Valeo Supplier Quality Manual TCV 2020-08-12
Valeo Supplier Quality Manual TCV 2020-08-12
Valeo Supplier Quality Manual TCV 2020-08-12
App. 7 Process Audit Questionnaire updated with agenda, raw material conformity verification, change over conditions added
App. 10 Updated with additional 2 options of cover sheet selection
App.15 Addition of Identification of Shipments
1
FOREWORD
Customer satisfaction is at the center of Valeo 5 AXES and the Supplier Integration and Total Quality
AXES are the two pillars promoted by VALEO to ensure excellence in product development and
operations
Supplier Quality continuous improvement towards excellence is mandatory to achieve our common
objective of sustainable and profitable growth.
This Supplier Quality Manual sets out VALEO policy and procedures to support our supplier partners in
their quest for EXCELLENCE and ZERO DEFECTS from the selection and nomination to the management
of development and production of CONFORM GOODS.
Continuous deployment and strict enforcement of the policies and procedures included in this manual
is a mandatory condition to the relationship between VALEO and its Suppliers partners.
AMENDMENT
With the acquisition of Spheros by VALEO in 2018 we continuously stop improving old standards but deploy Valeo
standards. Due to gaps we have to adjust existing VALEO standards to be applicable for TCV.
With the new revision of the SQA Manual in 2020 we remove the old standard QC1 to be replaced by this document.
2
CONTENTS
V- ACRONYMS 34
3
I -ADVANCED QUALITY PLANNING for Product & Process (AQP.pp)
Advanced Quality Planning for product and process is a structured method of defining and establishing the
necessary steps, which supplements supplier quality policy and rules implemented to ensure that a component
will comply with VALEO requirements.
The VALEO AQP.pp is attached in Appendix 1 (all mentioned appendix are part of the Supplier Quality Manual).
VALEO AQP.pp shall apply to all VALEO suppliers listed here below:
Category of
supplier Definition
Design components which will be fit for VALEO project specific purposes and will meet
Designer VALEO specifications. The supplier-designer is responsible for the definition and as the case
may be responsible for the supply of the components.
In a continuous improvement approach, Valeo reserves the right to adapt the AQPpp in function of the
technologies.
4
I.1 AQP.pp Procedure
The Advance Quality Planning procedure is a process which supplements supplier quality policy and rules and aims
at conducting a thorough validation of the design – product and process, in order to ensure that the supplier will be
in a position to deliver, as of the Start Of Production, the expected level of quality in line with VALEO requirements.
The Advance Quality Planning procedure includes the supplier pre-selection and 6 development milestones.
This procedure applies to all new customer application projects and to components already used in production
(product process changes).
The development process is followed-up in the Supplier Relationship Management (SRM) Portal
(https://suppliers.valeo.com/suppliers/) in the section called PQA module within scenarios adapted to each case.
The Valeo buyer will select the supplier representative to take in charge of the PQA Process initiated in the Portal.
From this moment the supplier is required to fulfil the corresponding actions on the deliverables to reach the
milestones within the deadlines agreed.
TCV will select key components within the scope of new projects (typically P2) to be covered within SRM PQA.
The IAM scenario is the minimum requirement for those components (only 1 mandatory per phase).
Currently the TCV PM is under revision to be comparable with RAISE. Especially milestones do not comply with TCV PM
phases.
5
The AQP.pp is adapted to 2 components categories:
● First category - VALEO Non-Specific Component : dedicated to validation of standard components and
:
catalogue components – as defined in the matrix below (1)
Raw materials Raw (steel, additives, plastic granulates, etc.) and standards
Catalogue
sold by a supplier site
Other components
Catalogue
sold by a distributor (retailer)
(1)
Suppliers for this Category of Components having only an ISO 9000 certification have to have a plan to certify
the quality system according to IATF 16949
● Second category - VALEO Specific Component : dedicated to validation of components that are
specifically developed to satisfy VALEO needs – as defined in the matrix below:
6
►
Specific Case - Component belonging to a Technology Family
A Technology Family is a set of components manufactured for VALEO by the same supplier site achieving the same
technical function, and which rigorously follow the same flow using same specific tooling. The list of components
belonging to a Technology Family shall be provided by supplier to VALEO for validation.
►
Specific Case – Any component delivered as Pass-thru
Any component delivered as Pass-thru will be managed as a VALEO specific component and therefore shall follow
the VALEO Specific Component AQP.pp category.
►
Specific Case - Safety / regulatory components
For all Safety / Regulatory components, purchasing from distributors is prohibited.
► Specific case - Wood components for transportation of goods (e.g.: Pallets / cardboard pallets / pallet collars...)
or used to wedge storing devices during transportation.
These components will not follow the AQP.pp procedure.
No EVAL and no ISO 9000 / IATF 16949 requested for suppliers delivering such components.
The validation will be done based on following documents / audits:
- Valid ISPM15 certificate
- IPPC number
- Wood CCL for assembly and/or Heat treatment validated
The following pages are describing the content and the specificity of each PQA Approach.
The list of deliverables of AQP.pp is detailed in Appendix 1.
7
I.2 Supplier pre selection
The purpose of this process is to validate that the performance of a potential supplier complies with VALEO
expectations.
Supplier must:
● guarantee the reliability of processes and keep records
● have a process of continuous improvement
● have a process to continuously capture what has been learned
It is based on:
● a clearly defined quality policy
● an organization capable of assuring quality at all stages of the component life, in line with VALEO
project development phases
● the willingness to work with VALEO in a spirit of partnership and continuous improvement and
problem solving attitude.
►
Assessment of potential suppliers
A Supplier intending to be part of VALEO panel has to meet the following conditions (applicable for each
and every new supplier, for any new production site of a supplier already belonging to VALEO panel)
● Quality Management System answering to IATF 16949 - 8.4.2.3, with a minimum certification according
to ISO 9001 standard, unless otherwise authorized by the customer, and with the ultimate objective of
becoming certified to IATF 16949.
NB: Suppliers eligible for certification to IATF 16949 according to “Area of impact for client consideration taken
from the Rules for achieving and maintaining IATF recognition - Fifth edition for IATF 16949”
● EVAL assessment conducted by VALEO according to the EVAL procedure with a score of at least 80%, and
with each of the mandatory questions qualified.
The purpose of the EVAL is to identify all process management related risks at the potential supplier,
along a supplier shop floor evaluation (of its current processes) – this assessment will be conducted by
Group Purchasing and Group SQA Commodity representatives.
EVAL is dedicated to assess new suppliers. EVAL assessment is not scheduled periodically with all VALEO
panel suppliers. There are other programs (RSQ, SD&P, YIS) assessing current suppliers.
● Commodity Check List assessment conducted by Group SQA Commodity – performed for each and every
new supplier as well as current suppliers intended to deliver components for segment not previously
assessed – with a minimum score of 80% and all Critical Questions conform (CQ) . Any supplier rated
below will be requested to submit an action plan (with responsible & due date) to achieve full
compliance with the requirements checklist.
►► For each project and each component to be purchased, VALEO Purchasing will define the list of approved
suppliers which will receive the RFQ for such business.
8
I.3 PQA Activities to be completed before “Sourcing Committee (SoCo) Completed” milestone
The purpose of this milestone is to select the best supplier in accordance with Segment strategy.
►
Definition of VALEO requirements
Valeo requirements and specifications specific to the parts, components, systems or material purchased are
detailed in the Specific Valeo Requirement File (S-VRF) and includes:
● the product specifications: set of functional, technical and general released specifications and drawings
including the SPPC (SPECIAL PRODUCT and PROCESS CHARACTERISTICS) and Customer Specific
requirements
● the applicable Commodity Checklist (CCL)
● the quality and logistics requirements
● Standard Control Plan when applicable
Supplier Design review is organized by Valeo Buyer and chaired by Valeo R&D to clarify technical
requirements or take into account possible Supplier improvement suggestions.
Following the above Supplier Design Review, S-VRF shall be updated and released to each Supplier
participating to the RFQ.
● compare pre-selected supplier’s performance and answers vs. the latest released version of S-VRF,
including CCL and preliminary design review
● review quality of the answers, dates and robustness of the quotation received
● analyze strengths and weaknesses of the suppliers
● select the supplier representing the best choice
Based on the Specific Valeo Requirements File released, requests for quotations are sent out and
retrieved by Suppliers from Valeo Purchasing Management tool (PuMa).
Both Quotations (including Cost Breakdown) and S-VRF are to be signed by the Supplier and uploaded on Valeo
Purchasing Management Portal (PuMa).
Valeo can possibly use auction process to make final Supplier Selection.
9
I.4 - PQA Activities to be completed before “Signed SVRF Uploaded” milestone
The purpose of this milestone is to put available the Specific VALEO Requirement File (Appendix 2.2) signed by
the Supplier for the development of the component.
As soon as supplier selection is decided by VALEO, then and only then the Nomination Letter can be sent to the
selected supplier with reference to S-VRF signed by both parties.
The purpose of the milestone Component Design Validated is to ensure that product and process quality
requirements are met (Quality Assurance File validated) before launching the tool.
►
FMEA study – Special Product Process Characteristic (SPPC) management
Supplier will have to follow the SPPC rules for FMEA (design and process) according to Appendix 3.
For each Special Product Process Characteristic (SPPC) identified after FMEA review, the supplier will have to
implement the relevant control according to the above referenced rule.
The supplier will have to list both:
● Customer SPPC characteristics: either customer interfaces or characteristics impacting VALEO or / and
OEM assembly – visual aspect – product performance and / or reliability (the aim is to ensure common
understanding between Supplier and VALEO)
● Internal SPPC characteristics: fundamental supplier product characteristics that could impact supplier
manufacturing process and / or non respect of supplier internal standards
►
Supplier has to prepare and submit the Measurement Protocol and RUCSL Control Criteria for Valeo validation
before Design Review
►
Design validation results:
The supplier will conduct the design validation on prototypes (if applicable).
The validation results compliant with the approved plan will be reviewed and signed at least by the:
10
►
Validation plan:
The validation plan template to be used by the supplier is attached in Appendix 4. The validation plan is
completed with the supplier on the basis of:
● to validate the component along the development and ensure the validation of the design.
● on the initial samples collected during the Full Day Production Run OR during the Process audit at the
supplier and approved by VALEO, in order to validate the process impacts on the product.
Once these documents have been examined and approved by VALEO, the supplier undertakes to comply with
them. Any proposal for modifying or improving the product or process, including proposal related to transfer of
production or move or relocation of the production equipment, must be approved by VALEO on the basis of the
documents modified by the Supplier respecting the Product and Process modification section of the present
manual.
►
Control plan:
The Supplier has to develop a control plan in line with IATF 16949 requirements and covering the phases of
Prototypes (if applicable), Pre-launch and Production showing the link, and incorporating information from the
design risk analysis (DFMEA, including input provided by the customer), process flow diagram, and
manufacturing process risk analysis outputs (PFMEA).
Upon validation of the Quality Assurance File by supplier and VALEO, the supplier shall be authorized to kick-off
tooling.
11
I.6 - PQA Activities to be completed before “Supplier Process Validated” milestone
The purpose of the milestone Supplier Process Validated is to ensure that the process developed by supplier is
capable to produce the defined components in compliance with VALEO requirements and consequently to
demonstrate the following:
● run at rate : proving that all committed volumes for VALEO and other customers can be met on shared
equipments at all operations of the process
● capability of the process
● validation of the product / processes of sub-suppliers (Appendix 14 – SQA Tier N management fulfilled)
● build correct product in accordance with approved work instructions and control plan in line with IATF
16949 and VALEO requirements.
►
Off tool: the component produced out of the off tool has to be evaluated and approved by VALEO in terms of
dimensional and assembling. If the component is approved at this stage of the project phase, it is not a final
approval of the component: the final approval will be given after Initial Samples submission (to satisfy the
milestone Supplier Initial Samples validated), out of the Full Day Production Run in serial conditions.
► P
reparation of VALEO FDPR at supplier plant:
The supplier is required to perform a preliminary Full Day Production Run (Appendix 5)
The FDPR readiness matrix (Appendix 6) shall be used and the supplier will need to fully comply with the
requirements in order to schedule the Full Day Production Run performed by VALEO Team.
► P
reparation of VALEO process audit at supplier plant:
The supplier is required to perform a self process audit evaluation based on the VALEO standard (Valeo
procedure - SQ 2102 and Appendix 7 of this manual) and CCLs self-audit prior to VALEO official audit.
The self process audit should be achieved with a score of 80% without any critical CAR (Corrective Action
Request) and CCL approved prior requesting VALEO SQA Engineer to attend the Process Audit.
● the duration must be sufficient to assess the stability of the process (minimum 3 hours of production) –
However, depending on the nature of the component VALEO reserves the right to require the supplier to
run longer and more components than referred here.
Following the full day production run, the following report must be issued:
● process audit report (Valeo procedure - SQ 2102 and Appendix 7 of this manual) including
capabilities for each SPPC (Cpk ≥ 1.67 / Ppk ≥ 2 / Cmk ≥ 2) and for others characteristics (if
requested: Cpk ≥ 1
.33 / Ppk ≥ 1
.67 / Cmk ≥ 1.67).
12
►►
Each SPPC will require a capability study performed according to Appendix 9.
● Confirmation of a statistically Normal distribution of the product / process parameters and Ppk results above 2
(Ppk: preliminary capability study calculated on components from the FDPR) or Cpk results above 1.67 (Cpk:
capability study calculated on components when in serial production). Then the process must be monitored
through SPC when in production.
● In case capability is not demonstrated, supplier must implement a Poka Yoke, 100% automatic control… in
order to put characteristics under control to meet specification.
● VALEO SQA Engineer will check on supplier site that the control plan:
o integrates the countermeasures listed in the PFMEA
o is respected on the shop floor, including the Reinforced Control Plan.
It is expected that this method of tracking and reacting to issues will also be applied while in serial production.
►►
The process is qualified by VALEO if the FDPR is accepted, and audit results are satisfactory (“Process Audit”
procedure ref. 2102). Otherwise, the supplier must draw-up an action plan and a follow-up audit will be performed
by VALEO.
►►
Case of rejection of a FDPR by VALEO:
An action plan will be submitted by the supplier on each opened CAR (Corrective Action Request).VALEO SQA
Engineer will conduct a new FDPR after release of each supplier CAR.
Action plan must be implemented within 10 days and must be sponsored by the Top Management of the supplier.
►► Traceability:
Suppliers must have a traceability system to trace back any component to the original batch of material (raw
material / primary components) used.
Along the process audit, VALEO SQA Engineer will verify the supplier system to control traceability and the respect
of the product coding.
►►
Production Capacity:
Suppliers must have a standard to manage on a weekly basis production and capacity planning, giving visibility
on 6 months production.
The standard has to:
o integrate all customer forecasts for all Valeo lines in order to ensure no capacity issues
o Alert customers when capacity issue is detected
►► Contingency Plan:
Suppliers shall develop a contingency plan (IATF 16949 – 6.1.2.3) for potential catastrophes disrupting product
flow to Valeo, and advise Valeo at the earliest in the event of an actual disaster.
In an actual catastrophe, suppliers shall provide Valeo access to Valeo’s tools and/or their replacements,
Contingency Plan shall contain as a minimum the following items:
● Information system; breakdown problems, partial or total destruction, natural damage, central data
13
system, CAO, production system, etc.
● Supplying system: supplier delivery orders management, raw material stock management, supplier
delivery failure (strike, disaster…), external supply quality failure, transport failure (strike, accident,
….)
In the case of several processes at the supplier (e.g.: several cavities inside a plastic injection tool) – the supplier is
requested to keep 5 initial samples per process and have them properly saved and identified.
► V
ALEO validation on Initial Samples:
VALEO will perform a production trial along with the VALEO FDPR approved initial samples in order to measure the
conformance of the supplier components in the VALEO manufacturing process.
The validation results, in compliance with the approved validation plan defined to satisfy the milestone
Component Design Validated, will be reviewed and signed at least by the:
►►
The supplier validation plan is considered completely executed when VALEO have completed their share of the
validation respectively of the VALEO product and of the vehicle utilizing a component supplied by VALEO
supplier.
►► Therefore the supplier validation is deemed to be successful when VALEO and VALEO customer have passed
their share of the validation respectively of the VALEO product.
► P
rocess audit frequency
While in production, periodic audits of the process must be performed by the supplier at the intervals defined in
the Control Plan.
Audit reports and corrective action plans are requested to be submitted to Valeo at least once per year in the scope
of the Yearly Initial Samples approach (see Chapter I.9 – Serial Life)
To ensure continuous validity of the process audit, VALEO reserves the right to perform process audits every 2
years and to carry out new audits whenever VALEO considers the need.
14
I.7 - PQA Activities to be completed before “Supplier Initial Samples Validated” milestone
The purpose of the milestone Supplier Initial Samples (IS) validated is (i) to check that the component
(performance, characteristics, reliability, capability, etc) comply with VALEO requirements and (ii) that the
process developed by supplier is capable to produce the defined components in compliance with VALEO
requirements.
Mass production components must be in compliance with Initial Samples approved by VALEO: no change on
product, process or packaging.
Master samples and initial samples file will be archived at the supplier plant during 10 years after the end of
lifetime of the manufactured product.
They will be used as a reference for comparison on the YIS report
● Process audit (including Reinforced Control Plan) and CCL, – validated by VALEO
● Dimensional report
● SPPC Characteristics capability
● Raw material Conformity
● Test on VALEO production Line to confirm no assembly issue on VALEO line
● Functional tests
● Packaging validation
● Report on subjective requirements (appearance – aspect – Buzz Squeak and Rattle noise) if applicable
● IMDS Database data entry completed (or local equivalent i.e. CAMDS)
If all the initial sample deliverables have been qualified, VALEO SQA will release the ISR signed (Appendix 10
Initial Sample Report – ISR).
The initial sample approval decision will be communicated to the supplier by sending the VALEO approved ISR.
In the case of IS not validated a MAQL / Deviation is required to deliver components. The supplier remains
responsible for the quality of the components delivered, and in case of
● MAQL - Valeo Buyer
● Deviation - Supplier / Valeo Buyer
will submit the request through the Deviation module in SRM. [ MAQL - Minimum Acceptable Quality Level ]
In the case that Supplier is requested to deliver components under deviation due to SISV Milestone not validated,
the list of deviated characteristics have to be included in the list of existing RUCSL control criteria and to be
followed until the specific deviation closure or until the exit of RUCSL activity.
15
I.8 - PQA Activities to be completed before “PQA Status granted” milestone
As soon as the Initial Samples have been accepted by VALEO, the supplier is allowed to deliver components to
VALEO according to the needs and to the logistic protocol as well as to the requirements of this chapter. This is
the serial production phase.
The supplier is fully responsible to deliver according to the specifications and in line with the accepted ISR.
► Probationary period
In order to validate the effectiveness of control plan, VALEO requires the implementation of a Ramp Up Control
Shipment Level (RUCSL). This additional control has to be done according to the following conditions:
►► If the exit criteria are not achieved after Valeo Customer SOP + 2 months, the Ramp Up CSL is extended for
one month.
►► If the exit criteria are not achieved within Valeo Customer SOP + 3 months, a Control Shipment Level 2 (CSL2)
activity must be implemented without a time limit.
This activity will be handled by a sorting company contracted by the supplier and approved by Valeo.
16
I.9 PQA Approach – Serial Life
When a component is granted the Product Quality Assurance (PQA) status, the component is no longer
subjected to a probationary control period and reinforced control plan has to be stopped.
PQA Management Flow purpose is to ensure that suppliers fulfil VALEO requirements and supplies
quality-secured purchased components along all the production period.
During serial life, the Supplier has to submit under Valeo request the update of documents submitted for validation
of IS to demonstrate that the PQA status is maintained.
Any delivery of parts without respecting the requirements agreed must be formalized by requesting a deviation.
The supplier will remain responsible for the quality of the components delivered and will submit the request to
VALEO through the Deviation module in SRM.
Initial Samples are re-validated on a yearly basis and shall be presented by the supplier to the VALEO Site at least
1 month prior to the anniversary date of Initial Samples approval (the year before).
The deliverables requested by VALEO for the Yearly re-qualification of the initial samples are outlined below and can
be found also in the AQP.pp matrix attached in the Appendix 1 of this manual.
VALEO will request the submission of a report with existing data of current production, including:
In case of a non conformity situation of the items mentioned above, the supplier will request a deviation to
VALEO and must develop an action plan to come back to conformity.
Upon request, the supplier must provide VALEO with the results of inspections carried out for each batch delivered
in line with the requirements of the AQP.pp (Appendix 11 PQA Management Flow).
17
VALEO has defined 2 different Product Quality Assurance Management flows:
● VALEO non specific component workflow: for components such as raw materials / catalogue
components / standard electronic components / non specific packaging as defined in the AQP.pp
definition section of the present manual.
● VALEO Specific component workflow: for components falling in the definition of the AQP.pp definition
section of the present manual.
In addition, for Pass-Thru logistic flow (components delivered directly to Valeo Customer), specific actions have to
be implemented as per Valeo request.
All PQA component deliveries must be identified with a PQA label on each container box.
Upon request, the supplier shall inform VALEO of the results of the inspections carried out for each batch
delivered in line with the requirements of the PQA management flow.
In all cases, VALEO will give the supplier written notification of the date for resumption of PQA status after the
problem has been solved.
When PQA status is lost – the supplier must take off PQA identification and when applicable identify with a label
on each box and container, the level of control shipment (1 or 2) requested (Appendix 11 PQA
Management Flow).
If the conditions agreed to remove the PQA suspension are achieved, the PQA status is recovered. Valeo SQA
authorize the Supplier to re identify boxes with the PQA label
►► Case of a product or process modification or transfer of a supplier production line (see Chapter II.5) – the PQA
status is therefore lost and the PQA status will need to be re-granted going through a complete PQA
approach.
18
II -CONTINUOUS QUALITY IMPROVEMENT
This chapter will focus on:
19
II.1 Incident processing
Supplier undertakes to use for incident treatment exclusively the PDCA / FTA methodology and answer through the
IMS (Incident Management System) Module of SRM Portal (https://suppliers.VALEO.com/suppliers) or via
existing communication channels. This may include use of E-Mail.
► D
efinition of Quality incidents
Any line, end of line reject at the customer or any reject occurring “in Non conformity on a component
CP1 the field” that is caused by a non conformity on a component under development is detected
delivered by a supplier without Initial Samples validated and with by the car maker
Deviation Request approved is recorded as a CP1 incident
Any component rejected on VALEO production line that is caused by Non conformity on a component
CP2 a non conformity on a component delivered by a supplier without under development is detected
Initial Samples validated and with Deviation Request approved is by Valeo Project team or in
recorded as a CP2 incident. VALEO Process
Any line or end of line reject at the customer or customer complaint
that is caused by a component delivered by a supplier is recorded as Car makers line or end of line
a C1 incident. rejects (C1).
C1 Any reject occurring “in the field” that is caused by a non conformity Warranty return (C1WR).
on a component delivered by a supplier is recorded as a C1WR
incident (Based on analysis, this incident can be changed to CA)
VALEO end-of-line rejects.
Any single component rejected from VALEO plant that is caused by a Sorting, rework, and line
C2 disruption.
component delivered by a supplier is recorded as a C2 incident
(Based on analysis, this incident can be changed to CA) Non-conformance identified in
the manufacturing process.
Valeo or Customer parts
rejected and linked with a
Perturbations in VALEO plants that are caused by a suspected suspected component delivered
CA component delivered by a supplier is recorded as a CA incident. by a supplier.
Based on analysis, this Alert should be closed or cancelled Root cause and responsibility
need to be determined between
Customer, Valeo & Supplier
►►
Recurrent incident:
►►► CP1, CP2, C1 or C2 recurrent incident: occurs on the same component number, the same failure mode
and the same suspected or identified root cause coming from parts belonging to a batch
produced after implementation of the corrective actions of a previous incident.
►►►
C1WR recurrent incident: occurs on the same component number, the same failure mode, and the same
suspected or identified root cause and for which production date is after implementation of the corrective
actions.
►
Definition of Logistic incidents
The logistic incident affects the Production line shutdown at VALEO due to shortage of part
L2 VALEO production lines deliveries
All suppliers are required to install broadband Internet and to systematically consult and make use of the SRM tool
and associated documents. Their response time is measured and recorded by SRM according to VALEO Reactivity
requirements:
In the case of a C1 and C1WR, the supplier is required to present to VALEO plant analysis. Physical presence will be
required when necessary. All answers (QR, PD, CA & LLC) must be formalized in English.
After the supplier submits its CCL Tooling section self assessment, VALEO will conduct a Genba check prior to
incident closure.
Each category of incident shall not be closed without submission of LLC and verification on genba.
The Category Alerts shall not be closed without submission of agreed actions between Valeo & the supplier.
Documented analysis will be required when necessary.
►► Cancelled incident:
If the Plan Do analysis concludes the supplier non-responsibility then the supplier incident is cancelled.
►
Sorting activity:
For any sorting activity requiring a sub-contractor, the Supplier will have to select a sorting company approved by
VALEO. Supplier shall ensure that the organization of the sorting shall enable an immediate communication of
any relevant information (including especially the sorting results) obtained by the supplier and/or the
sub-contractor during the sorting. All costs linked with the sorting, including costs to be paid to the
subcontractor, will be borne by the Supplier.
►►
Sorting at VALEO plant: the Supplier shall mandate a sorting company within the first 2 hours following the
incident notification in order to ensure that VALEO is secured latest 4 hours following the incident
notification to the Supplier. In case of delay VALEO will contract directly a sorting company and shall
charge back to the supplier all related costs.
►
Supplier Liability
Supplier remains liable for all direct and indirect costs caused by any non conformity to contractual
specifications or applicable regulations.
II.2 Quality and Logistic performance indicators
►
Quality indicators
Among other, the Quality performance of suppliers will be measured with the following indicators based on 3
months rolling ( M + (M-1) + (M-2) )
IPB – 3 Months:
Incidents C3M:
Quality
- Number of total incidents (C1+C1WR+C2)
none to date .
II.3 Systemic Recovery Plan
Valeo supplier, drifting from quality performance has to define action plan to identify systemic
weaknesses and propose corrective actions – Systemic Recovery Plan
The Systemic Recovery Plan is led by supplier top management and submitted to Valeo on regular basis.
II.4 Supplier development & follow-up
Valeo makes available to each Supplier a set of tools (tool box) applicable according to Supplier Quality
Performance level:
● Supportively, when the supplier Quality performance is stagnating, the following activities: QRQC
Deployment, Fundamentals of Quality may be launched by VALEO.
● Proactively, when the supplier Quality performance is identified at risk to drift, the following activities:
Supplier Development & Preventive (SD&P) program may be launched by VALEO.
● Reactively, when the supplier Quality performance is worsening, the following activities: Recover
Supplier Quality (RSQ) program, NBOH Alert / NBOH Status may be launched by VALEO.
► Q
uick Response Quality Control (QRQC) deployment:
VALEO may propose to support supplier improvement activity by sharing the QRQC / PDCA Methodology which is
based on 4 principles:
Valeo assesses and monitors regularly suppliers’ quality performance in order to prevent potential risk. Supplier
assessment is based on criteria covering project development, production quality and logistics results. There
are 3 Risk Levels: HR (High Risk), MR (Medium Risk), NR (No Risk)
VALEO has deployed a SQA Strategy to support the supplier improvement activity by deploying preventive or
corrective activities.
Based on the Suppliers Quality performance level, VALEO identifies suppliers at risk to deploy preventive and /
or corrective activities within the perimeter of SD&P and / or RSQ program
● Preventive activities dedicated to suppliers starting to drift according to specific criteria set up by Valeo.
The support will be given in function of the weaknesses detected and within a Supplier Development &
Preventive (SD&P) tool box.
● Corrective activities dedicated to top contributing suppliers to help them to recover quality level within a
program called Recover Supplier Quality (RSQ)
RSQ # 3
RSQ # 2
RSQ # 1
● In addition to RSQ 2&3 activities, RSQ 1 level involves Supplier Top Management (Group Senior
Management or Chief Executive Officer )
● Bi-Monthly follow-up addresses Systemic Weaknesses of Organization leading to changes in
management, system and organization.
● This is the highest level of escalation, this program will last 12 consecutive months in order to ensure
a sustainable improvement with strict follow up of defined exit criteria
Valeo develops a specific approach to assess and monitor quality performance of Suppliers delivering electronic
components. The eligible Suppliers are requested to join a RSQe program which is equivalent to the RSQ2 in
terms of tool box but deployed within a period of 12 Months
The exit of RSQ Program, extension for a specific period or escalation to the next RSQ category will be decided by
VALEO upon satisfactory achievement of the targets agreed at the beginning of the program with the supplier.
►
Control Shipment Level 1 and 2 (CSL1 and CSL2):
CSL1 and CSL2 will be required to the supplier in order to assure certified deliveries while awaiting the full
recovery of conformance on the production process or /and the product.
►► CSL1 – Following a request from VALEO, the supplier will implement a CSL1 in addition to the sorting of his
production.
The CSL1 and the sorting activity will be operated out of the production line in a dedicated zone and in
accordance with a specific control instruction approved by VALEO – Supplier will make available the
evidence that sorting operators have been trained to the sorting and CSL1 Instructions – the
performance of the sorting activity will be monitored on a daily basis by the supplier and reported by the
supplier in SRM on an agreed frequency basis. The supplier formally guarantees the conformance of
goods delivered for each delivery that takes place while CSL1 is in the process of implementation. The
cost of sorting will be borne by the supplier.
When the supplier fails to meet the commitments stipulated by CSL1 period, CSL2 is then required to be
implemented.
►► CSL2 – the supplier is required to put in place a sorting activity by an external company, validated by VALEO,
in line with criteria defined along the CSL1. The cost of sorting will be borne by the supplier. Sorting
results will be communicated to both VALEO and the supplier. VALEO has developed a panel of sorting
companies that VALEO suppliers will be required to work with.
►► Exit of CSL1 or CSL2: status can be lifted only after formal acceptance from VALEO in accordance with the
exit criteria defined in the CSL notification.
►►
In case of recurrent non-conformance, where the supplier clearly does not have sufficient control of his
production process, the Control Shipment Level (CSL) procedure will be applied.
►
Alert NBOH and NBOH (NEW BUSINESS ON HOLD):
In case of continuous drift (RSQ program) or potential risk at Valeo or its Customers, Valeo will send a
notification letter to request further investigation or assessment at corresponding level.
If there is no appropriate reaction from the supplier, Valeo may decide to apply a NBOH process.
►
Phase OUT:
If the supplier is not showing improvements, VALEO may decide to end the relationship with the Supplier.
II.5 Product & Process Change Management
When an engineering standard/specification change results in a product design change, Supplier has to refer to
the requirements in ISO 9001, Section 8.3.6.
When an engineering standard/specification change results in a product realization process change, refer to the
requirements in IATF 16949 Section 8.5.6.1.
The supplier has the obligation to communicate to VALEO Project / Productivity Buyer through SRM Portal
(Deviation / ECR Module), any product or process change intention (design, manufacturing process, material,
colour …) prior to its implementation, in order to obtain approval from VALEO
If a component subject to a change (previously approved by VALEO) is shipped to several VALEO sites – each of the
sites have to be informed and each VALEO site will advise the supplier on the validation to be performed by the
supplier to proceed with the change – shall the validation be successful. Upon receipt of written
agreement from each VALEO site, the supplier is authorized to implement the change.
The following chart is giving some examples of product and process changes – the list is not exhaustive:
►► Implementation of a Product or Process change by a supplier with no VALEO written agreement will
be reported to the IATF certification body by VALEO.
VALEO will require from the supplier to be placed under CSL2.
II.6 Audits & Audit schedule
During serial production, Supplier Sites / Products must be re-evaluated on a regular basis (see chart below). A
new audit may be scheduled at any time by VALEO.
A Yearly Initial Sample audit will be performed by supplier in accordance with the control plan approved along the
AQP.pp process developed for the validation of Initial Samples. This requires an agreement to follow the YIS
approach.
The quality system of the supplier will ensure that any production return of experience involving a product or
process change(s) is fed-back for a post mortem analysis.
EVAL New Suppliers, then No Limit VALEO Purchasing and At supplier’s plant
except entering in RSQ1 Program Group SQA
Supplier
1 Year (Self-Assessment) At supplier’s plant
Supplier
Product Audit / YIS (*) 1 Year (Self-Assessment) At supplier’s plant
(*): Supplier to provide results of the Product / Process Audit with the Yearly Initial Sample submission to VALEO.
The supplier has to ensure that the competencies of auditors comply with the requirements in IATF 16949
Section 7.2.3 and 7.2.4
III -END OF MASS PRODUCTION MANAGEMENT (EMP)
End of mass production life management cycle starts when the production of OEM product is stopped.
Then, the production of components from Suppliers is only for OES and Aftermarket needs.
The purpose of this chapter is to define how supplier ensures that once mass production is terminated, process at
Supplier is capable of providing for OES and Aftermarket.
6 months before the end of mass production, supplier has the responsibility to fill-in the EMP changes evaluation
checklist (Appendix 12 EMP – Section: Potential Changes Evaluation). This document aims at listing any process
changes that are planned to be executed by the supplier before EMP.
Supplier submits the check-list to VALEO Buyer and SQA in charge to obtain a formal Valeo approval.
Supplier will execute the required modifications, in line with the Product and Process change management section
and proceed with next step.
One month before EMP, the supplier has the responsibility to self assess its process through EMP process
assessment checklist.
The EMP process assessment checklist will then be submitted to VALEO SQA to check respect of steps (Appendix
12 EMP - Section: Process Assessment)
PQA status has to still be managed in accordance with PQA management rules.
No more systematic yearly initial sample submission is then requested the year following the end of the OEM life
and no more systematic periodical VALEO process audit will be performed.
VALEO process audits and initial sample submission will be nevertheless required following a product or process
changes occurring at the supplier.
IV- SUPPLIER QUALITY POLICY
The supplier, a professional in its field, is perfectly aware of the demands and requirements of the Automobile
Industry, in particular in terms of quality. It is the supplier's responsibility to define and implement a quality
policy in compliance with this Industry's standards and customary practices, as well as with laws, regulations and
standards in force. This SQM shall supplement supplier quality policy.
Nothing under this SQM may be interpreted as relieving the Supplier from any of its obligations towards VALEO and
especially its responsibility to deliver the Components in compliance with all documents that govern the
relationship between VALEO and the Supplier in connection with the supply of the Components.
Activities performed by each Party under this SQM and especially, inspection, audit, validation, testing and/or
approval made or granted by VALEO under this SQM as well as VALEO decision not to enforce all or part of this
SQM shall not affect Supplier responsibility concerning the quality and reliability of the Component and
compliance with its contractual obligation.
V- ACRONYMS
Definition
ADVANCED QUALITY PLANNING for product and process: aim of AQP.pp is provide VALEO with all the
AQP.pp guarantees concerning the means to achieve product quality. The AQP.pp includes: VALEO Requirements
File (VRF), Quality Assurance File (QAF), Initial Samples File (ISF) and a Quality Monitoring File (QMF).
CAR CORRECTIVE ACTION REQUEST
CARRY OVER Part already validated and used with same revision level in a project of any Valeo Site in current or stopped
mass production
CCL COMMODITY CHECKLIST
CERTIFICATION Notice given by an OFFICIAL organization on the basis of the appropriate procedures or documents by
which the component is recognized as being in compliance with STATUTORY requirements
CONFORMITY Fulfilment of a requirement. Note: The term "CONFORMANCE" is a synonymous but deprecated. (ISO 9000
- 2000)
CONTROL PLAN Documented description of the systems and processes required for controlling the manufacturing of a
product. (IATF 16949)
CONTROLLED SHIPMENT LEVEL 1 and 2: CSL1 and CSL2 are provisional procedures implemented with a view
CSL to guaranteeing certified deliveries while awaiting the re-establishment of the conformance of the
production process.
VALEO supplier evaluation tool taking into account 8 key criteria concerning operational and strategic
EVAL performance of the suppliers. This grid is used to select as well as to evaluate suppliers (present and
potential suppliers).
FULL DAY PRODUCTION RUN: Production run to validate the "full capacity / quoted rate" conditions. A
FDPR sufficient quantity of components shall be manufactured during this day to be considered statistically
significant. It shall extend for a period between 1 hour and 8 hours (one shift). At least 300 components
shall be manufactured unless a specific quantity is specified in relation to the rate of manufacture.
FAILURE MODE and EFFECT ANALYSIS: Deductive method and tools used to identify potential failure modes,
FMEA their causes and effects, and assess criticality of these failure modes, based on severity, occurrence and
detection probability criteria. Generic FMEA is applied on Product Design (DFMEA), Process Design
(PFMEA), and Equipment. It can also be applied on Product functions (Concept FMEA)
Genba Check Physical verification on the process to check if corrective actions from PDCA are implemented in "real
place"
HOSHIN A VPS tool for identifying simple solutions which can be applied immediately, to eliminate waste and
produce just-in-time, carried out with the involvement of personnel in all the areas concerned.
INCIDENTS MANAGEMENT SYSTEM: Incident Management System (IMS) enables to notify quality incidents
IMS to suppliers and to receive and approve their Quick Response PDCA (launching an alert after 24 hrs) and
their Analysis PDCA and Factor Tree Analysis (5 days to submit, 10 days to implement).
INITIAL SAMPLES: Units manufactured by final production methods and under "full production conditions".
IS IS approval shall validate the production equipment. After approval, they are used as reference for the
volume production.
ISR INITIAL SAMPLE REPORT
KOSU The actual direct labor time needed to produce one good part
LLC Lesson Learned Card: used to capitalize acquired knowledge and experience
MAQL Minimum Acceptable Quality Level
PASS THRU A pass thru component corresponds to a part produced by a Supplier of Valeo who delivers this very part
directly to Valeo Customer
PDCA (PLAN, DO, CHECK, ACT): is a methodology to settle and solve problems effectively. Based on
continuous improvement, PDCA comprises four different steps: Plan: grasp the problem, analyze causes
and effects and set objectives. Do: investigate solutions, identify the most effective one and implement it.
PDCA
Check: check the result in comparison to the objectives. Act: set a new standard to consolidate the result
and take action to prevent the re-occurrence of the problem.
POKA YOKE ERROR PROOFING (POKA YOKE): Product and manufacturing process design and development to prevent
manufacture of non conforming components. (ISO TS 16949)
PARTS PER BILLION: measures the ratio of defective supplier production parts detected at reception, in
production and at the customer. It includes technical defects as well as packaging and labelling errors.
PPB
* Only parts that have entered the site; consignment stocks awaiting reception are not included.
** For raw materials, replace number of parts by number of delivery units, i.e. unit of weight in most cases.
Non conformance is determined in terms of specifications: identification, size, aspect, function, mix, error in
quantity, etc. Non conforming parts formally accepted by VALEO are not included in the measurement of
defective parts; batches of products that have been destroyed or returned will be recorded as non
conforming. In the event that sorting operations have to be carried out at VALEO to which the supplier has
agreed and paid for, only the defective parts will be recorded as non conforming. In all other cases, the
whole batch is recorded as being defective.
RSQ Recover Supplier Quality – Program dedicated to top contributing suppliers to help them to recover quality
level.
QRAP Board QUICK RESPONSE ACTION PLAN board
QRQC QUICK RESPONSE QUALITY CONTROL : It is a way of management of problems applicable in every area:
Production, Projects, Logistics, Purchasing, etc
Recover Supplier Quality electronic - Program dedicated to top contributing Electronic component suppliers to help
RSQe them to recover quality level.
Ramp Up Controlled Shipment Level , provisional procedure implemented with a view to guaranteeing
RUCSL certified deliveries during ramp-up / probationary period of newly developed / modified component’s
production process. RUCSL workstation to be considered as the entry point of the Valeo plant.
SD&P Supplier Development Program dedicated to suppliers starting to drift – support will be given by focusing
on Production, Project and Logistics
STATISTICAL PROCESS CONTROL: Consists of monitoring a process by the statistical measurement of key
SPC parameters to detect process variations that impact the components ability to meet a required function.
The use of this method of control can therefore prevent the production of non-conforming products. SPC
can only be used for capable processes (see also "capability").
SPECIAL PRODUCT and PROCESS CHARACTERISTICS: and measurable characteristics of a component, System
SPPC or assembly which may have an adverse or degrading effect on the function, quality or reliability if an out of
tolerance condition occurs, Measurable elements of the process used to manufacture or assemble a
component that have significant impact on the function, quality or reliability of that components.
SUPPLIER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT: It is an Internet secured portal used to communicate with
SRM suppliers, through which, we can exchange several kinds of information (as for example: Quality incidents,
performances, standards, suggestion, etc.). (https://suppliers.VALEO.com/suppliers/)
SVRF Specific Valeo Requirements File
A document attesting to VALEO ownership when tooling has been placed at supplier premises for the
TOOLING LOAN production of components. This document must be signed by the supplier receiving the tooling or
AGREEMENTS equipment. This agreement addresses the following major aspects: Ownership of tooling, term and
termination of the agreement, conditions on the use of the tooling, maintenance and insurance.
YIS Yearly Initial Samples (see PQA Approach 7 – Product Quality Assurance management)
Appendix 1 VALEO Advanced Quality Planning for product and process - AQP.pp
Appendix 7 Process Audit Questionnaire & Report - (Appendix 3 & 4 of Procedure SQ 2102)
Appendix 12 EMP Changes Evaluation checklist and EMP Process Assessment checklist