Fex 2008.1
Fex 2008.1
Fex 2008.1
X M
L LL X M M
Y 2008
C,C
MCXM
XM.
L C MM
n preparing for the exam candidates should be mindful that the C modular curriculum
guides the range of content that may be assessed. t is important that candidates allow
appropriate time and resources for preparation for each section of the examination. s this is
the inal
ellowship examination, responses are expected to demonstrate a consultant level of prioritisation,
judgment, integration and decision-making. his report contains marking guides submitted by
examiners for the Q section of the paper to enable candidates to appreciate the standard of
response expected in this exam. he naesthesia viva section contains the opening scenario
and the main topics covered in the vivas.
MLLCC
verall 84% candidates passed the MCQ paper.
he table below outlines the number of questions in each subject category (noting that an individual
question may have more than one subject). nly subjects represented in 4 or more questions are
listed.
he subject spread in the MCQ paper varies from exam to exam, as it is partly determined by the
content of the short answer questions and viva sections of the exam, to ensure that an
appropriately wide range of subjects is covered by the whole examination.
hen sitting the MCQ paper candidates should be mindful that marks are not deducted for
mistakes, so every question should be attempted.
he overall pass rate for this section of the examination was 47%. Candidates are advised to
apportion their time equally amongst the short answer questions as all the questions are worth
equal marks.
Candidates are reminded to read the question carefully and answer the question asked. he use of
abbreviations is discouraged as these can be open to different interpretations. Logical, organised
answers with legible handwriting will attract better marks.
1. Outline how oxygen is stored at the hospital and delivered to operating theatres up to
and including the wall outlet. In your answer include features that ensure the safety of
the system.
o pass candidates were required to outline the most important features of the oxygen supply
including: the presence of a back up supply for the hospital, an alarm system in theatre or the point
of use, the sleeve index or similar connection system, and a few details about the oxygen supply
itself. etter candidates included more details about the and cylinder storage, details about the piping
system, pressures at different points in the system, and mentioned commissioning. ome candidates
did not read the question and included unnecessary details about the anaesthetic machine. here was
often confusion between the sleeve index and pin index systems, and some candidates believed that the
pipeline pressure was further reduced at the wall outlet to prevent barotrauma. hile not being points
that particularly affected the allocation of marks, many candidates stated that oxygen is explosive,
and there was confusion about cylinder sizes and lettering.
2. Why is the radial artery a common site for arterial cannulation? What complications
may occur from radial artery cannulation and how may they be minimised?
Marks were awarded for consideration of the reasons why the radial artery is frequently used:
sually convenient
elatively clean area
uperficial
Collateral circulation
iscrete from nerves
Correlates well with
Complications included:
nfection
hrombosis
and ischaemia
rug injection
echnical aspects such as disconnection/bubbles etc
t was not necessary to discuss all points to pass but it was necessary to relate the answer
specifically to the radial artery and strategies to minimize each complication needed to be
discussed.
his applied anatomy question is very relevant to current regional anaesthetic practice. ood pass
answers included a well-labeled diagram of the relevant cross section noting the appropriate
components of the brachial plexus and importantly local structures relevant to potential
complications.
xcellent answers included commoner anatomical variations that may be seen in this region.
oor answers simply drew a schema of the brachial plexus, others described in unnecessary detail
the indications for and physics applicable to ultrasound. ome drew the anatomy relevant to a
supraclavicular block, rather than the region required. useful recent reference relevant to this
question is the review rticle- egional naesthesia meets ltrasound: specialty in transition, cta
naesthesiol cand;52:456-466 2008.
Marks were awarded in the proportion of 6 for the clinical features and 4 for the treatment aspects.
ith regard to clinical features marks were given for situations where fat embolism syndrome is
likely to occur, the time course of the syndrome and the diagnostic features. he better answers
divided the diagnostic features of the condition into major (respiratory failure, characteristic
petechial rash, and neurological changes) and minor (fever, cardiovascular, renal failure,
thrombocytopenia etc).
Marks were awarded for discussion of early fracture fixation as having a preventative role and the
mainly supportive management involved in the majority of cases. brief discussion of ventilation
strategies and the management of failure/ Cardiovascular collapse was also expected. xtra credit
was given for mention of controversial therapies such as steroids and heparin.
he candidates who scored poorly tended to focus their answer on the fat embolism syndrome
developing intra-operatively as a result of intramedullary reaming. his limited their response both in
terms of the clinical features and the management approach.
5. 65 -year-old female who weighs 85kg and is 165 cm tall ( M 1) is scheduled for
total knee replacement surgery. he has no other health problems. iscuss the pros
and cons of intra-thecal morphine for post-operative analgesia in this patient.
n integrated discussion of the pros and cons of M for this particular patient was required to
achieve a pass in this question. Marks were awarded as follows:
oting the nature of pain after K , the need for adequate analgesia especially with passive M
devices and the dosage of morphine required for analgesia.
iscussion of the pros of M including the simplicity of post-op pain management and
technical ease of administration, the dose-related prolonged duration of action, the absence
of motor block, the minimal C effects post-op if used with spinal L compared with
resulting in earlier oral intake post-op and earlier mobilisation, the reduction of costs with
no need for expensive equipment or frequent attendance by nurses for analgesia.
iscussion of the pros and cons with specific relevance to this patient including this patient's
risk of respiratory depression with need for higher level of monitoring.
etter answers included the incidence and correct treatment of side-effects of opioids the
recognition of early and late respiratory depression and an appropriate discussion of use of
intrathecal catheter/infusion.
6. The electrolyte results below were taken from a 38 year old woman found obtunded 30
hours after abdominal hysterectomy. She had no intercurrent illnesses prior to
surgery. Explain how these electrolyte abnormalities are most likely to have arisen and
describe how you would correct them.
Marks were awarded as follows: 6 marks for how they have arisen (diagnosis, pathogenesis and assessment)
and 4 marks for treatment.
Candidates who had thought about hyponatremia and the possible causes and treatment options did well.
Hyponatremia is not totally academic; patients have died in Australasian Hospitals secondary to
hyponatremia and cerebral oedema. To score well candidates needed too:
Formulate a differential diagnosis for the electrolyte abnormality.
Discuss intelligently how to discriminate between differentials
Recognise that this patient was critically ill.
Illustrate some understanding of free water and sodium homeostasis
Discuss treatment options, including the use of strong saline.
Common errors:
Lack of detail
Failure to recognise that an obtunded patient is symptomatic.
Failure to assess the volume status and urine analysis for sodium and osmolality.
Inappropriate corrective fluid strategies.
“Admission to ICU for correction of low sodium”, is not good enough for a fellowship answer.
7. 4-year-old woman presents at 6 weeks gestation with an anterior placenta praevia
and Caesarean section is scheduled. he has no intercurrent health problems. he
has a history of two previous Caesarean sections under regional anaesthesia.
escribe and justify the changes this history would make to your routine pre-
operative and intra- operative management plan for Caesarean section.
5 marks were awarded for each of preoperative and intra-operative management changes. Key
points to be considered were:
re-operative changes:
Wider team consultation and planning than a routine Caesarean Section because of the risk of major
haemorrhage.
Scheduling to maximize hospital resources.
Procedure must be done by an experienced obstetrician perhaps with additional surgical support
capable dealing with potential for Caesarian hysterectomy and internal artery ligation.
Blood bank/haematology support with X-matched blood in theatre
Consideration of use of cell saver
Discussion of risks and plans with Operating room personnel.
Plans for post-op care.
Discussion of risks and benefits of Regional anaesthesia or general anaesthesia for this procedure.
Discussion of risks and management plans with patient and partner.
ntra-operative changes
Fluid balance management and monitoring
o dditional large bore access with efficient fluid warmer
o dditions to routine monitoring perhaps intra-arterial monitoring+/- C
Efficient patient warming and significance.
Special pharmacology (ergotamine, PGF2a, prostin)
Consideration of the need for a second anaesthetist
satisfactory answer required a good knowledge of the usual practice for the safe provision of
anaesthesia ( or ) for a Caesarean ection, and a clear and concise understanding of how and why
this may need to change in different circumstances.
Candidates who wasted time writing pages on either the pathophysiology of placenta praevia,
failed to gain any marks. surprising number of candidates did not seem to have read exactly what
the question was asking - and failed to mention either how their practice would change, or why.
8. You are asked to provide assistance to resuscitate a baby. ne minute after birth the
baby is apnoeic, grey/blue all over, floppy and unresponsive to stimulation, with a
pulse felt in the umbilical cord stump at 60/min. hat is this baby's score
escribe your resuscitation of the baby.
here were two aspects to this question - calculation of score and neonatal resuscitation.
o obtain a pass, the points regarding neonatal resuscitation which needed to be discussed were:
Airway and breathing - correction of hypoxia. IPPV at appropriate rate.
Circulation - initiation of chest compression at appropriate rate and method.
Resuscitation drugs/doses/routes - particularly Adrenaline
General measures - keeping neonate warm and dry, checking glucose.
oints discussed in those answers which scored higher marks were: approximate weight of term
neonate, size and endotracheal tube position in term neonate, resuscitation drugs/dosing/routes, fluid
resuscitation, consideration of causes of neonatal arrest and management following resuscitation.
etter answers had a structured, clear and systematic approach, and were in fact often shorter
than those answers that scored less.
Most candidates were able to correctly calculate score. ome confused with lasgow
Coma cale ( C ) and calculated a number out of 15, while others spent too much time on this
part of the question and wrote an inadequate answer on neonatal resuscitation.
9. 25 year old man is to have laser surgery for a vocal cord papilloma. hat are
the hazards associated with the use of a laser in this situation and how can
they be minimised
he response to this question was poor considering that there is an ustralian national standard on
this area of practice and all hospitals who are using L are required to have a policy and a L officer.
he better answers took a global approach and discussed the theatre environment and equipment,
the accreditation and safety measures for the staff, including fire drill and the protective
measures for the patient.
Many candidates chose to talk only about one or two of the above areas. his area of clinical
practice requires co-operation, discussion and ongoing co-ordination of the procedure with all
the staff in the theatre. his point was rarely made.
Question 10
Marks were divided between preoperative ( ), intra-operative (5) and post-operative (1)
management with an additional mark for understanding that biventricular pacing is both pacing of
the right and left ventricle (usually via coronary sinus) to restore ventricular synchrony in
patients with poor left ventricular function and heart failure.
Marks were awarded for the following points:
n preoperative management hese patients are high risk and need to be optimised for surgery and
only surgery that is absolutely necessary should be done. atient history and examination should
focus on signs and symptoms of congestive heart failure and poor L function, ventricular
arrhythmia's and pacemaker dependency. evice history should be checked and device performance
optimised.
ppropriate investigations reviewed including recent echo report.
ntraoperative: n view of poor L function and CC invasive monitoring esp. arterial line should almost
be mandatory. he antitachycardiac function of C should be switched off by technician or magnet
placed over device but biventricular pacing should be maintained to optimize L function i.e. do not
change to asynchronous pacing unless patient is pacemaker dependant and diathermy is very close to
the device. witch off rate responsiveness only if surgery and use of diathermy is close to the device.
ack plates for external defibrillation and external pacing should be applied. iathermy precautions
should be adhered to.
ost op: he antitachycardiac function should be switched back on. igh dependency area utilised for
monitoring. ood post op analgesia ordered
he majority of candidates did not appreciate that biventricular pacing is put in for patients with
severe heart failure and poor L function. he majority talked generically about pacemakers. Most did
not appreciate that these patients should be left in biventricular pacing and not changed to as a lot
of candidates suggested.
Most candidates appreciated the effect of diathermy and precautions thereof as well as getting advice
from pacemaker company and cardiology support.
11. You are the anaesthetist at a children's hospital. three- year-old child scheduled
for dental restoration and extractions is found to have a systolic murmur during
your preoperative assessment on the day of surgery. hey have been on a
waiting list for 6 months and have had a dental abscess that settled with
antibiotics. escribe how you would evaluate the significance of this murmur and
how this evaluation would affect your decision to proceed or not with surgery.
Marks were awarded for appropriately evaluating the significance of the murmur by history and
examination (6 marks) and integrating the information obtained into a decision to proceed or not (4
marks).
ood answers addressed the key elements of the question including the setting in a Children's
ospital where ready access to cardiology services is likely, it is a three year old with a systolic
murmur, the commonest age for common innocent murmurs, the procedure is at a high risk for
bacteraemia and bleeding, the parents have been waiting for six months, have already treated a
complication and would be anxious and probably very keen for the case to proceed, there are
stresses and costs involved in cancelling elective surgery for families and staff.
o pass candidates had to note that the aim in evaluation is to differentiate between innocent
physiological murmurs that are of little consequence and structural abnormalities that warrant
investigation pre-operatively. Candidates had to mention some of the symptoms and signs of heart
failure and heart disease in children and the distinguishing characteristics of an innocent vs
pathological murmur. etter answers noted that bacterial endocarditis is also possible with a history
of dental abscess and the possibility of a new heart murmur. etter answers also noted that a
happy, active thriving child is unlikely to have a significant murmur, and the place of pulse oximetry
and an C as simple investigations
here were various appropriate options for proceeding or not depending on evaluation as to the
significance of the murmur and any reasonable discussion gained a pass. n the absence of symptoms or
signs, with a typical innocent murmur, with a normal C , it would be reasonable to proceed with the
surgery. n a Children's ospital, if this was the first time the murmur had been noted and or the
anaesthetist was inexperienced, it would be very reasonable to consult a cardiologist on the day of
surgery, alter the operating list accordingly and schedule the operation for later in the list. he
cardiologist would then have time to perform an echocardiogram if indicated.
ntibiotic prophylaxis with amoxycillin pre op or at induction would not be indicated for an innocent
murmur but would be if pathological.
ny delay for a suspected pathological murmur would require a sympathetic and informed
discussion with the parents and the surgery should proceed without in-ordinate delay after
cardiological review perhaps with an overnight admission and surgery the next day.
xtra marks were gained by: low Chart showing a Management lgorithm, appreciation of an
ability to re-organize consultations and operating lists in referral hospitals, brief mention of new C
and ndocarditis prophylaxis guidelines, and the role of pre-operative trans-thoracic echo by
experienced anaesthetists.
1 . valuate the role of gabapentin in acute and chronic post surgical pain management.
Marks were divided between a brief introduction on the applied pharmacology of the drug which
applied to both areas of the question (2 marks) and its specific role in acute and chronic post
surgical pain for the remainder of the marks
n general the question was answered poorly. Many described neuropathic pain and talked about
the treatment of chronic neuropathic pain often giving correct information but not answering the
question about acute and chronic post surgical pain. Knowledge of basic applied pharmacology and the
effects of gabpentin in the acute pain setting were especially lacking.
14. escribe the advantages and disadvantages of multi-centre clinical trials in anaesthesia
research
Coverage of most of the following points would have been necessary to pass this question:
:
Can undertake studies that are not feasible at a single institution
ecruitment of large numbers of patients.
reater statistical power (e.g. for assessing rare events like
death) Quicker patient recruitment.
ider range of patients and clinical settings, and therefore better generalizability of results
than a single site study.
:
Logistics of managing many centres and staff at remote locations. (e.g. main investigator,
site investigator, patients).
upervision, reliability, honesty and protocol compliance of remote investigators.
xpensive. eed to source large funds usually from competitive grants.
rotocol must be applicable and approvable at all centres.
rotocol must conform with local standards and practices, and ethics.
Logistics of getting protocol through different ethics committees. ariable review standards;
but this is being streamlined through single ethical review (e.g. )
tudies of procedures depend on level of skill at each centre (e.g. epidural analgesia)
ome sites may not recruit adequately, and not offset set-up costs
dditional cost of central administration
:
urden of ensuring data quality, data queries and data cleanup.
eed to develop method of remote data submission.
eed 24 hour support for troubleshooting; especially for centres in different time zones.
May have industry sponsorship that may bias protocol and outcome.
Control of data analysis, writing of paper and publication relinquished to another body.
ata analysis more complicated than single centre study; as it needs to adjust for effect of
centres (i.e. cannot pool all patients as if similar).
Little ability for an individual site to change or influence protocol
pproval of international studies has possible problems of variable national standards, practices,
consent, ethics.
Local review of multicentre studies is a burden for local ethics committees.
ew candidates scored highly. his is surprising given the influence and publicity of recent large
multi- centre trials in anaesthesia conducted throughout ustralia, ew ealand and ong Kong (e.g.
M , - ware, M , poise). Many candidates would have been in departments that have
contributed to these studies.
15. utline the problems in providing general anaesthesia for an adult in the M suite
follows:
he remote location of M suites with implications for personnel, assessment, transfer and
recovery. 1.5
he naesthesia specific issues with regard to M suite
(access/airway/monitoring/drugs/emergency). 1.5
he Magnet specific environment including absolute and relative contraindications for
patient or personnel, ferromagnetic equipment, noise, burns. 2
Management of positioning and quenching magnet. 1
he implications of requirement for in adult claustrophobic/confused/impaired/unstable/etc.
1
ecovery issues (how, where, by whom, efficiency). 1
ange of solutions to various problems of anaesthesia. 1
xtra marks for more sophisticated analysis 1
eneral comments:
verall the standard of answers was poor, with few candidates achieving a high mark. his may have
partly reflected the fact that this question was the last on the paper.
M C L CL C L
he aim of this section of the examination is to assess the candidates' ability to:
pply principles of acceptable safe practice and demonstrate sound clinical judgement
nterpret complex situations and demonstrate ability to adapt to changing clinical situations
Marks are awarded for showing sound judgement in decision making, demonstrating adaptability
to changing clinical situations, applying basic scientific principles to clinical practice and the
ability to organiser and express thoughts clearly. volving clinical scenarios are used in this
section of the exam.
he introductory scenarios, initial questions and overall aims of the vivas were as follows:
2. 2 year old boy was a passenger in a car when he was struck in the head by a
flying brick lost from a passing truck.
n arrival at your hospital the paramedics report he responds to pain and they
have not been able to establish intravenous access.
is initial observations are:
eart rate: 120
lood ressure: 75 systolic
espiratory ate: 25
p 2: 99%
e is receiving oxygen by mask via a self inflating bag and has a bandage
wrapped around his head. e has a hard cervical collar in place.
utline the initial management of this patient.
3 You are called by your dentist colleague to the emergency department. e has
asked you to assess a 17 year old autistic boy who has a suspected tooth
abscess that requires drainage.
he boy has a large left submandibular swelling in the left submandibular region
and has complained to his parents of localised pain.
n arrival to the you observe a fearful young man who is curled up in the corner
being comforted by his parents.
is vital signs are as follows:
120, 110/70, 8.5
hat are the important aspects of your pre-anaesthetic assessment of this boy
hat are the important issues to consider regarding this patient's request not
to be resuscitated
5. 70 year old male requires a left lower lobectomy for squamous cell lung cancer.
e has ankylosing spondylitis, ceased smoking 25 years ago and is otherwise
healthy.
ne week ago under general anaesthesia for bronchoscopy and mediastinoscopy he
was noted to be a rade 4 laryngoscopy.
ow would you manage this man's airway for this surgical procedure
6. 65 year old male is booked for an elective endoluminal repair of his abdominal
aortic aneurysm in the angiography suite. e has had a history of ischaemic
heart disease with an episode of cardiac failure years ago; other medical
history includes controlled hypertension. is previous was 5 years ago for knee
arthroscopy.
Medications: trandolapril, carvedilol, simvastatin. il known allergies
utline your approach to assessing his cardiac risk for this procedure.
8 55 year old male scheduled for open radical prostatectomy is seen in the pre-
operative clinic one week prior to operation. e had a laminectomy for lumbar
radiculopathy three years prior and is on long term oxycodone for chronic back
pain.
e is otherwise well.
uring your discussion of the procedure he asks you if he's likely to need a blood
transfusion.
ow will you respond to his enquiry
9. he obstetricians call you from their antenatal clinic. hey would like you to review
a woman aged years with a M of 8 who is 6 weeks gestation as they are
concerned about her. he says she has become very short of breath recently
and she has marked peripheral oedema.
ow will you evaluate her dyspnoea and set about making a diagnosis
You are the lead care giver. ive an overview of your preparation for the child's
arrival in the mergency epartment.
M
escribe appropriate initial assessment and resuscitation.
iscuss transfusion strategies for massive blood loss in this child.
iscuss the principles of conservative vs operative management of blunt
trauma in children.
iscuss and management of hypoxia due to pulmonary contusions during
laparotomy.
M
iscuss the differential diagnosis of stridor in this patient.
iscuss options to secure airway.
ecognise and manage hypoxia and difficulty with ventilation from
misplaced tracheostomy tube.
12. male anaesthetic trainee in his rd year of training ( Y1) is rostered to be with
you on your routine gynaecology list. You meet the trainee the night before the
list and discuss the management of the booked cases.
he first case is a previously well 66-year old woman undergoing
laparoscopy for pelvic pain.
he other two cases have also been seen in clinic and are previously well
patients undergoing diagnostic laparoscopies for infertility.
hat are your expectations of a trainee at this level of training during this
operating list
13. You are asked to review a 1year old woman in the re-admission clinic. he
has myasthenia gravis and is booked to have a thymectomy via a median
sternotomy.
14. You are contacted by the nurse-in-charge of the Cardiac nvestigation unit, the
morning of your elective list in the catheterisation laboratory. ue to the
breakdown of the X-ray equipment in the regular cath lab, your list has been
transferred to another fluoroscopy suite which has satisfactory cardiac
investigation equipment. You have never been to this location.
Your first case is:
M . . 5M
L C Y L Y Y +/-
Q CY L
15. You are doing a locum for a private group. here is an addition to tomorrow's
list that has been emailed to you at 16.00.
60 year old woman presents for an elective left ankle arthrodesis. he has
had rheumatoid arthritis for 20 years.
er present medications include prednisone 20mg/day, long acting morphine
60mg/day, methotrexate and the C X-2 inhibitor, etorcoxib.
he preoperative questionnaire indicates she has some neck pain and back pain,
with non-specific intermittent pain down one leg. he has indicated she wants the
operation performed under 'some sort of local block'
hat further information do you need from your preoperative phone call the night
before
C M
LXM