Management Accounting
Management Accounting
Management Accounting
PART 1
CPA SECTION 2
STUDY TEXT
GENERAL OBJECTIVE
This paper is intended to equip the candidate with knowledge, skills and attitudes that will enable him/her
to apply management accounting principles and concepts in business
LEARNING OUTCOMES
CONTENT
2. Cost classification
3. Cost estimation
4. Cost accumulation
- Accounting for materials and inventory; material cost records, purchasing procedures, receipt and
issues of material, methods of valuing material issues, inventory control procedures; economic
order quantity (EOQ) and economic batch quantity(EBQ) models and back flush
- Accounting for labour: Methods of labour remuneration, labour control procedures, maintenance
of labour records
5. Cost bookkeeping
6. Costing methods
9. Standard costing
- Types of standards
- Principles of setting standards
- Standard cost card
- Behavioural aspects of standard costing
- Generation of standard cost information
- Materials, labour and overheads variances; price and efficiency variances
CONTENT PAGE
Cost accounting is a type of accounting process that aims to capture a company's costs of
production by assessing the input costs of each step of production as well as fixed costs such as
depreciation of capital equipment. Cost accounting will first measure and record these costs
individually, then compare input results to output or actual results to aid company management
in measuring financial performance.
The nature of cost accounting can be brought out under the following headings:
3. Cost accounting is an art: Cost accounting is an art in the sense it requires the ability
and skill on the part of cost accountant in applying the principles, methods and
techniques of cost accountancy to various management problems. These problems
include the ascertainment of cost, control of costs, ascertainment of profitability, etc.
4. Cost accounting is a profession: In recent years cost accounting has become one of the
important professions which has become more challenging.
While cost accounting is often used within a company to aid in decision making, financial
accounting is what the outside investor community typically sees. Financial accounting is a
different representation of costs and financial performance that includes a company's assets and
liabilities. Cost accounting can be most beneficial as a tool for management in budgeting and in
setting up cost control programs, which can improve net margins for the company in the future.
One key difference between cost accounting and financial accounting is that while in financial
accounting the cost is classified depending on the type of transaction, cost accounting classifies
Scholars have argued that cost accounting was first developed during the industrial
revolution when the emerging economics of industrial supply and demand forced manufacturers
to start tracking whether to decrease the price of their overstocked goods or decrease production.
During the early 19th century when David Ricardo and T. R. Malthus were developing the field
of economic theory, writers like Charles Babbage were writing the first books designed to guide
businesses on how to manage their internal cost accounting.
By the beginning of the 20th century, cost accounting had become a widely covered topic in the
literature of business management.
This type of of cost accounting uses ratios to compare efficient uses of labor and materials to
produce goods or services under standard conditions. Assessing these differences is called a
variance analysis. Traditional cost accounting essentially allocates cost based on one measure,
labor or machine hours. Due to the fact that overhead cost has risen proportionate to labor
cost since the genesis of standard cost accounting, allocating overhead cost as an overall cost has
ended up producing occasionally misleading insights.
Some of the issues associated with cost accounting is that this type of accounting emphasizes
labor efficiency despite the fact that it makes up a comparatively small amount of the costs for
modern companies.
Activity based accounting is defined as, "an approach to the costing and monitoring of activities
which involves tracing resource consumption and costing final outputs, resources assigned to
activities, and activities to cost objects based on consumption estimates. The latter utilize cost
drivers to attach activity costs to outputs."
Activity based costing accumulates the overheads from each department and assigns them to
specific cost objects like services, customers, or products. The way these costs are assigned to
cost objects are first decided in an activity analysis, where appropriate output measures are cost
drivers. As result, activity based costing tends to be much more accurate and helpful when it
comes to helping managers understand the cost and profitability of their company's specific
services or products. Accountants using activity based costing will pass out a survey to
Lean Accounting
Marginal Costing
Considered a simplified model of cost accounting, marginal costing (sometimes called cost-
volume-profit analysis) is an analysis of the relationship between a product or service's sales
price, the volume of sales, the amount produced, expenses, costs and profits. That specific
relationship is called the contribution margin. The contribution margin is calculated by dividing
revenue minus variable cost by revenue. This type of analysis can be used by management to
gain insight on potential profits as impacted by changing costs, what types of sales prices to
establish, and types of marketing campaigns.
Types of Costs
Fixed Costs are costs that don't vary depending ont he amount of work a company is doing.
These are usually things like the payment on a building, or a piece of equipment that is
depreciating at a fixed monthly rate.
Variable costs are tied to a company's level of production. An example could be a coffee roaster,
who after receiving a large order of beans from a far-away locale, has to pay a higher rate for
both shipping, packaging, and processing.
Operating costs are costs associated with the day-to-day operations of a business. These costs
can be either fixed or variable depending.
Direct costs is the cost related to producing a product. If a coffee roaster spends 5 hours roasting
coffee, the direct costs of the finished product include the labor hours of the roaster, and the cost
of the coffee green. The energy cost to heat the roaster would be indirect because they're inexact,
hard to trace.
Cost accounting is utilized for a number of purposes, some of which are briefly described in the
following points:
d) Decision making
Cost accounting information assists in the making of decisions about future operations of
the enterprise; such decisions making may be assisted by the information from cost
techniques and cost-volume-profit analysis.
f) Performance evaluation
Cost accounting information is used to measure and evaluate actual performance so as to
make a decision of the degree of optimality or efficiency of resource utilization.
Functions and objectives of cost and management accounting include the following:
1. Planning
2. Decision Making
3. Monitoring & Control
4. Accountability
Forecasting is the process of estimation of the expected financial performance and position of a
business in the future. Common types of forecasts include cash flow forecast, projected profit
and loss and balance sheet forecast. Forecasts assist in determining the likely change in the
financial performance and position of a business when considered in the context of the various
assumptions used in forming the projections. Forecasting is the starting point in determining the
resource requirements of a business which are quantified into budgets.
2. Decision Making
Control process in management accounting system starts by defining standards against which
performance may be measured such as standard costs and budgets. Actual results are measured
and any variance between targets and results are analyzed and where necessary, corrective
actions are taken. Management accounting plays a vital role in the monitoring and control of cost
and efficiency of the routine processes and as well as one-off jobs and projects undertaken by an
organization.
4. Accountability
Cost accounting department records, classifies and present cost information for manufacturing
and other activities of the organisation. It makes an analysis of cost of manufacturing, marketing
and administration and provides control reports and other decision making data to all levels of
management for the purpose of controlling and reducing costs.
It is, therefore, necessary that cost accounting department should have a proper coordination with
other departments of the organisation. All departments should help each other so that the
objective of minimum possible cost may be achieved without too many bottle-necks.
Cost accounting department and production department are closely related to each other.
Production department is concerned with the conversion of raw materials into finished
products. Cost accounting department helps in estimating the various costs involved in
the manufacturing process like material cost, labour cost and other expenses involved for
manufacturing a product.
The required information regarding costs relating to the manufacturing process both
budgeted and actual is collected by cost accounting department from the production
department and sent to the management for exercising cost control.
In these respects cost accounting department can help purchase department by setting
various levels of materials like minimum level, maximum level, reordering level,
economic order quantity etc. Various types of material control suggested by the cost
accounting department will be helpful in ensuring minimum possible cost of materials.
Cost accountant can recommend incentive plans for remunerating employees, which will
be attractive to the employees for earning more wages and salaries and at the same time
reducing labour cost per unit. In this way both departments personnel and cost accounting
can be helpful in developing a contented labour force which will be willing to work for
the organisation.
A close coordination is required between cost accounting department and finance and
accounts department for reducing and controlling costs. Finance department is dependent
upon the cost accounting department for making an estimate of funds required for
production and marketing purposes. Similarly, materials and other supplies cannot be
purchased at the minimum possible prices if the finance department does not provide the
required finance at the time it is required.
1. Cost ascertainment
Costing is the technique and process of ascertaining the cost. Costing is the process of
determining the costs of products, services or activities.
The above definition is very significant in as much as it carries the main theme of cost
accountancy. This definition emphasizes two important aspects, viz
(a) The technique and process of costing: The technique of costing involves two distinct
steps, namely,
(i) collection and classification of costs according to various elements and
(ii) allocation and apportionment of the expenses which cannot be directly charged to
production. As a process, costing is concerned with the routine ascertainment of cost
with a formal procedure.
(b) Ascertainment of cost: It involves three steps;-
(i) Collection and analysis of expenses,
(ii) Measurement of production at different stages and
(iii) Linking up of production with the expenses.
To achieve the first step, costing has developed different systems such as Historical, Estimated
and Standard Cost. For achieving the second step, costing has developed different methods such
as single or output costing. Job costing, contract costing, etc.Finally, for achieving the last step
costing has developed important techniques such as Absorption Costing, Marginal Costing and
Standard Costing.
The three terms indicated as ‘systems’, ‘methods’, ‘techniques’ are independent factors but co-
exist together. Ascertainment of cost of production is based on all these terms. For example,
continuous type of industries may use process costing as a method, using actual cost as a system,
under Standard Costing Technique.
2. Cost Accounting
Cost Accounting is the branch of accounting dealing with the classification, recording,
allocation, summarization and reporting of current and prospective costs.
3. Cost Control
Cost control represents the employment of management devices in the performance of any
necessary operation so that pre-established objectives of quality, quantity and time may be
attained at the lowest possible outlay for goods and services. The terminology published by
ICMA, London, defines cost control as “The guidance and regulation by executive action of the
cost of operating an undertaking.” According to this definition, cost control aims at guiding the
actuals towards the lines of target and regulates the actuals if they deviate from the targets. This
guidance and regulation is done by the executive who is responsible for causing the deviation.
This process will become clear by enumerating the steps involved in any cost control technique.
4. Budgetary control
It is the establishment of budgets relating to the responsibilities of executives to the requirements
of a policy and the continuous comparison of actual with budgeted results either to secure by
individual action the objectives of that policy or to provide a basis for its revision. In short, it
involves the fixation of budgets or estimated cost and comparison of actual cost with the budget
fixed.
1. Financial accounting
Financial accounting forms the basis for analysis and interpretation for furnishing meaningful
data to the management. The control aspect is based on financial data and performance
evaluation, on recorded facts and figures. So, management accounting is closely related to
financial accounting in many respects.
2. Cost accounting
Cost accounting is the process and techniques of ascertaining cost. Planning, decision making
and control are the basic managerial functions. The cost accounting system provides the
necessary tool for carrying out such functions efficiently. The tools includes standard costing,
inventory management, variable costing etc.
3. Budgeting andforecasting
Budgeting means expressing the plans, policies and goals of the firm for a definite period in
future. Forecasting on the other hand, is a prediction of what will happen as a result of a given
set of circumstances. Forecasting is a judgment whereas the budgeting is an organizational
object. These are useful for management accounting in planning.
4. Inventory control
Inventory is necessary to control from the time it is acquire till its final disposal as it involves
large sum. For controlling inventory, management should determine different level of stock. The
inventory control technique will be helpful for taking managerial decisions.
6. Interpretation ofdata
Analysis and interpretation of financial statements are important part of management accounting.
After analyzing the financial statements, the interpretation is made and the reports drawn from
this analysis are presented to the management. Interpreting the accounting data to the authorities
in the management is the principal task of management accounting.
7. Reporting to management
The interpreted information must be communicated to those who are interested in it. The report
may cover Profit and Loss Account, Cash Flow and Funds Flow statements etc.
9. Methods of procedures
This includes maintenance of proper data processing and other office management services. It
may have to deal with filing, copying, duplicating, communicating and management information
system and also may have to report about the utility of different office machines
Record keeping
recording business transactions
measuring results of financial changes
projecting financial effects of future transactions
preparing internal reports in a user-friendly format
Decision making
using cost information for pricing, capital investment and marketing
evaluating market and product profitability
evaluating the financial effect of strategies and plans
2. Lack of knowledge
The use of management accounting requires the knowledge of number of related subjects.
Deficiency in knowledge in related subjects like accounting principles, statistics, economics,
principle of management etc. will limit the use of management accounting.
4. Evolutionary stage
Management accounting is still in a development stage and has not yet reached a final stage. The
techniques and tools used by this system give varying and differing results. It is still named as
internal accounting and/ or operational accounting.
6. Psychological resistance
Changes in traditional accounting practices and organizational set up are required to install the
management accounting system. It calls for a rearrangement of the personnel and their activities
and framing of new rules and regulations which generally may not be liked by the people
involved.
Cost accounting is very closely-related to financial accounting. Some authorities on the subject
consider cost accounting to be the branch of financial accounting. But it may be said that cost
accounts is complementary to financial accounts, i.e., a subject which is necessary to make
financial accounts whole or complete. Financial accounts and cost accounts are both similar in
certain respects. But in some other respects they differ from one another. These points of
similarities and dissimilarities are enumerated below:
Points of Similarities
a) The fundamental principles of double entry are applicable in both the systems of accounts.
b) The invoices and vouchers constitute the common basis for recording transactions under both
the systems of accounts.
c) The results of business are revealed by both the systems of accounts.
d) The causes for losses and wastages of a business are provided by both these systems of
accounts.
e) The determination of future business policy is guided by both these systems of accounts.
f) A basis for comparison of expenses is being provided by both the accounting systems.
g) Accuracy of accounts is maintained under both the systems by means of exercising check
over errors and commissions which might creep in either of accounts.
1. Purpose The purpose of financial accounts The purpose of cost accounting is internal
is external reporting mainly to i.e., to the management of every business
owners, reporting, creditors, tax
authorities, government, and
prospective investors
Cost accounts are maintained voluntarily
This is to be maintained In some cases government has directed
2. Obligation compulsorily The preparation of some companies to maintain cost accounts
accounts must be in accordance to improve efficiency.
with the statutory provisions.
.
(a) Financial accounts records (a) Cost accounts records transactions
3. Recording transactions in a subjective in a subjective manner. i.e.,
manner, i.e., according an according to purpose for which
objective manner to the costs are incurred
nature of expenditure
(b) In cost accounts costs are
(b) In financial accounts expressed by proper analysis and
expenses are recorded in classification in order to find out
totals cost per unit
(a) It does not make use of any (a) It makes use of some important
control techniques. control techniques such a
5. Control (b) techniques such a Marginal Marginal Costing
Costing any technique (b) It exercises control over materials
using some techniques such as
(c) Control over labour is not ABC analysis level setting,
exercised economic order quantity etc.
(c) Control over labour is exercised
and efforts are taken to minimise
idle time, over time etc.
9. Valuation
Management accounting can also be defined as the application of professional knowledge and
skill in the preparation and presentation of accounting information in such a way as to assist
management in the formulation of policies and in the planning and control of the operation of the
undertaking.”
If we examine the above two definitions of management accounting it appears that both the
systems of accounts serve the same purpose.
1.Growth of The history of cost accounting This system of accounting evolved in the
dates back Accounting to middle of 20th century. Hence it is of
fourteenth century recent origin where compared to cost
accounting
2. Object The main objects of cost
accounts is to ascertain and The main objective of management
control cost accounting is to provide useful
information to management for decision-
3. Basis of making.
It is based on both present and
future recording transactions It is concerned purely with the
for cost ascertainment transactions relating to future.
4. Scope
Cost accounting has narrow
scope as it covers matters It has a wide scope in as much as it covers
relating to ascertainment and the areas of financial accounts, cost
5. Utility control of cost. accounts, taxation, etc.
It deals only with monetary It deals with both monetary and non-
transactions i.e., it covers only transactions monetary transactions, i.e.,
quantitative aspect both quantitative dealt with and
7. qualitative aspects
Observation
Cost accounts follow a definite It does not follow a definite principle and
principle of principles for Instead, the data to be presented and
ascertaining cost and a format format for recording. depends up on the
need of the management
At the outset it is to be understood that a common cost accounting system cannot be installed for
all types of business undertakings. The cost accounting system depends upon the nature of
business and the product manufactured. Before a suitable system of cost accounting is installed it
is necessary to undertake a preliminary investigation so as to know the feasibility of installing
cost accounting system to such business. While introducing a system of cost accounts it should
be borne in mind that cost accounting system must suit the business. There should not be any
attempt to make the business suit the system. One more consideration that is of practical
importance is that the benefits derived from cost accounting system must be more than the
investment made on it. This means the system must be simple and it must lead to savings through
the control of materials, labour and overheads when
Compared to expenses incurred in maintaining it. For the successful functioning of the costing
system, the following conditions are essential:
a) There must be an efficient system of material control.
b) A sound and well-designed method of wage payment must be set up.
c) The existence of sound basis for collection of all indirect expenses and a basis for its
apportionment to various production departments.
d) The integration of cost and financial accounts to facilitate reconciliation of profit as shown
by these two systems of accounts.
e) The use of printed forms so as to facilitate quick compilation of cost reports.
f) The duties and responsibilities of cost accountant must be made clear.
The following factors are to be considered before installing a cost accounting system:
1. History of business unit: The history of a business unit implies the duration of its existence,
position in the industry, the rate of growth, policy and philosophy of management and the
like. The history of business unit serves as the basis for designing the cost accounts in respect
of necessity, simplicity, and investment involved in installing cost accounts.
2. Nature of the industry: The nature of business such as manufacturing, mining, trading, etc.
determines the costing techniques to be applied. Similarly, the type of product manufactured
also determines the method of costing that is to be employed. In other words, there is no all-
purpose technique and method of costing that can be applied universally.
3. Product range: The range of products manufactured and sold also determines the method of
costing to be selected. Accordingly range of products must be analysed in terms of size,
models, fashions, area of market, competitors and whether the products are made to
customer’s specification or for stocking and selling.
Definition
Cost classification is the process of grouping costs according to their common characteristics. A
suitable classification of costs is of vital importance in order to identify the cost with cost centres
or cost units. Cost may be classified accounting to their nature, i.e., material, labor and expenses
and a number of other characteristics. The same cost figures are classified according to different
ways of costing depending upon the purpose to be achieved and requirements of particular
concern.
3. Controlling cost:
Labour cost: with the help of classification of cost an organization can control its
labour cost as well. If the labour complete their task well in time and with much
efficiency then the organization would be able to reduce its labour cost.
Material cost: material cost can be controlled if material wastage is avoided and
proper standardization of materials is used. Thus with the help of classification of
cost an organization is able to reduce the cost incurred on materials and thus able
to control material cost.
Overhead cost: overhead comprises indirect expenditure incurred in
manufacturing. By knowing the amount that has been incurred under various
heads an organization can device ways to reduce the cost. Thus with the help of
classification of cost an organization is able to control overhead cost.
Thus, classification of cost is of immense importance for an organization. With the help
of classification of cost an organization can make progress and also expand its production
by controlling its cost. Thus in the long run an organization can move towards higher
productivity and thus higher profits and can achieve its goals.
MANUFACTURING COSTS
Manufacturing costs are those costs that are directly involved in manufacturing of products and
services. Examples of manufacturing costs include raw materials costs and salary of labor
workers. Manufacturing cost is divided into three broad categories by most companies.
The materials that go into final product are called raw materials. This term is somewhat
misleading, since it seems to imply unprocessed natural resources like wood pulp or iron ore.
Actually raw materials refer to any materials that are used in the final product; and the finished
product of one company can become raw material of another company. For example plastic
produced by manufacturers of plastic is a finished product for them but is a raw material for
Compaq Computers for its personal computers.
Direct Materials are those material that become an integral part of the finished product and that
can be physically and conveniently traced to it. Examples include tiny electric motor that
Panasonic uses in its CD players to make the CD spin. According to a study of 37 manufacturing
industries material costs averaged about 55% of sales revenue.
Sometimes it is not worth the effort to trace the costs of relatively insignificant materials to the
end products. Such minor items would include the solder used to make electrical connection in a
Sony TV or the glue used to assemble a chair. Materials such as solder or glue are called indirect
materials and are included as part of manufacturing overhead, which is discussed later on this
page.
The term direct labor is reserved for those labor costs that can be essentially traced to individual
units of products. Direct labor is sometime called touch labor, since direct labor workers
typically touch the product while it is being made. The labor cost of assembly line workers, for
example, is a direct labor cost, as would the labor cost of carpenter, bricklayer and machine
operator
Labor costs that cannot be physically traced to the creation of products, or that can be traced only
at a great cost and inconvenience, are termed indirect labor and treated as part of manufacturing
overhead, along with indirect materials. Indirect labor includes the labor costs of janitors,
supervisors, materials handlers, and night security guards. Although the efforts of these workers
are essential to production, it would be either impractical or impossible to accurately trace their
costs to specific units of product. Hence, such labor costs are treated as indirect labor.
In some industries, major shifts are taking place in the structure of labor costs. Sophisticated
automated equipment, run and maintained by skilled workers, is increasingly replacing direct
labor. In a few companies, direct labor has become such a minor element of cost that it has
disappeared altogether as a separate cost category. However the vast majority of manufacturing
and service companies throughout the world continue to recognize direct labor as a separate cost
category.
According to a study of 37 manufacturing industries, direct labor averaged only about 10% of
sales revenue.
Direct Materials cost combined with direct labor cost is called prime cost.
In equation form:
For example total direct materials cost incurred by the company is $4,500 and direct labor cost is
$3,000 then prime cost is $7,500 ($4,500 + $3,000).
Manufacturing overhead, the third element of manufacturing cost, includes all costs of
manufacturing except direct material and direct labor. Examples of manufacturing overhead
include items such as indirect material, indirect labor, maintenance and repairs on production
equipment and heat and light, property taxes, depreciation, and insurance on manufacturing
facilities. Indirect materials are minor items such as solder and glue in manufacturing industries.
These are not included in direct materials costs. Indirect labor is a labor cost that cannot be trace
to the creation of products or that can be traced only at great cost and inconvenience. Indirect
labor includes the labor cost of janitors, supervisors, materials handlers and night security
guards. Costs incurred for heat and light, property taxes, insurance, depreciation and so forth
associated with selling and administrative functions are not included in manufacturing overhead.
Manufacturing overhead cost combined with direct labor is called conversion cost.
In equation form:
For example if total direct labor cost is $3,000 and total manufacturing overhead cost is $2,000
then conversion cost is $5,000 ($3,000 + $2,000).
Non-manufacturing Costs:
Non-manufacturing costs are those costs that are not incurred to manufacture a product.
Examples of such costs are salary of sales person and advertising expenses. Generally non-
manufacturing costs are further classified into two categories.
Marketing or selling costs include all costs necessary to secure customer orders and get the
finished product into the hands of the customers. These costs are often called order getting or
order filling costs. Examples of marketing or selling costs include advertising costs, shipping
costs, sales commission and sales salary.
Administrative Costs:
Administrative costs include all executive, organizational, and clerical costs associated with
general management of an organization rather than with manufacturing, marketing, or selling.
Examples of administrative costs include executive compensation, general accounting,
secretarial, public relations, and similar costs involved in the overall, general administration of
the organization as a whole.
FUNCTIONAL CLASSIFICATION
Production, Administration, Selling & Distribution are three important functions of a business
concern. Taking these functions into consideration, costs have been classified by:
BEHAVIORAL CLASSIFICATION
Cost behavior means how costs will respond or react to changes in the activity level. ie. as we
increase output or sales, are the costs rising, dropping or remaining the same. Cost Behavior can
be used to produce various classifications of costs such as:
Costs will be classified according to nature or behavior in relationship to change in the levels of
production such as:
i) Variable costs
ii) Fixed costs
iii) Semi fixed costs
Variable costs
If the number of units produced doubles, then variable production costs will double also. An
example would be the cost of material used to produce units.
If the number of units sold increases by 20% then variable selling and distribution costs would
increase by 20% also.
An example would be the factory rent. It does no matter how many units are made, the rent is
fixed.
Note that the cost per unit will decrease as the activity level decreases. For example, say that the
rent was $10,000 and 1,000 units were made. Then you could argue that it takes $10 rent to make
a unit ($10,000/1,000).
If, however, 10,000 units were made, the rental cost per unit would be only $1 ($10,000/10,000).
Higher production volumes are making better use of the fixed resource.
An example would be a telephone bill. Usually there is a fixed cost for the line rental then each
minute of telephone calls causes an additional cost.
COST CLASSIFICATION
Under this method, costs are classified according to whether or not they are influenced by the
action of a given member of the undertaking. On this basis cost is classified into two categories.
1. Controllable cost: Controllable costs are those which can be influenced by the action of
a specified member of an undertaking. Generally speaking all directs costs including
direct materials, direct labor and some of the overhead expenses are controllable by the
lower level management.
2. Uncontrollable cost: These are the cost which cannot be influenced by the action of a
specified member of undertakings. Most of fixed costs such as rent of buildings, salary
to managerial persons, wages of skilled workers, etc. are uncontrollable.
Costs can be classified in to historical or actual costs and predetermined or future cost.
Historical cost- It relates to the usual method of determining actual cost of operation
based on actual expenses incurred during the period. Such evaluation of costs takes
longer time, till the accounts are closed and finalized, and figures are already for use in
cost calculations.
Predetermined cost- It is prepared in advance before the actual operation starts on the
basis of specializations and historical cost data of the earlier period and all factors
effecting cost. Predet3ermined cost is therefore future cost and may be either estimated or
standard.
Estimated cost is prepared before accepting an order for submitting price quotation. It is
also used for comparing actual performance.
Standard cost is scientifically predetermined cost of a product or service applicable
during a specific period of immediate future under current or anticipated operating
conditions. The method consists of setting standards for each elements of cost, evaluating
the variance from standard cost and finding reasons for such variance, so that remedial
steps can be taken promptly to check inefficient performance.
Classifications are measured by the period of use and benefit. The capital expenditure and
revenue expenditure are classified under it. Revenue expenses relate to current accounting
period. Capital expenditures are the benefits beyond accounting period. Fixed assets come under
category of capital expenditure and maintenance of assets comes under revenue expenditure
category.
Under this classification, costs are classified according to the function they perform in an
organization. Costs can functionally be classified as:
33S T U D Y T E X T
(a) Product costs: are all the costs incurred in production of units during a time period e.g. raw
material costs, direct labour costs and production overheads. Such costs are capitalized and
expensed (charged to the profit and loss account) only when the manufacturer sells inventory.
These costs may be carried from one period to the other.
(b) Period costs: these are costs mainly incurred in the ordinary running of the business
enterprise. They include costs like electricity bill paid, salaries and allowances and rent
payments. They are referred to as period costs since they are expensed in the period they are
incurred.
a) Sunk costs: these are costs, which have already been incurred. They cannot be changed
by any decision made after incurrence. Such costs are irrelevant for decision making. For
example, cost of a delivery van already acquired by the organization shall be irrelevant as
it cannot be changed by any course of action taken by management.
b) Marginal cost: is the additional cost of producing an extra unit of output.
c) Opportunity cost: is defined as the cost of the next best foregone alternative or the
potential benefit that is lost by taking one course of action and giving up the other. For
instance, by deciding to take on a leave and forego wages, the opportunity cost of the
decision shall be the foregone wages.
d) Differential cost/incremental cost: these are costs that differ among alternatives.
They are costs relevant for decision making. They may be either variable or fixed. For
instance, if taking up a different business apartment amounts to an extra Shs2,000 rent
expense, the differential (incremental) cost of the decision shall be the Sh.2,000.
e) Imputed cost
Is an expense not incurred directly, but actually borne e.g example, a person who owns a
home debt-free has an imputed rent expense equal to the amount of interest that could be
earned on the proceeds from the sale of the home if the home weresold.
f) Replacement cost
The amount it would cost to replace an asset at current prices. If the cost of replacing an
asset in its current physical condition is lower than the cost of replacing the asset so as to
obtain the level of services enjoyed when the asset was bought, then the asset is in poor
condition and the firm would probably not want to replace it
g) Standard cost
A management tool used to estimate the overall cost of production, assuming normal
operations.
h) Budgeted cost
This is the cost estimated to be incurred and used for budgeting purposes. It is a cost
included in the budget representing cost expected. Most of the times, budgeted cost will
be derived from standard cost.
COST ESTIMATION
A cost estimate is the approximation of the cost of a program, project, or operation. The cost
estimate is the product of the cost estimating process. The cost estimate has a single total value
and may have identifiable component values. A problem with a cost overruncan be avoided with
a credible, reliable, and accurate cost estimate. An estimator is the professional who prepares
cost estimates.
Cost estimation methods are necessary only for costs that are identified as mixed costs. There is
no need to apply an estimation method to break a cost into fixed and variable portions if you
have already determined it is solely fixed or solely variable. All four methods produce estimates
of amounts of fixed and variable costs.
Recall that the = + is the equivalent equation used in accounting for estimating
costs. The total cost side of the equation (Y) can also be expressed as f(x) so that the formula
appears as:
( ) = +
1. ENGINEERING METHOD
The Engineering Cost Estimating method builds the overall cost estimate by summing detailed
estimates done at lower levels of the Work Breakdown Structure (WBS). It’s a technique where
the system being costed is broken down into lower-level components (such as parts or
assemblies), each of which is costed separately for direct labor, direct material, and other costs.
Engineering estimates for direct labor hours may be based on analyses of engineering drawings
and contractor or industry-wide standards.
Engineering estimates for direct material may be based on discrete raw material and purchase
part requirements. The remaining elements of cost (such as quality control or various overhead
charges) may be factored from the direct labor and material costs. The various discrete cost
estimates are aggregated by simple algebraic equations (hence the common name “bottoms-up”
Because of the high level of detail, each step of the work flow should be identified, measured,
and tracked, and the results for each outcome should be summed to make the point estimate.
The estimator’s ability to determine exactly what the estimate includes and whether
anything was overlooked,
Its unique application to the specific program and manufacturer,
That it gives good insight into major cost contributors, and
Easy transfer of results to other programs.
2. ACCOUNT ANALYSIS
Under account analysis method, the accountant examines and classifies each ledger account as
variable, fixed or mixed. Mixed accounts are broken down into their variable and fixed
components. They base these classifications on experience, inspection of cost behavior for
several past periods or intuitive feelings of the manager.
Illustration
Suppose a company ABC has the following costs with a value of 7000 units.
Amount Variable Fixed
Direct labour 150,000 150,000 -
Materials 125,000 125,000 -
Repairs and maintenance 5,000 5,000 -
Depreciation 15,000 - 15,000
Administration 1,000 - 1,000
overheads 4,000 - 4,000
Indirect labour 300,000 280,000 20,000
Solution
,
Variable cost b = =Shs 40
,
a = shs 20,000
Y= 20,000 + 40(1,400)
Shs. 76,000
Illustration
In the year 2012 VIP incurred the following expenses to maintain 1500 lecturers.
Sh
Administration expenses (40% variable) 4,000,000
Lecturing pay (60% variable) 8,000,000
Airtime allowance (fixed) 1,000,000
Sundry expenses (50% fixed) 500,000
Soda allowance (variable) 300,000
Required;-
a) Using accounts analysis method, express an equation in form y = a + bx
b) Using the equation expressed above, estimate the total cost of 2000 lecturers incurred to be
employed in 2013.
Solution
Total cost Variable Fixed
Administration expenses 4,000,000 1,600,000 2,400,000
Lecturing pay 8,000,000 4,800,000 3,200,000
Airtime allowance 1,000,000 - 1,000,000
Sundry expenses 500,000 250,000 250,000
Soda allowance 300,000 300,000 ______
6,950,000 6,850,000
, ,
b= = 4633.33 a = 6,850,000
In this method the highest and lowest activity together with their corresponding costs is
identified. The two points i.e. the lowest and the highest are used to derive a cost function in the
form of
= +
This method is based on an analysis of historical information of costs at different activity levels.
The high-low method finds the equation of the straight line joining the two points corresponding
to the highest and lowest activity levels. What we need to do is to separately identify the fixed
and variable cost elements so that each can be predicted for anticipated future activity levels.
The variable cost is estimated by calculating the average unit cost between the highest and
lowest volumes and the fixed and total cost function can then be derived.
For example, if the costs of producing the highest and lowest levels of production (10 units and
12 units) are shs.30 and shs.35 respectively then the variable costs per unit are sh. 5/2 units or sh.
2.50. The fixed costs are thus £5 and the total cost = sh.5 + sh. 2.50x where x = production level.
Illustration
Production Total cost
(units) sh.
High 120 3,500
Low 100 3,000
Change 20 500
.
Variable cost = = sh.25 per unit
Limitations
The limitations of the high-low method are as follows
Its reliance on historical data, assuming that (i) activity is the only factor affecting cost and
(ii) historical costs reliably predict future costs.
The use of only two values, the highest and the lowest, means that the results may be
distorted because of random variations in these values.
www.someakenya.com Contact: 0707 737 890 Page 38
4. THE SCATTER GRAPH METHOD
For this method a scatter diagram is constructed which is used to visually i.e. by inspection
deduce a relationship from observed pattern if there is any. By obtaining any two points on
constructed graph, we can fit a straight line if the pattern suggests a linear relationship.
Y
- Non-linear relationship
x x x x - Quadratic since has one
x x
x x x turning point
x x xx x
x x x x
x
x x
Sh.
1800 -
1600 -
1400 -
x x
1200 - x x x
1000 - x x x
x x
x x
800 - x x x
x
600 -
400 -
200 -
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110
Units of output
The dotted line is drawn to show the intersection with the vertical axis and thus gives an estimate
of the fixed content of the cost being considered, in this case 6400. The slope of the line, i.e. the
variable element, is found as follows:
Therefore the estimate cost function = sh. 400 + 8.5x where x = units of output, i.e. the
independent variable.
The graphical method is simple to use and provides a visual indication of approximate cost
behavior. Because each individual is likely to draw a different line with a different slope the
method is subjective and approximate. A more objective and accurate approach is to calculate
the line of best fit mathematically using the least squares method.
Regression analysis is a technique that uses a statistical model to measure the amount of change
in one variable (dependent variable) that is associated with changes in amounts of one or more
variables.
This method is used to determine the equation of the line of best fit by minimizing the sum of the
squares of the vertical
When it has been established that a causal relationship exists in the data and that a linear function
is appropriate the statistical technique known as least squares is frequently used to establish
values for the coefficients a and b (representing fixed and variable cost respectively) in the linear
cost function.
= +
y n a b x............................................(i)
2
x y a x b x ...................................(ii)
ii) In the formulas below
b
n xy x y
a
y b x _ _
or a y b x
n x 2 ( x ) 2 n
Where y is total cost – the dependent variable and x is the agreed measure of activity – the
independent variable
1. It is objectively determined.
2. It makes use of all the data or observations
3. It minimizes the sum of squares of the error terms
4. If there is a linear relationship between the dependent and independent variable, this
method gives the best predictions within the relevant range.
Illustration
The following table shows the number of units of a good produced and the total costs incurred.
Units produced Total costs
100 40,000
200 45,000
300 50,000
400 65,000
500 70,000
600 70,000
700 80,000
Solution
Step 1:
Tabulate the data and determine which is the dependent variable, y, and which the independent x.
Step 2:
Calculate∑ , ∑ , ∑ , ∑ (leave room for a column for ∑ which may well be needed
subsequently)
The calculation is set out as follows, where x is the activity level in units of hundreds and y is the
cost in units of sh.1, 000.
x y xy x2
1 40 40 1
2 45 90 4
3 50 150 9
4 65 260 16
5 70 350 25
6 70 420 36
7 80 560 49
28 420 1,870 140 n=7
∑ ∑ ∑
b= ∑ (∑ )
Try to avoid rounding at this stage since, although n ∑ are large, their difference is much
smaller.
( , ) ( ) , , ,
= ( ) (
= = = 6.79
)
∑ ∑
a = – = – 6.79 = 60 – 27.16= 32.84
This line would be used to estimate the total costs for a given level of output. If, say, 250 units
were made we can predict the expected yield by using the regression line where x = 2.5.
In the previous example, having found the equation of the line of best fit, we used this to forecast
the total cost for a given level of activity.
The validity of such forecasts will be dependent upon two main factors.
Whether there is sufficient correlation between the variables to support a linear
relationship within the range of the data used.
Whether the forecast represents an interpolation or an extrapolation
Illustration
The following data have been collected on costs and output:
Output (000s) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Costs (sh.000s) 14 17 15 23 18 22 31
Required;-
Calculate the coefficients in the linear cost function.
y = a + bx
Using
i) The Normal Equation and (ii) the coefficient formulae
Solution
Output (x) Costs (y) Xy x2
1 14 14 1
2 17 34 4
3 15 45 9
4 23 92 16
5 18 90 25
6 22 132 36
7 31 217 49
Σx = 28 Σy = 140 Σxy = 624 Σx2 = 140
∴ b = 2.286 and, substituting this value in one of the equations, the value of a is found to
be 10.86
( ) ( )
a= = 10.86
( )
( ) ( )
b= = 2.286
( )
When the coefficients have been calculated the cost function can be used for forecasting simply
by inserting the appropriate level of activity i.e. a value for x, and calculating the resulting total
cost.
For example, what are the predicted costs at output levels of:
Note: A prediction within the range of the original observations (1 to 7 in Example 1) is known
as an interpolation.
QUESTION ONE
The management of Limuru Processing Company Limited wishes to obtain better cost estimates
to evaluate the company’s operations more effectively.
Additional information:
1. In November, the opening work in progress inventory contained 1,000,000 units that were
30% complete with respect to conversion costs.
2. During the same month of November, the manufacturing department transferred 1,500,000
units.
3. The closing inventory for the month of November was 1,200,000 units and the units were
305 incomplete with respect to conversion costs
4. Using the above information, you have obtained the following variables by applying simple
regression analysis.
Sh. ‘000’
Constant 3,709
Slope 6,487
Required:
i) Use the high-low method to estimate the overhead cost function.
ii) Use the regression method to determine the overhead cost function.
Solution:
i) Use the high-low method to estimate the overhead cost function
Y = a + bx whereb = 7.16
Y = 15,280
Therefore 15,280 = a + 7.16 x 1690
a = 15,280 – (7.16 x 1690)
a = 3180
Therefore y = 3,180,000 + 7160x
ii) Use the regression method – determine the overhead cost function
y = a + bx where a = 3,709,000
b = 6487
Therefore y = 3,709,000 + 6487x
Completion % Conversion
Opening stock (WIP) 1,000,000 70 700,000
Completely processed during production 500,000 100 500,000
Closing stock (WIP) 1,200,000 1,199,695
Equivalent units with respect to conversion costs 2,399,695
The annual total and monthly average figures for the year ended 30 June 2003 were as
follows:
Required:
(i) Using the high-low method, estimate and interpret the fixed and variable cost elements of
the fuel oil expense.
(ii) Using the results in (i) above, predict the fuel oil expense for November 2004 if
experience indicates that 41,000 machine hours will be used.
(iii) Briefly explain any two limitations of High-low method of cost estimation that may be
overcome by using simple linear regression analysis.
The total fuel consumption will thereafter vary at the rate of Sh.8.182 for each machine hour
usage.
(ii) Fuel expense in November, 2004
= 287,264 + 8.182 x 41,000
= Sh.622,726
(iii) Limitations of high-low method
Relies only on two data points – highest and lowest which may be outside and
therefore not representative of the entire data set.
The method does not use robust statistical techniques, to measure the predictive
quality of the resultant function.
COST ACCUMULATION
DEFINITION
Cost accumulation is the use of an accounting system to collect and maintain a database of the
expenses incurred by a business in the course of its operation.
MATERIAL COSTING
Inventory consists of raw materials, W.I.P, consumer goods and spare parts etc.
Material costing entails the study of the inventory control systems of the items.
Stock costs
i) Purchase costs
Actual amount paid to the supplier of the stock item.
This levels will help determine when the order, how much to order, the quantity to be held.
These levels include:-
This is the amount that will be consumed during the time for waiting for deliveries. It should
satisfy the highest demand.
Maximum Stock level = Reorder level + Qty. demanded – (Min stock ×Min. lead-time)
= 1,400,000 + 5,000 – (50,000 ×3)
= 1,381,000 units
STOCK VALUATION
In a period stocks are normally purchased at different price and for product costing purposes and
profit determination stock have to be appropriately valued. This is because when stocks are
transferred to the stores they loss their identity and the issue price may not be accurately
determined because they are many in the store.
To enhance accuracy each stock item must have its own stock record where the transactions will
be recorded. There are several methods which can be used to maintain records for valuation
purposes. These methods have been discussed below.
The cost accountant of NyaliMbali Ltd decided he would apply first-in-first-out basis.
Required:
(i) A stores ledger account using first-in-first-out method and showing stock values at 30
September 2000.
Year Units Cost/ Value Unit Cost/ Value Units Cost/ Value
2000 unit (Shs) unit (Shs) unit (Shs)
27,000 4,015,000
21,000 - 3,465,000
31,000 5,905,000
Illustration
The following information relates to item P003 stocked by 2000 products Ltd for the month of
April 2012:
Receipts Issues
Date Units Units Unit cost (Sh)
April3 2,400 18
4 3,200
6 2,600 20
12 2,700
14 3,000 22
18 2,800 21
20 2,200
22 2,600 23
25 3,800
26 3,100 24
27 2,500 25
28 3,200 26
29 6,900
The closing balance for March 2012 was a batch of 3,000 units received at a unit price of Sh 19.
Solution
(a)
4 - - - 2,400 18 43,200
800 19 15,200
3,200 58,400 2,200 19 41,800
6 2,600 20 52,000 - - - 2,600 20 52,000
4,800 93,800
12 - - - 2,600 20 52,000
100 19 1,900
53,900 2,100 19 39,900
14 3,000 22 66,000 - - - 3,000 22 66,000
5,100 105,900
25 - - - 2,600 23 59,800
600 21 12,600
600 22 13,200
3,800 85,600 4,500 - 92,700
26 3,100 24 74,400 - - - 7,600 167,100
29 - - - 3,200 26 83,200
2,500 25 62,500
1,200 24 28,800
6,900 174,500 6,400 - 138,300
3) Weighted Average
Under this method the price of material issued is determine by computing the average price
of all items held in stock.
The quantity for each batch are considered when calculating the average price, the average
price is calculated by dividing the total cost of stock items held by the total quantities
available.
Illustration
NyaliMbali Ltd. are retailers who sell ceramic tiles. During the months of July to September
2000, there were price fluctuations. Due to the above problem the company had to adjust its
selling prices.
The following transactions took place during the period.
3 July Opening stock was 5,000 tiles valued at Sh 825,000.
10 July Orders placed with the company increased, so extra tiles had to be obtained from
Mombasa. Therefore 22,000 tiles were purchased at a cost Sh 140 each but in
addition there was a freight and insurance charge of Sh 5 per tile.
31 July During the month 20,0000 tiles were sold at a price of Sh 220 each.
4 August A new batch of 14,000 tiles was purchased at a cost of Sh 175 per tile.
30 August The sales for the month of August were 14,000 tiles at a selling price of Sh 230
each.
The cost accountant of NyaliMbali Ltd decided he would applyweighted average method
Required:
(i) A stores ledger account using weighted average method and showing stock values at 30
September 2000.
Solution
NyaliMbali Ltd
Stores Ledger Account for July to September 2000 (Using the Weighted Average
Approach)
Date RECEIPTS ISSUES BALANCES
Year Units Cost/ Value Unit Cost/ Value Units Cost/ Value
2000 unit (Shs) unit (Shs) unit (shs)
July 3 - - - - - - 5,000 165 825,000
July 10 22,000 145 3,190,000 - - - 22,000 145 3,190,000
27,000 149 4,015,000
July 31 - - - 20,000 149 2,974,074 7,000 149 1,040,926
ISSUES
January 9 800
February 14 800
February 17 600
March 9 400
March 28 800
Required;-
A stores ledger card using the simple average method
25
28
The opening balance was 2000 units valued at sh.80 per unit
Required
Stores ledger card using standard price method if the standard issue price is sh.95
Solution
Date RECEIP ISSUE BALANC
January Quantit T Amoun Quantit Cost/Un Amoun E Amount
1 y Cost/Unit t y it t Quantity 160000
2 - - - - - - 2000 576000
6 5200 80 416000 - - - 7200 120000
9 - - - 4800 95 456000 2400 561600
15 4800 92 441600 - - - 7200 219600
16 - - - 3600 95 342000 3600 565200
17 3600 96 345600 - - - 7200 291600
19 - - - 2880 95 273600 4320 109200
23 - - - 1920 95 182400 2400 608400
25 4800 104 499200 - - - 7200 433600
27 - - - 1840 95 174800 5360 739200
31 3200 108 345600 - - - 8560 209200
- - - 6000 95 570000 2560
1) Carriage Inwards
The cost of stock includes the purchases cost plus any other incidental cost incurred to bring
stock to their current or saleable state which includes insurance of goods in transit.
3) Losses
Stock losses if identified after stock counts should be adjusted so that the a/c reflects the
actual quantity losses will be recorded on the issue column and valued consistently with the
method in use.
Basic Terminology
Brief definitions of common inventory control terms are given below
a) Lead or procurement time. The period of time, expressed in days, weeks, months, etc.
between ordering (either externally or internally) and replenishment, i.e. when the goods are
available for use.
b) Demand. The amount required by sales, production, etc. Usually expressed as a rate of
demand per week, months or year. Estimates of the rate of demand during the lead time are
critical factors in inventory control systems.
Slope indicates
AverageMaximum
Anticipated Rates
Reorder level of Demand
(700 units)
800 -
Reorder
700 -
Quantity
(usu. EOQ)
600 -
In this case
Stock level
400 -
300 -
200 -
100 - Safety Lead Time
stock (5 wks)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
Time (in days or week etc)
Illustration
A simple manual reorder system illustrated.
The following data relate to a particular stock item.
Normal usage 110 per day
Minimum usage 50 per day
Maximum usage 140 per day
Lead time 25-30 days
EOQ (Previously calculated) 5000
Required;
Calculate various control levels
Solution
Using this data the various control levels can be calculated
Re-order Level = Maximum Usage ×Maximum Lead Time
= 140 × 3
= 4,200 units
Minimum Level = Re-order Level – Average Usage for Average Lead Time
= 4.200 – (110 × 27.5)
= 1,175 units
NB: purchase cost is part of inventory cost. However under EOQ purchase price is assumed to be
constant irrespective of quantity ordered.
It is also assumed that the company will not experience stock out therefore the purchase cost and
stock-out will be ignored under EOQ
NOTE:
a) It will be apparent that the above assumptions are somewhat sweeping and they are good
reason for treating any EOQ calculation with caution.
b) The rationale of EOQ ignores buffer stocks which are maintained to cater for variations in
lead time and demand.
a) Graphic method
Total costs
Holding cost
TC Cost
Ordering cost
b) Calculus approach
Total cost = ordering cost + purchase costs + holding costs
TC = 0+ +
FOC = − = =0
1
=
2
.
Q2 =
SOC = =
But D, Co, Q ≥ 0
Thus > 0 (+ve)
TC is minimized when
Q=
Illustration
A company uses 50,000 widgets per annum which are sh.10 each to purchase. The ordering and
handling costs are sh.150 per order and carrying costs are 15% of purchase price per annum, i.e.
it costs sh.1.50 p.a. to carry a widget in stock (sh.10 x 15%).
To graph the various costs involved the following steps are necessary:
Where
Total Costs per annum = Ordering Cost per annum + Carrying Cost per annum.
Where
Ordering cost per annum = No. of orders ×sh. 1.50
No. of orders =
,
No. of orders = = 10
,
And
Carrying cost per annum = average stock level × sh. 15
Average stock level =
Based on the above principles, the following table gives the cost for various order quantities.
Column I II III IV V VI
Order Average Annual Average Stock Holding Total Stock
Quantity No. of Ordering Cost Stock Cost p.a.
orders
p.a.
50000 Col. II x sh,150 Col. I Col. IV x £1.5 Cols III + V
Col. I Sh. 2 Sh. Sh.
We have Co = sh. 150; D = 50,000 widgets; Cc = sh. 10 x 15% = sh. 1.50 per widget.
,
This gives EOQ =
.
= √10,000
= 3162 widgets.
9000 -
8000 -
7000 -
6000 -
Total Cost
5000 - (Col VI)
costs
0-
1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000
EOQ Order size
Notes:
a) From a graph closer accuracy is not possible and is unnecessary anyway.
b) It will be seen from the graph that the bottom of the total cost curve is relatively flat,
indicating that the exact value of the EOQ is not too critical.
Illustration
A company had annual demand of 800,000 units the purchase per unit is 80 while the cost of
pressing are order is Sh.4,000. The annual inventory holding cost is 5% of the inventory value.
Currently the company has been purchasing 20000 units time, they place an order.
Required;
i) Calculate the total cost of current inventory policy
ii) Calculate the EOQ
iii) Calculate the cost savings if the company adopts EOQ policy
D Q
TC Co DC ch stockout cos t
Q 2
800,000 80,000
x 4000 x5% x80 800,000x80
80,000 2
= Sh40,000
A company may qualify for quantity discounts if it purchases stock items in bulk. This will have
an effect of rendering the effective purchase cost.
In determining whether the company should take advantage of quantity discount we compare the
total cost of using the E.O.Q without discount and the total cost after taking the advantage of
discount.
A particularly unrealistic assumption with the basic EOQ calculation is that the price per item
remains constant. Usually some form of discount can be obtained by ordering increased
quantities. Such price-discounts can be incorporated into the EOQ formula, but it becomes much
more complicated. A simpler approach is to consider the costs associated with the normal EOQ
and compare these costs with the costs at each succeeding discount point and so ascertain the
best quantity to order.
Adverse Effects
a) Increased costs arise from the extra stockholding costs caused by the average stock level
being higher due to the larger order quantity.
Illustration
Required;
Step I
Determine the best inventory for these items.
√2Dco
=
Ch
20
ℎ = x 5000 = 1000
100
√2 x 400 x 2000
. . = = 40 Units
1000
. = + 2 + ℎ
2
Step II
Step III
Recommendation – The Company should take advantage of the discount.
Illustration
Bora Supermarket carries on its operation in Nakuru Town. On annual basis, it orders 480,000
pens from a Nairobi based distributor. A packet of twenty four pens delivered to Bora’s
warehouse costs Sh.480 including transport charges. The supermarket borrows money from BCD
Bank at an interest rate of 10% per annum to finance its inventories.
The supermarket also incurs Sh.1,500 to place an order for the pens and Sh.8 carrying costs for
each pen
Required:
i) Economic order quantity (EOQ) for the pens.
ii) Total costs at the economic order quantity.
iii) For orders of 72,000 pens and above, the distributor has offered a discount rate of 10% on
the delivery price
Advise the management of the supermarket on whether to take advantage of the discount offer.
i) D = 480,000 pens
C= = 20
Co = 1500
√2Dco
=
Ch
2 × 480,000 × 1500
. . = = 1,200 Units
10
480,000 1200 × 10
E.O.Q= 48,000 × 20 + × 1,500 +
12 2
= Sh 9,720,000
P = 0.9 ×20 = 18
D = 480,000
C = 18
Q = 7,200
Ch. = 8 + (10% x 18) = 9.8
The company should take advantage of the discount because is more economical
So far it has been assumed that the demand and the lead time have been known with certainty. In
such circumstances the re-order level is the rate of demand times the lead time.
This means that regardless of the length of the lead time or of the rate of demand no buffer stock
is necessary when there are conditions of certainty.
Reorder Level
Stock Level
Illustration
An electrical company uses a particular type of thermostat which costs £5. The demand averages
800 p. a. and the EOQ has been calculated at 200. Holding costs are 20% p.a. and stock out costs
From the above the re-order level and safety stock should be calculated
Solution
Using the mid- point of each group calculate the average usage in the lead time.
x t tx
27 1 27
32 8 256
37 10 370
42 12 504
47 9 423
52 5 260
57 5 285
50 2,125
This is a model for manufacturing firms which produces component for use in the production of
a finished product.
The production technology is such that the production rate of the component is higher than the
usage rate. The balance of stock at the end of each day is put in storage facilities and it assumed
to the max. Stock level at the end of the production
The components are these produced in batches. Production stop for some time then started again
hence forth.
EBQ is the quantity to be produced per production run in order to minimize total cost model
policy variables include:-
Derivation of EBQ
Let R = set up costs per set up
S = Set up cost per set up
Ch = Ci
Q = economic batch quantity
P = production rate in units per day or any other period
U = usage rate in units per day or any other period
d = Length of production run in days or any other period
B = Length of the break between production runs
Then:
TC = Total variable production costs + set up costs + holding costs
TC = RC + + Average inventory x Cl
FOC = + 1− =0
= 1− =
Q2 =
EBQ =
Illustration
ABC Ltd manufactures components X for use in an assembly the usage rate of the component is
lower than the production rate.
The following data has been used for the components.
Production rate = 4000 Units per day
Usage rate = 1200 unit
Inventory holding cases = Sh. 20 @ unit @ annum
Unit variable production costs = Sh. 2000
Set-up cost = Sh. 110,000
Acquisition lead time = 10 Working days
Days in a year = 250 working days
Required;-
Formulate the best inventory policy for component X
Solution
Inventory Policy
, ,
1) EBQ = = = Sh 68,660.65 Units
,
4) Length of break = = = 29
,
68,660 1,200
= (300,000 110) + (20 × ) + 20 1 −
2 4,000
=Sh33,686,614
Assumption of EBQ
BACK FLUSH
Basically, back flush accounting is when you wait until the manufacture of a product has been
completed, and then record all of the related issuances of inventory from stock that were required
to create the product. This approach has the advantage of avoiding all manual assignments of
costs to products during the various production stages, thereby eliminating a large number of
transactions and the associated clerical labor.
Back flush accounting is entirely automated, with a computer handling all transactions. The back
flushing formula is:
Number of units produced × unit count listed in the bill of materials for each component
= Number of raw material units removed from stock
Back flushing is not suitable for long production processes, since it takes too long for the
inventory records to be reduced after the eventual completion of products. It is also not suitable
Labour costing
Entails analysis of labour related costs, labour remuneration, and recording of labour costs to
products
It entails an analysis of the cost of purchasing labour hours and employees services rendered to
an organisation and other cost related to labour. Categories include:-
i. Direct labour
ii. Indirect labour
Direct labour
Refers to employees engaged in the production process and are the ones who make the products.
Their cost form part of direct cost of production e.g. machine operators in a factory etc.
Indirect labour
Refers to employees not engaged in direct production, they support the process. Their costs do
not form part of labour cost of production and treated as production overhead e.g. indirect
employees in the office.
1. Basic wage
Basic wages is the amount contracted for. There are various methods by which basic wages can
be paid out.
They include
(a) Fixed rate or fixed salary per month or per annum
Here, the employees earn a fixed amount despite the amount of work done. For instance, a
production manager may be allowed a salary of Shs500,000 per month, whether the company
production is at peak or off-peak.
(b) Piece rate or piece work
Under this method, the earnings depend on the level of activity or output achieved and it is
expressed as Earnings = Output (units) x basic rate per unit
Under the piece rate system, there are three schemes of remuneration. These are straight piece
rate, straight piece rate with a guaranteed minimum pay and a differential piece rate.
i) Differential piece rate
ii) Straight piece rate with a guaranteed minimum pay
iii) Straight piece rate
2. Time keeping
A labour cost control routine should ensure that payments are paid only to employees who have
spent time at the work place and that payments are at agreed rates of pay including overtime
premium and shift premium payments where relevant. Where an employee is paid a fixed sum
for an agreed length of working week, it may be decided by a check by the supervisor that the
employee is at work is all that is necessary.
3. Time analysis
This is usually achieved by having the employee complete a daily or weekly timesheet or by
having job cards or piecework tickets. Where time sheets are issued, the employee records the
time analysis stating how much time was spent on each job and recording idle time. This sheet
will then be authorized by the supervisor. Job cards move with a job as it passes from one
employee to another.
There may be time clocks at each work center where the time spent on the job is recorded.
Where this routine is used, employees may also be required to clock idle time on an idle time
card, which will be analyzed to determine the cause of idle time. Where payments are made in
return for output units, piecework tickets may be completed which are signed by the supervisor
certifying the number of units claimed. The analysis of employee time will facilitate:
Correct charge of direct labour cost to each job
Correct charge of indirect labour cost to cost centers
Control of labour costs by job and cost center
Calculation of employee bonus
Measurement of efficiency
Suppose a worker falls in the 96% to 100% bracket, the actual amount of wages to be paid to him
is Shs.60,000. The challenge here is that some employees may be more or less efficient than
graded. Does the company still pay them the same amount as indicated in the efficiencytable?
This calls for a consistent review of the employees’ efficiency and remuneration scheme.
Where, for instance, an employee has performed more efficiently, the company may pay an
excess amount based on the evaluation. Assuming the employee in the same bracket as
aboveachieves 104% efficiency, the company may decide to pay him/her the basic amount plus
an extra amount based on evaluationi.e
= Shs.60,000 + ×10,000
= Shs.60,000 + 8,000
= Shs.68,000
Illustration
Patanisho Quarry Ltd remunerates its casual workers based on each day’s work. Workers are
graded into various efficiency bands after training and then paid a fixed sum according to
efficiency bands as follows.
Additional information;
1. Workers are guaranteed of their fixed pay within their efficiency bands irrespective of the
output achieved.
2. A wage rate of Sh. 700 per week is paid for efficiency levels below 81%.
3. Any excess units of production beyond the upper efficiency band limit are paid at Sh. 5 per
unit.
4. A 100% efficiency level repressing 1,200 units per week.
5. The data for a four-week period for three workers in a given time was as follows:
Weeks
Worker Efficiency band 1 2 3 4
% Units Units Units Units
1 81-90 1,210 860 1,280 1,330
2 101-110 1,220 1,240 1,190 1,250
3 11-120 1,500 1,540 1,390 1,460
Required;
Total earnings for each of the three workers for the four-week period
1,200
× 110
111 – 120 1,100 100 1,440
1,200
× 80
100
2)
Week 1 Week 2 Week 3 Week 4 Total
Bonus Bonus Bonus Bonus
W1 81-90 1,210-1,080 = - 1,280- 1,330 – 1,080
130 - 1,080 250 × 5
130×5 - 200 ×5 1,250 3,900
W2: 101 - 650 0 1,000 0
110 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
0 1,540- 0 1,460-1,440
W3: 111-120 1,500 – 1,440 1,440 - 20×5
60×5 100×5 - 100 900
300 500 -
Total earnings = Basic Wage + Bonus
Worker 1 = [(800 x 3) + 700] + 3,900 = shs .6, 000
Worker 2 = (1,000 x 3) + 900 = shs. 3,900
Worker 3 = (1,100 x 4) + 900 = shs .5,300
5. Overtime Premium
This is the compensation paid to employees in addition to normal wages for hours worked in
excess of normal working hours. The overtime is that time paid for over and above the basic
NB: Overtime cost by abnormal conditions e.g. shortage of materials, machine breakdown is at
premium should be expensed transferred to P& L statement
6. Shift Premium
Additional amount paid to an employee for working in a different shift i.e. working night shift
instead of day shift.
It is treated as indirect wage and transferred to over debt cost.
Illustration
Zawadi Ltd is a small company which manufactures a range of plastic commodities.
In order to manufacture a lunch box, the following five manual processes are required:
Process Time required per lunch Wage rate per hour(sh.)
box
1 Minutes 65
2 15 50
3 25 40
4 10 35
5 30 30
20
The weekly production target is 7,200 lunch boxes packed in cartons each containing twelve
lunch boxes.
The company’s working week has 40 hours.
Required;-
1. Number of casual workers required for each of the processes
2. Labour cost incurred per week to manufacture 7,200 lunch boxes.
Solution
(i) Number of casual workers required for each processes.
1. 15 × 7200 = 108000 Min = 1800hrs
60
= 45 workers
= 3600
40 = 90 workers
LABOUR TURNOVER
It is the number of employees leaving or being recruited in a period of time. It is expressed as a
percentage of the total labour force. It is expressed as;
Causes of labour turnover; these causes outline the reasons why an employee may leave an
organization. They include
Illness and accidents
Retirement and death
Rate of payment; the employee may find that the remuneration is not commensurate tothe
amount of work done
Poor working relationship between the management and the employee
Lack of opportunity for career or lack of job satisfaction
Replacement costsare costs incurred as a result of hiring a new employee. They include cost of
selection and placement (advertising and interviewing), inefficiencies in new labour, lower
productivity, cost of training, loss of output due to delay in new labour becoming available,
increased wastage and spoilage due to lack of expertise among the new staff, possibility of more
frequent accidents, cost of tools and machine breakages.
Preventive costsare costs incurred in order to prevent employees from leaving an organization.
They include cost of personnel administration in maintaining good relationships and cost of
welfare, services and pension schemes.
INCENTIVE SCHEMES
Employees do not put extra efforts if there is no reward for their efforts. Employers reward
workers in a direct proportion to work accomplished.
In these schemes, workers can earn more if they produce more out and therefore get incentives to
make them produce more.
Grouped into the following categories
1) Direct financial plans
2) Indirect financial plans
3) Plans other than financial
Rowan scheme
a) DavidRowan of Glasgow (U.S.A) introduced the scheme, under which time wage is
guaranteed as in the case of Halsey scheme. For the performance of a job, standard time is
fixed; otherwise operation or task is exactly in the same manner as in the case of Halsey
scheme. For the hours of his actual work, the worker gets his time wage; on this point also it
Advantages
a) Because the premium is proportionate to the time saved, if the rate has been wrongly fixed,
the effect will be less serious. So Rowan scheme is safer than the Halsey scheme, as far as
the point of view of employer is concerned.
b) The worker is in the most advantageous position when 50% of the time allowed is saved by
him, because otherwise his earning per hour will increase at a diminishing rate, if any more
time is saved by him. As a result, the chances of wastage, defectives, breakdown etc. will be
less as there is a limit to speed.
c) Fixed overhead per unit will be lower as a result of higher output.
d) Since both the employer & the employee enjoys the time saved; though proportion is not the
same as in the case of the Halsey scheme, to some extent labour cost also diminishes.
e) Better wage is earned by the employees; their improvement in efficiency is rewarded.
Disadvantages
a) The workers do not like the idea of sharing the savings by both employer & employee, since
the time is saved by the workers.The bonus hours will not exceed the 25% of the time
allowed in any case.
b) Apart from workers efficiency, saving of time depends upon standard of tools, materials &
implements & also upon the working conditions. No useful purpose will be served unless the
best of these are assured.
Illustration
Mr. A is being paid sh.9 per hour. The time allowed to complete a task is 12 hours. The actual
time taken by Mr. A to complete the task is only 8 hours
Solution
Mr. A’s gross pay
= (8 hours × sh.9) + (Time taken/Time allowed ×Time saved ×Rate per hour)
= (8 hours×sh.9) + (67% × 4 hours × sh.9)
= sh.96.12
The total earning is obtained by multiplying the sum of time allowed & time taken by half the
hourly rate.
Advantages:
a) The scheme & the calculation of the remuneration are easily understandable by the worker.
b) As time wage is guaranteed, penalty is not imposed on the slow workers; whereas rewards
are provided to the slow workers for their efficiency.
c) The workers are encouraged to save as much time as possible due to the bonus, because for
the higher time saved bonus will be higher.
d) Employers are enabled to obtain more output from the workers under the scheme, & as a
result of that, per unit fixed overhead get diminished.
ILLUSTRATION
Employees Adam Smith and John are each assigned a job and they each take 3, 2.5 and 2 hours
respectively to complete the job. The time rate is sh.40 per hour and the time allowed for each
job is 3 hours.
Required
a) Using the Halsey plan calculate the total earnings of each employee
b) Calculate the effective hourly rate of pay
Solution
a)
Adam Smith John
Time allowed 3 3 3
Time taken 3 2.5 2
Time saved - 0.5 1
Illustration
Calculate the total earnings of a worker & the effectively rate of labour wages per hour where
payment of bonus is under (a) the Halsey (50%) scheme & (b) the Rowan scheme from the
below mentioned particulars:
Basic wage rate per hour – shs.10.80, Time allowed for the job – 48 hours, Actual time taken –
36 hours.
Solution
(a) Under Halsey (50%) Scheme
Shs.
Normal time wage = 36 hours @ shs.10.80 = 388.80
Bonus = 50% of (Time saved×time rate) = 50% (12×10.80) 64.80
Total Wages 453.60
Alternatively
Total wages = (Time taken+50% of time saved) ×time rate
Illustration
40 hours is taken by a worker to do job for which time allowed is 50 hours. $. 1.25 per hour is
his daily rate. Calculate the works cost of the job under the following methods of payment of
wages:
(i) Time rate; (ii) Piece rate; (iii) Halsey plan &(iv) Rowan plan.
Additional information: (i) Material cost $.60; (ii) Factory overhead 125% of wages
i) Time Rate: Wages for 40 hours (actual time taken) @ shs. 1.25 = 50.00
ii) Piece Rate:Wages for 50 hours (time allowed for the job) @ shs. 1.25 = 62.50
iii) Halsey Plan:Normal time wage = 40 hours @ shs.1.25 = 50.00
Bonus=50% of (Time saved× Time rate) =50% of (10×1.25) = 6.25
Shs.56.25
=10/50×(40×1.25) = 10.00
Shs. 60.00
Illustration
A factory issues a job to two employees, Mark and Markus, paid at the rate of sh.210/hr. and
sh220/hr. respectively. Mark is issued with 400 containers and it takes twelve minutes to produce
each. Markus is issued with 240 containers and it takes nine minutes to produce e ach
For every hour saved a bonus is paid at the rate of 60% of bonus rat3e which is sh240/hr. The
factory works 42 hours week and overtime and overtime is paid at the rate of time and one third.
At the end of the week Mark band Markus clock cards shows 54 and 50 hours respectively and
the work complete. However Mark worked 4 hours on the indirect job given that week.
However, 40 and 60 containers of Mark and Markus fail to pass inspection due to faulty
materials. It was agreed to credit all output for bonus purposes.
Required;
i) Bonus due
ii) Total gross wage due
iii) Direct wages cost/containers passing inspection. Overtime is worked regularly
throughout the year as company policy due to labour shortage
Solution
Mark Markus
Expected units 400 640
Expected time 80hrs. 96hrs.
Amount payable Sh210 sh220
Actual hours 54 50
Time saved 26 46
i) Efficiency in production: when the volume of production is so important, the bonus incentive
scheme should reward higher producers i.e. should be based on output achieved.
ii) Effect on workers: the scheme should be designed to motivate the employees. It should be
simple and understood by those of average intelligence.
iii) Both the employer and the employees should share the gains in labour efficiency.
iv) This will motivate the employees to be more efficient since they benefit from the gains made.
v) The method of calculating the bonus should be known and acceptable to the employees
vi) The standard hours set should be achievable and realistic. When the standards are high then
the employees will not achieve them and the bonus will not be earned
Most of the firms aim at maximizing profits by minimizing costs, while optimizing on the
revenues received. Labour costs being a significant expense in the books of account must be
controlled in order to ensure that no overpayments are made and that only authorized payments
are effected.
i) Personnel department
ii) Production planning department
iii) Time keeping department
iv) Wages department
OVERHEAD COSTING
Overheads areany cost not directly attributed to any cost unit. They can’t be identified with any
particular cost unit. They are incurred for the benefit of cost providers.
They include indirect material cost e.g. fuel and lubricant for machine electronics for welding
etc.
Also indirect labour
Overheads may be divided into production overheads, administration overheads and selling and
distribution. With this, they may be charged to production cost centers i.e. making, finishing and
packing departments, service costs centers, for example, maintenance and power generation or
other non-production cost centers for example administration, selling and distribution.
Production overheads for instance, are added to the prime cost in order to obtain the total
production costs.
i) According to behaviour
Can be classified as semi-variable, fixed or semi-fixed costs, Purpose for this classification is for
decision making and cost control.
ii) According to function
This is classification depending with the purpose for which are referred. Is classified into number
of production overheads and none production overheads, administration and saving overheads,
The purpose for this class is to help for accounting of overhead cost costs for products cost
purpose.
Illustration
A company has the following costs
Overhead Amount (sh.)
Consumables Department P1 250,000
P2 150,000
S1 100,000
S2 50,000
Depreciation of factory 1,000,000
Supervision 1.5M
Depreciation of equipment 800,000
Canteen 900,000
Heat & Air Conditioning 500,000
Insurance of Equipment 200,000
Required
Calculate the amount that will be distributed to each department.
Solution
Overheads Basis Ratios Amount P1 P2 S1 S2
Consumables Allocation - 550,000 250,000 150,000 100,000 50,000
Depreciation Are occupied 3:4:2:1 1,000,000 400,000 400,000 200,000 100,000
of factory
No. of
Supervision Employees 2:2:1:1 1,500,000 500,000 500,000 250,000 250,000
Depreciation. Book value 6:5:2:1 800,000 243,857 285,714 114,265 37142
of equipment of Equipment
Number of
Canteen Employees. 2:2:2:1 900,000 300,000 300,000 130,000 150,000
Heating Area. 3:4:2:1 500,000 150,000 200,000 100,000 50,000
Insurance Book. Value 6:5:2:1 200,000 85,714 71429 28571 14286
of.
equipment
Apportionment is based on proportion of benefits received from service dpt. measured using the
following basis.
Illustration
MMC Ltd. produces machine parts on a job-order basis. Majority of the business contracts are
obtained through bidding. Business firms competing with MMC Ltd. bid full cost plus 20 per
cent mark up. Recently, with the expectation of increase in sales MMC Ltd. reduced its mark up
from 25 per cent to 20 per cent.
The company operates two support departments and two production departments. The budgeted
costs and the normal activity levels for each department are given below:
Support Departments Production Departments
Maintenance Power Grinding Assembly
Overhead costs (Shs.) 1,000,000 2,000,000 1,000,000 500,000
Number of employees 8 7 30 30
Maintenance hours 2,000 200 6,400 1,600
Machine hours - - 10,000 1,000
Labour hours - - 1,000 10,000
MMC Ltd. is preparing to bid for a contract, job K, that requires three machine hours per unit
produced in grinding and zero hours in assembly department. The expected prime costs per unit
are Shs. 670.
Required:
a) Allocate the support service costs to the production departments using the direct allocation
method.
b) Allocate the service costs to the production departments using the sequential allocation
method
Solution
(a) Overhead allocation (direct method)
Profit statement (absorption costing)
Production departments Support departments
Grinding Assembly Maintenance Power
Sh. Sh. Sh. Sh.
Direct costs 1,000,000 500,000 1,000,000 2,000,000
Maintenance 500,000 500,000 (1,000,000) -
Power 1,600,000 400,000 - (2,000,000)
3,100,000 1,400,000 - -
Repeated Distribution
This recognizes fully the reciprocal nature of service departments. It apportions the overhead
costs. It continuously reapportions a share of a service cost center to other service centers instead
of eliminating a center once its costs have been reapportioned.
The total overheads cost will be allocated on the basis of the total cost from the equation.
Total cost will be the allocated cost plus a share of other overheads of the other service
departments.
Total Overheads = Allocated Overheads + A share of overheads from service department.
Since total overheads are unknown the equation of total overheads will be formed and solved to
determine total overheads of service departments.
This method requires that the reciprocal nature of the service costs is expressed in a set of
simultaneous equations which are solved by matrix algebra
Let x = Total cost of the maintenance cost center
Let y = Total cost of the power generating cost center
Illustration
Bingwa Ltd. has three production departments and two service departments.
The following are the budgeted factory overheads for the year ended 31 December 2011:
Required:
Re-apportion the service department costs to the production departments using the simultaneous
equation method.
Solution
Re-apportioning the service department costs using the simultaneous method
S1 = 30,000 + 20% S2
S2 = 36,000 + 10% S1
36,000 = S2 -10% S1
30,000 = S1 -20%S2
36,000 = -10%S1 = S2
30,000 = S1 -20% S2
39,000 = 1.02S2
Therefore S2 =38,235
And S1 =37,647
Once overheads have been allocated, apportioned and reapportioned to product departments the
overheads will be charged to units or to products produced in that department. This is known as
recovery/application/absorption of overheads.
It is defined at charging of production overheads to units produced in a production department.
It involves two steps:
i) Computation of overheads rate (AR)
ii) Application of the rates to cost unit.
Certain limitations arise from use of actual data and therefore actual rates are not preferable. This
is due to:-
i) Actual data can only be compared at the end of the period delaying computation of the
product cost.
ii) Actual rates may vary from period to period making comparison to be difficult
iii) It causes delay in determination of selling prices
Units of output
Overheads are charged per unit produced. It is appropriate where similar products are produced.
It will not be preferred where products of different sizes or different qualities since they require
different resources.
Illustration
The following information was extracted from the books of ABC Ltd.
Budget A B
Machine hours 10,000 12,000
Output unit 1000 1500
Material cost 32,000 28,000
Labour cost 40,000 38,000
Labour hours 18,000 22,000
Budgeted overheads 36,000 42,000
Required
Calculate the overhead absorption rate of a department using
i) Direct labour hours
ii) Direct machine cost percentage
iii) Direct labour cost percentage
Solution
A B
= 50% = 63.4%
Prime cost = direct labour cost + direct mat. Cost
A = 40,000 + 32,000 = 72,000
B = 35,000 + 28,000 = 66,000
vi) OAR = Budgeted OH 36,000 42,000
Budgeted Output 1,000 1,500
=36 out unit =28
In order to determine the total cost of a product, the overheads are charged to the products on the
basis of the computed OAR.
The overheads charged to a cost unit will be the function of the OAR for the department and the
units of the base that a product requires.
Overhead charge or absorbed = OAR x Units of base/units
Overheads are absorbed using predetermined overhead absorption rate based on the budgeted
data at the beginning of the period.
Budgeted data may be different from actual at the end of the period i.e. the actual may be more
or less than the budget since budget is an estimate.
The difference between the actual and the budgeted data is known as over/under absorption of
overheads.
Over absorption arises where absorbed overheads to production is more than actual overheads.
This means that more overheads have been charged to production which results in overstatement
of cost of production as well as product cost.
Under absorption arises where absorbed overheads is less than actual overheads.
This means that production cost is understated as well as the production cost.
Illustration
Matatu Auto Spares Ltd. uses budgeted overhead rate in allocating overheads to individual job
orders on the basis of machine hours in department A and on the basis of direct labour cost for
department B.
The budgeted forecast for the six month period to June 2009 was as follows:
Department
A B
Material costs (Sh.) 100,000 80,000
Labour costs (Sh.) 80,000 120,000
Machine hours 10,000 30,000
Labour hours 40,000 30,000
Factory overheads (Sh.) 200,000 240,000
Required:
(i) The budgeted overhead rate for department A and department B.
(ii) The total overhead cost for Job B2.
(iii)The cost per unit for Job B2 given that the output is 10,000 units.
Solution
200,000
10,000
Shs 20/ machine hour
Department B
OAR =
ℎ
240,000/120,000
2 × 100% =200%
iii)The cost per unit for job B2 given that the output is 10,000 units
Cost Statement
Shs
Material cost (30,000 + 24,000 54,000
Labour cost (40,000 + 18,000) 58,000
112,000
Add overheads 84,000
Total Cost 196,000
,
= = = shs. 19.6 Per unit.
,
Others:
Electricity 1,250,000
Taxes 2,500,000
Insurance of machinery 375,000
Depreciation of machinery 3,750,000
Insurance of buildings 625,000
Salaries of the workers 2,000,000 10,500,000
2,9250,000
1. The following are additional information is available from books of Mjengo Ltd.
Required:
(a) Overheads analysis sheet.
(b) Reallocation of service department costs
(c) Overhead rates for each production department
Solution:
(a) Overhead analysis sheet
ABC is a costing method which recognizes that costs are incurred because of the activities which
take place within the organization and for each activity a cost driver may be identified.
Those costs which are driven or incurred by the same cost drivers are grouped together into cost
pools and the cost drivers are then used as a basis for charging the cost of each activity in the
product.
A cost pool is a collection of costs which may be charged to products by the use of a common
cost driver. A cost driver is any activity or activities, series of which take place within an
organization and which cause costs to be incurred. The essence of ABC is that activities are the
cost drivers, not products. Products do consume activities. If the cost of activities and their
The development of ABC has been a response to a change in the cost base of many
manufacturers over the last decades. In earlier times, most manufacturing was labour intensive.
The variable cost of direct labour greatly outweighed all other costs and the overheads were a
relatively small component of the total cost. Traditional absorption costing was accurate enough
in these circumstances. Nowadays, most manufacturing processes are automated. The fixed
overhead cost of depreciation is now an important component of the total cost. At the same time,
work forces have been greatly reduced. This means that the variable cost of direct labour is now
a much smaller proportion of the total cost. Traditional absorption costing has become inaccurate
as a result and misleading product costs have led to poor decision making.
ABC analyses costs as short-term variable cost and long-term variable costs. Short-term variable
costs equate with variable costs under the traditional absorption costing. These characteristics are
volume related and change proportionately with the volume of production. Long-term variable
costs are equivalent to fixed costs under traditional cost accounting. Under ABC, such costs do
vary with activity even though there is a time lag e.g. salaried production engineers will not be
immediately made redundant if the number of products decline but they may be if decline
continues.
Pure activity output volume – where the basic transactions of the activity are identical in terms
of their resource demands such as the purchasing of raw materials or a similar range of items.
Activity/output volume/complexity – where the basic transactions differ in terms of their
resource demands as when purchases are made from different overseas suppliers.
Situation – where an underlying factor can be identified as driving the workload of an activity
such as the number of suppliers when supplier vetting and liaison were vital components of the
cost pool.
Criticisms of ABC
A full ABC system with numerous cost pools with multiple cost driver undeniably more
complex than traditional systems and will thus be expensive to administer.
Much of work is defense related and pricing is on a cost-plus basis hence the need to show
accurate product costs. The applicability of ABC to companies has to use market-based
Illustration
Assume that a firm makes four products A, B, C and D. Data for the past period are as follows:
Product Output No. of Direct Machine Material Material
units production labour hrs. hours per cost per components
runs in per unit unit unit per unit
Shs
period
A 25 3 2 2 30 8
B 25 4 4 4 75 5
C 250 7 2 2 30 8
D 250 10 4 4 75 6
24
a) Compare costing
Total machine hours in period
Product Hours
A 25 ×2 = 50
B 25 × 4 = 100
C 250 x 2 = 500
D 250 x 4 = 1,000
1,650
OAR based on machine hours = sh.27,180 = sh.16.47 per machine hours
1,650
It will be seen that ABC charges more overheads to lower volume production and tends to charge
relatively less to higher volume production, especially product D in this case.
The above example has deliberately been kept simple in order to show the principles of the ABC
method.
REVISION QUESTIONS
QUESTION ONE
Wangu Manufacturing Company Ltd. is located at the industrial area in Nairobi. The company
uses four different machine groups, A, B, C and D in its manufacturing process.
The overhead costs budget for the year ending 31 December 2003 is as follows:
At present, overheads are absorbed into the cost of the company’s products by means of a single
direct wages percentage of 70 percent. The company wishes to change to machine hour
overhead absorption rate for each of its four different machine groups.
The following data is available for each of the four machine groups:
Machine groups
A B C D Total
Sh. ‘000’ Sh. Sh. Sh. Sh. ‘000’
‘000’ ‘000’ ‘000’
Tooling costs 5,400 4,100 2,600 1,200 13,300
Supervision 5,170 4,720 3,630 3,160 16,680
Supplies 1,200 800 200 400 2,600
Cost of machines 32,000 24,000 10,000 18,000 84,000
Required:
(a) Machine hour overhead absorption rate for each of the four groups of machines.
(b) The overhead cost to be absorbed by product XY123 if:
(i) It utilizes the following time resources of the indicated machine groups:
(ii) Direct labour cost is Sh. 22,000,000 and the direct wages percentage method is used.
Solution:
(a) Computation of Overhead Absorption Rates per Machine Hour
QUESTION TWO
The following budget and actual results relates to Cypo Ltd. for the last three quarters for the
year ended 31 March 2004.
The value of the opening and closing stock of the units produced is arrived at by using the FIFO
stock valuation method. The budgeted and actual opening stock for the quarter ended 30 June
2003 was 2,600 units and its valuation included Sh. 3,315,000 of fixed overheads. The company
absorbs its fixed overheads using a pre-determined fixed overhead absorption rate per unit which
Required:
(a) Calculate the under or over-recovery of fixed overheads for each quarter and indicate how it
will affect the profit or loss for the year ended 31 March 2004.
(b) Using the actual results given above, explain whether absorption costing gives a higher profit
figure than marginal costing.
(c) Explain briefly why absorption costing is usually considered to be unsuitable as an aid to
decision making.
Solution:
(a) Calculation of fixed overhead absorption rates
Quarter 2 Quarter 3 Quarter 4
Sh. Sh. Sh.
Budgeted FOH 10,400,000 19,170,00 17,360,000
Budgeted Production (units) 8,000 14,200 12,400
FOH absorption rate (per unit) 1,300 1,350 1,400
FOH absorbed (actual units x 10,920,000 18,360,000 12,880,000
rate) 11,200,000 18,320,000 16,740,000
Less actual FOH 280,000 40,000 3,860,000
Under absorbed Over Under
Deduction absorbed absorbed
Effects on Profit & Loss A/c Profit & Loss Add back Deduct
In Profit & In Profit &
Loss Loss
Whether marginal costing or absorption costing produces a higher profit in a given period
depends entirely on the amount of fixed overheads in opening and closing stocks. Fixed
overhead content of stocks.
Note that opening stock in quarter 3 is the closing stock in quarter 2 and opening stock in quarter
4 is closing stock in quarter 3.
Absorption costing profit is therefore higher than margin profit in quarter 3 but lower in quarter 2
and 4.
(c) Absorption costing is a product convention with many arbitrary assumptions and
subjective assessments e.g. analysis apportionment and absorption of overheads,
treatment of under/over absorption, the way cost centres are determined, the treatment of
service cost centres
In consequence, information based on absorption costing principles is not suitable for use
in decision making.
QUESTION THREE
Ardhi Company is considering the type of remuneration scheme to adopt for its employees. The
following information is availed to you for your analysis:
Mambo Saidi Mbogo
Actual hours worked 38 36 40
Hourly rate of pay (Sh.) 30 20 25
Output (units) A 42 120 -
B 72 76 -
C 92 - 50
A B C
Standard time allowed per unit (minutes) 6 9 15
For the calculation of piecework earnings the company values each minute at the rate of
Sh.0.5.
Solution:
Ardhi Company
i) Basic guaranteed hourly rates used to calculate earnings
Mambo Saidi Mbogo
Actual hours worked 38 36 40
Basic hourly rate of pay 30 20 25
Earnings (Basic x actual hours worked) 1140 720 1000
iii) Premium bonus, given that an employee earns the premium bonus at a rate of 2/3 of the time
saved.
Mambo Saidi Mbogo
Hours allowed 38 23.4 12.5
Hours taken 38 36 40
Hours saved - - -
Bonus hours (2/3 x hours saved) - - -
Bonus wage (bonus hours x hourly rate)
QUESTION FOUR
MMC Ltd. produces machine parts on a job-order basis. Majority of the business contracts are
obtained through bidding. Business firms competing with MMC Ltd. bid full cost plus 20 per
cent mark up. Recently, with the expectation of increase in sales. MMC Ltd. reduced its mark
up from 25 per cent to 20 per cent.
Additional information:
1. The direct costs of the maintenance department are allocated on the basis of employees while
those of power department are allocated on the basis of maintenance hours.
2. Departmental overhead rates are used to assign costs to products. Grinding department uses
machine hours and assembly department uses labour hours.
MMC Ltd. is preparing to bid for a contract, job K, that requires three machine hours per unit
produced in grinding and zero hours in assembly department. The expected prime costs per unit
are Shs. 670.
Required:
a) Allocate the support service costs to the production departments using the direct allocation
method.
b) What will be the bid for job K if the direct allocation method is used?
c) Allocate the service costs to the production departments using the sequential allocation
method.
d) What will be the bid for job K if the sequential allocation method is used?
e) Briefly explain the problems encountered in sett setting overhead cost standards.
f) Distinguish between cost allocation and cost apportionment
3,100,000
(b) Overhead Allocation Rate = = Shs. 310/machine hour i.e. Maintenance
10,000
Department.
Job K cost statement
Shs.
Prime cost 670
Overhead (3 x 310) 930
Total unit cost 1,600
Bid price Shs. 1,600 x 1.2 = Shs. 1,920
(f) Cost allocation is the allotment of whole items of cost. Cost apportionment is the sharing
of a common cost amongst cost centres.
Workings
MMC Ltd.
(a) Power cost allocated according to maintenance hours
6,400 + 1,600 = 8,000
6,400
x2,000,000 1,600,000
8,000
1,600
x2,000,000 400,000
8,000
30
x1,000,000 500,000
60
30
x1,000,000 500,000
60
(c) Power
Apportioned according to machine hours
2,000 + 6,400 + 1,600 = 10,000
COST BOOKKEEPING
Introduction
Bookkeeping involves the recording, storing and retrieving of financial transactions for a
company, nonprofit organization, individual, etc.
Common financial transactions and tasks that are involved in bookkeeping include:
1. Integrated cost accounting system - A system of accounting where the cost and
financial accounts are kept in the same set of books. This system avoids the need for
separate set of books for financial and costing purposes
Flow of costs refers to the manner in which costs move through a firm. Typically, the flow of
costs is relevant to a manufacturing environment where accountants must quantify what costs are
in raw materials, work in process, finished goods inventory and cost of goods sold. Flow of costs
does not only apply to inventory, but also to factors in other processes to which a cost is attached
such as labor and overhead.
Interlocking accounting system is a system in which company records his transactions on the
basis of financial accounting principles and cost accounting principles separately. It means, there
will be two records of accounts. One is financial accounts record and second is cost accounts
record.
Main benefit of interlocking accounting system is for big companies. Big companies keep double
record by independent accountants. So, there is less chance of fraud and mistake because in
reconciliation process, such fraud and mistake can be found by auditor. So, both cost and
financial accountants will be more careful about this.
This is a system where cost accounts and financial accounts are combined in one set of accounts.
Features/Advantages
In integrated account, ledger system has a number of features which may be viewed as preferable
to the interlocking ledger system. In the recent decade, there has in fact been a movetowards
greater integration of accounting information requirements in a single unified system (an
integrated ledger system).
1. Only one set of account is maintained and therefore there would be one profit results
hence no need of reconciling.
2. There is no duplication of work hence a saving in clerical cost.
3. Information obtained can be used by the management for decision making as well as for
financial reporting purposes.
4. Integrated account system help to coordinate the various forms of an organization.
5. It facilitates the use of IT systems.
6. Cost data can be obtained without delay as cost accounts are posted directly from the
basics of original entry.
1) Differences in the valuation of stock – In financial accounting stock is valued base on the
lower of cost and net realizable value whole in cost accounting stock is valued based on the
input cost. The difference in the valuation often brings a challenge in integrated accounts.
2) Problems associated with items appearing in cost accounting only e.g. overhead absorption,
notion cost and changing of depreciation based on the usage.
i. Appropriations of profits not dealt within the costing systems e.g. corporations tax,
dividends paid and proposed etc.
ii. Expenditure of a purely financial nature (i.e. nothing to do with manufacturing e.g. losses
on sale of fixed assets, interest on bank loans, bank charges etc.
i) General Ledger Adjustment Account: It is sometimes called the cost ledger account.
ii) All the items extracted from the financial account are recorded in this account. The
balance in this account represents the total of all the balances of the impersonal accounts
extracted from the financial books. It completes the double entry in the cost accounts.
iii) Stores Ledger Control Account: This account shows all the transaction of materials e.g.
purchases, issuance of materials, returns to suppliers, etc. The balance of this account
represents in total the detailed balance of the stores account.
iv) Work in Progress Ledger Control Account: It shows the total work in progress at any
particular time.
v) Finished Goods Ledger Control Account: Receipts from production and transfer to
distribution department are entered in this account and the balance of this account shows
the total value of finished goods in stock.
vi) Production Overheads Control Account: It gives the total production overheads
incurred in the manufacture or production of goods in question.
vii) Wages Control Account: It shows the total wages incurred in the production of goods.
The link between the two sets of books is achieved by operating a cost ledger control account
and a financial ledger control account (Cost Ledger Contra Account) in the financial and cost
books respectively. In the cost ledger control account, all the items which affect the costs
accounts are recorded, the same items are recorded in the financial ledger control accounts, but
on the opposite side of the account hence the account completes the double entry. The Cost
Ledger
Control Account is just a memorandum entry and is, therefore, made in addition to the normal
entries in the financial books of account.
Integrated and interlocking system is two cost book keeping methods. Interlocking system
maintains two set of ledger which allows detail analyses of costs and cost related processes.
Integrated system keeps only one set of ledgers and both financial and cost accounting
information needs are met from the same books.
1. Duplication of record
In Integrated system there is no duplication of record due to single set of ledgers where in
interlocking system there is duplication of record due to two set of ledgers.
2. Cost
Interlocking system require more resources than integrated system. More time is required to
maintain the interlocking system similarly interlocking system requires more human effort than
integrated system. More resources require more cost therefore interlocking system is deemed to
be more costly than integrated system.
3. Detailed analyses
Interlocking system allows more detail analyses of cost and other cost related process. These
analyses can be performed without any difficulty and delay due to separate set of ledger.
5. Computerized environment
Integrated system is the only system followed in computerized environment and detail cost
analyses are controlled through coding system (Charts of accounts). Interlocking system has no
relevance in the computerized system
Dr: Suppliers/Creditors
Cr: Stores control/Raw materials
To issue materials to production
To record wages
N/B
If the actual overheads is different from the OHD absorbed there is a case of over or under
absorption and the difference should be posted to in OHD adjustment A/C and later transferred
to the part A/C
To record sales
Dr: Bank/Debtors A/C
Cr: Sales A/C
Illustration
Bora Ltd. Commenced its operations on 1 march 2005 with a fully paid up issued share capital of
Sh.500,000 represented by fixed assets of Sh.275,000 and cash at bank of Sh.225,000. The
company has two departments; A and B.
7. Accruals as at 30 May 2005 were Sh.26, 000 for security of productions facilities and Sh.39,
000 for consultancy on production procedures.
8. The costs of finished goods were:
Sh.
Department: A 570,000
Department : B 555,000
9. Sales on credit amounted to Sh. 870,000 and the cost of these credit sales was Sh. 700,000.
10. Depreciation on production plant and equipment was Sh. 15,000.
11. Cash received from debtors totaled Sh. 520,000 and payments made to creditors
totaledSh.150,000.
Required:
(i). Using integrated cost accounting system, record the above transactions for the three
months ended 30 May 2005.
Solution
a) i)
Fixed assets a/c Selling overhead a/c
Sh. Sh. Sh. Sh.
Bal b/d 275,000 Bal c/d 275,000 Bank 40,000 P & L 87,500
275,000 275,000 Wages 47,500
87,500 87,500
Debtors Depreciation
Sh. Sh. Sh. Sh.
Sales 870,000 Bank 520,000 Bal c/d 15,000 Production
Bal c/d 350,000 Overhead 15,000
870,000 870,000 15,000 15,000
ii)
Profit and Loss Account for the period ended 30 May 2005
Sh. Sh.
700,000 Sales 870,000
Cost of sales 170,000
Gross profit 870,000 870,000
REVISION EXERCISE
QUESTION ONE
More Ltd. is a medium size manufacturing company and it maintains separate cost and financial
accounting books. The financial accountant provided the following statement for the year ended
31 March 2004.
More Ltd
Manufacturing, trading and profit and loss account for the year ended 31 March 2004
Sh. Sh.
Direct materials
Opening stock 150,000
Add: purchases 1,800,000
1,950,000
Less: closing stock 200,000
Direct materials cost 1,750,000
Add: direct wages 250,000
Prime cost 2,000,000
Add: factory overheads 300,000
2,300,000
Add: opening work-in-progress 125,000
2,425,000
Less: closing stock 130,000
Production cost carried forward 2,295,000
Sales 4,500,000
Less cost of goods sold
Opening stock 240,000
Production cost brought forward 2,295,000
2,535,000
Less: closing stock 255,000
Required:
Prepare a profit reconciliation statement for the year ended 31 March 2004. (20 marks)
Solution:
Workings:
Cost Financial Difference
Sh. Sh. Sh.
Opening stock of raw materials 160,000 150,000 10,000
COSTING METHODS
Introduction
Manufacturing costing methods are accounting techniques that are used to help understand the
value of inputs and outputs in a production process. By tracking and categorizing this
information according to a rigorous accounting system, corporate management can determine
with a high degree of accuracy the cost per unit of production and other key performance
indicators. Management needs this information in order to make informed decisions about
production levels, pricing, competitive strategy, future investment, and a host of other concerns.
Such information is primarily necessary for internal use, or managerial accounting.
Job order costing or job costing is a system for assigning manufacturing costs to an individual
product or batches of products. Generally, the job order costing system is used only when the
products manufactured are sufficiently different from each other. (When products are identical or
nearly identical, the process costing system will likely be used.)
Since there is a significant variation in the products manufactured, the job order costing system
will create a job cost record for each item, job or special order. The job cost record will report
the direct materials and direct labor actually used plus the manufacturing overhead assigned to
each job.
An example of an industry where job order costing is used is the building construction industry
since each building is unique. The manufacturers of custom equipment or custom cabinetry are
also examples of companies that will keep track of production costs by item or job.
The job cost records also serve as the subsidiary ledger or documentation for the cost of the
work-in-process inventory, the finished goods inventory, and the cost of goods sold.
The following journal entries relate to material procurement and issue from the store to the
production process.
Labour cost is measured and accumulated in the same way as material cost. It includes both
direct and indirect labour. Direct labour can be traced directly to the individual job where as
indirect labour cannot or if it has to be traced, it can only be done with expenditure of great
effort.
Labour costs are accumulated based on the time tickets prepared by workers. The worker needs
to indicate the duration of time he/she spent on a specific job or, when not assigned to a specific
job, what type of indirect labour task he was assigned to and the amount of time expended on the
task.
Total labour costs are calculated based on the time sheets submitted at the end of the day by all
the workers. An example of a time ticket is shown below STING
Production overheads go along with direct materials and direct labour in determining the cost per
unit or in batch processing or the cost of a particular job. However, it is difficult to
assignmanufacturing overheads because they cannot be traced directly to a particular job and it
consists of many unlike items with the variable and fixed cost components with fixed cost
constituting a large part of manufacturing overheads. Overheads are, therefore, assigned to units
of production through an allocation process.
The following journal entries are passed to record production overheads allocated for a
job.
3. Production Overheads
After the allocation of manufacturing overheads, total cost for a job can then be determined and
summarized in a job Cost Sheet or job cost account. Examples of the above are shown below
Required:
a) Pass the necessary journal entries to record the above transactions.
b) Prepare a costing profit and loss account for the period above.
Solution
Dr Cr
SHS SHS
1 Materials 100,000
Cash 100,000
2 Work in Progress 70,000
Manufacturing overheads 5,000
Materials 75,000
3 Factory Labour 250,000
Cash 250,000
To record labour costs incurred
4 Work in progress 220,000
Manufacturing overheads 30,000
Factory labour 250,000
5 Manufacturing overheads 72,800
Cash 72,800
8 Cash 200,000
Sales 200,000
Note: The cost of goods sold as computed above is the same as computed below when various
costs are accumulated as shown in the table.
Therefore, total manufacturing costs absorbed = 50% × total direct labour cost
= 50% ×220,000 = 110,000
COSTING
Accumulated costs of jobs;
Direct Direct labour Applied Total Cost
materials overheads
Job no 2.1 10,000 80,000 40,000 130,000
Job no 2.2 40,000 75,000 37,500 152,500
Job no 2.3 20,000 65,000 32,500 117,500
BATCH COSTING
This is a form of costing which is used where a quantity of identical articles are produced
together as a batch. The general procedures are very similar to costing jobs. The batch would be
treated as a job during manufacture and the various costs (material, labour and overheads)
collected in the usual manner. On completion of the batch the total batch cost would be divided
by the number of good articles produced so as to provide the average cost per article. Batch
costing procedures are common in a variety of industries including; clothing, footwear,
engineering components.
Illustration
The budgeted variable overheads of Githurai Ltd for the year 2001 are given as below:
Required: Calculate:
a) Total cost of the batch
b) Cost/Unit
c) Selling Price of the batch
d) Selling Price unit.
Solution
Cost Summary:
Shs.
Direct materials 87,000
Direct Labour 4,600
Manufacturing Overheads 2,680
Total Production Cost 94,280
Selling and admin costs (10%) 9,428
Total cost of Batch 103,708
Shs
Cost of the Batch 103,708
Mark up @ 25% 25,927
Selling Price of the Batch 129,635
PROCESS COSTING
This is a product costing method applicable where similar products are produced continuously in
a series of production steps commonly known as processes.
It is used where production is continuous in a series of production steps and similar products are
produced.
This is a costing method that is applied where there are standard operations with continuous
production of homogeneous and identical units. Products are produced in the same manner and
consume the same amount of material and labour. The output is the final product of a sequence
of operations. In this type of costing, costs are accumulated on the basis of process, and
individual units of output are thus assigned the average cost per unit. The cost per unit is arrived
at by dividing the total process costs by the number of input of the next process and further
materials can be added at each stage production. Therefore, cost per unit for the second and
subsequent processes is a cumulative cost. For example, the cost per unit for the output
transferred from process 2 is the cost of production for both process 1 and 2 and not for process 2
above.
Common features
1. Similar units are produced continuously
2. The continuous nature of production results in some units being incomplete at the end of
the period.
3. Loss is a common feature due to spoilage, wastage, evaporation etc.
4. Costs cannot be identified with individual products.
5. In some cases output may be multiple products.
a) Process losses
This represents loss of material due to spoilage, evaporation which arises due to the nature of the
product processes.
Process uses can be categorized into:-
i) Normal loss: This is the expected losses and they are unavoidable. They are cost by
inherent factors to production processes e.g. evaporation.
Normal loss is based on past experiences and indicates the expected loss under normal
working conditions.
No cost is allocated to normal loss. However, any amount realised from sale of normal
loss units reduces the cost of good output in unit cost calculation.
ii) Abnormal loss
These are extra units lost above the normal loss units.
It arises due to unfavourable working conditions i.e. substandard materials, accidents,
carelessness etc.
It carries its own cost and will be valued a good unit and the amount transferred to P&L
iii) Abnormal gain
This represents the expected loss transferred out as good output.
They are units which were expected to be loss but they were not lost.
It arises due to improved working conditions i.e. high quality material, less accidents
etc.
It is also accounted at the cost of good output.
b) Scrap
These are the discarded materials with some recovery value which is either disposed of
without further processing or can be reintroduced in place of raw materials.
c) Waste
These are discarded substance with no recovery value and normally they are disposed at a
cost i.e. a cost is incurred to dispose the waste. This cost is treated as part of process cost for
the process which generated the waste.
Normal loss
Cost of normal loss is absorbed by the cost of good units.
Normal losses are unavoidable costs that are expected to occur under efficient operating
conditions. They are inherent in the production process and cannot be eliminated or controlled.
The level of normal loss selected as being the standard for the period under review is based on
various factors such as past experience, quality control records from the past periods and
industry norms. These costs are assigned to the good output using two approaches;
(a) Recognition and Re-Assignment Approach In this approach, the normal spoilage is
included in the equivalent units computation; further, the normally spoilt units will be assigned
costs just like any other unit. The spoilage costs will then be reallocated to these good units that
have passed the inspection point. The steps to follow under this method are:
i) Compute equivalent units including normal spoilage.
ii) Assign costs to all units including normal spoilage.
iii) Reassign normal spoilage costs to good output.
Illustration
ABC Ltd. produces and sells a certain type of insecticide, YMX. In the year just ended, ABC
material input into production process I was 2000 units at Shs.10 per unit. Labour costs incurred
amounted to Shs.30,000 while overhead costs absorbed amounted to 20,000. The normal loss in
the process is 5%. Compute the cost of spoilage and the cost per unit of output transferred to
process II after reassigning the normal loss costs.
Solution
(The process I account will help us solve the problem)
Process I Account
Materials 2,000 20,000 Transferred to process 1,900 66,500
II
Labour cost 30,000 Normal loss 100 3,500
Overhead cost 20,000 -
70,000 70,000
Solution
The process I account will appear as follows
Process 1 Account
Materials 2,000 20,000 Normal loss (5%) 100 -
Labour cost 30,000 Transferred to process II 1,900 70,000
Overhead 20,000 -
cost 70,000 70,000
The cost per unit of the good units shall be computed using the formula given below
Cost per unit = Total accumulated cost
Expected output
The situation above exists where normal loss with no scrap value exists. There are instances
where the normal loss will have a scrap value. For instance, in the Jua Kali industry, the metal
scraps may be used to mend patches or be sold out for some other use. In this case, the revenue
obtained from the sale of scrap is offset against costs incurred in the production process to arrive
at the total costs to be allocated to each unit. In accounting terms, the cashbook is debited with
the amount received from the sale of scrap and the process account is credited with the
equivalent.
Required;
Prepare a process account.
Solution
800 good units should result and their cost per unit would be:
Abnormal losses
Abnormal losses and gains carry their own costs and will be valued at the cost of good output.
They are separately analyzed and the amount to P&L.
These costs do not add any production benefit to the company and are treated as accounting
losses. They are controllable losses which are not expected to occur under efficient operating
conditions e.g. improper mixing of ingredients, omission of some important chemical in the
manufacture of a product, etc. Abnormal losses are considered to result from production
inefficiencies that should be eliminated and are not an inherent part of the production process.
The cost of abnormal spoilage not included in the process cost nor included in inventory
valuation but reported separately as abnormal is written off directly as losses for the period in
which it occur.
Abnormal losses, just as normal losses, may or may not have a scrap value. Abnormal loss with
or without scrap value is treated in a similar way in the process account. The sales revenue
received from sale of abnormal loss units is offset against the cost of abnormal loss in the
abnormal loss account to arrive at the net abnormal loss that shall be charged to the profit and
loss account in the period in which it arises.
Abnormal gain
In some instances, the actual output may be greater than expected or, put in other words, actual
loss less than normal or expected. In such circumstances, abnormal gains are considered to have
arisen.
Illustration
In August 2000 kgs of a material were introduced to a process at a cost of sh.6/kg, and 200 hours
labor were spent at a cost of sh.15/hour. Overheads are absorbed at the rate of sh.4/ labour hour.
Normal losses are incurred at the rate of 5% of input and lost units can be sold for sh.0.9 per
Kilogram. 1,800 kgs were produced.
Required;-
Calculate the total absorption cost of the good output, the treatment of any abnormally lost or
gained units, and also show the process account and loss account.
Solution
Input costs less sale of normal loss = (2,000 ×sh.6) + (200 ×sh.15) + (200 ×sh. 4) – 100 × 0.9 =
15,710
Expected output = 2,000 × 0.95 = 1,900 (actual output = 1,800; abnormal loss = 100).
. ,
Cost per unit = ,
= sh.8.2684
Process account
Units Sh. Units Sh.
Material 2,000 12,000 To finished goods 1,800 @ 8.2684 14,883
Labour 3,000 Normal loss: sale of
Overheads 800 scrap [email protected] 90
- - Abnormal loss 100@ 8.2684 827
2000 15,800 2,000 15,800
Illustration
In May 5000 kgs of a material were introduced to a process at a cost of sh.9/kg, and labour and
overheads amounting to sh.25, 000 were also contributed.
Normal losses are incurred at the rate of 10% of input and lost units can be sold for sh.1 per
kilogram 4,700 kgs were produced
Calculate the total absorption cost of the good output, the treatment of any abnormally lost or
gained units, and also show the process account and loss account.
SOLUTION
Input costs less sale of normal loss = (5,000 × Sh.9) + Sh.25, 000 – 500 × 1 = 69,500
Expected output = 5,000 × 0.9 = 4,500 (actual output = 4,700; abnormal gain = 200).
. ,
Cost per unit = = Sh.15.4444
,
Process account
Units Sh. Units Sh.
Material 5,000 45,000 To finished goods 4,700 @ 15.4444 72,589
Labour and 25,000 Normal loss: sale of
overheads scrap 500 @1 500
Abnormal gain 200 @15.4444 3,089 - -
5,200 73,089 5,200 73,089
Illustration
ABC Chemicals Ltd manufactures a chemical compound branded 'X' used in making plastics.
The chemical compound involves two processes; A and B. The output of process A is passed to
process B where further material is added to mix. The details of the process costs for the
production period ended 30 April were as follows:
Process A:
Direct materials 5,000 kgs at Sh. 10 per kg.
Direct labour Sh. 40,000
Process plant time 200 hours at Sh. 220 per hour
Overheads Sh. 20,000
Process B:
Direct materials 3,000 kgs at Sh. 10 per kg.
Direct labour Sh. 25,000
Process plant time 120 hours at Sh. 220 per hour
Overheads Sh. 12,000
Additional information:
1. The expected and actual output for the processes was as follows.
A B
Expected output 90% of input 95% of input
Actual output 4,200 Kgs 7,340 Kgs
2. Assume no finished stock at the beginning of the period and no work in progress at either the
beginning or the end of the period.
3. Normal loss is sold as scrap for Sh.1.00 per kilogramme from process A and Sh.2.00per
kilogramme from process 3, for both of which immediate payment is received
Required:
(i) Process A account.
(ii) Process B account.
(iii) Abnormal loss/gain account,
(iv) Normal loss account
Process B
Expected output = 95%×3,000 = 2,850
Process plant time = 120×250 = shs30,000
Scrap value = 2
Process A Account
Units Amount Units Amount
Shs Shs
Direct materials 5,000 - 50,000 Output 4,200 34.111 143,267
Direct labour 40,000 Normal loss 500 1 500
Process plant time 44,000 Abnormal 300 34.111 10,233
Overheads ____ 20,000 loss ____ -
5,000 154,000 5,000 154,000
− /
=
−
, ,
= ,
= ,
= 34.111
Process B Account
Units Amount Units Amount
Shs Shs
Process A/c 4,200 34.111 143,267 Output 7,340 37.288 273,691
Direct materials 3,000 15 45,000 Normal loss 360 2 720
Direct labour 25,000
Process plant time 30,000
Overheads 12,500
Abnormal gain 500 37.288 18,644 _____ _____
7,700 274,411 7,700 274,411
In industries where process of manufacturing is continuous, some units may be incomplete at the
end of the period. A problem arises in unit cost as the complete units.
The solution to this problem is to express output in terms of equivalent units. Equivalent units
are assumed complete units output from a production process if a single unit is started and
completed before another is started.
It is based on percentage of completion of output e.g. if 10,000 units were started but only 8000
units were completed and the remainder was left in WIP with 60% degrees of completion, the
equivalent units which will be used for cost calculation will be given by:
Equivalents Units
Complete units – 100% = 800
W-I-P 2000 @ 60% = 1200
Equivalent unit of output 9200
The cost incurred in a process are not incurred uniformly and therefore equivalent units will not
be based on the same percentage of completion i.e. output in a process will carry different
degrees of completion for equivalents unit calculation.
i) Transfer in cost
This represents cost introduced in a process. These costs are accounted 100% since input is
transferred into the process as complete unit.
ii) Material added is this process
The percentage of completion depends on how the materials are added in the process.
iii) Conversion costs
This refers to the direct labour and overheads. The percentage of completion will depend on how
the cost is incurred.
ii) FIFO
In this method, the Opening work in progress and units transferred in this period maintain their
identity and are account separately.
Opening work in progress enters the process first and will be assumed to be completed from O.P
W.I.P and the units started and transferred this period.
The cost incurred will only be relayed to work computed this period i.e. only current cost will be
considered for unit cost calculation.
a) Physical flow of units; the WAM does not keep the beginning inventory units separate from
the units that were started and completed during the period
b) Equivalent units of production: in computing equivalent units of production, the WAM
does not keep the percentage of completion performed in the prior period separate from the
percentage of completion performed in the current period.
c) Costs to be accounted for: in identifying costs to be accounted for, the WAM does not keep
the costs of the units in the beginning inventory at the start of the current period separate
from the costs added to the production during the current period
d) Cost per equivalent unit of production: these are computed by dividing the costs to be
accounted for by the total equivalent units of production
e) Costs accounted for (Cost allocation): total costs to be accounted are allocated for each
category of costs to the units accounted for by multiplying the equivalent units of production
by the cost per equivalent unit of production. The WAM does not keep the cost of the units in
beginning WIP separate from the costs added to production during the current period.
Illustration
Process 2 received units from process 1 and after carrying out work on the units transferred them
to process 3. For one accounting period the relevant data were as follows:
The costs for the period were Ksh. 16,580 and no units were scrapped. It is required to prepare
the process accounts for process 2 units:
Solution
The valuation of the number of complete units transferred to process 3 is found from the balance
on the process account as follows:
Process 2 Account
Unit Ksh Units Kshs.
Opening WIP b/f. receipts 200 2,500 Transfers to 840 21,460
from process 1 800 4,300 process 3
Process costs 16,580 Closing WIP c/f 160 1,920
1,000 23,380 1,000 23,380
This is the amount by which the opening WIP valuation (based on the previous period's costs) is
greater than the current period costs i.e.
Thus, it would be seen that only the current period cost levels, i.e. The Kshs. 24 per unit are
carried forward to the next period in the closing WIP valuation.
Illustration
This example illustrates the treatment of opening and closing WIP where the WIP is broken
down into its various elements.
The following data relate to process y for accounting period 2.
At the beginning of period 2, there were 800 units partly completed which had the following
values:
Value Kshs Percentage complete
Input material (from process x) 8,200 100
Material introduced 5,600 55
Labour 3,200 60
Overheads 2,400 45
During the period 4,300 units were transferred from process x at a value of Kshs. 46,500 and
other costs were:
Kshs.
Material introduced 24,000
Labour 19,500
Overhead 18,200
At the end of the period, the closing WIP was 600 units which were at the following stage of
completion:
This value is used in the process account in the normal way with the value of the transfers to
finished goods being the balance on the account.
Process account – process y (FIFO)
Units Kshs. Units Kshs.
Opening WIP b/d 800 19,400
Transfer in from Transfers to
Process x 4,300 46,500 Finished goods 4,500 117,237
Materials Introduced 24,080 Closing WIP c/d 600 10,363
Labour 19,500
Overheads 18,200
5,100 127,600 5,100 127,600
The following data relate to process 2 for one accounting period. Process 2 receives units from
process 1 and, after processing, transfers them to process 3.
The normal loss is 10% of production and the scrapped units realized 40p each. It is required to
prepare the process account for process 2 using
i) The FIFO method,
ii) The average cost method.
Normal loss is 10% of 3,900 = 390, and as the actual number scrapped were 400, there were 10
units of abnormal loss.
The calculation of effective units for cost calculation purposes follows the same principles as in
examples 4 and 5 except that the number of units of abnormal loss must be included in the total
effective production because, as explained, abnormal losses are costed on the same basis as good
production.
(This is the cost of the material introduced, Shs. 2,956, less the resale value of the normal loss,
Shs.156 i.e. 390 @ 40p each. The resale value of the 10 units of abnormal loss is credited to the
abnormal loss account not the process account.)
The costs per unit calculated are then used to evaluate the value of the closing WIP and the
abnormal loss.
JOINT PRODUCTS
These are two or more products produced in the same process and separated at a certain
separation or split off point.
They are a group of individual products which are produced simultaneously together with each
product having a significant sales unless to merit recognition as a main product.
They are identified as individual products at a certain stage of completion where products
separate to become individual products.
Limitations
Products may separate at different states in liquids, gases, solids etc.
In this case the method will be unsuitable since the products have different units of measurement.
Illustration
AMC plc incurred joint costs of Shs.2,400 in manufacturing Product A and Product B to the
split-off
point; Product A weighed 700 kg and had a sales value at the split-off point of Shs1,800; Product
B weighed 300kg and had a sales value at the split-off point of Shs.1,200 Cost Allocation:
Required: Using the physical measure /unit approach, calculate the cost allocated to products A
and B. Prepare the income statement for the period
Solution
Income statement
Product A Product B Total
Sales 1,800 1,200 3,000
Cost of Goods Sold (1,680) (720) (2,400)
Gross Margin 120 480 600
Gross Margin %:
Product A = 120 / 1,800 = 7%
Product B = 480 / 1,200 = 40%
Total = 600 / 3,000 = 20%
Illustration
A production process has joint costs of Sh.12, 000 for the input of 1,000 kgs of material. Two
products are produced from this:
Product A: 600 kgs. Selling price = Sh.25/unit. Separate costs = Sh.4, 000
Product B: 400 kgs. Selling price = Sh.40/unit. Separate costs = Sh.7,000
Required;-
Calculate the inventory value of the production using
(a) Weight to apportion the joint costs
(b) Net realisable value to apportion the joint costs
Solution
(a) Joint costs apportioned using weight
Product A Product B
(600 kg) (400 kg)
Separate costs 4,000 7,000
Pre-separation costs60:40 sh.12,000 7,200 4,800
Total costs 11,200 11,800
Illustration
A production process has joint costs of Sh.12, 000 for the input of 1,000 kgs of material. Two
products are produced from this:
Product A: 500 kgs. Selling price = Sh.25/unit. Separate costs = Sh.4,000
Product B: 400 kgs. Selling price = Sh.40/unit. Separate costs = Sh.7,000
By product: 100 kgs. Selling price = Sh.2/kg
Solution
(a) Joint costs apportioned using weight
Sales of the by-product will produce revenue of Sh.200, so the joint cost is reduced to Sh.11, 800
Product A Product B
(400 kg) (500 kg)
Separate costs 4,000 7,000
Pre-separation costs 50:40 of Sh.11,800 6,555 5,245
Total costs 10,555 12,245
Product A Product B
Sh. Sh.
Sales value 500 ×25; Sh.400 ×Sh.40 12,500 16,000
Post separation/own costs (4,000) (7,000)
Net realizable value 8,500 9,000
Separate costs 4,000 7,000
Pre-separation costs 8.5/17.5 and 9/17.5 of 5,731 6,069
Sh.11,800 9,731 13,069
Total costs
Illustration
Jitegemee limited company uses a process costing system in its operation. In one of the
production processes, two joint products A and B and a by-product C are produced
The following additional information is provided:
1. Each processing run requires 12,500 kilograms of output. The costs incurred are as follow:-
Sh.
Materials 456,250
Labour 295,000
Overheads 268,750
Required:
i. Determine the total cost of the output from the production process
ii. Calculate the allocated joint costs for product A and product B
iii. Prepare a process account for the production process above
Solution
i)
Output units
Input units 12500
N. loss (20% ×12500) 2500
= 10,000kgs
Less:
Scrap for N. loss (2500 x 10) (25,000)
By-pdt C (1000×20) (20,000)
Total cost Joint costs (A&B) 975,000
, ,
B: × 975,000 = sh. 650,000
, ,
Process account
Units Cost Value Units Cost Value
R. materials 12,500 456,250 Joint product: A 5000 325,000
Labour 295,000 B 4000 650,000
O/HS 268,750 By-product 1000 20 20,000
- N. loss 2500 10 25,000
12,500 1,020,000 12,500 1,020,000
BY-PRODUCTS
These are products recovered incidentally from materials used to manufacture main products.
They are one or more products produced incidentally during this manufacture of the main
product.
Examples of by-products; wax, hides, molasses, saw dust and coffee husks
Features of a by-product
1. They have relatively low sales value when compared to the main products.
2. They are not intended to be produced.
Joint cost will only be allocated to the recognized main product.
No costs are allocated to the by-product. However any amount realized from sale of by-
products may be accounted for as follows:
i) The sales value on the net realizable value (NRV) of the by-products is added to the sales
of the sales of the main product i.e. it is treated as additional revenue of the main product.
ii) The sales on the net realizable value of the by-products is deducted from the cost of
production of the main product is valued at net cost of production. This is the main
method of accounting and by-products.
iii) The amount realized is treated as a miscellaneous income and transferred to P&L
statement.
SERVICE COSTING
Service costing is a cost accounting method concerned with establishing the costs of services
rendered.
Despite this definition, we should note immediately that even though we may be dealing with
services that are intangible, the cost accounting methods we use are essentially the same as if we
were making cars, biscuits or televisions.
When we set up a service cost accounting system, therefore, we would need to keep in mind the
fact that the progression, for example, of a cheque through the banking system, can be treated as
items of raw material passing through a production process. Similarly, we should readily
appreciate that the provision of a transport service has much in common, from the cost
accounting point of view, with the manufacture of the lorry or van that is being used to provide
the service.
Transport
Catering
Computing and IT
Accounting
Human resources
One key factor here is that we might be in the situation of assessing the least cost basis for
providing a service, rather than the highest profit possible.
Motor cars
Packets of biscuits or boxes containing, say, 100 packets of biscuits
Television sets
Service costing is no longer an elective pursuit, it is a compulsory exercise. It ensures that tariffs
represent prices for customers and competitors. Economic, accounting and engineering costs all
play a role in determining service costs. Engineering costs measure technological relationship
between inputs, outputs, Accounting costs record, analyze historic costs according to industry
rules, Economic costs apply the theories of resource allocation to forward looking costs
Examples of operating costs include repair and maintenance, labour, site rental, utilities, license,
regulatory fees and taxes and depreciation.
• Fully distributed cost; in here, the total cost of a service, both direct and indirect costs, are
distributed among the services sold. FDC comes from historic/embedded cost. It relates prices to
information available in accounting, billing systems. However, it requires judgment in allocating
indirect costs devising methodology.
• Marginal cost: this measures the change in total output resulting from a small change in the
level of activity. The marginal cost in this case is the cost of adding a service to an existing
portfolio of products or services.
Fully Distributed Cost (FDC) and Long Run Average Incremental Cost (LRAIC) are the
common ones in literature and in practice. FDC may be “easier” to calculate, but LRAIC
promotes operator
Illustration
Steer & Wheel Ltd distribute its goods to a regional retailer using a single lorry. The dealer's
premises are 40 km away by road. The lorry has a capacity of 10½ tones and makes journeys
twice a day fully loaded on the outward journeys and empty on the return journeys. The
following information is available for a four week budget control period: period 8 of 2004.
Solution
Let’s set out an attractive table showing our costs classified according to whether they are
running or standing costs:
Running Standing
Cost
Cost Cost
Petrol consumption X
Petrol cost per litre X
Oil X
Driver's wages and NI X
Repairs X
Garaging X
Cost of lorry when new (excludes tyres) X
Life of lorry X
Insurance X
Cost of a set of tyres X
Life of a set of tyres X
Estimated sales value of lorry at the end of its life X
Vehicle licence cost X
Other overhead costs X
NOTE: just in case there is any doubt, the driver's wages and NI are standing costs because they
do NOT vary with the number of km driven. Check that you agree with our other classifications.
Depreciation: (Cost of lorry - residual value ÷ life of lorry) × km driven = (Shs 18,750 - 2,750 ÷
80,000 km) ×3,200 km = £0.2/km ×3,200 km = Shs 640
Cost of Tyres: (cost of tyres ÷ life of tyres) ×km driven = (£1,250 ÷ 25,000 km) ×3,200 km =
Shs 0.05/km × 3,200 km = Shs 160
UNIT COSTING
The unit cost of a product or service is obtained by assigning total costs to many identical or
similar units.
Companies need to allocate total product costs to units for the following reasons:
i) The company may manufacture thousands or millions of units of products in a given period
of time
ii) Products are manufactured in large quantities, but may be sold in small quantities sometimes
at one time or in dozens or bulk.
iii) It is important to determine with accuracy the cost of goods sold as it is needed, especially at
the point of transfer from finished goods to cost of sales. This calls for a correct and accurate
accounting for product cost per unit in order to properly match costs against related sales
revenue. This also helps managers to maintain cost control over the manufacturing process.
iv) A small change in unit cost can represent a significant change in overall profitability, when
selling millions of units of a product. Managers thus need to keep track of per unit cost on
daily basis through the production process while at the same time dealing with materials and
output in large quantities
REVISION EXERCISES
QUESTION ONE
Timau Ltd produces a detergent which passes through two processes namely mixing and refining
to completion. The following data relate to the refining process for the month of June 2000.
Cost of opening stock: Sh.
Materials 100,000
Labour 25,000
Overheads 60,000
During the month 20,000 units were passed from the mixing to the refining process. Costs
incurred during the month were:
Shs
Labour 125,000
Overheads 108,100
Other materials 45,300
At the end of the month 21,000 units had been completed and passed to finished goods while
4,000 were still in process having reached the following stages:
Materials - 100%
Labour - 40%
Overheads - 60%
Required:
Refining Process Account
Timau Ltd
Production Statement: June 2000
Inputs Total output Material Labour Overhead
Units Units Units Units
Baa b/f 5,000 21,000 21,000 21,000 21,000
Mixing Process 20,000 4,000 4,000 1,600 2,400
25,000 25,000 25,000 22,600 23,400
At the end of the month, 21,000 units had been completed and passed to finished goods while
4,000 units were still in the process having reached the following stages:
Materials 100%
Labour 80%
Overheads 60%
Required:
Refining process account
Solution:
Tinn ltd
Production statement
Physical Units:
Shs.
Opening Stock 185,100
Costs Added
Labour 125,000
Overheads 108,000
Materials 45,300
Costs to Account for 463,400
Accounted for as follows:
To finished goods:
21,000 x 19.194 403,074
To work in process:
Material: 4000 x 5.812 23,248
Labour: 3,200 x 6.1983 19,836.4
Overheads: 2,400 x 7.184 17,241.6
Valuation of work in process 60,326
Total Costs accounted for: 463,400
Marginal Costing, also known as Variable Costing, is a costing method whereby decisions can be
taken regarding the ascertainment of total cost or the determination of fixed and variable cost in
order to find out the best process and product for production etc.
It identifies the Marginal Cost of production and shows its impact on profit for the change in the
output units. Marginal cost refers to the movement in the total cost, due to the production of an
additional unit of output.
In marginal costing all the variable costs are regarded as product related costs while fixed costs
are assumed as period costs. Therefore, fixed cost of production is posted to the Profit & Loss
Account. Moreover, fixed cost is also not given relevance while determining the selling price of
the product or at the time of valuation of closing stock (whether it is finished goods or Work in
Progress).
Illustration
Suppose company X makes two products A and B. A takes 2 labor hours each to make and B
takes 5 labor hours. What is the overhead cost per unit for A and B respectively if overheads are
absorbed on the basis of labor hours?
Solution
Step 4- Absorb overhead into the cost unit by applying absorption rate.
Note: The activity level of 100,000 hours is the basis over which the overheads will be absorbed.
Different bases will used as shown in the table illustration previously.
Absorption Costing is a method for inventory valuation whereby all the manufacturing expenses
are allocated to the cost centers to recognize the total cost of production. These manufacturing
expenses include all fixed as well as variable costs. It is the traditional method for cost
ascertainment, also known by the name Full Absorption Costing.
In an absorption costing system, both the fixed and variable costs are regarded as product related
cost. In this method the objective behind the assignment of the total cost to cost center is to
recover it from the selling price of the product.
On the basis of function, the expenses are divided into Production, Administration and Selling &
Distribution. The following are the types of Absorption Costing:
Illustration
PQR limited is a manufacturer of sports shoes. The company uses a standard system. The
standard cost per pair of spots shoes is as follows:
Sh.
Direct materials 500
Direct labour: 4 hours × sh. 60 / hour 240
Production overheads
Variable 4 hours × sh. 30 / hour 120
Fixed 100
Standard production cost 960
Standard selling price 1,500
Additional information
1. During the month of March 2011, production was 10,000 units as planned but he sales
made were 8,000 units
2. The total fixed production overhead variance during the month was sh. 100,000 adverse
Variable Fixed
Sh.
Selling and distribution 20% of sales 600,000
Administration 1,000,000
Required:
Income statement for the month of March 2011 using Absorption costing
Solution
PQR Limited
Income statement (using absorption)
For the month of March 2011
Sh. ‘000’ Sh. ‘000’
Sales (1500×8000) 12,000
Cost of sales
Cost of production (960×10000) 9,600
Closing stock (2000× 960) (1,920) (7,680)
Gross profit 4,320
Expenses
Selling & distribution: Variable 2,400
(20%×12000) 600 (3,000)
Fixed (1,000)
Administration expense (100)
Fixed production overheads under-
absorbed
Net profit 220
Comparison Chart
Basis for
Marginal Costing Absorption Costing
Comparison
Marginal costing
Product costs Shs
D. Material xxx
D. Labour xxx
V. Production O/H xxx
xxx
Absorption costing
Product costs Shs
D. Material xxx
D. Labour xxx
V. Production O/H xxx
Fixed O/H xxx
xxx
Marginal Costing
Profit and Loss Statement
Sales xxx
Less: Cost of sales
Opening stock xxx
Add: production cost
D. Material xxx
D. Labour xxx
V. Production O/H xxx
xxx
Less: Closing stock (xxx) (xxx)
Gross contribution xxx
Less: Other various costs xxx
Net Contribution
Less: Fixed costs
Production xxx
Administration xxx
Selling and distr. xxx (xxx)
N. Profit xxx
Example 1
In a period, 20,000 units of Z were produced and sold. Costs and revenues were:
Sh.
Sales 100,000
Production cost: Variable 35,000
Fixed 15,000
Administrative + Selling overheads: Fixed 25,000
Required;-
The operating statements for Z
Solution
Operating statements
Absorption costing approach Marginal costing approach
Sh. Sh. Sh.
Sales 100,000 Sales 100,000
Less production cost of sales 50,000 Less marginal cost 35,000
= Gross profit 50,000 = Contribution 65,000
Less admin + selling 25,000 Less Fixed costs
Overheads - Production 15,000
25,000 Admin S + D 25,000 40,000
Net Profit Net Profit 25,000
If these figures were used as guides to results at any activity level other than 20,000, they would
be incorrect and may mislead. For example, if the level of activity of example 1 changes to
25,000 units, it might be assumed that the total profit would be 25,000 x sh.1.25 = sh.31,150.
However, the results are likely to be as follows:
The difference is, of course, coursed by the incorrect treatment of the fixed cost. In such
circumstances the use of the marginal approach presents a clearer picture. Based on the data in
In Example 1
The marginal cost per unit and the contribution per unit are calculated as follows:
Marginal cost per unit = Sh35,000
20,000
= Sh1.75
Contribution per unit = Sales Price – Marginal cost per unit
= sh5 - sh1.75
= sh3.25
Sh.
Sales (25,000 ×5) 125,000
Less marginal cost (£25,000 ×1.75) 43,750
= Contribution 81,250
Less Fixed cost 40,000
= Net profit 41,250
Note: Students will note that the marginal cost and contribution per unit are assumed to be
constant and that the fixed costs remain unchanged.
PROFIT RECONCILIATION
There is always a difference between the profits reported using marginal costing and absorption
costing. This is brought about by the difference in stock relation.
In marginal costing, stocks are valued at variable cost of production while in absorption cost they
are valued at total cost.
This causes differences in the amounts that are charged to cost of sales which affects the profit
reported.
Illustration
Langata is a manufacturing company which produces a single product. The following standard
unit costs relate to the product.
Cost Sh.
Variable manufacturing 90
Fixed manufacturing 70
Variable selling and administration 16
Fixed selling and administration 60
236
Fixed manufacturing costs per unit are based on a predetermined absorption rate established at a
normal activity level of 45,000 production unit per period. Fixed selling and administration costs
are absorbed into the cost of sales at 20% of selling price.
Solution
Product cost
Marginal Absorption
Variable manufacturing 90 Variable manufacturing 90
90 Fixed manufacturing 70
160
Shs
Period 1
Profit as per marginal costing 2,345,000
Less: Understatement of opening stock 175,000
Profit as per absorption costing 2,170,000
Period 2
Profit as per marginal costing 2,880,000
Add: Understatement of closing stock 70,000
Profit as per absorption 2,950,000
The marginal costing technique recognizes variable cost as the product costs and fixed costs as
period costs. The principle is that only variable costs will change with a change in volume of
production and sales, but the fixed costs will remain the same.
Cost volume profit (CVP) analysis is a systematic approach of examining the relationship
between changes in volume and changes in total sales, expenses and net profit. The underlying
objective of CVP is to know the effect of fluctuation in the activity volume on financial results.
The following is a typical cost volume profit diagram that depicts how sales revenue, fixed costs
and variable costs respond to changes in the volume of sales and production. The volume of
The short run decisions where CVP analysis may be useful include choice of product mix,
product pricing, special order acceptance, shut down of a plant etc.
The only difference is that it shows the variable cost line instead of the fixed cost line. This is
done in order to overcome the major problem with traditional break even chart that it is not
possible to read contribution directly from the chart.
The same lines for total costs and sales revenue are shown so the breakeven point and profit can
be interpreted in the same way as with convectional chart.
The contribution can read as the difference between the sales revenue line and the variable costs
line.
d) Level of sales to result in target profit (in units) = Fixed Costs + Target profit
Contribution/unit
e) Level of sales to result in target profit after tax (in units)
Note: The above formulae relate to a single firm or one with an unvarying mix of sales. With a
multi -product firm it is possible to calculate the break- even point as follows:
Solution
Contribution = Selling price – Marginal Cost
= sh10 - sh6
= sh4
a) Break-even point (units) = sh60,000
4
f) Number of units for target profit with 40% tax = 60,000 + sh. 20,000
1-0.4
sh4
= 23,333
g) Note that the fixed costs, marginal cost and contribution have changed
No. of units for target profit = Sh70,000 + sh20,000
Sh3.50
= 25,714 units
Illustration
A company makes a single product with a total capacity of 400,000 litres p.a. Cost and sales
data are as follows:
Selling price sh.1 per litre
Marginal cost sh.0.50 per litre
Fixed costs sh.100, 000
Draw a traditional break-even chart showing the likely profit at the expected production level of
300,000 litres.
Profit at anticipated c
400 - Sales
production level
Sh. 000 Profit
f
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400
Output (000 litres)
Notes: The ‘margin of safety’ indicated on the chart is the term given to the difference between
the activity level selected and break-even point. In this case the margin of safety is 100,000
litres.
Illustration
By using the illustration above except that a contribution break-even chart should be drawn.
c
Sales
400 -
Profit
Sh. 000
300 - Break Even d
Point
b Fixed
200 - Cost
Contribution e
a Total Cost
100 -
Loss
Fived Cost
0 f
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400
Output (000 litres)
Notes:
a) The area c.o.e represents the contribution earned. There is no direct equivalent on the
traditional chart.
b) The area of d.a.o.f represents total cost and is the same as the traditional chart.
c) It will be seen from the chart that the reversal of fixed costs and variable costs enables the
contribution wedge to be drawn thus providing additional information.
An alternative form of the contribution break-even chart is where the net difference between
sales and variable cost i.e. total contribution, is plotted against fixed costs. This is shown in
Figure below once again using the same data as in the illustration above.
400 -
Sh. 000
300 -
Illustration
A firm has the following cost and revenue functions:
Variable cost function, c = sh. + 10
Demand function, p = sh. 150 +
Where P = price in sh.
c = Variable cost in sh’s
q = number of units sold per period
The fixed costs are sh.1,000 per period.
It is required to determine
a) The price, quantity and resulting profit if the firm’s objective is to maximize sales
revenue.
b) The price, quantity and resulting profit if the firm’s objective is to maximize profit.
Thus 150 - 1 =0
∴ q = £ 150 −
1
= 150 − 1 = q + 10
2
∴ 150 − 1 = q + 10
Sh.
Revenue sh. (56 x 108) 6,048
Less: Costs = sh. (56) + 10(56) + 1,000 3,128
2,920
Profit per period
They are a onetime decisions but once made they remain binding for a long period of time.
In making these decisions it is only the relevant costs that are considered i.e. irrelevant cost are
not taken into account.
Relevant costs.
The term relevant pertinent to the decision at hand, Relevant costs represent those future costs
that will be changed by a particular decision. They are the costs appropriate to a specific
management decision.
Relevant costs are costs that change with respect to a particular decision. Sunk costs are never
relevant. Future costs may or may not be relevant. If the future costs are going to be incurred
regardless of the decision that is made, those costs are not relevant. Committed costs are future
costs that are not relevant. Even if the future costs are not committed, if we anticipate incurring
those costs regardless of the decision that we make, those costs are not relevant. The only costs
that are relevant are those that differ as between the alternatives being considered.
Including sunk costs in a decision can lead to a poor choice. However, including future irrelevant
costs generally will not lead to a poor choice; it will only complicate the analysis. For example,
if I am deciding whether to buy a Toyota Camry or a Subaru Legacy, and if my auto insurance
will be the same no matter which car I buy, my consideration of insurance costs will not affect
my decision, although it will slightly complicate the analysis.
iii) Overheads
Variable overheads
It is an incremental cost which varies with activity level and it is therefore relevant
Fixed overheads
It is expected to remain constant irrespective of activity level and therefore irrelevant.
However, if there is actual increase arising from a decision made, the amount of increase is
relevant cost
Illustration
A company has spent Sh.100, 000 acquiring patent rights to manufacture a product. It hopes to
sell 30,000 units at a selling price of Sh.10 each and the variable costs of production will be Sh.7
per unit.
Should the company proceed with production?
Solution
Sh.100, 000 is known as a past cost or a sunk cost. That money is gone and what the company
has to do is to concentrate on future cash flows. The future cash flows will generate a
contribution of:
30,000 × (Sh.10 - Sh.7) = Sh.90, 000
Therefore, proceeding with production will increase the company’s wealth, so it should proceed.
[Note: The incorrect approach would be to look at all costs: 30,000 (Sh.10 - Sh.7) - Sh.100, 000
= - Sh.10, 000. This incorrect because the business has no control over the past cost of Sh.
100,000. The company has to make the best of what can be done in the future.]
Illustration
A company rents a factory for sh.100, 000 per year. Half of the factory is already occupied by a
machine. The company is considering installing an additional machine which would produce
20,000 units for a variable cost of sh.5 per unit. These units would sell for sh.7 each. Half of the
factory rent would be apportioned to the new machine.
Illustration
A company is considering installing a machine which would produce 20,000 units for a variable
cost of sh.5 per unit. These units would sell for sh.7 each. Additional space would have to be
rented at a cost of sh.50, 000.
Should the company take on this project?
Solution
Here the rent of sh.50, 000 is an incremental cost and is therefore relevant to the decision.
The new machine will generate a contribution of 20,000× (sh.7 - sh.5) - sh.50, 000 = - sh.10,
000.
Therefore, the project should not be taken on.
Illustration
A company has some inventory that was bought for sh.10, 000.
It could be sold for sh.4, 000 or used to make a product that would sell for sh.15, 000.
There is no other use for the inventory.
Additional costs needed to convert the inventory into the product are sh.9, 000. The material
could be bought now for sh.8, 000
Required;-
What should the company do?
Solution
The sh.10, 000 cost of the inventory is irrelevant: it is a sunk or past cost.
The sh.8, 000 current price is irrelevant because the company has no use for the material so
would not buy more.
The sh.4, 000 resale value of the inventory is relevant as the company could receive that cash by
selling the inventory. Therefore, sh.4, 000 is a future incremental cash flow. If the company
keeps the inventory and produces the product sh.4, 000 will not be obtained and the sh.4, 000 is
known as an opportunity cost.
If the company proceeds with the new product, the incremental cash flows will be:
Illustration
A 1 year contract has been offered which will utilize an existing machine that is only suitable for
such contract work. The machine cost shs.25, 000 five years ago and has been depreciated
£4,000 per year on a straight line basis and thus has a book value of shs.5,000. The machine
could be sold now for shs. 8,000 or in 1 years’ time for sh.1000. Four types of material would be
needed for the contract as follows:
W and Z are in regular use within the firm. X could be sold if not used for the contract and there
are no other uses for Y, which has been deemed to be obsolete.
Required;
What are the relevant costs in connection with the contract (ignoring the time value of money)?
Solution
Machine costs. The historic cost is a sunk cost and is not relevant. The depreciation details given
relate to accounting conventions and are not relevant.
The relevant cost is the opportunity cost caused by the reduction in resale value over the one year
duration of the contract, i.e. sh.8000 – 1000 = sh.7,000.
Material costs.
W
Although there is sufficient in stock the use of 300 units for the contract would necessitate the
need for replenishment at the current market price.
X
If the contract were not accepted 200 units of X could be sold at sh. 2.10 per unit. The balance of
900 units required would be bought at the current buying-in price of sh.2.80.
Sh.
∴ Relevant cost = 200 x sh.2.10 = 420
900 x sh.2.80 2540
= 2,940
Y
If the 600 units were used on the contract they could not be sold so the opportunity cost is the
current resale price of sh.0.60 per unit.
∴ Relevant cost = 600 × sh.0.60 = sh.360
Z
Similar reasoning applies to W, i.e. replenishment at current buying in price.
∴ Relevant cost = 1200 × sh.2 = sh. 2,400
.70,000 .20,000
No. of units for target profit =
.3.50
= 25,714 units
Note: The Contribution /Sales (C/S) ratio is sometimes known as the Profit/Volume(C/V) ratio.
Illustration
Plasma plc. deals in plastic buckets and bottles. It is uses polystyrene for manufacturing buckets,
and polyethylene terephthalate for manufacturing bottles. For every unit of bucket and bottle, it
requires 0.5 kg of the required raw material, each.
Plasma has received a bulk order for 1000 buckets and 800 bottles, and is evaluating this order.
The data relating to the raw material requirements are as follows
Polystyrene Polyethylene
terephthalate
Required quantity for the order 500 kg 400 kg
Inventory in hand 150 kg 80 kg
Original cost of inventory in hand (sh./kg) 60 80
Current purchase price of materials (sh./kg) 65 74
Current resale price of the materials 66 60
(sh./kg)
Required;-
What is the total relevant cost of materials for the project?
Solution
Relevant costs are cost related to a future decision
As mentioned in the given case plasma has stopped the production of bottles and the related raw
material has no alternative use. Hence it can be said that those materials can be sold in the
market.
However, plasma has received a bulk order for buckets and bottles. Hence those materials will be
used for the production of the bulk order.
The relevant cost of the required raw materials can be calculated as follows;-
Sh.
Cost of raw materials required for the production of
buckets 32,500
(500 kg × sh65)
Cost of materials required for the production of bottles 23,680
(320 kg ×74)
Opportunity cost of the raw materials required for the 4,800
production of bottles (80 kg × 60) 60,980
Relevant cost
Companies may consider accepting offers at price below the current price so as to utilize idle
capacity
If the revenue covers the relevant cost, the offer should be accepted
Other factors to be considered for an accept or reject decision to be considered. They include;-
The firms policy regarding the selling price
Illustration
TSLM Company Ltd. manufactures clothing and sells directly to clothing retailers. One of its
departments manufactures T-shirts. The department has a production capacity of 80,000 T-shirts
per month.
Currently, the company has excess capacity which has resulted from liquidation of one of its
major customers in the month of April 2012. For the next quarter, monthly production and sales
volume is expected to be 50,000 T-shirts.
The expected costs and revenues per T-shirt at this activity level are as follows:
Sh.
Direct materials 35
Direct labour 50
Production overheads: Variable 8
Fixed 30
Marketing and distribution costs 12
Total costs 135
Selling price 160
Profit 25
Additional information:
1. TSLM Company Ltd. is expecting an upsurge in demand and considers that the excess
capacity is temporary.
2. ABC Ltd. has offered to buy for its employees 2,000 T-shirts each month for the next three
months at a price of Sh.95 per T-shirt.
3. ABC Ltd. would collect the T-shirts from TSLM Company Ltd. factory and thus no
marketing and distribution costs will be incurred.
4. ABC Ltd. would require its logo to be imprinted on the T-shirts. This would cost TSLM
Company Ltd. an extra Sh.5 per T-shirt.
5. TSLM Company Ltd. has an agreement with its employees that entitles the employees at
least six months’ notice in the event of any redundancies.
Required:
Advise TSLM Company Ltd. whether to accept or reject the offer from ABC Ltd.
Solution
Accept or reject offer
Relevant costs
Sh.
Direct materials 35
Direct labour 50
Variable OHDs 8
Additional cost 5
Total cost 98
Advice;
Reject the offer because the selling price is below the cost of production
DROPPING A PRODUCT
From time to time management will be faced with the problem of deciding to abandon an
unprofitable activity. This is really a least-cost alternative decision and so made on the criterion
of relative marginal costs.
It is sometimes suggested that, where a given product is apparently making a loss, manufacture
and/or marketing of this product should cease, to improve the company’s overall profit
performance.
Illustration
A company produces three products for which the following operating statement has been
produced:
Required
Based on the above cost data should product X be dropped?
What other factors should be considered?
Solution
First calculate the fixed costs, as: 1/3 (36,000) + 1/3(38,000) + 1/3(34,000) = Sh.36,000
Rearrange the operating statement in marginal costing form:
Product X Product Y Product Z Total
Sh. Shs Sh. Shs
Sales 32,000 50,000 45,000 127,000
Less marginal Costs 24,000 25,333 22,667 72,000
= CONTRIBUTION 8,000 24,667 22,333 55,000
Less Fixed 36,000
Cost 19,000
= Net Profit
From this it will be seen that product X produces a contribution of sh. 8,000.
Should it be dropped the position would be:
Shs
Contribution Product Y 24,667
Contribution Product Z 22,333
Total contribution 47,000
Less Fixed Assets 36,000
=Net Profit 11,000
Thus dropping Product X with an apparent loss of sh.4,000 reduces total profits by sh.8,000
which is, of course, the amount of contribution lost from Product X. Other factors which need to
be considered:
a) Although Product X does provide some contribution, it is at a low rate and alternative, more
profitable products or markets should be considered.
b) The assumption above was that the fixed costs were general fixed costs which would remain
even if X was dropped. If dropping X results in the elimination of the fixed costs originally
apportioned to X, then the elimination would be worthwhile. However, this is unlikely.
Outsourcing is the process of obtaining goods or services from outside suppliers of providing the
same services within the organization.
In arriving on such a make or buy decision, the price asked by the outside supplier should be
compared with the marginal cost of producing the component parts. Other consideration
affecting the decision is:
i) Continuity and control of supply e.g. can be the outsource company be relied upon to meet
the requirement in terms of quality, delivery dates and price stability.
ii) Alternatives use of resources. Can resource used make this article be transferred.
The choice between making or buying a given component is one which is likely to face all
businesses at some time. It is often one of the most important decisions for management for the
critical effect on profits that may ensue. The choice is critical, too, for the management
accountant who provides the cost data on which the decision is ultimately based.
A make or buy problem involves a decision by an organisation about whether it should make a
product or carry out an activity with its own internal resources or whether it should pay another
organisation to carry out the activity. The make option gives management more direct control
over the work, but the buy option may have benefits in that the external organisation has
expertise and special skills in the work making it cheaper.
There are certain situations where the make or buy decision is not really a choice at all. There
can be no alternative to making, where product design is confidential or the methods of
processing are kept secret. On the other hand, patents held by suppliers may preclude the use of
certain techniques and then there is no choice other than buying or going without. The supplier
who has developed a special expertise or who uses highly specialized equipment may produce
better-quality work which suggests buying rather than making. In other cases, the special
qualities demanded in the product may not be available outside and so making becomes
necessary.
Where technical considerations do not influence the make or buy decision, the choice becomes
one of selecting the least-cost alternative in each decision situation. Comparative cost data are
necessary, therefore, to determine whether it is cheaper to make or to buy. In general this
requires a comparison of the respective marginal costs or, in some cases, the incremental costs of
each alternative. Incremental costs are relevant in decisions which include capacity changes. For
example, a certain component has always been bought out because the plant and equipment for
its manufacture has not been installed in the factory. When considering the alternative to buying,
the cost of making comprises all the incremental costs (including additional fixed expenditure)
Illustration
Which products should the company make and which should it buy?
Solution
A B C
Sh. Sh. Sh.
Buy-in price 15 19 18
Cost to make 12 14 16
Saving (per unit) –sh. 3 5 2
Kg of B 3 2 1
Ranking 3 1 2
C BUY 1,000
A BUY 2,000
Solution
A superficial view, based on the preceding example, is that because the marginal cost of
manufacture is substantially below the buying in price, the component should not be bought in
and thus further analysis is unnecessary. However, such an approach is insufficient in this more
realistic situation and consideration must be given to the loss of contribution from the displaced
product.
Cost analysis - Component 2543 in batches of 10,000
Sh.
Marginal Cost of manufacturer = sh4.75/unit x 10,000 47,500
+ Lost contribution for FP97 = sh20/unit x 1000 20,000
67,500
Buying in price = sh6.50/unit x 10,000 65,000
There is a saving of Sh.2,500 per 10,000 batch by buying in rather than manufacture.
Note: The lost contribution of sh.20,000 is an example of an opportunity cost.. This is the value
of a benefit sacrificed in favor of some alternative course of action. Where there is no alternative
use for the resource, as in Example 4, then the opportunity cost is zero and can thus be ignored.
OPERATING STATEMENTS
An income statement is a core financial statement that presents a company's operating results
over a specific period of time, often quarterly or annually. Also known as an operating statement,
an earnings report, or a profit and loss statement (P&L), an income statement starts with
revenues and then subtracts costs and expenses (such as cost of goods, depreciation,
amortization, and taxes) to calculate net income. Along with a balance sheet, a retained earnings
statement, and a cash flow statement, an income statement is one of the key financial statements
that summarize the finances of a company.
Anyone interested in active investing, picking stocks or investigating the financial health of a
company must know how to read financial statements, including the statement of operations. The
importance of the information contained in the statement of operations cannot be
overemphasized.
A firm’s ability or inability to generate earnings over the long term is the key driver of stock and
bond prices. Operating profit (EBIT) is the source of debtrepayment, and if a company can’t
generate enough EBIT to pay its debt obligations, it will have to enter bankruptcy or sell itself.
Net income is the source of compensation to shareholders (owners of the company), and if a
company cannot generate enough profit to compensate owners for the risks they’ve taken, the
value of the owners’ shares will plummet. Conversely, if a company is healthy and growing,
higher stock and bond prices will reflect the increased availability of profits.
REVISION EXERCISE
QUESTION ONE
The following information has been extracted from the books of Solarcross Ltd for the year to 31
March 2000:
Units ‘000’
Production 30
Sales 24
Production cost incurred: Sh. ‘000’
Direct material 7,200
Direct labour 1,800
Variable overheads 1,500
Fixed overheads 2,700
Selling and administrations costs:
Sales and salaries 450
Variable sales commission 300
Promotion and advertising 480
Other fixed costs 720
Solution:
a)
Solacross Limited
Profit and Loss Statement for the year ended 31st March 2000:
Using Direct Costing Approach
Shs ‘000’ Shs ‘000’
Sales: (24,000 ×550) 13,200
Cost of Sales
Direct Material 7,200× 24,000 5,760
30,000
Direct labour 1,800× 24,000 1,440
30,000
Variable Overheads 1,500× 24,000 1,200 (8,400)
30,000
GROSS CONTRIBUTION 4,800
Less: Variable Sales Commission 300× 24,000 (240)
30,000
Net Contribution 4,560
Expenses: Fixed costs of selling &
Administration
Fixed overheads (of production) 2,700
Sales salaries 450
Promotion and advertising 480
Other fixed costs 720 (4,350)
NET PROFIT 210
b)
Solacross Limited
Profit and Loss Statement for the year ended 31st March 2000
Using the Indirect Costing Method
Differences in the profit using the direct and indirect costing approaches arise due to the
valuation of stocks. In the direct method, cost of stocks is only variable costs while in the
indirect method, the costs of stocks is made up of both variable costs and the fixed production
overheads.
In direct costing, fixed production overheads are fully written off or expensed on period costs. In
indirect approach, part of them are carried forward in closing stocks to be written off in the next
accounting period.
QUESTION TWO
.
a) The following data relate to Kenya Ltd for the year ended 31 December 1999.
Sh. ‘000’
Sales 24,000
Less: Total costs 20,000
Net profit 4,000
Solution:
Kenya Limited:
Shs. ‘000’
Sales 24,000
Less: variable costs @ 60% x 20 million: (12,000)
Contribution: 12,000
Less: fixed costs @ 40% x 20 million (8,000)
NET PROFIT 4,000
= Shs 16,000,000
Profit Statements
Option 1 Option 2
Shs ‘000’ Shs ‘000’
Sales 30,000 27,600
Variable costs (50%) (15,000) (14,526)
Contribution 15,000 13,074
Fixed costs (10,500) (8,000)
NET PROFIT 4,500 5,074
QUESTION THREE
Jamii Company Ltd manufactures and sells a single product. The following information
regarding the company’s operations for the year ended 30 September 2001 was presented to you.
Profit and loss account for the year ended 30 September 2001
The following changes are expected to occur during the year ending 30 September 2002:
Required:
a) Break-even point in sales value
b) The margin of safety in sales value
c) The sales value at which profit of Sh. 4.5 million will be achieved
d) A summary operating statement that shows the net profit of Sh. 4.5 million above.
= shs 15,674,823
Use:
Profit = (P – V) X – Fixed costs
when X is sales in units.
X = Shs. 32,891,493.
d) Sales 32,891,493
Less Cost of Sales 24,294,493
CONTRIBUTION 8,597,000
Less Expenses (4,097,000)
NET PROFIT 4,500,000
A budget is a financial plan for the future concerning the revenues and costs of a business.
However, a budget is about much more than just financial numbers.
Budgets for income/revenue and expenditure are prepared in advance and then compared with
actual performance to establish any variances.
Managers are responsible for controllable costs within their budgets and are required to take
remedial action if the adverse variances arise and they are considered excessive.
1. Coordination
The budgetary process requires that visible detailed budgets are developed to cover each
activity, department or function in the organization. This is only possible when the effort
of one department’s budget is related to the budget of another department. In this way,
coordination of activities, function and department is achieved.
2. Communication
The full budgeting process involves liaison and discussion among all levels of
management. Both vertical and horizontal communication is necessary to ensure proper
coordination of activities. The budget itself may also act as a tool of communication of
what is expected of the departments and managers. High standards set calls for hard work
and more input in terms of labour, time and other resources.
3. Control
This is the process for comparing actual results with the budgeted results and reporting
upon variances. Budgets set a control gauge, which assists to accomplish the plans set
within agreed expenditure limits. The approach followed in the control process has five
basic steps:
i) Preparation of budgets based on the predetermined data on performance and prices.
ii) Measurement of actual performance and recording the data.
iii) Comparing the budget with the actual performance and recording the difference.
iv) Ascertaining reasons for the differences through, including others, variance analysis.
v) Taking corrective actions through administering of proper strategies and measures.
6. Planning
It is by Budgetary Planning that long-term plans are put into action. Planning involves
determination of objectives to be attained at a future predetermined time. When monetary
values are attached to plans they become budgets. Good planning without effective
control is time wasted. Unless plans are laid down in advance, there are no objectives
towards which control can be affected.
PREPARATION OF BUDGETS
MASTER BUDGET
Master budget has two major sections which are the operational budget and the financial budget.
They have following components:
Operational Budget
1. Sales Budget
2. Production Budget
3. Direct Material Purchases Budget
4. Direct Labor Budget
www.someakenya.com Contact: 0707 737 890 Page 237
5. Overhead Budget
6. Selling and Administrative Expenses Budget
7. Cost of Goods Manufactured Budget
Financial Budget
Note that all of the above component budgets may not be included in the master budget of every
business. Some of these such as production budget and cost of goods manufactured budget are
not need by a non-manufacturing business.
FUNCTIONAL BUDGET
Functional budget are prepared for an individual function. For each operation in the organization a budget
is prepared
Sales budget, purchases budget, production budget, cash budget etc. are ex ample of functional budget.
This budget are consolidated to arrive at a master budget
Usefulness
a) A functional budget give target to the individual functional manager
b) Those who actually implement the budget prepare the functional budget. They are familiar with the
problems at the grassroots level. Therefore the budgets are more realistic and motivating.
Problems
(a) As the functional manager prepares the functional budget, the target may not be in line with the
strategic objectives or may conflict with the organizational objectives or inter departmental
objectives. This problem can be avoided by encouraging co-ordination between the functional
managers.
(b) Functional budgets are based on forecasts. There are many extern al as well as well as internal
environmental factors (such as a change in demand for a product, non-availability of a particular raw
material high attrition causing shortages of skilled labour, etc.)that affect the functional budgets. If
these factors behave differently than predicted, this may render the budgetary system ineffective
Production budget
The production budget is usually expressed in quantity and represents the sales budget adjusted for
opening closing finished stocks and work in progress.
Illustration
ABC Ltd. which deals in products Cee and Dee wishes to prepare an operating budget for the forthcoming
period. The information regarding the products, cost and sales level is as follows:
Department
Cee Dee
Materials required
Aye (kg) 4 6
Bee (litres) 2 8
Labour hours required
Skilled (hours) 8 4
Semi-skilled (hours) 4 10
Sales level (units) 4,000 3,000
Opening stock (units) 200 400
Required;
Compute the Production (units)
Direct Materials budget: this shows the estimated quantities and costs of all the raw materials and
components needed for the output demand by the production budget. Sufficient raw materials must be
available to meet the production process and, in addition, provide ending raw materials working inventory
for the period under consideration. Direct raw materials budget is expressed in units. It consists of;-
Direct Materials Usage Budget: it shows the estimated quantities of materials required for budgeted
production.
Solution
Direct Materials Purchases Budget: It ensures that materials are within the planned materials stock
levels i.e. after considering both usage and material stocks required.
Format
Material
Solution
Materials purchase (Kg – Litres and Shs)
Aye Bee
Kg, shs Litres, shs
Budgeted closing Stock10% of demand 3,420 3,160
Budgeted material usage 34,200 31,600
Budgeted opening stock (600) 2,000
Budgeted material purchase (kg,litres) 37,020 32,760
Material price ×100 ×70
Material purchase (shs) 3,702,000 2,293,200
Direct Labour budget: this is crucial as it forecasts the number of labour hours required and thus helps
the company to know whether sufficient labour time is available to meet production needs in the budget
period. It is based on production budget estimate. This budget helps the company know whether it will
need additional labour force in the future and how much it will incur as labour costs.
Illustration
Compute the Labour (hours and shillings)
Solution
Labour cost budget (hours and Shs)
Skilled Semi-Skilled Total
Cee – 4,200 × 8 33,600 4,200 × 4 16,800 50,400
Dee – 2,900 × 4 11,600 2,900×10 29,000 40,600
Labour in (hours) 45,200 45,800 91,000
Labour cost × 120 × 80 -
Total labour cost(shs) 5,424,000 3,664,000 9,088,000
Capital Expenditure Budget: It represents the expenditure on all fixed assets during the budget period.
Addition intended to benefit future accounting periods, or expenditure which increases the production
capacity, efficiency lifespan or economy of existing fixed assets are also incorporated.
CASH BUDGET
It shows the expected receipts and payment of money for a given period.
A cash budget is useful because
i) Shows the expected surplus in the short run and long run so that the amounts can be invested in a
profitable venture
ii) Shows the expected deficit in the short run and long run so that the necessary arrangement can be
made to finance the deficit
Method of preparation
Forecast sales
Forecast time-lag on converting debtors to cash, and hence forecast cash receipts from credit sales.
Determine stock levels, and hence purchase requirements
Forecast time-lag on paying suppliers, and thus cash payments for purchases.
Incorporate other cash payments and receipts, including such items as capital expenditure and tax
payments.
Collate all this cash flow information, so as to determine the net cash flows.
Illustration
The opening cash balance on 1 January was expected to be sh.30,000. The sales budgeted were as
follows:
sh.
November 80,000
December 90,000
January 75,000
February 75,000
March 80,000
Analysis of records shows that debtors settle according to the following pattern.
60% within the month of sale
25% the month following
15% the month following
Required;
Prepare a cash budget for January, February and March.
Solution
Workings Receipts from sales
January
cash
Sh.
November (15% x 80,000) 12,000
December (25% x 90,000) 22,500
January (60% x 75,000) 45,000
79,500
February
cash
sh.
November (15% x 90,000) 13,500
December (25% x 75,000) 18,750
January (60% x 8,000) 45,000
77,250
March cash
sh.
November (15% x 75,900) 11,250
December (25% x 75,000) 18,750
January (60% x 8,000) 48,000
78,000
Payments for purchases
January
cash
sh.
December (10% x 60,000) 6,000
January (60% x 50,000) 49,500
55,500
February
cash
sh.
January (10% x 50,000) 5,500
February (90% x 45,000) 40,500
46,000
Cash budget
January February March
sh. sh. sh.
Opening balance 30,000 24,000 17,250
Receipts from sales 79,500 77,250 78,000
Insurance claim _____ _____ 25,000
= Total cash available 109,500 101,250 120,250
Payments
Purchases 55,000 46,000 54,000
Wages 15,000 15,000 15,000
Overheads (less depreciation) 15,000 15,000 15,000
Taxation _____ 8,000 ______
Total payments 85,500 84,000 84,000
Closing balance c/f 24,000 17,250 36,250
Note: The above example has been kept simple to show clearly the underlying principles which must be
understood. Typical complications which often appear include the following: purchases, wages, etc., may
not be given directly but have to be derived from stock/sales figures and where there are bad debts the
receipts from sales are not equal to 100% of sales and so on.
For example, when a transaction with a material effect on a company's financial condition is
contemplated, the finance department will prepare, for management and board review, a business plan
containing pro formafinancial statements demonstrating the expected effect of the proposed transaction on
the company's financial viability. Lenders and investors will require such statements to structure or
confirm compliance with debt covenants such as debt service reserve coverage and debt to equity ratios.
Pro forma figures should be clearly labeled as such and the reason for any deviation from reported past
figures clearly explained.
Also, banks will request pro forma statements in lieu of tax returns for a startup business in order to verify
cash flow before issuing a loan or line of credit.
Total assets must balance the total liabilities and owners’ equity.
Also, total liabilities added to total owners’ equity must equal total liabilities and owners’ equity. So, you
can determine total owners’ equity by subtracting total liabilities from total liabilities and owners’ equity.
Common stock added to retained earnings must equal total owners’ equity. So, by subtracting common
stock from total owners’ equity, retained earnings can be determined. This completes a pro forma balance
sheet.
The co-ordination and administration of budgets is usually the responsibility of a budget committee
(with the managing director as chairman). The budget committee is assisted by a budget officer who is
usually an accountant. Every part of the organisation should be represented on the committee, so there
should be a representative from sales, production, marketing and so on. Functions of the budget
committee include the following
a) Co-ordination of the preparation of budgets, which includes the issue of the budget manual
b) Issuing of timetables for the preparation of functional budgets
c) Allocation of responsibilities for the preparation of functional budgets
d) Provision of information to assist in the preparation of budgets
e) Communication of final budgets to the appropriate managers
f) Comparison of actual results with budget and the investigation of variances
g) Continuous assessment of the budgeting and planning process, in order to improve the planning and
control function
Step 1
Communicating details of the budget policy and budget guidelines
The long-term plan is the starting point for the preparation of the annual budget.
Managers responsible for preparing the budget must be aware of the way it is affected by the long-term
plan so that it becomes part of the process of meeting the organisation's objectives. For example, if the
long-term plan calls for a more aggressive pricing policy, the budget must take this into account.
Managers should also be provided with important guidelines for wage rate increases, changes in
productivity and so on, as well as information about industry demand and output.
If there are no units of product X already in inventory, and only 4,000 hours of grade A labour available
in the budget period, then the company would be unable to sell 1,000 units of X because of the shortage
of labour hours. Grade A labour would be a limiting budget factor, and the company's management must
choose one of the following options.
a) Reduce budgeted sales by 20%.
b) Try to increase the availability of grade A labour by 1,000 hours (25:1) by recruitment or
overtime working.
c) Try to sub-contract the production of 1,000 units to another manufacturer, but still profit on the
transaction.
In most organisations the principal budget factor is sales demand: a company is usually restricted from
making and selling more of its products because there would be no sales demand for the increased output
at a price which would be acceptable/profitable to the company. The principal budget factor may also be
machine capacity, distribution and selling resources, the availability of key raw materials or the
availability of cash. Once this factor is defined then the rest of the budget can be prepared. For example, if
sales are the principal budget factor then the production manager can only prepare his budget after the
sales budget is complete.
However in the public sector, the principal budget factor will not be profit related. You need to think
about the limiting factor for these organisations in terms of activity, for insurance consultant availability,
cash budget or accommodation.
Remember that state-run organisations providing services free at the point of consumption often face
almost unlimited demand for their services. Therefore resources available usually comprise the limiting
factor: -
a) Cash from government grants and ministries
b) Trained staff such as nurses and doctors
c) Equipment such as MRI scanners and hospital beds
Step 3
Preparation of the sales budget
For many organisations, the principal budget factor is sales volume. The sales budget is therefore often
the primary budget from which the majority of the other budgets are derived.
Before the sales budget can be prepared a sales forecast has to be made.
Sales forecasting is complex and involves the consideration of a number of factors.
a) Past sales patterns
b) The economic environment
c) Results of market research
d) Anticipated advertising
Step 4
Initial preparation of budgets
Finished goods inventory budget
Decides the planned increase or decrease in finished inventory levels.
Production budget
Stated in units of each product and is calculated as the sales budget in units plus the budgeted increase in
finished goods inventories or minus the budgeted decrease in finished goods inventories.
Budgets of resources for production
Materials usage budget is stated in quantities and perhaps cost for each type of material used. It should
take into account budgeted losses in production.
Machine utilization budget shows the operating hours required on each machine or group of machines. .
Labour budgetor wages budget will be expressed in hours for each grade of labour and in terms of cost.
It should take into account budgeted idle time.
Overhead cost budgets
Production overheads
Administration overheads
Selling and distribution overheads
Research and developmentdepartment overheads
Raw materials inventory budget
Decides the planned increase or decrease of the level of inventories.
Raw materials purchase budget
Can be prepared in quantities and value for each type of material purchased once the raw material usage
requirements and the raw materials inventory budget are known.
Overhead absorption rate
Can be calculated once the production volumes are planned, and the overhead cost centre budgets
Step 5
Negotiation of budgets with superiors
Once a manager has prepared his draft budget he should submit it to his superior for approval. The
superior should then incorporate this budget with the others for which he or she is responsible and then
submit this budget for approval to his or her superior.
This process continues until the final budget is presented to the budget committee for
approval.
At each stage of the process, the budget would be negotiated between the manager who
had prepared the budget and his/her superior until agreed by both parties.
Step 6
Co-ordination of budgets
It is unlikely that the above steps will be problem-free. The budgets must be reviewed in relation to one
another. Such a review may indicate that some budgets are out of balance with others and need
modifying. The budget officer' must identify such inconsistencies and bring them to the attention of the
manager concerned. The revision of one budget may lead to the revision of all budgets. During this
process the budgeted income statement and budgeted statement of financial position and cash budget
should be prepared to ensure that all of the individual parts of the budget combine into an
acceptable master budget.
Step 7
Final acceptance of the budget
When all the budgets are in harmony with one another they are summarized into a master budget
consisting of a budgeted income statement, budgeted statement of financial position and cash budget.
Step 8
Budget review
The budgeting process does not stop once the budgets have been agreed. Actual results should be
compared on a regular basis with the budgeted results. The frequency with which such comparisons are
made depends very much on the organisation's circumstances and the sophistication of its control systems
but it should occur at least monthly. Management should receive a report detailing the differences and
should investigate the reasons for the differences. If the differences are within the control of
management, corrective action should be taken to bring the reasons for the difference under control and to
ensure that such inefficiencies do not occur in the future.
The differences may have occurred, however, because the budget was unrealistic to begin with or because
the actual conditions did not reflect those anticipated (or could have possibly been anticipated). This
would therefore invalidate the remainder of tile budget.
The budget committee, who should meet periodically to evaluate the organisation's actual performance,
may need to reappraise the organisation's future plans in the light of changes to anticipate conditions and
to adjust the budget to take account of such changes.
The important point to note is that the budgeting process does not end for the current year once the budget
period has begun: budgeting should be seen as a continuous and dynamic process.
a) It is the major formal way in which the organisational objectives are translated into specific plans,
tasks and objectives related to individual management and supervisors. It should provide clear
guidelines for current operations
b) It is an important medium of communication for organisational plan, objectives and of the progress
towards meeting those objectives.
c) The development of budgets (done properly) helps to achieve co-ordination between the various
departments and functions of the organisation.
d) The involvement of all levels of management with setting budgets, the acceptance of defined targets,
the two way flow of information and other facets of a properly organised budgeting system all help to
promote coalition of interest and to increase motivation.
The boundaries between the two sectors have however become less apparent in recent years due to the
effects of externalisation, competitive tendering, the development of both internal and external trading
activities and an increasing emphasis on partnerships amongst both statutory agencies and the private
sector.
Nevertheless these key differences will influence the approach which public sector bodies take to
budgeting particularly in relation to the need for processes and procedures to be adapted to reflect the
external environment in which they operate and translate this into the setting of budget requirements.
By aggregating budgets throughout the public sector central government can then monitor its activities
against its plans or targets (as set through Comprehensive Spending Reviews and Public Service
Agreements) and take appropriate action to ensure that these are met.
The revenue expenditure of public bodies is funded at national level by either taxation or fees/charges and
at local government level by government grants, local taxation and fees/charges. Statutory frameworks
also exist to ensure that public sector organisations set balanced budgets. Balanced budgets are ones
where the organisation’s estimated revenue expenditure can be met from all sources together with
contributions from reserves.
Current developments in the public sector and their impact on budgeting theory
Over recent years the public sector has faced many challenges due to the rapid pace of change both in the
way services are delivered and in organisational structures and relationships. These changes have meant
that the finance and budgetary function has had to adapt itself to accommodate radically different ways of
working and delivering services and to play a key role in developing and maintaining an effective. As
new policy developments are introduced the need for effective governance and budgetary control
arrangements to ensure probity and sound financial management remain undiminished.
In any large organisation, and particularly in the public sector, there will be conflicting policy objectives
all of which will have different resource implications which may have either capital or revenue
consequences.
An effective budgeting process should allow all of the financial implications of alternative policy
objectives to be assessed thereby enabling policy makers to appraise them and compare the costs against
available resources.
As External Environment to Budgeting has illustrated, public authorities are not only restricted by
resource implications but also by the external environment and political context in which they operate.
The budget allows policy makers to assess their alternative plans and identify their priorities within their
affordable limits.
Budgets are a key element of effective strategy planning. Medium and Long Term Financial Planning
covers the differences between, and objectives of, long term or strategic planning, medium term and short
term financial planning.
The budget is a financial/resource representation of corporate objectives and also a plan of action for the
period covered. Once the budget is adopted by a public authority it's delivery is placed within the remit of
the accountable management who will have approval to incur expenditure in line with stated financial
regulations and a scheme of delegation.
The budget forms the basis of a controlling mechanism for the various resources of a public authority.
Budgetary control can be applied at all managerial levels provided that managers are made accountable
for the budgets for which they are responsible. The budget can also highlight variations from expectations
so that senior management can take remedial action to ensure that expenditure is contained within the
budget and remains consistent with corporate objectives and policies.
QUESTION ONE
The following information has been assembled by Sancross Products Ltd which manufactures and retails
products A and B. The details given below relate to the year commencing 1 July 200:
Standard Product
Price per kg A kg g
Direct material – M1 Sh 4 15 20
M2 Sh 5 14 12
Standard Product
Rate per hour A hours B hours
Direct labour – L1 Sh 8 20 15
L2 Sh 10 22 24
Fixed production overhead is applied on direct labour basis. Administration, selling and distribution
expenses are recovered at the rate of 20% of production cost and profit loaded at 25% of standard
production cost.
Product
A B
Sh ‘000’ Sh ‘000’
Projected sales for the year 12,033 10,053
Material
M1 M2
Sh ‘000’ Sh ‘000’
1 July 2000 200 250
30 June 2001 220 270
Solution:
L1 L2
Shs Shs
Product A 20 ×8 ×11,260 1,801,600 22 × 10×11,260 2,447,200
Product B 15 × 8 ×10,118 1,214,160 24 × 10 ×10,118 2,428,320
3,015,760 4,905,520
QUESTION TWO
You are in charge of making forecasts and preparing budgets. You have been supplied with cost and
revenue forecasts and details of payment as follows:
1. Forecast of revenue and costs for the quarter ending 31 March 2001
January February March
Shs. Shs. Shs.
Direct
Materials (purchases) 112,000 100,000 135,000
Wages 90,000 80,000 100,000
Overhead
2. Forecast of revenue and costs for the quarter ending 30 June 2001
April May June
Sh. Sh. Sh.
Direct
Materials (purchases) 90,000 67,000 79,000
Wages 72,000 54,000 63,000
Overhead
Production 45,000 36,000 40,000
Administration 22,000 25,000 27,000
Selling and distribution 13,000 11,000 16,000
Other details
Period of credit allowed by suppliers averages two months.
Debenture to the value of Shs. 125,000 are being issued in May 2001 and the amount is
expected to be received during the month.
A new machine is being installed at the end of March 2001 at a cost of Sh 150,000 and payment
is promised in early May 2001.
Sales commission of 3% is payable within one month of sales.
A dividend of Sh 100000 is to be paid in June 2001.
There is a delay of one month in the payment of overheads. There is also a delay in payment of
wages averaging a quarter of a month.
Twenty per cent of the debtors pay cash, receiving a cash discount of 4% and 70% of debtors
pay within one month and receive a cash discount of 2 ½%. The other debtors pay within two
months.
Required:
A cash budget on a monthly basis from the second quarter of the year 2001.
Solution:
Workings:
Debtors’ collection
April May June
Sales in: Sh. Sh. Sh.
February 350,000 35,000 - -
March 440,000 300,300 44,000 -
April 350,000 67,200 238,875 35,000
May 360,000 - 69,120 245,700
June 360,000 - - 69,120
402,500 351,995 349,820
Wages Payment
April May June
Month: Wages Shs Shs Shs
March 100,000 25,000 - -
April 72,000 54,000 18,000 -
May 54,000 - 40,500 13,500
June 63,000 - - 47,250
79,000 58,500 60,750
STANDARD COSTING
DEFINITION
A standard, as the term is usually used in management accounting, is a budgeted amount for a
single unit of output. A standard cost for one unit of output is the budgeted production cost for
that unit. Standard costs are calculated using engineering estimates of standard quantities of
inputs, and budgeted prices of those inputs. For example, for an apparel manufacturer, standard
quantities of inputs are required yards of fabric per jean and required hours of sewing operator
labour per jean. Budgeted prices for those inputs are the budgeted cost per yard of fabric and the
budgeted labour wage rate.
Hence, a standard is a type of budgeted number; one characterized by a certain amount of rigor
in its determination, and by its ability to motivate managers and employees to work towards the
company’s objectives for production efficiency and cost control.
There is an important distinction between standard costs and a standard costing system. Standard
costs are a component in a standard costing system. However, even companies that do not use
standard costing systems can utilize standards for budgeting, planning, and variance analysis.
Standard costing is for improving cost /cost control, simplify stock valuation and
improving costing and pricing of products.
Can be applied to jobs, operations, processes and department and are used in
manufacturing, engineering, processing and service industries.
Standard costing systems provide cost information for various uses. These include:
Once the budgets are prepared and agreed upon, the employees’ performance can be acceptably
measured against the set standards to determine whether the performance is acceptable or not.
Appropriate corrective measures can then be taken by the management.
(vi) Motivation
A standard costing system provides a challenging target that individuals are motivated to strive
and achieve. Involving the management and employees at all levels of operation in the setting of
(vii) Pricing
Standard costs act as a reliable base of calculating total cost of producing a good or service to
which a margin can be added to determine the selling price. (Cost plus markup method of price
determination)
TYPES OF STANDARDS
Following are different types of standards:
Basic standards
Normal standards
Current standards
Attainable (expected) standards
Ideal (theoretical) standards
Basic standards
These are standards established considering those factors that are basic in nature and remain
unchanged over a long period of time and are altered only when the business operations change
significantly affecting the very basic foundations of the entity and nature of busienss. These
standards help compare business operations over a longer period of time. Basic standards are
used not only to evaluate actual results but also current expected results (current standards). We
can say that basic standards work as a standard for other standards. As basic standards are not
updated according to latest circumstances thus they are not used often as they cannot help in
short term period variance analysis.
Normal Standards
These are such standards which are expected if normal circumstances prevail. Term normal
represents the normal conditions of the business in the absence of any unexpected fluctuations
(either favourable or unfavourable). Even through normal standards are more of a theoretical in
nature as reality cannot be sufficiently predicted with all its fluctuations in advance. Also,
circumstances may change in such a way that factors which were expected to be controllable are
not so controllable by the mangers. Thus it has limited application in today’s business
environment. However, normal standards acts as a good yardstick that represents challenging yet
attainable results and can be used by management in such environment which is simple in nature
and is not prone to great fluctuations.
These standards are representative of current business conditions. These are mostly short term in
nature and are widely used as they are the most relevant standards to be used for control
purposes. These standards represent the state that business currently achieving or must achieve.
These standards are based on current conditions and circumstances and represents what can be
attained with the present setup in place and if the current conditions prevail. Current standards
may be set lower or easier then expected standards but good managers always try to achieve
what is attainable so that no resource is left unused. It means that attainable standards are
representative of the potential that business is capable to achieve. For example a machinery is
expected to run for 4,000 hours where it can run for 5,000. Thus current standard is 4,000 hours
where attainable is 5,000 hours. These standards are useful as they help management to analyze
their performance and to use the unused potential at the right time.
These standards represents what business operations would be under ideal set of circumstances
where everything is running at the optimum level with an ideal balance. These standards are
representative of long term goals rather than for short term performance measurement. But with
the advancement of technology and inventions even the ideal standards become attainable over
the period of time but with every step taken forward and every question answered, more
questions and more complexities pop up and its in human nature that it always extends the way
forward with every milestone achieved. Therefore, ideal standards are not meant to be achieved
rather to act like a guiding star.
This is not like that one standard is always good and the other always bad. Its all relative. It is a
matter of situation and involves judgment to decide which standard is suitable for a particular
situation and which can provide relevant and reliable information which is also easily available
and applicable. Therefore, it depends on the requirements on the basis of which it is determined
what type of standard is suitable for use.
For example, in financial or environmental crisis it will be good if management stick with
current standards rather than using attainable standards as even maintaining current standards is
sometime difficult.
On the other hand if management is of the opinion that circumstances are favourable and also the
resources available are capable of facing a challenge then it may switch to attainable or even
normal standards and a bit to the extreme ideal standards where ideal standards may help to
motivate staff to perform at its peak.
Establishing a correct standard is very important because accuracy of the standards usually
determine the success of the standard cost system. It is more of an art than a science which
requires combined thinking and expertise of all the persons who have responsibility over prices
and quantities of input.
As we will see later, the standard cost system has very serious behavioral implications for the
staff whose performance will be measured against the standards. If the staff feels that the
standards are too high, (unachievable), they will be frustrated and will be greatly demotivated.
Also, if a disciplinary action is taken on an employee who fails to achieve the standards, but the
employees feel that it is unfair as the standard was inaccurate, this will bring about resentment,
sabotage and demotivation to the employees. On the other hand, if the standards are too low,
they will be easily achieved by employees and they will not be challenged to work harder.
In determining standard cost, each cost should be carefully analyzed to ensure all factors
affecting the cost level (in the period the costs are to be used) have been considered. In addition,
managers in charge of the departments responsible for meeting the standards should approve the
bases for the standards.
For the standard setting process and standards implementation to be successful, the employees
responsible for meeting the standards should have the opportunity to participate in the Standard
Setting Process. They are the best positioned in pinpointing inaccuracies in the set standards.
It is easier to enforce standards once their acceptance is solicited through participation in the
setting process.
The manager overseeing the setting of standards should also have an honest desire to set
achievable targets, and also to assist their lower managers and employees to achieve them.
Also, standards should only be set after there has been interaction between all the individuals
involved.
Last, and very important, the top management must fully support the standard costing process
from Standards Setting to standards implementation. This support gives the standards the
enforcement they need to be effected in the whole organization.
A standard cost card contains an itemization of the standard amounts of materials, labor, and
overhead required to create one unit of a product. The card also multiplies the standard cost of
each of these line items to arrive at the total standard cost of a product. The card has two
purposes:
The number of units and their standard costs that are listed on the card should be reviewed and
possibly revised regularly, due to all of the following factors. Otherwise, the standard cost card
will gradually diverge from the actual results experienced when manufacturing a product.
The standard cost card is comprised of the expected quantities of materials to be used
during the production process, which can vary somewhat from the actual amounts used.
For example, it may contain a certain amount of scrap that may be higher or lower than
the actual amount experienced. Also, the amount of spoilage encountered during the
setup of a production run may also vary from the standard amount listed in the standard
cost card.
The standard costs listed on the card may also vary from actual results. For example,
there may be an expectation to purchase a component for $1.00, but because it was
actually purchased in a smaller unit quantity than anticipated when the standard was
created, the supplier charges a higher price per unit.
The standard amount of labor stated on the card may be incorrect, because of changes in
worker efficiency, altered equipment configurations, changes in the mix of experience
levels used in a production team, and so forth.
Similarly, the standard cost of the labor stated on the card may be incorrect, because of
changes in the wages paid to employees, or in the amount of overtime paid, or in the mix
of employees used in the manufacturing process.
The standard amount of overhead allocated to the product may also vary from actual
results, since it is based on a combination of an expected pool of overhead costs and an
expected volume of production to be generated during the period. If either estimate varies
from actual results, then there will be a difference between the standard overhead cost
and the actual overhead cost.
A physical card is rarely used to store standard costs. Instead, this information is stored in the
computer system and printed as needed.
The following is a simplified version of the layout of a standard cost card. An actual card would
itemize the individual components in the product.
Total $47.43
Machine overheads: based on direct labour hours. They are incurred as Shs.11/hr indepartments
A and B.
Required
Prepare a standard cost card for product B.
Standards may be set and variance can be calculated for each element of cost (such material,
labour, and overheads). It is also possible to calculate variance for each of the factors such as
(price, volume and so on) which determine the cost.
The variance can either be favorable or unfavorable (adverse). In order to determine whether the
variance is favorable or adverse, we need to consider its impact on the profit of the entity
A cost variance (such as material price or labour rate variance etc.) is favorable if the actual cost
is less than the standard cost and vise- versa
A sales variance such as sales margin price or volume variance etc) is favorable if the actual
profit exceeds the standard the cost and vise –versa
BASIC VARIANCES
Material variance
Total direct material cost variance
The direct material total cost variance signifies the difference between the actual material cost
and the standard material cost for the actual production
If actual material cost is greater than the standard material for the actual production, the variance
is adverse (A); otherwise the variance is favorable (F)
The total material cost variance is made up of two elements
- The material price variance ; Which is the difference between the actual price of the
materials and the standard price for the actual quantity of goods made
- The material usage variance; which is the difference between what has actually used and
under standard terms at standard material price
If actual consumption is greater than the quantity of material purchased, actual materials costs
for calculation of direct material cost variance) should be derived 2from as the sum of the actual
cost of purchase of raw materials and the extent of opening inventory consumed at standard price
Total direct material cost variance=Standard material cost for actual production – Actual material
cost
Where material cost=Actual cost of usage of raw material out of current year’s purchase+ Extent
of opening inventory consumed at standard price (if there is opening inventory of material)
The total of material purchased is different from the materials actually used and raw materials
inventories are valued at standard cost
The material variance will be calculated based on the actual quantity of purchase whereas the
material usage variance would signifies the difference between actual usage and standard usage
NOTE
Material Cost Variance
This is the difference between the standard material cost allowed for the production level
achieved and the actual material cost incurred
Material Cost Variance = Standard Cost – Actual Cost.
NB: Material Mix variance + Material Yield Variance= Material Usage Variance.
Illustration
BCH Ltd. Produces a type of liquid fertilizer .The production of this liquid fertilizer requires
three different types of chemicals namely: Exe , Wye and Zed .The chemicals are mixed in the
proportion of 0.4,0.3 and 0.3 respectively and their standard costs are sh.12,sh.7 and sh.5
respectively
Additional information
a) In recent past the standard yield has been 80% on 100 litres of the chemical mix.
b) .The company maintains a policy of not carrying any raw materials, as storage space is
limited.
c) Annual production of liquid fertilizer has been set at 8,320,000 litres.
d) In the month of April 2006, the company produced 150,000 litres ofthe fertilizer at a total
cost of sh.1,708,000 .Actual number of litres used and cost per litre for the three chemicals
were as follows:
Required;-
(i) Material price variance
(ii) Material yield variance
(iii) Material mix variance
Solution
(A) Material price variance. = actual quantity (standard price – actual price)
Exe: 90000 (12-11) = 90,000 (F)
Wye: 70000 (7-8.40) = 98,000 (A)
Zed: 40000 (3-5.50) = 20,000 (A)
28000 (A)
(B) Material yield variance = Standard Cost per unit (Standard Output – Actual Output)
Standard Cost per Unit
Exe: 12 x 0.4 =4.8
Wye: 7 x 0.3 = 2.1
Zed: 5 x 0.3 = 1.5
8.4
Standard Output = 80% of Material. Mix
1 Litre of 0.8 of Outputs = 8.4
8.4
= 1 = ℎ 10.5
0.8
Standard Output (80%)
Total
Standard Output = Inputs x 80%
200000 x 80%
= 160000
(C) Material Mix Variance = Selling price ( Actual mix in standard Proportion – Actual Mix)
Actual Mix Actual Mix in Standard Proportion
Exe: 90000 0.4 ×200,000 : 80000
Wye: 70000 0.3 ×200,000 : 60000
Zed: 40000 0.3×200,000 : 60000
20000
Reconciliation
Material Mix Variance = 90,000 (A)
Material Yield Variance = 105,000 (A)
195,000 (A)
b) Yield variance
Favorable yield variance arises when the output is less than expected: when the actual loss
exceeds the normal loss. Use of cheaper but low quality materials may result to a drop in good
production. For instance, the change to a cheaper mix of material has resulted in the drop in yield
of good production in relation to the standard.
NOTE;
In some cases, there may be some hours paid which was non-productive i.e. idle time. Idle time
is the difference between the hours paid and hours worked.
This gives rise to idle time variance
Idle time V = Standard rate (Hrs. paid – Hrs. worked) or Standard rate (idle time)
OVERHEADS VARIANCES
Variable production overhead variances
The variable production overhead total variance can be subdivided into the variable production
overhear expenditure variance and the variable production overhead efficiency variance (based
on actual hours)
F. OH efficiency / F. OH capacity
productivity variance variance
Where;
TOCV isTotal overhead cost variance
OH is overhead
VOH is variable overhead
VOCV is variable overhead cost variance
FOCV is fixed overhead cost variance
VOEV is variable overhead expenditure variance
AH isactual hours
SH is standard hour
VOAR isvariable overhead absorption rate
VOPV is variable overheads productivity variance
FOEV is fixed overheads efficiency variance
BFOH is the budgeted fixed overheads
AFOH is the actual fixed overheads
BV is the budgeted volume
AV is the actual volume
Illustration
A company uses absorption costing for both internal and external reporting purposes as it has a
considerable level of fixed production costs. The following information has been recorded for the
past year.
Required:
a) Calculate the fixed production overhead expenditure and volume variances and briefly
explain what each variance shows.
b) Calculate the fixed production overhead efficiency and capacity variance and briefly explain
what each variance shows:
Solution
a) Fixed production overhead Expenditure variance
Fixed overhead expenditure variance = (Actual expenditure on fixed overhead – Budgeted fixed
Overhead)
= sh. (2,890,350 – 2,500,000)
= sh. 390,350 ( A)
This variance indicates that the company has spent more than originally budgeted.
Fixed production indicates that the company has spent more than originally budgeted.
Workings
Standard hours required for actual activity
For that first we shall calculate
Budgeted hours per unit = 500,000 hours / 62,500 units = 8 hours per unit
Standard hours required for actual activity = Actual units x Budgeted hours per unit
= 70,000 units x 8 hours per unit
= 560,000 hours.
This variance indicates that the company has used more labor than originally budgeted.
This variance shows that labour worked for more hours than was originally budgeted thereby
exceeding the budgeted capacity.
SALES VARIANCES
These can be used to analyze the performance of the sales function or revenue centers.
N.B. Sales variance calculations are calculated in terms of profit or contribution margin rather
than sales values. It sales values are used (actual sales compared to budgeted) there’s the risk of
ignoring the impact of the sales effort on profit. When we say profit margins, we assume
absorption costing and contribution margin when we are marginal costing.
Under the absorption costing method sales price variance is calculated as follows
Sale price variance= (Actual selling price per unit-Standard selling price per unit) × Actual
quantity sold
OR
Sales (profit margin) variance = (Actual profit margin – Standard profit margin) ×Actual sales
volume
= [Actual sales price-Standard cost per unit) - (Standard sales price-Standard cost per unit)] ×
Act6ual sales volume
If the margin is greater than the standard the standard margin the variance is favorable (F);
otherwise is adverse (A)
The sales variance signifies the difference between the actual quantities sold and the budgeted
quantity, multiplied by either the standard profit per unit or standard contribution per unit .It
should be noted that, in absorption costing, the standard profit per unit is used, whereas in
marginal costing environment Standard contribution per unit is used.
The variance identifies whether the standard quantity or sales exceeded the budgeted quantity
measures the overall impact of change in sales volume on profit or contribution 7of the case may
be
Where;
B. cont. is the budgeted contribution
BQ is budgeted quantity
AQ is the actual quantity
A cont. is the actual contribution
SMMV is Sales margin mix variance
SMQV is Sales margin quantity yield variance
ILLUSTRATION
From the information provided below, calculate the following variances:
standard Actual
Qty.(units) Unit Cost/ Total Qty. Unit Cost/unit Total
sales unit sales (units) sales (sh.) sales
price price(sh.)
(sh.)
A 2,000 4 3.5 8,000 2,200 4.10 3.70 9,020
B 2,500 5 4 12,500 2,000 5.25 4.30 10,500
C 1,750 6 5.25 10,500 2,000 5.75 5 11,500
6,250 31,000 6,200 3,020
Solution
Sales price variance = (actual selling price per unit – standard selling price per unit) x actual
quantity
Product A = sh. (10 – 4) × 2,200 == sh. 220(F)
Product B = sh. (5.25 – 5) ×2,000 = shs.500 (F)
Product C = sh. (5.75 – 6) ×2,000 = sh.500 (A)
Sales price margin variance = Actual contribution margin (W1) – standard contribution margin
(W2) x actual sales volume.
Product A = sh. (0.60 – 0.50) x 2,200 = sh.220 (F)
Product B = sh. (1.25 – 1) x 2,000 = sh. 500(F)
Product C = (0.50 – 0.75) x sh.2,000 = sh. 500 (A)
Workings
W1 actual margin
A = sh4.10 - sh3.50 = sh0.60
B = sh. 5.25 – sh. 4 = sh. 1.25
C = sh. 5.75 – sh. 5.25 = sh. 0.50
W2 budget margin
A = sh. 4 - sh3.50 = sh. 0.50
B = sh. 5 – sh. 4 = $ 1
C = sh. 6 – sh. 5.25 = sh. 0.75
Illustration
Cole Dale Ltd. Manufactures and sells product CC. The company operates a standard marginal
costing system. The standard cost card for CC includes the following:
Sh. Per
unit
Direct materials 20
Direct labour (6 hours @ sh. 7.50 per hour 45
)
Variable production overheads 27
Total 92
The budgeted and actual activity levels for the last quarter were as follows:
Units
Budget Actual
Sales 20,000 19,000
Production 20,000 21,000
Solution
a) Material variance
Direct material variance
= standard quantity for actual production at standard price – Actual quantity at actual price
= sh.20 x 21,000 units) – sh.417,900
= sh.420,00 – sh.417,900=
= sh.2,100 (F)
b) Labour variance
Direct labour rate variance
= Actual hours at actual rate – Actual hours at standard rate.
= sh.949,620 – (124,950 hrs. x sh.7.50)
= sh. 949,620 – sh. 937, 125
= sh. 12,495
Illustration
From the following information of lucky Plc calculate.
Budgeted Actual
Product A Product B Product A Product B
Units 400 800 480 790
Sales price Shs.5 Shs.4 Shs.4.75 Shs.3.9
Cost Shs.4.5 Shs. 3 Shs.4.6 Shs.2.9
Solution
a) Sales price variance = (Actual selling price per unit – standard selling price per unit) x
actual quantity sold.
Product A = sh. (4.74 – 5 ) x 480 units = sh. 120
Product B = sh. (3.9 – 4 ) x 790 units = sh. 79 (A)
Workings
W1 standard contribution margin
A = sh.(5 – 4.50) = sh. 0.50
B = sh. (4 – 3) = sh.1
c) Sales margin volume variance = (Actual quantity – Budgeted quantity ) x standard margin
Product A = (480 – 400) units × sh. 0.50 = sh. 40(F)
Product B = (790 – 800) units ×sh.1 = sh. 10(A)
REVISION EXERCISE
QUESTION ONE
A company ahs budgeted to produce 2,750 articles in 22,000 hours, with fixed overheads of Sh
88,000 and variable overheads of Sh 55,000. The company’s production during the period of the
budget was 2,700 articles in 21,500 working hours with fixed overheads costing Sh 90,000 and
variable overheads Sh 58,000.
Required:
Calculate the following variances:
a) Overhead variance.
b) Fixed production overhead variance.
c) Variable production overhead variance.
d) Fixed production overhead expenditure variance.
Solution:
QUESTION TWO
Tonga Ltd manufactures a single product whose cost structure is given below:
Sh Sh
Direct materials:
Material A (2 kg @ Sh 25 per kg) 50
Material B (3 litres @ Sh 75 per litre) 225 275
The variable and fixed overheads are absorbed on the basis of the direct labour hours.
During the year ended 31 October 2000, the company produced and sold 40,000 units and
incurred the following costs:
Sh. Sh.
Direct materials:
Material A (78,000 Kg) 205,000
Material B (121,000 Kg) 6,800,000 7,005,000
Direct labour (156,000 hours) 4,900,000
Variable overheads 3,000,000
Fixed overheads 900,000
Total cost 15,805,000
Required:
a) Material mix and yield variances.
b) Variable overhead expenditure and efficiency variances.
c) Standard cost card for 40,000 units.
Solution:
i) Material Mix Variance = (Standard Price of Standard Mix – Standard Price of Actual Mix)
But Standard Price of Standard Mix = Quantity Mixed× Standard Cost of Mix
Quantity per Mix
Material Yield Variance = Standard Cost of Mix ( Standard Yield – Actual Yield)
Therefore Material Usage Variance = Material Mix Variance + Material Yield Variance
= 3,200,000 – 3,000,000
QUESTION THREE
Nyundo Ltd manufactures a product whose standard variable cost is given below:
Direct materials (2 kg @ Sh 3) 6
Direct labour (0.75 hours @ Sh 4) 3
Variable overheads 1
The company treats fixed costs as period costs and therefore they are not charged to products.
Solution:
Nyundo Limited
Opening stocks assumed valued at standard price of Shs 3/2 kg = Shs 1.5
Closing stocks assumed an average of both opening stock and purchases (1.50 + 3.50) = Shs 2.50
2
9,350 units of production are expected to use: 2 kg x 9,350 = 18,700 kgs of raw material
= Sh 1,650 (F)
(b) Labour rate variance = Actual Hours (Standard Rate – Actual Hours)
= 8,000 (4 – 3.75)
= Sh 2,000 (F)
(c)Labour efficiency variance = Standard Rate (Standard Hours – Actual Hours)
= Sh 3,950 (F)
COST MANAGEMENT
VALUE CHAIN RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT-DESIGN-PRODUCTION-
MARKETING DISTRIBUTION AND CUSTOMER CARE
VALUE CHAIN
A value chain is used to define the combination of all the activities and resources needed for
generating products and services. The value chain often consists of several operators
(manufacturing industry, wholesale trade, retail trade, customer, etc.) The value chain ends with
the customer.
Michael Porter introduced the value chain analysis concept in his 1985 book ‘ The Competitive
Advantage’ . Porter suggested that activities within an organisation add value to the service and
products that the organisation produces, and all these activities should be run at optimum level if
the organisation is to gain any real competitive advantage. If they are run efficiently the value
obtained should exceed the costs of running them i.e. customers should return to the organisation
and transact freely and willingly. Michael Porter suggested that the organisation is split into
‘primary activities’ and ‘support activities’.
Primary Activities
Inbound logistics : Refers to goods being obtained from the organisation's suppliers and to be
used for producing the end product.
Operations : Raw materials and goods are manufactured into the final product. Value is added to
the product at this stage as it moves through the production line.
Outbound logistics : Once the products have been manufactured they are ready to be distributed
to distribution centres, wholesalers, retailers or customers. Distribution of finished goods is
known as outbound logistics.
Marketing and Sales: Marketing must make sure that the product is targeted towards the correct
customer group. The marketing mix is used to establish an effective strategy, any competitive
advantage is clearly communicated to the target group through the promotional mix.
Services: After the product/service has been sold what support services does the organisation
offer customers?. This may come in the form of after sales training, guarantees and warranties.
With the above activities, any or a combination of them are essential if the firm are to develop
the "competitive advantage" which Porter talks about in his book.
Support activities assist the primary activities in helping the organisation achieve its competitive
advantage. They include:
Procurement: This department must source raw materials for the business and obtain the best
price for doing so. The challenge for procurement is to obtain the best possible quality available
(on the market) for their budget.
Human resource management: The organisation will have to recruit, train and develop the
correct people for the organisation to be successful. Staff will have to be motivated and paid the
‘market rate’ if they are to stay with the organisation and add value. Within the service sector
such as the airline industry, employees are the competitive advantage as customers are
purchasing a service, which is provided by employees; there isn't a product for the customer to
take away with them.
Firm infrastructure: Every organisations needs to ensure that their finances, legal structure and
management structure work efficiently and helps drive the organisation forward. Inefficient
infrastructures waste resources, could affect the firm's reputation and even leave it open to fines
and sanctions.
i) Simple value chain: The value chain describes the full range of activities which are required
to bring a product or service from conception, through the different phases of production
(involving a combination of physical transformation and the input of various producer services),
delivery to final consumers, and final disposal after use.
ii) Extended value chain: In the real world, of course, value chains are much more complex
than this. For one thing, there tend to be many more links in the chain. Take, for example, the
case of the furniture industry. This involves the provision of seed inputs, chemicals, equipment
and water for the forestry sector. Cut logs pass to the sawmill sector which gets its primary
inputs from the machinery sector. From there, sawn timber moves to the furniture manufacturers
who, in turn, obtain inputs from the machinery, adhesives and paint industries and also draw on
design and branding skills from the service sector. Depending on which market is served, the
furniture then passes through various intermediary stages until it reaches the final customer, who
after use, consigns the furniture for recycling.
iv) One or many labels: There is a considerable overlap between the concept of a value chain
and similar concepts used in other contexts. One important source of confusion –particularly in
earlier years before the value chain as outlined above became increasingly widespread in the
research and policy domain – was one of nomenclature and arose from the work of Michael
Porter in the mid-1980s. Porter distinguished two important elements of modern value chain
analysis
The various activities which were performed in particular links in the chain. Here he drew the
distinction between different stages of the process of supply (inbound logistics, operations,
outbound logistics, marketing and sales, and after sales service), the transformation of these
inputs into outputs (production, logistics, quality and continuous improvement processes),
and the support services the firm marshals to accomplish this task.
He complements this discussion of intra-link functions with the concept of the multilinked
value chain itself, which he refers to as the value system. The value system basically extends
his idea of the value chain to inter-link linkages,
There are three main sets of reasons why value chain analysis is important in this era of rapid
globalization. They are:
The benefits include lower inventory level, emphasis on strict quality control by all parties, faster
market response, smaller manufacturing facilities and lower set up costs.
1. Set up times is significantly reduced in the factory.Cutting down the set up time to be more
productive will allow the company to improve their bottom line to look more efficient and focus
Disadvantages of JIT
1) High ordering cost due to high orders
2) There are chances of stock outs in case of failure on the side as the supplier
Let’s take time to briefly see the role computers are playing in the field of accounting, changing
some of the things that were manually done and facilitating accounting data processing.
Inventory Control
Electronic Inventory Control module has multiple functions, which includes tracking inventory
for both costing and tax purposes, aid managers in controlling purchasing (and the overall level
of expenditure) and minimizing the investment in inventory (and subsequent loss of cash flow).
It is integrated with the general ledger so it can automatically set aside the correct amount for
processing further.
Many shops now use stock control systems. The term "stock control system" can be used to
include various aspects of controlling the amount of stock on the shelves and in the stockroom
and how reordering happens.
Typical features include:
Ensuring that products are on the shelf in shops in just the right quantity.
Recognizing when a customer has bought a product.
Automatically signaling when more products need to be put on the shelf from the
stockroom.
Automatically reordering stock at the appropriate time from the main warehouse.
Automatically producing management information reports that could be used both by
local managers and at Head office.
These might detail what has sold, how quickly and at what price, for example. Reports could be
used to predict when to stock up on extra products, for example, at Christmas or to make
decisions about special offers, discontinuing products and so on. Sending reordering information
not only to the warehouse but also directly to the factory producing the products to enable them
to optimize production.
Spreadsheets
Electronic Spreadsheets allow you to do anything that you would normally do with a calculator,
pencil and columnar scratch pad. A typical integrated double entry accounting spreadsheet
system will contain some of the following components: general ledger, inventory levels, order
entry, payroll, time, and billing etc...
INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
Inventory management software is a computer-based system for tracking inventory levels,
orders, sales and deliveries. It can also be used in the manufacturing industry to create a work
order, bill of materials and other production-related documents. Companies use inventory
management software to avoid product overstock and outages. It is a tool for organizing
inventory data that before was generally stored in hard-copy form or in spreadsheets. It is often
associated with and is similar to distribution software.
Receipt of Goods
A retail store or a central warehouse uses bar code or radio-frequency identification scanning at
the point of receipt of goods. Scanning individual items or shipment pallets allows a company to
itemize all shipments from the supplier, which can be compared against the purchase order for
errors or losses in transit. When yourbusiness ships these goods out of the warehouse to their
point of sale, a second scan can automatically tally the remaining stock in the warehouse, and
send messages to the purchasing managers indicating that it is time to reorder.
Introduction
Performance measurement and target-setting are important to the growth process. While many
small businesses can run themselves quite comfortably without much formal measurement or
target-setting, for growing businesses the control these processes offer can be indispensable.
Knowing how the different areas of your business are performing is valuable information in its
own right, but a good measurement system will also let you examine the triggers for any changes
in performance. This puts you in a better position to manage your performance proactively.
One of the key challenges with performance management is selecting what to measure. The
priority here is to focus on quantifiable factors that are clearly linked to the drivers of success in
your business and your sector. These are known as key performance indicators (KPIs). See the
page in this guide on deciding what to measure.
Bear in mind that quantifiable isn't the same as financial. While financial measures of
performance are among the most widely used by businesses, nonfinancial measures can be just
as important.
For example, if your business succeeds or fails on the quality of its customer service, then that's
what you need to measure - through, for example, the number of complaints received. For more
information about financial measurement, see the page in this guide on measurement of your
financial performance.
If you've identified the key areas that drive your business performance and found a way to
measure them, then a natural next step is to start setting performance targets to give everyone in
your business a clear sense of what they should be aiming for.
Strategic visions can be difficult to communicate, but by breaking your top level objectives down
into smaller concrete targets you'll make it easier to manage the process of delivering them. In
this way, targets form a crucial link between strategy and day-to-day operations.
Financial performance exists at different levels of the organisation. This page is mostly
concerned with measuring the financial performance of the organisation as a whole, and of
measuring the performance of key projects. Furtehr measures are used as part of the particualr
problem of divisional performance appraisal.
Traditionally, financial performance measures are split into the following categories:
Profitability
Liquidity / working capital
Gearing
Investor ratios
Profitability measures
ROCE is a key measure of profitability. It shows the net profit that is generated from every $1
of assets employed.
ROCE is sometimes calculated using PBIT instead of net profit. Use whichever figure is
given in the exam.
Capital employed = total assets less current liabilities or total equity plus long-term debt.
Capital employed may be based on net book value (NBV), gross book value or
replacement cost. (note to students: Use whichever figure is given in the exam.
Increasing net profit, e.g. through an increase in sales price or through better control of
costs.
Reducing capital employed, e.g. through the repayment of long term debt.
The ROCE can be understood further by calculating the net profit margin and the asset turnover:
A high gross profit margin is desirable. It indicates that either sales prices are high or that
production costs are being kept well under control.
This is the net profit (turnover less all expenses) as a percentage of turnover.
Asset turnover
This is the turnover divided by the capital employed. The asset turnover shows the turnover that
is generated from each $1 of assets employed.
A high asset turnover is desirable. An increase in the asset turnover could be achieved by:
Increasing turnover, e.g. through the launch of new products or a successful advertising
campaign.
Reducing capital employed, e.g. through the repayment of long term debt.
EBITDA
EBITDA is:
The main reason why companies fail is poor cash management rather than profitability so it is
vital that liquidity is managed.
A company can be profitable but at the same time encounter cash flow problems. Liquidity and
working capital ratios give some indication of the company's liquidity.
Current ratio
The ratio measures the company's ability to meet its short term liabilities as they fall due.
A ratio in excess of 1 is desirable but the expected ratio varies between the type of industry.
A decrease in the ratio year on year or a figure that is below the industry average could indicate
that the company has liquidity problems.The company should take steps to improve liquidity,
e.g. by paying creditors as they fall due or by better management of receivables in order to
reduce the level of bad debts.
This is a similar to the current ratio but inventory is removed from the current assets due to its
poor liquidity in the short term.
This indicates the average number of days that inventory items are held for.
An increase in the inventory holding period could indicate that the company is having problems
selling its products and could also indicate that there is an increased level of obsolete stock. The
company should take steps to increase stock turnover, e.g. by removing any slow moving or
unpopular items of stock and by getting rid of any obsolete stock.
A decrease in the inventory holding period could be desirable as the company's ability to turn
over inventory has improved and the company does not have excess cash tied up in inventory.
However, any reductions should be reviewed further as the company may be struggling to
manage its liquidity and may not have the cash available to hold the optimum level of inventory.
This is the average period it takes for a company's credit customers / debtors / receivables to pay
what they owe.
An increase in the receivables collection period could indicate that the company is struggling to
manage its debts. Possible steps to reduce the ratio include:
This is the average period it takes for a company to pay for its purchases.
An increase in the company's payables period could indicate that the company is struggling to
pay its debts as they fall due. However, it could simply indicate that the company is taking better
advantage of any credit period offered to them.
A decrease in the company's payables period could indicate that the company's ability to pay for
its purchases on time is improving.However, the company should not pay for its purchases too
early since supplier credit is a useful source of finance.
Gearing ratios
In addition to managing profitability and liquidity it is also important for a company to manage
its financial risk. The following ratios may be calculated:
Financial gearing
A high level of gearing indicates that the company relies heavily on debt to finance its long term
needs. This increases the level of risk for the business since interest and capital repayments must
be made on debt, where as there is no obligation to make payments to equity.
The ratio could be improved by reducing the level of long term debt and raising long term
finance using equity.
This is the operating profit (profit before finance charges and tax) divided by the finance cost.
A decrease in the interest cover indicates that the company is facing an increased risk of not
being able to meet its finance payments as they fall due.
The ratio could be improved by taking steps to increase the operating profit, e.g. through better
management of costs, or by reducing finance costs through reducing the level of debt.
Investors will be interested in all of the above measures, along with the following:
A decrease in the dividend cover indicates that the company is facing an increased risk of not
being able to make its dividend payments to shareholders
Dividend yield
This is one way of measuring the return to shareholders but ignores any capital growth / loss.
Earnings yield
This is another one way of measuring the return to shareholders but, as with dividend yield,
ignores any capital growth / loss.
Shareholder value
As discussed above, profit based measures have a poor correlation with shareholder value.
Measures that have a closer correlation include the following:
Introduction
There are a number of areas that are particularly important for ensuring the success of a business
and where the use of NFPIs plays a key role. These include:
Traditionally the main performance measure for staff was cost (a FPI). However, businesses
have started to view staff as a major asset and recognise that it is important to attract, motivate
and retain highly qualified and experienced staff.
As a result, NFPIs are now also used to monitor and control staff. These can include the
following:
staff turnover
absentee rates / sick days
% of job offers accepted
results of job satisfaction surveys
competence surveys
Problems with product or service quality can have a long-term impact on the business and they
can lead to customer dissatisfaction and loss of future sales.
A product (or service) and its components should be critically and objectively compared both
with competition and with customer expectation and needs, for example:
Is it good value?
Can it really deliver superior performance?
How does it compare with competitor offerings?
How will it compare with competitor offerings in the future given competitive
innovations?
Developing and maintaining a brand and/or a company profile can be expensive. However, it can
also enhance performance. The value of a brand/company profile is based on the extent to which
it has:
high loyalty
name awareness
perceived quality
other attributes such as patents or trademarks.
NFPIs may focus on areas such as customer awareness and consumer opinions.
Decisions often appear to have been made on the basis of quantitative information;
however qualitative considerations often influence the final choice, even if this is not
explicit.
Conventional information systems are usually designed to carry quantitative information
and are sometimes less able to convey qualitative issues. However the impact of a
decreased output requirement on staff morale is something that may be critical but it is
not something that an information system would automatically report.
In both decision making and control, managers should be aware that an information
system may provide a limited or distorted picture of what is actually happening. In many
situations, sensitivity has to be used in interpreting the output of an information system.
Information in the form of opinions is difficult to measure and interpret. It also requires
more analysis.
Qualitative information may be incomplete.
Qualitative aspects are often interdependent and it can be difficult to separate the impact
of different factors.
balanced scorecard
The performance pyramid
Fitzgerald and Moon's building block model
The performance prism
BALANCED SCORECARD
A balance Scorecard is an integrated set of performance measures derived from the company’s
strategies that gives the top management a fast but comprehensive view of the organizational
unit. (i.e. a division or a strategic business unit (S.B.U)
The balanced scorecard philosophy assumes that an organizations vision and strategy is best
achieved when the organization is viewed from the following four perspectives.
1) Customer perspectives (How customers do see us?)
This gives rise to targets that matter to customer’s perspectives.
2) Internal business process (What must we excel in?)
This aims to improve internal processes and decision making quality control.
3) Learning and growth perspective (Can we continue to improve and create value?
This considers an organization’s capacity to maintain its competitive position through
acquisition of new skills.
4) Financial perspective (How do we look to shareholders?)
This covers traditional measures such as profitability, R. O. I etc.
By implementing the balanced scorecard, the major objectives for each of the four perspectives
should be articulated.
These objectives should be translated into specific performance measures and targets for
achievements.
This method integrates traditional financial measures with operations, customer and staff issues
vital in long run competitiveness.
Illustration
ABC Ltd has in the past produced just one fairly successful product. Recently, however, a new
version of this product has been launched .Development work continues to add a related product
to the product list. Given below are some details of the activities during the months of November
2009
Required:-
Suggest and calculate performance indicators that could be calculated for each of the four
perspectives on the balanced scored card.
1)Customer perspective
,
Percentage of sales by new products = ×100 = 18.5%
, ,
,
New product = = 4hours per unit
3) Financial perspectives
, ,
Gross profit; Existing product = ×100 =32%
,
, ,
New product = ×100= 44%
,
,
Development costs as a percentage of sales = × 100 = 7%
,