Midterm Assignment On HRM518.3-Md Badiul Alam-2020210005026-Spring
Midterm Assignment On HRM518.3-Md Badiul Alam-2020210005026-Spring
Midterm Assignment On HRM518.3-Md Badiul Alam-2020210005026-Spring
Southeast University
MIDTERM ASSIGNMENT (Spring Semester)
Course Title: Human Resource Management & Practices
Course Code: HRM518.3
Friday (MBA)
Submitted To:
JINNAT REHENA
LECTURER
SOUTHEAST BUSINESS SCHOOL
SOUTHEAST UNIVERSITY
Submitted By:
Name ID
Md. Badiul Alam 2020210005026
Date of Submission: 18 April, 2021
Answer to the Question Number 1 (a)
1(a).
Human resource management can be defined as “employing people, developing their resource,
utilizing maintaining and compensating their services in tune with the job and organizational
requirements”.
Figure ‐1
Figure ‐2
The ten "Cs" of human resources management are: cost effectiveness, competitive, coherence,
credibility, communication, creativity, competitive advantage, competence, change, and
commitment. The ten "Cs" framework was developed by Alan Price in his book "Human
Resource Management in a Business Context".
Conclusion: A career is a lifetime journey of building and making good use of your skills,
knowledge and experiences. It is the total of all events and relationships in your life that may
relate to all your work: family, friends, education, jobs, and leisure activities. Careers involve
choice, long-range planning, and often, higher pay. Each job you take advances you in your
career. If HRM is your career, you might move from HR assistant, to Compensation manager,
to a manager or management trainee, to a consultant
Figure-1(Personal management)
HRM
Figure-2
The Scope of Services
Human Resource Management is broader in scope than Personnel Management.
The scope of personnel management includes functional activities such as manpower
planning, recruitment, job analysis, job evaluation, payroll administration, performance
appraisals, labor law compliance, training administration, and related tasks. Human resources
management includes all these activities plus organizational developmental activities such as
leadership, motivation, developing organizational culture, communication of shared values,
and so forth.
The human resource management approach remains integrated to the company’s core
strategy and vision. It seeks to optimize the use of human resources for the fulfillment of
organizational goals. This strategic and philosophical context of human resource management
makes it more purposeful, relevant, and more effective compared to the personnel
management approach.
Difference in Approach
The personnel management approach tends to attach much importance to norms, customs and
established practices, whereas the human resource approach gives importance to values and
mission.
The personnel management approach also concerns itself with establishing rules, policies,
procedures, and contracts, and strives to monitor and enforce compliance to such regulations,
with careful delineation of written contract. The human resource management approach
remains impatient with rules and regulations. HR managers tend to relax rules based on
business needs and exigencies, and aim to go by the spirit of the contract rather than the letter
of the contract.
An illustration of this difference in approach lies in the treatment of employee motivation.
The personnel management approach holds employee satisfaction as the key to keeping
employees motivated, and institutes compensation, bonuses, rewards, and work simplification
initiatives as possible motivators. The human resource philosophy holds improved
performance as the driver of employee satisfaction, and devises strategies such as work
challenges, team work, and creativity to improve motivation.
Difference in Nature
Another dimension of the difference is the proactive nature of human resource management
compared to the reactive nature of personnel management.
Personnel management remains aloof from core organizational activities, functions
independently, and takes a reactive approach to changes in corporate goals or strategy.
Human resource management remains integrated with corporate strategy and takes a
proactive approach to align the workforce toward achievement of corporate goals.
For instance, while the personnel management approach concerns itself with a reactive
performance appraisal process, human resource management approach has a more
comprehensive and proactive performance management system that aims to correct
performance rather than make a report card of past performance.
Difference in Application
Personnel management is an independent staff function of an organization, with little
involvement from line managers, and no linkage to the organization's core process. Human
resource management, on the other hand, remains integrated with the organization's core
strategy and functions. Although a distinct human resource department carries out much of
the human resource management tasks, human resource initiatives involve the line
management and operations staff heavily.
Personnel management also strives to reconcile the aspirations and views of the workforce
with management interest by institutional means such as collective bargaining, trade union-
based negotiations and similar processes. This leads to fixation of work conditions applicable
for all, and not necessarily aligned to overall corporate goals.
Human Resource management gives greater thrust on dealing with each employee
independently and gives more importance to customer-focused developmental activities and
facilitating individual employees rather than bargaining or negotiating with trade unions.
Distinguishing between HRM and PM
First of all Staffing objectives, Performance objectives, Change-management objectives and
Administration objectives need to be taken into account, whether personnel management or
HRM. However, personnel management is viewed as workforce centered and more operational
in focus. Personnel managers recruit, select and carry out administrative procedures in
accordance with management’s requirements. They act as a bridge between the employer and
the employee. As a result, personnel managers were seen as functional specialists rather than
strategic managers and often had little power or status in the organization. The personnel
manager needed to understand the needs of the manager and the employee, and articulate those
needs to both sides. Some organizations, however, see HRM as a particular approach in the
management of people. HRM can be seen as a radical new approach linked to strategy and
viewing people as assets who need to be actively managed as part of the long-term interests of
the organization. HRM can be viewed as a radical integrated approach to the management of
people in an organization and, as such, can be seen as a general management function. Where
personnel managers can be viewed as specialists, HRM can be seen as the responsibility of all
managers, particularly senior managers, and as such is proactive rather than reactive.
1. Personnel management deals with employees, their payroll and employment laws. On the
other hand, Human Resources Management deals with the management of the work force, and
contributes to an organization’s success.
2. HRM basically deals with developing personnel management skills. It is Human Resources
Management that develops a team of employees for an organization.
Human resources planning is the important managerial function. It ensures the right type of
people, in the right number, at the right time and place, who are trained and motivated to do
the right kind of work at the right time, there is generally a shortage of suitable persons.
According to E.W. Vetter, Human Resource Planning is ―the process by which a management
determines how an organization should make from its current manpower position to its desired
manpower position.
Human resource planning is a systematic and strategic process aimed at evaluating the current
state of an organization’s human resources and predicting its future workforce requirements.
Also known as workforce planning, human resource planning helps organizations recruit,
retain, and optimize the deployment of people they require to meet strategic business objectives
and respond to changes in the market and the general environment.
A key part of human resource planning is projecting future workforce requirements and
developing strategies for deploying this talent to avoid skills shortages or surpluses proactively.
The aim is to achieve a balance of skills based on the needs and objectives of the enterprise.
HR planning must, therefore, be a continuous process, with a structure and monitoring system
that enables the organization to provide sufficient lead time for the recruitment and training of
employees to meet its future requirements.
HR Planning Methodology
Figure-1(HR Planning)
2) It helps in discovering the unused talent presently available with the organization.
1) To Make Optimum Utilization of Human Resources: HRP helps to make optimum utilization
of
the human resources in the organization. It helps to avoid wastage of human resources.
organizations. It helps to forecast the number and type of employees who will be required by
the organization in a near future.
3) To Face HR Problems: HRP helps to face the HR problems, which are caused by labor
turnover, introduction of new technologies, etc.
4) To Integrate Different Plans: HRP helps to integrate the personnel plans with the other
important plans of the organization.
5) To Make Employee Development Programs More Effective: HRP selects the right person
for the right job. The right person will get maximum benefits from the employee development
programs. Therefore, HRP helps to make the employee development programs more effective.
6) To Reduce Labor Cost: HRP helps to avoid both shortage and surplus of labor. It helps to
make optimum utilization of labor. It also helps to reduce labor turnover. All this helps to
reduce labor cost.
7) To Enable Organizations to Grow: When an organization grows, the number of jobs also
increases. More employees are required to perform these jobs. HRP helps to supply these
employees to the organizations. So HRP enables the organization to grow.
8) To Identify Potential Replacements: Each year many employees either retire or leave or are
taken out of the organization. HRP helps to find replacements for these employees. These
replacements may be either from inside or from outside the organization.
9) To Avoid Disturbance in the Production Process: In HRP, the manpower requirements of
the organization are determined well in advance. So the manpower is supplied continuously to
the organization. This helps the production process to run smoothly. Thus, HRP helps to avoid
disturbances in the production process.
10) Basis for Effective Recruitment and Selection: HRP is the basis for effective recruitment
and selection in the organization. It helps the organization to select the right man for the right
post.
The Benefits and Implications of Human Resource Planning
In a globalized economy fueled by technological innovation, changing work patterns,
demographic or cultural shifts, and changes in customer behavior, the life cycles of business
designs and products are shortening – and organizations must be able to adapt swiftly. Human
capital is more flexible in this regard than physical infrastructure or finance, and the strategies
that a business adopts to survive and thrive must take the management of this vital human
resource into account.
Organizations around the world are recognizing the importance of this. For example, 2020 HR
statistics reveal that 89% of medium-to-large companies have started using comprehensive
annual surveys for engagement assessment. These studies are assisting them in understanding
their workforce better and learning how to keep employees motivated and productive.
Businesses are also appreciating the importance of making a good first impression on their
prospective employees, and providing an incentive for them to fit into the organization and
work enthusiastically for its success. Human resources statistics from 2019 indicate that 87%
of applicants make a positive evaluation of the company and position they’re applying to, after
a positive interview and onboarding experience. The reverse also holds, with 83% of applicants
who reported a negative interview experience changing their initially positive opinion about
the company and the position they’re applying to.
Moving forward, human resource planners will not only have to face the adoption of new digital
processes and technologies — they will also have to accommodate new methods of doing
business, and new realities such as the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, with its movement
restrictions and emphasis on remote working and collaboration. They will likely have to
develop new methodologies for nurturing and retaining existing skills and cast a broader net in
discovering new talent.
Matthew Burr, Moderator of the Upstate HR Podcast and Principal at human resource
consulting firm Burr Consulting, LLC, sums it up like this: “The war for talent around the
world continues to grow. To win the human capital competition, companies should use a
strategic human resource plan as a roadmap to achieve three- to five-year goals. Strategic plans
influence the development of tactical resource planning. For example, a human resources
strategic plan may include long-term aims to recruit and retain excellent staff with a high level
of technical expertise. The tactical plan would include detailed action plans with completion
due dates. For the strategic recruitment goals, the tactical program might consist of short-term
goals, such as benchmarking salaries via survey data, or creating a social media campaign to
identify and recruit technical professionals. The plan may also target filling IT positions
through international recruiting.”
What Human Resource Planning Brings to the Organization
Deployed effectively, HR planning enables a business to optimize its usage of human
resources, increasing productivity while reducing labor turnover, employee unrest, and
absenteeism. It’s important to the enterprise in several respects.
The five business management functions of planning, organizing, leading, directing, and
controlling rely on the oversight and action of human resources planners for their effective
execution. At the organizational level, good HR planning enables the enterprise to optimize its
deployment and utilization of available talent, and to recognize earlier and in more detail the
need for additional or alternative skills.
Besides optimizing its usage of skills, the planning function also provides the organization with
a clearer path to the future, both in terms of anticipating skills requirements and creating an
order of succession for the promotion and shifting of talent within the corporate hierarchy.
Strategic workforce planning enables managers to more easily adapt to changes when
employees retire or leave the organization, and when it comes time to promote or transfer
personnel.
In times of economic uncertainty, human resource planning becomes a value add for the
organization, with its power to foresee and avoid short-sighted staffing decisions. For example,
unnecessary downsizing may result in costs to the enterprise due to the possibility of backlash
from worker’s unions, and the immediate loss of skilled personnel whose replacement will
require time, effort, expense, and training.
For the worker, a comprehensive and well-executed HR plan can provide improved
communications with management and a greater connection with the vision and objectives of
the enterprise. A human resources scheme with provision for incentives can also increase the
worker’s engagement with the organization, their commitment to its progress, and their sense
of job satisfaction.
Final Thoughts
Besides creating a smooth and efficient process for employee management and future
workforce development, human resource planning gives business leaders more freedom to
focus on meeting goals that drive revenue for the enterprise, rather than having to deal with
administrative issues and employee documentation. And with a number of options available,
HR planning isn’t restricted to huge corporations having hundreds of people on their HR teams
— it’s accessible to small and medium-sized businesses, as well.
Summary:
Businesses are therefore wise to lay greater emphasis on building a healthy organizational
structure that motivates the workforce, and on promoting healthy communications between
management and employees. Effective management and planning for human resources can
assist in this. Human resource planning enables businesses to meet their current and future
demands for talent, allowing human resource managers to anticipate and develop the skills
most valuable to an organization, and providing the enterprise with the optimal balance of staff
in terms of available skill-sets and numbers of personnel. Proper planning also provides a path
for future development by establishing a reservoir of talent capable of filling leadership roles.
And in the long term, human resource planning helps align human capital management more
closely with business strategy.
HR Planning Methodology: Step One: Analyze the objectives of your organization Step Two:
Make an inventory of current human resources Step Three: Forecast your HR demand Step
Four: Determine the number and extent of skills gaps Step Five: Draw up an action plan Step
Six: Integrate and implement the plan Step Seven: Monitoring, measurement, and feedback.
Answer to the Question Number 2(b)
Discuss the Major functions of HRM Management and describe different roles of
HRM manager.
(iii) It is not an end in itself but a means of managing people to obtain optimum results.
(iv) It is the responsibility of the organization to provide guidance and counselling to its
employees in planning their careers and in developing and utilizing their knowledge and skills.
(v) The basic aim of career planning is integration of individual needs and organizational
needs.
On the other hand, Training is a planned effort by a company to facilitate employees’ learning
of job-related competencies. Competencies include knowledge, skills or behavior critical for
successful job performance.
The goal of training is for employees to master the competencies and apply them to their day-
to-day activities.
Training is an Intellectual Capital that is concerned with basic skills advanced skills an
understanding of the customer or manufacturing system, and self-motivated creativity.
3) Performance & Compensation: As a business and society changes, so too must an
efficient HR function. Function evaluation is a technical aspect of HR. By evaluating
the HR function, the department ensures that the company is successful at both a
strategic level and with service delivery and support. The company needs to deliver the
level of services required, whilst operating strategically. Practically, function
evaluation involves comparing various parts of the overall HR operation. This can
include the quality, and availability of workers, job location, working times, the
economic situation, job responsibilities, and how much value a job adds to your
organization. The idea behind function evaluation is that similar jobs should be
rewarded similarly. There are different ways of internally ranking functions.
Become a People Analytics Specialist and start replacing gut feeling with data-driven
decision making
Ranking method: a method in which subject matter experts rank functions in terms of
how much they contribute to the organization as a whole. Functions are paired and
raters have to decide which one is more valuable. This is done with all functions and
based on the outcome, a ranking is established.
Classification method: jobs can also be classified in different categories using
classification methods. In this case, jobs are categorized and then ranked within these
categories to come up with a ranking. Categorizations can include education,
experience, the degree of specialized skills needed to do the job, the degree to which
these skills are in-demand, and so on.
Points method: jobs are categorized according to the factors the organization believes
contribute most to its success. Points are then awarded to each category for every job.
These categories can include key competencies, like problem-solving, technical
knowledge, communication and influencing skills, innovative capability, business
acumen, and so on. These competencies will differ per organization
Personal method: in this method, the job itself is not evaluated but the person doing
the job is. Here, employees are rewarded based on their skills and competencies.
Rewards
Rewarding employees for their work is a function that is impossible to miss.
Compensation and benefits are integral to attracting the right kind of candidate for the
role, and company. These will vary across different fields, countries, and cultures.
However, in countries such as the UK, where a public health system provides most
healthcare, to most people, this is not the case. Yet the total rewards framework shows
that rewards are more than just money. They can also be relational and psychological
outcomes.
Rewards include salary but also growth and career opportunities, status, recognition, a
good organizational culture, and a satisfying work-life balance. For example, fantastic
colleagues and meaningful work are also rewarding to employees. The monetary
reward of the job consists of financial rewards and other (secondary) benefits.
The Employee Value Proposition (EVP) sums up all these aspects. The EVP of your
company is distinct from the external image and brand. It is the image a company
reflects to its employees. Rewards are thus much more than just financial. Here is a
non-exhaustive overview of total rewards:
Base salary
Performance-based-pay
Bonuses
Social environment
Job security
Status
Alternating work
Autonomy
Growth opportunities
Feedback
4) Motivation & Maintenance
HR plays an important role in creating and implementing health and safety regulations.
Making these regulations part of the company culture is one of the main functions of
HR.
A famous example is oil company Shell where it is forbidden to walk the stairs without
holding the railing – also in the company’s HQ. This is part of Shell’s ‘Goal Zero’,
which stands for zero accidents. Although holding the railing is much more important
on an oil platform, safety is such a big part of the company culture that safety roles are
applied everywhere.
Personal wellbeing
HR has a function in assisting and taking care of employees when they run into personal
problems. Personal wellbeing is about supporting employees when things don’t go as
planned. Problems in the workplace and outside can negatively impact employee
performance, engagement, and productivity. This, in turn, harms a company’s bottom
line.
Good personal well-being led by your HR department must work at the level of one-
on-one communication with employees, and communication across teams, and
companies. For example, a company may offer an employee assistance program by
which anyone with mental health issues, can access counseling. On an organization-
wide level, the company could hold a mental health awareness day.
Administrative responsibilities
The final function of HR is its administrative responsibility. These include personnel
procedures and Human Resource Information Systems.
Most of us have, at some time been a ‘trainer’. As the training confirms, people, animals even
plants, can be ‘brought to a desired standard of efficiency, condition or behavior by instruction
and practice. Although there is legislation that requires statutory training to be identified,
organizations need to establish their own minimum standards for safe practice tailored to their
business demands and requirements. By publishing their mandatory training requirements, they
are establishing an organizational standard that offers clarity for the workforce and ensures
consistency and quality in their provision of statutory and mandatory training. To provide
proper training and after that its proper evaluation is essential for growth of any organization.
a. Critical analysis of nature of Training and its impact on the performance of the
Organization
b. To identify the gaps that exists between current situation and what is/ will be required
c. To study the cultural change of the organization through training
d. Suggest ways to improve the training based on the identified needs
e. To build confidence in employees to work with clients
f. Improve life style of clients through training of employees
Critical analysis of nature of Training and its impact on the performance of the Organization
Definitions of Training
c. The term training does not mean a traditionally defined program or event. It
has broader meanings because it covers a range of learning methodologies both within
the current job and beyond it.
Training gives confidence to employees to cope with the changes within and outside of
organization. An organization can only be successful by releasing and realizing the potential
of its workers and it can only be achieved by training. In service led industries, people in an
organization are its most important assets and training gives confidence to these people to
perform well. Training always plays a role in the performance of employees and hence
performance and success of organization.
Some of the benefits which an organization can achieve through training are given
below:
An organization is successful if its set objectives are being achieved regularly. It does not
matter if the organization is non-profit making or a commercial organization. Everyone in the
organization has to focus on their tasks to achieve these objectives. According to Truelove
(2007) training provides competence to individuals to perform their job efficiently. It also play
strategic role in long-term by involving leadership and organizational issues in training. It also
develops the organization by examining current methods, values and standards.
To provide best training, it is important to know that what type of training is needed. Martin
and Jackson (2002) describes that training needs arise because of various reasons. Including
political changes, economic changes, and environmental changes, changes in law,
technological changes and social changes.
Training takes place not only in schools and colleges but also in many other settings. It can be
community based training or at workplace. So, it can be classed base or on the job training.
There are many ways of training described in books. The committee on Post-Secondary
Education and Training for the Workplace describes four types of training based on the
characteristics of trainees.
b. Skill improvement Training, this type of training is for employed people who
want to upgrade their job mobility and knowledge through training.
c. Retraining, this type of training is for those people who have been or are about
to be displaced from their jobs so need to prepare for new line of work.
d. Second chance training, this training is for those people who need some basic
education and also job skills in combination with other social services, to reach
economic self-sufficiency through employment.
Another way of classifying training is by the contents of training, for instance, differentiating
the ‘on the job training’ from ‘general training’. In a general training the trainee can use the
gained skills in any firm or job. General training includes basic training skills, stress and time
management, basic computer skills, etc. But on the other hand on the job training is specific to
that job and usually cannot be used in any other firm. For example, training of handling of
customers through a specific machine or specific software used in a firm.
middle and junior level managers are responsible for implementing the training policies
developed by senior management. They should provide all the relevant information to people
involved in training. They should also allow leave to those trainees who have to go for external
training courses. Managers are responsible for team activities, project teams, problem-solving
group work, sharing knowledge, conducting performance reviews, and agreeing development
plans.
Managers sometime report some hurdles in training process. For instance, many organizations
has limited resources, hence they find it difficult to provide funds for training. Training requires
time which sometimes becomes hard because managers are extremely busy in other important
tasks at work. Lack of understanding about the impact of learning and development is also an
obstacle in learning process.
Critical Analysis
Ideally, all organizations integrate training into a comprehensive human resource strategy.
Each member of staff should have a training profile, as part of their own personal development
plan. Social services agencies tend to play this game at the organization level and fail culpably
at the individual level. Their plans, like community care plans and children’s plan, make
excellent, even if soporific, few agencies put the same level of effort into planning for
individual members of staff, unless they are staff with problems who tend to receive a
disproportionate amount of attention in order to dot the i’s and cross the t’s before shifting them
out of the workforce.
An analysis of who gets training in social work agencies tends to show that while some staff
put themselves forward for lots, other get none at all. Sometimes, provider-led courses are put
on with no reference to a training needs analysis simply because an in-house trainer has an
expertise in a particular area. Often, the staff who needs training most avoid it at all cost as part
of their general strategy to evade scrutiny. The social care organization of the future will be a
learning one. It will rely upon its own staff rather than external consultants. It will seek to
rebuild the camaraderie lost during the cold excesses of some public sector business planning
regimes.
Conclusion
This chapter has provided different theories and methods of training. It has also provided the
base to do the research in right way and to explore different angels of training in this research
in the light of the work done by experts of this field. It takes us to the next chapter to discuss
various research methodologies to gain an insight of the various prospects at offer in forms of
forming the right research pattern that could give us reliable results.
Answer to the question Number 3 (b)
Training
The acquisition of Knowledge, Skills and Abilities (KSA), to improve performance on one’s
current job. Usually consists of short-term focus on acquiring skills to perform one’s job
employees to develop the knowledge, skills and attitudes required to carry out the work needed
to meet an organization’s objectives.
Development
The acquisition of knowledge, skills and abilities (KSA), required to perform one’s future job
responsibilities and for the long-term achievement of individual career goals and organizational
objectives. The goal is to prepare employees for managerial careers. Improving an individual
in line with the requirements of that individual.
Methods of training
On the job training: A training method in which a trainee receives instruction and training at his or her
workstation from a supervisor or an experienced coworker. Method by which employees are given hands-on
experience with instructions from their supervisor or other trainer.
On the job training is unstructured most of time. On the job training is not restricted to trainees
own current job. There are also other helpful ways to provide training, for instance, job rotation,
special projects and work shadowing. On the job training can be readily provided on a just-on-
time basis without any delay. Following are the examples of on the job training.
a. Job instruction
c. Coaching
d, Mentoring
e. Peer relationships
f. Self-development groups
g. Learning logs
h. Work shadowing
Comfort Care Services & Bluebird Care both companies are using work shadowing, learning
logs, work diaries and log books very successfully at the moment. It is recommended to provide
staff with books and other material at work place. So, they can gain more knowledge about
mental health issues and care plan of the Service Users. It is also recommended to use role play
techniques for learning. Managers can be trained off-the-job and then they can provide on-the-
job training to staff. It will reduce cost of training for the organization. For instance, cost
involved to send a member of staff on a training course and also cost of covering his/her shift.
• OJT is relatively inexpensive. Trainees learn while producing and there is no need for
expensive training facilities like classrooms or programmed learning devices.
• OJT also facilitates learning because trainees learn by doing and get prompt feedback
on their performance. So it is most effective because it is learning by experience
• It is often informal
• It is least expensive
2. Plan a specific training schedule for each trainee, including set periods for
evaluation and feedback.
On-the-spot lecture
Gather trainees into groups and tell them how to do the job.
Viewed performance
Feedback
such as when the sales manager makes a call with a new salesperson.
Following Nellie
This describes the process of working alongside a colleague to observe and learn the skills
needed for a particular process. This can be a faster and more useful way of learning a job role
than studying a written manual. The colleague is always on hand to answer any questions or
deal with any unexpected problems.
Job-aid approach
A job aid (step-by-step instructions or video) is followed while the trainer monitors
performance.
Sequence
Following a planned sequence. On-the-spot lecture, gather trainees into groups, and tell them
how to do the job.
Off the job training: Off the job training helps to get the background knowledge needed for
some jobs. Off the training is mostly provided at academic schools, colleges and universities.
It helps individuals to develop skills to get a job. Off the job training will help individuals to
acquire basic knowledge, theories and legislation governing specific type of job. Off the job
training is very helpful to build confidence in individuals. Following are other examples of off
the job training.
c. Computer simulation
Training is an ongoing process. According to Martin and Jackson first of all it has to be
analyzed that what are the training needs usually it is called ‘training needs analysis’ then the
next process is to find out that how to plan a training program to satisfy all those training needs
which has been identified. Third step is to implement training program, it is recommended for
a trainer to keep in mind that what learning style is preferred by trainees. Last step is to evaluate
the training provided. This training cycle is continuous, because of today’s dynamic business
world.
There are many methods of training. Organizations have to find best suitable method of training
for its employees. There are many factors which determine the method of training. These
factors include cost, culture of organization, nature of learner group or individual learner,
benefits, applicability of method and organization’s strategic goals. It is noted by Marching
Ton & Wilkinson that traditional ways of learning and development are still most common and
effective. At non-managerial level and junior manager level instructor-led training was most
effective way of training but for senior level managers external coaches or a mentor was seen
to be most effective.
Training and development activities are not ends in themselves. Unless, there are some positive
changes in the performance of organization, training method need to be improved. It is
necessary to evaluate training to improve performance of company. Evaluation is also
necessary because organizations invest heavy amounts of money in training. Without
evaluation of training it is impossible to improve the process of training. Following points are
expanded from the reasons of training evaluation Martin and Jackson (2002) has described:
b. To see whether the needs and objectives of the training have been met.
d. Justification of expenses.
Training sometimes lacks planning, resources, time and also sometimes training is done for the
wrong reasons or in a wrong way. Evaluation of training is also difficult because most of time
it is hard to measure. Sometimes it is measurable but the expectations of outcome may be
wrong. For example, operating unit managers are looking for increased performance only after
training and not necessarily the increased learning, but trainers usually judge their training by
the increased learning of trainee. According to Berge (2008) it is very important to know the
causes for difficulty in evaluating training in the workplace because it will be helpful for
planners to plan training evaluation and to develop ways to overcome the difficulties.
It is hard to evaluate training in a company which deals with people suffering from mental
health problems because it is difficult to see changes in service users’ life due to staff training
and these changes are also not measurable. Some changes might does not have direct link with
staff training at all. But still there are many things which can be noticed and judged after
training and hence training can be evaluated to some extent. Personal experience tells that
training can be evaluated by interviewing employees to check their confidence level after
training, change in their behavior and improved performance can be noticed.
According to Torrington, it is easy to evaluate training when outputs of training are clear to
see. For instance, increasing trainee’s typing speed or reducing errors while dispatching goods
in a warehouse. But it is very difficult to evaluate the success of management training program
or social skill development. Training can be evaluated at different levels with different
techniques for each level. Examples of these levels are given below:
a. Level 1: At this level reaction of trainee observed about training and
methods of training. It is also recommended to observe that what the point of view of
trainee about training is.
b. Level 2: At this level it is checked that whether the trainee learned what
was expected.
d. Level 4: It is monitored that after training what are the changes in the
performance of that particular department.
To survive in this commercial world, all organizations have to continuously provide training
to their employees to make sure that they have up-to-date knowledge and up-to-date skills
(Martin and Jackson, 2002). These are essential for any organization to prosper. In a free market
economy all organizations has almost similar access to capital, customers and employees. The
only thing which distinguishes one organization from other is effectiveness and efficiency of
that organization. And this effectiveness and efficiency can only be acquired from knowledge
and skills of employees through training.
2. Preparing training plan: Ask your self “What are we going to achieve in the time
period?” Use a holistic approach by using a calendar for inputting your training
activities. Consider whether to design a long (5-10 years), medium (3-5 years) or short
(1 year) term plan.
6. Completing the training plan: Target group – assess your audience, Topic – task, skill
or attitude ingredient, Method –direct (one way communication) or indirect
(discussion, games, experimental exercises…). Important as evaluation of trainees
usually lies on the perception on what they did in the training session, Time – length,
period, breaks important to consider, Location – away from the office?
8. Evaluating the training: Three Levels of Evaluation, such as, Immediate Feedback,
Survey or interview directly after training, Post-Training Test, Trainee applying
learned tasks in workplace? Post-Training Appraisals, Conducted by immediate
supervisors of trainees.
9. Planning future training: After taking all evaluated comments, trainers should modify
the programs to keep good things and make suggested improvements
Remember, even with the same topic for different trainees, trainers should address
many parts of the training process again and consider new approaches.