Chapter-7 - Traffic Survey and Analysis
Chapter-7 - Traffic Survey and Analysis
Chapter-7 - Traffic Survey and Analysis
The construction of about 700 km long Jalandhar – Moga – Bhatinda – Kishangarh - Ajmer Express
Highway is one of these proposed highways which have been identified for implementation under
this programme. The NHAI as employer and executing agency has commissioned the services of
Intercontinental Consultants and Technocrats Private limited (ICT) in joint venture with Consulting
Engineers Group (CEG) Ltd, for carrying out consultancy services for preparation of Detailed
Project Report for Jalandhar – Moga – Bhatinda – Kishangarh - Ajmer expressway under this
programme.
Survey Duratio
Sl.
Location Locations Type of Survey n in Date on Survey Performed
No
No Days
Suratgarh to
17 37 Bikaner
CVC 3 20-11-2017 to 22-11-2017
Ajmer to Merta CVC 3 20-11-2017 to 22-11-2017
18 38
City Origin Destination 1 20-11-2017
Kishangarh to CVC 3 20-11-2017 to 22-11-2017
19 39
Jaipur Origin Destination 1 22-11-2017
Videography Classified Traffic Volume Count Survey was conducted at 16 locations, each location
representing mid-block count station for different homogeneous sections of the project road. The
videography was conducted for 7-day and 3-day durations at different locations (as mention in Table
7.1) to capture traffic in each direction. The cameras used for videography has infrared night vision,
so that the traffic netted during night is visible.
The video cameras were mounted on 12 feet high tripods, so that there is no occlusion in captured
videos. The video streams were stored continuously in a DVR, and for safety, every hour video was
saved in an external hard disk / pen drive.
Care was taken to ensure -
i. No vehicles are stopped in front of camera and no obstruction interrupts the video streams.
ii. There is continuous power supply to cameras and DVRs
iii. Sufficient shade is provided to protect cameras from adverse climate.
iv. Extra cameras, DVRs, etc., were maintained at site so that the video capture is continuous
and uninterrupted.
The video captured was processed at the laboratory for classifying the vehicles (through an image
processing software) based on the pre-decided vehicle categories in intervals of one hour. The
software used for classifying vehicles will store images of detected and classified vehicles in
different categories. Each image has time, date and vehicle type in its file name.
Following photographs depicts the site arrangement made for the traffic counts.
IMAGES
The count and classification was correlated to get an accurate and reliable traffic count and
classification in all conditions. The processed video was annotated through software. The annotated
video contains category types of vehicles superimposed on the video (for example, when a 2-axle
Truck passes through the vision of the camera, the annotated video displays the text of “2-axle
Truck”). This enables review of vehicle count as well as classification at a later date – without
counting the vehicles again. For ready reference a sample of screen shots of post processed images is
shown below.
IMAGES
The primary objective of O-D Survey is to study travel patterns of goods and passenger traffic along
the study corridor. The results have also been useful for identifying the influence area of the project
road, estimating the growth rates of traffic and planning the tolling strategies and for locating the toll
plazas on the most viable section of the project road.
The O-D survey was carried out for one day (24 hours) at twelve locations shown in
Table 7.1, simultaneously along with the Videography based classified traffic volume counts.
Roadside interview method was adopted for the survey. The vehicles were stopped on random
sample basis with the help of police, and trained enumerators interviewed the drivers to obtain the
required data. During the surveys the information pertaining to trip length, commodity types, loading
pattern and trip purpose as applicable for various vehicle types were recorded.
Axle Load Survey was carried out for 2 days (48 hours) at nine locations on the project road. The
main purpose for carrying out the survey was to assess the overloading pattern on the corridor and to
estimate Vehicle Damage Factor based on the commercial (Heavy) vehicle volume which is using
the road.
During the survey, Axle load of commercial vehicles, i.e. LCVs, 2-Axle, 3-Axle, Multi Axle Trucks
and Buses, were weighed on random sampling basis. The vehicles were stopped with the help of
police and the drivers were directed to stop their vehicles in such a way that wheel of each axle can
be weighed using portable Axle Load Weighing Pad. The readings were recorded by trained
enumerators for each axle separately.
The detailed Traffic Volume count data and analysis are given in Appendix-4.1 (Volume-II, Part-
I). The counts observed at the toll locations have been analyzed for the following:
Average Daily Traffic (ADT)
Traffic Composition
Daily Variation of Traffic
Hourly Variation of Traffic
Annual Average Daily Traffic (AADT)
From the above data it is understood that at all the locations 50% to 70% traffic composes
of 2 Wheelers, 3 Wheelers & Cars, while 10% to 30% is commercial traffic. The traffic
composition in terms of percentage at all the survey locations follows as:
Daily Variation
The direction wise daily variation of traffic at all the locations with respect to 7 days and 3
days average follows as:
Figure 4.3: Direction wise daily variation of traffic at Location 18 (Siwani -Rajgarh)
Location 19 Rajgarh to Churu
Figure 4.4: Direction wise daily variation of traffic at Location 19 (Rajgarh - Churu)
Figure 4.5: Direction wise daily variation of traffic at Location 20 (Nohar - Sahawa)
Figure 4.7: Direction wise daily variation of traffic at Location 22 (Taranagar - Churu)
Figure 4.8: Direction wise daily variation of traffic at Location 23 (Churu – Fatehpur)
Figure 4.9: Direction wise daily variation of traffic at Location 24 (Fatehpur – Sikar )
Location 25 Sikar to Kuchaman
Figure 4.13: Direction wise daily variation of traffic at Location 37 (Ajmer – Merta
City)
Location 39 – Kishangarh - Jaipur
The direction wise daily variation of traffic at all the locations with respect to 7 days average
follows as:
The hourly variation graphs for all the survey locations are as follows:
CVC-1 (km 104+000)
Figure 4.22: Hourly Variation of Total Traffic for Both Directions at km 104+000
Figure 4.23: Hourly Variation of Total Traffic for Both Directions at km 140+000
The directional distribution of tollable traffic for UP Direction v/s DN Direction has been
worked out, the directional split follows as:
S. UP Direction DN Direction
Location
No. (Raebareli - Allahabad) (Allahabad - Raebareli)
The directional distribution graphs for all vehicle categories for each location are as follows:
CVC-1 (km 104+000)
The calculation for Annual Average Daily Traffic (AADT) is done by multiplying the ADT
values with Seasonal Variation Factors (SVF). Seasonal variation factors by vehicle types
are required to account for variations in the pattern of traffic volume on the project road
sections over different months or seasons of the year. There are various methods of
determining the seasonal factors such as through past traffic count data or secondary data
(fuel sales data or toll plaza data). The past traffic count methodology is useful if it is carried
out round the year, but year round counts are seldom done in India on any road. Therefore,
the seasonal factors are generally calculated through secondary data. The traffic count
data is collected from an existing toll plaza located on Lucknow Raebareli stretch at km
42+500 to calculate the monthly SVF. The data is collected for duration of 12 months from
June 2015 to May 2016. The Average factors thus derived are as follows:
From the values obtained above, it is understood that the seasonal factors obtained from
toll data are consistent. The traffic survey was done in the month of November 2017, hence
the values considered for Seasonal factor will be from June 2015. The values thus adopted
for all the locations are follows as:
Categories SVF
Car/Jeep
Bus/Truck
LCV
MAV
Others
Applying the factors derived above the Annual Average daily Traffic in Vehicles and PCU
are given below:
The O-D survey was conducted at 12 different locations along our project corridor.
Roadside Interview Method was adopted for conducting the survey. The vehicles were
stopped at random under police presence and drivers were interviewed by trained
enumerators to collect the needful information/ data. The pertinent information in respect of
travel characteristics including the following were collected during these interviews:
Section-19 Section-20
Data Checking
The collected O-D data of all the locations was entered in the computer and checked
manually. Incorrect entries were corrected by cross checking with original field data sheets.
The data were also checked for inconsistencies, and other logical errors, the inappropriate
data has been discarded too. The sample size thus left for both the toll locations for
different categories is as under:
Section No. 19
km 140+000
Zoning System
In order to assess the movement pattern of traffic on the project influence area, a zoning
system has been developed keeping in view the major trip generation & distribution points.
The details of the traffic zones adopted for the study are presented in Table 4.13. The
project influence area mainly comprises of Immediate Influence Area (Zones along project
corridor, i.e. Jalandhar – Moga – Bathinda - Kishangarh- Ajmer), Intermediate Influence
Area (other zones of Punjab, Haryana & Rajasthan) and Broad Influence Area (Rest of the
states).
After coding of Origin – Destination data, a variety of commodity movement is found on the
project road, the commodities were categorized and allotted codes as presented in Table
4.14. Due consideration has been given to include all possible commodities and are
categorized into homogenous groups. Composition of commodity movement for all
categories combined is given below in the form of bar charts for each location.
Commodity
Commodity Type Description
Code
1 Minerals Coal etc.
2 Food Grains Wheat, Rice etc.
3 Cash Crops Cotton, Jute, Tea etc.
Vegetables, Fruits, Fish, Meat, Milk and
4 Perishables Items Milk Products etc.
5 Wood and Forest Products Timber, Furniture etc.
6 Building Materials Brick, Cement, Sand, Lime, Stone, Iron etc.
7 Oil and Natural Gas Petrol, Diesel, Oil, Lubricant etc.
8 Grocery Items Soap, Salt, Sugar, Pulses, Spices etc.
Electronic items, Vehicles, Medicine,
9 Manufacturing Items Leather, Wine, Tobacco, Rubber/ Tyre,
Plastics, Cloth, Paper etc.
10 Others Fertilizer, Rubbish, Animals etc.
11 Empty ------
The Origin-Destination details were collected from the trip makers during the O-D survey on
sample basis as stopping and interviewing all the vehicles was not possible. The sample
size varied for different survey locations depending upon the volume of traffic moving on
the road. Sampling rate also varied with the change in traffic flow during different time of
the day at the same location. Care had been taken to eliminate any element of bias in the
sampling method. Since the data was collected on the sample basis, expansion factors are
required to replicate the pattern as reflected in the sample to the total number of vehicular
trips made during the day. These expansion factors are calculated separately for each
class of vehicle. For example if “xc“ is the number of cars interviewed and “Xc“ is the total
number of cars counted during the day, then “Xc/xc“ would be the expansion factor for cars.
OD Matrices are developed to assess the traffic movement pattern. These matrices actually
provide distribution of inter-zonal trip movements for each zone. Multiplying the sample O-D
matrix obtained from the survey data with the expansion factors developed, vehicle wise O-
D matrices for both the survey locations were obtained. Accordingly O/D matrices, by
various vehicle categories, were developed for each of the survey locations. O-D matrices
for different vehicle types for each count station in the project road are presented in
Appendix-4.3 (Volume-II, Part-I). On the basis of O-D matrices, travel pattern of the
vehicles moving on the project road is discussed below.
Travel Pattern
The analysis of travel pattern reveals that about majority of trips are within the project
corridor & within the state and negligible trips to other states. The mode wise distribution of
trips (%) across various regions mentioned above is as follows:
Standar
d Bus 2- Axle 3- Axle
Zones Car Mini Bus LCV MAV
(Govt. & Truck Truck
Pvt.)
Standar
Mini d Bus 2- Axle 3- Axle
Zones Car LCV MAV
Bus (Govt. Truck Truck
& Pvt.)
Standar
Mini d Bus 2- Axle 3- Axle
Zones Car LCV MAV
Bus (Govt. Truck Truck
& Pvt.)
Commodity Analysis
The commodity distribution at both the locations followed by the major commodities carried
directionally is mentioned below:
S.
Commodity LCV 2 Axle 3 Axle MAV
No.
1 Minerals
2 Food Grains
3 Cash Crops
4 Perishables Items
6 Building Materials
8 Grocery Items
9 Manufacturing Items
10 Others
11 Empty
S.
Commodity LCV 2 Axle 3 Axle MAV
No.
Note: More than 40% empty LCV and 2 Axle are moving in one direction. It might be due to
change in route by the vehicles.
S.
Frequency LCV 2 Axle 3 Axle MAV
No.
1 Minerals
2 Food Grains
3 Cash Crops
4 Perishables Items
6 Building Materials
8 Grocery Items
9 Manufacturing Items
10 Others
11 Empty
100.00 100.00 100.00
Total 100.00%
% % %
Figure 4.30: Commodity Distribution at km 140+000
The O-D survey data has been further analyzed to obtain lead and ranges for various
passenger and goods vehicles. The trip length frequency distribution in terms of proportion
for the selected range is presented in Table 4.21 & Table 4.22.
Table 4.7.3-14: Mode Wise Distribution of Trips by Various Lead Ranges (%) at km
104+000
Trip Length
Car Mini Bus Standard Bus
0-20
20-50
50-250
250-500
500-1000
1000-1500
>1500
Total Vehicles 100.00% 100.00% 100.00%
Table 4.7.3-15: Mode Wise Distribution of Trips by Various Lead Ranges (%) at km
140+000
The intensity of traffic loading and corresponding damaging of different categories of vehicles is an
important parameter for the design of pavements. The primarily objective of axle load survey is to
determine the Vehicle Damaging Factor (VDF) of commercial vehicles and over loading. The
survey was conducted at 9 locations for 2 days (48 hrs) on random sampling basis to cover
directional traffic for both empty and loaded commercial vehicles using portable weighing pads.
The survey was carried out on random sampling basis to cover directional traffic for both empty and
loaded commercial vehicles, i.e. LCVs, 2-Axle, 3-Axle, Multi Axle Trucks and Buses. The drivers
were directed to stop their vehicles in such a way that wheel of each axle can be weighed using
portable Axle Load Weighing Pad.
Axle load Survey Image-01 Axle Load Survey Image-02
Figure 4.31: Axle Load Survey Locations
Equivalency is a convenient means for indexing the wide spectrum of actual loads to one selected
value, defined as “Equivalent Axle Load (EAL)”. One of the most important and useful products of
AASHTO Road Test was the development of a relationship characterizing the relative damaging
effect of varying axle load on pavements in terms of equivalent 80 kN standard axle load. This
relationship sometimes referred the “Fourth Power” rule has subsequently been verified by studies
reported by several agencies in different countries.
As per the guidelines of IRC: 37-2012, the equations used for computing equivalency factors for
single, tandem & tridem axles are mentioned below:
The values mentioned above are in terms of kN which is further converted into kgs, as the collected
load data during the surveys is also in the same unit.
The Total Equivalencies factors are obtained for each category from “Fourth Power” rule as the
product of numbers of vehicles sampled and load equivalency factor.
Total EAL= ∑ ( Number of Vehicles in ea c h weight class ×Load Equivalency Factor of weight Class )
Vehicle Damage Factor
The Vehicle Damaging factor (VDF) is an indexing factor for characterizing the traffic loading of
the road. The VDF can easily be computed from the axle load data, provided sufficiently large and
fairly distributed sample of vehicles are included in the axle load survey. The vehicle damage factor
is a multiplier to convert the number of commercial vehicles of different axle loads and axle
configuration to the number of standard axle load repetitions. It is defined as equivalent number of
standard axle per commercial vehicle. The VDF varies with the vehicle axle configuration, axle
loading scenario and No of traffic. VDF is calculated using following formula:
The Vehicle Damage factor calibrated for each location, vehicle type, and direction is given in
Appendix-4.4 (Volume-II, Part-I). The summarized sample and VDF values are presented in
Table 4.23 & Table 4.24 given below.
Km 104+000 Km 140+000
Vehicles (Raebareli - (Allahabad - (Raebareli - (Allahabad -
Allahabad) Raebareli) Allahabad) Raebareli)
LCV 89 122 65 86
Bus 22 5 17 9
2T 36 33 47 30
3T 96 85 103 132
MAV 27 38 47 31
7.5.1 Introduction
Traffic forecasting is at best an approximation, which is based on analysis of available data. Traffic
is generated as a result of the interplay of a number of contributory factors, some of which are
difficult to estimate with their trend in economy. Forecasts of traffic have, therefore, to be
dependent on the forecasts factors such as Vehicle Ownership, Net National Product (NNP), Net
State Domestic Product (NSDP), & Per Capita Income (PCI). Future pattern of change in these
factors can be estimated with only a limited degree of accuracy and hence the forecasting of future
traffic levels cannot be precise. It is necessary to distinguish between the following:
Normal Traffic
Normal traffic is the estimated traffic on a roadway facility due to increase in population, natural
change in land-use and normal socio-economic development in the region or PIA. The normal
growth should be estimated based on the past and envisaged future trend of traffic on the project
corridor or in the influence area. Normal traffic growths and expected to be higher for uncongested
operations but the growth rate declines with increase in congestion level, reaching a self-limiting
equilibrium.
Generated Traffic
Road improvements may attract trips from other routes, modes and encourage longer and more
frequent travel. The additional traffic volumes likely to be generated on project corridor due to road
improvements are termed as generated traffic. Generated traffic may be classified further as diverted
traffic and induced traffic.
Diverted Traffic
It is that component of generated traffic which is the result of shift in route and change of mode.
Diverted traffic could be both positive and negative.
Induced Traffic
Generated traffic reflects the economic “law of demand” which states that consumption of goods
increase as the price declines. Roadway improvements, that alleviate congestion and reduce
generalized cost of travel, encourage more travel/vehicle use. Depending upon the road network and
socio-economic profile of the PIA, generated traffic may constitute a significant part of the total
future traffic volume.
Keeping in view the above factors, in this study, for estimating growth factors and future traffic,
Elasticity of Transport Demand has been used. This method relies on the correlation between
The past trends in traffic on the project road/Motor Vehicles Registered in the State, and Time series
data of Net National Product (NNP), Net State Domestic Product (NSDP) & Per Capita Income
(PCI).
The secondary data required for the estimation of traffic growth rate is as follows:
The Vehicle registration data of U.P, Bihar, Uttarakhand, Jharkhand, Punjab, Delhi & All India has
been obtained from the Road Transport Year Book published by Transport Research Wing Ministry
of Road Transport & Highways and is summarized in Table 4.27 to Table 4.33.
7.5.3 Elasticity of Transport Demand
Elasticity of transport (traffic) demand is defined as the ratio of percentage change in traffic
to the percentage change in socio-economic parameters. The concept of developing
regression equation is to relate the dependent variable in terms of one or more
independent variables. The registered motor vehicles are dependent variable and socio-
economic parameters are independent variables. The traffic growth rates, by vehicle types
are obtained by using simple regression equation with perspective values of independent
variables. The selection of variables is a function of availability of data and goodness of
statistics (e.g. R-Square, t-value, etc.).
Regression Analysis
The Regression analysis tool performs linear regression analysis by using the "least
squares" method to fit a line through a set of observations. We can analyze how a single
dependent variable is affected by the values of one or more independent variables. In the
present case registered vehicles by type are dependent variables whereas the economic
parameters are independent variables. Once the relation is established by regression,
following are the measures to accept or reject the relation.
t-statistic
R-Square
R-Square is another measure of the explanatory power of the model. In theory, R-square
compares the amount of the error explained by the model as compared to the amount of
error explained by averages. The higher the R-Square value, stronger is the association.
Regression analysis is performed by developing econometric models, suggested in IRC:
108–2015, using historic vehicle registration data and their representative economic
Indicators, such as PCI for passenger vehicles and NSDP for Freight vehicles
TABLES
TABLES
TABLES
TABLES
TABLES
7.5.4 Traffic Forecast by Econometric Method
Traffic on the project corridor will comprise of normal, diverted and induced/generated
components. Traffic projections were made by applying the mode-wise growth rates as
discussed above to the base year (2016) traffic. Mode-wise projections are undertaken up
to time horizon year 2046 (30 years).
Normal traffic comprises traffic that is presently observed on the project corridor and will
continue to use the project road in the future. Diverted traffic comprises vehicular traffic that
will get diverted from other parallel roads to project road due to decrease in travel cost over
the project road after the proposed improvement is undertaken. Induced/ generated traffic
comprises that traffic which was non-existent earlier but will get added to the project road
only due to proposed improvements to the existing facility.
AADT observed at survey stations are applied with traffic growth rates to obtain the yearly
mode-wise traffic for the horizon years. Amongst the 3 different scenarios discussed above,
the most likely scenario refers to normal traffic projections. Projected normal traffic
(average of 7 days) on different sections of the project road for the cardinal years in terms
of AADT (PCU) is presented in Table 4.47. Vehicle wise detailed projected traffic is given in
Appendix-4.5 (Volume-II, Part-I).
Table 4.19: Projected Normal Traffic in AADT (PCU)-Most Likely Growth Scenario
Generated/induced traffic comprises that traffic which was non-existent earlier but will get
added to the project road only due to proposed improvements to the existing/adjacent
facility, considered in optimistic growth scenario. At present, the project road is State
Highway and maintenance does not take place in a regular interval and so the riding quality
is not good. After upgradation to National Highway the importance of road will increase and
shall be under definite maintenance, hence due to improved journey time, it shall attract
more traffic. Vehicle wise detailed projected traffic is given in Appendix-4.5 (Volume-II,
Part-I).
Capacity analysis for the project corridor is carried out in order to assess the Level of
Service (LOS) offered by road sections under prevailing roadway and traffic conditions.
Capacity and Design Service Volumes (DSV) specified in IRC-64-1990, Capacity of Roads
in Rural Areas have been adopted for determining the Level of Service offered by road
sections during study period. Based on the average rise & fall observed from the field
surveys, the project corridor runs through Plain terrain only. The capacity and design
service volumes for 2 lane and 4 lane configurations in case of plain terrain at different
LOS’s are presented in Table 4.51 given below:
The projected traffic is compared with Design Service Volume (DSV) to assess the
upgradation requirement for the corridor under prevailing roadway conditions. Capacity
augmentation is generally warranted for roads that cater to traffic volumes in excess of the
DSV at LOS C.
The Consultants have attempted to assess upgradation requirement to the existing road
based on the projected traffic in horizon years. Comparison of projected traffic with the DSV
at various LOS is shown in Table 4.52.
As per the capacity assessment given above, the upgradation of project road for four lane
with paved shoulder is required as for the base year the traffic observed exceeds the
design capacity for 2 lane road with paved shoulder as per ministry vide circular No.
RW/NH-33044/28/2015/S&R (R). Hence the project shall be developed for minimum four
lane with paved shoulder configuration as per the Guidelines of Ministry & IRC: SP: 73-
2015.