues to be on the teacher’s behavior.

In Arbaugh’s (2000) opinion, learning satisfaction includes the individual’s feelings and

attitudes towards the education process and the perceived level of fulfillment connected to the

individual’s desire to learn, caused by the learning motivation (Chang and Chang, 2012).
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 19

Harvey, Locke and Morey (2002) describe learning satisfaction as the pleasure resulted from

student’s implication in the specific activities suggested by the curricular designs, activities

that lead to fulfilling the learning needs initially felt by the student. The same authors highlight

the fact that individuals have different learning needs, focusing on different learning activities

and obtaining, consequently, varying levels of learning satisfaction (Chang and Chang, 2012)

In the same note, Hoyt (1999) talks about the influence that students' satisfaction with

the academic experiences and with the providing institution has on retention in higher

education, while Astin (1993) addresses different aspects of students' undergraduate

experience, underlying the determined correlations of variables such as student involvement,

student-student interaction, student-faculty interaction, with over-all students' satisfaction.

Curriculum

According to Danilo Sarmiento and Ronald Orale (2016), The Philippines was the last

country in Asia having a 10-year basic education and pre-university program (SEAMEO &

INNOTECH, 2012). Worldwide, the Philippines were joined by Djibouti and Angola of Africa

having the shortest pre-university education system with other countries having 13 or 14-year

cycles (Senate of the Philippines, 2011). The 12 years or more is in accordance with

international practice as stipulated in the Washington Accord, Bologna Process as well as in

the ASEAN and APEC Mutual Recognition Projects and much more. The much-needed

overhaul of the Philippine basic education system becomes a reality through Republic Act

10533, also known as the Enhanced Basic Education Act which was passed last May 2013

making the pre-university and basic education from 10 to 13 years (Congress of the

Philippines, 2011).
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 20

The K to 12 Program covers Kindergarten and 12 years of basic education (six years

of primary education, four years of Junior High School, and two years of Senior High School

[SHS]) to provide sufficient time for mastery of concepts and skills, develop lifelong learners,

and prepare graduates for tertiary education, middle-level skills development, employment,

and entrepreneurship. (Official Gazette, 2013)

Curriculum settings should depend on students’ abilities; Secondly, curriculum

content should reflect the new knowledge and technological innovations quickly. The

curriculum content should reflect the frontier dynamic and aim to meet students’ needs about

the latest. It is necessary to increase the interdisciplinary curricula and theories, which aims

to broaden the students’ visions. At the same time, the sharing of resources in different

disciplines and institutions is also very essential.

Synthesis

To succeed in today’s competitive higher education sector, service quality is an

essence to any institution of higher learning (Sandhu & Bala, 2011). In view of this, higher

education institutions must assess the quality of their services since outstanding service

quality can provide them with competitive advantage. (Albretch, 1991). Student satisfaction

plays a vital role in assessing the quality of education and service that an institution has to

offer. Students must be the major players in creating meaning out of their learning

experiences. One way that educational institutions may consider enhancing service quality in

the university is by considering how the students’ connection to the university campus and

their willingness to benefit from all the services may influence their level of satisfaction.

According to Chang and Fisher (2003) the level of a student’s satisfaction in a lesson is a very

important component for them to acquire the knowledge or skill they will be needing. Based
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 21

on the literatures from above, several factors might affect student’s satisfaction. A key factor

of student satisfaction is the quality of the teaching staff. As a result, the use of student rating

scales as an evaluative component of their teaching system has increased. The majority, if

not all, teaching staff at most universities have been required or expected to administer some

type of teaching evaluation form to their students during each course offering for some time

(Seldin, 1993). According to John Hattie (2016) There are four key dimensions that lead to

credible teaching which provide a useful framework and guide for teachers to master

credibility. Major changes in the areas of recruitment, preparation, licensing, teacher support

and opportunities for professional growth need to occur for teaching to improve, thus inevitably

and positively affecting the most important variable of all, the student. Based on the article,

“Too many teachers teaching outside their area of expertise”. Next, learning facilities has a

great impact in student’s engagement, Scheneider (2002) states in his study “Do School

Facilities Affect Academic Outcomes?” that school facilities affect learning. Spatial

configurations, noise, heat, cold, light, and air quality obviously bear on students' and

teachers' ability to perform. Then, issues such as privatization and increased competition

among higher learning institutions are now common in most countries. Hill (1995), states that

higher education is a service industry and that service quality is a critical determinant of the

success of higher learning institutions (Landrum, Prybutok & Zhang, 2007). The school

administration also affects student’s satisfaction, according to Schmoker (2006) these

administrators must be student and teacher centered and willing to tackle issues which there

are no easy answers. Then, learning experiences of the student must be regularly assess.

According to Zenawi Zerihun, Jos Beishuize, and Willem Van Os (2012) on their article

entitled “Student Learning Experience as Indicator of Teaching Quality”. Learning is less likely

to occur because of what is presented by teachers. Teaching and learning process must be
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 22

meaningful so that the students will not just enjoy learning, but they will also experience

fulfillment as indicator of effective learning experience. Lastly, the curriculum should be

aligned to what they society is needing. Philippines was the last country to adopt the present

K to 12 curricula. The K to 12 Program covers Kindergarten and 12 years of basic education

(six years of primary education, four years of Junior High School, and two years of Senior

High School [SHS]) to provide sufficient time for mastery of concepts and skills, develop

lifelong learners, and prepare graduates for tertiary education, middle-level skills

development, employment, and entrepreneurship. (Official Gazette, 2013) Curriculum

settings should depend on students’ abilities; Secondly, curriculum content should reflect the

new knowledge and technological innovations quickly. The curriculum content should reflect

the frontier dynamic and aim to meet students’ needs about the latest. It is necessary to

increase the interdisciplinary curricula and theories, which aims to broaden the students’

visions. At the same time, the sharing of resources in different disciplines and institutions is

also very essential. It also has a vital role in the personal growth and development of the

students. it talks about the importance of personal satisfaction that can directly affects the

level of satisfaction in their chosen track.


POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 23

Chapter 3

METHODOLOGY

This chapter discussed the design and procedures undertaken during the conduct of

this study. It presented the research design used, population, sample size, and sampling

technique. Instruments use and statistical treatment of the data.

Research Design

Burns and Grove (2003) defines research as a “blueprint for conducting a study with

maximum control over factors that may interfere with the validity of the results”. To identify the

dimensions that affects the degree of satisfaction of senior high school students in their

chosen academic track the researcher used the descriptive research approach. It is designed

to depict the participants in an accurate way. This study utilized a survey method wherein the

participants answer the questions and the researchers describe the responses given.

(Jackson, 2009)

Population, Sample Size, and Sampling Technique

This study used the Simple Stratified Random Sampling in determining the samples

of the study which is 267 from the total population of 850 Grade 12 students in CCP that took
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 24

academic track under ABM, HUMSS, STEM, and GAS, with 95% level of significance and 5%

margin of error.

Description of the Respondents

The researchers choose the Grade 12 Students of Central Colleges of the Philippines

who enrolled in the following strand: Accountancy, Business, and Management (ABM),

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM), Humanities and Social

Sciences (HUMSS), and General academic strand (GAS) under the academic track for S.Y.

2017-2018.

Research Instrument

The researchers used survey questionnaire in data gathering. In determining the level

of satisfaction of Grade 12 students they used the Likert Scale wherein the study used 4-point

scale and each point corresponds to a Likert item. There were two sets of questionnaires, the

first set is the student-respondent profile and the respondents were asked “Will you enroll in

college aligned to your track?” wherein they can answer “YES, NO, and MAYBE”, Then, the

second set has 6 major parts includes 8 items per each dimensions were they asked to

encircle the four-point Likert scale, wherein “4-highly satisfied”, “3-satisfied”, “2-moderately

satisfied”, and “1-dissatisfied” to indicate the effect of each dimensions that has an impact in

their satisfaction. Lastly,


POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 25

Data Gathering Procedure

First, the researcher creates a self-made questionnaire that is suited to the statement

of the problem. Then, the test was validated by the 2 professors and 1 research adviser in

PUP. A week after, the researchers seek the approval of the Principal and the Head of Senior

High School in Central Colleges of the Philippines to conduct the survey in their institution.

Then, the researchers personally administered the research and all the instrumentalities

needed by the study that was given to the respondents. They conferred and discussed the

significance of the study and accomplish the distribution of the instruments properly. The

respondents were given 10-15 minutes to accomplish the survey form to give them sufficient

time to think properly to answer what was being asked in the questionnaire. Then, when 267

questionnaires were already gathered, the researchers tallied the answer using excel and the

data was analyzed through frequency distribution, weighted mean, and matrix in getting a chi

square.

Statistical treatment of the data

The following statistical treatments were used in the study.

Slovin’s Formula is used to calculate the sample size (n) given the population size

(N) and a margin of error.

n = N / (1 + Ne2)

Where:

n = Number of samples
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 26

N = Total

e = Error of tolerance

Frequency Distribution. a tabular arrangement of data, where by the data is grouped

into different intervals and then, the number of observations that belong to each interval is

determined.

Where:

P= Percentage

F= Frequency

N= Total No. of Respondents

Weighted Mean. like an arithmetic mean (the most common type of average); where

instead of each of the data points contributing equally to the final average, some data points

contribute more than other.

X =∑fixi/∑fi

Where:

X = weighted mean
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 27

Chi-Square. a measurement of how expectations compare to results. The data used

in calculating a chi square statistic must be random, raw, mutually exclusive, drawn from

independent variables and be drawn from a large enough sample.

χ2
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 28

Chapter 4

Presentation, Analysis, and Interpretation of Data

This chapter presents the data gathered, interpretations and analysis. The data

gathered were presented through tables. Interpretations and analysis were given for better

understanding of the readers.

Profile of the respondents

Table 1

Frequency and Percentage Distribution of

Student-Respondents in terms of Age

Age Frequency Percentage (%)

Below 15 years old 8 3.00

15 - 20 years old 259 97.00

Total 267 100.00

The table 1 depicts the frequency and percentage distribution of the respondents when

grouped according to age, below 15 years old are 8 students with the percentage of 3% who

respond to the survey while 15-20 years old are 259 students or 97% dominated the survey
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 29

Table 2

Frequency and Percentage Distribution of

Student-Respondents in terms of Sex

Sex Frequency Percentage (%)

Male 87 32.58

Female 180 67.42

Total 267 100.00

Table 2 depicts the frequency distribution and percentage of the respondents when

group according to gender. The male respondents are 87 or 32.58% of the respondents while

180 or 62.42% of our respondents are female.

Table 3

Frequency and Percentage Distribution of

Student-Respondents in terms of Religion

Religion Frequency Percentage (%)

Catholic 218 81.65

Christian 39 14.61

Iglesia Ni Cristo 4 1.50

None 1 0.37

No Response 5 1.87

Total 267 100.00


POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 30

Table 3 depicts the frequency and percentage distribution of the respondents when

group according to religion. From the table, 267 respondents were given questionnaire. Out

of 267 respondents, 218 respondents are Catholic which represented 81.65% of the

respondents, 39 or 14.61% of respondents are Christian, 4 or 1.50% of the respondents are

Iglesia ni Cristo, 1 or 0.37% of the respondents has none religion, and 5 or 1.87% of the

respondents did not responded to this item. This implies that, majority of the respondents are

Catholic.

Table 4

Frequency and Percentage Distribution of

Student-Respondents in terms of City Address

City Address Frequency Percentage (%)

Manila 82 30.71

Quezon City 138 51.69

Pasig 22 8.24

Rizal area 15 5.62

Outside metro manila 7 2.62

No Response 3 1.12

Total 267 100.00

Table 4 depicts the frequency and percentage distribution of the respondents when

group according to city address. From the table, out of 267 respondents, 82 respondents are

residing in Manila which represented 30.71% of the respondents, 138 or 51.69% of the

respondents are residing in Quezon City, 22 or 8.24% of the respondents are residing in Pasig

City, 15 or 5.62% of the respondents are residing in Rizal area, 7 or 2.62% of the respondents
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 31

are residing outside Metro Manila, and 3 or 1.12% of the respondents did not responded to

this item. This implies that, most of the respondents are residing in Quezon City.

Table 5

Frequency and Percentage Distribution of

Student-Respondents in terms of Household Estimated Monthly Income

Monthly Income Frequency Percentage (%)

Below 10,000 81 30.34

10,001 to 20,000 124 46.44

20,001 to 30,000 36 13.48

40,001 to 50,000 15 5.62

100,001 and Above 10 3.75

No Response 1 0.37

Total 267 100.00

Table 5 depicts the frequency distribution and percentage of the respondents when

group according to the parent’s monthly income. There are 81 students or 30.34% of their

parent’s monthly income is below 10,000 while there are 46.44% or 124 students have 10,001

to 20,000 as their parent’s monthly income. As students with their parent’s monthly income of

20,001 to 30,000 represented 36 students or 13.48%. Next were the students with 40,001 to

50,000 as their parent’s monthly income is 15 students or 5.62%. Those students who are

their parent’s monthly income are 100,001 and above represented 10 students or 3.75% and

lastly 1 or 0.37 student did not respond to this item. It is evident from Table 1.5 that the

maximum numbers of respondents are having their parent’s monthly income of 10,001 to

20,000.
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 32

Table 6

Frequency and Percentage Distribution of

Student-Respondents in terms of Parent’s Highest Educational Attainment

Parent's Highest Educational


Frequency Percentage (%)
Attainment

Elementary level 6 2.25

Elementary Graduate 4 1.50

High school level 32 11.99

Highs school Graduated 80 29.96

College level 60 22.47

College Graduate 79 29.59

With Master’s unit 3 1.12

Table 6 depicts the frequency distribution and percentage of the respondents when

group according to the parent’s educational attainment. There are 6 students or 2.25% of our

respondents that parent’s highest educational attainments were elementary level, while 1.5%

or 4 students have parents that are elementary graduate as their highest educational

attainment. As students with parents that reach high school level and high school graduates

are 32 students or 11.99% and 80 students or 29.96% respectively. Next were students with

parents that reach College level and are college graduates are 60 or 22.47% and 79 or

29.59% respectively. And lastly, there are 3 students or 1.12% of the respondents that parents

with Mater’s unit and this figure was the same as to those students with parents that are

master’s Degree holder.


POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 33

Table 7

Frequency and Percentage Distribution of

Student-Respondents in terms of Strand

Strand Frequency Percentage (%)

Accountancy, Business, and


133 49.81
Management (ABM) strand

Science, Technology,

Engineering, and 89 33.33

Mathematics (STEM) strand

Humanities and Social


29 10.86
Sciences (HUMSS) strand

General Academic Strand


16 5.99
(GAS)

Total 267 100.00

Table 7 depicts the frequency and percentage distribution of the respondents when

group according to academic strand. It depicts that out of the total respondents of 267, one

hundred thirty-three (133) of the students representing Accountancy, Business, and

Management (ABM) strand which represented (49.81%) of the total respondents, followed by

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) strand with eighty-nine (89)

students representing (33.33%) of the total respondents, twenty-nine (29) students are under

Humanities and Social Sciences (HUMSS) strand representing (10.86%) of the total

respondents, 16 students representing General Academic Strand (GAS) strand which


POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 34

represented (5.99%) of the total respondents. This clearly indicates that majority of the

respondent’s falls under ABM and STEM academic strands than HUMSS and GAS strands.

Level of satisfaction of Grade 12 Students

Table 8

Level of student satisfaction in terms of Teacher’s Credibility

Weighted Verbal
TEACHER'S CREDIBILITY
Mean Interpretation

1. The teacher has the expertise on the subject


he/she teaches 3.54 Highly Satisfied

2. The teacher always gives timely feedback on


assignments either in a form of a grade, written 3.30 Satisfied
comments or verbal response

3. The homework assignments are relevant to what


we are doing in class 3.40 Satisfied

4. The teacher uses different instructional materials in


teaching 3.37 Satisfied

5. The teacher teaches based on his/her field of


specialization 3.45 Satisfied

6. The teacher practices his/her profession ethically 3.42 Satisfied


7. The teacher treats student's fairly 3.04 Satisfied
8. The teachers are approachable, and I can talk to
them outside the class 3.43 Satisfied

Table 8 depicts the average response of the senior high school students in their level

of satisfaction in terms of teacher’s credibility. First, the study reveals that grade 12 students
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 35

are “highly satisfied” in the expertise of their teacher on the subject s/he teaches (3.54), the

students are “satisfied” in the following aspects: the teacher who always gives timely feedback

on assignment either in a form of a grade, written comment, or verbal response (3.30), the

homework are relevant to what they learn in class (3.40), the teacher who use different

instructional materials in teaching (3.37), the teacher who teaches their field of specialization

(3.35), the teacher who treats their students fairly (3.04), and the teachers who are

approachable even outside their class hours (3.34). with the overall weighted mean of 2.96

means they are “satisfied”. According to the research study of John Hattie (2016), teacher’s

credibility is vital to learning, and students are very perceptive about knowing which teachers

can make a difference. There are four key factors of credibility: trust, competence, dynamism

and immediacy. One of its factor is trust, the teacher should show that they trust their students

and genuinely care about their personal and academic development and mostly treat their

students fairly. Then competence, students need confidence in the teacher’s ability to deliver

compelling and engaging information.


POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 36

Table 9

Level of student satisfaction in terms of learning facilities

Weighted Verbal
LEARNING FACILITIES
Mean Interpretation

1. The library has complete references 2.99 Satisfied


2. The computers and internet are functioning
properly 2.88 Satisfied

3. The students can access freely the internet for


doing assignments and other academic related 3.01 Satisfied
activities

4. The classrooms are clean, well ventilated and


conducive in learning 3.08 Satisfied

5. The supplies available in the school bookstore


are complete 2.75 Satisfied

6. The students have access in the audio/visual


room 2.84 Satisfied

7. The audio-visual equipment’s are in good


conditions 2.97 Satisfied

8. The classroom arrangements are well organized 3.17 Satisfied

Table 9 depicts the entire response of the senior high school students in terms of

learning facilities. They are “satisfied” in items 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8 aspects. These are the

library that has a complete reference (2.99), the computers and internet are working properly

(2.88), students can access freely the internet for research purposes (3.01), the classroom

are clean, well-ventilated and conducive for learning (3.08), the supplies are available in the
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 37

school bookstore (2.84), students have access in the audio/visual room (2.84), the audio-

visual room equipment’s are in good condition (2.97), and the classroom arrangements are

well organized (3.17). with the overall weighted mean of 2.96 means they are overall

“satisfied”. According to Dr. Bruce Baker (2015) in his article “The importance of School

Facilities in Improving Student outcomes”, discussed that the school facilities can have a

profound impact on both teacher and student outcomes. With respect to teachers, school

facilities affect teacher recruitment, retention, commitment, and effort. With respect to

students, school facilities affect health, behavior, engagement learning, and growth in

achievement. Thus, researcher generally concludes that without adequate facilities and

resources, it is extremely difficult to serve large numbers of children with complex needs.
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 38

Table 10

Level of student satisfaction in terms of school administration

Weighted Verbal
SCHOOL ADMINISTRATION
Mean Interpretation

1. The school has enough administrative staffs that


assist students during enrollment 3.25 Satisfied

2. The administrative office is open during


convenient hours 3.20 Satisfied

3. The library staffs are helpful and approachable 3.12 Satisfied

4. The clinical staffs are accommodating and


helpful 2.87 Satisfied

5. The counseling staff cares about the students as


individuals 3.30 Satisfied

6. The office of student affairs and their services


response well in the students’ needs and 3.06 Satisfied
requests

7. The restrooms and canteens are tidy and enough


to accommodate the whole population of the 2.95 Satisfied
students

8. The appropriate security measures in school are


properly implemented 3.16 Satisfied

The table 10 depicts that students are overall “satisfied” with the school administration

in CCP, these involves the school has enough administrative staffs that assists them during

enrollment (3.25), the administrative offices is open during convenient time (3.20), library
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 39

staffs ae helpful and approachable (3.12), clinic staffs are accommodating and helpful (2.87),

the counseling staff cares about the students as individual (3.30), the service of the office of

student affairs are responsive to the students need (3.06), the restrooms and canteens are

tidy and enough to accommodate the whole populations of the students (2.95), and the

appropriate security measures in school are properly implemented (3.16). with the overall

weighted mean of 3.16 means they are overall “satisfied”. To succeed in today’s competitive

higher education sector, service quality is an essence to any institution of higher learning

(Sandhu & Bala, 2011). In view of this, higher education institutions must assess the quality

of their services since outstanding service quality can provide them with competitive

advantage. (Albretch, 1991).


POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 40

Table 11

Level of student satisfaction in terms of learning experiences

Weighted Verbal
LEARNING EXPERIENCES
Mean Interpretation

1. The university arranges seminar for students as


part of their learning 3.36 Satisfied

2. The teacher provides different collaborative


activities 3.36 Satisfied

3. The instructions are given by the teacher in a


manner that enlightens rather than confuse 3.25 Satisfied
students

4. The level/difficulty of subject content is


appropriate for my chosen track 3.27 Satisfied

5. The class requirements are clear and reasonable 3.14 Satisfied

6. The students can share ideas during class


discussion 3.32 Satisfied

7. The students can experience intellectual growth 3.40 Satisfied

8. The practical learning period helps students


improve their learning achievement 3.32 Satisfied

Table 11 depicts the students respond when regards to their learning experiences are

“satisfied” with overall weighted mean of 3.30, they are satisfied in terms of the university

arranges seminar for them as part of their learning (3.36), the teacher provides different

collaborative works (3.36), the instructions are given in a manner that enlightens them rather
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 41

confuse the students (3.25), the level or difficulty of subject content is appropriate for their

chosen track/strand (3.27), the class requirements are clear and reasonable (3.14), the

students have the opportunity to share their ideas during class discussion (3.32), the students

are able to experience intellectual growth (3.40), and the practical learning period helps

students improve their learning achievement (3.32). Students must be the major players in

creating meaning out of their experiences. Some studies emphasize that student engagement

in the learning process is more important for learning (e.g., Biggs 1999; Chickering and

Gamson 1987; Shuell 1986). the students’ engagement in the process should be the focus

of assessing the effectiveness of teaching. Considering this, it may be difficult to evaluate

teacher performance in terms of its impact on student learning if the emphasis continues to

be on the teacher’s behavior.


POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 42

Table 12

Level of satisfaction of students in terms of curriculum

Weighted Verbal
CURRICULUM
Mean Interpretation

1. The subjects offered are aligned to my chosen


academic track 3.45 Satisfied

2. The teacher provides the course guide of the


subject 3.39 Satisfied

3. The teacher uses the community as a learning


facility 3.39 Satisfied

4. The teacher does team teaching to bring about


effective learning process 3.36 Satisfied

5. The teacher designs project based on learning


situations for active learning participations 3.34 Satisfied

6. The teacher integrates learner nature and interest


in the subject matter 3.31 Satisfied

7. The school provides training based on our chosen


academic track 3.28 Satisfied

8. The school exposes the students to the


community through excursion/field trip at least 3.08 Satisfied
once in a school year

Table 12 depicts the average response of the senior high school students in their level

of satisfaction in terms of the curriculum, the student response as “satisfied” in the following

aspects: the subjects offered are aligned to their track (3.45), the teacher provides the course
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 43

guide of the subject (3.39), the teacher provides the course guide of the subject (3.39), the

teacher uses the community as a learning facility (3.39), the teacher bring about effective

learning process (3.36), the teacher designs project based on learning situations for active

learning (3.34), the teacher integrates learner nature and interest in the subject matter (3.31),

the school provides training based on their chosen track (3.38), and the school exposes the

students to the community through excursion at least once a year (3.08). with regards to the

overall satisfaction of students they respond as “satisfied” with an overall weighted mean of

3.32. Zhou (2016) on her study of “Empirical Study on University Curriculum Satisfaction of

University Graduates” states that curricula in universities should meet the needs of society

and occupations”. Curriculum settings should depend on students’ abilities; Secondly,

curriculum content should reflect the new knowledge and technological innovations quickly.

The curriculum content should reflect the frontier dynamic and aim to meet students’ needs

about the latest. It is necessary to increase the interdisciplinary curricula and theories, which

aims to broaden the students’ visions. At the same time, the sharing of resources in different

disciplines and institutions is also very essential. (Zhou, 2016)


POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 44

Table 13

Personal satisfaction of students

Weighted Verbal
PERSONAL SATISFACTION OF STUDENTS
Mean Interpretation

1. I am encouraged to perform well in class by my


teachers 3.27 Satisfied

2. I perform well in class because I really like my


chosen track 3.30 Satisfied

3. I get high grades in my subjects 3.19 Satisfied

4. I can see that there is a good relationship between


the teachers and students 3.28 Satisfied

5. I am competent that I have gained sufficient


knowledge in my preferred track that helps me to 3.32 Satisfied
be equipped in my college study

6. I don’t feel any regret regarding my decision in


choosing my academic track 3.36 Satisfied

7. I look forward to the next class meetings 3.17 Satisfied

8. I have a plan of enrolling a course in college that


is aligned with my chosen track in Senior High 3.35 Satisfied
School

Table 13 depicts the overall response of the students with regards to their personal

satisfaction, they respond as “satisfied” with the following: I am encourage to perform well in

their class by their teachers (3.27), I perform well in class because I really like my chosen
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 45

track/strand (3.30), I get higher grades in their subjects (3.19), there is a good relationship

between the teachers and students inside the campus (3.28), I am competent that I have

gained sufficient knowledge in my preferred track that helps me to be equipped in my college

study (3.32), I don’t feel any regrets regarding my decision in choosing my academic track

(3.36), I look forward to the next class meeting (3.17), and I have plan of enrolling a course in

college aligned with my chosen track (3.28). the student’s overall response is “satisfied” based

on their self-assessment of their personal satisfaction with the overall weighted mean of 3.28.

Mai (2005) studied the student satisfaction in higher education and its influential factors. It

was found that the overall impression of the school, overall impression of the quality of the

education, teacher’s expertise and their interest in their subject, the quality and accessibility

of facilities and prospects of the degree furthering students careers were the most influential

predictors of the student’s satisfaction.

Relationship between senior high school student’s chosen academic

track/strand and their level of satisfaction in terms of:

Table 14

Teacher’s Credibility

Will you enroll in College


Teacher’s Credibility aligned to your track? Total
Yes No Maybe
Moderately Satisfied 8 0 5 13
Satisfied 105 12 32 149
Highly Satisfied 72 12 21 105
Overall 185 24 58 267
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 46

Based on the data that the researchers have analyze, 267 respondents were asked

the question, “Will you enroll in college aligned to your track?” the overall total of 185 out of

267 respondents said that “YES” they will continue their strand in college, while 24 said “NO”

and 58 students are undecided and said “MAYBE”. Teacher’s credibility plays a major role in

the overall satisfaction of the students. According to the research study of Donna Fong-Yee

and Anthony H. Normore of Florida International University, USA, entitled “The Impact of

Quality Teachers on Student Achievement” (2013) Education leaders, policymakers and

educators need to invest in critical areas that impact the quality of teacher and the quality of

teaching. While it is no secret that better teachers produce better learning, educational reform

must work toward restructuring and reinventing teacher preparation and professional

development by connecting clinical work in schools with knowledge about what works for

teaching and subject-matter knowledge. If we are going to teach students the standards, we

need to be able to ensure that the teachers who work with them will also be able to teach to

those standards, this literature explains even students are satisfied with their teacher’s

expertise and credibility some of them find areas of weak points. Based on the article, “Too

many teachers teaching outside their area of expertise”. The Conversation (2015) by Linda

Hobbs “Out-of-field” teaching - teaching a subject without specific training in that subject - has

for many years been offensive practice that all teachers know of, many have experienced, but

few have spoken up about due to its ubiquity. Little attention had been given to the effects of

out-of-field teaching on teacher well-being and retention, and on student attainment and

participation.
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 47

Table 15

Learning Facilities

Will you enroll in College


Learning Facilities aligned to your track? Total
Yes No Maybe
Dissatisfied 1 0 1 2
Moderately Satisfied 50 4 16 70
Satisfied 111 11 31 153
Highly Satisfied 23 9 10 42
Overall 185 24 58 267

Based on table 15, it depicts that with regards to learning facilities out of 267

respondents, 185 answered YES and 24 answered NO and 58 of them are undecided. It is

evident from the table above that most of the respondents are satisfied to the learning facilities

that CCP has. Through a comprehensive review of Schneider (2002) in his study, “Do School

Facilities Affect Academic Outcomes?” he concluded that “School facilities affect learning.

These might include spatial configurations such as noise, heat, cold, light, and air quality. This

factors obviously bear on student’s ability to perform well.”

Table 16

School Administration

Will you enroll in College


School aligned to your track? Total
Administration
Yes No Maybe
Dissatisfied 1 0 0 1
Moderately Satisfied 29 2 17 48
Satisfied 121 10 31 162
Highly Satisfied 34 12 10 56
Overall 185 24 58 267
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 48

Table 16 indicates that out of 267 respondents that was asked whether they will

continue to enroll in College that was aligned on their chosen track, a total of 185 students

agree and said Yes while 24 of them answered No and the rest of them comprised of 58

students remain undecided and answered Maybe. It also depicts that out of the 185 who

respond that they will continue to enroll in college aligned to their chosen track 72 students

are Highly Satisfied, 8 respondents said that they are Moderately Satisfied and 105 says that

they were Satisfied in terms of School Administration.

Table 17

Curriculum

Will you enroll in College


Curriculum aligned to your track? Total
Yes No Maybe
Moderately Satisfied 11 1 6 18
Satisfied 111 11 40 162
Highly Satisfied 63 12 12 87
Overall 185 24 58 267

Based on the data gathered by the researchers, 267 respondents were asked “Will

you enroll in college aligned to your track?” Out of 267 respondents, 185 respondents

answered “YES” they will continue their track in college, 24 respondents answered “NO” they

will not continue their track in college, and 58 respondents are undecided, and they answered

“MAYBE”. The table above depicts that most of the respondents are satisfied to the curriculum

given from their respective strand and they are going to enroll in college aligned to their

chosen track. As cited by Calderon (2014) she describes the present curriculum as congested.

This means that the student’s do not get enough time to perform tasks because the curriculum
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 49

is designed to be taught in the span of 12 years not 10 years. The most obvious results of this

is that high school student will graduate without the readiness to take upon higher education

or employment. She states that these students are not fully equipped with the basic skills and

competencies needed in work.

Table 18

Learning Experiences

Will you enroll in College


Learning aligned to your track? Total
Experiences
Yes No Maybe
Dissatisfied 1 0 0 1
Moderately Satisfied 10 1 9 20
Satisfied 109 9 33 151
Highly Satisfied 65 14 16 95
Overall 185 24 58 267

267 respondents were asked “Will you enroll in college aligned to your track?” and

based on the survey result, 185 respondents answered “YES”, they will enroll their track in

college, while 24 respondents answered “NO”, they will not enroll their track in college, and

58 respondents answered “MAYBE” or undecided. Table 17 depicts that most of the

respondents are satisfied to the learning experiences in their chosen academic track and they

are going to enroll in college with a course aligned to their track. Learning experiences plays

an important role in the satisfaction of the students. Harvey, Locke and Morey (2002) describe

learning satisfaction as the pleasure resulted from student’s implication in the specific

activities suggested by the curricular designs, activities that lead to fulfilling the learning needs

initially felt by the student. The same authors highlight the fact that individuals have different
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 50

learning needs, focusing on different learning activities and obtaining, consequently, varying

levels of learning satisfaction (Chang and Chang, 2012)

Table 19

Personal Satisfaction of the Students

Will you enroll in College


Personal Satisfaction aligned to your track? Total
of the students
Yes No Maybe
Dissatisfied 1 0 0 1
Moderately Satisfied 12 1 8 21
Satisfied 109 13 38 160
Highly Satisfied 63 10 12 85
Overall 185 24 58 267

Personal satisfaction of the students is one of the most important factors in assessing

their level of satisfaction. Based on the survey result analyzed by the researchers, 185 out of

267 respondents said that “YES” they will enroll their track in college while 24 respondents

answered “NO”, they will not enroll their track in college, and 58 respondents answered

“MAYBE” or undecided. Table 18 indicates that most of the students are satisfied in terms of

their personal satisfactions towards their chosen track and because of this, they will pursue

to enroll a course in college which is aligned to their track. Mai (2005) studied the student

satisfaction in higher education and its influential factors. It was found that the overall

impression of the school, overall impression of the quality of the education, teacher’s expertise

and their interest in their subject, the quality and accessibility of facilities and prospects of the

degree furthering students careers were the most influential predictors of the student’s

satisfaction.
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 51

CHAPTER 5

Summary of Findings, Conclusions, and Recommendations

This chapter presents the summary of findings, conclusions and recommendations

about the gathered information of the study.

Summary of Findings

This study was conducted to identify the level of satisfaction of Grade 12 students in

their chosen academic track in terms of: Teacher’s credibility, learning facilities, school

administration, curriculum, learning experiences, and personal satisfaction of students. After

determining the degree of their satisfaction, another purpose of this study is to determine if

the students will enroll a course in college aligned in their track based on the abovementioned

dimensions.

To gather the data relevant to this study, a survey was conducted by the researchers.

A self-made questionnaire which was validated by the 3 professors from College of Education

and Graduate School. The survey was conducted at Central Colleges of the Philippines,

Senior High School department during School year 2017-2018.

The following findings were accumulated by the researchers based in the respondent’s

answers:

According to the profile of the respondents, 97% or 259 students were ages 15-20

years old and 3% or 8 students were below 15 years old who participated in the survey.
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 52

32.58% were male while 67.42& were female. With regards to the student’s religion, out of

267 respondents, 218 said that they are Catholic which is 81.65%, 39 were Christian or

14.61% of the respondents, 4 or 1.50% of the respondents are INC. then, 5 or 0.37% has no

response, and 1 or 0.37% of the respondents has no religion. Based on the respondent’s city

address, 51.69% are from Quezon City area, 30.71% are from Manila area, 8.24 are from

Pasig city, 5.62% are from Rizal, and 2.62 are from outside Metro Manila. With regards to the

respondent’s estimated monthly income there are 81 students or 30.34% of their parent’s

monthly income is below 10,000 while there are 46.44% or 124 students have 10,001 to

20,000 as their parent’s monthly income. As students with their parent’s monthly income of

20,001 to 30,000 represented 36 students or 13.48%. Next were the students with 40,001 to

50,000 as their parent’s monthly income is 15 students or 5.62%. Those students who are

their parent’s monthly income are 100,001 and above represented 10 students or 3.75% and

lastly 1 or 0.37 student did not respond to this item. It is evident that the maximum numbers

of respondents are having their parent’s monthly income of 10,001 to 20,000. Lastly, the

respondents of this study are composed of 49.81% which are enrolled in ABM, 33.33% are

from STEM, 10.86% are from HUMSS, and 5.99% are from GAS strand.

The level of satisfaction of senior high school students was assessed in terms of the

following dimensions: First the students are “satisfied” with their teacher’s credibility which

includes his/her expertise in the subject matter with the overall weighted mean of 3.37.

According to the research study of John Hattie (2016), teacher’s credibility is vital to learning,

and students are very perceptive about knowing which teachers can make a difference. There

are four key factors of credibility: trust, competence, dynamism and immediacy and students

seeks confidence in their teacher’s ability to deliver compelling and engaging information. With
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 53

regards to learning facilities the students are also “satisfied” with the overall weighted mean

of 2.96. According to Dr. Bruce Baker (2015) in his article “The importance of School Facilities

in Improving Student outcomes”, discussed that the school facilities can have a profound

impact on both teacher and student outcomes. With respect to teachers, school facilities affect

teacher recruitment, retention, commitment, and effort. With respect to students, school

facilities affect health, behavior, engagement learning, and growth in achievement. The

service of the school administration that CCP has offered was also denoted as “satisfied” by

the students with the overall weighted mean of 3.11. In view of this, higher education

institutions must continually assess the quality of their services since outstanding service

quality can provide them with competitive advantage (Albretch, 1991). If the higher education

institutions provide quality service which meet or exceed that expectations of their students,

their services will be evaluated as high-quality service and if not, the services will be judged

as poor (Zammuto et al, 1996). In learning experiences, the students are “satisfied” with the

overall weighted mean of 3.30. Students must be the major players in creating meaning out

of their experiences. Some studies emphasize that student engagement in the learning

process is more important for learning (e.g., Biggs 1999; Chickering and Gamson 1987; Shuell

1986). the students’ engagement in the process should be the focus of assessing the

effectiveness of teaching. Considering this, it may be difficult to evaluate teacher performance

in terms of its impact on student learning if the emphasis continues to be on the teacher’s

behavior. Curricula should meet the needs of the students and the society, study depicts that

the students were overall “satisfied” with the curriculum of their chosen track with the overall

weighted mean of 3.32, the curriculum content should reflect the frontier dynamic and aim to

meet students’ needs about the latest trend. It is necessary to increase the interdisciplinary

curricula and theories, which aims to broaden the students’ visions. At the same time, the
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 54

sharing of resources in different disciplines and institutions is also very essential. (Zhou,

2016). Lastly, students are “satisfied” based on their personal satisfaction with the mean of

3.28, according to Mai (2005) students satisfaction are influenced by different factors these

includes teacher’s expertise, quality of education, and the degree furthering student’s careers.

Therefore, the researchers conclude that the level of satisfaction of senior high school

students in terms of these dimensions are overall “satisfied”.

The senior high school students were asked a question, “Will you enroll in college

aligned to your track?” this is sought to find out the relationship between the level of

satisfaction of students in terms of different dimensions and how it will affect their decision in

enrolling in college with a course aligned to their track. The survey result depicts that 185 out

of 267 students answered “YES” they want to enroll a course in college based on their strand.

The study also indicates that highest number of respondents are “satisfied” in the following

dimensions namely: teacher’s credibility, learning facilities, school administration, curriculum,

learning experience, and personal satisfaction. Somehow, 24 responded “NO” and 58 of them

said “MAYBE”. The researchers closely study the results of the data, the students are satisfied

with their chosen strand yet some of them respondent said NO or MAYBE, as cited by

Calderon (2014) she describes the present curriculum as congested. This means that the

student’s do not get enough time to perform tasks because the curriculum is designed to be

taught in the span of 12 years not 10 years. The most obvious results of this is that high school

student will graduate without the readiness to take upon higher education or employment. She

states that these students are not fully equipped with the basic skills and competencies

needed in work. Aside from this, there are no sufficient laboratories for communication

subjects and modules are also lacking particularly for their specialized and applied subjects.

(Tabora, 2014). Therefore, the decision of the students to continue their desire course in
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 55

college that is aligned to their track is somehow affected by the degree of their satisfaction

based on abovementioned dimensions. Then, study also shows that with regards to learning

facilities it gets the lowest weighted mean of 2.96, laboratories are very important especially

for specialized and applied subjects such as general biology or general physics subjects, the

institution should focus on adding facilities that help the students for exploratory and

experimentation subjects. References are important not just for the teachers but also for the

learners, classroom as well influences student’s engagement the school should always

consider if the classroom is conducive for learning and the students are enjoying while

learning. thus, researcher generally concludes that without adequate facilities and resources,

it is extremely difficult to serve large numbers of children with complex needs. According to

Gottfredson’s theory (1981) of occupational aspirations are reflection of one’s self-concept,

his theory describes that students are attracted to certain specialization because of their self-

concept or how they perceived their selves in the future using interest, attitudes, and skills

that are strongly influenced by our shared environment (e.g. family, peers, school, and

community). However, continuing learning intentions to take up future learning are strongly

and consistently related to current or recent experiences of learning and student’s satisfaction.

Conclusions

CCP senior high school students are overall satisfied in terms of different dimensions,

it was also revealed through the study that the senior high school student’s overall

satisfactions were based from their experiences inside the campus where they are learning.

All this finding can help the authorities and policy makers for the improvement of the quality

in higher education, considering that such areas are vital for the student’s life. The study
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 56

indicates that there is a direct relationship between the degree of satisfaction of the students

as stated in the different dimensions. Senior high school students are overall satisfied with

their teacher’s expertise for it gets the highest weighted mean (3.37), when it comes to

learning experiences students are satisfied for it results to the highest second weighted mean

(3.3.0) and the curriculum which the senior high school students are currently taking, this

study indicates that they are satisfied (3.32). lastly, when the students were asked if they

experience personal satisfaction they also responded “satisfied” (3.28). it depicts that students

are encouraged to perform well inside the class, they like and wanted to learn more of their

chosen track and they are confident that they have gained sufficient knowledge in their

preferred track. Yet, the researchers conclude that students can be highly satisfied in the

abovementioned dimensions if the school administration will focus on improving their quality

and continuously assess their service. This study suggests the following improvement for the

students to be highly satisfied. First, there is no problem with regards to teacher’s credibility,

if we are going to teach students the standards, we need to be able to ensure that the teachers

who work with them will also be able to teach to those standards (Fong-Yee, 2013). This will

include continuous professional development for the teachers, they should always undergo

training and seminars that will aid them in creating holistic and competitive individuals. Then,

study also shows that with regards to learning facilities it gets the lowest weighted mean of

2.96, laboratories and complete references are very important especially for specialized and

applied subjects such as general biology or general physics subjects, the institution should

focus on adding facilities that help the students for exploratory and experimentation subjects.

References are important not just for the teachers but also for the learners, so they could

review or help them in understanding more of their lectures in class. Classroom as well

influences student’s engagement; the school should always consider if the classroom is
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 57

conducive for learning and the students are enjoying while learning by doing regularly check-

ups to their facilities. thus, researcher generally concludes that without adequate facilities and

resources, it is extremely difficult to serve large numbers of children with complex needs.

These factors might affect the respondents who answered NO and MAYBE in the survey.

According to Gottfredson’s theory (1981) of occupational aspirations students see how they

perceived their selves in the future using interest, attitudes, and skills that are strongly

influenced by our shared environment (e.g. family, peers, school, and community). However,

continuing learning intentions to take up future learning are strongly and consistently related

to current or recent experiences of learning and student’s satisfaction

Recommendations

The results of this study must be viewed within the context of several limitations. First,

the analysis was relied on self-report information, the response of the students might over-

report or under-report their perceptions based on personal concerns. Some students might

not accurately rate their own satisfaction based on the Likert item given in the questions.

Second, the questionnaires are limited to further assess the satisfaction of the students in

terms of different dimensions. It is suggested to have a future research be conducted using

valid measures to determine student’s satisfaction in different areas in the K-12 curriculum.

Third, the study population only caters to one track of senior high school which is restricted to

a single private institution. Therefore, the results might not be generalized to different aspects

of the K-12 curriculum. Future research may continue in exploring the different factors that

affect student satisfaction in terms of the senior high school track within a bigger population
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 58

and smaller margin of error. The researchers also recommend a further study regarding this

thesis for only few consider doing this kind of study. Lastly, this study will be a great start to

consider conducting a further research about the K-12 curriculum and how it affects student

satisfaction.
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 59

References

Ilyas, M. & Arif, S., 2013. Quality of work-life model for teachers of private universities

in. Quality Assurance in Education, pp. 282-298.

Russian Education & Society, 52(5), 79–88. doi: 10.2753/RES1060-9393520507 Taylor &

Francis Online]

Wilkinson and Yussof (Wilkinson, R., & Yussof, I. (2005). Public and private provision of

higher education in Malaysia: A comparative analysis. Higher Education, 50(3), 361–386.

Quality and assessment in context: A brief review. Quality Assurance in

Education, 14(3), 277–288.

New Directions for Community Colleges, 2010(150), 89–94. doi: 10.1002/cc.40

Akareem & Hossain, 2012 Akareem, H. S., & Hossain, S. S. (2012). Perception of

education quality in private universities of Bangladesh

Ashraf, M. A., Ibrahim, Y., & Joarder, M. H. (2009). Quality education management at

private universities in Bangladesh: An exploratory study. Jurnal Pendidik dan

Pendidikan, 24, 17–32

Lizzio, A., Wilson, K., & Simons, R. (2002). University students’ perceptions of the

learning environment and academic outcomes: Implications for theory and practice. Studies

in Higher Education, 27(1), 27–52

http://www.ats.ucla.edu/stat/spss/dae/mlogit.htm

Retrieved from http://core.journals.yorku.ca/index.php/core/article/view/2724/1929

Agresti, A., & Kateri, M. (2011). Categorical data analysis. London: Springer.
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 60

Arnon, S., & Reichel, N. (2007). Who is the ideal teacher? Am I? similarity and difference

in perception of students of education regarding the qualities of a good teacher and of their

own qualities as teachers. Teachers and Teaching: Theory and Practice, 13(5), 441–464.

Bailey, A. R., Chow, C. W., & Haddad, K. M. (1999). Continuous improvement in

business education: Insights from the for-profit sector and business school deans.Journal of

Education for Business, 74(3), 165–180.

Ehrman, C. (2006). On using benefit segmentation for a service industry: A study on

college career counseling services. Journal of American Academy of Business, 8(2), 179–

185.

Ingvarson, L., Beavis, A., & Kleinhenz, E. (2007). Factors affecting the impact of teacher

education programmes on teacher preparedness: Implications for accreditation policy

European Journal of Teacher Education, 30(4), 351–381.

Gottfredson’s theory (1981) of occupational aspirations, www.wikipedia.com


POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 61

Appendix 1: Research Instrument

LEVEL OF SATISFACTION OF GRADE 12 STUDENTS IN THEIR CHOSEN ACADEMIC


TRACK IN CENTRAL COLLEGES OF THE PHILIPPINES

The purpose of this survey is to investigate the dimensions that affects the student’s
satisfaction in their chosen academic track in Senior High School of Grade 12 student in CCP.
This survey assures the confidentiality of the respondent’s profile and answer. Do not leave
any item unanswered and answer as honestly as possible to arrive the authenticity of results.

I. SOCIO-DEMOGRAPHIC PROFILE

NAME (optional): ________________________________________

What is your sex? (Pls. check one box)


 MALE
 FEMALE

What is your age? (Pls. check one box)


 Below 15 years old
 15 - 20 years old
 20 – 25 years old
 25 – 30 years old
 31 and above _________________

What is your religion? (Pls. check one box)


 Catholic
 Christian
 Islam
 Iglesia Ni Cristo
 None
 Others pls. specify ______________________
What is your city address? (Pls. check one box)
 Manila
 Quezon City
 Pasig
 Rizal area
 Outside metro manila

What is your parent’s monthly income? (Pls. check one box)


POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 62

 Below 10, 000


 10,001 to 20, 000
 29, 001 to 30, 000
 40, 001 to 50, 000
 100, 001 and above

What is your parent’s highest educational attainment? (Pls. check one box)
 Elementary level
 Elementary Graduate
 High school level
 Highs school Graduated
 College level
 College Graduate
 With Master’s unit
 Master’s Degree holder
 With Doctorate units
 Doctorate Degree Holder

II. ACADEMIC TRACK/STRAND

What is your strand in Senior High School?


 Accountancy, Business, and Management (ABM) strand
 Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) strand
 Humanities and Social Sciences (HUMSS) strand
 General Academic Strand (GAS)

Would you like to enroll a course in college aligned to your track in Senior High?
 YES
 NO
 MAYBE
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 63

II. DIMENSIONS THAT AFFECT STUDENT SATISFACTION

PLEASE ENCIRCLE YOUR LEVEL OF SATISFACTION TO


RATE THE FOLLOWING DIMENSIONS ACCORDING TO
THE 4-POINT SCALE WHEREIN:

4-HIGHLY SATISFIED, 3 - SATISFIED, 2 - MODERATELY


SATISFIED, & 1 - DISSASTISFIED

A. TEACHER'S CREDIBILITY HS S MS DS
The teacher has the expertise on the subject he/she teaches 4 3 2 1
The teacher always gives timely feedback on assignments
either in a form of a grade, written comments or verbal
response 4 3 2 1
The homework assignments are relevant to what we are
doing in class 4 3 2 1
The teacher uses different instructional materials in teaching 4 3 2 1
The teacher teaches based on his/her field of specialization 4 3 2 1
The teacher practices his/her profession ethically 4 3 2 1
The teacher treats student's fairly 4 3 2 1
The teachers are approachable, and I can talk to them
outside the class 4 3 2 1

B. LEARNING FACILITIES HS S MS DS
The library has complete references 4 3 2 1
The computers and internet are functioning properly 4 3 2 1
The students can access freely the internet for doing
assignments and other academic related activities 4 3 2 1
The classrooms are clean, well ventilated and conducive in
learning 4 3 2 1
The supplies available in the school bookstore are complete 4 3 2 1
The students have access in the audio/visual room 4 3 2 1
The audio-visual equipment’s are in good conditions 4 3 2 1
The classroom arrangements are well organized 4 3 2 1

C. SCHOOL ADMINISTRATION HS S MS DS
The school has enough administrative staffs that assist
students during enrollment 4 3 2 1
The administrative office is open during convenient hours 4 3 2 1
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 64

The library staffs are helpful and approachable 4 3 2 1


The clinical staffs are accommodating and helpful 4 3 2 1
The counseling staff cares about the students as individuals 4 3 2 1
The office of student affairs and their services response well
in the students’ needs and requests 4 3 2 1
The restrooms and canteens are tidy and enough to
accommodate the whole population of the students 4 3 2 1
The appropriate security measures in school are properly
implemented 4 3 2 1

D. LEARNING EXPERIENCES HS S MS DS
The university arranges seminar for students as part of their
learning 4 3 2 1
The teacher provides different collaborative activities 4 3 2 1
The instructions are given by the teacher in a manner that
enlightens rather than confuse students 4 3 2 1
The level/difficulty of subject content is appropriate for my
chosen track 4 3 2 1
The class requirements are clear and reasonable 4 3 2 1
The students can share ideas during class discussion 4 3 2 1
The students can experience intellectual growth 4 3 2 1
The practical learning period helps students improve their
learning achievement 4 3 2 1

E. CURRICULUM HS S MS DS
The subjects offered are aligned to my chosen academic
track 4 3 2 1
The teacher provides the course guide of the subject 4 3 2 1
The teacher uses the community as a learning facility 4 3 2 1
The teacher does team teaching to bring about effective
learning process 4 3 2 1
The teacher designs project based on learning situations for
active learning participations 4 3 2 1
The teacher integrates learner nature and interest in the
subject matter 4 3 2 1
The school provides training based on our chosen academic
track 4 3 2 1
The school exposes the students to the community through
excursion/field trip at least once in a school year 4 3 2 1

F. PERSONAL SATISFACTION OF STUDENTS HS S MS DS


I am encouraged to perform well in class by my teachers 4 3 2 1
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 65

I perform well in class because I really like my chosen track 4 3 2 1


I get high grades in my subjects 4 3 2 1
I can see that there is a good relationship between the
teachers and students 4 3 2 1
I am competent that I have gained sufficient knowledge in my
preferred track that helps me to be equipped in my college
study 4 3 2 1
I don’t feel any regret regarding my decision in choosing my
academic track 4 3 2 1
I look forward to the next class meetings 4 3 2 1
I have a plan of enrolling a course in college that is aligned
with my chosen track in Senior High School 4 3 2 1
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 66

Appendix 2: Statistical Treatment Results

Sex Frequency Percentage (%)


Male 87 32.58
Female 180 67.42
Total 267 100.00

Age Frequency Percentage (%)


Below 15 years old 8 3.00
15 - 20 years old 259 97.00
Total 267 100.00

Religion Frequency Percentage (%)


Catholic 218 81.65
Christian 39 14.61
Iglesia Ni Cristo 4 1.50
None 1 0.37
No Response 5 1.87
Total 267 100.00

City Address Frequency Percentage (%)


Manila 82 30.71
Quezon City 138 51.69
Pasig 22 8.24
Rizal area 15 5.62
Outside metro manila 7 2.62
No Response 3 1.12
Total 267 100.00
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 67

Monthly Income Frequency Percentage (%)


Below 10,000 81 30.34
10,001 to 20,000 124 46.44
20,001 to 30,000 36 13.48
40,001 to 50,000 15 5.62
100,001 and Above 10 3.75
No Response 1 0.37
Total 267 100.00

Parent's Highest Educational


Frequency Percentage (%)
Attainment
Elementary level 6 2.25
Elementary Graduate 4 1.50
High school level 32 11.99
Highs school Graduated 80 29.96
College level 60 22.47
College Graduate 79 29.59
With Master’s unit 3 1.12
Master’s Degree holder 3 1.12
Total 267 100.00

Strand Frequency Percentage (%)


Accountancy, Business, and
133 49.81
Management (ABM) strand
Science, Technology,
Engineering, and Mathematics 89 33.33
(STEM) strand
Humanities and Social
29 10.86
Sciences (HUMSS) strand
General Academic Strand
16 5.99
(GAS)
Total 267 100.00
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 68

Appendix 3: Assessment

HS S MS D
Weighted Verbal
TEACHER'S CREDIBILITY 4 3 2 1
Mean Interpretation
Frequency
The teacher has the expertise on Highly
154 104 8 1 3.54
the subject he/she teaches Satisfied
The teacher always gives timely
feedback on assignments either in
110 128 28 1 3.30 Satisfied
a form of a grade, written
comments or verbal response
The homework assignments are
relevant to what we are doing in 136 105 24 2 3.40 Satisfied
class
The teacher uses different
122 122 22 1 3.37 Satisfied
instructional materials in teaching
The teacher teaches based on
146 97 23 1 3.45 Satisfied
his/her field of specialization
The teacher practices his/her
136 107 23 1 3.42 Satisfied
profession ethically
The teacher treats student's fairly 86 119 48 14 3.04 Satisfied
The teachers are approachable,
and I can talk to them outside the 143 101 18 5 3.43 Satisfied
class
Overall Weighted Mean 3.37 Satisfied
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 69

HS S MS D
Weighted Verbal
LEARNING FACILITIES 4 3 2 1
Mean Interpretation
Frequency
The library has complete
64 142 54 7 2.99 Satisfied
references
The computers and internet are
65 112 82 8 2.88 Satisfied
functioning properly
The students can access freely the
internet for doing assignments and 87 110 56 14 3.01 Satisfied
other academic related activities
The classrooms are clean, well
ventilated and conducive in 82 129 51 5 3.08 Satisfied
learning
The supplies available in the
54 the 86 17 2.75 Satisfied
school bookstore are complete
The students have access in the
64 109 82 12 2.84 Satisfied
audio/visual room
The audio-visual equipment’s are
75 117 66 9 2.97 Satisfied
in good conditions
The classroom arrangements are
85 148 28 6 3.17 Satisfied
well organized
Overall Weighted Mean 2.96 Satisfied
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 70

HS S MS D
Weighted Verbal
SCHOOL ADMINISTRATION 4 3 2 1
Mean Interpretation
Frequency
The school has enough
administrative staffs that assist 102 130 34 1 3.25 Satisfied
students during enrollment
The administrative office is open
94 136 34 3 3.20 Satisfied
during convenient hours
The library staffs are helpful and
91 121 50 5 3.12 Satisfied
approachable
The clinical staffs are
79 96 70 22 2.87 Satisfied
accommodating and helpful
The counseling staff cares about
109 128 30 0 3.30 Satisfied
the students as individuals
The office of student affairs and
their services response well in the 82 127 50 8 3.06 Satisfied
students’ needs and requests
The restrooms and canteens are
tidy and enough to accommodate
87 94 71 14 2.95 Satisfied
the whole population of the
students
The appropriate security measures
103 112 43 9 3.16 Satisfied
in school are properly implemented
Overall Weighted Mean 3.11 Satisfied
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 71

HS S MS D
Weighted Verbal
LEARNING EXPERIENCES 4 3 2 1
Mean Interpretation
Frequency
The university arranges seminar
for students as part of their 114 137 14 2 3.36 Satisfied
learning
The teacher provides different
114 136 16 1 3.36 Satisfied
collaborative activities
The instructions are given by the
teacher in a manner that enlightens 97 144 23 3 3.25 Satisfied
rather than confuse students
The level/difficulty of subject
content is appropriate for my 106 128 31 2 3.27 Satisfied
chosen track
The class requirements are clear
95 123 41 8 3.14 Satisfied
and reasonable
The students have the
opportunities to share ideas during 114 125 27 1 3.32 Satisfied
class discussion
The students are able to
127 122 15 3 3.40 Satisfied
experience intellectual growth
The practical learning period helps
students improve their learning 117 122 24 4 3.32 Satisfied
achievement
Overall Weighted Mean 3.30 Satisfied
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 72

HS S MS D
Weighted Verbal
CURRICULUM 4 3 2 1
Mean Interpretation
Frequency
The subjects offered are aligned to
148 94 21 4 3.45 Satisfied
my chosen academic track
The teacher provides the course
130 111 25 1 3.39 Satisfied
guide of the subject
The teacher uses the community
131 111 24 1 3.39 Satisfied
as a learning facility
The teacher does team teaching to
bring about effective learning 124 114 29 0 3.36 Satisfied
process
The teacher designs project based
on learning situations for active 113 133 20 1 3.34 Satisfied
learning participations
The teacher integrates learner
nature and interest in the subject 117 117 30 2 3.31 Satisfied
matter
The school provides training based
120 110 29 8 3.28 Satisfied
on our chosen academic track
The school exposes the students
to the community through
126 72 34 35 3.08 Satisfied
excursion/field trip at least once in
a school year
Overall Weighted Mean 3.32 Satisfied
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 73

HS S MS D
PERSONAL SATISFACTION OF Weighted Verbal
4 3 2 1
STUDENTS Mean Interpretation
Frequency
I am encouraged to perform well in
104 131 30 1 3.27 Satisfied
class by my teachers
I perform well in class because I
113 123 29 2 3.30 Satisfied
really like my chosen track
I get high grades in my subjects 97 131 33 6 3.19 Satisfied
I can see that there is a good
relationship between the teachers 110 128 24 5 3.28 Satisfied
and students
I am competent that I have gained
sufficient knowledge in my
118 121 24 4 3.32 Satisfied
preferred track that helps me to be
equipped in my college study
I don’t feel any regret regarding my
decision in choosing my academic 139 92 30 6 3.36 Satisfied
track
I look forward to the next class
101 119 39 8 3.17 Satisfied
meetings
I have a plan of enrolling a course
in college that is aligned with my 142 89 24 12 3.35 Satisfied
chosen track in Senior High School
Overall Weighted Mean 3.28 Satisfied
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 74

Appendix 4: Chi square’s Contingency Table

Will you enroll in College


Teacher’s Credibility aligned to your track? Total
Yes No Maybe
Moderately Satisfied 8 0 5 13
Satisfied 105 12 32 149
Highly Satisfied 72 12 21 105
Overall 185 24 58 267

Will you enroll in College


Learning Facilities aligned to your track? Total
Yes No Maybe
Dissatisfied 1 0 1 2
Moderately Satisfied 50 4 16 70
Satisfied 111 11 31 153
Highly Satisfied 23 9 10 42
Overall 185 24 58 267

Will you enroll in College


School Administration aligned to your track? Total
Yes No Maybe
Dissatisfied 1 0 0 1
Moderately Satisfied 29 2 17 48
Satisfied 121 10 31 162
Highly Satisfied 34 12 10 56
Overall 185 24 58 267
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 75

Will you enroll in College


Curriculum aligned to your track? Total
Yes No Maybe
Moderately Satisfied 11 1 6 18
Satisfied 111 11 40 162
Highly Satisfied 63 12 12 87
Overall 185 24 58 267

Will you enroll in College


Learning Experiences aligned to your track? Total
Yes No Maybe
Dissatisfied 1 0 0 1
Moderately Satisfied 10 1 9 20
Satisfied 109 9 33 151
Highly Satisfied 65 14 16 95
Overall 185 24 58 267

Will you enroll in College


Personal Satisfaction aligned to your track? Total
of the students
Yes No Maybe
Dissatisfied 1 0 0 1
Moderately Satisfied 12 1 8 21
Satisfied 109 13 38 160
Highly Satisfied 63 10 12 85
Overall 185 24 58 267
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 76

Biographical Statement

Rubelyn Bataller is a graduate of Bachelor of Science in Business Administration major

in Marketing in Camarines Norte State College. She was a former Administrative assistant in

a telecommunication company. Her first ambition is to work in any prestigious company that

is why she pursued a business course. After working in different companies, she decided to

reach her second dream, and that is to become a Teacher. She resigns to her previous job

and started to pursue her passion in teaching. As of now, she is taking up Post baccalaureate

in Teacher education in PUP to make her dream into reality.

Mary Grace Luna is a graduate of Bachelor of Science in Cooperatives in University

of Eastern Philippines. Currently working as a travel tax processor at Tourism infrastructure

and Enterprise Zone Authority. She wanted to become a Professional Teacher. As of now,

she is taking up Post baccalaureate in Teacher education in PUP to become a Licensed

Professional Teacher.

Carina Monfero is a bachelor’s degree holder in Information Technology at Laguna

State Polytechnic University and currently working as a government employee. Her ultimate

dream is to become a teacher. As of now, she is taking up Post baccalaureate in Teacher

education in PUP.
POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES 77

Ma. Angelica Rivera graduated as a 4-year academic scholar with a degree of

Bachelor of Science in Business Administration major in Marketing Management at Philippine

School of Business Administration. She graduated as 1st honorable mention in high school

that makes her eligible to apply as Benjamin P. Paulino Scholar in PSBA. Now, she is currently

working as a Part-time teacher in Senior High School department and a full-time LIS

Coordinator and Administrative assistant in Central Colleges of the Philippines. She believes

that being a teacher is a calling from God and now she is currently taking up Post-

baccalaureate in Teacher Education in PUP to pursue this calling.

Rosabel Tan, is a graduate of Bachelor of Science in Accountancy at Camarines Norte

State College. She is now currently taking up Post-baccalaureate in Teacher Education in

PUP. She is an Internal Auditor at a private accounting firm that provides accounting services

to its client. Her ambition that started since high school is to become an Educator and that

she may impart her knowledge and skills to her future students especially to those located in

indigent places.

You might also like