Math 202B Solutions: Assignment 7 D. Sarason
Math 202B Solutions: Assignment 7 D. Sarason
Assignment 7
D. Sarason
0
25. Let f be in Lp (λN ) and g in Lp (λN ). Prove that f ∗ g is bounded and continuous.
R
Proof: Clearly, for any x, |(f ∗ g)(x)| = RN f (y)g(x − y) dλN (y) ≤ kf kp kgkp0 , so f ∗ g is bounded. Also,
if Ta represents the operation of translation by a (i.e. Ta f (x) = f (x − a)), then Ta (f ∗ g) = (Ta f ) ∗ g. Proof:
Z Z
(f ∗ g)(x − a) = f (y)g(x − a − y) dy = f (y − a)g(x − y) dy = ((Ta f ) ∗ g)(x).
RN RN
Thus, if 1 ≤ p < ∞, then kTa (f ∗ g) − f ∗ gk∞ ≤ kTa f − f kp kgkp0 → 0 as a → 0, which implies that f ∗ g is
uniformly continuous. If p = ∞, use symmetry to reverse the roles of f and g.
26. (a) Let the function ψ : R → R be of class C ∞ and have compact support. Let the function g be in Lp (λ)
(1 ≤ p ≤ ∞). Prove that ψ ∗ g is of class C ∞ , with (ψ ∗ g)(n) = ψ (n) ∗ g for all positive integers n.
Proof: It will be enough to show that ψ ∗g is differentiable with derivative ψ 0 ∗g; the desired conclusion
will then follow by induction.
For δ 6= 0 define the function Dδ ψ by
ψ(x + δ) − ψ(x)
Dδ ψ(x) = .
δ
One easily verifies that
(ψ ∗ g)(x + δ) − (ψ ∗ g)(x)
= (Dδ ψ) ∗ g(x).
δ
We now have Dδ ψ → ψ 0 pointwise; also, by the mean value theorem, Dδ ψ(x) = ψ 0 (c) for some c
between x and x + δ. However, since ψ 0 is continuous and has compact support, it is uniformly
continuous. This implies that kDδ ψ − ψ 0 k∞ → 0 as δ → 0. Also, if ψ is supported on [−R, R]
and |δ| < 1, then Dδ ψ is supported on [−R − 1, R + 1]. If we let K = [−R − 1, R + 1], then
0
kDδ ψ − ψ 0 kp0 ≤ kDδ ψ − ψ 0 k∞ m(K)1/p → 0 for p0 < ∞ also.
Therefore,
(ψ ∗ g)(x + δ) − (ψ ∗ g)(x)
− (ψ ∗ g)(x) ≤ kDδ ψ − ψ 0 kp0 kgkp → 0 as δ → 0,
0
δ
which gives the desired conclusion.
(b) Use Part (a) to prove that C ∞ (R) ∩ Lp (λ) is dense in Lp (λ) for 1 ≤ p < ∞.
Proof: Take a nonnegative C ∞ function ψ of compact support such that kψk1 = 1. For example, let
(
C exp x21−1 , |x| < 1
ψ(x) =
0, |x| ≥ 1,
where the constant C is chosen so that kψk1 = 1. For > 0 let ψ (x) = 1 ψ( x ).
Let g be in Lp (λ) (1 ≤ p < ∞). By Theorem 15.1 in lecture we have ψ ∗ g → g in Lp norm. By part
(a), each function ψ ∗ g is of class C ∞ , giving the desired conclusion.
27. Let E be a Lebesgue measurable subset of RN of finite positive measure. Prove that the set
E − E = {x − y : x, y ∈ E}
1
By problem 25, since χE ∈ L1 (λN ) and χ−E ∈ L∞ (λN ), this means that λN (E ∩ (E + a)) is a continuous
function of a. By hypothesis this function has value λN (E) > 0 at a = 0, so the function is positive for a
in some neighborhood of 0. In particular, for any such a, E ∩ (E + a) 6= ∅, so a ∈ E − E.
28. Prove that the algebra L1 (λ) has no identity (λ = Lebesgue measure on R).
Proof 1: Suppose, to the contrary, that there were a function e ∈ L1 (λ) such that e ∗ g = g for each
g ∈ L1 (λ). Let ψ = χ[0,1] , and for > 0 let ψ (x) = 1 ψ( x ). Then by Theorem 15.1 in lecture, we have
ψ = e ∗ ψ → e in L1 (λ) as → 0. However, this is impossible, since a straightforward calculation shows
that kψ2−n − ψ2−(n+1) k1 = 1, so the sequence (ψ2−n )∞ 1
n=1 is not Cauchy in L (λ).
Proof 2: If e ∈ L1 (λ) were an identity, then by problem 25 we would have e ∗ χ[0,1] = χ[0,1] is equal
to some continuous function almost everywhere. However, this is impossible since χ[0,1] clearly remains
discontinuous at 0 and 1 after any modification on a set of measure zero.