25 Reticulocytes
25 Reticulocytes
25 Reticulocytes
1986, 8, 169-179
REVIEW
Reticulocytes
In the 1860s Erb noted granules in red blood cells of humans and animals made
anaemic by venesection. He used picric or acetic acid to demonstrate these
granules (Erb 1865). These granules may have been ‘reticulum’ or perhaps
denatured haemoglobin similar to Heinz bodies. Ehrlich was probably the first
investigator to describe the cells now regarded as reticulocytes. He used
methylene blue to stain the reticulum. He thought that the reticulum was a
‘progressive coagulation necrosis of the stroma’ (Ehrlich 1891). In 1891 Smith
described supravitally stained erythrocytes containing reticulum in pernicious
anaemia of cattle, a disease caused by the tick-borne protozoan Boophilus
annulatus. He felt that these cells represented not degenerative forms, but rather
‘embryonic corpuscles, sent into the circulation before their time to make good
the losses going on’ (Smith 1891). In the early 1930s Heilmeyer published the
Correspondence: John A. Koepke, MD, P.O.Box 2929, Duke University Medical Center, Durham,
N C 27710.
169
170 J.F. Koepke and J.A. Koepke
Physiology of reticulocytes
Reticulocytes are immature red blood cells (RBC) in the final stages of
differentiation contemporary with the metarubricyte’s release into the peripheral
circulation. A reticulocyte is formed when a metarubricyte (orthochromatic
erythroblast) ejects its nucleus. The erythroblast divides unequally so that the
smaller portion contains the nucleus and a thin rim of cytoplasm while the larger
portion becomes the reticulocyte. The expelled nucleus is quickly ingested by a
neighbouring macrophage and is destroyed. The reticulocyte must then traverse
the wall of the marrow sinusoid, a specialized marrow vessel, in order to gain
access to the peripheral, blood circulation. The exact mechanism by which the
reticulocyte crosses this barrier is not known. Some investigators feel that the
diapedesis occurs at a junction between two endothelial cells similar to leukocytes
(Bessis 1973) while others feel that the mature reticulocyte passes through the
cytoplasm of a single endothelial cell (emperiopolesis) rather than between two
cells (Tavassoli & Takahashi 1982). In vitro measurements of membrane and
whole cell deformability indicate that erythroid maturation is accompanied by a
progressive increase in cellular deformability (Leblond, LaCelle & Weed 1971).
Thus, irrespective of the mechanism, more mature erythroid cells may more easily
transverse the marrow sinus wall.
The early reticulocyte contains mitochondria, a small number of ribosomes,
the centriole, and remnants of Golgi bodies. It is the precipitation and
aggregation of these organelles (particularly ribonucleoprotein) by supravital dye
techniques that give reticulocytes their name. The exact appearance of the
Reticulocytes 17 1
0. 1. It.
111. IV.
Figure 1. Reticulocyte maturation according to the five stages proposed by Heilmeyer (1932). 0,
nucleated red cell within marrow space; I, dense reticulum in the most immature non-nucleated cell;
11, more extensive but looser reticulum; 111, residual reticulum network; IV, scattered granules of
reticulum. This stage proves to be the most difficult to consistently identify. Reprinted with
permission Friedman (1984).
precipitate is extremely variable. When stained it may take the form of a delicate
network, a collection of fragments and rods, a few scattered dots, or diffuse fine
granules. This precipitate has been variously termed reticulum, granulo:
filamentous substance and reticulofilamentous substance (Marshall 1978). Hence
the cell is called a reticulocyte.
Maturation of the reticulocyte, determined by radioiron kinetic studies,
normally requires about three and one half to four days, and usually only the last
24 hours ,,or so is spent in the peripheral blood (Labardini et al. 1973,
Papayannopoulou & Finch 1975, Hillman & Finch 1985). Numerous
morphologic changes occur during the maturation of the reticulocyte (Bessis &
Bricka 1952). Using phase microscopy it has been shown that the youngest
reticulocytes have a multilobular form and are motile while more mature
reticulocytes are cup-shaped and non-motile (Coulombel, Tchernia & Mohandes
1979). Ultrastructural studies have shown that as the reticulocyte matures, the
mitochondria decrease in size and number and show degenerative changes such
as vacuolization and loss of cristae. The reticulocyte ejects degenerating
organelles by autophagy, the process in which small vacuoles encircle organelles,
fuse into a large single autophagosome, and then ejects the contents into the
extracellular space (Simpson & King 1968). Maturation of the reticulocyte is
concurrent with synthesis of the remaining one-third of the red cell haemoglobin
content (Papayannopoulou & Finch 1975).
172 J.F. Koepke and J.A. Koepke
In the United States the most popular supravital staining technique for
reticulocytes is the new methylene blue (NMB) method, first described in the late
1940s (Brecher 1949). t
Reference ranges
Correction methods
Shift correction
The reticulocyte count in the peripheral blood is a result of three variables: (1) the
rate of release of reticulocytes from the bone marrow; (2) the degree of
immaturity of the freshly released reticulocytes; and (3) the rate of disappearance
of reticulum (Baldini & Pannacclulli 1960). The last variable is usually not
appreciated, Under most conditions the relationship between the absolute
reticulocyte count and the number of erythrocytes produced in the bone marrow
is linear. However, in periods of intense erythropoietic stimulation younger
reticulocytes (so-called ‘shift cells’) are released into the peripheral blood. These
‘shift’ cells are basophilic macroreticulocytes with a cell diameter about 25%
greater than normal cells (Perrotta & Finch 1972). Some investigators feel that
under the effects of an erythropoietic stress, a generation is skipped in the
maturation sequence and larger cells are released prematurely into the circulation
(Brecher & Stohlman 1961, 1962). Other investigators do not postulate a skipped
generation but rather feel that these larger cells are not significantly different
from normal marrow reticulocytes but are merely released prematurely. Once in
the circulation they lose both haemoglobin and water and become normal
erythrocytes (Ganzoni, Hillman & Finch 1969, Papayannopoulou & Finch 1975).
In periods of intense erythropoietic stress, the reticulocyte maturation time in the
marrow may be shortened to less than 1 day, while the reticulocyte maturation
time in the peripheral blood correspondingly lengthens. Thus the number of
reticulocytes may be markedly increased in the blood without any increase in the
erythropoietic activity in the marrow. In theory only the last day of a
reticulocyte’s life should be considered when evaluating erythrocyte production.
There is no practical way, based on RNA content, to accurately determine the
age of a reticulocyte. However, if one sees an abnormally’high percentage
(greater than 5%) of ‘shift’ cells an empirical correction for RBC maturation
based on the packed cell volume may be made. A reticulocyte count corrected
both for PCV and maturation time is termed the reticulocyte production index.
Use of the reticulocyte production index as compared to an uncorrected
174 J.F. Koepke und J.A. Koepke
Marrow
Normoblasts and Blood
Hematocrit Reticulocytes Reticulocytes
t
45 3.5
35 3.O
25 2.5
15 1.5
I
Figure 2. The correlation of the packed cell volume (haematocrit) with the blood reticulocyte
maturation time. With increasing anaemia (and erythropoietin production) the maturation time of
the erythroid marrow normoblasts and reticulocytes progressively shortens from a normal 3.5 days
to 1.5 days or less. Conversely the reticulocytes in the peripheral blood persist for a longer time
when the patient is anaemic. These facts should be taken into account when calculating the
reticulocyte production index (reprinted with permission from Hillman & Finch 1985).
The maturation time of the reticulocyte in the peripheral blood is taken as 1 day
when the PCV is 0.45k0.5, 1.5 days when the PCV is 0.35k0.05,2 days when
the PCV is 0.25 k0.05,and 3 days when the PCV is 0.15k0.05 (Hillman & Finch
1967). Thus if a patient has an observed reticulocyte count of 9% and a PCV of
0.25, the reticulocyte production index is 2.5 (9% x 25/45+2). These
relationships are shown graphically in Figure 2. The normal range for the
reticulocyte production index is the same as for the uncorrected reticulocyte
count since the normal maturation time in the peripheral blood is 1 day.
There are certain pathological states, e.g., renal failure, where the
erythropoietin output is not consistent with the degree of anaemia present, and
the expected prolongation of reticulocyte maturation time does not occur. For
the shift correction to be valid, there must be a normal relationship between the
degree of anaemia and the increased erythropoietin concentration which
produces the shift. This is validated by finding a high percentage of basophilic
macroreticulocytes, or 'shift' cells, in the peripheral blood film.
Reticulocytes 175
There are two major factors which may influence the reliability of the reticulocyte
count; one is physiological and the other is related to laboratory technique
(Friedman 1984).
The physiological factor relates to the physiological variation of reticulocyte
production. Variations in the reticulocyte count have been claimed to occur
diurnally, daily or seasonally, but these deviations are not felt to be significant
(Lowenstein 1959).
Inter- and intralaboratory imprecision and inaccuracy affect reticulocyte
counting. The initial studies in this area were done in the 1970s by the College of
American Pathologists Hematology Resource Committee. They demonstrated an
extremely high interlaboratory coefficient of variation (from 25 to 48%) on three
stained reticulocyte smears distributed in the 1971, 1972 and 1974 Comprehensive
Hematology Surveys (Gilmer & Koepke 1976). Subsequent studies indicate four
different analytical variables which may contribute to the technical variation in
reticulocyte counts. They are: (1) interobserver variation in reticulocyte
definition; (2) the size of the sample of red cells evaluated; (3) the type of blood
176 J.F. Koepke and J.A. Koepke
film evaluated (i.e., variability in cell distribution); and (4) the use or lack of use
of an insert in the ocular of the microscope as a counting aid for standardization
of area reduction (Savage & Skoog 1985).
The best documented cause of imprecision in reticulocyte counting ,is
interobserver variation in the definition of a reticulocyte. The identification of the
Heilmeyer group IV cell is the most variable measurement due to interlaboratory
variation in the exact definition of a group IV cell and it was suggested that two
or more clumps or granules of reticulin be visible (Gilmer & Koepke 1976).
However, other authorities require an identifiable reticulum network remain
while others require three dots of reticulum. The inaccuracy of counting group IV
cells is further magnified by the fact that cytoplasmic particles unrelated to
ribosomal RNA may appear as granules on a supravital stain. These include
siderotic granules, nuclear remnants, Heinz bodies, precipitated stain and other
debris. One can readily appreciate that the difficulty in positivity identifying
group IV cells combined with the fact that about 60% of the reticulocytes in the
circulation are group IV cells can easily lead to markedly increased imprecision in
reticulocyte counts.
A statistical appraisal of manual reticulocyte enumeration was investigated by
Peebles, Hochberg & Clark (1981) who concluded that technologist-to-
technologist variation was the major source of inaccuracy at all reticulocyte
levels. The source for this large variation was different criteria for the
morphological identification and enumeration of reticulocytes. Although the
results might be clinically useful, they felt it was extremely difficult to obtain
manual results with sufficient accuracy to serve as a ‘reference’ reticulocyte
method (Peebles et al. 1981).
The second major analytical variable contributing to imprecision in
reticulocyte counting is the size of the sample evaluated. The precision of
reticulocyte counting follows a binomial distribution. Since the normal
percentage of reticulocytes is low, statistical variation can be great. For example,
the 95% confidence limits for a 1% reticulocyte count when 100 red blood cells
are counted is 0.03 to 5.45%; when 1000 red blood cells are counted the 95%
confidence limits drops to 0.48 to 1.84%. Thus it is appropriate to count at least
1000 red blood cells to maximize analytic precision in manual reticulocyte
counting (Greenberg & Beck 1984).
Variation due to the type of smear stained for examination is the third major
analytical variable which may contribute to the imprecision in reticulocyte
counting. One study reports that the distribution of reticulocytes and
erythrocytes is more uniform on spun slides as compared with wedge films (May
& Sage 1976). Further testing is needed to evaluate this potential source of
reticulocyte count imprecision.
Finally, the use or the lack of use, of a standardized area reduction device as a
counting aid in the microscope may contribute to imprecision in reticulocyte
counting. Early studies indicated that the use of the Miller disk for reticulocyte
counting diminished the observed standard error of the reticulocyte count
particularly at low reticulocyte levels (Brecher & Schneidermann 1950). However,
Reticulocytes 177
most laboratories have chosen not to use such an aid. This too is an area which
requires further testing to evaluate its contribution to the imprecision of
reticulocyte counting.
The present manual New Methylene Blue method for performing reticulocyte
counts is time consuming since 1000 red blood cells must be counted. However,
even when counting this number of cells this method is still relatively imprecise.
Because of this, methods for automating this laboratory test are being developed.
One technique recently developed uses automatic scanning of a NMB-stained
blood film with a pattern recognition device such as a Geometric Data Hematrak
(Perel, Herrman & Watson 1980), or a Coulter diff 3 (Kaplow & Crouch 1982).
The data obtained with these methods appears to be highly reproducible and in
good agreement with manual counting techniques. However, one major
drawback of the Hematrak system is that the operator must manually review all
reticulocytes found by the Hematrak. With time this leads to a decreasing
counting accuracy due to operator fatigue.
In 1952, a method for counting reticulocytes using acridine orange
fluorescence was first reported (Kozenow & Mai 1952). Certain fluorescent dyes
(e.g. acridine orange, pyronin Y and thioflavin T) combine with ribosomal RNA
in reticulocytes to produce fluorescence in ultraviolet light. The amount of
fluorescence in a particular cell is proportional to the amount of RNA present,
which in turn relates to the maturity of the reticulocyte. There is satisfactory
agreement between the microscopic fluorometric results and those obtained by
counting separately the four Heilmeyer reticulocyte maturation groups (Vander,
Harris & Ellis 1963; Thaer & Becker 1975). These fluorescent staining techniques
combined with flow cytometry have led to new automated systems for
reticulocyte counting (Tanke et al. 1980, 1983; Sage, O’Connell & Mercolino
1983). These flow cytometry methods have the potential to overcome the two
major deficiencies of the currently used manual reticulocyte counting methods.
First, since large numbers of cells are counted, the statistical reliability of low
reticulocyte counts as well as small changes in the reticulocyte count are much
improved. Second, as the amount of fluorescence in a cell is proportional to the
amount of RNA in the reticulocyte, these systems give information on the degree
of maturation of the reticulocyte population. This provides a more accurate
means for assessing the effective rate of red cell production by accounting for
shortened marrow transit time.
Reticulocytes have transferrin binding sites on their surface that are lacking on
mature red cells. This fact has led to an adaptation of the automated system
described above in which an immunofluorescent assay with antitransferrin
receptor antibody (which identifies the transferrin receptor on reticulocytes) is
combined with flow cytometry. This system also appears to give reproducible
reticulocyte counts (Seligrnan et al. 1983).
178 J.F. Koepke and J.A. Koepke
References