ECEN415/715:Physical and Economical Operations of Sustainable Energy Systems Spring 2021 Homework Assignment #5
ECEN415/715:Physical and Economical Operations of Sustainable Energy Systems Spring 2021 Homework Assignment #5
Energy Systems
Spring 2021 Homework Assignment #5
Problem 1 (60 points) (modified Example 5.7)
Let us consider a small electricity market where the demand varies between 300 and 720 MW. For
the sake of simplicity, we will assume that only one type of reserve is needed and that 250MW of this
reserve is required to maintain security for all loading conditions. Four generators are connected to
this system. The table below shows their relevant characteristics. We will assume that this market
operates on a centralized model, that the generators’ bids to produce electrical energy or provide
reserves are equal to their marginal costs.
Generating units Marginal cost of en- Marginal cost of re- Pmax Rmax
ergy ($/MWh) serve ($/MWh) (MW) (MW)
1 2 0 250 0
2 17 0 220 180
3 20 6 240 180
4 28 7 260 160
1. Give the formulation of this energy-reserve co-optimization problem, and remark the demand
variable as D (Please refer to the format in the Example 5.6 and 5.7 in the textbook).
2. Give the solution of the optimization problem for a range of values of the demand namely
300-720 MW (Please refer to the format in the Example 5.7).
Solutions:
1
1
min C = 2P1 + 17P2 + 20P3 + 28P4 + 0R1 + 0R2 + 6R3 + 7R4
P1 ,P2 ,P3 ,P4 ,R1 ,R2 ,R3 ,R4 ,
such that P1 + P2 + P3 + P4 = D
R1 + R2 + R3 + R4 ≥ 250
0 ≤ P1 ≤ 250
0 ≤ P2 ≤ 220
0 ≤ P3 ≤ 240
0 ≤ P4 ≤ 260
R1 = 0
0 ≤ R2 ≤ 180
0 ≤ R3 ≤ 180
0 ≤ R4 ≤ 160
0 ≤ P1 + R1 ≤ 250
0 ≤ P2 + R2 ≤ 220
0 ≤ P3 + R3 ≤ 240
0 ≤ P4 + R4 ≤ 260
Demand P1 R1 P2 R2 P3 R3 P4 R4
300-460 250 0 40 180 10-170 70 0 0
460-530 250 0 40 180 170-240 70-0 0 0-70
530-620 250 0 40-130 180-90 240 0 0 70-160
620-720 250 0 130 90 240 0 0-100 160
1. Given the parameters shown in the table below, which technology should it adopt for this
plant, assuming that the plant would have a utilization factor of 0.80 and would be able to
sell its output at an average price of 30 $/MWh? Assume the interest rate is 10%. (Even if
you don’t have the final answer, please make sure you write down the procedure.) (20 Pts)
2. If the interest rate is 15%, will Isabel Energy expect higher NPV (Net Present Value) or lower
NPV for the technology adopted? Give answer & explain your conclusion. (20 Pts)
Technology A Technology B
Investment cost 1000 $kW 700 $/kW
Expected plant life 30 years 30 years
Heat rate at rated output 8000 Btu/kWh 6000 Btu/kWh
Expected fuel cost 1.2 $/MBtu 3.0 $/MBtu
2
Solutions:
1
Company A:
• Production Cost = 0.8 × 600 [MW] ×8760 [h/yr] ×8000 [Btu/kWh] ×1.2 [$/MBtu] = 40366
k$
85.778 85.778 85.778
N P V = −600 + + + ... + = 203.71M$ (1)
1.1 1.12 1.130
Company B:
• Production Cost = 0.8 × 600 [MW] ×8760 [h/yr] ×6000 [Btu/kWh] ×3 [$/MBtu] = 75686 k$
50.45 50.45 50.45
N P V = −420 + + + ... + = 52.76M$ (2)
1.1 1.12 1.130
2
The NPV will be lower due to the higher interest rate.