Project Management Challenges and Difficulties: A Case Study of Information System Development
Project Management Challenges and Difficulties: A Case Study of Information System Development
Project Management Challenges and Difficulties: A Case Study of Information System Development
net/publication/266150891
CITATIONS READS
4 16,954
3 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Nordin Norani on 29 September 2014.
1
ESUH OSSAI-IGWE LUCKY, 2OJENIYI ADEGOKE,
3
NORANI NORDIN
1
College of Business, Universiti Utara Malaysia
2
School of Computing, Universiti Utara Malaysia
3
School of Technology Management and Logistics, Universiti Utara Malaysia
ABSTRACT
The successful development of Information System (IS) is not high even with
enormous interest and fund committed by organizations on this new technology.
It has been revealed that a combination of insufficient and unsuitable project
management issues are responsible for this low rate of IS development. This paper
presents the findings of the fieldwork and interview conducted on the challenges
and difficulties of system development project. The study employed both
personal interview and observation methods. The findings revealed that fund,
infrastructures (hardware and software), manpower, management commitment,
monitoring and inspection were the critical challenges and difficulties faced by
organizations during their system development. Therefore, the study concludes
that fund, infrastructures (hardware and software), manpower, management
commitment, monitoring and inspection play crucial role for an effective system
development. Our study recommends that there should be sufficient budget
to procure the right system hardware and software for right requirements.
Secondly, training of staff for both IS development and management should be
given urgent attention.
INTRODUCTION
LITERATURE REVIEW
COMPANY BACKGROUND
In 1996, the usage of computer was still new at PEH. They did not see
the need and the importance of having a database system. To develop a
database, it requires fund and time to collect all the relevant information
and data. Finally, the management agreed to give a chance to prove
that computer system can improve her overall data management in
PEH. With minimum support from the management, the head of IT
department and her team took the challenge to develop the system. They
review the whole process of the registration, the need and requirement
of the system and develop an in-house system. They have to work with
basic infrastructure due to low budget. A critical observation shows that
developing IS at PEH was not only a management challenge but also
includes users’ problem where staff (user) keeps changing due to either
retirement or transfer or other reasons.
In 1998 the system was finally ready for implementation. At this stage
according to the head of the IT department, the issues of end users were
still critical particularly where the end-users were afraid to use the system.
A special training on computer usage was conducted for the first stage
in order to make them familiar with the new equipment. They also have
to hire new staff (computer skilled) to speed up the implementation. In
2000, PEH developed a web page for the organization. The web consists
of Bulletin of PEH, organization chart, course offer and most important
is the registration form. They received a good feedback for the future
retiree army personnel since most of them are youngster and technology
driven.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Rosenberg and Yates (2007), Sekaran and Bougies (2009) and Zikmund,
Carr, and Griffin (2012) noted that for an adequately and in-depth
understand of phenomenon, case-study research design with interview
and observation research techniques are very important. Therefore,
toeing this line, this study utilized a case-study research design with
a face-to-face interview and observation research approaches. Two
key personnel of PEH were interviewed on the project management
challenges and difficulties experienced during the implementation of IS
in their organization.
Even PEH was established in 1994, yet the first recruitment of an IT staff
was conducted in 1996. There was no IT Department specifically at that
point of time. A critical observation shows that IS implementation of
PERHEBAT at the initial stage was manually. For example, the system
was stand-alone based on the requirement of each department. At this
stage, all data collected been processed in and by the ready-market
applications of database and spreadsheets such as Microsoft Access
for database and Excel for spread-sheet were later on converted to
Microsoft SQL Server 2000 to deal with number of data. They engaged
IS professional to develop the system for trainees’ data and registration.
They named it as Sistem Maklumat Pelatih (Trainee Information System).
As time goes by, the requirements of information are getting more
challenging and more complex from related departments for registration
of trainees, payrolls, procurements, human resource activities and
financial recordings and reports. The organization has developed in-
house systems based on departmental processes. However, the in-
house systems were not integrated with each other but stood alone
and were developed to serve each department alone. With the consent
of Management, few options have been considered and implemented
gradually to cater for requirements such as:
DISCUSSION
Fund
Generally, fund has been identified as one of the major that hinders
many projects particularly during early stage. As revealed by the key
informants, fund was a major obstacle and challenge that organization
faced during there IS development. This finding corroborates the ideas of
Benjamin and Blunt (2012) and Lederer (2013) that sufficient funding and
financial empowerment of new technologies is needed to survive in this
age of technological ever increasing competitive business environment.
Expressing her view, she said:
“The major difficulties faced with this organization in the time past are
lack of fund. There is always little money budgeted to the IT department
from the total budget of PERHEBAT. This has caused the department
so many limitations to carry on smooth running of the department.
There is an intention to move and upgrade to the latest technology but
cannot achieve this objective because of lack of fund. The organization is
constraint and could not move to the latest technology available in the
then market. Due to the same financial constraints, the IT departments
were unable to make purchases of latest technology in the market that
would have enhance the performance of the organization in general.
Example of such purchases includes; hardware, software, cable, and
other component relevant for upgrading.”
Infrastructure issues
Another factor that was identified to imposed a challenge on IS
development in PEH is infrastructures (hardware and software). There
is need for procurement of some hard ware facilities and migration from
old to the new or conventional machines. There is also need to build
Skilled Manpower
“The report of the study and review shows that there is low
number of computer literate staff in PERHEBAT. This is
because older staffs run away from computer job while only
younger staffs are interested in such job. Therefore, it calls
for training of older staffs or recruiting younger ones that
are interested in the job”.
Management Commitment
In addition to computer skill, the ability to convince the board on the need
for IS development was one key factor that was found challenging and
difficulty. Just like the issue of budget and fund, the ability to convince
the top management on why such fund should be use to that particular
project is more difficult. Because IS development is very expensive and
involves a lot of cost. It is always very difficult to convince the decision
makers why such budget or fund should be invest in the project. From
our observations, we discovered that it took the I.T department a lot
“In a situation where most board members are of the view that IT
engulf lot of fund with little to compensate for it. Then, it is a critical
circumstance to stand up and explain to them that application
currently in use should be replaced or up-graded with new vision
because of compatible issues. Am sure cost implication should be the
first question to be asked”.
“An integrated IS shall reduce the trauma and stress on the of manual
information retrieval system which slow down work process. With the
use and structured information system, PERE can have a good way for
tracking the trainees courses attended. Retrieving information of the
trainee, retrieving about the course attended, course offer and duration
are easier, faster and more efficient. Monitoring and inspection to
ensure all the trainee have completed their courses and succeed in their
life after retirement can be monitored. A list of report can be accessed to
show courses that they have attended and the advanced courses offered
if required by them.”
Apart from having, a central database there is need for PEH to upgrade
the Information System Department itself by having Secure Data Centre
to secure the data and the system by upgrading their Networking System
(LAN & WAN) and replacement of New Computer for each department.
From our reading and talk to the expert in Information System the
following action must be taken by PEH for their sustainable success
to improve their overall data management and other administration
processes:
CONCLUSION
REFERENCES
Benjamin, R., & Blunt, J. (2012). Critical IT issues: the next ten years.
Sloan Management. Review, 33(4).
Cadle, J., & Yeates, D. (Eds.). (2004). Project management for information
systems. Pearson education.
Higgins, E., Taylor, M., & Francis, H. (2012). A Systemic Approach to Fire
Prevention Support, Systemic Practice and Action Research, 25(5), 393-
406.
Korpela, M., A. Mursu, A., & Soriyan, H. A., (2002). Information systems
development as an activity, Computer Supported Cooperative Work
(CSCW), 11(1-2), 111-128.
Sekaran, U & Bougies, R. (2009). Research method for business, 5th John
Wiley and Sons, Inc: United Kingdom.
Zikmund, W. G., Carr, J. C., & Griffin, M. (2012). Business research methods,
CengageBrain. Com. (15th July 2013).