JABSREAPER
JABSREAPER
JABSREAPER
net/publication/288454437
Design and development of a cutting head for portable reaper used in rice
harvesting operations
CITATIONS READS
3 5,483
4 authors, including:
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Drought stress effects of engineering and milling properties of rice View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Mohammad Reza Alizadeh on 13 March 2017.
Design and Development of a Cutting Head for Portable Reaper Used in Rice Harvesting
Operations
Nesar Mohammadi BANEH1 Hosein NAVID1 Mohammad Reza ALIZADEH2* Hamid Reza GHASEM ZADEH1
1
Department of Agricultural Machinery Engineering, College of Agriculture, University of Tabriz, Tabriz, IRAN
2
Department of Agricultural Engineering, Rice Research Institute of Iran (RRII), Postal code: 41996-13475, Rasht, IRAN
*
Corresponding Author Received: May 07, 2012
e-mail: [email protected] Accepted: June 12, 2012
Abstract
In this study, a cutting head for a portable brush cutter was designed and for harvesting four Iranian rice varieties, two varieties of high yielding
named Khazar and Fajr and two varieties from local varieties named Binam and Hashemi. Cutting head consisted of a circular saw blade with 24
cm diameter and 2 mm thickness. Designed blade had 136 teeth with 0° rake angle, 30° clearance angle and 6 mm pitch. A simple windrowing
system made from aluminum sheet was designed and constructed. The cutting head installed on existent brush cutter and test was conducted in field
conditions. For each type of variety, the cutting energy and critical blade speed was computed. Results indicated that compared to local rice varieties
Maximum power consumption of about 1.132 kW was obtained for Khazar variety. Results also showed that rice losses of the portable reaper were
lower than manual harvesting and field capacity of machine was 4.20 times greater than manual harvesting.
Keywords: Rice harvesting, rice reaper, brush cutter, cutting energy
Abbreviations
d stalk diameter (m) Pks idling power (kWm-1 of cutting width) E0 cutting energy for cutting of one stalk (J)
Smax maximum cutting force (dan) Esc specific cutting energy (kJm-2) Fmax maximum cutting force (N)
Δm equivalent mass (kg) E modulus of elasticity (MPa) r radius of disk (m)
Pwt total powered required (kW) Wc Cutting width (m) I moment of inertia of stem (m4)
INTRODUCTION
Rice is one of the most important foods for human and has reapers have maximum effective field capacity and effective
a basic roll in secure of food for people of Iran and world. In field capacity by hand harvesting tools is minimum (Hasanjani
1996, rice was consumed by about 5.8 billion people in 176 et al., 2007).
countries (Van Nguu Nguyen, 2000). Harvesting is an important Koniger (1953) studied the principle of cutting plant
field operation for any food grain crops and itis cutting process material and stated that the mechanized separation occurred
carried out when the crops attains such physiological maturity at a predetermined and well-defined location in the material
that a maximum recovery of quality product is obtained. in contrast to crushing where several failure planes usually
Harvesting a crop at an appropriate stage of maturity minimize developed randomly (Ganesh et al., 2007). The cutting process
the field losses, thereby, increasing the total yield as well as in all cases was initiated when the edge of the knife first made
head yield (Mujumdar et al., 2003). contact with the material. During the continued motion of the
Harvesting of field crop is considered a labor intensive knife, the contact forces and stresses increased and a stress
operation and takes about 185-340 man-h/ha to cut and bundle pattern was built up inside the stalk until failure conditions
paddy or wheat crops (Michael et al., 1987) and 170-200 were reached. Chancellor (1988) stated that the biological
man-h/ha for cutting paddy crop (Koniger, 1953). Results of materials commonly subjected to cutting can be classified into
investigation in harvesting of rice crop in Iran showed that two general categories (Mujumdar et al., 2003):
70 N. M. Baneh et al / JABS, 6 (3): 69-75, 2012
1. Non-fibrous materials having uniform properties in all forward speed of 5km/h and tow series of blade with angles
directions at the time of cutting, the cells of these materials 30° and 45° on stalk were accomplished. Blade with 45° angle
being usually turgid with liquid cell materials. accomplished a fine cutting on stalks. Field test of harvester
2. Fibrous materials with high tensile strength fibers oriented for harvesting of 1 ha had total harvesting time of 45 minute
in a common direction and with a comparatively low strength including gathering of harvested stalk without any crushes or
materials bonding the fibers together. For cutting biological uncut stalks. Bautista et al (2005) designed a rotary cutting
materials, operation of a sharp or serrated-edged knife is reaper for rice. Their purpose was replacing the reciprocating
employed. Shear failure is achieved either by using a single cutter bar assembly with a rotary cutting system borrowed from
cutting element such as a sickle, rotary cutters or flail type cutter grass cutters. These rotary cutters require fewer blades and
or by employing double cutting element as in reciprocating-type less manufacturing tolerance. From the laboratory studies, the
cutters. number of blades per disc was set a three; blade tip speed was
In all cutting process, failure in shear or impact or both is set as 23- 30 m/s and forward speed ranged from 2.8 t0 3.3
possible when a system of forces act on the material. Before km/h.
shear failure, the material is invariably first compressed then In recent years several reapers and Chinese brush
bend which increases the work required in a cutting operation cutters were entered in Iran. Imported brush cutters don’t
(Bainer et al., 1978). Yore et al (2002) in order to aid the have satisfactory function and needed some modification to
development of novel header systems for combine measured the improvement of theirs ability for rice harvesting. An existent
cutting force and average cutting energy of rice straw. Treatments rice brush cutter was evaluated but it didn’t work well for
involved single and multiple stems. Result showed that cutting Iranian rice so a cutting head was designed, constructed and
location (node/internode) and number of stems (crop density) evaluated for Iranian rice plant. Therefore the objectives of this
are significant factors in cutting force and energy while rice study were design and constructing of a rice reaper suitable for
variety is not. Shearing energy was highest directly at the node Iranian rice varieties.
and decreased by a factor 2 moving into the adjacent internodes.
The shearing energy directly was proportional to the number of MATERIAL AND METHOD
stems. Tavakoli et al (2010) compared the mechanical properties
between two variety of rice straw (Hashemi and Alikazemi) in In this research a cutting head system was designed
three internodes position down from ear. The shear strength of suitable for portable reapers and four varieties of Iranian rice
Hashemi variety decreased towards the third internode while stem named Fajr and Khazar from high yielding rice varieties
there was no distinct trend for that of Alikazemi variety. The and Binam and Hashemi from local varieties were selected
shearing energy of both varieties increased significantly towards for the experiment. The head of an imported Chinese brush
the third internode. The young’s modulus in bending for both cutter model BG 430 was removed and a new cutting head for
varieties decreased towards the third internodes. Zareiforoush Iranian rice plant was designed and replaced. This cutting head
et al (2010) evaluated the effect of loading rate and internode consisted of a circular saw blade that utilizes impact cutting
position on the mechanical properties of rice straw. The result system for cutting of stems. In shear failure of plant stem that
showed that loading rate had only effect on the bending strength have counter shear, if the distance between blade and counter
and the internode position had significant effect on the shear shear is few, supports against cutting force is supplied by the
strength, shearing energy and young modulus and did not have counter shear. In absence of country shear all of this supports
any significant effect on the bending strength. O’Dogherty et al should be supplied by the plant. This supports supplied by the
(1991) studied the impact cutting behavior of grass and straw bending strength of remained parts of plant under the cutting
stems with sharp and blunt blades. At low cutting speeds of line and moment inertia of parts of plant above the cutting line.
grass stem, about 65% of the energy was utilized in overcoming For design of a special cutting system for numbered plant with
friction. For straw the frictional component was relatively low due attention to physical properties of rice stalk computing the
(5-10) %and stem kinetic energy was equal about 20% of the cutting speed, impact cutting force, impact cutting energy and
total energy input. Tuck et al (1991) studied the performance power required for cutting of stalk with blade is necessary. This
characteristics of rotary cutting mechanisms when cutting energy and power depend on variety, diameter of stalk, maturity
single and groups of grass stems. Results showed that when stage, moisture content and bevel angel (Persson s, 1993).For
cutting groups of stems most uncut stems occurred at speeds of defining the critical cutting speed or minimum speed required
20 m/s and less for blunt blades. for effective cutting stalks in impact cutting, equation (1) was
Persson (1993) designed, built and tested a rotary counter used that obtained from dimensional analyze (Sitkey G, 1986).
shear mower. It consisted of two concentric counter-rotating
discs. Results of tests showed that increase of forward speed
will improve the cutting performance. Cutting speed with this
type of rotors is less than other type of rotary disc cutters. Field
experiments on alfalfa showed that the power consumption was
less than 1.6 kW/m of cutting width. The rotary countershear
mower worked satisfactory in fine crops, tangled crops and
crops mixed with residue. Ghahraeiet al (2008) designed and
developed a special cutting system for sweet sorghum harvester. Where d is stalkdiameter’s (m), Smax is maximum cutting
Developed cutting mechanism in this research had a rotary disk force (daN), Δm is equivalent mass (kg) and c is the constant
with 50 cm diameter and four cutting blade. The stalks cut between 3.13 and 4.43. In impact cutting consumed energy
with the impact inertia forces at the linear velocity of 27 m/s for overcoming shearing resistance of the stem is equal to the
by cutting blade. Harvesting tests in sweet sorghum farm with energy required for quasi-static cutting plus energy expended
N. M. Baneh et al / JABS, 6 (3): 69-75, 2012 71
Field evaluation
In this study, the machine was evaluated for harvesting two
rice varieties namely Hybrid and Hashemi in the experimental
farms of the Rice Research Institute of Iran (RRII), Rasht,
Guilan, Iran. Used machine with designed cutting head is
shown in Fig.7 and the final form of harvested crop is shown in
Fig. 8. Results indicated that the forward speed of the operator
was measured to be 1 kmh-1 and cutting width in each blade
movement was 1.5 m. The total harvesting time in each plot
of 50 m2 was measured to be8 min. The labor requirements for
harvesting was obtained about 26.7 man-hha-1and that of manual
harvesting considering 14 labor in 8 working time was about
112 man-hha-1. Thus, field capacity of machine is about 4.20
Fig. 6. Schematic and dimensions of cutting head (left), schematic of times greater than manual harvesting. Results of investigation
windrowing system (right) in other countries (Van Nguu Nguyen, (2000) showed that field
CONCLUSION
In this paper we designed and constructed a cutting head
system for harvesting Iranian rice plant by portable reaper.
According to this study, Khazar variety has maximum cutting
force and so needed maximum cutting energy equal to 88.33
J. Among studied varieties, high yielding varieties required
cutting speed more than local varieties and critical cutting speed
of Iranian varieties is in range of 25-35 m/s. Power consumption
Fig. 7. Final form of used rice reaper with designed head by a rotating blade with 24 diameter in maximum status is
corresponded to Khazar variety and equal to 1.132 kW, so an
one cylinder internal combustion engine can operate this cutting
Table 7. Losses percentage of rice grain before of harvesting
head. Designed blade was circular saw and had 24 cm diameter,
and after harvesting with designed cutting system based on
percentage of product performance 136 teeth with 0° rake angle, 30° clearance angle and 6 mm
pitch (Fig. 5) and is proper for wooden material and straws
during harvesting time. Results of filed experiments with this
After harvest (%) Before harvest (%) cutting system showed that losses of harvesting was lower than
manual harvesting and operations was done faster since the field
Hybrid Hashemi Hybrid Hashemi repetition
capacity of machine is 4.20 time faster than manual harvesting.
0.45 0.97 0.07 0.09 1
Acknowledgements
0.82 0.63 0.05 0.07 2 Authors are grateful to Tabriz University and Rice Research
Institute of Iran (RRII) for scientific and financial support, and
0.92 1.02 0.06 0.12 3 providing the experimental facilities for this project.
0.75 0.74 0.09 0.05 4
REFERENCES
0.73 0.84 0.06 0.08 average
[1] Bainer R, Kepner RA, Berger EL (1978) Principles of
farm machinery, 3 rd edn. Willey, New York.
[2] Bautista E, Regalado JS, Juliano A, Ishihara S, Monobe
H, Ramos J, Molinawe L (2005) The PhilRice-JICA rotary
rice reaper: redesigning a technology for Filipino farmers
and manufacturers. Rice is life: scientific perspectives for
the 21st century 7: 229-232.
[3] Chakraverty A, Mujumdar AS, VijayaRaghavan
GS,Ramaswamy HS (2003) Handbook of post-harvest
technology cereals, Fruits, Vegetables, Tea and Spices.
Marcel Dekker Inc, p 883.
[4] Chancellor WJ (1988) Cutting of biological materials.
Handbook of Engineering in Agriculture, Vol 1. CRC
prero INC, p 35.
[5] Ganesh CB, Gunner KH (2007) Low cost mechanical aid
for rice harvesting. J Appl Sci. 7(23):315-318.
[6] Hasanjani H, Hoseyni M, Khademolhoseyni N, Alizade
Fig. 8. Harvested crop with designed cutting head system. M (2007) Evaluation of different harvesting method in
Guilan. J Agric Sci 9(1): 23-38.
[7] Kawasthima M (1951) Survey of shape and cutting force
capacity of machine is seven times greater than field capacity of a serrated sickle on the market. Memoir, Coll Agric
of manual harvesting depending on operator’s skill, variety and Utsunomiya University, Japan, 1951.
harvest conditions. [8] Koniger R (1953) Tentative theory for the cutting of plant
Experiments were conducted on 4 repetition and values of stems. Grundlagen der Landtechnik 5: 96-97
filed losses before harvesting and as well as after harvesting was [9] Michael AM, Ojha TP (1987) Principles of agricultural
measured and showed in Table 7. Other research conducted by engineering, Vol 1. New Dehli, ML Jain for Jain Brothers.
Hasanjani et al (2007) showed that losses in cutting stage were [10] O,Dogherty MJ, Gale GE (1991) Laboratory studies of
about 1.015% for manual harvesting. Values of field losses in the dynamic behavior of grass, straw and polystyrene tube
harvesting with this machine are lower than manual harvesting. during high-speed cutting. J Agric Eng Res. 49: 33-57.
The total weight of machine was about 9.5 kg and is suitable [11] Pandey MM, Devnani RS (1981) Development of
for field condition of paddy crops in Iran because of marshy improved CIAE sickle for harvesting cereals. Agric Mech
conditions of paddy. In this condition use of self-propelled in Asia, Africa and Latin America. 12: 54-58.
reapers is impossible and manual harvesting takes more time [12] Persson S (1987) Mechanics of cutting plant material.
and labors thus increase time harvesting and costs. ASAE monograph No 7, American Society of Agriculture,
p 288.
N. M. Baneh et al / JABS, 6 (3): 69-75, 2012 75