Lectures 9&10 - MAT1052
Lectures 9&10 - MAT1052
The sum of the series is not equal to .the value of the improper integral, if
it is convergent.
/
(ii) ∫. ' 0 10 and the series ∑/
%3. $% are both divergent.
To Summarize
To use the Integral Test to determine the convergence
or divergence of a given series, ∑% "#$ &" do the
following:
Replace n by x, to get f(x).
Check whether f(x) satisfies the following conditions: (i)
positive, (ii) continuous, (iii) decreasing on (1, ∞).
If the three conditions are satisfied then both the series
and the improper integral converge or both diverge.
Example 1
Determine whether the following series is convergent or divergent:
%
1
! .
'
"#$
Solution:
$
Step 1: Replace n with x to get ) * = .
,
Step 2: Check the three conditions of the integral test:
$
) * = is positive on the interval 1, ∞ .
,
$
) * = is continuous on the interval 1, ∞ .
,
$
) * = is decreasing on the interval 1, ∞ .
,
Example 1 Continued
Step 3: The integral test can be used since all three conditions in
step 2 are satisfied. Thus, check whether the following integral is
convergent or divergent:
#
1
! &%
%
"
The integral is divergent by the p-test, since ' = 1.
"
Therefore, the series ∑#
+," + is divergent by the integral test. This
series is called a harmonic series.
" "
NOTE: The Divergence fails for both ∑# #
+," + and ∑+," +- . However, the first diverges
while the second series converges.
Example 2
For what values of p is the series
%
1
! (
'
"#$
convergent? For example, if we take ) = −1, lim
$
= lim ' = ∞
"→% ":; "→%
Solution:
$ By the Divergence Test,
If ) < 0, then lim =∞
"→% "5 the series is divergent
$ for
If ) = 0, then lim 5 =1 )≤0
"→% "
Example 2 Continued
For the case where ! > 0, the Divergence Test fails. Therefore, we need to find a
different test that will give us information about the convergence/divergence of
the series. So, now it is the time to apply the Integral Test:
(
Step 1: Replace n with x to get % & =
)*
Step 2: We observe that for ! > 0,
(
% & = is positive on the interval 1, ∞ .
)*
(
% & = is continuous on the interval 1, ∞ .
)*
( By the p-test, the integral
% & = is decreasing on the interval 1, ∞ .
)* is divergent for ! ≤ 1
Step 3: Applying the integral test yields,
/ (
∫( )* 0& By the p-test, the integral
is convergent for ! > 1
p-Series
The series in example 2 is called a p-series, another popular
series which we will revisit quite often in our study of series.
In general,
$
The p-series ∑%
"#$ "& is convergent if ' > 1, and divergent if ' ≤ 1.
Note: you can use the above result whenever you need to determine whether a p-series
is convergent or divergent by clearly stating the value of p.
Example 3
Determine whether the following series is convergent
or divergent:
%
1
! (
' +1
"#$
Solution:
$
The Divergence Test fails as lim ". /$ = 0.
"→%
Thus, check whether the three conditions of the Integral
Test are satisfied, if so use it to conclude about the
series.
Example 3 Continued
Step 1: Replace n by x to get ! " =
$
.
% &'$
Step 2: Check the three conditions
$
! " = is positive on the interval 1, ∞ .
% &'$
$
! " = & is continuous on the interval 1, ∞ .
% '$
$ The improper integral is
! " = is decreasing on the interval 1, ∞ . convergent
% &'$
Step 3: The integral test yields,
- 4
1 1 4 > > >
, . 0" = lim , . 0" = lim arctan " 6 = lim arctan < − arctan 1 = − =
" +1 4→- " +1 4→- $ 4→- 2 4 4
$ $
Note: The above two series will play an important role in determining the
convergence or divergence of other series in this section.
Comparison Test
Now, consider the series
%
1
! " .
2 +1
"#$
To test the convergence/divergence of the series above, we
can use the Integral Test as all three conditions are satisfied
-
by the function * + = ./0-
(Check). However, the integral
of f(x) is not easy to evaluate.
How can we then, determine the convergence or divergence
of this series?
Idea: the series looks like a series we know everything
about. Can you guess which one?
%
1
! "
2 +1
"#$
We observe that if we ignore the 1 in the denominator,
we would get the geometric series
%
1
! "
2
"#$
Can we expect the same behavior for both series?
&
Since the series ∑%"#$ '( )& is less than a finite number, then its sum has to be finite.
Therefore, it is convergent. The test we used to conclude about the series is called
The Comparison Test
The Comparison Test
Suppose that ∑"# "$% ∑&# are series with positive terms.
If ∑&# is convergent and "# ≤ &# for all $, and so ∑"# ≤ ∑&# ,
then ∑"# converges.
If ∑&# is divergent and "# ≥ &# for all $, and so ∑"# ≥ ∑&# ,
then ∑"# diverges.
Remarks:
• We are making the assumptions that the terms "# "$% &# are positive because if
something is less than a finite number, it could be a finite number but it may also be−∞.
• The first scenario means that if the infinite sum is less than a finite number then
that sum must be finite.
• The second scenario means that if the series is larger than a divergent series, then its
must be divergent as well.
Example 5
Determine the divergence or convergence of the following
series:
%
5
! )
2( + 4( + 3
"#$
9
Therefore, the series ∑6
345 converges by the Comparison Test.
#3: ;<3;=
Example 6
Test the series for convergence or divergence:
%
ln (
!
(
"#$
In example 4, we showed that the series above diverges
by the Integral Test.
The goal of revisiting this problem is to show that more
than one test can be used to test the convergence or
divergence of a series.
Again, we need to think of a known series with which we
can compare our series of interest.
Example 6 Continued
Can we compare ln # to 1?
5 ./ 0
Therefore, the series ∑031 diverges by the Comparison Test.
0
Remarks about Example 6
As long as the conditions hold for all the terms except for finitely many terms
(the previous example the conditions hold except for * = 1 and * = 2),
then the conclusion of the test hold. This statement is true because an infinite sum
can be written as:
% "( %
! &" = ! &" + ! &"
"#$ "#$ "#"(
This sum is finite no matter what n0 is. A finite number will not
affect the convergence or divergence of a series.
The Limit Comparison Test
Consider the following series:
%
1
! " .
2 −1
"#$
To test the convergence or divergence of the following series, we might try to
compare it to the geometric series
%
1
! " .
2
"#$
We notice that,
2" −1 < 2" , for all 1 > 1
$ $
> Convergent Geometric Series
34 5$ 34 $
% % With 6 = < 1
1 1 3
! " >! "
2 −1 2
"#$ "#$
So the Comparison Test in this case is inapplicable.
The Limit Comparison Test
Goal: Develop a more powerful test.
The Limit Comparison Test (LCT): Suppose ∑ "# "$% ∑ &# are series with
positive terms.
,
If lim - = 0 where c is a positive number, then either both series converge or
#→+ .-
both series diverge.
Remarks:
,
• lim - = 0 means that an and bn almost of the same size up to a constant.
#→+ .-
• c cannot be negative since both terms of the series are positive.
• If 0 = 0, this implies that "# ≪ &# , which is nothing but the old Comparison Test.
Example 7
Test the following series for convergence or divergence
%
1
! " .
2 −1
"#$
Using the LCT, we need to compare the series to one of the series we have
$
information about, which in this case is the geometric series ∑%
"#$ +, .
$ $
Let -" = and 3" = , thus
+, /$ +,
1
-" 2 "−1 2" 2"
lim = lim = lim " = lim =1
"→% 3" "→% 1 "→% 2 − 1 "→% " 1
2 (1 − " )
2" 2
0
$ $
Therefore, by the LCT ∑%
"#$ converges since ∑%
"#$ is convergent.
+, /$ +,
Example 8
Determine whether the following series is convergent or
divergent: The dominant term is 2'(
%
2'( + 3'
!
"#$
5 + ',
.
Dominant term is ', =' /
(" / (
Therefore, a good candidate for comparison is the p-series ∑%
"#$ = ∑%
"#$ .
". "
("/ 12" (
Thus, if we let 0" = and 3" = , we can use the limit comparison test
,1". "
2'( + 3' , 2 , 3
, (
2' + 3' ' 2' + 3'
( ( ' ( 2 +
lim 5 + ' = lim = lim = lim ' =1>0
"→% 2 "→% 2 5 + ', "→% 2 5 + ', "→% , 5
' 2' (( +1
',
Example 8 Continued
% & $
Since the p-series ∑"#$ diverges (( = < 1), then
" &
.
&" /0"
%
∑"#$
by the LCT, the series is divergent.
1/"2
Example 9
Test the convergence or divergence of the series
%
1
! sin .
*
"#$
Solution: For completeness, let us check which convergence test may be
the optimal choice to determine whether this series in convergent or
divergent.
$
Divergence Test fails: lim sin =0
"→% "
The three conditions of the Integral Test are satisfied (check), yet we
$
cannot integrate the function 1 2 = sin .
3
The Comparison Test, will not work here because, the easy inequality
$
that we can think of (for sine) is: −1 ≤ sin ≤ 1, which will not help.
"
Example 9 (continued)
Clearly sin(1/') is positive, since 1/' < 1 for all ' > 1. We also know that sin ,
is positive on the interval from [0, 0]. Therefore, the terms of the series
5
∑6345 sin are positive.
3
To use the LCT, we have to find a series that you know of its behavior
(convergence or divergence). When you look at sin(1/') we can think of either
a geometric or p-series, so we would choose a p-series since we have 1/'. More
precisely, we will compare it to the Harmonic series
5
∑6
345 7 = 1, and hence divergent .
3
Using the LCT yields,
1 GHI E
sin Recall: lim =1
lim ' =1 E→F E
3→6 1
'
5
In conclusion, the series ∑6
345 sin diverges since the harmonic series is
3
divergent.
A Quick Summary
We learned about three tests to determine the convergence
or divergence of series that are neither geometric,
telescopic, nor p-series.
The Integral Test
All these tests share a common
The Comparison Test condition; namely the positivity
of the terms of the series.
The Limit Comparison Test
∑% " " * , - . 8 9
"#* −1 ":*
= − + − + − + −⋯
, - . 8 9 ;
Alternating Series Test (AST)
To determine the convergence of an alternating series,
we make use of the following test:
Therefore, by the Ratio Test, the series is absolutely convergent; and hence
convergent.
Recall: