De Beers 'Project Plus' Management System
De Beers 'Project Plus' Management System
Management System
VOLUME I
Section 1.0
January 2002
1.0 INTRODUCTION.............................................................................................................. 5
1.1 Purpose of the De Beers Project Management Systems Guideline.......................................5
1.1.1 Modus Operandi for the use of the De Beers Project Management
Systems Guideline.................................................................................................... 6
1.1.2 Essential Reading..................................................................................................... 6
Page 2 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
3.6 Evaluation Phase................................................................................................................. 16
3.6.1 Inputs...................................................................................................................... 16
3.6.2 Process................................................................................................................... 16
3.6.3 Deliverables (Outputs)............................................................................................17
3.6.4 References............................................................................................................. 17
3.7 Definition and Validation / Feasibility Stage........................................................................17
3.7.1 Inputs...................................................................................................................... 17
3.7.2 Process................................................................................................................... 18
3.7.3 Deliverables (Outputs)............................................................................................20
3.7.4 References............................................................................................................. 21
3.8 Engineering, Procurement and Construction Management.................................................21
3.8.1 Inputs...................................................................................................................... 21
3.8.2 Process................................................................................................................... 21
3.8.3 Deliverables (Outputs)............................................................................................22
3.8.4 References............................................................................................................. 22
3.9 Construction Stage.............................................................................................................. 23
3.9.1 Inputs...................................................................................................................... 23
3.9.2 Process................................................................................................................... 23
3.9.3 Deliverables (Outputs)............................................................................................24
3.9.4 References............................................................................................................. 24
3.10 Commissioning Stage.......................................................................................................... 24
3.10.1 Inputs...................................................................................................................... 24
3.10.2 Process................................................................................................................... 24
3.10.3 Deliverables (Outputs)............................................................................................25
3.10.4 References............................................................................................................. 25
3.11 Disposal and Restoration..................................................................................................... 25
3.11.1 Inputs...................................................................................................................... 25
3.11.2 Process................................................................................................................... 26
3.11.3 Deliverables (Outputs)............................................................................................26
3.11.4 References............................................................................................................. 26
Page 3 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
4.10 Estimation and Cost Control................................................................................................ 28
4.11 Procurement........................................................................................................................ 29
4.12 Progressing......................................................................................................................... 29
4.13 Inspection............................................................................................................................ 29
4.14 Project Reviews and Monthly Progress Reports..................................................................29
4.15 Construction/Commissioning............................................................................................... 30
4.16 Project Completion.............................................................................................................. 30
4.17 Safety Plan.......................................................................................................................... 30
4.18 Computer Aided Engineering Design and Draughting Support............................................30
INDEX...................................................................................................................................... 31
Page 4 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
1.0 INTRODUCTION
The purposes of this guideline is to define the philosophy for the consistent
formulation and control of projects and to assist Project Managers / Project
Leaders or any personnel involved in projects in the consistent, effective,
organised execution of projects through the application of best project
management principles, systematic thinking procedures, guidelines and
standards and to focus on critical items. It is expected that through application of
this guide, effective management of the projects will be achieved.
This guideline attempts to detail the steps required during the full life cycle of a
project, from the initial exploration phase to the actual execution of a project. The
full life cycle will involve a diverse range of disciplines from exploration geologists
through evaluation, establishing a resource, to plant and infrastructure designs
and construction.
At each stage it is necessary to identify all relevant stakeholders and integrate the
various disciplines involved to ensure that optimum and cost effective activities
occur at the right time and ensure that appropriate information is obtained to
make the decisions at each stage e.g. ore dressing and geotechnical information
can be obtained during exploration work.
Each of the project stages above are covered by separate sections below and a
generic checklist of information and discipline activities is needed for each stage.
This guideline does not attempt to cover the detailed activities for, exploration, ore
evaluation, ore dressing studies, project engineering and executions. It attempts
to tie these diverse activities together at the appropriate stages.
Page 5 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
1.1.1 Modus Operandi for the use of the De Beers Project Management
Systems Guideline.
To keep projects compliant with the “De Beers Mine Asset Management
Guidelines”, the Project Manager must take cognisance of this
document’s requirements.
All projects, no matter what size, need to have an appointed Project Manager or
Project Leader responsible for the execution of the project at that stage of the
project’s evolution and who is responsible for co-ordinating all the relevant
disciplines, consultants and contractors.
Page 6 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
2.3 Assignment of Responsibilities
The Project Manager is required to prepare a Responsibility Matrix for the project
based on the project scope which clearly defines the responsibilities of each
member of the team and how all parties interrelate with each other. The
involvement of contractors, specialist consultants and, or technology suppliers will
be defined at this stage and incorporated in the matrix.
The Responsibility Matrix will be agreed and signed by the Client and Contractor
and will be included as an integral part of any Contract.
In the application of the system approach, the design focus shifts away from
concentrating exclusively on the mission of the system, to concentrating on the
entire life cycle. At the same time the design focus shifts away from concentrating
exclusively on the major equipment, to concentrating on the entire system.
A URS (as per the System Hierarchy levels) is to be drawn up by the Project
Team at the initialisation of a project and states the desired capability and
requirements of the project in terms of business processes. It is important not to
specify a system that will provide that capability, as the more a user requirement
becomes a specification, the more the opportunities for trade-offs and
optimisation is lost.
The Project Manager shall agree with the Client, Project Sponsor, Discipline
Consultant and GM Engineering the philosophy to be applied to execute the
project (i.e. team structure, use of consultants and contractors). (See De Beers
Project Management System Volume 2: Business Process Manual).
Page 7 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
2.8 Multi-Disciplinary Task Force
The Project Manager shall establish and assemble, from within De Beers and
where necessary outside organisations, an experienced multi-disciplinary task
force to efficiently and effectively control and manage the project or the EPCM
contractor for a large project.
For larger projects it is highly desirable that all members of the multi-disciplinary
task force be accommodated in a common office under the direct control of the
Project Manager to ensure effective co-ordination. This task force will be termed
“the project management team”.
The location of the management of the project team shall depend on the
geographic centre of the most important activities and is generally where the
manager needs to concentrate his greatest activities. This may be at the project
site, EPCM contractors facility or a combination of the two.
It is imperative that, at the outset, the respective roles and responsibilities for the
De Beers project management team task force be critically considered and
agreed with the team member himself, the Client, Project Sponsor, Discipline
Consultant and GM Engineering. For example, the Client may wish to take
responsibility for construction, commissioning, cost control and administration.
The Project Manager is required to discuss, with the Client, Project Sponsor,
Discipline Consultant and GM Engineering, the factors for and against a split of
responsibilities, particularly in the discipline of construction, commissioning and
cost control. Care should be exercised in committing operational resources to
projects in which these may have conflicting duties in times of need.
Note: The same overall project management principal ideals are specified on
smaller or single source projects, however, these must be adjusted and or
simplified to fit the needs of these less complex acquisitions and conform to less
onerous requirements.
Page 8 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
3.0 PROJECT WORKFLOW AND METHODOLOGIES
The following is a work flow diagram for the system acquisition process as applied
to projects within De Beers.
Construction Disposal
Design Operation
Needs Definition
Requirements Concept
Manufacture &
& &
Identi- &
Determination Exploration
fication Comm- Restor-
Develop- Support
Validation issioning ation
ment
Pre- Operate/
URS Feasibility E.P.C.M. Close
feasibility Maintain
out
Needs
Close
Base Requirements Functional Allocated System Operational Disposal
out Base
Line Base Line Base Line Base Line Base Line Base Line Base Line
Line
The Needs and Requirements phases are the phases where the
required operational capability and constraints for the newly required
system are developed and documented in a Requirements Statement.
This Requirements Statement (also referred to as the ROC) forms the
Requirements Baseline in business terms but does not state any
solutions. It does however include cost and time constraints within which
the ultimate solution must be developed and implemented.
Page 9 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
3.1.2 System Acquisition
There are four phases within System Acquisition which have the
following main objectives:
Concept Exploration: To generate the most appropriate solution to
the Requirements Statement in concept by specifying the major
functions (e.g. flowsheets) and related equipment, equipment support
concept, security concept etc. A major output of this phase is a
System Specification that forms a part of the Functional Baseline.
Design and Development: During this phase the detail design for
construction and fabrication/manufacture is done and is based on the
preliminary design done in the DEVAL phase. The detail design of all
operating, support and manufacturing processes is done, in addition
to the design and development of products (equipment’s). Should
engineering development form part of the project, the new equipment
is then developed, qualified and prepared for commercial
manufacture. The output of this phase is a complete System Baseline
that defines the system in its totality and which will enable
implementation.
Page 10 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
3.2 Overall Model
The overall model (stages) of the typical life cycle of a project is illustrated below.
The corresponding financial cycle is also shown:
NEED IDENTIFICATION
INITIALISATION
Class 3 (Control
DESIGN & DEVELOPMENT Budget
PHASE (if required)
DISPOSAL &
RESTORATION
Attention is drawn to the fact that these macro-activities are not arranged on a
“finish to start” basis, but will in all probability substantially overlap in time.
Generally, a decision to proceed to the next phase, carry out further investigations
or to halt further work is made at the conclusion of each stage or milestone.
Page 11 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
An overview of processes and actions required for each stage follows. Details of
the processes are itemised in subsequent sections of the Guidelines (Volume 1 of
the De Beers Project Management System).
This stage of a project mainly involves exploration personnel with support from
the operational or production divisions. It is essential that other disciplines are
consulted during this early phase to ensure that critical aspects such as ore
dressing studies, test work and major project risks are identified and mitigated
where appropriate.
3.3.1 Process
Desk-top study.
- Identify regional areas with potential for new diamond deposits.
Reconnaissance stage
- Regional investigation of target areas for new diamonds deposits
and identify anomalies.
- Select area of potential Kimberlite occurrence for reconnaissance
programme.
- Survey area
- Data analysis
- Reconnaissance report
Anomaly investigation stage
- Target drilling
- Data analysis
- Target drilling report
Preliminary bulk sampling stage
- Preliminary bulk sampling plan
- Permitting
- Preliminary environmental baseline study
- Preliminary delineation drilling
- Bulk sampling drilling
- Data acquisition
- Treatment of samples to produce concentrate
- Diamond recovery - GSPS
- Diamond property studies – GSPS
- Diamond resource model formulated - Minred
Page 12 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
3.3.3 References
More details on some of the actions under this phase may be obtained
from the following:
Exploration - Diamond Exploration and Mining Handbook
Minred - Mineral Resource Management
3.4.1 Process
Page 13 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
3.4.3 References
More details on some of the actions under this phase may be obtained
from the following:
Exploration - Diamond Exploration and Mining Handbook
Minred - Mineral Resource Management
This stage of the project usually firms up the ore resources, preliminary
geotechnical, preliminary ore evaluations, allows for conceptual mining plans,
carries out detailed ore dressing studies, test work, preparation of preliminary flow
sheets, mass balances, conceptual designs and conceptual (class 1) estimations.
This is also the appropriate stage to carry out ore sampling and ore dressing
studies, scope production levels and outside alternatives at low level of cost
expenditure. “Black Boxes” should be eliminated if possible.
3.5.1 Inputs
3.5.2 Process
Geology / Minred
- Unfactored ore reserve per facies
- Block model
- Micro diamond analysis
Ore Evaluation
- Typical grades of facies
- Diamond valuation and SDF curves
Geotechnical
- Reconnaissance mapping
- Literary review of area, geology, structure and geohydrology
- Preliminary logging of existing core
- Index testing of core
Mining
- Base case mining plan with alternatives
- Global mining factors for dilution and recovery
- Financial model - IRR, NPV and payback period
- Inferred reserve
Metallurgy
- Global metallurgical factors for liberation and recovery
- Global costs factored for tonnage from similar operations
Page 14 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
Engineering
- Establish milestone map
- Define which project disciplines are needed and set up an
appropriate team (i.e. geological, ore evaluation, mining)
- Establish and agree functional philosophy with User
- Execute conceptual (preliminary design) appropriate for the
end objective including identification
- Generate alternative designs and conduct value engineering
thereon. This will include doing a scoping study to set
optimum capacity
- Evaluate alternatives with User, perform trade-off studies
- Prepare Level 2 project plan
- Prepare Class I cost estimate for project costs for all
subsequent phases for project engineering, project services,
including financial appraisal of project, construction,
commissioning, project closure, project capital costs and
project indirect costs namely, escalation, contingency,
insurance, shipping/transport, foreign exchange, spares,
commissioning, training and operating costs, including
consumables (lubricants, chemicals etc). Class 1 estimates
are usually factored from existing equipment and designs to
meet the available level of information.
- Develop factored working costs including consumables
(lubricants, chemicals, etc.), operation mining structures and
post implementation capital costs including closure
- Define environmental requirements and procedures
- Define liaison with statutory authorities
- Set up a financial project and operations financial model
based on a preliminary mining plan to show project IRR and
discounted cash flows and sensitivities.
Page 15 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
3.5.4 References
More details on some of the actions under this phase may be obtained
from the following:
Minred - Mineral Resource Management -
Mining - Mine economics - D Fricker
Metallurgy - Diamond processing handbook - Metallurgy Dept CHQ
Project Management System Vol. 1: Guidelines
Section 2 - System Acquisition
Section 12 - Project planning & resource scheduling
Section 13 - Cost estimation
Section 14 - Preparation of a project execution plan
3.6.1 Inputs
3.6.2 Process
Geology
- Ore / waste and detail facies model
- Detailed mineralogy
- Emplacement model
Geotechnical
- Geotechnical boreholes with core orientation
- Hydrogeological work
- Detail logging, structural, geotechnical and associated
classification
- Weathering tests
- Hydrogeological parameter model
- Selection of core for physical parameter testing
Drilling / Sampling
- Support size (Bulk)
- Density / position
- Further bulk samples if required for revenue or metallurgy
Page 16 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
Ore Dressing Studies
- Core drilling
- Comminution and Concentration tests
- Recovery tests
- Sampling
- Bulk scrubbing tests
- Concentration tests
- Water tests
- Unacidised diamonds
Geo statistics
Revenue
Evaluation
Geotechnical specifications for kimberlite and surrounding country
rock
Indicated / Measured resource
3.6.4 References
3.7.1 Inputs
Page 17 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
3.7.2 Process
Mining
- Mineability of blocks
- Detailed capital costs
- Detailed operating costs
- Revenue / block
- Contribution / block
- Detailed geotechnical and hydrological estimates
- Grade control / block
- Rigorous slope / mine design
- Detailed mining methods and equipment
- Efficiency factors / block
- Dilution factors / block
- Detailed ore blending requirements
- Detailed pit or alluvial optimisation
- Detail plan if underground mine method – draw control
- Manpower strategy
- Mining stock pile strategy
- Environmental plan
- Waste disposal plan
- Closure plan
- Contractor strategy
Metallurgy / ODS
- Additional drill cores
- Additional drill testing
- Additional sampling
- Additional sampling test work
- Detailed plant design
- Detailed recovery factors
- Detailed communication factors
- Detailed DMS factors
- Detailed capital costs
- Detailed operating costs
- Detailed resource consumption
- Detailed flow sheet
- Footprints
- Manpower strategy
- Control philosophy
- Stockpile / tailings strategy
- Construction and commissioning plan
- Detailed mass balance
- Technical and financial models for process simulation
- Detailed equipment selection and flow sheet simulation
Page 18 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
Survey
- Sample position and co ordinates
- Measurement of initial stock piles / bulk sampling extraction
- Measurement of areas and volume of bulk sample depletion
Engineering
- Establish milestone map
- Investigative and select preferred engineering concept
- Agree and obtain Client’s sign-off of preferred concept
- Appoint specialist consultants as required
- Undertake feasibility design, block plan and preliminary general
layout drawings
- Freeze flow sheets (PFDs) and GAs
- Prepare responsibility matrix for the project and agree with
Client
- Prepare Level 3 plan, including management of interfaces,
access constraints and co-ordination requirements
- Prepare Functional Specification
- Prepare General Specifications
- Prepare Particular Specifications
- Define procurement philosophy and procurement plan
- Prepare and agree approved Vendor list with Client
- Prepare and issue major enquiries, particularly for long
delivery items and critical construction/ erection activities
- Prepare Class 2 / 3 cost estimate for engineering, project
services, including quality assurance, financial appraisal, risk
analysis, construction, commissioning, project closure, project
capital costs and project in directs, namely escalation,
contingency, insurance, shipping/transport, foreign exchange,
spares, commissioning, training and operating costs including
consumables
- Prepare basis of cost estimate
- Prepare project implementation strategy
- Define project ethos (Technical excellence, co-operation,
teamwork, safety, in-house capability,
contractors/consultants) and communicate to project team
- Prescribe and issue project procedures
- Determine documentation requirements and procedures
- Prepare Quality Management Plan and agree with Client
- Define procedures and requirements for procedural and
design audits
- Define inter-disciplinary review requirements and procedures
- Review and adjust , if necessary, project organisation
structure, accommodation, equipment and software
requirements
- Prepare and agree spares and consumables with Client
- Establish and implement pre-qualification procedures for
Vendors and reporting thereon
- Define reporting procedures and formats including contents
and distribution
- Define coding systems and procedures
Page 19 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
- Prepare PFDs and P&IDs and agree with Client
- Conduct operability / Hazop / studies of maintainability
- Define project administrative requirements, namely accounts
receivable, accounts payable, audit requirements and
procedures.
- Conduct constructability reviews
- Define commissioning requirements and procedures for
incorporation into enquiries
- Define enquiry document requirements namely, detailed
Preliminary and General Costs breakdown, resource levels of
supervision, Labour and plant and breakdown of item pricing.
- Define Contract Variation procedures and reporting formats
for inclusion in enquiry/contract documents.
- Prepare project management, engineering, project services,
administration and contractor organisation resources and
timing
- Prepare Block Plan
- Define escalation philosophy and procedures for inclusion into
enquiry/contract documents
- Conduct Environmental Impact Analysis
- Report on expenditure versus budget and actual progress
versus planned progress for this stage
Page 20 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
- Class 2 / 3 estimate
Working costs estimate
Reporting procedures
Agreed Process Flow Diagrams and Piping and Instrumentation
Diagrams
Information management strategy
Project administration requirements and procedures
Commissioning requirements and procedures
Block plan and preliminary GAs.
EIA
Organisation structure and manpower strategy
Cost and Progress Report
Project and operations life cycle financial model
Full Feasibility report (for large projects this will be to bankable
standards)
3.7.4 References
More details on some of the actions under this phase may be obtained
from the following:
Minred - Mineral Resource Management
Mining - Mine economics
Metallurgy - Diamond processing handbook - Metallurgy Dept CHQ
Engineering - Asset Management Guideline
- Life Cycle Costing
Project Management System. Volume 1: Guidelines
Section 2 - System Acquisition
Section 9 - Change control
Section 12 - Project planning & resource scheduling
Section 13 - Cost estimation preparation
Section 14 - Preparation of a project execution plan
3.8.1 Inputs
3.8.2 Process
Engineering
- Initiate project “kick-off” meeting with project team
- Finalise Piping and Instrumentation Diagrams and agree with
Client
- Select plant and equipment and agree with Client
- Adjudicate enquiries
- Place contracts
- Execute detailed design and draughting
- Prepare Level 4 planning
Page 21 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
- Prepare Class 3 cost estimate including the item categories
as stated previously
- Prepare and implement Quality Assurance Systems and
Quality Control Plans
- Implement cost control and reporting system, namely CVR,
with base costs or actual costs as the reporting basis for final
cost
- Implement engineering design management (cost and time)
- Review and amend project responsibility matrix and agree
with Client and Contractor
- Finalise and sign-off agreement of service / contract with
Client and Contractor
- Prepare and monitor design and drawing programme
- Change management report on expenditure versus budget
and actual progress versus planned progress for this stage to
be part of project management
- Implement and control inter-disciplinary design reviews and
review/approval of designs and drawings
- Implement Quality Assurance reporting and Corrective Action
Requests
- Implement manufacture and fabrication phase
3.8.4 References
More details on some of the actions under this phase may be obtained
from the following:
Mining - Mine economics
Metallurgy - Diamond processing handbook - Metallurgy Dept CHQ
Engineering - Asset Management Guideline
- Life Cycle Costing
Project Management System. Volume 1: Guidelines
Page 22 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
Section 2 - System Acquisition
Section 4 - Commissioning management
Section 9 - Change control
Section 11 - Pre qualification, adjudication & selection of tenderers
Section 12 - Project planning & resource scheduling
Section 13 - Cost estimation preparation
Section 14 - Preparation of a project execution plan
3.9.1 Inputs
3.9.2 Process
Page 23 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
Implement cold commissioning procedures, report formats and
ensure that construction supervision staff and contractors adhere
to the system
Develop, issue and implement punch-list procedures, reports
and certificates, eg. Mechanical/electrical completion and safety
clearance certificates
Expedite and control delivery of vendor documentation, eg.
Commissioning planning, commissioning methods and
procedures, commissioning quality control plans, vendors
commissioning organisation and resources, operating and
maintenance manuals, training and as-built drawings
3.9.4 References
More details on some of the actions under this phase may be obtained
from the following:
Mining - Mine economics
Metallurgy - Diamond processing handbook - Metallurgy Dept CHQ
Engineering - Asset Management Guideline
- Life Cycle Costing
Project Management System. Volume 1: Guidelines
Section 4 - Commissioning management
Section 9 - Change control
Section 10 - Post completion audit preparation
3.10.1 Inputs
3.10.2 Process
Page 24 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
Prepare engineering as-built drawings and operating and
maintenance manuals as necessary
Obtain vendors’ operating and maintenance and vendor
as-built drawings
Review and approve commissioning resources
Conduct or arrange training of operating personnel
Approve equipment acceptance criteria
Conduct mechanical and electrical safety clearance
procedures
Conduct control and instrumentation check
Issue mechanical and electrical safety clearance
certificates
Arrange with User for supply of raw materials,
consumables and product for hot commissioning
3.10.4 References
More details on some of the actions under this phase may be obtained
from the following:
Mining - Mine economics
Metallurgy - Diamond processing handbook - Metallurgy Dept CHQ
Engineering - Asset Management Guideline
- Life Cycle Costing
Project Management System. Volume 1: Guidelines
Section 4 - Commissioning management
Section 9 - Change control
Section 10 - Post completion audit preparation
3.11.1 Inputs
Page 25 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
3.11.2 Process
3.11.4 References
More details on some of the actions under this phase may be obtained
from the following:
Mining - Mine economics
Metallurgy - Diamond processing handbook - Metallurgy Dept CHQ
Engineering - Asset Management Guideline
- Life Cycle Costing
Project Management System. Volume 1: Guidelines
Section 10 - Post completion audit preparation
Page 26 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
4.0 CRITICAL ACTIVITIES CHECKLIST
The following is not and exhaustive list and is proposed to highlight important items
which may be required to be actioned at each stage of the project cycle. Full details are
given in the relevant guidelines and procedures.
4.1 Organisation
Organisation Structure – review alternatives with Client.
Personnel policies including time sheets, invoice payment procedures.
Sufficient trained people.
Conflict resolution.
Maintain client relationships.
De Beers authorisations
Note: If a large project is being set up, the processes could be aligned to meet
ISO requirements.
Page 27 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
- Environmental
- Commissioning
- Closeout
Control above plans and reports.
Equipment lead times.
4.7 Contracts
Contract plan/philosophy.
Negotiated, selected tender, open tender basis.
Sign-off of vendors’ list by Client
Agree type of contract with Client e.g. turnkey, packaged,
fabrication/installation/commissioning.
Page 28 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
Standard estimate check-lists.
Contract variation request control.
4.11 Procurement
Control procurement schedule.
Tender receipt procedures and signing authorities.
Tender adjudication process, format reporting and signing authorities.
Contract award procedures and signing authorities.
Contract amendment procedures and signing authorities.
Full documentation requirements, scope and timing to be included in
tender documents.
Full details of critical contractors’ / vendors’ personnel to be included in
tender documents (e.g. full-time site planner).
Contract price adjustment to be structured to be competitive in tender
documents e.g. price fixing fee in lieu of automatic adjustments via the
various indices.
General and Special Conditions of Contract to be standard across the
project. It is preferable for a national or international official document to
be used for the General Conditions of Contract.
Foreign exchange risks.
4.12 Progressing
Copy of all orders and contracts to be issued to Project Co Ordinator
Regular visits to be made to Vendors’ factory, fabrication shop etc.
Report on visits to be issued within 24 hours.
Monitor and control variances from plan.
Progressing function to be closely integrated with Quality Control function.
4.13 Inspection
Clearly define quality assurance requirements in tender documents.
Do not skimp on quality assurance personnel.
Control adherence to statutory and specification requirements.
Concession requests for change to specification requirements to be
documented and sign-off by Client.
Page 29 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
4.15 Construction/Commissioning
Construction and Commissioning Planning and Control..
Quality Management Plans and Quality.
Control Plans for construction and commissioning.
Data books
Monitor and control punch lists.
Signed-off mechanical completion and safety clearance certificates.
Signed-off final acceptance certificates.
Adequate resources for construction supervision and commissioning.
As-built drawings.
Operator training.
Operation and maintenance manuals.
Retain contracted construction and commissioning personnel.
Planned reduction in contracted personnel.
Commissioning spares and start-up materials.
Page 30 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-
INDEX
Assignment of Responsibilities.................................................................................................................. 7
Commissioning........................................................................................................................................ 29
Commissioning Stage.............................................................................................................................. 24
Communication........................................................................................................................................ 27
Computer Aided Engineering Design....................................................................................................... 30
Construction............................................................................................................................................. 29
Construction Stage.................................................................................................................................. 23
Contracts................................................................................................................................................. 28
Cost Control............................................................................................................................................. 28
CRITICAL ACTIVITIES CHECKLIST....................................................................................................... 27
Definition and Validation.......................................................................................................................... 17
Disposal and Restoration......................................................................................................................... 25
Documentation Management................................................................................................................... 27
Engineering and Design........................................................................................................................... 28
Engineering, Procurement and Construction Management.....................................................................21
Estimation................................................................................................................................................ 28
Evaluation Phase..................................................................................................................................... 16
Feasibility Stage....................................................................................................................................... 17
Initialisation Phase................................................................................................................................... 13
Inspection................................................................................................................................................ 29
Interested and Affected Parties.................................................................................................................. 6
Man hour Estimation................................................................................................................................ 28
Material Take-Off..................................................................................................................................... 28
Model....................................................................................................................................................... 11
Model Organisation Structures.................................................................................................................. 8
Monthly Progress Report......................................................................................................................... 29
Multi-Disciplinary Task Force..................................................................................................................... 8
Need Identification Phase........................................................................................................................ 12
Needs and Requirements........................................................................................................................ 9
Organisation............................................................................................................................................ 27
Planning................................................................................................................................................... 27
Procurement............................................................................................................................................ 29
Progressing.............................................................................................................................................. 29
Project & Finance Life Cycle Model..................................................................................................... 11
Project Completion................................................................................................................................... 30
Project Execution Plan (PEP).................................................................................................................... 7
Project Initiation....................................................................................................................................... 27
Project Leader........................................................................................................................................... 6
Project Manager........................................................................................................................... 6, 7, 8, 27
Project Philosophy..................................................................................................................................... 7
Project Review......................................................................................................................................... 29
Project Steering Committee....................................................................................................................... 8
Purpose..................................................................................................................................................... 5
Responsibilities........................................................................................................................................ 27
Safety Plan.............................................................................................................................................. 30
Scheduling............................................................................................................................................... 27
Simple Projects.......................................................................................................................................... 8
System Acquisition................................................................................................... 7, 9, 10, 13, 16, 21, 22
System Utilisation.................................................................................................................................. 10
Systems Acquisition................................................................................................................................... 7
Systems Acquisitions Process Work Flow............................................................................................ 9
User Requirement Specification.................................................................................................7
Page 31 of 31
Section 1.0 De Beers Project Management System & Outline of Various Project Phases. 3rd ed. January 2002-