Advanced Application 1: Construction Stage Analysis of MSS Using The Wizard
Advanced Application 1: Construction Stage Analysis of MSS Using The Wizard
1
CONTENTS
Summary 1
Bridge Dimensions and General Section / 2
Loads / 4
Summary
Two construction methods, MSS (Movable Scaffolding System) and FSM (Full
Staging Method) are used to construct PSC box bridges span by span. In the MSS
method, concrete is poured onto the formwork that is supported by the MSS. Hence,
false work and shoring are not necessary. In addition when using this method, the
space under the new bridge being constructed can be used without being obstructed
by an existing river or roadway.
The structural system of the PSC Box Bridge, which is constructed using the MSS or
FSM method, changes at each construction stage. Hence, structural analysis should be
performed for each stage, and the sectional stability for each stage must be checked.
To consider time dependent characteristics for the concrete and relaxation of the
prestressing strand precisely, accumulated analysis results for the preceding
construction stages are required for each subsequent construction stage.
In this tutorial, the procedure for performing construction stage analysis of a PSC
Bridge using the MSS method, will be discussed. Analytical results, such as stresses,
prestress losses, deflections and section forces for each construction stage, will be
reviewed.
1
ADVANCED APPLICATIONS
C
L거Girder
더중심
CGirder
L 거 더 중 심
2
Construction Stage Analysis of MSS using the Wizard
In the MSS construction stage analysis, construction sequence shown above should be
followed precisely. In construction stage analysis, each construction stage is defined
through activation/deactivation of Structure Groups, Boundary Groups and Load
Groups. The procedure for performing construction stage analysis using MSS can be
summarized as below. Of the steps given below, steps 2 to 8 are performed
automatically when using the MSS Bridge Wizard.
3
ADVANCED APPLICATIONS
Superstructure Concrete
ASTM Grade C6000
Loads
Dead Load
Self-weight
Input Self-weight
Superimposed dead load
w=38.00 kN/m
Prestress
Strand (φ15.2 mm×22 (φ0.6˝- 22))
Area: Au = 1.387 × 22 = 30.514 cm2
Duct Size: 110/113 mm
Prestressing force: Jacking 70% of tensile strength
fpj = 0.7 fpu = 1330000 kN/m2
Pi = Au × fpj = 4058.362 kN
Prestressing losses after the initial loss are automatically calculated by the
program
4
Construction Stage Analysis of MSS using the Wizard
Relative Humidity: RH = 70 %
Air or Curing temperature: T 20 C
Applied Code: CEB-FIP
Creep Coefficient: automatically calculated within the Program
Shrinkage Coefficient: automatically calculated within the Program
5
ADVANCED APPLICATIONS
For the construction stage analysis, open a new file ( New Project) and save (
Save) as ‘MSS’.
And assign the unit system to ‘kN’ and ‘m’. This unit system can be changed
arbitrarily for the user’s convenience.
- Save (MSS)
6
Construction Stage Analysis of MSS using the Wizard
The PSC box section is Define material properties for PSC box girder and tendon.
defined within the MSS
Wizard, and need not be
defined separately. Properties / Material Properties
7
ADVANCED APPLICATIONS
Perform modeling the MSS Bridge using the MSS Bridge Wizard function. The MSS
Bridge Wizard consists of three tabs – Model, Section and Tendon.
The MSS Bridge and FSM Bridge Wizards automatically create models and
construction stages for the MSS and FSM Bridges, respectively. The difference in
construction stage analysis between MSS and FSM is the method of supporting the
wet concrete and self-weight of formwork. In the FSM method, wet concrete and self-
weight of formwork are supported by shoring and, hence, the PSC box girders, which
have been already constructed, are not affected by them. On the other hand, in the
MSS method, the weight of the wet concrete and self-weight of formwork is
transmitted to the overhanging parts of the constructed PSC box girders through the
rear crossbeam. This prevents uneven deflection across the construction joint. The key
difference between the MSS and FSM can be summarized as “the method in which
the wet concrete and self-weight of formwork are supported during construction”. If
the MSS Bridge Wizard is selected and the Movable Scaffolding Reaction is entered,
The Movable Scaffolding
Reaction is the reaction
from the self-weight of the this reaction is automatically calculated and inputted as a construction stage load.
MSS girder that acts on the
rear cross beam.
Rear Cross Beam
0.2 x L 0.2 x L
굳지 않은
Calculate reaction 콘크리트의
due 자중에of의한
to the weight wet반력 계산
concrete
Rc
8
Construction Stage Analysis of MSS using the Wizard
Select the MSS Bridge Wizard and input bridge material, span layout, horizontal
curvature radius, location of fixed support, location of construction joint, construction
duration for each span (20 days) and initial age for PSC box girder.
In this example, it is
assumed that 15 days
will be required for
installing formwork, If MSS Bridge Wizard is selected, the difference between the Stage Duration and
rebars and sheaths, and
Initial Member Age is calculated in the program to define Additional Steps, and then
5 days will be required
for pouring and curing the reactions due to self-weight of MSS girder and wet concrete are applied.
concrete. Hence, a total
of 20 days per each
segment is assumed.
Structure /
Model tab
Bridge Model Data Type>Type1 ; Bridge Material>1: Grade C6000
Span(L)>10@50 ; Radius (on)>2380; Convex (on)
In MIDAS/Civil, the load
that has a time lag in the Fixed Support>250(50) ; Segment Division per Span>10
same structural system can
Cold Joint (S3)>0.2 ; Anchorage(S4)>3
be defined by using
Additional Steps without Diaphragm(S5)>1 ; Stage Duration>20
having to define a different
construction stage. More
Initial Member Age>5 ; Movable Scaffolding Reaction>4000
detailed explanations can
be found in Functions of
Civil > Construction Stage
Analysis Data > Define
Construction Stage in the
Online help.
9
ADVANCED APPLICATIONS
Section tab
Center tab
H1 ( 0.2 ); H2 ( 2.75 ); H3 ( 0.3 ); H4 ( 0.3 )
H5 ( 0.2 ); H6 ( 0.54 ); H7 ( 0.2 ); H8 ( 0.25 )
B1 ( 2.75 ); B2 ( 0.75 ); B3 ( 2.8 ); B4 ( 1.75 )
B5 ( 1.7 ); B6 ( 1.2 ); B7 ( 0.988 ); B8 ( 1.45 )
View Option>Drawing
10
Construction Stage Analysis of MSS using the Wizard
C
L거 더중심
Girder
11
ADVANCED APPLICATIONS
Input the section properties for the construction joint part referring to Fig. 13. The
defined section shape can be reviewed by selecting Drawing under the View Option.
View Option>Bitmap
Joint tab
H3 (0.3); H5 (0.151); H7 (0.07)
B4 (1.75); B5 (1.28); B7 (0.348)
View Option>Drawing
Diaphragm tab
H4 ( 0.3 ); H5 ( 0.151 ); H6 ( 0.54 ); H7 ( 0.07 )
H8 ( 0.25 ); B5 ( 1.28 ); B6 ( 1.2 ); B7 ( 0.348 ); B8 ( 1.45 )
12
Construction Stage Analysis of MSS using the Wizard
C
L거Girder
더중심
13
ADVANCED APPLICATIONS
Tendons in the MSS Bridge are placed along a curvature within the webs of the PSC
box girder. In the MSS Bridge Wizard, this type of standard tendon placement can be
simply defined by the lowest, inflection and anchorage points.
Generally, the MSS Bridge has equal spans, and the structural system of the first span
is changed from a simple beam to a continuous beam at each stage as construction
proceeds. The maximum bending moment for the first span constructed is larger than
that of the other spans because it is a simply supported condition. Hence, additional
tendons should be provided for the first span. The additional tendons for the first span
are defined by general function, and only typical tendons are defined in the MSS
Bridge Wizard.
0.5
0.5
h
0.567 x h
0.5 x h
0.5 x h
0.44 x h
0.2
0.2
0.4 x L1 0.1 x L1
L1
Girder
CL 거 더중심
0.2
0.15
14
Construction Stage Analysis of MSS using the Wizard
Input typical tendon placement in the longitudinal direction referring to Fig. 14.
Tendon tab
N( 3 ); G1( 0.5 ); G2( 0.2 ); G3( 0.5 )
S1( 0.4 ); S2( 0.1 ); C( 0.2 ); a1( 0.567 ); a2( 0.44 )
15
ADVANCED APPLICATIONS
Input the tendon properties such as tendon areas, constants related to losses and tendon
strength.
16
Construction Stage Analysis of MSS using the Wizard
Input the tendon jacking force, grouting time and transverse arrangement. If the
grouting time is assigned using the Prestressing Step, the stress at the time of tendon
jacking is calculated based on section properties that include the effects of tendon area.
If the grouting time is assigned using Every (n) Stages, the stress at the time of tendon
jacking is calculated based on the net section, and the tendons tensioned during the n
stages are grouted simultaneously at the n-th construction stage. The tendon jacking
force is specified as 70% of the ultimate strength. The transverse arrangement of the
tendons is also defined. The tendons in the MSS Bridge are normally arranged parallel
to the webs of the PSC box girder. The transverse tendon arrangement as such can be
defined by setting the distance between the outer side of web and outer tendon, and
the spacing between the outer and inner tendons.
17
ADVANCED APPLICATIONS
After completion of data input, click button to end the MSS Bridge Wizard
session, and review the model. Specific parts of the model can be magnified and
reviewed by using the Zoom Window and Zoom Fit functions.
Point Grid (off), Point Grid Snap (off), Line Grid Snap (off)
Node Snap (on), Element Snap (on)
Display
Misc tab
Tendon Profile Point (on)
Zoom Window
18
Construction Stage Analysis of MSS using the Wizard
There are two working modes, Base Stage mode and Construction Stage mode, in
MIDAS/Civil for performing construction stage analysis.
In the Base Stage mode, all structural modeling data, loading conditions and boundary
conditions can be defined, but analysis is not performed in this mode. The
Construction Stage represents the state of model for which analysis is performed. In
the Construction Stage mode, the structural model data cannot be modified or deleted,
except that the boundary conditions and loads pertaining to each construction stage
may be changed.
19
ADVANCED APPLICATIONS
We will now review the structural systems and loads by selecting each construction
stage using the Stage Toolbar.
Display
Boundary tab
Support (on)
Load tab
Nodal Load (on)
20
Construction Stage Analysis of MSS using the Wizard
Additional tendons should be provided in the first span because the maximum bending
moment acting in the first span is larger than those in the other spans. This is because
the first span is a simply supported span during construction whereas the other spans
are continuous. The additional tendons in the first span are inputted in construction
stage 1 (CS01).
After completing construction of all the spans by the MSS method, superimposed dead
loads such as pavement, barriers and railings are constructed. We will define
additional construction stages, loads, and superimposed dead loads. The superimposed
dead loads are applied for 10,000 days to account for creep. This will enable the
generation of a camber diagram and, thus, managing the camber.
Define the additional tendons in the first span and the load conditions pertaining to
superimposed (2nd) dead loads.
21
ADVANCED APPLICATIONS
Define prestress for the additional tendons and generate a Load Group
corresponding to superimposed dead loads.
Hidden (off)
Display
Boundary tab
Support (off)
Load tab
Nodal Load (off)
Misc tab
Tendon Profile Point (off)
Group tab
Group / Load Group / New…(right click mouse)
Name>2nd
Name>BotTendon
22
Construction Stage Analysis of MSS using the Wizard
The prestress load due to the additional tendons in the first span acts at the construction
stage CS01. The procedure to apply this additional prestress load in the first span is as
follows:
2. Assign the prestress load due to the defined tendon profile in the load
group “BotTendon”.
3. Activate the load group “BotTendon” in CS01.
680 mm
62 mm
5m 5m 30 m 5m 5m
50 m
CL 거 더 중 심
Girder
2.235 m
0.68 m
The reference point of Define the tendon profile to be added in the first span, referring to Fig. 22. The
the tendon profile is the
Bottom Center of the additional tendons are placed over 40m length between the i-th end of Element 2 and
PSC box section since the j-th end of Element 9. The start and end points of the tendons are each located at
the PSC box section is 5m from the bridge end and the second support. The length of a single element is 50/10
defined relative to the
same location.
= 5m.
23
ADVANCED APPLICATIONS
Loads / /
Tendon Profile>
Tendon Name>Bot1 ; Tendon Property>Web
Assigned Elements>2to9
Input Type>3D ; Curve Type>Spline
Straight Length of Tendon>Begin (0) ; End (0)
The slope is fixed by a
given value if “fix” is ‘on’ Profile>Reference Axis>Curve (on)
or generated within the
1>x ( 0 ), y ( 0 ), z ( 0.68 ), fix (off)
program if fix is ‘off’.
2>x ( 5 ), y ( 0 ), z ( 0.062 ), fix (on), Ry ( 0 ), Rz ( 0 )
Select Curve and input 3>x ( 35 ), y ( 0 ), z ( 0.062 ), fix (on), Ry ( 0 ), Rz ( 0 )
the tendon profile
referenced to circular 4>x ( 40 ), y ( 0 ), z ( 0.68 ), fix (off)
curvature on the X-Y
Profile Insertion Point ( Node 2 )
plane since the current
example bridge is Radius Center (X, Y) ( 0, -2366.882 ); Offset ( -2.235 )
curved.
Direction>CW
13.118 m
Node 59
절점
절점
Node 1 Tendon Name (Bot2); Tendon Property>Web
(0,0) 절점
Node 119
Assigned Elements (2to9)
2366.882 m
Node 2
24
Construction Stage Analysis of MSS using the Wizard
Assign the prestress loads, which are defined by the tendon profile, to the BotTendon
load group, and apply them to the structural system.
25
ADVANCED APPLICATIONS
Activate the load group “BotTendon”, which represents prestress for the first span, at
the construction stage CS01.
Name>CS01;
Load tab
Group List>BotTendon
Activation>Active Day>First;
26
Construction Stage Analysis of MSS using the Wizard
Apply superimposed (2nd) dead load. Input the superimposed (2nd) dead load in
construction stage CS11 because the effect of creep and prestress losses during the
period of 10,000 days should be considered in the analysis. Assign the superimposed
(2nd) dead load to the 2nd load group and apply it to the structural system. The
magnitude of the superimposed (2nd) dead load is 38 kN/m acting in the –Z-direction.
Select all
Load Case Name>2nd; Load Group Name>2nd
Options>Add; Load Type>Uniform Loads
Direction>Global Z; Projection>No
Value>Relative; x1 (0), x2 (1), W ( -38 )
27
ADVANCED APPLICATIONS
Name>CS11;
Stage>Duration >”10000”
Save Result>Stage (on); Additional Step (on)
Load tab
Group List>2nd
Activation
Active Day>First
28
Construction Stage Analysis of MSS using the Wizard
After completing the modeling of entire concrete structure for both superstructure and
substructure, define the time dependent material properties (concrete strength gain
curve, creep coefficient and shrinkage coefficient) for all the sections, and then link
Creep and shrinkage coefficients these properties to each section.
are a function of sectional shape
(“Notational Size of Member”).
Therefore, we must first According to CEB-FIP standards, the creep and shrinkage coefficients for concrete
determine the variable section vary with the member dimensions. Therefore, in order to perform an analysis
dimensions and then input the
time dependent material
considering time dependent material properties, the material property of each section
properties. with different dimensions must be linked one-to-one to the corresponding time
dependent material properties. That is, the number of different time dependent
material properties and general material properties should correspond to the number
of elements with different sectional dimensions. The time dependent and general
material properties must be defined and linked for each element having different
sectional properties.
After completing the above procedure, creep and shrinkage coefficients are calculated
based on the coefficients defined in Step 3 for those elements having the Change
Element Dependent Material Property values during construction stage analysis. The
coefficients defined in Step 1 are not applied.
29
ADVANCED APPLICATIONS
30
Construction Stage Analysis of MSS using the Wizard
The strength of concrete increases with time. In this example, we will use the strength
gain function specified in CEB-FIP.
31
ADVANCED APPLICATIONS
32
Construction Stage Analysis of MSS using the Wizard
When the Change Element Dependent Material Property function is used to define
h (Notational Size of Member), the h value defined in the Time Dependent Material is
ignored. The creep and shrinkage functions for each element are then calculated using
the Notational Size of Member for each element defined by the Change Element
Dependent Material Property function.
If the Auto Calculate option Properties/ Change Element Dependent Material Property
is selected, the Notational
Size of Member for each
section is calculated Select all
automatically and applied Option>Add/Replace
to the calculation of creep
and shrinkage coefficients. Element Dependent Material
If the Input option is
Notational Size of Member>Auto Calculate ; CEB-FIP
selected, the creep and
shrinkage coefficients are
calculated from the defined
value.
33
ADVANCED APPLICATIONS
34
Construction Stage Analysis of MSS using the Wizard
35
ADVANCED APPLICATIONS
There are two methods of reviewing analysis results from construction stage analysis.
One is to review accumulated stresses and displacements of all the members at each
Refer to Results > Bridge Girder
Diagrams in the On-line manual. specific construction stage,and the other is to review the change in stresses and
displacements in specific elements due to the preceding construction stages. Either
Refer to Results > Stage/Step way, the construction stage analysis results can be checked in MIDAS/Civil by means
History Graph in the On-line of graphs and tables.
manual.
In the construction stages of MSS, the maximum stress occurs in the construction stage
1, when the structural system is a simple beam. We now review the stresses at the
bottom of the section for the construction stage 1.
Stage>CS01
Results / Bridge Girder Diagrams
MSS Bridge Wizard automatically Load Cases/Combinations>Step List>First Step, User Step:1 (on)
generates Structure Groups for
reviewing section stresses. Bridge
Load Cases/Combinations>CS: Summation
Girder represents the element Diagram Type>Stress ; X-Axis Type>Node
group pertaining to the main
Bridge Girder Elem. Group>Bridge Girder
girders.
Components>Combined
Combined (Axial+Moment)>1 (-y,+z)
All stresses at upper/lower and
left/right ends can be reviewed Allowable Stress Line>Draw Allowable Stress Line (off)
by selecting Axial, Bending My Generation Option>Current Stage-Step
and Bending Mz.
36
Construction Stage Analysis of MSS using the Wizard
A more detailed stress graph for any specific part can be reviewed. Simply place the
mouse on the part of interest and magnify it by dragging the mouse while keeping the
mouse pressed. We can revert to the original condition by right-clicking the mouse
and clicking Zoom Out All on the graph.
Drag
37
ADVANCED APPLICATIONS
Review the stress changes by construction stages at the second support (i-th end of
Element 11) using Stage/Step History Graph.
Activate Model View. The Model View
Stage/Step History Graph Results / Stage/Step History Graph
menu can be used only
when Model View is in an Define Function>Beam Force/Stress
activated state. Beam Force/Stress>Name (Top); Element No. (12); Stress
Point>I-Node; Components>Bend(+z)
Combine Axial (on)
Define Function>Beam Force/Stress
Beam Force/Stress>Name (Bot); Element No. (12); Stress
Point>I-Node; Components>Bend(-z)
Combine Axial (on)
Mode>Multi Func. ; Step Option>All Steps ; X-Axis>Stage/Step
Check Function to Plot>Top (on); Bot (on)
Load Cases/Combinations>Summation
Graph Title>Stress History
38
Construction Stage Analysis of MSS using the Wizard
39
ADVANCED APPLICATIONS
Review the member force changes by construction stages at the second support (i-th
end of Element 11) using Stage/Step History Graph.
Model View
Results / Stage/Step History Graph
Define Function>Beam Force/Stress
Beam Force/Stress
Name (Moment); Element No. (12); Force
Point>I-Node; Components>Moment-y
Mode>Multi LCase; Step Option>Last Step ; X-Axis>Stage/Step
Check Load Cases to Plot
Dead Load (on); Tendon Primary (on)
Tendon Secondary (on); Creep Primary (on)
Shrinkage Primary (on); Creep Secondary (on)
Shrinkage Secondary (on); Summation (on)
Defined Functions>Moment
Graph Title>Moment
40
Construction Stage Analysis of MSS using the Wizard
41
ADVANCED APPLICATIONS
We will now review the change in tension force as the construction stage progresses.
We can only review the tendons that are contained in the current stage in the Tendon
Time-Dependent Loss Graph dialog box. To review change in tension forces, first
change the construction stage to the stage that contains the tendon of interest and then
select the Tendon Time-Dependent Loss Graph menu. The change of tension forces
caused by the construction process can be reviewed by animation by clicking the
button.
42
Construction Stage Analysis of MSS using the Wizard
In MIDAS/Civil, the tendon coordinates for each quarter station within a single
element can be reviewed in a tabular form.
43
ADVANCED APPLICATIONS
44
Construction Stage Analysis of MSS using the Wizard
Ultimate strength checks should be performed for load combinations of section forces
due to dead load, live load, temperature changes and support settlements for the
completed structure. The analysis for load combinations, other than the load
combination defined by Construction Stage Load, can be performed in the PostCS and
can be combined with construction stage analysis results. In this example, loads other
than construction stage loads have not been defined. Hence, we will define a load
combination for construction stage loads and review the section forces. First, we will
define a load combination.
Change to PostCS Stage>PostCS
because load combinations
can only be defined and/or
deleted in the Base Stage Results / Combinations
or PostCS Stage.
45
ADVANCED APPLICATIONS
Results / /
Front View
Load Cases/Combinations>CB: Dead
Components>My
Display Options>5 Points ; Line Fill (on) ; Scale (1.0)
Type of Display>Contour (on) ; Legend (on)
46