Scribd
Upload
182 views2 pages

Ahmie

The document discusses two schools of thought on computer ethics education. The first views it as a form of remedial moral education, while the second sees it as a field worthy of independent study. For computer ethics to be considered a separate field, it must have a unique domain distinct from other forms of ethics. The document outlines Walter Maner's explanation of the two views, which are that some ethical issues are transformed by computers in a way that merits separate study, and that computers can create entirely new ethical issues not found in other domains. It then provides Maner's six justifications for the two views, including that studying computer ethics will help address policy vacuums and issues permanently transformed or novel issues created by emerging technologies.

Uploaded by

Nesty Sarsate
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
182 views2 pages

Ahmie

The document discusses two schools of thought on computer ethics education. The first views it as a form of remedial moral education, while the second sees it as a field worthy of independent study. For computer ethics to be considered a separate field, it must have a unique domain distinct from other forms of ethics. The document outlines Walter Maner's explanation of the two views, which are that some ethical issues are transformed by computers in a way that merits separate study, and that computers can create entirely new ethical issues not found in other domains. It then provides Maner's six justifications for the two views, including that studying computer ethics will help address policy vacuums and issues permanently transformed or novel issues created by emerging technologies.

Uploaded by

Nesty Sarsate
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 2

naturally, one would come to the conclusion that since we cannot stop

computer technology that causes these muddles, we need a plan of action that will

work with the changing computing technology and at the same time deal with the

ethical issues that do arise. We need computer ethics education. There are two

schools of thought on this subject. One school believes in the study of computer

ethics as remedial moral education. The other school believes in computer ethics

education not as a moral education but as a field worthy of study in its own right.

But for it to exist as a separate independent field of study, there must be a unique

domain for computer ethics distinct from the domain for moral education, distinct

even from the domains of other kinds of professional and applied ethics [12]. In his

paper “Is Computer Ethics Unique?” Walter Maner explains the existence of the

two schools with two views that:

1. Certain ethical issues are so transformed by the use of computers that they

deserve to be studied on their own, in their radically altered form.

2. The involvement of computers in human conduct can create entirely new ethical

issues, unique to computing, which do not surface in other areas

According to Maner, there are six levels of justifications for the two views: the

first two for the first school and the last four for the second school [12]:

1. We should study computer ethics because doing so will make us behave like

responsible professionals.

2. We should study computer ethics because doing so will teach us how to avoid

computer abuse and catastrophes.

3. We should study computer ethics because the advance of computing technology

will continue to create temporary policy vacuums.

4. We should study computer ethics because the use of computing permanently

transforms certain ethical issues to the degree that their alterations require

independent study.

5. We should study computer ethics because the use of computing technology


creates and will continue to create, novel ethical issues that require special

study.

6. We should study computer ethics because the set of novel and transformed

issues is large enough and coherent enough to define a new field.

7. Whatever school one falls in, there is enough justification to study computer

ethics.

You might also like