Handbook For Energy Storage Systems
Handbook For Energy Storage Systems
ENERGY STORAGE
SYSTEMS
ABOUT THE ENERGY MARKET AUTHORITY
The Energy Market Authority (“EMA”) is a statutory board under the Ministry of Trade and Industry.
Our main goals are to ensure a reliable and secure energy supply, promote effective competition
in the energy market, and develop a dynamic energy sector in Singapore. Through our work, EMA
seeks to forge a progressive energy landscape for sustained growth.
Website: www.ema.gov.sg
Facebook: facebook.com/EnergyMarketAuthority
Republic of Singapore
CONTENT PAGE
Foreword I
Acknowledgements II
Abbreviations and Acronyms II
1. Energy Storage Systems (ESS) 1
1.1 Introduction 2
1.2 Types of ESS Technologies 3
1.3 Characteristics of ESS 3
1.4 Applications of ESS in Singapore 4
1.4.1 Energy Market Participation 5
1.4.2 Provision of Ancillary Services 5
1.4.3 Consumer Energy Management 6
2. Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) 7
2.1 Introduction 8
2.2 Types of BESS 9
2.3 BESS Sub-Systems 10
3. BESS Regulatory Requirements 11
3.1 Fire Safety Certification 12
3.2 Electrical Installation Licence 12
3.3 Electricity Generation or Wholesaler Licence 13
3.4 Connection to the Power Grid 14
3.5 Market Participation 14
4. Guide to BESS Deployment 15
4.1 Role of a BESS System Integrator 16
4.2 Appointing a BESS System Integrator 16
5. Operation and Maintenance 19
5.1 Operation of BESS 20
5.2 Recommended Inspections 21
6. Conclusion 22
6.1 Energy Future of Singapore 23
Appendices
Appendix A. Design and Installation Checklist 25
Appendix B. Contact Information 27
Appendix C. Examples of ESS Deployments in Singapore 28
Table of Figures
Figure 1: Power output of a 63 kWp solar PV system on a typical day in Singapore 2
Figure 2: Types of ESS Technologies 3
Figure 3: Applications of ESS in Singapore 4
Figure 4: Global BESS deployments 8
Figure 5: Examples of BESS and battery chemistries 9
Figure 6: Image of a Lithium-Ion Battery 9
Figure 7: Model of a typical BESS 10
Figure 8: Screenshots of a BMS [Courtesy of GenPlus Pte Ltd] 20
Figure 9: Self-Regulating Integrated Electricity-Cooling Networks (“IE-CN”)
at the Marina Bay district cooling system [Courtesy of Singapore District Cooling
Pte Ltd] 28
FOREWORD
During the 12th Singapore International Energy Week in 2019, Minister for Trade & Industry, Mr Chan
Chun Sing spoke about Singapore’s Energy Story. This was about transcending the challenges of the
energy trilemma - to keep our energy supply affordable, reliable and sustainable. He also announced
that Singapore would set its installed solar capacity target to at least 2 gigawatt-peak by 2030, enough
to power about 350,000 households for a year.
Singapore has limited renewable energy options, and solar remains Singapore’s most viable clean
energy source. However, it is intermittent by nature and its output is affected by environmental and
weather conditions such as cloud cover. To overcome this challenge, we are deploying Energy Storage
Systems (“ESS”) which has the ability to store energy for later use. ESS not only addresses solar
intermittency, but also enhances grid resilience by actively managing mismatches between electricity
supply and demand. As part of the Energy Story, Singapore has put forth a target to deploy 200
megawatts of ESS beyond 2025 to support the increased deployment of solar.
To facilitate ESS adoption in Singapore, EMA has worked with various regulatory agencies and
industry stakeholders to develop this Handbook for Energy Storage Systems. This handbook outlines
various applications for ESS in Singapore, with a focus on Battery ESS (“BESS”) being the dominant
technology for Singapore in the near term. It also serves as a comprehensive guide for those who
wish to install BESS in Singapore.
We hope that this handbook will help readers better understand the opportunities presented by ESS
and encourage the support of ESS deployment in Singapore.
MR BERNARD NEE
Deputy Chief Executive
Energy Planning and Development Division
Energy Market Authority
Singapore
I
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We would like to thank the following organisations for their support and contributions to the
development of this handbook:
1. Durapower Technology (Singapore) Pte Ltd
2. Energy Market Company Pte Ltd
3. GenPlus Pte Ltd
4. Singapore Civil Defence Force
5. SP Group
Cover photo courtesy of Singapore Tourism Board
Alternating Current AC
Battery Energy Storage Systems BESS
Battery Management System BMS
Battery Thermal Management System BTMS
Depth of Discharge DOD
Direct Current DC
Electrical Installation EI
Energy Management System EMS
Energy Market Company EMC
Energy Storage Systems ESS
Factory Acceptance Test FAT
Hertz Hz
Intermittent Generation Sources IGS
Kilovolt-amperes kVA
Kilowatt-peak kWp
Licensed Electrical Worker LEW
Market Participant MP
Megawatt MW
Megawatt-hour MWh
Operation and Maintenance O&M
Photovoltaic PV
Power Conversion System PCS
Qualified Person QP
Registered Inspector RI
Singapore Civil Defence Force SCDF
Singapore Tourism Board STB
Site Acceptance Test SAT
SP Power Grid SPPG
SP Services SPS
State-of-Charge SOC
State-of-Health SOH
System Integrator SI
II
ENERGY
STORAGE SYSTEMS 01
1. Energy Storage Systems Handbook for Energy Storage Systems
1.1 Introduction
Energy Storage Systems (“ESS”) is a group of systems put together that can store and release energy
as and when required. It is essential in enabling the energy transition to a more sustainable energy
mix by incorporating more renewable energy sources that are intermittent in nature - such as solar
and wind. Such energy sources are also commonly known as intermittent generation sources (“IGS”).
70
60
50
Power output (kW)
40
30
20
10
0
6:00 7:00 8:00 9:00 10:00 11:00 12:00 13:00 14:00 15:00 16:00 17:00 18:00 19:00
As shown in Figure 1, the power output of a 63 kilowatt-peak (“kWp”) solar photovoltaic (“PV”)
system deployed in Singapore fluctuates throughout the day. These fluctuations are a result of
Singapore’s tropical weather conditions. For example, extensive cloud cover on rainy days can cause
a significant drop in solar power output. Such variations in solar power output can cause imbalances
in electricity supply and demand and affect the stability of the power grid.
To ensure that the power system remains stable and reliable, power system operators will require
power generators to be more flexible and responsive to address the intermittency from IGS. ESS’s
unique ability to store energy produced at a particular time for later use can help the system respond
to power fluctuations when required. This will help to smoothen the variable power output and
facilitate the integration of IGS into the power grid.
2
1. Energy Storage Systems Handbook for Energy Storage Systems
ESS technologies can be classified into five categories based on the form in which energy is stored.
Upper
Reservoir
Mechanical
Turbine/
• Pumped Hydro Energy Storage
Pump Lower • Compressed Air Energy Storage
Reservoir
• Flywheel
Electrochemical
• Lead Acid Battery
• Lithium-Ion Battery
• Flow Battery
Thermal
• Hot-Water Storage
H2O • Molten-Salt Energy Storage
• Phase Change Material Storage
Supercapacitor Electrical
• Supercapacitor
• Superconducting Magnetic
Energy Storage
Chemical
• Hydrogen
• Synthetic Natural Gas
ESS is defined by two key characteristics – power capacity in Watt and storage capacity in Watt-
hour. Power capacity measures the instantaneous power output of the ESS whereas energy capacity
measures the maximum amount of energy that can be stored.
Depending on their characteristics, different types of ESS are deployed for different applications.
For example,
i. Flywheel, which spins at high speed ii. Pumped Hydro Energy Storage, which
to store energy as rotational energy, pumps large amount of water to a higher-
is more effective in applications level reservoir, storing as potential energy,
where high-power output is required is more suitable for applications where
for short durations. energy is required for sustained periods.
In comparison, electrochemical ESS such as Lithium-Ion Battery can support a wider range of
applications. Their power and storage capacities are at a more intermediate level which allow for
discharging power at a relatively high output for a reasonable time period.
1
Electricity Storage Factbook, SBC Energy Institute 2013 3
1. Energy Storage Systems Handbook for Energy Storage Systems
ESS can be deployed for several applications, ranging from reducing consumers’ electricity costs,
generating revenue through energy market participation, to provision of ancillary services for the
power grid.
As this handbook provides information on ESS deployment in Singapore, the applications listed below
are specific to Singapore’s power systems.
ESS
Office Buildings
Power Plant
Substation
Solar Panels
Electric Car
Charging Stations
Hospital
Housing Estates
4
1. Energy Storage Systems Handbook for Energy Storage Systems
i. Energy Arbitrage
Owners of ESS can earn additional revenue by buying and storing energy in ESS when electricity
prices are low and discharging and selling energy to the power grid when electricity prices
are high.
i. Regulation
Regulation is a service provided by generators to fine-tune frequency variations due to
imbalances between load and the output from generation facilities. It is a frequency-following
service that maintains the system frequency within the allowable range of 50 ± 0.2 Hz. Due to
its rapid response characteristic, ESS can be deployed as a regulation resource to cover the
second-to-second variations.
ii. Reserves
Reserves are generation capacity that can be drawn upon when there is an unforeseen disruption
of supply. Following a loss in generation, reserves are required and ESS can be deployed as a
stand-by generator in the power system to arrest the fall in system frequency.
In Singapore, there are two types of reserves categorised by their response time.
5
1. Energy Storage Systems Handbook for Energy Storage Systems
There are two types of Demand Side Participation Programmes in Singapore today.
i. Peak Shaving
ESS can reduce consumers’ overall electricity costs by storing energy during off-peak periods
when electricity prices are low for later use when the electricity prices are high during the peak
periods.
6
BATTERY ENERGY
STORAGE SYSTEMS 02
2. Battery Energy Storage Systems Handbook for Energy Storage Systems
2.1 Introduction
Battery ESS (“BESS”) is an electrochemical ESS where stored chemical energy can be converted
to electrical energy when required. It is usually deployed in modularised container and has less
geographical restrictions when compared to other types of ESS. For example, Pumped Hydro Energy
Storage is limited to geographic areas with height variations and large water bodies, while Compressed
Air Energy Storage typically requires underground caverns.
The compact nature of BESS allows for high scalability and versatile deployment. Examples of utility-
scale BESS deployments in other jurisdictions are given below:
Rokkasho, Japan
34 MW/204 MWh Sodium-Sulfur Battery
by NGK Insulators
California, USA
2 MW/8 MWh Vanadium Redox Flow Battery b y
Sumitomo Electric and San Diego Gas & Electric
Hornsdale, Australia
100 MW/129 MWh Lithium-Ion Battery b y Tesla
8
2. Battery Energy Storage Systems Handbook for Energy Storage Systems
There are different types of BESS and battery chemistries available in the market. Each has its own
unique advantages and disadvantages. In the near term, Lithium-Ion Battery is likely to continue to
dominate the market given its cost, energy density and relatively faster response time. The price
curve of a Lithium-Ion Battery is largely driven by the development of batteries in electric vehicles,
and consumer electronics such as laptops and mobile phones.
2
Handbook on Battery Energy Storage System, Asian Development Bank 2018
9
2. Battery Energy Storage Systems Handbook for Energy Storage Systems
i) Battery System which includes Battery Rack, Battery Management System (“BMS”) and Battery
Thermal Management System (“BTMS”);
ii) Power Conversion System (“PCS”); and
iii) Energy Management System (“EMS”).
Battery Thermal
Management System
The BTMS removes excess heat
Figure 7: Model of a typical BESS generation through a heat exchanger
(e.g. air-cooling or liquid-cooling) to
keep the temperature of the battery
within the optimum limits and
Energy Management System prevent overheating.
The EMS monitors, controls and optimises the overall power flow and
distribution of the BESS based on the identified applications.
3
State-of-Charge measures the available capacity as a percentage of the maximum capacity.
4
State-of-Health measures the performance and conditions of the battery in comparison to a new battery.
10
BESS REGULATORY
REQUIREMENTS 03
3. BESS Regulatory Requirements Handbook for Energy Storage Systems
Thermal runaway occurs when excessive heat is generated and accumulated within the battery. This
can happen due to poor system design or mishandling, leading to the build-up of heat and flammable
gas such as hydrogen.
Under the Fire Safety Act, the owner of the BESS has to engage a Qualified Person (“QP”) who is a
registered architect or professional engineer. The appointed QP is required to seek SCDF’s approval
on the plan for fire safety works before the installation of BESS.
Once the works are completed in accordance with SCDF’s requirements, the owner will need to
engage a Registered Inspector (“RI”) to inspect and certify the fire safety works. With the Inspection
Certificate issued by the RI, the QP can then apply for the Fire Safety Certificate through SCDF, on
behalf of the owner.
The application procedures for the Fire Safety Certificate are available at SCDF’s website. If the QP/
owner wishes to seek any clarifications, he/she can arrange a consultation with SCDF.
Under the Electricity Act, an Electrical Installation (“EI”) Licence is required for all non-domestic
electrical installation with approved load exceeding 45 kilovolt-amperes (“kVA”). It is a requirement
for owners of electrical installations to appoint a Licensed Electrical Worker5 (“LEW”) to take charge
of their electrical installations.
The EI Licence will be issued to owners to operate their electrical installation after the appointed
LEW has inspected, checked and certified the fitness of the electrical installation under his charge.
If the owner has an existing EI Licence and the BESS is to be connected as part of the current
electrical installation, the BESS shall be covered under the same EI Licence issued to the owner.
The appointed LEW will have to update the single-line diagram on EMA’s ELISE website.
5
A licensed electrical worker is a person who is technically competent in carrying out electrical work and licensed by EMA to carry out electrical
work. LEWs and their contact particulars can be found on EMA’s ELISE website.
12
3. BESS Regulatory Requirements Handbook for Energy Storage Systems
Under EMA’s current regulatory framework, the type of licence required by the BESS, where one unit
of BESS is defined as one or more batteries connected to a single PCS, is dependent on the name-
plate rating of the BESS. It is determined based on the lower of:
i. Any person who owns a BESS that is either directly or indirectly connected to the grid will be
required to be licensed under an Electricity Generation Licence, or Wholesaler Licence, based
on the following:
Name-plate rating per unit Less than 1 MW or more but less than
10 MW or more
of BESS 1 MW 10 MW
For multiple units of BESS, each unit having its own PCS and connected to the same grid connection
point, the licensing requirement will be based on the name-plate rating of each unit of BESS.
ii. For BESS that is paired with IG S6 (i.e. sharing the same PCS/inverter), such a setup will be
considered as a single generating unit with name-plate capacity determined as the lower of:
Application for the Electricity Generation Licence or Wholesaler Licence can be made via the
GoBusiness Licensing Portal on EMA’s website.
6
Where the AC electricity output of an IGS and a BESS is through separate inverters and PCSs, which are connected in parallel at the same grid
connection point, the licensing requirement for the IGS and BESS will be assessed individually.
13
3. BESS Regulatory Requirements Handbook for Energy Storage Systems
The connection of the BESS to the power grid for all new or existing installations will require the
appointed LEW to complete an online application form and submit the relevant documents to SP
Services (“SPS”) via SP’s eBusiness Portal. Thereafter, the LEW will need to consult SP PowerGrid
(“SPPG”) on the connection schemes and technical requirements.
As part of the submission, the appointed LEW is required to submit installation details, such as the
type of BESS, name-plate capacity, application and installation location. The details collected will
be recorded in a registry maintained by SPPG which will be used to track BESS installations, and
assess the level of BESS in the system and its impact on the grid. This is important for the purpose
of ensuring power system stability, both at the localised and system level. The LEW is required to
inform SPPG before they disconnect or retrofit any grid-connected BESS installations. This ensures
that information in the BESS Registry is kept up to date.
More information is available in SP Group’s Handbook: How to Apply for Electricity Connection.
BESS’s installation will follow the existing requirements in Transmission Code and Metering Code
which are published at EMA’s website.
Under the existing Market Rules, the BESS is required to be registered with EMC as a Market
Participant (“MP”)7 if the owner wishes to participate in the wholesale market and provide ancillary
services.
To register as a MP, interested parties are required to submit relevant documents to EMC. The
application procedures for MP registration are set out in the Market Administration Market Manual
– Registration and Authorisation. MPs are to comply with the Market Rules.
7
For contestable consumers with embedded ESS capacity below 10 MW who participate only in the energy market, they can register under the
Enhanced Central Intermediary Scheme (ECIS) with SP Services and be paid at prevailing half-hourly average nodal prices.
14
GUIDE TO
BESS DEPLOYMENT 04
4. Guide to BESS Deployment Handbook for Energy Storage Systems
To deploy a BESS, the owner can engage a BESS System Integrator (“SI”). The appointed SI will be
responsible for the following:
• Design and install the BESS, • Ensure the Factory Acceptance • Conduct regular inspections
which includes integration of Test (“FAT”) and Site Acceptance and maintenance works after
hardware and software. Test (“SAT”) are conducted to commissioning.
detect any possible faults.
Those who wish to deploy a BESS through engaging a BESS SI may wish to take note of the
recommended procedures8.
STEP 3 Selection of SI
Selecting bids submitted by SIs for the BESS’s engineering, procurement and
construction processes is typically done through a tendering process which
considers the following factors:
8
Please refer to Appendix A. Design and Installation Checklist for more details.
16
4. Guide to BESS Deployment Handbook for Energy Storage Systems
Deploying additional fire suppression Having a reliable BMS for early detection
systems (e.g. powder extinguisher). of overvoltage or high temperature.
17
4. Guide to BESS Deployment Handbook for Energy Storage Systems
iii. Cost
The total cost for the BESS stated in the bids shall include equipment cost (i.e. hardware &
software), installation cost, maintenance cost, etc.
iv. Warranty
Depending on its applications, a BESS is typically designed to last for more than 10 years, with
two levels of coverage:
a. System Warranty which b. Product Warranty which
warrants the workmanship warrants the respective
of the BESS’s installation to equipment parts.
ensure the performance of
the BESS.
However, the details of the warranty can vary widely depending on the battery chemistries,
manufacturers, operating ambient conditions, charging-discharging characteristics such as cycle
life, C-rate9 or Depth of Discharge10 (“DOD”), etc. For example, the warranty period tends to
be lower if the C-rate is higher.
9
C-rate measures the rate of discharge relative to the maximum capacity.
10
Depth of Discharge measures the capacity that has been discharged as a percentage of the maximum capacity.
18
OPERATION
AND MAINTENANCE 05
5. Operation and Maintenance Handbook for Energy Storage Systems
Prior to the handover of BESS, the SI shall conduct basic operation and maintenance (“O&M”) training
for the owner and his/her operator. This is to be supplemented with an O&M manual to cover the
specification of the BESS, software manual, troubleshooting instructions and warranty information.
As the BESS will be controlled by the EMS, minimal operating procedures are required. The BESS
operator shall monitor the performance of the BESS and check regularly for any error messages to
ensure safe operation. This can be done via a monitoring software provided by the SI as part of the
BMS. Typically, the monitoring software will record the various parameters such as power, current,
SOC, cell voltage differences and temperature.
When the BESS is not in operation for an extended period, it is recommended for the BESS operator
to store the battery in a cool and ventilated environment, and to recharge and discharge the battery
regularly to prevent the degradation of battery cells.
20
5. Operation and Maintenance Handbook for Energy Storage Systems
The following table provides some common inspections for the BESS (i.e. non-exhaustive) as
recommended by SI. For more details, the operator can refer to the O&M manual and/or to consult
his/her SI.
Battery System • Battery modules for any abnormal cell behavior (e.g. smell)
• BMS for any error messages
• Ventilation fan for any impeded airflow
• Electrolyte leakages or water ingress
• Worn-out or damaged cables connecting to the battery modules
PCS • Terminal connections for burnt marks, hot spots and loose connections
• Water ingress
• System parameters (e.g. AC voltages, operating temperature) to ensure they are
within appropriate range
21
CONCLUSION
06
6. Conclusion Handbook for Energy Storage Systems
As Singapore progresses towards a cleaner and more efficient energy future, ESS is an important
asset that can provide multiple benefits such as supporting higher penetration of IGS in our power
grid and contributing to grid stability. It plays a vital role to meet Singapore’s 2030 solar target.
Against the backdrop of a growing interest in BESS due to its favourable characteristics, EMA
has developed this handbook to support and facilitate the deployment of ESS in Singapore. With
your continued support, we will continue to update this handbook as ESS technologies, policy and
regulatory frameworks evolve. EMA welcomes feedback and suggestion for future editions.
23
APPENDICES
Appendices Handbook for Energy Storage Systems
You may refer to the following checklist11 once you have decided to install BESS in your premises.
Select a SI. The appointed SI can recommend the appropriate battery chemistry and sizing
5.
of BESS. He/she will be responsible for the overall design and installation of the BESS.
Engage a LEW. The appointed LEW will be responsible for the design and implementation
6.
of the connection of your BESS to the electrical installation and/or power grid.
7. SI and/or LEW to select a PCS which meets the requirement for grid connection.
SI and/or LEW to ensure grounding protection is provided and sufficient breaker capacity
8.
at the switch box.
9. SI and/or LEW to determine if Lightning Protection System is needed for outdoor BESS.
13. QP to schedule a consultation with SCDF and submit Plan Approval for fire safety works.
11
Please note that the list is non-exhaustive and is subject to changes.
25
Appendices Handbook for Energy Storage Systems
22. SI and/or LEW to ensure continuity and insulation tests are conducted.
SI to conduct SAT and compare results with the FAT results. Contact battery supplier
23.
immediately if there is any abnormal operation.
26
Appendices Handbook for Energy Storage Systems
SP PowerGrid (SPPG)
Asset Management & Projects Department
Email: [email protected]
Tel: 6916 8888
27
Appendices Handbook for Energy Storage Systems
Figure 9: Self-Regulating Integrated Electricity-Cooling Networks (“IE-CN”) at the Marina Bay district cooling system [Courtesy of
Singapore District Cooling Pte Ltd]
Awarded by EMA under the Smart Grid Grant Call II (2014), Singapore District Cooling and the
Institute for Infocomm Research developed a hybrid 400 kW/400 kWh Lithium-Ion battery with
Thermal Energy Storage (i.e. ice tanks). The IE-CN is able to lower the district cooling network’s
electricity costs of producing chilled water by up to 38% and mitigate fluctuations in electricity demand
to maintain grid stability. In recognition of its outstanding R&D efforts, this project was awarded the
Merit Award under the Minister for National Development’s R&D Awards 2019.
28
Appendices Handbook for Energy Storage Systems
ESS Test-bed
In Oct 2017, EMA and SP Group jointly awarded Singapore’s
first grid-level ESS Test-bed to evaluate the performance
of Lithium-Ion ESS for different grid applications under
Singapore’s hot, humid and urbanised environment. A 2.4
MW/2.4 MWh Lithium-Ion ESS was deployed in a substation
as Singapore’s first utility-scale ESS. Insights from this
Test-bed helped to establish the standards and guidelines
associated with the deployment of ESS, and shaped the
policy and regulation framework required to facilitate the
introduction of ESS into the electricity market.
Distributed ESS
Awarded under EMA’s Energy Storage Grant Call in 2016,
the project team, consisting of Nanyang Technological
University, Panasonic and Sunseap, developed a cost-
effective Distributed ESS. It connects Lithium-Ion Battery at
multiple sites under a centralised control system to manage
fluctuating output of IGS.
29
DISCLAIMER:
The information in this handbook is for general information only and is subject to revision or change
(including from time to time) in view of developments or changes in the energy or electricity industry
in Singapore, and does not constitute or equate to or have the force of law, regulation, code of
practice, standard of performance or electricity market rules, and is not a substitute for any law,
regulation, code of practice, standard of performance or electricity market rules, that may apply
to the energy or electricity industry in Singapore. The Energy Market Authority (“EMA”) does not
guarantee or warrant the accuracy or reliability of any information in this handbook. The information
in this handbook does not constitute any advice or representation and shall not be treated as
constituting any advice or representation and shall not be relied upon in any way whatsoever, and
does not in any way bind EMA in relation to any matter, including but not limited to any policy or
grant of approval or official permission for any matter or any grant of exemption or any term in any
grant of exemption. EMA reserves the right to revise or change its policies and/or revise or change
any information in this handbook without prior notice or reference. Persons who may be in doubt as
to how any information in this handbook may affect them or their commercial activities should obtain
their own independent professional advice as they consider appropriate. EMA shall not be responsible
or liable for any consequences (financial or otherwise) or damage or loss suffered or cost incurred,
directly or indirectly, by any person resulting or arising from or in relation to any use of or reliance
on any information in this handbook.
www.ema.gov.sg
Republic of Singapore