Edgar Lawrence Doctorow A Political Nove PDF

Mediterranean Center of Social and Educational Research
Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences
Vol. 3, No. 2, May 2012
Rome, Italy 2012

Editor in Chief
Dr. Andrea Carteny
Executive Director, MCSER Scientific Coordinator

Prof. Antonello Biagini Prof. Giovanna Motta
Editing Graphic Design

Dr. Antonello Battaglia Dr. Gabriele Natalizia
Editorial Assistant Editorial Managing

Dr. Giuseppe Motta Dr. Igor Baglioni
Copyright  2012 MCSER – Mediterranean Center of Social and Educational Research
ISSN 2039-9340 (print)

ISSN 2039-2117 (online)
Vol. 3, No. 2, May 2012
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v2n3
Publisher
 MCSER – Mediterranean Center of Social and Educational Research

Piazza S. Giovanni in Laterano, 18/B
Cap. 00183, Rome, Italy
Tel/Fax: 039/0692913868
E-mail: [email protected]
Web: http://www.mcser.org
This issue is printed with the technology “print on demand”

by Gruppo Atena.net Srl
Via del Lavoro, 22,
36040, Grisignano VI, Italy
Tel: 0039/0444613696
Web: http://www.atena.net

Vol. 3, No. 2, May 2012
ISSN: 2039-9340 (print)

ISSN: 2039-2117 (online)
About the Journal
Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences (MJSS) is a double blind peer-reviewed

journal, published three times a year, by Mediterranean Center of Social and
Educational Research. The journal publishes research papers in the fields of
Mediterranean and World Culture, Sociology, Philosophy, Linguistics, Education,
History, History of Religions, Anthropology, Statistics, Politics, Laws, Psychology
and Economics. MJSS is open for the academic world and research institutes,
academic and departmental libraries, graduate students and PhD candidates,
academic and non-academic researchers and research teams. Specifically, MJSS is
positioned as a vehicle for academics and practitioners to share field research. In
addition to scientific studies, we will also consider letters to the editor, guest
editorials, and book reviews. Our goal is to provide original, relevant, and timely
information from diverse sources; to write and publish with absolute integrity; and
to serve as effectively as possible the needs of those involved in all social areas. If
your research will help us achieve these goals, we would like to hear from you.
MJSS provides immediate open access to its content on the principle that making
research freely available to the public supporting a greater global exchange of
knowledge. All manuscripts are subject to a double blind peer review by the
members of the editorial board who are noted experts in the appropriate subject
area.
Editor in Chief, Andrea Carteny

Sapienza University of Rom, Italy

Indexing/Abstracting/Library
Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences is included on the following index/abstracting/library
 IBSS - International Bibliography of  Georgetown University Library

the Social Sciences  Scirus Index
 ProQuest – Social Sciences Index  Open J. Gate Index
 ProQuest Political Sciences  Ohio Library and Information Network
 Sociological Abstract – ProQuest – OhioLINK
 PsycINFO – Bibliographic  Academic Journals Database
Database of the American  Indiana University Libraries
Psychological Association  California State Monterey Bay Library –
 MLA Index – International CSUMB
Bibliography of the Modern  University of Saskatchwean Library
Language Association  San José State University – Electronic
 DOAJ – Directory of Open Access Journal Index
Journals  University of Ottawa Library
 EBSCOhost  Birmingham Public Library
 EBSCO Publishing  Exlibris Index, The Bridge of
 Index Copernicus International Knowledge
 Cabell’s Publishing – Directories of  Shenzen University Library
Academic Journals  WZB Library
 Ulrichsweb – Global Serials Directory  Colorado States University Libraries
 Socol@r Index  Berlin State Library
 E-Journals.org  University of Washington Libraries
 World Wide Web Virtual Library  University Library of Regensburg
 Genamics JournalSeek  Digital Library of Wroclaw University
 Kaohsiung Medical University  Shenzen University Library
Library


Editor in chief Andrea Carteny
Sapienza University of Rome, Italy
International Editorial Board

Vincent Hoffmann-Martinot Marian Zlotea
University of Bordeaux, France Sapienza University of Rome / Government
Dimitri A. Sotiropoulos Agency, Romania
University of Athens, Greece Petar Jordanoski
Giuseppe Motta Sapienza University / University of Skopje
Sapienza University of Rome, Italy Slavko Burzanovic
Sibylle Heilbrunn University of Montenegro
Ruppin Academic Center, Emek-Hefer, Israel Martina Bitunjac
Marco Cilento Humboldt University of Berlin, Germany
Sapienza University of Rome, Italy Aranit Shkurti
Werner J. Patzelt CIRPS Sapienza University / EUT
University of Dresden Germany University, Albania
Mohamed Ben Aissa Francesco Randazzo
University of Tunis, Tunisia University of Perugia, Italy
Emanuele Santi Gulap Shahzada
African Development Bank, Tunis, Tunisia University of Science and Tecnology, Pakistan
Arda Arikan Nanjunda D C
Akdeniz University, Antalya, Turkey Universiy of Mysore, Karnataka, India
Alessandro Vagnini Nkasiobi S.Oguzor
Sapienza University of Rome, Italy Federal College of Education(Technical),
Godfrey Baldacchino Omoku- Nigeria
University of Malta, Malta Shobana Nelasco
Kamaruzaman Jusoff Fatima College, Madurai-India
Universiti Putra Malaysia Jacinta A. Opara
Daniel Pommier Vincelli Universidad Azteca, Mexico
Sapienza University of Rome, Italy Fernando A. Ferreira
Gabriele Natalizia Polytechnic Institute of Santarem, Portugal
Sapienza University of Rome, Italy Hassan Danial Aslam
Igor Baglioni Human Resource Management Research Society,
Sapienza University of Rome, Italy Pakistan
Tarau Virgiliu Leon Asoluka C. Njoku
Babes-Bolyai University, Cluj-Napoca, Alvan Ikoku Federal College of Education,
Romania Owerri-Nigeria
Dorina Orzac, Alice Kagoda
Babes-Bolyai University, Cluj-Napoca, Romania Makerere University, Kampala-Uganda

Addison M. Wokocha Sodienye A. Abere

Teachers Registration Council of Nigeria, Rivers State University of Science and
Abuja-Nigeria Technology, Port Harcourt, Nigeria
B.V. Toshev Luiela-Magdalena Csorba
University of Sofia, Bulgaria University Aurel Vlaicu, Romania
Benedicta Egbo Eddie Blass
University of Windsor, Ontario-Canada Swinburne University of Technology, Australia
Adriana Vizental Hanna David
University Aurel Vlaicu, Romania Tel Aviv University, Jerusalem-Israel
Florica Bodistean Raphael C. Njoku
University Aurel Vlaicu, Romania University of Louisville, USA
Bassey Ubong Ali Simek
Federal College of Education (Technical), Anadolu University, Turkey
Omoku-Nigeria Austin N. Nosike
A. C. Nwokocha The Granada Management Institute, Spain
Michael Okpara University of Agriculture, Gerhard Berchtold
Umudike-Umuahia, Nigeria Universidad Azteca, Mexico
S.E. Onuebunwa Samir Mohamed Alredaisy
Federal College of Education (Technical), University of Khartoum, Sudan
Omoku-Nigeria Lawrence Ogbo Ugwuanyi
Femi Quadri University of Abuja, Abuja-Nigeria
Federal College of Education (Technical), Oby C. Okonkwor
Omoku-Nigeria Nnamdi Azikiwe University, Awka-Nigeria
Abraham I. Oba Ridvan Peshkopia
Niger Delta Development Commission, Nigeria American Unievrsity of Tirana, Albania
Tutku Akter Murthy CSHN
Girne American University, Northern Cyprus Tezpur University Napaam Assam India
Fouzia Naeem Khan George Aspridis
Shaheed Zulfikar Ali Bhutto Institute of Technological Educational Institute (T.E.I.) of
Science and Technology, Pakistan Larissa
Marcel Pikhart Talat Islam
University Hradec Kralove, Czech Republic University of the Punjab, Lahore, Pakistan

TABLE OF CONTENTS
Articles
Game Theory and Competitive Analyse for Developing the Turistic Priorities in
Albanian Region. The Case Study of Vlora Coast 11
Miftar Ramosacaj, Alba Dumi
Sustainability of Agricultural Cooperative Societies in Nigeria:
The Case of South-South Zone, Nigeria 19
H. M. Ndifon, Agube, E. I., G. N. Odok

Unemployment and Persistent Poverty in the Niger Delta Region of Nigeria:

A Constraint to Sustainable Development in the 21st Century Nigeria 27
Inyang, Bassey, E.D. Simon
Analysis of Resource Productivity and the Level of Fertilizer - Manure
Substitution among Vegetable Farmers in the Southern Region of Nigeria 35
Sunday B. Akpan, Edet J. Udoh, Ememobong E. Bassey, Chukwuemeka Inya-agha, Friday J. Udo
Job Insecurity in Selected Banks in Ibadan Southwest Nigeria 47
Adebimpe A. Adenugba , Odunayo Oteyowo
Spatial Pattern of Road Traffic Accident Casualties in Nigeria 61
A.J. Aderamo
Evaluating Low Income Families’ self Perception of the Economic Aid Program:
The Albanian Case 73
Brilanda Lumanaj, Sidita Hasi
Voting Behavior of People Towards Different Political Parties in District Faisalabad, Pakistan 85
Durre-E- Shawar, Muhammad Asim
Great War in Transcaucasia: From Ottoman Occupation to the Treaty of Kars 93
Alessandro Vagnini
Determinants and Motivators of Dividend Policy: A Study of Cement Industry of Pakistan 103
Talat Islam, Muhammad Aamir, Ashfaq Ahmad, Muhammad Saeed
A View on the Customs and the Constitutional Conventions as Subsidiary
Sources of the Constitutional Law 109
Blerton Sinani, Alba Dumi
Money Talks: The Influence of Economic Crisis on Global Governance 117
Bassam A. Albassam
7

The Contrastive Move Analysis: An Investigation of Persian and English

Research Articles’ Abstract and Introduction Parts 129
Elham Zand-Vakili, Alireza Fard Kashani
An Assessment of Seasonal Variation of Waste Generation and Management
in Cross River State, Nigeria 139
Ukwayi Joseph K., Peter A Essoh, Inah, Sylvester Abam
Accessible Package of Services in Health Insurance Reform in Albania 147
Zamira Sinaj, Alba Dumi, Eliza Bodo
A Study into Methodological Issues in Cross-Cultural Pragmatic Research 153
Shirin Malekzadeh
A Study into Politeness Strategies and Politeness Markers
in Advertisements as Persuasive Tools 161
Reza Pishghadam, Safoora Navari
Online Reading Strategy Use and Gender Differences: The Case of Iranian EFL Learners 173
Saeed Taki, Gholam Hossein Soleimani
Ageing and Employment Prospects: The Case of Slovenian Unemployed Workers 185
Tjaša Redek, Andrej Sušjan
Traffic Congestion at Road Intersections in Ilorin, Nigeria 201
Adekunle J. Aderamo, Tolu I. Atomode
A Proposal for Open Standard Based Legal Document Management System
for the Parliament of Bangladesh 215
Mohammad Hasan Murad, Mohammad Saidul Islam
Globalization is Good or Bad? Considering View of Next Generation Leaders 225
Iftekhar Amin Chowdhury, Norazah Mohd Suki
Different Backgrounds and English Learning Styles of Bangkok University Student 233
Nuttanuch Munsakorn
Relative Impact of Infrastructural Provision by CBOs in Akure South LGA
of Ondo State, Nigeria: Application of Facility Contributory Index 243
Adebayo Adewunmi Emmanuel
Correlates of Alcohol Consumption among Adolescents in Ibadan North
Local Government Area of Oyo State, Nigeria 251
Adebimpe A.Adenugba, Ibhade Omonigho Ijagbone
Effects of Computer Assisted Instruction (CAI) on Students’ Achievement in
Social Studies in Osun State, Nigeria 269
Adeyemi B. A.
Frauds in Nigerian Banks:
Nature, Deep-Seated Causes, Aftermaths and Probable Remedies 279
Adeyemo Kingsley A.
Multiple Personality and the Dependence on an Intimate Ambience
( Between Luigi Pirandello and Ernest Koliqi) 291
Alva Dani
8

More than Fabric Motifs: Changed Meaning of Nsibidi on the Efik Ukara Cloth 297
Babson Ajibade, Esther Ekpe, Theodora Bassey
The Usage of Information and Communication Technology in Nigeria Primary Schools:
Problems and Prospects 305
Bada Tayo Abass, Ojediran Ayo
Community Parenting and the Concept of Child Abuse in Yoruba Culture 309
Odejobi Cecilia Omobola
Women in Military in India: The Cry for Parity 317
Arundhati Bhattacharyya
Strategies Used in The Translation Into Albanian of Allusions 327
in Walt Whitman's Poetry
Alketa Pema
Media Criticism: Class Fantasy and Ideology in the Movie Ganj-e Qaroon 335
Rasoul Rabani, Mehdi Adibi, Ehsan Aqababaee
Non-Verbal Communication and Volleyball: A New Way to Approach the Phenomenon 347
Gaetano Raiola, Alfredo Di Tore
Specifying Metadiscoursal Signals in the Novel Pride and Prejudice
and its Two Persian Translations By Copple’s model (1980) 357
Esmaiel Kaboli Boroujeni
An Assessment of Flood Hazard in Nigeria: The Case of Mile 12, Lagos 367
A. E Olajuyigbe, O.O Rotowa, E. Durojaye
Rural Development As Strategy for Food Security and Global Peace in The 21st Century 377
Nwagboso, I. Christopher
An Unromanticized Afghanistan in Saira Shah’s The Storyteller’s Daughter 391
Mais Qutami
Appraisal of Private Sector Involvement in Infrastructure Development
in Lagos State, Nigeria 399
Ojuola Olasijibomi Taye, Martin Oloruntobi Dada
Translating Dialect: a Comparative Study of the Novels of Luigi Pirandello 413
Mirela Papa
The Validity of Some Popular Readability Formulas 423
Pooneh Heydari
The Emphasized Legislative in Macedonia Institutions and Enforce Laws,
Regulations and Developing Administrative Improvements 437
Blerton Sinani, Alba Dumi
An Examination of the Usage of Vocabulary Retention Techniques (VRTs) 443
of Thai Undergraduate EFL Students
Win Jenpattarakul
Short and Long Run Relationship Between Value of Total Stock Exchange Transaction
and Key Macroeconomic Variables in Nigeria. A Cointegration Approach 457
Sunday B. Akpan, Chukwu E. Inya-Agha, Ebirigor A. Aya, Friday J. Udo, Obot D. Obot
9

Edgar Lawrence Doctorow; a Political Novelist? 465

Seyyed Mohammad Marandi, Zohreh Ramin
Topicilazation and Focalization in Persian 479
Vali Rezai, Manijeh Youhanaee, Hasan Ghasemi
Don’t Dampen the Laughter: Difficulties in Translating Comedies 497
Mirela Papa, Irena Lama
The Effect of Lingua Franca (Persian) on Minority Languages (Kurdish) 507
Mahnaz Saiedi, Payman Rezvani
Objective Correlatives of City and Places in T.S. Eliot’s the Waste Land 517
Manjola Nasi
The Impact of Person Job Fit on Job Satisfaction and its Subsequent Impact
on Employees Performance 523
Muhammad Tahir Iqbal, Waqas Latif, Wahab Naseer
Representation of the East in Western Literature
(A Critical Discourse Analysis of the Travelogue Eothen) 531
Neda Salahshour, Farzad Salahshour
A Vector Error Correction Modelling of the Composition of Government Spending
and the Real Exchange Rate in Nigeria 543
Victor E. Oriavwote, Ben U. Omojimite
Cohesion Analysis of L2 Writing: The Case of Iranian Undergraduate EFL Learners 557
Firooz Sadighi, Pooneh Heydari
Does Access to Finance Reduce Poverty? Evidence from Katsina State 575
Haruna Mohammed Aliero, Saifullahi Sani Ibrahim
10
ISSN 2039‐2117 Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences Vol. 3 (2) May 2012
Game Theory and Competitive Analyse for Developing the Turistic Priorities
in Albanian Region. The Case Study of Vlora Coast
Dr. Miftar Ramosacaj

Dean of Economic Faculty, ”Ismail Qemali” University of Vlora, Albania
Economic Faculty, Management department
Email: [email protected]
Prof. Assoc. Dr. Alba Dumi

Dean of Graduated School, ”Ismail Qemali”
University of Vlora Albania
Economic Faculty, Management department
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.11
Abstract: In this article, consider optimal decision making in two-alternative forced-choice. The paper research consist by
analyzing the mathematical models of TAFC decision making and show that all but one can be reduced to the drift diffusion
model, implementing the statistically optimal algorithm (most accurate for a given speed or fastest for a given accuracy). The
paper research prove further that there is always an optimal trade-off between speed and accuracy that maximizes various
reward functions, including reward rate (percentage of correct responses per unit time), as well as several other objective
functions, including ones weighted for accuracy. These findings address empirical data and make novel predictions about
performance under optimality. This literature review of decision making (how people make choices among desirable
alternatives), culled from the disciplines of psychology, economics, and mathematics, covers the theory of riskless choices, the
application of the theory of riskless choices to welfare economics, the theory of risky choices, transitivity of choices, and the
theory of games and statistical decision functions. In this paper we are trying to adopt the concrete data of ITC in Vlora region
for touristic promoting. The theories surveyed assume rational behavior: individuals have transitive preferences. There are two
points of hypothesis in this study: 1.The GTCA (Game theory and competitive analyse) theory and it apply in Albanian condition
for promoting the tourism.2. MMDM (Mathematics Models and Decision Making) theory and apply in developing the conditions
for promoting the reforming in Albania. Game theory, a discipline that was given its modern form by the mathematician John von
Neumann, models markets in which the actions of competing parties influence one another while each acts in its own self
interest.
Key words: Decision making, disciplines data, science influences, mathematical and economical theory, statistical decisions,
touristic priority in Vlora hotels, ICT system
1 Introduction
1.1 Conceptual and economical model overview and ITC data
These perspectives provide deeper insights into price structures than simple supply and demand, thereby
guiding investment and capital expenditure decisions. This paper identifies and addresses of the important
factors underlying of the, conceptual and economical model in decision making in Albania and changes in the
form of organization, under the administrative and implementing reforms in developing the touristic models in
Albanian region. The paper also introduces with the changes in Internet users, SME and Vlore University, for
taking part in this study. Analyzing a different competitive setting, a political scientist and a mathematician
have recently extended the age-old technique for dividing a piece of cake between two individuals one cuts,
the other chooses to fair division among many parties when economics and other complex forces are at
work. Such disputes might center on dividing cities and natural resources at the close of a multi-nation war.
11
The theoretical solution of the underlying mathematical problem that of fair, envy-free division among many
parties, might lead eventually to tools that heads of state could apply to deciding disputes like the division
decisions. The 1994 Nobel prize in economics was shared by John Headley and the mathematicians John
Nash and Mohelis & Holmess for their introduction of several different concepts of market equilibrium,
situations in which each player is in an optimum position relative to its competitors.
Information and Communication Technologies (ICT) have recognized a significant development in the
tourism industry. Digitization of all processes of the tourism development is a modern alternative to the
rapidly growing tourism industry in developing countries like Albania. Technology opportunities today offer the
possibility of excellence and development in the field of ICT in the tourism industry. However, the level of
tourism development varies according to regions, countries and continents. The main objective of this
research is to examine the ICT developments in tourism in Albania, particularly in its applications in hotels in
the Vlora, Ionian coast, as a great opportunity to bring them on the international tourism market. In particular,
the research examines the extent of ICT in enterprises of small and medium tourism. The level of Internet
presence is sufficient to study the level of the Destination Management System. Results show that the market
district of Vlora is in the early stages of its deployment. However, the low spread of ICT expresses once
again the lack of cooperation between tour operators and structures responsible for tourism development.
It also shows a lack of cooperation between companies that operate in the ICT sector and operators in the
tourism sector. The spread of ICT is a great opportunity to raise the revenues of small and medium tourism
enterprises through their presence in the global market. Ionian coast hotels occupy an important place in the
tourism industry in Albania. The increase of their activity is closely linked with the spread of information and
communication technologies (ICTs). It is very important to present first of all their demographic
characteristics. According to our assessment 58% of all the properties are family owned and about 13% of
them have an ownership group. 83% of the structures are multi-storey buildings and 17% of them are only
one-floor buildings. The amount and type of distribution in the structures in the hotels of this region is an
important element. Overall capacity of the hotels is small. Data show that only 10% of the hotels interviewed
have more than 40 rooms, 22% have 10-14 rooms. None of the hotels have a capacity greater than 80
rooms. About 96% of all rooms are single, while the largest number of rooms is composed of double, triple
ore matrimonial rooms. As regarding the number of the apartments available, data show that only 10% of
hotels have two to three apartments, while hotels with more than three apartments are only 3% of hotels in
the sample. A good part of them offer services such as restaurant, bar, respectively 85% and 82%. Only 17%
do not have restaurants. The working time in 60% of the structures of the sample is the entire year while the
rest, 40%, work only seasonally. Regarding their location we can state that 56% of them are located on the
seashore, 16.6% of 50m from the sea, and 12.5% of them more than 100 meters from the sea. The number
of employees varies from season to season.
2. Literature Review and Hypotheses
2.1. Focus of Mathematical concepts and using in management plan
Game theory is the branch of decision theory concerned with interdependent decisions. The problems of
interest involve multiple participants, each of whom has individual objectives related to a common system or
shared resources. Because game theory arose from the analysis of competitive scenarios, the problems are
called games and the participants are called players. But these techniques apply to more than just sport, and
are not even limited to competitive situations. In short, game theory deals with any problem in which each
player is strategy depends on what the other players do. The appropriate techniques for analyzing
interdependent decisions differ significantly from those for individual decisions. Using this methodology,
whether or not we end up ahead of another player will be of no consequence; our only concern will be
whether we have used our optimal strategy.
12
The reasons for this will become clear as we continue. In gaming, player actions are referred to as moves.
The role of analysis is to identify the sequence of moves that you should use. A sequence of moves is called
a strategy, so an optimal strategy is a sequence of moves that results in your best outcome. The aim of this
paper is to analyze the use of Internet by families in a developing region as is Vlore and its surrounding cities.
The methodology used includes the study through a questionnaire realized in a sample of students in
university environments who are asked as representatives of their families, in relation with the use of Internet,
the frequency, the reasons for using it or not and other issues about quality of services.
Primary data are gathered with a quality. Advanced econometric techniques are used to present an
assessment of demand for Internet functions, including socio-demographic characteristics of individuals and
their families. First of all it is presented a graphic analysis of data, looking for relationships between different
characteristics. Then, we have specified the two estimates with econometric models, the first for access at
home and the other for the intensity of Internet use outside home environment including the purpose of use,
reasons for obtaining Internet service as well as its impact on improving social capital.
2.2 MMDM and management analyses
Mathematics Models and Decision Making help in such cases when we want to plan a management strategy
and management SWOT analyses. Sometimes, the mathematical models use to create a root strategy for the
statistical and modeling decisions in management analyses. Supposedly there was de-emphasis of such
bugaboos as rote memory and drill and a renaissance of understanding and discovery. A pioneer
econometric focuses on the adoption of the broadband Internet service (Madden, Savage and Simpson
1996), with data collected in Australian homes. These authors were the first to discover that demographic
characteristics are one of the main influences on the individual decision to use the broadband Internet
service. Goolsbeey (2000), Duffy and Deno (2001), Kridel and Taylor (2002) also examine the demand for
Broadband Internet access with data from different samples in US cities and households. U.S. Department
of Commerce (2002) has its contribution in this regard too.
-H1 The development of a platforms of Mathematical Models of Economical Decision Making Processes for
developing the touristic region in Albania..Mathematical Economic Decision Making using in Albania for
promoting the tourism.
2.3 Evolution of Mathematical Decision and internet technology development
Dual monitoring system stimulates the use of multliple method for reporting and auditing ,increased
transparency of the process and the reliability of conclusion reached.The combination of internal monitoring
and external anabling effective action for improvements in the form of assistance from specialized units of
local and national. An important question that was raised with regard to the Gauss problem was "why?" One
of the most powerful human desires - to know why - is filled with ambiguity, and our obligation as individuals
and as a community is as much to engage in a dialogue that enables us to figure out what we are asking
when we ask the innocent sounding "why?" as it is to try to come up with answers. Internet is today one of
the most common phenomena of technology development. Though a relatively new network with its
beginning related to the use for military purposes, today it is the most widely used network in the world for
business, research, study, entertainment and social purposes. Historically, the use of systems to a common
network to allow connection of two computers began to develop in the early 60's. In 1969 the decision was
made to implement an experiment for the network that will enable the exchange of information between
different computers.
13
- H 2 If one starts with the hypothesis that aspects of mathematics learning could have an impact on the way
one conducts views the world in other domains as well, what are some of the possible mind-expanding ways
in which it might be conceived? It is unquestionable that the "structure of the disciplines" movement of the
past fifteen years solved some problems in the past decade for some people.
If we analyze the Internet phenomenon from a historical perspective in terms of adoption of a new
product/service, the Internet is nothing different from other products/services. Just as happens with some
new products, demand for content increases gradually until, in a very short time, it becomes a commodity.
The advent of Internet has pervaded our daily lives. The number of websites has increased from 130 in 1993
to well over 17 million in 2000 (Connolly, 2000). The aim of this study was also the construction of a model
which shows the demand (access and services). In fact, the use of a provided service by an individual is
possible.
This observation is central to the model of Averous Artileder (1973) and still represents a cornerstone for
modeling demand for the Internet (Taylor, 1994). An econometric model remains a goal for the future. The
literature suggests that Internet users differ from other users of telecommunication about the kind of attributes
that are important. This is supported by studies in 2002, when they describe the differences between the
phone application and Internet application. Jackson et al. (2002) tends to use a model of utility maximization,
assuming that customers want to have income, leisure activity and also online.
Theory shows that the maximization of customer service that has access at home is limited by
consumption of other goods and the allocation of time and income, but note that while theoretical arguments
suggest that the application is used to save money and time.
According to Taylor (1994), there are two types of respondents to the questionnaire:
: the set of respondents without access to the network

: the set of respondents with access to the network.
The individual utility function is expressed in the form
or U*TR*( qr* qs*qg) when r,s,g are indicators
i, qix ^ is the vector of goods consumed by individual i-, dichotomous variables that determine the access
status of an individual if he has (use) Internet access;
Otherwise
and = 0, a
, if the individual has access and otherwise.

The problem of maximizing service later said the individual functions
for each type of individual as follows:

= ( ) if =0
14
A linear approximation of the conditional utility function would be:
Where the utility function, β is the vector of parameters to be estimated and represents the array of
secondary services that are found to vector and error is the .
According to the model that we want build, Internet access and use are functions of several variables:
1) Internet Access = f (income, technology, social demographic distribution)
2)Using the Internet = g (income, technology, demographic distribution, access
Tab 1 The price for staying a night during the touristic season.
3. Methodology and Research Goal
For the past several years, some study have collaborated on an interdisciplinary program of experimental
and theoretical research involving applied mathematics, experimental psychology, systems and human
engineering, and computer science to develop a normative-descriptive theory to address problems of team-
distributed decision making / they have developed empirically validated normative-descriptive models that
capture the complexity, dynamicity, and uncertainty of the task environment and, in turn, quantify the
resulting team performance, coordination, and decision strategies in specific situations objectives of this
chapter are to present several of these models, to introduce the mathematical tools used to support the
modeling activity, to demonstrate the process by which the normative-descriptive theory is applied to
generate predictions of actual team performance, and to offer some novel hypotheses on team decision-
making behavior and performance / point out the characteristics of the distributed dynamic decision-making
problems that have been addressed, to define the normative-descriptive modeling approach, and to describe
a unique research paradigm for distributed decision making that has been used to generate and collect the
data to develop and validate the mathematical models.
The Internet has experienced explosive growth and the Internet traffic has grown exponentially in the last
decades. Technology has developed to resolve the traffic problem, in ways that many homes and access
15
points rely on different services, with different speed, offered by Internet service providers. There are some
early descriptive studies carried out on the basis of independent surveys concerning the adoption of
Information Technologies and communications in different countries. In Spain the National Institute of
Statistics (INE) began to compile this kind of information as of 2001.Different reports have been written to
consider demographic influences on the adoption of Internet in general, and especially broadband Internet.
Tab 2. The web page of the hotel
Finally, we should mention the report issued by the OECD (2001) which analyzes the adoption of Wideband
Internet connections in 30 countries. After careful consideration of literature review, primary data are
gathered through a survey done in the University of Vlora. Students were the respondents as representatives
of a middle level family type, including so families of all the region (Vlore, Fier, Berat,). The sample of
students is based on quotas according to year of the study and type of degree. Face to face interviewers
were administered during March-April 2011.The questionnaire designed includes all these topics and
comprises about 50 variables.
Data for the first section consist in obtaining information about the extent spread of fixed line very
important tool of ICT. We also analyzed the degree of their proliferation according to the service. [25][26][27]
Cell phones and the purpose of using them is the subject of the second section. Questions are asked about
the type of operator, costs, frequency of use, the number of SMS, the frequency of changing the mobile
device, etc. Questions also deal with information about the quality of Internet services and the impact of ICT
usage on social capital. Great attention has also been paid to the access to computer and Internet use at
work and study environments for developing the touristic situation in Albania.
Conclusions and recommendation
The literature suggests that Internet users differ from other users of telecommunication about the kind of
attributes that are important. This is supported by studies in 2002, when they describe the differences
between the phone application and Internet application All hotel owners claim that the interest of the clients
16
has increased for the Internet service and 100% of them claim that customers ask about the existence of this
service. During this analyze, we are find these conclusions: 1.The internet lines are very use full in Albania.
Game theory is the branch of decision theory concerned with interdependent decisions. We are study this
theory to promote the modeling system in Albanian touristic conditions and to arrangement the profits during
touristic season.
The problems of interest involve multiple participants, each of whom has individual objectives related to a
common system or shared resources. Because game theory arose from the analysis of competitive
scenarios, the problems are called games and the participants are called players. In this study the touristic
operators are “the players”
2. All hotel owners claim that the interest of the clients has increased for the Internet service and 100% of
them claim that customers ask about the existence of this service. In terms of payment for this service, the
hotel pays monthly to the ISP, from a minimum of20 euro to a maximum of 150 euro. 28% of them pay up to
20 at 30 euro per month while 27% of them pay 40-50 euro per month. Regarding their location we can state
that 56% of them are located on the seashore, 16.6% of 50m from the sea, and 12.5% of them more than
100 meters from the sea. The number of employees varies from season to season.
In this paper research we are trying to solve two hypotheses that are the indicators of this research.
MMDM and ITC modeling system are showing on points like:
1. Our intention in this work was to analyze the internet access and use by students and their families in
Vlora region.
2. In future, we will try to build a mathematical model explaining the relation between internet access and use
by other variables, economical, socio-demographical, individual characteristic related to mode of use, etc.
Our research will be improvement with other data in another our publishing. The literature suggests that
Internet users differ from other users of telecommunication about the kind of attributes that are important.
References
R Bogacz, E Brown, J Moehlis, P Holme, Psychological 2006 - psycnet.apa.org

Busemeyer, JR, & Rapoport, A. (1988). Psychological models of deferred decision making. Journal
Mathematical Psychology, 32, 91-134. Rapoport, A., & Burkheimer, GB (1971)
Models for deferred decision making. Journal of Mathematical Psychology, 8
MODELS; DECISION MAKING; DOCUMENTATION; ECONOMETRICS; ECONOMIC ANALYSIS;
ELECTRIC POWER; INFORMATION VALIDATION; LOAD MANAGEMENT; MULTIVARIATE
ANALYSIS; POWER DEMAND; ECONOMICS; MANAGEMENT; MATHEMATICS
Brown, Stephen 1. (1996b). Posing mathematically. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann Press.
Brown, Stephen 1. (1997). Math lingo vs. plain English: Multiple entendre. Humanistic Mathematics
Network Journal, 15, 5-10.Mathematical Models NEWELER YEAR 2010, PP 23
Study calls for better services’, by A. Warren, The Press, December 5, p. 2.
Garrett, N., Abbott, M. Cheung, V and DeSouza, R. (2007). International students.
Paper presented at the Asian Mental Informatic usage and internet pp23,
Clark, J., Baker, T., & Li, M. (2007). Student success: bridging the gap for Chinese students in collaborative learning.
Refereed paper for the 18th ISANA Annual Conference,
Success in International Education, from the 27-30 November 2007, at the Stamford Grand, Glenelg, Adelaide, Australia.
Cooper, J (2005) ‘Students not adapting to New Zealand: Study calls for better services’, by A. Warren, The Press,
December 5, p. 2.
MOH Data report Year 2010, pp 34,45,67,121
ISSH International JOURNAL year 2010, pp21
University of Vlore analyze, A Dumi analyze year 2009, publish Vlore Conference, pp45
Tirana Albania Focus Journal, year 2011, pp 7,8,9
Agencia de Calidad del SNS. Instituto de Información Barómetro Sanitario 2009. Madrid, 2010.
17
WHO. European Health for All Database, May, 2010

Instituto Nacional de Estadística. May 2010.www.methemetical formual.mat.it
OECD. Health Care Quality Indicators, OECD Health Data 2009, Paris www.ecosante.org
Market Access, Europe, Data from EUROCARE- 4, 2010.
Borkan J et al. Renewing primary care: lessons learned from Affairs 29,
Martín JJ. Crisis económica y sostenibilidad del Sistema Nacional de Salud, El Médico 2010;1109:16–19.
Mathematic model and Analyse M Ramosacaj IEFC Conference May 2012
Concepts and CASE STYDY M Ramosacaj Mathematical book Publish 2010, pp23,45,123,156,157,190
All rules and most examples here have been borrowed from: Dixit, Avinash K., and Barry J. Nalebuff.
Thinking Strategically. New York: W. W. Norton & Co., 1991.
This is an excellent nontechnical book on game theory, and this paper, internet link www.gtheory.mat.it
Gama theory and mathematical concepts, internet link www.mathemethical theory.nu.it
18
Sustainability of Agricultural Cooperative Societies in Nigeria:

The Case of South-South Zone, Nigeria
Dr. H. M. Ndifon
Agube, E. I.
G. N. Odok
Department of Agricultural Economics/Extension

University of Calabar
P.m.b 1115, Calabar, Nigeria
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.19
Abstract: The study looked at the sustainability of agricultural cooperative societies in the south-south geopolitical zone of
Nigeria. Out of six states of the zone, Cross River, Rivers and Edo were randomly selected for the study. The study identified the
socio-economic characteristics of cooperative societies, analyzed loan advanced to cooperative members, focus on the scope
for sustainability of cooperative societies, women empowerment and analyzed the loan utilization by the cooperative members.
Secondary data was sourced from the Nigerian Agricultural Cooperative and Rural Development Bank (NACRDB), Calabar
Branch. The information was analyzed using descriptive statistics. The result showed that out of the total loan advances made,
more than 50% went for consumption purposes. Rough estimate shows that about 50% of the cooperative members fall below
poverty line which shows that the cooperative groups of the zone comprised mostly of the economically poor.
Keywords: Agricultural Cooperatives, Sustainability, Capital
1. Introduction
In developing countries in which Nigeria is one, agriculture dominates the economy of the nation. It has been
established that about 70 percent of Nigeria population is engaged in agriculture (Obasi and Agu, 2000) while
90 percent of Nigeria total food production comes from small farms and 60 percent of the country population
earn their living from these small farms (Oluwalayo et al, 2008). The recent importation of food items into the
country to make up for the shortfalls in food supply is a dangerous indication of dwindling farm productivity
and warning sign that if the nation continue with the business as usual, the prospect of food security will be
bleak for millions of people (Nweze, 2003). The fall in agricultural production could be attributed to
inadequate infrastructure, under mechanization and inadequate finance (Oshiokaya, 2005). According to Ojo
(1998), one problem confronting small scale enterprise including that in agriculture is inadequate capital.
Inadequate finance has remained the most limiting problem of agricultural production. This is because
capital is the most important input in agricultural production and its availability has remain a major problem to
small scale farmers who account for the bulk of agricultural produce of the nation. In Nigeria, credit has long
been identified as a major factor in the development of agricultural sector (Balogun, 2007). Credit is
considered the catalyst that activates other factors of production and make under used capacities functional
for increased production (Ijere, 1998). It is a major factor necessary for technological transfer in traditional
agriculture (Oyaloye, 1981). Farm credit can be obtained from either the formal source which include the
banks and other government owned institutions or the informal sources which are self help group, money
lender, cooperatives and non-government agencies (NGO).
According to Afolabi and Fagbero (1998), the informal source of credit is more popular among small scale
farmers which may be to the relative ease in obtaining credit devoid of administrative delay, non existence of
security or collateral, flexibility built into repayment which is against what is obtained in the formal sources.
Ojo et al (1993), observed that the institutional lending system has failed to meet the objectives for which
19
they were set up. According to him only 15 percent of the trading bank credit to agriculture has been covered.
The major short-comings of their transactions he observed are due to the inaccessibility of these funds to
rural farmers as a result of bureaucratic procedures and high service cost, which are very difficult for the
farmers to meet. The situation has attracted the attention of Nigeria government to the creation of specialized
institution such as the Nigeria Agricultural Cooperative and Rural Development Bank (NACRDB) to cater for
the credit need in the agricultural sector.
However, Alufohai and Ahmadu (2005), studied its queue management and reported its ineffectiveness in
credit delivery. Inspite of the importance of loan in agricultural production, its acquisition is fraught with a
number of problems. The small scale farmers are forced to source for capital from relations, money-lenders
and contribution clubs. All of these are known to be ineffective in providing capital for substantial increase in
agricultural production. The last hope for the small scale farmers then lies with the cooperative societies
(Ijere, 1981), the cooperative has bee identified to be better channel of credit delivery to farmers the NGO’s in
term of its ability to sustain the loan delivery function (Alufahai, 2006). Thus, there is need for their
sustainability.
Cooperatives are defined as “an autonomous association of persons who unite voluntarily to meet their
common economy and social needs and aspiration through a jointly owned and democratically controlled
enterprise (ICA, 1995). Cooperatives are established by like-minded persons to pursue mutually beneficial
economic interest. Researchers are of the opinion that under normal circumstance cooperative play
significant role in the provision of services that enhance agricultural development. Patrick (1995), described
cooperatives as a medium through which services like provision of farm inputs, farm implements, farm
mechanization, agricultural loans, agricultural extension, members education, marketing of members farm
produce and other economic activities and services rendered to members. Regular and optimal performance
of these roles will accelerate the transformation and sustainability of not only the cooperatives but the
revampment of agricultural and rural economic development. Ijere (1981), further explains that it is the
cooperative that embraces all type of farmers and a well organized and supportive cooperative is a pillar of
strength for agriculture in Nigeria. Previous studies have shown that cooperative carryout the function of
credit delivery to farmers but there’s ample evidence that farmers face difficulties in obtaining credit and the
problem of sourcing for capital still lingers on. However, much of the credit supplied through cooperatives
gets used up for consumption purposes and therefore not productive. If members of the cooperatives ever
happen too feel that the credit coming forth from the cooperatives is not yielding adequate or no returns and
repayment of loans borrowed from them is inescapable, they may stop patronizing them (Katar sigh and
Gain, 1995, Dadhich, 2001).
The presumption that cooperative groups can bring down cost of lending, reduce over dues and can come
to be aid of those who need credit most the rural poor made NACRB to extend an all out support their
expansion, Enyenibe (2001). Also, the fact that most cooperative groups are formed by women, who by
nature thrifty and honest made everyone see cooperative groups as having a great future. The progress
achieved by the groups in South-South states of Nigeria is heartening. Cooperatives have grown from
strength to strength in the states and the policies of the government with their emphasis on women
empowerment have much to do with this.
Previous studies have shown that cooperatives carry out the function of credit delivery to farmers but
there’s ample evidence that farmers face difficulties in obtaining credit and the problem of sourcing for capital
sill lingers on. However, much of the credit supplied through cooperatives gets used up for consumption
purposes and therefore not productive. If members of the cooperative ever happen to feel that the credit
coming forth from the cooperatives is not yielding adequate or no returns and repayment of loans borrowed
from them is inescapable, they may stop patronizing them (Katar Sigh and Gain, 1995, Dadhich, 2000). The
continuing existence of cooperatives and their sustainability therefore depends upon how well the low skill
intensive products turned out by the members of the cooperative societies are received in the rural areas.
20
In the light of the above discussion, the main objective of the study is to focus on the scope for
sustainability to cooperative societies in South –south zone and the women empowerment through
cooperative groups.
The specific objectives are:
i) To analyze the socio-economic characteristics of the respondent.
ii) To analyze loan advanced to cooperative members (active and passive groups)
iii) To analysis loan utilization by cooperative members.
2. Methodology
The study was conducted in south-south zone of Nigeria. This zone comprises of six states namely; Cross
River, Rivers, Akwa Ibom, Bayelsa, Delta and Edo. For the purpose of convenience, three states, Cross
River, Rivers and Edo were randomly selected for the study. The list of all registered cooperatives societies
was obtained from the Nigerian Agricultural Cooperatives and Rural Development Bank (NACRDB); Calabar
branch. Secondary data for the study were collected, from the said institution, a total of 558 cooperative
groups were constituted, out of which 480 were active while 78 passive. Data obtained from the study were
collated and analyzed using simple descriptive statistics.
3. Result and Discussion
3.1 Sustainability
There are 558 groups of agricultural cooperative societies which were constituted in the selected three
states. The earliest group existed before now. It was during the period of restructuring of NACB in 2001. the
government policies at the state levels aided the formation of a large number of groups during the period.
The cooperative grew in number to a total of 558, out of which 480 became active while 78 passive.
Agricultural prosperity contributes to the sustainability of the cooperative.
There are some data on the activities for which loans are disbursed to members of the group. Loans are
taken by members for family maintenance, petty trading including garri and palm fruits procession, vegetable
sales, marketing of agricultural produce and investment in other smaller businesses.
It is noticed that of the total advances made more than 50% have gone for consumption purpose (table 1).
Table 1: percentage of loan advance by purpose (N000 )
Purpose Active group Passive group Total

Consumption % 6120 4920 11040
60.53 74.54 66.06
Production % 3990 1680 5670
39.46 25.45 33.93
Total % 10110 6600 16710
100 100 100
Field survey 2011
The occupational pattern of the members of the active cooperative groups is of interest. Thus a large majority
of members of the groups are dependent upon agriculture for a living and their incomes if anything would
fluctuate much more widely than the incomes of those in non-farm activities. This may have a telling effect on
the sustainability of cooperative groups.
21
Table 2: Occupation distribution of members of cooperative groups
Purpose Active Passive Total

group group
Agricultural % 252 24 276
52.50 30.76 52.27
Marginal farmer % 87 30 117
18.13 38.48 22.15
Non-farm active and rural artisan % 141 24 165
29.38 30.76 29.56
Total % 480 78 528
100 100 100
Field survey, 2011
3.2 Women Emplowerment
The yardstick used to the performance of a cooperative society should no always be its financial standing.
Even if a cooperative does not seem capable to sustaining itself financially, every effort should be made to
put it on the rails particularly when it empowers the economically and socially disadvantaged by giving them a
sense of belonging. The saving habit that is inculcated by cooperative groups among women should be also
taken into cognizance, for the money saved can make them feel independent. The interaction among the
members facilitates by the group meetings can make women think progressively about their children’s
education.
Table 3: Distribution of members of cooperative group by land holding
Particulars Active Passive Total

group group
Marginal farmer % 124 15 201
38.75 19.23 36.02
Small farmers % 57 9 66
11.88 11.53 11.82
Medium farmers % 24 6 30
5.00 7.69 5.37
Big farmers % 0.0 9 9
0.00 11.53 1.61
No level % 213 39 252
44.38 50.0 45.16
Total % 480 78 558
100.0 100.0 100.0
Field survey 2011
There is no denying the fact that the cooperative groups of the zone comprise mostly the economically poor.
Rough estimation shows that about 50% of them fall below poverty.
22
Table 4: Distribution of cooperative groups by literacy levels

group group
Illiterates % 168 30 198
35.00 38.46 35.48
Primary % 219 18 237
45.63 23.07 42.47
Secondary 57 15 72
11.89 19.23 12.90
Higher % 30 15 45
6.25 19.23 8.06
Above % 6 0.0 6
1.25 0.00 1.07
Total % 480 78 558
100 100
Field survey, 2011
Table 5: Distribution of members of cooperative groups by age

group group
No of group members 36 3 39
7.50 3.84 6.98
Age group below 25 years % 72 21 93
15.0 26.92 16.66
25-35 years % 243 24 267
50.62 30.76 47.54
Above 35 year % 129 30 156
26.87 38.46 28.49
Total 480 78 558
Field survey, 2011
Table 6: Responses of members classified by their level of participation in meetings of cooperative groups
Participation Active Passive Total

in group group group
actives members
Good % 300 45 315
62.60 19.23 56.45
Average % 132 27 159
27.50 34.61 28.49
Poor % 48 36 84
10.00 46.15 15.05
Total 480 78 558
Field survey, 2011
These details go to show that cooperative groups (active and passive) of the zone are largely in service of
the economically and socially weaker sections of the zone. Illiteracy has not deterred them from joining
23
cooperative group (Table 5). It should be possible to tap the hitherto untapped entrepreneurial skills of these
women. The interaction among members which is so essential for spread of knowledge about health,
education and more particularly for governing the activities of the cooperative groups seems good with 2.3rd
of members which is so essential for spread of knowledge about health, education and more particularly for
governing the activities of cooperative groups seems good with over 2.3rd of the members.
4. Conclusion
The importance of cooperative societies arises from the fact the rural poor (farmers) are not properly served
by formal institution agencies (viz, commercial banks and other government owned financial institution).
These institutions refrain advancing loan to the rural poor because of the bureaucratic procedures and high
cost service involved in lending to them. Cooperative societies also assume importance in view of the fact
that money lenders subject the rural poor to sever exploitation by charging high interest. By forming into
cooperative the rural poor can get over these two problems. In as much as the poor borrow and repay money
to banks as a group the cost of lending decreases. Since the members of the cooperative groups are of
homogenous economic class and since peer monitoring is the rule in the groups, loans advanced will
promptly. This makes cooperative group sustainable and the ever increasing number of cooperative societies
has much to do with this fact. The new NACRDB’s role in the expanding number of cooperative groups is not
to be betittled either.
Cooperative societies have grown from strength to strength particularly in South-south zone of Nigeria. In
this study 558 randomly selected cooperative groups of south-south zone cooperative groups are giving them
a new identity in the society. Saving on a monthly basis, which was unknown to women, is now a reality. The
hitherto untapped entrepreneurial skills of women are to the fore. To make the cooperative groups financial
sustainable, it is necessary to advance loans for activities which are not marginalized and which lead to
production of goods that have few substitutes in urban manufacturers.
5. Recommendation
1. The new role of NACRDB the expansion of number of cooperative groups should be seriously
upheld for cooperative sustainability.
2. To make the cooperative groups financially sustainable, it is necessary for the financial
institutions to advance loans for activities, in which it is meant for.
3. More commercial banks should be involved in granting loans from agricultural cooperatives.
4. Government should subsidized the interest rate and make it possible for the vast majority of
the farmers to acquire agricultural credit.
References
Alufohai, G. O. (2006). Sustainability of farm credit delivery by cooperatives and NGO’s in Edo and Delta State Nigeria. Educational
Research and Reviews 1(8):262-266.
Alufohai, G. O. and Ahmadu J. (2005). Queue management by Nigeria agricultural cooperative and rural development bank (NACRDB)
in farm credit delivery. The case of Benin Branch, Edo state, Nigeria proceedings of the 39th conference of agricultural society of
Nigeria (ASN) held at the University of Benin, Nigeria. 9th – 13th October, pp 300-303.
Balogun, E. D. (2007). Banking and credit facilities for integrated rural development, paper presented at the national seminar on rurual
development policy in Nigeria, Sheraton Hotel, Abuja.
Enyeribe, O. (2001). Principles of cooperative enterprise Enugu. Expressing publishing company.
Ijere, M. O. (1981). The prospect of employment creation through cooperative in Nigeria. Nigeria Journal of Rural Development and
Cooperative studies, 2:77 – 78.
Ijere M. O. (1998). Agricultural credit and economic development. In Ijere M. O. and Okories A. (eds), reading Agricultural finance,
Longman, Lagos, pp 4-9.
International Cooperative Alliance/CA (ICA) (1995). Report the centennial congress of the ICA, Geneva, Switzerland, October.
24
International Cooperative Alliance (ICT) (1995): Review of International cooperatives 4:85-86.

Nweze, N. J. (2003). Cooperative promotion in rural communities. The project approach. Nigeria Journal of cooperative studies, 2(2): 76-
89.
Obasi, F. C. and Agu, S. E. (2000). Economics of small scale rice farmers under different production systems in south eastern Nigeria.
Journal of agriculture, Business and Rural Development, 1:2
Olayemi, J. J. and Onyenwaku, C. E. (1999). Quantitative methods for business decision, Bosude printers Ltd, Ibadan, pp 55-81.
Oluwalayo, A. B. Sekumade and Adesoji, S. A. (2008). Resource use efficiency of maize farmers in rural Nigeria. Evidence from Ekiti
state, Nigeria World Journal of Agricultural Science, 4(1) 91-99.
Omotosho, M. Y. (2002). Operation research project, Yosode Publishers, Ibadan pp 63-77.
Oshiokoya, T. W. (2003). Financial Intermediation Resource mobilization and agricultural credit rural subsistence sector. The Nigeria
experience sustainable agriculture in Africa, proceedings of the agricultural seminar and research workshop selected paper,
University of Edmonton, Africa world press Inc. Treaton, New Jersey P, 121.
Oyaide, O. F. J. (1981). External financing for agricultural credit and finance in Nigeria, problems and prospects proceedings of seminar
organized by the central bank of Nigeria, April, 27 – 30.
25

Unemployment and Persistent Poverty in the Niger Delta Region of Nigeria:

A Constraint to Sustainable Development in the 21st Century Nigeria
Inyang, Bassey
Centre for General Studies,

Cross River University of Technology, Calabar
Dr. (Mrs) E.D. Simon
Department of Mass Communication, Centre for General Studies Unit

Cross River University of Technology Calabar
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.27
Abstract: This paper examines the phenomenon of unemployment and persistent poverty in Nigeria with special reference to
the Niger Delta region. Having diagnosed the episode of unemployment and poverty in the region, the paper unfolds that
unemployment and poverty have devastating effect on individuals, society and economy at large. This paper identifies that one
of the core causes of poverty in the Niger Delta today is the inability of many job seekers to secure gainful employment. It also
reveals the increasing level of poverty which has conditioned many people to a very low and undignified standard of living in the
region. The paper identifies unemployment and poverty as impacting negatively on the lives of the people and sustainable
development programmes in the region. Economic growth, which is supposed to be a solution to the problem of unemployment
and poverty, appears not to be in this region. In view of this, the paper recommends that the government and all stake-holders
must work together to get over the hurdles of unemployment and poverty and create more poverty alleviation programmes in
order to promote maximum investment and employment opportunity to the rural dwellers for sustainable development at the rural
setting.
1. Introduction
The Niger Delta region of Nigeria is endowed with multifarious and multitudinous resources in both human
and material resources. Notwithstanding the magnanimous contributions of the Niger Delta region to the
wealth of Nigeria, the people of the remain unemployed, impoverished, underdeveloped and blighted by
environmental and health hazards. However, due to gross mismanagement, profligate spending, kleptomania
and adverse policies of various governments of Nigeria, these resources have not been optimally utilized nor
adequately channeled to profitable investments to maximum economic benefits to the communities. As a
result of the foregoing, the region has been bedeviled with unemployment and poverty. And so, considerable
agitation, tension and violence have accompanied the attempts by oil producing communities in the region to
seek redress against the alleged neglect by government and the oil multinationals. The Niger Delta, a
massive and densely populated area of tropical rain forest and swamps located on the South-South geo-
political zone of the country, has always been an important centre for natural resources extraction, and has
become one of the most economically and strategically important territories in Africa since the discovery of oil
there in the 1950s. Economic growth, which is supposed to be a solution to the problems of unemployment,
poverty, corrupt politicians and civil servants, violent political agitation, and rampant lawlessness, the Niger
Delta region continues to languish, despite being one of the most oil-rich regions in the world. The region is
recognized with bad roads, low infrastructural development, high level of unemployment and poverty, female
prostitution and low industrialization rate. The Niger Delta is blessed with abundance of physical and human
resources, including the majority of Nigeria’s oil and gas deposits, good agricultural land, extensive forest,
27
excellent fisheries as well as a well developed industrial base an a vibrant primary sector (Duru, 1999). The
future of the region is threatened by incessant incident of militancy, kidnapping and insecurity as a result of
unemployment and poverty which in essence has grossly affected the tremendous potential for economic
growth and sustainable development in the area. “Violence, provoked by conflicts, has often turned the
people’s attention from creative production to creative destruction (Nnoli, 2003:3)
2. Conceptual Framework
This section of the paper considers relevant issues of unemployment, poverty and sustainable development.
There are various types of unemployment ranging from frictional, structural, cyclical, disguised and
underemployment. Frictional unemployment usually grows into long term unemployment. This is often
described as equilibrium unemployment (lLindbeck: 1999). Structural unemployment refers to a mismatch of
job vacancies with the supply of labor available, caused by shifts in the structure of the economy (Bannock et
al, 1998). Cyclical unemployment is an unemployment resulting from lack of aggregate demand in the
business cycle (Bannock, 1999). While disguised and underemployment describes the incidence of under
paid jobs. This is a core problem in the Niger Delta region that has many graduate job seekers to take to
under-paid and menial jobs. Poverty has become a major socio-economic in present day Nigeria. A
disturbing observation about poverty in Nigeria is that it is on the increase, both in incidence and intensity
despite the wide variety of national and international measures have been attributed to a multiplicity of
causes, of which the most frequently mentioned and emphasized include: inadequate conceptualizations of
poverty and development, failure to identify the root causes of the problem, lack of adequate organizational
requirement for effective programme implementation, wrong prescriptions given as solution to the problem of
poverty and various combinations of these shortcomings. Poverty is a comprehensive socio-economic virus
that constitutes one of the greatest afflictions of mankind. Generally in the Niger Delta region, poverty
appears endemic and at least its reduction has remained inextricable part of the policy and its excruciating
impact are pervasive and palpable on the people especially the rural dwellers.
According to Stanley (1995) the concept of sustainable development is a scientific notion capable of
precise, unequivocal measurement. The World Commission on Environment and Development (The
Brundtland Report, 1987) in our common future defines sustainable development as “Development that
meets the needs of future generations” (World Development Report, 1992). The report argues that
unemployment, poverty, resources depletion and environmental therefore is socio-economic and political
concept which largely incorporates the twin objectives of human development and environmental protection.
It is obvious from the analysis given above that the process of national development centers on man’s well
being and therefore entails finding solutions to the problems of health, unemployment, poverty, human
settlement, education and the exploitation of natural resources for a better and more meaningful life.
3. Unemployment and Poverty in the Niger Delta Region – A Time Bomb For The Country
One of the causes of poverty in the Niger Delta region today is the inability of many job seekers to secure
gainful employment. It is an inescapable fact that more than 70% of the Nigeria populace is currently
unemployed or underemployed. Those who are employed are earning starvation wages that cannot feed
them, let alone meet their various needs. More alarming is the fact that the burden of this huge
unemployment is borne by the youths and other energetic adults. See table 1& 2b below.
Politically, youth is defined as a transitional period from childhood to adulthood marked by events such as
completing schooling and further education, entering the world of work, achieving financial and residential
autonomy from family, engaging in close personal relationship and in some cases, marriages. The World
Health organization (WHO) describes the youth as anybody between the ages of 15 and 24 years. In
consonance with this, Ibonvbere (1989) says youth is conventionally conceptualized as a social category
28
made up of people whose chronological age falls within 15 and 24 years bracket and who also possess
certain distinct psychological and socio-cultural characteristic and constitutes over 20% of the population.
The African Youth Charter in Briggs (2008:18) sees a youth or young person as somebody, male or female
between the ages of 15 and 35 years. India also adopt this definition. Uzoeshi (2006) says that the period of
youth is the time to plan and execute, the time to aggregate, the time to give, the time to display energy and
the time to gather knowledge and avoid ignorance.
Table 1& 2 of the paper provides an insight into the distribution of unemployment in Nigeria. In the tables,
the age and sex distribution of unemployment are presented. The tables show that unemployment incidence
affects the job seekers within the ages of 20 – 24 and 25 – 44 years more, while there is less incidence of
unemployment within the ages of 55- 59 and 65 years and above.
Age group December 1998 March 1998 June 1999 September 1991 December 1999 March 2000 June 2000 December
2000
M F M F M F M F M F M F M F M F
15-19 16.7 16.3 18.3 18.4 17.5 23.3 18.1 22.7 18.1 32.2 19.7 25.4 NA NA 17.4 20.0
20.-24 29.8 30.6 35.2 31.6 30.7 27.2 30.5 26.7 27.6 31.2 29.4 32.9 NA NA 36.1 31.9
25-44 48.8 42.9 36.6 44.7 44.7 35.00 32.2 34.7 41.5 29.8 38.3 27.2 NA NA 36.91 34.9
45-54 3.6 4.1 5.6 2.6 5.3 11.7 6.8 6.7 3.2 1.3 3.4 5.6 NA NA 4.2 7.2
55-59 1.2 6.1 4.2 2.6 1.8 2.9 1.7 2.7 3.2 2.6 4.6 1.0 NA NA 3.1 2.6
60-64 .2 .1 .2 .2 .3 .7 10.2 6.7 6.4 2.6 4.6 7.9 NA NA 3.1 3.4
65+ - - - - - - - - - - - - NA NA - -
ALL
PERSONS 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 NA NA 100 100
Table 1. Percentage distribution of unemployed persons by age-group and sex, December 1998- December
2000 (urban centres)
Age group December March 1998 June 1999 September December March 2000 June 2000 December
1998 1991 1999 2000
M F M F M F M F M F M F M F M F
15-19 16.7 16.3 18.3 18.4 17.5 23.3 18.1 22.7 18.1 32.2 19.7 25.4 NA NA 17.4 20.0
20.-24 29.8 30.6 35.2 31.6 30.7 27.2 30.5 26.7 27.6 31.2 29.4 32.9 NA NA 36.1 31.9
25-44 48.8 42.9 36.6 44.7 44.7 35.00 32.2 34.7 41.5 29.8 38.3 27.2 NA NA 36.91 34.9
45-54 3.6 4.1 5.6 2.6 5.3 11.7 6.8 6.7 3.2 1.3 3.4 5.6 NA NA 4.2 7.2
55-59 1.2 6.1 4.2 2.6 1.8 2.9 1.7 2.7 3.2 2.6 4.6 1.0 NA NA 3.1 2.6
60-64 .2 .1 .2 .2 .3 .7 10.2 6.7 6.4 2.6 4.6 7.9 NA NA 3.1 3.4
65+ - - - - - - - - - - - - NA NA - -
ALL
PERSONS 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 NA NA 100 100
Source: Federal Office of Statistics. Labour Force Sample Survey

N.A.: Not Available
29
Table 2. Percentage distribution of unemployed persons by age-group and sex, December 1998- december
2000 (rural centres)
Age group December March 1999 June 1999 September December March 2000 June 2000 December
1998 1999 1999 2000
M F M F M F M F M F M F M F M F M
15-19 25.4 18.6 9.5 14.3 31.6 26.1 30.0 25.7 25.8 23.1 22.5 18.7 NA NA 27.5 20.1 NA
20.-24 28.5 28.4 21.6 23.1 31.6 26.1 30.0 31.4 35.9 33.7 31.88 48.8 NA NA 34.9 42.4 NA
25-44 36.9 33.3 52.6 52.7 31.6 40.6 30.3 28.8 27.6 27.8 30.8 21.4 NA NA 32.2 26.4 NA
45-54 3.1 12.5 11.2 7.7 5.2 2.9 2.7 3.8 4.2 8.7 3.0 5.3 NA NA 2.5 3.9 NA
55-59 4.9 7.2 5.1 2.2 NA 4.3 2.7 5.3 2.3 NA 5.2 2.6 NA NA 1.7 3.6 NA
60-64 1.2 NA NA NA NA NA 4.6 5.0 4.2 6.7 6.7 6.2 NA NA 1.2 3.6 NA
65+ - - - - - - - - - - - - NA NA - - NA
ALL 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 NA NA 100 100 NA
PERSONS
Source: Federal Office of Statistics. Labour Force Sample Survey N. A.: Not
AvailableThe age distribution of unemployment in the urban centres signals a great threat to the domestic
economy and the survival of the Nigerian nation. This is because many energetic youths with dynamic
resources wander around without gainful engagements. For instance, in December 1998, the urban centre
unemployment within the age bracket of 25-44 years was as high as 48.8 percent for males and 42.9 percent
for females. In December 1999, a figure of 41.5 and 29.8 percent were recorded for males and females
unemployment rate respectively while the corresponding time in 2000 had a record of 36.1 percent for male
job seekers and 34.9 for females in the urban centres. In the rural centres, official records in December 1999,
indicated a total of 27.8 percent unemployment rate within the ages of 25-44 years for males and females
respectively. The 2000 figure saw the rates for males increasing slightly to 32.2 percent with a slight
decrease in female unemployment to 26.4 percent within the same age bracket. Despite the various efforts of
government, stakeholders and economic players, by establishing a number of programmes such as the
National Directorate of Employment (NDE), the National open Apprenticeship Scheme (NOAS), the National
Poverty Eradication Programme (NAPEP), The Better Life, Family Support and the Family Economic
Advancement Programme (FEAP) during the life span of various administrations to address the hurdles of
poverty and unemployment, this monster among Nigerians is still on the speed lane. The World Bank and
associate agencies have been part of the poverty problem. Their Structural Adjustment Programme, (SAP),
relieve and poverty alleviation programme have only succeeded in diversity the attention of the poor from the
real causes of poverty (World Bank, 1975; Abasiekong, 1994; Abiodum, 1998). Millions of Nigerian youths
who graduated from the Universities, Polytechnics and other tertiary institutions cannot find jobs and
appropriate avenues to positively utilize their youthful energies. This segment of the populace is at the height
of their physical and mental powers. Normally, they should form the productive foundation of the economy of
any nation, but in Nigeria you find them roaming the streets in search of livelihood and employment
opportunities everyday and their frustrations keep mounting. The increase in both the frequency and intensity
of bank robberies is an outcome of unemployment and glaring social inequalities. No amount of police
equipment or training can rein crime unless the society strives to reduce the number of the frustrated. It does
not take much thinking to realize that an explosive mix of high volatility is brewing in the country especially in
the Niger Delta region, and it is being fuelled daily by elite insensitivity. If this vicious cycle of poverty and
unemployment continues unabated in this region, every unemployed, frustrated and pauperized citizen of the
region, becomes a potential social time bomb waiting to explode any moment. Nigerians are demanding
governmental accountability and good governance like never before and the results are trickling in. Someday
these trickles will turn to gales of mass discontent that will sweep bad leaders out of power at the pools. Inch
by inch that is the direction Nigeria is heading.
30
4. Poverty Alleviation
Indeed, the Nigerian landscape is crawling with a rapidly mutating population of jobless able-bodied men and
women who are angry, ill, frustrated and whose disempowerment accounts largely for the reign of cynicism in
the land and a high mortality rate. Unemployment and poverty have assumed a different and worrisome
dimension in view of the effects of the current global financial and economic crisis of the people. The
unemployment crisis in the Niger Delta region is linked to galloping poverty and of course, this is obvious. But
to put Nigerians to work, the solution lies in a reinvention of the nature and purpose of government. Once
upon a time in this country, Nigerians were a busy people, jobs were available, unemployment was low.
Companies used to rush to the universities every year and later to National Youth Service Corps (NYSC)
camps, to recruit skilled workers. Then, a certificate guaranteed a job and a better life. It is a common
practice now to see young graduates on newspaper stands, hotels and internet cafes in search of jobs
openings. Unemployment and poverty have social consequences as it increases crime rates in the country.
Poverty alleviation has been slow in developing nations such as Nigeria, and most African countries
because of the role of external power actors such as the World Bank and other “aid” donors. A number of
institutions, agencies and programmes established to alleviate poverty such as National Directorate of
Employment. (NDE) Directorate of Food, Roads and Rural Infrastructure (DFRRI), Better Life, and Family
Support Programme (FSP), National Poverty Eradication Programme (NAPEP) have not been able to meet
the enormous demands of the population. People and Community Banks are typical examples. Instead of
alleviating poverty, they mop up the little resources of the poor only to go distress leaving the poor depositors
in more difficult financial situations.
Again, instability in government and its parastatals is a crucial factor of poverty alleviation because when
development policies change suddenly with regimes, it becomes difficult if not impossible for rural
development and poverty alleviation to be implemented effectively (Ekong, 1991; Aziz, 1978).
It is regrettable that in spite of these efforts, socio-economic indicators continue to show that the number of
men and women joining the ranks of the unemployed working and those in vulnerable groups is perpetually
on the increase.
5. The Effect of Unemployment and Poverty on Sustainable Development in the Niger Delta Region of
Nigeria
In his book “Economic Development in the Third World”, Torado (1981) defines development as the process
of improving the quality of all human lives. This includes raising people standard of living, creating condition
conducive to the growth of people self esteem and increasing people’s freedom to choose by enlarging the
range of their choice variables. Sustainable development on the other hand refers to the basic of all people
that must be met in a way which provides for their needs with security and dignity and without absolute limits
to development. It also means a conscious and dignity and without absolute limits to development. It also
means a conscious and deliberate effort aimed at helping communities recognize their capacities to
participate fully in the life of the nation (Ekong, 2008). By implication therefore, sustainable development
involves active participation by the people themselves in efforts to improve their level with as much reliance
as possible on their own initiative and the provision of technical and other services in ways which encourage
initiative, effective self help and mutual help that meets the needs of the present without compromising the
ability of future generations to meet their own needs (Standley, 1995).
Central to the Niger Delta crisis is poverty and unemployment amidst unimaginable oil wealth. The oil
producing communities do seek to control their oil or at least participate actively in decision making on
matters affecting their areas. Over the past two decades, environmental degradation, including land
degradation has continued to worsen, exacerbating further poverty and food insecurity. This region is too rich
for her citizens to be poor. There has been a transformation in people perception of the poverty and
31
unemployment problem in the region. Until recently, the international community and national government
have tended not to appreciate the need for integrated rural poverty alleviation and environmental
management programmes in marginal areas.
Increasingly, the Niger Delta people are realizing that the fragile environment on which they depend for
their survival is being neglected and over exploited and it is now necessary to rehabilitate it and manage it
sustainably. The environment belongs primarily to them, and they must take the responsibility, for the land
and organize themselves in groups, cooperative, village development associations and other local
associations to defend it. They therefore have demanded for compensation to be paid to them by the oil
multinationals and for them to be sincerely committed towards the expansion of infrastructural facilities for
sustainable development. Sustainable development is not possible in a hostile environment where the oil
companies and community relations is highly contentious.
Tense atmosphere of conflict and violence in the region between the three major stakeholders had a
negative effect on sustainable development. Again, the presence of unemployed youths and poverty stricken
people and the exploitation of oil and valuable non-renewable natural resources is associated with increased
social unrest and youth restiveness in the Niger Delta Region. Oil and mineral extraction in the region
promoted the looting tendency by various government in Nigeria and have linked with unusually high poverty
rates, poor health care and high rate of mortality (Rose,20011). This means in effect that sustainable
development can hardly be achieved under this unfavorable and in secured environment.
The adverse effect of high unemployment and poverty on the domestic economy cannot be quantified.
The availability of abundant human resources if utilized could serve as great catalyst to sustainable
development but if otherwise, could exert negative influence on the economy. The unutilized large quantum
of human resources in the Niger Delta region due to unemployment has continued to impede the prospect of
growth. The resulting effect of unemployment and poverty such as perpetration of violence and general
insecurity threatens sustainable development to a large extent. It is no longer news that insecurity; instability
and uncertainty are the hallmarks that characterized the Niger Delta region due to youth restiveness. The
energies of the youths of the regions have not been meaningfully harnessed leading to sordid experiences in
the area (Agina-Obu,2008:47) .
Oil extraction in the region has worsened poverty and other negative behaviors by denying the oil
producing communities employment and access to oil revenues. Taken together, these trends have severely
jeopardized the socio-economic growth and development of both the economy and human capabilities in the
region. This has brought about violence and kidnapping which are desperate acts of desperate people who
have completely lost all sense of hope for a better future in the country. When environment and economic
development conditions deteriorate to unbearable level, the oil bearing communities naturally reacts. Instead
of the multinational responding to the plight of the people positively they rather respond by securing the
assistance of the Federal Government through the use of the Nigeria Police or military to terrorize and
brutalize the protesters. Most of their complaints relate to unemployment, poverty, environmental
degradation, destruction of means of livelihood and health. The deepening unemployment and poverty rate in
the region is already leading to mounting instability. Unemployment and poverty are the tinders which ignites
the resentments and fears that the oil communities harbour. Sustainable development and buoyant economy
can hardly be achieved in an atmosphere of crisis and hostility more so when the governments in the past
have always sidelined this region from meaningful development. The overall situation in this region till now
has been very hostile to economic growth and sustainable development.
6. Challenges of Unemployment and Poverty
Combating the challenges of the rising level of unemployment and poverty in the Niger Delta in particular and
Nigeria in general is a major task for stakeholders, policy makers and economic managers alike.
Unemployment and persistent poverty have been identified as the major hindrances to sustainable
32
development programmes in the region. The unemployment and sufferings among the youth of the Niger
Delta Region should be addressed spontaneously, as the increase in armed robbery, hostility to company’s
staff and properties, female youth prostitution and ritual killings are becoming alarming. Lack of employment
opportunities for many Nigerians has resulted in large number living in poverty . to enhance rapid economic
growth, increasing employment opportunities and heightening industrialization, the agricultural sector should
be revitalized.
The widespread unrest, turmoil, kidnapping, hostage taking and violence which is now afflicting an
unprecedented number of the oil producing communities is linked by one common thread of growing
economic malaise and underdevelopment. In order to eradicate unemployment and poverty in the Niger Delta
region, requires the development and implementation of more poverty alleviation programmes that will
directly benefit the poor, by restructuring sources of Nigeria’s gross domestic product (GDP) to significantly
include varieties of industries that are labour intensive, such as cottage industries. Also, governmental
organizations and landowners should be encouraged to make land available to poor Nigerians on a more
equitable basis for agricultural related industries such as farming. Until such radical steps are taken,
agriculture for sustainable development will continue to be unviable source of employment opportunity and
poverty alleviation for most Nigerians. Government should also make land available to private and public
organizations to set up cottage industries in the most economically depressed areas and provide training to
unskilled or economically deprived Nigerians which make ownership of small scale industries a viable source
of employment and building wealth for many Nigerians.
The agitation for resource control pursued by the Niger Delta people is without doubt, informed by actual
and perceived injustice, where the oil multinationals taking the oil from their land and giving them virtually
nothing in return and the complete marginalization and neglect by the Federal Government. Resource control
by the Niger Delta has to be influenced by some imperative political considerations which are intimately
connected with socio-economic rights of members of this region who have been consistently and
systematically neglected by the Federal Government. It is easy to observe that the monies earned by the
Federal Government from mineral resource-yielding communities are denied adequate funds for sustainable
development projects while other sections of the system are continually developed. Since the Federal
Government uses promulgated laws to control resources located in the Niger Delta region, and the proceeds
from the exploitation of such resources are not equitably shared or managed, the affected “people” are
justified in demanding control of their God given resources.
Various environmental problems arising from the impact of oil exploration and exploitation are
manifestations of the disharmony between development and the environment and they threaten to destroy
the basis of development itself. The lack of commitment by the Federal Government towards the enforcement
of standards in the oil companies has encouraged the oil companies to operate without hindrances. Nigeria is
a signatory to a number of International Conventions on environmental standards maintainable in the oil and
gas industries. These conventions have been honored in the breach than in their observance. Policies of
government should therefore, be streamlined to check the blatant oil exploitation and flaring of gas which are
associated with exceptionally low human development and poverty rates, conspicuously poor performance
on a range of important social welfare indicators and depressed rates of sustainable development. The
Ministry of Environment should not abandon their statutory role of policing the oil and gas companies. The
environmental impact assessment standards used in the United States of America and Europe should as well
be applied in the Niger Delta region.
7. Conclusion and Recommendation
From a historical antecedent of past reports and recommendations on the Niger Delta region, fifteen such
reports and recommendations have been initiated, from Henry Willinks Commission of 1958 to Ledum Mittee
led Technical Committee on the Niger Delta of 2008, without their implementation. We recommend that the
33
distilled recommendations raised by the Ledum Mittee led Technological Committee should be implemented
without undue delay. Again, the newly created Ministry of the Niger Delta Affairs should be provided with
enough funds to execute its master plan and to carry out integrated sustainable development programmes in
the oil producing communities to revitalize the Niger Delta economy by providing viable options to combat
unemployment and poverty that will help the Federal Government achieve sustainable development, peace,
human and environmental security in the Niger Delta region.
Unemployment and poverty crisis which manifest in layoffs, retrenchment, lack of jobs for young school
leavers and graduates, always intensify social distributional conflicts and economic contestations. As already
observed, the spate of conflict in the region will continue unless the Federal Government provides
appropriate remedies for the devastating consequences of unemployment and widespread poverty. Such
remedies should include improvement in the level of social provisions and infrastructures such as roads,
water, electricity, health care, housing, education, food production and distribution which are basic to the
realization of genuine rural development efforts for the people, as well as the introduction of other measures
such as setting up of cottage industries that would reduce the level of unemployment and poverty in the Niger
Delta region. The institution of a drastic land reform measure to ensure equitable distribution or redistribution
of land and land resources particularly in areas where gross inequalities in land ownership existed should be
put in place. Unemployment and poverty are serious constraints to sustainable development of the Niger
Delta Region of Niger’s socio-economic resources in the 21st Century Nigeria. The time to reverse this ugly
and unpalatable situation is now.
References
Abasiekong, E. M. (1994) “Rural Development Strategies” in Akwa Ibom States, The Land of Promise- A Compendium Journal.
Agina-Obu, T. (2008). Curbing Youth Restiveness in the Niger Delta: The Place of Music. In the International Researchers. Vol No. 2
Nov.
Aziz, S. (1978) Rural Development Learning from China. London: Macmillan Press Ltd.
Bannock, G. et al. (1998): “Penguin Dictionary of Economics”. 6th Edition The Penguin Books.
Briggs, C. (2008) Empowering Youths for Sustainable Development in Nigeria Journal Vol. 44 No. 1
Brundtland Report (1987) Our Common Future. Oxford University Press.
Duru, E. J. C. (1999) Oil Multinational and the Niger Delta Crisis: Issues and Perspective Owerri: African Scholars Publishing.
Ekong, E. (2003) An Introduction of Rural Sociology. Uyo: Dove Educational Publishers.
Ekong, E. E. (1991) “Rural Development and the Persistence of Poverty” in First Inaugural Lecture of the University of Cross River State,
Uyo Series No. 1
Englema, A: et al (1997). “Measurement Issues in Poverty” in Poverty Alleviation in Nigeria, Selected Papers for the 1993 Annual
Conference of the Nigeria Economic Society.
Ihonvbere, J. (1989). The Political Economy of Crisis and Underdevelopment in Africa Selected Works of Claude Ake, Lagos: JAD
Publishers
Inyang, J. D. (2001) Poverty: A Challenge to the 21st Century Rural Development in Nigeria. Journal of Education and Society, Vol. 4 No.
2. September.
Lindbeck, A. (1999) “Unemployment – Structural”, Institute of International Economic Studies, Stockholm University Seminar Paper No.
676, October.
Nnoli, O. (2003), (ed) “Communal Conflict and Population Displacement: An Introduction” in Nnoli O. (ed) Globalization and Democracy
in Africa.
Onuoha, J. J. (1995) “The Poor and Politics in Nigeria in Contemporary Issues in Social Sciences.
Rose, M. L. (2001) “Natural Resource and Civil Conflict: Evidence from Case Studies”.
Paper Prepared for the World Bank Workshop on “Civil Wards and Post Conflict Transition”.
Stanley, G. H. (1995) The Pursuit of Sustainability: Joining Science and Public Choice. The George Wright Forum 12 (3)
The World Bank (1975) Poverty Reduction Handbook. Washington D. C. The World Bank, 317 Journal.
The World Bank (1995). Nigeria Poverty Assessment, Washington D.C
Torado, M. (1981) Economic Development in the Third World. Longman.
Uzoeshi, K. (2006) The Role of the Youths in Community Development. Youth Focus. Vol. 1 No. 2
World Development Report (1992). Development. World Bank: Oxford University Press.
34
Analysis of Resource Productivity and the Level of Fertilizer - Manure

Substitution Among Vegetable Farmers in the Southern Region of Nigeria
Sunday B. Akpan
Department of Agricultural Economics, Michael Okpara University of Agriculture Umudike, Abia state,
P. M. B. 7267, Umuahia, Nigeria, E-Mail: [email protected]
Edet J. Udoh
Department of Agricultural Economics and Extension, University of Uyo,
P.M.B 1017, Uyo, Akwa Ibom State, Nigeria
Ememobong E. Bassey
Department of Agricultural Economics and Extension,
University of Uyo, P.M.B 1017, Uyo, Akwa Ibom State, Nigeria
Chukwuemeka Inya-agha
Department of Economics, University of Uyo
Friday J. Udo
Department of Business Administration, University of Uyo
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.35
Abstract: The study analyzed farm input productivity and estimated constant elasticity of substitution of fertilizer for manure for
vegetable farmers in the southern region of Nigeria. Primary data obtained from four hundred and eighty vegetable farmers in
Uyo and Itu regions of the southern part of Nigeria were used in the study. A combination of analytical tools including descriptive
statistics (percentages, frequency and tables), and regression analysis were used for data analysis. The generalized constant
elasticity of substitution function was specified and estimated through a system of coefficients relationship after which the
constant elasticity of substitution of fertilizer for manure for each crop enterprise was calculated. The empirical results revealed a
constant elasticity of substitution of fertilizer for manure of about 27.21% for waterleaf production and 35.11% for fluted pumpkin
production in the region. The Cobb-Douglas production function for waterleaf production revealed that planting material, family
labor, fertilizer, manure, and water have significant influenced on waterleaf production; while the linear production function for
fluted pumpkin production revealed that seed, hired labor, fertilizer, and manure have significant impact on the quantity of fluted
pumpkin produced. The result also revealed that the utilization of all significant production inputs of the two crop enterprises
were in the rational zone of the classical production surface. A mean total factor productivity of 45.60% and 45.59% were
realized for waterleaf and fluted pumpkin farms respectively in the region. The study however recommended that government
should increase fertilizer supply to vegetable farmer at a subsidized rate, intensify effort towards increasing research on manure
production to adequately complement the use of fertilizer and make land more accessible to vegetable crop farmers in the
region. Also, farmers cooperative organizations should be encourage among vegetable farmers as this would make inputs
acquisition less cumbersome.
Keywords: Vegetable, fertilizer, manure, substitution, CES, waterleaf, fluted pumpkin
1.Introduction
In Sub –Saharan Africa, agriculture has continues to be a primary instrument for sustainable development,
poverty reduction, attainment of household self food sufficiency and food security at large (World Bank, 2008
35
and Olwande et al., 2009). This is based on the fact that majority of the population are engaged in agricultural
activities. This make the agricultural sector in Africa a top preference for spurring growth, overcoming
poverty, and enhancing self food security. However, agricultural productivity in Africa has continued to
decline over the last decades and poverty level has increased (Olwande et al., 2009). Scale economies in
staple crop production and marketing are small. Staple crop production is especially plagued by many input
and factor market failures (Christiaensen and Demery 2010). In Nigeria, more than 60 percent of the
population is engaged in agricultural production; most of which are engaged in small scale production
(Deckers, 1993 and Olutawosin and Olaniyan, 2001). The ecological zones in the country support varieties of
crop production, ranging from cereals in the savanna region, root and tree crops in the rain forest and
vegetables in all ecological zones.
Vegetable production has been inconsistent in Nigeria; for instance in 2005 about 4924.9 thousand tonnes
were produced, while 2487.7 thousand tonnes were produced in 2006 (CBN, 2006). Vegetables are good
sources of protein, mineral salts, sugars, vitamins, and essential oils that increase man’s resistance to
disease (Hugues and Philippe, 1995 and Christian, 2007). Mlozi, (2003) and Francisca et al., (2006) asserted
that increased vegetable production improved food security and offer employment opportunities to many rural
women in Nigeria.
In the southern region of Nigeria, vegetable production is popular due to its high consumption rate easily
traced to it affordability. Waterleaf (Talinum triangulare) and fluted pumpkin (Telfairia occidentalis) are among
the major leafy vegetables grown by farmers in the southern region of Nigeria. The popularity of these two
major vegetable crops had been linked to low cost per unit of resource use in production, short gestation
period and quick returns on invested capital compared to other vegetable crops (Udoh, 2005). Sustained
production of vegetables in the southern region of Nigeria could only be achieved if farm inputs are readily
available and utilized optimally. Therefore, rational farm resources allocation and utilization are prerequisite
for attaining higher productivity in vegetable production in the southern region of Nigeria.
For instance, significant positive impact of fertilizer use on arable crop production in the southern region
Nigeria has been reported by Van Reuler and Prins (1993), Udoh (1993), Alimi et al., (2001), Osuhor et al.,
(2002) and Akpan et al., (2010). On the other hand, Fabiyi and Ogunfowora (1992), Udoh (1993), Chinedu et
al., (2002), Udoh et al., (2007), Olayinka et al., (1998), Udoh (2005) and Akpan et al., (2010) asserted
significant positive influenced of manure application on arable crop production in Nigeria. Also, significant
influenced of labor, capital, land size, planting material fertilizer and manure in vegetable production such as
Talinum triangulare and Telfairia occidentalis has been reported by Udoh (2005), Udoh and Sunday (2007),
Omonona and Babalola (2007), Nwachukwu and Onyenwaku (2007) and Enete and Ubokudom (2010) all in
Nigeria. Also the cultivation of vegetable crops in Nigeria is gender biased as it is dominated by women
(Amali, 1989; Okonjo, 1991; Auta et al., 2000; Mlozi, (2003); Rahman et al., 2003; Francisca et al., 2006;
Damisa and Yohanna, 2007; Udoh and Sunday 2007; Nwachukwu and Onyenwaku 2007 and Rahman,
2008).
Due to the population pressure, increasing urbanization and land fragmentation in the southern region of
Nigeria; vegetable crops is cutivated in the marginal or less fertile land by smallholder farmers under
traditional system of farming (Spencer, 1991; Enete and Ubokudom, 2010 and Udoh and Sunday, 2007). In a
situation of small farm sizes couple with the deteriorating condition of the soil, agricultural intensification
becomes the means of effectively addressing the problem of self-insufficiency in food production (Pinstrup-
Anderson and Pandya–Lorch, 1994). The issues on agricultural intensification have mixed impacts (Senjobi
et al., 2000 and DFID, 2002). Sustained vegetable production in the southern region of Nigeria could be
achieved under increasing agricultural resources intensification and dynamic economic environment only if
resource allocation and utilization occur in the rational stage of the classical production surface (CGIAR,
1988). The attainment of such farm objective especially in the developing countries is constrained by price
inelasticity of input demand among others. Farmers in response to these constraints are compelled to adopt
strategies to attain certain level of efficiency in resource allocation and utilization. Inputs substitution is one of
36
the strategies widely used by farmers in the developing countries to avert high price of complementing inputs.
Among vegetable farmers in the southern region of Nigeria, there is an evidence of increasing substitution of
fertilizer for manure in their production activities (Akpan et al., 2010). Despite the inherent advantages the
use of fertilizer has on food crop production and welfare of farmers, the adoption of the technology has been
hindered by multifarious factors including socioeconomics characteristic of farmers (i.e. education, social
status, attitude, social influence, estimated skills and resource endowments), budget constraint, characteristic
of the technology (i.e. relative advantage of the technology, its profitability and compatibility), environmental
factors, and unhealthy fertilizer policy as well as farmer’s related factors (Rogers, 1983; Byerlee, 1997and
Manyong et al., 2006).
In the face of the various agricultural programmes and policies implemented over the years by the
government of various states in the southern Nigeria to rise farmers’ efficiency and productivity in crop
production; the important of vegetable sub sector to the economy of the southern region of Nigeria
(temporary job creation, self food sufficiency, and good food complement sources), and production constraint
inherent in vegetable production; there is an overwhelming need to assess the productivity of vegetable farm
resources and determined level at which fertilizer is substituting for manure in the production of vegetables in
the region. Indices of farm resource productivity and allocation would help in formulating sustainable policy
frame work from which sound farm level policy could be base in the region. For an example, effective fertilizer
policy in the region would be promoted if the farm production and allocation index relating to fertilizer use
among farmers is known with certainty. If the index is low, the need for intensification policy could be
advocated and vice visa. Therefore, the study specifically assessed the resource productivity of vegetable
farmers and also determined the constant elasticity of substitution of fertilizer for manure among vegetable
farmers in the southern region of Nigeria. We assumed that the index of manure-fertilizer substitution among
vegetable farmers in the southern Nigeria is approximately constant due to the insignificant change in the sub
sector’s output and subsistence nature of production of the enterprise over the years (AKSMA, 2010).
2. Research Methodology
2.1 The study area; data sources and collection procedures
The study was conducted in Uyo region and Itu region in Akwa Ibom State and Cross River state all located
in the southern region of Nigeria. Uyo region consisted of Uyo, Uruan and Ibesikpo local government areas of
Akwa Ibom state. The Itu region consisted of Itu, Odukpani and Calabar local government areas of Akwa
Ibom state and Cross River State. Uyo and Itu lie within the humid tropical rainforest zone of Nigeria with an
average annual precipitation range of 2000 - 3000mm. Uyo is located between latitude 5o171 and 5o271N and
longitude 7o271 and 7o581E and covers an area of approximately 35 square kilometers as well as a
population of 305,961; while Itu is situated within latitude 40o and 20oN of the equator and longitude 30o and
47oE of the median and has an area of about 128.32 square kilometers as well as a population of 127, 850
(NPC, 2006). The areas are basically an agrarian environment and vegetable production is very prominent
among the inhabitants. Two – stage random sampling technique was used to select two hundred and forty
waterleaf farmers in Uyo region and another two hundred and forty fluted pumpkin farmer from intense
cultivation area in Itu region. Primary data collected from the farmers consisted of socio-economic and
production data. Personal interviewed were also conducted to validate the consistency and accuracy of
information supplied by the respondents.
2.2 Analytical Techniques
A combination of analytical tools including descriptive statistics (percentages, frequency and tables), and
regression analysis were used in the study. The regression analysis involved specification of various forms of
37
production functions. An implicit production function specified was as follows;

YWP=ƒ (QS, FL, MA, DEP, HL, FER, LNS, WAT) …………………….....….......... (1)
Where,
YWP = Output of waterleaf or pumpkin (kg)
QSwp = Quantity of seed or planting material (kg); HL = (in man days)
FL = Family labour (in man day); FER = quantity of fertilizer used (kg)
MA = Quantity of Manure used (kg); LNS = land size (in hectares)
DEP = Depreciation as a proxy of capital stock (N)
WAT = quantity of water used (in litres); U = Error term
The study specified only the important production inputs used in vegetable production in the areas. From the
survey it was noticed that about 99.9% of vegetable farmers in the regions do not used herbicides or any
form of agro chemical in the production of vegetables. Cultural barriers, unfounded rumors and high price
were some of the reasons farmers refused to applied chemicals in their farms.
To determine the constant elasticity of substitution of fertilizer for manure by waterleaf and fluted pumpkin
farmers in the study areas, the generalized constant elasticity of substitution (CES) production function was
specified for each of the crop enterprise as follows (Kmenta, 1967);
Yi= ƒ (FER, MAN) = A [δFER-+ (1- δ) MAN-]-V / …………………………….…. (2)
Where; A = efficiency parameter (A>O); δ = distribution parameter (O < δ <1)
 = substitution parameter (≥-1); YN = normalized output of the ith crop in kg
FER and MAN are as defined in equation (1) but were normalized using output price in equation (2).
V = return to scale parameter (v>o)
Kmenta (1967) states that in the above CES function, when β is in the neighborhood of zero or when the
elasticity of substitution σ is in the neighborhood of unity, that the CES function can be approximated with a
Taylor expansion series around β = 0. Using Taylor expansion series around β = 0; equation (2) was
linearized as in equation (3) and ordinary least squares method used to estimate it in the form of equation (4).
Hence,
In(YN)=In(A)+VδIn(FER)+V(1–δ)In(MAN)–βVδ/2(1–δ)In(FER)2–βVδ/2(1–δ)In(MAN)2 + β Vδ(1–δ) InFER)
In(MAN) + ei.……………………………………………............................................…….….(3)
Further simplification of equation (3) yield,
In(YN) = bo + b1In(FER) +b2In(MAN) + b3In{In(FER) – In(MAN)}2 + ei…...................….…(4)
The implication of the transformation is that, fertilizer and manure technology is assumed to have a constant
elasticity of substitution in the production of vegetable crops in the region due to the production constraints
inherent in its production. And this elasticity of substitution is assumed to be in the neighborhood of unity.
Following this assumptions, the input and the output values observed for the production of these crops could
be fitted to equation (4). It then follow that the restriction stated below could be used to test whether the
estimated function does in fact approximate the CES function in equation (2) and thus estimate the CES
parameters A, δ, β and V.
A = antilog of bo, V = b1 + b2, δ = b1 ⁄ (b1 + b2), β = -2b3(b1 + b2) ⁄b1b2 and σ = 1 ⁄ (1+ β)
Where, σ is the elasticity of substitution of fertilizer for manure in the production of each crop output. Given
the above definition of σ, the following relationships between σ and β hold (Bruno et al, 2005).
 σ = ∞ then (β = –1): CES takes the linear form and the inputs are perfect substitute so that the
farmers have no special preference for any of the inputs.
 σ =1 then (β= 0): CES becomes Cobb Douglas function and expressed a perfect balance between
substitution and complementary effects. That is unity elasticity of substitution between the two
inputs.
 σ <1 then (β> 0): CES function becomes production function with significant complementarity’s
effect between inputs.
38
 σ >1 then (β< 0): CES function shows inputs that are partial substitutes.
 σ = 0 then (β= ∞): CES takes the form of Leontief production function. This means that, the optimal
inputs combination or substitution in the production process does not depend on input prices but
fully determined by the parameters defining the production function.
Equation (3) and (4) are similar so that the parameters of CES were estimated using a system of coefficient
relationship described above.
3.1 Socioeconomic Characteristic of Vegetable farmers in the Southern Nigeria
The socioeconomic characteristics of vegetable farmers in the southern region of Nigeria are summarized in
Table 1. The survey revealed that female farmers dominated the cultivation of waterleaf (100%) and fluted
pumpkin (91.67%) in the southern region of Nigeria. The result revealed the significance of agricultural
activities to the sustenance of rural women folk in the southern Nigeria.
Table 1: Socio-economic Characteristics of Vegetable farmers in Uyo and Itu regions of Southern Nigeria.
Fluted Pumpkin Waterleaf Frequency
Characteristics Frequency Percentage Frequency Percentage
Sex Distribution
Male 20 8.33 0 0.00
Female 220 91.67 240 100.00
Total 240 100.00 240 100.00
Age Range (Yrs)
< 30 30 12.50 30 12.50
31-60 192 80.00 204 85.00
> 60 18 7.50 6 2.50
Total 240 100.00 240 100.00
Marital Status
Single 30 12.50 12 5.00
Married 162 67.50 132 55.00
Divorcee 12 5.00 30 12.50
Widowed 36 15.00 66 27.50
Total 240 100.00 240 100.00
House Hold Size (Yrs)
<5 66 27.50 60 25.00
5-10 138 57.50 162 67.50
> 10 36 15.00 18 7.50
Total 240 100.00 240 100.00
Level of Education (Yrs)
No Formal Education 18 7.50 36 15.00
Primary School 138 57.50 108 45.00
Secondary School 60 25.00 72 30.00
Tertiary Education 24 10.00 24 10.00
Total 240 100.00 240 100.00
Primary Occupation
Farming 174 72.50 174 72.50
Trading 24 10.00 18 7.50
Civil Service 12 5.00 30 12.50
Others 30 12.50 18 7.50
Total 240 100.00 240 100.00
Total Income/annum (N)
< 100,000 84 35.00 42 17.50
100,000 − 200,000 72 30.00 132 55.00
200,001 − 300,000 42 17.50 36 15.00
300,001 − 400,000 12 5.00 9 2.50
39
> 400,000 30 12.50 24 10.00

Total 240 100.00 240 100.00
Farming Experience (Yrs)
<1 20 8.33 50 20.83
1−5 50 20.83 90 37.50
>5 170 70.84 100 41.67
Total 120 100.00 240 100.00
Farm Size (ha)
< 0.1 40 16.67 70 29.17
0.1 − 1.0 196 81.67 170 70.83
> 1.0 4 1.66 0 0.00
Total 240 100.00 240 100.00
Source: Computed by the authors from field Survey, 2010
The finding implies that women are the dominant force in arable crop production in Nigeria and that poverty
alleviation programme targeted on women in the southern region of Nigeria would probably performed better
through agricultural sector. The result corroborates the findings of Amali, (1989), Okonjo (1991); Auta et al.,
(2000); Mlozi, (2003); Rahman et al., (2003); Francisca et al., (2006); Damisa and Yohanna, (2007); Udoh
and Sunday (2007); Nwachukwu and Onyenwaku (2007) and Rahman, (2008) in Nigeria.
Eighty percent of waterleaf farmers and eighty five percent of fluted pumpkin farmers fell within the age
bracket of 30 and 60 years with an average age of about 42 years for both enterprises. This implies that,
active labor force is involved in the cultivation of waterleaf and fluted pumpkin and this has a positive
implication for vegetable production in southern Nigeria. This is an incentive to agricultural innovation
dissemination as younger farmers are more likely to adopt new technology in agricultural production (Udoh
and Sunday, 2007 and Akpan et al., 2010).
The surveys also revealed that majority of vegetable farmers (i.e. 67.50% for fluted pumpkin farmers and
55% for waterleaf farmers) in the region are married and have household size range of 5 to 10 members
(57.50% for pumpkin and 67.50% for waterleaf) as well as an average household size of 6 members. The
result could be explained by the fact that most vegetable farmers in the region used the proceeds from the
vegetable enterprise to augment family income and employed relatively large and cheap family labor in
vegetable production. These have a positive implication on farmers’ welfare, sustainability of the enterprise
and cost minimization objective of vegetable farms in southern Nigeria.
Also, majority of vegetable farmers have at least 6 years of formal education with an average of 8 years for
all respondents. The result implies that there is a high probability of innovation adoption and diffusion among
vegetable farmers in the southern Nigeria. Around 35% of fluted pumpkin farmers made less than N100,000
per annum with an average of about N200,000/annum; while 55% of waterleaf farmers made between
N200,001 and N300,000 per annum with an average of about of N270,000/annum. This means that
vegetable cultivation is profitable in the southern Nigeria. In addition, the result showed that majority of
vegetable farmers in the region (about 70% for waterleaf and 41.67% for fluted pumpkin) have farming
experience greater than 5 years with an average farming experience of about 7 years for fluted pumpkin and
6 years for waterleaf farmers. This indicates that vegetable cultivation is an emerging enterprise in the in
southern Nigeria with vast potentials for increase private investment.
About 80% of fluted pumpkin farmers and 70.83% of waterleaf farmers have farm size that is between 0.1
ha to 1.0 ha with a mean farm size of 0.65 and 0.12 for fluted pumpkin and waterleaf farms respectively. The
result could be attributed to the continuous subsistence nature of cultivation of vegetable crops in the
southern Nigeria imposed by increasing land fragmentation and urbanization. The finding consolidated the
research report by Nwachukwu and Onyenwaku (2007) and Akpan et al., (2010).
40
4. Result of the regression Analysis
The estimates of production functions for waterleaf and fluted pumpkin in the southern region of Nigeria are
presented in Tables 2 and 3. Various functional forms were estimated for each crop enterprise. The
diagnostic tests and number of significant variables as well as the information criteria were used as basis for
selecting the lead or best equation. Double log production function was selected as the best functional form
for vegetable production.
Table2: Regression results for waterleaf production in Uyo region in southern Nigeria.
Variable Linear Exponential Semi-log Double-log (L*)

Constant 61.787 (2.083)** 4.742 (35.034)*** -55.801 (-1.856)* 1.517 (1.728)*
Planting Material 0.534 (4.932)*** 0.002 (4.483)*** 17.775 (4.447)*** 0.108 (6.789)***
Hired Labor -0.001 (-0539) -5.65e-006 (-0.834) 2.055 (0.490) 0.002 (0.179)
Family Labor 0.001(-0.358) 8.08e-009 (0.154) 2.687 (3.508)*** 0.007 (4.657)***
Fertilizer 0.114 (0.195) 0.001 (0.398) 8.731 (1.794)* 0.005 (2.500)**
Manure 0.014 (0.238) 0.001 (0.761) -3.099 (-0.126) 0.084 (2.466)**
Land size -3.948 (-1.238) -0.304 (-0.250 ) -5.150 (-1.653)* -0.108 (–1.074)
Depreciation 0.002 (1.680) 7.86e-006 (1.256) 17.857 (1.361) 0.047 (1.215)
Water 0.022 (1.165) 0.001 (1.857)* 1.958) (2.606)** 0.440 (2.849)***
Diagnostic Statistics
R2 0.848 0.757 0.813 0.877
Adjusted R2 0.809 0.694 0.764 0.846
F – Statistic 21.600*** 12.040*** 16.817*** 27.745***
Akaike Criterion 444.31 212.36 95.61 24.43
Schwarz Creterion 459.51 127.56 98.34 27.45
Hannan-Quinn 499.81 117.86 92.63 27.42
RESET test 1.96(0.172) 33.09(0.000)*** 2.300(0.201) 4.67(0.0300)**
Normality test 0.35 (0.838) 6.560(0.038) 17.778(0.000)*** 17.78(0.000)***
Note: Values in bracket represent t-values; asterisks*,**, and *** represent significance levels at 10%, 5%
and 1%. Variables are as defined in equation (1). Where L* represents the lead equation.
The result of the diagnostic test showed the R2 value of 0.877 for the lead equation. This means that about
87.70% of variations in waterleaf output (YW) are caused by the specified independent variables. The F-
statistic value of 27.745 for the lead equation is statistically significant at 1% probability level, suggesting that
that R2 is significant and this implies goodness of fit for the log linear model. The RESET test result is
significant at 1% probability level and this indicates that the equation is not mis-specified and that the
assumption of log linearity among variables is correct. The information criteria indicate the relevant of the
selected equation. The normality test confirmed the appropriateness of the ordinary least squares technique.
The empirical result showed that, planting material (QSw) has a significant positive relationship with the
waterleaf output. This implies that when the quantity of planting materials is increased, the output of waterleaf
would also increase. The result corroborates the research findings reported by Udoh (2005); Udoh and
Sunday (2007) and Omonona and Babalola (2007) on vegetable production in Southern Nigeria. Also, family
labor (FL) and fertilizer (FER) have a stimulating or positive correlation with the quantity of waterleaf output in
the region. In a similar way increasing these inputs would result in increase in waterleaf output in the region.
Udoh and Sunday (2007) and Enete and Ubokudom (2010 have reported similar result for waterleaf
production in Akwa Ibom state in the southern Nigeria. In a similar way, the quantity of manure (MA) and
volume of water (WAT) used by waterleaf farmers have significant positive impact on waterleaf output in the
region; this also indicates a stimulating influence of these inputs on waterleaf output. Udoh (2005) reported
similar result for vegetables farmers in south-south zone of Nigeria.
41
Table 3: Estimated Cobb-Douglas production parameters for waterleaf production in Uyo region of southern Nigeria.
Average productivity Marginal productivity Elasticity of production

Variable
Planting Material 5.9824 0.6464 0.108
Family Labour 0.6145 0.0043 0.007
Fertilizer 3.8223 0.0182 0.005
Manure 0.4759 0.0400 0.084
Water 0.0450 0.0198 0.440
Source: computed by the authors
The estimated parameters showed that the average productivities of all significant variables are greater than
their marginal productivities respectively. This implies that the level of input utilization in the production of
waterleaf in the southern region of Nigeria is in the rational zone in a classical production surface. Since
waterleaf production enterprise in the southern Nigeria has the features of perfect market structure, it
therefore means that farmers are price-takers; as such optimum input/output combination occurs in stage II in
a classical production surface. Therefore a unit increase in these inputs would only result in marginal
increase in the output of waterleaf produced by farmers. For instance, 10% increase in planting material
(QSw), family labor (FL), fertilizer (FER), manure (MAN) and water (WAT) would result in 6.5Kg, 0.04Kg,
0.18Kg, 0.40Kg, and 0.19Kg units’ marginal increase in waterleaf produced respectively. Also the production
elasticity value with respect to each significant input revealed inelastic relationship with the waterleaf output.
This implies that a unit change in the significant inputs would result in a less than equivalent unit change in
the waterleaf output. The scale of production of waterleaf enterprise in the region revealed a decreasing
return to scale value of 0.644. This means that continuous increase in the utilization of the specified inputs
would result in a decreasing waterleaf output in the long run. The mean total factor productivity (TFP) of
about 4.56 {i.e. antilog (1.517)} is obtainable among waterleaf farms in the region. This implies that inputs
productivity among waterleaf farms in the southern region of Nigeria is high; and this further revalidates the
rational used of farm inputs among waterleaf farmers in the region.
Similarly the estimated production functions for fluted pumpkin are presented in Table 3. The linear form
was picked as a lead equation (L*) because it has the highest coefficient of determination (R2 = 0.685) and
more significant explanatory variables compared to other models estimated. For the lead equation, the F-
statistic (3.531) is highly significant at 1% level which justifies the goodness of fit of the lead equation.
Table 4: Regression results for Pumpkin production in Itu region in southern Nigeria.
Variable Linear L* Exponential Semi-log Double-log L

Constant 255.89 (2.483)** 5.341(25.709)*** -1125.94 (-1.296) 1.524 (0.941)
Planting Material 0.78 (2.167)** 0.001 (1.765)* 142.15 (1.421) 0.341 (1.830)*
Hired labor 0.001 (1.680)* 4.96e-006(1.835)* 42.32 (0.682) 0.149 (1.287)
Family Labor -0.002 (-0.815) -2.76e-006 (0.730) -22.001 (-1.055) -0.057 (-1.459)
Fertilizer 1.470 (1.861)* 0.002 (1.753)* 0.328 (0.005) -0.064 (-0.502)
Manure 0.080 (3.773)*** 1.86e-005 (0.045) 5.839 (0.071) 0.062 (0.407)
Land Size -0.546( -6.067)*** -0.006 (-0.022) -23.03 (-2.239)** -0.033 (-2.183)**
Depreciation 0.0001(0.300) 1.64e-006 (0.689) 33.031 (0.761) 0.099 (1.219)
Diagnostic Statistics
42
R2 0.685 0.535 0.284 0.423

Adjusted R2 0.590 0.491 0.111 0.384
F – Statistic 3.531*** 2.216** 1.640 3.040***
Akaike Criterion 60.96 65.94 526.54 61.44
Schwarz Creterion 75.85 78.83 539.43 74.33
Hannan-Quinn 53.51 70.49 531.09 65.98
RESET test 0.219(0.044)** 0.009(0.095)* 0.11(0.742) 0.002(0.968)
Normality test 20.56(0.000)*** 5.18(0.075)* 31.30(0.000)*** 5.28(0.071)*
Note: Asterisks*,**, and *** represent significance levels at 10%, 5% and 1%. Variables are as defined in
equation (1). Figures in bracket are t-values and L* represents the lead equation.
The RESET test result is significant at 1% probability level indicating that the equation is not mis-specified
and that the assumption of linearity among variables is correct. The information criteria and normality test
indicate the important and correctness of the selected equation and the used of ordinary least squares
technique respectively.
The empirical result revealed that the coefficient of pumpkin seed (QSp) has a significant positive
relationship with the quantity of fluted pumpkin produced by farmers. The result implies that 10 percent
increase in the quantity of seed used would result in 7.8 percent units increase in pumpkin output. Similarly,
the coefficient of hired labor (HL) used in the production of fluted pumpkin has a stimulating influenced on the
pumpkin output. This indicates that a unit increase in (HL) would result in 0.001 units increase in the fluted
pumpkin output.
The slope coefficients of fertilizer (FER) and manure (MAN) have significant positive impact on fluted
pumpkin output in the study area. The results imply that 100 percent increase in both inputs would result in
147.0 and 8.0 percent increase in pumpkin output respectively. On the other hand, the coefficient of land size
(LNS) has a significant negative relationship with fluted pumpkin output. The result indicates that a unit
increase in land size would retard fluted pumpkin output by 0.546 units. The reasons for the result might be
explained by declining soil fertility in the study area attributed to increase soil intensification and the issue of
high cost of mineral fertilizer in the region. The mean total factor productivity (TFP) of about 4.59 {i.e. antilog
(1.524)} was obtainable among fluted pumpkin farms in the region. This implies that inputs productivity
among fluted pumpkin farms in the southern region of Nigeria is high; and this further reaffirmed the rational
used of farm inputs among pumpkin farmers in the region.
Table 5: Estimated Linear production function Parameters for Fluted Pumpkin in Itu region of southern Nigeria
Average productivity Marginal Elasticity of

Variable productivity production
Planting Material 0.29105 0.078 0.26700
Hired Labour 0.01234 0.001 0.08104
Fertilizer 7.32953 1.470 0.19885
Manure 1.38695 0.080 0.05768
Land Size 636.34266 -0.546 -0.00086
Source: Computed by authors
The average productivities of all significant variables are greater than their marginal productivities
respectively. This means that the level of input use in the production of fluted pumpkin in the study areas is in
the rational zone in a classical production surface. The elasticity of production of fluted pumpkin with respect
to each of the significant variable; planting material (QSp), hired Labor (HL), fertilizer (FER), manure (MAN),
and land size (LANS) revealed an inelastic relationship. The scale of production in fluted pumpkin enterprise
in the study area revealed a decreasing return to scale value of 0.6037. This means that continuous increase
in significant inputs would result in a decreasing fluted pumpkin output in the long run.
43
4.2 Estimates of constant elasticity of substitution of fertilizer for manure for vegetable farmers in Uyo and Itu
regions in the southern part of Nigeria.
The first part of the result in Table 6 shows the estimated equation (4) for waterleaf and fluted pumpkin farms.
The F-values of (11.287) for waterleaf, and (3.864) for fluted pumpkin production are statistically significant at
1 percent level respectively. This indicates goodness of fit for the specified double log linear model in
equation (4). The value of R2 for each crop enterprise shows considerable variations in outputs were caused
by the use of fertilizer and manure.
Table 6: Constant elasticity of substitution parameters for vegetable farmers in Uyo and Itu regions of Southern Nigeria.
Variable Waterleaf Pumpkin

bo -0.899 (-3.167)*** -0.536(-1.899)*
b1 0.026(0.399) 0.306(1.236)
b2 0.485(4.775)*** 0.691(2.346)**
b3 -0.033(-1.668)* -0.196(-2.361)**
R2 0.485 0.510
F-cal 11.287*** 3.864***
CES
A 0.1262 0.2911
V 0.511 0.997
δ 0.0508 0.3069
β 2.6745 1.848
σ 0.2721 0.3511
Note: figures in bracket are t-values, while *,** and*** represent 10%, 5%, and 1% significance levels
respectively. Variables are as defined in equation 2.
The second part showed the approximated CES parameters and the last part revealed the constant elasticity
of substitution of fertilizer for manure in the production of waterleaf and fluted pumpkin crops. The result
revealed that in the production of waterleaf and pumpkin, the constant elasticity of substitution of fertilizer for
manure is 0.2721 and 0.351 respectively and is less than unity. This implies that the use of fertilizer and
manure inputs in the production of vegetables in southern region of Nigeria has a significant complementarity
effect between them. This means that manure is frequently used to complement fertilizer in the production of
waterleaf and fluted pumpkin in approximated constant rate of 0.2721 and 0.351 respectively in the southern
region of Nigeria. The efficiency parameters (A) with respect to the used of fertilizer and manure in waterleaf
production is about 12.62% and 29.11% for fluted pumpkin production. The scale of production (V) revealed
a decreasing return to scale of 0.511 for waterleaf production and 0.997 for fluted pumpkin production. The
substitution parameters are less than unity for both crops and revealed one-sided substitution of one input for
another. This further validates the fact that more manure is used than fertilizer by vegetable farmers in the
region.
5. Summary and Recommendations
The study analyzed farm input productivity and fertilizer - manure substitution among waterleaf and fluted
pumpkin farmers in the southern region of Nigeria. Descriptive statistics and Ordinary Least Squares
regression model were used in the analysis. Empirical results revealed that planting material, family labor,
fertilizer, manure, and water are significant farm inputs affecting the production of waterleaf; while planting
material, hired labor, fertilizer, manure, and land size affect fluted pumpkin production in the southern region
of Nigeria. Constant Elasticity of Substitution of fertilizer for manure less than unity was discovered for the
crop enterprises. The result also indicated that the level of farm resources use in both waterleaf and fluted
44
pumpkin production in the region were in the rational stage of classical production surface. In addition, the
findings revealed the presence of decreasing return to scale in waterleaf and fluted pumpkin production.
The study therefore recommended that the state government of the region should increase fertilizer
supply to vegetable farmer at a subsidized rate. Also, government and private investors should intensify effort
towards increasing research on manure production to adequately complement the use of fertilizer among
vegetable farmers in the southern region of Nigeria. In addition, the regional governments should make land
more accessible to vegetable crop farmers in the region. This could be achieved through land extensification
programmes such as: land reclamation, development of Fadama and provision of accessible roads to interior
or undulating landscape areas. Farmers cooperative organization should be encourage among vegetable
farmers as this would make inputs acquisition less cumbersome. Vegetable production is a profitable venture
in the southern part on Nigeria, thus increase private investment is strongly advocated.
References
(AKSMA, 2010) Akwa Ibom state ministry of Agriculture annual report 2010.
Akpan, S. B., Udoh, E. J. And Aya, E. A., (2007). Fertiliser- Manure Substation among Arable Crop Farmers in Akwa Ibom State:
empirical evidence. Global Journal of Agricultural sciences. Vol. 9 No1 Pp 37-40.
Alimi, O., Ajewole, O., Olubode-Awosola and E.O. Idowu, (2001). Economic rationale of commercial organic fertilizer technology in
vegetable production in Osun State of Nigeria. Journal of Applied Horticulture, 8(2): 159-164.
Amali, E., 1989. The role of women in agricultural development process. Development Studies Review Centre Publication, University of
Jos, Nigeria, 1 and 2: 52-60.
Auta, S.J., S.Z. Abubakar and R. Hassan, 2000. An assessment of the contribution of women to family farming in north-eastern Nigeria.
A Research Report submitted to the National Agricultural Extension and Research Liaison Service, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria,
Nigeria, September 2000.
Bruno C., M. Benton, P. Sriran and V. Kasturi (2005). Market equilibrium for CES exchange economies: Existence, multiplicity and
computation. Paper presented at a DIMACS workshop on large scale games Chicago.
Byerlee, Derek and Carl K. Eicher (eds) (1997). Africa’s Emerging Maize Revolution. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner Publishers.
Central Bank of Nigeria. (2006). Annual Report and Statement of Accounts. Abuja.
CGIAR (Consultative Group on International Agricultural Research), 1988. Sustainable Agricultural Production: Implication for
International Agricultural Research TAC report (AGRI/TAC:/AR/8722 Rev.2) Washington D.C. USA.
Chinedu, N. and O. Adeolu A., (2002). Organic Manure Used Among Small holder in the Rainforest of Southeast Nigeria. Deytscher
witrenhausen, 14(2):516-515.
Christiaensen, L., and Demery, L., (2010): Are African Countries Paying Too Much Attention To Agriculture? WIDER Working Paper
2010.http://www.wider.unu.edu/publications/working-papers/2010/en_GB/wp2010-36/. 03-09-2011
Christian, A., (2007). Fluted pumpkin (Tefairia occidentalis) seed: a nutritional assessment. Electronic journal of environment, Agriculture
and food chemistry. 6 (2), 2007
Damisa, M.A. and M. Yohanna, 2007. Role of rural women in farm management decision making process: Ordered Probit analysis.
Trends in Applied Science Research, 2(3): 241-145.
Deckers, J. (1993). Soil Fertility and Environmental Problems in Different Ecological Zones of Developing Countries in Sub-Saharan
Africa. Van Pualer H. & Prins, W.H. Eds. Ponsen and Iooiven, Wageningen. Pp. 37-52
DFID (Department For International Development), 2002. Better Livelihoods for poor people: The role of agriculture. Issues. Fuller–
Davies Ltd. 1 Palace Street, London, UK. pp. 23.
Edet, G. E. and Etim, N. A., (2010). Economic analysis of okra production: a case of ivo local government area of Ebonyi state. Nigerian
Journal of Agriculture, Food and Environment. 6(1&2):99-103
Enete, A., and Ubokudom E., (2010). Economic of waterleaf production IN Akwa Ibom State, Nigeria. Field Actions Science Reports
(online), vol.4
Fabiyi LL, Ogunfowora O. O., (1992). Economics of production and utilization of organic fertiliser in organic fertiliser in the Nigeria
agriculture: Present and future. Ed. Federal Ministry of Science and Technology Lagos, pp. 138-144.
Francisca, S. I. and Eyzayuirre, P., (2006). African leafy vegetables: Their Role in the World Health Organization’s Global Fruit and
Vegetable Initiative
Hugues D and Phillippe D.L., (1995). African Gardens and orchards Growing Vegetables and Fruits. Alphabet publishers.
John Olwande, J., Geophrey Sikei and Mary Mathenge, (2009). Agricultural Technology Adoption: A Panel Analysis of Smallholder
Farmers’ Fertilizer use in Kenya. African Economic Research Consortium Conference paper.
Kmenta, J. 1967. On Estimation of the CES Production Function. International Economic Review 8:180–89.
Manyong, V. M., K. O. Makinde, N. Sanginga, B. Vanlauwe and J. Diels, (2009).Fertilizer and definition of farmer dormains for impact-
oriented research in northern Guinea Savanna of Nigeria. Nut. Cyc. Agroecosyst., 59(2): 129-141.
45
Mlozi, M.R.S. (2003). Urban Agriculture: Vegetable Production in Metropolitan Greater Vancouver District in Lanans Sokoine University
of Agriculture Morogore, Tanzania.
National population commission (2006), national census data for Nigeria.
Nwackukwu, I. N., and Onyenweaku C., (2007). Economic Efficiency of Fadama Telfairia Production in Imo State Nigeria. A translog
profit function Approach. Munich Personal REPEC Archive (MPRA). Paper No. 13469.
Okonjo, K., 1991. Acknowledging the existence of women--- Its consequences, In:Women in Nigerian Economy, Ed. M. O. Ijere. Enugu,
Nigeria: Acena Publishers.
Olayinka A, Adetunji A, Adebayo A (1998). Effect of Organic Amendments on Nodulation and Nitrogen Fixation of Cowpea. J. Plant Nutr.
21(11): 2455–2464.
Olutawosin G.A. and G.O. Olaniyan, (2001). Planning sustainable land management system for continuous crop production in Nigeria:
An ecosystem approach: Paper presented at Ecofarming Workshop NECOFA–NIGERIA, Dec. 20-21 pp.17-24.
Omonona, B., and D. A. Babalola, (2007). Determinants of the production of fluted pumpkin among farmers in Nigeria. Journal of
agricultural and food Information, vol. 8 issue 1, Pp, 95- 105
Osuhor, C. U. J. P. Alawa and G. N. Akpa (2002). Manure production by goats grazing native pasture in Nigeria. Tropical grassland, 36:
123-125.
Pinstrup–Anderson, P. and R. Pandya-Lorch, 1994. Alleviating poverty, intensifying Agriculture, and effectively managing natural
resources. Food, Agriculture andEnvironment discussion paper 1 pp. 1-18.
Rahman, S.A. and J.F. Alamu, 2003. Estimating the women interest in agriculture: The application of logit regression model. Nigerian
Journal of Scientific Research, 4: 45-49.
Rahman, S.A., 2008. Women’s involvement in agriculture in northern and southern Kaduna State. Journal of Gender Studies, 17: 17-
26.
Rogers, E.M. and Burdge, R.J. (1977) Community norms, opinion leadership and innovativeness among truck growers, Ohio Agricultural
Experiment Station Research Bulletin. 37: 1 – 5.
Senjobi, B.A., O. Odumaiya and D. Sosanya, (2000). Combating the land degradation hazards. A key to sustainable farming: Paper
presented at Eco-farming workshop, NECOFA–NIGERIA Dec. 20-21 pp. 31-32.
Spencer, D.S.C. (1991). International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (IITA) technologies and on farm adoption: Are we wasting our time?
IITA Research, 3: 24-25.
Udoh, E. J. (2005). Technical Inefficiency in Vegetable Farms of Humid Region. An analysis of Dry Season Farming by Urban Women in
South-South Zone, Nigeria J. Agric. & Social Sci., 1: 80-85.
Udoh, E. J. and S. B. Akpan, (2007). Measuring Technical Efficiency of Waterleaf (Talinum triangulure) production in Akwa Ibom State,
Nigeria. American Eurasian Journal of Agriculture and Environment Science 2 (5); 518 – 522.
Udoh, E. J., (und1993). Economic of Waterleaf Production in Calabar Municipality Cross River State. University of Calabar, Unpublished
B. Sc project.
Van Reuler, H. and W.H. Prins, (1993). The role of plant nutrients for sustainable food crop production in sub-saharan Africa. VKP:
Leidschendam, The Netherlands.
World Bank (2008). “Agriculture for Development”. World Development Report 2008 Washington: World Bank.
46
Job Insecurity in Selected Banks in Ibadan Southwest Nigeria
Adebimpe A. Adenugba (Ph.D)
Department of Sociology
Faculty of the Social Sciences
University of Ibadan, Nigeria
Odunayo Oteyowo (B.Sc, M.Sc)
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.47
Abstract: Job insecurity has become an important phenomenon that affects the job performance. This problem is prominent is
worsened in the banking sector of Nigeria. This paper examined Job Insecuity amongst bank workers in ten (10) selected new
and old generation banks in Nigeria. The study was anchored on Adam Smith’s Equity theory, utilized both qualitative and
quantitative techniques to gather data from two hundred and sixty (260) respondents randomly selected from the ten banks.
Findings from the study revealed that Findings from the study showed that 58.8% of the respondents agreed that unfavorable
government policy makes their future uncertain and 55.2% agreed that absence of trade unions make the future of their job
unprotected. Also, 39.8% of the respondents have intention to leave their present employer and 54.4% agreed that there is high
labour turnover in their respective organizations. From the bivariate analysis, there was significant relationship between old
generation banks and new generation banks on perception of level of job insecurity (X2c=15.475; p<0.05; there was significant
association between the age of respondents and perception on level of job insecurity (X2c=8.613; p<0.05); and there was no
significant association between respondents’ category of staff and perception on level of job insecurity (X2c=0.009; p>0.05).The
paper concluded that there is a high level of job insecurity among bank workers, especially those on contract appointment and
recommended : the need to harmonize the wage structure among both contract and permanent staff and to encourage trade
unionism in banks to protect the rights of workers
Key words: Job Insecurity, Contract staff, Permanent staff, New Generation Banks, Old Generation Banks
1. Introduction
Job insecurity has become an important organizational phenomenon impacting on both the individual and
organization hence the need to response at all levels. A study by Sverke and Goslinga (2003) revealed that
job insecurity has immediate consequences, which may affect the attitudes of individuals and have possible
long-term consequences that may affect an individual’s health and behaviour. According to different studies,
job insecurity is also related to work and organizational attitudes (Davy, Kinicki, & Scheck, 1997; Orpen
1993). Knowing the individual and organizational consequences of job insecurity and all its dimensions
emphasizes the need to investigate possible processes and factors that may moderate and mediate its effect.
From what has been theorized and inferred, it is understandable that job insecurity is highly threatening to
employees given the prospect of losing the positive material, social, and psychological benefits associated
with employment (De Witte, 1999). The notion that job insecurity may produce negative individual-level
effects is well established.
The current turbulent Nigerian business environment requires workers and organizations to re-examine
their practices. Banking is an inherently stressful profession with long working hours, stiff competition, ethical
dilemmas, regulatory bottlenecks and difficult customers. However, the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN)
47
introduced a consolidation programme as part of its over-sight functions of the banking industry as a result of
failed banks saga of the late 90s. Consolidation of the banking industry generally involves a combination of
existing banks, growth among the major players in the banking industry; and may lead to the exit of small and
weak banks from the industry (Ogunleye, 2005). Soludo (2004) submitted that the consolidation programme
became necessary because the Nigerian banking industry was plagued with persistent liquidity problems,
poor asset management, weak corporate governance, weak capital base, over-dependency on public sector
deposits, late or non-publication of annual accounts, and neglect of small and medium scale enterprises. The
CBN adopted a risk-focused, rule-based regulatory framework predicated on merger and acquisition to
implement the bank consolidation programme. Among other things, the minimum capitalization of Nigerian
banks was increased from 2 billion to 25 billion naira. This reduced the number of banks in Nigeria from 89
(as at June, 2004) to 25 (in December, 2005).
Though, the bank consolidation programme in Nigeria has helped stabilize and reposition the banking
industry, it is not without some challenges for the banks, the regulatory agencies, and their employees
(Ogunleye, 2005; Ojedokun, 2008). For banks, consolidation has increased inter-bank competition, demands
for high returns on investment, a need to retain highly skilled employees, and a bid to avoid the sanctions of
the monitoring and regulatory agencies. Consequently, there is a shift from transaction based model to sales/
service model (Ojedokun, 2008). For bank employees in Nigeria, the effect is not less. The sales model
adopted by banks puts a lot of pressure on the employees to perform, as higher targets are set to justify their
pay. For example, more than before, Nigerian banks hinge confirmation of appointment, promotion,
recognition, and remuneration of an employee on how well he/ she met job targets. High job targets may
increase demand/ time pressure in employees and may have implications for the health and job satisfaction
of such employees. Also, outsourcing of major functions has also been a major setback to employees’ career
satisfaction with ridiculous wage/salary structure.
Research into job insecurity has provided consistent evidence across firms, industries, and countries that
job insecurity is associated with negative employee attitudes, behaviours, and health (Sverke, et al 2002).
Despite the growth of evidence on job insecurity as reported in literature, not much research has been done
to link individual effects to organizational level effect. To fill this gap, this study therefore examined job
insecurity among workers in old and New Generation banks in Ibadan, Southwest Nigeria.
The main issues the paper focused on are investigations on the perceived causes of job insecurity, the
effects of job insecurity on job performance, and the consequences of job insecurity on organizational
performance.
2. Brief Literature Review
Job insecurity has been conceptualized widely in the international literature (Greenhalgh & Rosenblatt 1984;
Hartley, et al 1991; Hellgren, et al 1999; Roskies & Louis-Guerin 1990). As early as 1965, researchers and
writers identified job insecurity as a phenomenon to be considered in the changing world of work (Kronhauser
1965). Throughout the literature, job insecurity was conceptualized from two distinct perspectives; namely
global and multidimensional. The global perspective underwrites the assumption that job insecurity can be
conceptualized as the overall concern about the future of one’s job (Hartley, et al. 1991). The literature shows
the use of this conceptualization in the context of change or crises, such as political change, mergers or
reorganization. In these cases, job insecurity is normally considered to be the phase prior to unemployment
(Dooley 2003). Multidimensional conceptualizations conversely hold the viewpoint that job insecurity is a
more complex phenomenon than only the fear of losing a job and includes dimensions such as the fear of
losing job features, including job stability, positive performance appraisals and promotions (Greenhalgh &
Rosenblatt 1984; Jacobson 1991).
Mauno, et al 1999 conceptualized job insecurity as a stressor irrespective of its conceptualization as global
or multidimensional. This view includes the application of stress theories to research on job insecurity. Some
research done from the stress framework holds that stressors such as demands placed on the employee and
48
the employee’s experienced levels of strain may produce feelings of job insecurity (Ashford et al. 1989; De
Witte 2000; Mauno, et al, 1999; Sverke et al. 2002). Probst’s (2002) integrated model of job insecurity
confirms the perspective that job insecurity is a job stressor.
3. Theoretical Position
The Adams' Equity Theory model which this study utilized extends beyond the individual self, and
incorporates influence and comparison of other people's situations. The theory posits that when people feel
fairly or advantageously treated they are more likely to be motivated and when they feel unfairly treated they
are highly prone to feelings of disaffection and de-motivation. The way that people measure this sense of
fairness is at the heart of Equity Theory.
Adam’s equity theory’s relates with this study on the notion that job inequality is viewed and has been a
resurgent theme in job insecurity research employing justice frameworks, moderators of job insecurity
reactions among different categories of employment (contract and permanent). It is theorized to shed light on
how management should treat work in equitable manner to all categories of employees for desirable outcome
and output for greater efficiency and effectiveness to achieve organizational goals and objectives. This has a
long way to motivate and increase the morale of the employees, which has a reciprocal effect on the
organization.
4. Methodology
Survey method was adopted in this study. In other words, the study relied on combination of both qualitative
and quantitative methods.
The target population for the study were bank workers in 10 selected banks, in Ibadan. The banks were
selected through deep balloting from the surviving 25 banks from post consolidation exercise and it covered
both First/Old and New Generation Banks. They were:
NEW GENERATION BANKS FIRST GENERATION BANKS

First City Monument Bank Plc First Bank of Nigeria Plc
Skye Bank Plc Wema Bank Plc
Guaranty Trust Bank Plc United Bank for Africa Plc
Spring Bank Plc Afribank Plc
Intercontinental Bank Plc Union Bank Plc
The respondents were selected using simple random sampling technique to give each member a chance to
be involved in the study without any element of bias.
Fifty percent (50%) of the population in the selected banks was randomly selected to represent the entire
industry. The total sample size drawn from the selected 10 banks was 250 (25 respondents from each bank)
for the quantitative instrument (questionnaire), while for qualitative instrument, 10 IDIs were conducted, in
which one respondent was selected from each of the banks through simple random technique to complement
data generated through the quantitative instrument.
The research instruments used for the collection of data for this study were Questionnaire and In-depth
Interview (IDI). The questionnaire was divided into 5 sections. Section A dealt with socio demographic
characteristics of the respondents, section B dealt with the causes of job insecurity, section C was on job
performance, section D was on organizational performance and section E was on solutions to job insecurity.
The major advantage of using the questionnaire is that it provides opportunity to categorize the responses
and its ability to elicit information where many respondents are involved. Two hundred and fifty copies of
questionnaire were administered while 10 IDIs were conducted. The IDI was used because it gave the
opportunity to probe deeper especially on issues the questionnaire could not extensively deal with and to
complement data generated through the questionnaire.
49
4.1 Analysis of Findings
4.1.1 Socio-demographic characteristics of the Respondents
Table 1: Socio- Demographic Characteristics of the Respondents
Frequency Percentage
Sex NGB OGB NGB OGB Total Percentage
Male 45 42 18.0 16.8 87 34.8
Female 80 83 32.0 33.2 163 65.2
Total 125 125 250 100.0
Marital NGB OGB NGB OGB Total Percentage
status
Married 56 61 22.4 24.4 117 46.8
Single 69 64 27.6 26.6 133 53.2
Total 125 125 250 100.0
Religion NGB OGB NGB OGB Total Percentage
Christianity 84 90 33.6 36.0 174 69.6
Islam 41 35 16.4 14.0 76 30.4
Total 125 125 250 100.0
Educational NGB OGB NGB OGB Total Percentage
qualification
O’ Level - 9 .0 3.6 9 3.6
OND/NCE 21 40 8.4 16.0 61 24.4
B.SC/HND 80 48 32.0 19.2 128 51.2
Postgraduate 24 28 9.6 11.2 52 20.8
Total 125 125 250 100.0
Source: Field Survey (2011)
*NGB – New Generation Bank; *OGB – Old Generation Bank
The above table 1 presented the first part of socio-demographic characteristics of the respondents. From the
table 34.8% were males while 65.2% were females. This was because females were used for marketing and
the ability to attract customers, while males were more commonly used for banking operations. Data about
marital status reveals that there were more married respondents among the banks as indicated on the table
above, where married respondents were 53.2% as against single respondents which were 46.8%. An
inference that can be drawn here is that most respondents had family responsibilities. A closer observation
shows that most married respondents were located in OGB, while most single respondents were located in
NGB.
Regarding the religion of the respondents, the data shows that 69.6% of the respondents were
Christians, while 30.4% were Muslims. The implication here is that Christians dominated the sample and
were located in OGB. The importance of religion in the lives of individuals cannot be over emphasized
because it shapes one’s world view (Weber, 1904). As regard educational qualification of the respondents
revealed that 3.6% of the respondents, which constituted the lowest percentage of the distribution had O’
Level, 24.4% of the respondents had OND/NCE certificate, 51.2% which constituted the highest percentage
50
of the respondents were working with the BS.c/HND certificates, which indicates that respondents were well
read and 20.83% also indicated they had postgraduate degree. This shows that there were more skilled
personnel in the banking institutions and this may likely be as a result of competition for higher post and
prospect of switching career into another profession or inter-bank switching. Inference that can be drawn
from is that most of B.Sc/HND holders were located in NGB and OND/NCE were located OGB, while O’Level
School holders were located in OGB.
Table 2: Socio- Demographic Characteristics of the Respondents
Age range NGB OGB NGB OGB Total Percentage
21-30 69 72 27.6 28.8 141 56.4
31-40 48 38 19.5 15.2 86 34.4
41-50 8 13 3.2 5.2 21 8.4
50 above 0 2 .0 .8 2 0.8
Total 125 125 250 100.0
Employee NGB OGB NGB OGB Total Percentage
status
Senior staff 29 46 11.6 19.2 75 30.0
Junior staff 96 79 38.4 30.2 175 70.0
Total 125 125 250 100.0
Category of NGB OGB NGB OGB Total Percentage
staff
Permanent staff 36 48 14.4 19.2 84 33.6
Contract staff 89 77 35.6 30.2 166 66.4
Total 125 125 250 100.0
Years in service NGB OGB NGB OGB Total Percentage
1-5 99 87 39.6 34.8 186 74.4
6-10 16 24 6.4 9.6 40 16.0
11-15 7 12 2.8 4.8 19 7.6
16-20 3 0 1.2 .0 3 1.2
21 above 0 2 .0 0.8 2 0.8
Total 125 125 250 100.0
Monthly income NGB OGB NGB OGB Total Percentage
Below 50,000 42 31 16.8 12.4 73 29.2
50,001-100,000 44 47 17.6 18.8 91 36.4
100,001-150,000 25 25 10.0 10.0 50 20.0
150,001-200,000 7 10 2.8 4.0 17 6.8
200,001 above 7 12 2.8 4.8 19 7.6
125 125
The age distribution of the respondents from the above table 2 shows that 56.4% of the respondents fell
between the age range of 21-30. Also, 34.4% of the respondents fell between the age range of 31-40, 8.4%
of the respondents were between the age range of 41-50, and 0.8% were above 50. However, it is obvious
51
that the highest proportion of the respondents were clustered around age 21-30 (34.4.6%), this shows that
majority of the respondents were still at their productive age and at the same time the banks also made it a
point of duty to employ staff who have no family commitment. However, a closer observation shows that
most respondents at their productive age range were located in NGB, while most respondents at older age
were located in OGB.
Classifying the respondents by the employee status, the result from the table shows that the junior staff in
terms of transaction officers, cashiers and the bulk tellers (front desk officers) who were 70% dominated the
work force among the banks, while the cash officer, funds transfer officer, customer service officer,
relationship officer which constituted the senior staff were 30%. The inference from employee status further
reveals that most of the respondents that were senior staff were located in OGB, while most that were junior
staff were located in NGB.
Furthermore the frequency distribution data on category of staff of the respondents as presented in the
table revealed that 33.6% of the respondents were permanent staff, while temporary/contract staff constituted
the higher percentage of the staff at 66.4%. This shows that there were more outsourced staff among the
banks and this may be attributed to the current trend in the banking sector to use temporary staff to cut off
expenditures i.e. wages/salary costs to maximize their profits. However, most respondents in OGB were
permanent staff, and those that were contract staff were located in NGB.
The frequency table on years in service shows that the majority of the respondents 74.4% were clustered
around 1 – 5 years in service. Also, 16.0% fell into the category of 6-10 years, the length of service between
11-15 years was 7.6%, 1.2% in the category of 16 – 20 years, while 0.8% of the respondents are in the
category of 21 years and above. The highest category of 1 – 5 years in service can be linked to high labour
turnover, poor salary structure and tedious bank activities especially for marketers, which made bank workers
to leave the job prematurely and new staffs, were often recruited by the banks.
Lastly on table 2 above is the frequency distribution of the respondents by their salary grade. The data
reveals that, majority of the respondents 36.4% earned between 50,001 – 100,000 while the minority 7.6%
earned between 200,001 and above. The interpretation from this show that the salary structure in the banking
sector is poor and this may likely be as a result of factors like recent shift in business line transaction based
model to sales/service model as ascertained by Ojedokun (2008) and also, banks in their attempt to remain
in business need to cut operational cost especial salary and allowances of the employees. Further inference
that can be drawn from monthly income shows that most of those that earn high wages were from OGB,
while most of the respondents that earn low wages were from NGB as indicated in the above table.
4.1.2 Causes of job insecurity in the banking sector
This section deals with the respondents’ knowledge and views on the causes of job insecurity among the
employees of the selected banks.
Table 3: Frequency Distribution of Respondents’ views on Renewal and Change in Technology
Statement Frequency Percentage

Renewal and change/ in technology NGB OGB NGB OGB Total Percentage
use can make my present post
redundant
Strongly Disagree 53 30 21.2 12.0 83 33.2
Disagree 29 30 11.6 12.0 59 23.6
Undecided 11 10 4.4 4.0 21 8.4
Agree 26 37 10.4 14.8 63 25.2
Strongly Agree 6 18 2.4 7.2 24 9.6
Total 125 125 250 100.0
52
The above table 3 presents data on renewal and change in technology. The data reveals that highest
percentage of the respondents (33.2%) “strongly disagreed” that renewal and change in technology use
could make their post be redundant, 23.6% “disagreed”, 8.4% were “undecided” 25.2% “agreed”, while 9.6%
of the respondents “strongly agreed”. The data suggested that change in technology to some employees
could make their present post to be redundant while some employees believed that change in technology
cannot make their present post redundant. The interpretation from the above can be likened to research on
white collar jobs by Hartley (1991), who asserted that that there is existence of job insecurity on white collar
employees and which was systematically related to high job insecurity. However, closer observation shows
that most respondents that disagreed were located in NGB, while most that agreed respondents were located
in OGB.
Table 4: Frequency Distribution of Respondents’ views on Change in Organization Design

Change in organization NGB OGB NGB OGB Total Percentage
design/structure can
make me lose my job
Disagree 36 35 14.4 14.0 71 28.4
Undecided 29 19 11.6 7.6 48 19.2
Agree 21 42 8.4 16.8 63 25.2
Strongly Agree 18 6 7.2 2.4 24 9.6
Total 125 125 250 100.0
The above table 4 presents data on change in organizational design. From the table, 17.6% of the
respondents “strongly disagreed” that change in organizational design can make them lose their job. Also,
28.4% which constituted the highest percentage “disagreed” with the statement, 25.2% of the respondents
“agreed” with the statement, while 9.6% “strongly agreed” that change in organizational design could make
them lose their job. From the data, it can be seen that change in organizational design which include
activities merger and acquisition as witnessed in Nigeria between July 2004 to December 2005 brought about
restructuring in banking system where different banks embarked on activities like downsizing, change in
contract of employment, job redesign etc. This could actually cause job insecurity especially among contract
employees. However, most respondents that agreed (16.8%) were located in OGB, while those that
disagreed were located in NGB
Table 5: Frequency Distribution of Respondents’ views on Unfavourable Government Policy

Unfavourable government NGB OGB NGB OGB Total Percentag
policy is banking sector e
makes the future of my job
to be uncertain
Disagree 7 12 2.8 4.8 19 7.6
Undecided 32 31 12.8 12.4 63 25.2
Agree 51 62 20.4 24.8 113 45.2
Strongly Agree 17 17 6.8 6.8 34 13.6
Total 125 125 250 100.0
53
The data on the table above shows that 45.2% of the respondents agreed which constituted the highest
percentage and 7.6% of the respondents, with the least percentage signified that they disagreed that
unfavourable government policy in the banking sector could make the future of their job uncertain.
Government policy on merger and acquisition has resulted into some gain in the post consolidated era e.g.
the notched up of capital base to N768 billion and better corporate professionalism, but despite this
achievement it has posed a serious threat on human resource and employees of banks which was
characterized by job cut, retrenchment, salary and wages cut among others. A closer observation shows that
most respondents that strongly disagreed were located in NGB, while most respondents that agreed were
located in OGB.
The above data corresponded to the view of a respondent during an IDI session, he said:
Government in its different policies did not formulate viable policies for the private sector especially
banking sector. The issue of employment and contract of employment were not well addressed, and
their various policies did not indicate how we bank workers should be enumerated unlike in the public
sector, which has standardized scales.
(IDI/Male/FCMB/April, 2011)
Table 6: Frequency Distribution of Respondents’ views on Absence of Trade Unions

My job is unprotected as NGB OGB NGB OGB Total Percentage
a result of absence of
trade union
Disagree 28 18 11.2 7.2 46 18.4
Undecided 20 32 8.0 12.8 52 20.8
Agree 34 51 13.6 20.4 85 34.0
Strongly Agree 35 18 14.0 7.2 53 21.2
Total 125 125 250 100.0
The above table 6 presents data on absence of trade unions. The respondents were asked if the absence of
trade unions makes them feel unprotected on their job. The data depicted that minority of the respondents
5.6% “strongly disagreed”, 18% of the total respondents “disagreed”, 20.8% were “undecided”, and 34.0%
“agreed” that the absence of trade unions in their banks make them feel unprotected on their job. However,
21.2% “strongly agreed”. From the table, it could be seen that majority of the respondents agreed to the
statement that the absence of trade unions makes them feel unprotected with their job. It is likely that the
trade unions could be a key element in organizations that could help to protect the interest of the workers
against management prerogatives. It could be inferred from the results that banks allow trade unions to
represent the interests of the workers, this was reflected in the responses of the respondents as most
respondents who disagreed (11.2%) came from NGB.
In relation to this, a respondent said:
The trade union activities in the banking system are not potent unlike its public sector. But of recent like
Union Bank closure of its offices through trade union intervention has made it a starting point of duty for
protection of bank workers against management arbitrary decisions. (IDI/Female/Skye/April, 2011)
4.1.3 Effect of job insecurity on employee job performance
This section examined the effects and consequences of job insecurity on the employees’ performance. The
54
purpose is to determine how job insecurity affects employees’ performance and also to find out the
consequence on the organization.
Table 7: Frequency Distribution of Respondents’ views on Turnover Intention

I have intention to leave my NGB OGB NGB OGB Total Percentage
present employer
Disagree 14 18 5.6 7.2 32 12.8
Undecided 49 49 19.6 19.6 98 39.2
Agree 25 29 10.0 11.6 54 21.6
Strongly Agree 20 23 8.0 9.2 43 17.2
Total 125 125 250 100.0
The table above shows frequency distribution of the respondents on turnover intention. The result reveals
that overwhelming majority (38.8%) “agreed” that they had intention to leave their present employer, while
39.2% of the respondents were “undecided” if they would be leaving their present employer in the nearest
time. The other responses from the table depict that 9.2% and 12.8% of the respondents “strongly disagreed”
and “disagreed” respectively. The implication of this is that there would be higher turnover intention rate
among temporary staff, with translated effect of high absenteeism and lower motivation among contract staff
than among permanent staff of the respective banks. However, a closer observation showed that most
respondents with turnover intention came from OGB, while most respondents that disagreed with turnover
intention were located in NGB.
In relation to this, a respondent said:
Contract workers are no longer motivated and they leave the job anytime because of the fear of losing their
job at point in time, especially when the target is not met; therefore they tend to leave earlier more than
expected when they found a greener pasture elsewhere. (IDI/Male/UBA/April, 2011)
Table 8: Frequency Distribution of Respondents’ views on Commitment to other Jobs

I am committed to other jobs NGB OGB NGB OGB Total Percentage
outside my primary job
Disagree 31 27 12.4 10.8 58 23.2
Undecided 38 54 15.2 21.6 92 36.8
Agree 27 22 10.8 8.8 49 19.6
Strongly Agree 2 10 0.8 4.0 12 4.8
Total 125 125 250 100.0
The above table 8 presents data on commitment to other jobs. From the table, 15.6% and 23.2% of the
respondents “strongly disagreed” and “disagreed” respectively that they are committed to other jobs outside
their primary jobs. This is as a result of the fact some bank employers have won their employees’ loyalty and
thus they are willing to give their best to their work despite being underpaid or being outsourced staff.
Moreover, 36.8% were “undecided” whether they would be committed to other jobs or not while 19.6% and
4.8% of the respondents admitted that they will be committed to other jobs outside their primary job.
The above was further buttressed in one of the IDIs conducted:
55
I am very much committed to my job because this is what I do to sustain my family. The only thing is that the
salary package is low and despite this our job is time consuming from morning to late evening, so I don’t think
I can be chanced to engage in another form of job. (IDI/Female/Skye Bank/April, 2011)
4.1.4 The consequences of job insecurity on the organisation
This section examines the consequences of job insecurity on the organization. This study aims at identifying
the consequences of job insecurity on the organization by focusing on the following:
Table 9: Frequency Distribution of Respondents’ views on High Labour Turnover

There is high labour turnover NGB OGB NGB OGB Total Percentage
in this organization
Disagree 22 24 8.8 9.6 46 18.4
Undecided 26 33 10.4 13.2 59 23.6
Agree 55 52 22.0 20.8 107 42.8
Strongly Agree 16 13 6.4 5.2 29 11.6
Total 125 125 250 100.0
The above table 9 on high labour turnover shows that 11.6% of the respondents “strongly agreed” that there
is high labour turnover in their respective banks. 42.8% which constituted the majority “agreed”, 23.6%
“undecided”, while 18.4% and 3.6% “disagreed” and “strongly disagreed” respectively. The survey revealed
that 54.4% of the respondents believed that there was high labour turnover in their respective banks. From
the result on high labour turnover, it is believed that the banking sector over the years has witnessed an
increasingly labour turnover and this can be attributed to several factors like stiff competition, fear of
bankruptcy, perceived downsizing and ultimately as a result of poor wage/compensation system. Other
reasons include the assertion of Greenhalgh & Rosenblatt, 1984; Hartley et al., 1991 that qualified
employees/workers will more easily find a new job and thus are more likely to quit if they experience job
insecurity. However, a closer observation shows that most respondents 22.0% that agreed were in NGB
while the least that strongly disagreed were in OGB.
This is corroborated by a respondent during an IDI session, he said:
Over the years i have worked with different people. Some come in and leave within 2 months because they
cannot cope and precisely the money we earn as marketers is just too small to survive on to commensurate
our effort. (IDI/Male/Union Bank/April, 2011)
Table 10: Frequency Distribution of Respondents’ views on Deteriorated attitude to work

Attitude to work is deteriorated in NGB OGB NGB OGB Total Percentage
this organization
Disagree 40 15 16.0 6.0 55 22.0
Undecided 37 45 14.8 18.0 82 32.8
Agree 3 32 12.0 12.8 62 24.8
Strongly Agree 2 10 0.8 4.0 12 4.8
Total 125 125 250 100.0
56
The table above depicts that 4.8% of the respondents “strongly agreed”, that there is deteriorating attitude to
work. Also, 24.8% “agreed” as well, while 32.8% that constituted the majority of the respondents were
“undecided”. However, 22.0% and 15.6% “disagreed” and “strongly disagreed” respectively. From the table, it
shows that 29.6% of the respondents were in support of the question that there is deteriorating attitude of
workers to work in their respective banks. A closer observation shows that most respondents in NGB
disagreed, while most that strongly agreed were located in OGB.
However, the radical change from a traditionally secure working environment to a rapidly changing and
insecure one could be expected to have an impact not only on the well-being of the individuals, but also on
their work attitudes and behavior, and, on the long run, for the vitality of the organization as asserted in the
work of Greenhalgh and Rosenblatt (1984), that workers react to job insecurity, and their reactions have
consequences for organizational effectiveness.
Table 11: Frequency Distribution of Respondents’ views on Likelihood to merge with another bank

This organization will likely NGB OGB NGB OGB Total Percentage
merge with another in the
nearest time
Disagree 17 12 6.8 4.8 29 11.6
Undecided 43 52 17.2 20.8 95 38.0
Agree 9 23 3.6 9.2 32 12.8
Strongly Agree 23 4 9.2 1.6 27 10.8
Total 125 125 250 100.0
The data above reveals that 10.8% of the respondents “strongly agreed”, that their bank may likely merge
with another bank in the nearest future. Also, 12.8% “agreed” as well, while 38% that constituted the majority
of the respondents were “undecided”. However, 11.6% and 26.8% disagreed and “strongly disagreed"
respectively. There are distressed banks which could not meet up with the CBN regulation on share capital
base and thus will likely merge with another bank in the nearest time as claimed by some of the respondents.
4.1.5 Chi-squre test of association
Table 15: Chi-square Test of Association between Respondents’ Bank category and Perception of level of
Job Insecurity
Job insecurity
Variable
Category of staff Low High Total
Old generation bank 52 73 125
20.8% 29.2% 50.0%
New generation bank 83 42 125
33.2% 16.8% 50.0%
Total 135 115 250
54.0% 45.0% 100.0%
X2c = 15.475
X2t = 3.841
df = 1
Ls = 0.05
57
From the analysis of chi-square above on respondents’ bank category and level of job insecurity, it shows
that there is significant association between the old generation bank and new generation bank on job
insecurity because X2c is greater than X2t.
Table 16:Chi-square Test of Association between Respondents’ Age and Perception of level of Job
Insecurity
Variable Job insecurity

Age Low High Total
21 – 30 72 69 141
28.8% 27.6% 56.7%
31 – 40 44 42 86
17.6% 16.8% 34.4%
41 – 50 17 4 21
6.8% 1.6% 8.4%
51+ 2 0 2
0.8 0.0% 0.8%
Total 135 115 250
54.0% 46.0% 100.0%
X2c = 8.613
X2t = 7.815
df = 3
Ls = 0.05
From the analysis of chi-square above on respondents’ age and level of job insecurity, it shows that there is
significant association between the age of respondents and level of job insecurity because the X2c is greater
than X2t.
Table 17: Chi-square Test of Relationship between Respondents’ Category of staff and Perception of level of
Job Insecurity
Variable Job insecurity

Category of staff Low High Total
Permanent staff 45 39 84
18.0% 15.6% 33.6%
Contract staff 90 76 166
36.0% 30.4% 66.4%
Total 135 115 250
54.0% 46.0% 100.0%
X2c = 0.009
X2t = 3.841
df = 1
Ls = 0.05
From the analysis of chi-square above on respondents’ category of staff and level of job insecurity, it shows
that there is no significant association between permanent staff and contract staff on level of job insecurity
because the X2c is less than X2t. The inference that can be drawn from this is that irrespective of the category
of staff i.e. permanent or contract staff they all perceived job insecurity, but it could be observed that contract
staff reported more job insecurity than the permanent staff.
58
5. Conclusion
This research focused on job insecurity as a consequence that may follow upon the changing nature of work.
However, as this research has revealed, job insecurity may not be only an inherent and inevitable
consequence of downsizing, technological change, and organizational strivings for flexibility. Rather, job
insecurity can be described as a function of the objective situations as identified in this study (flexibility in
operations, labor market characteristics, organizational change, etc).
The accelerating rate of organizational change indicates that job insecurity is a phenomenon that will
continue to characterize modern working life in years to come. As the flexibility of the labour market is likely
to increase even more rapidly in the future, it is also of vital importance that research on job insecurity be
made sensitive to changes in working life and address more modern forms of employment relationships.
While flexibility certainly meets the demands of many employers, it could well be that work in a temporary
and outsourced employment are also in line with the expectations and wishes of bank workers.
By understanding and working with the framework in which job insecurity arises, policy makers
(government) and practitioners should be able to react to new events and interpretations concerning job
insecurity in banking sector. It has become an important organizational phenomenon and therefore a
response to its impact, not only on the individual, but also at the organizational level, is needed. Knowing the
individual consequences which were more pronounced in this study and organizational consequences of job
insecurity and all its dimensions as identified, it is therefore imperative to understand how to moderate and
mediate its effect. However, ignoring or neglecting the current and evident future presence of job insecurity
may result in dramatic and negative results for individuals, organizations and growth of business in Nigeria.
References
Ashford, S. J., Lee, C., & Bobko, P. (1989). Content, causes, and consequences of job insecurity: A theory-based measure and
substantive test. Academy of Management Journal, 4, 803-829.
Davy, J. A., Kinicki, A. J., & Scheck, C. L. (1997). A test of job security’s direct and mediated effects on withdrawal cognitions. Journal of
Organizational Behaviour, 18, 323-349.
De Witte, H. (1999). Job insecurity and psychological well-being: Review of the literature and exploration of some unresolved issues.
European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology, 8, 155-177.
Dooley, D. (2003). ‘Unemployment, underemployment and mental health: conceptualizing employment status as a continuum’, American
Journal of Community Psychology, 32(1): 9–16.
Greenhalgh, L., and Rosenblatt, Z. (1984). Job insecurity: Toward conceptual clarity. Academy of Management Review, 3, 438-448.
Greenhalgh, L., and Rosenblatt, Z. (1984). Job insecurity: Toward conceptual clarity. Academy of Management Review, 3, 438-448.
Hartley, J., Jacobson, D., Klandermans, B., & van Vuuren, T. (1991). Job insecurity: Coping with jobs at risk. London: Sage.
Hellgren, J., Sverke, M., & Isaksson, K. (1999). A two-dimensional approach to job insecurity: Consequences for employee attitudes and
well-being. European Journal of Work and Organization Psychology, 8, 179-195.
Kronhauser, W. (1965). ‘The interdependence of professions and organizations’, In Vollmer, H. & Mills, D. (eds.), Professionalism.
Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Mauno, S., Nätti, J., & Happonen, M. (1999). Perceived job insecurity: A longitudinal study among Finish employees. European Journal
of Work and Organizational Psychology, 8, 243-260.
Ogunleye, G. A. (2005). Regulatory challenges in a consolidated Nigerian banking system - NDIC perspective. A paper presented at The
14th Delegates Conference/ Annual General Meeting of the Money Market Association of Nigeria, held in Lagos on February 24.
Ojedokun, A. O. (2008). Perceived job insecurity, job satisfaction, intention to quit among employees of selected banks in Nigeria.
African Journal for the Psychological Study of Social Issues, 11(2), 204-220.
Orpen, C. (1993). Job dependence as a moderator of effects of job threat on employees' job insecurity and performance. Psychological
Reports, 72, 449-450.
Probst, T. M., & Brubaker, T. L. (2001). The effects of job insecurity on employee safety outcomes: Cross-sectional and longitudinal
explorations. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 6, 139-159.
59
Roskies, E., & Louis-Guerin, C. (1990). Job insecurity in managers: Antecedents and consequences. Journal of Organizational
Behaviour, 11, 345-359.
Soludo, C. C. (2004). Consolidating the Nigerian banking industry to meet the development challenges of the 21st century. BIS, 43, 1-6.
Sverke, M., & Goslinga, S. (2003). The consequences of job insecurity for employers and unions: Exit, voice, and loyalty. Economic and
Industrial Democracy, 24, 241-270.
Sverke, M., Hellgren, J., & Näswall, K. ( 2002). No security: A meta-analysis and review of job insecurity and its consequences. Journal
of Occupational Health Psychology, 7, 242-264.
Sverke, M., Hellgren, J., & Näswall, K.( 2002). No security: A meta-analysis and review of job insecurity and its consequences. Journal
of Occupational Health Psychology, 7, 242-264.
60
Spatial Pattern of Road Traffic Accident Casualties in Nigeria
Dr. A.J. Aderamo
Department of Geography and Environmental Management

University of Ilorin,
P.M.B. 1515, Ilorin, Nigeria
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.61
Abstract:The paper examined the spatial variation of road traffic accident casualties in Nigeria with a view to suggesting
measures to reduce the scourge. The data used for the study included the total number of deaths and number of injuries from
road traffic accident in Nigeria for the period 2004 to 2007. These were collected from the Nigerian Police Force Headquarters
and the Federal Road Safety Commission. Data were also collected from relevant federal and state ministries. The results of the
analysed data were then shown in map form to depict the spatial variation of road traffic accident casualties across the 36 states
and the Federal Capital Territory. Multiple regression method was then used to model the spatial pattern of road accident
casualties in Nigeria for the study period. The result showed that spatial variation exists in the incident of road traffic accident in
Nigeria. The paper finally made recommendations to reduce the carnage on Nigerian roads.
Keywords: Injuries, Deaths, Safety, Law enforcement, Risks
1. Introduction
Road accident fatalities continue to attract the attention of policy makers and the populace all over the world.
The incessant carnage on the roads, especially in developing countries, constitutes a major challenge to
safety professionals. This is evident from available statistics on road accident crashes and injuries all over
the world.
However, as a result of safety measures adopted in developed countries, variation exists in the magnitude
of this scourge between developed and developing countries. While for example developed countries have
experienced a decreasing trend since the 1960s, the fatality rate in African countries ranges from 10-fold to
more than 100-fold of those in the United States (Chen, 2010; Jacobs & Aeron-Thomas, 2000; Peltzer and
Renner, 2004). Lagarde (2007) also reported that while South-East Asia has the highest proportion of global
road fatalities (one-third of the 1.4million occurring each year in the world), the road traffic injury mortality rate
is highest in Africa (28.3 per 100,000 population) compared with 11.0 in Europe. Indeed, if major challenges
are not made to reverse the trend, it is feared that road traffic crash fatality rate in Africa as a whole is
anticipated to increase by 80 per cent between 2000 and 2020 (Peden et al., 2004).
In terms of vulnerability, road traffic injuries and fatalities are mostly concentrated on males of their most
productive age. According to OECD (2006) and Williams (2003); young drivers have been found to have
higher rates of accidents than older drivers (see also Lafont et al., 2008). Statistics has also shown that
mortality in road traffic accidents is very high among young adults in their prime and who also constitute the
workforce (Balogun et al., 1992).
Besides, pedestrians account for between 45 per cent and 75 per cent of all road traffic deaths in
developing countries (Odero et al. 1997). In Africa, pedestrians and passengers of public transportation are
the most affected (Lagarde, 2007). These are usually the breadwinners in many cultures. Over 75 per cent of
road traffic casualties in Africa are in the economic productive age bracket between 16 and 25 years.
The causes of traffic crashes and fatalities are also varied. Three major categories have traditionally been
identified. These are human, vehicle and highway infrastructure (Haddon, 1980). Amongst the three factors,
the human factors including road user behaviour and incapacitation have been found to account for more
61
than 85 per cent (see Odero et al., 2003). Among them, the two-best-known contributing factors are
speeding, drinking and driving (Chen, 2010; Afukaar, 2003). Human incapacitation, such as visual acuteness
and driver fatigue has also been identified among the human factors (Onabolu, Otulana and Awodein, 2008).
The vehicle factor relates to the road-worthiness of vehicles. Vehicle failure resulting from vehicle defects,
lack of maintenance and using low quality spare parts also contribute to road crashes and fatalities (Odero,
2003). Highway infrastructure defects such as potholes, sharp bends and generally poor road conditions also
have significant effect and contribute to road crashes.
A significant precaution to save lives in the event of road crashes is provision of emergency services.
Limitations that explain the poor outcome for people involved in road traffic crashes in Africa have been
identified as lack of trained surgeons, intensive care staff, and field para medics, underserved medical
facilities; inappropriate dedicated transportation and disorganized or non-existent emergency and trauma
services (Lagarde, 2007).
However, most studies in road traffic crashes and fatalities have concentrated on the trends of such
events and not emphasizing the spatial patterns. Yet, road traffic crashes and fatalities should be examined
also from spatial dimension. In the same way that variations exist in climate, vegetation and economic
resources, so also do variations exist in the incidence of road traffic fatalities at global, regional and local
levels (World bank, 1999).
The objective of this study is to assess the spatial variation in the incidence of Road Traffic Accident
Casualties across the 36 states in Nigeria including the Federal Capital Abuja with a view to making
recommendations to curb the carnage on Nigeria roads.
2. Review of Related Literature
A handful of theories have been put forward to explain Road Traffic Accidents causations. Some of the best
known theories use System theory and Risk theory in an attempt to explain the causation of Road Traffic
Accidents.
2.1 System Theory
The systems perspective views human performance as a function of many interacting system-wide factors. In
the context of human error and accident causation, for example, it is now accepted that errors are a
consequence of ‘systems’ failure rather than merely aberrant psychological factors within individuals. Human
error is thus no longer always seen as the primary cause of accidents, rather, it is treated as a consequence
of latent failures residing within the wider system (Reason, 2000). In a road safety context, elements of the
system beyond road users, such as vehicle design and condition, road design and condition, road policies,
and so on, all shape drivers behaviour on the road.
Although there are other models of accident causation (e.g. Levenson, 2004; O’Hare, 2000), the systems-
based models is the most prominent and it is now widely accepted that the accidents which occur in complex
socio-technical systems are caused by a range of interacting human and systemic failures (Salmon and
Lenne, 2009). Systems-based accident analysis and investigation, described also in the ‘Swiss model’,
(Reason, 2000) has been applied with significant success in a range of safety critical domains such as in
road transport, aviation, process control, rail transport and in a range of other domains which they have been
applied successfully (Salmon et al., 2009; Smith et al., 2001; Wiegmann et al., 2003).
2.2 Risk Theory
Risk theory has also been used in the description of accident causation. Risk can be defined as the effect of
uncertainty on objectives whether positive or negative. Its management is followed by coordinated
62
economical application of resources to minimize, monitor, and control the probability and impact of
unfortunate events (Hubbard, 2009; Rundmo, 2004; Moen, 2005) or to maximize the realization of
opportunities. Risks can come from uncertainty in financial markets, project failure, legal liabilities, credit risk,
accidents, natural causes and disas ters as well as deliberate attacks from an adversary. Road traffic
accidents risk, according to Dejoy (1989) is a function of four elements. The first is the exposure or amount of
movement or travel within the system by different users or a given population density. The second is the
underlying probability of crash, given a particular exposure. The third is the probability of injury given a crash.
The fourth element is the outcome of injury. Risk can also be explained by human error (Reason, 2000;
Rasmussen, 1999); kinetic energy, tolerance of human body and post-crash care (Bustide et al, 1989).
Lupton (1999) also asserts that Risks can be seen from four perspectives. These are the rationalist,
realist, constructionist and middle positions. The rationalist sees risks as real world phenomena to be
measured and estimated by statistics, prioritized by normative decision theory and controlled by scientific
management. The realist sees risks as objective hazards or threats that exist and can be estimated
independently of social and cultural processes but that may be distorted or biased through social and cultural
frameworks of interpretation. The constructionist sees nothing as a risk in itself. Rather, what we understand
to be a risk, the constructionist sees as the product of historically, socially and politically contingent ways of
seeing. Proponents of the middle positions between realist and constructionist theory see risk as an objective
hazard or threats that is inevitably mediated through social and cultural processes and can never be known in
isolating from these processes (see Jaeger et al., 2001; Horden, 2004).
2.3 Geographical Approach to Traffic Accidents
The geographical approach to the study of traffic accidents relates the concept of place, time and
environment to accident occurrence. It is believed that land use, road element, width of the road, bending of
road, hilly area, topography and regional distribution in occurrence of road traffic accident are factors to be
considered. According to Cutter (1993), geographical scale is important for impacts and their reduction. Land
use pattern, types of road network, local business and activity pattern will influence the system risk in an area
(Komba, 2006). There is also rural-urban differences. In urban areas, there are more accidents, lower degree
of injury while in rural areas, there are lower accident levels but more serious fatalities.
3. Materials and Methods
The data needed for this study are the number of deaths and the number of injured persons resulting from
Road Traffic Accidents in the different states of Nigeria for the period 2004 – 2007. The 36 states in Nigeria
and Federal Capital, Abuja are shown on figure 1. The data were collected from records of the Nigerian
Police Force Headquarters and the Federal Road Safety Commission office in Abuja.
Data were also collected on the total number of registered vehicles in the different states of the country for
the period 2004 – 2007 through the States’ Statistical Agencies. The distribution of the population of the
country by states were collected from records of National Population Commission (NPC). These were
obtained through the National Population Census conducted for the country in 2006.
Length of Federal Government of Nigerian Roads in the states were obtained from records of Federal
Ministry of Works and Annual Abstract of Statistics 2008 compiled by the National Bureau of Statistics. The
collected data were then collated, analysed and presented in form of maps to show the spatial distribution of
Road Traffic Accidents casualties by states in the country. These are shown in figures 2., 3. and 4. In
addition, regression method was used to build statistical models for the explanation of the spatial pattern of
Road Traffic Accident casualties in the country. The analyses were carried out using the Statistical Package
for the Social Sciences (SPSS) and Excel.
63
4. Results and Discussions
4.1 Pattern of Total Road Traffic Accident Casualties
The distribution of total Road Traffic Accident Casualties by states in Nigeria is as shown in table 1.0. The
distribution of the accident casualties has been divided into 3 groups based on the percentage of total
casualties recorded by each state.
The groupings are as shown on table 2.0. Group A comprise of states with percentage score of Road
Traffic Accident Casualties ranging from 0.00 – 2.99 per cent. Group B comprises of states with percentage
score of between 3.00 – 5.99 per cent while group C comprises of states with percentage score of between
6.00 – 8.99 per cent. The states that fall within group A are Abia, Adamawa, Akwa Ibom, Anambra, Bayelsa,
Borno, Delta, Ebonyi, Edo, Ekiti, Enugu, Gombe, Imo, Jigawa, Kebbi, Kogi, Kwara, Federal Capital – Abuja.
These states can be ranked as comparatively recording low level of total Road Traffic Accident casualties in
the country. Group B comprises of Bauchi, Cross River, Kano, Katsina, Lagos, Ondo, Osun, Oyo and Plateau
States. These states could be ranked as recording a relatively medium level of Road Traffic Accident
casualties. Group C comprises of Benue, Kaduna and Ogun States. These states standout as recording high
level of Road Traffic Accident casualties in the country.
Figure 2. shows the distribution of Road Traffic Accident casualties by states.
64
Table 2: Summary Grouping of States on Severity of Road Traffic Accident Casualties
Group Rank States

A Low Abia, Adamawa, Akwa Ibom, Anambra, Bayelsa, Borno, Delta,
(0.00 – 2.99%) Ebonyi, Edo, Ekiti, Enugu, Gombe, Imo, Jigawa, Kebbi, Kogi,
Kwara, Nassarawa, Niger, Rivers, Sokoto, Taraba, Yobe, Zamfara,
Federal Capital Territory
B Medium Bauchi, Cross River, Kano, Katsina, Lagos, Ondo, Osun, Oyo,
(3.00 – 5.99%) Plateau
C High Benue, Kaduna, Ogun
(6.00 – 8.99%)
Source: Author’s Analysis of Table 1.0
4.2 Pattern of Motor Vehicle Deaths
The distribution of motor vehicle deaths by states in Nigeria is also shown on table 1.
The distribution has been divided into 4 groups based also on the severity of total deaths recorded by the
states. The groupings are as shown on table 3.0. Group A comprises of Abia, Adamawa, Anambra, Bayelsa,
Borno, Delta, Ebonyi, Edo, Ekiti, Enugu, Gombe, Imo, Jigawa, Kebbi, Kogi, Kwara, Nassarawa, Niger, Ondo,
Rivers, Sokoto, Taraba, Yobe, Zamfara States and Federal Capital Territory. These states can be ranked as
recording relatively low level of motor vehicle deaths in the country.
Group B comprises of Akwa Ibom, Bauchi, Benue, Cross River, Kano, Katsina, Lagos, Osun, Oyo and
Plateau States. The states can be ranked as recording relatively medium level of motor vehicle deaths in the
country.
Group C comprises of Benue and Ogun State and these states can be ranked as recording relatively high
level of motor vehicle deaths in the country. The fourth group is Group D comprising only of Kaduna State
which can singularly be ranked as the only state with relatively very high level of motor vehicle deaths in the
country. Figure 3.0 shows the spatial distribution of motor vehicle deaths by states in the country.
65

66
Table 3: Summary Grouping of States on Severity of Motor Vehicle Deaths
Group Rank States

A Low Abia, Adamawa, Anambra, Bayelsa, Borno, Delta, Ebonyi, Edo,
(0.00 – 2.99%) Ekiti, Enugu, Gombe, Imo, Jigawa, Kebbi, Kogi, Kwara,
Nassarawa, Niger, Ondo, Rivers, Sokoto, Taraba, Yobe,
Zamfara, Federal Capital Territory.
B Medium Akwa Ibom, Bauchi, Cross River, Kano, Katsina, Lagos, Osun,
(3.00 – 5.99%) Oyo, Plataeu.
C High Benue, Ogun
(6.00 – 8.99%)
D Very High Kaduna
(9.00 – 11.99%)
4.3 Pattern of Motor Vehicle Injuries
The pattern of distribution of motor vehicle injuries by states in the country is also as shown on table 1.0. The
distribution can be grouped into 3 categories based on the severity of motor vehicle injuries recorded by the
states.
Group A comprises of Abia, Adamawa, Akwa Ibom, Anambra, Bayelsa, Borno, Delta, Ebonyi, Edo, Ekiti,
Enugu, Gombe, Imo, Jigawa, Kebbi, Kogi, Kwara, Nassarawa, Niger, Rivers, Sokoto, Taraba, Yobe and
Zamfara States. These states can be ranked as recording relatively low level of motor vehicle injuries in the
country.
Group B comprises of Bauchi, Cross River, Kano, Katsina, Lagos, Ondo, Osun, Oyo, Plateau States and
the Federal Capital Territory. They can be ranked as recording relatively medium level of Motor Vehicle
Injuries in the country.
Group C comprises or Benue, Kaduna and Ogun States and can be ranked as recording relatively high
level of Motor Vehicle Injuries in the country. Table 4.0 shows the summary groupings of the severity of Motor
Vehicle Injuries by states while figure 4.0 shows the spatial pattern of the distribution.
67
Table 4.Summary Grouping of States on Severity of Motor Vehicle Injuries
Group Rank States

A Low Abia, Adamawa, Akwa Ibom, Anambra, Bayelsa, Borno, Delta,
(0.00 – 2.99%) Ebonyi, Edo, Ekiti, Enugu, Gombe, Imo, Jigawa, Kebbi, Kogi,
Kwara, Nassarawa, Niger, Rivers, Sokoto, Taraba, Yobe,
Zamfara
B Medium Bauchi, Cross River, Kano, Katsina, Lagos, Ondo, Osun, Oyo,
(3.00 – 5.99%) Plateau, Federal Capital Territory.
C High Benue, Kaduna, Ogun
(6.00 – 8.99%)
5. Modelling the Spatial Pattern of road Traffic Accident casualties
The model developed here relates total accident casualties with total number of road accidents; population
estimates, length of roads and number of registered vehicles for a country. The model is a modification of
that used by Nasir in 2009 in his study of Road Accident Deaths in India and that used by Flanders in Belgiun
in 2001.
The original model takes the form:
RF = RA + PE + LR + PT + 
Where RF represents Road fatalities, RA – Road Accidents; PE – Population Estimates; LR – Length of
Roads; PT – Traffic Population;  is the Error term.
The model for this study takes the form:
RAC = TRA + PE + LR + NRV + 
Where RAC = Road Accident Casualties

TRA = Total Road Accidents
PE = Population Estimate
LR = Length of Federal Government roads
NRV = Total Number of Registered Vehicles
 = An Error term
Two multiple regression models were developed for the study. One for Motor Vehicle Deaths and the second
for Motor Vehicle Injuries for the study period in the country.
In order to take the interactive nature of the variables into consideration, the model was transformed into
its logarithm form (See Zlatopher, 1984; Pocock et al., 1982). Using the Least Square Regression Method the
collected data were analysed with the Statistical Package for the Social Science (SPSS) and Excel.
5.1 Pattern of Motor Vehicle Deaths
The model for motor vehicle deaths takes the form.

Log (MVD) = log (TRA) + log (PE) + log (LR) + log (NRV) + 
Where MVD represents Motor Vehicle Deaths, TRA represent Total Road Accidents, PE represents
Population Estimates; LR represents Length of Roads; NRV represents Number of Registered Vehicles
68
Table 5.0 shows the Regression Summary of Motor Vehicle Deaths with the independent variables. The
independent variables explain 73.2 percent of the total variation in motor vehicle deaths. The remaining 26.8
percent are variables which cannot be included in the model due to their exogenous features. These could
include lack of emergency services and first aid in the event of motor vehicle accidents.
Table 5: Regression Summary for Motor Vehicle Deaths and the Independent Variables
Dependent Independent Variables Regression Standard t-values Levels of

Variables Coefficient Error significance
Motor Constant -0.303 1.088 -0.279 0.782
Vehicle Total Road Accidents -0.013 0.220 -0.101 0.920
Deaths (TRA) 0.819 0.111 7.766 0.000*
(MVD) Population Estimate (PE) 0.166 0.138 1.596 0.120*
Length of Roads (LR) -0.025 0.080 -0.245 0.808
No. of Registered Vehicles
(NRV)
R2 = 0.732 DF = 4/32 F = 21.828 > 2.69
* Significant at 0.05 level of significance
The regression summary shows that motor vehicle deaths has negative association with total road accidents
and number of registered vehicles. This is not surprising since the establishment of the Federal Road Safety
Commission in Nigeria in 1988 has had positive impact in reducing motor vehicle accidents in the country
and consequently motor vehicle deaths.
The regression summary also shows that motor vehicle deaths has a positive association with population
estimate and length of roads. These outcomes are not surprising also because increase in the level of
motorization in a country is associated with increasing population. Increasing population is also associated
with higher probability of accident occurrence. Also, improvement in road networks encourages speeding by
drivers and also accidents.
Further the F-test shows that the regression is significant since the F-statistic of 21.828 is greater than the
critical value of 2.69 at 0.05 level of significance. The t-values also show that population estimate and length
of roads are significant at 0.05 level. The value of the coefficient of determination, R2 which is 73.2 per cent
shows that the model is a good fit for the data. The predictive ability of the model is thus confirmed. The
regression model obtained is:
Log (MVD) = -0.303 – 0.013log (TRA) + 0.819log (PE) + 0.166log (LR)
– 0.025log (NRV)
5.2 Pattern of Motor Vehicle Injuries
The model for motor vehicle injuries takes the form:

Log (MVI) = log(TRA) + log(PE) + log(LR) + log(NRV) + 
where MVI represents motor vehicle injuries; TRA, total road accidents, PE, population estimate; LR, length
of roads; NRV, number of registered vehicles.
Table 6. shows the regression summary of motor vehicle injuries and the independent variables. The
independent variables explain 83.8 per cent of the total variation in motor vehicle injuries.
69
Table 6.:Regression Summary for Motor Vehicle Injuries and the Independent Variables
Dependent Independent Variables Regression Standard t-value Levels of

variable Coefficients Error Significance
Motor Constant 1.037 0.833 1.245 0.222
Vehicle Total Road Accidents (TRA) -0.143 0.168 -1.474 0.150
Injuries Population Estimate (PE) 0.916 0.085 11.185 0.000*
(MVI) Length of Roads (LR) 0.237 0.105 2.945 0.006*
No. of Registered Vehicles -0.049 0.061 -0.636 0.530
(NRV)
R2 = 0.838 DF = 4/32 F = 41.46 > 2.69
* significant at 0.05 level of significance
The remaining 16.2 per cent are variables which cannot be included in the model as a result of their
exogenous features. These could include behaviour and driving capacities of drivers, and vehicle conditions.
The regression summary shows that motor vehicle injuries has positive association with population
estimate and length of roads. This is to be expected since population growth leads to increased level of
motorization and higher probability of accidence occurrence and also injuries. Also, improved road provision
promotes motorization and motorability.
In this study, total road accidents is found to have negative association with motor vehicle injuries. This
could be due to the efforts of the Federal Road Safety Commission established in the country in 1988 to
reduce road traffic accidents and injuries on the Nigerian roads. The results show that number of registered
vehicles has negative association with motor vehicle injuries. This is hard to interpret but one should not
dismiss the possibility that security checks by law enforcement agencies also help to reduce the number of
unregistered and un-roadworthy vehicles on the roads.
The study also shows that two independent variables, population estimate and length of roads are
significant at 0.05 level, considering their t-values. The value of the coefficient of determination R2 which is
83.8 per cent shows that the model is a good fit for the data. The F-test also shows that the regression is
significant since the F-statistic of 41.46 is greater than the critical value of 2.69 at 0.05 level of significance.
The predictive ability of the model is thus confirmed. The multiple regression model obtained is
Log(MVI) = 1.037 – 0.143log(TRA) + 0.916log(PE) + 0.237log(LR)
– 0.049log(NRV)
6. Conclusion and Recommendations
This study has examined the spatial distribution of road traffic accident casualties among the 36 states and
the Federal Capital Territory of Nigeria. The study shows that regional variations exist in the incidence of road
traffic accident casualties in the country within the study period of 2004 – 2007.
The study has tried to model motor vehicle deaths and motor vehicle injuries on Nigerian roads. The
results show that total road traffic accidents, population estimate, road lengths and number of registered
vehicles are important variables to take into consideration in examining road traffic accident casualties in the
country.
In order to curtail road traffic accidents on Nigerian roads, the following recommendations are pertinent:
1. Drivers should be trained and retrained as a means of effectively dealing with road traffic accident
reduction.
2. Motorists should drive within speed limits and with a speed consistent with road conditions.
3. Motorists should not drink and drive and should comply with the legislation on speed limits.
4. Seat belts should be worn by motorists for both short and long trips.
70
5. First aid kit should be provided in every vehicle and emergency first aid facilities should be made available
for accident casualties.
6. Road safety education should be part of the curriculum in our educational institutions.
7. Traffic laws must be judiciously enforced by the various law enforcement agencies in the country.
References
Afukaar, F.K. (2003). Speed control in developing countries: Issues, challenges and opportunities in reducing road traffic injuries.
International Journal for Injury Control safety Promotion, 10:6a – 7b.
Balogun, J.A., Abereoje O.K. (1992). Pattern of road traffic accident cases in a Nigerian university teaching hospital between 1987 and
1990. J Trop. Med. Hyg, 95: 23-29.
Bustide, S; Moath, J.P.; Pages, J.P; Fagan, F. (1989). Risk perception and social acceptability of technologies: The French case, Risk
Analysis 9: 215-223.
Chen, G. (2010). Road Traffic Safety in African Countries – status, trend, contributing factors, counter measures and challenges,
International Journal of Injury Control and Safety Promotion, 17(4): 247 – 255.
Cutter, S.L. (1993). Living with Risks: Geography of Technological Hazards. Great Britain: Edward Arnold.
Dejoy, D.M. (1989). The optimism bias and traffic accident risk perception. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 21: 333 – 340.
Haddon, W.Jr (1980). Advances in the epidemiology of injuries as a basis for public policy. Public Health Report, 95(5): 411 – 421.
Horden, J. (2004). Risk and uncertainty management strategies. 6th International CRN Expert workshop, Stockholm 22 – 24 April, 2004:
Societal security and crisis management in the 21st century.
Hubbard, D. (2009). The Future of Risk Management: Why It’s Broken and How to Fix it. John Wiley & Sons.
Jacobs, G. & Aeron-Thomas, A. (2000). Africa road safety review final report. Washington, DC: US Department of Transportation,
Federal Highway Administration.
Jaeger, C.C.; Renn, O. Rosa, E.A. & Webler, T. (2001). Risk, Uncertainty and Rational Action. Earthscan Pub. Ltd, London.
Komba, D.D. (2006). Risk Factors and Road Traffic Accidents in Tanzania: A case study of Kibaha District. Master Thesis, Department
of Geography, Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU), Trodheim
Lagarde, E. (2007). Road Traffic Injury is an Escalating Burden in Africa and Deserves Proportionate Research Efforts. PLOS Med, 4(6):
967 – 971.
Levenson, N. (2004). A new accident model for engineering safer systems. Safety Science, 42(4); 237 – 270.
Lupton, D. (1999). Risk. Routledge, London.
Moen, B.E. and T. Rundmo (2005). Worrying about Transport Risks. In Rundmo, T. and B.E. Moen (eds). Risk Judgement and Safety in
Transport. Rotunde Publication Number 87, Trodheim.
OECD (Organisation for Economic Coopration and Development), 2006. Young Drivers: The Road Safety. <http://www.cemet.org>.
Muhlrad, N; Lassare, S. (2005). Systems approach to injury control, New Delhi: Macmillan India Ltd.
O’Hare (2000). The ‘Wheel of Misfortune’ a taxonomic approach to human factors in accident investigation and analysis in aviation and
other complex systems. Ergonomics, 43(12): 2001 – 2011.
Odero, W; Garner, P. and Zuri, A. (1997). Road traffic injuries in the developing countries: a comprehensive review of epidemiological
studies. Journal of Tropical Medicine and International Health, 2(5): 445-460.
Odero, W; Khayes, M; Heda, P.M. (2003). Road Traffic Injuries in Kenya: Magnitude, Causes and Status of Intervention. Inj. Control Saf.
Promot, 10:53-61.
Onabulu, O.O; Otulana; T.O. & Awodein, O.G. (2008). Assessing the visual status of truck drivers in a developing country. Tropical
Doctor, 38: 54-55.
Peden, M. (2004). World Report on Road traffic Injury Prevention. Geneva: World Health Organisation.
Peltzer, K. & Renner, W. (2004). Psychosocial correlates of the impact of road traffic accidents among South African drivers and
passengers. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 36:367-374.
Pocock, S.J; Cook, D.G; and A.G. Shaper (1982). Analysing Geographic Variation in cardiovascular mortality: Methods and results. J. R.
Statist. Soc. A. 145 Part 3: 313-341.
Rasmussen, J. (1997). Risk Management in a Dynamic Society: A Modeling Problem. Safety Science 27 (243): 183-213.
Reason, J. (2000). Human error: Models and management. BMJ 320: 768-770.
Rundamo, T & Iversen, H. (2004). Risk perception and driving behaviour among adolescents in two Norwegian countries before and
after traffic safety campaign. Safety Science 42:1 – 21.
Salmon, P.N; Stephan, K; Lenne, M.G; Kopinathan, C; Williamson, A. (2009). Systems-based Human factors analysis of total road traffic
accidents: An explanatory case study. NRMA Road Safety Trust Report.
Smith, G.S; Barss, P. (1991). Unintentional injuries in developing countries: The epidemiology of a neglected problem. Epidemiol Rev.
13:228-66.
71
Wiegmann, D.A. and Shappell, S.A. (2003). A Human Error Approach to Aviation Accident Analysis: The Human factors Analysis and
Classification System. Astigate Publishing Ltd.
Williams, A.F. (2003). Teenage Drivers: Patterns of risk. Journal of Safety Research, 34:5-15.
World Bank, World Bank Atlas 1999, Washington DC, 1999,
Zlatopher, T.J. (1984). Regression Analysis of Time Series Data on Motor Vehicle Deaths in the United States. Journal of Transport
Economics and Policy; 18(3): 263-274.
72
Evaluating Low Income Families’ self Perception of the Economic Aid Program:
The Albanian Case
Brilanda Lumanaj
PhD Candidate
University of Shkodra “Luigj Gurakuqi”, Albania
Department of Psychology and Social Work, Faculty of Educational Sciences
Sidita Hasi
MA in Organizational Leadership
School of professional studies
Department of Organizational Leadership
Gonzaga University, Washington
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.73
Abstract: Given the complicated transition in which post communist countries have been going through during their rapid
development, it is important to make sure that concerns of the weakest part of these societies are taken into consideration and
not left on their own fate hidden in the chaotic transition process. This study is an evaluation of Albanian needy families’
perceptions of the public Economic Aid program. Qualitative research was based on ten interviews of Economic Aid recipients,
male and female baby boomers. They all had children. The findings showed a huge gap between the Economic Aid amount and
their real expenses and needs. In most cases this gap was covered from black market jobs. Recipients felt extremely poor,
inferior, hopeless, and concerned about surviving. The lack of trust in the Economic Aid program in specific and the government
in general was due to perceived high level of corruption. We recommended a practical framework for restructuring the Economic
Aid program in terms of the amount delivered, transparency, employment support, psychological assistance for both parents and
children, and better medical coverage.
Keywords: social services; Economic Aid; Albania; developing countries; temporary cash assistance.
1. Introduction
Developing countries in South Eastern Europe have been going through a complex transition in terms of
political changes, economic stability and social development. Corruption has been an evident unethical
phenomenon for these countries accompanying their journey towards development and integration. As a
result, the integration process has been complicated.
After Croatia being finally accepted in the European Union as of July 1st 2013, Albania is one of the next
candidates of Western Balkan whose application is being considered for the membership of European Union
(European Union Commission, 2010). It has been twenty years since communism collapsed in Albania and
many socio-economic changes have occurred since then. Yet, the efficiency of these changes still needs to
be evaluated. The lack of an appropriate preparation of the population to embrace the new capitalistic system
and an ineffective legal system to ensure stability prevented from appropriately addressing concerns of the
extreme poor class of the Albanian society.
According to INSTAT (Albanian Institute of Statistics, 2011) Albania still does not have an official Living
Minimum Standard. However, the public Economic Aid program that supports the needy families with no or
not enough revenues and invalids is considered 5-6 times under the assumed minimum standards. In
addition, the unemployment rate of 13.8 % (INSTAT, 2009) coexisted with a considerable increase in prices.
73
The intent of this article is to raise the voice of this class of the Albanian society being the official data
extremely ambiguous due to the informal economy and unethical political strategies still operating in this
country. In this study we are questioning the reality from people’s perspective in an attempt to understand
their experience with the public Economic Aid program and issues they have been going through without
establishing direct cause – effect relationships. The intent of this article is to identify their main concerns,
understand if the public Economic Aid is perceived as an efficient corrector, and how this is influencing their
quality of life.
This study can be relevant to needy families as the opportunity to externalize their needs and issues adds
value to their voice which hopefully will be taken into consideration for future antipoverty programs. The local
regional directories can gain from this research as well. If they start directing the culture of their organizations
to being more democratic and open to families’ in need feedback, they will be able to come out with more
efficient suggestions for their future budgets to be approved by the main directory of the Ministry of Work and
Social Affairs. As this ministry adopts a decentralized structure for its local operations, it will be easier for
different regions to have a personalized program for the social services they could provide to the needy
families as complementary or substitutes to the Economic Aid. In addition, the European Union Commission
can gain helpful information to evaluate the membership of Albania and ensure a more transparent
integration process. It is crucial for them to know that data observed are a correct reflection of the reality.
Other Not for Profit not owned by the government will have a better idea of what to offer to the community in
terms of antipoverty programs. By offering the extreme poor families what they really need, they would fulfill
the mission of their existence and support a democratic Albanian society in terms of socioeconomic welfare.
2. Literature review
“Everyone, as a member of society, has the right to social security and is entitled to realization,
through national effort and international cooperation and in accordance with the organization and
resources of each State, of the economic, social and cultural rights indispensable for his dignity and
the free development of his personality.”
Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Art 22
Many studies have been done to evaluate welfare programs’ efficiency. However, there is a lack on studies
that consider the recipients’ self perceptions on these programs (Nicolas & JeanBaptiste, 2001). Our intent is
to explore previous researches and theoretical concepts in order to build the foundations for a grounded
theory based on the triangulation process. By digging in the theory out there and analyzing different
perspectives provided us a better understanding of the theoretical context of our study. We focused our
attention in three main pillars that helped us create support the objectives of our study. First, we explored the
concept of human dignity in general and that of needy families in specific and the impact of welfare programs
on it. We wanted to understand how to value people as human beings and protect their integrity. Secondly,
we examined how developed countries deal with needy families issues in terms of welfare programs and
human dignity protection. Last, but not least, we considered other developing countries’ realities as they have
been going through socioeconomic transition similar to Albania. We mainly focused on how previous
researchers approached the Albanian welfare programs in particular and poverty issues in general within
their studies.
2.1 Humanitarian approach
Most of the previous studies define the welfare based on the humanitarian approach as an instrument to
protect human dignity. The protection of human dignity is a way to enhance human development and ensure
autonomy. All this leads to human rights protection (Gumbis, Bacianskaite, & Randakeviciute, 2010). These
74
studies mainly focus in the policies at the basis of human dignity protection. Different policies have different
consequences, thus should be taken into consideration very carefully before being applied.
Wax (2003) in his study states that the protection of human dignity is considered not just a government’s
responsibility, but of all members of a society as well. He argues that no one can take full benefit for what he
does and achieves as everything happens in a context which can be the society itself and its institutions.
Other studies embrace the same non individualistic approach (Gumbis, Bacianskaite, & Randakeviciute,
2010). According to these studies, no one, as long as they are a part of that society, has the right to be
against the distribution of welfare benefits even when they do not receive these benefits due to a lack of
need.
Based on these principles, Wax (2003) criticizes the concept of self-reliance by affirming that there is
nothing wrong in being dependent as long as the dependence is constructive. Other studies, however, have
not such a negative attitude toward the concept of self-reliance. Siegel, Green, Abbott, and Mogul (2007) fear
that welfare programs might induce dependency from these programs if not based in appropriate policies.
These researchers after analyzing the development process of welfare leavers and returners show that the
most efficient programs are the ones that prioritize human development and its attitude toward work, instead
of just cash benefits, in order to avoid dependence from the government. This way, people learn how to take
responsibilities. These priorities are set up through a requirement of people to work in order to have those
cash grants. Similar beliefs are particularly supported from a feminist perspective. Scott, London, and Gross
(2007) in their study regarding welfare-reliant women's perspectives on self-sufficiency have shown that
women equal self-reliance with independence from the state and marriage. They would prefer to work rather
than marry someone in order to be dependent from them. It is important to identify what people need and not
simply pretend to know their needs while making welfare policies.
2.2 Developed countries approach
In order for people to be able to know what they need it is important to provide full information of welfare
benefits and their impact on human development. Studies show that many people are not fully aware of what
is being offered in terms of welfare services. Most of them are familiar with the temporary cash support, but
not with the rest of the welfare programs. A study in UK has shown that full assistance through specific
advice centers had better results in human development compared to welfare policies with no advice
(Adams, White, Moffatt, Howel, & Mackintosh, 2006). People need to be guided while being in critical
situations in order to help them overcome those difficulties. Gabel and Kamerman (2006) analyzed twenty
one industrialized countries in order to identify the public commitment in investing in programs that support
children, help their development and at the same time make life easier to their parents. As the authors state,
“changing family structures, particularly among those families headed by mothers living alone, have made
families with children increasingly vulnerable to income poverty and its consequences” (Gabel & Kamerman,
2006, p.239). Families with a single parent are now common to our reality, thus adequate governments’
policies, other than just cash, would be helpful to single parents who straggle between being a parent and a
worker. It is interesting that regardless economic difficulties within the industrialized countries which were
under analysis, the government commitment toward these programs did not decrease as one might think.
Gabel and Kamerman (2006) found that non cash services provided by governments were intentionally
created as the interest of families had moved from cash benefits to finding the appropriate balance between
parental and worker responsibilities. This supports Scott et al. (2007) findings about the families with single
mothers that do not like to be dependent to state or marriage. Brown’s study (2009) done in Australia shows
the same findings in terms of people’s dependency from the cash benefits provided by the government. In all
these studies welfare programs based on cash benefits only would fail to meet all low income families’ needs.
Studies showed other reasons to have welfare programs not based just on cash benefits, especially
considering that parents’ unemployment influences also children’s quality of life in many aspects. Parents
who had less money and more emotional stress had higher probability of mental and physical health
75
decrease (García Rodríguez, 1998; Jin, Shah, & Svoboda, 1995) leading to an increase of divorce probability
(Kraft, 2001). This, in addition to the recession impact on children’s quality of life listing children in USA
during 2010 at the highest poverty level in twenty years (Land, 2010) was a strong evidence of the necessity
for efficient public policies in order to solve the critical situation in developing as well as developed countries.
Studies also showed how parents’ wellbeing impacted their children achievements, at least in the short
run, especially when parents were just high-school or less educated (Stevens, Huff, & Schaller, 2009). This
study highlighted the need for social programs which help parents get a degree, or support their children
during the stressful period of their parents’ unemployment. While Stevens et al. (2009) talk about a short-term
decrease at least from an academic performance point of view, the Foundation for Child Development based
on a longitudinal study stated that “research shows that children who slip into poverty, even for a short time,
can suffer significant setbacks, even when their families regain their economic footing.” (Land, 2010, p.3).
Same conclusion was reached in the Australian case study where Brown (2009) stated that:
The personal cost to these children, who grow up without the positive influence of a
working parent to teach them about responsibility and discipline and instill them with a
sense of ambition and self determination, cannot be underestimated. Family joblessness
leads to welfare dependency and child poverty, and inferior health, social, and
developmental outcomes for children (p.5).
The Australian welfare and tax policies went through a learning experience. The government realized that
people get dependent to welfare if they receive more over the same amount of money that they would take
while working. This is the reason why they applied financial and other incentives. As for financial incentives,
decrease of taxes or increase of wages was the key solution to make these people earn sufficiently more if
working. While in terms of non financial incentives, the Australian government found strict welfare rules to be
efficient on getting people to work. People would get punished if they did not go through the process of
looking for a job and being part of the programs that help them finding one (Brown, 2009, p. 3).
Research does not consider people’s unawareness of welfare services’ availability as a reason to fully
justify the state of poverty that people face. Many of the welfare systems are not perfect. Roth (2004) in his
study shows that the best instrument for change to occur is to raise the voice and make public the
inefficiencies of welfare systems. Claiming systems that do not work properly can increase awareness much
more than just demonstrating how things should be. On the other hand, it is important to be aware that the
attitude of the public towards welfare benefits depends on how much interest they have on those benefits
(Blekesaune & Quadagno, 2003). If people are not expecting to be unemployed, they are less willing to
accept taxes for the fair distribution of wealth. Similar attitudes where found regarding the Norwegian welfare
programs (Pettersen, 2001). Blekesaune and Quadagno (2003) also found that people tend to increase
awareness in situational cases, such as when unemployment is high, and they are more aware of the support
that public welfare state can give to them in terms of cash or support in finding a job. The advice centers
become once again crucial in helping people to overcome these situational moments (Adams, White, Moffatt,
Howel, & Mackintosh, 2006).
2.3 Developing countries approach
Speaking of available welfare services, studies have shown how in countries which experience a rapid
growth, the public policies were not ready to respond with appropriate policies to protect the human dignity of
the poor (Daniere & Takahashi, 1999). The gap between rich and poor increases when there is a rapid
economic increase (Ishay, 2010). This is the reality that most of the developing countries have been going
through. Thus, an adequate welfare system in these countries becomes even more critical. By adequate we
mean that these policies should not just exist, but should also be applied in an efficient way. Hadiprayitno
(2010), while analyzing the Indonesian policies about the right for food from a humanitarian approach, found
that the Indonesian government was struggling to practice the public policies as they should, failing this way
to protect the right for food. As a result the human dignity was not respected. Similar non positive effects of
76
social assistance in reducing poverty level were founded by Verme (2011) in his attempt to evaluate social
services performance in Moldova, the poorest country in Europe, also in transition after coming out from
communism. In contradiction with the Indonesian and Moldovan case, Sen (1981) focused his research in
four good examples of South Korea, Singapore, Hong Kong, and Taiwan as countries with a rapid, yet quality
economic growth in their early capitalism era. Findings on this study proved that the state’s commitment is
crucial to adopting effective public and welfare policies.
In addition, studies about Albania showed an interesting factor to be considered while analyzing the
quality of life and the poverty level. Carlett and Zezza (2006) found that there is a gap between Albanian
poverty measured based on objective instruments and Albanians’ perception about their poverty level. This
study concluded that Albanians in feelt poorer than objective measurement techniques would define their
quality of life, reason why we wanted to include the subjectivity factor while evaluating the efficiency of
existing policies and considering the introduction of new welfare policies.
The Commission of European Union (2010), in its annual report stated that Albania is in a good way
towards getting its membership. Still many more efforts needed to take place before that happened. The
political influence in the public administrative system has to decrease in order for this institution to work
efficiently. In addition the law has to be enforced so actual public policies can be applied properly. With
inefficient public institutions, no welfare system can protect human dignity, enhance human development and
increase low income families’ quality of life.
Previous studies about the performance of Economic Aid program in Albania, showed its public institution
inefficiency. Mangiavacchi and Verme (2009) found that this inefficiency consists mainly in a reaching the
real poor. They still could not define if this happens because of the complicated formula which is supposed to
target the real poor, or because of corruption and poor decentralization structure of the welfare system.
However, the inefficiency of the decentralized system of targeting the poor has been proved in other
Alderman’ s (2002) studies as well.
Independently from the public institutions efficiency, previous researchers have also included the
subjectivity factor while analyzing Albanians welfare. Interesting enough is the fact that Albanians perceive a
higher financial satisfaction if they are working in the informal sector, and have a low-positive attitude toward
tax payments. In few words, if two people have the same income, but one works in the formal sector, and the
other one in the informal sector accompanied by low-ethical attitude toward tax morale, the latter will perceive
a higher well being (Ferrer-i-Carbonell & Gërxhani, 2005).
2.4 Summary of the Literature
As supported from the literature above, the humanitarian approach consists on the idea that human rights are
protected if people’s dignity is respected and if these people are treated and enabled to live as human
beings. In order to achieve this, a constructive dependability is allowed, up to the point where people are still
motivated to reach self-reliance. For this to happen, effective welfare programs should exist and full
assistance in sharing information should be provided by public institutions in order to support needy families
during the process of overcoming their obstacles. Examples of developed countries approach with welfare
issues mainly highlighted the high influence of non cash benefits on avoiding the risk of unlimited
dependence of needy families on the state support. The relevance of non cash incentives is also enforced by
showing which additional non cash problems needy parents have to go through while raising their kids.
Emotional stress has a critical impact on parents and children’s health and socio development in the short
and long term. In conclusion, we analyzed other researches that have been done considering countries which
have gone through similar socio economic rapid growth accompanied by a huge gap between rich and poor
as happened in the Albania. Findings showed the successful countries had a strong public system which
helped to efficiently apply the exiting welfare policies. Mismanagement and corruption were the major causes
of the failure of these programs in other countries. Studies analyzing the Albanian reality showed that a
critical element of the financial satisfaction and quality of life depends on the fact that needy families work in
77
the informal job market or not. Even their attitude toward the taxation as an instrument which can influence
the Economic Aid changes depending on their participation in the informal job market. This theoretical
framework served as fundamentals of our study. They helped us better understand the context of our study
while considering different perspectives.
3. Methodology
The purpose of this study was to evaluate low income families’ self perception of the Economic Aid program
and its impact on their everyday life in an attempt to provide a guideline for antipoverty programs. In order to
achieve this goal the study focused on five major objectives which helped us build the fundamentals for
answering the research question of this study.
Our objectives were to:
 Define human dignity from needy families’ viewpoint.
 Evaluate the efficiency of Economic Aid program from needy families’ perspective.
 Identify root causes of the poverty state of low-income families.
 Point out the implications of poverty in general and the Economic Aid program in specific on needy
families’ lives.
 Explore opportunities for antipoverty programs as complements or substitutes of the Economic Aid.
This study was based on a qualitative research method in order to give value to people’s perceptions and
experiences. The inductive approach of understanding needy families’ context and the implications of it in
their lives helped us build a grounded theory.
3.1 Participants
The richness and variability of the data was enabled by using purposive sampling. Information about the
respondents was provided by the local public social work entities which distribute the Economic Aid. While
selecting our respondents we considered specific characteristics that would provide us with relevant
information necessary for reaching constructive conclusions. Major priority was given to characteristics such
as: age, duration of the needy state; the size of family; education; geographic area of living. Respondents
who fulfilled the characteristics we were looking for were selected while they were present in the public entity.
A total of ten interviews were completed. All ten interviewers were from urban area. Six out of ten participants
were female. All respondents were baby boomers. None of them had a higher education. This was relevant
to our study as this generation had a long experience with the communism and democracy as well. They
were all households with children aged five months to twenty-two years. Respondents were long-term needy
families having received Economic Aid for more than two years. A personal brief presentation of the purpose
of our study was communicated to them. Ten of the twenty two people approached volunteered to be
interviewed. Face to face interviews were scheduled on respondents’ preferred timing and location.
3.2 Instrument
Data collection was achieved through personal interviews covering thirty six questions among which two
open ended questions asking participants to pick the topics. Respondents were not comfortable in talking
about their personal issues in a focus group context because of cultural impediments. In the community
where respondents lived people were not easily open to group communications. They fear to be judged by
other members of the community, or stereotyped because of their low social status. We considered this
element as a critical key to our study, thus we decided that personal interviews would protect their comfort
zone. In addition, a survey of eleven questions provided us with participants’ socio demographic data.
78
3.3 Procedure
The interviews started with a more in depth prescription of our study and the role of the respondents in it.
Respondents were presented with the confidentiality policy and anonymity was insured not using their real
names and presenting the data in an aggregate form. The session continued with a short socio demographic
survey to be filled by each respondent. No reimbursement was provided to respondents for their participation.
The interview was guided by the interviewer towards five major pillars coherent with the objectives of our
studies. However, the questions had the characteristics of open ended questions in order to let respondents
guide the issues that were more relevant to them and the depth of the details they were willing to share.
The trustworthiness of this study was insured in terms of credibility, transferability, dependability and
conformability (Erlandson, Harris, Skipper, & Allen, 1993). Confirmation questions asked to respondents and
peer debriefing and blind coding was used to ensure credibility of the results. Transferability in this study due
to the small amount of interviews is guaranteed by providing a detailed and full picture of the context in order
to let other researchers and readers evaluate the amount of findings’ transferability into their own context.
Within this study a purposive sample was intentionally chosen in order to provide various contexts of people
having similar Economic Aid support. Our intention was to provide dependability information by showing how
changes of a certain context could affect our research differently. In addition, interviews were recorded and
notes were taken in order to provide full access to auditors and ensure conformability.
We analyzed our data through a constant comparative method (Glaser & Strauss, 1967). Statements were
codified and grouped into eight categories which led us to our results. The latter was presented through a
case study report in order to understand the connection the data with the context of our study and provide
information useful for our findings. Themes emerged from the respondents perceptions naturalistically
resulting in grounded theory.
4. Findings
4.1 The context
Our intent in this study was to raise the voice of Albanians needy families who deal on a daily basis with
poverty while being recipients of the public cash assistance known as Economic Aid program. People who
are accepted in this program have to be without income or invalid in order to receive the cash support.
Furthermore, they are all registered as unemployed people looking for a job. As soon as they find a job,
privately or through the help of public institutions they are no longer considered as cash benefit’s recipients.
The interviews were done at the respondents’ houses because they felt more comfortable there. This
helped us realize even better the reality of their lives. Their houses were extremely simple and clean. The
respondents were baby boomers, having had hard time to adapt to the transition of going from communism to
democracy. The downsizing of organizations owned from the government during communism, found these
people unprepared to the new capitalistic model during democracy. During the communism era people had
few opportunities to have a higher education, and the government was the only provider of jobs as
corporations were all state owned. With the fall of communism in 1991, the majority of the public corporations
shut down, having as a result a high increase in unemployment. The rapid economic change toward
capitalism made the job market require for higher education. Jobs were neither enough nor insured by the
government as they used to be during communism. The change of governments every four year came along
with high turnover. Thus the weakest part of the society became even weaker.
Data from INSTAT (2011) show that employment in the public sector during early democracy (1995) was
mainly focused in secondary level of education, while it had shifted rapidly to higher education with a
decrease of employment for people with a lower education level, which is mainly composed by the
communism generation known as baby boomers. It is in this context that the Economic Aid program was
adapted. Recipients of this cash support depending on individual circumstances take on average a monthly
79
payment of 4,500 ALL1 (around forty dollars). This amount did not change a lot during the years, while the
minimum average salary in the public sector has changed from 3,400 ALL in 1995 to 20,000 ALL in 2009
(INSTAT, 2011). This shows an increase of 500% of the minimum wage in fifteen years while the Economic
Aid for needy families represents only 25% of the minimum wage. In our findings section we will respond to
our four objectives while the last objective will be covered in the conclusion.
4.2 Define human dignity from needy families’ viewpoint
The findings of our study suggested that human dignity is not a definition we could generalize. Every human
being has his own perception of what dignity means to them and how they pretend to be treated in order for
their human dignity to be respected according to their expectances. Their definitions change based on their
background and the context they belong. In general human dignity to them is not just how the society sees
them, but also how they see themselves, intrinsic versus extrinsic. People who had a difference in identifying
their dignity based on the position that they have within the society versus the consideration that they have
about themselves, showed a difference in their perception of feeling treated as human beings or not. One of
the respondents stated: “No, I don’t feel treated as human being. The Economic Aid is insignificant and
doesn’t allow me to support my children. Working in the black market makes me feel not treated as human
being” (R1). This same respondent considered dignity as the position that she had within the society. On the
other side people perceiving human dignity from an intrinsic perspective had different perception about
feeling treated as human beings while stating: “Yes, I feel treated as a human being. I never argued with
someone.” (R2).
In terms of responsibility 80% of the respondents seem to agree in the fact that they see the government
as responsible to their quality of life (R1, R2, R3, R4, R5, R6, R8, & R10). They were very emotional while
talking and describing their lives’ conditions, and provided as main responsible the government. Other
respondents felt oppressed by the reality and inferior, although their tendency was to hide this feeling in front
of their children. “I try to not show how I feel, even though it is very hard for me. I really want to have my own
personality and not feel inferior” (R1).
In addition, we noticed a common altruistic value among our respondents while considering not just their
own human dignity, but that of other members of their community as well. They would be willing to be helpful
to other people in order to support their human dignity. However, they showed a difference in their potential
level of involvement, active versus passive behavior. Respondents that were community oriented, and
perceived human dignity based on the position and respect that they had among other members of the
society, perceived that all members of the society should be responsible for the fair distribution of richness.
They would agree to have an increase in taxes, in case they worked, in order for other needy members of the
society to receive a greater Economic Aid (R1, R2, R3, R4, R5, R6, R8). On the other hand, other people had
a more individualistic approach. “If I worked, I would not accept to have an increase in taxes, because
everyone has its own difficulties in life and works for that” (R2). These people learned from their experiences
that they can’t depend on any one, not even on the government as such, they expect others to see it the
same way (R10). However, the non acceptance of the increase in taxes was explained also as an inefficient
solution towards the community welfare improvement. They believe that more taxes mean higher prices (R7,
R9).
4.3 Evaluate the efficiency of Economic Aid program from needy families’ perspective.
While our respondents considered the government as the main responsible for their human dignity’s damage,
they did not consider the Economic Aid program as a solution at all. “For me the Economic Aid is nothing, is

1 Lek is the Albanian currency (ALL)
80
insufficient. My younger son has diabetes, and I cannot even afford to buy his medicines.” (R2). There was a
huge lack of information about this program even though the criticism towards it was high. They came to
know about this program mainly from families and friends. Only two of them went to ask for help on their own
and learned about the program (R5, R6). Others that used to work before, when they lost their jobs they were
given a form to fill for the application process and they did not know how much they would receive in terms of
cash. All respondents had higher expectations about the monthly cash amount they would have been be
receiving (R1, R2, R3, R4, R5, R6, R7, R8, R9, R10). Eight out of ten respondents suggested that minimum
cash needed to cover basic monthly needs was 3,000 ALL (300$), however they were spending around half
of this amount even though their Economic Aid provided them with one third of what they were spending.
With that amount they could barely afford to buy two pounds of bread a day, considering a family with an
average of four members.
Many of the respondents work in the black market, and still struggle to cover their basic needs. The more
we focused in understanding their perceptions about their Economic Aid, the more they continue to talk about
their extreme difficulties, and they became emotional, or avoided some of the questions. We did not find any
element of dependency from the Economic Aid program, as we found during our theoretical researches.
Respondents never stopped looking for a job. They could not depend on the Economic Aid they were
receiving. Even though some of the respondents did not stop looking for a job (R2, R4, R7, R8, R9), others
stopped looking for a job through the public institutions, due to the fact that they lost their trust in the
government and they figured out that there was no job for them (R1, R6, R10).
I have been working in the black market selling coffee in the streets for twenty years, since the
communism fell, and I lost my job. Public institutions told me that there were some vacancies only
for women under age 35 in the tailoring industry, but I was a man, and not that young. Thus I
stopped looking for a job through them. I do not want to know anything about the Economic Aid
program. All I want is to take care about my own difficulties. I depend only on myself, and try to
protect myself. (R2).
In addition respondents talk about corruption within the public institutions. Four out of ten, admitted the
existence of corruption and unfair distribution of the Economic Aid, however, information was vague (R1, R6,
R7, R8).
4.4 Identify root causes of the poverty state of low-income families.
Our respondents did not have a higher education and they were poor for almost twenty years, since the fall of
communism. As mentioned above, these people also did not have a great support in how to find a job, and
how to improve their skills in order to fit to the new job market requirements which had been continuously
changing during the transition period. We found that our respondents blamed as the cause of their poverty
the political system leading to unemployment as well as the lack of proper education. However, they did not
consider their low level of education as a direct cause of their unemployment (R7). All respondents were
always willing to work even more if job opportunities were available.
4.5 Point out the implications of poverty in general and the Economic Aid program in specific on needy
families’ lives.
Respondents perceived to be extremely poor and hopeless. While all their talk goes around their concerns
about their children, they feel that they cannot have the luxury to think about themselves even though they
would like to. However, they try to hide their emotional feelings as much as they can from their children. They
are open only to their partners (R1, R2, R3, R4, R5, R6, R9). Mainly their children do not judge their parents
about their standard of living, even though they are aware of it with the exception of some cases where kids
would blame them for what they can’t have in comparison with other kids of their age. However these mixed
feelings would last only in a short term (R1, R8). The respondents would eat less and satisfy their children’s
81
needs rather than let them feel inferior to their friends (R1). As much as our respondents try to protect their
children, there were circumstances were they had no choice. One of our respondents stated: “I got my
daughter married at age fifteen and my son emigrated” (R10). However, their children did not have problems
with school, drugs or other social problems. It seems that they were actually motivated to go to school and
achieve what their parents could not.
In terms of children-parent relationships, most of the respondents had really good and open relationships
with their parents (R1, R2, R3, R4, R5, R6, R7, R8, R9). Others not that good, however we don’t know all the
reasons behind it. In general, the respondents perceive appreciation and respect from their children who
explicitly show it. A respondent stated: “My nine years old son is sick and I do all I can to take care of him and
cover his medical expenses. He has been telling to my neighbors how much he loves and appreciates me.”
(R2). Nine out of ten of our respondents stated that they did not notice any difference on the respect given to
them from their children based on who works in the family and who does not (R1, R2, R3, R4, R5, R6, R8,
R9, R10).
5. Conclusion
First of all our findings highlight a huge gap between what people receive in terms of Economic Aid, what
they actually spend for living, and what they perceive they need in order to cover their basic needs and feel
treated as human beings. There were no discrepancies regarding the perception of the Economic Aid’s
inefficiency among the respondents. However, their approach to poverty showed some differences. Below we
are highlighting the main effects of poverty.
This study showed symptoms of inferiority among needy families, more in households than in their
children. Inferiority was not only related to how people consider themselves compared to other members of
the society, but also how people consider themselves. These findings further support our theoretical findings
which showed both an individualist and a communitarian approach. Respondents who were more social
oriented were people who criticized the government in general and the Economic Aid program in specific,
however, they still hoped in change. They were people who were willing to offer their services to the
community if that would have helped them improve their quality of life. These were people who were helped
by their relatives to overcome obstacles. Other people had a huge lack of trust in the government, including
the Economic Aid program which they did not even consider as a source of income. These people had the
tendency to not offer their services to the community. They would not pay more taxes if eventually working.
However, none of these people did show any sign of dependency on the Economic Aid as some of the
literature research showed. Needy families have been depending on their own, they did not stop working
even though on the black market. Our conclusion to these facts was that the economic Aid was so small that
it was impossible for these people to rely on it and create some sort of dependency on this program.
We also concluded that the perceived inefficiency of the Economic Aid program was sometimes leading
people to unethical behavior. First of all, our findings showed elements of perceived corruption within the
government in general and the public institutions of the Economic Aid provider in specific. These examples of
corruption, in addition to the insufficiency of the monthly Economic Aid, left people with no other choice than
working in the black market when possible. Even though, needy families perceive that not paying taxes is
unethical, some of them did not have a choice. Thus it is critical to understand that indirectly pushing people
to work in the black market has many side effects. First, we should consider the fact that these needy families
are mainly baby boomers generation, with no guidance to entrepreneurial skills, as they have been educated
under Marxism-Leninism principles during communism. Letting them on their own fate struggling in the new
capitalistic market is not just a cash flow deficit in terms of taxes for the government, but also a high
probability of entrepreneurship failure for these people, which will lead to increased poverty, and increased
social issues for the entire country. Our theoretical research showed case studies where the most efficient
welfare programs were the one with incorporated non cash support and full guidance.
82
Based on our theoretical and empirical findings, we recommend a framework that takes into consideration
the main issues revealed by our study. This way we move toward our last goal focusing in exploring
opportunities for antipoverty programs as complements or substitutes of the Economic Aid.
6. Framework for potential implementation
1. Reevaluate the amount of the Economic Aid. It is important to have coherence among the changes in
prices, the real purchasing power, and the minimum wage salaries while considering the appropriate
amount of Economic Aid. In order to do so it is critical to have an official minimum standard of living as a
reference.
2. Control all documentations of the existing recipients of the Economic Aid in order to make sure that
elements of corruption will be eliminated. This will require a restructure of the public institutions, and their
depoliticization.
3. Increase the public support on the job searching process. Strengthen collaboration with the local business
in order to diminish the job hidden market. Do job market research in order to see what skills are required
in the current and future job market and create training programs that help needy families achieve those
skills.
4. Revise medical support for members of needy families. Households are not able to cover their food
expenses. The partial current reimbursement is not enough for these people. A full coverage would avoid
health deterioration because of malnutrition and untreated disease.
5. Public psychological assistance. Long term poverty and perceived inefficient support from the
government, has made needy families go through mix feelings, such as; inferiority, stress, disappointment,
hopeless, insecurity and much more. During the interviews, we perceived an extreme need of these
people to talk about their feelings and to truly being listened from someone. Psychological support should
be available to parents and children as well.
7. Limitations
Our study was focused on the perceptions of needy families, thus we considered as more appropriate a
qualitative research method. It is hard to quantify and standardize the perceptions through a quantitative
research. Another limitation is the fact that interviews were held in Albanian, thus, the power of the responses
might have lost some of its strength due to their translation in English. In addition, respondents were very
unfamiliar with studies as ours, thus privacy concerns related to topics such as corruption, or simply a limited
tendency to openly talk about personal feelings, might have influenced their responses.
References
Adams, J., White, M., Moffatt, S., Howel, D., & Mackintosh, J. (2006). A systematic review of the health, social and financial impacts of
welfare rights advice delivered in healthcare settings. BMC Public Health, 681.
Alderman, H. (2002). Do local officials know something we don't? Decentralization of targeted transfers in Albania. Journal of Public
Economics, 83(3), 375.
Blekesaune, M., & Quadagno, J. (2003). Public Attitudes toward Welfare State Policies:A Comparative Analysis of 24 Nations. European
Sociological Review, 19(5). [Online] Available: http://www.sfi.dk/graphics/ESPAnet/papers/Blekesaune.pdf
Brown, J. (2009). Jobless families in a recession. Policy, 25(2), 5-8.
Carletto, G., & Zezza, A. (2006). Being poor, feeling poorer: Combining objective and subjective measures of welfare in Albania. Journal
of Development Studies, 42(5), 739-760. doi:10.1080/00220380600741896
Daniere, A. G., & Takahashi, L. M. (1999). Public policy and human dignity in Thailand: Environmental policies and human values. Policy
Sciences, 32(3), 247-268.
D'Entremont, A. (2007). Sustainable development and the family. Persona y Bioética, 11(28), 9-22.
Ferrer-i-Carbonell, A., & Gërxhani, K. (2005). Subjective welfare and the (in) formal sector in a transition country. [Online] Available:
http://www.dur.ac.uk/john.ashworth/EPCS/Papers/FerreriCarbonell_Gerxhani.pdf
83
Gabel, S., & Kamerman, S. B. (2006). Investing in Children: Public Commitment in Twenty-one Industrialized Countries. Social Service
Review, 80(2), 239-263.
García Rodríguez, Y. (1998). Efectos del desempleo sobre el nivel de salud mental y física, ansiedad y depresión. Ansiedad y Estrés,
4(1), 17-30.
Gumbis, J., Bacianskaite, V., & Randakeviciute, J. (2010). Human rights today. Jurisprudencija, 1(119), 125-145.
Hadiprayitno, I. I. (2010). Food security and human rights in Indonesia. Development in Practice, 20(1), 122-130.
doi:10.1080/09614520903447437
Ishay, M. (2010). The Universal Declaration of Human Rights at 60: A Bridge to Which Future? Perspectives on Global Development &
Technology, 9(1/2), 11-27. doi:10.1163/156914910X487852
Jin, R., Shah, C., & Svoboda, T. (1995). The impact of unemployment on health: a review of the evidence. CMAJ: Canadian Medical
Association Journal. Journal De L'association Medicale Canadienne, 153(5), 529-540.
Kraft, K. (2001). Unemployment and the Separation of Married Couples. Kyklos, 54(1).
Land, (2010). The 2010 Child and Youth Well-Being Index (CWI). The Foundation for Child Development. [Online] Available:
http://www.fcd-us.org/resources/2010-child-well-being-index-cwi on Sept. 13, 2010.
Mangiavacchi, L., & Verme, P. (2009). Impact Evaluation of an Anti-Poverty Program in Albania: Is a Negative Effect due to Targeting
Failures? [Online] Available: http://www.stat.unipg.it/aissec2009/Documents/papers/108_Mangiavacchi_Verme.pdf
Morrison, J., Howard, J., Johnson, C., Navarro, F., Plachetka, B., & Bell, T. (1997). Strengthening neighborhoods by developing
community networks. Social Work, 42(5), 527-534.
Nicolas, G., & JeanBaptiste, V. (2001). Experiences of women on public assistance. Journal of Social Issues, 57(2), 299-309.
doi:10.1111/0022-4537.00214
Pettersen, P. (2001). Welfare State Legitimacy: Ranking, Rating, Paying: The Popularity and Support for Norwegian Welfare
Programmes in the Mid 1990s. Scandinavian Political Studies, 24(1).
Preston-Shoot, M. (2010). On the evidence for viruses in social work systems: law, ethics and practice. European Journal of Social
Work, 13(4), 55-75.
Qizilbash, M. (1996). Capabilities, well-being and human development: A survey. Journal of Development Studies, 33(2), 143.
Roth, K. (2004). Defending Economic, Social and Cultural Rights: Practical Issues Faced by an International Human Rights
Organization. Human Rights Quarterly, 26(1), 63-73.
Rova, L., & Mano, R. (2009). The impact of financial crisis on the quality of life. Journal of Applied Quantitative Methods, 4(4), 514-524.
Scott, E. K., London, A. S., & Gross, G. (2007). “I Try Not to Depend on Anyone but Me”: Welfare-Reliant Women's Perspectives on
Self-Sufficiency, Work, and Marriage. Sociological Inquiry, 77(4), 601-625. doi:10.1111/j.1475-682X.2007.00210.x
Sen, A. (1981). Public action and the quality of life in developing countries. Oxford Bulletin of Economics & Statistics, 43(4), 287-319.
Siegel, D. I., Green, J., Abbott, A., & Mogul, M. (2007). Welfare Leavers and Returners: Correlates of Quality of Life. Journal of Human
Behavior in the Social Environment, 15(1), 69-97. doi:10.1300/J137v15n0104
Stevens, Huff, A., & Schaller, J. (2009). "Short-Run Effects of Parental Job Loss on Children's Academic Achievement," Working Paper
15480, Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research, 2009. [Online] Available: http://www.nber.org/papers/w15480
(September 16, 2010)
European Union Commission (2010). Commission Opinion on Albania's application for membership of the European Union. [Online]
Available: http://ec.europa.eu/enlargement/pdf/key_documents/2010/package/al_opinion_2010_en.pdf
Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Art 22. [Online] Available:
http://www.un.org/events/humanrights/2007/hrphotos/declaration%20_eng.pdf
Verme, P. (2011). The Poverty Reduction Capacity of Public and Private Transfers in Transition. Journal of Development Studies, 47(6),
870-893. doi:10.1080/00220388.2010.514334
Wax, A. L. (2003). Social Welfare, human dignity, and the puzzle of what we owe each other, Harvard Journal of Law & Public Policy,
27(1), 121.
84
Voting Behavior of People Towards Different Political Parties in District Faisalabad, Pakistan
Durre-E- Shawar
University of Agriculture Faisalabad, Pakistan
Muhammad Asim
Government College University Faisalabad, Pakistan

Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.85
Abstract: Voting is the main form of political participation in democratic societies and the study of voting behavior is a highly
specialized sub-field in political and social science. The study was concerned with the reasons why people vote the way they do.
The main objectives of the present study were to find out the factors which affect the voting behavior & to explore the factors that
constitute political affiliation in District Faisalabad. A sample of 160 household respondents was selected systematically from
District Faisalabad through multistage sampling technique. Specifically explored through this study the relationship of voting
behavior with education, internal changes in the party, voter’s satisfaction and biradrism are those factors that had strong effect
on voting decisions. More than fifty percent (55%) of the respondents vote for the candidate not for the party and (53.1%) of the
voters change their behavior due to the internal changes in the party. The value of Chi-Square and Gamma showed a significant
and strong association between voter satisfaction with particular political party, favour of biradrism and internal change in the
party are strongly associated with voter's behavior.
Keywords: voting behavior, class, religion, caste, ethnicity and biradrism
1. Introduction
Man is a social being, and as such he always contributes in social life. But this contribution is not constant:
the intensity and types of participation are relevant variables in political analysis. Voting behavior is very
important aspect of humans because through this we can know the will of people and also the way they want
to have it .Voting is very important tool in democratic societies. Democracy provides a chance to the people
to become a dynamic citizens rather than inactive subjects (Jost, 2006). A person who is the citizen of
Pakistan, is not less than 18 years of age on the first day of the January of the year in which the rolls are
prepared or revised, is not declared by a competent court to be of unsound mind and is or is deemed to be
the resident of an electoral area, can get himself enrolled as a voter in the electoral area. The citizens
registered on the electoral roll are only eligible to cast their vote. (GOP, 2011). Voting defined by Universal
Declaration of Human Right as "Voting is the fundamental right of almost all citizens over the age of eighteen.
It ensures that will of the people is preserved" (HRCP, 2008). Voting is the expression of a person's
preference for a candidate, or a group of candidates, as well as the person's preference of one political
system rather than another (Blais, et al., 2004).
The people of Pakistan do not have much experience in elections. The first 23 years of Pakistan were
without elections while from 1970 to 2010 nation has experienced 4 regimes of dictatorship. Frequent military
interventions hindered the development of a country. The election system has been changing since
independence. Hence the political system of Pakistan is still in its experimental stage. Political behavior is a
central part of politics of any political system. Politics is an activity related to political system. It is not only a
part of political life but social life too (Ahmed, 2004). Studies allied with voting behavior report that voters can
be classified into seven most important types by their inspiration to vote: Party Loyal, Morality Seeking
Voters, supporter Seeking Voters, Legislation Minded Voters, advance Seeking Voters, Biradari Bound, and
disbeliever Voters (Gallup, 2008).Voting decisions are the most important decisions that public make, They
85
decide who will rule the country and how the resources and capital are allocates. Voters do not know all of
the issues. They only relay on informational cues (Cohen, 2003). Demographic factors do affect the voting
decisions like gender, race are more important than socioeconomic factors like education (Leighley and
Nagler, 1992).In the last few years ethnic and racial influence on voting decisions was studied more than
other issues. Race and ethnicity had great influence on voting behavior (Branton, 2004). Social class plays a
significant importance in voting behavior. However, other factors are showing an ever increasing importance
today such as, social class, party policies, and ethnicity and region issues (Lednum, 2006). Voting for a
candidate of one’s own race might be a product of racism, or it may be the result of reliance on a simple,
readily available cue. In other words, voters may support a candidate of their own race or ethnicity based on
the assumption that a candidate who shares their racial or ethnic background also shares their basic political
views (Michelson, 2005).
2. Methods and Materials
This study was designed to assess the voting behavior of people towards different political parties. The
research uses a statistically valid random sample of 160 respondents to study the voting behavior of the
respondents in Faisalabad. The study was carried out in randomly selected town. The universe of the present
study was Faisalabad district. Out of eight towns of Faisalabad district one town namely Madina town was
selected randomly. At the 2nd stage two union councils were selected randomly and at 3rd stage four localities
from each Union Councils were selected randomly. At the 4th stage 20 respondents from each locality were
selected by systematically sampling technique. A well structured questionnaire consisting of open and closed
ended questions was prepared. Descriptive analysis such as percentage distribution, frequency distribution
and bi-variate analysis was made by using SPSS. Significant relationship was tested through chi-square and
gamma tests.
3. Results and Discussion
Voting is the expression of a person's preference for a candidate, or a group of candidates, as well as the
person's preference of one political system rather than another. The results about literacy level of
respondents exhibited by this study were very typical of Pakistani society. Study showed that 28.1%
respondents were without education while mean education of the respondents was 8 year school education
with 4.03 standard deviation reflecting the low level of education among the respondents. In Pakistan overall
literacy rate is 57% according to Economic Survey (Anonymous, 2010). Majority of the respondents 73.8%
belonged to age group of 18-30 years whilst mean age was 28.33 years.
Because of illiteracy the people of Pakistan do not have much awareness about the politics. They are
inclined by the campaigns and party slogans and vote accordingly. There are also various economic factors
behind their decisions. There are many factors that influence the voter's decision like biradrism was found
sound effect on the voting behavior. More than fifty percent 55% respondents vote to the candidate because
of the candidate and nominee belong to their own biradri or caste. Biradriism is the most powerful element in
Pakistan and it is the main basis of the voting behavior in Pakistani society. These results are analogous with
(Ahmad, 2004) who found that major part of voters has no political fidelity. People caste their votes to survive
as a group or biradri. In case of candidates belonging to the same biradari, voters use their preferences.
There is no party identification that is the psychological connection of a voter to a particular biradri. Wilder,
(1999) was also pointed out this phenomenon. He depicts that in Pakistan, particularly in Punjab the leading
aspect of the social system is biradarism. It has impact on the political system at national as well as at local
levels. Biradari is a stronger determinant of voting behavior. In Pakistani culture family is considered the
strong element and most of the people live in joint family system that’s why family members have strong
influence about any decision or matter.
86
Table. 1 Socio economic characteristic of the respondents
Standard
Age of the respondents Frequency Percentage Mean
Deviation
18-30 118 73.8 23.30 3.68
31-40 22 13.7 34.45 2.44
41 and above 20 12.5 51.30 8.97
Total 160 100.0 28.33 10.52
Education Frequency Percentage
Illiterate 45 28.1
Primary-Middle 16 10.0
Matric 32 20.0
Above Matric 67 41.9
Total 160 100.0
Mean = 8.02 Std Dev. = 4.03
Standard
Income Frequency Percentage Mean
Deviation
Up to 15000 36 22.5 10333.33 2151.41
15001-30000 90 56.2 23688.89 4312.62
Above 30000 34 21.3 37529.41 5406.14
Total 160 100.0 23625.00 9941.81
A mainstream of the 34.4% respondents vote to the parties because their parents and family members
pursued them to do that. They have not their own choice. They just pursue their parent’s decision. These
figures indicate that the people of the Pakistan are not sovereign yet to take their own decisions. They
depend on their parents and family members. The similar observations were of Birner et al, (2006) They
stated that an ample share of the voters also considered the opinions of others, including the landlord, the
community and husband or father as important. The results of present study was also supported by Ahmad,
(2004) who said that people vote for the same party because their biradari support them. It means people
caste their votes to biradri supported candidate. The ratio of biradri supported candidate in Faisalabad district
is 74%. The Pakistani people have keen interest about political matters and party manifesto. Data exhibited
that 45.6% respondents know about the party agenda. These findings line up with Lednum, (2006) who
reported that the agenda of the party had dominated explanations for voting behavior in U.K for example in
1992 (56%) of the social class AB voted for the conservatives and only 20% voted for labor. About 13.8%
respondents acquired information about political matters by newspaper. In developed countries media has
great exposure and have sizeable impact in shaping the public's political knowledge, attitudes and behavior.
But in developing countries like Pakistan people rely on their parents and peer group experiences. Result
demonstrated that 62.5% of the respondents caste the vote in the previous (2008) general election. The male
respondents were found dynamic role in casting the vote. In the total population about 64.7% of male
respondents had cast their vote and 36% of the female respondents cast their vote in the present research. It
was also repotted by Anonymous, (2010) that the voting turn out in the previous general election 2008 was
44.5% and in the 2002 general election the voting turnout was 41.8%. It shows that Pakistani people have no
much interest in the casting the vote. If we compare with other developed countries such as Sweden,
Australia, Switzerland, Denmark and Italy etc. have more than 80% voting turn out. Adma, (2007) It also
depicted that Pakistan had the problem a lack of political participation in the politics. Adma and Schoersh,
(2007) marked that between 1945 and 1997 about 41.8% of the populations, who had allowed to vote, had
voted. This compares with about 90.6% in India, 56% in Bangladesh and 63.7% in Nepal.
Data exhibited that Female voting turnout is low, if we compare with the male respondents. Birner et al,
(2006) are also in consonance to the findings of the present study. They also identified that women’s vote
87
turnout was considerably lower than men’s vote turnout in all Provinces. The difference was particularly
pronounced in khyber pakhtunkhwa, followed by Sindh. At the national level, 39.5% of the women voted, as
compared to 56.8% of the men. The researchers also found that the main causes of the non-casting vote
are inconvenient atmosphere did not have I.D card, had no name in voting lists, not take the interest in the
selection of the representative and fear of violence were the major causes of non-casting vote in the
election. The findings of the study carried out by Birner et al, (2006) they observed that more than a few of
the respondents who did not vote because they did not have an I.D card, were not registered as voters, or
because their name was not in the electoral list. Lack of possessing an I.D card was also a major reason
non-casting the vote.
Table. 2 Distribution of the respondents according to the reasons of non casting vote
No Reasons behind of non-casting the vote Frequency Percent

1 Not take an interest in the selection of representative 21 35
2 Have no name in voting/registration lists in electoral
10 16.7
area
3 Have not identity card (I.D) 7 11.6
4 Inconvenient atmosphere of polling zone 9 15
5 Fear of violence 10 16.7
6 Any others 3 5
Total
60 100
Table. 3 Distribution of the respondents according to their voting decisions
Yes No Total
No Response categories
Freq. %age Freq. %age Freq. %age
1 Vote caste in (2008) general election 100 62.5 60 37.5 160 100
2 Male respondent try to caste vote 55 64.7 30 35.3 85 53.1
3 Female respondent try to caste vote 27 36 48 64 75 46.9
4 Know about the party agenda which to 73 45.6 87 54.4 160 100
vote
5 Internal changes in party affect voting 85 53.1 75 46.9 160 100
decision
6 Decide before the election to which 97 60.6 63 39.4 160 100
party to vote
Data revealed that 53.1% of the voter's alleged that due to the Internal change in the party they vote to the
party. Best example of internal changes in the party effect the voter's decision was shown in the previous
elections where Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) got lead in the elections just due to the assassination of their
leader Banzeer Buhtoo. The voting behavior of the people abruptly changes and the entire sympathy vote
88
goes to PPP. In the history of Pakistan the voting prototype of Pakistani people remain the same if a family
gave vote to a particular party then they vote again and again to that party. And this affiliation goes
generation to generation. This is not done due to the contentment they get by the party work but in Pakistan
there are many other factors that affect the voting decisions and most important is biradrism in the present
study this phenomenon is studied. Data demonstrated that 60.6% respondents decide before the election
that to which party they will support in the next election. These statistics presented by Anonymous1, (2011)
who explored that the voting preference of the respondents in the previous election towards different political
parties such as Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) 47.5%, Pakistan Muslim League N (PML N) 30.0%, Pakistan
Muslim League Q (PML Q) 11.3% and 11.2% others political parties. These findings strongly grasped up the
2008 general election consequences in Faisalabad. There are total 11 seats of members in national
assembly (MNA) and 22 members in Punjab assembly (MPA) in Faisalabad district. In 2008 general election
members of national assembly (MNA) in Pakistan the winning candidate of Faisalabad district belonged to
different political parties such as (PPP) having 6/11, (PMLN) 3/11 and (PMLQ) 2/11. (Anonymous2, 2011)
was the eye viewed of Members of Punjab Assembly (MPA) (PPP) having 7/22 Pakistan Muslim League N
(PMLN) 10/22 and Pakistan Muslim League Q (PMLQ) 5/22 respectively. This data show that two major
parties PPP and PMLN are dominating in the Faisalabad politics. These findings are also lined up with
(PILDAT, 2008) also identified that all elections since 1970 show that there are four clusters of voters: The
PPP cluster, the Pakistan Muslim Leagues cluster, the Religious Parties and local Parties cluster. Past
electoral behavior demonstrates that roughly 60 to 75% of votes are alleged by the first two clusters (PPP
and PML) while the lingering gets distributed among the other two clusters as well as independents and
miscellaneous. There is a positive and highly significant association between age, income and education
toward voting behavior.
Table 4. Over all National Assembly results - Election 2008
Political Party Islamabad K.P.K Punjab Sindh Balochistan Total
Awami National Party 0 10 0 0 0 10

Pakistan Peoples Party 0 10 44 30 4 88
Mutthida Majlis-e-Amal 0 4 0 0 2 6
Pakistan Muslim League (N) 2 3 61 0 0 66
Muttahida Qumi Movement 0 0 0 19 0 19
Pakistan Muslim League (Q) 0 6 28 5 4 43
Independent 0 11 13 1 2 27
Total 2 44 146 55 12 259
Table 5. Over all Provincial Assemblies results - Election 2008
Political Party K.P.K Punjab Sindh Balochistan Total
Awami National Party 31 0 1 2 34

Pakistan Peoples Party 17 79 29 8 133
Mutthida Majlis-e-Amal 9 2 0 4 15
Pakistan Muslim League (N) 6 102 0 0 108
89
Muttahida Qumi Movement 0 1 20 0 21

Pakistan Muslim League (Q) 5 64 4 16 89
Independent 17 35 0 8 60
Total 85 283 54 38 460
Source: Associated Press of Pakistan, Islamabad (2008)
4. Conclusion
The people of Pakistan do not have a lot of experience in elections. . The first 23 years of Pakistan were with
out election while from 1970 to 2010 nation has experienced 4 regime of dictatorship. The election system
has been changing since independence. Hence the political system of Pakistan is still in its experimental
stage. Political behavior is a central part of politics of any political system. Politics is an activity related to
political system. It is not only a part of political life but social life too. Caste system seems to be stronger than
political loyalty now-a-days as far as motivations for voting behavior are concerned. Party affiliation
determines voting behavior. The strong and national level political parties are expected to wipe out the
influence of biradarism. The better level of education and political knowledge will reduce the power of
discouraging elements of biradarism. Biradarism as a racial or group prejudice should be discouraged.
Because of that our public does not have awareness' about politics we are still living in a non- politicalised
society.
5. Recommendations
1. The literacy rate in Pakistan is very low such as the present study showed that the majority of the
respondents were illiterate and they were not aware of the importance and right of the vote. The government
as well as civil society/NGOs should take necessary steps to create awareness among the people about the
importance, weight, meaning and the power of vote through adequate channels i.e. mass media, community
based awareness program and etc, and assure them that the future of a nation highly depends upon its
members’ taking right decision by casting their vote.
2. Most of the people caste their vote in support of a candidate who belong to their same Biradari, caste,
background and social order, but the people should choose and prefer to those candidate who are capable,
candid, devoted and flag- waver which ever of their alike caste, Biradari and social group or not, in respect of
abolishing the concept of Biradari and caste-favoritism, nepotism and chauvinism because these are the
hindrances and impediments in the way of progress of any country as well as the nation.
3. It is no doubt to say that there are only some archetypal families who have hold, cuddle and ascendancy
from top to bottom on politics in Pakistan. In this case, their should be created a atmosphere and ambiance
of such opportunities, accessibilities, feasibilities and circumstances in which every citizen of Pakistan may
access to politics and think about to be elected as a member of parliament. The people should encourage
and promote the new faces in politics.
4. The media is an important tool to represent and reflect the real picture of every aspect of life especially
politics. The media should play a positive role in politics and create awareness among the people regarding
hot and current political issues that are prevailed on politics in the country
90
References
Adma, S. and Schoresch, D. (2007). The Political crisis of Pakistan in 2007. European University center for peace studies (EPU)
Standtschlaining, Austria. Issue 08/07. pp. 10.
Ahmed, M. (2004). Faisalabad Division ke Siasat per Biradarism kay Asraat, Un-published Ph. D Thesis, Department of Political
Science and International Relations, Multan, B. Z. University. pp: 46.
Anonymous. (2010). Voter turnout data for Pakistan. Available at this web.
http://www.idea.int/vt/country_view.cfm?CountryCode=PK. Assessed by 28/03/2011.
Anonymous1. (2011). Province Assembly of the Punjab. Member’s directory. Available on this web.
http://www.pap.gov.pk/index.php/members/bydistrict/en/19/51. Assessed by 22/03/2011
Anonymous2. (2011). Complete list of Member’s National Assembly of Pakistan. National Assembley of Paksitan. Available at.
http://www.na.gov.pk/compelete_list.html. assessed by 22/03/2011.
Birner, R., S. K. Qureshi, K. Akramov and B. H. Khan. (2006). Voice and Votes—Does Political Decentralization Work the Poor and for
Women? Empirical Evidence from 2005 Local Government Elections in Pakistan. The Pakistan Development Review. 45 : 4 Part II
pp. 1345–60.
Branton, R. P. Voting in Initiative Elections: Does the context of racial and ethnic diversity matter? State Politics and Policy Quarterly.
2004, 4(3): 294-317
Blais, A., G. Elizabeth and N. Neil. (2004). Where Does Turnout Decline Come From? European Journal of Poitical Research. 43:221-
23.
Branton, R. P. (2004). Voting in Initiative Elections: Does the context of racial and ethnic diversity matter? State Politics and Policy
Quarterly. 2004, 4(3): 294-317
Cohen, K. (2003). Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 85: pp: 808-22
Gallup. P. (2008). Exit poll – Election Day Survey. Election. 2008. Gallup Pakistan in collaboration with PILDAT exclusively for the Daily
Business Recorder and Aaj TV.
GOP. (2011). Government of Pakistan. Election Commission of the Pakistan. Available at this web.
http://www.ecp.gov.pk/ElectionLaws/EligibilityofVoter.aspx Assessed by 02/04/2011
HRCP. (2008). Human right comession of Pakistan. State of human rights: An annual report Lahore, Pakistan.
Jost, J. T. (2006). The end of the end of ideology. American Psychologist. 61: (7). 651-70.
Leighley, E. and J. Nagler. (1992). Individual and Systemic Influences on Turnout: Who Votes? Journal of Politics. 54 :( 3). 718-40.
Lednum, G. (2006). Assess the Importance of Social Class to Voting Behaviour in the U.K. 2006. Available at this sight.
http://lednum.wordpress.com/2006/12/28/assess-the-importance-ofsocial-class-to-voting-behaviour-in-the-uk/
Michelson, M. R. (2005). Does Ethnicity Trump Party? Competing Vote Cues and Latino Voting Behavior. J. Political Marketing. 2005, 4
(4). Available online at http://www.haworthpress.com/web/JPOLM.
PILDAT. (2008). Pakistan Institute of legislative and transparency (PILDAT). A Dispassionate Analysis of How Elections are stolen & will
of the People is Defeated. Islamabad. Pakistan. ISBN 978-969-558-067-7.
Wilder, A. R. (1999). The Pakistani Voter: Electoral Politics and Voting Behavior in the Punjab, Karachi: Oxford University Press. Page.
179.
91

Great War in Transcaucasia: From Ottoman Occupation to the Treaty of Kars
Alessandro Vagnini
Department of History, Culture, Religions

Faculty of Philosophy, Arts, Humanities and Oriental Studies
Sapienza University of Rome,Italy
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.93
Abstract: In October 1914 the Ottoman Empire declared war on the Entente joining the Central Powers. Now the Turks
threatened Russia’s Caucasian provinces and the communications within the British Empire via the Suez Canal but the main
campaign of the Ottoman army would extend from southern Caucasus to eastern Asia Minor. Between 1914 and 1917 the
situation on this front was quite difficult for the Turks, only the collapse of the Russian forces would change this situation. In
November 1917, a first government of an independent Transcaucasia was created in Tbilisi while the Ottomans aiming at
creating their own rule on southern Caucasus launched a new offensive toward Baku. The Russian Revolution and the
capitulation of the Central Powers, however, open the way to the rivalry between Caucasian nationalities which will be solved
only with the arrival of the Soviet forces. Notwithstanding, the conflict between Armenians and Azerbaijani can not find a
definitive solution even if the Treaty of Kars restored at list a stable border between Kemalist Turkey and Bolshevik Russia.
Keywords: Great War, Transcaucasia, Ottoman Empire, Azerbaijan, Russia
1. Background
As a consequence of the assassination of the heir to the Austro-Hungarian throne, Archduke Franz
Ferdinand, in the summer of 1914 Europe was involved in a conflict of immense proportions. On 28 July, the
war opened with the Austro-Hungarian invasion of Serbia, followed by Russian intervention and the chain of
general mobilization. German invasion of Belgium, Luxembourg and northern France followed soon after
(Liddell Hart, 1934). Meanwhile, Russians launched an attack against Germany on the Eastern Front. In mid-
September, after the German march on Paris was brought to a halt, the Western Front settled into a static
battle of attrition over along trench line that changed little until 1917.
On the Eastern Front, the Russian army successfully fought against the Austro-Hungarian forces but was
forced back by the Germans while additional fronts opened after the Ottoman Empire joined the Central
Powers in October 1914; a secret Ottoman-German Alliance having been signed already on August 2, one
day after the German Empire declared war on Russia. It was this binding alliance that ultimately led the
Empire to enter the War on the side of Germany even if some important figures still favored an alliance with
France and Great Britain. The Sultan Mehmed V wanted the Empire to remain neutral; however, pressure
from Germany and the Young Turks led the Empire to align with the Central Powers. As a matter of fact,
Germany had invested heavily in Turkey in previous years and now needed the Ottoman Empire on its side.
The alliance was sustained by many high ranking officials, including Grand Vizier, the Minister of War Enver
Pasha, the Interior Minister Talat, and Head of Parliament Halil Bey (Biagini, 2002; Aksakal, 2008; McMeekin,
2010).
The Ottoman army threatened Russia’s Caucasian provinces and the communications within the British
Empire via the Suez Canal. For this reason, the Allies sought to defeat the Turkish forces as soon as
possible and opened overseas fronts with the Gallipoli and Mesopotamian campaigns. In Gallipoli Peninsula
(Eastern Thrace), where Anzac and French forces had landed in February 1915, after harsh fighting the
Ottomans successfully repelled the enemies. In Mesopotamia, by contrast, after the disastrous siege of Kut
(1915–16), British Imperial forces were able to reorganize and later captured Baghdad in March 1917. In the
93
west, the Suez Canal was successfully defended from Ottoman attacks in 1915 and 1916 and a British
offensive eventually brought to the fall of Palestine in 1917. The Caucasus, however, remained the main
theater of operations for Ottoman forces.1
2. The Caucasus Campaign
The main campaign of the Ottoman army extended from the southern Caucasus to the eastern Asia Minor.
The land warfare was accompanied by small operation of the Russian and Turkish navy in the Black Sea. At
the beginning of the war, the Turks had their Third Army based in the region, while the Russians lined up
their Caucasus Army under the nominal command of the Governor General of the Caucasus with his chief of
staff, General Nikolai Yudenich, as real commander.
On land, Enver Pasha, supreme commander of the Ottoman armed forces, aimed to conquer the Russian
Caucasus and eventually extend Turkish control over the whole central Asia. He launched an offensive in the
region in December 1914 with an army of a strength of about 100,000; however, insisting on a frontal attack
against mountainous Russian positions in winter season, the Turks suffered heavy losses at the battle of
Sarıkamış in December, 1914 (Erickson, 2001, pp. 55-60). After this almost suicidal attack in winter snow,
the Turks who were not already dead, many of them frozen and typhus-ridden, retreated to Erzurum (Allen
and Muratoff, 1953, pp. 249-285).
This brought to a brief standstill. Later on, General Yudenich, which had been given full command of
operations in 1915, launched a series of attacks that drove the Turks out of most of southern Caucasus.2
Hopes of an Ottoman victorious offensive now seemed to be compromised. On February 12, the Turkish
commander Hafiz Hakki Pasha died and was replaced by Mahmut Kamil Pasha in charged with the
reorganization of the army.
In March strategic situation was stable while the Ottoman Third Army received reinforcements, although
these supplements were no stronger than a division. As a matter of fact, the battle of Gallipoli was draining
every Ottoman resource. After small skirmishes, Russians forces kept the towns of Eleşkirt, Ağrı and
Doğubeyazıt in Eastern Anatolia. On April 20, 1915, fighting erupted in the city of Van between Armenians
and Turkish troops until Yudenich began an offensive (Bloxham, 2005).3 The Russians advanced towards
Erzurum. The Ottoman X Corps counter-attacked but they were not able to stop the enemy. On May 17,
Russian forces entered the town of Van and Ottoman forces continued to be pushed back.4 On May 21,
General Yudenich arrived to the city and supported an Armenian provisional government while fighting
shifted farther west for the rest of that summer.
On June 19, the Russian army launched another offensive northwest to Lake Van. However, they
underestimated the size of the Ottoman forces and were surprised by a large counter-attack. Actually,
although the conditions were extremely difficult, the Turks were now ready to face the Russian attacks.
On September 24, 1915, Grand Duke Nicholas was promoted to being charge of all Russian forces in the
Caucasus. Actually, he was removed from being Supreme Commander of the Russian Caucasus Army and
replaced by General Yudenich. The front was quiet from October till the end of the year and Yudenich used

1 For an overall analysis of the Ottoman army in the Great War, see E. Erickson, Ordered to Die: A History of the Ottoman Army in the
First World War, Westport, Connecticut: Greenwood Press, 2001; S. Shaw, The Ottoman Empire in World War I, Ankara: Turkish
Historical Society, 2006.
2 Also British-French operations at Gallipoli helped the Russian forces in the Caucasus front.
3 What happened at Van and the fear of an Armenian betrayal were among the main causes of the violent repression implemented by
the Ottoman authorities against them.

4 Moreover, Turkish supply lines were being cut, as the Armenian rebellions were causing additional difficulties behind the Ottoman lines.
94
this period to reorganize.5 The Ottoman situation was very different. The High Command failed to make up
the losses during the last months while fresh troops had been deployed to Gallipoli and Mesopotamia.
In early January, Yudenich secretly left its winter quarters and marched towards the Ottoman positions at
Erzurum where he achieved total surprise and destroyed an entire Ottoman division at Köprüköy, where
during further fighting both rings of the cities’ defenses had been penetrated. In April, the Russian army
moved from Erzurum and captured Trabzon. Soon after, Erzincan was captured too, while an Ottoman
counter-offensive against Trabzon was halted. Only in August, Mustafa Kemal, asked to organize the
defense in the region, recaptured Mush and Bitlis, while fighting around the east side of Lake Van continued
throughout the summer. However, by the late September, the Ottoman attack ended.
The rest of the year 1916 was spent by the Ottomans with organizational and operational changes in
Eastern Anatolian front. Fortunately for them, the Russians were quiet during this period. Moreover, the
winter of 1916–1917 was extremely harsh, which made fighting nearly impossible. The situation did not
change during the spring of 1917 and Russian plans for a renewed attack never substantiated.
In 1917, Grand Duke Nicholas assumed again command of the Caucasus Front. He appointed much
importance to the logistics and tried to obtain a decisive victory.6 The internal situation in Russia and the
Revolution brought to the collapse of the Russian Caucasus Army. The chaos in the Russian army put a stop
to all military operations. As a matter of fact, the Russian army slowly disintegrated but the Turks could not
take advantage of this situation. It is also true that, considering the condition of Turkish troops, until the
Bolshevik Revolution, Ottoman possible operation in Caucasus could not even be imagined.
However, the situation in Transcaucasia was now completely changed. During the summer, Western
Armenian Administration sponsored a conference to consider emergency measures and adopted plans to
form a militia while in September the Russian army in the region was about to be completely disintegrated.
In November 1917, a first government of an independent Transcaucasia, the Transcaucasian Diet, was
created in Tbilisi. It was headed by Nikolay Chkheidze, a Georgian Menshevik. Hope to organize a common
resistance in the emergency of the moment, however, proved unworkable and indeed such a measure did
not stop the degradation of forces in the region into smaller national entities. Armenia was the main problem
for the stability of the region. The Transcaucasian Diet, indeed, did not stop the degradation of military in the
region into smaller national forces. While sending some representatives to Transcaucasian Diet, at the same
time Armenian nationalists met at Erivan and tried to establish an Armenian Army Corps. They, above all,
had planned to keep their existence supporting the Allies and Russia and to establish their own national army
with Russian support.
Meanwhile, the Ottoman Third Army was protecting a line from Munzur Mountains to the Black Sea. On
December 5, 1917, an armistice was finally signed at Erzincan between the Russians and Ottomans.
However, at the turn of 1918, Allied Powers, Cossacks, Georgians, Pontic Greeks and Armenians were still
willing to build a resistance line against the Turks through gathering in the region. The fertile mind of Enver
Pasha, indeed, was always at work, and he had been watching the situation in the Caucasus over the course
of 1917 (Erickson, 2001, p. 182).7 Not satisfied with simply maintaining the status quo in the Caucasus, Enver
and the Turkish General Staff began to consider the possibilities of a renewed offensive. Now Enver was
seized with the idea of taking the offensive to regain not just the 1914 boundary but also what the Empire had
lost in 1877. The Third Army’s offensive began on February 5. The Ottoman forces moved through east of
the line between Tirebölü and Bitlis. The territories previously lost were now recaptured. The Turks advanced

5 At the turn of 1916, Russian forces reached a level of 200,000 men and 380 pieces of artillery. On the other side, in January 1916,
Ottoman forces were 126,000 men, less than half being combat, and 180 pieces of artillery.
6 Nicholas also planned a railway connecting Georgia to the conquered territories, so that fresh supplies could be brought up for a new
offensive.
7 Moreover, after receiving the reports on the Caucasian situation, Enver invited the refugee leaders of the Azeri Muslims to
Constantinople for discussions on eastward expansion.
95
fast and Kelkit was liberated already on February 7. Until February 22, Erzincan, Bayburt and Tercan were
also taken back. The important Black Sea port of Trabzon fell on February 24.
The Armenian militias, the last forces still on fight, fought to keep the city of Erzurum, but it was captured
by the Ottoman First Caucasian Corps on March 12.
The position of the Ottoman troops along the front had been stabilized. On March 3, the Grand vizier Talat
Pasha signed the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk (Wheeler-Bennett, 1938).8 It stipulated that Bolshevik Russia would
cede Batumi, Kars and Ardahan. It also stipulated that Transcaucasia was to be declared independent.
The actual arrangement of the Transcaucasian front remained, however, still open. On March 14, 1918, the
Trabzon peace conference opened among the Ottoman Empire and the delegation of the Transcaucasian
Diet. It lasted with any result until April. Conscious of the difficulties the Empire and Central Powers, Enver
Pasha offered to surrender all ambitions in the Caucasus in return for recognition of the Ottoman
reacquisition of the East Anatolian provinces at Brest-Litovsk. On April 5, the Transcaucasian delegation
accepted the proposal to use the treaty of Brest-Litovsk as a basis for more negotiations and wired the Diet
urging it to accept this position, but the mood prevailing there was very different. Tiflis had indeed
acknowledged a state of war between Transcaucasia and the Ottoman Empire.
On May 11, a fruitless German-mediated conference opened at Batumi. The Ottomans now extended
their demands to include Tiflis as well as Alexandropol and Echmiadzin, as operational bases to connect
Kars and Julfa with Baku. Thus Armenians and Georgians began to stall.
Beginning on 21 May, Ottoman forces, now renamed the Army of Islam, moved ahead determined to take
by force what was required by diplomatic means to no avail. Enver began to think about the idea of an “Army
of Islam” in July 1918. This new force, with a hard core of Ottoman divisions, would mobilize Muslims in the
Trans-Caspian and Caucasian regions, and would give back the Turks the initiative in the Middle East
(Erickson, 2001, p. 189). In reality, its core was not even a Corps size, numbering between 14,000 and
25,000 men and 40 pieces of artillery. It included the Ottoman 5th Caucasian and 15th divisions and an
Azerbaijani Muslim Corps.9 Since June it was leaded by Nuri Pasha (Enver’s brother).
On May 26, Georgia withdrew from the federation and declared itself a separate republic encouraged by
the German mission and followed by Armenia and Azerbaijan (Swietochowski, 1985). Two days after,
Georgia signed the treaty of Poti with Germany and welcomed a German Caucasus Expedition. With the
government of Azerbaijan moving from Tiflis to Ganja, Germany was concerned about how to see
guaranteed its access to Azerbaijan’s oil. Meanwhile, in Batumi, the Transcaucasian delegation split up and
each of the successor states began negotiating its own conditions of peace.
The Democratic Republic of Azerbaijan was in fact established on May 28, 1918. Germany had in fact
tried in vain to avoid a further worsening of the crisis and facing the new Ottoman advance, now tried to
safeguard its interests in Georgia. In June, the arrival of German military mission in Georgia actually
coincided with a growing German-Ottoman rivalry for Caucasian influence and resources.
On 4 June 1918, Azerbaijan and the Ottoman Empire signed a treaty of friendship and cooperation, which
held that the Turks would provide military assistance to Azerbaijan for maintaining peace and security in the
country (Swietochowski, 1985, p. 130).
On 10 June, the Ottomans confronted a joint German-Georgian force at Vorontsovka. As a consequence
of this clash, Berlin issued an official threat to withdraw troops and support from the Ottoman Empire. It was
the most serious crisis in the Turco-German relations, thus the Turkish government had to concede to
German pressure and to halt, for the moment, a further advance into Georgia. Meanwhile, since 6 June, the
Baku Soviet issued an order to begin offensive operations against the national Azerbaijani base at Ganja.
This offensive was eventually launched on 10 June (Erickson, 2001, p. 133).10 Being unable to defend its

8 The Treaty was signed on 3 March 1918, between the Bolsheviks and the Central Powers, marking Russia’s exit from the war.
9 Most of the soldiers were Ottomans, the army numbered also many Azerbaijani forces and volunteers from Dagestan.
10 It involved the 13,000 man-strong First Caucasian Corps of the Red Army; it should be noted that many of its troops were Armenians.
96
independence, the government of Azerbaijan asked for Ottoman military support. The Bolsheviks achieved
some initial success and by mid-June reached the halfway point between Ganja and Baku. Their advance
was stopped by the Ottomans in the battle fought at Geokchai between June 27 and July 1. Thus the Army of
Islam started advancing towards Baku.
In July, Enver Pasha made new plans ordering an offensive with the goal of taking Baku. This decision
was, however, strongly opposed by the Germans. Enver thus decided to launch his offensive on the
Caucasus, dividing his forces into two separate groups, one to face the British in northern Persia and the
other to strike at Baku through Armenia. This strategy did mean bypassing the main stretch of the
Transcaucasian railway which wound through Tiflis and fitted in well with the Young Turk idea of pan-
Turanianism (McMeekin, 2010, p. 334). The success of an Ottoman offensive indeed could open new
possibilities to a Turkish dominion over the southern Caucasus and eventually Central Asia.11
After the armistice of Erzincan Russian troops mainly had left the front and returned to their homes. Some
Russian forces, about 10,000 troops, still remained in Persian Azerbaijan and where supplanted by British
liaison officers. In 1918, the British also organized a force under the command of General Lionel Dunsterville
at Baghdad. Their goal was to reach Caucasus via Persia in order to organize an army with Armenians and
other pro-Ally elements. As a matter of fact, since January 1918, the British had become quite concerned
about Turkish inroads into the Caucasus and on 27 January, Dunsterville was ordered to keep the Caucasus-
Tabriz front intact and put a stop to Enver’s plans.
By mid-June 1918, the Ottoman army began a renewed advance eastward, proceeding along a twin axis
of approach toward the city of Baku. The first wing pushed east along the Akstafa-Baku road, the other one
along the railroad leading to Alyat on the Caspian coast south of the Azerbaijani capital (Erickson, 2001, p.
187). The Ottoman advance led to a series of battles at Sardarapat, Kara Killisse and the Bash Abaran. The
defeat of the Red Army at Geokchai and Ottoman subsequent counteroffensive brought to a head the long-
simmering political crisis in Baku. With Russia unable to provide any meaningful aid to the Commune, the city
increasingly suffered from hunger and was ill prepared for defence (Swietochowski, 1985, pp. 136-137).12 In
Berlin, the Soviet Ambassador Joffe, was begging the Germans to stop the Turks form attacking Baku.
Germany agreed so long as the Bolsheviks would guarantee them free access to Caspian oil production.
Thus Moscow also negotiated a supplement to Brest-Litovsk treaty accepting Georgian independence under
German protection and in exchange for keeping the Turks out of Transcaucasia, to give Germany a quarter
of Baku’s oil production. An agreement to that effect was eventually reached on 27 August (McMeekin, 2010,
p. 336).
The Bolshevik forces around Baku had about 6,000 man of the Baku Army. The vast majority of them
were Armenians and Russians. However, these few troops were not adequate to thwart a possible Turkish
attack. They counterattacked the advancing Ottoman columns and attempted to establish a defensive line at
Kurdamir. However, these forces were pushed onward towards Baku. By the 27 of July the Turks had
advanced to the high ground overlooking the city (Erickson, 2001, p. 189). Therefore, those in Baku who
were neither Bolsheviks nor Muslims began to agitate for inviting a British Expeditionary Force. On 26 July
1918, a coup overthrew the Bolsheviks in Baku establishing a Central Caspian Dictatorship (Swietochowski,
1985, pp. 137-138). Meanwhile, the avant-garde of the Army of Islam had reached the heights above Baku.
With the Turks camped out of Baku, the Armenian-dominated Soviet of the city decided to vote to invite the
British troops of General Dunsterville, then stationing near the Caspian coast of northern Persia, to save
them.13 These troops were ready to move and the main body of Dunsterforce began to debark in Baku on

11 In 1918, Enver himself encouraged the Ottoman media to promote pan-Turanianism, aiming to create a series of “Turkish” buffer
states in which to expand the Empire’s influence.

12 Actually, since the formation of the Baku Sovnarkom in April 1918, the city and its environs had lived under the rule of a de facto
Commune.
13 Worried by the threat to the Baku oil fields, the British General Staff began to send reinforcements to Dunsterville in June 1918.
97
August 20 (Erickson, 2001, p. 191). Actually, in Baku the Soviet was now cooperating with imperialists, both
interested in stopping any Turkish, or German, treat to Azerbaijan and beyond, to Persia and India.
Failing their aim to close the gap to the sea and create a strongly defensible line for Baku, from one end of
the Apsheron Peninsula to the other. The remnants of the British-Baku force retired to a line slightly north of
Diga. Clashes continued in mid-August and September. On 26 August, the Army of Islam launched its main
attack. Despite a shortage of artillery, British and Baku troops held their positions. However, faced with
increased artillery fire, they retired to the railway line. Later on, the Turks shelled the city heavily and attacked
the Binagadi Hill position. It was certainly very good results and the city seemed within reach of the Turkish
vanguard. However, Ottoman losses were so heavy that they were not immediately able to continue the
offensive. This gave the Baku Army time to reorganize but all hope of resistance seemed futile.
Faced with an ever worsening situation, Dunsterville organized a meeting with the Centro-Caspian
Dictators arguing that he was not willing to risk more British lives and hinted at his withdrawal. However, the
dictators protested and the British General eventually decided to stay until the very end. On the night of
September 13, the Turks began their last attacks. They nearly overran the strategic Wolf’s Gate west of
Baku. The fighting continued for the rest of the day and the situation eventually became hopeless. By the
night of the 14th, the remnants of the Baku Army and British forces left the city. Dunsterville ordered the
evacuation of the city that very day after six weeks of occupation and withdrew to Iran.14 With the withdrawal
of the British, chaos broke out amongst the defenders of Baku and the refugee Armenians. Throughout the
night, as the Turks drove in the remaining defences, fires, pillaging and massacre broke out in the city
(Erickson, 2001, p. 192). The Ottomans and their Azeri allies, led by Nuri Pasha, finally entered Baku on 15
September and slaughtered some thousands Armenians in retaliation for the March massacre of Muslims at
the hands of the Soviet-Armenian bands (McMeekin, 2010, p. 336).
The result of these fights was anyway inevitable. As a matter of fact, British forces were not strong enough
to stop the Turks. Ottoman troops threw the British out of Azerbaijan in September 1918, when the British
commander, general Dunsterville, ordered the evacuation of the city, after only six weeks of occupation, and
withdrew to Persia.
By the end of the war, the Ottoman Empire, although it lost Sinai, Palestine and Mesopotamia, had re-
captured all the territory which lost to the Russians in eastern Anatolia and occupied most of southern
Caucasus and especially of Azerbaijan. However, the Great War drew to a close, on October 30, 1918, the
Armistice of Mudros was signed and the Caucasus Campaign ended as well. As a matter of fact, the capture
of Baku proved to be a meaningless victory for the Ottoman Empire.
3. Ottoman withdrawal and the Turkish National Forces
The armistice of Mudros created many doubts on the future of the Ottoman troops in Transcaucasia. The
pan-Turanian dreams seemed long gone. However, in Baku, Nuri Pasha authorized his soldiers to join the
Azerbaijani Army. Soon after, General Thomson, who had succeeded Dunsterville in the British North
Persian Force, ordered that all Ottoman units must leave Baku in one week and Transcaucasia within a
month (Swietochowski, 1985, pp. 140-141). The Turks were forced to leave all their gains in the region going
back to the 1914 borders.
In fact, the retreat of the Ottoman troops from the Caucasus took place at a certain speed, but the vacuum
left by the Turks was soon followed by a series of clashes between different nationalities. As a matter of fact,
a border war between Georgia and Armenia broke out already in December 1918 over the parts of the then-
disputed districts of Lori, Borchalo and Javakheti, previously occupied by Ottoman forces. Not surprisingly, a
brief Georgian-Armenian war soon followed. The conflicts involved many civilians in the disputed areas,

14 Most of the Armenian population of the city escaped with British forces.
98
moreover, guerrilla operations were the main reasons for high civilian casualties. Skirmishes continued until
December 31 when a British brokered ceasefire was signed. Moreover, after the Turks began to withdraw
their forces, Armenians seized Nagorno-Karabakh to create a base for further expansion westward into
Nakhchevan; in doing so they created the conditions for further violence.
In Anatolia the situation was even worse. After Ottoman surrender the situation in the Empire became
extremely difficult, with England, France, Italy and specially Greece aiming to impose their control over the
country. The Turks had now to live Transcaucasia, while a harsh Greco-Turkish war in Asia Minor would
eventually follow after the organization of armed resistance by nationalist forces under the leadership of
Mustafa Kemal. It lasted until autumn of 1923. As a result of the disastrous defeat of Greek army, on 15
October 1923, the last Allied troops left Constantinople with the official birth of the Turkish Republic taking
place two weeks after (Vagnini, 2011).
In this period for the Turkish nationalists fighting their war of independence was essential to achieve a
favorable arrangement of the Southern Caucasus too, where the presence of Armenian bands was a
constant threat to the integrity of Turkey. Not surprisingly, relations between Ankara and the Government of
the Democratic Republic of Azerbaijan, as well as those with Bolshevik Russia, were especially good since
both countries were interested in containing and eventually remove the Armenian threat.
4. The Conflict between Azerbaijan and Armenia
By October 1918, German and Turkish troops in the Caucasus had been substituted by those of the Entente.
Control of Azerbaijan was strategically important for the British and consequently, headed by General W.
Thomson, who had declared himself the military governor of Baku, about 1,000 Commonwealth soldiers
arrived in Baku on November 17. By General Thomson’s order, martial law was implemented in the city.
British involvement during this period also extended into some branches of the civilian administration and
British officers occasionally intervened in the routine business of local authorities (Swietochowski, 1985, p.
144). Actually their main goal was to extend control over the oil fields.
Notwithstanding, the situation was not yet stabilized and the various nationalisms had already set in
motion. The Armenians in particular wanted to ensure international recognition for their state after that
already in March, ethnic and religious tensions had grew in Baku when Musavat and Committee of Union and
Progress had been accused of Pan-Turkism by Bolsheviks and their allies. Therefore, between March and
April 1918, southern Caucasus witnessed an inter-ethnic warfare and the massacre of up to 12,000
Azerbaijanis by the Bolsheviks and other armed Armenian units in the city of Baku and other locations in its
Governorate. There were many disputed territories on which the Armenians tried to establish themselves
against the Azerbaijani.15 Actually, it was question of a series of brutal conflicts that took place in 1918 and
then again from 1920 to 1922. Fighting involved civilians in the disputed districts of Kazakh-Shamshadin,
Zanghezur, Nakhchevan and Karabakh. As a matter of fact, beginning with 1918, a Republic of Mountainous
Armenia was declared in the area of Karabakh, with its government trying several times to seize Shusha
militarily but the Ottoman troops had prevented the realization of the Armenian nationalist’s dream. Only after
the Turkish withdrawal, Armenians seized Nagorno-Karabakh. Meanwhile, the British military command gave
the assurances to Armenians that the conflict would be solved with the Paris Peace Conference.
The role of British forces stationed in Azerbaijan was still important, but whatever British greed for the
wealth of Baku might have been, whatever the profits from Azerbaijani oil, they were not sufficiently strong to
compel London to forego its priorities, which lay elsewhere; in Egypt and India. Actually, British government
had decided as early as February 1919 to evacuate Transcaucasia as soon as possible. Thus, at the
beginning of April the Supreme Allied Council proposed that Transcaucasia, or at least Georgia, be placed

15It should be remembered that the first clashes between Armenians and Azeris had took place in Baku in February 1905 and lasted
until August.
99
under Italian occupation. Rome initially agreed to a mandate over the region. Anyway, the involvement of
Italy proved to be purely exploratory in character. Italy’s interest in Transcaucasia, indeed, failed to survive
the next change of cabinet in Rome (Sale, 2007).
During autumn of 1919 a dramatic turn in the Russian Civil War took place as the White Army bit off more
than it could in its drive on Moscow. At this juncture, Transcaucasia again came to the attention of the
statesmen in Versailles. In fact, in January 1920 Allied General Staffs were discussing the defence needs of
Azerbaijan and Georgia with their delegations in Paris (Swietochowski, 1985, p. 159). 16 Discussions,
however, that did not lead to any concrete decision.
In winter of 1920, London had begun a definite reappraisal of its Russian policy. Rather than continue the
unpopular and costly involvement in the Russian Civil War, the British government now considered moves
toward coming to terms with the Bolsheviks. It was in fact the prelude to final abandonment of Transcaucasia.
The situation in Southern Caucasus continued to be extremely tense and in spring 1920 major ethnic clashes
took place in Shusha. In those days, the Azerbaijan Democratic Republic was in a very troubled situation,
facing both Armenian and Bolshevik threat (Swietochowski, 1985, pp. 152-153).17 Rumors that the Red Army
was about to cross the border and invade Azerbaijan were particularly alarming. In this confused situation,
undoubtedly, Russia was a destabilizing factor. While allowing the possibility of a temporary compromise with
Armenia and Georgia, with which the Bolshevik Russia concluded bilateral treaties in fact, Moscow refused,
even in theory, any formal recognition of the independence of Azerbaijan. As a matter of fact, Russia
maintained a constant political and military pressure on Azerbaijan, trying to undermine its internal stability
thanks to the support of local Communist activists.
Actually, in the post-Great War Caucasus occurred three main events: fight for Karabakh, in early 1920;
Sovietization of Azerbaijan, in April 1920; Soviet invasion of Georgia on 25 February 1921.
While the Azerbaijani government and its army were in chaos, the Armenian militias used the opportunity
to assert their control over parts of Azerbaijani territory. The Red Army takeover in April-May 1920 resolved
the conflict between Azerbaijan and Armenia.
Faced with the Red Army, the Azerbaijani government officially surrendered, but local militias kept
resisting the advance of Soviet troops; so it took a while for the Soviets to stabilize their newly-proclaimed
Azerbaijan Soviet Socialist Republic. In the meantime, a Communist coup in Armenia failed.
While Azerbaijan was in chaos, the Armenian militias used the opportunity to assert their control over
parts of disputed territory, occupying Shusha and Khankendi. Actually, by the end of April the Armenians
were in control of most of western Azerbaijan including all of Karabakh, Nakhchevan and much of Kazakh-
Shamshadin district.
The definitive establishment of the Bolshevik regime in Azerbaijan therefore had an important ideological
and strategic value. Russia thus supported the expansion of communist ideology beyond its borders and
created a privileged base for propaganda in the direction of the Middle East and Central Asia. A key factor in
the fate of the Democratic Republic of Azerbaijan was the community of interest between Bolshevik Russia
and Turkey, both interested in obtaining accommodation in the Transcaucasian region favorable to their
interests.
In September 1920 Armenia was also engaged in a bitter war on another front against Turkish national
forces, particularly costly for the poor Armenian forces. In late November, there was a new Soviet-backed
Communist uprising in Armenia. On November 28, 1920 the Red Army crossed the demarcation line between
Democratic Republic of Armenia and Azerbaijan. Fighting lasted only a week and marked the final conquest
of Armenia by the Soviet Union.

16 The only tangible outcome of these talks was the de facto recognition of the two republics by the Supreme Allied Council on January
12 (Georgia) and on January 19 (Armenia).
17 Actually, relationship with the White Russian forces was also quite troubled.
100
The subsequent Soviet invasion of Georgia in 1921 would have put an end to the brief independence of
southern Caucasus.
5. The Treaty of Kars
The collaboration between Bolshevik Russia and Turkish nationalists had a decisive role in the arrangement
of the southern Caucasus. This collaboration was manifested through weapons and material from Moscow,
while on a political level the main result proved to be the elimination of the Armenian state. Harsh fighting
against the Turks in autumn 1920 had stripped Armenia of most of its south-western territories, including
Kars and Alexandropol. Armenian forces were now exhausted, even if in fact the Turks were unable to
completely defeat them and agreed to sign a cease-fire. Problems for Armenia, however, were not finished.
On November 28, 1920, blaming Armenia for the invasions of Sharur and Karabakh the Red Army occupied
the country.
The Treaty of Kars would be the ultimate solution to the issue of Caucasians borders, confirming the
Soviet control over the Transcaucasian republics and safeguarding the interests of Turkish nationalists. After
an initial agreement reached in Moscow in March 1921, it was signed in Kars on October 13, 1921, and
ratified in Yerevan on September 11, 1922. Signatories included representatives from the Grand National
Assembly of Turkey, which in 1923 would declare the Republic of Turkey, and also from Soviet Armenia,
Soviet Azerbaijan and Soviet Georgia all of which formed part of the Soviet Union after December 1922.
The treaty provided for the territory of the former Russian Batumi District of the Kars Governorate to be
divided. The northern half, with the port city of Batumi, was attached to Georgia, while Nakhchivan went to
Armenia. The southern half would be annexed by Turkey. It was agreed that the northern half would be
granted autonomy within Soviet Georgia. It eventually evolved into the Adjar Autonomous Soviet Socialist
Republic. Additionally, Turkey was also guaranteed the use of the port of Batumi without special charges.
The treaty also created a new boundary between Turkey and Soviet Armenia, defined by the Akhurian
and Aras rivers. Turkey obtained from Armenia most of the former Kars Governatorate, with Mount Ararat
and the cities of Kars, Ardahan and Oltu. Most of these areas were anyway already under Turkish military
control. The treaty required also Turkish troops to withdraw from other areas under their occupation. It was
also specified the partition of Nakhchivan as an autonomous territory under the protection of Azerbaijan.18
Both Turkey and Russia would become guarantors of Nakhchivan’s status.
6. Conclusions
The analysis of the situation in Transcaucasia during the final stages of Great War and between 1919 and
1921 seems to be extremely complex. The opposing nationalism and a long series of clashes, in which the
interference of the great powers has been very strong, in fact, affected the region until the final Soviet
takeover. In fact, national rivalries in Transcaucasia cannot seem to have any peaceful solution. Neither the
brief Ottoman occupation, nor the weak British presence proved able to stabilize the region. The conflict
between Georgia and Armenia was difficult to solve, the one between Azerbaijan and Armenia was indeed
impossible. By 1920 the only possible solution of these disputes could come either by military victory or by
the imposition from above of an imperial power. None of the national forces, however, was powerful enough
to win a decisive victory and after the British failed miserably to impose a settlement, the arbiters of the
situation turned out to be the Bolsheviks. The Red Army occupied Azerbaijan and Armenia in May and
November 1920 and eventually invaded Georgia in 1921. The Treaty of Kars would officially put an end to
this troubled period of Transcaucasian history.

18 In 1924, the region became the Nakhchivan Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic, an exclave subordinate to Azerbaijan.
101
References
Liddell Hart B.H., A History of the World War (1914–1918), 2nd ed., London: Faber & Faber, 1934
Wheeler-Bennett J., Brest-Litovsk: The Forgotten Peace, March 1918, London: Macmillan, 1938
Kazemzadeh F., The Struggle for Transcaucasia, 1917-1921, New York: Philosophical Library, 1951
Allen W.E.D. and Muratoff P., Caucasian battlefields. A History of the Wars on the Turco-Caucasian Border, 1828-1921, Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, 1953
Pipes R., The Formation of the Soviet Union, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1964
Swietochowski T., Russian Azerbaijan 1905-1920. The Shaping of a National Identity in a Muslim Community, Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press, 1985
Turner J., British Politics and the Great War, Coalition and Conflict, 1915-1918, London: Yale University Press, 1992
Swietochowski T., Russia and Azerbaijan: A Borderland in Transition, New York: Columbia University Press, 1995
Erickson E., Ordered to Die: A History of the Ottoman Army in the First World War, Westport, Connecticut: Greenwood Press, 2001
Biagini A., Storia della Turchia contemporanea, Milano: Bompiani, 2002
Bloxham D., The Great game of Genocide: Imperialism, Nationalism and the Destruction of the Ottoman Armenians, Oxford: Oxford
University Press, 2005
Shaw S., The Ottoman Empire in World War I, Ankara: Turkish Historical Society, 2006
Sale I., La missione militare italiana in Transcaucasia: 1919-1920, Roma: AUSSME - Ufficio Storico, 2007
Faroqhi S., L’Impero ottomano, Bologna: il Mulino, 2008
Aksakal M., The Ottoman Road to War in 1914, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2008
McMeekin S., The Berlin-Baghdad Express. The Ottoman Empire and Germany’s bid for World Power, Cambridge: Harvard University
Press, 2010
Vagnini A., Italia, Turchia e il Mediterraneo orientale, Roma: Nuova Cultura, 2011
102
Determinants and Motivators of Dividend Policy: A Study of Cement Industry of Pakistan
Talat Islam
Ph.D. Scholar, Faculty of Management and Human Resource Development,

Universiti Teknologi Malaysia, Johor Campus, Malaysia
Muhammad Aamir
Lecturer, Hailey College of Commerce, University of the Punjab, Lahore, Pakistan

Ashfaq Ahmad
Assistant Professor, Govt. MAO College Lahore, Pakistan

Muhammad Saeed
Lecturer, Govt. MAO College Lahore, Pakistan

Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.103
Abstract: Dividend is one of the most debatable topics for the researchers. Many researchers explore the factors of dividend
policy. The aim of the study is to find out the factors that motivate the dividend policy among the cement industry. For the
purpose data of eight firms was collected from Karachi Stock exchange and State bank of Pakistan. SPSS 17 was used to
analyze the data and it was found that PE ratio, EPS growth and sale growth are positively associated with the dividend payout
while profitability and debt to equity were found to have negative association with dividend payout.
Key words: Dividend policies; Determinants of dividend; Dividend payout; Cement industry;
1. Introduction
Dividend policy is one of the most researchable topics for the finance researchers. Numerous researchers
have studied on this topic to give the answer that whether companies should pay dividend to its shareholders
or not?. Many of them have developed different models to explain the dividend behavior (Baker & Powell,
1999) and some of them have surveyed personally to the top executives of the multinational organizations to
determine their views about the dividend (Baker, Veit & Powell, 2001). Despite extensive research of the
researchers, motivation for paying dividend is still a question mark (Baker & Powell, 1999).
Dividend plays a vital role in traditional stock valuation model, and motivation for dividend could betterly
be understood after understanding this stock valuation model. In such dividend models, stocks have value
because they hold future cash payouts. Dividend represent s the primary payments in the form of cash to the
shareholders of the organization, and the value of the stockholder’s share will be greater as there will be
greater expected future flow of dividends (Carlson, 2001).
Researchers have found controversial results regarding dividends impact on the shareholders wealth.
Some researchers argued that dividend and shareholders wealth are directly related i.e. dividend increase
the shareholders wealth (Gordon, 1959), some believed that dividend are irrelevant with the shareholders
103
wealth (Miller & Scholes, 1978), and some argued that dividend and shareholder’s wealth are inversely
related i.e. dividend decreases the shareholder’s wealth (Litzenberger & Ramaswamy, 1979).
The purpose of this study is to find out all the factors that motivate the dividend decisions. Simply dividend
policy is the determination that what portion of the earning should be kept by the firms for their further
investment and what portion should be distributed among the shareholders of the firm.
2. Literature review
2.1 Dividend Signal future success
Investors psychologically prefer to invest in those companies whose dividend stream is constant and positive.
This favorable behavior of the investors and the dividend policy suggests the value of the dividends. The
management’s choice of rising or declining the yield of dividends does not impact the value of the firm. Thus,
these changes have impact on the stock prices of the company in the markets.
Constant dividends are the indicator of company’s present and future success and this also increase the
company’s market creditability and reduces the risk level from the investor’s point of view. Stability in the
dividends eliminates the poor market valuation of the firm from the investors and on the other side decline in
the dividend results decrease in the firm’s stock price. Thus the decrease in the firm’s stock price is the
result of decline in the dividend (Shapiro 537).
In summing up managements should maximize the shareholders value, and dividends work to accomplish
this task that firm should not offer dividends at that point where they reject the investment with positive net
present value. Droms (1990) argued that dividends are necessary for the prosperity of the firm in present as
well as in future and normally a company’s prosperity leads to dividend yield and this also increases the
value of the stock.
2.2 Dividend Theories
The literature explains four dividend theories i.e.
2.2.1 Pure residual dividend policy
This policy states that when the firms return on equity capital exceeds then the rate of return, the investors
could reinvest those dividends in another equallent risk’s investment. Firm could reinvest the dividends on the
behalf of investors rather than issuing the dividends. The firm determines the best option available to benefit
the investors after determining its budget (Droms 218). Thus dividends are a function of fluctuations in
earning of the firm. This policy results change in dividend from year to year and equity finance must be
commenced to create a left over when the equity investment is greater than earning (Droms, 1990).
2.2.2 Smoothed residual dividend policy
This theory explains that dividend fluctuations are kept to a minimum level. According to Shapiro “Dividends
are set equal to the long-run residual between forecasted earnings and investment requirements. Dividend
changes, in turn, are made only when this long run residual is expected to change; earning fluctuations
believed to be temporary are ignored in setting dividend payments. The clear preference is for a stable, but
increasing, dividend per share” (Shapiro 532-533). Thus if earnings are low then dividends exceed the
residual.
104
2.2.3 Constant Payout Residual Dividend Policy
This theory of dividend is very simple and this suggests maintaining a constant dividends payout ratio
because this tends dividends to fluctuate directly with the earnings of the firm ( Kania & Bacon,2005).
2.2.4 Small Quarterly Dividend with Annual Bonus
This theory suggests dividends to the investors only when the earning explains the expectations and
according to this theory dividends are given to the investors periodically along with the annual bonus. Usually
large scale firms work with this policy as they earn beyond their expectations. This policy is benefited to both
the management (they have flexibility in earning) and to the investors (they get guaranteed dividend) ( Kania
& Bacon,2005).
2.3 Related Studies
Primarily dividends are based on the net income level of the organization and gradually adjusted to the
change in income level. Literature shows that increase in the tax rate encourages corporate savings in the
form of dividends. This is because retained earnings are not taxed without delay as compared to dividends.
Capital gain is paid by the stock holders at the time of the sale of their stocks (Lintner, 1956). In addition to
Lintner, Malkiel (1999) found that long term capital gain reduces the tax to a maximum of 20% and upper
level tax rate on the dividends is 39.6%.
According to Baker and Powell (1999) dividends policy affect the firm’s value. According to (Malkiel,
1999) cash dividends convey about the future profitability of the firm. Survey indicates that most of the big
invertors use to announce dividends to know about the to access the firm’s stock prices. For example steep
drop in the company’s dividends indicate bad about the future of the firm. Respondents were also uncertain
about the bird in hand theory of the dividend. This theory indicates that high yield of dividends higher will be
the firms value. Dividend represents increase in the share price of the firm because dividends are slightly
less risky as compared to capital gain. A firms continuity in dividend suggests stability and consistent growth
of the firm and this give investors confidence to invest in that firms stocks.
Hexter, Langrehr, and Holder (1998), found that there is negative correlation between corporate focus
and the dividend payout ratio. This means that more corporate focus will reduces the dividend payout ratio of
the firm. Smaller firms tend to have low dividend payout ratio as compared to the larger firms because they
are corporate focused. It is also found that insider ownership and dividend payout ratios are inversely related
to each other i.e. higher the insider ownership of the firm reduces its dividend payout ratio. Larger the number
of shareholders and the greater cash flow leads to the greater dividend payout ratios.
Lazo's survey (1999) argued that most of the dividend paying companies (almost 87%) are of the view
that dividends signal the future earning of the organization. On the other side of the same findings 93% of the
respondents were of the view that stock buyback program is more effective as raising the dividends of the
company.
Carlson (2001) has discussed few variables that affect the dividend decisions. Stock repurchase only
explains a small part of the decline in dividend yield. Increase in the retained earnings and investment might
also be the reason of the decline in the dividend yield. According to him the third reason for the decline in the
dividend yield might be the rapid acceleration of stock prices. In crux if the stock prices of the organization
accelerate then the dividend yield declines.
Kumar and Lee (2001) studied the determinants of dividend smoothing. Dividend smoothing is the
method of choreography the time profile of earnings. He concluded that constant dividend payments do not
disappoint the shareholders of the organization. While bankrupt, return on capital and investment have
impact on the dividend policy.
105
2.4 Justification of variables
Banerjee, Gatchev & Spindt (2002), argued that there is inverse relation between shares turnover and
dividend payout i.e. firms having lower share turnover are more likely to pay the dividends and vice versa.
External financing is greater needed by the highly growth firms. Thus, most of the companies have
established good reputation among the shareholders. Firms increase their reputation by issuing the dividends
(LaPorta, Silanes, Schliefer & Vishny, 2000). We measure the growth with the estimated five years sale
growth rate of the firm.
H1: sale growth is positively associated with dividend payout.
Higher stock price and higher price earning ratio (PE) leads to high dividend payout. In crux future cash flows
can be secured by increasing the dividends which results increase the PE ratio and stock price. Puckett
(1964), argued that a dollar given as dividend has almost four times greater impact on the stock price of the
firm as compared to the retained earnings. High price earnings may be associated with the less risk and high
dividend payout ratios, while low price earnings may be associated with the high or more risks and low
dividend payout ratios. Thus,
H2: Price to earnings ratio is positively associated with dividend payout.
DeAngelo, DeAngelo, and Skinner (1992), argued that current income is another determinant of the dividend
payout. Because most of the managers reduce their dividends when their earnings are poor and increase
dividends when current earnings are better. This suggests that dividends are related to the earnings of the
firm. However it is also reasonable to accept that all the all the firms with low income does not reduce
dividends. We measure current earnings with earnings per share growth for the last five years. Thus,
H3: Last five years earning per share growth is positively associated with dividend payout.
Usually the firms with the huge profits likely to pay more dividends to its stock holders (Banerjee, Gatchev &
Spindt, 2002). According to Lintner (1956) firms are traditional in their policies, as a result their dividend
payout activity is characterized by degree of inertia. Moreover all the companies which are uncertain about
their future profits, likely to hedge the risks by paying low dividend payouts (Friend & Puckett, 1964).
Corporate dividend policy usually change with the change in its past profits, current profits and expected
future profits (Darling, 1957). In the present study profitability is measured as the ratio of net income to
equity. Thus
H4: There is negative association between profitability and dividend payout.
All the companies having high cash flows are less likely to cut off their dividends, and on the other hand high
leverage increase the chances to cut the dividends. Such companies should not borrow more from the
external parties to increase their debt financing; they should invest more to increase their equity financing
(Benito & Young, 2001). High rate of retention are associated with heavy external financing. According to
Friend & Puckett, (1964) rate of retention is positively associated with the external financing. Therefore higher
the retention rate, the lower the dividend payout. Level of external financing is measured with debt to equity
ratio. Hence
H5 : Debt to equity ratio is negatively associated with dividend payout.
106
3. Methodology
To select the determinants of decision making policy, all the listed companies with the web of Karachi Stock
Exchange (www.kse.com.pk) were selected as population. There are 661 companies registered with the web
of Karachi Stock Exchange according to the year 2009. Twenty one among the registered companies are
belonging to the cement industry. Out of which 2 companies have been declared as defaulter by the state
bank of Pakistan, so there are 19 registered working cement companies. Out of these 19 companies eight
were chosen for analysis as sample on the basis of simple random sampling technique. Data was collected
from the web of state bank of Pakistan and Karachi stock exchange from 2004-2009. To analyze the
determinants of selected companies (OLS) ordinary Least Square regression was applied. We imperially test
the independent variables on the firm’s dividend payout ratio. Thus,
Dividend Decision (dividend payout) = f (profitability, price to earning ration, debt to equity ratio and estimated
five years growth sale)
Table 1 : Variables and Hypothesis Supported by the Literature
Hypothesis
Factor Definition Sign
Dependent
Dividend payout ratio Dividend / EPS variable
Profitability Net income / equity Negative
Price to earnings ratio Market value/ earnings per share Positive
Debt to equity ratio Long term debts/ equity Negative
Five years EPS growth Five years EPS growth Positive
Five years growth sale 5 years growth rate Positive
4. Data Analysis and Discussion
Table 2: Regression Results
Variables BETA Coefficient Hypothesized Sign P Value

Profitability -2.29 Negative 0.00
PE Ratio 0.189 Positive 0.21
Debt to Equity ratio -2.33 Negative 0.34
EPS growth 0.048 Positive 0.004
Sales growth 0.294 Positive 0.09
R = 0.317
R Square = 0.100
N= 48
The results of regression are shown in the table 2; the value of R square of the table is 10%. This indicates
that 10% of the change in dividend payout is due to the explained variables. From the early studies these
variables were found to have 25-30% change in the dividend payouts but, those studies were conducted on
the textile sector of European countries while the present study shows the results of cement sector of
Pakistan. The results of the table also revealed that profitability is negatively related to the dividend payout at
a significant level of 1%. Similarly debt to equity ratio is also negatively related with the dividend payout as
was hypothesized. The results indicate a positive relationship of price earning ratio, earning per share growth
and sales growth with the dividend payout. As observed earlier that high dividend payout is associated with
107
the high price to earning ratio. Raising the amount of dividend reduces the future risks and this increases PE
and stock price as well. Furthermore it was also found in literature that high growth firms need more external
financing and for this they try to increase their good will among the external parties to attract them for more
equity through higher dividend payout (LaPorta et al., 2000).
4.1 Limitation and direction for future studies
This present study was an attempt to find the determinants of dividend policy among the cement industries of
Pakistan. In future other sectors (i.e. textile, automobile etc.) should be kept in mind. In the present study only
five explained variables were selected other factors (i.e. current ratio, leverage etc.) also been explored by
the future researchers.
5. Conclusion
The aim of this study was to find out the factors of dividend policy among cement sector of Pakistan. To
analyze the factors a sample of eight cement companies (2004-2009) was taken from the web of Karachi
Stock Exchange and State Bank of Pakistan. It was found that higher the PE of an organization, lower the
risks and higher is its dividend payout ratio. Similarly earning per share growth and sale growth also leads to
dividend payout.
References
Baker, H. K. & G.E. Powell. (1999). How Corporate Managers View Dividend Policy. Quarterly Journal of Business and Economics.
Lincoln, (Spring).
Baker, H. K., E. T. Veit & G. E. Powell. (2001). Factors Influencing Dividend Policy Decisions of Nasdaq Firms. The Financial Review,
Eastern Finance Association, (August).
Banerjee, S., V. Gatchev & P. Spindt. (2002). To Pay or Not to Pay? The Dividend Dilemma of the Liquid Firm. Working paper, Tulane
University, New Orleans, Louisiana, November.
Benito, A. & G. Young. (2001), Hard Times or Great Expectations? Dividend Omissions and Dividend Cuts by UK Firms, Working Paper,
Bank of England, London.
Carlson, J. B. (2001). Why is the Dividend Yield so Low? Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland. Economic Commentary, (April).
Darling, P. G (1957). The Influence of Expectations and Liquidity on Dividend Policy, Journal of Political Economy, 65(3), (June), 209-
224.
DeAngelo, H., L. DeAngelo & D. Skinner. (1992). Dividends and Losses, The Journal of Finance, 47(5), Dec, 1837-1863.
Droms, William G. (1990). Finance and Accounting for Nonfinancial Managers: Third Edition.
Friend, I. & M. Puckett. (1964). Dividends and Stock Prices, The American Economic Review, 54(5), Sept, 656-682.
Gordon, M.J. (1959). Dividends, Earnings and Stock Prices, Review of Economics and Statistics May, 99-105.
Hexter, L., M.E. Holder & F. W. Langrehr. (1998). Dividend Policy Determinants: An Investigation of the Influences of Stakeholder
Theory. Financial Management. (Autumn).
Kumar, P. & B.S.Lee. (2001). Discrete Dividend Policy with Permanent Earnings. Financial Management. Tampa. (Autumn).
Kania, S.L., Bacon, F.W., (2005). What factors motivate the corporate dividend decision?, American Society of Business and Behavioral
Sciences, 1(1), 95-107.
LaPorta, R., F. Lopez-de-Silanes, A. Schliefer & R. Vishny. (2000). Agency Problems and Dividend Policies Around the World, Journal of
Finance, 55(1), February, 1-34.
Lazo, S. (1999). Speaking of Dividends: How do Corporate Leaders See Payouts? Barron's. Chicopee. (January).
Lintner, J. (1956). Distribution of Incomes of Corporations Among Dividends, Retained Earnings, and Taxes, American Economic
Review, 46(2), (May), 97-113.
Litzenberger, R. H. & K. Ramaswamy. (1979), The Effect of Personal Taxes and Dividends on Capital Asset Prices: Theory and
Empirical Evidence, Journal of Financial Economics (June) 163-195.
Malkiel, B. G. (1999). A Random Walk Down Wall Street, New York: W.W. Norton and Company Massachusetts: Addison-Wesley
Publishing.
Miller M.H. & M.S. Scholes. (1978). Dividends an Taxes, Journal of Financial Economics (December), 333-364.
Shapiro, Alan C. (1990). Modern Corporate Finance. New York: Macmillan Publishing Co.
108
A View on the Customs and the Constitutional Conventions as Subsidiary

Sources of the Constitutional Law
Mr.sc. Blerton Sinani
Teaching Assistant of the Faculty of Law, SEEU University, Tetova, Macedonia

E mail: [email protected]
Management Department, Economy Faculty, Tirana, Albania,

Dean of graduated school, University of Vlora Albania
Guest Professor in Law Faculty, SEEU University, Tetova Macedonia
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.109
Abstract The aim of this research article is “developing the topic” which is being analyzed. The treated issues in this research
article, with constitutional – juridical thematic, lay and focus in analyzing the customs and the constitutional conventions as
subsidiary sources of the constitutional law, as a branch of the law, it presents illustrative and concrete examples from the
practice of the comparative constitutional law. This article shows special interests, mainly and firstly, in the development of
theoretic and juridical – constitutional thought, and also treats professional and applicative issues. The juridical norms, if we use
a figure of speech, are “the spinal cord” or “the essence” of the constitutional law as a branch of the law. As a matter of fact, the
juridical norms constitute the content of the constitutional law. The juridical norms that regulate the social relations, which
compose the object of the constitutional law are called constitutional – juridical norms, and this is how they diverge from the
juridical norms that regulate other social relations, which on the other side, are included in other branches of the law (in the
administrative law, in the criminal law, in the civil law etc)1. The constitutional – juridical norms are juridical sui generis norms
(norms of a special kind), that are “regulated or sanctioned by the state” for the juridical regulation of the social relations which
are created during the activity of the highest and most important organs of a given state.
Key words: juridical sui generis norms, political relations, certain state organs
1. Introduction
The constitutional – juridical norms, which are comprised in the positive constitutional law of a certain state,
from the technical – juridical view are created and expressed in the constitutional acts (as general normative
juridical acts that have superior juridical power), like the constitution, the constitutional law, the constitutional
amendment or the constitutional annexes, these some examples that regulate the constitutional – juridical
matters. There are other juridical normative acts, that have lower juridical power compared to the
constitutional acts, but that regulate issues in the field of the constitutional law: certain legal acts, the
regulation for the work of the certain state organs (parliament, government, constitutional court), the
decisions of the constitutional courts etc. The constitutional – juridical norms are the most important norms in
the juridical system of a state.
These norms are important because they regulate the fundamental political relations, as a social
relations with special and extraordinary worth in the entire complexity of social relations, that are related,
mainly, with constituting, organizing and the function of the state power, as well, as the juridical position of

1 Dhimo Dhima, The Constitutional law of the Peoples Republic of Albania, Tirana 1963, page 19.
2 Dragan M. Stojanoviç, Ustavno pravo, Nish, 2004, page 3.
109
the individuals in a state and in the society which is manifested by assuring and protecting the fundamental
freedoms and the rights of the individual and citizen.
1.1 Juridical acts and “contra – constitutionem”
This is why the constitutional - juridical norms have juridical supremacy compared to the other juridical norms.
These juridical norms mainly are summarized and included in the constitution as the supreme and
fundamental juridical act in the hierarchy pyramid of the juridical acts2, in order to display and manifest the
supremacy of this norms compared to all the other juridical norms. Each juridical norm that disagrees with the
juridical and constitutional norms is unconstitutional (contra constitutionem), and as a result, is worthless, that
is why that juridical norm must be removed (with ex nunc or ex tunc) 3 by the justice institutions, by
constitutional courts4 and all the juridical consequences in the field of social relations must be discussed. The
norms of the constitutional law as branch of the law are displayed both in written form and in the unwritten
form. The written juridical norms are denominated as “primary or formal sources”. The unwritten rules that
may be half-juridical or extra-juridical are denominated as “secondary or subsidiary sources” 5. The primary or
formal sources of the constitutional law are the general normative acts, that are expressed in the written form
and that have a supralegal juridical power which regulate the constitutional – juridical matters, as well, as
they are integral part of the positive national law.
This normative acts are used to regulate the constitutional – juridical matters, that can be formed as a
result of the volition of the state organs, that are legitimated by the Constitution as authority subjects and that
are the juridical base for the construction and the function of the constitutional order in a given state.
Concerning the subsidiary or secondary sources of the constitutional law, they are half-juridical (non-juridical
and unwritten) sources, that are applied in a given state as an alternative, only in the cases of juridical gaps,
when there are no formal sources of the constitutional law, when there are lacks of norms and juridical acts in
the written form that have constitutional - juridical nature. Like the formal or primary sources, the subsidiary or
secondary sources of the constitutional law may differ. The most popular formal sources are the
constitutional acts, concerning the subsidiary sources that are custom popular are the constitutional customs
and the constitutional conventions6.
1.2 Constitutional Law and Albania Fundamental Statute
The constitutional acts are the formal and the most important source of the constitutional law, because they
have superior juridical power compared to all the other juridical acts. The constitutional acts regulate the most
important issues of constitutional – juridical matters, like organizing the state power and the freedoms and the
fundamental freedoms and rights of the individuals. These acts are displayed in different forms and
denominations like Constitution (or another juridical act like “The Fundamental Statute” in Albania since
1914), constitutional law, constitutional amendment, constitutional annex etc7. The Constitution as a juridical
written act, never displays a perfect document, that is complete and has no defects, or that is clearly
formulated without ambiguities, and that is precise and well defined. This is why the constitutional customs

3 Citation from Dr. Kurtesh Saliu, The constitutional law (E drejta kushtetuese), Prishtinë, 2004, page 198 – 200.
4 For more inf. Consult the sources of the constitutional law Dr. Kurtesh Saliu, E drejta kushtetuese, Prishtinë, 2004, page 163 – 200; Dr.
Kristaq Traja, Drejtësia Kushtetuese, Tiranë, 2000.
5 For more inf. Consult the sources of the constitutional law see: Dr. Pavle Nikoliç, page 22 –29.
Dr. Kasim Trnka, page. 14 – 18; Dr. Kurtesh Saliu, page 35 – 44; Dr. Luan Omari, Dr. Aurela Anastasi, page 14 – 22.
6. See : Dr. Svetomir Shkariq, cit. at page 17 – 18
7 Dr. Kurtesh Saliu, cit. at page 37
110
and the constitutional conventions are considered as a subsidiary or a secondary source of the constitutional
law8.
From an historical perspective, the customs and the constitutional conventions are older sources of the
constitutional law than the Constitutions and the laws as formal sources. Until the XVIII century, the
constitutional customs were the main sources and a dominant way for the regulation of the constitutional –
juridical matters, this customs may exist even nowadays in countries like England, where the major part of
the relevant constitutional institutions (state institutions) 9 are regulated with constitutional customs10. After
the presentation of the first written constitutions and after the evolvement of the juridical modern systems with
formal sources, the customs lost their importance as a source of the law in general and especially as a
source for the constitutional law. The customs are a main source of the law in general and especially of the
constitutional law11 only in the countries where radical changes do not happen, where there are no frequent
changes of the social relations for long periods of time (duly this are countries with e stable and consistent
juridical system) for instance, in countries like England and in the countries which have formed their juridical
system under the influence of the specific Anglo-Saxon juridical tradition (Common law legal system). On the
other side, the countries that accepted and that apply the European continental juridical system (Civil law
legal system), the customs are considered as a subsidiary or as a secondary source.
H 1. The countries (that apply Civil law legal system), want to consider the customs as a source of the
constitutional law, must fulfill two conditions: first, when there are gaps in the Constitution or in another
formal source (in the written form) of the constitutional law.
For instance, if an important constitutional issue is not regulated neither by the constitution neither from
another formal source (in the written form) of the constitutional law.
H 2. The Second condition to fulfill is that the custom must not disagree or be against the principles of the
constitutional order in power12.
The customs in general and the especially the constitutional customs are based in respecting a given
conduct (longa consuetudo) that is followed by the conviction that the conduct is also “juridical obligation” 13.
There are two elements that constitute a constitutional custom: 1 the external element (material) and 2 the
internal element (psychological). The constitutional custom is made from the precedents (frequent repetition)
and from the consciousness to behave in a certain manner (opinio iuris sive necessitatis). According to this
practice, the standard and constant behaviors repeated in longer periods of time turn into customs under the
action of material and psychological factors.
H 3. The material factor is the frequent repetition (regular and continuous) that displays and testifies the
existence of a general practice, which was accepted as fair.

8 Dr. Miodrag Joviçiç, O ustavu, Beograd, 1977, fq. 253.
9 Constitutional institutions are all the state bodies, in the Constitution there are provisions that define their building, competences and
functioning.
10 Dr. Jovan Stefanoviç, Ustavno pravo, Zagreb, 1956, page 8 – 9. Dr. Kasim Trnka, Ustavno pravo, Sarajevo, 2000, page 18.
11 Dr. Kasim Trnka, Ustavno pravo, Sarajevo, 2000, page 18.Dr. Arsen Baçiç, Ustavno pravo i politiçke institucije, Split, 2006, page 19.
12. Dr. Arsen Baçiç, Ustavno pravo i politiçke institucije, Spleit, 2006, page 19; Dr. Nurko Pobriç, Ustavno pravo, Mostar, 2000, page 16.
13 Dr. Nurko Pobriç, Ustavno pravo, Mostar, 2000, page 16.
111
The subjective factor is the consciousness that by acting or not acting in a given manner in given
circumstances is acceptable by the custom rules. When these two conditions are fulfilled simultaneously they
show and testify that a practice is transformed into a constitutional custom14. At this point the constitutional
customs display social unwritten rules which can regulate issues from the constitutional - juridical sphere15. In
the major part of the democratic countries, the constitutional custom can be taken under consideration in two
cases. The first case – when there are no provisions in the constitution neither in another formal (written)
source that can regulate an issue partially or completely determined by the constitutional - juridical matters.
The second case – when in the provisions of the constitution or of another formal source a constitutional –
juridical issue is partially or completely not clear, when it is not treated properly or enough, in order to express
the contain of the constitutional written norm.
The constitutional customs can contribute to make clear the volition of the constitution-maker and to
avoid further ambiguities in the formal and written source, it also eases the implementation of the constitution
or any other formal source. In both cases the repetitive and continual behavior within a long period of time
may create the conviction that acting in a given manner in given circumstances creates also the conviction to
behave in a given manner in a state organ or in any other political subject16. We can conclude by saying that
the constitutional customs play a double and auxiliary role, their role can be expressed in two main directions:
in the concretization or in clearing the meaning of a written norm, and in the enrichment of the written
constitution or of another formal source, in case of juridical gaps and of course when the constitutional
custom isn't against the principles of the constitution or of another formal source (secundum constitutione et
praeter constitutione)17.
2.1 An overview of the historical developing of constitutional stable system
This is important especially for the countries that have a very short and generalized constitution, that have an
aged constitution and a constitutional stable system, for instance U.S.A, Switzerland, Belgium, Sweden,
Norway etc18. It is important to give instances. Some of them are: members of the Congress, more precisely
of the Chamber Representatives that must reside in their electoral area (while the Constitution requires that
the candidates must be citizens of the country where they want to be elected); the president must appoint in
the Cabinet representatives of the most important regions of the U.S.A (even though in the Constitution there
are no provisions relevant to this issue); the Cabinet as a consultative organ, as a counseling organ that is
made from the Department Chiefs (The Constitution does not recognize The Cabinet as a constitutional -
juridical institution); not allowing the members of the presidential Cabinet to speak in the séances of the
Assembly Chambers of the U.S.A (even though it is not regulated in the Constitution); in the European
Parliamentary Monarchies19

14 Dr.. Miodrag Joviçiç, cit at., page 253 – 254.
15 Dr. Kurtesh Saliu, cit.at, page 40.
16 Dr. Josip Sruk, Ustavno Uregjenje Socijalistiçke Federativne Republike Jugoslavije, Zagreb, 1976, page 6; Dr. Branko Smerdel, Dr.
Smiljko Sokol, page 20.see: Dr. Arsen Baçiç, Ustavno pravo i politiçke institucije, Split, 2006, page 19.
17 See: Dr. Arsen Baçiç, Ustavno pravo i politiçke institucije, Split, 2006, page 19
18. Dr. Kurtesh Saliu, page 40.
19 Parliamentary monarchy – the reignition of the state, which is characterized by choosing the chief of the state on the principle of the
power heritage, and the “essential role of the parliament within the that sort of governing a state” – for more inf. Consult Palriamentary
Democracy – citated by Dr. Arsim Bajrami, Demokracia Parlamentare, Prishtinë, 2005, page 84.
112
Tab1. The indicators and retroactive effect of low
(Denmark, Norway, Sweden, Belgium and Holland) the monarchs never use the right of the suspensive veto,
even if it is foreseen by their Constitutions; in France the constitutional customs are created under the
influence of the France Constitution of year 1875, especially not using the right of the Chief of the Republic to
dissolve the parliament and the right to the suspended veto relevant to the approved laws from the
parliament (even though this authorizations were according to the Constitution), also preventing the
retroactive effect of laws (that is not part of the Constitution of 1875) 20; in Switzerland the Federative Council
reflects the number of the members of three linguistic communities (it isn’t required by the Constitution); in
Bosnia and in Herzegovina the six members of the of the Constitutional Court of Bosnia and Herzegovina,
which are chosen from the parliaments of the ethnics of Bosnia and Herzegovina, will be chosen in order to
put the ethnical balance “of the people that constitute”, in the Constitutional Court (two Bosnians, two
Croatians and two Serbians)- even though this is not expressed in the Constitution in power of Bosnia); the
Chairman of the Council of Ministers in Bosnia and Herzegovina must belong to different ethnic parts every
new mandate- the rotation- (this is not formally regulated in the Constitution) 21
2.2 The principles and ethnical culture communities
In both cases, of Switzerland and of Bosnia and Herzegovina its treated the principle of equality in the
democracy that “forbids the people to dominate on other people” by creating a consensual mechanism that
would diminish the possibility of the ethnical communities to become “a majority”. This is a principle for the
countries with heterogenic ethnical culture or that are multiethnic 22 . There is no doubt that the
implementation of the constitutional customs depends on the constitution-maker organ that can also in the
juridical aspect sanctioned the existence and their implementation or that can categorically suspend the
existence and the implementation, or can have a neutral position. For instance, The Grand Popular Assembly
of Turkey, during the rule of Kemal Ataturk, interdicted wearing the fez as a “non-civil custom”.
But the constitution-maker may have a dualist attitude to the custom: firstly, respect the existence of the
custom and secondly violate the existence of the custom. For instance the U.S.A for more than 140 years

20 Dr. Miodrag Joviçiç, page 255 – 259; Dr. Kasim Trnka, page 81; Dr. Svetomir Shkariq, page 46 – 47.
21 See : Dr. Kasim Trnka, page 18 – 23 and 46 – 49.
22 See : Anali Pravnog fakulteta u Beogradu - Časopis za pravne i društvene nauke, nr. 2/2005, Vojislav Stanovçiç, Demokratija i
Vladavina Prava, page 55 – 56.
113
respected the constitutional custom of not electing the same candidate for president more than twice. This
constitutional custom was not violated from any American president, except the president Frenklin D. Ruzvelt
which candidate for the third time in 1940 and in 1944 for the fourth time. In 1951 the constitutional-maker
legitimated this constitutional custom, and transformed it in a constitutional written norm in Amendment XXII
in the Constitution of the U.S.A: - “No person shall be elected to the office of the President custom than twice”
23 . It is important to mention the fact that this constitutional norm written since 1951 and in power until
nowadays is still respected.
2.3 Constitutional – juridical practice and functional duties
When the constitution-maker is not satisfied with a given constitutional custom, can regulate and adapt that
custom in order to implement it. During the constitutional – juridical practice in the Croatian Constitution in
1990 was amended a constitutional custom, because there was a juridical gap relevant to the incompatibility
of exertion of two functional duties as a depute and as a minister. By sharing the state power, the ministers
had the possibility to be elected as deputies of the Assembly.
3. Conclusions and Recommendation
This constitutional custom was implemented until the Law for the election of deputies in the Parliament
(Sabor) of Croatian Republic sanctioned the institute of the incompatibility, by anticipating in article 6 that “a
depute can’t be a chairman, vice-chairman, minister and member of the Croatian government…” 24 . The
Prime-Minister (James Callaghan) refused the demand for the resignition of the gouvernment and constated
that the convent for minister responsabilities is vis major 25 . The Chamber of Regions accepted this
interpretation and the convent was created with a new exception 26 . To conclude we can say that: the
constitutional conventions are not juridical norms, but they have constitutional nature in their content, this is
why the convents are treated as subsidiary sources of the constitutional right. The constitutional convents
differ from the constitutional customs for three reasons. Firstly, the constitutional convents are implemented
only under the activity of the crucial and most important state organs – parliament & government, the
constitutional customs are implemented broadly in the whole constitutional – juridical – matters. Secondly,
the constitutional convents have lower influence compared to the constitutional customs because they are
not enforced or recognized by the courts, in fact, their application depend from the will of the state organ that
is addressed the constitutional convention. Thirdly, the constitutional conventions are extra-juridical rules
(non-legal rules) that are more dynamic and flexible than the constitutional customs because the convents
can be changed easily.27
References
Dr. Josip Sruk, Ustavno Uregjenje Socijalistiçke Federativne Republike Jugoslavije, Zagreb, 1976, page 6; Dr. Branko Smerdel, Dr.
Smiljko Sokol, page 20.see: Dr. Arsen Baçiç, Ustavno pravo i politiçke institucije, Split, 2006, page 19.
See: Dr. Arsen Baçiç, Ustavno pravo i politiçke institucije, Split, 2006, page 19; Dr. Kurtesh Saliu, page 40.
Parliamentary monarchy- the reignition of the state , which is characterized by choosing the chief of the state on the principle of the
power heritage, and the “essential role of the parliament within the that sort of governing a state” – for more inf. Consult

23 See: Dr. Miodrag Joviçiç, page 261.
24 Dr. Branko Smerdel, Dr. Smiljko Sokol, Ustavno pravo, Zagreb, 2006, page 20.
25 Vis maior (supreme power).
26 Dr. Branko Smerdel, Dr. Smiljko Sokol, Ustavno pravo, Zagreb, 2006, page 70.
114
Palriamentary Democracy- citated by Dr. Arsim Bajrami, Demokracia Parlamentare, Prishtinë, 2005, page 84. Dr. Miodrag Joviçiç,
vep. e cit., 255 – 259; Dr. Kasim Trnka, page 81; Dr. Svetomir Shkariq, page 46 – 47.
Citation from Dr. Kurtesh Saliu, The Constitutional law (E drejta kushtetuese), Prishtinë, 2004, page 198 – 200.
For more inf. Consult the sources of the constitutional right Dr. Kurtesh Saliu, E drejta kushtetuese, Prishtinë, 2004, page 163 – 200; Dr.
Kristaq Traja, Drejtësia Kushtetuese, Tiranë, 2000
For more inf. Consult the sources of the constitutional right see: Dr. Pavle Nikoliç, page 22 –29 Dr. Nurko Pobriç, vep. e cit., fq. 12 – 18;
Dr. Kasim Trnka, page. 14 – 18; Dr. Kurtesh Saliu, page 35 – 44; Dr. Luan Omari, Dr. Aurela Anastasi, page14 – 22
Dr. Miodrag Joviçiç, page 255 – 259; Dr. Kasim Trnka, page 81; Dr. Svetomir Shkariq, page 46 – 47.
See : Dr. Kasim Trnka, page 18 – 23 and 46 – 49.
See : Anali Pravnog fakulteta u Beogradu - Časopis za pravne i društvene nauke, nr. 2/2005, Vojislav Stanovçiç, Demokratija i
Vladavina Prava, page 55 – 56.
Dr. Owen Hood-Phillips, Constitutional and Administrative law, London, 1967, pg. 11. – Cited by Dr. Krenar Loloçi, E drejta
kushtetuese, Tiranë, 1997, pg. 15.
The juridical act is defined as a technical – juridical instrument (means) for ‘the creation, expression and implementation of the law’.-cited
by Dr. Dimitar Bajallxhiev, Voved vo pravoto – kniga vtora, Shkup, 1999,pg. 103.
Veljko Mratoviç, Dr. Nikolla Filipoviç, Dr. Smiljko Sokol, Ustavno pravo i politiçke institucije, Zagreb, 1986,pg. 26.
Zhan Zhak Ruso, Kontrata Sociale, Tiranë, 2007.
Dr. Zejnullah Gruda, E drejta ndërkombëtare publike, Prishtinë, 2007,pg. 3 – 4.
Dr. John Alder, Constitutional and Administrative Law, New York, 2007,pg. 6.
In Albanian language to mark the constitutional law as an applicative juridical discipline, not rarely it is used the optional term, or the
alternative expression “the constitutional law”. After the declaration of Albania as an independent and sovereign state on
November the 28-th 1912, that discipline firstly was known as The fundamental law”
(Kristo Floqi, E drejta themelore, Shkodër, 1920),while in 1920-1924 as “The constitutional law” (Stavro Vinjau, E drejta konstitucionale,
Tiranë, 1923). – cited by Dr. Luan Omari, Dr. Aurela Anastasi, E drejta kushtetuese, Tiranë, 2008, pg. 10 – 11.
Dr. Anthony Bradley, Dr. Keith Ewing, Constitutional and Administrative Law, England, 2003, page 23 – 24; Dr. John Alder,
Constitutional and Administrative Law, New York, 2007, page 59 – 62.
115

Money Talks: The Influence of Economic Crisis on Global Governance
Bassam A. Albassam
School of Public Administration, Florida Atlantic University

Boca Raton, FL, USA
Doi:10.5901.mjss.2012.v3n2.117
Abstract: The economic crisis has had an influence on all aspects of life, from economic to social life, from national security to
governance, and from politics to sports. The consequences of the economic crisis of 2008 could shape the future of global
governance. Also, the appearance of new players in influencing and restructuring the global political system, such as private and
state-owned Transnational Corporations (TNCs), makes us rethink the ways in which we need to approach human development
issues such as fighting corruption, supporting human rights and higher living standards, and maintaining good governance
practices worldwide. Thus, this article addresses the influence of the economic crisis of 2008 on formal and informal governance.
The focus of this article is addressing the increasing of economic and political power of TNCs, especially state-owned TNCs, and
their influence on the global political system. The conclusion reached is that International Organizations (IOs), civil society
organizations, people, and even TNCs need to work together to reorganize the political scene with new international agreements
and IOs, because institutions and international agreements that initiated after WWII are not working affectively anymore.
Keywords: International organizations, Economic crisis, Transnational Corporations, State-owned TNCs, China, Governance
1. Introduction
Without a doubt, globalization has affected every corner of the globe; even isolated areas that were once less
affected by what is happening outside their borders have been affected as a result of globalization. Advanced
technology and transportation have translated communication and relational dynamics of global world into
those of a small village. In addition, the desire of Transnational Corporations (TNCs) to maximize their profits
and the willingness of states with strong economies to have bigger role in shaping world’s political systems,
among other factors, have participated in restructuring local and global governance in recent decades.
Politics, relationships between states, international trade, and culture are all influenced one way or
another by globalization. Accordingly, the economy is one of the fundamental factors that has shaped and
continues to shape this new era of globalization. Also, economic crises such as the one in Asia in the 1990s
and the current crisis that began in 2008 are good examples of how globalization became an unavoidable
fact. Consequently, the role of governments has changed dramatically, from welfare states trying to provide
jobs for citizens to facilitating states trying to provide a proper environment for investors. According to United
Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) (1996), “under forces of globalization, the role of
government is progressively shifting toward providing and an appropriate enabling environment for private
enterprise” (p.14). This new role for governments comes as a result of globalization and capitalism, as
modeled in the USA, Western European countries, and Japan.
Host states change some regulations to attract TNCs to invest. In contrast, financial crises are golden
opportunities for TNCs with strong financial status to have new investments.
According to Harris (2010),
The TCC [Transnational Capitalist Class] response to the world crisis is to expand transnational
accumulation through a deeper integration of the national into the global. For the TCC there is no
national industrial policy that is not a transnational policy. Economies at home and abroad have
merged in ways that intractably link the profits and strategies of TNCs. U. S. auto manufacturers can't
117
survive without their global footprint. The same is true of every auto corporation, no matter their
perceived national identity. (p. 407)
The 2008 economic crisis and its consequences such as increase in countries national debts and browning
costs show indications of the new structure of the global economic system. For example, a new report by
Financial Times shows that China, through China Development Bank and China Export-Import Bank, has lent
more money to developing countries than the World Bank did in 2010 (Dyer, Anderlini, and Sender, 2011). A
country borrowing from other countries is a frequent action and always happened, but this time is different for
two reasons. The first reason is that countries such as China, Qatar, and United Arab Emirates (UAE) have
started to invest in and lend money to countries in need of cash, such as Greece and some African countries.
These lenders record low in most governance indicators, such Worldwide Governance Indicators (WGI) by
the World Bank (Kaufmann et al., 2010), which raises the important issue of how these lenders could use
these loans and investments to influence the development of governance development in the receiving and
host countries. The second reason, which is related to the first, is the fact that these loans and investments
come with flexible conditions from lenders compared to loans guaranteed by IOs or developed countries, this
flexibility might have an influence on aspects of formal and informal governance, such as transparency and
the democratic process, in receiving countries. In the case of China, for example, Tull (2006) states that “by
offering aid without preconditions, China has presented an attractive alternative to conditional Western aid,
and gained valuable diplomatic support to defend its international interests.” (p. 459)
Transnational Corporations (TNCs) are the key players in the new global political system. Beyond the
mere exchange of goods and provision of services in foreign countries, TNCs participate in – or have an
enormous impact upon – the formation of regulations, public organizations, politics, and even the
governmental constitutions of home and host states. The economic and political influence of TNCs has risen
in recent decades (Henderson, 2000; UNCTD, 2011). According to the World Investment Report of 2011,
“TNCs’ production worldwide generated value-added of approximately $16 trillion in 2010, about a quarter of
global GDP. Foreign affiliates of TNCs accounted for more than 10 per cent of global GDP and one-third of
world exports.” (UNCTD, 2011a, p. x)
State-owned TNCs have been one of the main forces of globalization.
According to World Investment Report,
State-owned TNCs are an important emerging source of FDI. There are at least 650 State-owned
TNCs, with 8,500 foreign affiliates across the globe. While they represent less than 1 per cent of
TNCs, their outward investment accounted for 11 per cent of global FDI in 2010. (UNCTD, 2011a,p. x)
However, the main task of state-owned TNCs is maximizing profit and diversifying investment, or at least they
claim this is the case; however, there is no doubt that state-owned TNCs have other roles to play, including
political roles (Henderson, 2000; McLean, 2003; Rondinelli, 2003; UNCTD, 2011a).
This article will discuss the increasing role that privately owned TNCs and state-owned TNCs play in the
global governance and global economic system. This paper is structured as follows. First, the economic and
political influence of TNCs in world political systems and global governance will be discussed. Second,
responses to the economic crisis of 2008 from IOs and TNCs and its affect on formal and informal
governance will be explored. Finally, suggestions for further research will be presented, since this article is
intended as a step toward a better understanding of international governance structure.
2. Transnational Corporations (TNCs)
TNCs are defined as “incorporated or unincorporated enterprises comprising parent enterprises and their
foreign affiliates” (UNCTD, 2011b, p. 3). According to the World Investment Report of 2011, TNCs accounted
for 25 percent of world GDP, which explains their economic power. Simply stated, a transnational corporation
(TNC) is a corporation or enterprise that introduces services or/and production in other countries as well as
the home country.
118
Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) and other forms of TNCs have a positive impact on the market and
people of the countries where they operate. For example, FDI challenges the local companies with
competition, leading them to merge in order to have a strong firm (financially and professionally) and the
ability to compete with the big TNCs either in business or by launching new ideas with new products.
According to World Investment Report,
“each form of foreign investment plays a distinct and important role in promoting growth and
sustainable development, boosting countries’ competitiveness, generating employment, and reducing
social and income disparities.” (UNCTD, 2011a, p. 21)
Even though FDI and TNCs are a very important element in posting economy, it is important to keep in mind
that TNCs are profit driven, so they will relocate whenever there is a new opportunity or serious threat to their
operations (UNCTD, 2011a). In addition, TNCs, as a form of FDI, like to operate in countries with flexible
regulations (e.g., labor, environment) to reduce cost and maximize profit (Hill, 2008; Kwok & Tadesse, 2006;
Tull, 2006). According to Kwok & Tadesse (2006),
There are plenty of anecdotal evidences that TNCs sometimes bring undesirable influences. In some
situations, TNCs exploit natural resources, cause environmental pollution, employ child labor, or take
advantage of the looser regulations of the host countries (to bypass the stringent regulations and
costly requirements of parent countries). (p. 8)
In addition, according to Henderson (2000), there is always a conflict of interest between private and public
interests, which in this case refers to the interests of TNCs and the people of the countries they affect. Yet
economic globalization and liberalization movements give private sectors and TNCs advantage over the
public interest, and local governments have less power to control, manage, or organize TNCs’ activities.
Thus, TNCs have the necessary power to influence governments’ actions toward their interests, even if such
interests conflict with the public interest.
According to Henderson (2000),
Companies and TNCs still fight regulations with stonewalling, countless legal challenges, lobbying,
political fundraising, manipulating markets and finance, corruption, and in some cases, repression and
violence, even if a regulation would benefit them by organizing a new and larger market or help
capitalize a cleaner, cost-saving technology. (p. 1236)
Even though there is an attitude among reporters and in academia to distinguish between privately owned
TNCs and state-owned TNCs, there is no consensus on labels for non-state-owned TNCs, so we will call
them privately owned TNCs in this article. There are some characteristics that can help to distinguish private
and state-owned TNCs. While all TNCs are profit-driven, one could argue that privately owned TNCs enjoy
more freedom in running their operations even when governments own shares in the company (e.g., US
government ownerships of shares of GE), because the government’s shares’ ownership is a temporary
situation and the governments have little or no influence in these companies’ strategies. Thus, one could
argue that most of privately owned TNCs operate in developed countries. By contrast, state-owned TNCs are
owned completely or partially by governments, and in many cases these governments have their own agenda
carried out by the companies. For example, a report by U.S.-China Economic & Security Review Commission
in 2011 explains the relationship between China’s government and China’s state-owned TNCs:
Chinese outward investment activities are often directed by the Chinese government, especially for
firms in deals involving oil and minerals or telecommunications, which are required by the government
to remain under government oversight or control. Chinese governments at various levels often
appoint executives in such Chinese firms and finance the deals through state banks. The Chinese
government’s support for these industries includes a variety of subsidies as well as access to low-cost
financing from the largest banks, all of which are state owned. (Salidjanova, 2011, p. 4)
This statement relates specifically to Chinese state-owned TNCs, but this could be applied to all state-owned
companies in developing and transitional economies. Thus, privately owned TNCs have less political
119
involvement in host countries compared to state-owned TNCs, and both types have economic and political
influence in home-state countries.
Although it can be hard to distinguish between privately owned TNCs (governments have less control over
operations) and state-owned TNCs (governments direct TNCs economically, managerially, and politically),
following World Investment Report by UNCTD we will try to distinguish between the two politically and, to
some extent, economically. Thus, state-owned TNCs will be discussed in a separate section to clarify the role
that state-owned TNCs play in the world’s political systems. Also, we will discuss some countries, such as
China, that rely heavily on state-owned TNCs to gain international economic and political power.
2.1 Foreign Direct Investment
Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) has been one of the main indicators in measuring global trade. FDI refers to
inflow (investment to countries) and outflow (investment from countries). The World Investment Report
defines FDI as:
an investment involving a long‑term relationship and reflecting a lasting interest and control by a
resident entity in one economy (foreign direct investor or parent enterprise) in an enterprise resident in
an economy other than that of the foreign direct investor (FDI enterprise or affiliate enterprise or foreign
affiliate). (UNCTD, 2011b, p. 3)
However, state-owned TNCs from the U.S., China, and Western Europe have the biggest share of global
FDI, developing and transitional economies attracted more FDI in 2010 than other economies. According to
World Investment Report published by United Nations Conference on Trade and Development, global FDI
totaled $1.24 trillion worldwide in 2010. Consequently, FDI inflows increased 5 percent in 2010, which is 37
percent less than the peak point in 2007. By contrast, FDI outflows remained constant in 2010 compared to
2009 (UNCTD, 2011a).
2.2 State-Owned TNCs
International trade and the influence of state-owned TNCs in shaping the global political system is one of the
controversial issues among politicians, economists, and academics; however, there is no agreement among
international organizations and countries as to a specific definition of state-owned TNCs. McLean (2003) in
The Transnational Corporation in History studies the history of TNCs, and he argues that “because the legal
nature of corporations was not determined by international law, but rather by national or colonial law, the
status of the different corporations varied” (p.371). In this article, the U.N. definition will be adopted.
According to the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development, state-owned TNCs are “enterprises
comprising parent enterprises and their foreign affiliates in which the government has a controlling interest
(full, majority, or significant minority), whether or not listed on a stock exchange.” (UNCTD, 2011a, p. 28)
According to the World Investment Report of 2011, there are almost 650 state-owned TNCs and more
than 8,500 foreign affiliates around the globe; presumably, then, it would be unusual to find a country that
does not have TNCs or one of their affiliates present. Furthermore, in 2010, TNCs accounted for 25 percent
of global GDP, while their affiliates accounted for almost 10 percent of global GDP and one-third of world
exports. Even though TNCs and their affiliates account for less than 1 percent of all TNCs, they nonetheless
wield great economic and political power in their home and host countries (Clark & Chan, 1995; Harris, 2010;
Henderson, 2000). According to the report, in 2010, 19 of the 100 largest TNCs in the world were state-
owned and accounted for 11 percent of global FDI. Also, state-owned TNCs cover a variety of manufacturing
industries and services, contrary to the common myth that state-owned TNCs only concentrate on natural
sources industries, such as the energy industry. Finally, developing and transitional economies host more
than half of TNCs (UNCTD, 2011a). These figures show the economic power that TNCs have in the world.
120
As a result of their economic power, TNCs have become unofficial governments that participate in
influencing and shaping foreign and domestic affairs of their home and host states. For example, China’s
corporations conduct billions of dollars of business in Africa, which gives China the power to intervene heavily
in decision making processes in its TNCs’ host countries (Tull, 2006). The same thing happens to other
states that used state-owned TNCs to pressure host states (Clark & Chan, 1995; Farazmand, 2002;
Newfarmer, 2001; Salidjanova, 2011). According to Farazmand (2002), “the rule of giant organizations and
multinational corporations, backed by their supportive political and military-security organizations of powerful
states, is so formidable that few if any can escape their effects.” (p. 111)
3. TNCs and Global Governance
One of the controversial issues of state-owned TNCs is the influence of the government that owns a TNC on
its strategies and operations. This influence can be used to deliver home states’ political agendas in host
states. A TNC’s essential mission is supposed to be operating as a firm (i.e., increasing income and social
responsibility toward home and host countries) without political agendas. However, the other side of the coin,
which is the use of TNCs by home states to deliver their political agenda, has a long history. McLean (2003)
argues that British colonies in India in the 1800s had similar practices, using Indian companies owned by the
British government to deliver Great Britain’s political agendas. McLean (2003) thinks that modern TNCs have
the same vision, and he deems that globalization and the TNCs it produces constitute a new form of
colonization. According to McLean (2003), “The new world economic order is built on this colonial legacy.”
(p.373)
By contrast, some scholars argue that political activity is part of any organization, whether private or
public, so TNCs are not unique in defending their rights and fighting for their interests by using political
methods (Clark & Chan, 1995; Farazmand, 2002). Farazmand (2002) argues that “all organizations public,
private and nonprofit are involved in politics and political processes and activities. Indeed, all organizations
may be considered political institutions, for they all perform political functions in one way or another." (p. xix)
The influence of a TNC in its home and host states is both overt (in its entity and sales) and covert (in its
political and administrative influence). This influence is also both direct (in providing jobs for citizens, bringing
technology to its host state, and to some extent serving the community) and indirect (e.g., in its ability to
influence the passing of laws or regulations that will serve its interests). This influence takes different shapes
and forms. One of the most common forms is informal governance such as lobbying, especially in democratic
states where a group of people with similar interests seek to influence an issue. In non-democratic states,
other forms of informal governance appear, sometimes including illegal activities such as bribery and
nepotism (Henderson, 2000). According to Henderson (2000), “today, global corporations are capturing
global markets with foreign direct investment, globalizing production, outsourcing to weak states, and-often
overlooked in conventional analyses-negotiating global standard-setting processes.” (p. 1238)
While it is the TNCs’ right to fight for their interests, they sometimes become greedy, especially when
there is a conflict of interest between the corporation’s interests and the public interest. In such cases, the
public tends to suffer the most, especially when the host state is weak and cannot defend its citizens’ rights,
which is the case in most developing and transitional states (Henderson, 2000; McLean, 2003).
3.1 TNCs as Political Actor
State-owned TNCs have been criticized for being used by their owners (i.e., the governments of their home
states) to deliver and push the owners’ political agendas in host states. By contrast, privately owned TNCs
have been criticized for their influence on their home states’ governments to achieve their own interests,
regardless of conflict with the public interest. According to United Nations Conference on Trade and
Development (2011a),
121
State-owned TNCs are causing concerns in a number of host countries regarding national security,
the level playing field for competing firms, and governance and transparency. From the perspective of
home countries, there are concerns regarding the openness to investment from their State-owned
TNCs. (p. xiii)
Rondinelli (2003) argues that TNCs have influence on every aspect of life, including influencing public opinion
through media, affecting governments’ decisions through financial aid, helping governments to solve
problems such as creating jobs, and supporting candidates for public offices in democratic societies.
According to Rondinelli (2003),
[T]he expanding public roles of transnational corporations in private foreign aid, in self-regulation and
private certification of business practices, not to mention helping shape public policy, can be viewed
as evidence of corporate citizenship and social responsibility or as a threat to democratic decision
making and national sovereignty. (p. 13)
Another issue raised by Rondinelli (2006) is the exchange role between governments and TNCs. He argues
that one of the clear results of globalization and the TNCs it produces is the fact that global corporations
perform tasks that used to be performed by governments, such as influencing people socially and
economically. Rondinelli (2006) stated that:
[A] less visible, though nonetheless significant, aspect of globalisation is the rapidly expanding roles
that these corporations and their executives and industry associations have assumed in social,
economic, and environmental policy – areas that had in the past been the primary or exclusive
responsibilities of governments. (p. 15)
Over the 25 years, TNCs have become the largest provider of foreign aid in the world through their
donations and NGOs that they have initiated (Rondinelli, 2006). The increasing economic and political power
of TNCs causes governments to change laws and regulations either as a response to pressure from TNCs or
to attract them to invest in the country. Henderson (2000) stated that “today, the state is everywhere in retreat
and similar fears are now focused on the ascendance of markets and private corporate power in our
globalized economy” (p.1232). Rondinelli (2006) goes even further by deeming that TNCs have an
international influence rather than limited influence at the local level. According to Rondinelli (2006), “TNCs
also influence international policy dialogues prior to national governments and international organisations
enacting laws and regulations or attempt to influence the pace and direction of decisions by governments and
international organizations.” (p. 16)
Koenig-Archibugi (2004) shares Rondinelli’s views and thinks that TNCs in some cases have more power
than host states, where host governments are not able to hold TNCs accountable for their actions. According
to Koenig-Archibugi (2004), “host governments might be unable to act effectively as agents of accountability
between TNCs and citizens because of the lack of material and organizational resources for policy
formulation and implementation.” (p.244)
The economic and political influence of TNCs has spread throughout the globe, so no region or state is
immune from TNCs’ effects. “The growing economic influence of TNCs almost assures continued expansion
of the public role of the private sector in international policy” (Rondinelli, 2003, p. 21). In the United States, for
example, the massive bailout after the 2008 financial crisis raised a lot of questions regarding the amount
and timing of the bailout, as well as the political power that allowed TNCs to influence the passing of the bill
by Congress and the White House. In his study of the U. S government’s actions to bail out giant companies
such as GM and Ford, Harris (2010) argues that the massive bailout from the U.S. government to auto
companies as a response to the 2008 economic crisis is clear evidence that TNCs have strong political and
economic power that goes beyond countries’ ability to control them. According to Harris (2006),
But auto is an indicator of a broader trend in which TNCs are increasing their monopoly over the world
economy. Moreover, through all the global wheeling and dealing we see how government bailouts
help promote transnational investments that blur the identity of national ownership. (p. 405)
122
The case of China will be presented as an example of state-owned TNCs in the following section. It is
important to note that China’s authority insists in many circumstances that Chinese state-owned TNCs have
nothing to do with China’s political agenda in the world. Also, statistics regarding China’s TNCs activities are
outdated because they are infrequently collected. Salidjanova (2011) in his study about the U.S-China
economic relationship argues that “data most readily available from Chinese statistical sources generally
have a reputation for inaccuracy and opacity” (p. 27). Finally, although most developed and developing
economies have similar attitudes regarding state-owned TNCs, China is used in this article as a result of the
increasing economic and political power of Chinese TNCs around the globe.
3.1.1 State-Owned TNCs: China as Study Case
Unsurprisingly, recent reports have concentrated on the economic crisis and various countries’ efforts to
survive. Many articles and reports have been introduced lately that cover China’s government and China’s
state-owned TNCs and their involvement in helping governments financially (Salidjanova, 2011; UNCTD,
2011). A report by Financial Times shows that, as of 2011, China’s lending to developing countries has
exceeded lending from World Bank (Dyer et al., 2012). According to Dyer et al., (2012),
China Development Bank and China Export-Import Bank signed loans of at least $110bn (£70bn) to
other developing country governments and companies in 2009 and 2010, according to Financial
Times research. The equivalent arms of the World Bank made loan commitments of $100.3bn from
mid-2008 to mid-2010, itself a record amount of lending in response to the financial crisis.
Although this report concentrates on lending to developing countries, other reports show the increasing direct
and indirect support from China to all countries in need of financial assistance, such as Greece and African
countries. Investing in treasury bonds and securities in countries like the U. S. (e.g., more than 23.3 percent
of U.S Treasury Securities are held by China) is another example of the spread of Chinese investment all
over the globe (United States Department of the Treasury and Federal Reserve Board, 2012).
On the other hand, China’s FDI plays a major role in global FDI. According to World Investment Report, in
2010 China was the largest recipient of FDI among the developing countries with $106 Billion as 11 percent
increase from last year. In addition, outflows from China and Hong Kong increased 14.7 percent in 2010 to
reach $68 billion. The World Investment Report summarizes the increasing economic power of China and
China’s state-owned companies in the world as follows:
China’s position as a leading investor in extractive industries has been strengthened. The country
overtook the United States to become the world’s largest energy user in 2010, and Chinese oil
companies have continued their buying spree, spending $25 billion on overseas assets, accounting
for around one-fifth of all global deal activities. Mining companies from the country spent much less -
$4.5 billion - but are catching up, as highlighted by the $6.5 billion bid for Equinox Minerals (Australia
and Canada) by Minmetals Corporation. As a result of such investments, China has become the
leading foreign investor in Australia. (UNCTD, 2011a, p. 48)
In other words, although there has been a decline in global FDI and global economic activities since the
financial crisis of 2008, China and China’s state-owned TNCs have been raising their investments around the
globe. According to statistics from the Ministry of Commerce in China, Chinese investments are present in
more than 177 countries around the globe (Salidjanova, 2011). Most of these investments are carried by
Chinese state-owned TNCs, in which the Chinese authorities are heavily involved in directing operations and
strategies that serve the political agenda of the Chinese government. According to Salidjanova (2011),
Behind much of the concern over Chinese investments abroad lies the fear of the Chinese state -
acting through its large state-owned enterprises - acquiring increasing power and influence abroad,
and potentially engaging in other actions to promote the interests of the state and the Chinese
Communist Party. (p. 11)
123
In China’s Engagement in Africa, Tull (2006) investigates the ways that Chinese state-owned TNCs and
Chinese loans to African countries are used by Chinese authorities to influence internal and external affairs of
the countries receiving these loans and host countries of the TNCs. He argues that Chinese authorities use
business investments and loans to push the Chinese government’s political agenda. After reviewing statistics
of China’s investments in Africa, Tull (2006) argues that “China’s political and economic involvement in Africa
has a palpable impact on the domestic scene in many African states, which will increase should China
continue to pursue a more globally oriented foreign policy, particularly towards non-Western regions.” (p.
460)
Chinese state-owned TNCs are spreading all over the globe, with increasing economic power. This
economic power usually drives and results in political power as well, so it is clear the Chinese state-owned
TNCs are a fundamental tool used by Chinese authorities to gain a bigger role in the global political system.
4. International Organizations (IOs) vs. TNCs
International Organizations (IOs) have been key players in the global political system since World War II.
Many IOs have been established since WWII, such as the United Nations. In addition, as a result of
globalization, increasing in FDI activities globally, and the increasing economic and political role of privately
owned TNCs and state-owned TNCs, other IOs have been established, such as the World Trade
Organization (WTO). Accordingly, there has been a debate among politicians, economists, and academics on
the efficiency and effectiveness of IOs in pushing development, fighting corruption, supporting human rights
and higher living standards, and maintaining good governance practices worldwide. Also, there is a debate
among politicians with regard to the independence of decision-making process in IOs, where IOs have been
accused of serving developed countries’ interests. In the following section, IOs’ independence and economic
and political power will be discussed. Also, the increasing role of TNCs and the corresponding decreasing
role of IOs will be explored.
Dreher & Voigt (2011) argue that being a member of IOs claimed to add credibility to members. According
to Dreher & Voigt (2011), “membership in international organizations is often considered to have beneficial
consequences for their member countries – as well as for the international community at large” (p. 2).
However, in most cases, being a member of one or more of IOs is not enough to serve the country’s best
interest. Stone (2009) argues that informal governance is a necessary step for less powerful states to
participate and benefit from international organizations, even though such actions may negatively affect on
the credibility of IOs. According to Stone (2009),
Leaders of these countries find that the only way to exert effective leverage over international
organizations is to appeal to the leading states in the system—usually, to the United States—to exert
informal influence on their behalf. This intervention tends to undermine the credibility and autonomy of
the international organization involved, which may weaken its legitimacy vis-à-vis third parties. (p. 5-6)
Haftel and Thompson (2006) conducted research to study the factors that influence IOs’ political
independence and their ability to shape the global political system. They argue that “the independence of an
institution largely determines its authority and influence - in short, its ability to shape international politics”
(Haftel & Thompson, 2006, p. 254). The authors used three aspects of institutional design - decision making,
supranational bureaucracy, and dispute settlement - to study to what degree an IO is independent in making
decisions and adopting strategies. The study concludes that IOs’ economic independence and their ability to
shape the global political system are strongly correlated, so less economic independence means IOs will
have less influence in shaping the global political system.
Accordingly, as a result of the increased economic impact of TNCs through financial aid and investments,
privately owned TNCs and state-owned TNCs play an increasing role economically and politically compared
to IOs in shaping the global political system. In addition, the financial crisis of 2008 gave an advantage to
TNCs and countries with cash in hand, such as China, and their state-owned TNCs. Countries in need of
124
financial assistance go to IOs such as IMF and World Bank or to countries with the financial ability to help,
but since IOs have run out of money, countries ask strong economies such as China, Qatar, and UAE for
help. In response, these countries offer help directly through loans or indirectly through investment from
TNCs such as China Investment Corp. and Qatar Holding. However, “the ownership and governance of
State-owned TNCs have raised concerns in some host countries regarding, among others, the level playing
field and national security, with regulatory implications for the international expansion of these companies.”
(UNCTD, 2011a, p. X)
4.1 Thoughts for Success
The above discussion shows the importance of economic factors in shaping international relations, the
world’s political systems, and formal and informal governance. Many have called for the reorganization of IOs
so that they will have economic and political independence from the influence of powerful countries in order
to support human and governance development (Dreher & Voigt, 2011; Haftel & Thompson, 2006). Dreher
and Voigt (2011) hypothesize that “the degree of delegation to international organizations can improve the
credibility of nation-state governments.” (p. 1)
The WTO and Kyoto Protocol are examples of organizations and agreements attempting to regulate and
organize the world market in general and TNCs in particular, but due to the lack of political and economic
independence of such organizations, their success is limited. These organizations also have limited success
as a result of the conflict of interest between political and profitable issues, as well as the conflict of interest
between developed countries (USA, Japan, and Western EU) and developing countries (China, Brazil, and
India) (Bhagwati, 2005; Henderson, 2000; Jones, 2009; UNCTD, 2011a). Henderson (2000) states that
“international agreements on full disclosure, accounting standards, and other measures to police global
capital markets are still rudimentary.” (p. 1236)
On the other hand, Rondinelli (2003) thinks that recognizing the important role that TNCs (both privately
owned and state-owned) play in society and the global political system is the first step toward effective and
successful human and governance development. Also, he argues that the only way to hold TNCs
accountable for their actions at the global scale, and to make them work in the interest of the society of the
host and home states, is to give NGOs, civil society, and governments the power needed to function as a
‘watchdog’ on TNCs’ operations and tasks. According to Rondinelli (2003),
A more effective system of countervailing forces – allowing governments, NGOs and TNCs to apply
checks and balances that reduce the potential of any of the major participants in the global economy
of abusing their power or shirking their legitimate social responsibilities – depends on a better
understanding of the types of public roles that TNCs are playing and the scope and magnitude of their
impacts. (p. 21)
This suggestion relies on local authorities to protect the public interests, but it is missing the fact that TNCs,
as discussed before, operate mostly in nondemocratic political systems where corruption and ‘bad’
governance practices are common (Henderson, 2000; Koenig-Archibugi, 2004).
Bergsten (2008) studies the increasing influence of China as an economic and political power. He argues
that the power China has gained as a result of massive donations and loans to countries overthrows the role
of financial IOs such as IMF and World Bank. Thus, he argues that in the best interest of the U.S.
government economically and politically, the U. S. needs to absorb China’s raising power by sharing “global
economic leadership” (Bergsten, 2008, p. 1) with China. For economic and political reasons, Bergsten (2008)
argues that:
Washington would need to accept China as a true partner in managing global economic affairs, the
development of an intimate working relationship with an Asian country rather than its traditional
European allies, and constructive collaboration with an authoritarian political regime rather than a
democracy. (p. 8)
125
5. Recommendations and Future Researches
A state’s economy is the cornerstone of its existence. Thus, economic crises are a critical situation for any
state, in which they take every available step to minimize the consequences of such a situation. By contrast,
TNCs and states with a good economic status take advantage of other states’ economic crises by increasing
investments and increasing their economic and political power internationally.
Unfortunately, neither IOs nor most host governments are able to hold TNCs accountable for their actions
(Henderson, 2000; Koenig-Archibugi, 2004). Koenig-Archibugi (2004) draws a picture of the situation of
TNCs in host countries as follow:
The globalization of production exacerbates accountability gaps in the relationship between citizens
and corporations. Some of these gaps stem from the difficulties that governments have in holding
TNCs accountable under conditions of sustained capital mobility and opportunities for jurisdictional
‘exit’. Other gaps stem from the difficulties that citizens have in holding their government accountable
when it colludes with, and receives support from, economically robust corporations – and TNCs tend
to be robust in comparison to many host countries. Finally, sometimes governments are too weak to
function as effective links in the accountability chain between citizens and companies. (p. 257-258)
Consequently, the economic crisis situation makes any international efforts by countries and IOs to organize
TNCs’ activities even harder. Thus, Scherer el al. (2006) correctly state:
In a globalized world, however, global governance - referring to rule-making and rule-implementation
on a global scale - is no longer a task managed by the state alone. Today, transnational corporations
(TNCs), as well as civil society groups, increasingly participate in the formulation and implementation
of rules in policy areas that were once the sole responsibility of the state or international governmental
organizations. (p. 506)
Therefore, International Organizations (IOs), civil society organizations, people, and even TNCs need to work
together to reorganize the global political scene with new international agreements and IOs, because
institutions and international agreements that initiated after WWII are not working affectively anymore. Also,
the power of TNCs, especially state-owned TNCs, is increasing dramatically, so international community
needs to act fast to develop effective ways to protect the public interests and support human and governance
development.
This article raise concerns more than answers regarding the influence of the current economic crisis on
formal and informal governance. A few of the questions that should be considered are as follows. Will the
new tendency of states that are hit hard by the economic crisis to ask for help (both directly and indirectly)
from other countries such as China change governments’ priorities toward applying good governance
practices that have been pushed by IOs such as the UN, IMF, and World Bank? Are we experiencing a new
era of globalization and international governance as a result of the increasing economic and political power of
TNCs and the declining power of IOs? What do local governments need to do to protect citizen rights’ from
the greediness and selfishness of TNCs? And finally, what should we as citizen and civil society
organizations do to protect our interests? Each of these questions can be a research topic in itself, because
unfortunately there is no easy answer.
References
Bergsten, C. F. (2008). A Partnership of Equals How Washington Should Respond to China's Economic Challenge. Foreign Affairs,
July/August 2008.
Bhagwati, J (2005). Reshaping the WTO. Far Eastern Economic Review, 162 (22), 26-34.
Clark, C. and Chan, S. (1995). "MNCs and Developmentalism: Domestic Structure as an Explanation for East Asian Dynamism," in
Kappen, T. R. (ed.) Bringing Transnational Relations Back In: Non-State Actors, Domestic Structures and International Institutions.
Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press, pp. 112-145.
Dreher, A. & Voigt, S. (2011). Does Membership in International Organizations Increase Governments’ Credibility? Testing the Effects of
Delegating Powers. Journal of Comparative Economics, 39 (3), 326-348.
126
Dyer, G.; Anderlini, J and Sender, H. (2011, January 17). China’s lending hits new heights. Financial Times. Retrieved from
http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/488c60f4-2281-11e0-b6a2-00144feab49a.html#axzz1maJORzXx
Farazmand, A. (2002). Modern Organizational theory and Practice, (2nd ed). New York, NY: Praeger.
Haftel, Y. Z. & Thompson, A. (2006). The Independence of International Organizations: Concept and Applications. Journal of Conflict
Resolution, 50 (2), 253-275.
Harris, J. (2010). The World Economic Crisis and Transnational Corporations. Science and Society, 74 (3), 409-428.
Henderson, H. (2000). Transnational Corporations and Global Citizenship. American Behavioral Scientist, 43 (8), 1231-1261.
Hill, C. W. (2008). International Business (7th Ed.). Columbus, OH: McGraw-Hill.
Jones, K. (2009). The Doha Blues: Institutional Crisis and Reform in the WTO. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Koenig-Archibugi, M. (2004).Transnational Corporations and Public Accountability. Government and Opposition, 39 (2), 234-259.
Kwok, C. & Tadesse, S. (2006). The MNC as an Agent of Change for Host-Country Institutions: FDI and Corruption. (William Davidson
Institute Working Paper Number 882), University of MichiganIGAN
Kaufmann, D & Kraay, A. & Mastruzzi, M. (2010). The Worldwide Governance Indicators: Methodology and Analytical Issues (World
Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 5430). Washington, DC.: The World Bank.
McLean, J. (2003). The Transnational Corporation in History: Lessons for Today. Indian Law Journal, 79 (2), 363-377.
Newfarmer, R. (2001). Multinational Corporations, Globalization and Poverty. World Bank, Washington, D.C. Processed
Rondinelli, D. A. (2003). Transnational Corporations International Citizens New Sovereigns? Business Strategy Review, 14 (4), 13-21.
Salidjanova, N. (2011). Going Out: and Overview of China’s Outward Foreign Direct Investment. U.S.-China Economic & Security
Review Commission, Washington, D.C.
Scherer, A. G; Palazzo, G. & Baumann, D. (2006). Global Rules and Private Actors: Toward a New Role of the Transnational
Corporation in Global Governance. Business Ethics Quarterly, 16 (4), 505-532.
Stone, R. W. (2009). Informal Governance: International Organizations and the Limits of U.S. Power. Unpublished Manuscript, University
of Rochester.
Tull, D. M. (2006). China’s engagement in Africa: scope, signicance and consequences. Journal of Modern African Studies, 44 (3), 459
United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) (1996). Globalization and Liberalization: Development in the Face of
Two Powerful Currents. Report of the Secretary-General of UNCTAD to the Ninth Session of the Conference. Geneva: United
Nations Conference on Trade and Development.
United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTD) (2011a). World Investment Report 2011. New York, NY: United
Nations Publications.
United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTD) (2011b). World Investment Report 2011: Methodological Note. New
York, NY: United Nations Publications.
United States Department of the Treasury and Federal Reserve Board (February 15, 2012). Major foreign holders of Treasury securities.
U.S. Department of the Treasury. Retrieved from http://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/data-chart-center/tic/Documents/mfh.txt
World Bank (2012). Data. Retrieved 2/16/2012 from http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/BX.KLT.DINV.CD.WD
127

The Contrastive Move Analysis: An Investigation of Persian and English

Research Articles’ Abstract and Introduction Parts
Elham Zand-Vakili*
Iran University of Science & Technology
Alireza Fard Kashani

Iran University of Science & Technology
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.129
Abstract: The study of the generic and rhetorical structure of the research article genres and sub-genres is of crucial importance
in academic writing investigations. While the majority of such studies have mostly focused on articles written in English, the
analysis of the ‘moves’ in other languages might shed some light on cultural and linguistic variations in functional levels. The
present study investigated ten Persian and English Linguistics articles in terms of their moves in abstract and introduction parts.
Analysis was conducted by incorporating Hyland’s (2000) Information-Purpose-Methods-Products-Conclusion (IPuMPrC) model
and Swales’ (1990) the CreateAResearchSpace model (CARS) for abstract and introduction parts, respectively. Findings
revealed that while the moves mentioned by Hyland (2000) and others are totally typical to English research articles, some
significant variations exist in Persian articles.
Keywords: contrastive move analysis; linguistics; genre; research articles; abstract and introduction parts
1. Introduction
Over the recent years, a huge body of studies has been carried out on Research Articles (RA) and more
specifically, on their structure, social construction, historical evolution and etc. A number of these studies
have dealt with the overall organization of various parts of the research article, such as the abstracts (e.g.,
Salager-Meyer, 1992), the introduction (e.g., Swales, 1981, 1990; Swales & Najjar, 1987), the result section
(Thompson, 1993), discussion (Hopkins & Dudley-Evans, 1988). Various lexico-grammatical features of the
research article, ranging from tense choice to citation practices, have also been investigated. The social
construction of this genre (Myers, 1990) and the historical development of the research article (Salager-
Meyer, 1999) have been studied as well. In academic prose, abstracts, “a partgenre of the RA” (Swales &
Feak, 2009) have become an essential and inalienable part of research articles. Almost every scholarly
journal, written either in English or in other languages, would require an abstract to be submitted along with
the original research article (Marti, 2003). Abstracts have become a gateway into the research literature
(Hartley & Benjamin, 1998) and are a useful tool of mastering and managing the ever increasing information
flow in the scientific community (Ventola, 1994). The American National Standards Institute (ANSI) defines
abstract as follows: “[it] is an abbreviated, accurate representation of the contents of a document, preferably
prepared by its author(s) for publication with it” (Lorés, 2004: 281). This is especially true in today’s busy
information world. Nowadays, more and more research articles are accompanied by an informative abstract.
Previous studies of research article abstracts have covered several different disciplines, such as medicine,
psychology, and applied linguistics, and have mainly focused on two dimensions of abstracts: the rhetorical
organization or the move structure (e.g., Cross & Oppenheim, 2006; Lau, 2004; Santos, 1996) and the
linguistic realizations of the moves (e.g., Busch-Lauer, 1995; Pho, 2008).
Introduction, as one of the most researched sections of the RAs, has started to attract scholarly attention
since Swales’ (1981, 1990) work on the move structure of RA introductions, and since then the proposed
129
CARS model (Create-A-Research-Space) has been applied to other sets of texts. In 1990, Swales revised
his previous four-move structure to a threemove pattern, called the CARS model: 1. Establishing a territory,
2. Establishing a niche, and 3. Occupying the niche. The CARS model has influenced numerous later studies
on the structure of the introduction (Bhatia, 1997; Samraj, 2002, 2005). As Swales (2004) said, “the basically
threepart model for English language introductions in many leading journals is or has become prototypical”
(p. 226). The cyclical nature of introductions , the use of references in introductions , the investigation of
texts written in different languages and cultures using Swales’ model (e.g., Fredrickson & Swales, 1994),
the analysis of citation practices of ‘expert’ writers (e.g., Pickard, 1995), the investigation of citation practices
in academic texts (e.g., Thompson, 2000), extending Swales’ division of citation forms (e.g., Thompson &
Tribble, 2001), and the investigation of RA introductions from two disciplines (e.g., Samraj, 2002, 2005) are
among various studies conducted on the RA introduction. In spite of such studies in academic writing, there
has been less research on analysis of two types of sub-genres, namely, abstract and introduction parts,
written in two different languages of Persian and English, in terms of the moves in each language’s articles.
Moreover, although several studies have analyzed research article abstracts and introductions, only a few
studies have focused on articles in linguistics (e.g., Lorés, 2004; Pho, 2008; Santos, 1996). Hence, the
question probed in the present study was whether there was any difference in the use of functional moves in
sub-genres (i.e. abstracts and introductions) of theoretical linguistics articles written in Persian and English.
2. Theoretical Terms and Background
2.1. Concept of Genre
“The past decade or so has seen increasing attention given to the notion of genre and its application in
language teaching and learning” (Hyland, 2004: 303). A genre has been defined by Swales and Feak (2009)
as “a type of text or discourse designed to achieve a set of communicative purposes” (p. 1).
Scholars usually try three different approaches to genres: New Rhetoric approach, the ESP (English as
Specific Purpose) approach, and Systemic Functional Linguistics (Hyland, 2003). In the New Rhetoric
approach, Halliday (1994) develops classroom perspectives on the genre based the theory of systemic
functional linguistics. He focuses on social actions rather than form itself, which is a different feature from
systemic functional approach. He also argues that genres are resources for getting things done, and people
all have a repertoire of appropriate responses. The New Rhetoric school puts less emphasis on the form of
discourse and more emphasis on the action which is used to accomplish its purposes, seeking to establish
the connections between genres and repeated situations and to identify the way genre is seen as recurrent
rhetorical actions (Hyland, 2002). The ESP scholars define genre as a class of communicative events such
as a university lecture, or an academic essay (Paltridge, 2001). They also add that the events are linked by
shared purposes recognized by the members of a particular community and that the purposes are the
rationale of the genre. This point of view is based on Swales' work (1990) on the discourse structures and
linguistic features of scientific reports.
In Systemic Functional Linguistics, a genre is more often defined as a kind of text with related form,
function and context, such as a description, procedure, or exposition (Paltridge, 2001). In the view of
Systemic Functional Linguistics, a genre involves the interactions of participants using language in a
conventional, step-wise structure (Hyland, 2002). Thus, there are different views on how to define and
identify a genre. Some hold that a genre can be identified by the examination of textual structures alone, and
others present the view that genre identification requires a more complex perspective on the notion of genre.
The broadest of these views takes the position that several aspects contribute to the identification of a
communicative event as an instance of a particular genre and that this cannot necessarily be done with
reference to text structure alone (Paltridge, 2001).
130
Swales (1990) states that a genre comprises a class of communicative events, the members of which
share some set of communicative purposes. These purposes are recognized by the expert members of the
parent discourse community and thereby constitute the rationale for the genre. This rationale shapes the
schematic structure of the discourse and influences and constrains choice of content and style. Bhatia (1993)
asserts that a genre is a recognizable communicative event characterized by a set of communicative
purpose(s) identified and mutually understood by the members of the professional or academic community in
which it regularly occurs. Most often it is highly structured and conventionalized with constraints on allowable
contributions in terms of their intent, positioning, form, and functional value. He focuses on discourse within
the academic community and on the genre characteristics, conventions and constraints that are recognized
and understood by its professional members.
2.2. Move and Move Analysis
According to Samraj (2005), most of the studies in genre analysis have focused on single genres and not on
the relation among them. On the other hand, each ‘macro genre’ can be divided to some sub-genres
comprising a genre set. In other words, in the context of research articles, which can be viewed as a macro-
genre, there are some sub-genres like abstract, introduction, literature review, method, conclusion, etc parts
that are observable in most internationally acclaimed research articles. Accordingly, each sub-genre is
believed to be made of some functional moves revealing the purpose behind the linguistic expressions
written in that part. Richard and Schmidt (2002) define move as “a unit of discourse which may be smaller
than an utterance” (p. 344). Therefore, they are functional unites that are realized through the text.
Move analysis has also been employed in Contrastive Rhetoric (CR), studying cultural variation in
discourse structure. Kaplan stated, “the cultural background of the author might lead to variation of the
rhetorical structures of texts, and that such variation should be considered in ESL teaching programs” (as
cited in Li, 2011: 2). Considering the variations of RA structures among languages, researchers who wish to
succeed through publication in the international community will need to acquire awareness of crosslinguistic
differences in text structures. With the growing internationalization of the academic community, more and
more nonnative speakers (NNS) of English want to develop awareness and mastery over the writing
conventions of the AngloAmerican academic community in order to acquire international recognition. Due to
this fact, in the majority of crosslinguistic analyses of the RA structure, English RAs have always been
compared with RAs in other languages. Researchers who study the rhetorical patterns of ‘RA’ abstracts often
use move as the basic unit when conducting analysis. The analysis by move is also called that of information
structure. Santos (1996) gave a clear definition of move after Swales (1990) that “As genres are purposed,
staged activities, the move was chosen as the unit of analysis. A move is to be considered as a genre stage
which has a particular, minor communicative purpose to fulfill, which in turn serves the major communicative
purpose of the genre” (p. 485).
2.3. Previous Studies
In addition to move analysis, other features of abstracts in RAs in several disciplines, including both hard and
soft fields, have been examined. Some analyzed rhetorical structures of abstracts: for example, Lau (2004)
conducted a study using the corpus in the discipline of life science; Santos (1996) conducted analysis using a
corpus in applied linguistics. Others investigated verb-tense and modality used in three types of English
medical journal abstracts. Still others analyzed the rhetorical organization and thematic structures of journal
articles abstracts in linguistics. Lau (2004) compared RA abstracts written by 50 Taiwanese Ph.D. students
and those written by 30 foreign scholars in academic published journal papers of life science in an attempt to
show factors and beliefs that might affect structural patterns of academic abstracts. He used the abstract
structural patterns proposed by Hyland (2000)—Introduction, Purpose, Method, Product, and Conclusion for
131
the analysis of his corpora, substituting Result for Product used by Swales. After manual coding and analysis
of the 80 abstracts, results show that abstracts written by foreign scholars contain the assumed five moves,
with the exception of Method. Student abstracts do not contain all the five moves, and the percentage of
those with a five comprehensive move structure is relatively low compared with those of foreign scholars.
Three representative types in student abstracts were found: (a) BPuRC (B stands for background), (b) BRC,
and (c) RC. Lau gave three reasons for the findings of student abstracts: academic immaturity, linguistic
inadequacy, or word limit set for abstracts. He suggests the need to familiarize our graduate students with
various structural patterns. As for pedagogical implications, the five-move structural patterns and the
problematization process (Situation, Problem, Response, and Evaluation) can be useful in the teaching of
academic English.
Santos (1996) examined the moves structures of applied linguistics. He took a close look at the features
that constitute 94 published RA abstracts at the macro-level of textual organization and content as well as at
the micro-level of textual analysis taken from journals in the field of applied linguistics. Santos then raised a
number of issues based on the results of his study. First, there is an apparent mismatch between
recommendations in the technical writing textbooks and the way writers compose their articles. Second, the
proposed schematic pattern he used can be used as a pedagogic tool. Lastly, Santos expressed the concern
of the genre-specific conventions governing abstracts. Specifically, three major genre-specific features are:
the size of textual space allocated for each move (move balance), the blending of moves into the same
statement (move embedding), and the reversed sequence of moves (move reversal), might vary in different
disciplines (p. 497).
Similarly, Salager-Meyer (1992) conducted text-type and move analyses of verb tense and modality
distributions in English medical article abstracts. He aimed to find out how finite verb tenses and modals were
distributed across the different moves in abstracts of Medical English (ME) scholarly papers and across
different ME text types of all papers in his analysis. 84 abstracts of ME scholarly papers were collected for
analysis. Salager-Meyer concluded that a close relationship between the rhetorical function of each abstract
move and the use of verb tenses and modality has. Further, the communicative function of each ME text type
also determines the use of verb tenses in research papers. Lastly, it reaffirms the relationship between
suggestive discourse and the use of modality (or hedging), which reflects a limitation of claims and helps
writers move their findings away from the fact-like status. As for teaching implications, Salager-Meyer (1992)
suggested that when teaching verb tenses to scientists for reading or writing purposes, it is crucial to point
out their communicative purpose in the different rhetorical divisions of ME abstracts and in the different ME
text types. Lores (2004) analyzed the rhetorical organization and thematic structure of 36 research article
abstracts in applied linguistics. It was found that the rhetorical organization analysis showed that the
indicative type of abstracts followed the CARS (Swales 1990) structure other than the traditional IMRD
structure. Also, the finding in this study confirmed with previous ones that the two main types of thematic
pattern (simple linear and constant) are often combined in RA abstracts.
Hyland (2004) in his study of the generic structure of dissertation acknowledgements mentions about the
neglect of acknowledgement parts in such analyses. He identifies 3 macro moves, namely reflecting,
thanking and announcing moves. In reflecting move, the author gives his introspective comment on the
writer’s research experience; this macro move does not have any sub-move. On the other hand, ‘thanking’
move has 4 sub-moves, namely presenting participants, thanking for academic assistance, thanking for
resources, and thanking for moral support. In the ‘presenting participants’ sub-move, the author introduces
those to be thanked; in ‘thanking for academic assistance’ the authors thanks for intellectual support, ideas,
analyses feedback and etc; in ‘thanking for resource’, the writer thanks for data access and clerical, technical
and financial support; in the last sub-move, ‘thanking for moral support’, the author gives his gratitude for
encouragement, friendship, sympathy and patience. The last macro move is ‘announcing’ move in which the
writer accepts the responsibility of the study and states inspiration. This macro move in turn is divided into 2
sub-moves, namely ‘accepting responsibility’ and ‘dedicating the thesis’. In the former, the author gives
132
assertion of authorial responsibility for possible flaws and errors, and in the latter he gives a formally
dedicates the thesis to individual(s).
Ding (2007) in another study analyzed the moves in applications essays to medical and dental schools.
He also mentions that contrary to the significant role of personal statements in graduate school application,
little research has been done on its functional features and little instruction has been given about it in
academic writing courses. He therefore conducted a multi-level discourse analysis on a corpus of 30
medical/dental school application letters, using both a ‘hand-tagged’ move analysis and a computerized
analysis of lexical features of texts. He finally identified five recurrent moves, namely explaining the reason to
pursue the proposed study, establishing credentials related to the fields of medicine/dentistry, discussing
relevant life experience, stating future career goals, and describing personality.
Despite the bulk of research conducted into the analysis of research article genres and sub-genres
rhetorical structure and moves, most of such researches are conducted with the focus on articles written in
English, whether by natives or non-natives. This was the reason for the present study to address the inter-
linguistic difference in terms of the moves in Persian and English languages. Investigating the contrasts and
similarities in two languages’ articles, may help Iranian students to be familiar with the structure of the same-
filed research articles in English as an international language. Hence, academic writing needs to be explicitly
taught to those who want to participate in the academic circle. From the results of her lexical bundle study,
Cortes (2004) points out that simple exposure to research articles in one’s field does not guarantee
acquisition of the writing convention; thus helping students ‘notice’ and become aware of the different
contexts and discourse functions in academic disciplines is an important task for teachers.
3. Procedure and the Corpus
Having surfed the net, the researchers shared the list of related research articles with an outside expert and
the preliminary corpus (consisting of 13 RAs) was drawn form a range of articles refereed by the expert to be
central in the intended discipline (theoretical linguistics). The corpus was restricted to a period of 5 years
(2003-2008) to control for potential rapid changes within the discipline. The final corpus, 10 RAs (5 for each
language), was selected based on the importance and reputation of the journals and the extent to which the
journals were research-oriented. Moreover, to qualify for the final corpus, all the RAs had to report original
research. Furthermore, due to the fact that different disciplines may have different conventions to write
abstracts and introductions, and in order to present a more detailed analysis, the present study examined 10
theoretical linguistics articles’ abstracts and introductions from the dimension of move structure.
As Table 1 shows, the five English research articles were chosen from international journal of linguistics.
To recap, assuming that the type of journal might have a bearing in text organization, and to make the
analysis more reliable, only articles published in the international journal of linguistics were chosen and
included in the study.
Table 1. Five English Research Articles Selected from International Journal of Linguistics
No. Articles
1 ZHIMING, B. (2005). The aspectual system of Singapore English and the systemic substrates
explanation. J. Linguistics 41, 237–267.
2 ASUDEH, A. (2005). Control and semantic resource sensitivity1. J. Linguistics 41, 465–511.
3 HENGEVELD, K. (2004). Parts-of-speech systems and word order. J. Linguistics 40, 527–570.
4 GIEGERICH, H. J. (2005). Associative adjectives in English and the lexicon–syntax interface. J.
Linguistics 41, 571–591
5 SILVERMAN, D. (2003). On the rarity of pre-aspirated stops. J. Linguistics 39, 575–598.
133
Moreover, the five Persian research articles, two from Pazand Linguistic Journal, and three from Journal of
Language and Linguistics, were chosen from two national journal articles (see Table 2).
Table 2. Five Persian Research Articles Selected from Pazand Linguistic Journal
Articles No.
‫ ﺳﺎل‬:‫ ﻣﺠﻠﻪ زﺑﺎن و زﺑﺎﻧﺸﻨﺎﺳﯽ‬.‫ ﺗﺤﻠﻴﻞ ﻣﻌﻨﺎﻳﯽ واژﮔﺎن ﻣﺮﮐﺐ ﻣﻔﻌﻮﻟﯽ در زﺑﺎن ﻓﺎرﺳﯽ‬.(86) .‫ س‬،‫ ع و ﻣﺠﻴﺪﯼ‬،‫ﻣﻴﺮﻋﻤﺎدﯼ‬ 1
.‫ ﻣﺠﻠﻪ اﻧﺠﻤﻦ زﺑﺎﻧﺸﻨﺎﺳﯽ اﻳﺮان‬.‫ ﺷﻤﺎرﻩ اول‬،‫ﺳﻮم‬
‫ ﺷﻤﺎرﻩ‬،‫ ﺳﺎل ﺳﻮم‬:‫ ﻣﺠﻠﻪ زﺑﺎن و زﺑﺎﻧﺸﻨﺎﺳﯽ‬.‫ روﻳﮑﺮد ﻏﺎﻟﺐ در ﺗﺤﻠﻴﻞ ﮔﻔﺘﻤﺎن اﻧﺘﻘﺎدﯼ‬.(86) .‫ م‬،‫ ف و ﻏﻴﺎﺛﻴﺎن‬،‫ﺁﻗﺎﮔﻞ زادﻩ‬ 2
.‫ ﻣﺠﻠﻪ اﻧﺠﻤﻦ زﺑﺎﻧﺸﻨﺎﺳﯽ اﻳﺮان‬.‫اول‬
:‫ ﻣﺠﻠﻪ زﺑﺎن و زﺑﺎﻧﺸﻨﺎﺳﯽ‬.‫ ﺑﺮﺧﯽ از ﻓﺮﺁﻳﻨﺪهﺎﯼ واﺟﯽ در ﮔﻴﺶ ﮔﻴﻠﮑﯽ رودﺳﺮ‬.(86) .‫ م‬،‫ ع و ﺷﻌﺒﺎﻧﯽ‬،‫زﻋﻔﺮاﻧﻠﻮ ﮐﺎﻣﺒﻮزﻳﺎ‬ 3
.‫ ﻣﺠﻠﻪ اﻧﺠﻤﻦ زﺑﺎﻧﺸﻨﺎﺳﯽ اﻳﺮان‬.‫ ﺷﻤﺎرﻩ اول‬،‫ﺳﺎل ﺳﻮم‬
‫ ﻓﺼﻠﻨﺎﻣﻪ‬.‫ ﺷﻨﺎﺧﺖ زﺑﺎن ﺑﻨﻴﺎد در زﺑﺎﻧﺸﻨﺎﺳﯽ ﻧﻘﺸﮕﺮا و ﺷﻨﺎﺧﺖ ﻣﻔﻬﻮم ﺑﻨﻴﺎد در زﺑﺎﻧﺸﻨﺎﺳﯽ ﺷﻨﺎﺧﺘﯽ‬.(87) .‫ ف‬،‫ﺳﺎﺳﺎﻧﯽ‬ 4
.87 ‫ ﺑﻬﺎر‬،‫ﺷﻤﺎرﻩ دوازدهﻢ‬-‫ ﺳﺎل ﭼﻬﺎرم‬:‫ ﻧﺸﺮﻳﻪ ﻋﻠﻤﯽ زﺑﺎن‬،‫ﭘﺎزﻧﺪ‬
.‫ ﺑﺮرﺳﯽ راهﺒﺮدهﺎﯼ ﺷﻨﺎﺧﺘﯽ اﺳﺘﻌﺎرﻩ و ﮐﻨﺎﻳﻪ ﺗﺼﻮرﯼ در اﺻﻄﻼﺣﺎت ﺣﺎوﯼ اﻋﻀﺎﯼ ﺑﺪن‬.(87) .‫ ش‬،‫ ا و ﻣﻤﺴﻨﯽ‬،‫ﮔﻠﻔﺎم‬ 5
.87 ‫ ﺑﻬﺎر‬،‫ﺷﻤﺎرﻩ دوازدهﻢ‬-‫ ﺳﺎل ﭼﻬﺎرم‬:‫ ﻧﺸﺮﻳﻪ ﻋﻠﻤﯽ زﺑﺎن‬،‫ﻓﺼﻠﻨﺎﻣﻪ ﭘﺎزﻧﺪ‬
In order to probe the difference between Persian and English article journals of theoretical linguistics in terms
of the functional moves, the abstract and introduction parts of the five intended articles in each language
were compared based on Hyland’s (2000) Information-Purpose-Methods-Products-Conclusion (IPuMPrC)
model and Swales’ (1990) the CreateAResearchSpace model (CARS) for each part, respectively (Tables
3 and 4).
Table 3. The Number of Moves in Abstracts
Number of English
Articles Number of Persian
Articles Having This Move
Articles Having This Move
Functional Moves
Introduction:
4
(Statement of the Knowledge) 1
(Statement of the Problem) -

1
5 5
Purpose of the Study
Method 3 2
Results 4 5
Conclusions 1 4
134
Table 4. The Number of Moves in Introductions
Number of Persian Number of English

Article Journals
Articles Having This Move Articles Having This Move
Functional Moves
1. Establishing a Territory
A: Claiming Centrality: - 1
B: Making Topic Generalization: 3 4
C: Reviewing Previous Research: _ _
2. Establishing a Niche
A: Counter Claiming: _ 3
B: Indicating a Gap: _ 2
C: Question Raising: 1 _
D: Continuing a Tradition: 1 _
3. Occupying a Niche
A: Outlining Purposes: 3 4*
B: Announcing Present Research: _ 4*
C: Announcing Principal Findings: _ 5*
D: Indicating R Structure: 2 4*
*Each introduction has three or all four sub-moves in the ‘Occupying the Niche’ move. This case
was not observed in Persian articles.
4. Results
Results of the present study revealed that there are noticeable differences in the frequency of moves in
Persian and English articles’ Abstract and Introduction parts. The ‘purpose of the study’ move in Persian
articles was found present in all 5 research articles, then ‘results’ move was found prominent in frequency
with 4 articles having it. ‘Introduction’ move was only observed in one Persian article. Regarding English
articles, the 3 moves of ‘Introduction, Purpose, and Results’ were used in all articles. 4 English articles out of
five also had the ‘conclusion’ move. To sum up, the results showed the significance of the ‘purpose of the
study’ move in both Persian and English articles. The ‘results’ section was also prominent in both Persian
and English abstracts. But ‘conclusion’ move was found prominent only in English but not in Persian (only
one out five articles had this move in Persian).
Dealing with introduction part, significant difference was observed. 3 Persian articles’ introductions met
the ‘establishing a territory’ move, 2 met ‘establishing a niche move’, and 5 met ‘occupying the niche’ move.
But it was found interesting that all English articles met all these three ‘macro moves’ and variations were
only observable in the ‘sub-moves’ as shown in Table 4.
Another finding was that most of the English introductions included most of the sub-moves of the
‘occupying the niche’, but each Persian introductions met only one of these sub-moves. Therefore, the results
of the comparison and contrast showed that those articles written in Persian and those counterparts written in
English are significantly different in terms of the functional moves in their abstract and introduction parts.
5. Conclusions
The findings of the current study revealed that although moves are functional units which show the purpose
135
of linguistic expression used in academic settings, there might be some linguistic-cultural differences
between the uses of the moves in research articles. It is safe to assume that the English research articles
conform mostly to the moves identified by the experts due to the fact that their studies solely have focused on
genres and sub-genres in English language. But other languages, like Persian here, might incorporate (to
some degrees) different generic structures. As the current study showed, Persian articles, while having the
overall structure like English articles, contrary to English articles make use of more ‘general’ macro moves
and less specific detailed sub-moves. This genre-based study offers, to linguistic researchers as well as
EFL/ESP teachers, insights which can be used in instruction. Foreign language teaching can benefit from it,
mainly because it is an authentic sample of language in use. However, one important point has to be made in
order to avoid an over-use or misuse of it. Genre approach is a useful tool if one is looking for a holistic
teaching methodology but it has to be understood as a clarificatory description rather than prescription
(Swales, 1990; Bhatia, 1993). The findings of this research can be applied in English for Academic Purposes
courses for non-native English-speaking researchers or graduate students to contribute to the development
of learners’ awareness of the structures and grammatical forms that typify the discoursal patterns of the RAs.
Learners in such courses may profit from a pedagogical approach that raises their awareness about the
structures that exhibit syntactic-semantic distance. This can be achieved through activities that require, within
a discoursal framework, discriminating and judgment through alternative evidence provided on the basis of
appropriacy. Thus congruent and incongruent structures can be observed or contrasted across the
introductions of the RAs or contrasted with other scientific genres, allowing the learner to judge on the basis
of appropriacy rather than on the basis of grammaticality.
References
ANSI (1979). The American standard for writing abstracts. New York: ANSI Publication.
Bhatia, V (1993). Analyzing genre: Language use in professional settings. London: Longman.
Bhatia, V (1997). Introduction: Genre analysis and world Englishes. World Englishes, 16(3), 313–319.
Busch-Lauer, I. A (1995). Abstracts in German medical journals: A linguistic analysis. Information Processing & Management, 31(5),
769-776.
Cortes, V (2004). Lexical bundle in published and student disciplinary writing: Examples from history and biology. English for Specific
Purposes, 23, 379-423.
Cross, C., & C. Oppenheim (2006). A genre analysis of scientific abstracts. Journal of Documentation, 62(4), 428-446.
Ding, H (2007). Genre analysis of personal statements: Analysis of moves in application essays to medical and dental schools. English
for Specific Purposes, 26, 368–392.
Fredrickson, K. M., & J. M. Swales (1994). Competition and discourse community: Introductions from Nysvenska Studier. In B.L.
Gunnarsson, P. Linell & B. Nordberg (Eds.), Text and talk in professional contexts (9-22). Sweden: ASLA.
Halliday, M. A. K (1994). An introduction to functional grammar. London: Edward Arnold.
Hartley, J., & M. Benjamin (1998). An evaluation of structured abstracts in journals published by the British psychological society. British
Journal of Educational Psychology, 68, 443-456.
Hopkins, A., & T. Dudley-Evans (1988). A Genre based investigation of the discussion section in articles and dissertations. English for
Specific Purposes, 7(2), 113-121.
Hyland, K (2000). Disciplinary discourses: Social interactions in academic writing. Harlow: Longman.
Hyland, K (2002). Genre: Language, context and literacy. Annual Review of Applied Linguistics, 22, 113-135.
Hyland, K (2003). Genre-based pedagogies: A social response to process. Journal of Second Language Writing, 12, 17-29.
Hyland, K (2004). Graduates’ gratitude: The generic structure of dissertation acknowledgements. English for Specific Purposes, 22(3),
303–324.
Lau, H. H (2004). The structure of academic journal abstracts written by Taiwanese PhD students. Taiwan Journal of TESOL, 1(1), 1-25.
Li, Y (2011). A genre analysis of English and Chinese research article abstracts in linguistics and chemistry. Unpublished master’s
thesis, San Diego State University, California, The United States of America.
Lores, R (2004). On RA abstracts: from rhetorical structure to thematic organization. English for Specific Purposes, 23, 280-302.
Martin, P. M (2003). A genre analysis of English and Spanish research paper abstracts in experimental social sciences. English for
Specific Purposes, 22(1), 25-43.
Myers, G (1990). Writing biology. Madison, WT: The University of Wisconsin Press.
Paltridge, B (2001). Genre and the language learning classroom. Ann Arbor, MI: The University of Michigan Press.
Pho, P. D (2008). Research article abstracts in applied linguistics and educational technology: A study of linguistic
realizations of rhetorical structure and authorial stance. Discourse Studies, 10(2), 231250.
136
Pickard, V (1995). Citing previous writers: What can we say instead of “say”?. Hong Kong Papers in Linguistics and Language Teaching,
18, 89-102.
Richard, J. C., & R. Schmidt (2002). Dictionary of language teaching & applied linguistics (3rd Ed.). Longman Publications.
Samraj, B (2002). Introductions in research articles: Variations across disciplines. English for Specific Purposes, 21(1), 1-17.
Samraj, B (2005). An exploration of a genre set: Research article abstracts and introductions in two disciplines. English for Specific
Purposes, 24(2), 141–156.
Salager-Meyer, F (1990). Referential behavior in scientific writing: A diachronic study (1810- 1995). English for Specific Purposes, 18,
279-305.
Salager-Meyer, F (1992). A text-type and move analysis study of verb tense and modality distributions in medical English abstracts.
English for Specific Purposes, 11, 93-133.
Santos, M. B. D (1996). The textual organization of research paper abstracts in applied linguistics. Text, 16, 481-499.
Swales, J (1981). Aspects of article introduction. Aston ESP Research Report No. 1 Language Studies Unit. Birmingham: University of
Aston.
Swales, J (1990). Genre analysis: English in academic and research settings. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Swales, J (2004). Research genres: Explorations and applications. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Swales, J., & H. Najar (1987). The Writing of research article introductions, Written Communication, 4, 175-192.
Swales, J & C. B. Feak (2009). Academic writing for graduate students. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
Thompson, P (2000). Citation practice in PhD theses. In L. Burnard & T. McEnery (Eds.), Rethinking Language Pedagogy from a Corpus
Perspective (91-101). Frankfurt: Peter Lang.
Thompson, P., & C. Tribble (2001). Looking at citations: Using corpora in English for academic purposes. Language Learning &
Technology, 5(3), 91-105.
Thompson, D. K (1993). Arguing for experimental “facts” in science. Written Communication, 10, 106-128.
Ventola, E (1994). Problems in producing scientific abstracts in L2. In S. Cmejrkova & F. Sticha (Eds.), The syntax of sentence and text.
Philadelphia: John Benjamins.
137

An Assessment of Seasonal Variation of Waste Generation and Management

in Cross River State, Nigeria
Ukwayi Joseph K. (Ph.D)
Department of Sociology, University of Calabar, Calabar.

Email: jukwayiegmail.com
Peter A Essoh. (Ph.D)
Department of Sociology/Anthropology University of Uyo – Nigeria

Department of Urban &Regional Planning, Cross River University of Technology-Nigeria
Inah, Sylvester Abam. (M.sc)
Department of Sociology, University of Calabar, Calabar.

Email: jukwayiegmail.com
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.139
Abstract: The level of waste generation and management in Ugep and Ikom urban are of great concern to many scholars in
environmental management .This paper attempt to assess the seasonal variation of waste generation and management in the
two urban centre in Cross River State. One hundred and five copies of questionnaire were randomly distributed in each of urban
centre to the residents in three major streets in the area. Information such as flash points, dump sites, types of waste and the
frequency of waste disposal were captured in the questionnaire. Findings shows that there was no significant different in the
seasonal variation of urban waste generation and management in the two areas under investigation which was evidenced in the
tested hypothesis with high calculated value greater than the critical value of 1.56 at 0.05 level of significance. The fisher ISD
test was further used to buttress the above assertion and the result indicate that family size influence the amount of waste
generation in the two areas. However, the sustainability of the environment in these two areas depends on the various
stakeholders in area
Key words: Urban environment, stakeholders, flash points ,waste disposal.
1. Introduction
In many countries of the developing world, solid wastes management has constituted a serious problem
because of the low level of technology that is not sophisticated enough to handle the high rate of wastes
generation (Baum, 1973). The rapid rate of urbanization and population growth in a large extend has
contributed to the rate of waste generation especially in urban areas. Human population and rural-urban
migration has increase through urbanization, natural increase rate and industrialization, yet the service
rendered is not sizeable enough to control the high level of solid waste generated in urban areas and these
has contributed to a large extent, the nuisance and the damaging effect of the urban environment (Sule,
2004). The rapid growth of the urban areas, according to David M. (1985), has resulted in increasing number
of industrial establishments, and inhabitants. Increasing quantity of goods produced, increase in total income
with corresponding increase in level of consumption led to substantial increase in the amount of solid wastes
generated. Today, the rate at which waste is being generated is about 70% as compared to the total rate of
its disposal which is 30% (Edu, 2003). No doubt Edu (2003) argued that waste could be anything which may
not be directly useful or needed by man. In Nigeria, the dehumanizing effects of these circumstances in our
urban lives and bighted environments has often been cited and noted as contributing causes of Nigerian
139
urban decay (Asuquo, 1979). Ugep and Ikom urban are not left out in this scenario despite the huge revenue
allocated to waste disposal and management by the government, the rate of waste generation and
management constitute a serious problem in area. (Ekpoh, 2003). Beside, areas are crowded with
biodegradable and non-biodegradable waste which one cannot ascertain how they are disposed and
managed hence it posed great threat to the urban environmental quality in the area. It is also surprise that
the residents in these areas are ignorance of the problems associated with indiscriminate waste disposal,
even when the dump sites are provided, the waste are liter around the environment. In this vein, one may ask
why the residents are unable to manage their waste in an unacceptable manner, what is then responsible for
the negative attitude of the people towards waste disposal and management in the area? Therefore, this
paper seek to make a comparative analysis of waste generation management with specific reference to the
types of types of waste, methods of waste disposal, frequency of waste disposal and waste evacuation in the
areas.
2. Methodology
This study was conducted in Cross River State taking consideration two urban towns such as Ugep and
Ikom. Three (3) streets each were used for this study of which sampled location were considered especially
streets with flash points (i.e. where individual waste or domestic waste were empty before it is finally
disposed. In Ugep the streets considered were Bikobiko, Usaja and Lekpakom while in Ikom Ochedere,
Prince Niko and Bacha streets were considered. The rationale for using these major streets was base on the
fact that these streets witnesses a high population and socio-economic activities which gives rise to high level
of waste generation in the area. Data such as frequency of waste disposed types of waste generation and
evacuation methods were obtained from the questionnaire administered to the residents in each of the urban
centre. A sample population of 210 was drawn from the two areas of which 105 questionnaires each were
randomly administered to residents in the area. However, the data obtained were analyzed using the One-
way ANOVA.
3. Factors Influencing Solid Waste Generation
Solid waste generation is a product is brought about by many factors like population growth, urbanization,
increase in per capital income, improvement in living standard of people and even technological
advancement. Stren and Whyte, (1989) noted, as a result of rapid population growth and the increasing
density of people and houses in major urban centres, the volumes of waste generated have grown
tremendously, Unfortunately, the capacity of the municipal governments to handle this and other urban
challenges is not commensurate with the rate of urbanization and the growth in magnitude of the urban
problems. Piles of uncollected wastes are common in many urban centres in Africa, making the urban
environment unhealthy, unclean and unattractive to investment. The greater the size of urban centres, the
greater the level of environmental pollution.
This is because the inhabitants of these cities generate wastes that accentuate the size and volume of
pollution. As these cities grows with increase population, the land areas decreases leaving little or not space
for efficient waste disposal sites. Sule (1991). Over the last five decades, population of towns and cities in
Nigeria has been on the increase by 5 percent per year. In the last ten years alone, the urban population had
grown by more than 350 million people, Sule (2001). Most of these people are being drawn to the cities by
the prospect of finding a better standard of living, which when achieved will result in the increase in daily
consumption of food and in the rate at which people purchase good and materials thus discarding the old
ones and as a result increase in solid waste generation. In the context of technological advancement, Sule
(2004) noted the rich societies of the developed countries are likely to be more concern about the
unfavorable effects of solid waste produced based on technological advancement than those nations in the
140
developing countries where poverty and hunger are the order of the day. Solid waste management is the
collection, transport. processing, recycling or disposal of waste materials. The term usually relates to
materials produced by human activity, and is generally undertaken to reduce their effect on health,
aesthetics, or amenity. Waste management is also carried out to reduce the materials effect on the
environment, and to recover resources from them (Odum, 2007). Solid waste management practices differ for
developed and developing countries, for urban and rural areas, and for residential and industrial producers.
Management for non-hazardous residential and institutional waste in metropolitan areas is usually the
responsibility of local government authorities, while management for non-hazardous commercial and
industrial waste is usually the responsibility of the generator. Ekpoh (2003) argued that the solid management
requires a more serious attention. This fact is true because, in Nigeria, inadequate attention about solid
waste management has resulted in littering of waste everywhere. The nation, he added, need to pay more
than usually attention about solid waste management. Well, in Nigeria, the Federal and State even the Local
Government have set various solid waste management arrangements in many parts of the nation.
4. Findings
4.1 Types of waste generation
Types of waste generated in the area as shown in table I revealed that there was no significant variation in
the types of waste generation in the two seasons as indicated with a maximum value of 54.28% and 50%
which shows that majority of the waste generated in two seasons composed of garbage and vegetable waste
while 14.75% of the waste were wood/glass and plastics. Table 1 shows that the sampled population in
Ugep urban were of the opinion that garbage was the major waste generated in the area during wet season
with a value of 34.28% which was on the high side compared to dry season with a value of 24.76%. This
variation was wideness in Ikom urban with garbage having a low value of 17.14% during wet season
compared to dry season with a high value of 27.61%. Accordingly, this situation was observed in the
vegetable waste generated as presented in table 1.
Table 1: Types of waste generated in the area
Variables Types of waste generation Types of waste generation Percentage Percent

Wet season Dry season maximum age
Ugep Percentage Ikom Perce Ugep Perce Ikom Percentage Wet season maximu
urban urban ntage urban ntage urban m Dry
season
Garbage 36 34.28 18 17.14 26 24.76 29 27.61 28.57 23.81+
Vegetable 30 28.57 30 28.57 29 27.61 21 20.00 - -
Paper/glass 19 18.09 16 15.23 17 16.19 6 5.71 - -
Wood/bone 10 9.52 5 4.75 13 12.38 2 1.90 7.14 *7.14
Cans 9 8.57 25 23.80 11 10.47 30 28.57 - -

Plastics 5 4.76 11 10.47 9 8.57 12 11.4 7.61 *10.00
Total 105 100 105 100 105 100 105 +54.28 +50.00
*14.75 *17.14
Source: Field survey (2011)
However, the trend analysis of types of waste generation in the area presented in figure 1 shows a seasonal
variation in the types of waste generated in the two areas which ranged from garbage, vegetables,
paper/glass, wood/bone, cans and plastic waste.
141
Figure 1: Trend analysis of different types of waste generation in the area
4.2 Methods of waste disposal in the area
Table 2 which represent the methods of waste disposal shows that there is no significant variation in the
methods of waste disposal in the dry season with a percentage maximum of 36.19% which indicate that
waste were basically disposed in open pits and gutters. This result was also evidenced in wet season as
23.85% and 43.80% of waste generated were disposed in gutters with a variation in the methods of waste
disposal as observed in a value of 45.75% compared to 41.90% which indicate that the residents in Ugep
were used to disposing their waste in open pits and space during wet season which was contrary to 23.80%
which shows that majority of the residents preferred dumping their waste in gutters during dry season.
However, this was also obtained in dry season with 37.14% and 39.04% of the resident having the opinion
that gutters and open pits constitute the major methods of waste disposal even though other methods such
as backyard, cans and roadsides exist.
Table 2: Methods of waste disposal in the area
Variables Wet season Dry season Percentage Percentage

Ugep Percentage Ikom Percentage Ugep Percentage Ikom Percentage maximum maximum
urban urba urban urban Wet Dry season
n season
Waste 13 12.38 16 15.23 2 1.90 4 3.80 - -
cans
Backyards 18 12.00 5 4.76 4 3.80 6 5.71 - -
Gutters 23 21.90 25 23.80 41 39.04 35 33.33 23.85 36.19
Pits, open 48 45.75 44 41.90 39 37.14 37 35.23 43.80 36.19
space 48
Roadsides 3 2.85 15 14.28 19 18.09 23 21.90 - -
Total 105 100 105 100 105 100 105 100
142
4.3 Number of flash points
The number of flash points presented in figure 2 indicate the number of flash points located in both areas
which varies from one another. This was observed in 55.15% flash points located in the streets in Ikom which
was on the high side compared to 51.71% of the flash points in Ugep urban. Figure 2 shows that number of
flash points in Prince Niko streets were high with a value of 24.13 compared to Bikobiko streets were high
with a value of 24.13 compared to Bikobiko streets with a value of 20.68%. However, it was observed that
Lekpakom and Ugep urban and Ndoma Egba street in Ikom recorded a low number of flash points with
values of 13.79% and 10.34% respectively which shows that waste generation and management is very poor
in these locations.
Figure 2: Number of flash points in the areas
4.4 Frequency of waste generation
The frequency of waste generated presented in figure 3 indicate that 50.47% and 56.19% of the sampled
population in both areas are of the opinion that waste were disposed on daily bases in both wet and dry
season as also evidenced in wet season with maximum value of 48.57%. It was observed in figure 3 that
majority of the sampled population are of the opinion that waste are evacuated and disposed after 3 days in
both Ugep and Ikom urban with values of 49.52% and 55.23% respectively. However, a critical assessment
shows that a maximum of 48.57% and 35.25% of the entire population sampled are of the opinion that waste
were mostly disposed daily or after 3 days during wet season which was on the high side compared to dry
season with values of 26.19% and 52.3% respectively.
143
Figure 3: Frequency of waste disposed in the area
5. Result analysis
Result on the analysis of the influence of family size on the rate of waste generation as shown in table 3
indicate a high calculated of 6.42 which was greater than 4.07 critical f-value at 0.05 level of significance.
This result shows that family size has a significant influence on waste generation as shown in table 3. The
fishers’ least significance difference (LSD) post hoe test was used to assess if or not the class of family size
greatly influences the amount of waste generation in the study area as presented in table 4. The LSD post
hoe test shows that the significant t-values was observed between groups ‘1’ and 2, 3, 4, 1 and 5, 2 and 3, 2
and 4; and between groups ‘2’ and e and also significant difference between groups 1 and 2, 3 and d and
between group 3 and 4. The interpretation of this result shows that there was a significant difference in the
rate of waste generation between the group the t-values are significant below the diagonal as presented in
the fisher’s LSD test l. In each of the group, the calculated t-values was greater than the critical t-value of
1.56 at 0.05 level of significance.
Table 3: Fishers’ LSD of the influence of family size on the rate of waste generation
Group Family size 1 2 3 4 5

(n1-31) (n2-26) (n3-50) (n4-45) (n5-17)
1-2 42.03 -0.10 -6.33 -3.78 -3.20
3-4 -0.17 41.20 -6.04 -3.35 -3.17
5-7 -6.33* -7.54* 43.30 0.56 0.74
8-10 -5.44* - 6.73* 1.02 42.64 0.19
11 and above -3.47* - 44.0* 0.65 0.19 43.39
Msw = 7.94
Source: Data analysis (2011)
144
6. Recommendations
It was observed from the findings that accept waste generation and management is revolutionaries in the
areas under investigation, the problems of waste generation and management would continue to persist.
Therefore, the following are recommended if the problems of waste must be averted in the areas.
 Effective campaign should be carried out for residents to see the necessity of consciousness with regards
waste disposal and management.
 Government should re-introduced the monthly sanitation in order to make the people more conscious of
the purity of their surroundings.
 Government should provide adequate funds for proper execution of environmental programs . This would
help secure new modern waste management technology that could help correct the negative attitude of
citizens towards waste disposal and management.
 Open dump sites should be declared out of bound as they are always in a state of abuse by the people
7. Conclusion
Today, waste generation has generated great concern to many scholars in environmental studies due to it
impact on the human health and sanity. The study shows that both residents in Ugep and Ikom were not
conscious of the implication of poor waste management which has resulted to the poor nature of the human
ecosystem in the two cities. However, since environmental enlightenment changes the people’s attitudes
towards waste management, there is need for urgent enlightenment programs that would help educate the
people on waste management and control in the area
References
Afangideh, A.I. and L. Njoku (2001). Modeling for the relationship between weather and heat induced health problems in University of
Calabar., A Journal of Environmental Analysis No.7 pp.660-672.
Ekpoh, I. J. (2003). Environmental continuity and change. Waste management, in Nigeria: St Paul publishing and printing company;
Nigeria.
Baum, B and Parker, G. H. (1973). Solid waste disposal, vol. 1 incinerations and landfill, Michigan Ann Arober Science Publishers
incorporated.
Bourton, J. I. (1973). Solid waste, factor influencing generation rates, Chicago: Department of Geography, University of Chicago.
Edu,N.(2003). Environmental Waste and management: Ushie printers and publishing Co.Ltd. Calabar.
Odum, A. E. (2000). The problems and prospects of solid waste disposal: Owerri An unpublished B.Sc Diss.
Okpiliya, F. I. and A. I. Afangideh (2004). Determination of the level of Degradation floral diversity in the tropical rainforest ecosystem of
Boki, Nigeria. Environmental Analar, A Journal of Environment analysis. No.10,pp.1169-1183.
Sule R. O. (2001): urban environmental pollution critically: A synopsis, published by BAAJ international company Calabar/Benin.
Sule, R. O.I (2004): Solid and faecal waste disposal urban Development planning framework the Nigeria experience ; .thumbprint IntI
Company, Nigeria.
Turner, J. F (1969): uncontrolled urban settlements, problems and policies. Readings on urbanization prentice Hall, pp. 507-531.
Uchegbu, S. N. (1988): Environmental Management and protection precision printers and publishers, Nigeria.
Wagner, R. H. (1991): Environmental and man. New York W. W. Norton and Company.
145

Accessible Package of Services in Health Insurance Reform in Albania
Ma Zamira Sinaj
Director of Health Care Public Institute, Vlore Albania

Dean of Graduated School,”IsmailQemali University”Vlore Albania,

Economic Faculty, Management department2
Ma Eliza Bodo
Health Care Public Institute, Vlore Albania

Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.147
Abstract: This article presents a summary of the current status, of health Albanian system.The developing health care system of
undergraduate, postgraduate and continuous medical education in Albania and suggests opportunities for development and
partnerships that would help the country's medical education reform. The impact of these changes and developing health care
sector may be reduced by two modifications in undergraduate medical programs. First identifying, training practice
discrepancies, with a view of correcting them. Computerization of all pharmacies started for the first time in 2007. Partnership
with health institutions and namely with pharmacies was also strengthened. The intention of this corporation was to insure
hardware equipment to support the software produced by HII.Since their system was designed in such a way that it served not
only to HII, but also to pharmacies in their everybody work, very soon pharmacists that previously didn’t want to procure
equipment became our collaborators in improving the system. The HII received more than 17% of all health funds, with 8.5%
coming from the state budget, 4.3% from employers and 4.4% from individual contributions. While the state remains the major
source of health care financing, its contribution shrank from around 84% in 1990 to less than 60% in 1999 as other funding,
especially out-of-pocket payments, increased.
Keywords: Health insurance, health care system, Bismark model, cost- effective and reference system, contribution payer,
Government priorities, hospital indicators.
1. Introduction
Healthcare is funded by the state and private practice is limited to a small niche sector. The state system is
supposed to be funded through insurance contributions from those employed and their employers, but
poverty in Albania is rife and few can afford to pay. The net result is that many people fail to get much
needed medicine and medical care to treat their ailments. The failure to collect a substantial amount of
contributions means that healthcare system is strongly reliant on charitable aid for medical supplies and
drugs. Albania is a small south-eastern European country still recovering from almost half a century of a
fierce communist regime. While major reform and support have focused on healthcare and higher education
(HE) in the past decade, there have not been major attempts to improve medical education. The time is now
ready for medical education improvements created by increasing internal and external pressures as Albania
aims to align its HE with the European Union standards and adapts the Bologna system.
Health care seeks to prevent, diagnose, and treat disease and to improve the physical and mental well-
being of all Americans. Across the lifespan, health care helps people stay healthy, recover from illness, live
147
with chronic disease or disability, and cope with death and dying. Quality health care delivers these services
in ways that are safe, timely, patient centered, efficient, and equitable. Unfortunately, Americans too often do
not receive care that they need, or they receive care that causes harm. Care can be delivered too late or
without full consideration of a patient's preferences and values. Many times, our system of health care
distributes services inefficiently and unevenly across populations. Some Americans receive worse care than
other Americans. These disparities may be due to differences in access to care, provider biases, poor
provider-patient communication, and poor health literacy. Each year since 2003, the Agency for Healthcare
Research and Quality (AHRQ) has reported on progress and opportunities for improving health care quality
and reducing health care disparities.
Management functions require urgent attention, and Albania does not have any professional management
consultants. Managerial performance is judged more by political commitment than by effectiveness. Most
funding is determined centrally by comprehensive budgets that are allocated at the start of each financial
year. District administrators and health care managers have little flexibility and limited technical capacity to
manage effectively. There is also an urgent need to establish management information systems, which would
provide useful and accurate program and budgeting information.[7][8][9] Other stakeholder groups, such as
professional associations, unions and consumer groups, play little role in planning or regulation. Health
service providers are still not accountable to their patients, despite the policy objective of the Ministry of
Health to “put the patient at the centre of the system”.
2.1 Decentralization of the health care system.
The health care system in Albania remains highly centralized and hierarchical, despite some decentralization.
Some administrative responsibility (but no political or policy responsibility) has devolved to the 36 districts,
though they remain accountable to the Ministry of Health. Responsibility for running and maintaining rural
PHC facilities has largely devolved to the local governments. Rural PHC doctors primarily use these facilities
but receive their salaries, based on capitation fees, from the Health Care System in Albania.
2.1.1 Which are the categories that benefit from health insurance scheme? Source: ISKSH Albania, year
2009, Focus Journal
All citizens of the Republic of Albania benefit from health insurance schemes, whether contributory or
vulnerable categories, since the state contributes for the later. The state specifically contributes for these
categories just like children, pupils, and full-time students; retirees, the disabled people (mental and
physical), the unemployed, people receiving economic and social assistance; mothers on maternity leave;
citizens who perform military service.
2.2 Which are the benefits from the health insurances?
The entire population benefits health services free of charge through health insurances; free of charge
service by the family doctor; specialist doctors; free of charge health services at home, from polyclinics and
hospital; free of charge laboratory and radiological examinations; unique tertiary examinations with a 90%
reimbursement by the HII and 10 % with the patient co-payment; free of charge drugs from the reimbursed
drugs list for children 0-12 months, invalids, pensioners, blind and orphans; free of charge drugs for veterans
with chronic disease and war invalids; patients with tumors, kidney transplantation, multiple sclerosis and
major CA.
148
H 1.Two competing models: 1. (Bismark and Beverage), 2. (Mogediss and Creblenn) was based on
insurances health care system in Albania. Is the actual model the best one for Albania and why?
The recently formed HII is a new health sector entity. Eventually, the institute is intended to assume a larger
health-funding role. Though the decentralization initiatives noted here are now being implemented, no
decision has been made about the extent or form of future decentralization. The Ministry of Health apparently
intends to test different models before proceeding with a larger decentralization program at the national level.
In addition, other central bodies (such as the Ministry of Finance, Ministry of Local Governments, Ministry of
Justice, etc.) are also involved in Albanian development health care programs, legal programs, health funds
for management.
H 2.The important problem facing the government after the transition to multiparty democracy in 1992 was
finding the financial resources to maintain essential health services, given the very small government budget.
What changes are introduced in the health insurance scheme in recent years?
Management functions require urgent attention, and Albania does not have any professional management
consultants. Managerial performance is judged more by political commitment than by effectiveness. Most
funding is determined centrally by comprehensive budgets that are allocated at the start of each financial
year. District administrators and health care managers have little flexibility and limited technical capacity to
manage effectively. The e-taxes reform is progressing and as of January 2008, income tax was reduced from
20% to 10%, one of the lowest in the region. In addition, as of May 2009, the social insurance contribution
payable by employers will be reduced again from 20% to 15%, down from 29% in 2006. 300 thousand people
have a family doctor, Businesses can file their tax returns and social insurance declarations electronically in
12 cities including Tirana and electronic payment of taxes is also possible through certain banks.[ Source:
Health care Albanian Reform, year 2009]
Tab1. Health care financing (level 1), state budget (level 2), individual contribution (level 3)
Businesses claim that neither VAT nor income tax refunds are reimbursed in a timely fashion. Management-
Financing levels for Albanian health care remain very low and, for the last decade, the sector emphasis has
been on how to do more with less. There is little information on the scale of funding before 1990. In
149
Communist ideology, health care was considered a nonproductive sector and thus a low priority. In 1987,
health expenditure in Albania was estimated to be 3.0% of GDP, compared to a CEE average of 2.8% and an
EU average of 7.3% (26). Albanian health services are funded through a mix of taxation and statutory
insurance. [Source: MOH government report 1992-1999]
3. Albanian health service and statutory insurance
3.1 Albanian public health financing
The latest project of HII has to do with the way of calculating the hospitals costs. This system currently
operates in each cost center of about 40 hospitals. The basis of information is the patient clinical card and
other hospital financial forms. So we can determine: the number of hospitals inpatients and the cost for each
patient, service, diagnoses etc. So, while in previous times, the information was insufficient and incorrect
because it was mainly based on registers and manual work, currently due to the implementation of various IT
projects, quicker and effective analyses were made valid and qualitative information for decision making was
insured. Implementation of IT project has followed some directions as:
1. Systems that enable registration of electronic information at the “source of its creation”, largely including
the service providers.
2. A good coordination of donor resources, the World Bank funds, funds of contractors and HII.
3. Systems “in due time” providing solutions for specific management objectives of HII and, very frequently
different, fast and parallel implementation phases.
4. Frequent support of the staff for software designing and building.
5. Computerization of the actors.
6. Systems that base their implementation in the respective contract with health institutions.
Diagnoses No. of patients No. of prescriptions Reimbursement(in Leke)

Essential Hypertension 182,317 786,659 762,024,922
Diabetis – mellitus 47,697 215,581 441,484,544
Thalasemia- Major 283 1,257 294,618,695
Kidney chronic Insufficiency 2,213 9,225 269,883,549
Bronchial Asthma 18,718 70,131 251,777,024
Cardiac Insufficiency 22,729 93,210 162,277,454
Myeloid Leukemia 222 570 152,462,381
Schizophrenic Psychosis 9,324 39,358 152,398,327
Epilepsy 9,333 41,014 124,582,444
Female breast maline tumor 2,613 12,328 121,138,471
Glaucoma 10,136 44,632 119,752,950
Heart disease from 23,969 82,071 110,155,916
hypertension
Multiple sclerosis 209 753 71,281,329
Prostate Hipoplasia 11,812 49,360 54,972051
Parkinson syndrome 4,687 20,339 53,396,761
Hypophysis gland disturbances 318 1,148 44,724,957
Arteriosclerosis 12,854 42,536 43,247,910
Prostate maline tumor 556 2,195 41,451,208
Post renal transplant condition 139 608 41,311,840
Heart rhythm disorders 16,554 65,991 38,844,910
Tab2. The data for diagnose, reimbursement funds in Albania, ISKSH publishing data, year 2011
Source: ISKSH Albania
150
3.2 Treatment cost and hospital examination of patients with dominant polycystic kidney disease.
Chronic kidney disease (CKD) is a global problem for the patients, their families and society worldwide.
Today treatment of these diseases occupies about 80%of health spending in the world. The Medicare cost
for the terminal stage of CKD has increased from $ 12.2 in 2000 to 20.8 billion in 2007.These numerals
require a review of cost-effectiveness of prevention and treatment of CKD. The main clinical manifestations
are lumbar pain, hematuria, calculus, urinary tract infections (UTI), arterial hypertension (HTA) and chronic
renal failure (CRF).
If we want to improvement the health care system, we will analyze the example of USA.Health care helps
people stay healthy, recover from illness, live with chronic disease or disability, and cope with dying. Quality
health care delivers these services in a way that is safe, timely, patient centered, efficient, and equitable.
Unfortunately, Americans too often do not receive care that they need or they receive care that causes harm.
Care can be delivered too late or without full consideration of a patient's preferences and values. Many times,
our system of health care distributes services inefficiently and unevenly across populations.Each year since
2003, the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ), together with its partners in the Department
of Health and Human Services (HHS), has reported on progress and opportunities for improving health care
quality, as mandated by the U.S. Congress. The information amassed for the National Healthcare Quality
Report (NHQR) since its inception is a growing knowledge base that addresses two critically important
questions:
 What is the status of health care quality in the United States?

 How is the quality of the health care delivered to Americans changing over time? These questions we will
use and in our study.
3.3 Material and Methods of Paper Research
In this retrospective study are included 51 patients with ADPKD admitted in Service of Nephrology, UHC
“Mother Teresa” during the period January 2008 – July 2010. Is prepared a fold tip taken following data: age,
gender, birthplace, the examinations made the cost for each examination in money (leke), treatment day and
expenses for each medicament taken by patients. The diagnosis of ADKP was based on household data for
the presence of ADKP and echographic criteria. The renal function alteration was considered then the
creatininemia level was bigger than 1.5 mg/dl. For data analysis was used SPSS. For continuous data were
calculated the average and standard deviation. For the comparison between the groups was used
ANOVA.P≤0.05 was considered significant.
Results of this paper research and conclusions
Democratic Albanian local governance is a prerequisite to the meaningful decentralization of infrastructure

management. When people participate in defining visions for sustainable development for their communities,
in formulating strategies for equitable access to services and resources and in setting priorities for action,
they have endorsed. Participation also sharpens their awareness of the interrelations between economic,
social and environmental issues.
This is a highly significant feature of infrastructure Albanian programs and carries important implications
for local development. The health care is one more important field that Albanian Government has it`s priority.
During the years 2009-2011 the health care system is developing with new and progress indicators.
Healthcare Reform is confusing to say the least. It would seem that the news coverage is focusing more
on the political side rather than on the substance of medical care itself. We will try to focus on the main
changes and highlight the main points of the healthcare reform and how it will affect us and Medicare as it
151
stands now. Changes recommended in these contracts, concern mainly strengthening of mutual
accountability, the best ways to implement the current system of health services and their funding, with the
ultimate goal of providing health services in primary health care, enabling a more complete access of the
citizens to these services and creating financial sustainability of these services. Despite these successes in
Albania health care system is, some tensions and challenges that were always there have become
increasingly visible. Firstly, Albanian regions have tended to over-spend their allocated budgets, with
Parliament and central Albanian government having virtually no control over such expenditure.
References
Agencia de Calidad del SNS. Instituto de Información Sanitaria. Barómetro Sanitario 2009. Madrid, 2010.
Barbullushi M, Koroshi A, Tase M. Albanian contribution to the treatment of refugee renal patients from Kosovo. Nephrol Dial
Transpl 2000; 15: 1261
Borkan J et al. Renewing primary care: lessons learned from the Spanish health care system, Health Affairs 29, 2010:1432–41.
Deutsche fur international Albania health reforming, pp 45,46
Hoering, Uwe. 2002. Public Private Partnerships in the Water Sector
Instituto Nacional de Estadística. May 2010.
ISKSH Focus Magazine nr 11, year 2010, pp 12,14,22,26
ISKSH Fokus Magazine nr 14 year 2011, pp12 15 17
ISKSH Tirana Albania Focus Journal, year 2011, pp 7,8,9
ISKSH Tirana Albania, Fokus Journal Year 2008, pp12,23,18
ISKSH Tirana Publishing Data, International Conference, pp 23
ISKSH Vlore analyze, A Dumi analyze year 2009, publish Vlore Conference, pp45
ISSH International JOURNAL year 2010, pp21
KantarHealth. Oncology Market Access, Europe, Data from EUROCARE- 4, 2010.
Martín JJ. Crisis económica y sostenibilidad del Sistema Nacional de Salud, El Médico 2010; 1109:16–19.
MOF , USAID Financial report 2011, pp 37-39
MOF analyze international report year 2011, pp19-25
MOH analyze international conference, June 12 year 2010, pp 11-14
MOH Data report Year 2010, pp 34,45,67,121
MOH Report year 2011, nr 13, pp 29-33
OECD. Health Care Quality Indicators, OECD Health Data 2009, Paris www.ecosante.org
Provision of medical, pharmaceutical and hospital care to foreigners, no 8992/13-7-2000. Ministerial decree: Greek Ministry of Health
and Welfare, 2000.
The National Strategy for Socio-Economic Development (NSSED).
Theodorakis P, Lionis C, Seniorou M, Kosta J, Trell E, Glaros D. Primary health services in southern Albania: current situation and
perspective. 6th European Conference on General Practice and Family Medicine. Vienna, Jul 2—6, 2000
Theodorakis PN, Benton JI, Anderson JP, Glaros D, Trell E, Lionis C. A comparative study of two primary health care practices on the
Greek-Albanian border: 51st European General Practice Research
WHO. European Health for All Database, May, 2010
Workshop on research of general practice in transitional environment. Zagreb, Oct 19—22, 2000 (abstr).
152
A Study into Methodological Issues in Cross-Cultural Pragmatic Research
Shirin Malekzadeh
Department of English Language,

Urmia Branch, Islamic Azad University, Urmia, Iran.
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.153
Abstract: The methodological issues are one of the areas of pragmatics which have gained considerable attention recently. The
foundation of basic instruments in speech act research can be placed in a two-polar continuum. At one end, there are the
perception/comprehension methods and at the other end production methods are placed. Each level then has its own specific
instruments. As for the perception/comprehension methods, instruments such as rating, multiple choice, and interview tasks can
be utilized. In production methods, instruments such as discourse completion, closed role play, open role play, and observation
of authentic discourse are placed (Kasper & Dahl, 1991). Furthermore, methods can be categorized according to an
elicited/observational continuum. In the elicited end, methods such as rating, multiple choice, interview tasks, discourse
completion, closed role play, and open role play are placed. In the observational end, observation of authentic discourse is used.
This study is useful for those novice researchers who are interested in conducting pragmatic studies and may not be familiar
which instrument they should use in particular situation.
Keywords: Pragmatics, Methodological Issues, Instrument, Speech Act Theory
1. Theoretical Background
In the past, on the basis of Grammar Translation Method (GTM), language was taught as a string of linguistic
structures, grammatical rules, translation exercises and list of words to memorize (Richards & Rogers, 2001).
Although grammatical and lexical meaning of a sentence is taken into consideration in GTM, it has not been
accounted for the way in which language is used in daily communications. Later on, with the emergence of
Communicative Language Teaching, however, learners were engaged in the pragmatic, authentic and
functional use of language for meaningful purposes (Brown, 2007). Pragmatics rising to prominence occurred
with the emphasis put on the meaning and communicative aspect of language.
Pragmatics does not have a clear-cut definition (Ellis, 2008), however, according to Verschueren (1999, p.
1), pragmatics is “the study of linguistic phenomenon from the point of view of their usage properties and
processes.” Richards and Schmidt (2002) defined pragmatics as “the study of the use of language in
communication, particularly the relationships between sentences and the contexts and situations in which
they are used” (p. 412). Clearly, pragmatics is simply the study of language which is used in daily
communication. It is usually seen in the pertinent literature that a learner’s full knowledge about the grammar
of the target language does not guarantee that that person is pragmatically competent too (Bardovi-Harlig,
1996; Bardovi-Harlig & Dörneyei, 1998; Kasper & Rose, 1999). They can produce grammatically correct but
pragmatically inappropriate utterances. Therefore, it is no exaggeration to say that pragmatic aspects of
utterances are of paramount importance.
As mentioned by Verschueren (1999, p. 18), one of the subsets lies in pragmatic is speech act. The
theory of speech acts describes how one can use language to do things (Fromkin, Rodman & Hymes, 2003).
Typically, a speech act is usually defined as a functional unit which plays an important role in communication.
Moreover, it was reported that linguistic elements could be interpreted on the basis of speech acts
(Verschueren, 1999). In dealing with speech acts, one thing that deserves special attention is that there are
different ways for individuals to express their intention, requests, and apologizing. To make it clearer, one
should consider which type of speech act is appropriate for which situation. For instance, is the act of
153
apologizing in a restaurant similar to a classroom? Austin (1962) introduced speech act theory which includes
the three categories, namely:
 Locutionary act
 Illocutionary act
 Perlocutionary act
A significant dilemma in pragmatics which has been of considerable debate is the instrument used to elicit
and gather data (Hinkel, 1997). How to collect appropriate data is a crucial issue in pragmatic research
because the data collection instrument and the methodological issues will determine whether the data
gathered are reliable or not. Practically speaking, most methodological discussions concern to what extent
the instrument is accurate to represent authentic performance (Kasper & Dahl, 1991; Billmyer & Varghese,
2000).
2. Discussion on Methodological Issues
The role of instruments in pragmatic research is of crucial importance to conduct a suitable study. One of the
areas of pragmatics which has been of considerable debate is the instrument used to elicit and gather data
(Hinkel, 1997). There are different types of data, validating each of which requires large-scale research. The
pioneer studies on speech act used various instrument unlike pragmatic research instruments utilized in
current studies. To have a general picture of the nature of instrument used in pragmatics, the following
continuum can be used:
Perception/Comprehension Production
Walters (1980) investigated the politeness phenomenon in request strategies based on card paired
comparison. The participants were to decide on the relative politeness of ‘shut up’ and ‘please be quiet’
irrespective of the context. Carrell and Konneker (1981) investigated non-native speakers’ (NNS) perceptions
of politeness in request strategies. They presented eight request strategies written on cards and the
participants were asked to sort the strategies according to politeness. Among the strategies, native speakers
(NS) referred to five and NNS mentioned seven request strategies as being polite. Tanaka and Kawade
(1982) replicated the study conducted by Carrell and Konneker (1981) in which they analyzed politeness
strategies based on social context. They prepared a questionnaire and asked the students to choose the
politeness strategy that best represents the situation.
In another study, Olshtain and Blum-Kulka (1985) examined politeness in request and apology speech
acts of NNS of Hebrew. They used a questionnaire of four request and four apology situations and these
situations were accompanied by six different request and apology strategies. Participants were asked to
decide which strategy is suitable for the situations described. Carrell (1979) used a questionnaire with twenty-
seven short dialogues and a subsequent three multiple choice answers to investigate non-native
comprehension of indirect answers. In the study done by Carrell (1981), the instrument was a multiple-choice
questionnaire based on forty tape-recorded requests and the participants were asked to differentiate between
positive and negative requests. The body of research which was described earlier, mostly tried to examine
perception and comprehension. However, Kasper (1984) used the data based on conversational
performance to investigate individuals’ pragmatic comprehension.
154
The concern of most methodological discussions is to what extent the instrument is capable to
approximate authentic performance (Kasper & Dahl, 1991; Billmyer & Varghese, 2000). In the same vein,
Manes and Wolfson (1981) argued that the most authentic information comes from sociolinguistic research
which emphasizes ethnographic observation. However, Manes and Wolfson’s utopia was not appreciated by
researchers and many criticisms were documented on the use of ethnographic observation (Blum-Kulka,
House, & Kasper, 1989; Aston, 1995). Since observation did not satisfy the researchers, another instrument
referred to as discourse completion test (DCT) was employed to analyze pragmatic knowledge. As it is cited
in Kasper and Dahl (1991), “Discourse Completion Tasks have been a much used and a much beleaguered
elicitation format in cross-cultural and interlanguage pragmatics.” Discourse completion tasks (or tests) are
some prompts based on various situations in which individuals are required to write their reactions in each
episode. Levenston and Blum (1978) were the first researchers who developed DCTs to study lexical
simplification, and Blum-Kulka (1982) adapted it to investigate speech act. After these pioneering studies, a
body of research accompanied the newly-developed DCT instrument for the realization of different speech
acts (Blum-Kulka, 1982; Blum-Kulka & Olshtain, 1986; Faerch & Kasper, 1989; House & Kasper, 1987;
Kasper, 1989; Olshtain & Weinbach, 1987).
However, the heydays of DCTs do not last for a long time. Some criticisms were leveled at DCTs too.
Among the criticisms of DCTs, inability to gather authentic information and inconsistency with the state-of-
the-art literature were more picturesque. As an attempt to improve the quality of DCTs, Billmyer and
Varghese (2000) conducted a study on request speech act based on a modified DCT in which the improved
situational prompts were given to native and non-native speakers of English. The modification included
enhancing the situational prompts and more elaborated requests in native and non-native groups.
Hinkel (1997) tried to validate multiple choice and DCT instruments through a study done on Chinese
speakers. In another similar study, Golato (2003) studied the differences among compliment response types
with respect to two instruments. Golato used conversation analytic methodology and a discourse completion
task to elicit data. After analyzing the data, Golato figured out that “these data collection procedures do not
always yield data that speak equally well to given research questions” (p. 90). He further argued that naturally
occurring talk is useful to reveal the organization of language but DCTs are beneficial to show prior
experience with language. Johnston, Kasper, and Ross (1998) studied the effect of different types of
rejoinders such as positive, negative, and absent on native and non-native informant choices of complaints,
requests, and apologies. They advocated that there is a relationship between the type of rejoinder and the
choice of strategies. Their study was mainly conducted to validate different data elicitation procedures—
naturally occurring and production instruments.
Rose (1992) with emphasis on more cross-cultural studies on speech act, investigated two forms of DCTs
based on the inclusion and exclusion of hearer response. Rose found out that “although responses on the
non-hearer response (NoHR) DCT tended to be slightly longer and used slightly more supportive moves and
downgraders, inclusion of hearer response did not have a significant effect on requests elicited” (p. 49).
Role play is another instrument used in pragmatic studies. Walters (1980) investigated children
interlanguage speech act based on role play. He observed children while they were playing and interacting
with puppets. He came to this realization that grammar and pragmatic knowledge are not related to each
other; in other words, children were able to use the language with appropriate politeness but they were not
able to produce grammatically sound sentences. Scarcella (1979) used videotaped open role plays to
investigate developmental patterns of politeness. Kasper (1981) conducted a study on 48 dyads of German
learners of English and recorded their role plays carried out on various speech acts such as requests,
suggestions, offers, invitations, and complaints.
The findings of Kasper study show that the speech act pattern of participants were related to neither L1
nor L2. This means that the participants’ interlanguage were systematic and independent in performing
speech act. However, the study is limited to two cultures. More studies are needed to investigate the
interlanguage pragmatics. Tanaka (1988) was another author who employed role play in studying speech act.
155
Tanaka analyzed the request speech act of Japanese learners while they were interacting with friends or
lecturers. The interactions were videotaped. The findings revealed that nonnative students used more direct
strategies to perform requests. Trosborg’s (1987) study deals with Danish apology speech act with different
proficiency levels while they were interacting with native speakers of English. Trosborg mentioned that
politeness varies with respect to participants’ proficiency level.
Some studies have used observations to collect data on particular speech acts. Wolfson’s (1989) study
which last about 2 years and examined compliment and compliment responses dealt with “ethnographic data
collected through observation and recording of naturally occurring speech in everyday interactions in a wide
variety of situations” (Wolfson, p. 227). In another study based on observation, Bardovi-Harlig and Hartford
(1990) found that nonnative speakers offered fewer suggestions with respect to native speakers.
Hinkel points out that discourse completion tests (DCTs) have been largely used as a means of
comparing native speakers and non-native speakers’ socio-pragmatic behaviors. She came to this realization
that “DCTs may not be the best elicitation instrument for LI and L2 data pertaining to ambiguous and
situationally constrained pragmalinguistic acts” (p. 1). Hinkel further emphasized that:
The ideal data for speech act analysis would consist of a large number of carefully recorded observations
of particular speech acts by representative subjects and control group subjects in similar natural situations
when the subjects are unaware of the observation. (p. 2)
Huth and Taleghani-Nikazm (2006) came to this realization that the information obtained through
conversation-analysis-based studies is strikingly different from the same data gathered through DCTs. They
argued that when required to complete the DCTs, “native speakers overwhelmingly stated that they would
accept compliments with ‘Danke’ which was in stark contrast to their actual interactional behaviour, where no
‘thank yous’ could be found at all” (p. 63). Rose (1992) studied the construction of DCTs in which two forms
of a DCT were investigated. One form was gathered through hearer response and the other did not. The data
gathered by the two forms were identical and the use of hearer response did not have significant effect on the
elicited requests.
Billmyer and Varghese (2000) tried to find out the effect of systematic modification to the DCT for eliciting
requests produced by native and non-native speakers of English. The findings of their study revealed the
importance of external modification of production speech act.
Many other researchers tried to investigate speech acts based on a combination of different instruments
some of which were mentioned before. For instance, many studies used combined production and
metapragmeatic assessment data (Einstein & Bodman, 1986; Fraser, Rintell, & Walters, 1980; Garcia, 1989;
House, 1988; Olshtain & Cohen, 1983; Rintell, 1981; Takahashi & Dufon, 1989) while some employed
different types of production data in their approach toward speech act investigation (Beebe & Cummings,
1985; Rintell & Mitchell, 1989). Hinkel (1997) investigated the responses of Chinese speakers to multiple
choice questionnaires and discourse completion tests with regard to appropriateness of advice in both
common and observed situations.
Turnbull (2001) investigated the appropriateness of pragmatic elicitation techniques in both free and
controlled situations and came to this realization that role play and experimental technique provide more
natural data. Golato (2003) compared two data analysis through conversation analytic (CA) methodology and
a discourse completion task (DCT). The results of the study showed that there is no difference between the
DCT and naturally occurring data. Johnston, Kasper, and Ross (1998) conducted a study to validate the data
collection of interlanguage pragmatics. The research emphasized the validation of production questionnaire
(PQ) on non-native and native informants’ choices of complaints, requests, and apologies. The findings
revealed that different PQ formats cannot be compared and further validation is needed.
Therefore, the foundation of basic instruments in speech act research can be placed in a two-polar
continuum. At one end, there are the perception/comprehension methods and at the other end production
methods are placed. As for the perception/comprehension methods, instruments such as rating, multiple
choice, and interview tasks can be utilized. In production methods, instruments such as discourse
156
completion, closed role play, open role play, and observation of authentic discourse are placed (Kasper &
Dahl, 1991). Furthermore, methods can be categorized according to an elicited/observational continuum. In
the elicited end, methods such as rating, multiple choice, interview tasks, discourse completion, closed role
play, and open role play are placed. In the observational end, observation of authentic discourse is used.
Bardovi-Harlig (1999) criticized that the nature of interlanguage is ignored in studies on interlanguage
pragmatics. The main motive behind his research on interlanguage in interlanguage pragmatics was the
study conducted by Kasper and Schmidt (1996) which stated that the main focus of interlanguage pragmatics
is cross-cultural pragmatics. What Bardovi-Harlig tried to emphasize was the way individuals acquire
pragmatics and mentioned that there is a great need for longitudinal research on acquisitional aspects of
interlanguage pragmatics. His discontent of comparative nature of pragmatic studies and his interest in the
idea of acquisitional pragmatics lay in the idea that “many articles from 1979 to 1996—with the exception of
the explicitly acquisitional studies with cross-sectional and longitudinal designs—identify non-native speakers
as ‘non-native speakers’ rather than learners, and they are described only by their first language” (p. 680).
Maybe one of the concerns of Bardovi-Harlig is that scholars should pay attention to the procedure of gaining
proficiency in pragmatics not just resorting to comparative studies. His concern is in line with the nature of
second language acquisition studies in which the process of acquisition is of key importance.
Demeter (2007) stated that methodology and instrument used in gathering pragmatic knowledge of
individuals are of key importance which can influence the outcome of the study. He further reveals that most
of the studies conducted on pragmatics use “discourse completion tests, interviews, questionnaires, corpus
linguistics, or natural interactions” (p. 83). Emphasizing the use of role plays in pragmatic studies, he
compared two sets of results obtained through role play and a discourse completion test and came to this
understanding that “although DCTs are more appropriate for studying the main types of strategies in speech
act production, role-plays seem a better choice when the interaction between the speaker and hearer is also
important for the study” (p. 88).
Grotjahn and Kasper (1991) investigated various methodologies used in second language acquisition in
which speech act theory is also considered. Bonikowska (1988) brought a new perspective into the field of
pragmatic study in that in this study the speaker’s decision not to perform a speech act is taken into
consideration. Bonikowska came to this realization that it is not only the pragmatic choice that matters but
opting out choice is important too.
In summary, some of the methodological issues regarding gathering results are mentioned below
(Martinez-Flor, 2005; Martinez-Flor, 2006; Martinez-Flor & Fukuya, 2005; Martinez-Flor & Soler, 2004):
 Hinkel (1997):
 DCTs may not be the best elicitation instrument for investigating pragmatic knowledge.
 Bardovi-Harlig (1999):
 Lack of longitudinal research on pragmatics.
 A need for more studies on acquisitional aspects of pragmatics.
 Current studies on pragmatics have ignored the nature of interlanguage.
 DCTs are not a good device to gauge interlanguage pragmatics of learners at all levels.
 Golato (2003):
 Manifold advantages of DCTs.
 The results obtained from DCTs are very different from naturalistically collected data.
 In interactions, individuals use strategies different from what is obtained through DCTs.
 Huth and Taleghani-Nikazm (2006):
 Conversation-analysis-based materials provide learners with socio-pragmatically appropriate verbal
behavior.
 The information obtained from DCTs is strikingly different from the same information gathered by
conversation-analysis-based studies.
157
 Demeter (2007):
 DCTs are appropriate for studying various strategies in speech acts and role-plays are good instruments
to find out the nature of interactions between learner and speaker.
 Responses provided through DCTs are much longer than the ones provided by role-plays.
Therefore, it can be concluded that every social context may impose some limitations on the choice of words
and sentences which is different across cultures. Another factor which renders the research on pragmatics
cumbersome is the instrument itself. As it is mentioned by Kasper and Dahl (1991), the purpose of the study
influences the choice of instruments. According to Kasper and Dahl (1991):
In pragmatics, we are dealing with a double layer of variability: (a) variability that reflects the social properties
of the speech event, and the strategic, actional, and linguistic choices by which interlocutors attempt to reach
their communicative goals; and (b) the variability induced by different instruments of data collection. (p. 215)
3. Conclusion
In this review article, it was tried to have an overview of various instruments in the realm of pragmatics. As it
was discussed, each instrument has its own advantages as well as its flaws. To have a clear picture of
current methodological issues and to provide novice researchers a general picture of what is going on in data
elicitation and data gathering phase of pragmatic studies, which is one of the main concerns in pragmatic
research, this review article is of great help. Most of the researchers who are going to conduct studies on
pragmatics and speech act verbs are not familiar with different instruments in the field and they may have
difficulties choosing a suitable instrument which best represent their purpose. The matter of validity is under
question if the instrument fails to represent what the researcher tried to investigate. In this sense, we suggest
that the researcher use different instruments and compare the results. Although this trend is time consuming
and impractical, if conducted carefully, it can provide researchers with reassuring data since the utilization of
various instruments will surely reduce the validity problems.
References
Aston, G. (1995). Say ‘thank you’: Some pragmatic constraints in conversational closings. Applied Linguistics, 16(1), 57 – 86.
Austin, J. L. (1962). How to do things with words. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Bardovi-Harlig, K. (1996). Pragmatics and language teaching: Bringing pragmatics and pedagogy together. In L. Bouton & Y. Kachru
(Eds.), Pragmatics and Language Learning, Monograph 3 (pp. 21-39). Urbana-Champaign, IL: University of Illinois Division of
English as an International Language.
Bardovi-Harlig, K. (1999). Exploring the interlanguage of interlanguage pragmatics: A research agenda for acquisitional pragmatics.
Language Learning, 49(4), 677-713.
Bardovi-Harlig, K., & Dörnyei, Z. (1998). Do language learners recognize pragmatic violations? Pragmatic versus grammatical
awareness in instructed L2 learning. TESOL Quarterly, 32(2), 233-262.
Beebe, L. M., & Cummings, M. C. (1996). Natural speech data versus written questionnaire data: How data collection method affects
speech act performance. In S.M Gass & J. Neu (Eds.), Speech acts across cultures. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Billmyer, K., & Varghese, M. (2000). Investigating instrument-based pragmatic variability: Effects of enhancing discourse completion
tests. Applied Linguistics, 21(4), 517-552.
Blum-Kulka, S. (1982). Learning how to say what you mean in a second language: A study of speech act performance of learners of
Hebrew as a second language. Applied Linguistics, 3, 29-59.
Blum-Kulka, S., & Olshtain, E. (1986). Too many words: Length of utterances and pragmatic failure. Studies in Second Language
Acquisition, 8(2), 165-179.
Blum-Kulka, S, House, J., & Kasper, G. (Eds.) (1989). Cross-cultural pragmatics: Requests and apologies. Norwood: Ablex Publishing.
Bonikowska, M. P. (1988). The choice of opting out. Applied Linguistics, 9(2), 169-181.
Brown, H. D. (2007). Principles of language learning and teaching. (5th ed.). White Plains, NY: Longman.
Carrell, P. L. (1979). Indirect speech acts in ESL: Indirect answers. In C. A. Yorio, K. Perkins, & J. Schachter (Eds.), On TESOL 79 (pp.
297-307). Washington, DC.: TESOL.
Carrell, P. L. (1981). Children’s understanding of indirect requests: comparing child and adult comprehension. Journal of Child
Language, 8, 329-345.
158
Carrell, P. L., & Konneker, B. H. (1981). Politeness: comparing native and nonnative judgments. Language learning, 31(1), 17-30.
Cohen, A. (1996). Investigating the production of speech act sets. In S. M. Gass & J. Neu (Eds.), Speech acts across cultures (pp. 23-
43). Berlin, Mouton de Gruyter.
Demeter, G. (2007). Role-plays as a data collection method for research on apology speech acts. Simulation & Gaming, 38(1), 83-90.
Eisenstein, M., & Bodman, J. W. (1986). ‘I very appreciate’: Expressions of gratitude by native and non-native speakers of American
English. Applied Linguistics, 7, 167-185.
Ellis, R. (2008). The study of second language acquisition. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Faerch, C., & Kasper, G. (1989). Internal and external modification in interlanguage request realization. In S. Blum-Kulka, J. House, & G.
Kasper (Eds.), Cross-cultural pragmatics (pp. 221-247). Norwood, N. J.: Ablex.
Fraser, B., Rintell, E., & Walters, J. (1980). An approach to conducting research on the acquisition of pragmatic competence in a second
language. In D. Larsen-Freeman (Ed.), Discourse analysis in second language research (pp. 75-91). Rowley, Mass.: Newbury
House.
Fromkin, V., Rodman, R., & Hyams, N. (2003). An introduction to language (7th ed.). Massachusetts: Thomson Heinle.
Garcia, C. (1989). Apologizing in English: Politeness strategies used by native and non-native speakers. Multilingual, 8, 3-20.
Golato, A. (2003). Studying compliment responses: A comparison of DCTs and recordings of naturally occurring talk. Applied Linguistics,
24(1), 90-121.
Grotjahn, R., & Kasper, G. (1991). Methods in second language research: Introduction. Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 13(2),
109-112.
Hinkel, E. (1997). Appropriateness of advice: DCT and multiple choice data. Applied Linguistics, 18(1), 1-26.
House, J. (1988). “Oh excuse me please…”: Apologizing in a foreign language. In B. Kettemann, P. Bierbaumer, A. Fill, & A. Karpf
(Eds.), English als Zweitsprache (pp. 303-327). Tuebingen: Narr.
House, J., & Kasper, G. (1987). Interlanguage pragmatics: Requesting in foreign language. In W. Loerscher & R. Schulze (Eds.),
Perspectives on language in performance: Festschrift for Werner Huellen (pp. 1250-1288). Tuebingen: Narr.
Huth, T., & Taleghani-Nikazm, C. (2006). How can insights from conversation analysis be directly applied to teaching L2 pragmatics?
Language Teaching Research, 10(1), 53-79.
Johnston, B., Kasper, G., & Ross, S. (1998). Effect of rejoinders in production questionnaires. Applied Linguistics. 19(2), 157-182.
Kasper, G. (1981). Pragmatic aspekte in der interimsprache. Tuebingen: Narr.
Kasper, G. (1984). Pragmatic comprehension in learner native speaker discourse. Language Learning, 34(4), 1-20.
Kasper, G. (1989). Variation in interlanguage speech act realization. In S. Gass, C. Madden, D. Preston, & L. Selinker (Eds.), Variation in
second language acquisition: Discourse and pragmatics (pp. 37-58). Clevedon: Multilingual Matters.
Kasper, G., & Dahl, M. (1991). Research methods in interlanguage pragmatics. Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 13, 215-247.
Kasper, G., & Rose, K. (1999). Pragmatics and SLA. Annual Review of Applied Linguistics, 19, 81-104.
Kasper, G., & Schmidt, R. (1996). Developmental issues in interlanguage pragmatics. Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 18, 149-
169.
Levenston, E., & Blum, S. (1978). Discourse completion as a technique for studying lexical features of interlanguage. Working Papers in
Bilingualism, 15, 13-21.
Manes, J., & Wolfson, N. (1981). The Compliment formula. In F. Coumas (Ed.), Conversational routine: Explorations in standardized
communication situations and prepatterned speech (pp. 115-132). The Hague: Mouton Publishers.
Martínez-Flor, A. (2005). A theoretical review of the speech act of suggesting: Towards taxonomy for its use in FLT. Revista Alicantina
de Estudios Ingleses, 18, 167-187.
Martínez-Flor, A. (2006). Task effects on EFL learners’ production of suggestions: A focus on elicited phone messages and Emails.
Journal of English and American Studies, 33, 47-64.
Martínez-Flor, A., & Fukuya, Y. J. (2005). The effects of instruction on learners’ production of appropriate and accurate suggestions.
Pragmatics in Instructed
Language Learning, 33(3), 463-480.
Martínez-Flor, A., & Soler, A. E. (2004). Developing pragmatic awareness of suggestions in the EFL classroom: A focus on instructional
effects. Journal of Pragmatics, 40(2), 279-306.
Nelson, G., Carson, J., Al Batal, M., and El Bakary, W. (2002). Cross-cultural pragmatics: Strategy use in Eqyptian Arabic and American
English refusals. Applied Linguistics, 23(2), 163-189.
Nurani, L. (2009). Methodological issues in pragmatic research: Is discourse completion test a reliable data collection instrument? Jurnal
Sosioteknologi Edisi, 17(8), 667-678.
Olshtain, E., & Cohen, A. (1983). Apology: A speech act set. In N. Wolfson & E. Judd (Eds.), Sociolinguistics and second language
acquisition (pp. 18-35). Rowley, Mass.: Newbury House.
Olshtain, E., & Blum-Kulka, S. (1985). Degree of approximation: Nonnative reactions to native speech act behavior. In S. M. Gass & C.
Madden (Eds.), Input in second language acquisition (pp. 303-325). Rowley. Mass.: Newbury House.
Richards, J. C., & Rodgers, T. (2001). Approaches and methods in language teaching (2nd ed.). New York: Cambridge University Press.
Richards, J. C., & Schmidt, R. (2002). Dictionary of language teaching & applied linguistics (3rd ed.). Pearson Education: Longman.
Rintell, E. (1981). Sociolinguistic variation and pragmatic ability: A look at learners. International Journal of Sociology of Language, 27,
11-34.
Rintell, E., & Mitchell, C. J. (1989). Studying requests and apologies: An inquiry into method. In S. Blum-Kulka, J. House, & G. Kasper
(Eds.), Cross-cultural pragmatics: Requests and apologies (pp. 248-272). Norwood, N. J.: Ablex.
159
Rose, K. R. (1992). Speech acts and questionnaires: The effect of hearer response. Journal of Pragmatics, 17(1), 49-62.
Scarcella, R. (1979). On speaking politely in a second language. In C. A. Yorio, K. Perkins, & J. Schachter (Eds.), On TESOL 79 (pp.
275-287). Washington, D.C.:TESOL.
Takahashi, S., & Dufon, P. (1989). Cross-linguistic influence in indirectness: The case of English directives performed by native
Japanese speakers. Unpublished manuscript, University of Hawaii at Manoa.
Tanaka, N. (1988). Politeness: Some problems for Japanese speakers of English. JALT Journal, 9, 81-102.
Tanaka, S., & Kawade, S. (1982). Politeness strategies and second language acquisition. Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 5,
18-33.
Trosborg, A. (1987). Apology strategies in natives/non-natives. Journal of Pragmatics, 11(2), 147-167.
Turnbull, W. (2001). An appraisal of pragmatic elicitation techniques for the social psychological study of talk: The case of request
refusals. Pragmatics, 11(1), 31-61.
Verschueren, J. (1999). Understanding pragmatics. London: Arnold.
Walters, J. (1980). Grammar, meaning and sociocultural appropriateness in second language acquisition. Canadian Journal of
Psychology, 34, 337-345.
Wolfson, N. (1989). The social dynamics of native and nonnative variation in complementing behavior. In Miriam Eisenstein (Ed.), The
dynamic interlanguage (pp. 219-236). New York: Plenum.
160
A Study into Politeness Strategies and Politeness Markers

in Advertisements as Persuasive Tools
Reza Pishghadam
Associate professor of TEFL
Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Iran
Safoora Navari
Ph.D. candidate of TEFL
Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Iran
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.161
Abstract This study aimed to investigate the pragmatic function of politeness in a less-talked-about communicative act:
advertising. Politeness theory being discussed by Leech (1983) and being analysed by the taxonomy of Brown and Levinson
(1987), is known to be as one of the essential factors for a successful communication whose success is guaranteed by
appropriate persuasive tools. The major focus of this study was to explore the politeness strategies adopted in English and
Persian ads and finding their persuasive factors by comparing and contrasting them. To this end, a corpus of 100 Persian and
English ads was collected. Their lines were first analysed to pinpoint the politeness strategy category and subcategory in both
languages and then their frequencies were computed. Analysis of the results based on Brown and Levinson’s (1987) taxonomy
of politeness functions indicated that English ads made more use of Positive politeness strategies while in Persian ads indirect
Off-record strategies were more favoured. Exploring the findings according to Nisbett’s (2004) classification of Eastern and
Western cultural system confirmed the collectivist in contrary to individualistic nature of culture in those countries respectively.
Consequently, it was illustrated that the choices of psychological strategies made by advertisers to persuade customers were in
line with their intended culture.
Keywords: advertisement, Persian, English, culture, politeness strategies
1. Introduction
Advertisement is some sort of a directive speech act (Searle, 1970) and an impositive one (Leech, 1983),
whose aim is to persuade and encourage people to buy products. Advertisers generally employ different
language techniques to achieve this aim, one of which can be using linguistic politeness strategies. These
strategies are used to foster rapport and maintain social equilibrium (Fraser & Nolen, 1981).
People who encounter polite linguistic elements which display respect or consideration for others are
more willing to pay attention to that polite language. Therefore, since it is of critical importance for advertisers
to attract readers` attention and to maintain social and emotional relationships with their customers, they are
expected to employ politeness strategies with much care in their ads. Furthermore, based on the specific sets
of politeness strategies being used in discourse, different cultures can be differentiated from one another and
as Hughes (1984) pointed out one way of exploring the cultural notions is through analyzing newspapers or
other media’s advertisements. Since those working in advertising try to change the buying behavior of
customers by persuading them to follow their leads, there is no shade of doubt that advertises in every
culture and language adopt different persuasive strategies which have to be in line with social politeness
strategies of that culture in order to cultivate success.
Lakoff (1975) holds the view that politeness has been developed to reduce friction in communication and
Hill, Ide, Ikuta, Kawasaki, and Ogino (1986, p. 349) define it as “one of the constraints on human interaction,
whose purpose is to consider others` feelings, establish levels of mutual comfort, and promote rapport”.
Moreover, Ide (1989, p. 225) views it as ‘language usage associated with smooth communication’. All of
161
these definitions reveal the fact that politeness is an important factor in developing effective relationships with
people, and any misuse of these strategies can hinder the effective communication, leading to individuals`
dissatisfaction and indifference.
Granted the fact that different cultures utilize different linguistic strategies to be polite, it seems that
delving into the nature of these differences can be of great interest and help to researchers and practitioners.
Thus in this study, we aim to investigate different linguistic politeness strategies which are used in Persian
and English ads to persuade people to buy different products.
2. Theoretical Background
Politeness as a linguistic phenomenon has directed the attention of researchers (e.g. Brown & Levinson,
1987; Geis, 1982; Lakoff, 1982; Scollon & Scollon, 2001) in exploring the different areas of theoretical
and practical issues related to it. Having the Grice’s Cooperative Principle and Speech Act Theory as its
background (Watts & Mesthrie, 2003), politeness theory has turned to a cornerstone by which the socially
correct and appropriate behavior can be analyzed. Due to its importance in characterizing the elements
specific to polite discourse and behavior, many studies (e.g. Hardin, 2001; Matsumoto, 1989;
Pishghadam, 2011; Schmidt, Shimura, Wang, & Jeong, 1995) related to politeness theory in pragmatic
linguistics has opened the doors to familiarizing the audience with politeness strategies in different
cultures.
In everyday interaction, a large extent of polite strategies is exchanged among people in order to
maintain effective communication. As Johnstone (2008, p.145) observed, people in every culture can hire
politeness markers to “use and interpret language appropriately in actual social interaction”. The crucial
point in every interaction then can be studied by the amount and type of politeness strategies used by
speaker(s) and hearer(s) in order to construct appropriate interpersonal relationships (Woods, 2006).
In the field of pragmatic linguistics, proponents like Lakoff (1973), Leech (1983) attempted to provide
definitions of politeness theory along with their specific rules. Leech’s ideas, for instance, focused on the
“goal-oriented speech situation in which speaker uses language in order to produce a particular effect in
the mind of hearer” (p.15). Criticizing Leech’s (1983) politeness model as too abstract and theoretical and
not a production model (cited in Watts & Mesthrie, 2003), Brown and Levinson (1987) proposed a
politeness model which was built on social interaction and viewed the strategical choices of people in
interactions to mirror the cross-cultural variability presenting in communication. In their theory which is
widely known as the most comprehensive and influential model in pragmatic politeness, Brown and
Levinson (1987) believed to base their notion of ‘face’ on that of Goffman (1955). For them, the two types
of desires which are attributed by one interactant to the other, that is, “the desire to be unimpeded in
one’s actions (negative face) and the desire to be approved of (positive face)” are the components which
mainly compose the notion of face (cited in Johnstone, 2008, p.146).
In compliance with the idea that everyone tries to keep his face in the duration of social interaction as
much as possible, it can be expected that all those involved in interactions try to reduce face-threatening
acts (FTAs). Nevertheless, Brown and Levinson’s (1987) model presupposed that whenever a person is
forced to perform a FTA as an action which poses a threat to the addressee’s positive or negative face,
he would resort to some strategies that reduce or “redress” the coming threat. Woods (2006) reports a
set of five “super-strategies” proposed by Brown and Levinson’s (1987) model from which the speakers
use to minimize the FTAs. These super-strategies range from the one which increases the risk of losing
face (Bald on-record strategy) bringing about FTA without any redressive action to the one which
decreases the risk factor (Avoidance strategy).
One crucial factor that makes Brown and Levinson’s (1987) model as a reliable source for analyzing
politeness strategies may be considered as its universality and the fact that almost all of our daily
interactions are under their impact. Another significant point of this model is its emphasis on recognizing
162
the target cultures based on the three social variables that provoke FTAs in any interaction: the social
distance between participants, their relative power, and the ranking of imposition in any specific culture.
Analyzing culture in this model is facilitated by focusing on the amount of positive and negative strategies
and weighing them against one another in each culture to find out in which one solidarity or imposition
rule more. By a similar token, Scollon and Scollon (1981) pointed out that while in different cultures
negative politeness determines the seriousness of the imposition, the positive one emphasizes the
general nature of relationships among interactants.
Among different areas of research which have been conducted on politeness strategies, there exist
many that focus on advertising on cross-cultural scales. Advertisement as one of the most accessible
sources of written persuasive discourse has ‘persuaded’ many researchers (e.g. Geis, 1982; Hardin,
2001; Lakoff, 1982; Lin, 2005; Schmidt, et al. 1995) to carry out studies with respect to the special culture
and society of use. Print advertisements or commercials as verbal interactions are categorized as
persuasive discourse. Lakoff (1982) as a pioneer in the field of pragmatic study of persuasive discourse
(cited in Lin, 2005, p.77) defines persuasive discourse as “the non-reciprocal attempt or intention of one
party to change the behavior, feelings, intentions, or viewpoint of another by communicative mans”.
Persuasive discourse according to Reardon (1991) can be divided into three types, ranging namely
interpersonal persuasion, organization persuasion, and most commonly-used one, mass media
persuasion such as advertisement. In 1982 Lakoff explored the elements of persuasive discourse and
pointed out that some successful examples of advertising contained violations of Grice’s Cooperative
Principle and Maxim of Manner.
Furthermore, Geis (1982) made a more comprehensive study on TV ads and concluded that apart
from a set of special linguistic techniques, advertisers favor the indirect ways of claim-making for their
products. Also, Pearson (1988) conducted a study to find out how speakers in church business meetings
negotiate support for their opinions by making use of politeness strategies. He discovered that in such
meetings ministers, who hold the first role, make more use of positive and negative politeness strategies
in comparison to others resulting in their being more skilled, powerful and persuasive. Matsumoto (1989)
attempted to emphasize the importance of Japanese culture in interpretation of politeness phenomenon,
holding that the significance of social context should be highlighted in the politeness theories of non-
western languages.
TV commercials also have been investigated by Schmidt et al. (1995) who had the aim of
differentiating the realization of speech acts among cultures. In their study, they compared the
commercials from the United States, Japan, the China, and South Korea and reported that consumer
product ads in U.S. are more persuasive than the similar ones in the Asian countries in terms of
frequency of suggestions to buy and the level of the related imperatives being used in them. In another
study, Obeng (1997) studied politeness strategies utilized by some legal professionals in Akan and
reported that these professionals hired some sort of politeness strategies like deferential modes of
address and reference along with hedges and compliments with the aim of softening the “locution of up-
coming face threatening acts and thereby render them polite and persuasive” (p.50).
Moreover, exploring the pragmatic devices that are often used in TV commercials, Hardin (2001)
analyzed a corpus of 214 ads taken from three countries: Chile, Spain, and United States. Politeness
strategies among the other pragmatic devices in her study were compared and contrasted in three
countries based on Brown and Levinson’s (1987) model and the results depict interesting differences in
the use of positive and negative politeness in those cultures.
Benkendorf, Prince, Rose, De Fina, and Hamilton (2001) conducted a study in terms of politeness
strategies over some indirect speech of medical consultants. In their study they found out that in
transferring their ideas to the patients, counselors try to soften the direct imposition of their views “by
choosing more impersonal and indirect language” (p.205). Yet in another study, Daly, Holmes, Newton,
and Stubbe (2003) paid attention to the ways in which one form of ‘Expletive’ was used in two face-
163
threatening acts of ‘direct complaints’ and ‘refusals’ by the workers in a factory team work. By analyzing
the workers use of a certain form of expletive according to politeness theory, they observed that making
use of specific expletive expresses the socio-pragmatic function of that word and shows belonging to a
given community of practice.
In another study, Lin (2005) examined the realization of politeness strategies in Chinese sale talks by
introducing a new data collection method called: Natural Data Elicitation Technique. As a result of this
study, Lin (2005) concluded that salespersons make different use of politeness strategies and on top of
them positive strategies which emphasizes the collectivist-oriented nature of Chinese culture. By
analyzing the effects of impoliteness as an entertaining factor in a TV quiz show, Culpeper (2005)
illustrated how impoliteness can increase the possibility of face-damage. In this study he argued how
creative the nature of discourse is and how by analyzing prosody, valuable information about
impoliteness can be gathered. Another study in the context of medicine was undertaken by Brown and
Crawford (2009) in which they explained the importance of appropriate politeness markers in telephone
conversations between health advisors and callers in need for medical advice. They reported that the
medical advisors tried to minimize the imposition and increase rapport through using appropriate
politeness markers.
Analyzing the impact of impoliteness on American TV news hosts’ identity formation (Blitvich, 2009);
discussing the effects of uncertainty reduction theory and politeness theory on creating face threat
(Knobloch, Satterlee, & DiDomenico, 2010); comparison of the realization of politeness strategies in
Iranian and English official letters (Pishghadam, 2011) are some of the recent studies in the field of
politeness theory.
3. Purpose of the Study
Since there is no study done which has examined politeness strategies by Iranian advertisers, and one way
to recognize the politeness strategies used in one culture is by contrasting them with those of another culture,
the present study aims at comparing and contrasting the linguistic politeness strategies which are employed
by Iranian and English advertisers in their print ads.
Therefore, this study is seeking to answer the following questions:
a. Are there any significant differences between the uses of politeness strategies in the Persian ads?
b. Are there any significant differences between the uses of politeness strategies in the English ads?
c. Are there any significant differences between the uses of politeness strategies in Persian and English ads?
4. Methodology
4.1. Corpus
The corpus of this study is a collection of 150 written English and Persian advertisements from which a
sample of 100 was selected. Advertisements were collected from some of the most-read and popular
magazines in each language on particular topics of lifestyle, consumer, fashion, or home.
The adverts were mostly full-page ones featuring consumer products, food, fitness and beauty services
and also database contained some ads from the classified advertisement sections of the above mentioned
magazines. The reason behind selecting these types of ads was connected with their being published
repeatedly due to their high attraction and application which is a sign of their persuasive tool. The samples in
both languages did not vary in length and were mostly consisted of 2 to 3 lines and had an average of 32
words.
Furthermore, the sample ads were intended to be highly representative of the types of advertising which
are considered to be more persuasive and successful in each language. The rest of the corpus was thus
164
discarded. The English ads consisted of 50 written ones and the same number applied for the Persian
database. We stopped adding more ads at time we got they are yielding similar information.
4.2. Procedure
The first step in analyzing the data in this study was to find out the politeness strategies proposed by Brown
and Levinson (1987). According to their model of politeness, five super-strategies exist that individuals may
choose when attempting to conduct a FTA.
These strategies which reduce or increase the level of face-threatening acts include: 1) bald-on-record:
FTA performed bald-on-record, in a direct and concise way without redressive action. e.g. imperative form
without any redress: ‘Wash your hands’; 2) positive politeness: FTA performed with redressive action.
Positive strategies are oriented towards positive face of the hearer. e.g. strategies seeking common ground
or co-operation, such as in jokes or offers: ‘Wash your hands, honey. 3) negative politeness: FTA performed
with redressive action that is strategies oriented towards negative face of the hearer. e.g. indirect formulation:
‘Would you mind washing your hands?’ ; 4) off-record: FTA performed off-record, strategies that might allow
the act to have more than one interpretation. They may consist of all types of hints, metaphors, tautologies,
etc. `Gardening makes your hands dirty`; and 5) Avoidance: don’t do the FTA.
To analyze the advertisement lines, every strategy was explored based on its categories. At first, five
strategies were labeled as groups 1-5. The categories of each group represented the different kinds that the
politeness strategies are recognized with. After that the lines of the ads were read and analyzed by both of
the researchers to improve the reliability of the data and to ensure their persuasiveness as the aim of this
study. The second step included analyzing every line to find out its group of strategies and subcategories.
Every ad was carefully scrutinized and the highlighted subcategories were codified. The subcategories of the
politeness strategies according to Brown and Levinson’s (1987) model along with one example from
database are sorted as follows:
Category 1: Bald on record
A1: disagreement (criticism); “No one makes your hair stronger” (EA#35)
A2: suggestion/advice; e.g. “Dress like a goddess and gods will flock to you!” (EA#2)
A3: request
A4: warning; threatening; e.g. “Don’t hide your body smell!” (PA#7)
A5: imperative form; e.g. “Go hi-polish! Get magnified shine!!” (EA#29)
Category 2: Positive Politeness
B1: show concern, interest, be optimistic; e.g. “Be a shade braver!” (EA#14)
B2: promise, guarantee, offer, give reasons; “We’ve got something for everyone!” (EA#31)
B3: solidarity/in-group talk
B4: compliment; e.g. “Have the hair that feels stronger...Because you’re worth it!” (EA#8)
B5: joke, humor; e.g. “Do you know that there’s a thin person inside any fat one?” (PA#23)
B6: exaggerate sympathy, approval; E.G “We want to protect your family and whole world from smoking”
(PA#46)
Category 3: Negative Politeness
C1: question, hedges (lexical, syntactic, particles, prosody); e.g. “Tired of wispy, thin hair that never looks
healthy?” (EA#40)
165
C2: show deference; e.g. “Everyone has a diamond these days, darling!” (EA#41)
C3: indirect strategies; E.G. “Nobody here is a stranger” (PA#9)
C4: apologize
C5: impersonalize the speaker and hearer. Avoid the pronouns I and YOU
C6: stating FTA as an instance of a general rule
Category 4: Off-record strategies→ indirect speech acts
D1: give hints→ give association clues, presuppose; e.g. “To be fit has been man’s wish in all ages” (PA#8)
D2: contradictions, be ironic, metaphor, rhetorical questions; e.g. “When you march on like wind, you leave
no room for chance” (PA#20)
D3: understate, overstate, use tautologies; e.g. “For the first time in the world, experience the good food
without oil” (PA#27)
D4: be ambiguous, be vague, over generalize, be incomplete, use ellipsis; e.g. “Let the funky jewelry do the
talking…” (EA#44)
Category 5: avoidance strategies
Note: PA (Persian ad), EA (English ad)
After coding the ads, the frequency of each politeness subcategory was displayed in tables and the total
frequency for each group of strategies was calculated. Afterwards, the frequency of the politeness strategies
used by English and Persian advertisements was compared. Next, in order to check the significance of
frequencies in both sets of advertisements, the results of the tables were analyzed using a Chi Square test.
And finally, the results were compared and contrasted with each other in order to explore the cultural
differences for persuasion between the two cultures.
5. Results
As the results of Table 1 exhibit, almost the same number of strategies have been employed in both Persian
and English ads (N=266, N=268), and Avoidance strategies were not employed by either groups. Moreover,
the table shows that among Persian ads Off-record strategies (N=111) are the most frequently used ones
while Positive politeness strategies (N=126) are employed more frequently by English ads.
Table 1. Frequency of Strategies Used in Persian and English Advertisements
Ads Bald on Positive Negative Off-record Avoidance Total
Persian 43 104 8 111 0 266
English 58 126 15 69 0 268
As it is illustrated in Table 2, there was a significant difference between the advertisement strategies used by
Persian speakers ( = 110.692, p<.05). The table shows that both Off-record (N=111) and Positive
politeness (N=104) strategies were utilized more often than expected (N=66.5). The results also revealed that
Bold-on record (N=43) and Negative politeness (N=8) strategies were less than expected (N=66.5).
166
Off-record>Positive>Bold-on>Negative
Table 2. Results of the Chi Square Test for the Advertisement Strategies Used by Iranian Community
Strategies Observed N Expected N df X² Sig.

Bold on 43 66.5 3 110.692 .000
Positive 104 66.5 3
Persian
Negative 8 66.5 3
Off record 111 66.5 3
The results of the Chi Square test presented in Table 3 revealed a significant difference between the
strategies used by the English community ( = 93.582, p<.05). Here, again both Off-record (N=69) and
Positive politeness (N=126) strategies were utilized more often than expected (N=67), and Bold-on record
(N=58) and Negative politeness (N=15) strategies were less than expected (N=66.5). In fact, the results show
that unlike the Persian ads in which Off-record strategies were used more, in the English ads Positive
politeness strategies were given more priority.
Positive>Off-record >Bold-on>Negative
Table 3. Results of the Chi Square Test for the Advertisement Strategies Used by English Community

Bold on 58 67 3 93.582 .000
Positive 126 67 3
English
Negative 15 67 3
Off record 69 67 3
According to Table 4, there is a significant difference between Persian and English ads with respect to Off-
record strategies ( 9.8, p<.05). The table shows Off-record strategies have been employed more often
than expected (N=90) by Persian speakers (N=111). It implies that Iranians opt for these strategies more
than the English in their ads. Moreover, considering Bold-on ( 2.22, p>.05), Positive politeness
( 2.1, p>.05), and Negative strategies ( 2.13, p>.05) strategies, no significant differences were
found between Iranian and English ads.
167
Table 4. Results of the Chi Square Test for All Strategies between Persian and English
Bold on
Persian 43 50.5 1 2.228 .136

English 58 50.5 1
Positive
Persian 126 115 1 2.104 .147

English 104 115 1
Negative
Persian 8 11.5 1 2.130 .144

English 15 11.5 1
Persian 111 90 1 9.800 .002

Off re
English 69 90 1
6. Discussion
This study aimed at first investigating the types of politesses strategies used in the Persian ads, second
examining the types of politesse strategies employed in the English ads, and finally comparing and
contrasting the linguistic politeness markers in Persian and English ads.
Regarding the first aim of the study, the results revealed that Iranian advertisers used Off-record and
Positive politeness strategies more than Bold-on record and Negative strategies. Off-record strategies are
indirect strategies, which mostly consist of giving hints, contradictions, overstating, understating, and being
vague. Actually, while Off-record strategies invite the performance of FTA, they leave the actual interpretation
of the act to the addressee. In other words, if a speaker employs an FTA but prefers to escape the
responsibility of doing it, he can opt for an Off-record strategy and thereby makes the addressee responsible
for interpreting it as a threat to face or not (Lin, 2005). The superior use of this type of strategy more than
others by Persian advertises thus may refer to their unwillingness to impose their will on the addressees by
leaving it up to them to interpret it.
Furthermore, as Brown and Levinson (1987) believe, Off-record strategies enjoy the most polite way
of performing an FTA by communicating indirectly to the audience. Indirect FTAs such as Off-record are
classified as imposing the least threat in politeness theory, and as a result are ranked as the most polite
verbal acts. Considering that the advertisements serve the two-fold function of communicating with their
customers and at the same time persuading them to buy the product, use of indirect strategies and on
top of which Off-record ones, provides more credibility for ads. Face saving theory is mostly relevant to
indirect advertising language and the most effective persuasion in advertising design and promotion
according to Gass and Seiter (1999) happens through the use of least redressive features available in
indirect strategies.
A closer look at these indirect strategies suggests the existence of what Brown and Levinson (1987)
refer to as ‘relational harmony’ which emphasizes a collectivist nature of eastern culture (Nisbett, 2004) in
which a person prefers to be identified in harmony with a group in his community rather than gaining
absolute identification as an individual. Actually, as Mao (1994, p.460) holds about the Chinese culture,
168
Persian interpretation of the notion of face comparing with that of the English may also be more of a
relative one not just emphasizing the “accommodation of individual needs or desires, but more of the
harmony of one’s conduct with the views or judgment of the community”.
Regarding the second aim of the study, the findings illustrated a major tendency of English
advertisements towards Positive politeness strategies which include: show concern, interest, be optimistic,
promise, guarantee, offer, give reasons, compliment, joke, humor, exaggerate sympathy. As the main
purpose of positive politeness strategies, Brown and Levinson (1987) refer to shortening the social distance
that is to make the advertiser and addressee closer to each other and thus build up an individualistic
connection. Having positive feeling about oneself along with praising personal success in western culture is
considered at the opposite of group-driven success in eastern culture (Nisbett, 2004) which is gained in most
of English ads through the use of Positive politeness strategies. Moreover, in accord with Lin’s (2005)
findings, positive strategies by minimizing the face threatening force of an act, try to save a person’s positive
face and provide him with more feeling of personal success which can lead to stressing the more
individualistic and self-motivated nature of western communities.
The findings related to the third aim of the study revealed that employing mostly Off-record politeness
strategies by Persian advertisers as a sign of successful persuasive tool in comparison with using Positive
politeness strategies at most by English advertisers offered some differences between these two cultures. To
start, the notion of face and face-saving acts as proposed by Goffman (1967), as well as the notion of ‘self’
may not be as individualistically perceived in eastern cultures like in Persian ads as they are perceived in
western ones. Following the classification of culture into individualistic and collectivist as a highly mentioned-
topic of cross-cultural research, Ting-Toomey and Cocroft (1994) reported that in eastern communities the
realization of ‘self’ is mainly gained through “personal achievements and self-actualization processes”,
whereas in western communities the realization of ‘self’ happens by more “role relationships, family
reputation, workgroup reputation” (p. 514).
Moreover, according to Allami and Naeimi (2010) in a high- context culture such as Iran, people tend to
use indirect, symbolic, vague, and implicit style of communication whereas low-context culture is generally
represented by direct and explicit communication approach. As a result of the above mentioned
classifications of culture in eastern and western communities, more use of indirect and Off-record politeness
strategies which are supposed to be one of the least FTAs, creates an atmosphere in which the addressee
feels in- group membership and can enjoy the feeling of group-driven success. Our findings can also be
consistent with those of Pishghadam (2011) who stated on the basis of Scollon and Scollon`s (2001)
categorization, Iranian culture is a hierarchal one in which social hierarchy is assumed as a natural structure,
whereas American culture works on the basis of a deference politeness system in which the interlocutors
share the equal social level and rights. Undoubtedly, indirect way of talking is more prevalent in hierarchical
cultures whole cultures based on deference favor for more direct way of dealing with issues.
Furthermore, that Persian advertises’ endeavor to build a relationship with customers via indirect
strategies is probably in line with Nisbett’s (2004) classification of Asian and western cultures. To put it
another way, in Asian countries people are more favored to construct relationships in the community by any
possible way. Moreover, as Miracle (1987) claims, unlike western advertisers who use learn-do-feel
strategies, advertisers in Asian countries generally use feel-do-learn strategies to entertain and establish
feelings. Even if the Persian advertisement lines lack the essential factors to offer adequate reasons for their
claims (like the repeated use of overstate strategy: the best, the first, the only…), yet; their close-circle
connection making with the customers is one remarkable success they have proved to gain as an effective
persuasive tool. Thus, Persian advertisers should constantly keep in mind that however appealing their ads
may seem, they must never ignore the fundamental notions underlying the collectivist concept which comes
with indirectness in their polite realizations of ads.
To wrap up, one should not ignore the role of culture in analyzing the words stated by speakers of a given
language. Culture and cultural norms, among other things, can create major impact on the language through
169
which people communicate. Therefore, it is believed that the findings of this study can ensure compliance
with the findings of Nilsen and Nilsen (1978); and Brown (1980), that the influence of language on thought
and behavior can probably best be depicted in the world of advertising. Considering the “reciprocal influence
of culture and thought on advertising” (Valdes, 1986, p.3), the differences in politeness strategies adopted by
advertisers in Persian and English contexts seem adequately representative of the cultural norms existing in
them.
Finally, considering the limited number of studies on Persian advertisement as a type of speech act
especially at cross-cultural level, it is thereby recommended that further studies explore other forms of
advertisements such as commercials. Moreover, highlighting the types of politeness strategies applied in the
ads of one culture can facilitate the grasp of norms of that culture. At the end, it is believed that comparing
the politeness strategies available in Persian ads with those other Asian countries can yield more
opportunities of finding similarities and differences at a closer cultural background.
Acknowledgement
We gratefully acknowledge the project reported here was supported by a grant-in-aid of research from
Ferdowsi University of Mashhad in 2011 (contract code: 17407) without which this research would not have
been possible.
References
Allami, H., &Naeimi, A. (2010). A cross-linguistic study of refusals: An analysis of pragmatic competence development in Iranian EFL
learners. Journal of Pragmatics, 43(1), 385-406.
Benkendorf, J., Prince, M., Rose, M., De Fina, A., & Hamilton, H. (2001). ‘Does indirect speech promote nondirective genetic
counseling? Results of a sociolinguistic investigation’. American Journal of Medical Genetics, 106, 99-207.
Blitvich, P. (2009). Impoliteness and identity in the American news media: The “Culture Wars”. Journal of politeness research.
Language, Behavior, Culture, 5(2), 273-303.
Brown, H.D. (1980). Principles of language learning and teaching. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall.
Brown, P., & Levinson, S. (1987). Politeness: Some universals in language. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Brown, B., & Crawford, P. (2009). Politeness strategies in question formulation in a UK telephone advisory service. Journal of Politeness
Research. Language, Behavior, Culture, 5 (1), 73-91.
Culpeper, J. (2005). Impoliteness and entertainment in the television quiz show: The weakest link. Journal of Politeness Research.
Language, Behavior, Culture. 1(1), 35-72.
Daly, N., Holmes, J., Newton, J., Stubbe, M. (2003). Expletives as a solidarity signal in FTAs on the factory floor. Journal of Pragmatics.
36(5), 945-964.
Fraser, B. & Nolen, W. (1981). The association of deference with linguistic form. International Journal of the Sociology of Language, 27,
93-111.
Gass, R., & Seiter, J. (1999). Persuasion, social influence, and compliance gaining. Needham Height, MA: Allyn & Bacon.
Geis, M. L. (1982). The language of television advertising. New York: Academic Press.
Goffman, E. (1955). On face work: an analysis of ritual elements in social interaction. Psychiatry, 18, 213-231.
Goffman, E. (1976). Replies and responses. Language in Society 5, 257-313.
Hardin, K. J. (2001). Pragmatics in persuasive discourse of Spanish television advertising. Dallas, TX: International Academic Bookstore.
Ide, S. (1989). Formal forms and discernment: Two neglected aspects of linguistic politeness. Multilingua, 8, 223-248.
Hill, B., Ide, S., Ikuta, S., Kawasaki, A., & Ogino, T. (1986). Universals of linguistic politeness: Quantitative evidence from Japanese and
American English. Journal of Pragmatics, 10, 347-371.
Hughes, G.H. (1984). An argument for culture analysis in the second language classroom. In J.M.Valdes, (Ed.). Culture bound: Bridging
the cultural gap in language teaching (pp. 162-170). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Johnstone, B. (2008). Discourse analysis. Malden: Blackwell.
Knoblocch, L., Satterlee, K., & DiDomenico, S. (2010). Relational uncertainty predicting appraisals of face threat in courtship: integrating
uncertainty reduction theory and politeness theory. Communication research, 37(3), 303-334.
Lakoff, R. (1973). The logic of politeness: or, minding your p’s and q’s. Papers from the Ninth Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic
Society (pp. 292-305). Chicago: ChicagoLinguistic Society.
Lakoff, R. (1975). Language and women's place. New York: Harper and Row Publishers.
Leech, G. (1983). Principles of pragmatics. London: Longman.
170
Lin, H.H. (2005). Contextualizing linguistic politeness in Chinese –A socio-pragmatic approach with examples from persuasive sales talk
in Taiwan Mandarin. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Ohio State University- Ohio.
Matsumoto, Y. (1989). Politeness and conversational universals-observations from Japanese. Multilingua-Journal of Cross-cultural and
Interlanguage Communication, 8(2), 207-222.
Miracle, G. E. (1987). Feel-do-learn: An alternative sequence underlying Japanese commercials. In F. Feasely (ed.), Proceedings of
the 1987 conference of the American academy of advertising (pp. R73-R78).
Nilsen, D., & Nilsen, A. (1978). Language play. Rowley, Mass.: Newbury House.
Nisbett, R.E. (2004). The geography of thought: How Asians and Westerners think differently …and why. New york: Free Press.
Obeng, S.G. (1997). Communication strategies: Persuasion and politeness in Akan judicial discourse. Text 17 (1), 25-51.
Pearson, B. (1988). Power and politeness in conversation: encoding of face-threatening acts at church business meetings.
Anthropological Linguistics 30 (1), 68-93.
Pishghadam, R. (2011). An analysis of the realization of politeness parkers in official letters: A cross-cultural study. Paper presented in
6th international symposium on politeness: Corpus approaches. Ankara, Turkey.
Reardon, K. K. (1991). Persuasion in practice. London: Sage Publications.
Schmidt, R., Shimura, A., Wang, Z., & Jeong, H. (1995). Suggestions to buy: television commercials from the U.S., Japan, China, and
Korea. In S. Gass & J. Neu (eds.), Speech acts cross cultures: Challenges to communication in a second language (pp. 285-316).
Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Scollon, R., & Scollon, S. (1981). Narrative, literacy and face in interethnic communication. Norwood, NJ: Ablex Publishing Corporation.
Scollon, R., & Scollon, S. (2001). Intercultural communication. 2nd Ed., London: Blackwell Publishing.
Searle, J. (1970). Speech acts. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Ting-Toomey, S. & Cocroft, B. (1994). Face and facework: theoretical and research issues. In Stella Ting-Toomey (Ed.), The challenge
of facework (pp. 307-340). Albany, NY: State University of New York Press..
Valdes, J.M. (Ed.). (1986). Culture bound: Bridging the cultural gap in language teaching. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Watts, R., Mesthrie, R. (2003). Politeness: Key topics in sociolinguistics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Woods, N. (2006). Describing discourse. London: Hodder Arnold.
171

Online Reading Strategy Use and Gender Differences:

The Case of Iranian EFL Learners
Saeed Taki
Shahreza Branch, Islamic Azad University, Iran

Gholam Hossein Soleimani
Shahreza Branch, Islamic Azad University, Iran

Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.173
Abstract: This study investigated the online reading strategies used by Iranian EFL students and the differences between male
and female learners in terms of online reading strategy use. It also made an attempt to answer the question of whether skilled
strategy users in the offline environment are skilled strategy users in the online environment. Participants in this study were 30
students (15 males and 15 females) selected from among 50 MA students at IAU University of Shahreza, Iran. The Survey of
Reading Strategies (SORS) and Online Survey of Reading Strategies (OSORS) were adapted to the purposes of this study. The
results indicated that participants used online reading strategies moderately. Problem-solving strategies and global reading
strategies were used the most. The findings revealed while there were no overall significant differences between males and
females in terms of online reading strategy use, they did differ significantly on a number of individual strategies. The findings also
indicated that active strategy users in the offline environment were active strategy users in the online environment. The findings
hold implications for EFL teachers, students, material developers, and for researchers.
Keywords: Reading skill; Online reading strategies; Learning strategies; English proficiency
1. Introduction
Reading is one of the main four skills that a learner needs to master in order to ensure success in learning.
According to Anderson (2003), reading is the interaction of four things: the reader, the text, the fluent reading,
and strategic reading. Today, texts, especially academic texts, can be found in either print or online
environments. Nowadays, educational institutions such as universities and schools provide their students
with more online classes; news corporations provide online newspapers; and publishers release more online
books and journals. Therefore, a large amount of reading is carried out in the online environment. As a result,
reading in the online environment is becoming more popular for most people, especially teachers and
students.
Over the last three decades, the focus of a great deal of research studies has been on the role of
strategies in the second language learning (Anderson, 1991; Cohen, 1990; Karbalaei, 2010; Mokhtari, &
Reichard 2004; Malcolm, 2009; O’Malley, & Chamot, 1990; Oxford, 1990; Rubin, 1975). The findings of these
studies indicate that language learners utilize strategies in an active way to fulfill their learning goals. In the
context of reading, Garner (1987) defined reading strategies as “generally deliberate, planful activities
undertaken by active learners, many times to remedy perceived cognitive failure” (p. 50). She claimed that
these strategies help language learners in building meaning and facilitating reading comprehension.
However, the strategies to use for reading online are not necessarily the same as those used for reading in
print. Thus, this study set itself the goal of answering the following research questions:
1.What online reading strategies do the participants use when reading English texts online?
173
2.Are there any significant differences between male and female participants in terms of online reading
strategy use?
3.Are active strategy users in the print environment active strategy users in the online environment?
2. Literature Review
Over the last three decades there has been a great focus on learners and learning rather than teachers and
teaching. Much of the research conducted in this area has been influenced by developments in cognitive
psychology (Williams, & Burden, 1997). The focus of most of such studies has been on the process of new
information by learners, the strategies used by learners to understand, learn, or remember the new
information, and the variables influencing learners’ choice of strategies. O'Malley and Chamot (1990), Oxford
(1990), Oxford and Cohen (1992), Cohen (2007), and many others studied strategies used by language
learners during the process of foreign language learning. Wenden and Rubin (1987) defined learning
strategies as "... any sets of operations, steps, plans, routines used by the learner to facilitate the obtaining,
storage, retrieval, and use of information." (p. 19). Cohen (2007) holds that language learner strategies are
“conscious or semi- conscious thoughts and behaviors employed by learners, often with the intention of
enhancing their knowledge about and performance in a second language (L2)” (p. 57).
As for reading, there are three subcategories in the categorization of reading strategies. Global reading
strategies are those strategies that language learners utilize to plan, regulate, and evaluate their reading
(Pookcharoen, 2009). Setting a purpose for reading, activating prior knowledge, and verifying whether the
content fits the purpose are examples of global reading strategies. Problem-solving strategies contain
strategies or steps that language learners take to enhance and improve comprehension difficulties. Adjusting
reading speed, paying closer attention to reading, and pausing to reflect on reading are examples of problem
solving strategies. Support strategies are techniques or materials that second language readers use when
problem-solving strategies are not sufficient in achieving comprehension. Taking notes, paraphrasing text
information, and using a dictionary are examples of support reading strategies.
2.1 Gender and Second Language Reading Strategies
Unlike the research on language learning and second language learning studies, there have been few
studies on the subject of gender and reading strategies. The findings of such studies do not show greater
strategy use for either males or females. Phakiti (2003) in his study explored male and female differences in
reading strategy utilization. He found that while there were no significant differences between males and
females in terms of the cognitive strategies, males used significantly more metacognitive strategies than
females did. Sheorey and Mokhtari (2001) examined the metacognitive, cognitive, and support strategies of
second language readers. The findings revealed no significant overall differences between males and
females. Finally, Young and Oxford (1993), interested in the strategies used while reading passages in both
English and Spanish, found insignificant differences between males and females. Although the data gathered
from such studies cast light on gender differences and strategy use, more and more research needs to be
conducted to draw general conclusions about gender and strategy use.
2.2 Research on Online Reading Strategy Use
In comparison with the abundant research conducted in the area of reading strategies in the print
environment, relatively few studies have investigated the online reading strategies in the online environment.
Zaki, Hassan, and Razali (2008) investigated the difference between online and offline reading strategies
used by second language readers. According to the results, global, support and problem-solving strategies
lead to better reading comprehension.
174
The type of online reading strategies and their classifications in the online reading environment have been
the focus of recent studies. Elshair (2002) conducted a qualitative study and used think-aloud while Anderson
(2003) conducted a quantitative study and used questionnaires. Elshair (2002) pointed out that it was
important to include both text-related and web-related strategies when reading online texts. To compare ESL
and EFL students’ different use of online reading strategies, Anderson (2003) created the Online Survey Of
Reading Strategies (OSORS). This questionnaire was adapted from Survey Of Reading Strategies (SORS)
(Sheorey & Mokhtari, 2001). He found no differences between the subjects in the study and in the use of
global and support reading strategies between the two groups.
Chang (2005) investigated the effects of self-regulated and self-monitoring strategies to ease learning in
web-based environment. According to the findings of this study, self-regulated strategies made the students
more responsible for their learning and self-monitoring strategies had a positive effect on academic
achievement among both more proficient and less proficient learners. Poole (2008-2009) investigated the
relationship between the utilization of online reading strategies and the overall reading proficiency. The
results demonstrated a significant relationship between strategy use and reading proficiency. Hsieh and
Dwyer (2009) found that different reading strategies had different instructional structures and functions in
facilitating student achievement of different types of learning objectives. Huang, Chen, and Lin (2009)
examined EFL learners’ online reading strategy use and the effects of online reading strategy use on
comprehension. According to the findings, global strategies played the most significant role and led to better
comprehension.
3. Methodology
3.1 Participants
The participants in this study were 30 students (15 males and 15 females) were selected from 50 MA
students majoring in Teaching English as a Foreign Language (TEFL) and English Language Translation in
IAU University of Shahreza, Iran. They were selected based on their Oxford Placement Test scores. Those
students who scored above 75 were selected for the purposes of the study. They were all in their first or
second year of study. From these 30 students, 16 students were chosen to answer the third research
question.
3.2 Research Instruments
The Oxford Placement Test (OPT) was administered to ensure the selected participants were linguistically
homogeneous. To collect information about the participants’ offline and online strategy use an adapted
version of the Survey Of Reading Strategies (SORS), developed by Mokhtari and Sheorey (2002), and an
adapted version of the Online Survey Of Reading Strategies (OSORS) (Anderson, 2003) were used. Finally,
an Internet Use Questionnaire (IUQ) was used to elicit general information about the participants’ personal
background and their ability and experience with reading on the Internet.
3.3 Data Collection
An OPT was administered to 50 MA students as mentioned above. Then, an IUQ was administered. Finally,
for the purpose of the current research, 30 students were chosen from the participating students based on
their OPT scores and their responses to the IUQ.
Participants were divided into two male and female groups, 15 each. For the sake of answering the third
research question another group, called strategic readers group, was formed. The members of this group
were selected from among those participants who indicated a high level of strategy use when answering the
175
questionnaire (OSORS). In order to answer the first and second questions of the study, the participants (male
and female groups) were asked to read three online passages in the computer laboratory of the university
(available online at http://onlinereading.mihanblog.com/post/author/437814). After reading the text, an Online
Survey Of Reading Strategies (OSORS) was administered to identify the online reading strategies used by
participants. In order to answer the third question, the participants of the strategic reader group read the print
version of the above-mentioned passages and were asked to fill in the SORS to recognize the offline reading
strategies. Finally, the results were compared.
3.4 Data Analysis
Descriptive statistics and t-tests were used for data analysis. The mean and the standard deviation of each
SORS and OSORS item were calculated and interpreted using score interpretation suggested by Oxford and
Burry-Stock (1995):
Mean of 3.5 or higher = High
Mean of 2.5 to 3.4 = Medium
Mean of 2.4 or lower = Low
To see whether the difference between male and female learners in terms of online reading strategy use was
significant an independent-samples t-test was used. Moreover, to examine whether active strategy users in
the print environment were active strategy users in the online environment a paired-samples t-test was
applied.
4. Results
4.1 The Results for the First Research Question
The first research question aimed to identify the online reading strategies reported to be used by Iranian EFL
students who participated in this study.
As depicted in Table 1 (see Appendix), the participants used each item with varying degrees of frequency.
The means of OSORS items range from 1.63 to 4.13. According to the results, the mean for the overall
strategy use was 3.08. The most frequently used strategies were no. 16 Paying closer attention to reading
(M= 4.13) followed by no. 32 Guessing meaning of unknown words (M= 3.96) and no.1 having a purpose in
mind (M= 3.86). The least frequently used strategies were no. 4 Taking notes while reading (M= 1.63), no. 3
Live chatting with native speakers (M= 1.90) and no. 7 Reading aloud when text is hard (M= 1.96).
Table 1 reveals that the learners utilized problem-solving strategies the most (M= 3.50), global reading
strategies the second most (M= 3.19), and support reading strategies the least (M= 2.35). Based on Oxford
and Burry-Stock’s (1995) score interpretation explained before, 6 items from global reading subcategory
(15.38%) and 6 items from problem-solving subcategory (15.38%) fell in the high usage group, while there
was no item from support strategies subcategory in the high usage group. There were 12 items from global
reading subcategory (31%), 4 items from problem-solving subcategory (10.25%), and 4 items from support
reading subcategory (10.25%) in the medium usage group. Lastly, for the low usage group, there were 2
items from global reading subcategory (5.12%), 5 items from support reading subcategory (12.82%), and no
item from problem-solving subcategory. Of all 39 strategies, 12 strategies (31%) were used at the high level,
20 strategies (51%) were used at medium level, while only 7 strategies (18%) were used at low level.
Therefore, the majority of the strategies used by participants fell in the medium level, which indicates that
they used these strategies on a relatively regular base.
176
4.2 The Results for the Second Research Question
The second research question was related to the differences between Iranian male and female EFL students’
online reading strategy use and the significance of such differences. To determine statistically if there were
significant differences between male and female readers in terms of overall strategy use, a t-test was
administered.
Table 2. T-test for Males and Females’ Overall Strategy Use
Levene's Test for

Equality of Variances t-test for Equality of Means
95% Confidence
Interval of the
Mean Std. Error Difference
F Sig. t df Sig. (2-tailed) Difference Difference Lower Upper
t Equal variances
.187 .668 -.550 28 .587 -3.06667 5.57927 14.49528 8.36195
assumed
Equal variances
-.550 27.356 .587 -3.06667 5.57927 14.50742 8.37409
not assumed
As indicated in the table above, the Significance (2-tailed) value is .587. The magnitude of the differences in
the means (mean difference = -3.06, 95% C1: 14.49 to 8.36) was small (eta squared = .01). According to the
results, there is no a significant difference in the mean scores for males and females. Thus, males and
females did not significantly differ in their overall strategy use.
In order to determine whether the difference between males and females was significant in terms of
individual strategy use, an independent-sample-t-test was conducted for each item.
Table 3 (see Appendix) shows that males and females only differed significantly on four individual strategies:
one global strategy (2. Live chatting with other learners), two problem-solving strategies (13.Adjusting
reading speed, and 19.Pausing and thinking about reading) and one support strategy (21.Paraphrasing for
better understanding). On the strategies no. 2 (global), no. 19 (problem-solving), and no. 21 (support)
females indicated higher strategy use, while males did on the strategy no. 13 (problem-solving).
4.3 The Results for the Third Research Question
The third research question aimed to answere whether strategic readers in the offline environment were
strategic readers in the online environment. The data for analysis were gathered from two questionnaires:
SORS and OSORS. A paired-samples-t-test was conducted to determine whether there was a statistically
significant difference in the mean scores for strategic readers group in both environments. Table 4 provides
paired samples statistics for strategic readers group.
Table 4. Paired Samples Statistics for Strategic Reader Group
Std. Error
Mean N Std. Deviation Mean
Pair Zscore(Online) -3.02400 16 1.00000000 25000000
1 Zscore(Offline) -1.01300 16 1.00000000 25000000
177
Table 4 provides the mean scores for each of the two sets of scores. There was an increase in
strategic readers mean scores from offline environment (M= -1.01, SD= 1) to online environment (M= -3.02,
SD= 1), t (15) = -5.104, p > .05 (two-tailed). Therefore, we can conclude that there was a significant
increase in strategic readers test scores from offline environment to online environment.
Table 5. Paired-Samples T-test for Strategic Reader Group
Paired Differences
95% Confidence
Interval of the
Std. Error Difference
Mean Std. Deviation Mean Lower Upper t df Sig. (2-tailed)
Pair Zscore(Online) -
-2.01097 1.57588899 39397225 -.839732 83973197 -5.104 15 1.000
1 Zscore(Offline)
In Table 5 , the significance level (2-tailed) is 1.00. The mean increase in both scores was -2.01 with a 95%
confidence interval ranging from -.83 to .83. The eta squared statistic (.53) indicated a moderate effect size.
Therefore, we can conclude that there is not a significant difference in the strategic readres’ scores in offline
environment and online environment.
5. Discussion and Conclusions
The first research question has to do with the online reading strategies that Iranian EFL students use when
reading online. The findings revealed that the participants were moderate strategy users. Of the three
subclasses included in the OSORS, problem-solving subclass was used with the highest frequency followed
by global-reading strategies and support reading strategies. Therefore, problem-solving strategies are the
most important strategies for the participants followed by global reading strategies.
These findings are consistent with the findings of other previous studies (Anderson, 2003; Mokhtari &
Reichard, 2004; Pookcharoen et al., 2009) which indicated the highest frequency of use for problem-solving
strategies. The results also support Motallebzadeh and Ghaemi’s (2009) study which indicated that problem-
solving strategies were used most frequently followed by global reading strategies and support reading
strategies.
As for the overall strategy use, a medium frequency was observed. This reveals the participants’ high
degree of awareness while reading in English. These findings support the findings of Poole’s (2008) study
using relatively the same version of OSORS.
Interestingly, the students seldom took notes, although this strategy has been found to be beneficial in
increasing comprehension. Even though readers in the print environment often take notes to better
understand what is read, the participants in this study indicated a low mean for this strategy and found it
mentally taxing. At the same time, the low means attached to the strategies of translating from English into
Persian, using reference materials, reading aloud when text is hard, and taking notes can imply that students
avoid using time-consuming strategies. Because utilizing such strategies requires using additional materials
and opening extra web pages. Therefore, the factors of time and effort could be significant factors that affect
the participants’ strategy use. On the other hand, the low frequency attributed to the strategy reading aloud
when text is hard could be because of the awkward feeling that the students may have when reading aloud.
In addition, as Eskey (2005) maintained, reading words out loud is a characteristic of bottom-up unskilled
readers.
Another interesting point is that neither of the strategies related to the live chatting with native (global) or
non-native (global) speakers were highly used by the participants. This may be because of the fact that
178
students in Iran study English as a foreign language as well as the limited opportunities to interact with native
speakers may explain the low mean of live chatting with native speakers.
It is noteworthy that strategies used more frequently or with a high frequency may not require using outside
materials and taking relatively little time and efforts to execute than those requiring such elements. As an
example, participating in live chat, besides being time-consuming, requires using extra devices and
sometimes opening extra web pages. In addition, this strategy may not be an option for many students,
except for those that their coursework included a course website containing features such as discussion
boards, live chat, etc.
One possible conclusion is that the learners use the same types of strategies while reading online.
Perhaps another conclusion is that in the context of Iran problem-solving strategies play a more important
role in EFL reading instruction than global reading and support reading strategies. EFL teachers can have
their students pay more attention to problem-solving reading strategies to help them improve their online
reading ability. Furthermore, the findings of this study maintain that a relatively equal and important position
should be considered for the teaching of different online reading strategies in the classroom.
The second research question explored the differences between male and female students in terms of
online reading strategy application. The participants of both groups reported using more than half of the
strategies with a high or medium frequency. One possible reason for such a frequency can be the
relationship between reading proficiency and active strategy use that has been thoroughly studied and
documented for second language readers (Anderson, 1991; Cabral & Tavares, 2002; Upton, 1997; Yang,
2002; Zhang, 2001).
As for the differences between males and females, a negligible difference was observed between them,
though it was not statistically significant. All in all, no significant differences were found between males and
females in terms of overall strategy use. The amount of instruction received by both sexes can account for
such negligible differences. In other words, a similar level of strategy application may indicate a similar
amount of instruction. Language proficiency and years of study are other factors that can affect the perceived
strategy use.
The findings of this study provide further support for previous studies conducted on the topic in the print
environment (Phakiti, 2003; Poole, 2005; Sheorey & Mokhtari, 2001) which indicated that males and females
did not differ significantly on overall strategy use and on any of the three subscales. In the context of online
reading, these findings are in line with Amer et al. (2010) findings. Furthermore, as Sheorey and Mokhtari
(2001) claim, such results are in contrast with previous strategy research (Poole, 2009; Sheorey, 2006;
Sheorey & Boboczky, 2008) in which females reported using more strategies than males. In fact, according to
Oxford (1993), females are higher L2 Achievers not because of their innate gender differences but because
of their higher level of strategy use. This claim was supported by Sheorey and Mokhtari’s (2001) study in
which more proficient L2 readers utilized more strategies than less proficient ones. Furthermore, Brantmeier
(2001) found that passage content is pertained to reading success. In other words, the type of passage
affects students’ performance—i.e. males do better on science-oriented passages, while females score
higher on humanities-related topics. Therefore, one conclusion that can be drawn is that, as Ehrlich (1997)
claimed, it is possible that gender differences are more related to task demands and contextual motivation
than biology.
The participants differed significantly on four individual strategies: one global strategy, two problem-solving
strategies, and one support reading strategy. The results found in this study in the context of online reading
are relatively consistent with Sheorey and Mokhtari’s (2001) results, which indicate that male and female
college ESL students only differed in one individual strategy. The findings are also in line with Poole’s (2005)
study which showed that both genders differed in two of the 30 individual strategies. They are also in line with
Poole’s (2009) study in which females scored higher than males on eight individual strategies. As mentioned
before, proficiency and the years of study may explain such differences. It could be that females had studied
English for longer amounts of time than males.
179
All in all, the findings revealed that there was a relatively similar pattern of strategy use among males and
females. No statistically significant differences were found between both genders in terms of three OSORS
subscales.
The third research question sought to investigate the strategic readers in the offline and online
environment. The results of the paired sample t-test indicate that strategic readers in the offline environment
were strategic in the online environment. One explanation for this result is the connection between reading
strategy use and overall reading proficiency. In other words, highly proficient readers may be more active
strategy users than less proficient readers, as they are in both offline and online environments.
An important finding pertaining to the results of this research question is that the participants utilized all 30
strategies listed on SORS in the online environment. This shows that strategic readers transfer many of the
strategies that they use in the print environment to the online environment. In this regard, the reading strategy
instruction received by the participants can play an important role in their transfer of such strategies to the
online environment. By considering the fact that the great majority of reading in Iran takes place in the print
environment this is not entirely surprising.
Another finding is that strategic readers in the offline environment are not struggling readers in the online
environment. This finding is in contrast with Coiro’s (2007) findings which indicated that lower-performing
offline readers can be higher-performer online readers.
In conclusion, the results demonstrated that strategic readers in the offline environment were strategic
readers in the online environment. Thus, good readers are active strategy users in both print and online
contexts. Furthermore, the findings demonstrated that strategic readers transferred strategies used in the
print environment to the online environment.
Reference
Amer, A. Al Barwani, T. & Ibrahim, M. (2010). Student teachers’ perceived use of online reading strategies. International Journal of
Education and Development Using Information and Communication Technology, 6 (4), 102-113. Retrieved April 23, 2011 from
http://www.ifets.info/journals/12_3/3.pdf
Anderson, N. J. (1991). Individual differences in strategy use in second language reading and testing. Modern Language Journal, 75,
460-472.
Anderson, N. J. (2003). Scrolling, clicking, and reading English: Online reading strategies in a second/foreign language. The Reading
Matrix, 3(3), 1-33.
Brantmeier, C. (2005). Effects of reader’s knowledge, text type, and test type on L1 and L2 reading comprehension. Modern Language
Journal, 89, 37-53.
Cabral, A. P., & Tavares, J. (2002). Practicing college reading strategies. The Reading Matrix, 2(3). Retrieved April 28, 2011 from
http://www.readingmatrix.com/articles/cbral_tvares/article.pdf
Chang, M. M. (2005). Instructional strategy application in Web-based language teaching and learning. Taipei: Crane Publishing
Company.
Cohen, A.D. (1990). Language learning: Insights for learners, teachers, and researchers. New York: Newbury House.
Cohen, A. D. (2007). Coming to terms with language learner strategies: Surveying the experts. In A. D. Cohen & E. Macaro (Eds.),
Language learner strategies: Thirty years of research and practice (pp. 29-45). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Coiro, J. (2007). Exploring changes to reading comprehension on the Internet: Paradoxes and possibilities for diverse adolescent
readers. Unpublished dissertation: University of Connecticut. Retrieved April 28, 2011 from
http://proquest.umi.com/pqdlink?Ver=1&Exp=12-10-2012&FMT=7&DID=1372023711&RQT=309&attempt=1&cfc=1
Ehrlich, S. (1997). Gender as social practice: Implications for second language acquisition. Studies in Second Language Acquisition,
19(4), 421-446.
Elshair, H. M. (2002). The strategies used by students to read educational websites and their relation to website usability and text
design. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Retrieved January
Garner, R. (1987). Metacognition and reading comprehension. Norwood, NJ: Ablex.
Hsieh, P. H., & Dwyer, F. (2009). The Instructional effect of online reading strategies and learning styles on student academic
achievement. Educational Technology & Society, 12(2), 36–50.
Huang, H., Chern, C., & Lin, C. (2009). EFL learners’ use of online reading strategies and comprehension of texts: An exploratory study.
Computers & Education, 52, 13–26.
Karbalaei, A. (2010). A comparison of the metacognitive reading strategies used by EFL and ESL readers. The Reading Matrix, 10(2).
180
Malcolm, D. (2009). Reading strategy awareness of Arabic speaking medical students studying in English. System, 37, 640–651.
Mokhtari, K., & Reichard, C. (2004). Investigating the strategic reading processes of first and second language readers in two diﬀerent
cultural contexts. System, 32, 379–394.
Mokhtari, K., & Sheorey, R. (2002). Measuring ESL students’ awareness of reading strategies. Journal of Developmental Education,
25(3), 2-10.¬¬¬
Motallebzadeh, K., & Ghaemi, H. (2009). The relationship between online reading strategies and the choice of offline reading strategies
of intermediate EFL learners. The Iranian EFL Journal, 3, 64-81.
O’Malley, J. M., & Chamot, A. U. (1990). Learning strategies in second language acquisition. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Oxford, R. (1990). Language learning strategies: What every teacher should know. Boston: Heinle & Heinle.
Oxford, R. (1993). Research on second language strategies. Annual Review of Applied Linguistics, 13, 175-187.
Oxford, R. L., & Burry-Stock, J. A. (1995). Assessing the use of language learning strategies worldwide with the ESL/EFL version of the
Strategy Inventory for Language Learning (SILL). System, 23, 1-23.
Oxford, R. L., & Cohen, A. D. (1992). Language learning strategies: Crucial issues of concept and classification. Applied Language
Learning, 3, 1-35.
Phakiti, A. (2003). A closer look at gender and strategy use in L2 reading. Language learning, 53(4), 649-702.
Pookcharoen, S., Lee, V. Y., & Kigamwa, J. (2009). Exploring metacognitive online reading strategies among EFL university students.
Poster presented at the 43rd Annual TESOL Convention and Exhibit, Denver, Colorado.
Poole, A. (2005). Gender and academic reading strategies: A survey of adult EFL learners in Mainland China. Hong Kong
Journal of Applied Linguistics, 10(2), 38-51.
Poole, A. (2008). Awareness of reading strategies among male and female college students when reading online. Journal of Balanced
Reading Instruction, 15(1), 127-140.
Poole, A. (2008-2009). The Relationship of reading proficiency to online strategy use: A study of U.S. college students. Journal of
College Literacy & Learning, 35, 3-11.
Rubin, J. (1975). What the “good language learner” can teach us? TESOL Quarterly, 9, 41-51.
Sheorey, R., & Baboczky, E. (2008). Metacognitive awareness of reading strategies among Hungarian college students. In K.
Mokhtari & R. Sheorey (Eds.), Reading strategies of first-and second-language learners (pp. 161-173). Norwood, MA:
Christopher-Gordon.
Sheorey, R. (2006). Learning and teaching of English in India. New Delhi: Sage Publications.
Sheorey, R., & Mokhtari, K. (2001). Diﬀerencies in the metacognitive awareness of reading strategies among native and non-native
readers. System, 29, 431-449.
Upton, T. A. (1997). First and second language use in reading comprehension strategies of Japanese ESL students. TESL-EJ, 3(1).
Wenden, A. & Rubin, J. (1987). Learner strategies in language learning. New Jersey: Prentice Hall
Williams, M., & Burden, R. L. (1997). Psychology for language teachers: A social constructivist approach. Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press.
Yang, Y. (2002). Reassessing readers’ comprehension monitoring. Reading in a Foreign Language, 14(1), 18-42.
Young, D. J., & Oxford, R. L. (1993). Attending to learner reactions to introductory Spanish textbooks. Hispania, 76, 593-605.
Zaki, I. M., Hassan, F., & Razali, A. B. M. (2008). ESL students’ online and offline reading strategies: Scrolling, clicking, flipping and
reading. Asian Journal of University Education, 4(2), 61-78.
Zhang, L. (2001). Awareness in reading: EFL students’ metacognitive knowledge of reading strategies in an acquisition-poor
environment. Language Awareness, 10(4), 268-288.
Appendix
Table 1. Participants’ Level of Strategy Use
Types Of
Reading Reading Strategies M SD Level of Use
Strategies
Global Reading 1. Having a purpose in mind 3.86 .86 High
Strategies
2. Live chatting with other learners 2.16 .79 Low
3. Live chatting with native speakers 1.90 .96 Low
5. Using prior knowledge 3.33 1.91 Medium
6. Scrolling through text 3.56 1.16 High
181
8. Analyzing if the content fits purpose 3.63 1.06 High

10. Noting length and organization 2.66 1.03 Medium
14. Deciding what to read closely and what to ignore 3.66 .96 High
17. Clicking on links to other sites 3.03 1.06 Medium
18. Using tables, figures, and pictures 2.73 1.18 Medium

20. Using context clues 3.50 1.18 High
23. Using typographical features (e.g., italics) 3.26 .90 Medium
24. Evaluating and analyzing the information presented in 3.13 .81 Medium
the text
26. Checking my understanding 3.40 1.14 Medium
27. Reading for academic purposes 3.23 1.05 Medium
28. Guessing what the content is about 3.60 1.00 High
31. Confirming predictions 3.16 1.02 Medium
33. Scanning the text before reading 3.46 1.09 Medium

34. Reading for fun 3.40 1.06 Medium
37. Looking for both sides of an issue 3.26 .93 Medium
Overall 3.19 1.05 Medium
9. Reading slowly and carefully 3.66 1.07 High

11. Trying to stay focused on reading 3.66 .96 High
13. Adjusting reading speed 3.26 .82 Medium
16. Paying closer attention to reading 4.13 .91 High
19. Pausing and thinking about reading 2.76 .79 Medium
Problem-solving 22. Visualizing information read 2.93 .99 Medium
Strategies 29. Rereading for better understanding 3.86 1.04 High
32. Guessing meaning of unknown words 3.96 .80 High
35. Evaluating text before using it 3.26 1.08 Medium
36. Distinguishing fact from opinion 3.53 .90 High
Overall 3.50 .93 High
4. Taking notes while reading 1.63 .9 Low
7. Reading aloud when text is hard 1.96 1.05 Low

12. Printing out a hard copy of text 2.56 1.00 Medium
15. Using reference materials 2.33 1.00 Low
Support Reading 21. Paraphrasing for better understanding 2.56 .93 Medium
Strategies
25. Going back and forth in text 3.13 1.04 Medium
30. Asking myself questions 2.60 1.25 Medium
38. Translating from English into Persian 2.03 1.03 Low
39. Thinking in both English and Persian 2.40 1.10 Low

Overall 2.35 1.03 Low
182
Table 3. T-test for Males and Females’ Individual Strategy Use
Male Female
Name Strategy (n = 15) (n = 15) T P-value
M SD M SD
1. Having a purpose in mind 4.13 0.74 3.60 .98 1.67 0.10

2. Live chatting with other learners 1.53 0.91 2.80 .67 -4.31 0.00018*
3. Live chatting with natives 1.60 0.91 2.20 1.01 -1.70 0.09
5. Using prior knowledge 3.46 1.18 3.20 1.20 0.45 0.65

6. Scrolling through text 3.40 1.05 3.73 1.27 -0.77 0.44
8. Analyzing if the content fits purpose 3.80 1.01 3.46 1.12 0.85 0.40
10.Noting length and organization 2.53 1.06 2.80 1.01 -0.70 0.48
14. Deciding what to read closely and what 3.60 0.89 3.73 1.03 -0.18 0.85
to ignore
17. Clicking on links to other sites 2.93 1.13 3.13 0.99 -0.34 0.73
18. Using tables, figures, pictures 2.93 0.96 2.53 1.40 0.90 0.37
Glob 20. Using context clues 3.33 0.97 3.66 1.39 -0.75 0.45
23. Using typographical features 3.13 0.83 3.40 0.98 -0.80 0.43
24. Evaluating and analyzing the information 3.26 0.96 3.00 0.67 1.53 0.13
presented in the text
26. Checking my understanding 3.13 1.06 3.66 1.23 -1.26 0.21
27. Reading for academic purposes 3.06 1.16 3.40 0.94 -0.34 0.73
28. Guessing what the content is about 3.66 1.17 3.53 0.83 0.35 0.72
31. Confirming predictions 3.26 1.27 3.06 0.77 0.17 0.89
33. Scanning the text before reading 3.13 1.33 3.80 0.86 -1.78 0.08
34. Reading for fun 3.26 1.06 3.53 1.06 -1.03 0.31
37. Looking for both sides of an issue 3.20 1.37 2.66 0.48 1.41 0.17
9. Reading slowly and carefully 3.46 0.74 3.86 1.40 -0.97 0.34
11. Staying focused on reading 3.80 0.86 3.53 1.06 0.75 0.45
13. Adjusting reading speed 3.73 0.88 2.80 0.77 3.07 0.005*
16. Paying closer attention to reading 4.26 0.70 4.00 1.13 0.77 0.44
19. Pausing and thinking about reading 2.33 0.81 3.20 0.77 -2.98 0.006*
Prob
22. Visualizing information read 2.93 1.09. 2.93 0.88 .000 1.00
29. Rereading for better understanding 4.13 1.35 3.60 0.73 1.84 0.07
32. Guessing meaning of unknown words 4.00 0.65 3.93 0.96 0.22 0.82
35. Evaluating text before using it 3.33 0.89 3.20 1.26 0.33 0.74
36. Distinguishing fact from opinion 3.60 0.82 3.46 0.99 0.40 0.69
Supp 4. Taking notes while reading 1.60 0.91 1.66 0.89 -0.20 0.84
7. Reading aloud when text is hard 1.66 0.89 2.26 1.20 -1.37 0.18
12. Printing a hard copy of text 2.40 1.29 2.73 0.70 -0.87 0.39
15.Using reference materials 2.26 1.09 2.40 0.91 -0.36 0.72
21. Paraphrasing for better 2.00 0.96 3.13 0.91 -3.50 0.002*
understanding
183
25. Going back and forth in text 2.93 1.27 3.33 0.81 -1.02 0.31
30. Asking myself questions 2.80 1.32 2.40 1.18 0.87 0.39
38. Translating from English into Persian 2.33 1.09 1.73 0.96 0.88 0.38
39. Thinking in both English and Persian 2.40 1.29 2.40 0.91 .000 1.00
184
Ageing and Employment Prospects: The Case of Slovenian Unemployed Workers 1
Tjaša Redek
Faculty of Economics, University of Ljubljana

Kardeljeva ploscad 17, 1000 Ljubljana
Andrej Sušjan
Faculty of Economics, University of Ljubljana

Kardeljeva ploscad 17, 1000 Ljubljana
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.185
Abstract: The paper analyzes the perceptions of older unemployed in Slovenian labour market. The empirical results are based
on a survey, which was conducted in April 2009. The results show that even 52 % of older unemployed workers believe that they
have been victims of age discrimination. They believe that age is a disadvantage when seeking work. The consequences of
perceived discrimination are most often that the individuals do not apply for a job, because they feel that they would not be
chosen, a highly undesirable result in an ageing population. The analysis is one of the few of its kind in the region. It also offers
important policy conclusions and potential for future research.
Keywords: age discrimination, unemployed, demographic change, empirical analysis
1. Introduction
Sargeant (2006) claims that age defines numerous aspects of our everyday lives: the right to drive, to vote, to
marry, to retire, to use public transport for free, to have children, to take on a leading post in a company and
many other. Some age limits are very clearly defined by law, others exist as a norm, an accepted standard,
something considered as 'normal'. Therefore, as Sargeant (2006) says, the society at large constantly
judges, whether someone is old, too old, or just old enough to do something.
When discussing age discrimination, it is important to distinguish ageism and age discrimination. Ageism
is considered as attributing some general qualities that are understood as characteristic of older to a specific
individual. Discrimination based on age, on the other hand, refers to the use of such generalizations as
decision-making tools in employment process, promotion, additional on-the-job training and other. But
ageism as such is closely related to discrimination (Macnicol, 2006).
Age discrimination and ageism (stereotyping) are especially problematic in the labour market. Many
studies and data (discussed later on) report of the problems of older employed and unemployed in the labour
market. Those employed have less chances of getting promoted, get less opportunities to receive additional
training. They are perceived as a less productive, but expensive burden (OECD, 2006, pp. 63-64). Those
unemployed on the other hand are less likely to find a job, have higher chance of becoming long-term
unemployed; they feel discouraged and are prone to leaving the labour market as soon as possible (Age
counts, 2009, Johnson and Park, 2011, Johnson, 2009).

1An earlier version of this paper was presented at the conference "An Enterprise Odyssey: From Crisis to Prosperity - Challenges for
Government and Business", held in Opatija, Croatia, May 26-29, 2010. We are grateful to the participants for their useful comments and
suggestions.
185
The problem of old age discrimination in Europe is especially fierce in view of the demographic change.
By 2060 European population (EU27) will change significantly in size and structure. Those, aged 65 or more,
will represent 30 % of total population compared to 'just' 17.1 % in 2008. Dependency ratios are expected to
deteriorate dramatically. By 2060 the ratio between old and those aged 15 to 64 will be 1 to 2. In 2008 four
people aged 15 to 64 lived for every person aged 65 or more (Eurostat, 2011). Changing demographics is
feared to have a detrimental impact on economic growth due to lack of (productive) workers (e.g. Prskawetz
et al., 2008). But, at the moment the employment of older people is far from desirable Stockholm and
Barcelona targets. In view of coming change, such a situation seems unreasonable and should be analyzed.
Partially, the low employment of older workers can be explained also by (perceived) discrimination. We
believe that ageism as a tool for discrimination in the labour market is not specific just for the employers. The
unemployed also perceive themselves partially as society does. As old. And feel thus more discouraged,
which contributes to their comparatively poor position on the labour market.
The aim of the paper is to analyze the perceptions of older unemployed in comparison with the younger in
the labour market in Slovenia about the importance of age. Our main hypothesis is that the old are much
more pessimistic than the rest (the younger 2 ) about their situation, which is reflected also in the
consequences of (perceived) discrimination and their actions to improve their situation. The analysis is based
on survey results, conducted in April 2009.
The structure of the paper is as follows. First, we discuss the problem of ageism and age discrimination
and the problem of age discrimination in the context of the demographic change, then we provide a brief
analysis of causes of discrimination, followed by the analysis of the perceptions of age discrimination among
Slovenian unemployed.
The paper makes several contributions to the existing literature. It is to the best of our knowledge one of
the few empirical analyses of such kind among the unemployed in the region, adding to the understanding of
the perception of discrimination in the discriminated group itself and allowing the study of its consequences in
the region. The analysis is relevant also because of its policy implications. The results also show the
differences between the two groups in the labour market: old and young, allowing the interested institutions to
make educated and differentiated policy proposals.
2. Age discrimination in the context of demographic change
European future is one of demographic ageing (Eurostat, 2011). Current situation in the labour market,
problems in employing older workers along with the attitudes towards older could be detrimental to future
economic success. Primarily because ageing directly impacts the availability of human capital and also
indirectly by impacting the supply.
2.1 Definition of age discrimination
Discrimination is a social phenomenon, leading to less favourable treatment of individuals because of their
sex, nationality, skin colour, age, religion and other factors. Although discrimination is forbidden in many
countries, it is nonetheless present and can significantly impact the relative position and self-confidence of an
individual. Age discrimination is just one aspect of discrimination (Discrimination in the EU, 2009, Equality
and human rights commission, 2011).
According to the International Longevity Centre (2009) Robert N. Butler coined the term ‘ageism’ in 1968.
Since then, the term has been widely used, but, as 'isms' usually do, it continues to denote something
negative. According to Traxler (1980, 4, in Woolf, 1998) ageism is ‘any attitude, action, or institutional

2Throughout the text we use 'old' and 'young(er)'. We use 'old' to capture those aged above 49 years of age. The rest are referred to as
young(er). 49 years is also the delimiting age normally used in the literature and statistical tables (for example, see Eurostat).
186
structure which subordinates a person or group because of age or any assignment of roles in society purely
on the basis of age’. Several other definitions relate the problem of stereotyping the older population. Ageism
is less acknowledged than racism or sexism, but it is nonetheless a harmful prejudice resulting in widespread
mistreatment, such as stereotypic, even degrading media images, physical and financial abuse, unequal
treatment in the labour market, lack of appropriate medical care and services and other (Promoting active
ageing – capitalising on older people’s working potential, 2010).
Although ageism is not itself already age discrimination, it does serve as a foundation for it. According to
Macnicol (2006) ageism is stereotyping, an attribution of generally perceived qualities to an individual without
any solid base. Age discrimination is the use of these generalizations to make decisions about an individual.
In case of the labour market, ageism or stereotyping of older is used to decide whether to employ, to
promote, to provide extra training or education, to sack etc. Buesch et al. (2004) define age discrimination as
fewer opportunities for older workers, which are not a result of lower productivity.
Data also show that discrimination is something to worry about, even if it is banned by law (see Ellis, 2005
on EU anti-discrimination law) and very clear guidelines on how to solve potentially questionable situations
(e.g. dress codes, pregnancy, etc.) are prepared (for example see British Equality and human rights
commission, 2010). Public opinion polls conducted by Eurobarometer (for example Discrimination in the EU
2007 and 2009) show that a large share of Europeans believe that discrimination based on age is
widespread (46% in 2007, 58% in 2009). In 2009 Hungary was at the top with 79 % of respondents saying
that age discrimination is widespread in their country, followed by citizens of the Czech Republic (74 %),
France (68 %), Latvia (67 %) and The Netherlands (66 %). Slovenia is with 52 % ranked 19th. Age is also
perceived by Europeans as an important disadvantage when seeking employment. In 2007 49% of
respondents saw age as a disadvantage if companies had two equally qualified and skilled choices (a tie
with disability). Interestingly, lookism won with 51%. In 2009 age discrimination was considered to be
widespread by 58%. And people believed that financial crisis would actually increase discrimination, primarily
based on age (64% of people), followed by ethnic origin (57%) and disability (56%).
2.2 Age and employment in the EU
Age is obviously perceived as disadvantage in public opinion polls. Unfortunately, employment data do not
oppose this (we are not claiming any causality at this moment). The employment rate and activity rate of
older population are lower than the averages in both Slovenia and EU and the rate of long-term
unemployment among older is higher than among younger (Eurostat, 2011). What do these data imply for an
ageing society?
By 2060 European population (EU27) will change significantly in both size and structure. Median age is
expected to rise from 40.4 years (2008) to 47.9 years (2060). Those, aged 65 or more, will represent 30 % of
total population compared to 'just' 17.1 % in 2008. Dependency ratios are expected to deteriorate
dramatically. By 2060 the ratio between old (65+) and those aged between 15 and 64 will be 1 to 2. In 2008
four people aged 15 to 64 lived for every person aged 65 or more (Eurostat, 2011). This will increase the
pressure on social welfare networks.
Ageing will affect macroeconomic performance and long term growth (Prskawetz et al., 2008), especially
due to the changes in the labour force, which is still the most important production factor. The size and
structure of the labour force will change. Domadenik et al. (2008) calculate that by 2040 the share of the
workforce aged 50 or more in the total working age population (15-64) in Slovenia will reach 37 %, compared
to roughly 27 % in 2005. Similar trends are also noticeable in other EU economies (Perlitz et al., 2010). In
order to maintain macroeconomic dynamics, it is very important to ensure the participation of those aged 50
or more in the labour market.
Momentarily, the situation is rather grim. The EU Stockholm and Lisbon strategies’ goals stress that the
employment of those aged 55 to 65 should increase to 50 % by 2010 (Stockholm target) and that the
187
retirement is expected to be delayed by 5 years (Barcelona target) (Report requested by Stockholm

European Council: "Increasing labour force participation and promoting active ageing", 2002). But Eurostat
(2011) data show that both in the EU and in Slovenia, the retirement age has been increasing very slowly,
from 2001 till 2009 it increased by roughly a year in the EU-27 (from 59.9 to 61.4) and for about 3 years in
Slovenia (from 56.6 in 2002 to 59.8 in 2006, the data for 2001, 2007-2009 were not available for Slovenia).
The employment rates of older workers (55 to 64 years) in the EU and in Slovenia are with the overall
employment rate of 46.3 years in the EU in 2010 and 35.0 % for Slovenia also below the desired targets.
Employment rates for men are with 54.6 % in 2010 above the 50 % target in the EU on average, but Slovenia
lags well behind with 44.5 %. The problem is even deeper among women with only 38.6 % employment in
the EU and very low 24.5 % in Slovenia. Although the situation has been generally improving since 1999 both
in the EU and in Slovenia, the data is still worrying (Eurostat, 2011).
The unemployment data are also very unfavourable for the older workers. The older represent slightly less
than a third of total number of unemployed since 2000 on (Table 1). But there are differences within this
group: while the share of those aged 50-59 remained relatively stable between 2000 and 2009, the number of
those aged 60 or more increased by 72% (Data: Employment service of Slovenia, 2010).
Table 1. Structural characteristics of registered unepmloyment in Slovenia: endangered groups in % of total

unemployed, 2000-2010
Average number of registered
Long term unemplyoed

First time job seekers
No formal education
26 years old or less
unemplyoed
Disabled
Women
Year
50 +
2000 106,601 23.4 17.9 50.7 62.9 47.2 27.5 16.1

2001 101,857 24.1 18.8 50.8 58.9 47.0 27.0 18.3
2002 102,635 24.0 19.6 51.2 54.4 47.0 25.4 18.3
2003 97,674 26.1 23.2 52.8 48.6 44.2 21.4 10.7
2004 92,826 26.2 25.2 53.1 46.2 41.6 21.0 9.2
2005 91,889 24.2 24.3 53.8 47.3 40.8 22.7 9.9
2006 85,836 21.2 22.3 54.8 48.8 39.3 25.4 10.9
2007 71,336 16.7 19.4 54.9 51.2 39.3 31.1 13.8
2008 63,216 14.4 16.9 52.8 51.1 40.1 30.6 16.8
2009 86,354 15.4 14.3 49.1 36.5 39.4 30.3 14.1
Dec. 2010 110,021 16.5 14.6 50.9 39.4 36.3 30.0 17.3
Data: Employment service of Slovenia, 2010-2012.
Older are also much more endangered to become long term unemployed. The data for the duration of
unemployment between 2001 and 2010 shows that on average, the duration of unemployment was
deceasing in this period, and fell by approximately 1 year from 2 years 7 months to 1 year and 8 months in
2010. But the duration of unemployment depended on age. Already the 40-50 year-olds could expect to stay
unemployed longer, only by 3 months in 2010, but the difference increases with age. Those aged between 50
and 60 stayed unemployed longer by about 9 months in 2010, while those aged 60 or more by a year and 3
months longer. The difference is systematic, very obvious both in men and women. Data definitely confirm
the unfavourable position of older workers in the labour market in Slovenia (Table 2).
188
Table 2. Unemployment duration by age between 2010 and 2010 (May)*
Year Total Up to 18 Over 18 to 25 Over 25 to 30 Over 30 to 40 Over 40 to 50 Over 50 to 60 Over 60

All
2001 2y 7m 6d 0y 5m 27d 0y 10m 14d 1y 6m 1d 2y 4m 26d 3y 4m 21d 3y 11m 11d 6y 2m 5d
2003 1y 10m 22d 0y 5m 1d 0y 9m 22d 1y 3m 15d 1y 11m 26d 2y 5m 29d 2y 9m 10 3y 10m 7d
2005 1y 10m 21d 5m 16d 9m 10d 1y 3m 4d 2y 0m 4d 2y 7m 2d 2y 7m 15d 3y 4m 11d
2008 2y 0m 25d 4m 16d 6m 3d 11m 3d 1y 9m 26d 2y 8m 25d 2y 10m 8d 3y 5m 21d
Women
Men
* Y denotes years, m denotes months and d denotes days.

Data: Employment service of Slovenia, 2011.
The position of older workers in Slovenia is grim. On the other hand, 'The 2009 ageing report' stresses that
the labour market participation is expected to increase in the future, especially among older, those aged 55 to
64: by 20 percentage points for women and 10 for men. For now, the trends are not favourable. In the context
of these changes, it is very important to examine and understand the motivation of all parties in the labour
market. It is important to understand how and why the firms employ and what the logic of individual labour
supply is and his motivation and drive to seek work at an older age. And potential discrimination is very
important in this context. Will only the lack of labour solve the problem of discrimination or will just the barrier
be moved to an older age?
3. Age and employment: employer and (potential) employee perspective
The obstacles for older workers in the labour market can be identified both on the side of companies as well
as among workers themselves. Grossman (2005, p.72) stresses that despite the legal protection against age
189
discrimination; the general notion among the companies is still that ‘it is hard to teach an old dog new tricks’.
The workers inevitably feel this general attitude and can consequently become even more unmotivated to
work, invest into training or seek work. The two phenomena can result in a negative spiral leading to low
employment among old and worse results in comparison with the young.
This is similar to the opinion of Berger (2006), who stresses that the existing literature mistakenly links
individual’s identity to age and individual’s identity to work. All three elements should be considered together,
especially in cases when individuals seek work. Such an approach is also the starting point of our analysis.
Therefore, we first analyze the position of the employers, followed by the attitudes of the workers.
Why are companies more prone to employing the young? According to many authors, the causes are in
the perceived economic benefits of employing the young. According to Hutchens (1988) the young have the
comparative advantage of being able to stay in the company longer, which is a rational cause for employing
younger. Thus the company is more motivated to employ and invest into the training of younger workers,
especially in those industries and jobs where specific knowledge and training is required. Consequently
Hutchens (1988) claims that ageing leads to fewer job opportunities. Similarly, also Roscigno et al. (2007)
claim that age discrimination is becoming more evident with ageing, and is most evident once a person is
close to retirement age. Exclusion is the most common form and the primary causes are the standard
stereotypes that older are less flexible, have a lower learning ability, are less productive and also simply the
fact that clients might prefer younger employees.
Schwarz-Woelzl et al. (2008) claim that many managers believe that younger candidates are more
energetic, flexible and have more desire for training. Also, they claim, that in many cases the organizational
culture is such that younger workers are the yardstick. Consequently, authors stress, that mature job seekers
get caught in a discrimination cycle, which stresses limited ability to benefit from training, thus to actual
exclusion from training, outdated skills. Downsizing also comes as a greater expense for older, according to
Schwarz-Woelzl et al. (2008).
But, as Schwarz-Woelzl et al. (2008) stress, ageing is an individual process, which includes both a
decrease in certain functions but also an increase. And regardless of age, everyone faces the problems of
adapting, learning, adjusting the behaviour and developing new perspectives in life, as a result of individual
ageing process. The authors (2008, p. 6) thus emphasize that ‘the decisive factors for a person’s individual
ageing process are to be found in his or her specific life and job history’.
The relatively bad comparative position of the older workers is in part caused also by the beliefs and
attitudes of the workers themselves. Berger (2006) stresses the triangular linkage among identity, work and
age. Usually, theory linked identity and age and separately also identity and work. But the three elements
should be analyzed together in order to understand fully the individual’s motives, attitudes and motivation in
the process of seeking work.
Kooij et al. (2008) claim that there are a number of reasons that stem from the individual’s attitudes and
could explain, at least in part, why old age discrimination appears:
1. When a person is approaching the retirement age, often work becomes perceived as a burden and people
become less involved with the job processes;
2. Older workers might feel less capable and more dependent on others, which has a negative impact on
motivation;
3. Older workers are less productive due to rusted skills and knowledge, which can also be caused by the
inability or the lack of desire to learn;
4. Age has also negative consequences on personal strength, reactions, abilities to learn, memory;
5. Older people appreciate leisure more, therefore their work drive and motivation are lower.
The analyses show that the causes of discrimination can be identified on both the supply and the demand
side. In order to raise the employment of older workers, the understanding of these problems is crucial.
190
4. The case of unemployed in Slovenia
In Slovenia, the employment rate of older workers is below the desired targets, the unemployment rate is
higher and the duration of unemployment is significantly higher than on average. One of the potential causes
could be discrimination.
The purpose of the analysis is to identify whether older unemployed feel (perceive) that age discrimination
is actually present and presents the nature and consequences of perceived discrimination.
The study is based on survey data, carried out in April 2009 with the assistance of ‘Employment service of
Slovenia’ 3 , the national unemployment agency among the unemployed in all Slovenian regions. The
response rate was 37.1 %.
4.1 Sample description
The sample of unemployed consisted of 371 people, 127 men and 241 women (3 did not provide information
on their sex). The average age of the respondents was 37.36 years, 37.55 for men and 37.32 for women. 84
respondents were aged 50 or more, the average age of the older group was 54.33 years. 283 respondents
were aged 49 or less, the average age in this age group was 32.34 years.
The majority of the respondents finished secondary schooling (41.8 %), followed by those with a
‘vocational degree’ (14.3 %), those with the university degree (13.2 %) and those with only primary degree or
even less (11.6 %). The differences in educational attainment among the two age groups are only slight; the
biggest difference is in the share of those with secondary diploma, which is bigger among the younger group
(43.1 %) than the old (38.1 %). But cumulatively in both age groups around 75 % of the respondents have
secondary schooling or less.
4.2 Results
As we continue, we present the results of the survey. We show that there is a strong feeling among the older
that age is a disadvantage.
The respondents were directly asked, whether they feel that they have been already victims of age
discrimination. 52 % of older unemployed workers believe that they have been, while only 24 % of those
younger than 50 (denoted as the rest in the Figure 1) feel so, while on average 30.5 % of respondents feel
that they have been discriminated4. The average value of the binomial variable is quite informative: for older
unemployed it is 0.58, while for the rest only 0.25. The differences between both groups (old and the rest) are
highly statistically significant with p=0.000.

3 The Employment Service of Slovenia helped the survey by asking their regional offices for assisting us in distributing the
questionnaires and returning them to us. Without their support such an analysis would be much harder. In total, 1000 questionnaires
were distributed randomly.
4 The percentage generally might not be as high as expected given the Eurobarometer study, but our survey asked ‘Whether you believe
that you have already been discriminated’, which is much different than the Eurobarometer (2009), where the question focuses on ‘how
widespread do the respondents believe that a certain type of discrimination is’.
191
Figure 1. Do you feel that you have been already victims of age discrimination? Average answer *
,00 ,10 ,20 ,30 ,40 ,50 ,60 ,70
Rest ,25
Rest women ,31
Rest men ,13
Old ,58
Old men ,63
Old women ,55
* Answers were either 0 (No) or 1 (Yes).
Gender differences are also highly interesting. The percentage of those who believe that they have been
discriminated is also significantly higher among older men with 60.6 % than among older women (47.1 %).
The differences are not statistically significant (p=0.186). It must also be noted that the minimum retirement
age for men is higher than for women (56.75 years for women and 58 for men in 2010), which can influence
the result given that men must be active longer and are therefore also longer exposed to this problem. Within
the younger than 50 group (the rest) the differences are also quite notable with men being less affected as
perceived by age discrimination. The differences between the two gender groups in this case are statistically
significant (p=0.000)5.
In order to further examine the perceived status of older in the labour market, a series of questions was
asked. The perception of age discrimination existence is also confirmed by the fact that the respondents
believe that age is a disadvantage when seeking work and they report of mistreatment. Respondents were
asked (on a scale from 1 to 5), whether they agree that the companies prefer to employ younger people. In
the group of older respondents, the mode was even 5 and the average was 4.23. The younger group was
indecisive with a mode of 3 and an average of 3.65 (Table 3).

5 It is very interesting that the gender differences within the group of older are much less notable than in the group of the rest. The
average age of younger than 50 women was 33 years (median 31), while the average age of men in the group was 31.4 years (median
30). Given that in both cases, the majority of respondents were on the left side of the age distribution, the perceived age discrimination
could be linked to the problem of motherhood (potential motherhood) in young women. Data shows that 58.9% of those younger women
that claim to feel discriminated also have children (only 44.1% of those that did not feel discriminated).
192
Table 3. To what extent do you agree with the following statements? Average answer.*
Sig.
(2-
Group N Mean t tailed)
Companies always choose the younger of the two otherwise comparable Old 84 4,23
candidates. Rest 281 3,65 4,394 ,000
Older workers are in worse shape, have poorer health, therefore the Old 83 3,66
employers rather don't employ them. Rest 280 3,69 -,173 ,863
The older are not prepared to learn, therefore the employers rather do not Old 83 3,16
employ them. Rest 278 3,22 -,387 ,699
The older are less flexible and have problems adjusting to change, which is Old 83 3,24
also an obstacle. Rest 281 3,31 -,426 ,671
The younger are less loyal to the company, if a good opportunity arises, Old 83 4,01
they change job. Rest 275 3,90 ,763 ,447
The younger are more productive. Old 80 3,18
Rest 279 3,44 -1,636 ,104
The younger are prepared to work overtime. Old 81 2,84
Rest 270 3,20 -2,211 ,029
The younger are prepared to work overtime in order to be promoted. Old 83 3,08
Rest 277 3,42 -2,206 ,029
Parents with young children also have problems when seeking work. Old 83 4,02
Rest 281 3,84 1,338 ,183
Young women are due to potential pregnancy and motherhood in a Old 80 4,25
comparatively worse position. Rest 274 4,14 ,854 ,395
My experience is that family is an obstacle for finding a job. Old 80 3,09
Rest 278 2,99 ,650 ,516
The older workers in higher positions are an obstacle for the promotion of Old 82 3,59
the young. Rest 282 3,45 ,923 ,357
* Evaluated on a scale from 1 to 5 (1- strongly disagree, 2-do not agree, 3 – I do not know, 4 – agree, 5 –
strongly agree).
Table 3 presents also some other stereotypical statements on age and labour market. Although the answer to
the first claim on employers always choosing the young is very clear, the rest of the statements obtained
much less ‘stereotypical’ support. It could be expected that those younger would claim older to be inflexible,
not so eager to learn, but the differences are not as clear as expected. Although there is some indication that
the young believe to be more productive (p=0.104) and clear indication that they believe to be more prepared
to work overtime also in order to be promoted (p=0.029 in both cases).
Table 4 presents the personal experience of the unemployed in the labour market and in the companies.
Importantly, there is again clear persuasion in the group of older workers that the companies prefer to employ
the young (also differences significant with p=0.000). Consequently, the unemployed quite strongly agree to
be consequently less motivated to seek work (again differences significant with p=0.000). Older also feel
more pushed away than the younger, they feel that despite their education and experience, they do not get
the appropriate decision-making power (with significant differences with the rest at p=0.000 in both cases).
The results show that the older are less eager of attending additional training than the rest (p=0.16), although
on average they agree more with the statement that they had opportunity in the past for it and also took it
(p=0.000 and p=0.062).
193
Table 4. Answers to ‘what extent do you agree with the following statements? Please, evaluate on a scale
from 1 to 5 (1- strongly disagree, 2-do not agree, 3 – I do not know, 4 – agree, 5 – strongly agree).’ Average
answer value provided.
Group N Mean t Sig. (2-tailed)

I wish I had more opportunities for additional training in the Old 83 3,82
company. Rest 279 4,15 -2,445 ,016
I had the opportunity for training in the past. Old 83 3,45
Rest 272 2,62 4,784 ,000
If I got the opportunity for additional training, I always took it. Old 82 4,30
Rest 276 4,07 1,883 ,062
In the company, where I worked last, the working climate was Old 84 3,67
good. Rest 273 3,71 -,281 ,779
Good working climate is important for good work. Old 83 4,67
Rest 274 4,73 -,638 ,524
Companies prefer to employ young. Old 82 4,27
Rest 275 3,69 4,855 ,000
Since the companies prefer to employ the young, I am not Old 82 3,60
motivated to seek work. I believe that I will not get it due to my Rest 273 2,58 6,683 ,000
age.
Due to my age, I do not get the appropriate decision-making Old 83 3,46
power despite my education. Rest 275 2,99 3,196 ,002
Due to my age, despite experience, I do not get the appropriate Old 82 3,55
decision-making power. Rest 274 2,88 4,675 ,000
I would expect faster promotions due to my education and Old 83 3,75
experience, but I do not. I feel that it is because of my age. Rest 276 2,79 7,172 ,000
* Evaluated on a scale from 1 to 5 (1- strongly disagree, 2-do not agree, 3 – I do not know, 4 – agree, 5 –
strongly agree).
These results are very important in terms of motivation of older unemployed to actively seek work, to be
involved in life-long learning and to remain motivated and involved at work.
The analysis was based on a sample of unemployed. The unemployed are those according to ILO that
actively seek work. Employment prospects depend on a series of factors, most importantly experience and
education. But if discrimination is felt to be a problem, the perspective of relative importance of employment
factors could become skewed with age obtaining more than needed attention. Namely, the results show that
although the candidates are comparable in all aspects, except age, the belief is that the younger candidate
will have an advantage over the old. In order to examine the position of the older workers vs. the young, the
respondents were also asked to choose whether age is the most important factor for obtaining work and if
not, which is (Figure 2).
Each respondent either chose age or multiple other factors. 18 % of the younger respondents feel that
age is the most important factor when seeking work compared to 37 % of the older respondents. The
differences between the two groups are statistically highly significant (p=0.000). Among those in the younger
group, that do not agree that the age is the most important factor, the most commonly chosen factor was
'work knowledge and experience', which was chosen by 50.5 % of all young people (143 respondents),
statistically significantly more than among the old, it was chosen by 27.4 % of all older respondents (23
people) (p=0.000). Also 'work knowledge and experience' is not the most common factor chosen by the older,
namely the older believe that it is the networking that is most important next to age. This was chosen by 38 %
of all older respondents (32 people).
194
Among other factors, formal education was very important (40 % of younger, 20 % of older),
recommendations (26 % of older, 23.9 % of younger) and health (around 22 % in both age groups). This
again reveals that the older feel that their age is important and that this feeling is stronger than it is among
the younger respondents. It is also interesting that those, that did not choose age as most important, often
chose ‘networking’ as an important factor. This factor could also be understood in a manner that the older
see ‘connections’ as their way out.
Figure 2. Do you believe that age is the most important factor when seeking a job? In % of all. *
60
Young
50
Old
40
30
20
10
0
Not, Work knowledge and
YES
Not, Formal education
Not, Personal connections
experience obtained by on‐
Not, Health
Not, Recommendations
Not, Knowledge and
the‐job training
experience
* The respondents could choose Yes. If they chose ‘not’, they could circle multiple ‘Not’ answers and point to
those that are more important than age according to their belief.
The respondents were also asked which of the listed events did, according to their belief, happen to them
due to their age. Although the answers among the two age groups of respondents do not differ significantly,
the results again indicate that age is a problem when seeking work. 51 % of older respondents (43 people)
chose the answer ‘the problem of getting a job’, which was also chosen by 26 % of younger respondents (76
people). The older population also mentions getting a worse contract, which was chosen by 28.4 % of
respondents (Figure 3).
195
Figure 3. Which of the following events did you, according to your belief, experience because of your age?
Multiple answers were possible.
None
Comparatively worse job contact
(wage, promotion, education..)
Less chances of being promoted
Temporarily laid off
Hard to get a new job
Harrassement
Getting fired
Old
Young
0,0 20,0 40,0 60,0
Usually, the older unemployed are the more problematic age group among the unemployed; the likelihood of
becoming long-term unemployed is higher. Therefore it is even more important that the older group does not
feel discriminated or that the feeling that age might be of importance does not change their motivation to seek
work. Also, they might be more inclined towards trying to retire early, which is in the light of demographic
change again an unfavourable consequence.
The consequences of perceived discrimination are just as important as the consequences of actual
discrimination in terms of economic and social (individual) consequences. The analysis showed that the
perception that age is important led to the most undesirable outcome – the individuals did not apply for a job,
because they felt that they would not be chosen. 34.5 % of the older respondents claimed to have done so in
comparison with 21.9 % of the younger.
An additional problem of feeling discriminated and having low chances for employment can lead also to
other important consequences which further deteriorate personal self-perception and motivation to seek
work. Therefore, it was also very important to examine the impact that the feeling of being discriminated had
on the individuals (Figure 4). 32.5 % of younger respondents and 45.2 % of older (again, multiple answers
were possible) chose the answer that this led to lower self-esteem. 31.1 % of younger and 46.4 % of older
felt that they lost the hope for getting a job in the future. Similarly, a fear of when they would find work
appeared in 34.2 % of younger respondents and 33.3 % of older. 24.0 % of younger respondents and 33.3 %
of older also lost confidence in their skills, knowledge and abilities.
196
Figure 4. Answers to the question ‘What impact did the discrimination have on you?’ Multiple answers were
possible.
Had no impact on me
Attempted to prove my abilities on the
job Old
Increased motivation for education and Young
training
Fear of how you will be able to provide
for your family
Fear of when you will get next job
Loss of hope for getting a job
Loss of social contacts
Depression
Doubt in own abilities
Loss of self‐esteem
0 10 20 30 40 50
Overall, the results indicate that age is perceived to be a problem among the older population of unemployed.
Indeed, the analysis was limited by the sample, both its size and structure, heavily skewed in size towards
the younger. Nonetheless, the majority of results would most likely be confirmed also in a larger sample. This
remains one of the key challenges in future work.
5. Future research challenges and conclusion
Age discrimination refers to less favourable treatment of those of certain age, usually young and old age
discrimination appears. It affects decisions whether to employ, promote, provide extra training or education,
sack etc.
The article focused on old age discrimination. Given the forthcoming dramatic demographic shift the
problem of age discrimination should be considered very seriously since it affects the ability and the desire or
motivation of older to work. In order to formulate suitable policy measures to stimulate the employment of
older, it is very important to examine and understand the motivation of all parties in the labour market. The
article contributes to the problem by providing an insight into the logic of individual labour supply, the
motivation and drive to seek work at an older age. The existence of both actual as well as potential
(perceived) discrimination is very important in this context.
The purpose of the article was to analyze the situation among the unemployed in Slovenia. Primarily, we
wanted to understand their comparative position as perceived by themselves. The results show that 52 % of
older unemployed workers believe that they have been victims of age discrimination, and there is additional
strong indication that they do believe that age is a disadvantage when seeking work. The older namely
statistically significantly more often than the rest feel that age is the most important factor when seeking work,
more important than education or experience. Also, they believe that it was harder due to age to get a job,
197
also a less favourable job contract and getting fired due to age are much more common beliefs among the
older.
Unfortunately, the perceived worse position of the older in the labour market in the end as results show
lead to the most undesirable outcome. Statistically significantly the older are less motivated to seek work as a
consequence, even more, 34 % report that they do not apply for a job, because they feel that they would not
be chosen. They feel more pushed away than the younger, they feel that despite their education and
experience, they do not get the appropriate decision-making power and show less desire for additional
training. In perspective of an ageing population such results are highly undesirable and should be tackled by
a set of policy measure to keep older workers motivated and engaged in life-long learning.
The topic is very relevant also for future research. First, an analysis of the employees in a similar manner
would be useful to obtain the comparative position of individuals’ self-perception conditional on employment.
Also, repeating the survey and increasing the sample would provide better and more reliable results and
would also allow an important comparison in time and would also show the impact of the economic crisis. A
similar analysis for the young, often mentioned as those in comparatively worse position in the labour market,
presents an additional challenge. Merging these results with the views of the companies would provide a
valuable input for the policy-makers.
References
Age Counts: Inquiry into issues specific to older workers seeking employment, or establishing a business, following unemployment.
Standing Committee on Employment, Education and Workplace Relations. [Online] Available: http://www.aph .gov. au/house/
committee/edt/owk/report/Chapter4.pdf (September 2011).
Berger, Ellie D. (2006). Aging' identities: Degradation and negotiation in the search for employment. Journal of Aging Studies, 20(4),
303-316.
Buesch, V, Sven-Age D, & D.A.V. Dittrich. (2004). Age discrimination in hiring decisions – A comparison of Germany and Norway.
[Online] Available: ftp://papers.econ.mpg.de/esi/discussionpapers/2004-14.pdf (November 20, 2009).
Discrimination in the EU 2009. 2009. Special Eurobarometer No. 317. European Commission: Eurobarometer. [Online] Available:
http://ec.europa.eu/public_opinion/archives/ebs/ebs_317_sum_en.pdf (accessed January 10, 2010).
Discrimination in the EU. Summary. (2007). European commission: Eurobarometer. [Online] Available: http://ec.europa.eu/public
_opinion/archives/ebs/ebs_263_sum_en.pdf (July 2011)
Domadenik, P.,Ograjenšek, I. & Redek, T. (2008). Ageing in Slovenia and the European Union : the macroeconomic and the
microeconomic perspective. Ljubljana: Ekonomska fakulteta.
Ellis, E. (2005). EU Antidiscrimination Law, Oxford: Oxford University Press. [Online] Available: http://fds.oup.com/www.oup.co.uk/pdf/0-
19-926683-2.pdf (August 2011).
Employment service of Slovenia. (2011). [Online] Available: http://www.ess.gov.si/trg_dela/trg_dela_v_ stevilkah/registrirana _ brezpo
selnost (August 2011).
Employment service of Slovenia, 2010-2012. Data prepared on request by the Employment service of Slovenia
Equality and human rights commission. (2010). Codes of practice. [Online] Available: http://www.equalityhumanrights.com/advice-and-
guidance/information-for-advisers/codes-of-practice/ (August 2011).
Eurostat. (2011). Eurostat on-line database. [Online] Available: http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/portal/page/portal/eurostat/home
(through 2011).
Grossman, R. J. (2005). The under-reported impact of age discrimination and its threat to business vitality. Business Horizons, 48(1), 71-
78.
Hutchens, R. M. (1988). Do job opportunities decline with age? Industrial and labour relations review, 42(1), 89-99.
International Longevity Centre. (2009). [Online] Available: http://www.ilcusa.org/pages/projects/ageism.php (December 12, 2009).
Johnson, R.W. (2009). Rising Senior Unemployment and the Need to Work at Older Ages. Washington: The Urban Institute. [Online]
Available: http://www.urban.org/uploadedpdf/411964_senior_unemployment.pdf (September 2011).
Johnson, R.W. & Park, J.S. (2011). Can unemployed older workers find work? Washington: The Urban Institute. [Online] Available:
http://www.urban.org/UploadedPDF/412283-Unemployed-Older-Workers.pdf (September 2011).
Kooij, D., de Lange, A., Jansen, P. & Dikkers, J. (2008). Older workers` motivation to continue to work: five meanings of age. Journal of
Managerial Psychology, 23(4), 364-394.
Macnicol J. (2006). Age discrimination: an historical and contemporary analysis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
OECD. (2006). Older workers. Living longer, working longer. DELSA Newsletter Issue 2. [Online] Available: http://www.oecd.org/
dataoecd/54/47/35961390.pdf (December 8, 2009).
198
Perlitz, M., Schulze, L. & Wilke, C.B. (2010). The demographic and economic transition in Central and Eastern Europe – Management
implications. Journal for East European Management Studies, 15(2), 149-176.
Prskawetz, A., Bloom D. & Lutz, W. (2008). Population Aging, Human Capital Accumulation, and Productivity Growth, A supplement to
Population and Development Review Vol. 33, New York: Population Council.
Promoting active ageing – capitalising on older people’s working potential. (2010). Council of Europe. [Online] Available:
http://assembly.coe.int/Main.asp?link=/Documents/WorkingDocs/Doc10/EDOC12431.htm (July 2011)
Report requested by Stockholm European Council: "Increasing labour force participation and promoting active ageing". (2002).
European Commission, Brussels. [Online] Available: http://ec.europa.eu/employment_social/news/2002/feb/com_2002_9_en.pdf
(December 8, 2009).
Roscigno, V. J., Mong, S., Byron, R. & Tester, G. (2007). Age discrimination, Social Closure and Employment. Social Forces, 86(1), 313-
334.
Sargeant, M. (2006). Mandatory retirement age and age discrimination. Employee Relations, 26(2), 151-166.
Schwarz-Woelzl. M., Oblak, M. & Healy, M. (2008). Become an employer of choice. Take age out of recruitment decisions. Research
part of the EU-project mature@eu - Supporting Employers Recruit-ing and Selecting Mature Aged Persons, funded by the
Leonardo da Vinci Program. [Online] Available: www.zsi.at/attach/matureateu_brochure.pdf (December 3, 2009).
Woolf, L. M. (1998). Ageism. Webester University. (Online) Available http://www.webster.edu/~woolflm/ageism.html (accessed
November 17, 2009).
199

Traffic Congestion at Road Intersections in Ilorin, Nigeria
Dr. Adekunle J. Aderamo

Tolu I. Atomode
Department of Geography,
University of Ilorin., PMB 1515, Ilorin, Nigeria
Doi:10.5901mjss.2012.v3n2.201
Abstract: The paper examined traffic congestion problems and their causes at selected road intersections in Ilorin, Nigeria. The
characteristics of the intersections that predispose them to congestion problems and the spatial pattern of traffic congestion at
the road intersections were also identified. In addition, traffic volume and delays were estimated and causes of delays identified.
Data were collected through direct field survey on intersection characteristics, traffic volume and composition, traffic delay and
causes and land use activities. Data were also collected from past research reports, journals, textbooks, maps and the Internet.
The analysis of data collected revealed that spatio-temporal variations exist in traffic flows and delays at the studied
intersections. Also, traffic wardens and parking problems were found to be the greatest causes of delays at the road
intersections in the city. The study therefore recommends that the road intersections be signalized and vehicle parking be strictly
prohibited at road intersections to reduce traffic congestion and delays at road intersections in the city.
Keywords: traffic congestion, road intersection, traffic volume, traffic delay, land use
1 Introduction
Cities and their transport systems are fully complementary. As defined by Rodrigue et al (2006), cities are
locations with a high level of accumulation and concentration of economic activities, which form complex
spatial structures that are supported by transport systems. The transportation systems according to Berry
and Hurton (1970) are the veins and arteries of urban areas linking together social and functional zones.
Urban productivity is highly dependent on the efficiency of its transport systems to move people and goods
between multiple origins and destinations. Thus, the most important transport problems are often related to
urban areas when transport systems, for a variety of reasons, cannot satisfy the numerous requirements of
urban mobility (Rodrigue et al, 2006).
One of the most significant urban transport problems is traffic congestion. It is experienced when the
supply of the urban transport networks can no longer meet the demand for them. Today nearly all cities in
both developed and developing countries suffer from traffic congestion. It manifests itself predominantly in
recurrent queues, delays and time wastage which commuters experience along major networks especially
during rush hours. Due to incessant increase in population, increase in household incomes and its resultant
increase in the level of car usage coupled with poor land-use planning, poor transport design and planning,
traffic congestion has become an intractable problem in urban centres in Nigeria.
Traffic congestion is a major curse on urban movements. It is a plague that has become an integral part of
normal life in almost all urban areas in the world. More seriously, traffic congestion causes unpredictability in
journey times, thereby making urban commuters to plan for these problems by leaving home early just to
avoid being late.
The problem of traffic congestion in urban areas is worse at road intersections. Indeed, there is no other
point on cities roads that can be greatly congested as road intersections. As defined by O’Flaberty (1997),
intersections (where two or more roads meet), are points of vehicle conflict. Similarly, Mchsare et al (1998)
201
noted that at no other location within the street and highway systems are so many potential and actual
conflicts than at road intersections. This is because at intersections, vehicular flows from several different
approaches making either left-turn, through and right-turn movements seek to occupy the same physical
space at the same time. In addition to these vehicular flows, pedestrians also seek to use this space to cross
the street and thereby worsening the already bad traffic situation.
Urban traffic problems are further exacerbated by the concentration of most of the working places in the
same areas (usually in the city centres), so that traffic is essentially unidirectional during the morning and
evening peak periods (see Okpala, 1980; Onakomaiya and Ekanem, 1981). It is this latter problem which
results in spatial variation of congestion in urban areas that this study examines. The principal objective of
this study is to examine the spatial aspects of traffic congestion at road intersection in Ilorin, as well as
identify the possible causes and proffer solutions.
The issue of traffic congestion in Ilorin like many other state capitals in Nigeria draws significant attention
each day. Intra-urban movements to work, recreational centres, markets, shops and schools are becoming
more and more difficult and are characterized by discomfort, delays, waste of time, energy and resources.
The problem is more pronounced during the peak periods of morning and evening when vehicles stand still in
long queues resulting in stress and reduction in the productive hours of commuters. Although the situation in
Ilorin has not grown out of control, signs of potential bottlenecks are already emerging along some routes.
2. Traffic Flow Theories and Congestion Problems
Traffic congestion emanates from the problems encountered with traffic flow. Traffic flow is the movement of
individual drivers and vehicles between two points and the interactions they make with one another.
Unfortunately, studying traffic flow is difficult because driver behaviour is something that cannot be predicted
with one-hundred percent certainty. Fortunately, drivers tend to behave within a reasonably consistent range
and thus, traffic streams tend to have some reasonable consistency and can be roughly represented
mathematically. The three main characteristics among which relationships can be established mathematically
in traffic flow are: flow, density and velocity. These relationships help in planning, design and operation of
roadway facilities.
The speed is the space mean speed; the density or concentration is the number of vehicles per unit length
of the highway and the flow is the number of vehicles passing a given point on the highway per unit time.
The relationship between these parameters of the flow may be derived as follows: consider a short cross
section of highway length L in which N vehicles pass a point in this section during a time interval T, all
vehicles travelling in the same direction. (Salter, 1974).
The volume of flow Q = N/T
The density D = average no. of vehicles travelling over L/L
The average number of vehicles travelling over L is given by;

N
 t
=1
T
where t is the time of travel of the th vehicle over the length L; then
N N L
D =  t = T 1
=1 N N ti
L =1
T
202
Volume
i.e. Density =
Space mean speed
Numerous observations have been carried out to determine the relationship between any two of these
parameters for, with one relationship established the relationship between the three parameters is
determined. Usually the experimenters have been interested in the relationship between speed and volume
because of a desire to estimate the optimum speed for maximum flow (Salter, 1974; Pensaud and Hurdle,
1991; Hall and Banks, 1992; Disbro and Frame, 1992).
Geographical theories have also been used to explain traffic flow. A basic geographical interest in flow is
to provide answer to the question – “why do people and goods move in space?” Ullman (1956) postulated
three conditions for spatial interaction (flow), namely complementarity, intervening opportunity and
transferability.
The first condition, according to Hagget (1972) is a function of areal differentiation of places. In order for
two places to interact, there must be a supply or surplus in one place and a demand or deficit in another
which must be specifically complementary. Complementarity will however generate flows between two places
only if no intervening opportunity occurs. This means the absence of another location in-between the two
places which may provide an alternative source of supply or demand. The third condition in Ullman’s
principle, transferability refers to the possibility of moving a product. It is a function of distance measured in
terms of time and monetary costs (Hagget, 1972).
Before Ullman’s principle, geographers were preoccupied with graphical presentation of statistics of traffic
flow. Ullman’s principle introduced basic conceptual explanation for flow in space and since then, there has
been an increasing awareness of the need for concept and method in flow studies (See Smith, 1970).
However, all the concepts about flow can be summed up in a matrix-defined origin and destination with origin
as rows and destination as columns. According to Smith (1970), there are three characteristics of interest in
the matrix, namely, volume, structure and efficiency of flows.
The volume of flows is concerned with diagnostic statements on the magnitude of flows which can be
expressed as “more than” or “less than”. It involves quantity of people and goods that move along a route.
The structure of flow is concerned with the identification of generic locational characteristics of groups of
origins or groups of destinations, or groups of origins and destinations – dyad (see Lowe and Moryadas,
1975). The third characteristic, efficiency of flows, is concerned with descriptive and normative characteristics
of routing a flow. Transport networks only rarely link a set of nodes by the shortest distance and almost any
movement over a given route involves a certain amount of distance inefficiency. The efficiency concept,
therefore, aims at optimizing flows by minimizing distance, or transport costs, subject to certain constraints.
The geographical theory of traffic flow is most suitable for the study because it addresses the issue of
pattern of flow. This theory has been applied by various scholars in urban transportation studies relating to
movement of goods and of people. For instance, Goddard (1970) discerned the pattern of flows in central
London and concluded that the Central Area contained a number of specialized sub-centres in which closely
related activities aggregate and these districts are maintained by a clear pattern of internal circulation.
Also, Ogunsanya (1982) in his study on the Spatial pattern of urban freight transport in Lagos identified
four patterns of flow. These are the metro-originating, metro-terminating, intra-metropolitan and through
traffic. All these affect the general pattern of traffic flow in the city. Adenle (1977), writing on factors militating
against the flow of traffic in metropolitan Lagos identified amongst others that the chief factors affecting the
flow of traffic in metropolitan Lagos is the interface with or imbalance in the composition of the variables flow,
density and space mean-speed.
Okoko (2008) studied the pattern of urban goods movement in various landuse typologies in Akure,
Nigeria. The study identified through gravity modeling and linear programming, the urban landuse typologies
that are major generators of urban goods transport and the landuses that are major attractors of urban goods
movement in the city. Other studies include Aderamo (2000) who identified the spatial pattern of intra-urban
trips in Ilorin using Factor Analysis and Nystuen and Dacey’s (1961) concept of flow structuring in urban
203
centres. He found that the zonal pattern of intra-urban trips in cities is hierarchical in order because of the
functional association between these zones (see also Ogunbodede, 1999; Galtima, 1999).
3. Materials and Methods
The data required for this study include information on intersection characteristics and road network; traffic
volumes and characteristics. These were collected through primary and secondary sources. The primary
sources which represent first hand information were collected through direct field observation and field data
collection while the secondary data were collected from journals, textbooks, the internets and past research
reports. The road network map of Ilorin with grid reference at one degree interval was used for identification
of the studied intersections. As it is not possible to study all the intersections in the city, a sampling technique
was employed and a ten per cent sample of the intersections in each four combined grid squares at 2
degrees intervals was selected at random (see also Aderamo, 1998). Some major intersections which were
hitherto ignored by sampling were also included. Through this process, the following intersections were
selected: (1) Saw-mill/Air Port; (2) Surulere/Agbo-oba; (3) Oloje/Mt. Carmel College; (4) Taiwo/Ita-Amodu;
(5) Murtala/Amilegbe; (6) Tanke/Tipper Garage; (7) Gaa-Akanbi/Offa Garage (see figure 1).
A reconnaissance survey of the study area was first carried out at the selected intersections to identify the
characteristics that predispose them to heavy traffic. This was followed by traffic census conducted manually
using simple hand-tally method to estimate the volume and composition of traffic at the intersections. A
continuous count of all vehicles by class/category that passed through the intersections was done by field
assistants. The field assistants were instructed to concentrate on a single lane each, and count the vehicles
as they depart the intersections. This is because turning movements cannot be fully resolved until vehicles
depart the intersections. The number of field assistants at any intersection was determined by the number of
legs or approaches to the intersection.
3
°1
'
0
1
"
4
°2
'
0
2
"
5
°3
'
0
3
"
6
°4
'
0
4
"
Ka
Sobi Rd
im
aR
d
Rd
ed
r
Rail line
ve
Ri
am
a
uh
As
M
3
Ok
la
#
ita
"
e le
ur
3
0
'
M
8
le
°3 Al
°3
8
.
'
d
im
S t.
St r
0
in R
iR Am N
3
na n
"
Rd u
A la lo gu
d i le g
re
B as
A lo
Pakata Rd be Fa te
Ba
Em St . Rd
ir's Fate Rd
Rd
Rd
5 W E
Ata
#
Pipeline Rd
Ag b Offa R d
ez
o oba Unive rsity R d 6

e
Rd iw o Rd Amo du Bello #
Az
2
# Ib ra h im
Ta # Avenue
S
du
Un ity Rd
4
Ab
"
2 Rd
0
' S ta dium Agba-Da m
7
°2 Admiralty Rd
°2
Rd
7
'
Olo
0
2
r
in Rd
un LEGEND
ro
"
so
Sa
#
go
Rd 7 Gaakanbi Rd
a ru
O ko-Er
# River
Um
1
Asa River
d
Y id
iR Rail line
Rd
As w
Ne
o
a -D Road
os
am
om
Rd
Of
Round-About
gb
fa
O
"
ga
1
0 Dam
rr a
'
6
°1
°1
ge
6
#
'
Studied junction
0
Asa-Dam
1
Rd
"
3
°1
'
0
1
"
4
°2
'
0
2
"
5
°3
'
0
3
"
6
°4
'
0
4
"
100 0 100 200 Kilometers THE STUDIED

INTERSECTIONS
1. Saw-Mill/Airport
Road junction
Figure 1 : Road Network Map of Ilorin showing the Studied Road 2. Surulere/Agbooba
Intersections Rd. junction
Source: Kwara State Ministry of Lands and Housing, 2007. 3. Oloje/Mt. Carmel
204
The study was limited to off-peak periods because the peak hour traffic study is particularly useful in that it
provides most important information concerning maximum traffic loads imposed upon the road network (and
their intersections) and as such relates to the capacity analysis and the design of future facilities (Salter,
1974; Ogunsanya, 1984). Therefore, the peak hour periods of morning and evening peaks of 7.00a.m to
9.00a.m and 3.00p.m to 6.00p.m respectively were used. The data were collected for three consecutive days
(i.e. Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday) of which the average was then used.
4.1 Characteristics of the Studied Intersections
The studied intersections are comprised of 4-legged and 3-legged road junctions selected from different
locations on major roads in Ilorin. The intersections serve as links to major routes which connect different
types of land use activities in the study area. All the studied intersections are unsignalized but traffic flows are
controlled by traffic wardens. Also common to all the intersections is the presence of road-side hawkers and
traders, and the location of retailing shops along the intersecting roads. These result in road-side obstructions
and parking problems from customers who patronize the sold products and thereby impeding the free
movements of vehicles. Associated with these problems are the problems of narrowness and poor or no
channelization of the intersecting roads to separate the traffic streams. Table 1.0 shows the characteristics of
the studied intersections.
Table 1. Intersection Characteristics and Associated Land-use
S/N Intersection Name Intersection Types Land-use Characteristics

1. Sawmill/Airport 3-legged Institutional, Sawmill industry, commercial motor parks,
retailing shops.
2. Surulere/Agbooba 4-legged Markets, Commercial centres, Institutional, Residential estate,
retailing shops.
3. Oloje/Mount Carmel 3-legged Market, commercial centres, motor park, Institutional,
College Residential estate, retailing shops.
4. Taiwo/Ita Amodu 4-legged Commercial centres, retailing shops, Institutional.
5. Murtala/Amilegbe 4-legged Motor park, Institutional, Offices, Market, Commercial centres,
retailing shops, Government Residential Area.
6. Tanke/Tipper Garage 4-legged Retailing shops, Institutional, Commercial motor parks,
Government Residential Area.
7. Gaa-Akanbi/Offa 3-legged Institutional, Retailing shops, Private and public commercial
Garage motor parks, Industrial.
Source: The Authors
Table 1 shows that 3 of the intersections constituting 42.9% are 3-legged. These are Sawmill/Airport;
Oloje/Mt. Carmel and Gaa Akanbi/Offa Garage. The 4-legged intersections which constitute 57.1% are
Surulere/Agbooba, Taiwo/Ita Amodu, Murtala/Amilegbe and Tanke/Tipper Garage.
In terms of land use characteristics of the studied junctions, majority of them are located where
institutional, commercial, markets, retailing shops, motor parks predominate. The intersecting arms also
connect residential estates, public and private institutions and other major activity-centres in the city.
4.2 Pattern of Traffic Flow
Table 2. and Figure 2 show the average traffic volumes in vehicles per hour at the studied junctions for both
morning and afternoon peaks.
205
Table 2. Average Volume of Traffic at Selected Junctions in Ilorin
Morning peak Afternoon peak

S/N Intersection VPH % of Total VPH % of Total
1. Sawmill/Airport 4044 12.64 4070 12.59
2. Surulere/Agbooba 4959 15.49 4996 15.46
3. Oloje/Mt. Carmel 3680 11.50 3861 11.95
4. Taiwo/Ita Amodu 5419 16.93 5401 16.71
5. Murtala/Amilegbe 5619 17.56 5567 17.23
6. Tanke/Tipper Garage 4479 13.99 4591 14.21
7. Gaa-Akanbi/Offa Garage 3807 11.89 3829 11.85
Total 32,007 100.00 32,315 100.00
Source: The Authors, 2008
Table 2. shows that for both morning and afternoon peaks, Murtala Mohammed/Amilegbe junction recorded
the highest volume of traffic among the studied roads. These are 5619 vph (17.56%) and 5567 vph (17.23%)
of total volume for morning and afternoon peaks respectively. This is followed by Taiwo/Ita Amodu junction
with 5419 vph (16.93%) and 5401 vph (16.71%) for morning and afternoon peaks respectively.
Surulere/Agbo-Oba junction ranks third recording 4959 vph (15.49%) and 4996 vph (15.46%) morning and
afternoon peaks respectively while Tanke /Tipper Garage junction ranks fourth recording 4,479 vph (13.99%)
morning peak and 4591 vph (14.21%) afternoon peak.
Fig. 2.0 Average Peak-hour Volume at the Studied Intersections
6000
5000
4000 Key
Volume of Traffice (vph)
Morning Peak
3000
Afternoon Peak
2000
1000
0
Sawmill/Airport Surulere/Agbooba Oloje/Mt. Carmel Taiwo/Ita Amodu Murtala/Amilegbe Tanke/Tipper Gaa-Akanbi/Offa
Garage Garage
Intersections
Sawmill/Airport junction ranks fifth recording 4,044 vph (12.64%) morning peak and 4,070 vph (12.59%)
afternoon peak. Gaa-Akanbi/Offa Garage junction ranks sixth with 3,809 vph (11.89%) morning peak and
3829 vph (11.85%) afternoon peak while Oloje/Mt. Carmel junction ranks seventh with 3,680 vph (11.50%)
morning peak and 3,861 vph (11.95%) afternoon peak respectively.
The average volume of flow at Murtala Mohammed/Amilegbe junction exemplifies the importance of the
roads converging at this junction and the land use activities they serve. Murtala Mohammed Road services
206
Post Office and the commercial activities along it. The northern arm of the road services Maraba Motor Park,
Kwara State Polytechnic main campus, Ilorin Government Secondary School and Federal Secretariat while
Amilegbe road services Ipata Market, University of Ilorin Teaching Hospital Maternity Centre and many
retailing shops. These activities account for the high volume of traffic at the junction.
Taiwo/Ita Amodu junction is another road experiencing high volume of traffic. Taiwo road is one of the
busiest commercial belts in Ilorin with supermarkets, eateries, retailing shops along it. Ita Amodu road also
services many commercial activities along it and links with Oja Oba market in the heart of the city. Adamu
road directly opposite Ita Amodu road also contributes to the traffic volume at this junction resulting from
commercial and institutional land use along it.
The volume of flow at Surulere/Agbo Oba junction also explains the importance of the roads converging at
the junction. These are Abdulaziz Attah road which carries a lot of traffic from Oja-Oba, Baboko Market and
the University of Ilorin Teaching Hospital, Agbo Oba road services the heavily populated residential area of
Agbo-Oba and Adewole Housing Estate while Surulere road links the junction with Taiwo road with retailing
shops along it.
Tanke/Tipper Garage junction is an emerging commercial centre with University of Ilorin permanent site
road, Pipeline road and Tipper garage road radiating from it. The University of Ilorin road services University
of Ilorin permanent site and an array of secondary and primary schools, residential and commercial uses
along it. Pipeline road services a new Government Reservation Area and links with Ajasse-Ipo road to the
South which also harbours residential and commercial land uses. Tipper garage road services predominantly
residential areas to the north of the junction.
Sawmill/Airport junction services commercial, institutional and residential land uses. Sawmill garage road
links with an important motor garage in the city. This garage caters for vehicles carrying passengers to
Lagos, Ibadan, Abeokuta, and Ogbomoso. The road also accommodates commercial activities along it.
Airport road is an extension of AbdulAziz Attah road and services the Ilorin international Airport with a lot of
commercial activities along it.
Gaa-Akanbi/Offa garage junction is a convergence of predominantly residential and commercial land
uses. Gaa-Akanbi road services Gaa-Akanbi residential quarters with some commercial activities along it
while Offa road links with Offa garage to the South-east and some residential, commercial and institutional
land uses along it.
Oloje/Mt. Carmel junction is to the western end of the city and services residential and institutional land
uses. These include Oloje residential quarters, Ogidi village, Mt. Carmel College, Federal Government
College and Oko Olowo quarters.
The distribution of traffic volume at the sampled junctions depicts the nature of the predominant land use
activities the roads converging at the junction serve and their classification within the general road network
pattern of the city. Three out of the four arms of Murtala Mohammed/Amilegbe junction are dual carriage
ways while two out of the four arms of Taiwo/Ita Amodu junction are dual carriage way. Surulere/Agbo-Oba
junction also has two out of its four arms as dual carriage ways while Tanke/Tipper garage junction has three
out of its four arms as dual carriage ways. The Sawmill/Airport junction has two out of its three arms as dual
carriage ways while Mt. Carmel/Oloje junction and Gaa-Akanbi/Offa garage junction each has two of its three
arms as dual carriage ways. Consequently, they all carry significant volume of traffic within the city’s road
network pattern.
4.3 Pattern of Traffic Delays
Table 3. and Figure 3. show the average delay times in minutes at the studied intersections for both morning
and afternoon peaks.
207
Table 3. Average Traffic Delay Time at Selected Junctions in Ilorin
Delay Time (Minutes)

S/N Intersection Morning peak Afternoon peak
Minutes % of Total Minutes % of Total
1. Sawmill/Airport 79 12.10` 72 11.69
2. Surulere/Agbooba 106 16.23 96 15.58
3. Oloje/Mt. Carmel 59 9.04 62 10.06
4. Taiwo/Ita Amodu 115 17.61 105 17.06
5. Murtala/Amilegbe 123 18.84 116 18.83
6. Tanke/Tipper Garage 84 12.86 91 14.77
7. Gaa-Akanbi/Offa Garage 87 13.32 74 12.01
Total 653 100.00 616 100.00
Table 3 shows that in terms of distribution of peak-hour delay time during morning peak, Murtala Mohammed
junction ranked first (18.84%) followed by Taiwo/Ita Amodu junction (17.61%) while Surulere/Agbo-Oba
junction ranked third (16.23%). Gaa-Akanbi/Offa garage junction ranks fourth (13.32%) while Tanke/Tipper
garage ranks fifth (12.86%). The sixth and seventh junctions in rank are Sawmill/Airport (12.15%) and
Oloje/Mt. Carmel junction (9.04%) respectively.
During afternoon peak, delay time recorded at the junctions rank Murtala Mohammed/Amilegebe junction
(18.83%) first followed by Taiwo/Ita Amodu junction (17.06%). Surulere/Agbo-Oba junction ranks third
(15.58%) while Tanke/Tipper garage ranks fourth (14.77%). The fifth junction in rank is Gaa-Akanbi/Offa
garage (12.01%) with Sawmill/Airport junction coming sixth (11.69%) while Oloje/Mt. Carmel junction attained
the seventh position (10.06%).
Overall, the delay times are associated with the traffic volumes at the various junctions which ultimately
translate to traffic congestion.
Fig. 3. 0 Av er ag e De lay Tim e at the Inte rs ec tion s
1 30
1 20
1 10
1 00
90 Key
80
De lay Tim e (M in ut es)
70 M or nin g Peak
After no on Pea k

60
50
40
30
20
10
0
S awmill/A irport Surulere/A gbooba Oloje/Mt. C armel Taiw o/Ita Amodu Murtala/A milegbe Tank e/Tipper G arage G aa-Akanbi/O ffa G arage
Ju nctio ns
208
4.4 Pattern of Traffic Composition
Table 4. and Figure 4 show the average peak-hour traffic composition at the sampled intersections. The table
shows that of all the vehicle types recorded at the sampled junctions, motorcycles had the highest numbers
of an average of 1372 vehicles (29.87%) which is followed by taxis with an average of 1370 vehicles
(29.83%). Private cars ranked third with 1143 vehicles (24.89%) while buses came fourth with 386 vehicles
(8.40%). Other types of vehicles recorded at the sampled functions are delivery vans, 219 (4.77%)
trucks/tractors/lorries/tankers/tippers 99 (21.6%) and other vehicles 4 (0.1%). The dominance of
motorcycles among the types of vehicles recorded shows the emerging trend in the use of motorcycles for
public transportation in the city. This mode is now becoming popular and it has helped a lot in reducing the
transportation problem in the city. Taxis are a regular mode to use in meeting the needs of the inhabitants in
terms of public transportation while there is now more private cars on the city’s roads due to improved
income and better purchasing power of workers.
Table 4. Traffic Composition at the Studied Junctions
Traffic Composition
S/N Intersection A B C D E F G
1 Sawmill / Airport 1196 994 1187 319 199 102 4

2 Surulere/Agbooba 1492 1253 1463 400 262 108 5
3 Oloje/Mt. Carmel 1176 1007 1159 206 155 81 4
4 Taiwo/Ita Amodu 1629 1299 1644 463 260 113 4
5 Murtala/Amilegbe 1637 1340 1683 553 288 83 4
6 Tanke/Tipper Garage 1336 1202 1336 378 181 106 5
7 Gaa-Akanbi/Offa 1136 906 1118 380 187 97 3
Garage
Total 9602 8001 9590 2699 1532 690 29
Average 1372 1143 1370 386 219 99 4

A = Motorcycle C = Taxis E = Delivery vans
B = Private cars D = Buses F = Trucks/Trailers/Lorries/Tankers/Tipper
G = Others
209
F ig . 4 T r a f f ic C o m p o s it io n a t t h e J u n c t io n s
1500
1400
1300
1200
1100
1000
900
800
700
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
A B C D E F G
V e h ic le T y p e s

A = Motorcycle C = Taxis E = Delivery vans
B = Private cars D = Buses F = Trucks/Trailers/Lorries/Tankers/Tipper
G = Others
Buses provide services for the transportation of goods and people while delivery vans are used mainly for
transporting goods in the city. Trucks, trailers, lorries, tankers and tippers are heavy-goods vehicles and they
provide intra-city and inter-city services for the transportation of goods, materials for housing construction and
petroleum products.
4.5 Time taken by Delay Causes
Table 5. and figure 5 show the pattern of time taken by delay causes in average daily peak-hour traffic delay.
The table shows that of all the delay causes, traffic control by wardens ranks first, an average 42 minutes and
constituting 46.7% of the total delay time. This is followed by parking problems with an average of 21 minutes
and constituting 23.3% of total delay time. The parking problems experienced include on-sheet parking,
double parking, parking to load and unload which reduce the road space thereby impeding the free
movement of vehicles.
Table 5. Delay Causes at Studied Intersections
S/N Intersection Delay Causes (minutes)

A B C D E F G
1 Sawmill / Airport 37 4 19 1 5 4 4
2 Surulere/Agbooba 45 7 22 2 4 9 9
3 Oloje/Mt. Carmel 29 2 15 2 1 2 8
4 Taiwo/Ita Amodu 47 6 27 5 6 8 9
5 Murtala/Amilegbe 55 8 28 3 3 9 11
6 Tanke/Tipper Garage 40 3 20 2 5 5 11
7 Gaa-Akanbi/Offa 42 4 16 1 1 6 7
Garage
210
Total 295 34 147 16 25 43 59

Average 42 5 21 2 4 6 8
Percentage 46.7 5.6 23.3 2.2 4.4 6.7 8.9
A= Traffic Controller/Wardens E= Road-side hawking & Retailing

B= Accident F= Vehicle Breakdown
C= parking problems G= Vehicle turning & Manouvering Problems
D= Pedestrian Crossing H= Others
Turning and maneuvering problems take an average of 8 minutes and constitute 8.9%. This can be attributed
to the narrowness and the non-channelization of most of the intersecting roads. Vehicle breakdown and
accidents take an average of 6 minutes and 5 minutes and accounting for 6.7% and 5.6% respectively of total
delay time. Also road-side hawking and retailing account for an average of 4 minutes delay time constituting
4.4% of total delay time while pedestrian crossing accounts for only 2 minutes delay time and 2.2% of total
delay time. Other causes of delay identified include conflicts, construction works and rainfall which also
account for an average of 2 minutes constituting 2.2% of total delay time.
Fig. 5: Pattern of Delay Causes at the Intersections
9%
Key
7%
4%
A
2% B
48%
C
D
24% E
F
6% G

A= Traffic Controller/Wardens E = Road-side hawking & Retailing
B= Accident F = Vehicle Breakdown
C= parking problems G = Vehicle turning & Manouvering Problems
D= Pedestrian Crossing H = Others
5. Implication for Urban Transportation Planning
Traffic congestion problems are manifesting in many of the major urban centres in Nigeria. They are indeed
becoming a menace to free flow of traffic in these cities. These problems are caused by ineffective use of
211
road space and growth in the number of vehicles on our roads associated also with urban population growth.
The study of congestion problems at sampled intersections in Ilorin revealed that there are significant spatio-
temporal variations in traffic flows and delay times at the studied intersections during morning and afternoon
peak periods. These variations can be attributed to the differences in land use characteristics at the
intersections and the areas served by the roads.
The analysis of the causes of delays in Ilorin showed that delays at road intersections are mainly caused
by traffic wardens and parking problems. The problem of traffic wardens can be attributed to the absence of
modern traffic management techniques at the road intersections. Since human labour for traffic control is
susceptible to failure due to fatigue and exhaustion, the traffic wardens are therefore not efficient or present
to control the traffic when they are exhausted or during bad weather (like rainfall and in some cases,
scorching sunshine).
The parking problems found can be attributed to narrowness of the intersecting roads which do not give
room for side-kerb parking. In addition, there is no provision for off-street parking in the city and as such
vehicles have no alternative than to use the roads as parking space. This therefore gives room for
indiscriminate on-street parking and parking to load and unload.
The findings from this study have implication for urban transportation planning. The designs of the road
intersections in the study area should be reviewed such that the approaches are broad for a distance of
about 200 metres to avoid obstruction of side turning vehicles by the straight moving ones. All the
approaches to the intersections should also be chanelized to separate traffic streams. Also, road-side
hawking and trading and all forms of commercial activities should be strictly restricted up to a distance of 200
metres from the intersections. Town planning control mechanism should be used to control developments
around the intersections.
The public transportation system in the city should be improved by introducing high-capacity buses and
tricycles to work alongside with taxis and motorcycles for the conveyance of people in the study area. This
will reduce the number of vehicles on the road. Besides, there is the need to signalize the intersections by
installing traffic lights and signals to serve as substitute for the ineffective human labour of traffic
management.
In addition, there is the need for provision of off-street parking spaces in Ilorin and along the intersecting
roads. Also on-street parking of whatever types should be strictly restricted up to a distance of 200 metres
away from the intersections. This can be done by installing NO PARKING and NO WAITING signs at the
intersections to discourage arbitrary parking.
Many of the problems identified at the studied junctions are common to other road intersections in the city.
The recommendations made are therefore useful for solving traffic congestion problems at road intersections
generally in the city.
6. Conclusion
The study examined traffic congestion problem at road intersections in Ilorin and has offered useful
suggestions for improving traffic flow at the junctions.
Though the traffic flow problem in Ilorin has not yet assumed the dimension of those of Lagos, Ibadan,
Port-Harcourt and other bigger urban centres in Nigeria, signs of potential bottlenecks are already emerging
(Aderamo, 1998). There is therefore the need to evolve more effective traffic management method for the
city. As population increases and people become more affluent, traffic congestion problem becomes worse.
With the high rate of growth of Ilorin, traffic problem should not be left until it deteriorates to the level of larger
urban centres in Nigeria. It is on this note that this study has suggested immediate solutions to traffic
congestion and delay problems at road intersections in Ilorin.
212
References
Adenle JA (1981). Factors militating against free flow of Traffic in Metropolitan Lagos. In Onakomaiya, S.O. and Ekanem, N.F. (Eds).
Transportation in Nigerian National Development, Ibadan: NISER.
Aderamo AJ (1998). Route forms and Traffic Flow in a medium-sized city. The case of Ilorin, Nigeria. Centre Point, 8 (1) 29-43.
Aderamo AJ 2000. Spatial Pattern of Intra-urban Trips in Ilorin, Nigeria, Geo-Studies forum 1 (1 & 2).
Berry BJL, Horton FE (1970). Geographic Perspective on Urban Systems, Englewood Cliffs N.Y: Prentice Hall.
Disbro JE, Frame M (1992). Traffic Flow Theory and Chaotic Behaviour. Transportation Research Record, 1225:109-115.
Galtina M (1999). Disaggregate Trip Pattern in Maiduguri. Unpublished Ph.D. Thesis, Department of Geography, University of Ilorin.
Goddard JB (1970). Functional Regions within the City Centre: A study by Factor Analysis of Taxi Flows in Central London. Institute of
British Geographers, 49:161-182
Hagget P (1972). Geography: A modern synthesis, New York: Harper and Row.
Hall FL, Hurdle VF, Bank JH (1992). A synthesis of Recent work on the Nature of Speed-Flow and Flow-Occupancy (or Density)
Relationships on Freeways, Presented at TRB 71st Annual Meeting. Washington D.C.
Lowe J, Moryadas S (1975). The Geography of Movement, Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
Mchsane WR, Roess PR, Prassas ED (1998). Traffic Engineering, Second Edition New Jersey: Prentice Hall.
Nystuen JD, Dacey MF (1961). A graph theory interpretation of nodal regions. Papers and Proceedings Regional Science, 7:29-42.
O’Flaherty CA (2002). Transport Planning and Traffic Engineering, London: Butterworth Heinemann.
Ogunbodede EF (1999). Changing Pattern of Land Use and Intra-Urban Transport development in Akure, Ondo State, Nigeria.
Unpublished Ph.D. Thesis, Department of Geography, University of Ilorin.
Ogunsanya AA (1982). Spatial pattern of Urban Freight Transport in Lagos Metropolis. Transportation Research, 16A (4).
Ogunsanya AA (1984). Traffic Congestion in an Urban Centre: The Case of Ilorin, Nigeria. The Nigerian Geographical Journal, 27: ( 1-2).
Okoko E (2008). The Spatial Pattern of Urban Goods Movement in Akure, Nigeria. Pakistan Journal of Social Sciences, 5 (3): 226-234.
Okpala DCI. (1981). Urban Traffic Management in Nigerian Cities. The Necessity for Mass-Transit Priorities. In Onakomaiya SO,
Ekanem NF (eds.). Transportation in Nigerian National Development, Ibadan: NISER.
Onakomaiya SO, Ekanem NF (1981). Nigerian Transportation: An Overview. In Onakomaiya SO, Ekanem NF (eds.) Transportation in
Nigerian National Development, Ibadan: NISER.
Pensand BN, Hurdle VF (1991). Some New Data that challenge some old ideas about Speed-Flow Relationships. Transportation
Research Record, 1194:191-198.
Rodrigue JP, Comtois C, Slack B (2006). The Geography of Transport Systems, London: Routledge.
Salter RJ 1974. Highway Traffic Analysis and Design, London: Macmillan.
Smith RHT (1970). Concepts and Methods in Commodity Flow Analysis. Economic Geography. 46:404-416.
Ullman EL (1956). The Role of Transportation and the Basis for Spatial Interaction. In Thomas WL (ed.). Man’s Role in Changing the
Face of the Earth, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
213

A Proposal for Open Standard Based Legal Document Management System

for the Parliament of Bangladesh
Mohammad Hasan Murad
Assistant Professor, Department of Law

International Islamic University Chittagong, Bangladesh
Mohammad Saidul Islam

Lecturer, Department of Law
International Islamic University Chittagong, Bangladesh
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.215
Abstract Purpose : A fast and progressive legislative system is necessary for Bangladesh in order to address pressing issue
where regulatory solutions are required. In order to achieve efficiency and functionality of the working of the legislative body,
information systems should be introduced for reliable creation, storage, retrieval and dissemination of legislative documents such
as bills, discussions, committee reports ,arguments ,minutes of parliament and laws. In this paper We have explored the
methods and challenges of developing a legislative Document Management System (DMS) for the Bangladesh Parliament.
Approach – This research outlines the need for a Document Management System for the Bangladesh Parliament and proposes
strategies that can be followed in building process of such system especially in connection with the structuring of documents and
following open standard. Findings – It can be concluded that A Document Management System based on XML standard will be
ideal for the Bangladesh Parliament despite challenges and obstacles. Limitation: This paper does not cover the technical side
of the DMS. It is out of the scope of the paper to discuss all components of a Legislative Information System. Further research
may be conducted on developing specific models of the Information System for the Parliament. Value – This paper has the
potentials to inspire the e-government proponents of the developing countries to promote ICT in the Legislative Houses and will
act as a primary guideline for the policy makers.
Keywords : Parliament , Parliamentary DMS , Open Standard , Legal Informatics , Bangladesh
1. Introduction
A Parliament is the center in running democratic affairs of a state. It is in the parliament where a country’s
present policy is scrutinized and future stance is constructed by way of debates, deliberation and legislation.
In almost all democratic states a parliament has played the central role to introduce legislation, taxes and
allow expenditures for the government. It has been argued that the primacy of legislation is going to an
end(Sartor G ,2008) and we are gradually moving from the era of legislation to the age of
administration(Halvey E,1983) (by special technical bodies),or jurisdiction (creation of law by judges ,
supported by jurists) or customs and soft regulations (as emerging especially from economic relation,
contracts and decisions by arbitraries) or even computing code(enabling or constraining actions in virtual
environments)(Lessig L, 2006). However, the emergence of other sources of law does not necessarily render
legislation less important and less central and the parliament and its legislation will continue to be the major
sources of laws and regulation in the foreseeable future especially in developing countries like Bangladesh.
The inherent values that parliamentary legislation should address are as follows(Sartor G ,2008):
a) Legislation should provide regulation that will be capable of giving solution to the problem they
address being supported by best available knowledge.
215
b) Legislation should provide regulation that will be a product of open and rational debate among law
makers and stakeholders. In this process, relevant advantages, disadvantages and alternatives are
considered.
c) Legislation should reflect opinion of the public in general and should be able to adapt to social
changes.
d) Legislation should promote legal certainty by way of providing effective normative guideline to the
people and decision makers and means to check arbitrary exercise of power.
e) Legislation should enable citizens to be aware of their rights so that in the event of default they are
able to claim their rights.
Information and Communication Technology has the ability to contribute to achieve the above mentioned
values in a modern parliament by providing-
a) ICT tools to monitor and evaluate the impact of present or new law on the administration and
society.
b) Communication and Information retrieval tool to promote informed debate on legislative initiatives.
c) New platform for interaction between citizens and their representatives and voicing opinion i.e.
social networking, online feedback, e –petition system.
d) Systems facilitating access to law and other legislative information, making law more
understandable and common citizen friendly.
e) Making more accessible knowledge about rules and remedies, clarifying procedures and
automation of repetitive tasks.
It is out of the scope of the paper to discuss all components of a Legislative Information System. However the
main focus of this article is outlining a system for document management within parliament which will be a
significant part of the whole information system in the Bangladesh Parliament.
2. The need for a Document Management System for the Bangladesh Parliament
Different Governments of Bangladesh who came to power failed to make the Parliament an effective forum
for democratic process. The causes which are identified are inter alia , Lack of political will, conflict and
disunity between the opposition and treasury in almost every matter, lack of education and awareness among
members of parliament who mostly come from business community and an age old system of internal
management of the Parliament. This is unrealistic to think that Introducing Information and Communication
Technology in day to day activities of the Parliament will change the situation overnight. Nevertheless, it will
definitely increase the productivity and efficiency of the house and citizens will be largely benefitted and this
will set the ground for transforming the Parliament to concentrate on more citizen centric debate rather than
making it a political war ground. A Document Management System in The Parliament is expected to bring
the following benefit as it did for many Parliaments around the world-
I. The process of legislation takes up months and even years in the present system due a poor
communication between different actors in the legislative process. The Proposed system has the
potential to integrate all communication channels between the actors involved and makes it much
quicker to establish communication and document transaction among them. This will certainly
reduce time in different level of legislation.
II. Law makers need instant access to previous laws, regulation, meeting reports and committee
reports to assess a current situation. An easy search and retrieval tool of such document will be a
great help for them to decide and deliberate on important issues.
III. Cost is a big issue in the Parliament. Printing and storing volumes of report in paper format involves
huge cost and traditional communication by letter is also not so cheap and highly inefficient.
Members will be able to file their queries to the government through the system leading to speedy
and paperless flow of information across the treasury and opposition benches. While investment in
216
Information Technology is one time and maintenance cost is quiet manageable as compared to the
productivity and length and extent of service it has to offer.
IV. Since all proceedings, discussion and decisions will be recorded and protected by encryption, No
one in the administration can alter any decision taken in a committee whimsically and this will
ensure transparency and accountability. The opposition will have the opportunity to be more
involved in the democratic process knowing their opinions will be valued.
V. The work flow of the legislature will be improved which may lead to efficiency and cost reduction.
VI. The most important benefit will be the online accessible publication of proceedings, laws and
regulation. In the proposed system laws and regulation will be updated on regular basis and will be
freely accessible by any citizen through various delivery channels i.e., World Wide Web, mobile
device, community information center etc. The system can be instrumental in strengthening citizen
engagement, providing innovative ways of interaction between citizen and legislature.
VII. The system will help connect parliamentarians and parliamentary institutions with their worldwide
counterparts, thus sharing and strengthening their knowledge and information on the issues they
confront.
VIII. Finally the whole system will be an important driving force to the countries aspiration for greater
democracy and development.
ICT policy of Bangladesh clearly supports the objectives in general terms as ‘(the policy is intended to1)
promote use of ICT by providing special allocations for ICT project implementation in the public sector. Train
the decision makers in ICT use and promote an ICT culture’.2
Introducing ICT in the Parliament and law making process in a developing country like Bangladesh is a
tough challenge to undertake and the system will undoubtedly have some pitfalls too. Firstly, the history of
system management in Bangladesh is somewhat disappointing. The DMS could be managed by inefficient
people resulting in catastrophic information failure. Secondly, like most e-government projects digital divide
will hamper in ripping the benefit of the parliamentary information system for the mass people. However, with
the increasing awareness and literacy of ICT it is hope that this effect will get substantially reduced in future.
Thirdly, it will be difficult to train the lawmakers to use the system because usually most lawmakers are not so
ICT friendly. Fourthly, it will be difficult to resolve the issue of the status of originality and state of being official
version of documents contained in the Database.
3. Strategies of Building a Document Management System
Before developing and introducing a DMS for the Bangladesh Parliament a thorough study should be made
on the methods and ways to be adopted in such a system and strategies should be planned beforehand in
order for the smooth development and deployment of the system.
Bengt Eriksson, a Swedish specialist who has long practical experience within the area of Legislative
Informatics, explained the core strategy to be adopted while developing a document management system for
parliaments,
‘Over the years, we have learned a few things. One is that standards come and standards go.
Concretely , that could mean that instead of viewing today’s internet and today’ standards as the
final answer to the document access and information exchange , you should ask yourself which of
today’s standards are likely to survive long enough to establish themselves as standards of
tomorrow. From that point of view, it is obvious that the solutions that you seek today must be as
generic as possible, proprietary only to the extent that is deemed absolutely necessary. If such
solutions are not found, you stand the risk that because of compatibility difficulties much of your

1 Words in parenthesis are added by Authors.
2 Section 2.2.3 of The ICT Policy of The Government of Bangladesh 2009.
217
work is rendered useless whenever a new software tools and software version is released.’(
Ericsson B, 2009)
A particular solution developed today must be flexible enough to embrace future technology given the fact
that ICT is growing and transforming at an exponential rate. Such system should not be complex and user
friendliness should be given utmost priority as the users of the system are not supposed to have advanced
user level of IT knowledge.
A Document Management Systems may contain the following elements –
a. Document Production
b. Document Storage in Database
c. Document Distribution and Retrieval
d. Document archival
3.1 Document Production
The following strategies are to keep in mind while designing rational production system of documents-
a) Document should be structured.
b) Metadata and Information about the structure should be entered as close
to the source as possible.
c) Information security should be ensured.
Structuring of Document
Numerous documents are produced during the working of a Parliament i.e. Bills, Committee Reports,
Session Minutes, Committee hearings etc. These documents can be produced in raw and flat format or in
structured format. Structuring of documents means breaking down of the documents in parts and marking
them up so that they can be recognized by a system identification and retrieval.. Every system
development procedure within the field of legal document management requires a document analysis at the
very outset and it is practically imperative when the docware3 technique is applied(Sjöberg CM,2009). A
document is structured when we can trace and identify different parts of it such as title, headings,
paragraphs, articles and references etc. It is also possible to set rules as to what parts of the document may
contain what kind of data.
A structured document is useful for various reasons. Firstly, it allows the search of document to be very
efficient. Documents may be considerable in size and word matching search within the documents may not
produce desired results. Search is more effective when documents are structured. Secondly, if the document
is structured it will be much easier for a search engine to locate the exact kind of information a researcher
wants. Structured document with better information retrieval technique has the potential to cater to the
information need more efficiently. Thirdly, it is quite obvious that technology will evolve very fast in near future
and structured documents will be more suited to adapt to the new technologies. Fourthly, rules can be set up
with structure which will not allow wrong kind of data to be entered in a specific part of the document leading
to the integrity and reliability of the documents. Finally, structured documents are easily manageable in
respect to the version control and applications of amendments.

3 Standardized document markup language ie. XML
218
Title
Motions

Recommendation

Summary

Conclusion
Figure 1 : In a structured document, every part is clearly identified.
Information Standard
All those benefits of structuring document mentioned above can be achieved by document mark up. There
are many markup standard or information standard out there such as HTML , SGML ,XML. XHTML etc. The
question is which standard will be appropriate for our system. A suitable standard should be open not limited
by intellectual property, vendor independent, supported by a well accepted standardization Authority such as
International Standardization Organization (ISO) and most importantly its definition should be publicly
accessible and generally understandable. An appropriate standard for legislative document may contain a set
of straightforward, technology neutral representation of Parliamentary documents and an enabling structure
for the effective exchange of machine readable documents such as legislation, records and minutes (Vitali F,
2008). Machine readable means organizing document in a structured and systematic manner so that a
software application may read it without any flaw.
In this era of globalization parliamentary information and experience exchange across the world is crucial
to promote democracy and international co operation. A good standard allows interlinking and web-enabling
of Parliaments. Such standard will address policies and specifications for connecting Parliament information
system across countries. Country Parliaments should use the guidance provided to supplement their national
e- Government Interoperability Frameworks with an international dimension and thus enable international
interoperability of Parliaments(Vitali F, 2008).
The choice of standard and XML solution
HTML (Hyper Texts Markup Language) is one of the easiest and widespread mark up standard used to day.
219
However, it is designed largely to define how text and data will be presented to the user. Most of the text
presentations we encounter in today’s website are defined by HTML. It has predefined mark up tags which
seriously undermines the usability of it as information career. In view of this HTML will not be a good choice
to structure Legal document although it will be used in the presentation and user interface part of the system.
XML or eXtensible Markup Language is a popular information standard in the legal arena. XML does not DO
anything in itself. XML was instead created to structure, store, and transport information. It is just pure
information wrapped in tags. Someone must write a piece of software to send, receive or display it.4 It is a
meta language that can be used to build different kind of information models. XML. XML has elements and
attributes. An XML element is everything from (including) the element's start tag to (including) the element's
end tag. An element can contain other elements, simple text or a mixture of both. Elements can also have
attributes. XML elements can have attributes in the start tag, just like HTML.5 Attributes provide additional
information about elements. XML based standards means the standard in question uses XML to describe
the information model that is the object of the standardization attempt (Lunblad N ,2009). XML is suitable for
structuring the legislative documents because it offers the flexibility to the developers to invent their own tags,
it is an open standard which means no royalty payment is required and most importantly it provides a system
called schema or grammar which is a set of rules that describe the structure of a document and which could
be used to validate a document.
<REPORT>
<TITLE>………………..</TITLE>
<MOTIONS>…………..</MOTIONS>
<RECOMMENDATIONS>………………</RECOMMENDATIONS>
<SUMMARY>……..</SUMMARY>
<CONCLUSION>…….</CONCLUSION>
</REPORT>
Figure 2: A simple example of XML document with different elements.
Document Type Definition and Schema
Document Type Definitions and XML Schemas both provide descriptions of document structures. A
Document Type Definition (DTD) defines the rules of an XML document. It defines the document structure
with a list of legal elements and attributes. XML Schemas express shared vocabularies and allow machines
to carry out rules made by people. They provide a means for defining the structure, content and semantics of
XML documents. in more detail. XML Schema was approved as a W3C Recommendation on 2 May 2001.6
An XML Schema defines the elements, child elements and the attributes that can appear in a document. It
can also define the order, the number of child elements, the data types for elements and attributes

4 http://www.w3schools.com/xml/xml_whatis.asp accessed on January 10,2011
5 http://www.w3schools.com/xml/xml_attributes.asp accessed on January 11,2011
6 http://www.w3.org/XML/Schema accessed on February 02,2011
220
<xs:schema>
<xs:element name="REPORT">
<xs:complexType>
<xs:sequence>
<xs:element name="TITLE"
type="xs:string"/>
<xs:element name="MOTIONS"
type="xs:string"/>
<xs:element
name="RECOMMENDATIONS" .
Figure 3 : Example of Schema of the figure 2 XML document.
Meta data
Meta data can be defined as ‘data about data’. Meta data is not included in the actual content of a document
rather they are outside information which describes the content of the document. Metadata is structured data
which describes the characteristics of a resource. It shares many similar characteristics to the cataloguing
that takes place in libraries, museums and archives. The term "meta" derives from the Greek word denoting a
nature of a higher order or more fundamental kind. A metadata record consists of a number of pre-defined
elements representing specific attributes of a resource, and each element can have one or more values.7
Following is the example of meta data
Element Value
Title The Document
Creator Committee 1
Meeting No 1
Format XML
Date of creation 12.02.2010
DDI, EAD, e-GMS are some examples of meta data standards (Bloom , J 2009).
Using controlled vocabulary such as taxonomies, thesauries and anthologies meta data could be created
in a document in a more sophisticated manner. Taxonomies and thesauri are vocabulary terms arranged into
a hierarchal structure where each term has one more vocabulary and grammar for using that vocabulary to
express something meaningful within a specific domain of interest (Eriksson B ,2009). The Parliamentary
Ontology needs to be designed to be extensible so that those Parliaments with different, or more specific,
metadata needs may add extra elements and qualifiers to meet their own requirements (Vitali F, 2008). Meta

7 http://www.library.uq.edu.au/iad/ctmeta4.html accessed on February 02,2011
221
data facilitates more knowledge about the document in question and offers users many more possibilities of
locating the specific data he or she wants.
Meta data could play an important role in the legal information management like our proposed
Parliamentary Document Management System. Meta data in an information retrieval system greatly improves
the recall and precision of a particular search. In a legal information retrieval system word matching searches
are not always so efficient and effective. Adding meta data to the documents along with latest search
technology enables field and semantic searches. The goal is to enhance user satisfaction on the IR system
by providing useful search results. A particular legislation may be amended to address the need of time. In
that case the facts behind amendment would be added with the document as meta data. The amendment
information such as amendment date, amending bill submission authority ,votes etc are just as important as
the amendment text itself. So meta data could supplement new information.
Ensuring Information Security
Information Security is a crucial issue to be considered while developing the Document Management System.
The system is required to be safe and reliable both from technical and information quality point of view.
Information Security is the overreaching concept that encompasses security of information whether the
information is paper based or electronically stored. Internal and external vulnerabilities of the system should
be considered and adopt measures to minimize risks and ensure greater confidence and trust. It is customary
to discuss three concepts while discussion information security of particular system (Andersson H et all,
(2010)
Confidentiality: prevention of unauthorized disclosure of information or information resources. The assets
of the information system could only be accessed by authorized persons. Various level of access could be
granted to persons with different responsibilities. This will be controlled by an information security policy. In
our system some information may be sensitive and must be protected before it is right time to disclose them.
Integrity: prevention of unauthorized modification of information or information resources. Integrity is the
most important issue to be ensured in our system. We must make sure that all legislative documents are
stored exactly as they were produced and they do not also change when the documents are retrieved.
Electronic signature using asymmetric cryptography could be used to achieve integrity.
Availability: prevention of unauthorized withholding of information or information resources. According to
ISO 7498-2 availability is ‘ the property of being accessible and useable upon demand by an authorized
entity(Andersson H et all, (2010). This concept indicates under usual condition the system must be functional
so that the stakeholder of the system could benefit from it.
3.2 Document Storage
Adequate storage and efficient access methods are crucial elements in any document administration(Sjöberg
CM,2009). Documents with its structure and meta information has to be stored in a Database for reference
and retrieval through various delivery channels. A database is crucial element for our system to organize and
store the documents produced in manner described above. In designing the database and choosing a
database solution we have to keep in mind that it should support structured document format; it will be better
to choose an open source solution to minimize cost and most importantly it must be reliable and secured.
3.3 Document Distribution and Retrieval
Intranet and Extranet
Our proposed document management system will be composed of intranet and extranet. An intranet is a
222
private computer network that uses Internet Protocol technologies such as HTTP to securely share any part
of an organization's information or operational systems within that organization. 8 Intranet is the private
network connecting different ministries, parliamentary secretariat, and legislative drafting wing and law
commission. The intranet will facilitate synchronized work flow among different agencies above involved in
law making process through highly secured and closed network. Through the system a particular ministry can
initiate a legislative proposal and the proposal can see it life cycle of transforming into law by work flow
defined and established in the system.
An extranet is a computer network that allows controlled access from the outside for specific purpose.9
The public documents can be viewed through extranet. The extranet is the extension of internet to ensure
accessibility off site. Some part of the parliamentary web site will be part of extranet.
The Website
Websites have become an indispensible publishing media due to proliferation of internet in every sphere of
life. Almost every parliament around the world has a website providing the viewers from basic information to
sophisticated e-citizens consultation service. The official website of parliament should be a one stop center
for all information regarding the legislature. It should be authoritative and non-partisan and must be easily
understandable, user friendly and freely accessible to anyone. The website has to provide information in
timely, accurate and comprehensive manner. It is required to be well managed and supported so that it could
meet the growing needs of citizens and members , keep pace with new technology and help ensure
transparency and accountability of the Parliament.
Objectives of the website
In general the parliamentary websites started with the principle aim of a web presence providing basic
information. Over the years parliamentary websites are developed and improved to offer a very diverse range
of information in a more complex and challenging way. The following are the objectives of a modern
parliamentary website-
a) To provide basic information about the history, functions and members of the parliament.
b) To provide copies of official texts of proposed legislation.
c) To provide a code of law for the country containing all laws and rules in force in the country.
d) To provide accounts of debate and summaries and plenary actions and copies and committee
documents.
e) Two way communication between members and citizens and engaging citizens in the policy
process.
f) To provide improved methods of access through better search engines for retrieving documents.
g) To provide alerting service to enable citizens to be notified of the introduction and changes in the
proposed legislation.
h) To provide audio and video streaming of sessions live or from archive.
i) To provide an easy and user-friendly interface for citizens.
j) To provide download facilities of authoritative parliamentary documents.
The website has to be designed and developed keeping in mind the above objectives. In addition the website
should be designed such a way that in one hand it ensures the access to information of all who interested, on
the other hand it protects persons and their personal data from unauthorized access and processing. A
privacy policy should be incorporated in the website to achieve the above goal.

8 http://compnetworking.about.com/cs/intranets/g/bldef_intranet.htm accessed on June o8,2011
9 Id.
223
3.4 Document Archival
Due to advancement in technology electronic archiving has become more common place and serves as
affordable as well as reliable solution for preserving documents. Through electronic archiving it is now
possible to easily archive different forms of data such as images and videos. All the data created and
preserved in Document Management System should be delivered to the national archive where they will be
preserved for future use. Suitable technological solution is to be explored for such archives as they are meant
to last many years to come. Standardized methods of archiving are being developed. There should be rules
and regulation to describe the procedure to be followed for delivering data to electronic archiving. Information
standard could be suggested as the required delivery formats in this regard(Sjöberg CM,2009).
4. Conclusion
A Document Management System based on XML standard offers many challenges and obstacles and some
of them are quite formidable. Practical experience has suggested that it is really a time consuming and
laborious task to fully realize the potential of XML standard in combination with available software. Once
various tools are acquired, uncertainty still looms at the stage of information retrieval. It is quite challenging to
establish proper establishment and updating of hypertext links in a frequently recurring environment of legal
texts(Sjöberg CM,2009). A particular amendment may contain a lot of background report and information and
it is difficult to fit all the information in and linking them appropriately.
XML require an investment of time and effort by key stakeholders to agree on the format of official
documents and on the tags to be used to mark them up. This calls for a specialist team consisting legal
experts, technical experts and interdisciplinary experts of Law and Information Technology. It will be quite
difficult for Bangladesh to gather and maintain such a team due to unavailability of expert human resource
and low compensation structure. The effort needed to reach agreement is also quiet overwhelming.
Adding meta data is also a challenging task. The question is who will add meta data. Meta data should be
added by the document creator or meta data can be added by automatic means. In this regard, the drafters
work will be significantly increased if meta data is to be added manually.
The system will need high degree of security and availability. It is quite imaginable the degree of chaos
and confusion could be created if the system goes offline or malfunction without warning. The system is
vulnerable to inside and outside threats and calls for various preventive and remedial measures. An
Information security policy should be formulated which will describe the possible course of action that may be
taken to deal with the emergency situation arising from time to time.
References
Andersson H , Yngström L (2010) , Information Security , Legal Management of Information System –incorporating law in e-solutions,
edited by Cecelia Magnusson Sjöberg , Studentlitteratur , Lund.
Bloom , J (2010) . Meta data say what? http://www.cs.stir.ac.uk/~jmb/publications/jmb_publications.bib accessed on June 6, 2011
Eriksson B (2009) ,Maintaining Information Quality – Experience from the Swedish Parliament – Sveriges riksdag, Legal Management of
Information System –incorporating law in e-solutions, edited by Cecelia Magnusson Sjöberg , Studentlitteratur , Lund .
Halvey E (1983),, Bureaucracy and Democracy, London: Routhledge and Kegan Paul. E .
Lessig L (2006), Code and Laws of Cyberspace. New York: Basic Books.
Lunblad N (2009), Legal anlysis of XML based information standards, , Legal Management of Information System –incorporating law in
e-solutions, edited by Cecelia Magnusson Sjöberg , Studentlitteratur , Lund .
Sartor G (2008), Open Management of Legislative Document, Drafting Legislation: A Modern Approach, Xanthaki, Helen (Editor)
Stefanou, Constantin (Editor), Ashgate Publishing Ltd.
Sjöberg CM(2009) , Critical factors in legal document management, Legal Management of Information System –incorporating law in e-
solutions, edited by Cecelia Magnusson Sjöberg , Studentlitteratur , Lund .
Vitali F( 2008), A standard-based approach for the management of legislative Documents, Global Centre for ICT in Parliament Working
Paper No. 2 , retrieved from www.ictparliament.org.
224
Globalization is Good or Bad? Considering View of Next Generation Leaders
Iftekhar Amin Chowdhury
Labuan School of International Business and Finance

Universiti Malaysia Sabah
Norazah Mohd Suki
Labuan School of International Business and Finance

Universiti Malaysia Sabah
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.225
Abstract Globalization has the effect on world business in this 21st century undoubtedly. Effects come through both positive and
negative (dark) sides. This study aims to examine how future business leaders view globalization. 494 samples involved and
were selected via nonrandom convenient sampling process. Results infer that business majors have a different attitude toward
globalization compared with non-business majors. Next, students’ attitude toward globalization is also likely to be influenced by
their family background, especially their parents’ occupations. Ultimately, business environments are going global, internal
environments, including the mind-set of future managers, may change toward more globalization, resulting in potentially more
globally oriented strategies. Managers need to be on guard against antiglobalization sentiments tendency experienced by large
segments of the population for more “creeping globalization.”
Keywords: learning style; field of study; length of tertiary study; gender; age; learning language experience;
1. Introduction
Globalization has the effect on world business in this 21st century undoubtedly. Effects come through both
positive and negative (dark) sides. However, it seems especially important to know how future generation
view globalization if the future generations are to avoid more surprises on the road toward further
globalization. But scholars actually know very little about how the present students view globalization. Do
these future business leaders have a different attitude toward globalization compared with the general public
and the current business leaders? If so, where do these differences come from? This aims to address these
crucial but unanswered questions. Second, from a scholarly point of view, although there are numerous
studies on the attitude of executives, policymakers, and academics toward globalization cited earlier and on
the attitude of university students toward such issues as careers (Collins, 1996) and cooperation (Frank,
Gilovich, & Regan, 1993), there has been no study of the attitude of students toward globalization. To the
extent that the future of globalization will be shaped by the current generation of students, such a lack of
understanding of their values and views is alarming. Given the importance and timeliness of this issue, as
evidenced by the recent protests and debates, this study helps fill a crucial gap in knowledge about how
future business leaders of Bangladesh view globalization.
Prior studies were researched among executives (Ball & McCullough, 1993; Beamish & Calof, 1989; Hoffman
& Gopinath, 1994), policymakers (Czinkota & Ronkainen, 1997), and academics (Kwok, Arpan, & Folks,
1994) shows a great progress toward globalization was made during the 1990s. Fueled by advances in
225
technology, increases in global trade and investment, and improvements in standard of living, globalization
was widely believed to be a positive force embraced by a majority of the global public. Yet, toward the end of
the decade, massive antiglobalization protests, organized primarily by union members, environmentalists,
and human rights activists designed to derail a World Trade Organization (WTO) meeting, suddenly broke
out in Seattle in December 1999. Since then, similar antiglobalization protests have repeatedly broken out in
places such as Washington (April 2000), Quebec City (April 2001), and Cancun (September 2003). As a
result, executives, policymakers, and academics were caught off guard by the strong antiglobalization
feelings expressed (sometimes violently, as in Seattle) in these protests. More importantly and alarmingly,
antiglobalization feelings have recently moved from being minority views to more mainstream sentiments that
enter political debates (Bhagwati, 2004; Stiglitz, 2002).
These protests and debates suggest that while most executives, policymakers, and academics—whom
we collectively term “elites”—surveyed in the U.S. would embrace globalization, a substantial segment of the
global public and certain politicians seem to have a strong backlash against globalization (“Backlash behind
the Anxiety over Globalization,” 2000). Although it is long known that globalization carries both benefits and
costs, business leaders, in their drive toward more globalization, may have failed to adequately take into
account the social, political, and environmental costs associated with globalization (Clark & Knowles, 2003;
Eden & Lenway, 2001). It is likely that during their formative years while they were in college and universities,
these elites were not exposed to the “dark” side of globalization and would only embrace a “rosy” picture of
globalization.
Given such a wide divide between the views of the elites and those of the public, it seems especially
important to know how future generation view globalization if the world is to avoid more surprises on the road
toward further globalization. Future business leaders are people who are currently being educated in
business schools and who will influence the global economy in the future. Having been better exposed to
both sides of the globalization debate compared with the current business leaders, these individuals may
hopefully make more informed and balanced decisions when they assume leadership positions. Management
educators have the mandate to train a new generation of business leaders who will be able to handle these
difficult responsibilities.
2.1 The influence of Economics
Future business leaders have two characteristics. First, they are young enough to have more opportunities to
assume important positions in the corporate world than the general public. Second, they are interested in
economics and business. The sample consisted of undergraduate and graduate students who took at least
one required; introductory-level economics class (Micro / Macroeconomics). Research suggests that the self-
selection to study economics and the socialization within an economics curriculum are likely to lead to certain
attitudinal changes in favor of more market competition (Frank et al., 1993). In economics, especially at the
undergraduate and graduate introductory level, free trade is widely regarded as a positive force for all
countries, whereas barriers to free trade would decrease its benefits. It follows, then, that the future business
leaders, who had an opportunity to study economics, are more likely to be positive toward globalization than
the general public, who may not have such knowledge of economics. Accordingly, the study hypothesizes
that:
Hypothesis 1: Future business leaders are more positive toward globalization than the general public.
2.2 The Influence of Being a Business Major
Business majors may have a different attitude toward globalization compared with nonbusiness majors
(Rynes & Trank, 1999). Business (and economics) students are often found to be more materialistic (Collins,
226
1996) and individualistic (Frank et al., 1993) than the rest of the student population. The reason may be
either self-selection or socialization within the program. In either case, being a business major may shape a
student’s worldview, including his or her attitude toward globalization. For example, business majors may
focus more on the economic gains of globalization than nonbusiness students do. As a result, they may be
less concerned with the social, environmental and political costs associated with globalization. Therefore, the
study posits:
Hypothesis 2: Business majors are more positive toward globalization than nonbusiness majors.
2.3 The Influence of Family Background
During their formative years, students’ attitude toward globalization is also likely to be influenced by their
family background, especially their parents’ occupations. In particular, parents who have blue-collar jobs are
more likely to lose their jobs due to global competition. Conversely, white-collar employees tend to be better
educated and may benefit more from globalization. Such a privileged position may influence their children’s
view. Thus, the study hypothesizes that:
Hypothesis 3: Students who have white-collar parents are more positive toward globalization than students
who have blue-collar parents.
3. Methodology
Using 494 undergraduate and graduate students who were taking a required, introductory-level international
business class at public and private universities, it was replicated by the Business Week survey (see
Appendix 1). The survey was administered in the middle of the term, after students were exposed to both
sides of the globalization debate, including an explicit discussion of the antiglobalization protests in Seattle
and elsewhere. With an enrollment of over 50,000, the university attracts students from all walks of life, thus
representing tremendous diversity. Ranked by University Grants Commission (UGC) as among the top 15 in
the country, the upper-division undergraduate and graduate business program is highly popular on campus,
and generally requires a 3.0 GPA during the freshman and second years to enter. The city in which the
university is located is regarded as solidly “center of Bangladesh,” with its racial distribution similar to that of
the country and its cost of living index approaching 100% of the Bangladesh average. Dhaka is often used as
a test marketing site for major consumer goods companies before they undertake nationwide product
launches.
4. Data Analysis
Among the sampled students, 58% were male and 42% female. Their age ranged between 19 and 49, with a
mean of 22. Approximately 90% of the sampled students majored in business. The research asked the
students to characterize their parents’ background. Slightly less than 50% of the students came from a white-
collar family. Students who were from urban areas would have more exposure to globalization compared with
those from rural areas. Urban areas tend to be more cosmopolitan, with more abundant opportunities to
sample flavors of international cultures, foods, and imports. These benefits may be hard to access from rural
areas, which may be more parochial. Therefore, the students born and raised in urban areas may have a
different attitude toward globalization than those from rural areas, thus calling for a control of this factor.
Overall, 69% of the sample came from urban areas.
Although some students have jobs, not all hold regular, professional jobs. It is possible that students
who have regular, professional jobs may be less affected by the winds of globalization than those who have
227
unstable, nonprofessional jobs. Therefore, the students had professional jobs when they took the course
were also controlled. About 27% of the students reported to have professional jobs. Further, the substantial
foreign student enrollment at the university (representing 7% of the student population), which has one of the
largest international student contingents in the country, and in the class thus gave an opportunity to tease out
the nationality effect as another control variable. It was found that 12% of the sampled students had non-
Bangladeshi citizenships.
Table 1. Socio-demographic profile of respondents
Variables Category Frequency Total

Male 281
Sex 488
Female 207
Range 19-49
Age 492
Average 22
Business 450
Major 494
Nonbusiness 44
White collar 235
Parents’ Background 494
Blue collar 259
Urban 343
Hometown 494
Rural 151
Professional 132
Current Employment 494
Nonprofessional 362
Bangladeshi Citizen 430
Students 490
Non-Bangladeshi Citizen 60
4.1 Correlation Analysis
The inter-relationships between the seven variables were examined using correlation analysis and it is
summarised in the Table 2. All of the Pearson’s correlations between variables were greater than 0.3 and
lesser than 1. Hence, there is no multicollinearity problem in this research and allowing to proceed with
hypothesis testing.
Table 2. Correlation matrix
Sex Male Age Business White- Urban Prof. Job Non-

Collar Bangladeshi
Sex Male 1.000
Age -0.090 1.000
Business -0.028 0.148 1.000
White-Collar 0.006 0.007 0.013 1.000
Urban/Sub 0.027 0.051 0.039 0.131 1.000
Professional Job 0.099 -0.228 -0.116 0.039 -0.046 1.000
Non-Bangladeshi 0.036 -0.221 -0.064 0.031 0.139 -0.123 1.000
In Table 3, it was undertaken that a univariate analysis to test H1 through two-sample z tests. Specifically,
nearly all of the students (96%) believed that globalization is good for global consumers, whereas only about
two-thirds of the general public held a similar view. In terms of the percentage of respondents who believed
that globalization is good for International companies, student sample outnumbered the general public by 14
percentage points (77% versus 63%). A significantly higher percentage of the students (88%) also believed
that globalization is good for the world economy, whereas about one-quarter less of the general public (64%)
shared a similar view. Moreover, 82% of the students supported the view that globalization benefits poor
countries’ economies, whereas 75% of the public polled held such a view. Interestingly, students seemed to
228
have a more dismal view on globalization’s impact on Global jobs, with only 43% believing that globalization
is good for creating global jobs—this was probably a reflection of the recent recession that resulted in a very
poor job market. In contrast, half of the surveyed public believed so. Nevertheless, such a difference was not
significant. In conclusion, it was compared with the general public, next generation leaders indeed have a
significantly more positive view toward globalization. Therefore, H1 of future business leaders are more
positive toward globalization than the general public was strongly supported.
Table 3. Next generation leaders versus the general public of those who answered “good”
Questions: Overall, do you think globalization Next Generation Leaders General Public z-Score
is good or bad for
1. consumers like you 96% 68% 12.2**
2. international companies 77% 63% 5.5**
3. the world economy 88% 64% 9.8**
4. creating jobs in world market 43% 50% -2.6
5. strengthening poor countries economies 82% 75% 3.1**
Notes: * p<0.05; ** p<0.01.
4.2. Logistic Regression
Binary logistic regression was undertaken for H2 and H3. Specifically, “business major,” “white-collar
parents,” “urban origin,” “professional job,” and “non-Bangladeshi citizenship” were coded 1, and others 0.
For H2, it was found that business majors in Models 1 and 5 showed significantly positive results toward
globalization than nonbusiness majors (Table 4). In Models 2, 3, and 4, although the signs of the coefficients
were all positive, it was unable to find a significant association. Thus, H2 was partially supported.
Table 4. Business majors, parental background, and attitude toward globalization
Models (1) (2) (3) (4) (5)

Constant 17.91 -1.86 -0.77 -1.16 0.45
(12.58) (3.61) (4.66) (3.47) (4.14)
Controls
Sex Male -0.55 0.21 -0.47 0.32+ 0.03
(0.52) (0.22) (0.31) (0.19) (0.24)
Age -0.20 0.03 0.04 0.01 0.01
(0.37) (0.05) (0.06) (0.04) ((0.05)
Urban 0.37 -0.18 -0.27 -0.31 -0.17
(0.51) (0.25) (0.33) (0.21) (0.27)
Professional Job -0.55 -0.27 -0.21 -0.12 0.03
(0.52) (0.25) (0.33) (0.22) (0.28)
Non Bangladeshi Students -0.69 -0.24 0.71 0.15 -1.07**
(0.69) (0.34) (0.56) (0.30) (0.32)
Predictors
Business major 1.29* 0.49 0.36 0.14 0.75*
(0.63) (0.37) (0.48) (0.36) (0.38)
White-collar parents 0.04 0.21 0.07 0.38* -0.14
(0.48) (0.22) (0.29) (0.19) (0.23)
Log-likelihood -76.080 -257.599 -167.057 -320.465 -232.976
G 7.468 6.553 6.660 8.615 18.093
p-value 0.382 0.477 0.465 0.282 0.012
Notes: + p < 0.1; * p < 0.05; ** p <0.01.
229
Testing H3, in four out of five models, the result found, as predicted, that students with white-collar parents
had positive signs toward globalization than students who have blue-collar parents. However, only the
coefficient for Model 4 was significant, implying that students from white-collar households were more likely
to believe that globalization is good for creating global jobs. At least for the job creation, potential of
globalization for the world, this finding is especially strong, in light of the results reported in Table 3 that
students in general are less likely than the general public to have a positive view on such potential. As a
result, H3 was also partially supported.
5. Discussion
This study aims to examine how future business leaders view globalization. Results enumerates that
compared with the general public, business students, though at a relatively young age (on average 22 years
old), already hold a substantially more positive view toward globalization. While not surprising, this finding is
significant, because it establishes a baseline difference during these next generation leaders’ formative
years. It is possible that as these individuals progress in their business career, their positive view toward
globalization may strengthen, thus increasingly converging with the view held by current executives.
Business majors and/or students with white-collar parents are especially likely to have a positive attitude
toward globalization. Because of possible self-selection, it is difficult to establish a causal link between
majoring in business and such an attitude. It is, however, plausible to argue that socialization in a white-collar
household may lead to a more positive attitude toward globalization.
Further investigation of the study revealed that foreign students had a mixed view toward globalization
in Models 1 through 4 in Table 4, in Model 5 they were significantly less likely to agree with the position, often
embraced by Bangladeshis such as those surveyed by the research, that globalization is good for
strengthening poor countries’ economies. Given that some of these foreign students are likely to assume
leadership positions in their own countries, such a finding implies that some future foreign business leaders
may not be as enthusiastic about globalization as their non-native colleagues are. Therefore, it is not
surprising that international proposals for more globalization in international forums such as the WTO often
meet resistance. The data and information of this research, at a very micro level, hint at why this may be the
case.
6. Conclusion and Recommendations
In a nutshell, business majors have a different attitude toward globalization compared with non-business
majors. Next, students’ attitude toward globalization is also likely to be influenced by their family background,
especially their parents’ occupations. Based on an exploratory study, the findings need to be interpreted with
at least three limitations in mind. First, this research was relied on a nonrandom, convenient sample. The
sample size, nearly 500 people, is not necessarily small, given that the presumably nationwide Business
Week survey only included slightly over 1,000 people. However, it remains to be seen whether similar
findings would emerge if more business students in a wide variety of universities are surveyed. Second,
attitudes toward globalization may be changing more recently, as more white-collar jobs in world market are
reportedly threatened by low-cost countries. Whether business students will continue to hold a “rosy” picture
of globalization while some of their (future) jobs may be threatened remains to be seen in future research.
Finally, globalization, by definition, is not a country based phenomenon, and antiglobalization protests also
erupted in Asia, America and Europe recently. Therefore, global validation of the research findings is called
for.
For managers who are working at global enterprises, the message from this study has some
implications for action. First, the finding that young student are more positive toward globalization than the
general public may imply that globalization strategies will become more and more popular in the near future
230
when these students become business leaders. This means that as business environments are going global,
internal environments, including the mind-set of future managers, may change toward more globalization,
resulting in potentially more globally oriented strategies. Thus, given the large antiglobalization sentiments
experienced by large segments of the population, managers need to be on guard against this tendency for
more “creeping globalization.”
Second, this study may have an important implication for global firms’ internal staffing. The empirical
result that business majors are likely to have a positive attitude toward globalization suggests that relative to
other majors, business majors can be more motivated if they are assigned to internationally oriented
positions. Better motivation of employees is obviously more likely to lead to better firm performance. As a
result, managers may need to recognize different attitudes toward globalization between business majors
and nonbusiness majors and take advantage of business majors’ stronger interest in and more positive
attitudes toward globalization.
Although this study helps fill a gap in scholarly knowledge about next generation leaders, its
implications for the people as management educators are profound, rewarding, or unsettling—depending on
one’s point of view. On the one hand, perhaps researchers should congratulate themselves because the
students, even at a relatively young age, are already found to exhibit similar values shared by their more
accomplished seniors. Despite the possible self-selection in their major selection and the probable family
influence, there is no denying that their values are shaped, at least in part, by the educational experience
educators provide. To the extent that business schools aspire to train next generation leaders by providing
them with the dominant values practitioners hold, educators seem to have succeeded in this mission.
On the other hand, a more unsettling question, in light of the sudden outburst of antiglobalization
protests in Seattle and elsewhere, is: Have researchers been too successful? Since it is increasingly clear
that globalization has two sides and that its “dark” side carries substantial social, political, and environmental
costs, how can (or should) researchers intervene to correct business students’ seemingly one sided view
toward globalization? In other words, given the usual compulsion among textbook authors to praise
globalization, should researchers devote more time in the classroom on the “dark” side of globalization so as
to sensitize students about its potentially devastating consequences? Moreover, should researchers tell
students that the problem is not with globalization itself but with how it has been managed, as Stiglitz (2002)
suggested?
On this crucial issue, it seems that management educators need to strike a very delicate balance.
Although the findings imply that a heavier emphasis in the teaching on the more negative aspects of
globalization may be called for, an influential recent book by Bhagwati (2004) argued that the positive effects
of globalization on the social, political, and environmental conditions – the so-called human face of
globalization need to be emphasized more. It certainly makes sense that in the teaching, educators should
avoid overemphasizing any one side – either negative or positive of globalization. The challenge for
researchers as concerned management educators is how to strike such a balance (Peng, 2006; Ricks, 2003).
If as a consequence of this article more professors (as well as students, executives, and policymakers)
become interested in exploring the two-sidedness of globalization and endeavoring to establish a more
informed and balanced understanding, then the purposes will have been well served.
References
Backlash behind the anxiety over globalization. (2000, April 24). Business Week, pp. 38-48.
Ball, D. & McCullough, W. (1993). The views of American multinational CEOs on the internationalized business education for prospective
employees. Journal of International Business Studies, 24, 383-391.
Beamish, P. & Calof, J. (1989). International business education: A corporate view. Journal of International Business Studies, 20, 553-
564.
Bhagwati, J. (2004). In defense of globalization. New York: Oxford University Press.
231
Clark, T. & Knowles, L. (2003). Global myopia: Globalization theory in international business. Journal of International Management, 9,
361-372.
Collins, M. (1996). Who are they and what do they want? Journal of Career Planning and Employment, 57, 41-56.
Czinkota, M. & Ronkainen, I. (1997). International business and trade in the next decade: Report from a Delphi study. Journal of
International Business Studies, 28, 827-844.
Eden, L. & Lenway, S. (2001). Multinationals: The Janus face of globalization. Journal of International Business Studies, 32, 383-400.
Frank, R., Gilovich, T. & Regan, D. (1993). Does studying economics inhibit cooperation? Journal of Economic Perspectives, 7, 159-171.
Hoffman, R. & Gopinath, C. (1994). The importance of international business to the strategic agenda of U.S. CEOs. Journal of
International Business Studies, 25, 625-637.
Kwok, C., Arpan, J. & Folks, W. (1994). A global survey of international business education in the 1990s. Journal of International
Business Studies, 25, 605-623.
Peng, M.W. (2006). Global strategy. Cincinnati, OH: Thomson South-Western.
Ricks, D. (2003). Globalization and the role of the global corporation. Journal of International Management, 9, 355-359.
Rynes, S. & Trank, C. (1999). Behavioral science in the business school curriculum: Teaching in a changing institutional environment.
Academy of Management Review, 24, 808-824.
Stiglitz, J. (2002). Globalization and its discontents. New York: Norton.
Appendix 1. Key questions in the survey
Goods and services produced in different regions of the world are distributed worldwide through export /
import. Most of the goods and services of different nations are imported from elsewhere. Overall, do you think
globalization is good or bad for
Good Bad Don’t know Refuse to answer

1. Consumers’ like you a b c d
2. International companies a b c d
3. The world economy a b c d
4. Creating jobs in world market a b c d
5. Strengthening poor countries’ a b c d
economy
232
Different Backgrounds and English Learning Styles of

Bangkok University Student
Nuttanuch Munsakorn
Assistant Professor, Language Institute

Bangkok University, Thailand
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.233
Abstract: The purpose of this research was to investigate the influence demographics, gender, faculty, and level of general
English has on students’ learning styles. Subjects were 410 students representing Accounting, Business Administration, and
Economics faculties and studying Business English courses at Bangkok University. A Perceptual Learning Style Preference
Questionnaire: PLSPQ (Reid, 1987) was used for collecting data via a five point Likert scale. Data were analyzed and calculated
in percentage, mean, standard deviation and Chi-squared test at the level of 0.05.The results show that Bangkok University
students do not have a specific style of learning English. The three main forms of learning English are; study in a group, learning
and practicing in different situations, and listening respectively. Some results varied based on gender, faculty and levels of
academic performance in general English variables. However, the styles of learning English did not.
Keywords: different backgrounds, learning styles, PLSPQ,
1. Introduction
The growth of business and advancement of communication technology have made the role of English an
increasingly important tool for expanding international competitiveness. Approximately 80 percent of the
information available via Electronic Media is in the English language (Kluver, 2000). This information shows
the importance of the English language in today’s world. Therefore, Thailand should accelerate students’
development and preparation of the English language skills to a level where they can communicate,
collaborate, negotiate and build international business relationships effectively.
Developing and preparing students to communicate using their English language skills has a direct
impact on the development and evolution of design styles for learning and teaching English in higher
education institutions in Thailand. This paper argues that the development of teaching General English alone
is not sufficient for development and preparation of personnel for international business. Therefore, the
educators should on English skills that emphasis English language communication skills for the workplace in
order to respond to the needs of learners more effectively.
Teaching English for the workplace should aid learners’ achieve important career goals by preparing the
learner to use English for communication in workplace situations such as significant vocabulary terms
(Robinson, 1980).
Therefore, it is important to prepare lessons, teaching activities and teaching materials that correspond
to the instructional model of learning in order to develop skills in English language learners
effectively.Currently the development of teaching English for careers is focused on several issues such as
development in curriculum and content, education environment and using technology media to assist in
teaching. However, this overlooks the several key issues in the process of learning English, for example
developing the students’ ability to have a direct role in communication and building the students’ confidence
in their use of English for the workplace.
The key point that has been ignored is learning English in a practical way, therefore the author believes the
development of learning and teaching English needs to change and become more learner focused. This
concept idea is consistent with Cohen’s (1990) studies of the process of teaching a foreign language is that
233
attention must be redirected from the instructors to the students and not aim to improve the teaching method
alone.
So English for business purposes is an important subject for people in broadly diversified employment
situations, ranging from employee to executive. Businesses are staffed by accountants, management,
marketing, public relations, research and development so each employee and each position may be required
to use English in performing their job. Each student will use a different style of learning to gain the most
benefit from a course in English for the workplace, the success of each student comes from the ability to
provide for a variety of learning styles. The learning style does not mean the direct abilities but it is the way
that each person uses their abilities for thinking and learning. This suggests that there not a best or worst
form of learning but that the method of providing knowledge must be flexible enough to accommodate a
range of learning styles. The success of learning thus relies on the nature and style of learning of the learner
themselves, and providing for the most suitable style to allow the learner develop that style of learning and
allow the best performance.
Learning styles and the effectiveness of teaching and learning in the classroom have become the focus of
a considerable number of studies by educators and psychologists. According to the Merriam Webster
dictionary, the word “style” refers to the a particular manner or technique by which something is done,
created, or performed, so ‘learning style’ may be defined as the physical characteristics, idea and feeling that
person use in recognition and response interacted with the learning environment as relatively constant
(Keefe, 1979, Hong & Suh, 1995).
Learners need a learning style that builds confidence in using English, therefore encouraging students to
participate and develop the ability to communicate in English corresponds with the philosophy of teaching
and learning. An important issue is that teacher needs to understand the learning styles of students because
currently most of the management of learning and teaching English in universities focuses on demographic
points such as gender, age and ability level in learning the instructional documents, variety and styles of
activities, and interests of students. However, the instructor may be negligent by not focusing on other
student related issues, because instructors have different teaching styles. Thus, if the instructor knows the
learning style of the learner it will be very helpful because the instructor can manage the learning
environment. Instructors can understand the behavior and problems of individual learners, there by assisting
students to gain the confidence to use English in the real work situation without the need for further English
language study. This, in turn, offers students a competitive advantage in achieving suitable employment
opportunities after graduation.
Bangkok University wants to develop a program that produces graduates that have the abilities to use
English communication skills that offer a clear response to the labor market demand.
The purpose of the research
1. To study Bangkok University student’ English language learning styles.

2. To investigate Bangkok University student’ English language learning styles
according to demographics, gender and levels of academic performance of general English.
2. Scope of research
1. The population is Bangkok University undergraduate enrolled in Business English in the first semester of
the academic year 2010. All data were collected in English classes during the month of August 2010.
2. The variables of the study
2.1) Variables such as different backgrounds of students include:
- Gender divided into Male and Female
- Faculty divided into Accounting, Business Administration and Economics.
234
- Levels of academic performance in general English are divided into four levels: very good, good,
moderate and not satisfactory.
2.2) Dependent variables are styles of Learning English divided into 6 types; using visual (VLS - Visual
Learning Style), listening (ALS - Auditory Learning Style), practices in different situation (KLS - Kinesthetic
Learning Style), performance (TLS - Tactile Learning Style), learning alone (ILS - Individual Learning Style)
and study in group (GLS - Group Learning Style)
3. Theory and Related Research
3.1 Conceptual studies of learning by PLSPQ
PLSPQ is a tool to survey patterns of English language specific to those learning English as a second
language (ESL) or foreign languages (EFL). It is a questionnaire that surveys a pattern of learning from
channel of perception data that can be divided into the following six types; using visuals (VLS - Visual
Learning Style), listening (ALS - Auditory Learning Style), practices in different situation (KLS - Kinesthetic
Learning Style), performance (TLS - Tactile Learning Style), learning alone (ILS - Individual Learning Style)
and study in a group (GLS - Group Learning Style) (Reid, 1984)
1. Learning through visual (Visual Major Learning Style Preference) includes visual reading and studying
charts and media composed of other images such as image, signboard, video and movies. This type of
learner has the ability to view information from text books, on the (white) board or via exercises and be able
to memorize the information more effectively than if memorizing via the teaching of the instructor. This type of
learner does not need to listen to the explanation of others but rather rely on reading and self understanding
of messages to aid in recognition. This type of learner prefers to study alone with books rather than
interacting with the others.
2. Listening (Auditory Learning Style Preference) means learners learn from listening activities such as
listening to a lecture, conversation, or cassette. These learners learn and remember from the explanations of
other people and they may like to read aloud for recognition of the content of courses.
3. Learning by practicing in different situations (Kinesthetic Learning Style Preference) means learning
from practicing scenarios that require motion in the learning situation such as role play like drama, interviews
and learning from real experiences. Learning by participating in activities (Total physical involvement in
learning) the learner is able to remember the knowledge obtained by participating in class, having outdoor
activities, role play or learning by mixing auditory and kinesthetic methods.
4. Learning through performing (Tactile Learning Style Preference) means learning by doing (hands-on) for
example, creating a model, experimentation in a laboratory and learning from tangible objects such as photo
book or card. This type of learner likes learning by doing things by themselves, reading, listening to other
people or observation.
5. Learning individually (Individual Learning Style Preference) means the way that the learner does self
study both in and out of the classroom in order to achieve the goal of learning. This type of learner prefers
learning by them self and will be able to solve various problems as well as understanding more about the
facts when they perform self study.
6. Studying in a group (Group Learning Style Preference) means the situation where learners work together
with friends or classmates either in pairs or groups. They prefer solving the new problems as part of a group
rather than by themselves. Motivation in learning new things comes from the support and help of the group.
Learners can be further segmented into 3 types being; Major (main), Minor (secondary) and Negative (do not
have). Each learner will have either a major, minor or negative style of learning, learners with major style tend
to have a very good study characteristics, while learners that have minor style can receive and remember the
information at a good level. Those who do not have a style of learning will have difficulties in learning
235
cognitive information during the learning process. Reid’s (1987) construct of perceptual sensory learning
styles comprise six major preferences: Visual, Auditory, Kinesthetic, Tactile, Group, and Individual.
4.1 Population and samples
1. Bangkok University undergraduate students enrolled in Business English courses

in the first semester of the academic year 2010 made up the population (1,347 people).
2. Subjects were 410 students representing Accounting, Business Administration, and Economics faculties
and studying Business English courses at Bangkok University. This is from a stratified random sampling. The
size of the sample is calculated from the formula of Yamane that the movement equal 0.05 (Yamane, 1973)
that got a sample of at least 309 people. However, the researcher consider using the sample of 410 people
that mostly are women with 277 people and the remaining are 67.6 percent are male. The number of 133
people where 32.4 percent study in the faculty of Accounting and faculty of Business administration with 43.9
percent per 180 people and faculty of Economics with 50 people were 12.2 percent having results of levels of
academic performance of general English in average and at the highest level were with 152 people by 37.1
percent, moderate level were 32.0 percent, not at a satisfactory level were 25.4 per cent and 5.6
percent were at very good level.
4.2 Data Collection
Data were collected in class during the month of August 2010.
4.3 Research Tool
Tool used in this research can be divided into 2 parts.

Part 1: Data base of respondents gender, faculty and level of academic English skills.
Part 2: Perceptual Style Preference Questionnaire (PLSPQ) (Reid, 1987), designed to explore the patterns of
learning English language as a second language (ESL) and foreign language (EFL) in higher education.
PLSPQ was used to assess participants’ Perceptual Learning Styles, which took 25 minutes to complete and
score. The PLSPQ required students to write down a numerical value at the end of each of 30 questions. A
Likert rating scale was used to assess the level of performances and the scoring criteria (strongly agree = 5
marks, agree = 4 marks, no decision = 3 marks, disagree = 2 marks, strongly Disagree = 1 mark). They were
instructed to complete all the values, to add the numbers, and finally, multiply the answer by two. Their major,
minor, and negligible styles were determined by analyzing the separate scores on the six perceptual
categories. Major learning style preference scores ranged from 38 to 50 minor ranged from 25 to 37, and
negligible ranged from 0 to 24.
Scoring and interpretation are as follows.
Scoring: Score format = Total score of the question in each model x 2

Interpretation: The learning model is divided into three groups.
Scaling score model Meaning

38-50 marks Major Learning Style Preference
25-37 marks Minor Learning Style Preference
0-24 marks Negligible Learning Style Preference
236
Statistical data analysis
1. Basic statistics are percentage frequency, mean and standard deviation.

2. The statistic used to test assumptions is Chi-square test.
5. Results
The participants have a main learning style as follows; VLS at 22.1 percent (93 students); TLS at 26.6
percent (109 students); ALS at 29.8 percent (122 students); GLS is 42.9 percent (176 students); KLS at 39.0
percent (160 students) and ILS at 13.7 percent (56 students). Learning English in the Minor style results are
as follows; VLS at 64.4 percent (264 students); TLS at 63.7 percent (261 students); ALS at 62.0 percent (254
students); GLS at (48.8 percent) (200 students); KLS at 52.0 percent (213 students); ILS at 57.1 percent (234
students). Learning English in the negligible style results are as follows; VLS at 12.9 percent (53 students);
TLS at 9.8 percent (40 students); ALS at 8.3 percent (34 students); GLS at (9.0percent) (37 students); KLS at
29.3 percent (120 students); ILS at 57.1 percent (234 students).
Figure 1

40 35.4
35
30
25
19.3
20 14.6
15 12.9
8.8
Pe rcen ta ge (%)
10 5.4
3.7
5
0
1major style
No major 2major styles
3major styles
4major styles
5major styles
6major styles
style
Number of Major Learning Styles
Figure 1 shows that the most of Bangkok university students do not have major learning styles at the 35.4
percent followed by 1 major style is at 19.3 percent, 3 major styles is at 14.6 percent, 2 major styles is at 12.9
percent, 4 major styles is at 8.8 percent and 6 major styles is at 5.4 percent respectively and the lowest is 3.7
percent for 5 major styles.
237
Figure 2
Male Female 2=1.913,
30
24.7 24.5 25.1
p=0.861
25 21.1
Percentage(%
)
20 17.7
14.2 15.7 15.5
15 12.3 13.3
10 8.2 7.6
5
0
VLS TLS ALS GLS KLS ILS
Learnigstyle
Figure 2 shows the English learning styles of Bangkok University’s student. GLS is at 24.5 percent of female
students and 24.7 percent of male students, KLS is at 25.1 percent of male students and 21.1 percent
of female students, ALS is at 17.7 percent of female and 15.5 percent of male students, TLS 15.7 percent of
female and 14.2 percent of male students, VLS of male students is at 12.3 percent and 13.3 percent of
female students, ILS is at 7.6 percent of female student and 8.2 percent of male students.
When testing the relationship between English learning styles of BU student by gender, results
were statistically significant at 0.05. Where the learning styles of BU student do not have relationship with
gender of the student (2=1.913, p=0.861).
Figure 3
2=5.682,
Accounting Business Administration Economics
27.7
p=0.841
30 25.7
25 23.624.5 23.5
18.9 19.9
Percentage(%
)
20
14.213.2 14.515.715.8 15.715.8
15
8.9 8.8 7.5
10 5.9
5
0
Learningstyle
Figure 3 shows that 24.5 percent of students in the Business Administration faculty, 27.7 percent of students
in Economics faculty and 23.6 percent of students in the Accounting faculty. KLS students in the faculty of
Accounting 19.9 percent, students in the faculty of Business Administration 23.5 percent and 25.7 percent of
students in the Economics faculty. ALS students in the faculty of Business Administration 15.7 percent,
students in the faculty of Economics 15.8 percent and 18.9 percent of students in the faculty of Accounting.
TLS students in the faculty of Business 15.7 percent, students in the faculty of Economics 15.8 percent and
14.5 percent of students in the faculty of Accounting. VLS students in the faculty of Accounting 14.2 percent,
students in the faculty of Business Administration 13.2 percent and 8.9 percent of students in the faculty of
238
Economics. ILS students in the faculty of Accounting 8.8 percent, students in the faculty of Business
Administration 7.5 percent and 5.9 percent of students in the faculty of Economics.
When testing the relationship between learning styles of Bangkok University students classified by faculty
of the students, results were statistically significant at 0.05. Where the learning styles of Bangkok University
students do not have relationship with student faculties (2=5.682, p=0.841).
Figure 4
Verygood Good Moderate Notsatisfactory 2=8.829,

35
30.4 p=0.886
30 28.1
25 22.223.2 23
21.322.8 21.7
Percentage(%
)
18.3
20
15.7 17.1 16.5 16.117.4
13.4 14.814.2
15 13
10.18.7 9.6 8.1 8.7
10
5.5
5
0
Learningstyle
Bangkok University students at each level of academic performance of general English have common styles
of learning English, these are GLS, where students have very good academic performance is at 22.2 percent,
level of good performance is at 23.2 percent, moderate level of academic performance is at 28.1 and not
satisfactory level is at 30.4 percent. KLS, where students have very good at academic performance is at 21.3
percent, good performance is at 22.8 percent, moderate level is at 23.0 and not satisfactory academic
performance is at 21.7 percent. VSL, students with very good academic performance is at 15.7 percent, level
of good performance is at 13.4 percent, moderate level of academic performance is at 10.1 and not
satisfactory in academic performance is at 8.7 percent. TLS, students with very good at academic
performance is at 14.8 percent, good performance is at 14.2 percent, moderate level is at 17.1 percent and
not satisfactory academic performance is at 13.0 percent. ALS, students with very good at academic
performance is at 16.5 percent, good performance is at 18.3 percent, moderate level is at 16.1 and not
satisfactory academic performance is at 17.4 percent. ILS, students with very good at academic performance
is at 9.6 percent, good performance is at 8.1 percent, moderate is at 5.5 and not satisfactory academic
performance is at 8.7 percent.
When testing the relationship between learning styles of Bangkok University students according to their level
of general English, the results were statistically significant at 0.05, (2=8.829, p=0.886).
6. Summary and discussion of the results
The results show that most of the Bangkok University students who participated in this study do not have a
main style for learning English, this suggests that these students may have difficulties in the recognition of
English language information. This may be due to the time allocated to English as a foreign language for Thai
students to practice the four skills, (listening, speaking, reading and writing) is relatively limited which requires
the learners to use a variety learning styles at the same time. For example students like to study with friends
239
in a group but do not like to help each other to answer questions because they want their own individual
score.
When considering students who have a main learning style, we found that the style preferred by most of
the Bangkok University students who participated in this study is learning in a group. Students like to learn
with a group rather than thinking and solving problems by themselves when learning new things, thus they
learn by interacting as a member of a group. Motivation to learn new things comes from the help of a group
(Reid, 1987) because the habit of Thai students is to rely on each other, helping each other, which is one of
the outstanding characteristics of Asian students and this is consistent with studies of Wintergerst et al.
(2002).
When considering the main style used by students, the top three styles are, learning as a group (GLS),
learning by practicing in the different situations (KLS) and listening (ALS), respectively. This corresponds with
Wasanasomsithi (2542) research which studied the styles of learning of Chulalongkorn University students in
Thailand. That study found that the top three styles were learning as a group (GLS), learning by practicing in
different situations (KLS) and listening (ALS), respectively. While according to Nimmansut (1994) study of the
styles of learning English language in a vocational education department in Thailand, students used listening
style (ALS) and learning with a group (GLS) as the second and third preference respectively.
These results support research undertaken in a range of countries, for example Mulalic, et al. (2009)
studied the style of learning English of Malaysian university students and found that students prefer learning
through practice in the different situations (KLS), while Peacock (2001) found that Chinese students who
learn English as a foreign language at The City University of Hong Kong like to learn by practicing in different
situations (KLS) and the listening style (ALS). Wintergerst, et al. (2003) found that Russian university
students who study English as a second language like to learn by practicing in different situations (KLS),
followed with the listening style (ALS). Jones (1997) found that Chinese university students in Taiwan prefer
the learning through practicing in the different situations (KLS). Chu, Kitchen and Chew (1997) found that
Singaporean university students prefer practicing in the different situations (KLS) and the research of Melton
(1990) that studied Chinese university students’ style of learning English as a foreign language prefer to learn
by practicing in the different situation (KLS) as the second style.
However, Bangkok University student’ learning styles are different from international students who prefer
not to learn in a group (GLS) (Reid1987, Melton 1990, Hyland 1993, Mulalic, et al. 2009), this might be due to
culture differences because Thai’s are Asian and have characteristics different from Westerners (Hofstede
2001). Hofstede describes general characteristics of Asians as shy, lacking of confidence, fear of losing face,
and do not like confrontation which consistent with studies of Wintergerst, et al. (2003) which concluded that
Asian students have group-oriented style characteristics which is different from Russian students.
Furthermore this research’s results are not consistent with studies regarding university students studying
in the business field’s style of learning English, for example marketing students have a style of learning by
improving and like to learn from direct experience (Jaju, et al. 2000). While accounting, marketing
management and general business students have an absorption style of learning, they prefer not to learn by
action or practicing but rather they have the ability to summarize the principles or rules and prefer to work
with objects more than people (Novin A. and Jordan 2003, Nijoroge and Senteza, 2006).
Although the three majors (Economics, Accounting and Business Administration) of Bangkok University
students are Business for Professionals, they do not have a main style of learning but each student used a
variety of learning styles. This is consistent with the research of many studies about the style of learning
English for the university students, Reid (1987) said students have a different style of learning (Mulalic, et all.,
2009; Wintergerst, et all., 2003; Jones, 1997; Hyland, 1993; Melton, 1990).
The relationship of pattern of learning English by Bangkok University students comparing their different
backgrounds including gender, faculty and levels of academic performance in general English. For both male
and female students of Bangkok University at all levels of general English and in each faculty and the styles
of learning English is not different from each other. This means that students will learn in a group followed by
240
practice in different situations and listening respectively in accordance with Mulalic, et all (2009), who
studied the styles of learning English by Malaysian University students and found that male students prefer
learning styles by practicing in different situation (KLS) and learning by listening (ALS). This is
because learning with others creates confidence while doing activities to practice the language skills.
Learning as part of a group allows brainstorming with others, to express one’s opinion as
some comments may be consistent with majority. This is necessary because learners have people to help in
supporting the ideas of the learner rather than making them lose confidence and not participate in activities
for fear of losing face (as observed in class by the researcher). In addition, learning with others creates
opportunities to support the interdependent learning such as when the learner cannot answer nor do
exercises. Other learners in the group may be able to find the answer on behalf of the learner. The learner
will have the confidence to learn and develop more of their English skills (as observed in class by the
researcher). Learning as a member of a group also reduces the pressure and stress in competitive situations
because learning in groups emphasizes the unity of collaboration between the members of the group.
Therefore, this can lead to competitive situations to rarely occur (Wintergert, et al., 2003).
In addition to this, learning in groups is a driving force for the learner to have enthusiasm for learning and
practicing their language skills better. So participating and creating group activities can make the learner
perceive their level of abilities and other members in the group all the time. If the learner is the weakness of
the group, the learner must find the way to develop their abilities. At the same time, the learners who are the
strength of the group have to maintain and increase their abilities in order to be a refuge of the group (as
observed in class by the researcher). Although, Wintergert has said that the pattern of learning in group has a
less competitive situation involved.
The result of this study is not consistent with the studies of Milgram (2007) which found that female
students prefer learning by cooperating and not competition. While the male student prefer, learning by
doing. Apart from this, male student has skills to use equipment and solve problems during learning by doing
or action more than by female students in learning STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering and
Mathematics).
Where the learning pattern does not focus on doing experiments in accordance with the nature of boys
that have a basic characteristic of learning and playing (Play and Learn) which is different from girls. Students
in the faculties of Accounting, Business Administration and Economics have a pattern of learning English
which is not different from each other. Probably because from the faculties of Accounting, Business
Administration, and Economics are liberal art faculties that have to focus on the participation of the student
and learning from direct experience in real situations regarding actual occupations. This is
consistent with research of Jaju and Knak (2000), which found that the marketing subject has a learning
pattern where the learner prefers to learn from experience and performing a real experiment.
Students with academic performance at level of very good, good, moderate and not satisfactory use
learning styles that are not different, perhaps because the university student are not yet aware with the
learning styles of learning English. Therefore, Bangkok University students may be have random
characteristics of learning patterns and other ways of instinct learning learned from when they born and as a
learner may use the various patterns of learning one thing also according to the study of Mackeracher (2004)
that summarizes a brief fact about the learning pattern with nine questions and one of the facts said that
there is no best pattern of learning.
References
Cohen, A.D. (1990). Language Learning: Insights for Learners, Teachers, and Researchers. Boston, Mass: Heinle & Heinle.
Davis E., & Nur, H., & Ruru S. 1994. Helping Teachers and Students Understand Learning Styles , English Teaching Forum, 32 (3), 12-
19.
Hofstede, G. (2001). Culture's Consequences: comparing values, behaviors, institutions, and organizations across nations (2nd ed.).
Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications.
241
Hong, E., & Suh, B. (1995). An analysis of change in Korean-American and Korean students’ learning styles. Psychological Reports, 76,
691-699.
Hyland, K. (1993). Culture and Learning: A Study of the Learning Style Preferences of Japanese Students. RELC Journal. 24(2): 69-91.
Jones, N.B. (1997). Applying Learning Styles Research to Improve Writing Instruction.Paper presented at RELC Seminar on Learners
and Language Learning,Singapore, April 1997.
Jaju, A., & Kwak, H. (2000). Learning preferences of marketing students. Marketing in a time of great change.
Kluve, R. (2000). “Globalisation, informatization and intercultural communication.”
American Communication Journal, 3(3), http://acjournal.org/holdings/vol3/Iss3/spec1/kluver.htm), Accessed: 31st December 2010.
Mackeracher, D. (2004). Making sense of adult learning (2nd edn.). Toronto, University of Toronto Press.
Melton, C.D. (1990). Bridging the Cultural Gap: A Study of Chinese Student’s Learning Style Preferences. RELC Journal. 1(June 1990):
29-47.
Milgram S. (1997), Obedience to Authority: An Experimental View, London: Pinter and Martin Ltd.
Mulalic, A., & Mohd Shah, P., & Ahmad, F. (2009). Perceptual learning styles of ESL students. European Journal of Social Sciences,
7(3) pp. 101-113.
Njoroge, J., & Senteza, J. (2006). Learning styles, performance, and attitudes towards technology: focus on business students. Journal
of College Teaching & Learning, 3(5).
Nimanphisut, D. (1994). Study the pattern of learning English of student level. Certificate in Vocational Education Department. Bangkok:
Master thesis, Chulalongkorn University.
Novin, A., & Arjomand, L., & Jourdan, L. (2003). An investigation into the preferred learning styles of accounting, management,
marketing, and general business majors. Teaching and Learning, 18(1), 24–31.
Peacock. M. (2001). Match or Mismatch? Learning Style and Teaching Styles in EFL. International Journal of Applied Linguistics. 11(1).
38-58.
Reid, J. M. (1987). The learning style preferences of ESL students. Tesol Quarterly, 21(1), 87-111.
Robison, P.C. (1980). ESP (English for Specific Purposes). Oxford: Pergamon Press.
Vincent, A., & Ross, D. Training techniques; Learning styles; Personality tests; Myers-Briggs type indicator. The Learning Organization,
8 (1), 36-43
Wasanasomsithi, P. (2542) study style of learning (Learning Style) of learner learning English as foreign language. Search on October
28, 2553, from http://www.culi.chula.ac.th/e-Journalt/panchalee.htm.
Wintergerst, et al. (2003). Conceptualizing Learning Style Modalities for ESL/EFL students. System 31, 85-106.
(http://sciencedirect.com), Accessed: 31st December 2010.
Yamane, T. (1973). Statistics: An Introductory Analysis. Tokyo: Harper International.
242
Relative Impact of Infrastructural Provision by CBOs in Akure South LGA

of Ondo State, Nigeria: Application of Facility Contributory Index
Dr. Adebayo Adewunmi Emmanuel
Department of Urban and Regional Planning

School of Environmental Technology,
Federal University of Technology,
Akure, Ondo State, Nigeria

Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.243
Abstract: Infrastructural provision is a catalyst for economic development at various levels. The influence on local economic
development and the alleviation of poverty is unquantifiable. In some instances, CBOs embark on physical development projects
to provide facilities in their communities. This paper exposes the relative impact of facilities provided by CBOs in Akure South
Local Government Area of Ondo State, Nigeria on the economy of residents. 262 respondents of the LGA which were selected
by stratified random sampling provided information through a questionnaire to reveal the degree of contribution of certain 10
facilities to their personal economy. Facility Contributory Index (FCI) model was developed using likert’s scale to determine
various levels of contribution of the facilities. It was discovered among other things that Health related facilities ranked highest on
the FCI Table of assessment while recreational facilities remain the least contributor due to low provision coupled with degree of
contribution. Recommendations include a policy overhaul to establish partnership between government and NPOs in order to
stimulate efforts of CBOs in local communities.
Keywords: local economic development, poverty, community-based organisations, infrastructure, facility contributory index.
1. Introduction
Local Economic Development (LED) is multi-dimensional in its approach. According to Emmanuel (2003),
growth of economic or business ventures in rural areas is impeded by lack of or inefficient infrastructure. LED
involves partnerships between local governments, community-based groups and the private sector in which
resources are managed to create jobs and stimulate the economy of a well-defined territory. Hence,
Community Based Organisations (CBOs) have roles to play in economic development of individuals and local
communities. One of three broad categories of LED initiatives is the community-based economic
development. This involves a kind of what Town Planners refer to as disjointed incrementalist approach in the
planning of communities but with a tendency towards economic improvement. It is the most direct of
categories of LED initiatives. The involvement of CBOs in this context cannot be ignored.
Nden (2004) sees CBOs as those organisations which are involved in various developmental activities
that enhance the living standard of their communities. They are non-profit oriented organisations, which help
to promote economic activities and provide infrastructural facilities. CBOs act as facilitators or avenues
through which initiatives are executed within or diffused into communities. They exist in form of cooperative
societies, user associations, workers’ unions or producers associations (Helmsing, 2001; Bingen, 2003).
Despite this, the main focus has always been to reduce poverty and improve the economy of individuals and
well-being of households in a local setting.
One of the “tools” employed by CBOs to assist the development of local economies or alleviate the
poverty of the people in their communities is the provision of basic infrastructure. At times, such provision
could be as essential and common as water for cottage industry and domestic consumption. At other times, it
could include the capital intensive construction of roads within or linking communities.
243
This paper focuses on the activities of CBOs in an urban-dominated Local Government Area (LGA) of
Ondo State, Nigeria. It employs the application of Facility Contributory Index (FCI) model, which was
developed using Likert’s Scale, to determine the extent to which infrastructural provision in the hands of
CBOs have contributed towards improving the economy of the residents in the study area.
2. Summary of Literature Review
The concepts of Poverty and Local Economic Development (LED) have linkages in welfare discourse. The
latter attempts to find a solution to the former. Hence, Poverty is viewed as a problem requiring suggested
solutions. Poverty studies date back to the end of the nineteenth century when researchers like Charles
Booth and Seebhom Rowntree worked to determine minimum requirements for human survival in terms of
food, clothing and certain household sundries in order to fix poverty lines for an individual or family (Booth,
1889 and Rowntree ,1901). Despite certain criticisms, the works of Booth and Rowntree formed the basis for
modern poverty studies.
Relatively recent studies have considered poverty as a function of education, health, life expectancy and
child mortality among other things. In the process of measuring human development, the United Nations
makes use of four basic indices one of which is the Human Poverty Index (HPI). The HPI employs major
dimensions which measure poverty in terms of education, longevity and income (UNDP, 2001). This implies a
merger of the initial and basic measure of poverty using poverty line (income) and the recently derived
measure using dimensions such as education and life expectancy.
The concept of LED involves several multi-actors and approaches. It involves a framework whereby the
local government, private sector and several non-profit organisations (NPOs) engage in measures to assist
individuals and communities to improve their economy while making use of resources in their immediate
environment (World Bank, 2001). Measures are taken to boost the local economy through investment in hard
infrastructure, support for small and medium-scale enterprises, capacity building, supporting the growth of
new enterprises and supporting growth of particular clusters of businesses. The Multi-actors involved in this
process are usually governments (especially local government), International Organisations, Non-
Governmental Organisations (NGOs), Community-Based Organisations (CBOs) and private organisations.
Yankson (2000) says local NGOs and CBOs constitute important groups within civil society. At times, they
are used interchangeably to represent private, voluntary, non-profit organisations independent of any
government, which are funded through individual and corporate donations, levies imposed on members and
grants from international agencies and governments (Jegede, 2000). CBOs have existed for long as major
survival strategists for the common man, giving immediate support to their economic challenges. However, in
most cases, they have been limited by lack of sufficient funds. The commonest expressions are in form of
Cooperative Societies and Community Development Associations (CDAs).
Mandela (1995) emphasized the fact that the participation of CBOs and NGOs had enriched the evolution
of the Reconstruction and Development Programme (RDP) into a concrete policy document in South Africa.
Participatory Rural Appraisal (PRA) is an approach used by NGOs and other agencies involved in
international development. The approach aims to incorporate the knowledge and opinions of rural people in
the planning and management of development projects and programmes (Wikipedia, 2010). PRA involves
rural people examining their own problems, setting their own goals, and monitoring their own achievements.
Community-Driven Development (CDD) is an approach that gives control of development decisions and
resources to community groups. Poor communities receive funds, decide on their use, plan and execute the
chosen local projects, and monitor the provision of services that result. It improves not just incomes but also
people’s empowerment, the lack of which is a form of poverty as well (International Development Association,
2009).
Ibem (2009) worked on community-led infrastructural provision in low-income communities in Ohaifa,
Nigeria and discovered that local organisations were addressing infrastructural challenges in their
244
communities. Identified organisations were able to harness local resources. Also, the fact that mobilisation of
resources in project initiation, design, implementation and funding influenced the type of infrastructural
projects embarked upon by these organisations was established. Findings equally exposed conceptual and
policy implications for integrating community-based approaches into urban development process in
developing countries.
Francis et al (1996) examined local organisations in 36 rural and urban communities of Nigeria. A
significant discovery was the fact that CBOs were after the communal benefit as a whole and not particular
about individuals or the poorest “per se”. In essence, CBOs are highly valuable in the improvement of
individual and local economies through such things as provision of infrastructural facilities and local projects
which are solely or jointly funded in partnership with several international organizations. At times, CBOs’
contribution may come in form of manpower mobilization and involvement.
This paper focuses on the people’s assessment of the impact of the contributions of CBOs to their
economic development through the provision of certain infrastructural facilities in their communities in Akure
South LGA of Ondo State, Nigeria.
3. The Study Area: Akure South LGA
Akure South LGA is located in Ondo State in the South-western geopolitical zone of Nigeria. It was carved
out of Akure LGA on 1st October, 1996. It occupies a land area of 2,303 square kilometres and lies within
6094’ - 7025’N and 5005’ - 5040’E. The headquarters of the LGA is Akure city which doubles as the capital city
of the State. The LGA is 346km from Lagos and accommodates less than 400,000 people (Federal
Government of Nigeria, 2007). The area is dominated by Yorubas who form the major tribe in southwestern
Nigeria. Major settlements in the LGA are Akure and Oda while some of the minor settlements are Aponmu,
Ipinsa, Iwoye, Igbatoro, and Isagba. Akure, the state capital, is a university town which boasts of resources
such as kolanut, cocoa, oil palm, and rocks which are converted into useful stones for various construction
works. The LGA is divided into 11 political wards.
4. Methodology
Akure South LGA was selected for this study based on the multi-dimensional cultural, professional and
business characteristics being exhibited. Akure South LGA is a landlocked area dominated by an urban
setting (characteristic of a state capital which Akure town is) and accommodates most of the highest income
earners in the state. Its population has divergent cultural background though dominated by the Yoruba tribe.
The LGA was divided into strata using the existing 11 geopolitical wards out which 10% of the districts or
settlements in each ward were randomly selected as sample for investigation. Certain wards which exist
within the city of Akure have districts or streets while some wards outside the city had distinct settlements
from which selection was made.
Both open and close ended questions were employed to elicit data from household-heads in the
respective settlements or districts. A total of 262 copies of the survey questionnaire were retrieved out of the
275 distributed to respondents (representing 95.3% response rate). The Survey was conducted by trained
field assistants on a weekend to allow for easy and maximum access to respondents. Data processing
involved uni-variate analysis resulting in the generation of tables and charts which were later employed in the
development of the Facility Contributory Index (FCI) model. The model was further developed using Likert’s
Scale (such that weights were assigned to the people’s perception of the level of each facility contribution) in
order to obtain the contribution of the facilities provided by CBOs to the respondents’ economy.
245
5. Research Outcome
This section highlights the results from the FCI model employed in the analysis of collated response from the
residents of Akure South LGA on CBOs-provided facility.
5.1 Facility Contribution for Akure South LGA: Sum of Frequencies for Levels of Contribution
To arrive at the output on Table 1 (see Appendix), respondents were required to indicate whether the listed
facilities had been provided or not by CBOs in their community. Also, for those who responded positively,
they were to indicate the perceived level of contribution of each facility to their personal economy. However, it
is important to inform that not all the listed facilities were found in every community investigated. Therefore,
Table 1 shows the number of respondents who responded affirmatively to the enquiry on facility provision
and also the disaggregation of those respondents according to the perceived level of contribution of each
facility to their personal economy.
For each facility, it is easily inferred from the Table that most respondents indicated non-provision or did
not respond at all; since the total number of respondents is 262. This confirmed an earlier finding that
Government had performed far better than CBOs and NGOs in providing facilities in communities.
5.2 Facility Contribution for Akure South LGA: Sum of Weighted Value and Facility Contributory Index
Computation
Table 2 (see Appendix) gives the calculated values for Sum of Weighted Values (SWV) and the FCI for each
facility in a ranked manner. The weighted values were first calculated by multiplying the weights attached to
each level of contribution with the number of respondents for that level of contribution. The SWV is the
addition of all weighted values for a particular facility while the FCI was obtained by dividing the SWV by the
total number of respondents (n) for that facility. Afterwards, the mean, variance and standard deviation of the
FCIs were equally obtained.
The rankings (on Table 2) show that Health Facility has the greatest contribution to personal economy of
households with FCI of 3.13 while the presence of recreational centres/playground contributed the least with
FCI of 1.33. The mean FCI is 2.69. Also, 7 of the 10 facilities are found above the mean. This reveals
facilities with positive and negative deviations about the mean. The facilities with positive deviations are
Health Facility, Waste Collection Facility, Community Hall, Secondary School facilities, Primary School
facilities, Market and Water Supply. This implies that these facilities are perceived to have contributed more
than the average contribution of all the 10 assessed facilities. The facilities with negative deviation about the
mean are Road, Electricity and Recreational facilities. These are the facilities with low level of contribution.
It is necessary to emphasize again that this assessment is for only those facilities provided by CBOs and
does not include those provided by the government. The Health Facility has attracted attention as a strong
“indirect” contributor to improved economy. The cliché that “health is wealth” cannot be ignored. The
availability of dispensaries, clinics and chemist’s shops were facilitated by access to land, building or labour
mobilisation through the CDA.
For a waste disposal facility, a high and positive FCI from as many as 75 individuals (which is the highest
response rate) may be unexpected. However, when CBOs such as CDAs provide such facility, it is a way of
reducing expenses on refuse disposal and consequently reducing running cost of businesses which in the
long run helps to maximise business profit. In Akure metropolis, where residents are expected to pay for such
service to be rendered at their homes, a major facility provided by the CDA at certain locations, if properly
managed, reduces expenses on waste disposal. The Waste Disposal Board functions adequately well in the
city and is always ready to deal with erring residents while the Board provides large refuse containers around
246
markets. Furthermore, this scenario cannot be disconnected from health reasons which are linked with the
ranking of provision of Health Facility as highlighted earlier.
Community hall ranks 3 on the Table with FCI of 3.06. These are venues for meetings and other social
and political engagements. Additionally, such halls are rented for functions and ceremonies. Therefore, the
community generates income from them. Also, individuals in the community have spill-over benefits in form of
sales and services to users of such community halls who may want to rent canopies and chairs, buy water
and drinks, and obtain catering services among others. When Halls are provided by private individuals, the
community halls tend to be cheaper and more affordable though with less quality and quantity of facilities.
Community halls are not common place in Akure metropolis except at the central slums like Odo-Ikoyi.
Rather, they are found in the outskirt settlements of the LGA like Oda and Igbatoro towns.
The provision of community secondary and primary schools provide not only jobs for teachers and other
staff working in the school premises but also persons living within and around such schools who trade in
stationery, confectionery, food, snacks and drinks in and around the premises of such schools. At times,
these include the approved food and stationery vendors within the school premises. The CBOs may not have
built the schools especially as in the case of Akure South LGA but have assisted in the provision of furniture
and other learning facilities for these schools. These come in form of donations to the schools.
However, the FCI for the secondary and primary schools are 3.06 and 2.86 respectively while they rank
third (secondary school and community hall share same position) and fifth on the Table. This implies that
secondary schools were perceived to have contributed more to individual economy in the LGA than the
primary schools. Despite a higher number of respondents for primary school (64) than that of the secondary
school (31), the secondary school attracted a higher rating for economic benefits; an important factor being
that they posses more matured students (compared with the primary school pupils) which include those who
do part time work to make money to cater for their school needs.
Market has a FCI of 2.76 (ranking 6) with a deviation of 0.07 about the mean. This implies a slightly
above-average contribution to the economy of the people. The respondents are wide spread. Most
importantly, CBOs hardly provide markets for communities in Akure South LGA. Consequently, the influence
of markets on the economy may not have come as such from those provided by CBOs. For this reason,
contrary to expectations, the FCI (2.76) is not very high as it has a deviation of 0.07.
Water Supply is ranked 7 with a FCI of 2.74. This is low enough as its potentials had not been harnessed
by the CBOs. Also, the fact that it serves as raw material in the production process of many small
businesses in addition to packaging as bottled and sachet water has not been appreciated. Community
boreholes exist in some places though most are sunk and solar-powered by the government. Also, public
water taps run in few places at certain times of the week. Therefore the influence of the CBOs is minimal.
In Akure South LGA, it is not surprising to discover that road and electricity have negative deviations of -
0.11 and -0.46 about the mean of the FCI. In a rural environment, the impact of road construction to the rural
economy is considerably high since the road serves as means of communication between the villages and
market centres. Road construction plays a major role in individual’s economy. However, though roads are
essential to the development and life of urban dwellers too, the provision of roads by CBOs has a low FCI.
The best the CBOs had done was to fill up potholes with broken bricks and laterite at desperate moments.
They have no economic power to provide such good roads that will contribute to the economy of even those
who live in slightly rural areas of Akure South LGA. The best that could be done was to clear a stretch of road
or grade without overlaying macadam.
Electricity is hardly provided by CBOs. Except in few cases where limited supply is in form of generator
provisions for individuals with small-scale businesses. This can come from cooperative society purchase or
by loans obtained from such cooperative societies. In some other cases, people in the community are told to
contribute money towards repairs of transformers or extension of lines or replacement of damaged poles
after rain storm. The CDAs in some situations provide cash support from the community purse and
247
coordinate donations towards such ventures. Electricity provision is highly germane to the economy of the
people but the contributions of the community or CBOs are limited to the above; hence, the low FCI.
Recreational centres and playgrounds are lowest on the FCI Table with a value of 1.33 and a -1.36
deviation about the mean. These hardly provide income for the people except in few cases as provided by
private individuals where certain Television viewing points have been established for watching international
football matches and premiership matches. More importantly is the fact that CBOs hardly get involved in
provision of such facilities.
6. Recommendations and Conclusion
The clear need for generation or review of policies to favour or promote the contributions of CBOs to the
development of communities cannot overemphasized. Such policies provide legal and administrative
environments for CBOs to operate. To address this concern, certain recommendations are necessary.
First, there is great need for partnership between government and CBOs in order to facilitate the efforts of
CBOs towards infrastructural development of communities to ultimately catalyse poverty alleviation and local
economic development. This starts with initiation of a periodic forum for interaction between the government
and the NPOs. Organised interactions of this sort will generate memoranda of understanding to spring up
partnership between governments and the NPOs especially the CBOs.
Also, since, provision of stable power supply is a sine quanon in the process of improving both micro and
macro economy of a nation, the power sector will need both policy and infrastructural overhaul. At the micro
level, many businesses are negatively affected as traders in perishable goods have problems running their
business without regular power supply. The cost of purchase and maintenance of a good and high KVA
power generator to run businesses actually shoots up the running cost for such businesses. The general
noise and air pollution aggravate environmental degradation; not to mention the danger posed by powering
generators with Premium Motor Spirit (PMS). Hence, Pubic-Private Partnership (PPP) is suggested within a
decentralised power generation system which puts power supply in the hands of state government; coupled
with an Environmental Management Plan to tackle pollution problem. CDAs are to provide security of power
installations and facilities in their communities as part of the contribution to stable power supply.
Participatory Monitoring and Evaluation approach should be introduced by CBOs to monitor projects while
adequate feedback mechanism should be put in place. For CBOs such as cooperatives, the awareness of
the performance of help-initiatives will assist in improving the contributions of CBOs to the economic welfare
of the people. Furthermore, there is need for CBOs to invest more in recreational facilities in order to promote
the culture of rest and relaxation among the people. The provision of parks and gardens with various
attractions and incentives will encourage people in communities to visit such centres and also improve their
health. This will further increase their appreciation of good health as vital to wealth as already implied in the
high FCI values for health and waste disposal facilities.
Local groups and expressions in the area of community development and self empowerment will continue
to aid the bottom-up approach to infrastructural and economic development. The need to continue exploring
this aspect of the society will ever remain germane to the welfare of the human race and the development of
the developing nations.
References
Bingen, J. (2003). Community-Based Producer Organisations: A Contribution to The West African Regional Action Plan For The Initiative
to End Hunger in Africa. Agricultural Policy Development Programme. Bethesda: Abt Associations Incorporated.
Booth, C. (1889). Life and Labour of the People. Vol. I. London: Williams and Norgate. In Holman, R. (1978). Poverty: Explanation of
Social Deprivation. Oxford: Martin Robertson & Co. In Olanrewaju D.O. (1990): Spatial Distribution of Urban Deprivation in Akure,
Ondo State, Nigeria. PhD Thesis. University of Sheffield.
Emmanuel, A.A. (2003). Exploring Local Economic Development Initiatives for Community Empowerment in Odigbo Local Government
Area of Ondo State. MTech Thesis. Federal University of Technology, Akure.
248
Federal Government of Nigeria (2007). Federal Republic of Nigeria Official Gazette. Vol.94, No.24. Supplement to Legal Notice on
Publication of the Details of Breakdown of the National and State Provisional Total 2006 Census, Lagos: The Federal Government
Printer.
Francis, P., Akinwunmi, J. A., Nkem, S.A., Odihi, J., Olomajeye, J.A., Okunmadewa, F. et al (1996): State, Community and Local
Development In Nigeria, World Bank Technical Paper No. 336, African Region Series, Washington: World Bank.
Helmsing, A.H.J. (2001). Local Economic Development - New Generations of Actors, Policies and Instruments. A Summary Report
Prepared for The UNCDF Symposium on Decentralization Local Governance in Africa Institute of Social Studies, The Hague.
[online] Available:www.cdsea.org/CDSKnowledge/cds2activities/CB-
M2/017%20M2%20Handout%20%20%20LED%20New%20Generations%20of%20Actors.pdf February 4, 2004)
Ibem, O.E. (2009). Community-led infrastructure provision in low-income urban communities in developing countries: A study on Ohafia,
Nigeria. Cities, 26(3), 125-132 .
International Development Association (2009). Community-Driven Development: Delivering the Results the People Need. Online
[Available]: http://siteresources.worldbank.org/IDA/Resources/IDA-CDD.pdf (September 10, 2010)
Jegede, A. O. (2000). Assessment of Selected Non-Governmental Organisations on Poverty Alleviation Strategies: A case study of
Countrywomen Association of Nigeria (COWAN). BTech. Thesis. Federal University of Technology, Akure.
Mandela, N. (1995). Message of The President to The Conference of Community-Based Organisations, Johannesburg. [Online]
Available: http://www.anc.org.za/ancdocs/history/mandela/1995/sp950727.html (November 5, 2005)
Nden, S.J. (2004): The Assessment of Community-Based Organizations in Poverty Alleviation in Okene, Kogi State. PGD
Thesis.Federal University of Technology, Akure.
Rowntree, S. (1901) Poverty: A Study of Town Life, London in Hopkins, M. (1998). Contemporary Thinking about Anti-Poverty Strategies
for Sub-Saharan Africa: A Brief Review. Chapter 3 of Challenges and Prospects for Sustainable Human Development in Africa.
New York: UNDP.
United Nations Development Programme (2001). Human Development Indicators. Human Development Report. 2001 New York:
University Press.
Wikipedia (2010). Participatory Rural Approach. Retrieved September 8, 2010 from
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Participatory_rural_appraisal.
World Bank. 2001. World Development Report 2000/2001. Attacking Poverty. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Yankson, P.W.K. (2000). Community-Based Organisations (CBOs) and Urban Management and Governance in an Era of Change in
Ghana: The Case of the Greater Accra Metropolitan Area (Gama). Ghana Social Science Journal, 1(1), 97-136.
Acknowledgement
The Author acknowledges the support of the Federal University of Technology, Akure, Nigeria through the University Research Grant
awarded to carry out the above research.
Appendix
Table 1: Facility Contribution for AKURE SOUTH LGA – Frequencies for Levels of Contribution
S/N Facility Provided/ Very Little Little Fair High Very High
No. of Contribution Contribution Contribution Contribution Contribution
Respondents
1. Waste Collection Facility 75 12 9 17 33 4
2. Market 74 15 23 14 9 13
3. Water Supply 70 18 18 7 18 9
4. Road (untarred) 65 14 17 19 12 3
5. Electricity 64 18 21 17 8 0
6. Primary School Classrooms and 64 16 10 12 19 7
Furniture
7. Secondary school Classrooms and 31 8 2 4 14 3
Furniture
8. Community Hall 31 5 5 8 9 4
9. Health Facility 30 1 10 7 8 4
10. Recreational Centre /Playground 27 21 4 1 1 0
Source: Author’s Computation, January 2008

249
Table 2: Facility Contribution for AKURE SOUTH LGA – Sum of Weighted Value and FCI Computation
S/N Facility Freq. for Freq. for Freq. for Freq. for Freq. for
Provided/ Very Little Little Fair High Very High
R an k in g .
no. of Contribution Contribution Contribution Contribution Contribution SWV FCI FCI – (FCI-
respondents x1 x2 x3 x4 x5 Mean Mean)2
1. Health Facility 30 1 20 21 32 20 94 3.13 0.44 0.1936 1

2. Waste Collection Facility 75 12 18 51 132 20 233 3.11 0.42 0.1764 2
3. Community Hall 31 5 10 24 36 20 95 3.06 0.37 0.1369 3
4. Secondary School 31 8 4 12 56 15 95 3.06 0.37 0.1369 3
(Classrooms & Furniture )
5. Primary School 64 16 20 36 76 35 183 2.86 0.17 0.0289 5
( Classrooms & Furniture)
6. Market 74 15 46 42 36 65 204 2.76 0.07 0.0049 6
7. Water Supply 70 18 36 21 72 45 192 2.74 0.05 0.0025 7
8. Road (untarred) 65 14 34 57 48 15 168 2.58 -0.11 0.0121 8
9. Electricity 64 18 42 51 32 0 143 2.23 -0.46 0.2116 9
10. Recreational Centre/ 27 21 8 3 4 0 36 1.33 -1.36 1.8496 10
Playground
∑FCI 2.7534
=26.86
Mean = 26.86/10 = 2.69. Variance = 2.7534/10 = 0.2753. SD = (0.2753)0.5 = 0.5247.
Source: Author’s Computation, January 2008.
250
Correlates of Alcohol Consumption among Adolescents in Ibadan North

Local Government Area of Oyo State, Nigeria
Adebimpe A.Adenugba (Ph.D)
University of Ibadan Nigeria
Ibhade Omonigho Ijagbone (B.Sc)
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.251
Abstract: Alcohol consumption is a behavioural problem defined relative to age and is considered problematic below a certain
age or stage in life. Young people by virtue of their stage in development are likely to engage in drinking alcohol. The aim of the
paper is to examine the correlate of alcohol consumption among adolescents in Ibadan North Local Government area of Oyo
State, Nigeria. The paper was based on the social action theory and it adopted the survey design and multi-stage sampling
procedure to elicit information from 313 adolesce
nts. Some of the findings revealed that males were more predisposed to alcohol consumption.71.9% of males had drunk alcohol
compared to 32.5% females’ counterparts. Males who still drink alcohol prior to the study were higher than females (47.2%
compared to 15.8%). The hypothesis revealed that there was no significant relationship between peer pressure and alcohol
consumption. Another hypothesis revealed that marital status, high level of education mother’s occupation, father’s highest
education and father’s occupation had positive correlation with alcohol consumption. Ethnicity, religious affiliation, occupation,
persons living with and type of house showed a negative correlation toward alcohol consumption with only religion having a
significant relationship. This shows that socioeconomic status will jointly and independently affect alcohol consumption. The
paper concludes that males should be warned about the implications of alcohol consumption since they are likely to be more
predisposed to alcohol than females, career counselors must encourage students to abstain from high levels of alcohol
consumption so that they may be focused in life.
Keywords: Adolescents, alcohol consumption, peer influence, socio- economic status and correlates.
1.Introduction
Adolescence is a period of many transitions, which involves a process of confrontation with diverse tasks of
development and with demands on development. It is a time of change, exploration, exuberance and
youthful searching. Adolescents show marked changes in their social relationships sometimes leading to the
breaking away from the family. During adolescence, there is a sharp increase in the amount of behavior that
exposes a child to danger. Many adolescents prove resilient in the face of these challenges and demands;
on the other hand, many engage in risky health behavior and, for a minority, this risk-taking can have serious
adverse consequences. One of such behavior often initiated during adolescence is experimentation with
alcohol. Alcohol consumption, however, appears to be far from innocuous behavior and may have extensive
ramifications, affecting users’ physical, psychological, social, financial and economic well-being. Young
people, by virtue of their developmental status and their varied emotional and social needs, are less adept at
contending with these substances and are, therefore, more liable to experience a range of negative
outcomes.
251
The prevalent rate of alcohol consumption among adolescents in different parts of the world gives room
for concern. For instance, in the United States of America according to the National Youth Violence
Prevention (2000), it was reported that 52% of the eighth graders and 80% of the high school seniors have
taken alcohol at sometimes, 25% of the eight graders and 62% of high school seniors have been drunk. As
pointed out by Eastand (1990) cited in Adeyemo (2004), there are about 5 million habitual alcohol drinkers in
France. The situation in Nigeria shows that there is high prevalence of alcohol consumption among
adolescents and there is a high probability that the frequency of alcohol drinking will continue to increase
(Ogunremi and Rotimi, 1989 cited in Adeyemo, 2004) coupled with the fact that there is no legal minimum
age for drinking in the country.
Data on the long-term implications of such alcohol consumption are emerging while intoxication, memory
loss, violence and sexual risk-taking are associated with current patterns of adolescent alcohol consumption.
The sociological implications of alcohol abuse among the Nigerian adolescents have been a major threat to
the peaceful co-existence of all and sundry in this contemporary society, thereby destroying the socio-
political dignity, personality and integrity of dependence on life. The pertinent issue to raise therefore is- what
is it that is sustaining or reinforcing the consumption of alcohol among adolescents despite the awareness of
the potential dangers it constitutes to healthy living? The purpose of the present study is to examine the
likely determinants of the consumption of alcohol among adolescents by answering the following research
questions:
1.What are the key determinants of alcohol consumption among adolescents?
2.How do adolescents perceive alcohol?
3.Why do adolescents agree or refuse to drink alcohol?
4.What do adolescents understand about the implications of alcohol consumption?
5.How can adolescents’ knowledge of alcohol be managed?
2. Brief Literature Review
2.1 Determinants of alcohol consumption among adolescents
Steinberg (2002) argued that the high rate of alcohol consumption was due to changes in the family. Earlier
studies by Horton and Hunt (1980) mentioned the family as the basic social institution from which other
institutions have grown as increasing cultural complexity made them necessary. In light of these scholarly
studies, alcohol consumption can be understood in the context of the family. For Coon (1995), the quality of
mothering and fathering is of prime importance. Other scholars have shown that living in a family where
family members consume alcohol increases the chance that an adolescent has friends who drink alcohol
(Bahr, Marcos and Maughan,G 1995). Perceived availability is commonly associated with adolescent alcohol
use. Perceived availability and drinking volume appear to be shaped by the adolescents’ social environment.
Part of this social environment includes having siblings who drink. Based on the fact sheet of Institute of
Alcohol Studies on adolescents and alcohol (2009:10) it indicated that among the youngest adolescents the
usual drinking place was the home. As they grew older, they continued to drink at home, but the usual site of
their drinking shifted, first to parties, then to clubs and discos and finally to pubs
More generally, findings suggest that family structure has a moderate effect on youth substance use; that
parental and peer relations are better predictors than family structure of levels of alcohol consumption; and
that variations in parental attachment, parenting style, and peer relations across family types explain some,
but not all, of the effects of family structure on adolescents’ substance use behaviours (Crawford, 2008).
Family bonding has been repeatedly shown to be negatively related to adolescent drinking (Kuending and
Kuntschi, 2006). This is reflected in perceived monitoring, communication, involvement and joint activities in
the family. Family bonding can be defined as a feeling of closeness and intimacy towards one’s parents (Bahr
et al., 1995, Zhang et al., 1999 cited in Kuendig and Kuntschi, 2006). Researchers suggest that strong family
252
bonding is reflected in the adolescent’s adoption of parental and societal norms and values, which in turn
protect against involvement in risk behaviors (Bell et al ., 2000 cited in Kuendig and Kuntschi, 2006). Studies
have shown that parental death is associated with some negative attitudes in terms of alcohol consumption
which could be measured as number of drinks (Umberson and Chen (1994) cited in marks et al., 2007).
Umberson and Chen (1994) cited in Mark’s et al (2007) found that a father’s death was associated with a
greater increase in alcohol consumption over a period of 3 years than not experiencing a father’s death.
Many parents who drink excessively fail to establish strong family bonds as they tend to create high
levels of stress and emotional harm among other family members. Therefore, strong family bonds are not
easily developed, established and maintained in families where excessive drinking habits are
common(Eurocare and COFACE, 1998 cited in Kuendig and Kuntsche, 2006). Individuals with distant,
hostile, or conflicted family relationships are more likely to develop substance- abuse problems than their
peers who grow up in close nurturing families ( Steinberg, 2002). What differentiates children of alcoholics
who develop substance-abuse problems from those who do not has to do with the extent to which parent’s
alcoholism interferes with family functioning (Steinberg, 2002). Poor parenting increases the adolescents’
involvement in problem behavior overall which in turn is linked to alcohol consumption (Steinberg, 2002).
Improving the quality of family relationships and parenting attitude has been shown to be beneficial in
delaying the initiation of alcohol use (Spoth et al., 1999 cited in Kuendig and Kuntschi, 2006).
Studies have also shown that there is a substantial effect of socioeconomic background of adolescents on
alcohol consumption. Adolescents from the lowest occupational group had almost twice the odds of being a
large consumer than the highest occupational group (Droomers, et al 2003). The association between
father’s occupation and high alcohol consumption during adolescences was explained by friends’ approval of
alcohol consumption and lower parental attachment among adolescents from lower occupational groups
(Droomers, et al 2003). The consumption of alcohol in Mexico for instance has been linked with higher
socioeconomic status (SES); half of the alcohol consumed in the country is consumed by the 30% of the
population with the highest SES (Medina-Mora & Rojas Guiot, 2003 cited in Marsiglia, et al, 2009). Hogher
SES, which often is associated with higher parental levels of education, also appears to have an effect on
adolescent substance use. Higher level of education of the head of the house in Mexico are correlated with
higher adolescent substance use, especially for alcohol and tobacco (Felix-Ortiz et al, 2001; Medina-Mora,
Carreno, & De la Fuente, 1998; Medina-Mora & Rojas Guiot, 2003; Villatoro et al, 1998 cited in Marsiglia, et
al, 2009). Because higher levels of education are often associated with higher SES, increased levels of
alcohol use by adolescents may therefore be associated with easier acess to the money needed to purchase
those substances (Felix-Ortiz et al, 2001 cited in Marsiglia, et al 2009) and possibly with weaker anti-drug
norms present among higher SES families.
Apart from influence of parents, adolescents’ drinking behaviors has been shown to be enhanced by peer
groups, and their relationship with their peer groups (Yeh, 2006). It is primarily through interactions with peers
that adolescents learn to define substance use as an acceptable and desirable activity (Crawford and Novak,
2008). Best friend’s alcohol use has been shown to be the most important predictor of adolescents’ own
alcohol use in every sub-sample (Kemppainem, et al., 2008). Friends are presumed to exert a substantial
influence on young people’s drinking patterns. Schoor et al (2008) conducted a study to whether personality
traits and peer drinking affect alcohol consumption in young adults. Data were analyzed from a study that
was conducted in a ‘bar laboratory’ in which ad-lib drinking of peer groups was observed. The findings
indicated that personality was not associated with young adults’ actual alcohol consumption. Further, peer
drinking levels were strongly related to young adults’ drinking. They noticed that agreeableness interacted
with the effects of peer drinking on young adults’ drinking in such a way that agreeable individuals adapted
their actual alcohol consumption more easily than others when socializing in a high- or a low- drinking peer
group. They therefore concluded that drinking in a peer context, irrespective of personality, played a major
role in forming young adults’ drinking.
253
Adolescents who use alcohol are more likely to choose other alcohol users as friends but spending time
with friends who use these substance increases adolescents’ own use as well (Curran et al., 1997; Urbrerg,
Degirmenciglu, & Pilgrim, 1997 cited in Steinberg, 2002:186). It appears that to some extent when it comes to
anti-social behaviours birds of the same feather flock together (Steinberg, 2002:186).
2.2 Adolescents’ perception of alcohol
How people view alcohol and its effects also influences their drinking behavior including whether they begin
to drink and how much. An adolescent who expects drinking to be a pleasurable experience is more likely to
drink than one who does not. Studies have shown that perceived benefits and risks, grade level and
independence are directly associated with participation in alcohol-related activities (Hampson et al., 2001).
According to the Institute of Alcohol Studies (2009) most adolescents under 18 years view drinking positively.
They see it as a means of socializing with friends (62%) and increasing their confidence. The National
Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism (2006) indicated that beliefs about alcohol are established very
early in life, even before the child begins elementary school (15). The institute also reported that before age
9, children generally viewed alcohol negatively and saw drinking as bad, with adverse effects. By about age
13, their expectancies shifted, becoming more positive. It also indicated that adolescents who drank the
most, also placed the greatest emphasis on the positive and arousing effects of alcohol. This arousal effect
could be in terms of enhancing sexual performance (Adeniyi, 2009). The perception that nothing would
happen and that they had control over the situation is a common characteristic among adolescents, which
has contributed to a reduced risk perception and increased the consumption of alcohol (Gil et al, 2008).
A study conducted by Anderson (1999) among male adolescents, participants indicated that most of their
substance use was a natural, everyday acitivity, not requiring conscious thought or active decision making.
They said, “the comments of one teen participant exemplified those of many others. In his remarks about
beer he said “ just mellow you out… Kick back; drink a beer after a hard day… or whatever.” The participants
did not consider that drinking beer was a dangerous behavior requiring much thought or careful decision
making. A study conducted by Onohwosafe et al (2008) on drug use among secondary school children in
central Delta state, Nigeria, showed the students had little knowledge about the different drugs and their
effects.
2.3 Adolescents’ reasons for the acceptance or rejection of alcohol consumption
Many researchers feel that the need to belong in a group is very strong in adolescence. The compelling need
to fit into and belong to a group of friends may be motivating factors in alcohol use (Adeyemo, 2007:322).
This need is what many feel leads adolescents to partake in such risky behaviours (Wolf et al 1995) such as
alcohol use and abuse. Jessor and Jessor (1975) and Nash (1997) cited in Adeyemo D. A, (2007:321) found
out that adolescents consumed alcohol because they were exposed to it by their friends and peers. Similar
finding was made by Mcpherson (1997) cited in Adeyemo, 2007:322) who confirmed that peer pressure is
one of the factors that encouraged students to drink alcoholic beverage. Research on preparing styles and
alcohol use among non-Latinos also indicated that authoritative parenting was associated with less alcohol
use (Ennett et al., 2001; Lilja et al., 2003 cited in Cristina, 2009). Qualitative research suggest that individual
based reasons (such as changing mood, coping with stress and feeling happy), socially based reasons (such
as developing trust with friends) and peer influence explain why adolescents drink alcohol (Institute of Alcohol
Studies, 2009).
According to Percy (2008) adolescent substance use can be considered to be behavior that can be both
intrinsically motivated (i.e. it is an activity undertaken for its own pleasure or reward, for example, intoxication)
and extrinsically motivated (i.e it is not undertaken for it own pleasure but to attain some pleasure external to
the activity such as peer approval or increased social status. These factors are generally related to the
254
curiosity to achieve pleasure and satisfaction, relaxation from psychological tensions, facilitate socialization,
avoiding social pressure from a group, social isolation, family dynamics and low self-esteem (Gil et al, 2008).
Van Hecke (1995) cited in Adeyemo (2007), pointed out that the use of alcoholic beverages by adolescents is
often seen as a way to look more like adults. Many students use alcohol to establish status symbol and
attract the attention of colleaques especially the female students. This behavior emanates from a society that
seems helpless in the face of value decay that has engulfed the African traditional institution in the name of
globalization (Odekina, 2207). In a study conducted by Odekina (2007), on alcohol use among junior
secondary school students in Nigeria showed that 40% of the students have used alcohol at least once in
their life 26% drank an alcoholic beverage to the point of intoxication, 32% had used their own money to buy
an alcoholic drink for personal consumption in the past while 48% never had any contact with alcohol.
The influence of peer factor such as peer alcohol use, peer norms and susceptibility to peer pressure
have been found to account for significant variance in adolescent alcohol consumption (Schwarzer, 1996
cited in Adeyemo, 2007:322). Harmful health consequences of alcohol use and religious injunction are the
most prevalent reasons for abstinence among moslems (Moore and Weiss, 1994). Christians abstain mainly
because of the harmful effects of alcohol on health and dislike of its taste and / or smell (Moore and Weiss,
1994). Other reasons for this type of risky behavior in adolescents include attaining social maturity and
establishing identity (Benthin, et al 1993 cited in Adeyemo, 2007:322).
Lastly, explanation for the reasons why adolescents might refuse alcohol can be traced to their career
aspiration. This is because it is believed that alcoholism can have other direct effects on wages and can
affect career choices and stability (Macpherson, 1998). It has been shown that it is possible for alcoholic to
self-select into jobs that are less demanding, and therefore low paying. Alcoholics are likely to be less
concerned about their career. Therefore, alcoholics tend to gravitate towards jobs that require no great efforts
or are not taxing. In fact, there is evidence to support the hypothesis that alcohol and earnings have a
parabolic relationship (Macpherson, 1998). In other words, teetotaler and heavy drinkers both earn less than
moderate drinkers. It has been estimated that wages peak for individuals consuming an average of 2.40
drinks per day, which is consistent with the medical literature (Macpherson, 1998).
2.4 Adolescents’ knowledge of implications of alcohol consumption
Research suggests that from the age of about 12 or 13 years, young people are similar to adults in their
ability to identify and evaluate possible consequence of engaging in risky behavior (Fischoff et al, 1999 cited
in Dworkin, 2006). When youth drink they tend to drink intensively, often consuming four to five at one time.
The National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism (NIAAA) in 2006 defines “binge drinking as a pattern
of drinking alcohol that brings blood alcohol concentration (BAC) to 0.08 grams percent or above”. The
institute also indicated that people who reportedly started drinking before the age of 15 were four times more
likely to have met the criteria for alcohol dependence at some point in their lives (9). In fact, new research
shows that the serious drinking problems including what is called alcoholism) typically associated with middle
age actually begin to appear much earlier, during young adulthood and even adolescence. Research shows
that the brain keeps developing well into the twenties during which time it continues to establish important
communication connections and further refines its function. Scientists believe that this lengthy
developmental period may help explain some of the behavior which is characteristic of adolescence-such as
their propensity to seek out new and potentially dangerous situations (NIAAA, 2006). For some teens, thrill-
seeking might include experimenting with alcohol.
Developmental changes also offer a possible physiological explanation for why teens act so impulsively,
often not recognizing that their actions--such as drinking--have consequences (NIAAA, 2006). Adolescents
who drink the most also place the greatest emphasis on the positive and arousing effects of alcohol. The
National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism (2006) showed that the differences between the adult
brain and the brain of the maturing adolescent also may help to explain why many young drinkers are able to
255
consume much larger amounts of alcohol than adults by age 17 before experiencing the negative
consequences of drinking, such as drowsiness, lack of coordination, and withdrawal/hangover effects. This
unusual tolerance may help to explain the high rates of binge drinking among young adults. At the same
time, adolescents appear to be particularly sensitive to the positive effects of drinking, such as feeling more
at ease in social situations, and young people by ages 18 or 19 years may drink more than adults because
of these positive social experiences (NIAAA, 2006).
However with the exception of beer, students incorrectly define the volumes of standard servings of
alcohol, overestimating the appropriate volumes (White, 2005). They tend to overstate the appropriate
volumes, leading them to over pour drinks and underreport levels of consumption. Adolescents are more
likely than adults to list social consequences of engaging in or avoiding risky behavior. Teenager also report
engaging in behavior that they describe as more likely to have positive than negative consequence.
Research also shows that adolescents are more likely to see themselves as invulnerable (Fischoff, et al,
1999 cited in Dworkin, 2006). Adolescents’ involvement in risky behavior has often been attributed to the fact
that they see themselves as invulnerable-to bad consequences will not happen to them.
2.5 Management of adolescents’ knowledge of alcohol
Alcohol is not only legal, but its use is socially acceptable in Nigeria (Dimah and Gire, 2004). For most
cultures, alcohol is too engraved in the society to just get rid of it. So far there has not been any policy put in
place to manage adolescents’ knowledge of alcohol. What had been done so far to manage their knowledge
is basically a recommendation guiding policy formulation in relation to health. The Institute of Alcohol Studies
(2001) indicated primary prevention as a means to curbing alcohol problems, which may be achieved by
encouraging, through education and other means, a more healthy approach to the use of alcohol and its
place in society. It also noted that alcohol use should be more effectively integrated into social and family
life, so that it becomes an adjunct to other activities rather than an end in itself, and the mystique surrounding
alcohol use is reduced. Restrictions on hours of sale, age of legal consumption and so on may be counter
productive, as they are likely to act as impediments to integrated, healthy drinking attitudes and practices.
3. Theoretical Position
3.1 Social Learning Theory
This theory posits that people learn from one another, via observation, imitation, and modeling. People learn
through observing others’ behavior, attitudes, and outcomes of those behaviors. Most human behavior is
learned observationally through modeling: from observing others, one forms an idea of how new behaviours
are performed, and on later occasions this coded information serves as a guide for action. Bandura
suggested that the environment also reinforces modeling in different ways. First the observer is reinforced by
the model. For example a student who changes his or her dress code to fit in with a certain group of students
has a strong likelihood of being accepted and thus reinforced by that group. Secondly, the imitated behavior
itself leads to reinforcing consequences. Many behaviors that we learn from others produce satisfying or
reinforcing results. For example, a student in a multimedia class could observe how the extra work a
classmate does is fun. This student in turn would do the same extra work and also receive enjoyment.
Lastly, consequences of the model’s behavior affect the observer’s behavior vicariously. This is known as
vicarious reinforcement. This is where the model is reinforced for a response and then the observer shows
an increase in that same response. Bandura illustrated this by having students watch a film of a model hitting
an inflated clown doll. A group of children saw the model being praised for such action. Without being
reinforced, the group of children began to also hit the doll. The incidence of substance use among
adolescents is high. It has been suggested that alcohol consumption during adolescence is almost always a
256
social experience and a learned behavior (Ench A. U and Stanley P.C, 2004) and which often times takes
place in schools.
Relating Bandura’s postulation to the subject matter of this study, this theory can help explain why in
order to gain information or access to opportunities that a peer group provides and enjoy social and
emotional support, an adolescent who was never an alcohol user suddenly starts drinking so as to fit into a
group of students who share the same characteristics in terms of age and the same sex. Also, receives
enjoyment in drinking after observing how members of his peer group have fun when drinking socially.
Lastly, drinks alcohol because the friends he is imitating are always being motivated for their drinking habits
not minding the risk involved. This motivation could be in the form of shouting, hailing and praising or inviting
such a person to chair a party.
Adolescents observe the drinking motives of their peer group observe the rewarding consequences
obtained by their peer group and then model the motives displayed by their peers. For example, those who
go out with friends who drink for social motives might also learn to drink for the same motives themselves
due to observation and imitation of these peer motives. It is also important to note that reinforcement and
punishment influences the extent to which an individual performs an action. In other words, it influences the
rate at which youths drink. This means that an adolescent who is punished in school or at home for drinking
alcohol will not stop that action but reduce the frequency at which he drinks. Nigeria is a country where
millions of people do not have the usual or socially acceptable amount of money or material possession
where only a few people are comfortable. As a result, adolescents who are inflicted by this crisis who have
friends who drink and at the same time are rich, try to learn their behavior. The reason is to gain their
approval and also have a portion of these resources from their friends.
4. Description of study area
Ibadan North Local Government Area of Oyo state was the area the research took place. It is one of the
Local government area in Ibadan region, it was the founded by the Federal Military Government of Nigeria on
27th September 1991. It lies between longitude 4’53E and 4’55W. it is the largest local government in Ibadan
with a land area of 145.58km2 which is approximately 4.66% the total land area of the city. This geographic
space is one of the local governments in Ibadan municipal. It is used to be a relatively dormant place but
received more attention all of a sudden in terms of development because its location in the state capital of
Oyo-state. This area is a host to many educational centers in Nigeria. It has over 100 secondary school,
more than 300 primary school a polytechnic and the University of Ibadan (Filani, Akintola, and Ikporukpo,
1994:77)
5. Methodology
The Survey Research Design was adopted for this study while the questionnaire was the only instrument
used in gathering data. The population comprised of entire adolescents (ages 10 – 19) in Ibadan North Local
Government of Oyo State, Nigeria. The Sample size of 432 was drawn from the entire population of males
and females from six (6) communities within the twelve (12) wards in the Local Government Area.
Two Sampling techniques were adopted for this study. The stratified sampling technique was used to
group the local government into Wards and six (6) communities were randomly selected out of the twelve
(12) Wards within the Local Government. Secondly, the purposive sampling technique was used in selecting
the respondents based on their age. The Sample Size of four hundred and thirty (432) consisting of seventy
– two (72) respondents from each of the six (6) selected communities. The samples were made up of two
hundred and thirty – two males (232) and two hundred (200) females.
The instrument for data collection was the questionnaire and this was because the adolescents were not
willing to discuss freely or openly their involvement in alcohol consumption. This ruled out the possibility of
257
using the interview method to elicit information on the study.

However the data gathered from the use of questionnaires were analysed using the Statistical Package
for the Social Sciences. The descriptive statistics of frequencies and percentages was used to analyze all
sections of the questionnaire. The inferential statistics of multiple regression and chi-square were used to
analyse variables on social and demographic characteristics and reasons for alcohol consumption. The
decision criterion for accepting or rejecting the hypothesis was set at 0.05 level of significance. The chi-
square statistics and regression were chosen for being appropriate because of its usefulness for establishing
the degree of relationship among the test items and testing of the influence of the independent variables on
the dependent variable (alcohol consumption).
6. Discussions and Presentation of Results
Four hundred and thirty two (432) copies of the study questionnaire were administered out of which three
hundred and thirteen (313) were filled correctly. The data analysis was therefore based on this final figure.
6.1 Social and demographic characteristics of the respondents
This segment discusses the social and demographic characteristics of the respondents. Table 1 shows the
frequency distribution of the respondents’ social and demographic characteristics. It shows that 36.4% of the
respondents are females while 63.6% are males. This shows that more males participated in the study
probably due to the patriarchal dominance in the study area. Data on the respondents’ marital status shows
that 98.4% were not married and 0.3% were separated or divorced. This large proportion of the unmarried
respondents is expected given the fact that only adolescents participated in the study area, where the
average age for marriage is between 22-25 years for females and 25-30 years for males. This shows that
because they are adolescents they are yet to acquire the basic necessities of life and might still be under
parental control.
The mean age of the respondents was 17.2 years though their ages ranged from 13-20 years. This
findings show that respondents in their late adolescence dominated the study. Concerning the respondents’
ethnicity 72.8% were Yoruba and 1% were Hausas. The explanation for this could be due to the fact that
they study area is largely dominated by the Yorubas. The respondents’ religious affiliation shows that 55.9%
are Christians and 0.3% claimed to be traditional worshippers. This implies that majority of this Christians
are likely to abstain from alcohol consumption mainly because of its harmful effects on health and dislike of
its taste and/or smell (Moore and Weiss, 1994). The respondents’ occupation shows that 90.1% were
students and 0.1% indicated they were farmers. This implies that people now know the worth of education.
Also, the governments’ policy on Universal Basic Education is a likely explanation for the predominance of
the respondents who claimed to be students. Also, the respondents’ education shows that majority which
constitutes 51.9% are still in secondary school and 0.6% indicated others for whose education did not fall
within the option stated. This implies that majority of the respondents’ are not likely to be drinking alcohol.
Data on the respondents’ income shows that only 82 gave information about their monthly income. The
reason for this could be that the parents, sponsors or self do not think there is any need for it and that they
are capable of settling their expenses as they arise. The data also shows that 43.9% earned below N2,000
and 3.7% earned between N4,001 and N6,000 per month. This result could be because of the fact that
majority of the respondents are students and parents/guardian do not believe in exposing their children to
huge amount of money. Income in the context of this study refers to all money available to the respondents
through their parents, sponsors or self. The data concerning the respondents’ living arrangement shows that
71.9% lived with their mother and father and 0.65 lived with their spouse. This implies that majority of the
respondents are still young to afford an apartment of their own. It also implies that the respondents’ are
unlikely to develop substance-abuse problems (Steinberg, 2002). However, some studies have recorded the
258
situation in which children indulge in delinquent act including alcoholism at young age despite their parental
control. Family disorganization is likely to be a major cause of such situation.
Table 1: The Respondents’ Social and Demographic Characteristics
CHARACTERISTICS CATEGORIES FREQUENCY PERCENT

Sex Female 114 36.4
Male 199 63.6
Total 313 100
Marital status Not married 307 98.4
Married 4 1.3
Separated/divorced 1 .3
Total 312 100
Age(years) 13 3 1.0
14 24 7.7
15 31 9.9
16 50 16.0
17 52 16.6
18 65 20.8
19 74 23.6
20 14 4.5
Total 313 100
Mean: 17.2
SD: 1.7
Ethnicity Hausa 14 4.5
Igbo 52 16.7
Yoruba 227 72.8
Others 19 6.1
Total 312 100.0
Religious affiliation Christianity 174 55.9
Islam 136 43.7
Traditional 1 .3
Total 311 100.0
Occupation Student 282 90.1
Self-employed 22 7.0
Private sector 4 1.3
Public sector/civil servant 1 .3
Unemployed 3 1.0
Farming 1 .3
Total 313 100.0
Highest level of education Primary 7 2.2
Secondary(Completed) 141 45.2
Other 162 51.9
Total 2 .6
312 100.0
Monthly income() N0-N2,000 36 43.9
N2,001-N4,000 13 15.9
N4,001-N6,000 3 3.7
>N6,000 30 36.6
Total 82 100.0
Living arrangement Mother 23 7.3
Father 16 5.1
Mother and father 225 71.9
Spouse 2 .6
Relative 15 4.8
Friends 11 3.5
Self 17 5.4
Others 4 1.3
Total 313 100.0
259
6.2 Respondents’ parental background characteristics
This segment discusses the respondents’ parental background. Table 2 shows the frequency distribution of
the respondents’ parental background characteristics. The data on respondents’ mothers’ highest education
shows that 30.1% had been to the university and 6.4% which constituted the least had only primary
education. This implies that majority of their mothers are educated. The finding on father’s highest education
shows that 42.8% had been to the university and 4.1% have had only primary education. This implies that
their social status is likely to affect the respondents’ type and frequency of alcohol consumption. The
respondents’ mother’s occupation shows that 49.8% were self-employed and 0.6% indicated they were
students. This implies that majority of them are not working for the government but engaging in an activity in
order to earn income. It also means that they are able to monitor the activities of their children or wards
thereby not exposing them to risky behavior. Considering respondents’ father’s occupation, 37.4% constitute
the private sector and 0.7% constitutes the unemployed. This also implies that majority of them are not
working for the government. The bar chart in figure 2 and figure 3 compares the father and mother status
using their occupation. It shows that the fathers’ status is higher than the mothers’ status considering the fact
that majority of the fathers work in private sector and therefore has stable income. The data also shows that
50.3% of the respondents which constituted the majority indicated they lived in a flat or duplex and
21.320.4% which constituted the least indicated they lived in a single room or room and parlour. This
indicates that majority of the respondents’ parent can afford to live in a flat or duplex taking into cognizance
that such residences are more expensive than a single room and self contained house.
Table 2: Respondents’ Parental Background Characteristics

PARENTAL CHARACTERISTICS CATEGORIES FREQUENCY PERCENT
Mothers’ highest level Primary 12 4.1
of education Secondary 38 13.1
Polytechnic/College of Education
University 57 19.7
Postgraduate 124 42.8
Total 59 20.3
296 100
Fathers’ highest level Primary 12 4.1
of education Secondary 38 13.1
Polytechnic/College of Education
University 57 19.7
Postgraduate 124 42.8
Total 59 20.3
290 100
Mothers’ Occupation Student 5 .6
Self-employed 155 49.8
Public sector 67 21.5
Unemployed 3 1.0
Others 15 4.8
Total 311 100.0
Fathers’ Occupation Self-employed 96 31.5
Public sector 77 25.2
Unemployed 2 .7
Others 16 5.2
Total 305 100.0
Residence/dwelling unit Single room/room
and parlour 64 21.3
self contained 85 28.3
Flat/duplex 151 50.3
Total 300 100.0
260
6.3 Respondents’ awareness and knowledge of alcohol consumption
The frequency table in this segment shows the awareness and knowledge of alcohol consumption among
adolescents. It indicates that 57.5% have drunk alcohol while 42.5% have never drunk alcohol. Also, 37.2%
indicated ‘yes’ to the question if they still drank alcohol while 62.8% indicated ‘no’ to the question. This drop
in the percentage of those who have drunk alcohol to those who still drink could imply that the possible
consequences of drinking alcohol have been identified and evaluated (Fischoff et al, 1999 cited in Dworkin,
2006). Those who still adhered to alcohol consumption have defined the substance as desirable and
acceptable through the interaction with their peers (Crawford and Novak, 2008). It also indicates that despite
the fact that majority of the respondents live with their mother and father, some of them still drink alcohol.
This could imply that it is either their parents are aware of it or alcohol is consumed without their knowledge.
The data on the respondents’ perception of the best age to drink alcohol shows that 67.6% of the
respondents were of the view that drinking should start between 16 and 20 years and 9.6% were of the view
that drinking should start from 26 years. This finding implies that majority of the respondents are of the view
that the ability to exhibit self control when drinking alcohol starts from late adolescence (Blakemore &
Choudhury, 2006; Posner & Rothbart, 2000; Wiers et al., 2007 cited in Percy, 2008).
Considering the respondents’ experience of place of first alcohol drink, 40.9% which constituted the
largest proportion indicated that they first consumed alcohol at a party, while the least which constituted 1.2%
indicated that they consumed it from a church. This means that adolescents can be exposed to alcohol at
parties either through their peers or friends. The data on best time to drink alcohol shows that 51% believe
that the best time to drink alcohol is in the evening while 4.3% believe in the morning. This implies that
alcohol is viewed as a substance which has a sedative effect capable of making one feel less anxious or
more relaxed.
Table 3: The respondents’ awareness and knowledge of alcohol consumption

AWARENESS AND CATEGORIES FREQUENCY PERCENT
KNOWLEDGE
Ever drunk alcohol Yes 180 57.5
No 133 42.5
Total 313 100.0
Still drinking alcohol Yes 112 37.2

No 189 62.8
Total 301 100.0
Best age to start drinking alcohol <16years 14 10.3

16-20 years 92 67.8
21-25 years 17 12.5
>25 years 13 9.6
Total 136 100.0
Place of first alcoholic drink Home 28 11.6
Party 99 40.9
Friends 39 16.1
Bought it 15 6.2
Church 3 1.2
Others 58 24.0
Total 242 100.0
Best time to drink alcohol Morning 11 4.3

Afternoon 18 7.1
Evening 130 51.0
Anytime 41 16.1
Others 54 21.2
Total 254 100.0
261
6.4 The respondents’ predisposition to alcohol consumption
Table 4 below shows that 54.9% of the respondents are of the belief that one can be asked to drink alcohol
against one’s desire while 45.1% are of the belief that one cannot be asked to drink alcohol against one’s
desire. This implies that in order to fit into a group it is possible to accept an alcoholic drink against ones
desire. This agrees with the findings of Adeyemo (2007) who indicated that the compelling need to fit into
and belong to a group of friends may be a motivating factor in alcohol use. The data also shows that 60.9%
of the respondents are of the belief that it is good to refuse alcohol from closest friends while 39.1% are of
the belief that it is not good to refuse alcohol from closest friend. The implies that friends are presumed not
to exert a substantial influence in young people’s drinking patterns. This finding is contrary to the study
conducted by Kemppainen’s et al (2008). They indicated that best friend’s alcohol use has been shown to be
the most important predictor of adolescents’ own alcohol use in every sub-sample (Kemppainen, et al.,
2008). The data also shows that 54% of the respondents believe that one can be abused or laughed at if one
refused alcohol while 46% believe that one cannot be abused or laughed at if one refused alcohol. This
implies that an adolescent is likely to drink alcohol when pressure is exerted.
Furthermore, 67.2% of the respondents are of the belief that it is good not to drink alcohol even if one is
the only one who is not drinking among friends while 32.8% believe that it is good to drink alcohol even if one
is the only one who is not drinking among friends. The reason for the latter figure could be due to the
perception ‘that everyone is drinking’ (Adeyemo, 2007) or might imply the need to attain peer approval or
increased social status (Percy, 2008). The data also shows that 58.3% of the respondents believe that one
cannot be discouraged by friends not to drink alcohol while 41.7% are of the belief that one can be
discouraged by friends not to drink alcohol. This implies that majority of the respondents do not believe that
an adolescent is not likely to be stopped by his friends from drinking alcohol.
Concerning the respondents’ data on belief that alcohol will not help one get along with close friends,
78.3% indicated that alcohol will not help one get along with close friends while 21.7% indicated that alcohol
will help one get along with close friends. This implies that the compelling need to fit into and belong to a
group of friends may not be a motivating factor in alcohol use. In addition, 78.4% were of the belief that
alcohol will not make friends like you while 21.6% were of the belief that alcohol will make friends like you.
This implies that majority of the respondents do not belief that alcohol consumption can be used to facilitate
socialization. Also, 63.5% respondents believe that alcohol consumption will not make one look matured
while 36.5% believe that alcohol consumption will make one look matured. This implies that majority of the
respondents do not view drinking alcohol as a way of attaining maturity. This is contrary to the study
conducted by Benthin, et al, (1993) cited in Adeyemo (2007) who indicated that one of the reasons
adolescents engage in risky behavior is to attain social maturity. The data also shows that 85.8% of the
respondents believe that alcohol drinking is not because of being shy while 14.2% believe that alcohol
drinking is because of being shy. This implies that majority of the respondents view drinking alcohol as a
natural or day to day activity, not requiring any conscious thought (Anderson, 1999). Lastly, 69.9% of the
respondents believe that alcohol drinking is not because of being bold while 30.1% believe that alcohol
drinking is because of being bold. This also implies that majority of the respondents believe that drinking
alcohol is like a natural or day to day activity which requires no conscious thought.
Table 4: The respondents’ predisposition to alcohol concumption
CATEGORIES FREQUENCY PERCENT

Belief that one can be asked to drink alcohol No 137 43.8
against one’s desire Yes 167 53.4
Total 304 100
Belief that it is good to refuse alcohol from No 119 39.1
closest friend Yes 185 60.9
Total 304 100.0
262
Belief that one can be abused or No 138 46.0

laughed at if one refused alcohol Yes 162 54.0
Total 300 100.0
Belief that one can be abused or No 138 46.0
laughed at if one refused alcohol Yes 162 54.0
Total 300 100.0
Belief that it is good not to drink No 100 32.8
alcohol even if one is the only one Yes 205 67.2
who is not drinking among friends Total 305 100.0
Belief that one can be discouraged No 175 58.3
by friends form drinking alcohol Yes 125 41.7
Total 100 100.0
Belief that alcohol will not help one No 65 21.7
get along with close friends Yes 235 78.3
Total 300 100.0
Belief that alcohol will not make No 65 21.6
friends like you Yes 236 78.4
Total 301 100.0
Belief that alcohol consumption will No 110 36.5
not make one look matured Yes 191 63.5
Total 301 100.0
Belief that alcohol drinking is not No 43 14.2
because of being shy Yes 260 85.8
Total 303 100.0
Belief that alcohol drinking is not No 90 30.1
because of being bold Yes 209 69.9
Total 299 100.0
6.5 Gender and alcohol consumption
Table 5 below shows that 67.5% of the female respondents have not drunk alcohol while 71.9% of the male
respondents have drunk alcohol. The chi-square tests show that there is a significant relationship between
gender and alcohol consumption. Table 4.5.2 indicates that 79.8% of the females do not still drink alcohol
while 47.2% of the male respondents still drink alcohol. It also shows that 4.4% of the female respondents
and 3.5% of the male respondents did not respond probably due to the fact that they do not drink. The chi-
square test result shows that there is significant relation between gender and adolescents who still drink
alcohol. This means that the higher the population of males the higher the propensity to drink alcohol. The
findings shown above imply that drinking alcohol is more acceptable among males than among females in
the Nigerian society. This also implies that if the females are questioned on whether they drink alcohol, they
are likely to report that they do not drink alcohol.
Table 5: Gender and history of alcohol consumption

have you ever drank alcohol *sex crosstabulation
SEX TOTAL
FEMALE MALE
Ever drunk Yes Count
Alcohol 37 143 180
% with in sex 32.5% 71.9% 57.5%
No Count 77 56 133
% within sex 67.5% 28.1% 42.5%
Total Count 114 199 313
% within sex 100.0% 100.0% 100.0%
CHI-SQUARE TEST
VALUE
Df Asymp.sig (2-sided)
Pearson Chi-Square 46.051(b) 1 .000
Contingency .358
263
Table 5.1: Gender and regular alcohol consumption

do you still drink alcohol *sex crosstabulation
GENDER TOTAL
FEMALE MALE
Still drinking Yes 18 94 112
% within sex 15.8% 47.2% 35.8%

No Count 91 98 189
% within sex 79.8% 49.2% 60.4%
No Count
Response 5 7 12
% within sex 4.4% 3.5% 3.8%
% within sex 100.0% 100.0% 100.0%
CHI-SQUARE TESTS
Value Df Asymp.sig
(2-sided)
Pearson Chi-Square 31.396(b) 2 .000
Contingency coefficient .302
6.6 The respondents’ understanding of the implication of alcohol consumption
Table 5.1 indicates that 19.3% of the respondents had experienced effects from drinking alcohol while 80.7%
of the respondents had not experienced any effect from drinking alcohol. This implies that majority of the
respondents have little knowledge of alcohol and its effect (Onohwosafe et al 2008). It also implies that even
with these effects some of these respondents still drink alcohol. These effects could also help explain why
some of the respondents who have drunk alcohol stop drinking. Some of these effects as indicated by the
respondents as indicated in table 4.5 include unconsciousness (24.1%), unruly behavior (2.2%), and
dizziness (22.2%) and body pain (13.0%).
6.7 Hypotheses Testing
HYPOTHESIS ONE: There is a significant association between peer influence and alcohol consumption.
Table 7 (A) shows that respondents who have ever drunk alcohol and who believe that one can be
discouraged by friends from drinking alcohol constitute 69.6% while respondents who believe that one cannot
be discouraged by friends from drinking alcohol and who have drunk alcohol constitute 50.3%. On the other
hand, respondents who have never drunk alcohol and who believe that one can be discouraged by friends
from drinking alcohol is higher (49.7%) compared to respondents who believe that one can be discouraged
from drinking alcohol (30.4%). Explanations for this abstinence from alcohol could be due to strict parental
control or ones religious affiliation. The table also tests the relationship between respondents who have ever
drunk alcohol and peer influence. The table shows that there is a significant relationship between
respondents who have ever drunk alcohol and peer influence (X2 = 11.191, p=0.001<0.05). This implies that
peer influence can encourage an adolescent from tasting or having drunk alcohol.
The findings above indicate that it is possible for an adolescent’s friend to initiate first alcoholic drink. This
can be possible if there is absence of alcoholic drinks in the home and the need to have a taste of one or it
could be due to the adolescent’s religion which might have prevented him or her from having a taste of this
alcoholic drink. This is because certain religions do not accept one to drink alcohol. Also, it could be due to
the advertisement of the alcoholic beverages that are displayed on the media such as the advertisement of
Guinness that would have initiated the urge to drink alcohol. As a result peers or friends who might be
celebrating their birthday and with the disposition of alcoholic beverages by the parents of the celebrant
264
would have been encouraged by the friend to have a taste of alcohol or just drink for once by the celebrant,
considering the fact that majority of the respondents indicated getting their first drink from a party. Even
within the party, the adolescent might have been referred to as a ‘baby’ which would have been
embarrassing and in order to prove them wrong ends up engaging in this act.
Another explanation for this could be due to the imitation of close friends who are seen as role models.
This means that to be like these role models one will tend to imitate there behavior or personality by drinking
alcohol if they drink and not drinking if they do not.
Table 5.2 (b): The cross tabulation of respondents who still drink alcohol and peer influence
Belief that one can Total

be discouraged
by friends not to drinking alcohol
No Yes
Do you still drink Yes Count 65 45 110
alcohol % within belief that one can be 37.1% 36.0% 36.7%
discouraged by friends not to drink alcohol
No Count 105 75 180
%within belief that one can be discouraged 60.0% 60.0% 60.0%
by friends not to drink alcohol
%within belief that one can be discouraged 100.0% 100.0% 100.0%
by friends not to drink alcohol
CHI-SQUARE TEST
Value Df Asymp.Sig(2 -
sided)
Pearson Chi-square .312 2 .856
Likelihood Ratio .308 2 .857
Linear-by-Linear Association 300 1 .580
N of Valid Cases
a. 1 cell (16.7%) have expected count less than5. The minimum expected count is 4.17
6.8 Socio-economic background and alcohol consumption
HYPOTHESIS TWO: Socio-economic background will jointly and independently influence alcohol
consumption among adolescent.
Using regression analysis, the P value (P=0.006)<0.05. This shows that socio-economic background
(type of house, father’s occupation, sex, ethnic, marital status, occupation, living arrangement, mother’s
highest education, religious affiliation, highest level of education, mother’s occupation, father’s highest
education) jointly and independently influences the alcohol consumption. However in table using chi-square
test it indicates that it is only religious affiliation that independently influences alcohol consumption. This is
because P (0.03) <0.05. The relationship between these two variables is negative. This means that the
more religious parents or guardians are the more they are likely to discourage their children or wards from
drinking alcohol. This can account for the reason why some adolescents do not drink alcohol. One of the
values preached by religion is obedience to parents/obedience. Therefore in order to abide by this and not
be recognized as a deviant, most adolescent will want to obey particularly when they have been warned by
their parents or wards or religious leaders from drinking alcohol.
265
Table 5.3: The determinant of alcohol consumption
Model Sum Df Mean Square F Sig.

of Squares
1 Regression 79.572 12 6.631 2.411 .006(a)
Residual 651.886 237 2.751
Total 731.457 249
A. predictors: (constant), type of house, father’s occupation, sex ethnic, marital status, occupation, persons
living with, mother’s highest education, religious affiliation, highest level of education, mother’s occupation,
father’s highest education.
B. Dependent Variable: Alcohol Scale.
Coefficients (a)
Model Unstandardized standardized t Sig

Coefficients Coefficients
B Std.Error Beta
1 (Constant) 7.109 1.444 4.923 .000
Sex -.379 .243 -.107 -1.560 .120
Ethnic -.198 .173 -.073 -1.138 .256
Religious affiliation -.498 .228 -.148 -2.185 .030
Occupation -.281 .210 -.087 -1.335 .183
Marital status .405 .733 .036 .553 .581
Highest level of education .351 .208 .116 1.684 .093
Living arrangement -.128 .078 -.108 1.642 .102
Mother’s highest education
-.047 .121 -.032 -.389 .698
Mother’s occupation -006 .109 .004 .054 .957

Father’s highest education .029 .123 .019 .232 .817
Father’s occupation .074 .094 .053 .788 .432
Type of house -.042 .078 -.035 -539 .590
HYPOTHESIS THREE: There is a positive correlation between volume of alcohol consumed and career
aspiration
The table below shows the cross tabulation of maximum quantity that can be consumed by adolescents
and career aspiration of respondents which has been categorized into professional and non-professional
aspiration. It shows that respondent who drink less than one bottle of drink in a day and who have
aspirations which are non-professional constitute 23.2% which is higher compared to those who desire to
have aspirations within professional ambition, 33.3% compared to 17.7%. There are 12.1% respondents
who indicated that they can drink between four to five bottles of alcohol and who desire to be non-
professionals in life compared to 4.8% respondents who desire to be professionals in life. Lastly, 12.1% who
can drink more than five bottles of drinks and who desire to be non-professionals in life is higher compared to
3.2% of the respondents who desire to be professionals in life. This is consistent with the findings indicated
by MacPherson (1998), alcoholics tend to gravitate towards jobs that require no great efforts or are not
taxing.
266
Table 5:4 The cross tabulation of ambition and alcohol cosumption
Ambition
Professional Non-Professional Total
Maximum <1 Count 46 14 60
Quantity
(Volumes in % within ambition 74.2% 42.4% 63.2%
bottles)
2-3 Count 11 11 22
% within ambition 17.7% 33.3% 23.2%

4-5 Count 3 4 7

>5 Count 2 4 6

% within ambition 100.0% 100.0% 100.0%

CHI-SQUARE
value Df Asmp.sig(2-
sided)
Pearson Chi-square 9.951a 3 .019
Likelihood Ratio 9.812 3 .020
Linear-by-Linear Association 8.923 1 .003
N of Valid Cases 95
A. 4 cells (50.0%) have expected count less than 5. The minimum expected
count is 2.08.
7 Conclusion
Adolescence is a transitional stage of physical and mental human development that occurs between
childhood and adulthood. It is a period when every child look forward to and has the belief that they are no
longer children. This predisposes them to certain risk behavior such as alcohol consumption which has been
discussed above. The influence of socioeconomic status is very important in explaining why adolescents are
predisposed to alcohol consumption which determine to a large extent who an adolescent would be or
become in generations to come.
References
Abiola, F.( 2001). Handbook on Ibadan North Local Government. Ibadan: Segab Press.
Adeyemo, D. A. (2007). Interpersonal Factors as Correlates of Alcohol Use among Secondary School Adolescents in Oyo State,
Nigeria. Anthropologist 9(4):321-326. Retrieved Oct. 8, 2008 from www.krepublishers.com/02-Journals/T-Anth/Anth -09-0-000-
2007.../Anth-09-4-321-07-411-Adeyemo-D-A-Tt.pdf.
Adeniyi, S. January 8, (2009). Your Health: Reasons some men Collapse during sexual activities. The Tribune Newspaper, Nigeria.
Agber, D. and Gire, J. G. (2004). The Health and Economic Consequences of alcohol use on Central Nigeria. African Journal of Drug
and Alcohol Studies 3(1&2). Retrieved March 5, 2009 from http://indesmedicus. Afro.who.int/iah/fulltext/pages%202005vol4-4.
Pdf.
Anderson, N.L.R. (1999). Perception about substance Use among male adolescents in Juvenile Detention. Western Journal of Nursing
Research 21(50: 652-672. Retrieved April 29, 2009. Retrieved April 29, 2009 from http://wjn.
Sagepub.com/cgi/content/abstract/21/5/652.
Bahr, S. J., Marcos, A.C. and Maughan, S. L. (1995). Family, educational and Peer influences on the Alcohol Use of Female and Male
Adolescents, Journal of Studies on Alcohol vol.56, No.4: 457 – 469. Retrieved March 1, 2009 from http://cat.inist.fr/? A
Modele=afficheN and cpsidt=3590608.
267
Cohen, G. L. and Prinstein., M. J.( 2007). Peer Contagion of Affression and health-rsk behavior adolescent males: The Experimental
Investigation of Effects on Public conduct and Private Attitude. Child Development Vol.77, Issue 4. Retrieved March 5, 2009
from http:// www.unc.ed/--mjp1970/Publications/Cohen%20&%20Prinstein, %202006.pdf.
Cristina, M. (2008). The Influence of parental Warmth and Control on Latino Adolescent Alcohol Use. Hispanic Journal of Behavioural
Sciences Vol.30: 89-105. Retrieved April 15, 2009 from http:/hjb sagepub.com/cgi/reprint/30/1/89.
Droomers, M. Schrijvers, C. Casswell, S. and Mackenbach, (2003). Occupational level of the father and alcohol consumption during
adolescence; patterns and predictors, Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health 57.9: 704-710. Retrieved April 15, 2009
from http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi? Artid=1732575.
Dworkin, J. (2006). Teen Decision Making about Risky Behaviour. Research Background for Facilitators. Retrieved May 28, 2009 from
http://www.extension.umn.edu/distribution/family development/cpmponents/8210 background.pdf.
Gil, H., Mello, D., Ferriani, M. and Silva, M. (2008). Perception of adolescents Student on the Consumption of Drugs: A case Study in
Lima, Peru. Rev. Latino-Am. Enfermagem vol.16: 551-557. Retrieved 12, 2009 from
http://www.scielo.php?pid=so10411692008000700008&script=sci_artte xt.
Nigeria Galleria. (2004). Nigeria Information Guide. Retrieved May 25, 2009 from
http://www.nigeriagalleria.com/Nigeria/States_Nigeria/Oyo_State.html.
Hampson, S. E. (2001). Risk Perception, Personality Factors and Alcohol Use among Adolescents. Personality and Individual
Differences Vol.30, Issue 15: 167-181. Retrieved April 11, 2009 from linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pil/so 30640304000498.
Institute of Alcohol Studies Fact Sheet, 2009. Adolescents and Alcohol. Retrieved May, 2009 from
http://www.ias.org.uk/resources/factsheets/adolescents.pdf.
Kemppainen, U., Tossavainen, K., Vartianen, E., Jokela, V., Puska, P., Pantelejev, V., and Uhanov, M. (2008). Environmental Factors
as Predictors of Alcohol use among Ninth-Grade Adolescents in Pitka”ranta (Russian Karelia) and in Eastern Finland.
Scandinavian Journal of Public Health 36: 769-777. Retrieved April 26, 2001 from http://sjp.sagepub.com/cgi/reprint/36/7/769.
Kuendig, H and Kuntschi, E. (2006). Family Bonding and Adolescent Alcohol Use: Moderating Effect of Living with Excessive Drinking
Parents. Alcohol and Alcoholism 41. 4: 464-471. Retrieved April 10, 2009 from http://www.oxfordjournals.org/our
journals/alcalc/about.html.
Macpherson. N. (1998). The Effect of Alcoholism on Earning Capacity, Economica Newletter. Retrieved May 26, 2009 from
http://www.economica.ca/ew03_2p/.htm.
Marsiglia,F. F., Kulis, S., Rodriguez, M. G., Becerra, D. and Castillo, J. (2009). Culturally specific Youth Substance Abuse Resistance
Skills: Applicability across the U.S.- Mexico Border. Research on Social Work Practice 19. 2: 152 – 164. Retrieved April 28,
2009 from http://rsw. Sagepub.com/cgi/reprint/19/2/152.
Marks, N. F., Jun, H. and Song, J. (2007). Death of Parents and Psychological and physical Well-Being: A Prospective U. S. National
Study. Journal of Family Issues 28(12): 1611-1638. Retrieved May 26, 2009 from
htt://www.pubmedccentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=2638056.
Moore, M. and Weiss, S. (1995). Reasons for Non-Drinking among Isreali Adolescents of four Religions. Drug and Alcohol Dependence
Vol.38, Issue 1: 45-50. Retrieved April 15, 2009 from linkinghub. elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/03768716995011047.
National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, (2006). Underage Drinking-why do adolescents Drink, What are the Risks and How
can Underage Drinking be prevented No.67. Retrieved April 15, 2009 from http://pubs.niaaa.nih.gov/publications/AA67.htm.
Odekina, D. A. (2007). Alcohol use among Junior Secondary School Students in Nigeria, Symposium delivered in Seattle, Washington.
Retrieved December 17, 2008 from http://www.icadts2007.org/print/poster66_studentsnigeria.pdf.
Onohwosafe, P.S., Egenege, A. J., and Blinkhorn, A. S., (2008). Drug Use among Secondary School Children in Central Delta State,
Nigeria. International Journal of Health Promotion and Education. Retrieved Dec. 18, 2008 from
http://fondarticles.com/cgi/reprint/30/1/89.
Percy, A. (2008). Moderate Adolescent Drug Use and the Development of Substance Use Self-Regulation, International Journal of
Behavioural Development 32; 451. Retrieved April 29, 2009 from http://jbd.Sagepub.com/cgi/content/abstract/32/5/451.
Schoor, G. V., Bot, S. M., and Engels, R.C.M.E. (2008). Alcohol drinking in Young Adults: The Predictive value of Personality when
Peers come around. The Netherland European Addiction Research Vol.14, No.3. Retrieved May 26, 2009 from
content.karger.com/ProdukteDB/produkte.asp?Aktion=ShowPDF&Artike1Nr=13041&Ausgabe=237371&ProduktNr…P.
Steinberg, L. (2002). Adolescence. 6th ed. New York: McGraw-Hill.
White, A.M., Kraus, C.L., Flom, J.D., Kestenbaum, L.A., Mitchell, J.R.,Shah, K. and Swartzwelder, H. S. (2005). College Students lack
knowledge of Standard Drink Volumes: Implications for Definitions of Risky
Drinking Based on Survey Data. Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research vol.29, No 4: 631-638.Retrieved April 15, 2009 from
http://content.Karger.com/Produktedb/produkte.asp?typ=fulltext&file=000130416.
Yeh, M. Y. (2006). Factors Associated with Alcohol Consumption, Problem Drinking, and Related Consequences among High School
students in Taiwan. Psychiatry ClinNeurosci 60(1): 46-54. Retrieved May 28, 2009 from bases.bireme.br/cg
bin/wxislind.exe/iah/online/?IsisScript=iah.xis&src=google&base=ADOLEC..P…-37k.
268
Effects of Computer Assisted Instruction (CAI) on Students’ Achievement in

Social Studies in Osun State, Nigeria
Adeyemi B. A. (Ph.D)
Institute of Education,
Faculty of Education,
Obafemi Awolowo University, Ile-Ife.
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.269
Abstract: The study investigated the effect of Computer Assisted Instruction (CAI) on Junior Secondary School Students’
achievement in Social Studies. The study equally examined the interaction effects of treatment of academic ability on students’
achievement in Social Studies. Simple random sampling was employed in selecting 160 students from four co-educational
public secondary schools in Osogbo and Ife Central Local Government Areas of Osun State, Nigeria. The study used a 2 x 2
factorial analysis of ANOVA and three null hypotheses were tested. Four instruments were used namely: “Social Studies
Achievement Test” (SSAT) “Computer Assisted Instruction Guide for Social Studies” (AIGSS), “Teacher Operational Guide for
Social Studies Instruction” (TOGSSI) and “Students’ Academic Ability Test” (SAAT) with reliability coefficients of 0.87, 0.79, 0.71
and 0.78 respectively. Data Analysis was done by using Analysis of Covariance Procedure. The results indicated that there is
no significant main effect of treatment (Computer Assisted Instruction and Conventional Methods) on student achievement in
Social Studies (F(1,153) = 0.415, P > 0.05). The result also revealed that there is significant main effect of academic ability on
students’ achievement in Social Studies (F(1,153) = 7.852, P < 0.05). The high academic ability students were significantly better
than the low ability students in their achievement in Social Studies. The findings further revealed that there is no significant
interaction effect of treatment and students’ academic ability in their achievement in Social Studies (F(1,153) = 0.687, P > 0.05).
Based on the findings of the study, recommendations were made among others, that conducive environment should be provided
with adequate facilities for Computer Assisted Instruction (CAI) as a mode of instruction to be effectively utilized in schools.
Keywords: Computer Assisted Instruction, Conventional Teaching Method, Academic Ability, Social Studies and Achievement
1. Introduction
The recent changes in the world and within nations have brought about changes in educational goals. The
schools are called not only to equip the learner with basic knowledge of Social Studies content as far as
Social Studies Curriculum is concerned, but also with practical skills capable of enhancing self-development
and continuous learning. This is to say that the quality of education in particular could not be compromised
in the modern day of science and technology.
The pedagogical implication of the above statement centred on teachers and ways and methods
employed in imparting facts and ideas to learners. According to NTI (2008), the old approach to teaching is
teacher-centred which implies that teacher does all the talking, and the learners do all the listening. Cooper
(1973) noted that the traditional or the conventional instruction method is characterized by:
1.Unspecified or vague objectives
2.Emphasis on instructor behaviour rather than student behaviour.
3.Use of lectures to provide critical information
4.A constant instruction – set pace for all students
5.Evaluation which is infrequent over large sections of materials, and for the purpose of assigning relative
standing rather than for remediation.
6.Delayed feedback to student about his performance.
7.Minimal responses of students to the instructional materials.
8.Few faculty/student or teacher/student interactions.
269
Hess and Lehman (1976) noted that under the traditional system of instruction, the student is motivated
primarily by the fear of receiving a poor grade, of losing a course credit or of being forced to leave the
College (droping out) for academic failure.
However, the new approach is learner centred, the learner is not treated as an empty vessel. He is
credited with knowledge, skills and attitudes from the day he or she is born which requires development,
through guidance, encouragement and motivation.
It is therefore not a gainsaying to say that the quality of education is largely dependent on the quality of
instruction provided in the classroom. There is no doubt that technology has become incorporated into our
school system. Computers are not only used as means of helping schools analyse data, they have become
pervasive tools toward optimizing students’ learning. For example, students are regularly using the internet
to gather and assimilate information for use in research assignments. According to Traynor (2003),
computers are used in preparing “electronic” presentations using computer presentation programs and LCD
projectors. He was also of the view that many schools have incorporated interacted computer-assisted-
instruction into programme to provide students opportunities to master specific educational objectives or
standards.
Computer Assisted Instruction (CAI) can be referred to as a self-learning technique usually offline/online,
involving interaction of students with programmed instructional materials. CAI is an interactive instructional
technique whereby a computer is used to present the instructional material and monitor the learning that
takes place. CAI uses a combination of text, graphic sound and video in enhancing the learning process.
The computer has many purposes in the classroom, and it can be utilized to help a student in all areas of the
curriculum.
CAI refers to the use of the computer as a tool to facilitate and improve instruction. CAI programs use
tutorials, drill and practice, simulation and problem solving approaches to present topics and they best test
the students’ understanding.
Previous studies such as Kulik, Kulik and Bangert-Drowns (1985), Wade (2006), Macaruso & Rodman
(2009) have succeeded in examining typicality, types, advantages and limitation of CAI.
Typical CAI provides:
1.Text or multimedia content
2.Multiple-choice questions
3.Problems
4.Immediate feedback
5.Notes on incorrect responses
6.Summarized students’ performance
7.Exercises for practice
8.Worksheets and tests.
Types of CAI include:

1. Drill-and-practice. Drill and practice provide opportunities for students to repeatedly practice the skills
that have been previously presented and further practice is necessary for mastery.
2. Tutorial: Tutorial activity includes both the presentation of information and its extension to different forms
of work, including drill and practice, games and simulation.
3. Games: Game software often creates a content to achieve the highest score and either beat others or
beat the computer.
4. Simulation: Simulation software can provide an approximation of reality that does not require the expense
of real life or its risks.
5. Discovery: This provides a large database of information specific to a course or content area and
challenges the learner to analyse, compare, infer and evaluate based on their explorations of data.
270
6. Problem-solving: The approach helps children develop specific problem skills and strategies.
Advantages of CAI include:
– One-to-one interaction
– Great motivator
– Freedom to experiment with different
– Instantaneous response/immediate feedback to the answer elicited
– Self pacing – allowing students to proceed at their own pace.
– Help teacher to devote more time to individual students
– Privacy helps the shy and slow learner to learn
– Individual attention
– Learn more and more rapidly
– Multimedia helps to understand difficult concepts through multi-sensory approach
– Self directed learning – students can decide when, where and what to learn.
Limitations of CAI include:

– May feel overwhelmed by the information and resources available.
– Over use of multimedia may divert the attention from the content
– Learning becomes too mechanical
– Non availability of good CAI packages.
– Lack of infrastructure
In the light of all the above, it is considered appropriate to examine the extent to which CAI method of
teaching will affect students’ achievement in Social Studies. Therefore, this study examines the effect of CAI
on students’ achievement in Social Studies through an experimental study.
2. Hypotheses
Ho1: There is no significant main effect of treatment on students’ achievement in Social Studies.
Ho2: There is no significant main effect of academic ability on students’ achievement in Social Studies.
Ho3: There is no significant interaction effect of treatment and academic ability on students’ achievement in
Social Studies.
3. Research Design
The study makes use of 2 x 2 randomized pre-test, post-test factorial design in a quasi-experimental setting.
4. Variables in the study
The design crossed the independent and moderator variable to provide for a 2 x 2 factorial analysis of
ANOVA.
5. Population
All the Junior Secondary School II students in Osun State constitute the population.
6. Sampling and Sample
Simple random sampling was employed in selecting four co-educational schools from Ife Central and Osogbo
Local Government Areas which were also randomly selected. Simple random sampling was equally
271
employed in selecting 40 students in each of the schools selected. In all, 160 students constituted the
sample for the study. Subjects were therefore classified into the experimental and control groups.
7. Instruments
Four major instruments were made use in their study. These include:
(i) Social Studies Achievement Test (SSAT). This is a 60-item multiple choice test. It covers three levels of
cognitive domain i.e. knowledge comprehension and application. This instrument has a reliability estimate of
0.87.
(ii) Computer Assisted instruction Guide for Social Studies (CAIGSS).
The Computer Assisted Instruction Guide for Social Studies (CAIGSS) is a programmed instructional
package for the purpose of instruction in the classroom. The instructor guide which contain three major
topics in Social Studies – (i) Leadership and followership (ii) Science and Technology and (iii) Transport and
communication.
The programmed Computer Assisted Instruction consists of a lesson plan for each lesson, and each of the
lesson plan contains specifics such as:
. The subject
. The content (topic)
. The objective to be achieved at the end of the instruction
. The instructional materials; and
. The assessment
The CAIGSS has a reliability value of 0.79
(iii) Teacher Operational Guide for Social Studies Instructional (TOGSSI)

The teacher Operational Guide for Social Studies is an instructional guide employed in teaching the control
group by utilizing the conventional method of teaching. It consists of lesson plan written for each lesson.
Each of the lesson plan contains specifics like:
. The subject
. The content (topic)
. The objective to be achieved at the end of the instruction
. The instructional materials
. The specific activities; and
. The assessment
The TOGSSI has reliability coefficient of 0.71
(iv) Students’ Academic Ability Test (SAAT)

This is a 30-item multiple choice achievement test with five options per item A to E which the students were
to choose the correct option. It was adopted from Ugo (2008). The thirty questions were selected from a pool
of verbal aptitude test on N.C.E.E. which were already standardized However, the 30 items were still
subjected to Kuder-Richardson formula 20 in order to establish the internal consistency of the items and this
yielded the reliability coefficient of 0.78.
8. Treatment Procedure and Data Collection Strategy
Two research assistants were trained on how to use the instruments. SSAT and SAAT were administered on
the experimental and control groups prior to the instruction. The scores obtained after administering SSAT
272
served as pre-test while the scores obtained from SAAT was used to classify the students into high and low
ability groups. The students who scored below the mean score in SAAT are classified as low ability students
while those whose score range between mean score and above were classified as high ability students.
The students in the two groups were taught three topics
(i) Leadership and followership (ii) Science and Technology and (iii) Transport and communication, the
experimental group with the use of Computer Assisted Instruction (CAI) and the control group with the use of
conventional method. At the end of the six weeks the post-test in Social Studies achievement was
administered on the two groups. A two-way Analysis of Covariance (ANCOVA) was used to analyse the data
obtained. Normally, one would have used a t-test analysis to compare the experimental and control group;
and at the same time use t-test to compare low and high students’ academic ability, but the researcher is also
interested in interaction effect which could only be carried out with the use of ANCOVA.
The findings of this study are presented in the following tables:
Table 1: Summary of Analysis of Covariance (ANCOVA) on Social Studies Achievement
Source Type III sum of df Mean F Sig Partial Eta squared

squares square
Corrected model 10400.559a 4 2600.140 90.027 .000 .699
Intercept .649 1 .649 .022 .881 .000
Achievement pre- 8042.212 1 8042.212 278.452 .000 .642
test
Method 11.999 1 11.999 .415 .520 .003
Level of ability 226.783 1 226.783 7.852 .006 .048
Method * level of 19.836 1 19.836 .687 .409 .004
ability
Error 4476.685 155 28.882
Total 88365.000 160
Corrected Total 14877.244 159
a R Squared = .699 (Adjusted R Squared = .691)
Table 2: Summary of level of Students’ Academic Ability
Level of Academic Mean Standard Error 95% confidence interval

Ability
Lower Bound Upper Bound
Low Ability 20.073a .913 18.270 21.876

High Ability 23.229a .671 21.904 24.555
a Covariates appearing in the model are evaluated at the following values: Achievement Pre-Test = 14.72
273
Table 3: Summary of Method of Teaching and Students’ Level of Academic Ability
Method of Teaching Level of Academic Mean Standard 95% Confidence Interval

Ability Error
Lower Upper Bound
Bound
Computer Assisted Low Ability 20.915a 1.716 17.525 24.305
Instruction (CAI) High Ability 23.138a 1.148 20.870 25.406
Conventional Low Ability 19.231a .668 17.911 20.551
High Ability 23.320a .694 21.950 24.691
a Covariate appearing in the model are evaluated at the following values: Achievement Pre-test = 14.72.
Hypothesis 1
There is no significant main effect of treatment on students’ achievement in Social Studies.

The ANOVA Table 1 shows that there was no significant main effect of treatment (Computer Assisted
Instruction and Conventional Methods) on students’ achievement in Social Studies (F(1,153) = 0.415, P > 0.05)
since the value of “F” is not significant, it means that the hypothesis on the main effect of treatment
(Computer Assisted Instruction and Conventional Methods) on students’ achievement in Social Studies is
accepted. This shows clearly that the experimental group (Computer Assisted Instruction) is not significantly
better than the control (Conventional method) with respect to students’ achievement in Social Studies.
Hypothesis II
There is no significant main effect of academic ability on students’ achievement in Social Studies.
The ANOVA as presented in table 1, shows that there was significant main effect of students’ academic
ability (high and low) on their achievement in Social Studies (F(1,153) = 7.852 < 0.05) since the value of “F” is
significant, it follows that the hypothesis on the main effect of students’ academic ability on achievement in
Social Studies is rejected. Also, as shown in table 2; the high ability students had mean score of 23.229
while the low academic ability students had mean score of 20.073. Table 3 as well shows the level of
academic ability of students based on the teaching methods. In Computer Assisted Instruction, high ability
students had mean score of 23.138 as against low ability students who had mean score of 20.915, for
conventional method, high ability students had mean score of 23.320 while low ability students had mean
score of 19.231. These results clearly showed that the high academic ability students were significantly
better than the low academic students with respect to students’ achievement in Social Studies.
Hypothesis III
There is no significant interaction effect of treatment and students’ academic ability on students’ achievement
in Social Studies.
Analysis of ANOVA, as presented in table 1 revealed that there is no significant interaction effect of
treatment and students’ academic ability on their achievement in Social Studies (F(1,153) = 0.687, P > 0.05).
Since the value of F is not significant, it follows that the hypothesis on the interaction effect of treatment and
students’ academics ability on achievement in Social Studies is accepted.
10. Discussion of Result
According to the findings of this study, there was no significant main effect of treatment (Computer Assisted
Instruction and Conventional Methods) on students’ achievement in Social Studies. This implies that
students taught via Computer Assisted Instruction did not perform better in Social Studies achievement than
274
those students taught with conventional method. This study contradicted most of the earlier studies such as
Tabassum (2004) who was of the view that students taught through CAI as supplementary strategy performs
significantly better than other students. Also Ford, Mazzone and Taylor (2005) were of the view that students
exposed to Computer Assisted Instruction in the learning of Musculoskeletal Special Tests performed better
than students exposed to traditional mode of instruction of the same task. Other similar studies that gave
credence to the importance of Computer Assisted Instruction are Jamaison, Suppes and Butler (1970),
Bialozor, Fine, McLaughlin (1991), Caryl and Noonan (2000), Soe, Koki and Chang (2000) Basturk (2005),
Maitoned, DuPaul and Jitendra (2005), Liao (2007). The insignificant of result present study might be as a
result of the fact that most of the students were used to conventional method of teaching, not only that, it was
observed that most of the students in the course of this study find it difficult to quickly adjust to the use of
Computer Assisted Instruction due to environmental problem It was equally noticed that the procedures
involved in the acquisition of skills needed by the students in the learning of the basic concepts are somehow
difficult.
The findings of the effect of treatment on academic ability show that high academic ability students
performed more significantly in Social Studies than the low academic students in both Computer Assisted
Instruction and Conventional Methods. This result corroborated Abadzi (1985), Holmes and Ahr (1994),
Emeke and Adegoke (2001), Condron, (2003), Falaye (2006), Adewale (2008), Denessen, Veenman,
Dobbelsteen and Vanschilt (2008), Karademir (2009), who were all of the view that high ability students
performed better than low ability students. Although it is not mandatory that there should be significant
difference between higher and low students ability as pointed out by Muhfahroyin (2009) whose result
indicated no difference between higher and lower students ability in the cognitive achievement of Biology,
Critical thinking and process skills. Also, Holmes and Ahr (1994) were of the view that ability grouping has no
effect on students’ achievement.
Furthermore, this study found that there was no significant interaction effect of treatment as students’
academic ability on their achievement in Social Studies. This implies that treatment (Computer Assisted
Instruction and Conventional Methods) are not sensitive to students achievement in Social Studies. This
finding is in line with the findings of Muhfahroyin (2009) who found out that there was no effect of interaction
between learning strategy and academic ability towards the cognitive achievement of Biology, Critical and
Process skills. Also, Ibode (2008) found that there was no interaction effect of treatment and students’
academic ability on achievement in English language.
11. Conclusion
This study has shown that students exposed to Computer Assisted Instruction (CAI) did not perform
significantly better in their achievement in Social Studies than those students exposed to conventional
method of instruction. In the same vein, high academic ability as revealed by the study boosts students’
achievement in Social Studies as against low academic ability. Also, the study revealed that no significant
interaction effect existed in treatment of students’ academic ability and achievement in Social Studies.
In conclusion therefore, the use of Computer Assisted Instruction should be seen as so germane in this
present dispensation and students and teachers should be so equipped in the usage and conducive
environment should be provided. Also, the influence of high academic ability on the achievement of
students, which this study found, underscores the need for students to strive to improve their academic ability
since it has proven to be an important factor in Social Studies achievement.
12. Recommendations
Based on the findings, the following are recommended:

(1) Conducive environment should be provided with adequate facilities for Computer Assisted Instruction to
275
be effectively utilized in schools.

(2) There is need for Social Studies teachers to update themselves through seminars, conferences and
workshop that will enhance the teaching of Social Studies.
(3) Motivation is central to creativity students should be motivated to use Computer Assisted Instruction
(CAI) so that its usage will not serve as a burden or waste of time.
(4) Concerted effort is required on the part of Ministry of Education to provide schools with enough funding
for the purchase of necessary materials like ICT facilities for use of Computer Assisted Instruction.
(5) Computer Assisted Instruction strategy will go a long way to improve the attitude of both the students and
teachers toward the use of this strategy in their future classroom interaction.
(6) There is need for Computer Assisted Instruction to be gradually introduced into the teaching and learning
process in Nigeria to supplement the existing method of instruction.
References
Abadzi, H. (1985) Ability Grouping Effects on Academic Achievement and Self-Esteem: who performs in the long run as expected.
Journal of Educational Research 79(1).
Adewale, J. G. (2008) Effect of Brainstorming on Students’ Achievement in Junior Secondary School Mathematics: An Effort in Making
School Effective. Journal of Sociology and Education in Africa 7(1) 203 – 218.
Basturk, R. (2005) The Effectiveness of Computer-Assisted Instruction in teaching Introductory Statistics. Educational Technology and
Society 8(2) 170 – 178.
Bialozor, R. C., Fine, L. P. & Mclaughlin, T. F. (1991). An analysis of Computer Assisted Instruction on Scholastic aptitude test
performance of rural high school students. Education spring 111(3) 400 – 403.
Caryl, H. H. & Noonan M. J. (2000) Computer Instruction of Early Academic Skills. Topics in Early Childhood Special Education. Vol.
20. Available online at www.questia.com/.../internationalperspectives-on-the-design -of-technology-supported-learning-
environment-by-erik-de-corte-robert-glaser-he.
Condron, D. J. (2003) An Early start: Effects of ability grouping on reading achievement. Retrieved online
http://www.allacademic.com/meta/p/107314index.html.
Cooper, J. L. (1973) Learning theory and effective instruction, Journal of Higher Education 44. 217 – 234.
Denessen, E; Veenman, S. Dobbelstean, J. & Vanschilt, J. (2008) Dyad Composition effects on cognitive elaboration and students’
achievement. Journal of Experimental Education 76(4) 363 – 383.
Emeke, E. A. & Adegoke, B. A. (2001). The interaction effect of test response mode, students’ numerical ability and gender on cognitive
achievement in Senior Secondary School Physics. In Y. Awoska et al (eds) Topical Issues in Education. Paper honour of
Professor C. O. Udoh. Available online at findarticles.com/p/articles/m-993765/is_200611/…/pg2.
Faleye, F. V. (2006) Numerical ability, course of study and gender differences in students’ achievement in Practical Geography.
Research in Education. Available online at http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi/-993765/is2006.n17194298/pg.21.
Ford, G. S.; Mazzone, M. A. & Taylor, K (2005) Effect of Computer-Assisted Instruction versus Traditional Modes of Instruction on
Students Learning of Musulo Skeletal Special tests. Journal of Physical Theraphy Education 19(2) 22 – 30.
Hess, J. H. & Lehman, G. R. (1976) PSI and the Generic method of programmed instruction. Journal of Programme and Educational
Technology 13(1) 13 – 22.
Holmes, C. A. Ahr, T. J. (1994) Effects of ability grouping on academic achievement and self-concept of African-American and While
students. Retrieved online at http://www.highbeam.com/doc/IGI-15630405.htm.
Ibode, O. F. (2005) Effects of the use of Video Tape instruction of Students’ Achievement in English Language. West African Journal of
Education. XXV 94 – 104.
Jamision D., Suppes P. D., & Butler C. (1970) Estimated costs of Computer Assisted Instruction for Compensatory Education in Urban
Areas. Educational Technology 10, 49 – 57.
Karademir, C. A. (2009) The effect of ability grouping classes on 7th grade students’ academic achievement on the unit “if there were no
pressure in science and technology education. Eurasian Journal of Physics and Chemistry Education 1(1), 32 – 44.
Kulik, J. A.; Kulik, C. C. & Bangert – Drowns, R. L. (1985) Effectiveness of Computer-based education in Elementary schools.
Computers in Human Behaviour 1, 59 – 79.
Levinson, D; Peter, W. C. & Alan R. S. (2002) Effect of student academic ability on achievement: Education and sociology: An
Encyclopedia. Retrieved online at http://books.goggle.com.gh.book.
Liao, Y. C. (2007) Effects of Computer Assisted Instruction on Students’ achievement in Taiwan: A meta Analysis. Computer and
Education 48(2) 216 – 233.
Macaruso, P. & Rodman, A. (2009) Benefits of Computer Assisted Instruction for Struggling readers in middle schools. European Journal
of Special Needs Education 24(1) 103 – 113.
Maitoned, A, Dupaul A. K. & Jitendra, A. K. (2005) The effects of Computer-Assisted Instruction on the Mathematics Performance and
Classroom behavior of children with ADHD. Journal of Attention Disorders 9(1) 301 – 312.
276
Mulifahroyin, M. (2009) The effect of STAD and TRS integration learning strategy and academic ability toward the cognitive
achievement of Biology, critical thinking and process skills of Senior High School Students in Kota metro: Dissertasi dan Tesis
Program. Pascasarjana, U. M.
Salawu, I. O. (1999) Effects of Three instructional media on student-teacher learning outcomes in selected teaching skills. Unpublished
Ph.D Thesis, University of Ibadan.
Soe, K.; Koki, S & Chang, J. (2000) Effect of Computer-Assisted Instruction on Reading Achievement. A meta Analysis. Available from
Pacific for Education and Learning. Website: http://www.preliorg/products/effect-cai.htm.
Tabassum, R. (2004) Effect of Computer Assisted Instruction (CAI) on the secondary school students’ achievement in science. A Ph.D
thesis, University of Arid Agriculture, Rawalpindi.
Traynor, P. L. (2003). Effects of Computer Assisted Instruction on different Learners. Journal of Educational Research. 79(1).
Ugo, C. U. (2008) Nationwide Common Entrance Examinations to Federal and State Colleges on English Language and Verbal aptitude
test. 13th Edition. Lagos: Ugo, C. Ugo Publishing Company Ltd.
Wade, L. L. (2006) Teaching Information Literacy Skills Using Computer Assisted Instruction. Retrieved Oct 11, 2009 from
http://skills.org/teaching/computer-html.
NTI (2008). Manual for the Re-training of Primary School Teachers on Social Studies. A Millennium Development Goals Project (MDG).
Kaduna: National Teachers’ Institute Press.
277

Frauds In Nigerian Banks: Nature, Deep-Seated Causes, Aftermaths And Probable Remedies
Adeyemo Kingsley A.1
Department of Accounting
Covenant University, Ogun State, Nigeria
E-mail [email protected]; [email protected]
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.279
Abstract: This paper is descriptive in nature and it examines the nature, causes, effects and remedy for bank frauds in Nigeria.
In recent years, frauds in Nigeria banking sector seemed to have assumed a frightening dimension and to a large extent, the
confidence the general public reposes in it, is put in jeopardy. The ability of banks to promote growth and development in any
economy is a function of the extent to which financial transactions are carried out with trust, confidence and least risk. These no
doubt require a safe and sound banking practice which many of the banks in Nigeria today have despised to their own peril. This
study leaned heavily on the Nigerian Deposit Insurance Corporation (NDIC) annual reports for data relating to total amount
involved in frauds and forgeries, ten banks with the highest fraud cases and categories of bank staff involved in frauds and
forgeries. The paper concludes that the battle for the preclusion, uncovering and retribution of fraud offenders must be fought on
two extensive fronts: First is to reduce the temptation to commit fraud and second to increase the chances of detection. While a
positive work environment will help to achieve the former, the latter can be achieved by sound internal control system.
Key words: Frauds, Banks, NDIC, Frauds Motivation model
1. Introduction
Among the Nigerian industrial sectors today, one can say that the banking industry is the most visible and
arouses the most public interest. The importance of the banking sector in any economy stems from its role of
financial intermediation, provision of an efficient payment system and facilitation of the implementation of
monetary policies. In intermediation, banks mobilize savings from the surplus units of the economy and
channel these funds to the deficit unit, particularly private business enterprises, for the purpose of expanding
their productive capacity.
According to Olismbu (1991:20), the banking sector has become one of the most critical sectors and
commanding heights of the economy with wide implications on the level and direction of economic growth
and transformation and on such sensitive issues as the rate of unemployment and inflation which directly
affect the lives of our people. Today, the very integrity and survivability of these laudable functions of
Nigerian banks have been called into question in view of incessant frauds and accounting scandals.
According to Oseni (2006:16), “the incessant frauds in the banking industry are getting to a level at which
many stakeholders in the industry are losing their trust and confidence in the industry”. Corroborating the
views of Oseni, Idolo (2010:63), stressed that the spate of fraud in Nigerian banking sector has lately become
a source of embarrassment to the nation as apparent in the seeming attempts of the law enforcement
agencies to successfully track down culprits.
Although the incidence of fraud is neither limited to the banking industry nor peculiar to Nigeria economy,
however the high rate of fraud within the banking industry, calls for urgent attention with a view to finding
solutions. Fraud in its effect reduces organizational assets and increases its liabilities. With regards to
banking industry, it may engender crises of confidence among the banking public; impede the going concern

1The author is a Lecturer in the institution specified above. He is an associate member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of
Nigeria (ICAN), he possesses a B.Sc degree in Accounting, MBA, M.Phil (Accounting) and doubles as a Ph.D student in the same
University where he lectures.
279
status of the bank and ultimately lead to bank failure. The Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) reported that cases
of attempted fraud and forgery in banks, as at half-year 2007 exceeded what was recorded in the whole of
2006. For instance, the CBN half-year report for 2007, disclosed that a total of 741 cases of attempted fraud
and forgery, involving N5.4 billion (US $34.8 million), were reported as at June, 2007. Whereas in 2006, the
entire cases of fraud reported were 1,193, involving the sum of N4.8 billion (US $30.97). The CBN also
maintained that the dwindling situation is occasioned by weaknesses in the internal control system of the
affected banks. The foregoing statistics clearly unfolds the extent to which fraud had eaten deep into the
financial strength of Nigeria banks.
Thus, the remaining part of this paper will be divided into four parts namely: Nature and classification of
frauds, profound causes of frauds, effect of fraud and prevention and control of frauds, and conclusion.
2. Nature and Classification of Frauds
The term ‘Fraud’ has been defined in different ways by different authors. According to the Collins English
Dictionary, fraud can be defined as: "deceit, trickery, sharp practice, or breach of confidence, perpetrated for
profit or to gain some unfair or dishonest advantage". Also, the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners
defines fraud as “any illegal acts characterized by deceit, concealment or violation of trust. These acts are not
dependent on the application of threat of violence or of physical force”. Frauds are perpetrated by individuals
and organizations to obtain money, property or services; to avoid payment or loss of services; or to secure
personal or business advantage.
According to Boniface (1991), fraud is described as “any premeditated act of criminal deceit, trickery or
falsification by a person or group of persons with the intention of altering facts in order to obtain undue
personal monetary advantage”. Frauds usually involve the perpetration of some forgery or falsification of
documents or illegal authorization of signature (Ojo, 2008:91). It can be summarily concluded from the
foregoing definitions that fraud arises when a person in a position of trust and responsibility digresses from
agreed standards, breaks the rules to advance his personal interest at the expense of the interest of the
public.
Fraud has been classified in various ways and using various parameters. However for the purpose of this
paper, we shall employ the perpetrators criteria as follows:
a) Management of the banks (otherwise referred to as management fraud).
b) Insiders. These perpetrators are purely the employees of the banks.
c) Outsiders. These include customers and/or non- customers of the banks.
d) Outsiders/Insiders. This is a collaboration of the bank staff and outsiders as described in (b) and (c)
above.
3. Management Fraud
Management fraud is frequently committed by management staff of a reporting entity, which comprises the
director, general managers, and managing directors to mention but a few. The category of victims of
management frauds are investors and creditors, and the medium for perpetrating the fraud is financial
statement. The predilection for management fraud in most cases is to pull in more investment from both
existing and potential shareholders to the organization. Another motivation for management fraud is to paint
the bank in good light in the eyes of the regulatory authorities such as Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN),
Nigerian Deposit Insurance Corporation (NDIC), Nigerian Accounting Standards Board (NASB) etc.
Additionally management fraud can also be effectuated to secure tax advantage from tax authorities.
According to Fakunle (2006:173), management fraud is the manipulation of records and the accounts,
typically by the enterprise’s senior staff with a view to benefiting in some indirect ways. Deception and
280
Deprivation are the two elements of fraud and management fraud meets the criteria. According to Ajisebutu
(2006:6), the key elements of management frauds are:
a) A material false statement;
b) Knowledge of its (statement) falsification;
c) Reliance on the false statement by victim; and
d) Damage suffered by victim.
Though management fraud manifests itself through overstatement of assets or revenues, and
understatement of liabilities and expenses, Association of Certified Fraud Examiners (ACFE) believes it is
carried out through the under listed five methods:
i) Fictitious Revenues
ii) Timing Differences
iii) Improper Asset Valuation
iv) Concealed Liabilities and Expenses
v) Improper and /or Inadequate Disclosure
4. Insiders or Employees Frauds
This is also known as non-management fraud and they are usually perpetrated by the employees of the
Banks or organizations. It is the application of fraudulent means to obtain money or other property from the
organization (Robertson, 1996:292). According to Olatunji (2009:183), insiders frauds in the bank involves
falsification of some kind, lying, exceeding authority, violation of employer’s policies, embezzlement of
company’s funds, usually in form of cash or other assets. Boniface (1991:23), indentifies some of the typical
manifestations of employees frauds in the banks to include:
(I) Cash thefts from the tills by banks’ staff;
(II) Forgeries of customer’s signature with the intention of illegally withdrawing money from the account
with the bank;
(III) Use of forged cheques to withdraw money from the customer’s accounts;
(IV) Opening and operating of fictitious account to which illegal transfers could be made and false
balance credited;
(V) Lending to fictitious borrowers effected through fictitious account opened at a branch;
(VI) Claiming of overtime for hours not worked;
(VII) Suppression of cash / cheques.
(VIII)Fund Diversion: In this case, bank staff (for personal use), sometimes diverts customers’ deposits
and loan repayment. Another case of this is the tapping of funds from interest in suspense
accounts in the bank.
(IX) Computer Fraud: This type of fraud takes the form of alteration of the programmes or application
packages and even bursting into the system via remote sensors. Diskettes and flash drives can
also be tinkered with to gain access to unauthorized domains or even give credit to accounts for
which the funds were not ab initio intended. This kind of fraud can remain undetected for a long
time.
5. Outsiders Frauds
These are frauds perpetrated by customers and non-customers of banks. The primary function of a
commercial bank is to connect customers with capital deficit to customers with capital surplus in the financial
market. In implementing this function, banks and bank workers come in contact with both customers and non-
customers, and this contact engenders the risk of fraud. According to Onkagba, (1993), as sited in Idowu,
(2009:629), the most common methods of outsiders’ fraud are:
281
a. Advance Fee Fraud

This may involve an agent approaching a bank, a company or individual with another to access large funds at
below market interest rates often for long term. This purported source of funds is not specifically identified as
the only way to have access to it is through the agent who must receive a commission “in advance”. As soon
as the agent collects the fee, he disappears and the facility never comes through. Any bank desperate for
fund especially distressed banks and banks needing large funds to bid for foreign exchange can easily fall
victim of this type of fraud. When the deal fails and the fees paid in advance are lost, these victims are not
likely to report the losses to the police or to the authorities.
b. Forged Cheques
This is most likely the commonest method by which the customers and the bank are defrauded. They occur
mainly in company’s accounts and are invariably perpetrated by staffs within the company who have access
to the company’s cheque book.
c. Cheque Kitting
This occurs when a depositor utilizes the time required for a cheque to clear to obtain an authorized loan
without interest charge. The goal of the cheque kitter may be to use these uncollected bank funds, interest
fees for a short time to overcome a temporary cash shortage or to withdraw the funds permanently for
personal use. Competition among banks in the era of deregulation encourages bank to make funds available
before collection of customers’ cheque in order to attract special business accounts.
d. Account Opening Fraud

This involves the deposit and subsequent cashing of fraudulent cheques. It usually starts when a person not
known to the bank asks to open a transaction account such as current and savings account with false
identification but unknown to the bank.
e. Counterfeit Securities
Counterfeiting of commercial financial instruments is one of the oldest forms of crime. Modern photographic
and printing equipment has greatly aided criminals in reproducing good quality forged instruments. The
documents may be total counterfeit or may be genuine documents that are copied, forged or altered as to
amount, payout date, pay or terms of payment. A common fraud is to present the counterfeit stocks or bonds
as collateral for loan. The presenter would draw out the proceeds and disappear before the financial
instruments are found to be counterfeit.
f. Money Transfer Fraud

Money transfer services are means of moving financial resources to or from a bank to beneficiary account at
any bank point worldwide in accordance with the instructions from the banks’ customers. Some common
means of money transfer are mail, telephone, over-the-counter, electronic process and telex. Fraudulent
money transfer may result from a request created solely for the purpose of committing a fraud or altered by
changing the beneficiary’s name or account number or changing the amount of the transfer.
g. Letter of Credit Fraud

This generally arises out of international trade and commerce. They stimulate trade across national borders
by providing a vehicle for ensuring prompt payment by financially sound institutions. Overseas suppliers
continue to receive spurious letters of credit, which are usually accompanied by spurious bank drafts with
fake endorsements which guarantee payments.
282
h. Clearing Fraud
Most clearing frauds hinge on suppression of an instrument so that at the expiration of the clearing period
applicable to the instrument, the collecting bank will give value as though the paying bank had confirmed the
instrument good for payment. Clearing cheques can also be substituted to enable the fraudster divert the
fund to a wrong beneficiary. Misrouting of clearing cheques can also assist fraudsters to complete a clearing
fraud.
i. Duplicating or skimming card data, copying magnetic stripe information off a card for duplication.
6. Outsiders/Insiders Fraud
This involves a collaboration of bank staff and outsiders for the purpose of defrauding the bank. For bank’s
outsider fraud to succeed, more often than not, there must be an insider who is providing information and
other logistic support to the outsiders.
7. Causes of Frauds in Nigerian Banks
In the words of Ojo (2008:92), the causes of fraud and forgeries in banking transactions can be classified
under two generic factors namely: the institutional or endogenous factor and the environmental or exogenous
(social) factors.
7.1 Institutional Factors
The institutional factors or causes are those that are traceable to the in-house environment of the banks.
Though the list of institutional factors is inexhaustible, the notable ones are:
A) Weak accounting and internal control system;
B) Inadequate supervision of subordinates;
C) Disregards for “know your customers (KNC)” rule;
D) Poor information technology and data base management;
E) Hapless personnel policies;
F) Poor salaries and conditions of services;
G) General frustrations occasioned by management unfulfilled promises;
H) Failure to engage in regular call-over;
I) Employees’ refusal to abide by laid-down procedures without any penalty or sanction;
J) Banks reluctance to report fraud due to the perceived negative publicity or image. This is capable of
engendering more fraud;
K) Banking Experience of staff: frauds in banks occur with higher rate of recurrence among staff with little
experience and knowledge in financial praxis. The more experience and knowledgeable a staff is, the less
probability that frauds would pass such staff undetected unless with active support of that staff.
L) Inadequate Infrastructure: Poor communication systems and power failure, result to a buildup of
unbalanced postings, overcrowded office space etc, these encourage the committal of fraud in banks.
M) Inadequate training and re-training;
N) Poor Book-Keeping
O) Genetic traits:- These are trans-generational (or inherited) attribute possessed by an individual that
propels him to engage in frauds. For instance, a kleptomaniac who pathologically steals for the fun of it would
naturally not do well as professional banker.
283
7.2 The Environmental or Social Factors
According to Idowu (2009:632), environmental factors are those that can be trace to the immediate and
remote environment of the bank. These factors or causes according to Ogbunka (2002:188), are manifest in
the following manner:
I) The penchant to get rich quick;
II) Slow and tortuous legal process;
III) Poverty and the widening gap between the rich and the poor;
IV) Job insecurity;
V) Peer group pressure;
VI) Societal expectations;
VII) Increased financial burden on individuals;
VIII) Stiff competition in the banking industry which saw many banks engaging in fraud so as to meet up in
terms of liquidity and profitability.
Why People Commit Fraud
Classical fraud theory made plane and comprehensible, the propensities for fraud as a triangle of perceived
opportunity, perceived pressure, and perceived rationalization. Every fraud executor is confronted with some
kinds of pressures, which constitute the first component of fraud. More often than not, the pressure
constitutes a financial want, although nonfinancial pressures—such as the need to report results that are
better than actual performance and competitors, frustration with the nature of work, or even a challenge to
beat the system—can also induce fraud. Research has shown that these pressures don't have to be
authentic; they simply have to seem valid to the perpetrator.
Figure 1: Classical Fraud Motivation Model
PERCEIVED OPPORTUNITIES
PERCEIVED PRESSURES PERCEIVED RATIONALIZATIONS
The second constituent of the fraud triangle is perceived opportunity. The executor of fraud must believe that
he or she can commit the fraud and not get caught (or, that if he or she does get caught, nothing grave will
happen). Like perceived pressures, perceived opportunities don't have to be real; they only must be
perceived as authentic by the executor.
The third driver of fraud is ability of the perpetrators to find a way to rationalize their actions as acceptable.
The following are some familiar rationalizations: “its serves the bank right since the organization has not
honour their obligations to me”, “I deserve it. I am only taking my share”, “the plot is only temporary. After this
I’m done”, “we are not injuring anyone; the bank will blow their money anyway”. Some fraudsters may say
that the bank has enough money and it won't affect them in a big way etc.
The three elements of the fraud triangle - perceived pressure, perceived opportunity, and perceived
rationalizations are indispensable to every fraud. Whether the fraud is one that benefits the perpetrator
284
personally or one that benefits a perpetrator's business. In the case of financial statement fraud, for example,
the pressure could be the need to meet (or even surpass) analysts' and regulatory authorities’ expectations
or debt covenants, the opportunity could be a weak audit committee or pitiable internal controls, and the
rationalization could be that you are only getting over a temporary slump in business.
8. Effects of Frauds on Nigerian Banks
Sections 35 and 36 of Nigerian Deposit Insurance Corporation (NDIC) Act 2006, mandates banks to render
monthly returns of frauds and forgeries and also notify the corporation of any staff dismissed or whose
appointment was terminated on accounts of frauds or financial irregularities.
Presented in this section are the reported cases of frauds and forgeries for a period of ten years (2000-
2009), Table No 2, shows the ten banks with highest fraud cases between 2003 and 2009, and Table No 3,
evinces the status and the number of bank staff involved in frauds and forgeries, within 7 years (i.e. 2003 to
2009). Table 1 below, shows the number of reported cases of frauds and forgeries, the amount involved,
expected loss and number of staff involved, for 10 years (i.e. 2000 – 2009).
Table N. 1: Total Amount Involved in Fraud and Forgeries
YEAR Total No of Fraud Total Amount Total Expected Proportion of Staff

Cases Involved (N’ Loss (N’ Million) Expected Loss to Involved
Million) Amount Involved
(%)
2000 403 2,857.11 1,080.57 37.82 493

2001 943 11,243.94 906.30 8.06 152
2002 796 12,919.55 1,299.69 10.06 85
2003 850 9,383.67 857.46 9.14 106
2004 1,175 11,754.00 2,610.00 22.21 383
2005 1,229 10,606.18 5,602.05 52.82 378
2006 1,193 4,832.17 2,768.67 57.30 331
2007 1,553 10,005.81 2,870.85 28.69 273
2008 2,007 53,522.86 17,543.09 32.78 313
2009 1,764 41,265.50 7,549.23 18,29 656
Total 10,719 168,390.79 43,087.91 2,514
Source: Adapted from NDIC ANNUAL REPORTS (2000 – 2009)
As depicted in the table, a total of 10,719 cases of frauds and forgeries were reported during the period,
involving N168.84 billion (that is, N168.84 billion, US $1.09 billion), and perpetrated by a total of 2,514 staff of
various designates. It is noteworthy that the year 2008 witnessed the highest number of frauds and forgeries
cases (i.e. 2,007 cases), and the highest total amount of frauds and forgeries of N53.52 billion, (i.e.US
$345.31 million). The table also indicates that Nigerian banks had the highest number staff involved in frauds
and forgeries in the year 2009 (i.e. 656 staff).
285
Table N. 2: Ten Banks With Highest Fraud Cases
Group 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
Amount % Amount % Amount % Amount % Amount % Amount % Amount %

Involved Share Involved Share Involved Share Involved Share Involved Share Involved Share Involved Share
(N’ (N’ (N’ (N’ (N’ (N’ (N’
Million) Million) Million) Million) Million) Million) Million)
Total
for 10
8,635.38 92.02 10,024.00 85.88 9,373.74 88.38 2,512.73 51.77 2,565.01 25.64 34,311.72 64.11 37,179.90 90.10
Banks
Total
for All 9,383.67 100 11,754.00 100 10,606.18 100 4,832.17 100 10,005.81 100 53,522.86 100 41,265.50 100
Banks
The 10 banks with the highest number of reported frauds and forgeries cases, as presented in Table 2
above, were responsible for 92.02%, 85.88%, 88.38%, 51.77%, 25.64%, 64.31%, and 90.10% of the total
frauds and forgeries that were reported in the banking industry in the 7 seven years (i.e. 2003-2009)
respectively. The year 2003 and 2009 were the most infamous for the fact that they comprise the highest
proportions of 92.02% and 90.10% respectively. For instance, in 2003, of the total of N9.38 billion (US $60.54
million) cases of frauds and forgeries reported by the entire banking sector, N8.64 billion (US $55.71 million)
were perpetrated by staff of 10 banks. Similarly in 2009, out of the N41.27 billion (US $266.23 million) cases
of financial irregularities in the banking sector, 10 banks accounted for N37.18 billion (US $239.87 million). It
is noteworthy that the rate of conversion was N155 to $1, i.e. the rate existing as at the time the paper was
written.
Table N. 3: Categories of Bank Staff Involved in Frauds and Forgeries

Rank 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
Number % Number % Number % Number % Number % Number % Number %
Supervisors & 25 23.58 157 40.99 169 44.70 118 35.64 87 30.76 48 15.33 94 14.32
Managers
Officers, 41 38.68 129 33.68 124 32.80 90 27.19 89 32.60 127 40.58 137 20.88
Accountants &
Executive
Assistants
Clerks & 25 23.58 61 15.93 54 14.28 50 15.10 34 12.45 48 15.33 200 30.49
Cashiers
Typists, - - 18 4.70 16 4.23 16 4.83 21 7.69 20 6.39 64 9.76
Technicians &
Stenographers
Messengers, 7 6.60 15 3.92 12 3.17 7 2.11 - - - - 11 1.68
Drivers,
Cleaners,
Security
Guards &
stewards
Temporary 8 7.55 3 0.78 3 0.79 50 15.10 45 16.48 70 22.37 150 22.87
Staff
TOTAL 106 100.00 383 100.00 378 100 331 100.00 273 100.00 313 100.00 656 100.00
Table 3 shows the status and number of banks’ staff involved in frauds and forgeries from 2003 to 2009.
Within the seven years, a total of 2,440 were reported to have been involved in frauds and forgeries, while in
286
2009, a total of 656 members of bank staff were reported to have taken part in financial impropriety, this
statistics accounted for an increase of 109.58% as against the 2008 figure of 313. Additionally, of the 656
number of staff reported to have engaged in fraud and forgeries in 2009, 431 of them were core operating
staff such as supervisors, officers, accountants, managers, executive assistants, clerks and cashiers, thus
accounting for 65.7%.
According to NDIC 2009 report, the banking industry performance and the level of soundness declined in
2009. Out of the 24 banks in the country, 13 were rated sound, one was marginal while 10 were rated
unsound as against just one unsound in the previous year.
Undoubtedly, frauds lead to loss of money which belongs to either the bank or customers. This loss
results in a decline of productive resources available to the bank. Adewunmi (1996), identified the under
listed effects of bank frauds and forgeries:
a) It destroys the bank’s reputation
b) It discourages banking habit among the banking public.
c) The bank ceases to meet up with staff welfare
d) The trust and understanding among staff is reduced
e) The bank will lack the ability to compete favourably with its competitors
f) Fraud reduces bank’s profitability
g) It places emotional and psychological burdens on the fraud victims.
Others include:
Increased operating expenses, reduced operational efficiency, damage to credibility, public criticisms,
endangered bank’s plans and strategies, bank’s liquidation, a decrease in foreign direct investments (FDI)
and foreign investors, depletion of shareholders’ funds and banks’ capital base, and bad national image.
Summarily, it can be said that the Cost of Fraud in Banks = Instantaneous loss due to fraud + Cost of
fraud preclusion and exposure + Cost of lost business + Opportunity cost of fraud avoidance and uncovering
+ deterrent effect on spread of e-commerce.
9. Prevention and Control of Bank Frauds and Forgeries
To guarantee effective strategies of fraud prevention and control, banks are to ensure that operational
systems are designed with inbuilt control devises. Banks can reduce or better still eradicate frauds and
forgeries if all control devices built into the system are uncompromisingly respected. Additionally,
stakeholders in the banking industry can reduce the incidence of frauds by complying with the following
recommendations.
1) Instauration of an encouraging work atmosphere

An encouraging work environment propels employees to follow established policies and procedures, and
operate in the best interest of the organization. It opens line of communication between employees and
management of the bank, and guarantees positive employees recognition and sound reward system. This
kind of environment is likely to reduce the drive for internal fraud and forgeries.
2) Hire sincere people

The need to hire honest people cannot be over emphasized. Though it is the ambition of every organization,
but it is easier said than done. Cost of hiring a dishonest employee is incalculable: a dishonest employee will
undermine any attempt to create a positive work environment and constantly strive to defeat any internal
control put in place. Pre-employment background checks that cover criminal history, educational history
verification, previous employment verification, civil history for possible lawsuits etc, will be helpful in hiring
honest people.
287
3) Perform expected- and unexpected- audits

Every bank should have regular assessments procedures which will be complemented with uncustomary,
random, unannounced financial audits and frauds assessments. This can help to unearth any vulnerability
and appraise the effectualness of the existing controls, and send the message to all employees that fraud
prevention and control are of high priority to the bank.
4) Enforce internal controls

This should be designed to promote operational efficiency and effectiveness, provide reliable financial
information, safeguard assets and records, encourage adherence to prescribed policies,
and comply with regulatory agencies. A sound internal control will ensure that transactions are: Valid,
properly authorized, recorded, properly valued, properly classified, reconciled to subsidiary records and not
carried through by a single employee (i.e. ensure separation of duties)
5) Probe every unpleasant incident

A meticulous and timely investigation of any allegation of frauds, threat to internal control and warning signals
of fraud, will give the indication that frauds and forgeries are not treated with kid-gloves by the organization.
6) Exemplary leadership
Top management of the bank must set the standard for other employees by their conduct. A cavalier
approach to rules and regulations by senior management will soon be reflected in the stance of the
employees. Every staff, no matter how highly placed, should be governed by the rules of the organization and
not above it.
7) Adequate training and education most especially on frauds and forgeries should be organized from time to
time for banks’ staff.
8) The judicial process should be reinforced to encourage speedy hearing of fraud cases brought before it.
10. Conclusion
To say that the banking sector of Nigerian economy has become a terrain for various appalling corrupt and
fraudulent practices is to say the obvious. According to a US- based Global Financial Integrity group, Nigeria
sits atop a list of African countries which have suffered a massive outflow of illicit funds in Africa between
1970 through 2008. The study, titled Illicit Financial Flows from Africa: Hidden Resource for Development,
reveals that Nigeria lost $165.697 billion, about 19% of the total $854 billion outflows from Africa to other
western countries. Queuing behind Nigeria are Egypt ($70.5 billion), Algeria ($25.7 billion), Morocco ($25
billion) and South Africa (24.9 billion).
Accomplishing greater triumph in the battle against Nigerian fraud will require continued interagency
collaboration, public education and greater international cooperation. As for the banking industry, the
detection and prevention of frauds are basically the responsibility of the management through the
establishment of efficient and effective internal control System.
The battle for the prevention, detection and punishment of fraud offenders must be fought on two
extensive fronts. First is to reduce the temptation to commit fraud and second to increase the chances of
detection. While a positive work environment will help to achieve the former, the latter can be achieved by
sound internal control system as earlier discussed.
288
References
Adewunmi, W. (1986), Fraud in banks, Nigeria institute of bankers, Land mark publication, Lagos.
Ajisebutu, A. (2006), “Financial Statement Fraud: What Auditors should know”, The Nigerian Accountant, 39(2), p17.
Boniface, C. (1991). Fraud in the banking industry. The Nigerian Banker Oct.-Dec. 22&23. CIBN Press.
Fakunle, B. (2006), Audit Companion. 2nd Edition Lagos
Idowu, A. (2009), An assessment of fraud and its management in Nigeria commercial banks. European Journal of Social Sciences, 10(4)
628-640
NDIC: Nigeria Deposit Insurance Corporation “Annual Report and Statement of Account”. Various Issues (2000 -2009), Lagos, Nigeria.
Ogbunka, N.M., 2002. Risk and internal control. Management in Financial Institutions, pp: 187-188
Ojo, J. A. (2008), Effect of bank frauds on banking operations in Nigeria. International Journal of Investment and Finance 1(1), p 103.
Olatunji, O.C., 2009. Impact of internal control system in banking sector in Nigeria. Pak. J. Social Sci.,
6: pp.181-189.
Olisabu, E. S. (1991). Banking in Nigeria: Sign post in the nineties. First Bank Quarterly Review June 1991 Edition.
Oseni, E. (2006). Across the counter frauds in the Banking Industry and evaluation of some of the available controls. The Nigerian
Accountant , January/March
Robertson, J.C. (1996). Auditing. 8th Edition, Irwin Book Team Publications, London
Withittington, O.R. and Pany, K. (2004), Principles of auditing and other assurance services. McGraw hill.4th Edition.
289

Multiple Personality and the Dependence on an Intimate Ambience

( Between Luigi Pirandello and Ernest Koliqi)
Alva Dani
Faculty of Foreign Languages

University of Shkoder “Luigj Gurakuqi”, Albania
E.mail: [email protected]
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.291
Abstract:The author of this article aims at analysing the motif of multiple personality which emerges as a consequence of the
modern man crisis. By making a comparison with Luigi Pirandello and referring to short stories by Ernest Koliqi, she intends to
make known the presence of this phenomenon even in the Albanian literature of the years ’20-’30. This is no accidental
comparison, for Ernest Koliqi was an Albanian writer who was educated from early age in the Italian colleges and later on in the
Italian Universities. He worshiped Italian literature and believed in its educational power. With his philosophical way of thinking
and deep psychological and spiritual analysis, Pirandello influenced Koliqi’s work and it can be said that he elaborated Koliqi’s
way of reflecting and art making. This is best illustrated through the analysis of an individual’s personality, who does not have a
certain identity any more, but only a conflict with himself/herself and the ambience that surrounds him/her, which will inevitably
push him/her toward a fatal solution.
Keywords: personality, ambience, psychological war, identity, drama, impuls
1. Introduzione
La personalità dell’individuo rimane uno degli argomenti più interessanti che ha continuamente attirato
l’attenzione non solo degli psicologi e filosofi, ma anche e specialmente degli scrittori e letterati, i quali hanno
sempre preferito giocare con i loro personaggi, trasformarli e renderli capaci di tutto. Però si sa che la
personalità costituisce la ragione di essere di molti comportamenti e atteggiamenti, di molti pensieri e giudizi
che caratterizzano tutti gli esseri umani, in tutte le loro forme, in quelle che sono realmente e in quelle che
appaiono. Luigi Pirandello, il celebre scrittore e il grande erudita italiano riuscì a penetrare a fondo, meglio di
chiunque altro, la psicologia dell’uomo e riuscì a capire prima di tutto che essa è mutabile. Uguale alla vita
stessa che oltre l’essenza, porta anche una sua forma, che sarebbe come una veste esterna che si cambia
continuamente a seconda del punto di vista degli altri. Questo rapporto è stato studiato da molto tempo, da
grandi filosofi, cominciando da Aristotele, ma l’interpretazione di Pirandello, costituisce un’altra particolarità
della sua arte, un’altra sua filosofia, un’altra linea di ragionamento e un’altra maniera di percepire le diverse
situazioni e i diversi personaggi che ne partecipano. Questo significa che la personalità dell’individuo e la sua
realtà psichica si mettono proprio al centro della sua narrativa, facendo svanire, in questo modo il ruolo della
fabula. E così la fabula non ha più l’importanza di prima, la sua funzione rimane limitata, si serve solo per
mettere più in evidenza e dare più importanza alla personalità del personaggio centrale dell’opera. In base al
pensiero filosofico di Pirandello, questa personalità risulta composta di molti elementi, i quali nel momento in
cui si scompongono, fanno sì che questa personalità non si riconosca più, perché l’individuo stesso può
essere uno1, ma può essere anche nessuno, o anche centomila, creando una realtà psichica problematica e
in molti casi molto difficile a percepirla.
Questi importanti pensieri filosofici hanno sicuramente influenzato la narrativa del tempo e non solo quella
italiana. Pirandello era un grande erudita e quindi un grande esempio a cui riferirsi, per molti altri scrittori

1 Parole prese dal titolo dell’opera di Pirandello “Uno, nessuno e centomila”
291
europei. Uno di quelli era anche lo scrittore albanese Ernest Koliqi (1903 – 1975)2, il quale visse per molti
anni in Italia e lavorò come professore universitario a Roma, dove anche morì. Nutriva una grande
ammirazione per la letteratura e la civiltà italiana, e questo lo dimostrava tramite le continue traduzioni di
molte opere classiche e non solo di questa letteratura, in modo che anche il lettore albanese di quel tempo
conoscesse e raffinasse i suoi gusti con le opere più famose di questa letteratura europea, dimostrando in
questo modo anche una padronanza perfetta della lingua italiana.
Non sappiamo se Koliqi ha avuto dei contatti diretti con Pirandello, ma siamo certi di una cosa, che lui ha
letto la sua opera e in modo consapevole o no ha ricevuto una certa influenza, specialmente per quanto
riguarda la psicologia del personaggio e la scomposizione della personalità. È interessante come i
personaggi di questi due autori, scoprono in un certo momento della loro vita il valore artificiale della forma e
degli schemi che li rendono stranieri a loro stessi. E poi sicuramente, “... l’uomo che “ha capito il gioco”, per
usare un’espresione pirandelliana, si rende conto della convenzionalità dei valori accettati, dei ruoli assunti e
subiti, delle istituzioni – prima fra tutte la famiglia – che reggono la vita associata, ma questa scoperta lo
porta a una solitudine e incomunicabilità con gli altri ancora maggiore, così che talvolta l’unico sbocco è la
pazzia o il suicidio” (Guglielmino/Glosser: 771).
2. Analisi
Leggendo le novelle pirandelliane, si incontra una galleria eccezionale di personaggi tratti da uno sfondo
severo siciliano, ai quali è stato imposto di muovere solo entro alcuni pregiudizi remoti, entro i canoni
tramandati per secoli, da una generazione all’altra. Ed è proprio qui il punto dove nasce il conflitto, dove
nasce in fin dei conti la crisi dell’uomo moderno. E infatti l’uomo è cosi preso dalla vita, dal lavoro che fa, dai
rapporti intensi con la gente, tanto che spesso dimentica chi è veramente. E per questo Pirandello pensa che
esiste un momento di tranquillità interiore “...in cui l’anima nostra si spoglia di tutte le finzioni abituali, e gli
occhi nostri diventano più acuti e più penetranti, noi vediamo noi stessi nella vita, e in se stessa la vita, quasi
in una nudità arida, inquietante; ci sentiamo assaltare da una strana inpressione, come se in un baleno, ci si
chiarisse una realtà diversa da quella che normalmente percepiamo, una realta vivente oltre la vista umana,
fuori delle forme dell’umana ragione” (Pirandello, 1993: 119). Questo modo di scrivere pieno di tensione
sembra testimoniare l’esperienza della vita stessa di Pirandello, un aspetto molto importante che aiuta a
capire bene la filosofia del suo pensiero. Una delle novelle che trasmette questo suo modo di ragionare è la
Carriola, l’unico personaggio della quale, un avvocato – professore, rimasto davanti il nome scritto sulla porta
della casa sua, sente un lampo di luce che gli percorre l’intero corpo e gli fa capire che è un’altra persona,
diversa dalla forma che gli è dovuto assumere per servire ai bambini, alla moglie, agli studenti, e a tutte le
persone che gli avevano fidato la proprietà, l’onore, la vita. Ma lui reagisce dal profondo dell’anima, contro
questa forma imposta, con una grande rabbia: “ E grido, l’anima mia grida dentro questa forma morta che
mai non è stata mia... E ho nausea, orrore, odio di questo che non sono io... questa forma morta, in cui sono
prigioniero e da cui non mi posso liberare” (Pirandello, 1993). E il professore continua a subire dei
cambiamenti sotto questo flusso di coscienza che l’ha assorbito quasi tutto intero, continua a muoversi tra
istinti e idee, tra pensieri e dubbi, e si rende conto che sotto questa forma data dalla società, c’è il vuoto, c’è

2 Ernest Koliqi nacque a Scutari il 20 maggio 1903. All’inizio studiò al collegio gesuita “Arici” a Brescia, poi a Bergamo insieme ad altri
giovani fondò il giornale “Noi giovani”. Dopo dieci anni di residenza italiana, torna in Albania nel 1921, per partire di nuovo verso l’ex –
Jugoslavia nel 1924. Pubblica a Tirana il poema drammatico “Kushtimi i Skenderbeut”. Il 1929 pubblica a Zara la raccolta di novelle “Hija
e maleve” (L’ombra delle montagne). Il successo di questo libro lo battezzò come il fondatore della novella albanese. Dal 1930 fino a
1933, insegna letteratura presso il ginnasio statale di Scutari. Traduce dall’italiano “I grandi poeti d’Italia”, (le poesie di Dante, Petrarca,
Ariosto e Tasso), seguito da un secondo volume. Pubblica il libro di poesie “Gjurmat e stineve” e “Kangjellat e Rilindjes”. Nel 1935 esce
la raccolta di novelle “Tregtar flamujsh” (Commercianti di bandiere). Nel 1937 finì gli studi presso l’Università di Padova. Per molti anni
dirige la Cattedra della lingua e letteratura albanese all’Università di Roma. Dal 1957 fino al 1973 pubblica il periodico letterario più noto
“Shenjzat” (Le pleiadi), uno dei monumenti insostituibili della letteratura albanese. Muore a Roma il 15 febbraio 1975.
292
la verità che lui non ha mai vissuto realmente, e così deve continuare ad accettare questa forma. ”Serve così
e non posso mutarla, non posso prenderla a calci e levarmela dai piedi... se non per un attimo solo, ogni
giorno... cogliendo con trepidazione e circospezione infinita il momento opportuno, che nessuno mi veda”
(Pirandello, 1159). Eppure il personaggio si rende conto che può essere un momento in cui si può vedere se
stesso, si può sentire in un profondo silenzio la voce dell’anima, che rivela chi è lui veramente e cos’altro può
fare (giusto come il caso quando gioca con il cane, prende le due zampine di dietro e lo fa fare la carriola,
proprio come fanno i bambini). La forma e il contenuto stanno come due parti inseparabili di un corpus intero,
di una personalità che si trasforma. E tutte le volte che una mette capo, l’altra si rimpicciolisce e dorme in
silenzio, per svegliarsi appunto quando uno lo stuzzica e lo irrita, oppure tutte le volte che trova il terreno
giusto per svilupparsi, e dominare l’altra.
La novella “Gjaku” (Il sangue) di Ernest Koliqi è quella che ci offre la possibilità di vedere come si può
trasformare una personalità anche nella letteratura albanese, come si può cambiare fino a diventare vittima
di un dramma spietato senza nemmeno accorgersene. Dramma che è capace di sconvolgerlo e svestirlo
dalla bella forma che aveva preso con così tanta fatica e dedizione. È una novella che va interpretata sotto
un’ottica psicologica, più che artistica. Si tratta di uno studio profondo della psicologia del personaggio
centrale chiamato Dodë, dei gravi conflitti che gli nascono dentro, in rapporto con se stesso e specialmente
con la cultura dell’ambiente dov’è cresciuto. Doda è un insegnante, preparato e istruito nelle scuole europee,
è un intellettuale che vuole portare a termine una missione: portare la luce della civiltà a un popolo immerso
nelle tenebre dell’ignoranza. Ma questa sua missione coraggiosa doveva avere delle forti fondamenta, per
poter soppravivere e per poter penetrare la profonda realtà spirituale albanese, scolpita nei secoli,
generazione dopo generazione. Ma in modo del tutto naturale subentra un elemento narrativo che impedirà
la continuazione della missione e sconvolgerà i forti principi. Zeka, il fratello di Doda verrà ucciso da i Fetej e
secondo la legge del Kanun* lui ha il dovere della vendetta del sangue del fratello, cosa inaccettabile per i
principi di Doda.
La sua realtà psichica divenne sempre più grave, Doda ormai si trova nel suo stretto ambiente, nella terra
dov’è nato e cresciuto, nella terra dove le ombre delle montagne fanno le leggi e condannano fino alla morte.
È qui che comincia il suo conflitto con se stesso, comincia la scossa della personalità, la trasformazione di
una persona ben istruita, e alla fine il ritorno all’origine. Doda assomiglia a uno di quei personaggi
pirandelliani che si smaniano per le inquietudini e i dubbi tremendi, che parla continuamente con la sua
coscienza, e assume degli atteggiamenti e comportamenti che mai avrebbe potuto pensare. Possiamo
interpretare questa novella seguendo due linee principali, riferendosi in questo modo al ragionamento
filosofico di Pirandello. La prima linea consiste nel rapporto tra Doda e l’ambiente in cui vive quotidianamente
e in cui ritorna dopo vent’anni di lunghi studi in Europa, cioè il rapporto con la società, con i genitori che non
gli permettono di scordare neanche per un momento chi è veramente e qual’è il suo compito. Suo padre
vuole che lui riprenda il sangue del fratello “... se la scuola non ti ha ancora tolto la “burrnija” non devi
trascurare di compiere quel dovere che tu hai...” e anche il prete della montagna insiste nella vendetta del
sangue “Il sangue non diventa acqua, caro signorino. Siamo albanesi e in noi agisce l’influsso dell’ambiente.”
(Guzzetta, 1968: 44), ed anche la madre della sua fidanzata, Nusha, che gli voleva bene come ai propri
occhi, “ Io so che domani o dopodomani, tra un mese o tra un anno, sfogherai la tua giusta collera contro
qualcuno di quelli che hanno verso di te un debito di sangue” (Guzzetta, 1968). Tutta la gente gli ricorda il
suo dovere, la restituzione del debito. Sono quelle montagne, laddove è cresciuto, che gli ricordano che il
suo sangue contiene la loro DNA, che per lui è proprio impossibile separarsi da quell’ambiente ovunque lui
vada e qualunque forma lui prenda. Questa prima linea, cioè questo rapporto elabora il suo carattere e lo
rende un individuo dipendente da loro, una cosa difficilmente accettabile da lui. Ciò porta inevitabilmente un
conflitto interno, che continuerà a svilupparsi durante tutta la novella e costituirà la sua essenza, offrendoci
così da seguire la seconda linea di studio. Questa seconda linea consiste in un secondo rapporto, tra Doda e
la sua coscienza, come una continua lotta tra quello che lui desiderava fare e a quello che passo dopo passo
verrà sottoposto a causa di una insistente pressione psicologica. Il flusso di coscienza è uno degli elementi
293
fondamentali che aiuta nell’esposizione di tutti i sentimenti, ricordi e dolori che prova questo personaggio, un
flusso che divenne sempre più violento, tutte le volte che si sconvolgono le fondamenta della cultura “...
gettata su una base malsicura, rose e urtate dalle correnti indomabili delle forze ataviche” (Guzzetta, 1968:
52). All’inizio lui sembra irremovibile e pieno di fiducia in quello che rappresenta, pensando di essere tanto
abile e istruito da poter sopravvivere a qualunque attacco esterno “Tutti mi sono levati contro... Nessuno mi
aiuta a tener duro contro la tentazione... Ebbene io, io resisterò a questo ambiente depravato... Io non mi
abbasserò davanti a questa coscienza bestiale e selvaggia... Io voglio essere un esempio vivo di coraggio
civile a quanti per l’avvenire dichiarerà guerra alle malvagie usanze” (Guzzetta, 1968: 58). Ma non durerà a
lungo e questa forte personalità, questa sana ragione comincierà a turbarsi e a sentire le inclinazioni
pericolose dell’acre istinto, i pregiudizi morbosi che dormono nell’inconscio, i pensieri cupi che quella sana
ragione non può nemmeno accettare. Ormai la vita di prima era troppo lontana, era quasi estranea a lui;
come se non fosse stato lui a viverla ma qualcun’altro. Doda ha già perso la forma con la quale aveva vissuto
fino a quel momento, la forma che gli aveva dato la scuola, la cultura e la civiltà nella quale aveva vissuto per
lunghi anni, e dalla quale pensava che non ci sarebbe stata nessuna ragione al mondo a separarlo. Ma, “egli
sentiva che impercettibili fermenti cominciavano a muoversi e schiudersi... Mani invisibili l’afferravan dietro la
schiena e l’attiravano dietro le tenebre... Gli sembrò d’impazzire”
Koliqi è uno scrittore di rare virtù e di grande talento. Lui ha saputo conoscere bene la personalità umana,
così come fece anche Pirandello, ma nel frattempo Koliqi ebbe il merito di conoscere profondamente la realtà
psichica dell’albanese, una realtà più che difficile, a causa dell’indole stessa troppo chiusa del suo popolo.
Koliqi si comporta da bravissimo analista che sa capire e penetrare mirabilmente la mente, è un novellista
“che sa entrare nel profondo dei sentimenti secolari del popolo, sa come analizzarli e dipingerli; è un abile
descrittore di emozioni e diversi stati d’animo” (Smaqi, 1998: 73). Così si scriveva di Koliqi fin dal 1930, un
anno dopo in cui scrisse Hija e maleve (L’ombra delle montagne). Lui ci fece conoscere la pesante realtà
interiore di una persona che soffre, che prova delle profonde confusioni, nel tentativo di mantenere vivo la
forma da una parte e quella di indebolire il suo contenuto dall’altra. Questo principio morale della vendetta
del sangue, questa usanza era ormai diventata un’istituzione radicata e tramandata per secoli, generazione
dopo generazione. Doda non solo non può far niente per cambiarlo, ma si trasformerà in un assassino, in un
criminale, che non avrebbe mai voluto essere, in una persona che pensava di averlo lasciato dietro per
sempre, abbracciando una nuova visione per il suo avvenire e per quello della nazione albanese. Il
personaggio di Doda analizzato in queste due linee di studio può trovare una sicura base teorica, in quella di
Pirandello, secondo il quale “La vita è un flusso continuo che noi cerchiamo d’arrestare, di fissare in forme
stabili e determinate, dentro e fuori di noi, ... Le forme... sono i concetti, sono gli ideali a cui vorremmo
serbarci coerenti, tutte le finzioni che ci creiamo... Ma dentro di noi stessi, in ciò che noi chiamiamo anima, e
che è la vita in noi... sotto gli argini, oltre i limiti che imponiamo, componendoci una coscienza, costruendoci
una personalità” (Pazzaglia, 1992: 305). Quella insistente e forte personalità che possedeva anche Doda, la
quale lo fece resistere a lungo senza scuotersi di fronte ai pregiudizi pericolosi dell’ambiente esterno. Ma
facendo avanti con lo schema filosofico di Pirandello giungeremmo la stessa conclusione di Koliqi, e
avremmo lo stesso destino che subì anche il suo personaggio, Doda. Pirandello avverte la perdita della
forma, l’intera trasformazione del personaggio, e il suo passaggio in un’altra fase di sviluppo esprimendosi in
questo modo: “In certi momenti tempestosi, investite dal flusso, tutte quelle nostre forme fittizie crollano
miseramente” (Pazzaglia, 1992). In egual modo come crollarono gli ideali di Doda e ogni altra forma che lui
poté assumere faticosamente. Ne fu sufficiente questo primo confronto con il suo reale contenuto, con
l’ambiente e la società, per capire che tutto quello in cui lui credeva era destinato a finire forse, ancora prima
di cominciare. Ma questa insolita confusione di personalità, ci porta verso un’insolita conclusione della
novella. L’omicidio compiuto da Doda non era il risultato di un’azione ben pensata oppure di un giudizio
momentaneo a sangue caldo che può caratterizzare chiunque davanti un simile omicidio, ma venne come
risultato di una giornata serena e di un’anima limpida, come se tutta quella lotta interiore fossa passata senza
nessun rimorso, come se Doda finalmente avesse deciso di continuare la sua missione gettando dietro le
294
spalle il tormento dei pregiudizi e ogni altro influsso che spargeva solo buio e ignoranza. “La sua anima era
calma come l’onda che dorme al sole, senza rughe e senza tremiti. Nessun pensiero triste più lo inquietava;
nessuna traccia più, in lui, delle lotte terribili della vigilia... I suoi sentimenti erano limpidi come i raggi del
sole. Anche la voce gli suonava più chiara per la via, nel rispondere ai saluti mattutini dei conoscenti.”
(Guzzetta, 1968: 59). Sembra molto strano per una logica normale, provare una così grande serenità.
Seguendo le azioni di Doda, sembra quasi seguire il ragionamento che continua e fare Pirandello durante lo
sviluppo della sua filosofia, dando in questo modo anche una possibile spiegazione a quella strana serenità
che aveva invaso la sua anima. “Con uno sforzo supremo cerchiamo allora di riacquistar la coscienza
normale delle cose, di riallacciar con esse le consuete relazioni... Ma a questa coscienza normale... a questo
sentimento solito della vita non possiamo più prestar fede, perche sappiamo ormai che sono un nostro
inganno per vivere e che sotto c’è qualcos’altro, a cui l’uomo non può affacciarsi, se non a costo di morire o
impazzire” (Pazzaglia, 1992: 306). Questo significa che tutta quella tranquillità che aveva avvolto il
personaggio era falso, perché si trattava solo di un modo per nascondere quello che lo faceva soffrire e dal
quale non aveva mai potuto staccarsi, neanche per un solo momento. Dopo quella finzione, dopo quel falso
stato di tranquillità, dopo un ultimo sforzo per mantenere viva la normalità, avremmo di conseguenza una
soluzione fatale, che deve avere per forza la novella di Koliqi, una morte che riuscirà a stabilizzare il rapporto
del personaggio con l’ambiente (solo dopo aver realizzato l’omicidio la società sarà più soddisfatta da Doda
“Il colpo t’apporti gloria... E fuggi , che noi t’apriamo la via”) e specialmente metterà in pace la sua anima
(“Solo in fondo a quella sua povera anima tormentata c’era qualcosa di lieve: come un senso indefinito di
liberazione”) anche se con un prezzo che lui aveva deciso di non accettare. Questa realizzazione artistica di
questo stato d’animo, cioè quando Doda si trova di fronte all’assassino, lo troviamo in ugual modo anche
nell’altra novella koliqiana Ke tre lisat (Dalle tre querce) ed è proprio il momento in cui Mrika prende la
decisione di salvare il suo uomo amato prima di separarsi definitivamente da lui. Dopo una lunga notte in
febbre “Tutta la debolezza del suo corpo, tutta la incertezza del suo animo che l’avevano fiaccata la sera
prima, erano scomparse, come fugate dalla luce dell’alba” (Guzzetta, 1968: 74). Lei era completamente
tranquilla, serena e pienamente chiara, così come anche Doda “Ella non pensava a nulla. Era padrona
assoluta dei suoi nervi. Aveva la fredda calma di chi è risoluto a tutto. Immobile, una cosa sola con la roccia
cui era appoggiata, gli occhi perduti in lontananza attendeva, paziente, calma, senza preoccuparsi del tempo
che passava”. Mrika è un altro personaggio, tanto normale quanto Doda, con una stessa filosofia di azione,
che lo porterà senza il minimo dubbio verso una morte quasi sicura. È proprio questo substrato filosofico
nella concezione artistica delle novelle che dà a questa prosa koliqiana il sapore della modernità.
3. Conclusione
A questo punto noi possiamo ritenere che quello che congiunge Koliqi e Pirandello è la psicologia moderna e
proprio quel suo punto in cui si mette in crisi l’identità dell’individuo, una tesi totalmente diversa da quella che
sosteneva la psicologia tradizionale. Si sà ormai che la psicologia tradizionale sostiene chiaramente
l’esistenza di una sola identità dell’uomo. Secondo questa tesi ognuno di noi si trova in continue relazioni con
gli altri e quindi in situazioni dalle più diverse, e così di conseguenza è obbligato ad adattarsi e comportarsi in
diversi modi. Ma dentro se stesso, l’individuo non cambia, cambiano solo gli atteggiamenti, così come si
cambiano i vestiti tutte le volte che vogliamo mettere qualcos’altro, oppure i diversi ruoli che gioca l’attore,
rimanendo sempre lo stesso individuo. Questa è la risposta della psicologia tradizionale, la quale non vuole e
non può rinunciare a questa identità dell’individuo. In tanto che con Pirandello, e poi anche con Koliqi non
succede la stessa cosa. È appunto questa identità personale che loro mettono in crisi, e con la quale si
occupa la psicanalisi, un metodo della psicologia moderna. Per lo scrittore albanese questo non sarebbe
stato per niente facile, perché subito dopo la pubblicazione delle novelle, si troverà davanti una troppo severa
critica. “Per Koliqi – scrive il critico albanese S.Çapaliku (1995) – è già finita l’epoca degli eroi e ha
cominciato a mettere capo l’epoca degli antieroi, come segno di una negatività sociale. Così la strada lo
295
porta verso i tabù, verso le cose che l’uomo albanese non aveva osato neanche pensarli, verso le categorie
dalle quali questo stesso uomo albanese provava una paura mortale”. E come risultato di questi punti di
vista, di questi pensieri controcorrente e contro tradizione, verrà criticato in un articolo del 1930, intitolato
“Volumi letterari – Ombra delle montagne” ( Criticus, 1930: 114) in questo modo “... un’opera per quanto
classica sia, se non corrisponde ai principi della ragione e dell’umanità, ... porta innumerevoli danni in tutti i
livelli della vita sociale e individuale ”. La stessa cosa si dirà anche in un altro articolo del 1935, intitolato
“L’arte letteraria e il morale”: “Se volete veramente educare il popolo albanese, e non volete ubriacarlo,
dovete tener presente la forza morale ed anche il potere spirituale dei lettori, misurateci bene quello che la
sua anima può sopportare e quello che non può”. Questa ci offre una ragione in più per pensare quanto
lontano sembra Koliqi per il lettore di quel tempo, e per di più per i letterati e i critici, i quali non volevano
vedere la nudità della vita e della mente. Si tratta di un altro punto di vista, da dove abbiamo cercato non solo
di fare un riscontro possibile tra questi due scrittori, ma anche di capire il perché di quest’arte di Koliqi.
Perché era proprio lui a impadronirsi di questo particolare modo di fare arte, creando una rottura con la
tradizione dei predecessori e scrivendo una letteratura moderna di stampo europeo.
References
Criticus, (1930) Vallime letrare – Hija e maleve, Hylli i dritës, nr. 2

Çapaliku. S (1995), Artisti si auto-da-fe, Studime shqiptare 3, Shkodër
De Sanctis. F (1994), Storia della letteratura italiana, Vicenza, Orsa Maggiore
Guzzetta. A (1968), Ernest Koliqi, un poeta sociale, Milano
Hamiti. S (2000), Letërsia moderne shqiptare, Tiranë, Alb-ass
Pirandello. L (1993), Novelle per un anno, Milano, Newton
Pirandello. L (1993), L’Umorismo, Roma, Newton
Pazzaglia. M (1992), Il Novecento 4, Bologna, Zanichelli
Smaqi. L (1998) Receptimi i veprës së Ernest Koliqit në vitet ‘30, Studime filologjike, nr 3-4, Tiranë
296
More than Fabric Motifs: Changed Meaning of Nsibidi on the Efik Ukara Cloth
Babson Ajibade
Department of Visual Arts and Technology,

Cross River University of Technology, Calabar, Nigeria
Esther Ekpe
Department of Visual Arts and Technology,

Cross River University of Technology, Calabar, Nigeria
Theodora Bassey
Department of Theatre and Media Studies,

University of Calabar, Calabar, Nigeria
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.297
Abstract: Among the Ejagham people of the Cross River, extending from the Cameroon to Nigeria’s Cross River Sate, the ukara
cloth and nsibidi visual signs are very critical aspects of history, religion and general cultural worldviews. While the ukara cloth is
prominent among initiates of the Ejagham’s many Leopard Societies, the nsibidi is a visual language, unspoken but forming the
main body of motifs on the ukara fabric design. As a traditional African written language peculiar to the Ejagham peoples,
Carlson (2003: 225) has suggested that nsibidi can “adapt to new historical circumstances and culture” when transmitted to non-
Ejagham societies. Using evidence from fieldwork in villages in five local government areas where Efik clans are located in
Cross River State, this study sort to find out if the meanings of key nsibidi signs have changed or adapted when transmitted into
a non-Ejagham cultural space in Calabar. The study found out that the transmission from the Ejagham culture to that of the Efik
has brought on adaptations and changes in the meaning of nsibidi. And, that through its use in the design of the ukara fabric of
the Ekpe society, nsibidi has maintained its relevance among the Efik for many centuries because of its ability to adapt to new
social and cultural situations, while remaining true to its original identity.
Keywords: Ejagham, Calabar, Efik, ukara cloth, nsibidi, visual language, cultural space, change,
1. Introduction
Nigeria’s Cross River State is one of 36 states. It is situated southeast of the country and shares boarder with
Cameroon, close to the Atlantic Ocean. The state derives its name from Cross River, a river that traverses
Cross River and Akwa Ibom states and empties into the Atlantic Ocean from its rise in the Cameroon
Mountain. According to Röshenthaler (1996:10), Cross River “curves from the Cameroon grasslands to the
Atlantic ocean”. Geographically, the river is usually divided into the ‘upper Cross River’ and ‘lower Cross
River’. While the lower Cross River includes the whole of Akwa Ibom State, Calabar, Odukpani, and
Akamkpa local government areas in Cross River State, the upper Cross River consists of Obubra, Ikom,
Ogoja, Obudu and Ugep. Along with ethnic groups that flow across to the Cameroon, these Nigerian
ethnicities are called the Ejagham group, whose “territory is concentrated within the large southwest bend of
the Cross River” (Röshenthaler 1996:10). According to estimates, the Ejagham language is spoken by about
70,000 speakers in Nigeria (Languages of the World 2010).
Efik, Qua and Efut are the three ethnic groups in Calabar, the southernmost part of Cross River State,
near the Atlantic Ocean. Of the three ethnicities, the Qua are Ejagham. With a population of about 1.2 million,
Calabar is also the capital city of Cross River state. Whereas each of the three ethnic groups in Calabar has
297
its own different language, they nonetheless share certain cultural patterns such as occupation, food,
dressing, architecture, arts, crafts and rich cultural enactments like masquerading – of which the Ekpe is the
most prominent. The Ekpe masquerade is owned and enacted by a cult of the same name among the Efik.
While literature suggests that the Ekpe institution diffused from Ejagham to Efik land, it appears that the
ukara cloth (the Ekpe’s official fabric) with its nsibidi designs, came along in the diffusion.
2. Statement of the Problem
Carlson writes that nsibidi should not be apprehended as a static thing of the past. Rather, nsibidi needs be
seen to provide an intellectual tradition that has “relevance today” and can “adapt to new historical
circumstances and culture” (2003: 225). Therefore, if as Carlson insists, the nsibidi can change meaning as it
adapts to new cultural contexts, is there evidence to suggest that its transmission from the Ejagham culture
to that of the Efik has brought on adaptations and changes in meaning? Using evidence from fieldwork in
seven clans of the Efik, this study sort to find out if the meanings of key nsibidi signs have changed or
adapted when transmitted into a non-Ejagham cultural space in Calabar.
3. Methodology
In terms of methodology, the authors had personal interviews with initiates, elders, priests and shrine
attendants of the Ekpe society using enlarged and tabulated nsibidi visuals to which respondents offered the
contemporary meanings associated with particular nsibidi signs among the Efik. To get the broadest view, the
authors went to villages in Odukpani, Calabar Municipality, Calabar South, Akpabuyo and Bakassi (five local
government areas of Cross River State where Efik clans are located), collated and harmonized the
responses in a tabular form. Since most of the respondents are not literate in the (written) English language,
the Efik language was used in most personal interviews and the authors recorded interviewees’ responses.
The results of this visual survey among the Efik of Calabar were then tabulated and compared to that
encountered by Carlson (2003) among the Bakor-Ejagham people.
4. Ekpe, Nsibidi and Ukara among the Efik of Calabar
While ‘Ekpe’ is the name of a masquerade among the Efik of Calabar, the term is also the name of the
leopard and of the traditional sacred institution that owns the masque. The Ekpe (sometimes called Mgbe)
society is also called the ‘leopard’ society because the Ekpe masquerade is a visual cultural reference to a
leopard – its costume, makeup and props define it as such. The link between the Ejagham peoples, the Ekpe
society and the leopard goes back in time. Koloss (1985) narrates a story that links the fear of the leopard to
Ejagham people in 1904. At the time the Ejagham and their neighbours rebelled and the German colonial
administration had to resettle the population into larger villages, for easier control. However, much social
tension prevailed among the people, which resulted in witchcraft accusations in which many suspected
witches were murdered. Coincidentally, at the same time witches were said to be killing people, man-eating
leopards were also mauling people in the communities. The killer leopards were not deemed culpable.
Rather, the communities interpreted the fearsome man-eating leopard as the witches’ preferred form. It does
seem, as Marwick (1965) suggests, that witchcraft accusations are indices of social tension and accusing
others of witchcraft enables accusers to sever relationships with the accused, using real or imagined
episodes. In this case the leopard and the fear of it has remained among the Ejagham generally and has
been appropriated as part of the corporate ambience of the Ekpe cult. The Ekpe society is the most
renowned traditional institution in Efik history not just because of its spiritual or cultic functions but also for the
fact that the institution was a pre-colonial police and judiciary system. The Ekpe was vested with the powers
of policing and bringing justice to the Efik kingdom. In a Personal Interview (2011) with Chief Edem Okon, a
298
long standing initiate of Ekpe, he made it very clear: “In the olden days before the white man came into
contact with the Efik people, Ekpe was government. Ekpe was in control of everything. The white man even
used Ekpe to organize and push people to attend church services. Nothing was possible in Efik society
without Ekpe”. In essence, the Ekpe society was the law before the advent of colonialism and western
democracy. Today, however the Ekpe cult is still strong among the Efik. But it has no function within the
postcolonial democratic frameworks of governance. Membership is still very strong and masquerading and
other cultic performances are very visible in the society.
One of the most prominent paraphernalia of the Ekpe society is the ukara cloth, a fabric that is used by
members of the cult. As the official and traditional apparel of the Ekpe society, the ukara is a blue and white
fabric inscribed with two dimensional motifs called nsibidi (it is called nsibiri among the Ejagham). While
initiates wear the ukara fabric as a wrapper, the cloth may also become a wall hanging of sort in the personal
spaces of individual initiates or at a venue for the cult’s activities. Nsibidi motifs also form a good part of the
visuality of the Ekpe masquerade’s costume.
While scholars have written bout the Ejagham generally (Thompson 1974, Kubik 1986, Onor 1994,
Röschenthaler 1996, and Ojong 2008), the most comprehensive work done about the nsibidi is Amanda
Carlson’s Nsibidi, Gender, and Literacy: the Art of the Bakor-Ejagham, Cross River State (2003). Carlson’s
extensive fieldwork among the Bakor Ejagham people dealt with funerary sculptures, monoliths,
masquerades, body and calabash decorations employing nsibidi motifs in the broader context of sign-use. To
Carlson, nsibidi is performance, object and graphic communication. Based on her interactions with producers
of ukara cloth in Aro Chukwu (Abia State) and merchants in Calabar who sell the fabric, the author insists
that the ukara cloth is both a trade good and a contemporary channel for transmitting nsibidi.
In another light, Carlson underscores the fact that unlike men’s use of it, Ejagham women use nsibidi
visual forms without “overt emphasis on secrecy or the mediation of power” (216). As women paint both their
bodies and that of ancestral representations like monoliths, they “are actively involved in a discourse that
creates meaning in relation to the body, one of the most potent and powerful symbols within Ejagham culture”
(217). Thus, as an African writing system, nsibidi, be it on the body, fabric or other cultural spaces “provides a
language that is not dependent on verbal communication” as “it allowed for linkages between the numerous
peoples of the Cross River region” (217).
Whereas the term nsibidi is popularly known as the visual motifs or writings on Ejagham cultural artifacts
like the Ikom monoliths, the ukara cloth and as body decorations among the Efiks, it is also the name of a
special team of seven virgin young men (members of the Ekpe society) who are sent to make arrests for
serious crimes that usually attract the death penalty. On this trip the nsibidi are masked with multicolour body
painting. Pre-outing preparations take 7 days in the forest until they become ‘spiritual’ entities. Only second
sons (and never first sons) of initiates are permitted to become nsibidi. A first son must go into hiding when
nsibidi is passing, else the nsibidi will literally extract flesh from his body. While on an arrest mission, the
nsibidi boys do not talk but hold fresh palm fronds in their mouths and can only make a humming sound.
They come topless and wear only a skirt made from palm fronds also. As far as the Efik tradition goes, it is
forbidden for women to gaze upon the nsibidi except women that are initiates of the Ekpe (Chief Edem Okon,
Personal Interview). At the end of the assignment, the nsibidi must go back into the forest to be debriefed and
neutralised before it becomes safe for them to re-enter the society. As a distinguishing feature of the broad
Ejagham cultural group spread across Nigeria and Cameroon (Thompson, 1974), the nsibidi motifs inscribed
in the ukara textile’s surface function as both ideograms and pictograms (Onor, 1994, Kubik, 1986). In fact,
Ojong (2008) has compared the Ejagham nsibidi to the Egyptian hieroglyphics. To the Efik people, the
pictographic and ideographic nsibidi is in fact a ‘language’ rather than a mere system of motifs. Chief Edem
Okon puts it succinctly:
Whereas the ukara cloth produced today are on white fabric, the olden days types were made on thicker
brownish calico. The scripts on the ukara cloth are nsibidi. But nsibidi is not limited to the symbols on the
ukara cloth. Nsibidi is more than that. Nsibidi includes a whole range of verbal and non-verbal sign
299
systems, including body movement, eye language, drawing in the air, or on the floor with the feet and
many more. It is with the nsibidi that initiates talk among themselves and with the Ekpe. Right under the
nose of non-initiates, an initiate can hold a conversation with the Ekpe using only eye movements.
Nsibidi is the language of Ekpe and nsibidi is Ekpe.
Nsibidi sign system is used among initiates of the Ekpe society in Efik land to communicate with one another
and with the Ekpe. While individuals may inscribe it as tattoos or on walls at home or the cult’s spaces, the
ukara cloth, which is the official apparel of the Ekpe society, is the most prominent surface on which nsibidi is
utilized and circulated among the Efik of Calabar. Members of the Ekpe society tie the cloth during the cult’s
activities and meetings. Larger versions of the ukara fabric are sometimes hung on one wall of the leopard
society’s meeting place as backdrop for ritual and other social occasions to which only initiates are in
attendance.
The ukara is dyed only in indigo and nsibidi signs are embedded on the fabric by stitching and tie-dyeing
the fabric. After dyeing, the stitches and ties are removed to reveal the white designs that appear against the
deep blue background. The production process is essentially a resist dyeing method which, as Boser (1985)
notes, may be the oldest method of producing non-woven patterns on dyed fabric. The finished ukara cloth is
a patchwork of signs that uniformly cover the surface of the fabric. Besides functioning as a symbol of
membership in the Leopard Society the ukara cloth acts as a summary of the Ekpe cult, its social reputation
and its principles. There are several nsibidi signs such as leopard, snake, turtle, birds etc that appear on
ukara cloths and may signify multiple levels of meaning beyond the representation of the actual subject (see
Figures 2 and 3). However, there may be deeper more esoteric meanings associated with some symbols that
may only be known to certain category of initiates. According to Elder Etok from Calabar municipality, a
member of the cult, ukara cloth serves several functions to the members of the Ekpe society including the
following:
1. Ukara cloth is used by Ekpe members of sufficient rank and wealth, and these men are its designers.
2. Most ukara cloths are custom-made for specific individuals or ritual uses. A good many are
personalized these days with their owner’s names “written” in one corner.
3. Patterns are drawn from the Ukara cloth by Ekpe society members, incorporating both common Ekpe
designs and symbols with personal meanings for the prospective owner. (Personal Interview, 2011)
In a Personal Interview with Mr. Nsa Efangha, a native of Nsidung and an initiate of the Ekpe Society, he
reveals that while there is a newer form of ukara produced on white cotton fabric, there was an older version
that was made of very thick calico (Plates 1 and 2). This older version is difficult to come by these days and is
available only in the Ekpe cult’s shrine and other spaces belonging to the confraternity.
Plate 2: Contemporary ukara cloth made with white

Plate 1: An older form of ukara cloth made with
cotton fabric. Notice the better clarity and fidelity of
calico fabric, which is brownish.
lines and forms.
300
NASARAWA
KOGI
Makurdi
BENUE
Nigeria
EBONYI CROSS
RIVER
Cameroon
ABIA
Ejagham
Uyo
RIVER Aba
Calabar
AKWA IBOM
Port
Harourt Bight of Bonny
Figure 1: Map loosely indicating the Ejagham territory, from where the
Ekpe and nsibidi are thought to diffuse to the Efik who live in Calabar,
Figure 2: Some Nsibidi Symbols from the Ejagham people
Nsibidi Meaning Nsibidi Meaning

Dead friend/relative Pregnant woman
Captive Harlot
Stranger Snake
Sexual intercourse Palaver, Court case
Source: Adapted from Carlson 2003.
301
Figure 3: Some Nsibidi Symbols from the Efik people of Calabar
Nsibidi Names Meaning
Ekpe Indicating the Ekpe’s strength and potential for

(Usime-Ekpe) anger and violence against anything when
provoked.
Uden This is a harmless object of peace. It goes around

pecking at food.
Ubok This outspread palm is a representation of the

pioneers of the Ekpe society, as well as departed
prominent members. It is for remembering
important personages such as King James Eyo
Honesty from Creek Town.
Nkongho Inua This crustacean stays in the river and only comes
Akpa (Crab) out when the river is calm. It reflects the Ekpe’s
ability to adapt to its environment, and to be calm
and peaceful, in response to the immediate
environment.
Okposong Eto The Efik being a riverside people, the fish is a

prominent symbol. The image indicates four
fishes coming to the centre from the proverbial 4
corners of the earth. It shows Ekpe’s centrality in
the affairs of man.
Ufok Ekpe This set of concentric rectangles represents the

(Ekpe’s house) inner house of the Ekpe, which initiates are under
oath not to reveal.
5. Results
Figure 2 shows some nsibidi symbols identified by Carlson (2003) among the Ejagham people, while Figure 3
shows that from the Efik of Calabar. In Figure 2 the images are a lot simpler, and made up of lines in an
alphabetic sort of way. In Figure 3, however, the images are much more developed, in a pictographic way.
Whereas the Ejagham symbols are grossly abstracted, restricting understanding to the “enlightened” or
initiates, those of the Efik are much less so, providing easier insights into the meanings of the symbols for
302
everyday people. However, there are also highly complex nsibidi signs known only to initiates. While Efik
nsibidi is generally visually elaborate, those from the Ejagham are very simplified forms. The meaning of the
symbols also contributes to the differential in both forms of nsibidi. The Ejagham versions are straight
meanings representing a word or phrase (Figure 2). In contrast, however, the nsibidi of the Efik of Calabar
have elaborate and narrative meanings (Figure 2). On another note, most of the Efik nsibidi are reproduced
in indigo colour, while the Ejagham versions are often represented in neat, black lines. Thus, in terms of
scripting or reproduction, the Ejagham nsibidi may be faster, as against most of the Efik versions that need
more creative efforts in drawing and colour application.
6. Conclusion
If, as literature suggests, the Ekpe and its cultural nuances like the nsibidi writing system evolved from the
Ejagham and diffused elsewhere to neighboring peoples like the Efik of Calabar, then data from this study
seems to support the view. For, the Efik of Calabar are a much smaller culture residing south of Ejagham
territory, making it most probable for the Ekpe and nsibidi to diffuse through processes like inter-marriages,
migrations, trade and cultural cooperation generally. However, whereas the nsibidi may have diffused from
the Ejagham to the Efik of Calabar, Figures 2 and 3 suggest that nsibidi tradition has not been static but has
adapted to historical circumstances of the newer culture. As the differences in visual representation, style of
rendering and development of meaning in Figures 2 and 3 show, nsibidi can and does change meaning as it
adapts to new cultural contexts. Therefore, it is evident that the transmission from the Ejagham culture to that
of the Efik has brought on adaptations and changes in the meaning of nsibidi. Through its use in the design
of the ukara fabric of the Ekpe society, nsibidi has maintained its relevance among the Efik for many
centuries because of its ability to adapt to new social and cultural situations, while remaining true to its
original identity.
References
Boser, R. (1985). Textile and Text: Language and Technology in Yoruba Arts. Journal of Anthropological Research 41/2: 121 – 147.
Carlson, A. (2003) Nsibidi, Gender, and Literacy: the Art of the Bakor-Ejagham, Cross River State. PhD Thesis. Indiana University.
Kalu, O. (1980). Writing in Pre-colonial Africa: A Case Study of Nsibidi. In African Cultural Development. Ed. O. U. Kalu, Enugu: Forth
Dimension Publishers.
Koloss, H. (1985). Obasinjom Among the Ejagham. African Arts 18(2): 63-65+98-101+103.
Kubik, G. (1986). African Graphic Systems with Particular reference to the Benue-Congo or ‘Bantu’ Languages zone. Muntu 4(5): 72-
135.
Languages of the World. Ethnologue. Online. <http://www.ethnologue.com/show_language.asp?code=etu>. Accesses 02/10/11.
Marwick, M. G. (1965). “Some Problems in the Sociology of Witchcraft and Sorcery.” In African Systems of Thought. Eds. M. Fortes and
G. Dieterlen. London: Oxford UP: 171-191.
Ojong, F. E. (2008). Funeral Rites of the Ejagham People in Cross River State: An Appraisal of Akamkpa Local Government. Global
Journal of Social Sciences 7(2): 79-84.
Onor, S. O. (1994). The Ejagham Nation in the Cross River Region of Nigeria. Ibadan: Kraft Books.
Röschenthaler, U. (1996). Ejagham. New York: Rosen Publishing.
Thompson, R. F. (1974). African Art in Motion. Los Angeles: University of California Press.
303

The Usage of Information and Communication Technology in

Nigeria Primary Schools:Problems and Prospects
Bada Tayo Abass, Ph.D.
Department of Educational Technology,

Obafemi Awolowo University. Ile – Ife.
Ojediran Ayo
Department of Special Education and Curriculum,

Obafemi Awolowo University, Ile – Ife.
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.305
Abstract:The paper investigated the usage of Information and Communication Technology (ICT) in Osun State Primary
Schools. Questionnaires were administered to 100 primary school teachers. The questionnaires were designed to find out the
roles of ICT in teaching and learning and problems associated with its usage in the primary schools.Results showed that majority
of the primary school teachers in Osun State lack the basic skills required for the usage of computer. In addition, the teachers
support the implementation of ICT in the primary schools. The results also revealed that the ICT is facing with problems in Osun
State Primary Schools.
Key Words: Primary schools, skills, impact.
1. Introduction
Information Technology (IT) is conceived with the use of technology in managing and processing of
information. In particular, Information Technology deals with the use of electronic computers and computer
software to convert, store, protect, process, transmit and retrieve information. However, The Oxford
Advanced Learner’s Dictionary defines information as facts or details about something or somebody.
Chambers compact Dictionary defined information as knowledge gained or given. Technology has been
defined as scientific knowledge used in practical ways in the industry. Cambridge international Dictionary of
English defined technology as the study and knowledge of the practical use of scientific discoveries. The
above definitions show that there is a close relationship between “information” and technology.
Communication on its own part is an indispensable tool in all human Endeavour’s and it has been defined by
Akanbi (1988) as the process of transmitting and exchanging ideas, knowledge, information and skills
through symbol, writing to create mutual understanding between the communicator and the communicate.
Adekomi (2004) also defined communication as the flow of information from a source to the receiver. Thus,
information communication Technology is concerned with the transfer of information through scientific
means.Information technology was formally integrated into the school curriculum when the national
curriculum was first devised in United Kingdom (Forman 1987). It was quickly realized that the work covered
was useful in all subjects. With the arrival of internet and the broadband connections to all schools, the
application of information technology knowledge, skills and understanding in all subjects became a reality.
According to Pringles (2002) this change in emphasis has resulted in a change of name from Information
Technology to Information and Communication Technology (ICT). ICT in education can be understood as the
application of digital equipment to all aspects of teaching and learning Winglet (2002). The growth of use of
ICT and its tools in the field of education has seen tremendous growth in the recent past; technology has
305
entered the classroom in a big way to become part of the teaching and learning process. According to
Carison, (1995), the roles of ICT in teaching and learning process cannot be underestimated. He therefore
summarized the roles thus:
(a) It makes education more child-centered by providing many alternative paths with a variety of resources so
that learning can take place in accordant to the learner’s study performance.
(b) It makes learning more immediate by bridging the gap between the worlds inside and outside, the
classrooms by means of the experience that educational resource materials can provide.
(c) It supplements the teacher through enhancing his effectiveness in the classroom.
(d) It checks the provision of limited facilities like classroom, study halls, and library for learners.
(e) It provides learning guidance through individualized learning study package system thus removing the
much dependence on teachers for learning their own without coming in contact with the teacher.
The objective of this paper therefore is to address the usage of ICTs in relation to primary education and
relate it to sustainable development of education in Nigeria and Osun State in particular. In addition, to
examine the problems and prospects associated with the usage of ICT in Osun State primary schools and to
find out the effectiveness of ICT on Osun- State Primary school education.
2. Research Questions
For this study, the following research questions were put forward.
(i) How often is computer being used in teaching and learning in your school?
(ii) Are there problems with implementing the use of computer as a medium for effective teaching in Nigeria
primary schools?
(iii) What are the factors that may hinder the implementation of the usage of computer in primary schools’?
(iv) Can other aspects of information Technology like slide, clip art, etc be used apart from computer in the
primary school?
3. Methodology
(i) Subjects.
The sample for the study consisted of one hundred primary school teachers. 20 teachers each were
randomly selected from 5 primary schools making up One hundred (100) teachers altogether. The schools
were all from Ife Central Local Government Area of Osun State, Nigeria.
(ii) Instrumentation
The instrument used for this study was questionnaire. The questionnaire was all about the usage of
Information and Communication Technology (ICT) in Osun State primary schools. The questionnaire was
divided into three sections. Section A focused on obtaining information on age, sex, position and years of
service.
Section B focused on finding out the usage of Information Communication and Technology in primary school
while section C was about the problems encountered while using computer.
100 copies of questionnaire were administered on the teachers. The validation of the instrument was
established by applying content sampling technique.
(iii) Treatment
One hundred copies of questionnaire were administered to the teachers by the researcher. The respondents
reacted to the items of the questionnaire as either Yes or No. The responses of the teachers were analyzed
and converted to simple percentage.
(iv) Results
Research Question 1: How often is computer being used in your school?
306
Table 1: Presents results on the first research question
S/N ITEMS YES % NO %
1 Do you use computer in your school as 68 68% 32 32%

complement to chalking and talking?
2 Is computer being used in teaching and learning 72 72% 28 28%
in primary school?
3 Do you agree with the introduction of computer 100 100% - -
into primary school curriculum?
Table 1 above showed that 68% of the respondents used computer in their school while 32% do not use
computer in their school. It is also indicated that 72% of the respondents agreed that computer is used for
teaching and learning in their schools while 28 which represents 28% of the respondents do not use
computer for teaching and learning in their schools.
Lastly, 100% of the teachers agreed with the introduction of computer into the primary schools curriculum.
From the above result, it is clear that computer package is not being used by majority of the teachers. Even
though a very large number of them support the introduction into the school curriculum.
Research Question 2: Are there problems with the implementing the usage of computer as a medium for
effective teaching in primary schools?
Table 2. Presents results on the second research question
S/N ITEMS YES % NO %

1 Are there problems with implementing of usage 89 89% 11 11%
of computer as a medium for effective teaching?
From the table 2 above, 89 teachers which represent 89% of the respondents agreed that there are problems
while 11
teachers that is 20% disagreed that there were no problems in the implementation. This result is in line with
Bada and Bamidele (2005) who were of the opinion that computer education is faced by a lot of problems in
Osun State.
Research Question 3: What are the factors that may hinder the implementation of the usage of computer as a
medium for effective teaching?
The factors are itemized below and the responses to choice were graded as agree, strongly agree,
undecided, disagree and strongly disagree.
Table 3 Presents results on the third research question
S/N FACTORS A % SA % U % D % SD %
1 Power Failure 78 78% 22 22% - - - - - -
2 Disturbance from friends 66 66% - - 10 10% 24 24% - -
3 Lack of computer skills by 66 66% 34 34%
teachers
4 Lack of Funds 85 85% 10 10% 5 5%
Lack of information about
the use/impact it may have
on teaching and learning.
62 62% 38 38%
307
The above table reveals that there are lots of problems with implementation of computer usage as a medium
for effective teaching in primary schools. The implication of the above results is that the above listed factors
would have contributed to non-effective and utilization of computer in Osun-State primary schools. Although
the teachers agreed that the package is available in their schools in addition they support the introduction of
computer usage into the school curriculum.
Research Question 4: Can other areas of Information Technology like slides, clip arts etc be used in primary
schools apart from the usage of computer?
Table 4. Presents results on the fourth research question
Respondents Number of Respondents Percentages

Yes 85 85%
No 15 15%
Total 100 100%
The table 4 above shows that 85% of the teachers agreed that other areas of information technology like
slide, videos, clip art can be used in primary school apart from the use of computer while 15%disagreed.
4. Discussion
From the results obtained, it may be inferred that computer package is not being used by majority of the
teacher in Osun State primary school even though a large number of teachers support the introduction of
computer usage into the Primary schools’ curriculum. It is also revealed that there are factors that have
hindered the effective utilization of computer in Nigeria primary schools even though some of these schools
have the package. Some of these factors include among others constant power failure, lack of funds, lack of
computer skills on the part of teachers, and lack of information about the impact of ICT on teaching and
learning.
5. Conclusion
The conclusion of this study based on the finding is that there is no doubt that teachers in primary schools in
Osun State have incredible resources available if they have access to the internet. By integrating information
and communication technology into primary school curriculum a fundamental shift in the way teacher teaches
and students learn will evolve. However, to integrate computer into teaching and learning in primary school in
Osun State, there must be proper and adequate funding of education. Nigeria and Osun state in particular
need to invest heavily on the internet business by creating enable environment for primary school students to
participate in downloading available and useful knowledge on internet.
Finally, constant training in form of seminars, lectures and workshops should be organized for the
teachers to enhance their efficiency in the use of ICT.
References
Adekomi, A. A. (2004). The use of internet. Ibadan McMillan.

Akanbi, D.K.(1988). Educational Technology in Methodologies of Teaching .Ondo. J.A .Ife Oluwa Ent. (Nigeria) Ltd.
Bada, T.A. and Bamidele, F. (2002). Problems and Prospects of Computer Education in Teaching and Learning Process in Osun State.
Ife Journal of Behavioural Research, O.A.U., Ile-Ife.4 (1), 73-84.
Carison, P.J. (2005). Technology .A combination .U.S.A .MI. Techniques Ltd.
Forman, D.C. (1987). The use of multimedia Technology for training in business and industry. Multimedia monitor .13, 2-27.
Pringle, D.V. (2002). Motivating pupil through the use of ICT. Oxford. Pergamum press.
Winglet, C. (2002). Telemetric in Education. Michigan .Longman.
308
Community Parenting and the Concept of Child Abuse in Yoruba Culture
Odejobi Cecilia Omobola, Ph.D
Institute of Education, Faculty of Education

Obafemi Awolowo University
Ile-Ife, Osun State, Nigeria
Email:[email protected]
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.309
Abstract: The study investigated whether or not child abuse existed in the traditional Yoruba culture. The population consisted
of all the secondary students and their parents in Ile-Ife metropolis. Purposive random techniques was employed in selecting 241
male and 259 female that made up of three sets of people (non-literate parents, literate parents and students) which comprises
of 66 males and 84 females non-literate parents and 75 males and 75 females literate parents as well as 100 males and 100
females students that were selected from 10 secondary schools in Ile-Ife .using purposive sampling technique. A questionnaire
titled “Parenting and Child Abuse Questionnaire” (PCAQ) was developed by the investigator to elicit information from both
students and parents on the issue related to child abuse. The non-literate parents that could not read the questionnaire were
made to respond as the investigator read in native language. The questionnaire was validated before use and the reliability
coefficient yielded 0.85 which is significant at 0.05 level of significance. Data were analysed statistically using percentages.
Findings showed students do not see the type of training giving to them in the traditional setting as child abuse. Non-literate
parents do not see fostering children as child abuse. Also the literate parents see child abuse as a fruit of western civilization.
The paper concluded that child abuse should be examined within the context of culture. Practices with cultural undertones
should not be condemned.
1. Introduction
Culture according to Akinjogbin (2002) consists of all the items in the life of a group of a human beings which
make them feel belong to one another and distinct from any other group around them. It comprises of their
social system, economic system, their dresses and so on. It is therefore necessary to look at what parenting
in traditional Yoruba cultural practice entails before justice could be done to the issue of child abuse in
Yoruba culture.
Africans especially Yoruba are gregarious hence they dwell in a collection of apartments for individual
families. This is known as “Agbo-ilé” (compounds). These families may be monogamous or polygynous. This
is the smallest social unit, known as “Ebí” (relations). Akinjogbin (2002) asserts that the concept of “Ebí” does
not stop at only a man and his wife or wives and children but extended to anybody with whom one could
trace his affinity by blood to. Whether a family is monogamous or polygynous, the husband, wife or wives
and children live under the same roof.
The peaceful co-existence within the “Ebí” sees the husband as the “Baálé”, the first wife as the “Ìyáálé”
while the second wife is the “Ìyàwó” The position of the second wife is not static; it will change as soon as her
husband marries another wife. She then becomes “Ìyáálé” and the new wife is called “Ìyàwó”. This
arrangement follows the principle of first come first serve otherwise known as the principle or concept of
“Àgbà” (elder). Within the extended family, the oldest wife is the overall “Ìyáálé” who had authority over all
other wives and children in the families.
In African setting especially among the Yoruba, the “Ìyàálé” takes charge of all the children and ate with
them from the same plate. It was generally believed that “A kìí fọ̣mọ kẹ́mo”, “that is, people do not pamper
their child at the expense of other children”. Therefore, whatever power or authority wielded over any child by
the “Ìyàálé” is never questioned or querried, not even the mother of the child. It is believed that all the
children belong to her hence equal treatment is given to them all. Apart from blood relations, slaves are also
acquired and live under the same roof with their masters. A person either male or female may be enslaved
309
due to debt, crime, capture in battle or in conquered towns, capture in raids, kidnapping for sale, being born
by slave parents and self-condemnation.
With this background in our mind, parenting in African setting, Yoruba land in particular, is the concern of
everybody in the family. If any of the wives resents criticism and kindly correction, people will ignore her and
her children. This is disastrous because the training due to her children will not be given. In fact,
Fadipe,(1970) confirms that such a woman asserts her independence at the price of foregoing the
assistance, the cooperation and even the protection of the member of the “Ebí” except in critical situations.
2. Concept of Child Rearing in Yoruba Culture
According to McGehee (1984), discovering and becoming concerned with behaviours termed abusive of
children is a function of how people understand the nature of children in the parent-child relationship, the
goals and values of the society and the condition under which that society has to live. The African people
especially the Yoruba, have their own views about existence, social arrangements, political values and
judgements within the context of which their actions are taken. Therefore, the kind of education given to the
children in Yoruba culture is an immediate induction into the social and a preparation for adulthood. This
showed that African education emphasizes social responsibility, job orientation, political participation, spiritual
and moral values (Fagunwa, 1974). Yoruba tradition stresses that parents are the first teacher of their
children, instructing them in the proper way of relating to their elders and people of the same age group.
A young child is expected to obey the orders of his elders as soon as he/she is past the infant stage.
There is the practice of handling of whip to the older and instructing him/her to use it on his/her junior
whenever the latter first becomes offensive and insubordinate towards him/her to instil the lesson of respect
and obedience into the heart of a rebellious junior (Fadipe, 1974). In the communal atmosphere of the
traditional family, parents of children who behave in approved ways are equally approved as successful. In
the same vein parents whose children misbehave are shamed and advised to put their houses in order
(Babatunde, 1992).
Parents as the primary agents in the socialization of children make and enforce rules in the home and
made clear to the children. Children are expected to behave in conformity with these rules. Hence children
are punished appropriately if the rules are violated (Owolabi, 1999). The most usual form of punishment was
flogging accompanied by a severe warning against recurrence. A recurrence of the offence was sometimes
punished by flogging and rubbing of ground pepper into the weals left by the flogging. In some community
according to Fadipe (1970), such a child had the back of his/her hand slashed with a knife after which pepper
was rubbed into the wound.
Also, Adewale (1986) confirmed that parents in Yoruba tradition brought up their children ethically and in
the knowledge of God. Children are therefore made to believe in reward and punishment potency of blessing
and the efficacy of curses of spiritual beings. It then becomes the duty of adults in the society to take that
child and create out of him/her a useful social being. The kind of person a child would be is determined by
adults’ interest and goals especially by parents and other adults in the family and the community.
It is a fact that the well-being of today’s children is inseparable from the peace, progress and prosperity of
tomorrow’s world. It is therefore imperative that children be nurtured in an environmentally sustainable
pattern to promote national and global peace and progress as well as the image of their family. Hence
parents strive to train their children to become good ambassadors of their family wherever they find
themselves. An age-long injunction says “Train a child in the way he should go and when he is old, he will not
depart from it” (proverbs 22:6). Parenting in African context is autocracy, not democracy especially during the
formative years of a child (Owolabi, 1999).
310
3. Parenting and Yoruba Culture
Parents are the primary agents in the socialization of children. Hence the importance of guidance and
counseling from parents to children cannot be overemphasized. As the child grows into adulthood, which
involved the total attempt to adjust to new socio-psychological condition, absence of adequate guidance and
counseling could be disastrous. Inappropriate counseling could lead to fatal destruction of a child’s life that no
one could be able to rectify again. In a general sense, one could say that since charity begins at home, home
sets the pattern for the attitude of children towards people, things and instructions. The Yoruba have great
overall principles of how to raise their children. These principles include the child having someone he/she
sees as enforcer (oníbẹ̀rù), emphasize on respect for elders, the belief that it takes a village to raise a child
and the importance of education. In training the children, the Yoruba want their children to be upright, honest,
kind and helpful to others (Awodele, 2006). The saying, ‘spare the rod and spoil the child’, is very much
relative in Yoruba culture. Parents prefer to remain childless rather than have children who will bring shame
and dishonor to the family. Hence, severe physical punishments e.g spanking is generally mated out to
young offenders in the hope that it will serve as a deterrent to others. According to Babatunde (1992, 91), the
flogging/spanking is seen as an act of kindness aimed at preventing the child from becoming a difficult
person, or at protecting them from true danger. This attitude is expressed in the proverb, “ọmọ ò gbọ́n à ní kó
má kù ú, kí ní n pa ọmọ bí kò ṣe agọ̀”. (When the child behaves foolishly, one prays that he may not die; what
kills more quickly than foolishness?). Parenting in Yoruba culture also includes parents deliberately putting
temptation in the way of the child to test honesty, perseverance and truthfulness to mention but a few. If any
child falls into the trap, severe punishment is meted out to him/her. These type of training given to children
they belief was functional and relevant to the needs of their society.
Parents especially the father pursues that desire with single-mindedness that his own father or
grandfather married several wives who will produce many children to help him out at the farm. Hence, a
farmer’s sons from the age of six up to marriage assist their father in productive operations on the farm; girls
on the other hand assist their mothers at whatever occupation they do (Fadipe, 1970). This is to stimulate
them to industry. In fact a father allots a small part to a son while he is still young to work on during his spare
time. It is after a son is married that his father allots him sufficient land for the needs of his own family.
For effective training, parents always apprenticed their children to the relatives, friends or competent
craftsmen or mistress, if girls, to learn one form of trade or another since they are not free to choose trade on
their own. The psychological reasons for sending children to be trained by other hands are: (i) to avoid
sentiment in the training of the children (ii) to employ sterner measures to make the children more serious on
their job (Fafunwa 1974). It was observed that those children who are trained by other people different from
their parents did better and it was therefore regarded as the most successful form of education. In Yoruba
culture, children remind parents of their lost opportunities. Hence, they see in their children the chance to re-
live their lives by ensuring that their children better their achievement (Obiagwu, 1997).
Problem of unemployment did not arise in Yoruba land. This is because there was no question of
existence without means of subsistence. Practically everyone was engaged in agriculture. Even craftsmen,
who were first and foremost townsmen, had farms tended by slaves, peons and their sons as well. The
Yoruba were not left out of the western civilization. They send their children to school and when they come
back they run errand for their parents. It is not easy to dissociate completely from one’s culture. Children
were never regarded as parents’ mere properties in Yoruba culture as Fawole (2003) pointed out, but they
are cherished and given the best of training that could make them functional themselves and in the society at
large. This study was therefore designed to examine the concept of child abuse within the context of Yoruba
culture.
311
4. Purpose of the Study
The purpose of this study is to examine whether or not there is child abuse in the traditional Yoruba culture.
1. Did students believe that child abuse exist in the type of training given to children in
2. the traditional Yoruba setting?
3. Did non-literate parents believe that sending out children for apprenticeship in traditional Yoruba
setting connotes child abuse?
4. Did the literate parents believe that child abuse is a fruit of western civilization?
6. Methodology
The population consisted of all the secondary students and their parents in Ile-Ife metropolis. Purposive
random techniques was employed in selecting 241 male and 259 female that made up of three sets of people
(non-literate parents, literate parents and students) which comprises of 66 males and 84 females non-literate
parents and 75 males and 75 females literate parents as well as 100 males and 100 females students that
were selected from 10 secondary schools in Ile-Ife .using purposive sampling technique. A questionnaire
titled “Parenting and Child Abuse Questionnaire” (PCAQ) was developed by the investigator to elicit
information from both students and parents on the issue related to child abuse . The non-literate parents that
could not read the questionnaire were made to respond as the investigator read in native language. The
questionnaire was pre-tested for validity using a random sample of 20 non-literate people from Sekona
market in Osun State. 15 students from Ife Oluwa Girls Grammar School. Osogbo and 20 literate people from
Federal Polytechnic Ede. The test retest reliability co-efficient was 0.85 which is significant at 0.05 level of
significance. Data were collected, analyzed and findings reported in percentages as reflected in tables below:
Table 1. Educational Background of the Respondents
Items Male Female

No % No %
Non-literate people 66 44 84 56
Literate people 75 50 75 50
Students 100 50 100 50
The following were the results of the data analyzed.
7.1 Research Questions 1
Did students believe that child abuse exist in the type of training given to children in the traditional Yoruba
setting?
312
Table 2. Students view on Child Abuse in Yoruba Culture
S/N ITEMS Yes % No %
1. Do you hawk for your parents? 160 80 40 20

2. Do you hawk in order to sustain the family? 60 30 140 70
3. Do your parents provide for your needs? 180 90 20 10
4. Do you leave school for hawking? 10 5 190 95
5. Are you sent to hawk by your parents out of - - 200 100
hatred?
6. Is running errand for your parents’ child abuse? - - 200 100
7. Do you suffer any injury for running errand for - - 200 100
your parents?
8. Is learning a trade in pre-colonial period child - - 200 100
abuse?
Table 2 shows that majority of the respondent 80% confirmed that they hawk for their parents while, 20% of
them responded negatively. For item 2, a large number 70% of the respondents revealed that they hawk as a
way of training them to be responsible. Only 30% said they hawk to sustain the family. It was revealed that
parents provide the needs of about 90% of the respondents while the needs of only 10% were not met.
Majority of the respondents (95%) confirmed that they did not leave school for hawking while only 5%
responded otherwise. All the respondents (100%) revealed that, they were not sent out to hawk out of hatred;
they did not see running errands for their parents as child abuse; they did not suffer any injury whether they
run errands or not for their parents and that learning a full time trade in pre-colonial era was not a child
abuse. From the above, it could be concluded that students did not believe that child abuse exists in Yoruba
culture.
7.2 Research Questions 2
Did non-literate parents believe that sending out children for apprenticeship in traditional Yoruba setting
connotes child abuse?
Table 3. Views of non-Literate Parents on Child Abuse
1. Sending children to hawk in traditional Yoruba setting is not child abuse 140 93 10 7
2. Parents do not send their children for apprenticeship out of cruelty? 120 80 130 20
3. Parents leave their responsibilities for their children to bear in Yoruba culture 150 100
4. Parents spank or cane their young children out of cruelty? 120 14 130 86
5. Is sending children out for apprenticeship normal in Yoruba tradition? 145 97 5 3
6. Parent inflict bodily injury on their children for not running errand 50 33 100 67
7. Parents send their children for apprenticeship to boost the family’s 5 3 145 97
economy?
8. The training given to children in Yoruba culture does not mount to child 130 86 20 14
abuse.
Table 3 reveals that majority (93%) of the respondents confirmed that sending children to hawk is not child
abuse in the traditional Yoruba setting. They also said that they did not inflict bodily injury on their children
313
and also that they did not send their children to learn a trade in order to boost family’s economy. In fact all the
respondents agreed that they did not leave their responsibilities to their children.
Based on this finding, it could be concluded that the non-literate parents do not see sending out children
for apprenticeship with other people in the traditional Yoruba setting as child abuse.
7.3 Research Question 3
Did the literate parents believe that child abuse is the fruit of western civilization?
Table 4. views of literate parents on child abuse in yoruba culture
1. Taking male children to work on their fathers’ farm in Yoruba setting is 20 14 130 86
child abuse?
2. Is there any difference in the cultural settings of the Yoruba people and 150 100 - -
that of the western people?
3. Unemployment that causes child abuse today exists in Yoruba culture? 50 33 100 67
4. Does the traditional Yoruba culture allow the type of freedom children 120 80 30 20
have today?
5. Children in the Yoruba traditional set up are morally sound than children 135 90 5 10
of today?
6. Do we enjoy the type of peaceful society we have today in the traditional 125 83 25 17
Yoruba culture?
7. Do you think western civilization brings child abuse to Yoruba culture 130 86 20 14
As shown in table 4, majority of the respondents 86% affirmed that taking children to work on the fathers’
farms in Yoruba setting was not child abuse. All the respondents agreed to differences in Yoruba and
western cultures. 86% of the respondents confirmed that western civilization brought the wave of child abuse
into Yoruba culture. 90% of the respondents affirmed that children in the traditional Yoruba setting were as
morally sound as children of today.
Based on these findings, it was concluded that literate parents were of the opinion that western civilization
brought child abuse to Yoruba culture.
8. Discussion
The results of the study showed that the students did not believe that child abuse existed in Yoruba culture,
considering the type of training given to them. According to McGehee (1984) ways by which children may be
raised are legion. In spite of the fact that children are not always raised or trained in the same way does not
make them vagabonds. In fact, countless number of children grows up every day and become productive
members of the society.
The findings of research question two shows that non-literate parents do not see the practice of sending
out children to another person for apprenticeship as a form of child abuse. This finding corroborated the
assertion of LeVine & LeVine (1981) that fostering children with other families facilitate training the child for
family economic roles and also developing a sense of responsibility. This finding also debunked the
submission of Fawole (2003) that children were sent to other members of the extended family to face
hardship.
Research question three indicates that the literate parents believed that child abuse is one of the fruits of
western civilization. To support this view, Fraser & Kilbride, (1980); Haditono, (1981); and Okeahialam (1984)
314
confirmed that child abuse pointed to the consequences of the disruption and decline of the family in the face
of modernization, urbanization and industrialization.
9. Conclusion
The issue of child abuse borders on the method by which a child is to be socialized. The question of how
children should be raised becomes imperative. According to Kobrin, (1981), three levels of considerations are
suggested. They are (1) practices which are viewed by one culture as abusive and by another as acceptable;
(2) detrimental environmental and economic conditions not related to cultural practices and (3) idiosyncratic
abuse which falls outside all social definitions to understand child rearing as opposed to child abuse, there
should be a distinction between seeing an act from participants point of view and the broader trans-societal
point of view.
An adage says, one man’s meat is another man’s poison. Some practices that reflect cultural value may
be harmful in another culture, for example a Nigerian father resident in the United States might be afraid to
cane his child for the child can phone the police or relevant authorities to complain of being abused. But here
in Yoruba land, the police will wave it off by saying that the father is teaching the boy a lesson so as to
behave well in future. Child abuse should be examined within the context of cultures. Several works on child
abuse like (Fawole, 2003;Kempe, Siherman, Steele, Droeje, & Silva (1962; Keep Kid Healthy,(1999) have
contributed in no small measure in bringing to lime light many important facts regarding the African
perception of child rearing. Moreover, the centre piece of these scholarly writings in many instances is totally
out of harmony with the African reality of child rearing as it has been subjected to Eurocentric interpretations
(Moloye, 1999). Punishing a child mildly in an honest way sets him/her on the right path. This is part of
Yoruba culture which should not be misunderstood by people from other cultures.
References
Adewale, S.A. (1986). Ethics in Ifa in S.O. Abogunrin, (ed.) Religion and ethics in Nigeria. Ibadan: Daystar Press, pp. 60-71.
Akinjogbin, I.A.(2002). Milestones and social systems in yoruba history and culture: a key to understanding Yoruba history. Ibadan, Olu-
Akin Publishers.
Awodele, F. (2006). Home improvement series disciplining a child irrespective of culture Nigeria world, U.S.A. http://nigeriaworld.
Babatunde, E.D. (1992). Culture, religion, and the self: A critical study of Bini and Yoruba value systems in change. Lewiston, NY: Edwin
Mellen Press.
Daily Sketch, (1989). Who is to blame for child abuse?
Fadipe, N.O. (1970). The sociology of the Yoruba. Ibadan: Ibadan University Press.
Fafunwa, A.B. (1974). The history of education in Nigeria. London: George Allen & Unwin Ltd.
Fawole, J.O. (2003). A study of child abuse and neglect and intervention strategies in Nigeria: in Nigerian School Health Journal,
15(1&2) 3-17.
Fraser, G. & Kilbride, P. (1980). Child abuse and neglect –rare, but perhaps increasing, phenomena among the Samia of
Kenya. Child Abuse & Neglect, 4; 27-232.
Haditono, S. (1981). Prevention and treatment of child abuse and neglect among children under five years of age in Indonesia. Child
Abuse & Neglect 5, 97-101.
Keep Kid Healthy, (1999). Child abuse. http://www.keepkidshealty.com/welcome/ commonproblems/childabusehtml
Hempe, C.H., Shiherman, F.N., Stecle, B.F. Droeje M. and Silva, H.N. (1962). The battered child syndrome in Journal of the American
Medical Association, 181: 17-24.
Kobrin, J. (ed) (1981). Child abuse and neglect cross-cultural perspective: Berkeley cal. University of Califonia press.
LeVine, S. & LeVine, R. (1981). Chiold abuse and neglect in sub-saharan African. In Korbin, J. (ed) Child abuse and neglect: cross-
cultural perspectives Berkeley, Cal. University of Califonia press. Pp 35-55.
Lyons-Ruth, K., Alpern, L., & Repacholi, B (1993) Disorganized infant attachment classification and material psycho social problems as
predicators of hostile aggressive behaviour in the preschool classroom. Child Development, 64, 572-585.
McGehee. C.L. (1984). Responses to child abuse in world perspective; paper presented at the third International Institute on Victimology
Lisbon, Nov. 11-17.
Moloye, O., (1999). The Philosophy of Upgradeable Cosmos: The Essences of "Omo" (Children) in Yoruba Ethno-Cosmology.The
Western Journal of Black Studies,Vol. 23,
Obiagwu, K. (1997). In defence of child abuse in Sunday Times; February 16.
315
Okeahialam, T. (1984). Child abuse in Nigeria. Child Abuse and Neglect. 8, 69-73.
Owolabi, R.O. (1999). Effective parenting: strategies that works and mistakes. U.S.A Bob & Bob Pub.
Uviller, R. (nd) save them from their savior: the constitutional rights of the family in Garbner et al (eds) 147-155.
316
Women in Military in India: The Cry for Parity
Arundhati Bhattacharyya
Assistant Professor
Dept. of Political Science
Bhairab Ganguly College Kolkata-7000056, West Bengal
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.317
Abstract: Gunnar Myrdal in his “Asian Drama” argued that the traditional societies cannot modernize themselves, unless they
recast their traditional institutions, beliefs and values, to suit the demands of development. But, India has proved that it is not
necessarily true, particularly, in the restructuring of gender relations in the workplace. Women have proved their worth, not to the
exclusion of their male counterparts. But, Indian women have distinguished themselves by working shoulder to shoulder with
men. Yet, the women made their own mark and proved a cut above the rest in so many areas of performance. The Indian State
has also supported them. In the final document of the Vienna Conference, States formally recognized the human rights of
women to be an integral, inalienable and indivisible part of universal human rights. They further demanded that the equal status
of women and the human rights of women…be integrated into the mainstream of….the United Nations human rights activities.
The World Bank had observed that empowerment stands for expansion of assets and capacities of the
marginalized groups, especially women, to participate and control institutions, regulating their life. There are
four elements in this process, namely, a) access to information, b) inclusion and participation, c)
accountability and d) networking with other social groups, to mount pressure on power. Empowerment
implies providing freedom of choice, voice and the public space, so that the women can develop their latent
talent. Women in the workplace require room for ventilating their merit and occupying spaces on that basis.
Indian Constitution has protected rights of Indian women along with the male counterpart. Article 14 in
the Indian Constitution ensures equality in political, economic and social spheres. Article 16 provides for
equality of opportunities in matters of public appointment for all citizens. Article 15 prohibits discrimination
against any citizen on the grounds of religion, race, caste, sex etc. Article 15 (3) of the Indian Constitution
allows the State to make any special provision for women and children. Wife bashing is a favorite sport in
India. Women are subject to physical and mental torture by their husbands and their families. Article 39(a)
mentions that the State will direct its policies towards securing all citizens, men and women, the right to
means of livelihood while Article 39 (c) ensures equal pay for equal work. Article 42 directs the State to
ensure just and humane working conditions. The constitution imposes a fundamental duty on every citizen
through Article 15 (A) (e) to renounce practices derogatory to the dignity of women. Another law that protects
women against a seemingly milder crime is Section 509 of the IPC. This law punishes individuals who have
insulted the modesty of a woman. Offensive language, sounds, gestures and intrusion of a woman's privacy
are punishable under this law. Outraging the modesty of a woman is also punishable under Section 354 of
the IPC. Under this law, an individual who has assaulted a woman, used criminal force on her or outraged
her modesty in any other way can be punished with imprisonment of up to 2 years. Laws such as the Immoral
Traffic (Prevention) Act, Sati Prevention Act, Dowry Prohibition Act and Indecent Representation of Women
(Prevention) Act protect women from the more "traditional" crimes such as rape, abduction, dowry, torture,
molestation, sexual harassment and selling of girls into slavery.2
Traditionally, Indian women had a dependency syndrome. (Seth 2001) They had to depend on male
members of the family from birth to death. He could be the father, husband or son at each stage of her life.
Women have always been misled by the imposed ideal of womanhood.(Devi 1995) The patriarchal society
and the system forced her to believe that she had no place in the world of work, outside her home. Man was
317
the maker of that world. The woman’s duty was to make a home for him. The woman should never think of
her own identity, independence or ambitions. In the traditional Indian society, the success of a man is
expected to be celebrated by his wife, as her own success. However, very rarely, Indian men can appreciate
the success of his wife, especially when her progress is more than his own. (Bhattacharyya 2010)
However, Indian women have proved that they can be manifestations of will power, grace, dedication,
hard work, brilliance. They raise their bar and break untouched barriers. Innate intelligence and quickness of
judgment have been instrumental not only at critical points in their career paths but in day-to-day business
life. Closely, involved with this is the capacity for making rapid decisions based on further qualities of
knowledge and experience, the ability to communicate, and the talent for persuasion and the ability to win the
cooperation, loyalty and trust of colleagues, employees and clients. (Menon 1998)
Women in India have been successful in all fields. They have contributed in the freedom struggle.
During the struggle, both men and women took active part in it. Without the support of the men-folk, India’s
men would not have been successful in their attempt of freeing the country from the chains of bondage. 3
Women who are mentally robust, physically fit and highly motivated resent preferential treatment being meted
out to them. They want to be treated at par with their male colleagues so that they get a fair opportunity to
prove their worth. They do not want to be treated as weaklings as it offends their sensitivities and self-
respect.
In the Indian National Army, the contribution of Dr Lakshmi Sahgal in the Indian National Army has
been applauded by all. She led around 1000 women soldiers recruited for the Rani of Jhansi regiment,
against the British Raj.
Indian Experience After Independence Regarding Women in the Armed Forces
In India, entry of women into the armed forces was limited to the Army Medical Corps, the Army Dental Corps
and the Military Nursing Service. It was in early 1990s that a decision was taken to induct them into the non-
combat wings of the armed forces as short-service commissioned service officers. The maximum period of
recruitment is 14 years. They are inducted into Engineers, Signals, Army Service Corps, Ordnance,
Education, Intelligence, Legal Branch and EME (Corps of Electrical and Mechanical Engineers). Presently,
the Indian Army counts 2.44 percent women in its ranks, the Indian Navy 3.0 percent and the Indian Air Force
6.7 percent. Apart from the medical corps, army has around 1100 women officers out of 35,000 officers; 700
out of 10,700 officers in the IAF; and 280 out of 8000 officers in the Navy. Women officers serve in non-
combat arms (engineering, ordnance, signals, intelligence, education, law, air traffic control among others.
IAF has 58 women copter & transport aircraft pilots. Women officers can serve upto 14 yrs only. In 2008,
Government approved permanent commission in the legal and educational wings of the three Services. The
2009 batch can opt for permanent commission. Doctors, dentists, nurses get permanent commission. There
are 800 women doctors, 90 dentists and 3200 nurses. Government does not admit combat duty for women
in infantry, armored corps, mechanized infantry or artillery. Women cannot fly fighters or serve on warships or
submarines. 4
Storming Another Bastion
Recently, an important question has come up regarding providing permanent commission to women in the
army. There has been a long-standing demand of the women in the army. The ‘glass ceiling’, is soon to be
cracked. The ‘glass ceiling’ has been defined as ‘a barrier so subtle that it is transparent, yet so strong that it
prevents women and minorities from moving up in the management hierarchy,’5 Women encounter barriers
on the way to occupational mobility. Such barriers serve to create and maintain a glass ceiling that restricts
women’s career advancement and satisfaction. 6 Many have stated that the ‘last bastion’ of patriarchal
system in India will soon be conquered by the Indian women. The Indian army is really in the crossroads,
318
where a new era will soon begin. However, the matter should be taken seriously as it should be remembered
that the most important aim of the army is to defend the country. The security of the country cannot be risked
for any reason. The efficiency of the military should be the only criterion for recruitment.
Points of Discrimination
1. Sexual Harassment Cry- The Armed forces should ensure safety to the women officers. The acceptability
of the women officers among the male soldiers should improve. Most of the soldiers are from rural areas,
where the patriarchal mindset is internalized, since the childhood days. So, it is most necessary for the armed
forces to instill the changed mindset among them. Many times, sexual harassment cases are dismissed as
‘frivolous’ and blame ‘over-sensitivity’ of the women officers. However, there have been cases where sexual
harassment has taken place and punishment has been imposed.7In one case, a colonel had to lose years
and was stripped of his stars and dignity in 2007. 8
2. Alleged Lack of Job Satisfaction &Low Acceptance - Women have complained, at times, that they are
marginalized and not involved in major decision making. Their minor faults are scrutinized. They have to work
twice as hard in order to prove their worth. Some of the women complain that in spite of their technical
qualification, they are given routine desk work or task organizing social occasions. Acceptance among the
male soldiers is low.
3. Alleged Poor Comfort Level-Most women accepted the fact that their presence amongst males tends to
make the environment ‘formal and stiff’. Mutual comfort level between men and women colleagues is low.
Men miss their light hearted banter which is considered essential to release work tensions and promote
group cohesion. They consider women to be intruding on their privacy. Male jokes can be sexist in nature,
which may make the women colleagues uncomfortable.
4. Doubts about Role Definition-Women, in some cases, were confused about the way they should conduct
themselves. If they behave lady-like, their acceptance amongst male colleagues is low. On the other hand,
their active participation in casual repartee carries the danger of their losing colleagues’ respect, at times.
Grievances Put Forward by Women Officers
The Army suffers from acute gender bias to deny permanent commission to women officers who work
shoulder to shoulder with male officers to assist and support troops in combat zones. The advocate for Major
Seema Singh, a complainant and others made a strong plea for permanent commission status. She stated
that the policies for women in the Army not only discriminate her against male officers but also lower her
status to that of a jawan/junior commissioned officer, whom she has been leading for 14 years.
Women officers work for the Army for 14 years, which is neither pensionable nor gives her any
retirement benefits. She is simply thrown out of the organization after 14 years and that too not on the basis
of poor performance but due to her gender and left to fend for herself. This is discriminatory in nature. Some
of the unfit gentlemen officers are absorbed in services like Ordnance Corps, Service Corps, Corps of
Electrical & Mechanical Engineers, Judge Advocate General, Education Corps, Medical Corps, Dental Corps,
Remount and Veterinary Corps, Corps of Engineers, Corps of Signals and Military Intelligence Corps.
However, women officers who endure identical job hazards for 14 years are thrown out at the end of 14
years.
4. Women officers and gentlemen officers commissioned into these services are performing similar jobs,
undergoing similar professional courses and are being posted to all field and peace postings. There is no
319
separate charter of duties for women officers or short service commissioned male officers and permanent
commissioned male officers.
5. There are women officers commanding Army supply convoys single-handedly through the most militancy-
affected areas and winning laurels for the country abroad during UN peace keeping operations in disturbed
African countries.10 But, in India, they are being denied permanent commission.
Many of the applicants were single women supporting their families and facing serious financial hardship
because of non-payment of salaries for a considerable period of time.
The bench also issued notice on another application filed by six more women officers whose discharge from
the Army was stayed by the Supreme Court on March 4. They alleged that though they have not been
released from the Army, they have not been paid salaries since March. They complained that the applicants
are posted at various places and they are discharging their respective duties diligently. Despite stay of
release order, the Army is not releasing salaries to the applicants with intention to harass the women officers.
Some of the women lady accused the Army of suffering from gender bias in not granting permanent
commission to women who work shoulder to shoulder with similarly placed gentlemen officers in non-combat
arms of armed forces. 12
Women army officers awaiting permanent commission have not received their salaries since February this
year. In an application before the Supreme Court the officers claimed that non-payment of salary was
violation of the Supreme Court order in March this year, which restrained the army from releasing women
Short Service Commissioned (SSC) officers. The army had started relieving them although there was no stay
order against the HC verdict on March 12, 2010, which directed the army to grant permanent commission to
women officers, who joined between 1992 and 2006. A Bench headed by justice J.M. Panchal took the
application filed by the ninth batch officers, and directed the army not to release any SSC women officer
entitled for permanent commission.
Advocate Meenakshi Lekhi appearing for the women officers, apprised the Bench of justice Panchal and
justice H.L. Gokhale of the Army’s “defiance”. She said the officers were working as per the SC order, but
have not received their salaries. Additional Solicitor-General (ASG) Parag Tripathi promised that salaries
would be released within a week. The Bench also asked the ASG to file the government’s response on
another application moved by 11 of the 22 women officers, who were petitioners before the Delhi HC, but had
retired while the case was pending. These 11 have requested the Supreme Court to direct the army to
reinstate them as per the HC order. Then the government told the SC that it was considering giving
permanent commission to women officers in atleast 7 branches of the army. The government has, however,
failed to present a detailed proposal on this issue. 13
Standpoint of the Army Chief
Army Chief General V.K. Singh observed that as far as women officers in the Indian Army are concerned,
whatever we have given them to do, they have fared pretty well. They have measured up to whatever work
was given to them. He was sure that this is the reason why opportunities are opening up. It is a very gradual
process. He added that we are not a country where women have been soldiers for a very long time. This has
to evolve slowly. It cannot be done in one press of a switch. The army chief wanted the overall effect of
permanent commission to both men and women officers to be studied further. However, he said the two
issues should not be linked to each other, though the army had started recruiting women to bridge the
320
11,000-odd shortfall in the strength of the officer cadre. He also continued that the AV Singh committee's
premise has been that there should be smaller permanent commission and large short service commission
officers. 14 They are weighing in all aspects before taking action. Recently, the Delhi high court, after hearing
the plea of serving women officers, ordered the armed forces to provide permanent commission. 15
Grounds Against Inducting Women in Combat Roles
There is certain logic in not utilizing them in direct ground combat roles. Israel has made it optional for their
women officers. To a senior army officer, society is still not ready to face the prospect of our women, as
Prisoners Of War or with terrorists. Another logic here is that Indian warships do not have separate facilities
for women, in terms of cabins or washrooms. The Indian Air Force feels that it takes to spend Rs 11.66
crores to train a fighter pilot. It takes 13-14 years of active flying by fighter pilots to recover the huge
investment, made on them. With woman fighter pilot, this may take a major hit, since they will get married
and have children. This will cause disruption in fighter flying schedules. But many feel that these problems
are not insurmountable. To a woman officer, all women officers do not go for combat roles, but if one opts in
she should have the right to join. Technology is increasingly making attributes like physical toughness
redundant. 16Nevertheless, women in technical fields such as meteorology, weapons development,
cryptography, software development, ordinance, navigation, and so forth may be equally capable as men.
Some will be superior. In an increasingly technological army, the light-switch phenomenon asserts itself: no
special gender advantage for flipping a light switch on or off. This phenomenon — a product of modern
technology — is the great equalizer of the sexes.17
Grounds for Justification of Denying Permanent Commission
The reason was simple. Women officers are neither been trained for command nor given the responsibility so
far, a senior officer observed. Women normally get commissioned at the age of 23 to 25 years. Soon,
thereafter, family pressures start building up on them to get married. Many women confess that managing
married life with military service is difficult, though marrying a service officer helps. Subsequent pregnancy
and motherhood prove very demanding.
The forces are going in for a large Short Service Commission base and a lean permanent commission
cadre. Granting permanent commission to existing women Short Service Commission officers will hit the
entire restructuring process. This must be based on military needs and organizational requirements, not
social factors ,or pressure exerted by some groups. It has to be a gradual process. There are operational
problems in women being deployed along the borders or in counter-insurgency operations. 18
Course Correction
In September 2010, fresh guidelines have been issued regarding recruitment of women officers. But these
guidelines have excluded serving and retired women officers.19 The Delhi High Court has ruled that those
who have approached the Court & those who are still serving, they should be extended full-term. Those
women officers who have retired by 12th March, 2010 during the Court proceedings, they should be
reinstated in service, if they are still within service age limits. That apart, they must be granted all financial
facilities including pensions. 20 Indian Parliamentary panel has also upheld the justification of awarding
permanent commission and full retirement benefits for the women officers in the military service.
Women could become Lt-Colonels and their equivalents in IAF and Navy at the most in these 14 years.
But now, women might well make it to one-or two-star general ranks (brigadiers and major-generals) in the
years ahead. There have been women major-generals and Lt-Gens earlier but they all belonged to the
medical stream. An officer stated that this is in accordance with the government decision in 2008 to grant
321
permanent commission to women officers in the legal and education wings of the 3 Services, as also the
accounts branch of IAF and the ‘naval constructor’ department of the Navy. In line with this new policy,
women being inducted into the armed forces from the 2009 batch onwards will be given the option, a year or
two before they complete 10 years in these wings, to opt for permanent commission. The Army Educational
Corps is planning to induct more women officers in future, by opening exclusive Sainik (military) schools for
women. 21
Combat Role
According to the news agency BBC, Cadet Divya Ajith Kumar surpassed almost 230 other cadets, including
70 female peers, to earn the coveted “Sword of Honour” at the Training Academy in Chennai in September
2010. Kumar became the first female cadet to receive the honour after 49 weeks of grueling training. 22The
armed forces remain opposed to combat roles- where chances of physical contact with the enemy are high-
for women officers. A senior officer observed that women officers need to be gradually exposed to more and
more functions and trained for them progressively. So far, women officers have neither been trained for
command nor given the responsibility. Permanent Commission cannot be given to them in a hurry. There has
to be a sufficient gestation period.
As a 1st step, women cadets are now undergoing pre-commissioned training at par with male
counterparts at the Officers’ Training Academy (OTA), Chennai. Earlier, it was 24 weeks for women cadets,
but now it is 49 weeks like male cadets. At present, though women officers are inducted into armed forces,
since the early 1990s, they can have for a maximum of 14 years only at SSC. Moreover, while they serve in
engineering, ordnance, intelligence, signals, education, law, logistics, air traffic control and the like, they are
not allowed to fight fighter jets, serve on warships or join “fighting” arms like infantry, armoured corps, and
artillery. But, while many women officers are not asking for combat role, they certainly want Permanent
Commission. After 14 years, a second career becomes difficult, felt a woman officer. There are just about
950 women officers in the Army out of a total of 35,377; 750 women out of 10,760 officers in the IAF; and 250
women out of 7,394 officers in Navy. Personnel below the officer rank, of course comprise only men. 23
According to the opinion of a particular group of people it is now commonly accepted that women should
be encouraged to join the services only under the following circumstances:
1. When a country is short of men or there are not enough men volunteering to join the forces.
2. When the armed forces of a country are technologically very advanced and there is a huge requirement for
highly qualified personnel for high-tech support functions, women can be gainfully employed for the same.
3. Where societal and cultural ethos have matured to the extent that barriers of gender prejudices have
vanished and both sexes have adjusted to the desired level of mutual comfort.
4. Where militaries are not deployed on active combat duties and are generally assigned comparatively
passive tasks. A number of countries like Canada and Australia induct women in their forces as they are
aware that they will never be required to participate in an operation at home or abroad.
The above parameters act as a universally accepted benchmark to determine the need and extent of
women’s’ employment in the forces.
Scene Elsewhere
 Belgium, Canada, Denmark, France, Germany, New Zealand, Norway, Portugal and Sweden allow
ground combat roles for women.
 Australia, Belgium, Canada, Chile, Denmark, France, Germany, Israel, Italy, Portugal, Singapore,
South Africa, Spain, Sweden, Tunisia, United Kingdom allow women to serve on combat ships.
322
 Women in Israel allow women in frontline combat units, but on a voluntary basis. Even the army of
Israel, which is most gender neutral, goes by role considered suitability, rather than mere lip service
to gender equality.
 Even in a conservative society like Afghanistan, women officers have been inducted.22 Twenty nine
women graduated from the Afghanistan National Army Officer Candidate School in September
2010. They will work in finance, logistics and intelligence positions in the Ministry of Defense. There
are around 300 Afghan women serving in the Army.
 Malaysia, Sri Lanka and Bangladesh deploy women on sea-faring warships. The US has deployed
them on submarines.
 Even Pakistan has seven women fighter pilots. But India is reluctant.
 China graduated its first class of sixteen women fighter pilots in April 2009.

In the United States, women constitute 13.4 percent, 15.4 percent and 19.5 percent of Army, Navy
and Air Force personnel respectively.24
Suggested Remedies
At the entire training centre curriculum, the value of gender-parity should be internalized by series of
achievements of women officers in the forces in other countries and also in India. The attitudes or biases of
the male officers should be clearly debated and the myths may be busted. Joint teams of male and female
officers may be formed in different training exercises, in order to form better rapport among the trainees. All
women groups of lady officers may also be formed to go into theoretical and practical exercises. Their
strengths and weaknesses may be analyzed closely. It may well be found that their strengths and weakness
nearly resemble those of the male officers.
Not only the cadets but also the officers of the forces at all levels should be sensitized regarding the
values of gender parity and gender contribution. Every workplace relies heavily on the quotient of job
satisfaction. Any gender exclusion policy is leaving a major slice of women officers unhappy. No organization
can afford to carry a baggage of discontent out of discrimination. The officers of the forces may be reminded
the contributions of their mothers, wives and daughters in their family lives and such positive features if they
are engaged in any public space activity, such as teaching, social service, functionaries in local bodies, like
panchayats and municipalities, doctors, engineers, scientists etc. Indeed, right from the top brass, every male
officer should be encouraged to motivate their women family members to join the forces. Supposing that one
senior officer is exercising gender bias, he may also at the back of his mind be reminded of such fare of
disparity to his own family members elsewhere in any other commanding unit.
Essential Prerequisites for Smooth Induction of Women
Change is often accompanied by a measure of initial chaos, which gradually settles down, after sometime.
However, an organization like the army simply cannot afford, chaos, since the entire nation's security and
honour is at stake. There have been teething problems but these are no more than in any other employment
sector. In fact, it is to the credit of the Indian Army that its in-built mechanism of grievance redressal is
sufficiently well equipped to deal with such issues. The lady officers seem to be quite happy with their chosen
profession. An interaction with them clearly illustrates their professionalism and will to stand tall next to their
male colleagues, in the discharge of their duties.
A spirit of comradeship has developed between the younger generation of officers of both genders, who
have trained and grown together in service. They exhibit a rare comfort level, which has developed with time.
Therefore, it can be safely presumed that the experiment has been a resounding success and there is no
case to now look back on the issue. Research has shown that women are more perceptive and intuitive and
endowed with organizational skills that help plan right down to minute detail. They have the ability to
323
empathize and understand. This makes them excel in all such fields that deal with interaction with human
personnel. These are fields where women in the army can make a good contribution. On hindsight it seems
that the entire debate that was ignited, when the idea was in its nascent stage was not unprecedented.
Whenever, women have first stepped into essentially male worlds, the opposition has always been there.
Such debates have had more to do with ideologies, principles, traditions and safety of the women. However
now, almost two decades post the event, one can sit back and take a more rational view of things and feel
that the idea of women in the Indian Army has finally arrived.
People often wonder as to why women would like to join the Army in the first case. After all it is a tough
life with eternal questions of modesty and propriety coming to the fore. The thrill and pride of serving one's
motherland is an additional attraction. All this comes along with a well laid down code of conduct that makes
things far more orderly, disciplined and easy to adhere to. Some feel that women feel more safe within the
Army than they do in other services of a similar genre' in the civil sector. They also have an attractive pay
packet.
There is a lot at stake and such decisions should be taken only after careful consideration and gradually.
So far, the induction of women into the Indian Army has been a successful experiment and the credit for this
goes, both, to the organization as well as the women. In order to ensure that future experiments are just as
successful, one must proceed with a measure of foresight and judicious contemplation. 25
The experience of the countries that have inducted women in their armed forces need to be studied.
They have been certain adjustment problems even in societies that are developed and profess gender
equality. Army life requires both mental and physical prowess. Many advanced countries have not inducted
women in fighting units. They have been taking precautions to ensure followed by others. Every nation has to
weigh its options against the backdrop of its own that women are neither pitched against enemy in face-to-
face direct combat nor exposed to the risk of capture by the adversary. It is imprudent to replicate the model
or path social and environmental mores. Every country has its own social/cultural moorings, type of hostilities
encountered, level of technology and larger manpower issues.
Conclusion
There are some subjective and objective grounds, adduced for denial of permanent commission to the
women officers in the armed forces. In the Indian Army and Air Force, permanent commission has already
been granted to women officers. All of them have proved their worth; busting the myth that quality will go
downwards. One subjective plea is that the rural based soldiers are not used to taking orders from a woman
officer. But, this attitude can be overcome by the example of merit-based promotions and leadership roles of
the women officers. The women officers can definitely be considered for pc, after case-to-case scrutiny by a
selection committee. This committee should comprise of lady officers. The alleged cases of gender
exploitation and harassment are a handful, compared to the total strength of the defense and military officers.
In those cases, the law and the concept of human dignity, may take its own course. These are isolated
instances, and should not be blown-up, out of proportions.
References
1.Gallagher A., “Ending the Marginalization-Strategies for incorporating Woman into the United Nations Human Rights
System,” Human Rights Quarterly, vol. 19, 1997.
2. http://goarticles.com/article/CONSTITUTIONAL-RIGHTS-OF-WOMEN-IN-INDIA/1577722/
Accessed 18. 10.11
3. Bhattacharyya, Arundhati, ‘Women in Administration: The Indian Experience,’ in Ghosh, Arunava, Women in India:
Problems, Potentialities and Power, Mitram Publications, Kolkata, 2010, 242-258.
324
4. Pandit, Rajat, ‘Top Military Brass Resent Permanent Commission For Women’ , The Times of India, Kolkata, March 13,
2010, p.1.
5. Morrison, A. M. and von Glinow, M.A. (1990), ‘Women and Minorities in Management’, American Psychologist, vol. 45:
pp 200-208.
6. Powell, Gary N., ‘The Glass Ceiling: Explaining The Good and Bad News,’ in Davidson Marilyn J. and Burke Ronald J.
(eds), Women in Management: Current Research Issues II,’ Sage Publications, New Delhi, 2000, pp 236-246.
7. Suman, Mrina, ‘Women in the Armed Forces India’,http://www.indiandefencereview. com/spotlight/Women-in-the-
Armed-Forces.html Accessed 10.8.11
8. Ajay Sura, ‘molest colonel to lose 6 years’, The Times of India, Kolkata, August 27, 2010, p.14.
9. Mahapatra, Dhanajay, ‘Army suffers from gender bias: Major’, The Times of India, Kolkata, February 20, 2010, p.8.
10. ‘SC: Why not reinstate women Army officers?,’ The Times of India, Kolkata, August 12, 2011, p.13.
11. ‘SC stops Army from discharging woman officers’, The Times of India, Kolkata, March 5, 2011, p.7.
12. Sinha, Bhadra, ‘No pay to women officers,’ Hindustan Times, Kolkata, August 12, 2011, p.12
13 ‘Women in combat units not simple: Army chief’ http://www.dnaindia.com/india/report_women-in-combat-units-not-
simple-army-chief_1366288 Accessed 2.7.11
14. Rajat Pandit, ‘Is combat role the next step for women?,’ The Times of India, Kolkata, March 13, 2010, p.9
15. North, Gary, ‘The Case against Women in the Military’, http: www.lewdrockwell.co .m/north/north334.html Accessed
28.6.11
16. Pandit, Rajat, ‘Officers feel women not trained to combat units, The Times of India, Kolkata, March 13, 2010, p.9.
17.‘Baishamyo muche diye senabahinithe ebar puro meyad medero’ Anandobazar Patrika, Kolkata, March 13, 2010,p.1.
18.‘Women may soon be 1-or 2-star generals’, The Times of India, Kolkata, December 1, 2010, p. 9.
19. ‘Military school for girls on drawing board’, The Times of India, Kolkata, August 8, 2011, p.10.
20. ‘India: New Legacy of Women in the Army’ http://www.dialogoamericas.com/en_ GB/articles/rmisa /features/
global_panorama/2010/10/01/feature-02
21.Rajat Pandit, ‘ Forces’ glass ceiling may crack’, The Times of India, Kolkata, April 28, 2008, p.7
22. ‘Women back in Afghan army after decades’, The Times of India, Kolkata, September 24, 2011, p.15.
23. Kahlon Simrit ,‘Women in the Indian Army: An idea whose time has arrived
http://www.rediff.com/news/column/women-in-the-army-an-idea-whos-time-has-arrived1/20110114.htm Accessed
2.5.11
24. Scanlan, Susan & Manning, Lory, Women in The Military, A Women in the Military Project Report of the Women’s
Research & Education Institute, Washington DC, 2010.
25. http://ibnlive.in.com/news/permanent-commission-to-women-in-2-months-army/127996-3.html Accessed 2.5.11
325

Strategies Used in the Translation into Albanian of Allusions in Walt Whitman's Poetry
Alketa Pema
Faculty of Foreign Languages

University of Tirana, Albania
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.327
Abstract: A translator who examines a text with a view to translate it will have a number of concerns. Among them, allusions are
likely to become puzzles when they cross a cultural divide. Translating allusions can be a demanding task due to the fact that
they simultaneously activate two texts and have specific meanings in the culture and language in which they arise but not
necessarily in others. However, the use of allusions by an author shows an expectation that the reader is familiar with the
references made, otherwise the effect is lost. Taking this into account, the present study focuses on personal proper noun and
key phrase allusions in the poems of the- famous American poet Walt Whitman and their translations into Albanian. It aims to
investigate how translation- strategies would provide the translators, in particular the novice ones, with useful insights concerning
intertextual references in general and allusions in particular in order that the translators might find it no more challenging a task.
In order to achieve the above mentioned purpose, the personal proper noun and key-phrase allusions in Leaves of Grass and
their equivalents in the Albanian translation were first identified. Then, Leppihalme's (1997) proposed strategies for the
translation of allusions were analyzed. The analysis revealed that the most common strategy for the translation of personal
proper nouns was that of 'retention without any guidance' and for key-phrase allusions was that 'literal translation with minimum
change'. This is indicative of the translator's wish to be as faithful as possible to the source texts to demonstrate that the allusive
language of the original texts and connotations conveyed by them were largely ignored by the translator.
Key words: Intertextuality, allusion, proper noun allusion, key phrase allusion, translation strategies.
1. Introduction
The translation of poetry is known as a very hard and somehow impossible task; it is probably the subject in
translation studies that triggers the strongest polemics. Even those who are not specialized in translation
often have an opinion on the subject. Keeping the form and stylistic features of a poem from one language
into another without distorting the meaning is really difficult to accomplish; moreover, the translator must be
able to get the real message and convey it to the TT, he has to be fully aware of the capacity of language to
make his message highly effective. The words of the poem surpass their textual denotations; they take new
shades of meaning dictated by the poetic context. So the translator has to understand not only the basic
elements of a poem such as rhyme, meter and figurative language, but also the allusions which bear
connotations, are culture dependent. Abrams (1999) define allusion “as a passing reference, without explicit
identification, to a literary or historical person, place or event or to another literary work or passage.” Allusion
as a kind of intertexuality can be attributed as one of the most powerful figures of speech since it can refer to
an external text. Therefore, it can be a rich source of meaning and connotation and can be added to the
meaning wealth of a text. One term which is used to describe allusion is 'culture bump', which Leppihalme
(1997) defines as follows: “Culture bump occurs when an individual finds himself or herself in different,
strange, or uncomfortable situation when interacting with persons of a different culture”.
She agrees that when one wants to recognize and translate something rooted strongly in another nation‟s
culture, he/she needs to have much knowledge other than what is seen explicitly; in fact, the understanding
of an allusion is prevented by culture unless the receivers are biculturalized, so this cultural barrier should be
removed. Allusions are one type of cultural specific items. From this translators' point of view culture-bound
or culture specific items are elements of the source text which refer to those elements in the source culture
which are peculiar and pertinent to this community and not present in the culture of target community. As
327
culture specific elements, allusions resist translation rendering them successfully depends largely on the
translator’s familiarity with their references.
Snell-Hornby (1988) believes that in translation, a culture specific item does not exist of itself but due to
nonexistence or the different values of an item in the target language culture; for example, the status of a CSI
occurs as a translation problem when one wants to translate the image of "lamb" into a language in whose
culture this animal is unknown or, if known, does not have connotations of innocence and helplessness.
Snell-Hornby (1988) maintains that the translatability of a text depends on the extent to which the text is
embedded in its own specific culture and also on how far apart, with regard to time and space, the ST and TT
receivers are.
In the present study, the distance is great: the ST is a collection of American poems which allude to people
and events specific to America only. Culturally, then, there is a great distance. Another term used to describe
allusion is Intertextuality. Intertextuality is derived from the Latin „intertexto‟, first introduced by French
semiotician Julia Kristiva in 1966. It subverts the concept of the text as self-sufficient, highlighting the fact that
all literary production takes place in the presence of other texts.
Every literary work consists of poetry is situated in the middle of a network of intertexual relations. For
Barthes (1977, cited in Allen, 2000), who proclaimed the "death of the author", it is the fact of intertextuality
that allows the text to come into being. He notes that any text is a new tissue of past citations which have
passed into the text and are redistributed within it. In other words, a literary work is not simply the product of
a single author, but of its relationship to other texts. However, based on Hatim and Mason (1997) one should
be well aware of the fact that Intertextuality can operate at “any level of text organization” involving
phonology, morphology, syntax or semantics and Hatim (1997a) believes that expressions ranges from single
words or phrases that have special cultural significance in a given linguistic community at a certain time, to
macro-textual conventions and constraints associated with genre, register and discourse.
Therefore, intertextuality encompasses any element (macro- or micro-) that enables readers to identify
and derive meaning from the surface features of the text in question by reference to other texts or text
features they have previously come across.
Over the past two decades, the theoretical interest in intertextuality has generated a great deal of
interesting discussion of the device of literary allusion. Translating allusions can be very challenging due to
the fact that the use of allusions presupposes a particular kind of participation on the part of the receivers.
Allusions enrich the texts in which used since they are used as literary devices make the texts ambiguous or
exaggerated and at the same time they are used to create ambiguity especially when it is not possible to
speak directly because of social or political considerations.
It can rightly be said that allusion plays the most important role in persuading its readers to accept what the
author says especially when they quote some parts from religious texts or famous literary works.
2. Types of Allusions
Based on Leppihalme (1997) allusions are divided into four thematic groups based on their sources; religious
allusion, mythological, literary, and historical allusion. However, the present study is based on the main
classification of allusions by Leppihalme.
Leppihalme (1997) makes a distinction between proper noun (PN) allusion (the one with a name in it) and
key phrase (KP) allusion (the one without the name).
3. Translating Allusions
Based on Leppihalme (1997) translating allusions is a challenging task since: the translator has to identify
any intertextual references and then judge the likelihood that the target language readership will be able to
recognize them and cue in to the intended references. Moreover, allusions are considered as Cultural
328
specific items (CSI), so they are heavily and exclusively grounded in one culture which seem impossible to
translate into the terms of another. Leppihalme agrees that a cultural barrier can prevent the understanding of
an allusion, unless the receivers are sufficiently biculturized.
To cope with the aforementioned problems, a set of strategies are introduced by Leppihalme (1997); that
a translator should decide what translation strategy will be appropriate for the allusion in question.
Leppihalme (1997) proposes a set of strategies for translating the proper noun allusions:
i. Retention of the name:
a. using the name as such; b. using the name, adding some guidance; c. using the name, adding a detailed
explanation, for instance, a footnote.
ii. Replacement of the name by another (beyond the changes required by convention), with two
subcategories:
a. replacing the name by another SL name; b. replacing the name by a TL name.
iii. Omission of the name:
a. omitting the name, but transferring the sense by other means, for instance by a common noun; b. omitting
the name and the allusion altogether.
Potential strategies for translating Key Phrase (KP) allusions=allusions containing no proper noun are as
follows:
A. Use standard translation;
B. Literal translation (minimum change);
C. Add extra-allusive guidance to the text;
D. Provide additional information via footnotes, endnotes;
E. Introduce textual features that indicate the presence of borrowed words;
F. Replace with a performed TL item;
G. Rephrase the allusion with an overt expression of its meaning;
H. Re-create the allusion by creatively constructing a passage that reproduces its effects;
I. Omit the allusion completely.
3.1. Procedure
This study is a comparative-descriptive research and its aim is to carry out an analysis of particular strategies
applied to cope with allusions (Key-phrase and personal proper nouns) and to find which strategies are more
frequent. The personal proper noun and key phrase allusions in Leaves of Grass and their equivalents in
Albanian translation are identified. After categorizing Personal proper noun and key–phrase allusions
(Historically, religiously, mythologically, and literally), they are entered into the chart respectively and their
frequencies are calculated.
3.2. Research questions
1. What are the strategies used in translating proper noun and key phrase allusions from English to Albanian
in Whitman’s poetry based on Leppihalme (1997)?
3.3. Corpus
The corpus of this study is a body of allusions which would be extracted from Leaves of Grass as translated
by S. Luarasi. The collection covers a great deal of different proper noun and key phrase allusions which
might prove challenging for the translator.
Luarasi has done the translation of a part of the book. His rendering has been described as accurate,
erudite, accessible, faithful, and a much respected translation of Whitman into Albanian.
329
3.4. Words, proper nouns and key phrase allusions as translated into Albanian:
 Alleghanies – Alliganëve ( Albanian version, the allusion not explained )

 The Alleghanies are the oldest mountain range in the United States. This is Whitman's own spelling of the
word.
 Banner and Pennant
 A banner and pennant are flag shaped symbols of a nation, or army, often flown at patriotic occasions.
 Bugle Trills – altered in meaning
 A bugle trill is a short burst of notes from a bugle horn, often meant to signify military victory.
 Calamus
 In Greek mythology, Calamus is a figure who turned into a reed out of grief for the death of his young male
lover. In Leaves of Grass, Whitman uses this imagery to describe the intense erotic love between men.
 Camerado – shok ( Albanian version, the allusion not explained )
 A camerado is Whitman's own term for a friend, or comrade.
 Canuck – not rendered
 Canuck is a term for a person from Canada.
 Centenarian - qindvjecar
 A centenarian is a person who is 100 years old.
 Cuff – kufi ( Albanian version, completely altered )
 "Cuff" is an African day-name for a male born on a Friday.
 Eidolons – hije, fantome, not exact
 An eidolon is the perfect form of an idea. For Whitman, this is the ideal of spiritual and intellectual
enlightenment for which all humanity must strive.
 Jonathan – Xhonatan (Albanian version, the allusion not explained )
 Jonathan is a common name for a New England Yankee. Whitman uses the name to collectively describe
all New England patriots.
 Mannahatta – Manahata (Albanian version, the allusion not explained )
 Mannahatta is Whitman's term for New York City's island of Manhattan. This is the original Algonquian
word meaning "large island," which Whitman uses to invoke a historical and natural spirit to the city.
 Metaphysics - metafizike
 Metaphysics is a branch of philosophy devoted to explaining the basic nature of being.
 Paumanok – Paumanok (Albanian version, the allusion not explained )
 Paumanok is the original Native American term for Long Island, New York. Whitman uses this term to name
his boyhood experiences in Long Island's natural surroundings.
 Wolverine – volverinasi
 It is the fourth of Seventh-month – eshte kater korriku
 Yankee – janki
4. Results and Discussions
To make a summary of the results, the most common strategy for the translation of these allusions was that
of 'retention without any guidance' (1a). Therefore in most of the cases the connotational meaning is lost in
the Albanian translation, and therefore some footnotes or explanations are needed. (Examples: Alleghanies;
En-Masse; Mannahatta etc. )
The second strategy, 'The use of guidance' (1b) has been used successfully in some instances to clarify
the concept. (Examples: Oconee- lumi Okoni; Fourth- month – prilli; Christ Divine- Krishtin Birin e Perendise
etc.)
330
The strategy 'Omission' (3b); omitting the name and the allusion altogether was employed by Luarasi in
few instances. ( Example: carol, camerado)
Obviously, full comprehension of an allusive line of poetry is inevitably limited to those who recognize the
name and its connotations.
As Leppihalme (1997) argues, the appropriateness of a strategy depends at least partly on the familiarity
of the name. However, in the translation of Leaves of Grass by Luarasi, the retention of PPN was applied not
merely to transcultural names, but also to names very likely to be unfamiliar to TT readers. This tends to
reduce a TT reader's chances of spotting such allusions, and comprehending the point the SL author
intended to make.
4.1. Discussion of key phrase allusions
Results of Key Phrase allusions in ”As I pondered in silence” are illustrated in the table:
Original Poem Albanian translated version 1 Albanian translated version 2

Poems Vjershat Poemat
Considering, lingering long Dhe rrihja ti shihja Shqyrtoja, ndalja gjatë
With distressful aspect Me ballin te vrenjtur Me pamje të pabesë
Forever enduring bards Për bardët që kërkojnë amshimin Për bardët e përjetshëm
The making of perfect soldiers Ëma e ushtarëve të përsosur Bërje e ushtarëve të përkryer
Haughty Shade Hije krenare Hije mendjemadhe
Body and the eternal Soul Trupin e Shpirtin e amshuar Trupin e shpirtin e përjetshëm
Promote brave soldiers Nxjerr ushtarë trima Përkrah ushtarë guximtarë
1. Strategy B: Literal translation with minimum change

Luarasi by rendering word by word didn't convey the connotations and the alluding part, although, this verse
may be unfamiliar to Albanian readers, too. In the earlier mentioned verse, the translator renders the allusion
word by word without minimum change. But this strategy is not suggested by Leppihalm (1997), so strategy B
is considered for the translations of such allusions.
2. Strategy C: Add extra-allusive guidance to the text: It seems the translator was aware of the alluding parts
which he put in the quotation marks.
3. Strategy G: Rephrase the allusion with an overt expression of its meaning: The translator by explicating
the meaning of tries to; somehow, conveys the meaning that brings the evoked text to the original text.
4. The last strategy applied is omission. By applying this strategy Luarasi changed the meaning of the
alluding part, maybe, because he himself had been unfamiliar with that alluding part. Moreover, it is
probable that the translator may omit elements s/he perceives as too difficult to translate which are to some
extent culture bound and depend on translation norms in the target culture. Thus, the discussion of key-
phrase allusions shows: Luarasi is faithful to the original text he preferred literal translation without having
inclinations to change the structures to make a rhyming poems.
The percentage of strategy B indicates that this strategy is applied more with the Albanian translation
which suggests that he is faithful to the original text. Luarasi preferred literal translation without having
inclination to change the structures to make a rhyming poem (Strategy B). Although, the fact of not being
restricted by rhyming patterns and music provided the translator with more freedom to be faithful to the
source text and to give precise equivalents at word level. This limitation of the translation unit to word and
turning a blind eye to factors beyond the text like intertextuality and potential purposes of application of a
word or structure by text producer led to refusing to search the text for the existence of any allusion and;
consequently, to removing potential connotations carried by those allusions. Moreover, some allusions are
rendered word by word with no change. The second prevalent strategy used is the strategy C.
331
In the case of strategies like marking the alluding texts by the translator, demonstrates that he is aware of
the connotations the text embodies. Strategy G was found in 7 instances: Although using strategy G tells
nothing about the translator's attention to allusive language, it certainly asserts that, in such cases, the
translator has reached a realization of the existence of connotative language and has seriously pursued ways
of making those connotations and senses overt in the TT at the expense of radically changing the ST. Using
this strategy also has the message that preserves just the sense and connotation, but deprives TT readers of
the aesthetic aspect of alluding or referring to other texts, since they are left unaware of the author's
application of the allusions. Moreover, the strategy I occurred when the translator didn't understand the
meaning of the alluding part and has removed the allusion completely; maybe unintentionally.
5. Conclusion
This article is concerned with the notion of intertextuality and embarks upon an analysis of allusions in
Leaves of Grass. Intertextuality is a wide-ranging, omni-present textual phenomenon that is crucial to text
processing both within and between languages. The problem for translators is to render intertextual
references into the target language and culture such that the meanings invoked in the ST are preserved and
made accessible to the maximum extent possible. However intertextuality eclipsed allusion as an object of
literary study.
It is obvious that most of the proper nouns and phrases have allusions which refer to other texts. It seems
necessary for an acceptable translation to produce the same (or at least similar) effects on the TT readers as
those created by the original work on its readers. But most translators do not appear to be successful in their
challenging tasks of efficiently rendering the allusions when they sacrifice, or at least minimize, the effect of
allusions in favor of preserving graphical or lexical forms of source language allusions. In other words, a
competent translator is well-advised not to deprive the TL reader of enjoying, or even recognizing, the
allusions either in the name of fidelity or brevity. Hence, the translator carefully searches for strategies to
cope with these problems. Consequently, the translator's choice of strategy for the translation of allusive
elements may subtly result in preventing the TT readers from spotting and enjoying allusions and in failure to
transfer the connotation the original author intended to evoke in his/her readers. Beyond a shadow of doubt
the choice of strategy is related to the translator's fidelity or lack of fidelity to the ST author. The findings of
this study suggest that a translator can be more faithful to the ST author when he uses 'retention' (1a) (95%)
for PPN allusions and literal translation (68%) for key-phrase allusions. However, in many cases the
translator failed to elaborate at length upon the allusions as well as the stories behind references. In other
words, he could employ more extensive translation strategies so that the target text readers might
understand the implied references. It is pertinent to mention that native speakers and readers who live in the
same linguistic and cultural community as the author may fail to recognize the allusive nature of an element
in a text. This difficulty is intensified when the receptor is not the native speaker of the source language and
is from a culture different from that of the source one and; consequently, has more limitations in accessing to
the source of allusions. However, it is necessary not only for competent readers (poets, authors) in SL but
also for translators to grasp these allusions so that they can convey the connotations to competent TL
readers. As to implications, translation teachers and student translators who are considered as competent
ones, are expected to learn about the intertextual elements of the ST, that allusions are one type of them.
Moreover, translation students and practicing translators need to consider the difficulty of translating
allusions, recognizing the responsibility of the translators to TT readers.
The examples of various strategies discussed in this study can provide them with solutions to tackle
these problems. Through discussing and evaluating these strategies, novice translators will learn that if they
translate a text without spotting and understanding its allusions, the meanings of allusive terms and passages
will be lost for most TT readers.
332
Although, some translators consider translation together with footnotes undesirable, in fact their uses can
assist the TT readers to make better judgment of the ST contents. In general, it seems that the 'notes' would
have a higher potential for conveying the concepts. It can be claimed that the best translation method seems
to be the one which allows translator to utilize 'notes.' Furthermore, employing 'notes' in the translation, both
as a translation strategy and a translation procedure, seems to be indispensable so that the foreign language
readership could benefit from the text as much as the ST readers do.
References
Abrams MH (1999). A Glossary of Literary Terms. US: Heinle & Hein.

Allen G (2000). Intertextuality. London and New York: Routledge. pp: 158-176.
Hatim B (1997a). Intertextual intrusions: towards a framework for harnessing the power of the absent text in translation. In Simms, K.
(ed.). Translating Sensitive Texts: Linguistic Aspects. Amsterdam: Rodopi.
Hatim B, Mason I (1997). The Translator as Communicator. London: Routledge. pp. 128-162.
Hornby SM (1988). Translation studies: An integrated approach. Amesterdam: John Benjamin B.V.
Leppihalme R (1997). Culture bumps: An Empirical Approach to the Translation of Allusions Topics in Translation. England: Multilingua
matters. pp. 122-127.
333

Media Criticism: Class Fantasy and Ideology in the Movie Ganj-e Qaroon1
Rasoul Rabani, PhD, Full Professor
University of Isfahan, Department of sociology, Isfahan, Iran

Mehdi Adibi, PhD, Assistant Professor

Ehsan Aqababaee, PhD

Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.335
Abstract: Subjects due to their class position may construct specific fantasies. Class fantasy, one of the given fantasies, is
constructed by lower-classes in the society. This study is to critically scrutinize this type of fantasy in media discourse data.
Furthermore, as ideology is a means by which cinema apparatus sutures audience within movie narration, the movie ideology
and its relation with the given fantasy will be discussed as well. Indeed, the paper presents an attempt to illustrate how movies,
through the construction of the fantasy, serve to justify the prevailing ideologies at the time. A case in point is melodrama. The
data are extracted from one the most popular movies in the history of Iranian cinema, Ganj-e Qaroon (meaning Qaroon’s
Treasure). Analysis of the data is done within the frameworks of Bordwell (1995); Cormack (1992); and Zizek (2008a). Findings
show that the class fantasy is constructed through the movie. That is the hero, reaching the object-cause of desire namely the
girl of narration, may fill the class gap; however, a change in his position causes the object to lose its significance. Concerning
the movie ideology, results indicate that the movie ideology, i.e. the class ideology, proposes class coexistence in peace.
Indeed, the movie not only represents class fantasy but also uses the end of fantasy in its favor.
Keywords: Subject, fantasy, ideology, desire
1. Introduction
In the present section, first, the concept of fantasy, in the words of Lacan, will be presented. Next, ideology,
according to Marx, will be clarified.
1.1. Fantasy
Subject is generally defined as “the ‘I’ who experiences and interacts with the world” (Malpas, 2005, p.56).
Subject, based on the given definition, was first originated from Descartes’ thoughts. Cartesian conception of
the subject “pictures a conscious and unified individual marked by inherently rational capacities that allow
one to experience and make sense of the world according to the properties of that world” (Barker &
Galasinski, 2004, p.40).

1 Qaroon’s Treasure
335
Lacan, breaking up the subject into two parts of conscious and unconscious, rewrites Descartes’
proposition as “where I think ‘I think, therefore I am’ that is where I am not” (Weedon, 2004, p. 12).
Accordingly, he conceptualized the subject, i.e. barred subject, according to his own view. Lacan believes
that when a child is born he is named and allocated a room. That is, the symbolic of social constructions is
vigorously presented in his life. In other words, subject confronted the symbolic2, “is trapped in the net of
language, through a discourse and a social bond that are induced and commanded by the other” (Branustein,
2003, p.109).
Subject discovers that ‘there’ is a world (Being-in-the-world) and it is constantly in particular non-arbitrary
situations, times, and places whose profitability, on a daily basis, is not justifiable. In the word of Heidegger
(1962), this unwanted universal situation is defined as Gewerfenheit, i.e., ‘thrownness of one’s destiny into
the particular place in the world (Hersch, 2003, p.393)’. This real situation, according to Heidegger (1962), at
first is totally alienated for every entity. That is to say, subject, quite arbitrarily, is given a place in the inter-
subjective network of symbolic relations, including a teacher, a clerk, a sales person, a king and so on.
The above situation is arbitrary and non-inherent in sense that ‘its nature is performative, it cannot be
accounted for by reference to the ‘real’ properties and capacities of the subject (Zizek, 2008a, p. 170)’. One,
who occupies the place of a ‘king’ within the inter-subjective network of symbolic relations, doesn’t deserve
any characteristics of being a king. Hence, “the subject who possesses the quality of being a king is
automatically confronted with a certain ‘Che vuoi?’, with the question of the Other. The Other is addressing
him as if he himself possesses the answer to the question of why he has this mandate, but the question is, of
course, unanswerable. The subject does not know why he is occupying this place in the symbolic network.
His own answer to this ‘che vuoi!’ of the Other can only be the hysterical question: “Why am I what I'm
supposed to be, why have I this mandate? Why am I [a teacher, a master, a king . . . or George Kaplan]?”
Briefly: “Why! Am I what you [the big other] are saying that I am?” (Zizek, 2008a, p.170)
Fantasy is a scenario which provides an answer to the following questions (Fink, 1995, p.54). A fantasy
constitutes our desire; provides its coordinates; that is, it literally ‘teaches us how to desire3’; it provides a
‘schema’ according to which certain positive objects in reality can function as objects of desire4, filling in the
empty places opened up by the formal symbolic structure (Zizek, 2008b, p.7).
For Lacan, the object is precisely that which is “in the subject more than the subject itself, which I
fantasize that the Other (fascinated by me) sees in me”. Thus, it is no longer the object which serves as the
mediator between my desire and the Other’s desire; rather, it is the Other’s desire itself which serves as the
mediator between the ‘barred’ subject $ and the lost objea that the subjea ‘is’ - that provides the minimum of
phantasmic identity to the subject (Zizek, 2008b, p.10).
Each fantasy consists of a number of characteristics. Some of the typical characteristics of a fantasy may
include 1) a fantasy obfuscates the true horror of the real5 and let the subjects get away from the real of their
subjects; 2) fantasy is the primordial form of narrative, which serves to occult some original deadlock; 3)
fantasy, being in line with the law, supports it as well; 4) fantasy always encompasses an impossible gaze; 5)

2 The symbolic in its most general definition is an arena of culture and society. For Lacan, this is related to language, metaphor, or
function of a father who is sometime called ‘the Other’. ‘. The Other can hence be viewed as “the Other of language, of certain ideals,
norms and ideology of a particular society or community and as a position, a presumed or posited point (or perspective) of authority,
knowledge, validation” (Dashtipour, 2009, p. 323).
3 Desire is the nature of human as well as a social category. Subjects desire from the view of the other (Evans, 1996).
4 Object-cause of desire is defined as the object triggering the desire of subject. Object is, in essence, lacking, and is believed to be
primordial lost form. For Lacan, fantasy determines unattainable relationship between subject and object-cause of desire. This object fills
the existing split in the Other (Zizek, 1999, p.19; Boothby, 1991, p. 109).
5 In integrating social relations, there always remains a surplus sticking out from the frame of symbolic reality. Lacan calls this hole ‘the
real’. Thus, the real is the universe itself before having been split in by language. This means that the real is non-descriptive and
impossible. Indeed, the real is non-symbolized, unrepresented and uncrossable threshold for the subject (Bowie, 1991, p.109). Subjects,
constructing fantasy, tries to get away from the real.
336
fantasy supports and strengthens the social realities of the subject life; 6) In order to be operative, fantasy
has to remain ‘implicit’; it has to maintain a distance towards the explicit symbolic texture sustained by it, and
to function as its inherent transgression(Zizek,2008b, p.11-39). It is worth mentioning that fantasy may
include some or all of the characteristics referred to.
1.2. Ideology
Presumably, a number of different theories have so far been proposed regarding ideology. However, in the
present study, due to the influence class ideology, only the ideology as that of supporting the benefits of
upper-classes will be focused on.
Marx clarifies ideology based on materialistic practices. According to him, what makes the system of
beliefs ideological is the fact that the belief system, covering the real nature of social and economical
relations up, helps out to justify the legitimacy of the uneven distribution of economical and social resources
in the society. Accordingly, although all classes of the society, in particular the working class, are capable of
creating an ideology, this creation will be considered as an ideology only if it leads to drive the benefits for the
dominant class in the society (McLellan, 1995, p.16). By the end of Pahlavi period in Iran, bourgeoisie, as the
most differentiated dominant class in the society, possessed, or in more specific terms occupied, the main
economical resources of the society. Furthermore, having held and controlled the distribution network,
consumption goods, credits, and the entire national budget, they set aside the chief positions in the dominant
hierarchies of the state including the economical, financial, official, and military ones for themselves
(Sodagar, 1999, P. 205).
Sodagar (1999) has segregated four dominant bourgeoisie strata of sixties and seventies in Iran. The
given bourgeoisie strata include 1) great monarchy bourgeoisie; 2) traditional bourgeoisie; 3) liberal
bourgeoisie; and lastly 4) leftist bourgeoisie (p. 206). The great monarchy bourgeoisie, as the most principal
of the bourgeoisies, was shaped by the bureaucratic transformation namely civil and military elites, traditional
landowners, and great merchants. This bourgeoisie was the only main support of the Pahlavi class authority.
The greatest factories, the most prolific lands and gardens, the most profitable businesses, contractors,
banks, and financial institutions, the top official and military positions, the highest-paid public posts, and the
production command system were all occupied by and under the control of this great capitalist monarchy
(Sodagar, 1999. P. 208). Hence, Mohammad Reza Pahlavi, the then King of Iran, can be considered as the
chief of the Iran capitalist class who supported the ideology which not only justified the unevenness of the
classes but also normalized it, as well.
1.3. The Current Study
“I mean it has happened to me several times that I’ve looked at rich girls regretfully, and it has happened
several times that at nights, while falling asleep, I’ve imagined that a rich girl with a high-tech car has barked
in front of me, picked me up, and fallen in love with me”. These statements which have been extracted from
an interview with an Iranian youth indicate that some Iranian youth from the lower-classes of the society
attempt to imaginarily associate their own life style with that of upper-classes. This study aims at bridging this
kind of imagination with Lacan’s concept of fantasy and tracing the given imagination to one of the best-
selling movies in the history of Iranian cinema at the time named Ganj-e Qaroon. Moreover, since cinema
acts as an apparatus or technology which makes an attempt to normalize an imaginary reality and makes the
audience be sutured within the movie narration due to indestructible nature of cinematic apparatus (Hivard,
2009, p.14), in order to clarify the relationship between fantasy and ideology, the main ideology within the
movie will be discussed as well. In other words, regarding fantasy, this study was to address the following
questions:
1.Who is the subject? Who is the big other the subject confronted with in the movie narration?
337
2.What desire does the subject have?

3.What actions and events was the fantasy of the subject made of?
4.Whose subject or entity is the object-cause of desire in the movie narration? What role does the object play
in the subject’s fantasy?
5.What relationship does the object-cause of desire have with the big other?
6.Is the subject’s fantasy that of the subject or the big other’s?
7.Answering question 6, is the subject’s desire the same as the big other’s or not?
Also, concerning the ideology, this study addressed the following ones:
1.How were the characters represented within the movie? What actions and dialogues do the characters
make use of?
2.Answering the previous question, what reality was offered by the movie? How was this reality shaped?
3.How are the complexification and resolution within the narrative structure?
4.Are the given complexification and resolution related to the specific ideology?
5.From which point must one look at the movie? What ideology is this point related with?
6.With reference to the background knowledge of the social-political conditions prevailing in the period of
filmmaking, is the movie ideology along or in contrast with one of the on hand ideologies at the time?
2. Methodology
2.1. Materials
The data gathered for the purpose of this study were extracted from one of the most famous and popular
Iranian movies at the time, Ganj-e Qaroon. The movie was aired in 1965. Ganj-e Qaroon was highly
successful and visited by almost 870000 out of one million residents of Tehran, capital of Iran. As a result of
its success, the movie had been on the screen for more than two successive years. To analyze the movie, it
was initially segmented into distinct parts. Subsequently, the movie fantasy and ideology were investigated.
2.2. Coding and data analysis
Analysis of data was done within the framework of narrative analysis. Narrative analysis of the movie is the
most recent branch of semiotic inquiry emerged from the critical initiatives which redefined film theory in the
1970s. Narrative analysis seeks to peel away the seemingly ‘motivated’ and ‘natural’ relationship between the
signifier and the story-world in order to reveal the deeper system of cultural associations and relationships
that are expressed through narrative form (Stam, Burgoyne, & Flitterman, 2005, p. 70). Presumably, a
number of scholars have so far proposed a number of different approaches towards narrative analysis (cf.
Propp, 1928; Barthes, 1977; Chatman, 1978). However, the present study was founded on Bordwell’s (1995)
conception of narration; Cormack’s (1992) narrative analysis of ideology; and Zizek’s (2008a) notion of
ideological ‘gaze’.
Bordwell (1995) regards ‘discourse’ and ‘story’ as the basic elements of narrative analysis. According to
him, ‘story’ describes events that occur through specific time or place and are ‘related through a causal or
thematic chain’. ‘Discourse’, on the other hand, refers to ‘order or potential presentation of film story’ (p.105).
In his term, the principles which provide a link between story and discourse are the causal relations including
time and place (Bordwell, 1995, p.9). Bordwell believes two elements namely characters and events can
function as a cause in narration. In the present study, subject is equal to the character and events equal
natural incidents or social actions (Bordwell & Thomson, 1998, p. 77). As said by Bordwell (1995), movie has
a narration but no narrator (Lothe, 2000). Therefore, consistent with the aims of the study, a ‘covert narrator’
was considered for the movie. The ‘covert narrator’ is defined as an ideological system of values a text
implicitly makes use through the combination of all sources (Lothe, 2000, 31).
338
Cormack (1992), in analyzing the ideology of narrative movie, considers the five elements including
content, structure, absence, style, and modes of address significant in terms of methodology. This study only
draws on content and structure to analyze the movie ideology. Hence, just the content and structure will be
focused on. Following, is a brief account of the two.
I. Content: According to Cormack (1992), ideology can be traced within the explicit statements,
vocabulary used, characters, and actions taken within a movie. These four subcategories “are used to
express a view of reality – a view which the audience is asked to share” (p. 29).
II. Structure: the structure of a movie is the result of its events. In narrative movies, the events can be
complexification and resolution. Thus, it may be possible to account them as a part of an ideology. Likewise,
the kind of movie resolution may sometimes be consistent and sometimes inconsistent with the movie
ideology as well.
The term ‘gaze’, another concept which was used in the analysis of the ideology, as Zizek accounts for it,
refers to the point through which one may look at the movie. As an example, in Chaplin movies, the vicious,
sadistic, humiliating attitude towards children is nothing but the gaze of the children themselves; or the
Dickensian admiration of the poor but happy, close, unspoiled world of the ‘good common people’, free of the
cruel struggle for power and money, is the view of aristocracy towards them (Zizek, 2008a, p.118-119).
In sum, in order to analyze the movie, first the movie was demarcated into distinct parts. Each part
consisted of one or more scenes. Next, the data were extracted, transcribed, and subsequently modified. To
describe and analyze the fantasy, this study draws on Bordwell’s (1995) conception of narration, without
focusing on the aesthetics of the movie. Indeed, the movie was considered as a self-contained text, i.e., apart
from its relation to cultural, cognitive, social and phenomenological conditions outside. In other words, only
the theoretical model was followed within the movie. It is worth mentioning that within one movie the whole
narration may be the fantasy of one character; however, within the other one, like the case under
investigation, a number of actions, events, and characters may construct the fantasy of one character and the
rest narrative part comprises the reality of the scenario. To analyze the ideology, the study resorts to
Cormack’s (1992) narrative analysis of ideology; and Zizek’s (2008a) notion of ideological ‘gaze’.
Furthermore, the background knowledge from the ideological atmosphere within the period of filmmaking was
employed as a presupposition.
Concerning the validity of the study, as said by Polkinghorne (2007), the validity of a narrative movie can
be determined through the well-off details and clear descriptions. Besides, in a narrative analysis, an analyst
must justify his own interpretations to his readers. Accordingly, this study made an attempt to offer a precise
and detailed investigation of the movie narration. Hence, it was tried to present detailed explanations and
provide the necessary references to the original movie dialogues if needed. Moreover, in order to assure the
validity of the study through ‘theoretical triangulation’, a combination of different theoretical frameworks was
applied in this study.
3. Findings
3.1. Situational context
Ganj-e Qaroon is the story of a poor young man who was basically the son of a rich man. Indeed, his father,
going after his own ambitions, left him and his wife many years ago. After many years, the son found his
father through an incident. Having found the truth, the son didn’t want to see his father anymore. However,
later on, his father convinced him that he had been changed and the movie ended with a family reunion.
Three narrations could be traced within the movie discourse. The first one was about an old depressed man
named Qaroon. Being trapped in the meaningless of life, Qaroon decided to kill himself. The next was about
339
a girl named Shirin. Shirin looked for a way to get rid of her suitor whom she didn’t like at all. The last was
about a young man named Ali Bi-gham6. Along with his mother and his friend, Hasan Jeghjeghe7, Ali had an
ordinary life. The movie discourse, making use of two events, provided a link among the three narrations. The
first event included Qaroon’s action in killing himself within Zayanderood8. This event bridged the first and the
third narration. Rescuing Qaroon, Ali and Hasan brought him to their home and accordingly Qaroon with the
name of Esmal Bi-kale9 came into the narration. The second event happened when the tire of Shirin’s car
dropped into a hole while she was driving and Ali helped her out. Making use of another event, this event
provided a link between the second and the third narration. That is, Faramarz, the insistent suitor, decided to
took her beloved away by force; however, Ali and Hasan rescued her. Following this scene, the three
narrations were interwoven. Ali agreed to play the role of Qaroon’s son and help Shirin. Consequently, Ali
paid a visit to Shirin’s family. Meanwhile, Faramarz, made an attempt to reveal Ali’s real identity. In a scene
through which Faramarz was to succeed, Esmal who had earlier convinced Ali’s mother, his ex-wife, to
reunite him once more, dressed up as the real Qaroon and prevented Faramarz to reveal the real identity of
Ali.
In the last scene, Ali who had known his real father did not accept him as the father had left his family for
many years; however, later on, while his father was being beaten, Ali addressing him as “father” saved his
life.
3.2. Movie segmentation
To suit the research purposes, the movie was segmented into distinct parts. Following is the demarcation of
the movie. It is worth mentioning that each part may be only one scene long or the summary of several
scenes.
 Part 1: The movie discourse including many servants, a luxury house and a private airplane indicates
that Qaroon is a man from the upper-class of the society. Qaroon is on the threshold of death and his
physical condition only allows him to have the basics of living including partial amount of bread and water.
 Part 2: Travelling to Isfahan, a metropolis in Iran, Qaroon looks at the photos of his family regretfully.
 Part 3: Qaroon is to loan Faramarz who is to marry the daughter of Mr. Zarparast, Shirin, almost 800 $.10
 Part 4: Qaroon is desperately in a hotel in Isfahan. He feels regretful over making his family leave the
house many years ago. Saying “this life is of no use”, he dismisses his servant and makes up his mind to go
on a long trip.
 Part 5: Two passer-bys see a man throwing himself into the Zayanderood. The man is Qaroon. Ali, the
younger passer-by, jumps into the river to rescue him. Addressing the older passer-by, Hasan, Ali says:
“being unhappy with his miserable life, he decides to kill himself”.
 Part 6: Ali and Hasan bring the man into their house. Entering the house, Ali asks his mother to leave the
room as their guest is a man11. Putting his own clothes on the man, Ali sings to him. Qaroon conceals his real
identity.
 Part 7: The Zarparast12, a wealthy family, talks with Faramarz about his marriage with their daughter,
Shirin. Entering the room, Shirin informs her family that in her trip to India, the son of Qaroon, falling in love
with her, has made up his mind to marry her.

6 Free from care or sorrow
7 Rattle; Hasan is in business of rattles
8 A famous river in Isfahan
9 Brainless; Esmal does things in unintelligent way including throwing himself in the river
10 Big money at the time
11 A cultural norm among some Iranians which, highly emphasizing piety, says women should leave the room when they have a guest
who is a man and with whom they don’t have a relationship of blood, foster, or in-law.
340
 Part 8: While Ali Bi-gham, Hasan Jeghjeghe, and Qaroon who from that moment on is called “Esmal Bi-
kale” are crossing the street, Shirin’s car suddenly changes its course and drops into a hole. At first, Shirin
finds Ali guilty and addresses him as “the street youth”; however, at last, she asks him for help and Ali helps
get the car out of the hole.
 Part 9: Ali with his mother vilifies the father who had left them many years ago and says: “Like all my
coevals who have a father, I wish I had a father who lovingly called me ‘my son’”.
 Part 10: Ali, Hasan and Esmal are in a bar. Ali and Hasan are having beer. Ali in response to Esmal’s
refusal to drink addresses him “that’s the way life goes on; to continue life, you should be healthy and happy”.
Fighting breaks out in the bar.
 Part 11: While Ali, Hasan and Esmal are walking on the street, Ali sings “I don’t wish for Qaroon’s13
treasure; I don’t wish for loads of treasure….”
 Part 12: Faramarz is forcefully to take Shirin away; while crossing the street, Ali, Hasan and Esmal don’t
allow this to happen.
 Part 13: Ali, Hasan and Esmal bring Shirin into Ali’s house. Ali addresses his house “the poor house” and
says “this poor house does not deserve this lady”. Telling them that she lied to her family about the son of
Qaroon’s wooing her, Shirin asks for their help. They agree to help her. Ali says “we must always help
people”.
 Part 14: Ali, playing the role of the “son of Qaroon”, Hasan as his translator, and Esmal as their driver,
leave for Royal Tehran Hilton Hotel to meet Shirin’s family. Shirin’s mother describes Ali as “a handsome
wealthy educated gentleman”.
 Part 15: Qaroon’s servant enters. The movie discourse indicates that Qaroon himself orders him to come.
The servant drives them to Qaroon’s house.
 Part 16: Ali and Hasan can’t have meals like those of upper classes; they eat food with their hands.
Esmal and Shirin glare crossly at them. They even can’t sleep well on the bed; they sleep easier on the floor.
While Hasan is complaining that “I wish we were wealthy”, Ali responses “Get to sleep! Don’t be ingratitude
towards Allah!! What is the use of being wealthy? Be Healthy all the time!”
 Part 17: Shirin and her mother are talking about Ali at home. Her mother describes Ali “well-mannered
and noble”. Shirin continues that Ali isn’t a fan of nightclub and bar.
 Part 18: Faramarz does the trick, brings Ali’s mother into Tehran, capital of Iran, and introduces her as a
laundress to Zarparast family; however, Ali pretends that he doesn’t know her.
 Part 19: Faramarz decides to take Ali’s mother away; however, Ali and Hasan rescue her. Knowing Ali’s
mother, Esmal conceals himself.
 Part 20: Ali takes her mother with him to Qaroon’s house. Describing the house to her mother, Ali says
“look around and take pleasure in …….. take a look at the plasterwork………. see what the plasterer has
made…………..look on!”.
 Part 21: Ali’s mother recognizes her own furniture in Qaroon’s house. She is Qaroon’s lost wife.
 Part 22: Entering the house, Qaroon asks his wife to forgive him because of leaving her and their son. At
first, she beats around the bush; however, she forgives him at last.
 Part 23: At the courting ceremony, Ali sings “Festival night! and my beloved’s wishful pleasure………….
Cooked beetroot, and me devoid of Qaroon’s14 treasure……” Faramarz discloses Ali’s identity. Ali makes up
his mind to confess everything; however, at the last minute, Qaroon and his wife, Ali’s mother, appear.
 Part 24: Ali embraces the father while he thinks that they are playing a trick to perform the plan. Qaroon
addresses Faramarz “you’re well aware! I can make you invisible forever!!”

12 Having a great love of jewels
13 An immensely rich man at the time of Islamic Prophet Musa; not the character of the narration
14 An immensely rich man at the time of Islamic Prophet Musa; not the character of the narration
341
 Part 25: Ali’s mother tells him that Qaroon is his real father. Seeing red, Ali addresses his father
“disgraceful” and makes up his mind to leave the house. Shirin stops him. Ali says “go to hell; all these are
because of you! You are guilty! You’ve involved me in these circumstances! I had an ordinary life. I got paid
peanuts for doing my job but I earned my living respectfully. I never change my poor life with this man’s
Qaroon’s treasure. You make my life a misery! I don’t want to see you anymore!”
 Part 26: Movie discourse indicates that Ali and Hasan have been alone in Isfahan for a couple of days.
Hasan takes Ali with him to the home.
 Part 27: At home, Ali confronting his mother embraces her. Shirin who is in another room enters. Mother
says that she has come to live with them. Ali responds “with whom? Ali Bi-gham and his mother? Or the son
and wife of Qaroon? .......... I have no business with her…… she makes a mistake to do so.” Qaroon dressing
as Esmal Bi-kale enters. Ali makes fun of him. Defending Qaroon, Shirin says “you don’t deserve to be a
human! You are a beast! Where are the zeal, honor, and manliness you have been proud of? .......... You
don’t deserve to be a human!”
 Part 28: Qaroon and Shirin leave Ali’s house.
 Scene 29: In a bar near Ali’s house, Qaroon tells Shirin that if he dies Ali and her mother will be the
beneficiaries. Meanwhile, fighting breaks out in the bar. Qaroon is being beaten.
 Part 30: Passing nearby, Ali hears the sound of fighting. Entering the bar, he rescues his father. The
movie ends with the reunion of Ali, Shirin and his father.
3.3. Textual context
3.3.1. Fantasy
Ali Bi-gham is an ordinary man from the lower-class of the society. Constructing a fantasy and expressing
his desire, Ali responds to what the big other wants and what his role for the big other is. To explain his
position as a worker in the Symbolic, the big other asks him to help others: “we must help others”; be honest:
“nothing is better than honesty in the world”; not be interested in money: “what is the use of being wealthy?
Be Healthy all the time”. However, Ali desires to have a life style like that of the upper-class of the society.
This given desire has been presented through several parts including the one in which Ali, astonishingly,
addresses her mother while describing the Qaroon’s house “look around and take pleasure in …….. take a
look at the plasterwork………. see what the plasterer has made…………..look on!” (cf. part 20) or the one
through which Ali sings “I don’t wish for Qaroon’s treasure; I don’t wish for loads of treasure….” (cf. part 11).
This desire is a kind of projection namely a sort of denegation indicating that he desires to both Qaroon’s
treasure and loads of treasure. Accordingly, through his world of fantasy, he plays the role of “Qaroon’s son”
since “Qaroon” is known to be the wealthiest man among people. Within his fantasy, he is described as
“handsome, wealthy, gentleman, educated, well-mannered, and noble” (cf. part 14 & part 17). The given
attributes are those which Ali doesn’t truly possess in the Symbolic; however, in his fantasy he deserves
himself to have those. Likewise, Shirin describes him as the man who is not a fan of nightclub and bar as in
reality Ali enjoys going to bars (cf. part 17).
In the scenario of Ali’s desire, there is an object-cause of the desire, as well. Shirin as a cute girl and a
member of the upper-class plays the role of an object that fascinates Ali. However, why should Ali bring
Shirin into his fantasy through a driving accident? In response to this question, no explicit reason is provided
within the movie narration, but, an absent element may be constituted. Imagine a young mechanic wearing
greasy coveralls is working. A cute girl driving her car enters his garage to fix his auto. He is attracted by her
without knowing that he is just a street youth in her mind. He fixes her car. Paying no attention to him, the girl
leaves the garage. In Ali’s fantasy, this cute girl shapes as a girl whose car has found problems and this is Ali
who helps her out. Similarly, Shirin sings to him (projection of desire in the fantasy since Ali himself sings
through the movie), offers him clothes of Qaroon’s son and falls in love with him. Thus, Ali constructs a
342
fantasy within which he changes to the son of the wealthiest man in the city and a rich girl falls in love with
him, too. Next, he enters an upper-class luxury house, swims in their private pool, and owns a chauffeur.
Accordingly, the subject resolves the eternal deadlock of the narration of class evenness for himself so that
he can signify his life and position in the Symbolic and justify lack of the subject.
Furthermore, object-cause of desire can be related to the big other, as well. The big other involving a gap
in essence makes an attempt to fill it in. “Object petit a” fills the vacancy in. Here, the gap of the big other is a
kind of class gap which asks Ali Bi-gham to resort to the object, Shirin. In the character Shirin, there is
something more than Shirin herself that triggers Ali’s desire, i.e., subject can resolve the class gap within the
society for himself and the big other through having a wealthy and pretty wife. Desire of Ali, i.e., the desire of
the other is the desire of Shirin for him and in reality the desire of the big other.
The fantasy constructed by Ali has kept on till the identity of Esmal Bi-kale is disclosed to him. Evaluating
subjectivity of Qaroon for Ali Bi-gham can be recognized as a kind of eruption of the Real. The Real is a
surplus in Symbolic relations. That is, Esmal Bi-kale who had previously been a poor miserable man making
up his mind to kill himself because of his miserable life changes to a father whom Ali seeks his patting hands
throughout his life. From this moment on, the whole fantasy of the subject knocks down. The class gap no
longer signifies the one intended by the big other. Ali faces with crisis and his object-cause of desire changes
to a piece of shit. That is why Ali crossly addresses Shirin “go to hell; all these are because of you! You are
guilty! You’ve involved me in these circumstances! I had an ordinary life. I got paid peanuts for doing my job
but I earned my living respectfully. I never change my poor life with this man’s Qaroon’s treasure. You make
my life a misery! I don’t want to see you anymore!” This Anger is due to the big other paradoxical relationship
with the subject. On one hand, the big other asks Ali not to be interested in money; on the other hand, it has
enriched him through fulfilling his fantasy. Accordingly, realizing that Shirin is preparing to live with him, Ali
says “with whom? Ali Bi-gham and his mother? Or the son and wife of Qaroon?” (cf. part 25).
In the given part, Ali’s father helps his anger subside, as well. Previous to Qaroon’s entrance to their
house, Ali and his mother had lived together in a mythical unity within the imaginary reality. Hasan Jeghjeghe
is also a part of this reality since rattle is a baby’s toy and where Ali has experienced his first jouissance in
the company of his mother. While Esmal is entering the house, Ali asks her mother to leave the room as their
guest is a man and he doesn’t want his mother to be seen by a “Na-Mahram15”. When it becomes evident to
Ali that Qaroon is his real father, he looks on his father as a jouissance who is to forcefully take his mother
away. Therefore, addressing his father, Ali says “you are my father! My disgraceful father! … Good for me!
I’m ashamed of knowing you as my father……” Thus, leaving his mother with his father, he goes away. In our
mind, the fantasy of the subject is ended at this point and the rest of movie narration refers to the ideology.
3.3.2. Ideology
3.3.2.1. Content
The character Qaroon is represented in two ways in the movie. On one hand, having many servants, a luxury
house and a private airplane, Qaroon is a rich man owning all the requirements of a capitalist lifestyle. He is
such a man who strongly talks with his inferiors. According to Qaroon’s claim, this strength has an absolute
performance guarantee. This is truly evident when he addresses Faramarz “you’re well aware! I can make
you invisible forever!!” (cf. part 24). He is a benevolent man, as well. Loaning Faramarz, Qaroon tries to make
Faramarz’s life prosperous, too; thus the life of another man is in his hands. He, who within the social
stratification is classified into the higher strata of the society, is only short of one point namely having no wife

15 The man with whom the woman doesn’t have any relationship of blood, foster, or in-law
343
and children and finding him at fault because of making his family leave the house many years ago. This
authoritative man kneels down and asks for forgiveness (cf. part 22).
On the other hand, Qaroon plays the role of Esmal Bi-kale, a poor man who seeks a shelter to live in, gets
into an ignorant fight with others, is satisfied, and helps people like what Ali does. This second representation
indicates that an authoritative rich man dressing worn-out and poor clothes doesn’t greatly differ from the
members of lower-classes.
The most principal action taken by Qaroon is making a decision to kill himself. With this action, the audience
takes pity on him and asks “Does he really deserve to kill himself?” “Why should such a nice man die?” “Have
he been in search of great things?” Furthermore, at the end of the movie, Qaroon being beaten inspires the
same pity once more. Therefore, the overall cost Qaroon has to pay throughout the movie is being beaten
and taken pity on. In this way, the audience gets prepared to accept that Qaroon is worthy of having the great
love of his son.
Concerning the character Ali Bi-gham, the trait attributed to him is “carefree”. This choice of terminology
summons up an image in the audience mind that Ali has a life free from care or sorrow. Ali is also
represented in two ways within the movie. On one hand, he is a poor man who earns his living through
working in a garage and is satisfied with his life with his mother and Hasan Jeghjeghe. His dialogues simply
justify his social position, e.g. “that’s the way life goes on; to continue life, you should be healthy and happy”
(cf. part 10). Through this dialogue, he is represented to be of better physical health condition in comparison
to his sick father. On the other hand, he plays the role of Qaroon’s son. In this representation, however, he
can’t get along well with the norms of the upper-classes and tells Hasan that he is happy he ends his role as
the son of Qaroon soon. His actions in rescuing Qaroon, helping Shirin out, and helping his father once more
at the end of movie are more outstandingly screened to indicate his best intentions in the mind of the
audience. When Ali doesn’t accept his father, Shirin addresses him “you don’t deserve to be a human! Where
are the zeal, honor, and manliness you have been proud of? .......... You don’t deserve to be a human!” that
is, honor necessitates him to forgive his father. The audience is also convinced that Ali as an altruism man is
better, indicating manliness, to forgives his father.
The content of the representation and actions undertaken by these two characters of the movie present a
particular kind of the reality. That is, the members of the upper-classes are not happy with their lives.
Although they are not concerned about material welfare, they are terribly sick and deserve to be taken pity
on. In contrast, those of lower-classes, despite their low incomes are kind, generous and enjoy good physical
health.
3.3.2.2. Structure
Some complexifications occur for both Shirin and Qaroon, namely the subject of upper-classes, within this
movie narration. Qaroon has been trapped in the meaningless of life and Shirin is desperate because of the
suitor whom she doesn’t like at all. These complexifications are resolved by Ali and Hasan Jeghjeghe,
namely the subject of lower-classes. Ali sings “Festival night! and my beloved’s wishful pleasure………….
Cooked beetroot, and me devoid of Qaroon’s treasure……” (cf. part 23). That is, the one who resolves the
complexifications of Qaroon and Shirin is the one who cannot even afford his own basics of living. These
complexification and resolution within the movie narration is the cost the ideology pay to the members of
lower-classes to set out an obtainable reason for their social lives. In other words, the poor may not have
enough power and wealth to change their path of lives. However, they can help others, in particular those
who are wealthier, through their altruism and sacrifice. Although they cannot make radical changes, their
representatives in the movie including Ali and Hasan have the power of change; this suggests that the
members of lower-classes have the power of change, as well.
344
3.3.2.3. Gaze
The question posed here is “from which point must we look at the movie?” In answering this question, we
refer to the movie segmentation. When Ali and Hasan go to Qaroon’s house and dine at a luxury dining table,
Ali and Hasan can’t have meals like those of upper classes; they eat food with their hands. Glaring crossly at
them, Esmal and Shirin make an attempt to prevent them. The point looks at this event is the one looks at the
narration. In this movie, Ali, his mother, and Hasan, as the representatives of lower-classes, have a happy
life. In contrast, Qaroon, as the representative of upper-classes, has faced with crisis. Also, Zarparast family,
who as their name suggests has a great love of jewels, only thinks about power and money. Description of a
life full of happiness and joy in lower-classes is an ideological gaze taken by those of upper-classes to justify
the lack of social welfare in this way. At the end of the movie, Ali, who had previously left the city, is obliged
to meet his father in Isfahan while he’s dressing up as Esmal Bi-kale and supports him, as well. Besides, he
has to accept the girl. This support and acceptance can be regarded as an obligatory choice for Ali in order to
keep the social order through empty gesture. At the end of the movie, while Ali, Qaroon, and Shirin are
passing by the camera, the given ideological gaze tells the audience that although you are wearing worn-out
clothes, your wealthy father with the same worn-out clothes is with you and you are a happy family.
4. Discussion and Conclusion
This study was to resolve a specific kind of fantasy namely class fantasy and illustrate how movies, through
the construction of the fantasy, serve to justify the prevailing ideologies at the time. Class fantasy is
constructed by the subjects of lower-classes. Within this fantasy, the subject doesn’t accept his position in
social atmosphere, and desires the lifestyle of upper-classes. Accordingly, having no way to get away from
the real, in his imagination, through having relationship with a rich girl, he makes an effort to consider himself
as a rich man. In Lacan terms, a rich girl is the object-cause of desire. That is the object that triggers the
subject’s desire and provides him the promise of a change. The same has been screened in the movie Ganj-
e Qaroon. When Ali Bi-gham recognizes that he is originally a rich man, object-cause of desire changes to a
piece of shit and loses her position within the scenario of Ali Bi-gham’s desire. The reason behind it is that,
the object-cause of desire fills in the gap of the big other, in this scenario the class gap, so that the subject of
the lower-classes can fill the given gap; however, when the subject recognizes himself as a member of
upper-classes, the object loses it prior symbolic sense and changes into a piece of junk. As the analysis of
the movie indicates, Ali’s acceptance of Shirin and his father refers to the ideology of the movie. This
ideology, to be exact class ideology, screens the class fantasy. That is why the movie could sell well.
Concerning the ideology, we can refer to the given bourgeoisie at the time. Great monarchy bourgeoisie was
Iran most principal capitalist class in 1960s; a class whose major source of asset and income was provided
by “dollar-based trading in the oil”. While exploiting labor force didn’t provide them with direct income,
legitimacy of their rule was accounted vital necessity for them. Furthermore, White Revolution, a fatherly
action taken by the most distinguished figure of Iran great monarchy bourgeoisie namely Shah to fascinate
people and legitimize the Pahlavi dynasty, was launched in 1960s. Shah intended the country to improve,
and the rule to promote the welfare of all citizens. Indeed, he was going to show considerable public
sympathy this way. Likewise, the ideological representation of social class in the movie offers a peaceful
coexistence of upper-classes with lower-classes. Although those of upper-classes have high incomes, it
couldn’t provide them happiness in their lives. Indeed, these are the people of lower-classes, who are content
with their lives, have lives free from care or sorrow, are filled with a sense of well-being, help their kind father
out, and continue the path of life with the father of upper-classes arm in arm. Without a doubt, representing a
kind of class peaceful coexistence, the movie sutures audience within the narration through which they are
filled with a kind of contentment. They are content with their life in the company of the father, at this point the
king of Iran Mohammad Reza Pahlavi. In other words, cinema apparatus represents the class fantasy of the
345
subjects and in order to control the desire of the audience, uses the end of fantasy in favor of the benefits of
the class honesty or to be precise its own favor.
References
Barker, C., & Galasinski, D. (2001). Cultural studies and discourse analysis. London, Thousans Oaks, New Delhi: SAGE.
Boothby, R. (2001). Freud as philosopher: Metapsychology after Lacan. New York: Routledge.
Bordwell, D. (1985). Narration in the film fiction. United States, Madison: The university of Wisconsin Press.
Bordwell, D., & Thompson, C. (2008). Film art: An introduction. New York City: McGraw Hill.
Braunstein, N. A. (2003). Desire and jouissance in the teaching of Lacan. In J. M. Rabate (Ed) The Cambridge companion to Lacan.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Bowie, M. (1991). Lacan. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Cormack, M. (1992). Ideology. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.
Dashtipour, P. (2009). Contested identities: Using Lacanian psychoanalysis to explore and develop social identity theory. Annual Review
of Critical Psychology, 7, 307-327.
Evans, D. (1996). An introductory dictionary of Lacanian psychoanalysis. London & New York: Routledge.
Fink, B. (1995). The Lacanian subject: Between language and juissance. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Hayward, S. (2006). Cinema studies: The key concepts. London & New York: Routledge.
Hersch, J. (2003). L'étonnement philosophique: une histoire de la philosophie. Trans. Abbas Bagheri. Tehran: Ney Publication.
Lothe, J. (2000). Narrative in fiction and film: an introduction. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Malpas, S. (2005). The Postmodern .New York: Routledge.
McLellan, D. (1995). Ideology. . Minneapolis: Open University Press.
Polkinghorne, D. (2007). Validity issues in narrative research. Qualitative Inquiry, 13(4), 471-486.
Sodagar, M. (1999). Growth trends in capitalism in Iran. Tehran: Farzin Press.
Stam, R., Burgoyne, R., & Flitterman, L. (2005). New vocabularies in film semiotics: Structuralism, post structuralism, and beyond.
London & New York: Routledge.
Weedon, C. (2004). Identity and culture: Narratives of differences and Belonging. Cornwall, Bodmin: MPG Books Ltd.
Zizek, S. (1992). Looking awry: An introduction to Jacques Lacan through popular culture. Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press.
Zizek, S. (2005). Slavoj Zizek. In M. Farhadpour, M. Eslami, & O. Mehregan (Eds) Collected writings of Slavoj Zizek: Theory, politics,
and religion. Tehran: Gam-e No.
Zizek, S. (2008a). The sublime object of ideology. New York & London: Verso.
Zizek, S. (2008b). The plague of fantasies. New York & London: Verso.
346
Non-Verbal Communication and Volleyball: A New Way to Approach the Phenomenon
Gaetano Raiola, Ph. D.

Alfredo Di Tore, Ph. D. student
University of Salerno, University of Basilicata, Italy
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.347
Abstract: Too often in sports the qualitative aspects of performance are addressed with superficially and approximation because
it believes that it is not scientifically possible to explain everything that is not easily quantifiable and expressible in the form of
numbers. In volleyball, the ball is rejected, both among members of a team and between the two opposing teams, with a
frequency significantly greater than in other team sports. For this reason, in volleyball, not immediately quantifiable aspects of
the game action are greater than other team sports. The qualitative aspects in volleyball concern technical skills, tactical
decisions, strategy and more. Among these, non-verbal communication has not yet been considered as an object of study and
thus not yet investigated. This study provides the initiation of an integrated research between social science and sports science
to allow technicians, coaches and physical education teachers to learn more about another important aspect of quality for the
purposes of training and education. The aim is to identify applications of the principles of nonverbal communication, which has
its own epistemological framework, to volleyball through the systematic analysis of specific game situations. The method
integrates the theoretical-argumentative and descriptive approach. Communicative events attributable to non-verbal
communication were classified into three categories: communication tactics, functional communication and diagnostic
communication. The frequency and outcome of these events were investigated in relation to three specific volleyball technical
skills related to nonverbal communication: a) the second ball goes to the opposite court instead of setting for attacking; b) the
attack as fast as possible in the middle of the net; c) the off speed hit instead of power spike over the block; The results show a
significant incidence of communicative events related to non-verbal communication on the final outcome and, therefore, suggest
that non-verbal communication is subject of interest to technicians, coaches and physical education teachers
1. Introduction
Nonverbal language, according to major authors such as Shannon, Weaver (1948, 1949), Argyle (1988),
Meharabian (1972), Watzlawick (1967), Hall (1966), Jackobson (1956), Ekman and Friesen (2007), has its
own epistemological framework where the message is empirically investigated in its. An Albert Meharabian
study (1972) showed as the 7% of the message content is given by the meaning the word, the 38% by the
tones of the voice and the 55% by facial expressions and body movements or kinaesthesia. Communication
is the foundation of sociability and socialization, as implies cooperation, exchange of roles (transmitter /
receiver), a code-sharing and the sharing of a context and a channel. According to phenomenological theory
(Husserl 1936, Merleau Ponty 1945) Communication is sociability because it consists of several behaviours
that help socialization through the constant exchanging among individuals, called intersubjectivity, to
construct the meanings. The human being, through the natural development and evolution in the interaction
with the socio-cultural environment, acquires a set of norms, values and patterns of behaviours characteristic
of that certain cultural reality. They are learned and assessed in the variability of contexts. Only from within
the context it is possible the decoding of a nonverbal message; this is difficult from the outside because there
is no relevant information on specific signs, symbols, signals, attitudes, postures, spaces,
distances (Meharabian 1972).
The knowledge of the factors of communication does not ensure the success of the communication;
in case of relations among individuals belonging to different contexts, it is necessary to remove the barriers
of separation against which the communication would not be effective. In order to have an effective
communication it is necessary being able to identify the message, the transmitter (the one who produces it),
and the receiver (the one who has to decode), the context within which the process takes place,
347
the communication channel and the attributed conventional code . Code means a shared system for the
organization of signs that refers to a linguistic and / or body code. Channel means the physical space by
which the communicative act takes place. The context, understood as an environmental and psychological
scenario in which communicative acts occur, may interfere with the communicative process when, for
example, the code of the transmitter is understood by the receiver, but the sense is distorted for ideological
reasons (Jakobson 1956). Non-verbal language represent the first real form of communication between
individuals.
Some aspects of nonverbal communication are universal, some others are different in different cultures
and backgrounds, which is "a major source of antagonism, misunderstanding, and contrast among cultural
and ethnic groups (Argyle 1988). The smile, facial expression and symbol in conformity with different
contexts, cultures and places, is universally interpreted as a sign of contentment, while in Japan the smile is
used as a mask that can hide reticence or embarrassment. Facial expression (Ekman & Friesen 2007) is the
first element to be analyzed in a first approach, followed by posture, by movements and kinaesthesia. Facial
expressions that communicate emotions are very similar in different cultures and in different
contexts. If Ekman and Friesen studies emphasize that facial expressions express emotions, feelings and
moods, no less importance must be given to gesture, which " is the aspect that seems to change more in
different cultures "(Argyle 1988).
Argyle defines emblems the nonverbal acts that have a direct verbal translation, such as nodding,
beckoning and pointing. The origin of these actions is derived from fundamental human experiences or from
natural symbols that describe actions or people. If pointing is considered to be universal in all cultures,
nodding in many cultures as in Northern Europe is used to indicate "no", while in Greece a rapid backward
movement of the head is a sign of denial (this movement is also specific in the Neapolitan body
tradition). The same sign with the thumb and the index closed to form a ring is a sign of approval in the
U.S.A. and in Northern Europe meaning "OK", but in Southern France indicates something worthless
remembering . It should not be neglected the contribution of sign language that in its purest form has been
developed by categories of people who cannot use words such as deaf. The visual interaction considerably
varies within different cultures. Arabs, South Americans and Southern Europeans in a research conducted in
1970 by Watson on a sample of 110 foreign students of Colorado University, stare more than students from
other cultures where physical contact is limited. Just as American blacks stare less than white ones, giving
the impression of a little attention or understanding when combined with mild head movements during
listening. While for Afro-Americans gazing directly at a senior would be index of equal status, so they are
reluctant to do so because their action would be interpreted as a lack of respect (Meharabian 1972). Even the
spatial behaviour must be properly considered in the relationship between individuals and
groups. The anthropologists often distinguish between cultures with frequent physical contacts and cultures
without or very limited physical contacts. Individuals from cultures with a frequent physical contact (Arabs,
Latin Americans, Southern Europeans) are closest, are often more opposite of each other, they touch
themselves and stare much more at each other, they also speak more loudly than people from cultures of
non-contact such as Asians, Indians, Pakistanis and Northern Europeans.
The Arabs, for example, during the salute, shake hands for a certain period of time, or they can embrace
and kiss hands, beards or faces on formal occasions; Arab men, during their conversations, touch
themselves on the upper arm with their right hand and playfully slap each other with their right hand; Arab
women, on the contrary, are in no way touched in public. Most likely the differences of spatial behaviour may
result from differences in the structure of the physical environment, such as the dimensions of houses and
the degree of crowding. Instead, we are likely to interpret the spatial behaviour in a very simplistic way: who
gets too close is considered intrusive as opposed to that who approaches too little that is considered cold and
aloof. There are considerable cultural differences regarding the quantity and type of contact. The Arabs also
have a stretched forward posture at an angle of the body most directly aimed at contact, while the Japanese
bows, even up 45 °, are just a sign of respect. Another characterization of ethnic groups is the use of tone
348
and vocal intensity, not to associate with verbal communication that is the absolute transmission through
content of the word that is the meaning. The inhabitants of the West Indies for example do not point to the
end of sentences with a rising tone of the voice appearing rude to the English culture, they also make use of
high tones to emphasize what they say, incorrectly interpreted as sudden outbursts of anger. The Arabs use
a very high one of voice compared to that of the most part of other cultures that could be seen as assertive
while for them talking with a high tone is synonymous of sincerity. Japanese people change their vocal
style according to sex and social status of their interlocutor; Morsbach has assumed the distinction of eight
separate tones of voice (Argyle 1988). According to Paul Watzlawick, human communication can be divided
into three areas: syntax, semantics and pragmatics. The first covers issues related to coding and decoding of
information, to channels, to redundancy and to noise, the second is concerned with the meaning of
communication for transmitters and finally the third focuses on the effects of communication on the
receivers, particularly on the influence it exerts on their behaviour.
The Palo Alto school, where Paul Watzlawick belonged, was the seat of the specific studies of the
behaviourist version of communication. Paul Watzlawick, together with Janet Helmick Beavin and Don
D. Jackson, publishes "Pragmatics of Human Communication. A Study of Interactional Patterns, Pathologies,
and Paradoxes " and over the years deals primarily with this third aspect of the communication:
pragmatics. He arrives at the conclusion that behaviour is communication, in clear agreement with the
Behaviourism.
Proxemics is the field of knowledge that studies the space and the distances within the communication. It
has another element of nonverbal communication. The term proxemics was introduced by the anthropologist
Edward T. Hall in 1963 to indicate the study of neighbourhood relations in communication. Hall noted that
the distance among people is related to the physical distance, he has assumed and measured four
"distances" among people. The distance defined intimate that passes between 0 and 45 cm for people with
special relations, the personal distance between 45 and 120 cm for friends, the social distance is between
1.2 and 3.5 meters for the communication between acquaintances or teacher- student relation and finally the
public distance that goes beyond the previous distances for public relations. In the book The Hidden
Dimension, Hall observed that the distance to which you feel comfortable with other close people depends
on the culture and on social contexts and therefore is variable.
This brief analysis provides the backdrop for the study of nonverbal communication in situation sports.
It helps to collect a set of empirical factors related to communication and relations during the game and to
systematize them in a specific theoretical framework. The confrontation between adversaries also occurs
through bodily communication, with effects in the specific context, in a specific time and place.
The body communication is undoubtedly among the qualitative aspects of the movement, ranging from the
technical fundamentals of the game tactics, individual and collective (Teodorescu 1985) and the organization
of learning and teaching (Pieron & Wauquiepr, 1984). Each context has its elements of communication: a
sport is different from another for the dynamics, rules, structures and composition of individuals (Hughes &
Franks 2004).
In team sports where the ball continuously runs, there is the maximum of the complexity for the high
number of variables and its dynamic as well as volleyball. Currently the processes of training, the
organization of it and the methodology of teaching and of the training need more knowledge about every
aspects of sport (Wrisberg & Schmidt, 2008). For this view the quantitative aspect of performance is
important and it includes the strength and its mechanism to improve the power and it is an unique
quantitative and qualitative process. Too often in sports the qualitative aspects of performance are addressed
with superficially and approximation because it believes that it is not scientifically possible to explain
everything that is not easily quantifiable and expressible in the form of numbers.
In volleyball, the ball is rejected, both among members of a team and between the two opposing teams,
with a frequency significantly greater than in other team sports. For this reason, in volleyball, not immediately
349
quantifiable aspects of the game action are greater than other team sports. The qualitative aspects in
volleyball concern technical skills, tactical decisions, strategy and more.
Among these, non-verbal communication has not yet been considered as an object of study and thus not
yet investigated.
This study provides the initiation of an integrated research between social science and sports science to
allow technicians, coaches and physical education teachers to learn more about another important aspect of
quality for the purposes of training and education.
Focus of this work is the study of nonverbal communication in volleyball. The aim is, on the
epistemological basis of nonverbal communication, to identify and to systematically argue the incidence of
nonverbal communication on volleyball performance through an applied study of selected actions of game.
The analysis of the result of sport performance can highlight relationships between score and some technical
skills, which in this case are attributable to nonverbal language, among which is included the feint. The
coaching approach of Performance Analysis can help in the investigation for matters related to the
result. The datum can help coaches to re-evaluate some specific aspects of technical skills (Hughes &
Bartlett, 2002) depending on bodily communication.
2. Method
The overall methodology of the work was inspired by the ecological trend of the integration of knowledge for
the realization of a "well done head" (Morin, 2006) and by the plurality of intellective forms (Gardner 2002)..
The sports research in education requires a plural and integrated approach to enable the competition of
different methods in order to offer the widest scientific speculation. The knowledge is derived from fields of
knowledge attributable to different scientific traditions that apparently do not seem to communicate.
The method of this study is integrated between a theoretical-argumentative approach and descriptive one.
The theoretical-argumentative approach belonging to the field of human sciences and the applicative one
belonging to the field of performance analysis.
It consists of two consecutive steps.
The survey of datum is entrusted to the methodology of performance analysis and is gradually carried out
with the contribution of experts, coaches, analysts. The identified technical skills of the fundamental of the
attack are:
a) the second ball goes to the opposite court instead of setting for attacking;
b) the attack as fast as possible in the middle of the net;
c) the off speed hit instead of power spike over the block; (Raiola 2012)
The analysis takes place during the game always in opposition to the opposite block. Experimental research
in sports-education field allows us to analyze the movement through performance analysis methodology and
notational analysis methodology (Hughes & Tavares, 2001). The qualitative research for the study of
movement also includes quantitative aspects, highlighting the substantial uniqueness and wholeness of the
gesture, of the execution and even the relationship that is established in teaching communication. In
approaching to sports-teaching research it is in fact present the simultaneous use of qualitative and
quantitative methods, the use of tools and techniques with applications of rigour and consistency to help you
analyzing, evaluating, estimating the uniqueness and wholeness of the sport phenomenon.
The activity of investigation of the movement in the educational environment is subject then to bonds that
require specific skills of the researchers to functionally integrate methodological approaches used by
education sciences with strategies of research peculiar to the movement sciences and to sport sciences.
The theoretical argumentative research, which belongs to human sciences, is complemented by
experimental research, by action research or intervention and by descriptive research. It becomes complex
350
and ecological. Complex because it consists of multiple approaches, ecological because it is opposed to
reductionism to contextualize the dynamics in a single process. It is integrated because it combines
various theoretical aspects of pure study joining them to the observed data with quantitative models of field
observations. The tools are those of performance analysis with annotations in real time and also delayed
by the use of video-software by experts, coaches and analysts, the latter already specifically trained for
operators who, although holders of amateur status, are regularly paid within the sports system. In particular,
data of the analyst were collected after a specific request of the researcher about what to observe, how to
observe and to record as in line with the traditional request action of the coach for each
competition. Generally, the evaluation of datum is provided by a team made by the analyst, by the coach and
in some cases by the athlete. However, the datum is derived by the analyst which expresses the last
assessment, because he plays this function even in the real field. The tools are provided by the performance
analysis with hand notation and delayed with the use of video-software made by the analyst. In this study, the
activities are conducted in a research group formed by trainers, technicians, recruiters and performance
analysts of the Qualification Centre of Regional Committee of Campania of the Italian Volleyball Federation
since 2008. . Observers group analyzes three fast volleyball skills to evaluate the type of phenomenon by
the following four steps:
1.specialized literature review

2.observation
3.investigation
4.focus group
The focus group is composed by are three coaches of major level of the observed team and by six athletes of
the observed volleyball team .
Theoretical and argumentative approach are addressed to the applicability of the foundations of the
theory of nonverbal language to volleyball about attack actions and to look for a possible specific definition of
it for typologies of activities. This is aimed to combine and to deduce the elements of knowledge on non-
verbal languages with the impact on human behaviours into the competitive activities of volleyball, so to
identify some of the technical skills of the fundamental of attack, including the elements of nonverbal
communication.
The work develops in stages with the methodology of focus group (Albanesi 2004). The first stage is the
training by the researcher with the use of knowledge relating to bodily communication and the purpose of the
study quoted in the introduction of this work; and the second is about the analysis of specific game phases of
3 league competitions to define some applications of coding and decoding of the message of bodily
communication and a possible classification applied to volleyball. The activities were analyzed in real time by
three coaches, punctuated by frequent comparisons during numerous suspensions (ball changes,
substitutions, rest times, various interruptions) with annotations and written notes. At the end of each of the
three competitions, the group meets with the researcher and, with the methodology of focus group, they talk
about the possible type of nonverbal communication in volleyball. It is defined for activities of the various
forms of nonverbal communication connected to the different fundamentals of game.
Finally, the six athletes give their contribution to give the subjective opinion on the evaluation and the type
of classification.
3. Results
The results are two types: empirical and descriptive one. The empirical results classify the non-verbal
communication in functional, diagnostic and tactical. The descriptive results on the 3 chosen technical skills,
351
where the nonverbal communication is present, are: the off speed hit 10.32%, 8.70% the first time spike in
the middle of the net, 6.10% the second ball of the setter instead of setting; for an total amount of 25.12%.
4. Empirical results
Volleyball is particularly suited to the study of nonverbal communication for the peculiarity of the reduced
time that have the neuropsychological processes at their disposal in the mandatory mode of the clearance of
the ball, otherwise it is sanctioned the foul (Raiola 2010a). This feature does not happen in any team and
situation sport. The technical and tactical aspects assume greater significance in volleyball than those
quantitative ones. In addition, particular issues non verbal communication take into account the body feint,
manifest intention to achieve a goal through the initial execution of a motor plan with specific signs, postures,
attitudes, etc., then is realized in completely different way (Raiola 2010b). In this case the neurophysiological
and psychological bases of the movement associated with perception affect the implementation
of fundamental and the single technical skills.
Summary nonverbal communication is made by three steps (fig.1).
Fig. 1: Karl Bühler’s communication model, sender-message-receiver
Communicating means to establish a relation between two persons and among people and it implies
the transfer of information. However, communication is not only transmission of information through a
channel, it is also relation in the sociality where sender and receiver cooperate for a common goal and they
exchange roles as the following systematic scheme. The communicative process is a unique and dynamic
flow made of several steps: sender, context code, communication channel , and receiver, as the following
scheme (Jakobson 1956) (fig. 2).
Fig. 2: Reunited model of communication (Karl Bühler - Roman Jakobson)
The whole phenomenon of nonverbal communication is represented by the model in figure no.3 where are
visible further specifications and other variables as follow (fig.3):
 Transmitter is also the source of information, he gives an initial message by encoding
 Sender releases and deliveries the initial signal
 It passes throughout the source of noise with modifications
 It becomes the final signal
 Receiver acquires and decodes the final message
 Addressed is also the destination of information, he receive a final message by decoding
352
Fig. 3: The systemic model of communication (Claude Shannon-Warren Weaver)
About the classification of decoding the nonverbal message, the result was restricted to three possible types
of decoding of behaviour:
1. The decoding of the signs of facial expressions is functional when it is done in the same team and it
involves communication among teammates or between the coach and the athletes about tactics intentions,
strategies and game problems. Examples are the call using the conventional signs by the setter for the
actions of attack and by the middle hitter in the wall for the actions of defence. In volleyball, for example, the
setter uses conventional prearranged signs to communicate to the other players the plans of the game (hand
gesture) fig.4:
a.index finger meaning the ball will be set (tossed) in front of the player (setter) for a very rapid spike
centered on the net by the attacking player;
b.middle and index finger meaning the ball will be set (tossed) behind the player (setter) for a very rapid spike
on the right side of the net by the attacking player;
c. thumb and index finger meaning the ball will be set (tossed) away and in front of the player (setter)
between the left side and the centre of the net for a very rapid spike by the attacking player;
d.thumb and little finger meaning the ball will be set away and behind the player (setter) between the right
side and the centre of the net for a very rapid spike by the attacking player.
Fig. 4 The setter uses conventional prearranged signs to communicate to the other players the plans of the
game (hand gesture).
2. Decoding is diagnostic when analyzing the various forms of nonverbal communication of the opposing
team, the signs of the athletes and of the coach that anticipate or call for game actions. Examples are the
actions of opposing attack in the combination of patterns of smash through a reading or options of wall
players to choose which shot attack to contrast.
353
 close contact and a glance (distance between the players of two teams, visual contact through the net);
 expressive ability (facial expressions and corporeal [body] gestures that precede, continue, and follow the
actions of play);
 significant difference between signs (difference between corporeal signals, conventionally coded,
prearranged, or personal);
 rituals (gestures, facial expressions, or attitudes that mark the behaviour of the athlete);
 symbolic presentation of oneself (utilization of the body and of gestures to express one’s own needs or
demands).
3. Decoding is tactics when the act or the action simulates an action game to stimulate a reaction of the
opponent team. Example is the feint in all technical skills of the fundamentals.
 dominate when an athlete dominates the area of game thanks to his high athletic and/or technical ability
works.
 hostile or adverse when in the adverse phases, the technical-athletic ability works in conjunction with the
facial signs and the body pantomime which communicate aggressiveness).
 friendly (during training when the actions of the game are finalized to improve on the plans of attack and
defense. In this case, the players of the same team split into 2 separate [rival] teams).
 subjected or mastered (when the offensive abilities of a team are obviously higher)
5. Descriptive results
Currently the analysis of performance in volleyball shows the relationship between the score and the
fundamentals of game: service, attack, counterattack, block, defence, receive through the use of the analysis
of video performance with dedicated software (Data Project, Dartfish, Focus Elite). The methodology of the
Performance Analysis (Hughes & Franks 2004) expands the knowledge on sport performance as it analyzes
more deeply performance by seeking possible relationships between the outcome of a part or of the whole
performance and the processes associated. The group identifies in the fundamental of the attack the greater
number of episodes characterized by bodily communication. the decoding tactics is frequent for the following
skills: lobs instead of the powerful smash from all the positions of attack, the second direct hits in the
opposing field of the setter instead of the lofted ball, the combinations of attack called with fixed schemes, the
fast smashes of the first time from the central place, from behind of the setter with the elevation of a leg and
of second-line from central place. It identifies three specific technical skills included in the fundamental of the
attack: lob instead of a smash on a lofted ball in position 4, smash in the first time in position 3 and the
second touch of the setter from position 2 in the opposing field instead of setting. The game positions in the
field go from 1 to 6 and leave from the service position and they develop in a counter clockwise sense.
The second part is a pilot study over 10 championship randomly sampled competitions of the team from
Naples belonging to female C division.
As a result of the outcome of the first part of the study concerning the identification of 3 technical skills of
the attack, it was carried out an analysis of the scores awarded to the 3 technical skills techniques identified
and added to the final measurement. The remark was made by hand in real time, hand notation, by the
researcher that is also the coach of the team. This activity is included in the practice of monitoring the field of
competition that is made by the coach, by the second trainer or by the analyst for the usual post-
competition deepening in the first following training session.
The results are: 10.32% lob, 8.70% first time smash, 6.10% second touch of the setter for a total of
25.12%
354
Tab. 1 & graph. 1
second ball of the setter to

first time spike in 3°zone the off speed hit in 4°zone the opposite court Other outcomes
8,70% 10,32% 6,10% 74,88%
6. Discussion
The study helps:

 To define a first inventory of signs used more frequently in volleyball according to the principles of bodily
communication (Argyle, 1988), the aspects of perceptive senses (Berthoz, 2002) and the neurobiological
implications (Rizzolatti & Sinigaglia, 2006)
 To give a general plan for training that includes knowledge about the function of gestures, signs and
mimicking, the structure and the mean of nonverbal messages and the effects of bodily communication on
behavior in order to build expressive and communicative skills of volleyball coaches. The paths of training for
sports game coaches reflect the guidelines of studies and research on the methodology of the training of
volleyball focused on the improvement of functional aspects, on the development of conditional abilities and
energy mechanisms and on optimization of the bio-mechanical aspects, undervaluing the function of
nonverbal communication during the game through the gestures, the signs and the mimicking.
Usually, the phases of game that differentiate the successful from the unsuccessful teams are determined
according to the analysis of the situation parameters of matches in sports game (Hughes & Franks., 2004).
For that purpose, matches or sets are used as entities inside such as the quality of performances of recorded
phases or volleyball elements is analyzed. Nonverbal communication could determine the outcomes for the
actions and skills examined (Raiola, 2011a). Furthermore, in volleyball there are six players in one field that,
depending on their playing role, are placed in six different zones and they are rotating clockwise during a
game always for one zone, that is, it happens for every step of rotation. For this reason, the volleyball is very
variable. In order for a team to be successful, it is necessary to achieve the balance of performance in every
actions and for every player. The data obtained with the analysis of the situation efficiency of every phase of
a game are used as main guidelines in the planning and programming of volleyball training.
Further research and software development will focus on quantifying the critical performance values and
expanding the software for other actions and skills.
355
The aspects of non-verbal communication in volleyball, its codes and the technical and tactical usage of
gesture, are the result of the meeting between tacit and implied dimension that comes from experience
gained on the range of activities and a theoretical dimension that scientifically characterizes and justifies the
expressive and communicative potential of body (Raiola 2011b).
References
Albanesi, C. (2004), I focus group, Carocci , Roma, Italia

Argyle, M., (1988), Bodily Communication. Second edition, London: Metheun & Co Ltd. UK
Berthoz, A. (2002), The Brains Sense of Movement. Boston, USA: Harvard University Press.
Ekman, P. & Friesen W. V. (2001), Giu la maschera, Los Angeles USA.
Husserl, D. (1936). Die Krisis der europaischen Wissenscaften und Die transzendentale Phanomenologie (The crisis of european
science and transcendental Phenomenologie), Philosophia Serbia.
Gardner, H. (2002). Frame of the mind, the theory of multiple intelligences. Basic Books,New York, USA:
Hall, T. E. (1966). The Hidden Dimension. Garden City, N.Y.: Doubleday. USA
Hughes, M. , Tavares, F. (2001), Notational Analysis of Sport - IV, Porto: Faculty of Sports Sciences and Education Portugal
Hughes, M.D. and Franks, I.M. (2004), Notational Analysis of Sport 2nd Edn.-Better Systems for Improving Coaching and Performance.
London: E. and F.N. Spon. UK
Hughes, M.D. and Bartlett, R.M., (2002), The use of performance indicators in performance analysis. J. Sports Sci., 20: 739-754
Iacoboni M., (2008), Mirroring People. The new science of how we connect with others. , L.A. Farrar Straus & Girox USA
Jakobson R. and Halle, M. (1956). Fundamentals of Language. Gravenhage : Mouton, USA.
Lewin, K. (1946) Action research and minority problems. J Soc. Issues 2(4): 34-46
Meharabian, A. (1972), Nonverbal communication, Library of Congress Catalog Number USA.
Merleau Ponty, M. (1945), Phenomenologie de la perception, Paris: Libraire. France
Morin, E., (2006), La testa ben fatta, Cortina, Italy
Pieron M., Wauquier P. (1984), Modification de comportements d'enseignement chez des Etudiants en éducation physique en stage
d'agrégation. Revue de l'Éducation Physique, 24, 4 : 29-37.
Raiola G, 2010a, Tactical choice of volleyball central blocker at the opposing attacks with the help of bodily communication, Scientific
Report Series Physical Education and Sport No. 14,Vo.1/2010, 72-76
Raiola, G, 2010b, Bodily communication performance analysis in volleyball by new way of gathering data system, Scientific Report
Series Physical Education and Sport No. 14, Vo.1/2010), 77-81
Raiola G. (2011a) Bodily Communication in Volleyball and New Data System, Journal of Social Sciences 7 (4): 671-675, Science
Publications, USA
Raiola G. (2011b) Theoretical, argumentative and empirical volleyball study on body communication and its relation to anticipation skills.
New perspectives of coaching formation Vol. 5, Issue 2; December 25, Acta Kinesiologica, Bosnia & H.
Raiola G. (2012) Bodily Communication in Volleyball Between Human and Experimental Sciences, Mediterranean Journal of Social
Science, Italy
Rizzolatti, G. (2006). So quel che fai. Il cervello che agisce e i neuroni specchio (I know what I do. The brain acts and mirror neurons)
Raffaello Cortina Editore, Milano, Italia.
Schmidt, R., A. and Wrisberg, G., A. (2008), Motor Learning and Performance. Champaign, Ill.: Human Kinetics, USA.
Shannon, C. E. (1948), A mathematical theory of communication, Bell System Technical Journal, 27, pp. 379-423 and 623-656, July and
October, 1948
Shannon, C. E. & Weaver, W., (1949) The Mathematical Theory of Communication. The University of Illinois Press, Urbana, USA
Watzlawick, P., Beavin, J.H. & Jackson, D.D. (1967). Pragmatics of Human Communication-A Study of Interactional Patterns,
Pathologies and Paradoxes. New York: Norton. USA.
Wrisberg, G. A., (2009). Sport Skills for Coaches. Champaign, Ill.: Human Kinetics USA
Teodorescu, L. (1984). Problemas de teoria e metodologia nos jogos desportivos (Problems of theory and metodologia in sports games).
Lisboa: Livros Horizonte, Portogallo
356
Specifying Metadiscoursal Signals in the Novel Pride and Prejudice

and its Two Persian Translations
By Copple’s model (1980)
Esmaiel Kaboli Boroujeni
Islamic Azad University, Shahreza Branch

Faculty of Humanities
English Language Department
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.357
Abstract: Finding out the metadiscoursal signals in any language and analyzing their usage specially in meaning transfer
between two different languages is very important. The present paper adopted the model presented by Vande Copple (1980), to
find all of the metadiscoursal signals in the first five chapters of the novel Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen. The number of
metadiscoursal signals in all of the related parts in the original novel was compared with those of its two Persian renderings by
Pooranfar and Ardakani by a comparative study using Vande Copple’s model. The results of the study showed that the number
of metadiscoursal signals usage in the TL translation made by Ardakani was more than of those in Pooranfar’s translation.
However, considering both translations, they were poor in transferring the original metadiscoursal signals into the Persian
language and it resulted to the less comprehensibility of them comparing to that of original novel. Besides, the consistency,
meaningfulness and communicativeness of the translated texts were in a lower level than the original due to the lower number of
metadiscoursal signals. As a result, it was made clear that the use of metadiscoursal signals is necessary and complementary in
any kind of discourse use.
Key words: Metadiscourse signals, Text connectives, Code glosses, Validity markers, Narrators, Illocution markers, Attitude
markers, and Commentaries
1. Introduction
In the process of transferring the meanings, ideas, attitudes, and information we are dealing with language
and its different devices (Johnston, 2008). One of the most applicable ways to transfer the ideas in any
language is writing. The world of writing is an expanded world for which there have been many debates,
researches, and techniques. These techniques can be applicable from the very direct and surface to the very
indirect and deep sections of the language. The techniques used in the deepest part of the language
especially in writing in order to transfer the meaning and ideas are as deep and complex as what their names
denote (Woods, 2006).
One of these complicated tools is the metadiscourse through which we can add to the deepness of
meanings, attitudes, and ideas which are not very clear as we look at the surface part of a piece of writing
(Hyland, 2005). So, it becomes clear that we should adopt a good method and point of view to deal with the
metadiscourse and its signals in a text. One of the best views found upon the metadiscourese signals is the
model presented by Vande Copple (1985), which has broadly dealt with the metadiscoursal signals (MDSs).
Using this model, the present study has tried to find out the extent to which metadiscoursal signals have been
used in the novel “Pride and Prejudice”. Besides, this study tries to find out that how much these original
metadiscourse signals are transferred in both translations made by “Pooranfar” and “Ardakani”. Then, the
researcher has done a comparison among the results of the study to determine which one of the
metadiscourse signals has been more successfully transferred to the target language and which one has the
least portion in the target language.
357
All of the language producers and receivers are dealing with the use of metadiscourse signals throughout
the language production all the times (Johnston, 2008). Metadiscourse is somehow the inner side of the
language and as the term “meta” denotes, it is something more than what we can deal with (Hyland, 2005).
So, one of the most important features of any text is its usage of metadiscourse signals. When the issue of
translation between two completely different languages is under investigation, this matter gets more and
more highlighted. In the course of translation, in addition to the elements of grammar, vocabulary, text type,
and context there should be a great consideration for discourse and in a larger and deeper scale,
metadiscoursal elements. As a matter of fact, without the useful application and noting the metadiscoursal
elements a comprehensive and full scale translation will not be fulfilled. Therefore, first, all of the
metadiscoursal elements should be understood perfectly in the original text and be explainable in a
comprehensive way; later on, in transferring the materials to the target language the best counterparts or
equivalents should be used in the translated text instead of the metadiscoursal elements within the original
text.
2.1. Metadiscourse Definitions and Continuums
According to Ken Hyland (2005), metadiscourse is in relation to the self-reflected expressions used in a piece
of text by the writer or in a speech by a speaker in order to negotiate and interact the meaning to the reader
or audience. Later, he points out the near relationship between metadiscourse job and the one by rhetoric.
Based on his assumptions “rhetoric is the art of persuasion” and hence, it is about the way we influence our
audiences. Ken Hyland (2005) has brought some pieces of writings in different genres to show how
metadiscorsal elements can insert meaning to the text and how they can be influential.
a) I admit that the term ‘error’ may be an undesirable label to some teachers.
(PhD dissertation )
b) To call a patient at the Royal Free costs 39 off-peak and 49 peak - time per minute!!
(Letter to the editor)
c) As you know I always meet the assignment de ad-lines
(Personal email)
d) The newly devised menu ‘Essence D’asiatique’ (of Asian influence) features tantalizing cuisine
expertly prepared on the premises.
(Restaurant review)
e) Read could be sighted on the square minutes before the start of the test receiving deliveries from
James Anderson (remember him?)
(Sports journalism)
The underlined parts and even the shapes are considered the metadiscoursal signals of these pieces of text
by all of which the writer has efficiently transferred some implicit meanings to the readers. Part (a) uses ‘’ to
show this is not the writers attitude. Part (b) makes use of exclamation mark to show surprise. In part (c)
through the use of smile, the writer points out that it’s a joke. In part (d) the usage of parenthesis shows an
explanation and finally in part (e) through the application of a question there is a shift to readers to offer a
personal comment.
In all of the written or spoken discourse works, there are two levels: the primary level upon which the
propositional content in established, and the metadiscourse level which is added to the primary level to signal
the presence of authors (Vande Copple, 1985). In addition, Halliday (1985) believes that there are three
functions of language: (1) the ideational function of language used to express referential information about
the matter; (2) the interpersonal function of language in which authors or speakers interact with the readers
358
or hearers; and (3) the textual function of language used to shape language into a connected text. While the
ideational function of language is fulfilled by the primary level of discourse, the other two functions of
language are fulfilled by the metadiscourse level (Copple, 1985). The use of metadiscourse can be seen in
the works of the earliest scholars such as Aristotle as well as those of modern authors, but the point is the
inconsistency of use (Hyland, 2005). They use metadiscoursal elements to show different matters and
opinions. For example, Aristotle used words which show self confidence authority, whereas another writer,
like Bruner, made use of hedges or later authors used metadiscourse elements in their essays and treatises
(e.g. Borges, Calvino Descartes, Geothe, (2003); scientists such as Darwin, Gould, & Woodruff (1998)). In
addition, metadiscourse is frequently found in popular magazines and books, as well as in technical articles,
reports, and books (Crismore and Farnsworth, 1990).
The potential importance of metadiscourse has been approved by numerous scholars in different
disciplines. A number of communication scholars, modern rhetoricians, and educators believe that, when
used appropriately, metadsicourse can guide and direct readers through a text by helping them understand
the text and the author’s perspective (Bradley, 1981; Williams, 1985; Winterowd, 1983), thereby making the
text more friendly and considerate (Singer, 1986).
Obviously, Metadiscourse exists in most of the written works and this illustrates its long history span over
major historical periods. Metadiscourse can be used across ten genres and disciplinary discourse types:
history, drama, handbooks, textbooks, poetry, religion, biography, fiction, essay, philosophy, and science.
Authors discourse about their discourse by choosing from a wide variety of forms to present their textual and
interpersonal metadiscourse: as single words, phrases, full clauses/sentences, and paragraphs (Widdowson,
2007). They often choose from such categories of textual metadiscourse (e.g. code glosses, logical
connectors, topicalizers, previews and reviews, and narrators) and interpersonal materials (e.g. direct
addresses to the readers, hedges and emphatics, evaluatives, and other commentaries), (Johnstone, 2008).
Sometimes the authors use metadiscourse elements about the content, text or the processes and strategies
used during writing. Metadiscourse is used for different purposes to inform, to persuade, or to express.
Sometimes there are multiple pruposes as to inform and persuade, to express and persuade, or to inform
and express (Crismore, 1985).
The model used in this study to analyze the related data is mainly the model presented by Vande Copple
(1980), then after collecting the related information from the original and translations, through the use of
charts and diagrams more information was gathered about the original and target language MDSs. So, all of
the MDSs in the original novel and its two translations were detected and elaborated. The model is as follow:
3.1. Categorization of Metadiscourse
Considering depth of meaning realized by discourse markers and the amount of meaning they are
transferring to the readers, there are a number of different models elaborating the categorization of
metadiscourse.
3.2. Vande Copple Model (1980)
The model presented by Vande Kopple (1980) has been used for data collection and analysis of the study
due to its elaborative and full scale nature in the explanation of metadiscourse and being favored by
numerous writers such as Crismore and Farnsworth (1985). Vande Copple’s model which is divided into two
main parts, regarding the linguistic and extra linguistic factors, considers all the possible available types of
metadiscourse in any kind of text. Although there are some problems concerning the application of this model
359
and similar models for different kinds of texts especially their translations, it will be hardly tried to elaborate
well the use of MDSs in both original and translated novel. Here the first part of Copple’s model is presented:
3.2.1. The First Part of the Model
Textual Metadiscourse Signals
Text Connectives Code Glosses Validity Markers Narrators
Figure1. First Part of the Copple’s Model
As presented, the first part is concerned with the textual types of metadiscourse which mainly deal with
linguistic and cohesion markers. They will be clearly explained here:
3.2.1.1. Text connectives
Text connectives show how different parts of the text are connected to each other. These items can connect
different parts of a text together and shape a cohesive text. They are mainly classified in three categories as
below:
A. Consequences: first, next ….
B. Reminders: as I mention, as it made clear…
C. Topicalizers: with regard to, in connection with …
3.2.1.2. Code glosses
Code glosses are used to help the readers or hearers understand the writer’s or speaker’s intended meaning.
Based upon the reader’s or hearer’s knowledge these devices can reword, explain, define or clarify. All of
these are done through putting the desired information within parentheses or making it as an example.
3.2.1.3. Validity markers
Validity markers are used to express the writer’s or speaker’s commitment to the probability or truth of a
statement. In other words s/he tries to show how much s/he is in agreement with the quoted information.
There are mainly three groups of validity markers including:
A. Hedges: perhaps, might …
B. Emphatics: clearly, undoubtedly …
C. Attributers: according to …
3.2.1.4. Narrators
Narrators are used to inform readers of the sources of presented information. Sometimes, writers want to
directly quote someone else’s believes for which they should use statements like: according to …
360
3.2.2. The Second Part of the Model
Interpersonal Metadiscourse Signals
Attitude Markers Illocution Markers Commentaries
The second part of Copple’s model is dedicated to the interpersonal metadiscourse where lots of attention is
devoted to the bidirectional relations between two communicators. Here we should go further the linguistic
and structural matters and even lots of symbols may have their own meanings. These subparts will be
defined here:
3.2.2.1. Attitude markers
Attitude markers are used to express the writer’s attitude to the propositional matter presented. In other
words the attitude markers show how much the writer is interested in the presented materials. This is done
through the use of statements like:
Unfortunately, interestingly, I wish that …
3.2.2.2. Illocution markers
Illocution markers are used to make explicit the discourse act the writer is performing at certain points. As
explicitness is very important to transfer the desired meaning and since it is necessary for the writer to give
his/her readers the sense of end, illocution markers are used in texts by using statements like:
To conclude, I hypothesize, to sum up …
3.2.2.3. Commentaries
Commentaries are used to address readers directly by commenting on the reader’s probable mood or
possible reaction to the text. This helps the writer to build a closer relationship with his/her readers.
Commentaries are fulfilled by statements like:
You will certainly agree that, you might want to read that …
As it was made clear, this study tries to put all the metadiscoursal elements of the original novel into such
a distinction and table; then, the same procedure will be followed for the two translations and at last, a
comparison between them will be made.
3.3. Materials
The data used in this study was gathered from the original novel pride and prejudice written by Jane Austen.
This novel has got sixty one chapters and the text belongs to two hundred years ago. The first translation has
been done by Pooranfar and the second translation by Ardakani. Pooranfar has not rendered three of the
original novel chapters in her translation, while Ardakani has translated all of the original novel chapters into
Persian. Then the counterpart and equivalent data in two translations done by Pooranfar and Ardakani were
analyzed in order to have a comparison and contrast between the MDSs presented in the original novel and
their equivalents. Clearly, all of the data gathered based on the model from the original and translated novels
will be usefull in MDSs analysis.
361
4. Findings and Discussion
As the figure4.3 shows, the highest and fewest number of metadiscourse signals belonged to the validity
markers and illocution markers respectively, where blue stands for the original novel, red stands for the first
translation, and green stands for the second translation. Moreover, as depicted clearly, the second translation
appeared to be more similar to the original text in the use of certain MDSs than the first translation. Both
translators have rendered less number of MDSs in their translations comparing to that of the original novel.
4.1. Data Analysis
Concerning the investigated novel of Pride and prejudice the first translation by Pooranfar transferred 347
MDSs to the target language out of 452 original MDSs, while the second translation by Ardakani rendered
411. The lower the amount of MDSs in any text especially the translated texts, comparing to the original one
shows the less capability of that text to state clearly the original meaning. There were many differences
between the two translations concerning the amount of MDSs use.
Although all of the Chapters in the original novel have been analyzed, in this paper the researcher has just
brought three sample chapters of the original novel in a comparison with its two Persian renderings. Here are
the tables of detailed information of those three chapters of the novel:
Table 1: Metadiscourse elements in chapter 1 of the novel
MD Signal Original Translation 1 Translation 2
_ However little ‫_ ﺑﻬﺮﺻﻮرت ﮐﻤﺘﺮ در‬ ‫_ درهﺮﺣﺎل ﮐﻤﺘﺮ در ﻣﻮرد‬

Text known the feeling… ... ‫ﻣﻮرد اﺣﺴﺎﺳﺎت‬ ... ‫اﺣﺴﺎﺳﺎت‬
Connectiv _ But it is, returned ..... ‫_ اﻣﺎ اﻳﻦ واﻗﻌﻴﺖ‬
es she;… ..... ‫_ اﻣﺎ اﻳﻦ واﻗﻌﻴﺖ‬
_ …,that Netherfield ...‫ درﺁﺧﺮ ﭘﺎرﮎ ﻧﺪرﻓﻴﻠﺪ‬-
park is let at last… ...‫ ﺑﺎﻻﺧﺮﻩ ﭘﺎرﮎ ﻧﺪرﻓﻴﻠﺪ‬-
Code _ He agreed… that he ‫_ او ﻣﻮاﻓﻘﺖ ﮐﺮد ﮐﻪ‬ ‫_ وﯼ ﺑﺎ اﻳﻦ ﻧﻈﺮ ﻣﻮاﻓﻘﺖ ﮐﺮد‬
Glosses is to take possession ...‫ﻣﻴﺘﻮاﻧﺪ ﻣﺎﻟﮑﻴﺖ‬ ...‫ﮐﻪ‬
of…
Narrators _ …, returned she. ...:‫_ در ﺟﻮاب ﮔﻔﺖ‬ ...:‫_ در ﺟﻮاب ﮔﻔﺖ‬

_ …, said his lady ‫_ ﺧﺎﻧﻤﺶ روزﯼ ﺑﻪ او‬ .:‫_ ﺧﺎﻧﻤﺶ روزﯼ ﺑﻪ او ﮔﻔﺖ‬
to… .:‫ﮔﻔﺖ‬
Validity _ …, you must ...‫_ ﻗﺎﻋﺪﺗﺎ ﺑﺎﻳﺪ ﺑﺪاﻧﯽ‬ ...‫ ﺑﺎﻳﺪ اﻳﻨﺮا ﺑﺪاﻧﯽ ﮐﻪ‬-
maker know…
_ It is very likely ...‫_ ﺧﻴﻠﯽ اﺣﺘﻤﺎل دارد ﮐﻪ‬ ...‫ ﺁﻧﭽﻪ ﺧﻴﻠﯽ اﺣﺘﻤﺎل دارد‬-
that…
Attitude _ He has good fortune ‫_ وﺿﻌﻴﺖ و ﻣﻮﻗﻌﻴﺖ‬ ...‫_ وﺿﻊ ﻣﺎﻟﯽ ﺧﻮﺑﯽ ﮐﻪ‬
markers to… ..‫ﺧﻮب‬ ...‫_ ﺷﺎدﻣﺎﻧﯽ زﻳﺎد او‬
_ …and was so much ...‫_ او ﺧﻴﻠﯽ ﺷﺎد ﺑﻮد ﮐﻪ‬
delighted
362
According to the data presented in the table, there are generally 10 MDSs in this Chapter of the original novel.
Both translations have done a good job and they have transferred all of the original MDSs into the Persian
language.
MD Marker Original Translation 1 Translation 2

Text connectives _ He could do it but… ... ‫_ وﻟﯽ از ﻃﺮﻓﯽ او‬ ... ‫_ اﻣﺎ او ﺑﺎﻳﺪ‬
_ Impossible is that… ..‫_ اﻳﻦ ﻏﻴﺮ ﻣﻤﮑﻦ اﺳﺖ ﮐﻪ‬ ...‫_ ﻏﻴﺮ ﻣﻤﮑﻦ اﺳﺖ‬
Validity markers _ Impossible, …, .. .‫_ اﻳﻦ ﻏﻴﺮ ﻣﻤﮑﻦ اﺳﺖ‬ ‫_ ﻏﻴﺮ ﻣﻤﮑﻦ اﺳﺖ ﺁﻗﺎﯼ ﺑﻨﺖ‬
impossible… .‫ﻣﺤﺎل اﺳﺖ‬
_ replied Elizabeth, …
Narrators _ cried her mother ...‫_ اﻟﻴﺰاﺑﺖ ﭘﺎﺳﺦ داد‬ ‫_ او ﭘﺎﺳﺦ داد‬
‫_ ﻣﺎدرش در ﺟﻮاب ﻣﻴﮕﻮﻳﺪ‬ ...‫_ ﺻﺪاﯼ ﻣﺎدرش درﺁﻣﺪ‬
Attitude markers _ She said resentfully ‫_ ﺑﺎ ﺧﺸﻮﻧﺖ ﮔﻔﺖ‬ ...‫_ ﺑﺎ ﻏﻴﻆ ﮔﻔﺖ‬
_ I am glad to find out… ‫_ ﺧﻴﻠﯽ ﺧﻮﺷﺤﺎﻟﻢ‬ ...‫_ ﺧﻮﺷﺤﺎﻟﻢ ﮐﻪ‬
_ He replied fretfully .‫_ ﺑﺎ ﺑﺪ اﺧﻼﻗﯽ اداﻣﻪ داد‬ .‫_ ﺑﺎ ﺑﺪاﺧﻼﻗﯽ ﺟﻮاب داد‬
Illocution markers _ Aye, so it is… .......... _ .‫_ ﺑﻠﻪ اﻳﻨﻄﻮر اﺳﺖ‬
_ So, it will be important ...‫_ ﭘﺲ اﻳﻦ ﻣﺴﺌﻠﻪ‬ ....‫_ ﺑﻨﺎﺑﺮاﻳﻦ‬
Commentaries _ She has no discretion .‫_ او ﮐﻪ ﮔﻨﺎهﯽ ﻧﺪارد‬ ‫_ او ﺑﺮاﯼ ﺳﺮﻓﻪ ﮐﺮدن‬
this matter. ‫ﻣﻼﺣﻈﻪ ﯼ هﻴﭽﯽ را ﻧﻤﻴﮑﻨﺪ‬
According to the table, there were eleven MDSs in this chapter of the original novel. Both translations have
rendered all of the original MDSs except one of the text connectives. As a result, both translations have done
a good job in this respect.
MD Original Translation 1 Translation 2

Marker
Text _ Not all that Mrs. Benet, … ...‫_ ﺧﺎﻧﻢ ﺑﻨﺖ ﺑﺮاﯼ‬ ...‫_ ﺧﺎﻧﻢ ﺑﻨﺖ ﺑﺮاﯼ‬
connectiv _ consequently she was… ...‫_ او و اﻟﻴﺰاﺑﺖ ﻣﺮﺗﺒﺎ‬ .... ‫_ و در ﻧﺘﻴﺠﻪ‬
es _ …, in town so soon after… ......‫_ ﺑﻌﺪ از ﭼﻨﺪ روز ﺁﻣﺪن ﺑﻪ‬ ...‫_ ﭘﺲ از ﺁﻣﺪن ﺑﻪ ﺷﻬﺮ‬
Code _ Only five all together: she ‫ ﺧﻮدش‬.‫_ ﺑﻴﺶ از ﭘﻨﺞ ﻧﻔﺮ ﻧﻴﺴﺘﻨﺪ‬ :‫_ ﺷﺶ ﺧﺎﻧﻢ را ﺑﺎ ﺧﻮدش ﺁوردﻩ‬
glosses and her daughters,… ...‫و دﺧﺘﺮاﻧﺶ و‬ ...‫ﺧﻮدش و دﺧﺘﺮاﻧﺶ و‬
Validity _ They were wonderfully ...‫_ ﺑﺴﻴﺎر ﺧﻮش ﻗﻴﺎﻓﻪ ﺑﻮدﻧﺪو‬
markers handsome, … ...‫_ زﻳﺒﺎﯼ ﺷﮕﻔﺖ اﻧﮕﻴﺰ‬
_ …extremely agreeable and.. ..‫_ ﺑﺴﻴﺎر دوﺳﺖ داﺷﺘﻨﯽ‬ ...‫_ ﻓﻮق اﻟﻌﺎدﻩ ﺧﻮش رو‬
Narrators _ …, said Mrs. Benet… ...‫_ ﺧﺎﻧﻢ ﺑﻨﺖ ﮔﻔﺖ‬ ...‫_ ﺧﺎﻧﻢ ﺑﻨﺖ ﮔﻔﺖ‬
_ …, said he. ...‫_ او در ﭘﺎﺳﺦ ﮔﻔﺖ‬ ...‫_ او در ﭘﺎﺳﺦ ﮔﻔﺖ‬
Attitude _ Wonderfully handsome… ....‫_ زﻳﺒﺎﯼ ﺷﮕﻔﺖ اﻧﮕﻴﺰ‬ .‫_ ﺑﺴﻴﺎر ﺧﻮش ﻗﻴﺎﻓﻪ ﺑﻮدﻧﺪ‬
markers _ Extremely agreeable… ...‫_ ﺑﺴﻴﺎر دوﺳﺖ داﺷﺘﻨﯽ‬ ...‫_ ﻓﻮق اﻟﻌﺎدﻩ ﺧﻮش رو‬
_ They had the advantage of.. ...‫_ دﺧﺘﺮان ﻣﻮﻓﻖ ﺑﺮاﯼ‬ .‫_ ﺑﺮاواﻣﺘﻴﺎزﯼ داﺷﺘﻨﺪ‬
363
According to the table, there were eleven MDSs in this chapter of the original novel. Both translations have
rendered all of the original MDSs except one of the text connectives. As a result, both translations have done
a good job in this respect.
Figure3. Frequency of metadiscourse signals in the novel
120
100
80
60
Original
40 Translation 1
Translation 2
20
4.2. Discussion
In the current research the focus was on the presence of seven metadiscourse signals in the novel pride and
Prejudice and its two Persian renderings by Pooranfar and Ardakani through the model presented by Vande
Copple (1985). The results derived from the analysis of sixty one chapters of the novel helped the researcher
to answer the question concerning the amount of metadiscourse presence in the original novel and its
Persian translations. The analysis has shown that the metadiscourse signals of the original novel have been
less transferred to the Persian translations. The discussion of results will be presented in seven separate
paragraphs for each metadiscourse type.
Concerning Text connectives, all the Sixty One tables related to the Chapters of the novel showed that 75
instances were found in the original novel. Considering the first translation, fifty five of them have been
transferred to the Persian language while a great number of the metadiscourse signals have remained
untranslated. Yet, the second translation did a better job and transferred sixty six of them to the Persian
language. As text connectives are very crucial in text consistency and help a lot in building the meaning, the
second translation should be considered as a more valuable and meaningful translation than the first one.
In terms of Code glosses, according to the data collected in Chapter Four their total number in the original
novel was fifty nine of which the first translation has transferred forty and the second translation fifty. Code
glosses are definitely necessary to make the meaning more explicit and exemplify some information in a text,
hence the code glosses’ role is crucial (Hyland, 2005). Therefore, the meaningfulness and transparency of
the second translation has been considered and done well. Meanwhile, the first translation did not render
about one third of the original code glosses showing less effort to transfer the meaning correctly.
Considering the data available in Chapter Four, there were one hundred seven Validity markers in the
original novel of which the first translation had just rendered 67 and the second translation ninety four items
to the Persian language. The role of validity markers in identifying the amount of validity and correctness of
364
any information in a text is absolutely fantastic (Halliday, 2002). Without them, it is not clear how much the
reader can trust any specific part of the text and the extent of the writer’s belief in what is said remains
ambiguous. Therefore, the amount of trust upon the validity and trueness of the information in the novel
seemed greater in the second translation. But, considering the first translation, forty items of validity markers
have not been transferred to the Persian language, showing weakness of translation in this respect.
Regarding the narrators, there have been sixty three narrators detected in the original novel. From this
range of MDSs the first translation has transferred 56 and the second translation has rendered sixty one into
the Persian language. Narrators metadiscourse signals identify the source of any information within the text
and without this nothing can be regarded authoritative and reliable (Gee, 1999). Considering this fact, we can
conclude that the second translation is more authenticated due to the higher application of narrators; on the
other side, the first translation has not transferred seven original narrators’ MDSs to the Persian language
and should be considered as a less reliable text.
The number of metadiscourse signals in attitude type was One Hundred and Three on the whole. While
the first translation rendered ninety three to the Persian language, the second translation transferred one
hundred MDSs to the target language. Among the metadiscourse signals, attitude markers are used in order
to show the writer’s attitude toward the propositional content (William, 1983). Considering the amount of
transferred attitude MDSs to the Persian language, the second translation again has done a better job and
just three original attitude markers have remained untranslated. As a result, the second translation can better
show the writer’s attitude toward everything in the text and it will be more explicit and meaningful.
In this study the least amount of metadiscourse signals belonged to illocution markers. Nineteen illocution
markers were discovered in the original novel out of which the first translation has rendered fourteen and the
second translation has transferred sixteen. This kind of metadiscourse signal can show where and how the
speech and discourse is going to have a conclusion (Johnston, 2008). Because of the higher amount of
illocution markers transferred to the target language, the second translation is more valuable in making
conclusions through the text. But, again the first translation has done poorer job in this respect and it has a
less sense of closure in any part.
Finally, in relation to the commentaries the total number of occurrence in the original novel was twenty six
in all. While the first translation has transferred twenty two to Persian language, the second translation has
rendered twenty four. The commentaries’ usage in a text is to declare the writer’s opinion about the reader or
the audience (William, 1983). It can be concluded that the first translation has not been so successful in
transferring the original commentaries, while the second translation has done a better job in this respect. As a
result, the second translation is more powerful in showing the writer’s comments about the reader.
5. Concluding Remarks
The presence of metadiscoursal signals is crucial and necessary in identifying the exact and deep meaning,
either in formation or understanding (Cook, 1994). The use of metadiscourse signals can help the writer to
meaningfully build his/her text as well as the readers or audience to better understand the writer’s or
speaker’s intended meanings (Gee, 1999). In other words, without discourse and in a deeper scale
metadiscourse signals nothing is meaningful and the use of language would be just a hodge-podge of
different linguistic items. The analysis of data presented in this study led to the following conclusions:
Concerning the text connectives, there were twenty MDSs less than the original in the first translation and
just ten MDSs less than the original. It can show why the first translation failed to render different textual
connections. So, the meaningfulness of the first translation is weaker than the second translation. The
second translation rendered the code glosses better than the first translation and this was helpful in
explaining more the intended meanings. There is the same story for the validity markers and narrators. This
matter makes the translation more authentic and meaningful.
365
As far as the interpersonal MDSs are concerned, the first translation again did a worse translation
comparing to the second translation and considering all attitude markers, illocution markers and
commentaries the second translation was more authentic, meaningful and understandable. In fact, the first
translation rendered lower amount of interpersonal MDSs and it was less comprehensible and it was not well
connected.
As a result, according to the data given about the number of MDSs in both translations and the original
novel, from the discourse and metadiscourse point of view, the second translator has a more acceptable and
meaningful translation comparing to that of the first translator.
References
Abrams, M. (1953). The discourse of literary criticism and theory. London: Routledge.
Armbruster, B. (1981). Schema theory and the design of content area textbooks. New York: Palgrave Macmillan
Cook, G. (1994). Discourse and literature: the interplay of form and mind. London: Oxford University Press.
Crismore, A & Vande Kopple, W. (1998). Metadiscourse in persuasive writing: a study of texts written by American and finnish university
students. Newbury Park: Sage.
Cutting, J. (2008). Pragmatics and discourse: A resource book for students. New York: Routledge.
Gee, J. P. (2005). An introduction to discourse analysis. London: Routledge.
Halliday, E. (1978). Language as social semiotic: The social interpretation of language and meaning. EUA: University Park.
Hyland, K. (2005). Metadiscourse,exploring interaction in writing. London: Routledge.
Johnston, B. (2008). Discourse analysis. New York: Routledge.
Marandi, S. (2002). Contrastive EAP rhetoric: metadiscourse in Persian versus English. Tehran: university of Tehran.
McCarthy, M. (1991). Discourse analysis for language teachers. New York: Cambridge university press.
Widdoson, H. G. (2004). Text, context, pretext: critical issues in discourse analysis. New York: Blackwell pub.
Woods, N. (2006). Describing discourse: a practical guide to discourse analysis/ Nicola Woods. London: Hodder Arnold.
366
An Assessment of Flood Hazard in Nigeria: The Case of Mile 12, Lagos
A. E Olajuyigbe
O.O Rotowa
E. Durojaye
Department of Urban and Regional Planning,

Federal University of Technology,
P.M.B 704, Akure, Nigeria
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.367
Abstract: Apart from traffic congestion, flood is the most common serious physical urban problem in most Nigerian cities. This
usually results from high river levels, concentration of overland flow following heavy rainfall, limited capacity of drainage systems
and blockage of waterways and drainage channels. This study identified the factors responsible for perennial flooding in Mile 12
area of Lagos, Nigeria which has constituted serious menace in terms of socio-economic and environmental consequences. The
research methodology involved questionnaire administration on households, key informant interview especially on Lagos State
Physical Development Authority (LASPPDA) officials and participant-observation, while other data were collected from
secondary sources including various relevant publications and text books. The result shows that the perennial flooding problem
in Mile 12 is as a result of consistent high rainfall and water releases from Oyan dam in the neighbouring state of Ogun, Nigeria.
Other causes of flood in the study area include blockage of drainage channels by refuse and other wastes, narrow river channels
and construction along floodplain. In a bid to ameliorate the seemingly intractable problem of flooding in the study area, the
recommendations made include: provision of sufficient setback to streams and rivers, construction of roads with good drainage
system, channelization and building of more dams to avoid excess loading of the existing dam.
Key Words: Flood, Lagos, Mile 12, Hazard and Oyan Dam
1. Introduction
Flood is a large amount of water covering an area that is usually dry. It is an overflowing of a great body of
water over land not usually submerged. Nwafor (2006) defined flood as a natural hazard like drought and
desertification which occurs as an extreme hydrological (run off) event. On the hand, Abam (2006), defined
flood as large volume of water which arrives at and occupy the stream channel and its flood plain in a time
too short to prevent damage to economic activities including homes.
Flooding is the most common environmental hazard in Nigeria (Etuonovbe, 2011). Flood disaster is not a
recent phenomenon in the country, and its destructive tendencies are sometimes enormous. Reports have it
that serious flood disasters have occurred in Ibadan (1985, 1987 and 1990), Osogbo (1992, 1996, 2002),
Yobe (2000) and Akure (1996, 2000, 2002, 2004 and 2006). The coastal cities of Lagos, Port Harcourt,
Calabar, Uyo, Warri among others have severally experienced incidences that have claimed many lives and
properties worth millions of dollar. Floods occur in Nigeria in three main forms: coastal flooding, river flooding
and urban flooding (Folorunsho and Awosika 2001; Ologunorisa, 2004). Coastal flooding occurs in the low-
lying belt of mangrove and fresh water swamps along the coast (Folorunsho and Awosika 2001; Ologunorisa,
2004). River flooding occurs in the flood plains of the larger rivers, while sudden, short-lived flash floods are
associated with rivers in the inland areas where sudden heavy rains can change them into destructive
torrents within a short period (Folorunsho and Awosika 2001; Ologunorisa, 2004). Urban flooding on the
other hand occurs in towns, on flat or low-lying terrain especially where little or no provision has been made
for surface drainage, or where existing drainage has been blocked with municipal waste, refuses and eroded
soil sediments (Folorunsho and Awosika 2001; Ologunorisa, 2004). In spite of series of recommendations
367
from research and government efforts at mitigating the menace, urban flooding has become a perennial
event in most Nigerian cities.
Urban flood problem is a global experience but the management practices differ according to prevailing
technologies and aptness in planning concerns. The experience is however worse in Third World cities where
unplanned and uncoordinated development is prevalent. Odemerho (2004) and Nwafor (2006) identified 12
causes of urban flooding. These include: surcharges in water level due to natural or man – made construction
on flood path, sudden dam failure, inappropriate land use, mudflow, inadequate drainage capacity to cope
with urbanization, excess encroachment in flood ways, ice jam, rapid snow fall, deforestation of catchment
basins, reclamation, construction sites and solid waste. Odemerho (2004) also identified three factors
accentuating flood problems in Benin City, Nigeria namely: land and physical development problems, gaps in
basic hydrological data, design and implementation problems and cultural factors. Okereke (2007) listed the
consequences of urban flooding in his studies in Dhaka, Bangladesh to include: loss of human lives, flooding
of houses, streets, inflow to soak away, municipal pollution, damage to properties, health hazards, cleanup
costs, disruption of services, traffic problems, adverse effects on aesthetics, disturbances on wildlife habitats,
economic loses and infrastructural damage.
The Nigerian Punch (2010) reporting on flooding in Lagos, Nigeria made detailed report of frequent flood
occurrences in Ikoyi, Victoria Island, Ipaja-Ayobo, Ajegunle, Ikorodu, Agiliti and Mile 12 (the study area). The
report concluded that there is a need for flood control coordination between relevant departments. It also
clamored for a well articulated flood control policy and societal re-orientation on this critical issue.
This study is therefore a further attempt to identify the factors responsible for perennial flooding in Mile 12
area of Lagos, Nigeria with a desire to suggest plausible solutions to this seemingly intractable problem
which has constituted serious menace to livelihoods and environmental quality.
2.Materials and Methods
The study area is Mile 12, Lagos State, Nigeria. It is one of the 35 settlements in Kosofe Local Government
Area of Lagos State (Figs 1 and 2). Due to its location as the gateway to Lagos state, Mile 12 houses people
from the Northern and the Eastern parts of the country who engages in commercial activities. The population
of the settlement according to the 2006 national population census is 682,772 (National Population
Commission, 2006). The vegetation is the swamp forest which had made way for the construction of houses,
markets and other infrastructure. The area is influenced by two climatic seasons namely: dry and wet
seasons. Dry season occurs between November to March, and wet season, between April to October. Ogun
River and its tributaries drain the Northern part of the town, which is densely settled. Some of the residential
neighbourhoods are traversed by Ogun River.
368
Fig.1: Lagos State in Nigeria
Five neighbourhoods in this settlement that annually experience critical flooding were used for analysis in this
study. These are: Ajelogo, Agiliti, Agboyi, Maidan and Owode-Elede. The research populations for this study
are households and buildings in the flood prone areas of the settlement. The total numbers of buildings
identified to be flood-prone in the areas are 830. These structures were identified using SPOT imagery of
Lagos coupled with ground-truthing as recorded by Lagos State Physical Development Authority (LASPPDA,
2010). Out of the total population of 830 structures affected, a 20% sample was taken using random
sampling technique. As a result of this 166 household questionnaires were administered. It is imperative to
emphasize that the population figure of this settlement was not disaggregated by the National Population
Commission. Thus, this study assumed equal population for each neighbourhood.
369
Fig.2: Mile 12 in Lagos State, Nigeria.
3.Results and Discussion
The study shows that the release of water from Oyan Dam built across Oyan River, a tributary of Ogun River
in Ogun State arising from heavy rainfall is the main cause of flood in this settlement. Specifically, 75.9% of
the households attributed the reason for this menace to this factor (Table 1). Following such heavy falls in the
recent years, the reservoir level of Oyan Dam had been consistently high. Consequent upon this
development and in conformity with the operational rule of dams, it has become imperative to release water
gradually in order to maintain a tolerable capacity level for the dam safety and by extension, safety of life and
properties downstream. This scenario is further aggravated by increased water from Atlantic Ocean arising
from wave action and the global rise in ocean water which often find its way to Mile 12 especially during high
tides.
In this community, waste management is rather too poor. Refuse and other wastes are usually dumped
into available open spaces, including drainage channels and river plains and valleys. This practice has led to
the blockage of the drainage channels at various points. 7.2% of the households agreed that flooding is
usually a product of such blockages. In general, during heavy rainfall which usually leads to partial opening of
Oyan dam, the waste dumped along the river plain obstruct the free flow of the river. The drainage channels
cannot therefore accommodate the flow of the fast running storm water from the dam making it to spill into
streets and houses.
370
Table 1: Major causes of flooding
Causes of flooding Frequency Percent

Heavy rainfall 10 6.0
Poor drainage 4 2.4
Opening of Oyan Dam in Ogun State 126 75.9
Waste disposal 12 7.2
Narrow stream/river channels 14 8.4
Total 166 100.0
Source: Field work (2011)
Flood incidence is further compounded by the fact that most buildings were built right within the immediate
floodplain of the river. In general, a greater proportion (63.8%) of these buildings observed less than 30
meters setback to the river. Specifically, 37.3% of the buildings have a setback of less than 10 meters (Table
2). These data indicate the weakness of development control mechanism in this community. The field survey
further shows that 79.1% of the inhabitants did not have approval for their buildings from the Planning
Authority. Only 13.3% of the buildings were formally approved by the Planning Authority (Table 3). This
explains the reason why some of these buildings did not have adequate setback.
Table 2: Building Setback from the river plain
Setback Frequency Percent

1m – 10m 62 37.3
11m – 20m 14 8.4
21m – 30m 30 18.1
31m – 40m 26 15.7
41m and above 34 20.5
Total 166 100.0
Source: field survey (2011)
Table 3: Building Plan Approval
Approval Status Frequency Percent

Formal Approval 22 13.3
No Approval 131 79.1
Not too sure 4 2.4
No response 9 5.2
Total 166 100.0
371
Plate 1: In this settlement, buildings are constructed along floodplains thereby aggravating the devastating
effects of flood events
Assessment of the buildings located on the floodplain showed that they are in poor and squalid conditions.
Building and foundation materials for most of these buildings have low water resistance and low water
retaining capacity. Table 4 shows that 80.7% of the respondents used cement concrete for their foundation
material. The inappropriateness of such material is reflected in the continuous retention of water on building
walls which usually leads to building collapse. Only 2.4% used stone materials which could be considered as
adequate in this terrain. Again, 2.4% uses mud materials which are rather unsafe. A significant proportion
(14.5%) of the respondents used others materials such as wood that are largely temporary in nature. The
adoption of such temporary materials is a reflection of non-security of tenure as owners could be displaced at
any time by flood.
Table 4: Foundation materials used in the building
Material Frequency Percent

Marble concrete 4 2.4
Mud 4 2.4
Cement concrete 134 80.7
Others 24 14.5
Total 166 100.0
The overwhelming effect of flooding in this settlement is reflected in the complete submergence of entire
streets (Agiliti and Iyase Streets) by water. In addition, more often than not, the flood usually results into
traffic snarls along the ever busy Mile 12 - Ikorodu road. In table 5, almost all the inhabitants attested to the
fact that the effects of flooding on lives and properties in their community are highly devastating. It was
reported that a 12-year old girl was drowned by the flood in October 2010. In addition, animals were lost to
flooding while many bridges collapsed and electric poles destroyed. The study also revealed that most
people in this area could not go to their places of work for some days since access roads were blocked and
submerged for days. Many farmlands were swept away while schools and markets were submerged for
weeks. In many other places, residents resorted to boarding canoes to get to their houses. Due to incessant
372
flooding events, many emergency boat termini had been constructed by people wishing to cash in on this
situation to make money.
Table 5: Estimation of the effects of flood on lives and properties
Intensity Frequency Percent

Very high 92 55.4
Fairly high 74 44.6
Low 0 0
Total 166 100.0
Source: Field work (2011)
Over the years, 830 structures have been affected by flood while 5,030 inhabitants were displaced (Table 6).
The total number of the inhabitants that were displaced is quite significant as this represents 0.73% of the
total population of Mile 12. The most affected neighbourhoods are Agiliti and Agboyin. According to
LASPPDA (2010), aggravated flooding events in these neighbourhoods could largely be attributed to either
blocked drainage channels or lack of drainage channels.
Table 6: Devastating effect of Flooding on Population and Properties
S/N Location No. of Affected No. of Displaced Observations (Possible Causes)

Structures People
1 Ajelogo 80 480 The connecting bridge was flooded due
to blockage of drainage channels
2 Agiliti 1 & 2 200 1,200 Lack of drainage channels
3 Agboyi 1, 2 & 3 200 1,600 Lack of drainage channels
4 Maidan 150 900 Blocked drainage channels
5 Owode Elede 200 850 Blocked culverts resulting into lack of
connectivity for storm water
Total 830 5030
Source: Lagos State Physical Planning Authority (LASPPDA) 2010.
Plate 2: Above is a typical submerged access road and properties following

a flood event in the settlement
373
The devastating effect of floods was not limited to physical structures. Our interaction with the inhabitants
also indicates that flooding events are usually accompanied with prevalence of diarrhea and other water-
borne diseases as most sources of water are polluted. Other effects include increased poverty arising from
destruction of farmlands and disruption of essential services.
Based on the information received from the LASPPDA and from the study it is evident that the level of
development control in this area is very low while its physical development is on the increase. In addition, the
study area does not have a Master plan guiding its physical development. It is clear that the State
government has not found permanent solution to the problem of flooding in the area but always shows
concern any time there is flood in the area. Some of the inhabitants affected are relocated to other
communities within the state even though such areas are far from the main city. Invariably most people that
are rehabilitated after the flood events moved back to their previous places of abode irrespective of their
precariousness thereby recycling this teething problem.
At the moment government has resumed frantic effort at rehabilitating and re-construction of township
roads and other inter-community roads within the local government. This is part of the efforts of the
government at eradicating the menace and devastating effect of flood in the area.
4. Conclusion
This research has identified the various causes of flooding and its devastating effects on lives and properties
in Mile 12, Kosofe Local Government, Lagos State, Nigeria. Investigation revealed that flooding in the area is
largely due to the frequent release of water from Oyan dam in Ogun State during the wet seasons. Secondly,
most of the buildings in the study area do not have enough set back to river channels, a situation arising
largely from failure to obtain building plan approval from the appropriate regulation agency. Thirdly, blockage
of drainage channels by refuse and other wastes as a result of poor waste management.
In order to minimize flood hazard stringent flood control measures are necessary in this area since it is
becoming a densely urbanized area. Building without plan approval in this settlement should be
unacceptable. Roads that are well furnished with adequate drainage and bridges should be constructed.
Channelization of existing streams and rivers in this settlement would go a long way to increase their storm
water intake thereby reducing water overspill during heavy rainfall. Strict adherence to dam safety and
maintenance regulations should be observed by the management of Oyan dam. In addition, construction of
more dams along River Ogun could be a plausible strategy at reducing excess loading of the existing Oyan
dam.
Finally, there is the need to monitor the various urban expansion and flood incidences within Lagos Mega
city. A flood early warning signal system with the capability to deliver reliable timely and effective flood
information at an appropriate response time should be installed. It is suggested that the system option must
involve integration of Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) technology into Geographical Information
System (GIS) framework towards appropriate flood modeling, simulation and forecasting. This will ease
service information provision on real time flood risk analysis, flood extent, acceptable risk level modeling and
mapping and potential damages and alerts.
References
Abam, T.S.K., 2006. Development Policy Framework for Erosion and Flood Control in Nigeria. EARTHWATCH - Magazine for
Environment and Development Experts in Nigeria, 5(1), 25-32.
Etuonovbe, A.K., 2011. Devastating Effect of Flooding in Nigeria. FIG Working Week 2011
Folorunsho, R. and Awosika, L.F., 2001. Flood Mitigation in Lagos, Nigeria through Wise Management of Solid Waste: a case of Ikoyi
and Victoria Islands; Nigerian, Paper presented at the UNESCO-CSI workshop, Maputo 19-23 November 2001.
Nwafor, J.C., 2006. Environmental Impact Assessment for Sustainable Development: The
Nigerian perspective. Enugu: EL ‘DEMAK pubs, pp. 359-394.
Odemerho F.O., 2004. Benin City: A Case Study of Urban Flood Problems” In Sada P.O and
374
Odemerho F. O (eds) Environmental Issues and Management in Nigeria development. Evans Brothers Nig. Publishers Ltd.
Okereke R. A., 2007. Incidence of Flooding in Southern Nigeria, International Journal of Environmental Issues 5(1 & 2).
Ologunorisa, E.T., 2004. An Assessment of Flood Vulnerability Zones in the Niger Delta, Nigeria. International Journal of Environmental
Studies, U.K., 61(1).
The Nigerian Punch, 2010. Lagos Flood. The Punch Newspaper Tuesday 12, October 2010. Retrieved from
http://www.punchng.com/Articl.aspx?theartic on April 19, 2011.
375

Rural Development As Strategy for Food Security and Global Peace in The 21st Century
Nwagboso, I. Christopher
Assistant Lecturer
Department of Political Science
University of Calabar, Calabar
P.m.b 1115, Unical, Cross River State –Nigeria
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.377
Abstract: This paper discusses rural development as strategy for food security and global peace in the century. The paper
adopts descriptive methodological orientation to investigate how the abysmal failure of governments in the contemporary world
to develop their rural areas has adversely impacted on food security. However, the paper argues that why the quest for rural
development has remained elusive particularly in the developing countries is largely due to up-bottom approach currently
adopted by countries. It further argues that this strategy has not only resulted to abject poverty in most countries, but also failed
to achieve food security among individuals, families and communities around the globe. The implication of this sorry state of
affairs is that the attainment of global peace in the 21st century has remained an exercise in futility in spite of the over-
dramatized efforts of international organizations like the UN. The paper, therefore, recommends among others, the need to
establish a specialized agency to study the success of rural development policies and programmes in some countries like China
and replicate such strategies in other parts of the world for effective food security on global peace in the 21st century.
Key Words: Rural Development, Food Security, Global Peace
1. Introduction
Rural development as a concept has no generally acceptable definition. This is largely because scholars
within the purview of political science, sociology, geography, among others, view the concept from different
analytical tradition and disciplinary perspective. Also, scholars sometimes define the concept not only on
parochial basis but also on individual perception and experience. However, such definitions most times
reflect their cultural orientation, environmental milieu and ideological inclination.
Notwithstanding these unsettled controversies, rural development is conceived as strategy aimed at
finding ways to improve the rural lives with participation of the rural people themselves so as to meet the
required need of the rural area (Zhude, 2010). According to World Bank (2005), rural development is the
process of rural modernization and the monetization of the rural society leading to its transition from
traditional isolation to integration with the national economy.
Also, rural development is perceived as a process of not only increasing the level of per capital income in
the rural areas but also the standard of living of the rural population measured by food and nutrition level,
health education, housing, recreation and security (Diejomoah, 1973). To give more credence to the real
meaning of rural development, Ollawa (1971) asserts that:
…rural development aims at restructuring the economy in order to satisfy the material needs and aspirations
of the rural masses, and to promote individual and collective incentives to participate in the process of
development… this involves a host of multi-sectoral activities including the improvement of agriculture, the
promotion of rural industries, the creation of the requisite infrastructure… establishment of decentralized
structure in order to allow mass production…
A critical look at the above position by Ollawa reinforces the role of agriculture in the achievement of rural
development objectives. Thus, the improvement of agriculture in the rural areas all over the world requires
not only the collective efforts and participation of the rural people but also strong political will and commitment
377
by the government. Such commitment and political will are usually manifested through the formulation and
effective implementation of development policies and programs capable of boosting food production.
Ultimately, the adoption of the above critical step by nation-states through their domestic policy actions is
therefore expected to being about radical transformation of agricultural sector and production. Similarly, the
availability of sufficient quantity of food for consumption in a given country energizes states to adopt people-
oriented strategies to secure food products already produced. However, such strategy is therefore expected
to assist nation-states to be free from hunger, assist other countries in dire need of food for consumption,
have sufficient food to export for exchange earnings, address the increasing spate of violence occasioned by
hunger and famine, create employment for the large population of youth in their countries and foster cordial
relations among states in the contemporary globe
In consideration of the import of these strategies as well their benefits to states, this paper seeks to
examine the extent to which rural development (bottom-up approach) could be used as strategy to achieve
food security and global peace in the 21st century.
2. Theoretical Perspective
This study adopts Political Economy approach and Big Push theory in the analysis of rural development as
strategy for food security and global peace in the 21st century.
According to the proponents and adherents of political economy approach (Brewer, 1989; Callaghy, 1993;
Dolan, 1993; Ake, 2002), this theory establishes the close relationship between the super-structural and sub-
structural strata of society. They bluntly argued that rural development is the best option to stem down rural
poverty, reduce urbanization, balance the economy, radically bring down civil uprisings and reinvigorates the
collapsing states particularly those in the third world.
The basic methodological premise of the political economy approach is that the primary basis for
explaining social life should be the material conditions of the people. This is succinct because, the most
fundamental of all the needs of man are those of economic nature. Thus, without these needs, life itself
would be meaningless. Therefore, an understanding of the “economic assets” of society invariably leads to
the understanding of the laws, politics, culture, religion and modes of thought of that society.
By application of this theory to our study, we argue that the sorry state of most rural areas in some states
in the contemporary world is as a result of deliberate policies of governments to exploit rural areas in order to
develop the urban centres. Thus, the peripheral formations are underdeveloped to aid the ascendancy of
core formations.
Hence, the political economy approach assists us to trace the root causes of rural underdevelopment
which consequently affects food security and global peace. This is because, political economy of rural
development is replete with exploitation, urban bias and elitist class interest. Thus, a classic case of this
phenomenon is the geometric development of metropolitan cities in Africa, America, Asia, Europe and Latin
America, from the resources generated from the rural areas in these continents.
Thus, this approach has been criticized on several grounds. The critics argued that political economy
approach has failed to suggest implementable strategies to be adopted by states to address the imbalances
between the rich and poor and between the developed and underdeveloped economies in the world.
Consequently, lack of proper prognosis for the transformation of these countries and their rural areas other
than “delinking” from the world system coerced us to adopt the “Big Push Theory” as part of measures to find
lasting solutions to perennial challenges bedeviling rural development, food security and global peace, in the
21st century.
The theory of the “big push” is associated with Professor Paul N. Rosenstein-Rodan (Edame, 2006). The
thesis is that a “big push” is needed in the form of a high minimum amount of investment to overcome the
obstacles to development in an underdeveloped economy and to launch it on the path of progress.
378
Therefore, there is a minimum level of resources that must be devoted to a development programme
(rural development, food security and global peace), if it is to have any chance of success. Accordingly,
launching a country into self-sustaining growth is a little like an airplane off the ground. Hence, there is a
critical ground speed which must be passed before the craft can become airborne. Therefore, the big push
theory argues that proceeding “bit by bit” will not launch the economy successfully on the development part.
By application of this theory to our study we argue that why development has remained elusive in most
rural areas in many countries in the world is as a result of lack of commitment and poor investment by
governments on rural development policies and programmes.
Therefore, for rural development to serve as strategy for food security and mechanism to achieve global
peace in the 21st century, the “big push” theory posits that nation-states must be willing to devote substantial
investments to their rural areas, rather than concentrating on urban centres. Such political will must be
manifested in their national development policies and should be faithfully funded, implemented, monitored
and evaluated by appropriate governmental agencies in their respective states.
3. Rural Development on Global Perspective
…the differences between the village and the town or city are only too obvious to warrant any serious debate.
The city is simply where bright lights are found, where the tempo of life is fast and where all the good things
of life prevail in abundance while the village is the area with opposite attributes.… (Ekong, 2010: 2).
The above position by Ekong captured the sorry situation of most rural areas especially in countries located
in Africa, Asia, and Latin America. Thus, what this implies is that lack of basic amenities or infrastructures
characterized most rural areas particularly in the peripheral social formations. Therefore, an area is
conceived as rural when half or more than half the adult male working population is engaged in farming, then
a greater population of the country is included irrespective of settlement pattern (Bogle, 1977: 28).
To shade more light on the conceptualization of rural area with Nigeria as a point of departure, Ekong
(2010:3) argues that 45% of Nigeria’s population was engaged in agricultural activities. It was also estimated
that 36% of the population was urban dwelling while 64% was rural. Accordingly, 19% of the working
population engaged in non- farming occupations, work in cities but reside in rural areas. In view of this, the
quest for rural development especially in most developing world has been elusive. Thus, in spite of the fact
that the greater population of people in most countries resides in the rural areas, no appreciable efforts have
been made by some governments to improve the living conditions of the affected people. The need to
address this ugly situation partly explains why the 2010 UN’s Human Development Report asserts:
…people are the real wealth of a nation. It is now universally acceptable that a country’s success or an
individual’s well-being cannot be evaluated by money alone.… Income is of course crucial without resources,
any progress is difficult …we must gauge whether people can lead long and healthy lives, whether they have
the opportunity to be educated and whether they are free to use their knowledge and talent to shape their
own destinies.
The pathetic situation in most rural areas in the world has resulted in what is globally referred to as
“poverty”. Poverty as a phenomenon is conceived as misery linked to an insufficient resource base, lack of
income, narrow margins, high risk of failure, hunger and diseases (World Bank, 2010). Therefore, the
menace of poverty and its attendant consequences on the lives of the common man in the rural areas across
the contemporary globe captured the views and curiosity of Delang (2006: 231).
…eradicating hunger and poverty require an understanding of the ways in which these two injustices
interconnect. Hunger and malnourishment that accompanies it, prevent poor people from escaping poverty
because it diminishes their ability to learn, work, and care for themselves and their family members.
379
Hence, poverty affects virtually all aspects of social, economic and political lives of rural dwellers in the
contemporary world. This was also captured in the 2010 Human Development Index presented in the table
below:
Table 1: The 2010 HDI and its Components:
S/N THREE DIMENSIONS POOR INDICATORS
1. Health Life Expectancy at Birth
2. Education Mean years of Schooling

Expected years of Schooling
3. Living Standards Gross national income per Capital
Source: Human Development Index Report, 2010.
From the above table, it becomes pertinent to underscore the import of improving the living condition of the
rural dwellers. Thus, most rural people in view of the above presentation are believed to be living in abject
poverty when once they do not have access to basic health facilities, education, water, good road network,
recreational facilities, security, employment opportunities, among others.
Notwithstanding, it is therefore crucial to note that poverty is a global human problem. Hence, poor
people also exist even in the developed nations of the world. The rate of poverty is sometimes evaluated
through a country’s Human Development Index like the sample presented in the table below:
Table 2: Human Development Index Report, 2010 (Selected Countries).
HDI RANK HDI LIFE MEAN EXPECTE GROSS GNI PER NON
VALUE EXPECTA YEAR OF D NATIONAL CAPITA INCOME
NCY AT SCHOOLIN YEARS OF INCOME RANK HDI
BIRTH G SCHOOLIN (GNI)PER MINUS HDI VALUE
(YEARS) (YEARS) G CAPITAL RANK
(YEARS) (PPP2008,$)
1 0.938 81.0 12.6 17.3 58,810 2 0.954
Norway
4 0.902 79.6 12.4 15.7 47,094 5 0.917

United States
11 0.884 83.2 11.5 15.1 34,692 11 0.917
Japan
15 0.872 81.2 11.9 15.6 27,831 14 0.916
Israel
26 0.849 79.8 9.5 15.9 35,087 -6 0.860
United
Kingdom
55 0.752 73.3 7.8 13.5 24,726 -20 0.742
Saudi
Arabia
65 0.719 67.2 8.8 14.1 15258 -5 0.729
Russian
Federation
380
67 0.713 70.8 10.2 13.0 8,747 8 0.769

Azerbaijan
70 0.702 71.9 7.2 14.0 11,764 -3 0.725

Iran
73 0.699 72.9 7.2 13.8 10,607 -3 0.728
Brazil
83 0.679 72.2 6.5 11.8 13,359 -26 0.679
Turkey
89 0.663 73.5 11.4 7.5 7,258 -4 0.707
China
101 0.620 70.5 6.5 11.0 5889 -8 0.657
Egypt
119 0.519 64.4 4.4 10.3 3,337 -6 0.549
India
169 0.140 47.0 7.2 9.2 176 0 0.472
Zimbabwe
Source: Human Development Index Report, 2010.
The above table indicates that Norway, which is located in Europe is the most developed in view of the 2010
HDI report while Zimbabwe (located in Africa) is the least developed among the countries selected. The
implication is that the pace of rural development in both countries (Norway and Zimbabwe), cannot be the
same. It is even possible to regard rural areas in Norway as urban centres or cities in Zimbabwe as well as
most countries in Africa.
Therefore, it is urged that rural development policies and programmes receive significant boost from most
governments in developed countries like USA, Norway, Britain and France than the underdeveloped
countries like Nigeria, Mali, Uganda, Chad, Benin Republic, South Africa, Kenya, and Niger. Also, it is argued
from this premise that agriculture which plays dominant role in food production is better funded and prioritized
in developed economies than the third world social formations.
As a result of this, food security could best be understood within the trajectory of developed social
formations than in the developing states. It is also possible to think of peace even though not on a global
scale among developed economies than countries like Zimbabwe, Nigeria, Benin, Uganda, Niger, Liberia,
Chad, Morocco, Sudan, Mauritius and Somalia (located in African). These countries are ravaged by poverty,
illiteracy, health challenges violence, internal insurrection, militancy, leadership crisis, political instability,
among others.
4. The Nexus Between Rural Development and Food Security
In most developed world, rural development is often multi-dimensional. In Europe for instance, rural
development actions also integrate environmental management which is often neglected in Africa, as a core
component. Hence, rural development programmes in Europe particularly in Luxembourg, Lithuania, Ireland,
Italy, Hungary, Greece and Croatia, are usually top-down; from the local or regional authorities, regional
development agencies, NGOS, national government or international development organizations (Rosegrant
etal, 2005: 65).
Rural development policies in the above countries are designed to accommodate the participation and
initiatives of the rural people for development.
The import of integrating the rural dwellers in policies and programmes of rural development has been
well articulated by Swaminathan etal, (2004):
…rural development aims at finding the ways to improve the rural lives with participation of the rural people
themselves so as to meet the required need of the rural area. The outsider …may not understand the setting,
381
culture, language and other things prevalent in the local area. As such… people themselves have to
participate in their sustainable rural development.
However, what this suggests is that the term rural development is not limited to developing countries. In
fact, many of the developed countries have very active rural development programmes. This is succinct
because, the main aim of the rural government policy in most developed countries like Australia is to develop
the underdeveloped villages.
Thus, the most viable occupation of large number of people residing in the rural areas in most countries of
the world is agriculture. Also, about 97% of foods consumed by those residing in most cities in developed
countries (New York, Vilnius, Skopje, Paris, Tbilisi, Berlin, Helsinki, Prague, Ottawa, Sofia etc ) and those in
developing countries (Abuja, Algiers, Yaoundé, Cairo, Kinshasa, Beijing, New Delhi, Kuwait City etc), are
produced in the rural areas (FOA, 2010).
Therefore, there is a direct relationship between rural development and food security. Whereas rural
development is conceived as a strategy designed to improve the economic and social conditions of rural
people, food security connotes a situation when all people at all times, have physical, social and economic
access to sufficient, safe and nutritious food that meets their dietary needs and food preferences for an
active and healthy life (World Food Submit, 2010).
Contrarily, food insecurity exists when people are undernourished as a result of the physical unavailability
of food, their lack of social or economic access to adequate food, and /or inadequate food utilization (World
Food Submit, 2005). Therefore, food-secured people are those whose food in-take falls below their minimum
calories (energy) requirements, as well as those who exhibit physical symptoms caused by energy and
nutrient deficiencies resulting from inadequate or unbalanced diet.
Similarly, some observers (Uyanga,1980; Olarenwaju, 1984; Magbogunje, 1980; Vincent, 1981; Ekpo
2006, Ntukidem, 2006; and Kherallah et al, 2002), have incisively argued that there are strong direct
relationship between agricultural productivity, food security, hunger and poverty. This assertion is supported
by the 2010 HDI statistics which argues that:
…three–quarters of the world’s poor live in the rural areas and make their living from agriculture. Hunger and
child malnutrition are greater in these areas than in urban areas. (HDI, Report, 2010).
Therefore, it is bluntly argued from the above premise that effort towards curbing the increasing menace
of food security must first start from radical improvement of agricultural sector by nation-states across the
world. This is clearly because, increase in agricultural productivity will not only enable farmers grow more
food but also ensures food security. Also, it will obviously lead to high income generation to farmers as well
as enable them diversify production and grow higher-value crops. Hence, these outcomes are therefore
expected to impact positively not only on farmers and common man who consume the foods produced but
also on the economic development of states in the globe.
5. The Interface Between Food Security and Global Peace
…Food security is a complex sustainable development issue…linked to health through malnutrition, but also
to sustainable economic development, environment, and trade. There is a great deal of debate around food
security with some arguing that… there is enough food in the world to feed everyone adequately; the problem
is distribution… future food needs can or cannot be met by current levels of production…national food
security is paramount or no longer necessary because of global trade… globalization may or may not lead to
the persistence of food insecurity and poverty in rural communities (Rosegrant etal, 2005: 48).
The above observation by Rosegrant and others, reinforces the argument among scholars on
conceptualization of food security as a social phenomenon. Notwithstanding, food security is a complicated
issue that is susceptible to many forces. According to Latham (1997), food security is built on three pillars:
i. Food availability: This refers to sufficient quantities of food available on a consistent basis.
ii.Food access: This connotes having sufficient resources to obtain appropriate foods for a nutritious diet.
382
iii. Food use: This implies appropriate use based on knowledge of basic nutrition and care, as well as
adequate water and sanitation.
Generally, food security happens:

When all people at all times have access to enough food that is affordable, safe and healthy… when it is
culturally acceptable… meets specific dietary needs…is obtained in a dignified manner… is produced in
ways that are environmentally sound and socially just… (www.foodthoughtful.ca.).
Thus, the attainment of food security in the contemporary globe has been largely constrained by the following
factors:
A. An underdeveloped agricultural sector

The major challenge to food security in the world today is that agricultural sector in most countries especially
in Africa is underdeveloped. Indeed, this sector is characterized by over-reliance on primary and crude
method of farming, low fertility soils, minimal use of external farm inputs, environmental degradation,
significant food crop loss both pre and post harvest, minimal value addition and product differentiation, and
inadequate food storage and preservation. According to Nwaniki (2003), “about 95% of food production in
Sub-Saharan Africa, Latin America and some countries in Asia, is influenced by adverse whether conditions”.
Similarly, there is an overall decline in farm input investment including fertilizers, seeds, and technology
adoption. Thus, access to fertilizer use is constrained by market liberalization and trade policies that increase
fertilizer prices relative to commodity prices.
B. Poor governments’ policies:
The formulation of poor policies by many governments have greatly affected food security in the
contemporary world. Such handicapping policies are evident when the focus of governments’ policies,
structures and institutions are put above that of the rural people.
Thus, one such way this ugly trend has taken place in some countries is through uneven development
within countries where certain regions or state are preferentially developed for political reasons at the
expense of rural areas. Therefore, policies that promote monopolistic competition for the large scale
industries not only hurt cottage/small industries, but also the development of rural areas where food
production takes place.
C. Diseases and infection:
Available evidence shows that diseases and infection have continued to plague many countries particularly
those in Africa, Asia, and Oceania. Thus, diseases such as malaria, tuberculosis and HIV/AIDS, not only
reduce the manpower available to agriculture and household food acquisition, but also increase the burden of
household in acquiring food in most countries, particularly in the above continents (Zhang and Zhang, 2002).
For instance, in Sub-Saharan Africa, AIDS is the leading cause of adult mortality and mobility.
Consequently, the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) estimates that by 2020,
the epidemic will claim the lives of 20% or more of the population working in agriculture in many African
countries. Also, more than two third, ( 2 ) of the total population of the 25 most affected countries resides in
3
rural areas (FAO, 2010). It is, therefore, important to note that lack of resources also makes it difficult if not
impossible for HIV-affected households to supplement their diets through the purchase of more nutritious and
varied foods (Hilary, 2004).
D. Poverty:
As earlier noted, failure to develop rural areas anywhere in the contemporary globe ultimately results in
poverty among the people. However, poor people no doubt, lack access to sufficient resources to produce or
buy quality food. This is obviously the trend in some countries like Mali, Niger, Madagascar, Malawi, Kenya,
Jamaica, Haiti, Gabon, Costa Rica, Chile, among others. As a result of this pathetic scenario, food imports
have witnessed unprecedented increase in these countries since 2003 (World Bank, 2005).
383
This is largely because, poor farms in these countries have very small farm, use less effective farming
techniques and/or be able to afford fertilizers and labour saving equipment. Hence, all these factors limit
food production (Gordon, 1976).
The implication of the above sad situation on food security and global peace has been carefully put to
perspective by Wilkin (2009):
…. Without economic resources and a political voice, poor farmers may be forced on to less productive land
possibly causing further environmental deterioration… addressing poverty is critical to ensuring that all
people have sufficient food…
E. Health:
Available researches in the field of medicine have proved that without sufficient calories and nutrients, the
body slow down, making it difficult to undertake the work needed to produce food. Consequently, without
good health the body is also less able to make use of the food that is available. This scientific discovery
perhaps explains why Jorge (2010) asserts that:
….a hungry mother will give birth to an under-weight baby, who then faces a future of stunted growth,
frequent illness, learning disabilities and reduced resistance to diseases… contaminated food and water can
cause illness, nutrient loss and often death in children…
However, the HIV/AIDS pandemic has reduced food production in many affected countries, as productive
adults become ill or die. Thus, lacking the required labour, resources and technical know-how to grow staples
and commercial crops, many households particularly in US, Europe, Oceania and Asia, have shifted to
cultivating survival foods or leaving their fields or farm lands, thereby reducing food supply not only in their
countries, but also in the globe (World Bank Report, 1990). Hence, addressing health and health-related
issues will ultimately improve the production, utilization and availability of food.
F. Water and the Environment:
Food production requires massive amount of water…it takes one cubic metre (1000 litres) of water to
produce one kilogram of wheat and 3,000 litres of water to produce one kilogram of rice… producing
sufficient food is directly related to having sufficient water… (Stewart, 2003).
The above assertion underscores the import of water and environment to food security and its attendant
consequences on global peace. Hence, the import of irrigation in food security cannot be underestimated.
Consequently, irrigation ensures an adequate and reliable supply of water which increases yield of most
crops by 10% to 40%. Although it is estimated that about 40% of global crop land is irrigated, only 17%
produces world’s food (FAO, 2010).
G. Gender Equity:
It is globally acknowledged that women play crucial roles in providing food and nutrition for their families
through their indispensable roles as food producers, processors, traders and income earners. Yet, women’s
lower social and economic status occasioned by adverse cultural practices as well as harsh/biased policies of
government culminate to limit women access to education, training, land ownership, decision-making and
credit facilities for agricultural production. Consequently these social and cultural practices against women,
particularly in the developing world, lead to their inability to improve their access to and use of food.
Therefore, food utilization can be enhanced by improving women’s knowledge of nutrition, food safety
and the prevention of illness. Also, increasing women’s involvement in decision –making by countries all
over the world, and their access to land and credit, will in turn improve food security. This is succinct because
as Ukpong (2006) rightly observed “the involvement of women particularly in decision-making by
governments of nation-states will ultimately assist women invest in fertilizers and better seeds, labour- saving
tools, irrigation and land care”.
H. Disasters and Conflicts:
Experts have argued that droughts, floods, cyclones and pests can quickly wipe out large quantities of food
as it grows or when it is in storage for later use. Likewise, seeds can be destroyed by environmental dangers
such as earthquake and windstorm as the case in Haiti and Japan.
384
Similarly, conflicts such as the experiences in Libya, Sudan, Syria, Iran, Tunisia, among others, can also
destroy food production or storage, as farmers flee to safety or become involved in civil war. Thus, previously
productive land like the case of Iran, Bolivia, Afghanistan Cambodia, among others, can be contaminated
with explosive debris and need to be cleared before it can again be used for food production.
However, stored food, seeds and breeded livestocks may be eaten or destroyed by soldiers, leading to
long-term food shortages. Therefore, government’s spending in the affected states like Sudan, Southern
Sudan, Libya, Syria etc, need to prioritize food security in the after math of conflict.
I. Population and Urbanization:
It is generally accepted by experts that population growth increases the demand for food. Thus, with most
productive land already in use, there is pressure for land to become more productive. However, poor
harvests and higher costs lead many farmers to migrate to cities to look for work (Roundinell, 2008). Hence,
expanding cities spread out across productive land, pushing food production further and further away from
consumers (Hauang et al, 2002).
J. Trade:
Many poor countries (Gabon, Ethiopia, Rwanda, Zambia, Malawi, Chad, Niger, Benin Republic, Namibia,
Uganda, Sudan, Uruguay, Venezuela, Vietnam, Syria and Sri Lanka), can produce staples more cheaply
than rich nations (United Arab Emirates, Germany, Canada, France, Switzerland and Spain). Unfortunately,
barriers to trade such as distance from markets, quarantine regulations and tariffs sometimes make it difficult
for them to compete in export markets against highly subsidized farmers in these rich countries of the world.
6. Rural development: a bottom–up approach to food security and global peace in the 21st century
A cursory survey of policies and strategies to rural development by most nation-states indicates the
continuous adoption of up-bottom approach of decision-making in rural development efforts. In most
countries in Europe, America, Asia, and Africa, rural development policies and programmes are formulated at
the central, national or federal level, while implementation are designed to take place at the regional, local,
community and village levels. Consequently, majority of these policies and programmes have failed to
address the challenges of rural underdevelopment for which they were designed.
As a result, the desire for food security – all people at all times having access to sufficient, safe nutritious
food to maintain a healthy and active life by countries, international organizations (UN, FAO, EU, AU, USAID,
Etc), has been unrealistic.
Hence, achieving food security with the ultimate view to promote global peace in the 21st century in its
totality has continued to be a critical challenge and a “clog in the wheel of progress,” not only in the
developing countries, but also in the developed nations.
Although the difference lies in the magnitude of the problem in terms of its severity and proportion of the
population affected, the fact remains that the existing approach of decision-making in rural development (up-
bottom approach), by some countries in the developed and developing world has no capacity to impact
positively on food security and global peace in the 21st century.
In consideration of the above thesis, this study advocates the adoption of bottom-up approach in rural
development policies and programmes by all countries in the world. Thus, rather than formulating and
implementing rural development policies and programmes from the federal/national levels to regional/local
government levels, nation-states should now consider the socio-cultural, political and economic realities at
local, community and village levels in their countries. The following are justification of the
proposed/recommended paradigm shift in rural development:
1. Availability of land:
It is no longer doubtful that significant population of people in many countries lives in rural areas. In some
countries, agriculture accounts for over 60% of the GDP. Also, about 70% of the population of some
385
countries relies heavily on agriculture for their livelihood. Therefore, rural development policies and
programmes should reflect the realities in rural areas.
Thus, the implementation of rural development policies should be done by those who not only have
access to available productive lands for agricultural production in their localities but also by those for whom
the policies and programmes were designed to serve.
2. Decision-Making in rural development issues:
Decision making according to policy experts denotes choosing among completing alternatives (Dror, 1968),
Thus, rural development policies and their implementation must take cognizance of the role of the rural
dwellers and their communities, belief systems and cultural practices, for the success and efficacy of the
policies and programmes.
Hence, such policies and programmes should originate after due consultation of the opinions of the rural
people (the elders forum, the traditional rulers, women and the youths). Thus, rural development policies and
programmes designed to achieve food security must ultimately involve the rural communities in their
implementation, monitoring and evaluation. The chat below presents how such policies and programmes
should originate:
Fig. 1: A Sample Of Proto-Type Bottom-Up Approach Of Rural Development For Achievement Of Food
Security And Global Peace In The 21st Century
UP Global Level:
P  International Organizations and donor agencies (UN; UNDP,

World Bank, IMF, and their specialized agencies)
 International security formations
Regional Level:
 Regional Organizations (EU, AU, DFID, USAID, ECOWAS,

NEPAD, NATO etc.
 Regional NGOs with advocacy on poverty alleviation, food
security, peace and conflict resolution.
 Regional security apparatuses
National Level:
 Ministries and departments of Agric, Foreign Affairs, Interior,

Finance, Works, Health, Youth/Women Development,
Intervention agencies on poverty eradication, health, HIV/AIDS,
peace and conflict resolution.
 Security agencies and organizations operating at national levels
State Level:
 Ministries of Agric and Rural Development; Local Government

and Chieftaincy Affairs and Local Government Service
Commission.
 Special Intervention Agencies (Office of the Governor).
 NGOs Operating at State Level.
 All security formations at the State Level.
 NGOs involved in rural Local Government Level:  Inclusion of structures in

development rural areas: Traditional
programmes, food-  Consultation with Institutions, Women and
related matters, peace families, villagers and Youth Associations.
and conflict community members.  Vigilante groups and
resolutions.  Assessment of the history, Divisional Police Hqtr.
beliefs and value systems
of the community.
BOTTOM
Source: Nwagboso’s Field Work, 2011
386
3. Proper education on various international actions to achieve rural development and food
security:
The UN Millennium Development Goals are one of the initiatives aimed at achieving food security in the
world. However, in its list of goals, the first Millennium Development Goal states that the UN “is to eradicate
extreme hunger and poverty,” and that “agricultural productivity is likely to play a key role in this agenda
(Usman, 2010).
Therefore, of the eight Millennium Development Goals, eradicating extreme hunger and poverty that are
traceable to food insecurity depend largely on agriculture the most. In view of this, the rural dwellers and their
communities that are regarded as “centres of attraction as advocated by “bottom-up approach” must be
properly informed of the goals of MDGs as well as their efficacy to address critical problems not only in their
localities but also in the world.
4. Implementation of Policies to address the challenges of climate change in rural areas
Efforts to addressing the negative effects of climate change in rural areas require education and advocacy
among the rural populace.
Indeed, practices among the rural people, particularly in Africa, such as land clearing, over-exploitation of
species, bush–burning, over-grazing, deforestation, among others, require proper education by enlightened
group residing in urban centres (Awa, 1992). They must visit these villages and communities to influence
their behaviours on these practices that impact negatively on the environment and global climate.
Therefore, addressing climate change and its adverse effects on food security and global peace requires
bottom-up approach and not conventional up-bottom approach currently existing in many countries.
Therefore policies and programmes on food production by governments should meet the standards and
expectations of those who engage in the profession (rural dwellers).
5. Global inequality
The failed attempts by UN and many other international organizations to close the gap between the rich
(developed) countries and the poor (underdeveloped nations) are achievable through “paradigm shift” and
“international re-focusing”.
This shift should rather than attempting to address inequality on a global scale, “re-focuses on finding
lasting solutions to factors that breed inequality in the rural areas (families, villages and communities).
Thus, inequality in rural communities and villages are perceived in the area of few individuals and families
deliberately having access to productive farm-land to the detriment of large population of the area, access to
river(s) for fishing activities, access to primary, secondary and university education, access to good water,
primary health care facilities, housing, among others.
Consequently, poor access to these critical facilities by large number of indigenes in the many rural
areas, lead to disaffection, acrimony, conflicts and violence (Toye, 1995). This consequently, results in
shortage of food (food insecurity) and disharmony among the people. Therefore, global peace cannot be
achieved until inequality at rural areas all over the world is decisively tackled (McSweeney, 1999).
6. Conclusion
…what strikes a visitor from the advanced country to most rural areas is the low level of technological
practice in some countries especially in Asia, Africa and Latin America…this state of affairs gives the
impression that engineers and scientists in these continents are careless about devising the technologies
387
appropriate to the rural sector… the government should first stop deceiving itself and the public that the rural
sector does not yet have the type of technologies and facilities it needs… (Ogbudinkpa, 1991).
Rural development as strategy designed by countries to improve the lives of the rural people in order to
meet their required needs has abysmally failed to achieve this lofty objective, particularly in the developing
world. Rural development whose emphasis should be on issues germane to agriculture and technological
developments of rural communities has tremendously left large population of the contemporary world in
hunger, poverty and avoidable crisis. Thus, since rural development policies and programmes are
incapacitated to bring about desired food security, the attainment of global peace has continued to attract mix
reactions by observers and public commentators all over the world.
In India for instance, (the second most populous country in the world), about 30 million people have been
added to the ranks of the hungry since the mid 1990s and 46% of children in this country are underweight
(Human Right Watch Reports, 2010). World-wide, about 852 million people are chronically hungry largely
due to extreme poverty, while 2 billion people lack food security due mainly to varying degrees of poverty-
related cases (Yao and Colman, 2010).
Similarly, experts have argued that about six million children die of hunger every year and 17,000 every
day (Mousseau, 2003). However, this situation is attributed to failure of rural development policies and
programmes to achieve food security. As demonstrated in this study, the root causes of food insecurity in the
world today is the inability of people to gain access to food largely due to poverty. While some developed
countries in the world have made significant progress towards rural development, food security and poverty
alleviation, many countries in Africa, particularly the Sub-Saharan Africa, Asia and Latin America, have
continued to lag behind (Ekong, 2010).
The above ugly trend particularly among African states (Nigeria, Mali, Cameroon, Gambia, Senegal, Cote
D’ivoire, Madagascar and Zimbabwe), has not only affected the development of their rural economy, but also
subjected the people to abject poverty. Notwithstanding, it is important to observe that an appreciable level of
improvements have been recorded recently by some countries in the developing world.
Consequently, global peace cannot be achieved when most countries in the contemporary world “have
their second name as poverty. (IFPRI, 2002)” Understandably, peace hardly triumphs in poverty-driven
environment. This, therefore, underscores the need for global action towards combating the root causes of
rural backwardness, poverty and food insecurity in order to achieve global peace in the 21st century.
In view of this, nation-state should emulate and replicate the strategies and actions adopted by Australian
and Chinese Governments to address the problem of rural underdevelopment and food insecurity in their
countries (Pinstrup-Aderesen, 2002). This is crucial because as FAO (2010) observes:
The Australian Government helps developing countries in its region to reduce poverty and address food
security by promoting trade liberalization, peace and stability, good governance, security of land tenure, rural
develop and agricultural research.
However, the AU, EU, and other regional organizations in Africa and Asia should strictly adopt bottom-up
approach with rural communities as centre of attraction in order to address the pathetic situation of
underdevelopment in rural areas. This ugly phenomenon is responsible for increasing rate of poverty, food
insecurity, crisis and reported cases of violence in many parts of the world today.
7. Recommendations
1. The United Nations as a body should identify the strategies and factors that aided the Chinese
Government to achieve desired heights in rural development. The identified strategies should, therefore, be
replicated in other countries particularly the developing world to enable them address critical problems of
rural underdevelopment in their respective states.
2. The United Nations should also establish specialized agency charged with the responsibility of ensuring
that cultivated or productive land in developing and developed countries are equitably distributed to
388
households as it is the trend in China and Australia. This could be done through collaboration between this
envisaged UN specialized agency and regional bodies in respective continents such as AU, EU, NATO
among others.
3. There should be a paradigm shift among states (developed and developing), in the area of concentrating
development programmes in the metropolitan or Urban centres. It is strongly recommended that the
approach to development of rural areas in this 21st century should be “bottom-up”. Thus, the “bottom-up”
approach emphasizes the involvement, consultation and participation of the rural populace on critical issues
of rural development in their localities.
4. It is strongly recommended that all countries in the contemporary world should declare what is referred to
as “Food Sovereignty”. Thus, “Food Sovereignty” is the right of people and communities to safe, nutritious,
culturally appropriate food, food producing resources, and ability to sustain themselves.
5. The international organizations, NGOS and some food-secured countries in the world should formulate
implementable strategies and action-plan capable of benefiting food insecure countries like India, Benin
Republic, Niger, Mali, Zimbabwe, Haiti, among others. This strategy would rather than supplying food stuffs
and relief materials to the affected countries, focuses on ways to address the root causes of food insecurity to
enable them become food producers.
References
A workbook on food security and influencing public policy. www.foodthoughtful.ca. Retrieved: September 28, 2011.
Ake,C. (2002). A political economy of Africa. Lagos: Longman.
Awa, E. O. (1992). Theories and strategies of African rural development. In Olisa, S. O. and Obiukwu, J. I. (eds). Rural development in
Nigeria: Dynamics and Strategies (pp. 3-16). Awka: Mekslink Publishers.
Bogle, J. E. (1977). “Infratructure for rural development” Ekistics, 43 (257), 195-198.
Brewer, A. (1989). Marxist theory of imperialism: A critical survey. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Callaghy, T. M. (1993). Vision and politics in the transformation of the global political economy: Lesson from the second and third worlds.
In Slater, et al (eds.). Global Transformation and the Third World. London: Lynne Renner Publishers.
Dalang, C. O. (2006).“The role of wild plants in poverty alleviation and biodiversity conservation in tropical countries.” Process in
Development Studies 6 (4), 275-286.
Diejomaoh, V. P. (1973). Rural development in Nigeria: The role of fiscal policy. Proceeding of the 1972 Annual Conference of the
Nigeria’s Economic Society.
Dolan, M. (1993). Global economic transformation and less developed countries. In Slater, etal (eds). Global Transformation and The
Third World. London: Lynne Renner Publishers.
Dror, Y. (1968). Public policy re- examined. New York: Chandler.
Edame, E. (2006). Development economics and planning in Nigeria. Lagos: Macmillan.
Ekong, E. E. (2010). Rural sociology (third edition). Uyo: Dove Educational Publishers.
Ekpo, A. H. (2006). The dialectics of rural development: Theory and evidence. In Ebong, M. O. (ed). Mobilization of resources for rural
development in Nigeria (pp. 82-103). Calabar: MABASS Printing Company.
FAO, (2001). World food submit: The state of food insecurity. Washington D.C: FAO.
FAO, (2010). Food security for all by 2020: Getting the priorities and responsibilities right. Washington DC: IFPRI.
FAO, (2010). Practical guide: Basic concepts of food security. Washington D.C: FAO.
FAO, (2005). World food submit: Basic information. www.fas.usda.gov. Retrieved: September, 22, 2011.
Goldon, D. (1976). Credit for small farmers in developing countries. New York: Westview Press.
Hilary, J. (2004). Trade liberation, poverty and WTO: Assessing the realities New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Huang etal, (2000). The economy of China’s agricultural and rural development. Beijing: China Agricultural Press.
Human Right Watch Report (July 10, 2010). Islamic assailants kill hundreds of christians near Jos, Nigeria.
IFPRI Report, (2002). Reaching sustainable food security for all by 2020: Getting the priorities and responsibilities right. Washington
D.C: IFPRI.
Jorge, N. (2010). Human security and mutual vulnerability. Ottawa: International Development Centre.
Kherallah etal (2002). Reforming agricultural markets in Africa. IFPRI: The John Hopkins University Press.
Latham, M. (1997). Human nutrition in the developing world. Rome: FAO.
Magbogunje, A. L. (1980). The development process in Nigeria. London: Longman.
McSweeney, B. (1999). Security, identify and interests: A sociology of international relations. London: Cambridge University Press.
Mousseau, M. (2003).” The nexus of market society, liberal preferences, and democratic peace”. International studies Quarterly, 47 (4)
483-510.
389
Ntukidem, A.E. (2006). Towards a humanistic rural development in Nigeria. In Ebong, M.O.(ed). Mobilization of resources for rural
development in Nigeria (pp. 59-84). Calabar: MABASS Printing Company.
Nwaniki,A. (2003). The utilization of locally grown plant materials in the production of an intervention formulation for malnourished
children in marginal areas: The case of Makindu location Makueni District. Unpublished masters thesis, University of Nairobi.
Ogbudinkpa, R.N. (1991). Quest for Nigeria’s rural technological development: The way out. In Olisa, M. S. and Obiukwu, J. I. (eds.).
Rural development in Nigeria: Dynamics and strategies (pp.165-182). Awka: Mekslink Publishers.
Olarenwaju, S.A.(1984). The rural development problem revisited: Some lessons from the Chinese. Unpublished paper presented at the
National Seminar on Innovations and Approaches to Development Theory, NISER, Ibadan.
Ollawa, P. E. (1971). “On a dynamic model for rural development in Africa”. Journal of Modern African Studies, 15 (3), 457-480.
Pinstrup-Aderesen, P. (2002). Food and agricultural policy for a globalizing world: Preparing the future. American Journal of Agricultural
Economics, (84), 1201-1214.
Rosegrant etal (2005). Looking ahead: Long-term prospects for Africa’s agricultural development and food security. Washington D.C:
IFPRI.
Roundinell, etal (2008). Urbanization and rural development. Washington D.C.: Praeger Publishers.
Stewart, F.(2003). “Conflict and the millennium development goals”. Journal of Human Development, 4(3), 325-351.
Swaminathan, etal (2004). Agriculture, food security, nutrition and the millennium development goals (2003-2004) IFPRI Report.
Toye, J. (1995). Is the third world still there? In Ayres, R. (ed). Development studies: An Introduction through selected readings (pp. 35-
49). Dartford: Greenwich University Press.
Ukpong, E. A. (2006). Rural women in food production: A review of agricultural policies in Cross River State. In Ebong, M.O. (ed).
Mobilization of resources for rural development in Nigeria (pp. 115-127) Calabar:MABASS Printing Company.
UNDP (2010). Report of Human Development index. Washington D.C: UNDP.
Usman, A. T. (August 21, 2010). It is time to re- assess Nigerian national security: Establish a ministry of homeland affairs security. Daily
Sun, p. 35.
Uyanga, J. T. (1980). A geography of rural development in Nigeria. Washington D.C: American University Press.
Vincent, A. (1981). Rural industrial development: A practical handbook for planners, project managers and field staff. London: Chaucer
Press.
Wilkin, P. (2010). “Global poverty and orthodox security”. Third World Quarterly, 23 (4), 633-645.
World Bank (1990). World development report on poverty. Washington D.C: World Bank.
World Bank (2005). African development indicators. Washington D.C: World Bank.
World Bank (2010). Glossary of poverty and human development. Washington D.C. World Bank. Washington D.C: World Bank.
World Bank Policy Notes (July 10, 2003).
World Food Summit. (2010). Food security measurement. Washington D.C: FAO.
World Food Summit. (2001). Measuring food security and hunger. Washington D.C.: FAO.
Yao, S. & Colman, D.(2010). “Agricultural development in China.” Oxford Agrarian Studies 18 (1), 23-34.
Zhang, F. S. & Zhang, X. (2002). Growth, inequality and poverty in rural China: The role of public investments. In IFPRI Research, No.
125: International Food Policy Research Institute, April 2002.
Zhude, X. (2010). Some key issues in agriculture and rural economic development. In Zhude, X. (ed.). Research on key issues of
China’s rural economy. Beijing: China Statistics Press.
390
An Unromanticized Afghanistan in Saira Shah’s

The Storyteller’s Daughter
Mais Qutami
Assistant Professor, English Department

Zahra College
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.391
Abstract In this paper I examine Saira Shah’s representation of Afghanistan and her conflicted position as a viewer and
narrator whose “way of seeing” the East and West sometimes fluctuates between an Orientalist and a nationalist perspective. I
argue though that her affiliation to the West and Orientalist views seem to dominate her perception of Afghani culture and its
people far more than she had expected. Despite her attempts to renegotiate her hyphenated identity, as an Afghani- British, she
finds herself unable to embrace the new torn- up Afghanistan that replaces the romanticized image she had of it in the past. In
The Storyteller’s Daughter, Shah tries to bring Afghanistan and its culture to light, but indirectly contributes to its invisibility and
misrepresentation by the colonial discourse. She shares with her readers her experiences with the Taliban and the women she
met in Afghanistan which she thought of as a mysterious land until she was disillusioned with its horrific state of war and political
turmoil.
Key words: Identity, Saira Shah, Afghanistan, Orientalism, Third World
For it is often the way we look at other people that imprisons them within their own narrowest
allegiances. And it is also the way we look at them that may set them free. (Maalouf, 2000, p. 22)
1. Introduction
Saira Shah grew up as a British citizen in an Afghani family that has been displaced from their ancestral
home but its memories were kept alive through storytelling. The stories she hears from her father are so
compelling that she cannot wait to visit this mysterious land to experience life there and reclaim her long lost
Afghani identity. Shah eventually visits Afghanistan as a war correspondent during the Soviet occupation and
returns to it in 2001 with the BBC to film her documentary Beneath the Veil which gained popularity after
9/11. Shah, in The Storyteller’s Daughter, gives her readers a glimpse of Afghanistan’s tumultuous history as
she explores the country of her ancestry and tries to come to terms with the “unromanticized” version of
Afghanistan that just hits her by surprise.
The essay examines Saira Shah’s (2003) conflicted views and representation of Afghanistan, its culture,
and history in The Storyteller’s Daughter. It brings to the fore Shah’s tendency to fluctuate between a
Western and Orientalist perspective of her homeland, on the one hand, and a nationalist perspective of it on
the other. The essay, while it highlights instances of Shah’s nationalist and nativist perspective, reflects, more
often than not, her colonialist and Orientalist views that largely inform her representation and perception of
the East. The discussion also focuses on Shah’s journey to Afghanistan in search of an identity she had
longed for. It unravels her experiences at this homeland, her encounter with the Taliban and Afghani women.
2. Identity
Shah’s (2003) narrative presents a dialectical opposition between East and West. Shah struggles with these
two conflicting cultures, ideologies and sets of values. It is through her journey to Afghanistan that she
becomes more aware of the two parts that are in war with each other and that make up her hyphenated
391
identity which she tries to reconcile as best she could.1 She hopes for a new and coherent identity, hence her
narrative is a renegotiation of her multiple identities. Towards the end of the narrative, Shah (2003) states
that:
Despite myself, I felt a glow of pleasure that I had fallen on the Eastern side. I wondered why
being an Afghan was still so important to me. To this day, I dreaded the question, “Where are you
from?” Why did it matter to me that I could never answer in just one word? I had always longed to
belong to a single place: why couldn’t that place be the West? (p. 221)
She is torn between two cultures; her British and Western upbringing is often in conflict with her Afghani and
Eastern origins. Therefore, she wishes to bring together her two opposing identities and believes her journey
to Afghanistan will help bring about peace between them.
Shah recalls the magnificent stories about Afghanistan told by her father. As she is fascinated by these
stories of a rich culture passed down from father to daughter, she becomes eager to visit the origins of her
ancestors. Shah realizes she has unresolved issues with her identity and sense of belonging. Shah (2003)
wonders, “How could my father expect us to be truly Afghan when we had grown up outside an Afghan
community? When we went back home, wouldn’t we children be strangers, foreigners in our own land?”(p. 6).
Her father comments “I’ve given you stories to replace a community. They are your community” (Shah, 2003,
p. 7). She recognizes the complexity of her situation as a foreigner in her own land. As an adult, she finally
realizes that stories told by her father cannot replace an entire community or culture, nor can they truly
preserve her connection to her cultural origin.
Shah suffers from a double- consciousness that can be analyzed through Lois Tyson’s (1999) discussion
of displacement and belonging. In Critical Theory Today: A User –Friendly Guide, Tyson (1999) notes that:
This feeling of being caught between cultures, of belonging to neither rather than to both, of finding
oneself arrested in a psychological limbo that results not merely from some individual psychological
disorder but from the trauma of the cultural displacement within which one lives, is referred to … as
unhomeliness. (p. 368)2
Although Shah tries to reclaim her lost identity, she seems to be struggling more with her Afghan origins and
roots rather than her Western identity. She does not complain about being mistreated or viewed as “the
other” by the West, neither does she speak of any injustices she personally experiences due to her Afghan
cultural origins. We do not feel Shah is traumatized by a cultural displacement, nor do we sense pain or
psychological devastation due to her state of in-betweeness. Tyson rightly claims that “Being ‘unhomed’ is
not the same as being homeless. To be unhomed is to feel not at home even in your own home because you
are not at home in yourself: your cultural identity crisis has made you a psychological refugee” (p. 368).
Shah’s narrative does not reflect her unhomeliness or homelessness, neither do we get the sense that her
cultural identity has made her a psychological refugee either. On the contrary, she seems to feel at home
with her Western identity.
It is no surprise that Shah does not feel at home during her visit to Afghanistan. Her initial experience with
the Afghan culture and first impression of its social and religious practices is negative. This is exemplified by
Shah’s first encounter with the “burqa” which she could never accept as part of the cultural norms in this
society. She is only able to look at the “burqa” from a Western feminist lens. She makes no attempt to learn
about its significance, or the rationale behind such a practice. She quickly decides that this culture is very
oppressive of women, for they are forced to wear a burqa that makes them invisible. It is only natural for
Shah, as a Western and British woman in particular, to reject this dress code, and feel that it constrains her,
limits her freedom and strips her of her individuality. It is this unpleasant image of Afghan women that leads

1 For more reading on hyphenated identities, see Sirin, S.R., & Imamoglu, S. (2009). Muslim-American hyphenated identity: Negotiating
a positive path. In Phillips,R. (Ed.). Muslims in West: Spaces of Hope. (pp. 236-251). London: Zed Books
2 For further reading on “unhomeliness” see Bhabha (1994) in The Location of Culture. London/New York: Routledge
392
her to develop a negative attitude toward the entire culture. She expresses her detestation of this cultural
practice when she writes “I am merely a notation on the papers of my male escort. As a woman, I have
ceased to exist. The burqa is my passport, my cloak of invisibility” (Shah, 2003, p. 14). She is forced into a
disturbing state of invisibility through the burqa. Obviously, she is unhappy with her invisibility and the silence
that comes along with it.
Shah is critical of the patriarchal system in Afghanistan that dominates women and deprives them of their
rights. Ironically, she puts great emphasis on the Afghan male experience during war while she deals with the
plight of Afghan women very briefly in her narrative. She is under the disguise of a man, and goes on with her
journey accompanied by men from the Taliban. She distances herself from the Afghan women so as to avoid
falling into that category of Third World women which would make her a member of “the other.”
3. The “Us” and “Them” Binary
Chandra Mohanty (2003), a well- known postcolonial theorist, offers a critique of the discourse of Western
feminists that tend to group all women of the Third World into a single coherent and homogeneous group that
shares identical interests regardless of cultural differences, race, class or religion. She believes it is this
process of homogenization of these women’s oppression that results in producing the image of an “average
Third World woman.” Based on her feminine gender this average Third World woman is read as “sexually
constrained, and her being “Third World” is read as “ignorant, poor, uneducated, tradition-bound, domestic,
family-oriented, victimized… this… is in contrast to the (implicit) self-representation of Western women as
educated, as modern, as having control over their own bodies and sexualities and the freedom to make their
own decisions” (Mohanty, 2003, p. 22). Shah is aware of these polarized binaries to a great extent. She fails
to bring a new perspective or new way of seeing through which she can unsettle these oppressive binaries of
West/ East, the oppressor/ the oppressed, modern/ traditional and First World/ Third World. She recognizes
the complexity of such constructions that set “us” apart from “them,” as Edward Said puts it in his seminal
book Orientalism (1980). Due to her fear of being otherized, she sets herself apart from this image of Third
World woman. Furthermore, she asserts herself as a Western woman who is by contrast educated and in
control of her own life. She believes the best way to maintain this privileged status is by associating herself
with Afghan men who are dominant, relatively free compared to the women, and in control of their lives.
Shah is disguised in man’s clothes through which she detaches herself from the female world, and her
gender as woman in order to be heard. In other words, she makes the assumption that her appearance as
woman in a patriarchal society as such may cripple the progress of her journey. Perhaps her positioning of
herself, away from the margins and subaltern subjects, can be justified in the light of Gayatri Spivak’s (1988)
reply with an emphatic no to her own question “Can the subaltern speak?” Spivak (1988) strongly argues that
“the subaltern as female cannot be heard or read” (p. 106). Shah clearly understands the politics of power,
dominance, and invisibility, and thus, does not want to be subordinated through a subaltern position that only
ignores her voice. In spite of the good intentions she may have, she herself is entrapped by the Western
patriarchal mentality that marginalizes women, for she decides to unravel the complexities of the life of the
male mujahideen barely touching upon issues concerning Afghan women. Ironically, she is critical of the
invisibility of women in Afghanistan when she herself makes them invisible in her narrative, and does not
make their voices heard. It is not surprising that she is entangled in Western stereotypes and misconceptions
of the East, and the colonial discourse. Perhaps, Shah is unconsciously influenced by this colonial and
patriarchal mentality that reinforces the centralization of males and the marginalization of females. By joining
the men in the Taliban, she empowers them as a patriarchal force which is characteristic of colonial power
and ideology. Simultaneously, she tries to help three little girls at the end of the narrative as a way to express
her rejection of the injustices females experience during an era of colonization and war. Even this act of
kindness on her behalf can be interpreted as reflective of typical Western colonialist behavior, that is, the
colonizer usually takes on the role of savior who helps its colonized and inferior subjects especially women.
393
This act of kindness through which Eastern women are saved and liberated actually reinforces the colonizer’s
superiority and domination over colonized cultures. Shah (2003) represents Western stereotypes of the
Islamic state that victimizes and suppresses its women. She perceives Afghan women as “ignorant, poor,
uneducated” and subordinate. She sums up what she believes to be the premise on which women’s status is
based in the “Islamic” state. She supposes that “Women must be protected, and the best way to do that is to
keep them indoors… Girls over nine are barred from school. Females are banned from almost all jobs”
(Shah, 2003, p. 13).
Shah, however, does not completely give in to Western notions of the East, in her journey with the men,
she puts aside the Orientalist and Western lens through which Afghan men are usually perceived, and gives
them a chance to demonstrate who they truly are. In fact, she improves the image of Afghan men with whom
she feels respected and safe. She subverts the distorted Western image of Third World men that constantly
portrays them either as savage and uncivilized, or hypersexual beings that are driven by their sexual and
animal instinct. When Karima, her Afghan hostess, asks her “Do you not have trouble traveling alone as a
woman with so many men?” Shah narrates “I told her that the mujahidin were engaged in jihad, a holy
struggle. I could imagine no other group of soldiers where I could travel in such perfect safety” (Shah, 2003,
p. 93). Not only does she overcome her personal bias against these men who keep their women indoors, but
also praises them for the security she has felt and experienced in her journey with them.
4. In- Between a Nationalist and Orientalist Discourse
Shah continues to fluctuate between her two identities on the one hand, and her varied representations of
Afghanistan, on the other. She continuously shifts back and forth between two conflicting perspectives: the
Western Orientalist as opposed to the nationalist or nativist perspective. In Bananas Beaches and Bases:
Making Feminist Sense of International Politics, the postcolonial feminist Cynthia Enloe (1989) discusses
how nationalism functions and develops among anti-colonialists. She believes that:
A nation is a collection of people who have come to believe that they have been shaped by a common
past and are destined to share a common future. That belief is usually nurtured by a common language and a
sense of otherness from groups around them. Nationalism is a commitment to fostering those beliefs and
promoting policies which permit the nation to control its own destiny. Colonialism is especially fertile ground
for nationalist ideas because it gives an otherwise divided people such a potent shared experience of foreign
domination. (Enloe, 1989, p. 45)
In the light of this explanation of nationalism and the sense of otherness it involves, it hardly seems that
Shah’s representation of Afghanistan comes from a nationalist perspective. Although she has the cultural
origin that connects her to the East, she does not consider herself one of the Afghan people who is destined
to share a common future, nor has she been shaped by a common past with them either. In other words, she
knows she would eventually return to England where her past was shaped and her future will come into
existence. Her visit to Afghanistan is more of a journey into the past that has been wiped away, and replaced
with the harsh reality of the present which to her is only temporary and unpleasant. She comments “I didn’t
need anyone to teach me how to see what I wanted to see. I didn’t want this fractured war-torn place: I
wanted the lost homeland I had been told about” (Shah, 2003, p. 111). Shah realizes that this journey will
come to an end and that she will be gone, and thus, will not share a common future or destiny with its people.
She is even glad to be leaving her “homeland” because staying there involves great sacrifices and struggles
that she could no longer endure. She admits it and states, “I stepped on to the pontoon, guiltily glad to be
leaving Afghanistan. A stretch of muddy brown water opened up between me and the shore” (Shah, 2003, p.
251).
There are several occasions, on the other hand, during which she sees herself an Afghan, and separates
herself from the West, and actually views it as a manipulative colonial force. She presents her view towards
the West through the gaze of the colonized and speaks as an outsider of the Western culture. She writes:
394
I gazed at the Westerners under their safe canopy and I thought: However much they love us or
hate us, and however much they want to believe the myths they have invented about us, they will
never clip our beak and our crest and our cruel…talons and turn this hawk into a pigeon. (Shah,
2003, p. 125)
She resists the myths created by the West that dehumanize and belittle people of the East, mainly Arabs or
Muslims. We sense defiance and compassionate resistance of the colonial rule in her tone which reinforces
her Eastern and Afghan identity.
Shah (2003) suffers, relatively speaking, from an identity crisis. She is unable to commit herself to one
identity or one culture, nor can she limit her representations of either culture to a single perspective. She also
understands the nature of her dilemma and is aware that her Afghan identity is based on myths and legends
and not reality. She declares “My own identity was shaped more by myths and legends than by my passport
or birth certificate. Most of them enshrined lessons from history” (Shah, 2003, p. 15). The stories she grows
up with do not build a solid foundation for her Afghan identity. Furthermore, the fact that her connection to the
Afghan culture is merely based on stories and myth makes her loyalty to her ancestral origins questionable.
She compares her situation with regard to her Afghan identity to the people of Afghanistan in general in an
attempt to find peace with herself. Shah emphasizes that:
Four million Afghan refugees have been exiled from their homes for two decades. A whole
generation has grown up outside Afghanistan. They have never lost their Afghan identity, because
they have never been offered another in its place. (p. 26)
This comment illustrates the divide that exists between other Afghans and someone like her who has been
offered a Western identity in replacement of her Afghan one which justifies the loss of her Afghan identity.
Although we see her expressing her uneasiness with the state of in- betweenness she finds herself in at
certain points in the narrative, she seems to struggle with her Afghan origin that is causing her distress rather
than her Western upbringing through which she can easily define herself.
Shah wants to come to terms with her identity as long as it does not interfere with her identification of
herself as a Westerner that functions as a shield through which she protects herself. If she had been placed
in a position in which she had to choose between East and West, she seems to be more willing to sacrifice
what links her to the East but not the West. She states:
“I hoped that the myth of the romantic Afghan resistance would stand up to the rigours of my
journalistic enquiry. I hoped my family’s map of tales might be my guide without my having to
sacrifice Western method. And above all I hoped that, by resolving these contradictions, I could
reconcile my incompatible worlds of East and West.” (Shah, 2003, p. 79)
Shah is, evidently, influenced by the Orientalist and colonialist discourse that emphasizes myth, exoticism,
and romanticization in its handling of any given colonized culture. In this quote, one notices that in her
description of Afghanistan, the terms associated with it are “myth,” “tale,” and “romantic,” however, terms
such as “method” and “enquiry” are associated with the West. Obviously, her perception of the East is highly
informed and shaped by the polarized binaries of East/ West read as ignorant/ knowledgeable and instinctive/
rational respectively. After examining her journey and experience in Afghanistan, we get the sense that the
desired reconciliation between the East and the West is unlikely to happen.
Shah inevitably prefers to present herself to the reader as a Westerner with all the power, superiority, and
dominance this identity entails. It is common for those who have multiple identities to choose one identity
over the other based on the hierarchical structure of society. Anna Cieslik and Maykel Verkuyten (2006)
discuss this issue of multiplicity and negotiation of identities. Cieslik and Verkuyten (2006) argue that “The
various identities may interact according to a situational hierarchy where one position becomes the main
distinction along which other sources of identity are ranked and periodically subsumed” (p. 79). Because s
Shah is subject to the hierarchal structures of Western society and identity, her Afghan identity is naturally
subsumed and subordinated by the more dominant identity.
395
Shah holds on to her Western identity due to the fact that it empowers her and the knowledge she
provides her readers with as a writer and journalist. Mohanty (2003) agrees with Vandana Shiva’s analysis of
Eurocentrism and the Western view of “the other”, and their knowledge which assumes that “the knowledge
of the Third World and the knowledge of people of color is not knowledge. When that knowledge is taken by
white men who have capital, suddenly creativity begins… Patents are a replay of colonialism, which is now
called globalization and free trade” (Mohanty, 2003, p. 233). In her memoir, Shah (2003) detaches herself
from the Afghan culture, and sees it from a Western lens for the most part. She resists blending in perhaps to
make sure that the knowledge she produces and the information she includes in her narrative will not be
considered that of the Third World, and so be rejected or devalued by the West. Therefore, she clings to her
Western origin that will guarantee her a far better future than what Afghanistan can offer her. Taking on a
new identity as an Afghan to Shah would involve great struggles, suffering, and many battles to fight within
herself, within the Afghan society, and the outside world which may not be worth the trouble. Mohanty (2003)
recognizes the importance of Third World women’s narratives, particularly, the way they are “read,
understood, and located institutionally.”3 She stresses that the point is not just “to record one’s history of
struggle, or consciousness, but how they are recorded; the way we read, receive, and disseminate such
imaginative records is immensely significant” (Mohanty, 2003, p. 78). Shah does not realize the extent to
which her narrative can be taken seriously since she is Western with connections to the East. Her readers
are likely to consider her narrative a reliable source on Afghan, Islamic and Middle Eastern issues which is a
huge responsibility. Her voice is also heard because her knowledge represents knowledge of the West
superior to that of the East. Her views are highly respected in Afghanistan too. This can be illustrated through
the question Halima’s husband asks her “Tell us, what are ordinary people in the West saying about our
lives?” (Shah, 2003, p. 36). As she is faced with this question, she cannot help but sympathize with these
people who think the West would be concerned with what they experience every day during war. After
reflecting upon it, she reports that “They wait for me to make my point, because they already assume people
in the West believe oppression anywhere in the world concerns us all. But they are wrong: they have been
abandoned. Sitting here in the darkness, they are quite alone” (Shah, 2003, p. 37). Shah realizes that these
Afghans have been failed by the West and its promise to bring upon justice.
Shah, following her journey, destroys the myth of the beautiful and inspiring Afghanistan and,
unfortunately, depicts it as a nation in absolute chaos and ruin. Shah seems to be doing what Ania Loomba
(1998) warns us against which is viewing the Third World as “a world defined entirely by its relation to
colonialism. Its histories are then flattened, and colonialism becomes their defining feature” (p. 18). Shah
resists romanticizing the East so it is not represented as the “exotic,” however, her extremely grim and horrific
representation of Afghanistan is somewhat problematic. Her representation of Afghanistan does not do it
justice. She does not provide an account of its historical or cultural past prior to colonization, nor does she
contrast current Afghanistan with former Afghanistan in the pre– war and pre- colonial period. In fact, it is
unusual not to have much mentioning of the past in the discussion of a culture that strongly reveres an
individual’s past. Yvonne Ridley (2003) points out in her review of The Storyteller’s Daughter that she was
envious of Shah because of her rich family history, stretching back almost 2,000 years, and emphasizes that
“For an Afghan, a person’s past is just as important as their future.” It is only reasonable to conclude that if a
person’s past is important in such a culture, then the nation’s past, history, and culture must be of great
significance to its people, especially that Afghans take pride in their past victories. It is ironic that within this
context of Afghan culture the narrative lacks a historical background of the nation’s achievements and
successful past that truly reflects Afghanistan.

3 For further information on identity and Third World Feminsim see Narayan (1997). Dislocating Cultures: Identities,Traditions, and Third
World Feminism. New York: Routledge
396
Shah (2003) makes the common mistake referred to by Loomba (1998) which is dealing with postcolonial
societies, Afghanistan in this case, as if “colonialism is the only history of these societies.” Loomba (1998)
raises crucial questions we ought to pay attention to regarding this issue like “What came before colonial
rule? What indigenous ideologies, practices and hierarchies existed alongside colonialism and interacted with
it?” (p. 17). Shah fails to address these questions in her narrative that are quite essential for her
representation of Afghanistan and its history. Her representation, apart from the myth, gives the impression
that colonialism is the only history of Afghanistan. She exposes the tragedies and destruction caused by the
colonial and imperial power, but does not place enough emphasis on the Afghan cultural heritage, religious
and social values that are subject to loss and distortion. As a journalist, she, perhaps, does this to maintain a
sense of objectivity in her representations of the current Afghanistan in an era of war. Nevertheless, the
question that raises itself is “how can she portray a different picture of an Afghanistan she is not familiar
with?” Her knowledge of it seems to be limited to its state of war and conflict, and not peace and prosperity
that she can speak of. Therefore, it can be said that while her representation of Afghanistan may be justified
to some, it is not to others. In her description of Kabul, she writes “…beloved Kabul- lies like a jewel at my
feet. I know by now that its beauty is an illusion: close up, the city is in ruins, as shattered and broken as this
garden. I have missed the golden age. I have come too late” (Shah, 2003, p. 44).
Shah’s stress on the dreary conditions of the people in Afghanistan can be viewed as an attempt to offer a
critique and contestation of the Western colonial and imperialistic power exerted against the “other”. In
addition, in her search of the myth, she finally comes to realize that nothing is left of it. She acknowledges the
harsh fact that “War had changed Afghanistan…-nearly eight percent of the population- had been killed. Four
million more were banished… A generation of children had been left uneducated, their future as good as
destroyed. Agriculture was bombed to shreds…” (Shah, 2003, p. 188). Her eschewal of the myth can be
interpreted as a means to force people to open their eyes to see reality as it really is in order to provoke
active and assertive resistance to colonialism. Her portrayal of the obliteration of the nation and chaos in
Afghanistan comes as a warning against underestimating the tragic and horrific consequences of war,
imperialism, and victimization of the colonized by the colonial rule. She highlights the way such an oppressive
power can erase and wipe out the entire history of a nation not leaving any trace of civilization, or cultural
heritage for that matter. In Culture and Imperialism, Said (1993) speaks of the severe and threatening cultural
and historical damage nations under colonial rule undergo. He agrees with Fanon that “Colonialism is not
satisfied merely with holding a people in its grip and emptying the native’s brain of all form and content. By a
kind of perverted logic, it turns to the past of the people, and distorts, disfigures and destroys it” (p. 237). In
the narrative, Afghanistan has been destroyed and its culture distorted. Colonialism left no trace of its past.
It is painful and disappointing for Shah to lose hope of a recovering and a healed Afghanistan, for it will
take years and years to repair the enormous damage inflicted on this nation and its people. At the same time,
Shah herself and her identity are torn by the colonial power. That is, her perception of her double identity is
influenced by the Oriental and Western discourse, and notions of the East that she is unable to overcome.
She only perceives her multiple identities as incompatible and in war with each other. She declares, “Two
people live inside me. Like a couple who rarely speak, they are not compatible. My Western side is a
sensitive, liberal, middle-class pacifist. My Afghan side I can only describe as a rapacious robber baron. It
revels in bloodshed, glories in risk and will not be afraid” (Shah, 2003, p. 14). She is convinced that the two
halves within her, Western and Eastern, cannot reconcile. She realizes that her journey to Afghanistan did
not repair the relations between the “two people [living] inside [her].”
5. Conclusion
At the end of the narrative, Shah finally accepts her failure to bridge the two worlds within her and is ready to
return to the West. Unfortunately, she views her multiple allegiances as a shortcoming. She does not
embrace the diversity and multiculturalism her double identity introduces to her. She is unaware of the crucial
397
role she can play due to her multiple allegiances suggested by the Middle Eastern novelist Amin Maalouf
(2000). In his discussion of identity, Maalouf provides examples of the roles that can be played by people
who have allegiances to two nations who are in conflict with one another. As Maalouf (2000) puts it so
eloquently:
They live in a sort of frontier zone crisscrossed by ethnic, religious and other fault lines. But by virtue of
this situation … they have a special role to play in forging links, eliminating misunderstandings, making some
parties more reasonable and others less belligerent, smoothing out difficulties, seeking compromise. Their
role is to act as bridges, go-betweens, mediators between the various communities and cultures. And that is
precisely why their dilemma is so significant: if they themselves cannot sustain their multiple allegiances, if
they are continually being pressed to take sides or ordered to stay within their own tribe, then all of us have
reason to be uneasy about the way the world is going.” (p. 5)
Shah tries through her journey to take on the responsibility as that “bridge” and “mediator” between the
Western and Eastern culture, but does not succeed. She is not able to succeed in such an endeavor as she
continues to be controlled by an engrained colonialist mentality that compels her to hold on to her Western
half at the expense of her inferior half. She herself cannot “sustain [her] multiple allegiances.” Her Orientalist
representations of Afghanistan do not necessarily reflect the truth, and so demand an intelligent reader to
challenge them and put them to test.
References
Bhabha, H. (1994). The Location of Culture. London/New York: Routledge.

Cieslik, A. & Verkuyten, M. (2006). National, Ethnic and Religious Identities: Hybridity and the Case of the Polish Tatars. National
Identities, 8, 77-93.
Enloe, C. (1989). Bananas Beaches and Bases: Making Feminist Sense of International Politics. Berkeley: University of California
Press.
Loomba, A. (1998). Colonialism/ Postcolonialism. London: Routledge.
Maalouf, A. (2000). In the Name of Identity: Violence and the Need to Belong. Trans. Barbara Bray. New York: Arcade Publishing.
Mohanty, C. (2003). Feminism without Borders: Decolonizing Theory, Practicing Solidarity. Durham: Duke University Press.
Narayan, (1997). Dislocating Cultures: Identities, Traditions, and Third World Feminism. New York: Routledge
Ridley, Y. (2003). The Third Sex: Rev. of The Storyteller’s Daughter by Saira Shah. Available at
http://www.newstatesman.com/200309010032
Said, E. (1980). Orientalism. Londres: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Said, E. (1993). Culture and Imperialism. New York: Random House, Inc.
Shah, S. (2003). The Storyteller’s Daughter. New York: Random House, Inc.
Sirin, S.R., & Imamoglu, S. (2009). Muslim-American hyphenated identity: Negotiating a positive path. In Phillips, R. (Ed.), Muslims in the
West: Spaces of Hope (pp. 236-251) London: Zed Books.
Spivak, G. (1988). Can The Subaltern Speak? In C. Nelson & L. Grossberg (Eds.), Marxism & the Interpretation of Culture (pp. 271- 313)
London: Macmillan.
Tyson, L (1999). Critical Theory Today: A User –Friendly Guide. New York: Garland Publishing, Inc.
398
Appraisal of Private Sector Involvement in Infrastructure Development

in Lagos State, Nigeria
Ojuola Olasijibomi Taye

Martin Oloruntobi Dada*
Department of Building, University of Lagos, Lagos, Nigeria

*E-mail: [email protected]
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.399
Abstract: The need for the provision of infrastructure in any developing country cannot be overemphasized as it constitutes the
backbone of the country’s national economy. Considering the importance of infrastructure, government at all levels has often
borne the full responsibility of providing infrastructure via dependence on loans and credits from financial institutions not
recognizing the fact that the investment requirement for the infrastructure deficit is such that cannot possibly be met by relying on
the public sector to boost public investment without increasing public borrowing. To this end, this research sought to appraise the
involvement of the private sector in infrastructure development in Lagos State through the use of the public-private-partnership
(PPP). Questions were asked to investigate the level of awareness about and the use of various models or variants of PPPs.
105 questionnaires were administered on professional firms/agencies (construction consultants, contractors, financing
institutions and concessionaires) that have been or are involved in PPP projects in Lagos state. 66 responses were obtained.
The data was subjected to both descriptive and inferential statistical analysis. The results of the study indicate that the levels of
awareness of private sector involvement in infrastructure development using PPPs as well as the areas of involvement were not
significant. It is recommended that government should put more efforts to improve the level of awareness on the involvement of
the private sector participation in the provision of infrastructure through public enlightenment both locally and internationally
stating the benefits that are obtainable both for citizens and investors.
Key Words: Private Sector, public-private-partnership, Infrastructure, Development, Nigeria.
1. Introduction
A country’s level of social and economic infrastructure constitutes the backbone of the national economy; it
improves human welfare, contributes to economic activities and has considerable potential for directly
reducing poverty (Ogunlana, 2010; DFID, 2007). It also determines to a large extent the type of operating
environment that is available to the production sectors of the economy. It is a fact that the level of
development of these facilities is a measure of the living index for her people according to Dozie (1999) as
cited by Adeniyi (2008). To improve the efficiency and productivity of an economy, it is therefore important to
provide adequate and reliable infrastructural facilities.
The level of awareness is an essential factor in ensuring a successful implementation of any new policy
like the private sector involvement in infrastructure provision. The level of awareness is seemingly too low
going by the scarcity of available relevant literature and limited experience on this type of relationship
(Ikechukwu, 2007) and this may hinder the full productive implementation of the concept as awareness of a
process is the first step at endearing the concerned construction industry professionals and the citizens
(Akintola, 2006) about the possible benefits of its acceptance. People tend to be confusing private sector
participation in infrastructure provision with privatization which is not generally accepted as it received a great
uproar by the citizens of Nigeria (Alabi, 2000). In the words of Andrew Porter of Price Waterhouse Cooper
(PWC) Corporate Finance PPP specialist in Johannesburg (PWC, 2006) as cited in (Adeniyi, 2008) “the initial
reaction to public private sector collaboration in service delivery resulted from the belief that it is a new ploy
by the capitalist to corner public resources”.
According to Ehebha (2011) infrastructure development has in recent times assumed a central importance
in Nigeria’s fight to attain social and economic stability. The federal government and all state governments
399
are using infrastructure as the focal point of their administrations and policy enactments. Infrastructure
generally has to do with the fixed provision of tangible assets on which other intangibles can be built on. Not
limited in scope, it revolves the provision of housing, power (electricity), transport, education, communication,
and technology.
2. Statement of problem
Essentially, the need for the provision of infrastructure in any developing country cannot be overemphasized
as it constitutes the backbone of the country’s national economy. Considering the importance of
infrastructure, government at all levels (local, state and federal) has always borne the full responsibility of
providing infrastructure via dependence on loans and credits from financial institution not recognizing the fact
that the investment requirement for the infrastructure deficit is such that cannot possibly be met by relying on
the public sector to boost public investment without increasing public borrowing. So as to achieve the aim of
introducing private investors into the development of public infrastructure, the level of the public’s awareness
of private sector involvement in infrastructure development must be assessed in addition to the areas of
private sector involvement infrastructure development. As a result, this work seeks to appraise the private
sector involvement in PPP for infrastructure development.
Specifically the study is set out to pursue the following objectives:
1. To determine the level of awareness about private sector involvement in PPP for infrastructure
development.
2. To assess the areas of involvement of the private sector in PPP for infrastructure development in the
economy.
3. Overview
3.1 The concept of PPP
Public-private partnership (PPP) is emerging as an alternative method for the delivery of infrastructure and
services in different parts of the world (Cheung & Chan, 2011; Forrer, Kee & Newcomer, 2010; Sarmento,
2010; Dada & Oladokun, 2008). PPP depicts a government service or private business venture which is
funded and operated through a partnership of government and one or more private sector companies. These
schemes are sometimes referred to as PPP or P3 (Harris, 2008). Typically, a private sector consortium forms
a special company called a special purpose vehicle (SPV) to build and maintain the asset. The consortium is
usually made up of a building contractor, a maintenance company and a bank lender. It is the SPV that signs
the contract with the government and with subcontractors to build the facility and then maintain it. A typical
PPP example would be a hospital building financed and constructed by a private developer and then leased
to the hospital authority. The private developer then acts as landlord, providing housekeeping and other non
medical services while the hospital itself provides medical services (Adeniyi, 2008). Initially, most public-
private partnerships were negotiated individually, as one-off deals. In 1992, however, the Conservative
government of John Major in the United Kingdom introduced the Private Finance Initiative (PFI) (UNISON,
2007) the first systematic program aimed at encouraging public-private partnerships. In the 1992 program,
the main focus was on reducing the Public Sector Borrowing Requirement, although, as already noted, the
effect on the public accounts was largely illusory.
400
3.2 The difference between PPP and privatisation
PPPs must not be confused with privatization. PPPs constitute an approach to introducing private
management into public service by means of a long-term contractual bond between an operator and a public
authority. Fundamentally, it secures all or part of the public service, so delegated by private funding and calls
upon private sector know-how. On the other hand, privatization means transferring a public service or facility
to the private sector, sometimes together with its ancillary activities, for it to be managed in accordance with
market forces and within the framework of an exclusive right granted by a ministerial or parliamentary act (or
sometimes a license). (UN/ECE, 2000)
According to Delloitte (2006) critics of PPP argued that it is just privatization (a process with pejorative
connotations in some places) “by the back door” and some definitions place privatization at one end of a
range with conventional procurement at the other end and PFI type PPP in the middle. It is important to
realize that there are, however, fundamental differences between the two approaches. Privatization is about
taking an existing state owned business, ideally reorganizing it to make it attractive for sale and then
dropping it, some would say dumping it, into the private sector. Done properly, with an accurate assessment
of the size of the assets concerned, a clear objective as to the purpose of the privatization (hopefully
efficiency gains rather than just revenue raising for the government) and sensible pricing to develop
competition this process can produce very positive results for the government and the consumer. However,
many governments, particularly in the developing world, understandably are concerned about the loss of
national assets to a (probably) foreign owned private sector. Essentially, the public sector loses control of the
asset to the private sector except for a certain amount of regulatory control over items such as customer
tariffs. PPP is an entirely different approach to delivering services to or on behalf of the public sector. The
effect of a typical PPP structure is usually to create a single stand-alone business, financed and operated by
the private sector. The purpose is to create the asset and then deliver a service to the public sector client, in
return for payment commensurate with the service levels provided. Rather than taking the existing delivery
mechanism and transplanting it into a wholly different operating environment as in privatization, the PPP
process takes the service delivery back to basics and begins by defining the services to be delivered
specified only in terms of the outputs to be achieved. The key is to specify the output of the service required
and to allow the private sector to determine which inputs are required, including infrastructure and skills, to
achieve that specified output. Because it is the public sector specifying the required output of the private
sector it retains a great deal of control over the standards and type of service to be delivered in a way that a
privatization arrangement does not. In addition, a privatization is, to all intents and purposes, a permanent
arrangement whereas a PPP contract is for an agreed and finite time period. Full operational control and
“ownership” reverts to the public sector at the end of the contract term. It is this temporary nature of the
agreement and the degree of control enjoyed by the public sector, which fundamentally differentiates PPP
from privatization. It is also important to note that there is no need to transfer title of the asset to the private
sector. The state owns the asset throughout the process; there is no “loss” of national assets. It is generally
true; therefore, that PPP is more likely to be suitable for stand-alone projects whilst privatization is more likely
to be suitable for large utilities. However, it is important to remember that roles formerly carried out by state
employees are now likely to be carried out by private sector employees (although they may be state staff
seconded to the private sector operator) and there well may be job losses(Harris 2008).
401
Table 1: Main differences between Conventional public procurement and PPP/concessions
Conventional public procurement PPP/Concession contracts
Definitions Supply, works, or service as defined by Private concessionaire creates facility and
public authority. service on the basis of a negotiated
agreement between public private sectors
Main characteristics Single objective Multiple objectives
Short term Long term
No link to operation Linked to service management
No public project delegation Public mission assignment
• Public authority direct operation • Operation directed by concessionaire
• No prior financing, co-financing or
project financing • Financing, co-financing, mission financing
•No entrepreneurial investment by concessionaire
• No project design freedom • Investment by concessionaire
•Contract does not deal with service • Project/service design freedom
(secondary contract) • Contract deals with service needed by
• Entrepreneur is not project manager public authority (“main contract”)
• No management freedom • Concessionaire is project manager
• No long-term occupancy of public •Concessionaire is free to manage contract

Property • Generally long-term occupancy
Source: United Nations Economic Commission for Europe (2000).
3.3 The construction industry and infrastructure
The construction industry can be defined as that section of the economy responsible for planning, designing,
procurement, construction and delivery of building, civil engineering and public works for government and
private institutions as well as individuals (Osaba, 1993 as cited in Adewuyi, 2004). Seeley (1984) stated that
the construction industry embraces a wide range of loosely integrated organization that collectively
constructs, alters and repairs a wide range of different building and civil engineering structures. Also Willis
(1987) supported that the construction industry is a company organization, which centers on the project
under construction or adaptation.
3.4 Suitable sectors
A PPP approach is suitable for any sector where it is possible to develop a service based on an output
specification. In the United Kingdom (UK), the following sectors are being patronized: Health (hospitals and
clinics), Education (Schools and University accommodation), Justice (prisons and courthouses), Transport
(light rail, roads, bridges), Utilities (water, waste disposal and street-lighting), social housing, defence
(training simulators, sea and land tank transporters) and government buildings. The only sector where it has
not really worked and where the UK government has recommended that no more projects take place is in
Information Technology (UN/ECE2000). This for a number of reasons that include: (1) the speed of change in
the sector making it difficult to define effective long-term outputs;(2) the high level of integration of IT into
other business systems makes it difficult to delineate areas of responsibility and effectively allocate risk; and
(3) the nature of the capital investment with IT project costs dominated by operating costs not up-front
investment. Areas where PPPs have been used include:
402
3.4.1 Transportation
Public-private partnerships have played an increasingly central role in answering the pressing need for new
and well maintained roads, tunnels, bridges, airports, ships, railways, and other forms of transportation.
Internationally, transportation has been far and away the largest area of PPP investment (Doyin, 2006).
3.4.2 Water and Waste Water
The largest European water PPP is in the Netherlands, where the Water Board of Delft land awarded a 30-
year concession, with a total contract value of €1.58 billion. The project includes the design, construction, and
operation of a new wastewater treatment plan and, to comply with more stringent discharge requirements, the
refurbishment and operation of an existing wastewater treatment plant. Water and Wastewater PPPs (Doyin,
2006)
3.4.3 Education
PPPs can deliver substantial innovation to education infrastructure and service delivery. While arrangements
differ, the private sector typically finances, designs, constructs, and operates a public school facility under a
contract with the government for a given time period, for example, 20 to 30 years. At the end of that
concession period, ownership of the school facility transfers to the government. Under typical education PPPs,
the private sector invests in the school infrastructure and provides related non-core services (school transport,
food services, cleaning, and so on), under contract while the government continues to provide core services,
namely, teaching.
3.4.4 Health/Hospitals
In recent years, a number of countries have aggressively moved to diversify the sources of health care funding
by using PPP arrangements to meet the growing demand for health care infrastructure. Typically, a private
consortium designs, builds, owns, and operates a hospital and leases it back to the relevant government
entity—such as a hospital board—for a period of 20 to 60 years. In Portugal, 31 hospitals will be built using
PPPs. The entire program, at an estimated cost of $37 billion, should be complete by 2014, with 10 new
hospitals launched in 2006 (Delloitte, 2006). The contract covers the design, construction, financing,
maintenance, and operation of the facilities as well as hospital management and some clinical services.
3.4.5 Public Housing, Land and Area Development
In Australia and Ireland, the central governments have encouraged the use of concession models in their pilot PPP
public housing projects. But the country with the deepest experience in this sector remains the Netherlands, which
has been applying PPPs to social housing and regeneration projects for nearly two decades. This model proved
quite successful for more than 100 locally initiated projects in the Netherlands (Nijkamp , VanDer Burch & Gabriella,
2002) Joint venture, the most commonly used PPP arrangement for these projects, suits the local governments’
need to retain control over planning and development while utilizing the private partners’ available resources and
expertise. Housing and Development PPPs:
3.4.6 Defence
PPP projects in the defence sector include equipment maintenance and installation, supply chain integration and
operational support, depot maintenance, specialized military training and real estate management (land
403
development, privatized housing and base closures and development). The projects typically are designed to
overcome fiscal constraints, manage life-cycle costs, and reduce pressure on military personnel. The UK Ministry of
Defence has employed various PPP models for more than 56 defence projects—everything from building military
accommodations to training personnel to putting up satellites. Total value: £4.65 billion.
3.4.7 Justice/Prisons
Herizonte (2006) as obtained from (news.bbc.co.uk) reported that Britain currently has 10 prisons run by
private companies, 8 of them built under the PFI. These buildings are leased back to the prison service for a
period of 25 years after being designed and constructed by commercial groups .The results have been
generally positive, as construction times have dropped by more than 40 percent; costs by 20 percent
(http://www.chi.org.uk/pdf/prisonsupport.pdf).
4. Research methods
The research was conducted by an examination of relevant literature and recourse to field investigation. From
the 172 firms and agencies involved in the execution of the various PPP projects executed by the Lagos State
Government as obtained in the course of the research, a sample size of 105 respondents which represents
61% of the firms and agencies were employed based on non probabilistic sampling. Survey research design
which was cross-sectional in nature was employed with the aid of questionnaires and interviews as the
research instruments for the study. Well structured questionnaire after the objectives of the study coupled with
personal interviews with professionals representing the professional firms or agencies (i.e. Builders, Quantity
Surveyors, Architects, Engineers and Estate Surveyors), financial institutions and concessionaires were used.
The questionnaires requested biographical information about the respondent organisations. It also sought to
know the level of awareness of respondent organisations about the involvement of the private sector in PPP
for infrastructural development. The levels of measure were from 1= ‘not aware’ to 5 = ‘strongly aware’. Areas
where the private sector has also been involved in infrastructural provision were also requested. The level of
involvement of the private sector in infrastructure provision was also used. The levels of measure were from 1
= ‘not involved’ to 5 = ‘highly involved’.
78 questionnaires were distributed to professional establishments (Quantity Surveying {26}, Architectural
{12}, Building {8}, Estate Surveying {2} and Engineering {30}). Financial institutions received 18 and
concessionaires received 9 so as to obtain information from a good size of the sample frame. At certain times
during the course of this report, the researchers were obligated to seek information on the subject matter
through interviews with some respondents when given the opportunity. This way, the researchers were able to
understand answers given both to the open and closed-ended questions posed to the respondents. Due to the
fact that some of the questions in the questionnaire were left unanswered by some respondents coupled with
the fact that some of the questionnaires got missing probably as a result of carelessness on the part of
respondents, the breakdown of the properly filled questionnaire which represents 62.85% of the total
questionnaire properly completed is provided below: The analysis of the collected data was carried out using
descriptive and inferential statistical methods. Tables 2 to 10 indicate some aspects of the results of the
descriptive statistical analysis.
5. Analysis and results
5.1 Descriptive analysis
404
Table 2: Type of firms/Agencies
Firms/agencies Frequency Percentage

Building 3 4.50
Quantity Surveying 18 27.30
Architecture 10 15.20
Engineering 24 36.40
Estate Surveying 1 1.50
Concessionaire 6 9.10
Bank 4 6.00
Total 66 100.00
Table 2 shows that 4.50% of responses were obtained from Building firms, 27.30% of them are Quantity
Surveying firms, 15.20% of the sample are Architectural firms, 36.40% of the respondents are engineering
firms, and 9.10% of them are Concessionaire while the remaining 6.00% of the respondents are Bank
representatives.
Table 3 indicates the number of years of experience of respondents
Table 3: Number of years of experience of respondents
Years of work experience Frequency Percentage (%)

1 -5 yrs 36 54.50
6 -10 yrs 20 30.30
11 - 20 yrs 10 15.20
21 - 30 yrs - -
above 30 yrs - -
Total 66 100.00
In terms of years of working experience, it was discovered that 54.5% of the respondents have worked for
between 1 – 5 years, 30.3% of them have worked for between 6 – 10 years while the remaining 15.2% of the
respondents have between 11 – 20 years of working experience.
Table 4 reports on the level of awareness of respondents about PPP as a method of project delivery
Table 4: Awareness about Public-Private Partnership as a method of project delivery
Frequency Percentage (%)

Slightly aware 54 81.80
Aware 7 10.60
Strongly aware 5 7.60
Total 66 100
Table 4 shows that 81.8% of the sample is slightly aware of the public –private partnership which was defined
as a method of project procurement that entails a cooperative venture between a government service and a
private sector company, 10.6% are aware while the remaining 7.6% of the sample are strongly aware.
Table 5 indictes the awareness of respondents about parties involved in PPP projects.
405
Table 5: Awareness about parties involved in PPP arrangement.
Level of awareness Frequency Percentage (%)

Aware 17 25.80
Total 66 100
From Table 5, it is observed that 3% of the respondents are strongly aware that government and a private
company are always the parties involved in any public-private partnership arrangement, 25.8% of them are
aware while the remaining 71.2% are slightly aware.
Table 6 indicates the level of awareness about various models of PPP
Table 6: Awareness about various models of Public-Private Partnership.

Strongly unaware 63 95.50
Unaware 1 1.50
Aware 1 1.50
Total 66 100
In terms of the various models of public private partnership, 95.50% said they are strongly unaware of the
various models, 1.5% are unaware, 1.5% are aware while the remaining 95.5% of the sample said they are
strongly aware of the various model of public – private partnership.
Table 7 indicates level of awareness about concession as a way of government granting an entity exclusive right
Table 7: Awareness about concession as a way of government granting an entity exclusive right

Aware 4 6.10
Total 66 100
On collating the respondents’ definition of concession as a process whereby the government grants a private
entity exclusive right to provide, operate and maintain an asset over a long period of time in accordance with
performance requirements set forth by the government, it was discovered that 1.5% are slightly aware of the
definition, 6.1% of them are aware while the remaining 92.4% of the respondents are strongly aware of the
definition.
Table 8 indicates the awareness about employing private sector in infrastructure provision in only few
sectors
406
Table 8: Awareness about employing private sector in infrastructure provision in only few sectors
Unaware 11 16.70
Aware 1 1.50
Total 66 100
Table 8 reveals that 69.7% of the respondents are strongly unaware of the fact that private sector can only
be employed in infrastructure provision in only a few sector, 16.7% were unaware, 12.1% are slightly
aware while the remaining 1.5% said they are aware.
Table 9 indicates level of awareness about the concept of privatization as a process of transferring a
public service to the private sector
Table 9: Privatization as a process of transferring a public service to the private sector
Level of
awareness Frequency Percentage (%)
Unaware 13 19.70
Aware 3 4.50
No response 1 1.50
Total 66 100
The responses on the definition of privatization were collated from which it was observed that 68.2% of the
sample was strongly unaware of the definition, 19.7% are unaware, 6.1% of them are slightly aware, and
4.5% said they are aware of the definition while the remaining 1.5% did not answer the question.
One of the questions was structured to establish the extent of involvement of respondents identified in the
study population in the use of PPP. Table 10 shows the results.
Table 10: Number of PPP projects respondents have been involved in
Project Frequency Percentage (%)

1-5 Projects 57 86.40
6-10Projects 9 13.60
Total 66 100.0
Table 10 shows that 86.4% of the respondents have been involved in PPP projects ranging from a
minimum of 1 to a maximum of 5 while the remaining 13.6% of them have been involved in such projects
ranging from a minimum of 6 to a maximum of 10 projects. It is worthy of note that the involvement of this
respondents is at any stage of the construction/building process and it is also possible for 2 or more
professionals to be involved in the same project.
Table 11 shows areas of private sector involvement in infrastructure development
407
Table 11: Areas of private sector involvement in infrastructure development
Sectors of Involvement N Mean Ranking

Education 23 4.26 1
Transportation 64 4.08 2
Tourism 47 3.38 3
Housing 45 2.89 4
Security 59 2.76 5
Agriculture 49 2.10 6
Sport 41 2.10 6
Commerce / industry 56 2.09 8
Health 46 1.59 9
Power/Electricity 64 1.59 9
Communication 51 1.47 11
Water 56 1.36 12
Judiciary 52 1.00 13
In terms of the frequency of private sector participation in infrastructural development in Lagos state, it was
discovered that the private sector have been most involved in the educational sector which ranked 1st, in
the 2nd position is the transportation sector, rated 3rd is the tourism sector of the economy. For the three
sectors that respondents has experienced least participation, it was observed that Judiciary was rated least
with a ranking of 13, next was the water sector ranked 12th, in the position of third least sector of PPP
involvement in infrastructural development is the communication sector with 11th position.
5.2. Inferential statistical analysis
5.2.1 Test of hypotheses
Two hypotheses were set up for this study. The first one tests for awareness about the use of PPP in
infrastructure development while the second one investigates the level of use of PPP for infrastructural
development.
Hypothesis One
Null (Ho): There is no significant awareness about PPP for infrastructural development
Alternative (H1): There is significant awareness about PPP for infrastructural development
In order to carry out this analysis, the average of the items that measures the level of awareness of the
respondent organisations about the use of PPP for infrastructural development were collated and used to
carry out the analysis.
Table 12 shows the results of the statistical test
Table 12: One sample t-test of level of awareness
Test Value = 2.5

t df Sig. (2-tailed) Mean Difference Lower Upper
Awareness 40.473 65 .213 1.63333 1.5527 1.7139
408
In accordance with the decision rule in statistics, the null hypothesis is rejected when the p-value of the
analysis is greater than the level of significance at which the test was carried out and the alternative should
be accepted when the p-value is less than the level of significance of the test. In this case the p-value is
0.213 which is greater than 0.05 (level of significance), hence the decision to accept the null hypothesis
which invariably means there is no significant awareness of private sector involvement in infrastructural
development.
Hypothesis Two
H0: There is no significant involvement of stakeholder/respondent organisations in the use of PPP for
infrastructural development
H1: There is significant involvement of stakeholder/ respondent organisations in the use of PPP for
infrastructural development
In order to carry out this analysis, the average of the items that measured the level of
infrastructural development was computed and used to carry out the analysis; the descriptive
statistics is presented below.
Table 13: One sample t-test of infrastructure development
Test Value = 2.5

t df Sig. (2-tailed) Mean Difference Lower Upper
Infrastructure -4.100 65 .103 -.21554 -.3205 -.1105
In this case the p-value (significance at two-tailed) is 0.103 which is greater than the level of significance of
0.05, hence the null hypothesis is accepted which means that the private sector does not involve
significantly in infrastructure development.
5.3. Discussion of findings
It was revealed that only few professionals have handled projects under the delivery system which is as a
result of the government poor attitude of enlightening the citizenry on the benefits of engaging the private
sector in infrastructural development as well as providing the needed legislation guiding private sector
involvement so as to encourage the private sector, this concurred with Akintola (2006) who in a research
conducted found out that that lack of legislation and adequate enlightenment hinders the full productive
implementation of any concept as awareness of a process is the first step at endearing the concerned
construction industry professionals and the citizens about the possible benefits of its acceptance.
Furthermore, the level of awareness is an essential factor in ensuring a successful implementation of any
new policy like the private sector participation in infrastructure provision. This is in agreement with
Ikechukwu (2007) who in a research carried-out establish that the level of awareness is seemingly too low
going by the scarcity of available relevant literatures and limited experience. It was further observed that
there is no significant awareness of private sector involvement in infrastructural development.
The study revealed that education and transportation received the highest patronage i.e. projects like
road, airport, seaport, bus terminus, hostels, and similar ones are more attractive to the private sector
presently due to the return mechanism put in place as both the public and private sector have established
ways of recouping their capital via toll and rent within a specified period. This finding corroborated Olaloku,
Adejugbe, Fajana and Tomori (1979) who in their work submitted that the private investor is traditionally
profit oriented and are interested in Directly Productive Activities (DPA). It was observed that investors were
409
not involved in almost all sectors due to the substantial procurement cost with relatively small returns
compared to the investment in-addition to the possibility of future changes in policy and demographic shift.
This also supports one of the findings of Forrer et al (2011) where costs and benefits were part of the
factors in a model on PPP performance. Furthermore, in a bid to encourage investors into more of the
sectors there must be flexibility as well as paying careful attention to lifecycle costing. In addition, this
research indicates that the private sector was not significantly involved in infrastructural development in
Lagos state.
6. Summary, conclusions and recommendations
6.1 Summary of findings
The study was centered on private sectors involvement in infrastructure development in Lagos state. The
study revealed the following:
1. Most professionals had idea about the concept as they have been involved in at least one project
where any of the PPP model was employed as a means to delivering infrastructure.
2. The private sectors participation is mainly in two sector of the economy they are education,
transportation and partially in tourism sector.
3. The level of awareness of PPP is still insignificant despite government effort to get the private
sector involved in the provision of infrastructure.
4. The involvement of the private sector in infrastructural development is very insignificant as there is
a great concentration on a particular sector while other sectors are left unattended to.
6.2 Conclusions
The study investigated the level of awareness about, and the areas and the extent of use of the private sector
in PPP for provision of infrastructure in Lagos State, Nigeria. The study revealed that despite government’s
effort to get the private sector involved in the provision of infrastructure in Lagos state, the level of awareness
about and use of private sector involvement in infrastructural development was not significant. Furthermore, it
was revealed that the involvement of the private sector in infrastructural development was not significant
considering the fact that there is a great concentration on a particular sector due to adequate ways employed
in generating income while other sectors were left unattended to as a result of little or no establishment of
ways required to yield income. The study results from the analysis of responses further indicate that, in Lagos
State, the sectors that ranked highest (first, second and third respectively) with private sector participation
through PPP in the delivery of public infrastructure are education, transportation and tourism. Additionally,
there was no private sector involvement in the judicial sector(with least ranking) as well but very minimal
involvement in the areas of portable water provision, the reason being that both the government and the
private sector were yet to formulate ways of yielding income from the said sectors. Stakeholders expressed
opinions that Public Private Partnership model remained an initiative that can best be employed in tackling
the growing complex and multifunctional issues in building infrastructure projects as well as to help meet the
demands for creative, functional and efficient delivery of projects. It was also viewed that the strategy also
allows private investors to participate in profitable social development projects through partnership with the
public sector.
6.3 Recommendations
Based on the conclusion drawn above, the following recommendations are hereby proposed:
410
1. The government should put more efforts to improve the level of awareness on the involvement of the
private sector participation in the provision of infrastructure through public enlightenment both locally and
internationally stating the benefits that are obtainable both for citizens and investors.
2. Government should demonstrate a sure touch in assessing the return that is required by the private sector
in return for taking responsibility for risk considering the fact that if expected returns from a project are too low
bidders will divert their skills and resources to other more attractive projects in different countries and
jurisdictions. The government and the private sectors should fashion out adequate and improved means of
generating income from every sector of the economy so as to encourage private sector involvement
considering the fact that no investor would invest in a sector where their investments cannot be recouped.
This can be achieved via adequate training and development of contributing parties more especially the local
talents in the area and structuring of competence.
3. Government should modify the traditional relationship between infrastructure and profit making as the
desire of every private investor is a worthy return, thereby turning a traditionally indirectly profitable activity
into a directly profitable activity and to the satisfaction of all parties involved.
References
Adeniyi, O. (2008). Assessment of Public Private Partnership in Infrastructural Development, B. Tech Project (Unpublished), Federal
University of Technology, Akure, Nigeria.
Adewuyi, A. (2004). Effect of government Economic policies on Construction Industry in Nigeria, PGD Thesis (Unpublished), Federal
University of Technology Akure, Nigeria.
Akintola, A.A. (2006). Problems and Prospect of the Adoption of E-Tendering in Nigerian Construction Industry, B. Tech Project
(Unpublished), Federal University of Technology Akure, Nigeria.
Alabi, K. (2000). Why Nigeria lags in construction. Civil and Engineering Policy Magazine,
July 24-30, 1, 10.
Cheung, E. & Chan, A.P. C. (2011). Evaluation model for assessing the suitability of PPP projects. Journal of Management in
Engineering, 27 (2), 80-89
Dada, M.O., & Oladokun, G. (2008). Critical Success factors in public-private-Partnership projects in Nigeria: A perceptual Survey’’ in
Karter, C., Ogunlana, S.O., and Kaka, A. (Eds.), Transformation through construction: Joint 2008 CIB W065/055 Symposium
proceedings, Herriot Watt University, Edinburgh, pp. 1-10.
Deloitte Research, (2006). Closing the Infrastructure Gap: The Role of Public-Private Partnerships. Available from: www.deloitte.com
(Accessed 5th June, 2011)
Department for International Development (2007). Private Sector participation in Infrastructure Development. Available from:
www.dfid.gov.uk/pubs/files (Accessed 2nd October, 2011)
Doyin, A. (2006). Solutions to International Challenges in PPP Model Selection: A Cross- sectoral Analysis, paper prepared for Deloitte
Research and the London School of Economics, March 13, 2006.
Ehebha, L.R. (2011). An Appraisal of Performance of Public Private Partnership in Provision of Infrastructural Facilities in South Western
Nigeria, Master of Project Management Project (Unpublished), University of Lagos, Lagos.
Forrer, J., Kee. J.E., & Newcomer, K.E. (2010). Public Private Partnerships and the public accountability question. Public Administration
Review, May/June, pp 475-484
Harris, S. (2008). Public Private Partnerships: Delivering Better Infrastructure Services International Financial Services, London.
Retrieved February 1, 2011, from www.ifsl.org
Herizonte, B. (2006). Infrastructure in Latin America, Slow! Government Obstacle ahead. The Economist, Vol. 41, pp 4-18.
Ikechukwu, S. (2007). Public Private Partnership for accelerating infrastructure development in Nigeria. A paper presented at a 2 day
regional workshop for Stakeholders on Public Private Partnership in West Africa held at The Nigerian Universities Commission
Auditorium, Abuja from 12 to 13 October, 2007.
Nijkamp P., VanDer Burch M., & Gabriella V., (2002). “A Comparative Institutional Evaluation of Public Private Partnership in Dutch
Urban Land-use and Revitalization Projects.”Urban Studies, 39, 1865-1880.
Ogunlana, S.O. (2010, February). Sustaining 20:20:20 Vision through construction: A stakeholder participatory approach. Being a
lecture delivered under the distinguished lecture series of the School of Post-Graduate Studies, University of Lagos in February
10, 2010.
Olaloku O., Adejugbe F., Fajana O., & Tomori A., (1979). Structure of Nigerian Economy; Macmillan Press Ltd, Lagos.
Sarmento, J.M. (2010). Do PPPs create value for money for the public sector? The Portuguese experience OECD Journal on Budgeting,
2010/1, 93-119
Seeley, I.H. (1984). Quantity Surveying Practice. London, Macmillan Press Ltd.
411
The Private Stake in the UK’s Prison,” BBC News, Retrieved June 4 2006, (http:// news.bbc.co.uk/hi/English/static/in-
depth/uk/2001/prison_ppp/ default.stm).
United Nations Economic Commission for Europe UN/ECE (2000). “Guidelines on Private Public Partnerships for Infrastructure
development”. A paper presented at United Nations Economic, Geneva.
UNISON (2005). Overview of Public Private Partnerships in the UK retrieved March 10, 2011 from http://www.unison.org.uk/pfi/
Willis, C.J. (1987). Practice and Procedure for Quantity Surveyor 9th edition London Press, London.
412
Translating Dialect: a Comparative Study of the Novels of Luigi Pirandello
Dr. Mirela Papa
Docente di Traduzione e Interpretariato

Università di Tirana
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.413
Abstract Typically, the dialect is used in a smaller area than the language, which it seems to be diffused in a wider area.
Dialects have always been the subject of reflection on the difficulty to finding the linguistic equivalence into the LT. The use of
dialect in a literary work by a writer is always intentioned and meaningful. To comply with the intentio auctoris the translator must
choose between the different approaches offered by the critics of translation even if it may not lead to a satisfactory solution.This
paper will examine the translations of the novels of the Italian writer, Luigi Pirandello into Albanian language. The aim is to
identify the strategies used by translators to infer expressions and terms which the Italian writer has used in the related dialect
into the Albanian language.
Keywords: translation, literary work, dialects.
Tradurre il dialetto: studio comparatistico dei romanzi di Luigi Pirandello
1. Introduzione
In genere il dialetto è usato in un’area più circoscritta rispetto alla lingua, la quale invece appare diffusa in
un’area più vasta (Dardano&Trifone 1997).
Propriamente il termine dialetto (dal greco diàlektos “lingua”. Derivato dal verbo dialégomai “parlo”) indica
due diverse realtà:
1. un sistema linguistico autonomo rispetto alla lingua nazionale, quindi un sistema che ha caratteri strutturali
e una storia distinti rispetto a quelli della lingua nazionale (per esempio i dialetti italiani, spagnoli);
2. una varietà parlata della lingua nazionale, cioè una varietà dello stesso sistema; per esempio i dialects
dell’anglo-americano sono varietà parlate dell’inglese degli Stati Uniti; ovviamente tali “dialetti” hanno gli
stessi caratteri strutturali e la stessa storia della lingua nazionale (Dardano&Trifone 1997).
L’uso del dialetto in un’opera letteraria da parte di uno scrittore è sempre intenzionato.
Il corpus del nostro studio viene costituito da 3 romanzi di Luigi Pirandello tradotti nella lingua albanese.
Precisamente si tratta di:
1999, L’esclusa (Marta Ajala), traduttore Zija Vukaj, casa editrice Elite, Tirana.
2000, Il fu Mattia Pascal (Tre herë vetëvrasës), traduttore Sabah Ramja, casa editrice Helena Kadare,
Shkodër.
2001, Uno, nessuno e centomila (Një, asnjë dhe njëqind mijë), traduttore Zija Vukaj, casa editrice Elite,
Tirana.
2002, Uno, nessuno e centomila (Një, asnjë dhe njëqind mijë), traduttore Dritan Çela, casa editrice Sejko,
Elbasan.
2003, Il fu Mattia Pascal (I ndjeri Matia Paskal), traduttore Violanda Canko, casa editrice Elena Gjika, Tirana.
2. Riflessioni teoriche
Le varietà diatopiche sono state sempre oggetto di riflessioni per la difficoltà che rappresentano nel trovare
413
un’equivalenza linguistica. Rosa Rabadán esclude in maniera categorica la possibilità dell’equivalenza. La

critica pensa che si tratti di uno di quegli argomenti problematici per i quali non esistono soluzioni
soddisfacenti.
Si offrono comunque delle varie soluzioni a proposito. La prima possibilità è la traduzione del dialetto con
la varietà standard o neutrale della lingua d’arrivo. Questa possibilità permette di trasferire il significato
semantico del testo originale, però si produce una perdita di tono e di ricchezza espressiva, specialmente se
la varietà linguistica è importante nella costruzione delle identità (Carbonell i Cortes, 1999: 92). Per
alleggerire un po’ questa perdita, si intromette una glossa intratestuale (del tipo “detto in dialetto”) oppure
extratestuale (nota a piè di pagina) in modo da informare il lettore che un personaggio parla in una
determinata varietà.
La seconda possibilità consiste nella traduzione o la sostituzione del dialetto originale con un dialetto
specifico della lingua d’arrivo. Catford e Julià sostengono la traduzione del dialetto come possibilità di
conservare la ricchezza funzionale che esiste tra le varietà geografiche del testo d’origine. La critica esclude
questa possibilità. Lefevere (1992: 69-70) ritiene che le connotazioni prodotte dalle varietà linguistiche negli
utenti della traduzione di solito sono assai differenti; a questo va aggiunto il fatto che la scelta del dialetto
nella lingua d’arrivo può essere condizionata da qualche approccio ideologico del traduttore. (Lefevere 1997:
78).
La terza possibilità invece prende come punto di partenza la varietà standard della lingua d’arrivo e
suggerisce di sottometterla ad un processo di manipolazione introducendo vari elementi a diversi livelli
(lessico-semantico e morfosintassi) per dimostrare al lettore che alcuni personaggi parlano in un modo
particolare e diverso dalla forma considerata standard.
Occorre dire che nessuna delle tre opzioni non assicura la mancanza della perdita dell’espressione o del
tono.
Ciascun testo poi ha le sue peculiarità e la sua relazione con il contesto di partenza e quello d’arrivo
suggerisce la traduzione più o meno adeguata per poter ridurre le perdite. Nella scelta della strategia bisogna
prendere in considerazione sia gli aspetti linguistici, sia quelli contestuali. Per di più bisogna analizzare il
contesto della ricezione della traduzione sul quale influenzano fattori importanti tra cui la situazione
linguistica della comunità per la quale si traduce. Bisogna prendere in considerazione anche la situazione
della cultura d’arrivo, se viene caratterizzata dalla presenza di molte varietà linguistiche, riconosciute e
accettate, oppure se, al contrario, si tratta di una comunità monolingue.
La situazione delle varietà geografiche in Albania differisce da quella italiana. In Albania si nota la
presenza di soli due dialetti che geograficamente si dividono dal fiume Shkumbin. A destra di Shkumbin si
estendono le regioni in cui si parla il dialetto del nord o il dialetto geg, mentre alla sua sinistra si estendono le
regioni che parlano il dialetto del sud ossia il dialetto tosco (Gjinari&Shkurtaj 2009). Tenendo conto che: «...il
linguaggio letterario albanese è costruito sulla base base della fonologia e fonetica del dialetto tosco...(...)...
Ovviamente, in questa lingua standard unificata sono entrate e continuano ad entrare anche non pochi
elementi del dialetto gego e questo è un processo delle trasformazioni della comunità sociale alanese e
conseguenza dei movimenti e delle numerose trasformazioni demografiche e sociali culturali...»
È importante inoltre prendere in considerazione la situazione letteraria: se la letteratura autoctona
suggerisce la tendenza della normalizzazione linguistica e se gli scrittori rifiutano l’uso delle varietà non
standard, il pubblico non sarà abituato ad averne a che fare, e questo contribuisce a creare delle determinate
aspettative linguistiche, e per questo, delle determinate strategie nella traduzione.
Per quanto riguarda la tradizione della scrittura in dialetto, in Albania negli anni del regime comunista
viene imposto agli scrittori l’uso della lingua standard e viene represso ogni tentativo di ricorrere all’uso del
dialetto nelle opere letterarie. Perciò la tradizione richiede l’uso della lingua standard e non del dialetto.
414
3. Pirandello e il dialetto
Pirandello, educato in un ambiente della filologia romanica, si prende cura del dialetto come prezioso
strumento con il quale arricchire la lingua italiana, per rinnovare una lingua morta e sostituire le deformità
della retorica. Il dialetto è capace di dare vivacità alla lingua. La ricerca della naturalità espressiva è una
costante dello stile pirandelliano. Dall’analisi delle traduzioni dei suoi tre romanzi che costituiscono anche il
corpus del nostro studio notiamo l’uso dei tre dialetti: siciliano, toscano e quello piemontese.
3.1 Il dialetto siciliano
La parlata siciliana, debitamente strutturata, non è per lui, come per il Verga, “la lingua degli angeli” per usare
un’espressione del Russo; ma solo un punto di passaggio, obbligato, per giungere, secondo il suo ideale,
all’adozione di uno stile, che, assorbendo in sé il succo di tutti i dialetti, li risolva in una forma superiore”.
Verga così penetra dall’interno il dialetto siciliano, vi si adagia con tutti i suoi disegni, Pirandello, invece, ne
resta fuori: se vi entra è solo momentaneamente e col cuore rivolto a un paese lontano, senza
denominazione né confini (Puglisi 1968: 118).
S’è parlato di verismo a proposito di lui e anche opportunamente (Momigliano 1960: 619), ma il vero
Pirandello non è, come per il Verga, quello che appare ai sensi, sebbene quello che si rivela al sentimento
nella sua doppia faccia. L’essere, che per gli altri, per il Verga, è realtà, per lui è illusione; reale per lui è solo
il divenire. Ciò che è non pare, e ciò che pare non è! C’è sempre questo intento in lui di rivelare l’essere di là
dell’apparire, di mettere a fuoco questo con quello, in modo da farne scaturire il contrasto e con esso i lati,
triste e comico, della vita.
Si deve a tutto questo complesso di ragioni, se Pirandello per un lato s’accosta al dialetto della Sicilia e
per un altro ne rimane sdegnosamente lontano.
In Verga hai il poeta, che, prima di dare inizio alla sua opera, getta nella stessa fornace la lingua sua e
quella dei suoi personaggi, e ne fa una lingua sola; in Pirandello hai l’artista che mescola, sì, non fonde, lo
stile suo con quello delle sue creature, ma con la segreta speranza di spremere da quest’ultimo solo la parte
sostanziosa onde farla passare nell’altro e renderlo più vitale. Nella prosa del Verga non noti alcuno distacco,
alcuna dissonanza: la forma aderisce al contenuto sempre, puntualmente, in quella di Pirandello avverti non
poche stonature (Puglisi 1968: 119).
E non solo i termini, si tenga presente, stridono tra loro per la diversa fattura e provenienza, ma le
costruzioni stesse della proposizione, del periodo, si trovano non di rado a disagio nella prosa pirandelliana
(Puglisi 1968: 122).
Più che un accordo in Pirandello, tra la lingua dotta e quella dialettale, quell’accordo che c’è in Capuana,
nel Verga massimamente, c’è un compromesso. Si direbbe ch’egli conceda, sì, ai suoi personaggi la facoltà
di parlare nel loro dialetto, ma tosto li ferma per far passare sottobanco nel loro frasario qualche termine suo,
quasi li volesse abituare a poco a poco a parlare la lingua madre (Puglisi 1968: 123).
Il provincialismo – dice bene il Russo – in Pirandello è una moda di ritorno, solo che nello studio della sua
opera non ci si dovrebbe fermare a questo secondo momento della sua attività, e paragonarlo, a tutto scapito
dello scrittore agrigentino, con quello convulsivo del Verga. Il vero mondo di Pirandello con la forma che lo
riguarda non è qui: la Sicilia con l’influenza ch’essa esercita sulla sua formazione è una tappa obbligata della
sua maturazione, una tappa che non si può passare sotto silenzio da chi voglia avere nitido il quadro del suo
processo artistico, ma che non si deve considerare come la sua meta ultima: sarebbe come mettere spalla a
spalla, per confrontarne la statura, un fanciullo di dieci anni e un uomo di trenta. La forma dialettale, così
come entra nella prosa di Pirandello, ab extra, non può non inficiarla. Ecco, ci sono esclamazioni, modi di
dire, propri dei Siciliani, ma, siamo sempre lì, cacciati a forza all’interno del periodo, del discorso, e che
restano pertanto soli, soli, spauriti (Puglisi 1968: 126).
415
Cos’è che resta dunque della Sicilia nello stile di Pirandello? Non il vocabolario (...), non la sintassi ben
presto superata, ma il fremito, l’ansito come direbbe lui, il nervosismo dei Siciliani che si ripercuote sul loro
linguaggio, a scatti, convulso, mai pago di sé, che fa ricorso alla mimica per completarsi e che rimane,
malgrado ciò, in aria il più delle volte (...) (Puglisi 1968: 719).
Ecco alcuni esempi tratti dai suoi romanzi.
Mattia Pascal
- Me ne vado, e salute a voi.
- Po iki e të rrini me shëndet. (RAMJA, VII, 72)
- Po iki, mbetshi me shëndet. (CANKO, VII, 68)
«Salute a voi» espressione scopertamente siciliana (Pirandello 1993) che ricorda al lettore l’ambiente
siciliano.
- Sono brutto? E là: brutto bene, di cuore, senza misericordia. Che ne dice?
- I shëmtuar? Në rregull! Me gjithë zemër e pa hidhërim. Ç’thoni? (RAMJA, XI, 130)
- Nuk më shohin dot me sy? Le të mos më shohin: jam një përbindësh i shpifur, por
shpirtmirë e s’kam nevojë për mëshirë. Si thoni? (CANKO, XI, 124)
«Brutto bene» espressione di colore dialettale per «molto brutto».
... non tiravo più fiato.

Mezi merrja frymë. (RAMJA, XVIII, 227)
... më zihet fryma. (CANKO, XVIII, 215)
Espressione di sapore dialettale per «non avevo più fiato»
- Che se poi, con le buone, non riesci a vincerlo, niente paura: un bel volo dal nido, e
s’aggiusta ogni cosa. (IV)
- ... Po qe se nuk arrin ta bindësh, fluturo nga çerdhja e ndreqet gjithçka. (RAMJA, IV,
29)
- E tek e fundit, në nuk e bind dot me të mirë, bëje me pahir mos të të dridhet qerpiku: një
ta rrëmbyer e një të fluturuar nga çerdhja dhe kështu i vihet kapaku kësaj pune.
(CANKO, IV, 29)
«Volo dal nido» uno dei passi che più vistosamente “tradiscono” la sicilianità dell’ambiente dell’opera. Alla
fuga o al simulato rapimento si ricorreva nel Sud, come è noto, per rendere possibili le unioni contrastate.
io andrò via, e sarà come non ci avessimo mai conosciuto...

do të ik e do jetë, sikur mos të ishim parë... (RAMJA, XVIII, 235)
unë do të largohem dhe zëre se nuk jemi njohur kurrë... (CANKO, XVIII, 223)
La sintassi risente qui del dialetto, poiché l’italiano corretto richiederebbe l’uso dell’ausiliare “essere” (“come
se non ci fossimo mai conosciuti”).
Per quanto riguarda la strategia adoperata da parte dei traduttori è la stessa: traduzione nella lingua
standard. In questo modo si trasmette il significato semantico, ma non viene rievocato l’ambiente siciliano
che è anche l’intenzione dell’autore.
Uno, nessuno e centomila
Anche in questo romanzo si nota la presenza di alcune parole del dialetto siciliano.
...una pinna di naso.
416
... një flegër hunde. (ÇELA, Libri i parë, II, 13)

... një flegër hunde. (VUKAJ, Libri i parë, II, 15)
«Una pinna di naso» è un uso dialettale per dire punta di naso = maja e hundës. La strategia del traduttore è
quella dell’uso delle parole della lingua standard, anche se in questo specifiko caso di tratta di un errore nella
traduzone.
- Ecco: dicono le donne del popolo che quando a un nato i capelli terminano sulla nuca in
un codiniccio come codesto che tu hai costì, sarà maschio il nato appresso.
- Ta them unë: gratë e urta thonë se, kur një pinjolli flokët i përfundojnë mbi qafë në një
bishtuk si ky që ke ti këtu, do të jetë djalë fëmija i ardhshëm. (ÇELA, Libri i parë, II, 13)
- Ja: gratë e thjeshta thonë se, kur një fëmije të sapolindur i përfundojnë flokët mbi zverk,
në një bishtëz si ai që ti ke këtu, do të jetë mashkull ai që lind pas tij. (VUKAJ, Libri i
parë, II, 16)
«Codiniccio» è una parola del dialetto siciliano che vuol dire codino = bishtalec. Nella novela “Le nonne”, del
1920, si parla di un codino di capelli, fatto da streghe, “che guaj a tagliarli o a cercar di districarli”.
La strategia dei traduttori è quella della traduzione con parole dell’albanese standard. In questo modo si
trasmette il significato semantico, però non ri rievoca l’ambiente siciliano che è anche l’intenzione dell’autore.
M’ero mogio mogio, rinchioccito tra le gonnelle di Dida...

Isha kruspullosur, urtë e butë, mes fundeve të Didës... (ÇELA, Libri i Pestë, II, 110)
Isha si pulë e lagur, i skuqur mes fustaneve të Didës... (VUKAJ, Libri i Pestë, II, 124)
«Rinchioccito» è un termine dialettale che significa “rannicchiato, come un pulcino sotto l’ala protettrice della
chioccia”. Nella traduzione viene dato con un termine dell’albanese standard.
L’Esclusa
Mi minchioni?
Tallesh me mua? (Pjesa e dytë, Kapitulli i njëmbëdhjetë, 173)
Il verbo appartiene alla parlata popolare del dialetto siciliano e vuol dire canzonare, prendere in giro.
Gira gira, alle corna. La parte era quella, doveva esser quella.
Rrotullo, rrotullo brirë! Ky ishte fati, ky duhej të ishte. (Pjesa e parë, Kapitulli i dhjetë, 77)
Io, di corna negozio.

Unë, me brirë merrem. (Pjesa e parë, Kapitulli i dhjetë, 77)
Fece con una mano le corna e le agitò in aria.

Bëri me njërën dorë brirët dhe i tundi në ajër. (Pjesa e parë, Kapitulli i parë, 13)
Nella lingua popolare, con ironia, specialmente nel plurale si usa per colui che è vittima di un tradimento
del/della consorte o della persona a cui si è legati sentimentalmente.
Per quante riguardo alla strategia usata dal traduttore, è la traduzione con termini dell’albanese standard.
In questo modo si trasmette il significato semantico, ma non si rievoca l’ambiente siciliano.
3.2 Il dialetto toscano
Il dialetto toscano insieme a quello siciliano costituiscono la fonte più ricca per quanto riguarda le parole
dialettali del lessico pirandelliano. Ci sembra perciò adeguato riportare il panorama linguistico dell’Italia
nell’epoca in cui Pirandello scrisse le sue opere.
Importante per l’influenza esercitata sulla lingua è il famoso Proemio scritto da Ascoli nel 1872 per il primo
volume dell’Archivio Glottologico italiano (1873). Lo studio dell’eloquenza lascerà poco a poco il posto allo
417
studio critico della letteratura. Mezzo secolo di unità nazionale non bastava, logicamente, per unificare la
lingua scritta e tanto meno quella orale. Però nelle varie regioni del Nord e del Sud e, specialmente nelle
città, si usa sempre di più la lingua nazionale accanto al dialetto. I primi decenni della vita del nuovo regno
saranno pervasi dalle discussioni sulla lingua. Manzoni sosterrà la tesi fiorentina: sostenuta da alcuni e
criticata da altri. L’arrivo del nuovo secolo servirà a calmare le anime.
Comunque è innegabile il fatto che l’introduzione delle parole nella lingua scritta e quella orale è molto
forte dopo l’unificazione politica specialmente negli anni quando Firenze era capoluogo del regno (1865-
1871). Per scrittori toscani quali: Fucini, Collodi, Martini ecc. è facile e spontaneo l’adozione delle parole o
delle espressioni del dialetto toscano parlato. Quelli che non sono di Toscana per seguire il modello, spesso
esagerano, specialmente quando usano parole ed espressioni popolari anche in quei casi quando il tono
della scrittura non lo permette. Comunque con il passar del tempo si ridurranno le differenze tra l’italiano
standard ed il toscano.
Pirandello non poté evitare l’influenza esterna. Uno studio dettagliato della sua opera non può non
mettere il risalto la presenza del dialetto toscano. Nella maggior parte dei casi si tratta dell’uso delle varietà
toscana al posto dell’equivalenza dell’italiano standard.
Notiamo la presenza del dialetto toscano in due romanzi di Pirandello: Uno, nessuno e centomila e
l’Esclusa.
Esempi tratti dal romanzo Uno, nessuno e centomila.
...e con quell’alido esalante da un forno

...me atë thatësirë të përhapur nga një furrë... (ÇELA, Libri i Katërt V, 93)
...me atë thatësirën kundërmuese nga një furrë... (VUKAJ, Libri i Katërt V, 106)
«Alido» è una parola del dialetto toscano che nell’italiano standard vuol dire aridità = thatësirë.
Quantorzo, allora, rimasto come a mezz’aria vagellò...
Kuantorco, atëherë, i ngelur në hava, jermoi... (ÇELA, Libri i Pestë, VIII, 125)
Kuantorci, atëherë, i mbetur si pezull, u përçart. (VUKAJ, Libri i Pestë, VIII, 141)
...nel bianco vagellare della lieve persona...

...mbi jermin e bardhë të kurmit të saj të hajthshëm... (ÇELA, Libri i Gjashtë, I, 147)
...në të bardha e fantazoja personin e lehtë që dukej se shpetëzohej e tëra... (VUKAJ,
Libri i Gjashtë, I, 140)
«Vagellare» è un altro termine del dialetto toscano che nell’italiano standard significa sragionare, farneticare,
delirare per febbre, demenza o altro = flas përçart, jam në kllapi. La strategia dei traduttori è quella della
traduzione con un corrispondente dell’albanese standard (pur trattandosi di termini del linguaggio letterario)
eseguendo così la prima possibilità per la traduzione dei dialetti.
Esempi tratti dal romanzo L’esclusa.
La madre pareva impazzita: voleva a ogni costo che il marito parlasse, e l’abbracciava e
gli stringeva le mani diacce, già morte.
Nëna dukej si e marrosur: donte me çdo kusht që i shoqi të fliste. E përqafonte dhe i
shtrëngonte duart e ngrira, tashmë të vdekura. (Pjesa e parë, Kapitulli i gjashtë, 51)
Il termine «diacce» è una varietà tosccana della parola italiana ghiacce.
Trattenuta, come sotto un incubo, forzava gli occhi a scrutare questa via solitaria, lontana
dall'Alvignani, lontana dal marito; e anelava, e spiava nello stesso tempo in sé, nel suo
corpo, qualche accenno che le désse cagione di sperare.
418
E përmbajtur, si nën një ankth, i shqyente sytë që ta pikaste këtë rrugë të vetmuar, larg
Alvinjanit, larg të shoqit dhe digjej e përgjonte, në të njëjtën kohë brenda vetes, në trupin
e saj, ndonjë gjurmë që t’i jepte shkak të shpresonte. (Pjesa e dytë, Kapitulli i
trembëdhjetë, 187)
Il sostantivo «cagione» viene dal dialetto toscano e nell’italiano standard vuol dire causa determinante di
qualcosa che in albanese si traduce shkak.
Don Fifo s'era levato in piedi e messo a svariare per la camera con gli occhi
ammammolati.
Don Fifoja ishte ngritur në këmbë dhe po shëtiste sytë e përgjumur nëpër dhomë. (Pjesa
e dytë, Kapitulli i katërmbëdhjetë, 205)
L’aggettivo «ammammolati» che deriva dal dialetto toscano popolare e vuol dire addormentati in italiano.
- Arrivederli, arrivederli.
- Mirupafshim, mirupafshim. (Pjesa e dytë, Kapitulli i pesëmbëdhjetë, 209)
Forma di saluto che deriva dal toscano popolare.
Io fo’ le viste di non aver capito a chi si riferisce.

Unë po bëj sikur s’e kam kuptuar se kujt i drejtohet. (Pjesa e dytë, Kapitulli i tretë, 133)
Voce toscana del verbo fare.
Dal puno di vista della morfologia e riguardo ai pronomi dimostrativi italiani (questo, codesto, quello) la
varietà toscana «codesto» è quella che si predilige nella lingua letteraria. Nei giorni nostri si è ridotta sempre
di più la zona della sua influenza. Si può affermare che solo a Toscana si nota chiaramente l’uso di cadauno
dei pronomi.
Pirandello toscaneggia “costà”, “codesta”, sono termini che in Sicilia non usa nemmeno quella gente che
Pirandello chiama uniformando in uno dei suoi movimenti a zig-zag il suo linguaggio a quello dei suoi
corregionali, “allitterata” (Puglisi 1968: 121).
Levati codesto cappello dagli occhi.

Ngrije atë kapele nga sytë... (Pjesa e parë, Kapitulli i parë, 12)
- Volete farmi impazzire con codesta tragedia che mi rappresentate attorno?

- Doni të më bëni të çmendem me këtë tragjedi që po më shfaqni rreth e qark? (Pjesa e
parë, Kapitulli i pestë, 47)
- Ecco, signorina, faccia vedere codesta carta alla mamma.

- Ja zonjushe, tregoja nënës këtë letër. (Pjesa e parë, Kapitulli i njëmbëdhjetë, 80)
Prima, prima dovevi chiedermi perdono, con codesta voce, e non te l’avrei negato...
Më parë, më parë duhet të më kërkoje të falur me atë zë dhe nuk do të të kisha
kundërshtuar... (Pjesa e dytë, Kapitulli i pesëmbëdhjetë, 211)
Accanto alle tre forme degli aggettivi dimostrative ci sono anche le forme sostantivate usate per il soggetto
«costui», «cotesti» e «colui» per il genere maschile e «costei», «cotestei» e «colei» per il genere femminile
con la forma «costoro», «cotestoro» e «coloro» per il plurale. C’è da notare che «costui», «costei»,
«costoro» hanno assunto una connotazione peggiorativa. Anche «colui» può avere questa connotazione.
Proprio con questa sfumatura peggiorativa si usano questi pronomi anche da Pirandello in questo romanzo.
419
Costui l'aveva chiesta in moglie; ma Anna, onestamente, aveva voluto confessargli tutto;
Ky e kishte kërkuar për grua, por Ana ndershmërisht kishte dashur t’ia rrëfente të gjitha; (Pjesa e
parë, Kapitulli i pestë, 45)
E aveva finanche nascosto alla madre una lettera di Anna Veronica, in cui si parlava a lungo di
Rocco, delle furie di costui dopo la loro partenza, di minacce di nuovi scandali, di pazzie...
Dhe prandaj i kishte fshehur së ëmës një letër të Ana Veronikës, ku flitej gjatë për Rokun, për
tërbimet e tij pas nisjes së tyre, për kërcënimet për skandale të reja, për marrëzi… (Pjesa e dytë,
Kapitulli i dytë, 124)
- Andate via. Attenderò io a costoro.
- Shkoni. Do të rri unë me këta. (Pjesa e parë, Kapitulli i njëmbëdhjetë, 82)
Ma che volevano da lei tutti costoro?
Po çfarë donin prej saj të gjithë këta? (Pjesa e dytë, Kapitulli i tretë, 137)
Ma io... guarda, piuttosto... giacché nulla è valso per costoro e la mamma e Maria per vivere
debbono avvilirsi con me al servizio altrui... io, guarda, a un altro piuttosto scriverei... a Roma...
Po unë… shiko, më mirë… meqenëse asgjë nuk ka më vlerë për to dhe nëna e Maria për të jetuar
duhet të ulin vetëm me mua në shërbim të dikujt tjetër… unë, shiko, një tjetri më mirë do t’i
shkruaja… në Romë… (Pjesa e parë, Kapitulli i trembëdhjetë, 100)
Si nota inoltre anche l’uso dell’avverbio costà, anche questa del dialetto toscano che significa in codesto
luogo, cioè në këtë vend.
...ho saputo ch'egli stamani è partito per costà.
…prej nga kam mësuar ai sot në mëngjes është nisur andej nga ju. (Pjesa e dytë,
Kapitulli i tretë, 138)
Poi cercò con gli occhi il campanile del Duomo, dietro a cui sorgeva la sua casa; e subito,
al pensiero della madre e della sorella che colà la aspettavano, sentì più vivo il
turbamento, più acuto il rimorso, e una sfiducia profonda e disperata di sé.
Pastaj kërkoi me sy kambanaren e Duomos, prapa së cilës ngrihej shtëpia e saj; dhe
menjëherë, duke menduar për të ëmën dhe të motrën që e prisnin aty, e ndjeu më të
fortë shqetësimin, më të mprehtë vrarjen e ndërgjegjes dhe një mosbesim të thellë e të
pashpresë për veten. (Pjesa e dytë, Kapitulli i tetë, 162)
Per quanto riguarda la strategia del traduttore per la traduzione dei segmenti testuali in dialetto, occorre dire
che i segmenti nel dialetto toscano si traducono con segmenti nell’albanese standard, applicando così la
prima strategia per la traduzione del dialetto.
I pronomi e gli avverbi soprariportati costà, colà, costui, codesto ecc., e anche quelli del dialetto toscano
sono parole che in Sicilia non le usano nemmeno le persone colte. Queste parole creano disparità
(mancanza di unità di linguaggio) nella lingua del romanzo, le parole si sentono a dosagio nell’enunciato.
Non trasmettendo questa marcatezza lessicale (caratteristica che fa sì che una parte del testo risalti in
konfronto al contesto, si differenzi dall’enunciato nella forma in cui lo si potrebbe facilmente aspettare),
abbiamo ovviamente una perdita nel testo tradotto, ma si tratta di una perdita inevitabile.
3.3 Il dialetto piemontese
È il dialetto che si nota per la maggiore presenza nel romanzo Il fu Mattia Pascal e viene usato da parte
dell’autore per caratterizzare uno dei personaggi del romanzo che è di Torino e parla con un forte accento
torinese.
420
- Dôve ca l’è stô me car parent?

- Ku asht ky kushërini jem i dashtun. (RAMJA, XII, 146)
- Ku ma ka futur kokën ai kushëriri im i dashur? (CANKO, XII, 139)
Dov’è questo mio caro parente?
- Cusin, - Tut i Meis i sôma parent.

- Kushri, - të tanë na Meis jena kushri me njeni-tjetrin. (RAMJA, XII, 147)
- Kushëri, - Të gjithë Meisët janë kushërinj. (CANKO, XII, 140)
Tutti i Meis sono parenti.
- Oh, ma côsta ca l’è bela! – L’è prori për lon che mi t sôn vnú a trôvè.
- Oh, kjo asht e bukur. – tamam për këtë kam ardh ktu me t’gjet. (RAMJA, XII, 147)
- Oh, kjo po që është e bukur! – Je tamam kushëriri im që erdha ta përshëndosh.
(CANKO, XII, 140)
Oh ma questa è bella (...). è proprio per lui che sono venuto a trovarti.
- a l’à dime che to pare a l’è andàit an America: cosa ch’a veul di’ lon? A veul di’
che ti t’ses fieul’ d barba Antôni ca l’è andàit ‘ntla America. E nui sôma cusin.
- m’ka thanë qi gjyshi jot ka ken n’Amerikë, ça don me thanë kja? Kja don me than qi ti je
djali i axha Antonit, aj ka shku n’Amerikë e ne jena, kushri. (RAMJA, XII, 147)
- më tha që ka ardhur nga Amerika: ç’do të thotë kjo? kjo do të thotë, që ti je i biri i xha
Antonios, që iku në Amerikë. Dhe ne jemi të një gjaku. (CANKO, XII, 140)
Mi ha detto che tuo padre è andato in America: cos’ha voluto dire? Ha voluto dire che tu
sei figlio di zio Antonio che è andato in America. E noi siamo cugini.
- A m’smiava Antôni... I veuì nen côstradite: sarà pro Paôlo. I ricordo nen ben,
perché mi’ i l’hai nen conôssulo.
- Ndoshta i kan thanë Anton... nuk du me ju ra ndesh. Ndoshta i kan than Paolo, nuk
m’kujtohet mir se nuk e kam njoft. (RAMJA, XII, 148)
- Më duket se e quanin Antoni... Unë nuk dua t’ju kthej fjalë: mbase quhej edhe Paolo.
Nuk e mbaj mend mirë, sepse unë vetë nuk e kam njohur. (CANKO, XII, 141)
Si chiamava Antonio. (...) Io non voglio contraddirti: si sarà anche chiamato Paolo. Non
ricordo bene perché non l’ho conosciuto.
ancor masnà
se qysh fëmijë (RAMJA, XII, 148)
ishte ende një picirruk (CANKO, XII, 141)
ancor piccolo.
- fran nen. – A sôn passà trant’ani

- E kishte harruar – kan kalu tridhjet vjet. (RAMJA, XII, 148)
...nuk i binte dot në të. – Kanë kaluar tridhjetë vjet. (CANKO, XII, 141)
Sono passati trent’anni.
Per quanto riguarda la strategia dei traduttori per tradurre le parole e le espressioni in dialetto, occorre dire
che ognuno di loro ha una sua propria strategia. Così CANKO traduce le parole nel dialetto torinese con
parole della lingua standard albanese, applicando la prima soluzione suggerita dalla critica e pratica della
traduzione per la traduzione del dialetto.
RAMJA, da parte sua, opta per la seconda soluzione, ossia per la traduzione del dialetto con un altro
dialetto della lingua d’arrivo ossia il dialetto gego.
421
Le parole dialettali nel prototesto sono in corsivo. Ciò mette sull’avviso il lettore dell’opera originale. Nel
metatesto quest’informazione iconica viene data da CANKO, però non comunica niente al lettore della
traduzione perché le parole sono quelle dell’albanese standard.
4. Conclusioni
Dallo studio comparatistico che abbiamo fatto dei 3 romanzi di Pirandello si evince che la strategia
predominante nella traduzione del dialetto è quella della traduzione del dialetto con l’albanese standard. Il
metatesto si è allontanato dal prototesto, dal codice artistico dell’autore, e si è avvicinato
all’individualizzazione espressiva del traduttore evidenziando così l’idioletto espressivo del traduttore. La
traduzione come comunicazione secondaria deve basarsi sulla condizione della conservazione
dell’informazione invariante nel testo. Nel corpus del nostro studio non viene rispettato infatti l’intentio-
auctoris. Cercando di osservare l’equivalenza funzionale o skopos theory (una traduzione deve produrre lo
stesso effetto a cui mirava l’originale) qui siamo di fronte a una perdita assoluta. Comunque essendo molto
differente la situazione delle varietà diatopiche albanesi da quelle italiane si tratta di una perdita assoluta,
preannunciata, inevitabile.
Possiamo solo confermare quello che già sapevamo che il processo traduttivo può comportare
naturalmente delle perdite inevitabili come nel caso della traduzione del dialetto.
Goethe (1813) ha dichiarato che le parole di tutte le lingue si sovrappongono e lasciano aperte delle
lacune semantiche che non potranno mai essere colmate.
References
Fonti primarie
Pirandello, L. (1999). Marta Ajala, tradotto da Zija Vukaj, Tirana: Elite.
________, (2000). Tri herë vetvrasës, tradotto da Sabah Ramja, Shkodër: Helena Kadare.
________, (2001). Një, asnjë dhe njëqindmijë, tradotto da Zija Vukaj, Tirana: Elite.
________, (2002). Një, asnjë dhe njëqindmijë, tradotto da Dritan Çela, Elbasan: Sejko.
________, (2002). I ndjeri Matia Paskal, tradotto da Violanda Canko, Tirana: Elena Gjika.
Fonti secondarie
Carbonell i Cortés O., (1999). Traducción y cultura: de la ideología al texto. Madrid: Ediciones Colegio de España.
Catford, J. C, (1965). A Linguistic Theory of Translation, An Essay in Applied Linguistics, Language and language learning. London:
Oxford University Press.
Crepaldi, C. (a cura di) (2002). Sintesi Il fu Mattia Pascal di Luigi Pirandello. Introduzione all’opera. Riassunto e analisi. Approfondimenti.
Vita e opere dell’autore. Milano: Avallardi.
Dardano, M. & Trifone, P. (1997). La nuova grammatica della lingua italiana, Bologna, Zanichelli.
Filippo, P. (1968). Il dialetto siciliano nella lingua di Pirandello. In Pirandello e la sua lingua. Cappelli Editore.
Gjinari, J. & Shkurtaj. Gj. (2009). Dialektologjia, Tirana: shblu.
Lauretta, E. (1952). Come leggere «Il fu Mattia Pascal». Milano: Mursia.
_________, (1993). Il fu Mattia Pascal, Testo integrale, schede storiche e letterarie, note al testo. Vimercate: Meravigli Editrice.
Lefevere, A. (1992). Translating Literature: Practice and Theory in a Comparative Literature Context. New York: The Modern Language
Association of America.
_________, (1997). Traducción, reescritura y la manipulación del canon leterario. Ma Carmen Africa Vidal e Román Alvarez (traduttori).
Salamanca: Ediciones Colegio de España (Translation, Rewriting and the Manipulation of Literary Fame, Londër: Routledge, 1992).
Momigliano, A. (1960). Storia della letteratura italiana. Principato.
Pirandello, L. (1993). Il fu Mattia Pascal. Testo integrale. Schede storiche e letterarie. Note al testo. Milano: Meravigli Editrice.
Rabadán, R. (1994). Traducción, intertextualitad y manipulación. in Amparo Hurtado Albir (ed.) Estudis Sobre la traducció. Castelló:
Universitat Jaume I, 129-39.
422
The Validity of Some Popular Readability Formulas
Pooneh Heydari
Department of Foreign Languages, Shiraz Branch,

Islamic Azad University, Shiraz, Iran.
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.423
Abstract: This study aimed at exploring the correlation between readers’ evaluation of text-readability on one hand and some
popular readability formula’s (Flesch Reading Ease Readability Formula, Gunning’s Fog-Index of Readability, The SMOG Index
of Readability, Flesch-Kincaid) evaluation of text-readability on the other. This study was conducted with an overall number of
118 participants. The participants were selected from among male and female undergraduate students studying different EFL-
related majors at the Department of Foreign Languages and Linguistics of IAU, Shiraz Branch. The participants were chosen
using convenient sampling procedure. To achieve the objectives of the study, 5 passages of different readability index were
used. Moreover, a questionnaire aimed at tapping responses from the participants was devised on each passage. Finally, a
number of SPSS analyses were run and the results of the study did not reveal any significant correlations between readers’ and
the formulas’ evaluation of text-readability level. As a conclusion, it seems that those teachers who have used the readability
formulas as valuable measures for evaluating materials to use with their students should use them cautiously. Of course, further
research seems necessary to check the validity of the readability formulas.
Key Words: text readability; readability formula; Flesch Reading Ease Readability Formula; Gunning’s Fog-Index of Readability;
The SMOG Index of Readability; Flesch-Kincaid Formula; validity of readability formulas.
1. Introduction
Broadly speaking, factors affecting reading comprehension can be classified into two general categories:
reader variables and text variables. The first category of variables which includes factors such as readers'
background knowledge, skills, abilities, motivation, and attitude are internal to readers. The second category
of variables which includes factors such as text-content, type, genre, organization, typographical features,
and readability are internal to texts rather than to readers (Alderson, 2000 cited in Mehrpour & Riazi, 2004).
How easy or difficult is it to read a text? How clearly does a text express ideas and emotions? These
questions are inextricably bound up with the concept of readability (Bailin & Grafstein, 2001). According to
Richards, et al. (1992, p. 306), readability means: "how easily written materials can be read and understood.
This depends on several factors including the average length of sentences, the number of new words
contained, and the grammatical complexity of the language used in a passage."
Generally, Dale and Chall's (1949) definition may be the most comprehensive: "The sum total (including
all the interactions) of all those elements within a given piece of printed material that affect the success a
group of reader have with it. The success is the extent to which they understand it, read it at an optimal
speed, and find it interesting."Other definitions have been proposed for readability (see, e.g., McLaghlin,
1969).
Procedures used to measure readability are known as readability formulas. Today, there are more than 40
different readability formulas used to measure readability, but some of them are better known and more
popular than the others. Perhaps, the most common and the most publicized readability formula was the one
credited to Rudolph Flesch (1948). The popularity of his formula made Flesch a leading authority on
readability.
Flesch Reading Ease Readability Formula (1948) has also been incorporated and installed in Microsoft
Office Word. A text in word can be checked for its spelling and grammar, as well as its readability level.
423
Readability index is based on the average number of syllables per word and words per sentence. Flesch
Reading Ease Readability Formula rates texts on a 100-point scale—the higher the score, the easier it is to
understand the text. The Flesch Reading Ease Readability Formula is usually defined by the following
formula (Flesch, 1948):
206.835 – (1.015 × ASL) – (84.6 × ASW)
Where, ASL is the Average Sentence Length (the number of words divided by the number of sentences),
and ASW is the Average of Syllables per Word (the number of syllables divided by the number of words).
DuBay (2004) provides interpretation of the Flesch Reading Ease Score as indicated in Table 1.
Table 1: Description and predicted reading grade for Flesch Reading Ease Score (DuBay, 2004)
Reading Ease Description Predicted Reading Grade Estimated Percentage of

Score U.S. Adults
0-30 very difficult college graduate 4.5%
30-40 difficult college grade 33%
50-60 fairly difficult 10th-12th grade 54%
60-70 standard 8th-9th grade 83%
70-80 fairly easy 7th grade 88%
80-90 easy 6th grade 91%
90-100 very easy 5th grade 93%
It is not clear why the 40-50 range is left out in DuBay’s table (Heydari & Riazi, 2012).
After that, in The Technique of Clear Writing, Gunning (1952) published a readability formula developed
for adults, the Fog-Index, which became popular because of its ease of use. It uses two variables, average
sentence length and the number of words with more than two syllables for each 100 words.
Grade Level= 0.4  (Average Sentence Length + Number of hard words)
Where:
A hard word is defined as a word that is more than two syllables long.
The Gunning's Fog-Index is shown in Table 2.
Table 2: Gunning's Fog-Index
Fog-Index Estimated Reading Grades
17 College graduate
16 College senior
15 College junior
14 College sophomore
Danger line 13 College freshman
12 High school senior
11 High school junior
10 High school sophomore
Easy 9 High school freshman
Reading 8 Range Eighth grade
7 Seventh grade
6 Sixth grade
The publication of such formulas conveniently marks the end of the first 30 years of classic readability
studies.
424
After that, G. Harry McLaughlin (1969) published his SMOG (Simple Measure Of Gobbledygook) formula
in the belief that word length and sentence length should be multiplied rather than added. By counting the
number of words of more than two syllables (polysyllable count) in 30 sentences, he provided this simple
formula:
SMOG Grading = 3 + square root of polysyllable count
Another known readability formula, the Flesch-Kincaid Formula (1975 cited in Greenfield, 1999), is a
recalibration of the original Flesch Formula. It rates text on a U.S. grade school level. For example, a score of
eight means that an eight grader can understand the document. For most documents, the writers aim for a
score of approximately 7.0 to 8.0.
The formula for the Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level Score is:
(0.39 × ASL) + (11.8 × ASW) – 15.59
Where:
ASL is the Average Sentence Length (the number of words divided by the number of sentences), and ASW is
the Average of Syllables per Word (the number of syllables divided by the number of words).
The present study tries to deal with the validity of the popular aforementioned readability formulas. The next
section presents a review of the background on the text readability.
2. Review of the Readability of the Texts
Reviewing the literature on readability formulas, one can easily understand that such studies are of three
different types including:
1. History of readability
2. Applications of readability formulas
3. The pros and cons views toward the use of readability formulas
The first strand of studies on readability present different readability formulas devised to measure the
readability of texts (Flesch, 1948; Dale-Chall, 1948 cited in DuBay, 2004; Gunning, 1952; Fry, 1968;
McLaughlin, 1969; Flesch-Kincaid Formula, 1975 cited in Greenfield, 1999). In fact, the earliest investigations
of readability were conducted by asking students, librarians, and teachers what seemed to make texts
readable. Such studies led to the development of mathematical formulas. Today, readability evaluation of the
texts is calculated by computer programs. As such, most grammar or editing software programs can
determine the readability level of the written materials.
The second group of studies on readability deals with the application of the readability formulas.
Readability formulas have had a wide range of applications. Indeed, they were originally created for testing
the readability level of school textbooks (Serevin & Tankard, 1992 cited in Balachandran, 1997). Fry (1986,
p.1) pointed out that "articles on the readability formulas are among the most frequently cited articles of all
types of educational research." The applications give researchers an objective means for controlling the
difficulty of passages in their experiments (DuBay, 2004). Today, readability formulas can be applied to
anything from textbooks to government documents and they are more popular than ever. Some of such
applications are as follows: (educational system: Kennedy, 1979; Reed, 1988; mass media including
newspapers: Lostutter, 1949; Fusaro & Conover, 1983; newsletters: Balachandran, 1997; wire services:
Catalano, 1990; brochures: Christ & Pharr, 1980; websites: Baker, Wilson, & Kars, 1997; Graber, Roller, &
Kaeble, 1999; manuals: Stahl, Henk, & Eilers, 1995; TV programs: Vancura, 1955; and court actions and
legislation: DuBay, 2004). Moreover, there are readability formulas for Spanish, French, Dutch, Swedish,
Russian, Hebrew, Hindi, Chinese, Korean (see Rabin, 1988 cited in DuBay, 2004), and Farsi (Dayyani,
1993). The formulas have survived 80 years of intensive application, investigation, and controversy with both
their credentials and limitations remaining intact.
The third group of studies discusses the pros and cons views toward the use of readability formulas. Such
studies mostly deal with a closer examination of the formulas' underlying principles (Kirkwood & Wolfe, 1980;
425
Bertram & Newman, 1981; Frase, Rubin, Starr, & Plung, 1981; Bailin & Grafstein, 2001), the concept of their
validity and appropriateness for either native or second language learners (Froese, 1971; Hamsik, 1984;
Brown, 1998; Greenfield, 1999; Rezaei, 2000; Ardoin, Suldo, Witt, Aldrich, & McDonald, 2005), the
discrepancy between the scores of different formulas (Chen, 1986; DuBay, 2004) , and so forth. Such studies
help readers to become familiar with the background of the formulas, the theory on which they stand, what
they are good for and what they are not.
Synopsis of the Literature Reviewed
Indeed, it can be declared openly that the formulas have both advantages and disadvantages.
Advantages of using readability formulas:
1. By definition, readability formulas measure the grade-level readers must have to read a given text.
The results from using readability formulas provide the writer of the text with much needed
information to reach his target audience.
2. Readability formulas do not require the readers to first go through the text to decide if the text is
too hard or too easy to read. By readability formulas, one can know ahead of time if his readers
can understand the material. This can save time, money and energy.
3. Readability formulas are text-based formulas; many researchers and readers find them easy to
use.
4. Today, readability formulas can be performed by computer. As such, most grammar or editing
software today can determine the readability level of written materials.
5. Readability formulas help writers convert their written material into plain language.
Disadvantages of using readability formulas:
1. Unfortunately, readability formulas are not of much help if one wants to know how well the target
audience understands the text.
2. Due to many readability formulas, there is an increasing chance of getting wide variation in results
of a same text.
3. Readability formulas cannot measure the context, prior knowledge, interest level, difficulty of
concept, or coherence of text. (Heydari & Riazi, 2012; Zamanian & Heydari, 2012)
Indeed, it is important to re-examine the use of readability formulas as a measure of reading difficulty. This
abundance of research by itself is the material proof for the significance of the topic under study. Of course,
this fact necessitates further research in this area, and the present study intends to do that. It aims at
exploring the validity of some better-known and more popular readability formulas.
3. Objectives of the Study
The purpose of this study is to empirically assess what readability formulas claim, how these formulas match
or do not match the assumptions of specialists in the field, and how they can be used to create and evaluate
texts for L2 learners. In doing so, it concentrates on the validity of some popular readability formulas. This
study aimed at helping EFL educators and practitioners to make more objective decisions about how to go
about selecting, revising, teaching, and evaluating EFL texts by evaluating the readability formulas and
correlating standard indexes with the indices obtained by other means like assessing learners. Revisiting the
concept of EFL text-readability formulas, the consequent related issues in the EFL reading skill such as
reliability and validity, plus the scarcity of research in this area for EFL learners constitute the significance of
the scope of this study. Moreover, they will provide further useful information that will be of value in the
validation process of reading texts. Such knowledge is certainly crucial in the areas of teaching reading,
material development, and testing.
The following questions are to be answered through this study:
426
1. Is there any correlation between readers’ evaluation of text-readability and Flesch Reading Ease
Readability Formula’s evaluation of text-readability?
2. Is there any correlation between readers’ evaluation of text-readability and Gunning’s Fog-Index
Formula’s evaluation of text-readability?
3. Is there any correlation between readers’ evaluation of text-readability and the SMOG Formula’s
evaluation of text-readability?
4. Is there any correlation between readers’ evaluation of text-readability and Flesch-Kincaid Grade
Level Formula’s evaluation of text-readability?
4. Method
4.1. Participants
This study was conducted with an overall number of 118 participants. The participants were selected from
among male and female undergraduate students studying different EFL-related majors at the Department of
Foreign Languages and Linguistics of Shiraz Azad University. The participants were chosen using convenient
sampling procedure.
Indeed, there was a convincing reason for selecting undergraduate students in this study which goes as
the following. At first, 5 reading passages were randomly taken from the book Practice and Progress by
Alexander (1967), a reading textbook which is being taught to EFL undergraduate students at the advanced
level of reading course (Reading Comprehension # 3) at Shiraz Azad University. Using Flesch Reading Ease
Readability Formula, the readability scores of the 5 passages were determined. Then, their average
readability score (79.87) was compared with that of the 5 passages from Ackert (1986) used in the current
study (74.5). The result of the comparison revealed that the information of the 5 prepared passages taken
from Ackert (1986) might be at the level of undergraduate students to read and understand. Accordingly, this
study was conducted with a number of undergraduate students in the field.
4.2. Materials and Instruments
First, 5 reading passages were selected from the book of Concepts and Comments: An ESL Reader (Ackert,
1986), a reading text-book for EFL students studying at the advanced level of reading courses locally (see
Appendix). This book contains 25 high-interest reading passages serve as springboards for reading skills
development, vocabulary building, Language analysis, and thought-provoking discussions and writing. In
Concepts and Comments: An ESL Reader, the readings address a wide range of fresh and engaging topics.
The 5 passages were accompanied by 10 comprehension questions including 5 true/ false questions and 5
multiple choice questions which aimed at tapping responses from the participants on the difficulty-level of the
passages as well.
Table 3 presents the texts along with different readability formulas used in the present study.
Table 3: Readability Scores of the Passages Using Different Readability Formulas
Passage Flesch Reading Ease Score Gunning’s Fog-Index The SMOG Index Flesch-Kincaid
Grade Level
1 (buy me!) 82.8 7.4 5.6 4
2 (memory) 77.6 7.2 5.4 4.2
3 (Braille) 75.5 7.6 5.9 5.4
4 (Greenland) 68.5 6.9 5.8 6.7
5 (the Olympic games) 67.2 6.1 5.7 6.2
427
4.3. Data Collection Procedures
Firstly, the 5 prepared passages were given to participants. Participants were asked to provide feedback on
text difficulty by filling out the 2 different prepared types of questions (true/false and multiple choice) on each
reading. Their answers on each reading were collected for analysis. On the other hand, the readability levels
of the 5 prepared passages were calculated using different readability formulas.
4.4. Data Analysis Procedures
The data were analyzed through appropriate statistical procedures including non-parametric Spearman’s rho
correlation coefficient.
For the four research questions of the study investigating if there were any correlations between readers’
evaluation of text-readability level and different readability indices, a correlation was run for each.
Table 4 presents the descriptive statistics and rank order of the 5 prepared passages as evaluated by the
participants and the different readability indices of the texts as presented in Table 3.
Table 4: Descriptive statistics of the texts based on the different used readability formulas’ and participants’
evaluation
Texts Participants Participants Flesch Flesch Fog Fog SMOG SMOG Flesch Fk
Mean rank order Mean rank Mean rank Mean rank Kincaid rank
order order order Mean order
1 5.4 2 82.8 5 7.4 2 5.6 4 4.0 5
2 6.1 4 77.6 4 7.2 3 5.4 5 4.2 4
3 6.0 3 75.5 3 7.6 1 5.9 1 5.3 3
4 4.4 1 68.5 2 6.9 4 5.8 2 6.7 1
5 7.1 5 67.2 1 6.1 5 5.7 3 6.2 2
Comparing the means and the rank orders, one can conclude that they are not close to each other. However,
they turned out to be quite far from each other. To see if such differences were significant or not, a non-
parametric Spearman’s rho correlation coefficient was run on each case (participants’ mean and each
readability formula’ index). Table 5 shows the results of the comparison between different evaluations.
Table 5: Results of the comparison between different evaluations
Correlation Sig. (2-tailed)

Correlation between participants’ mean & Flesch -.300 .624
Correlation between participants’ mean & Fog -.300 .624
Correlation between participants’ mean & SMOG -.300 .624
Correlation between participants’ mean & FK -.100 .873
As this table shows, in all cases the correlations between the two evaluations are not significant. In other
words, participants’ scores on text-readability level and the evaluation of text-readability through the use of
these popular readability formulas were significantly different for five passages.
The result of the present study is consistent with those of Froese (1971), Carrell (1987), Brown (1998),
Rezaei (2000), Ardoin, Suldo, Witt, Aldrich, and McDonald (2005), who attempted to re-evaluate the validity
of different readability formulas. These researchers studied the validity of readability formulas in comparison
428
to various independent criteria of reading difficulty such as cloze units, multiple-choice items, and equivalent
forms. All of them asserted that the formulas are not valid measures of the difficulty of the written materials.
Findings of the present study are in sharp contrast to Hamsik (1984), Fry (1989), and Greenfields' (1999) who
asserted that not only readability formulas can prove to be valuable tools for measuring the difficulty of texts
for native English speakers, but also they do measure the readability level of texts for EFL learners.
6. Conclusions
This study was carried out to investigate the validity of some better-known and more popular readability
formulas (Flesch Reading Ease Readability Formula, Gunning’s Fog-Index of Readability, the SMOG Index
of Readability, and Flesch-Kincaid Formula). The study investigated if there are any correlations between
students’ scores and the four aforementioned readability indexes on text difficulty. Results of correlation
suggested that there were not any correlations between the two sets of evaluations (human evaluation
versus readability formulas). The following table summarizes results of the study.
Table 6: Summary of the findings of the study

text1 text2 text3 text4 text5
Participants’ means on text difficulty 5.4 6.1 6.0 4.4 7.1
Level of difficulty difficult easy average very difficult very easy
Readability index based on Flesch formula 82.8 77.6 75.5 68.5 67.2
Level of readability very easy easy average difficult very difficult
Readability index based on Fog-Index 7.4 7.2 7.6 6.9 6.1
Level of readability difficult average very difficult easy very easy
Readability index based on SMOG Index 5.6 5.4 5.9 5.8 5.7
Level of readability easy very easy very difficult difficult average
Readability index based on Flesch-Kincaid 4.0 4.2 5.3 6.7 6.2
Level of readability very easy easy average very difficult difficult
As can be seen in Table 6, the five texts were evaluated differently by participants and by the readability
formulas.
The findings of the study have implications for materials and test developers. While further research is
needed to validate the findings of the present study, it can be suggested that decisions for text selection in
terms of text difficulty and readability are not based on readability formula per se. Human judgments are
needed to be considered as well.
References
Ackert, A. (1986). Concepts and Comments: An ESL Reader. New York: CBS College Publishing.
Alexander, L. G. (1967). Practice and progress. London: Longman.
Ardoin, S. P., Suldo, S. M., Witt, J., Ardrich, S., & McDonald, E. (2005). Accuracy of readability estimates' predictions of CBM
performance [Electronic version]. School Psychology Quarterly, 20(1), 1-22. Retrieved December 23, 2007, from
http://proquest.umi.com/pqdweb?did=818687841&sid=2&Fmt=&clientld=46449&RQT=309&VName=PQD
Bailin, A., & Grafstein, A. (2001). The linguistic assumptions underlying readability formulae: A critique. Language & Communication, 21,
285-301.
Baker, L. M., Wilson, F. L., & Kars, M. (1997). The readability of medical information on Info Trac: Does it meet the needs of people with
low literacy skills? References & Users Services Quarterly, 37(2), 155-160.
Balachandran, B. (1997). Readability standards of newsletters. Unpublished master's thesis, University of California, Fresno, U.S.
Bertram, B., & Newman, S. (1981). Why readability formulas fail (Report No. 28). Illinois University, Urbana: Center for the Study of
Reading. (Eric Document Service No. ED205915)
Brown, J. D. (1998). An EFL readability index. JALT Journal, 20, 7-36.
Catalano, K. (1990). On the wire: How six news services are exceeding readability standards. Journalism Quarterly, 67(1), 97-103.
429
Chen, W. S. (1986). A comparison of seven computerized readability formulas as applied to elementary social studies textbooks.
Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Columbia University College, U.S. Retrieved November 10, 2008, from:
http://proquest.umi.com/pqdweb?did=771892981&sid=9&Fmt=4&clientld=46449&RQT=309&VName=PQD
Christ, W. G., & Pharr, P. (1980). Readability of brochures produced by state of Florida. Journalism Quarterly, 57, 150-159.
Dale, E., & Chall, J. S. (1949). The concept of readability. Elementary English, 26, 23-33.
Dayyani, M. H. (1993). An assessment of the readability of special Farsi texts written for newly-literates. Adult Education and
Development, 2(3), 27-48.
DuBay, W. H. (2004). The principles of readability. Retrieved February 12, 2008, from: http://www.nald.ca/fulltext/readab/readab.pdf
Flesch, R. (1948). A new readability yardstick. Journal of Applied Psychology, 32, 221-233.
Frase, L. T., Rubin, A., Starr, K., & Plung, D. L. (1981). Readability formulas: Used or abused? [Electronic version]. IEEE Transactions
on Professional Communication, PC24 (1), 48-54. Retrieved December 23, 2007, from:
http://proquest.umi.com/pqdweb?did=1135513&sid=9&Ftm=2&clientld=46449&RQT=309&VName=PQD
Froese, V. (1971). Cloze readability versus the Dale-Chall formula. Paper presented at the meeting of the International Reading
Association, Atlantic City, NJ.
Fry, E. B. (1968). A readability formula that saves time. Journal of Reading, 11, 513-516.
Fry, E. B. (1986). Varied uses of readability measurement. Paper presented at the 31st Annual Meeting of the International Reading
Association, Philadelphia, PA.
Fusaro, J. A., & Conover, W. M. (1983). Readability of two tabloid and two nontabloid papers. Journalism Quarterly, 50, 360-363.
Graber, M. A., Roller, C. M., & Kaeble, B. (1999). Readability levels of patient education material on the Word Wide Web. The Journal of
Family Practice, 48(1), 58-61.
Greenfield, G. R. (1999). Classic readability formulas in an EFL context: Are they valid for Japanese speakers? Unpublished doctoral
dissertation, University of Temple, U.S.
Gunning, R. (1952). The technique of clear writing. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Hamsik, M. J. (1984). Reading, readability, and the ESL reader. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, The Florida University, U.S.
Retrieved December 23, 2007, from:
http://proquest.umi.com/pqdweb?did=749006291&sid=1&ftm=2&clientld=46449&RQT=309&VName=PQD
Heydari, P. & Riazi, A. M. (2012). Readability of texts: Human evaluation versus computer index. Mediterranean Journal of Social
Sciences, 3(1), 177-190.
Kennedy, K. (1979). The reading levels of high school physics texts. The Physics Teacher, 17, 165-167.
Kirkwood, K. J., & Wolfe, R. G. (1980). Matching students and reading materials: A cloze-procedure method for assessing the reading
ability of students and the readability of textual materials. Toronto: Ontario Department of Education. (ERIC Document
Reproduction in Service No. ED 195 928)
Lostutter, M. (1949). Some critical factors of newspaper readability. Journal Quarterly, 26, 307-314.
McLaughlin, G. H. (1969). SMOG grading: A new readability formula. Journal of Reading, 12(8), 639-646.
Mehrpour, S., & Riazi, A. M. (2004). The impact of text length on EFL students' reading comprehension. Asian EFL Journal, 6(3), 1-13.
Reed, K. X. (1988). An analysis of reading levels of students and readability levels of textbooks at second junior colleges in the state of
Alabama. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Auburn. Retrieved October 12, 2008, from:
http://proquest.umi.com/pdqweb?did=744752841&sid=2&Fmt=2&clientld=46449&PQT=309&VName=PQD
Rezaei, A. A. (2000). The validity of the "Fog-Index of Readability". Journal of Humanities of Islamic Republic of Iran, 7(4), 17-27.
Richards, J. C., Platt, J., & Platt, H. (1992). Longman dictionary of language teaching and applied linguistics. London: Longman.
Stahl, N. A., Henk, W. A., Eilers, U. (1995). Are drivers' manuals understandable? [Electronic version]. Transportation Quarterly, 49(1),
105. Retrieved December 10, 2008, from:
http://proquest.umi.com/pqdweb?did=4468887&sid=2&Fmt=2&clientld=46449&RQT=3098VName=PQD
Vancura, R. H. (1995). Flesch readability formula applied to television programs. Journal of Applied Psychology, 39(1), 47-48.
Zamanian, M. & Heydari, P. (2012). Readability of texts: State of the art. Theory and Practice in Language Studies, 2(1), 43-53.
Appendix
Passage 1
Buy me!
People in cities all over the world shop in supermarkets. Who decides what you buy in the supermarkets? Do
you decide? Does the supermarket decide?
When you enter the supermarket, you see shelves full of food. You walk in the aisles between the
shelves. You push a shopping cart and put your food in it. You probably hear soft, slow music as you walk
430
along the aisles. If you hear fast music, you walk quickly. The supermarket plays slow music. You walk slowly
and have more time to buy things.
Maybe you go to the meat department first. There is some meat on sale, and you want to find it. The
manager of the supermarket knows where customers enter the meat department. The cheaper meat is at the
other end of the meet department, away from where the costumers enter. You have to walk by all expensive
meat before you find the cheaper meat. Maybe you will buy some of the expensive meat instead of the meat
on sale.
The daily department sells milk and milk products such as butter and meat. Many customers like milk that
has only a little butterfat in it. One store has three different containers of low fat milk. One says 1 percent
(1%) fat on the container. The second says 99 percent (99%) fat free. The third says low fat in big letters and
1% in small letters. As you can see, all the milk has the same amount of fat. The milk is all the same. The
amount of milk in each container is also the same. However, in this store the three containers of milk cost
three different amounts of money. Maybe the costumer will buy the milk that cost the most.
Most of the food in the supermarkets is very attractive. It all says “buy me!” to the customers. The expensive
meat says “buy me!” as you walk by. The expensive milk container says “buy me! I have less fat.” The
supermarket tells you what to buy.
True or False?
1. The supermarket tries to tell you what to buy.
2. Butter is in the meat department.
3. Most food in the supermarket is attractive.
4. You put your food in a big basket in the supermarket.
5. If you hear slow music, you walk quickly.
Multiple-Choice Questions
1. People walk in the ……in the supermarket.
a. shelves b. dairy c. aisles d. amount
2. The manager knows …….
a. which customers like low fat milk b. which customers like slow music
c. where customers enter the meat department d. where customers come from
3. When you walk by the expensive meat…..
a. maybe you will buy some b. maybe you will buy low fat milk
c. you will look for fresh fruit d. you will walk on the shelves
4. There are three different containers of low fat milk.
a. one is 90% fat free b. they all cost the same amount of money
c. one has less fat than the others d. they all have the same amount of fat
5. Supermarket managers make the food attractive because………
a. the customers will buy more b. it is very expensive
c. it is in the dairy department d. it is cheap
Passage 2
Memory
“Memorize these words.” “Learn this spelling rule.” “Don’t forget the quiz tomorrow.” You remember things
every day, but how do you do it?
You find a telephone number in the phonebook, dial it and then forget it. This is your short term memory. It
lasts less than 30 seconds. (There are 60 seconds in a minute). However you don’t look in the phonebook for
a friend’s number. You know it. This is long term memory. Your long term memory has everything that you
remember.
431
Why do you forget something? What is the reason? You did not learn it in the beginning. This is the major
reason for forgetting. For example, you meet some new people, and you forget your names. You hear the
names, but you do not learn them. Then you forget them.
You can remember better. Here are some ideas.
1. Move information from your long term memory to your long term memory. Practice the information. Say the
information to yourself. Think about it. Spend time on it.
2. Overlearn. After you learn something, study it some more. Learn it more than you need to. For example,
when you know a list of new words, don’t stop. Practice the words a few more times.
3. be sure that you understand the information. It is difficult to memorize something you don’t understand.
4. Do only one thing at a time. Study in a quiet place. You cannot listen to music or people and memorize at
the same time.
5. Try to connect the information with something you already know. For example, when you learn the name of
a new kind of food, think of a similar kind of food.
6. Divide the information into parts. Do not have more than seven parts at the same time.
7. Make a picture in your mind. For example, maybe you see a new word. It is a kind of furniture in a room.
Remember what it looks like.
8. Try to relax when you study. Enjoy it. You cannot remember things when you are tired or unhappy.
Some people have a photographic memory. They see everything like a picture. Later they can see the picture
in their mind again and describe everything in it. They can remember long lists of numbers and thousands of
other things. Would you like to have a photographic memory?
True or False?
1. Your short term memory lasts a minute.
2. Your address is in your long term memory.
3. Overlearning helps you remember.
4. It is easy to memorize things that you don’t understand.
5. Connect a new word to a similar word in your mind.
1. When you learn something and continue studying it, you are…….
a. remembering b. looking at c. overlearning d. learning
2. In order to learn, divide the information into…….. parts.
a. 20 b. 7 c. 10 d. 12
3. You cannot remember things when you are……….
a. tired b. happy c. glad d. not tired
4. Why do you remember your friend’s number?
a. because you listed it b. because you overlearn it
c. because it is in your long term memory d. because it is in your short term memory
5. What is the major reason for forgetting?
a. you did not remember it in the beginning b. you don’t have long lists of everything
c. you did not learn it in the beginning d. you don’t have a photographic memory
Passage 3
Braille
Louis Braille was born in France in 1809. His father had a small business. He made shoes and other things
from leather. Louis liked to help his father in the store even when he was very small. One day when Louis
was three years old, he was cutting some leather. Suddenly the knife slipped and hit him in the eye. Louis
soon became completely blind.
432
When he was ten years old, he entered the National Institute for the Blind in Paris. One day his class went
to visit a special exhibit by a captain in the army. One thing in the exhibit was very interesting for Louis. It
showed messages in code. Armies send messages in secret codes so no one else can read them. The
captain wrote his code in raised letters on very thick paper.
Louis thought a lot about this code. Then he decided to write in the same way so blind people could read with
their fingers. It is very difficult to feel the differences between raised letters. Instead of letters, Louis used a
cell of six dots. He arranged the dots with two dots across and three down.
There are 63 possible arrangements of the dots in the Braille system. Each arrangement stands for one
letter, punctuation mark, or number. He also used this system to write music. Louis Braille invented this
system when he was only fifteen years old.
Blind people can also write Braille. They use a special kind of pen to make the dots. Today there are
Braille books in all written languages in the world. However, these books are large and expensive to make.
They must be on special paper. Someone who can see must learn the Braille alphabet and make the raised
dots in the paper by hand or with a special typewriter.
Now there is an easier way for blind people to read. Talking books are complete books or magazines on
cassette tapes or phonograph records. Blind people listen to the book. Blind people can also write using a
typewriter or a computer.
Louis Braille invented a way for blind people to communicate. He invented it before the time of
phonographs, tape recorders, type writers, and computers. When he died in 1852, he was buried in the
Pantheon in Paris. This is where the national heroes of France are buried, and Louis Braille was a national
hero.
True or False?
1. Braille invented a system of reading for blind people.
2. Braille was buried in the Pantheon because he was a national hero.
3. Braille showed messages in letter.
4. He was 10 years old when he invented this system.
5. Blind people also use talking books and type writers today.
1. Louis Braille’s father made things from …….
a. leather b. wool c. exhibit d. codes
2. When Louis was ten years old, he began to study ……….
a. at his neighborhood school c. at a special school for the blind
b. at a university d. in the army
3. He saw a special exhibit. It showed………... in code.
a. messages b. system c. arrangements d. computers
4. It is difficult to feel the differences between………
a. coded messages c. a system of raised dots
b. arrangements of dots d. raised letters
5. Talking books………
a. are on cassette tapes c. have raised dots
b. have raised letters d. are on computers
Passage 4
Greenland
Greenland is the largest island in the world. It covers over 2000000 (two million) square kilometers. Most of it
lies inside the Arctic Circle. And a huge sheet of ice covers 85% of it. Imagine that a map of Greenland is on
top of the map of Europe. Greenland stretches from London to the middle of Sahara desert.
433
The ice sheet is more than 1.6 kilometers thick, and it never melts. They are probably only rock under the
ice, but no one knows for sure.
Along the sea coast, mountains rise from the sea. There are a few low trees in the southwest, but no
forests. Snow covers everything in winter, but in summer very low plants cover the ground between the sea
and the ice sheet.
Norwegian Vikings were the first Europeans to see the island in A.D. 875, but no one visited it until 982.
Three years later a few Vikings went to live there. In 1261 the people in Greenland decided to join Norway.
Norway and Denmark united in 1380. This union ended in 1814, and Greenland stay with Denmark.
Greenland is fifty times larger than Denmark, but it is still a part of this small country.
About 62000 people live in Greenland. Most of them are part Eskimo and part Danish. Almost all of them
live in towns and villages on the southwestern coast because that is the warmest part of the island. A few
pure Eskimos live in the far north and some Danes live in the towns. Life in Greenland is difficult because the
weather is very cold. In January it is -29.5° C (minus 29 point 5 degrees Celsius) and in July it is 4° C (4
degrees Celsius). It is dark twenty four hours a day during winter. In summer it is always daylight.
The island has very few natural resources. The people raise a few vegetables and sheep. They used to
fish and hunt, but now they usually buy food at stores.
Greenland is important to the world because scientists study the weather there. They can tell when storms
are developing over the North Atlantic Ocean. It is important to know when storms are developing there
because it is an important shipping area.
Life in Greenland is changing very fast. People lived a traditional life for centuries, but now they are
moving into the modern world very quickly. They are losing their old traditions, but there is nothing to take
their place. There are a lot of problems among the people. It is difficult for any country to move from a
traditional life to a modern life. It is especially hard for Greenland because the people spent centuries with
very little communication with the rest of the world. These problems will probably continue into the future.
True or False?
1. Greenland is a part of Denmark.
2. The union between Norway and Denmark ended in 1261.
3. People live in south-eastern areas of Greenland because of the warm weather there.
4. Greenland doesn’t have any natural resources.
5. In 982 A.D. Europeans first go there to live.
1. Most of Greenland lies…….
a. above the Arctic Circle c. in the Sahara Desert
b. below the Arctic Circle d. in Europe
2. The ice sheet ……
a. melts in summer c. is three kilometers thick
b. is always three d. has a few green plants under it
3. Greenland …….
a. is flat c. is rich in natural resources
b. has warm winters d. has mountains along the seacoast
4. The first Europeans to live in Greenland were……..
a. Danes b. Eskimo c. Norwegian Viking d. English
5. Greenland is important to the world because…….
a. scientists the weather there c. it has communications with the rest of the world
b. it has rich natural resources d. a huge ice sheet covers it
Passage 5
The Olympic Games
434
Every four years people all over the world watch the Olympic Games. It is a time for all kinds of people to
unite in peace. Some of them join together to compete for gold medals. Millions of other people watch them
on television.
Why do we have the Olympics? How did they begin? The first Olympic Games were in Greece in 776 B.C.
There was only one event. People ran a race the length of the stadium. The games lasted one day. Slowly
people added more events. The games were only for men, and women could not even watch them. Only
Greeks competed. They came from all parts of the Greek world. The time of the games was a time of peace,
and the government let everyone travel safely. Kings competed against common people. The winners
became natural heroes.
The first modern Games were in 1896 in Athens. The Greeks built a new stadium for the competition.
Athletes from several countries competed. Then there were Olympics every four years in different cities in
Europe and the United States until 1952. After that they were in Melbourne, Tokyo, Mexico City and Montreal
besides in European cities. Each year there were athletes from more nations. The first Winter Olympics were
in 1924. The athletes compete in skiing and other winter sports.
Today there must be Olympic Games every four years. The games must have at least fifteen events, and
they cannot last more than sixteen days. There is no age limit—people of any age can compete.
The competitors must not be professionals. They must be amateurs. The athletes compete for gold medals.
The winners are still natural heroes, as they were in early Olympic Games in Greece.
In 1956, Egypt, Iraq, and Lebanon boycotted the Games. They did not compete in the Games because
several countries took the Suez Canal from Egypt that year. Other countries boycotted the Games in 1964
and 1976. In 1980 the United States and other countries boycotted the games in Moscow. In 1984 the Soviet
Union and other countries boycotted the games in Los Angles. How can the nations of the world solve this
problem? Maybe the games should be in Greece every year, where they began. The athletes from all over
the world could compete without any boycotts.
True or False?
1. The first Olympic competitors ran the length of the stadium.
2. Only men competed in the first Olympics, but women could watch them.
3. Only Greeks could compete in the first Games.
4. After 1956 there were on Games in Europe.
5. Professional athletes usually win the most medals in the Olympics.
1. What was the only event in the first Olympic Games?
a. skiing b. boxing c. running d. football
2. Where were the first modern Games?
a. Athens b. Tokyo c. Melbourne d. Montreal
3. When where the first winter games?
a. 1952 b. 1924 c. 776 B.C. d. 1984
4. How many events are in the games? At least ……. events.
a. 4 b. 2 c. 20 d. 15
5. How many countries boycotted the games in 1956?
a. 3 b. 2 c. 1 d. 5
435

The Emphasized Legislative in Macedonia Institutions and Enforce Laws,

Regulations and Developing Administrative Improvements
Mr.sc. Blerton Sinani1

Prof. Assoc. Dr. Alba Dumi 2
1, Teaching Assistant of the Faculty of Law, SEEU University, Tetova, Macedonia
E mail: [email protected]
2Management Department, Economy Faculty, Tirana, Albania,
2Dean of graduated school, University of Vlora Albania
2Guest Professor in Law Faculty, SEEU University, Tetova Macedonia
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.437
Abstract: The definition of the constitutional law is an important theoretical problem, because in literature, generally, "there is
no single definition" of the constitutional law. Seen from the perspective of the broad (wide) comparative juridical-constitutional
literature, a conclusion drawn can be, that the constitutional law can be defined in two main meanings: first, in the traditional
meaning and, secondly, in the modern one. In the traditional sense, the constitutional law is defined as "a set of juridical norms
that refer to the dispersion of state power and the exercise of that power by the state bodies and with which in the same time the
reciprocal relationships within state bodies, and the reciprocal relationships between state, citizens and institutions are defined.
"In the frame of the traditional sense, the constitutional law can be viewed in two basic meanings (senses) one, in the strict
meaning and, two, in the broad one. In its narrowest sense, the constitutional law can be defined as "a set (an entirety) of
juridical norms, intended to regulate relationships within the state between the ruler (ruler) and the governed (ruled). 1
Key words: Constitutional law, juridical norms, reciprocal relations, legislative politics, illegal act
1. Introduction
This study empirically examines the impact of reforms in legislative politics in Republic of Macedonia under
progress and developing reforms in low and judiciary system, debt management policies on borrowing costs
incurred by state governments when issuing debt in the municipal bond market. To answer the question what
is" the constitutional law" means to define the term "the constitutional law." The question is raised: what is the
definition? To define means to explain in a concise and scientific manner the (constitutional reference data)
meaning of the certain expression. 2
Although the definitions of various social phenomena, so even for the constitutional law, are necessary
and important "to explain the essence" of them, they, as a rule, do not reveal all sides and features of social
phenomena. 3 Of course the same happens with the efforts to define the constitutional law as a branch of the
law. While, in its broadest sense the constitutional law can be defined as a set of juridical norms which
regulate the juridical- constitutional matter (materia constitutionis) within the framework of the juridical system
of a certain state. These classical definitions are held in the juridical- constitutional literature, since the
nineteenth century. 4

1 Dr. John Alder, Constitutional and Administrative Law, New York, 2007, pg. 6.
2 Albania Vocabolary, Shtëpia Botuese, Toena, Tiranë, 2002, pg. 979.
3 Dr. Esat Stavileci, Nocione dhe parime të administratës publike, Prishtinë, 2005, pg. 17.
4 See: Dr. Aleksandar Gjurgjev, Dr. Marijana Pajvançiç, Ustavno pravo, Novi Sad, 1991, pg. 14
Dr. Svetomir Shkariq, Sporedbeno i makedonsko ustavno pravo, Shkup, 2004, pg. 5; Dr. Krenar Loloçi, E drejta kushtetuese, Tiranë,
1997, pg. 15 - 16.
437
1.1 The notion of the Constitutional law
In modern terms, the constitutional law is defined as "a set of juridical norms that regulate and guarantee the
freedoms and the fundamental rights of man and citizens, at the same time the organization of state power at
the service of the juridical protection of freedoms and fundamental rights of citizens is determined through
these norms." 5 This automatically would mean that state power does not exist for itself, but it exists as a
subject (factor) and mechanism for the protection of freedoms, of fundamental rights and dignity of man and
citizen from any kind of discrimination.
In relation to that, we can say that it’s not casual that in almost all modern democratic constitutions, the
part of freedoms and fundamental rights of man and citizen comes immediately after the principles or the
basic provisions and before the parts that regulate the organization of state respectively state power. The
part that includes the freedoms and fundamental rights of man and citizens is the crucial part of the
constitution, even they occupy the leading place and the state institutions exist primarily to guarantee
them. That, because it is considered that the state as a social institution sui generis was born as an
expression of the general will of the people (volonté general), respectively, as an expression of the
sovereignty of the people .
1.2 The fundamental mission of the constitutional law.
The fundamental mission of the state is the maximum guarantee and protection of the freedoms and
fundamental rights of the individual as a citizen of a certain state. The people 6 in order to protect the
freedoms and their personal rights, guided by reason (ratio), with their own will constitute the state as a
political community, in which the constitution as a social contract (originere, contractus originarius ose
pactum sociale), regulates the political system of the state, sets and defines the legal boundaries within
which the activity of the state can be stretched (extended) and exercised in the society, expresses legally the
sovereignty of the people and guarantees the freedoms and rights of man, which are natural rights and
not donated by the state. 7 It is about the theory of "the social contract" (The Social Contract) whose creator
and originator is the brilliant French political philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau.8
Therefore, it is drawn the conclusion that the freedoms and human rights are earlier and older than the state,
may be they even precede the state constitution and the organization of the state power, because man
enjoys some "freedoms and natural rights since birth, such as the right to life and liberty, the right to equality,
the right to security, the right to property, the right to resist to oppressors and the right to seek happiness.
They are inherent, inviolable, inalienable and unpredictable "because they are given by the Creator of nature
(God),9 but with the constitution of the state and the organization of the state power, their implementation and
concrete juridical protection is ensured through juridical means and protective mechanisms which individuals
can consume (use) when considering that with the illegal act ,any right or legal interest has been violated or
harmed by certain state bodies.
2 Literature Review and Hypotheses
Meanwhile, in the contemporary conditions and circumstances as a reflex of strong dynamic and developing

5 Dr. Svetomir Shkariç, cited work., pg . 3.14;
6 By the expression ‘people’ the science of the Constitutional Law means the entirity of the citizens whithin the border of the territory of a
certain state – citied by Dr. Xhezair Zaganjori, Demokracia dhe shteti i së drejtës, Tiranë, 2002, pg. 32.
7 Veljko Mratoviç, Dr. Nikolla Filipoviç, Dr. Smiljko Sokol, Ustavno pravo i politiçke institucije, Zagreb, 1986, pg. 26.
8 Zhan Zhak Ruso, Kontrata Sociale, Tiranë, 2007.
438
trends of European, North Atlantic and globalization integration processes, increasingly ti is required that the
rights and fundamental freedoms of man remain "on the basis of the entire juridical system ". In accord with
that, the state authorities "not only will be necessary to respect the fundamental freedoms and rights of man
and citizens, but also should play an active role in their realization." It is known the definition of the
constitutional law given by the eminent British professor of the constitutional law Albert Venn Dicey: "The
constitutional law includes juridical (legal) norms which have legal effect directly or indirectly on the
distribution and the exercise of the sovereign state power in the state”. 9 This definition, as noted, is
exclusively oriented to "the state power", as the only regulatory sphere of the juridical norms of the
constitutional law.
H 1 The essential deficiency of this definition consists in the fact that it bypasses the non-state
sphere of the constitutional law which is fabricated (created )by the freedoms and the fundamental rights of
man and citizens and the rights of local self-government units, as a "constituent and very important segment"
of the constitutional law on one hand, and, as means and measure of juridical restriction on the state power
and for not exercising the state power arbitrarily abusively on the part of those who are in power , on the
other hand .
Stavro Vinjau, in his book "the constitutional law”10, defines the constitutional law as a “set of rules
imposed by the state, which contain the fundamental commandments on which the state is based. The same
author, elaborating deeper the notion of the constitutional law says: the constitutional law, essentially,
contains the regulation of the main state issues as: the form of the state, its organs, competences and mode
of action, the boundaries within which the freedoms of the state can be exercised towards citizens,
designated as personal freedoms.” 11Dhimo Dhima says that "the constitutional law refers to the branch of
law that includes a certain category of juridical norms, which ratify the social and state order of a certain
state, and the position the individual occupies in that state." 12 Luan Omari considers that "the constitutional
law can be defined as the set of juridical norms that define the fundamental principles of the political
organization of the society and the state.
H 2 The aforementioned formal sources of the constitutional law function for a more concrete and
detailed regulation of those relationships and specific issues which are regulated by the constitutional acts,
they function respectively for clarifying, elaborating and realizing the principled solutions of the juridical-
constitutional norms in the constitutional acts.
He further adds that: In particular, the juridical- constitutional norms treat the organization, functioning
and competences of the highest state bodies, their mutual relations, but also the relationships that they have
with other state bodies and with citizens." 13 A well known Croatian author, who deals with the theory on the
state and the law, 14affirms the idea that "the constitutional law is an entirety of juridical norms with the
highest juridical power within the framework of the state – juridical order which establish state organization,
establish the basis of the social and political regulation of the state and guarantee the freedoms, rights and
fundamental duties of man and citizen” Nurko Pobriç asserts that "the constitutional law includes the entirety
of the juridical norms, which regulate the political institutions in which the majority of the sovereign power in

10 In Albanian language to mark the constitutional law as an applicative juridical discipline, not rarely it is used the optional term, or the
alternative expression “the constitutional law ”. After the declaration of Albania as an independent and sovereign state on November the
28-th 1912, that discipline firstly was known as The fundamental law” (Kristo Floqi, E drejta themelore, Shkodër, 1920),while in 1920-
1924 as “The constitutional law” (Stavro Vinjau, E drejta konstitucionale, Tiranë, 1923). – cited by Dr. Luan Omari, Dr. Aurela Anastasi, E
drejta kushtetuese, Tiranë, 2008, pg. 10 – 11.
11 Stavro Vinjau, E drejta konstitucionale, Tiranë, 1923,pg. 28. – Dr. Ismet Elezi, Mendimi juridik shqiptar, Tiranë, 1999, pg.
37 – 41.
12 Dr. Dhimo M. Dhima, E drejta kushtetuese e Republikës Popullore të shqipërisë, Tiranë, 1963, pg. 6.
13 Dr. Luan Omari, Parime dhe institucione të së drejtës publike, Tiranë, 2006,pg. 8.
14 Dr. Nikolla Viskoviç, Teorija drzhave i prava, Zagreb, 2001,pg. 272.
439
every state is concentrated , as well as the personal and collective freedoms and rights with which the
political(state) power is limited". 15
3. Methodology and Research Goal
The famous French author of the constitutional law Jacques Cadart, defines the constitutional law as "an
entirety of juridical norms through which the state mechanism is built, 16 and through which the structure and
the competences of the highest state bodies are determined".17 From the point of view of the author Owen
Hood Phillips, the constitutional law implies an entirety of juridical norms, which are declared in the
constitution. Thus, the constitutional law is the branch of law which refers to the constitution as a juridical
act." 18 Such definition of the constitutional law is unacceptable and unsustainable from the view of legal
science, for two basic reasons.
First, because the other branches of law (not only the constitutional law),are related relatively - in a
smaller or larger size, to the constitution as a juridical act.19 This is justified by the fact that the constitution
establishes the contours and the basic juridical principles for all branches of law, where as an integral node, it
joins together all branches of the law within the unique legal system;
Second, although the constitution is the main and most important formal source of the constitutional law,
within the composition of which there are included and collected the cardinal juridical norms with the highest
juridical force, through which the fundamental issues of social and state regulation of a state, it is not a full
single unique and formal source of the constitutional law.
3.1 Juridical normative acts and constitutional amendments
This is substantiated by the fact that the social relationships that enter (are included in) the object of the
constitutional law are regulated not only by the constitutional acts (the constitution, the constitutional law, the
constitutional amendments, the constitutional annexes) as the most important fundamental formal sources
of the constitutional law, but also partially they are regulated by other general juridical normative acts, such
as: certain juridical acts, regulations for the work of certain state bodies(regulation for the work of
parliaments, regulations for the work of governments, regulations for the work of the constitutional courts),
the decrees with legal power, the acts of the autonomous political and territorial units and units of local
government, the constitutional courts decisions, as formal sources of the constitutional law, with which the
juridical - constitutional norms in the constitutional acts are completed and developed.

15 Dr. Nurko Pobriç, Ustavno pravo, Mostar, 2000, pg. 21.
16 The state mechanism, in its most general sense can be defined as a system of state bodies through which the state power is realised
and the managerial role of the state in the society is ensured .The state mechanism consists of different bodies which differ from each
other on “ the task they complete and the role they have” in thi mechanism.
In’the main parts of the state mechanism‘ are included:the head of the state; government; administrative body; order force; and armed
force .- cited by Dr. Dimitar Bajallxhiev, Voved vo pravoto – prva kniga, Shkup, 1999, pg. 325.
17 Dr. Nurko Pobriç, work cited, pg.15.
18 Dr. Owen Hood-Phillips, Constitutional and Administrative law, London, 1967, pg. 11. – Cited by Dr. Krenar Loloçi, E drejta
19 The juridical act is defined as a technical – juridical instrument ( means)for ‘the creation, expression and implementation of the law.-
cited by Dr. Dimitar Bajallxhiev, Voved vo pravoto – kniga vtora, Shkup, 1999,pg. 103.
Related to the definition of the juridical act as a technical-juridical instrument( means): first for ‘the creation and expression’ of ‘the law’,
and second for ‘ the implementation’’ of the law’ it should be pointed out the fact that these two dimensions are not present in all juridical
acts. For example, the constitution as the highest juridical act, act with the highest juridical power, it is not an act through which the law is
implemented, but it is an act through which the law only is created. That because there does not exist any other juridical act above the
constitution that it would have to execute.
440
One fair, logical and consistent conclusion that can be drawn about that, is that the juridical norms that the
formal sources with the lowest juridical power compared to the constitutional acts contain, regulate matter of
substantial juridical-constitutional nature ( certain legal acts, regulations on the work of certain public bodies,
such as regulations on the work of parliamentarians, regulations on the work of governments, regulations on
the work of the constitutional courts, decrees with legal power, political acts of autonomous territorial units
and units of local government, the constitutional court decisions), they are not authentic and primary in the
regulation of the juridical- constitutional matter, but are derivative (the derivative), secondary and
complementary in relation to legal norms which are in the constitutional acts, which are issued based on
and for the implementation and application in practice of the juridical norms of the constitutional acts.
Therefore, all these formal sources of the constitutional law (the constitution, the constitutional law, the
constitutional amendments, the constitutional annexes, certain legal acts, regulations on the work of certain
public bodies, decrees with legal power , acts of autonomous political-territorial units and local government
units, the decisions of the constitutional courts) as a whole or together form the constitutional law as a
branch of the positive internal law of a certain set. Therefore, rightly it is said that the notion the constitutional
law as a branch of the law is a broader notion than the notion constitution as a juridical act. 20
The constitutional law, as the basic branch of the juridical system of any modern state, as professor
Alexander Gjurgjev expresses, "includes the juridical norms with the highest legal power, which, as a rule,
are systematized and codified in the constitution as a written and codified legal act and which of importance
is at the top of the hierarchy of general legal acts. 21 By Gjurgjev's definition “it can be learned " that the
notion of the constitutional law as a branch of the law "unifies or equates with the notion of the constitution (in
the formal sense) as a juridical act, respectively the constitutional law as a branch of the law is identified with
the legal norms in the constitution as a written and codified juridical act with the highest legal power within the
framework of the positive juridical order of a certain state." In this case, it is drawn the attention that the
constitutional law as a branch of the law does not fully comply with the juridical norms ratified and expressed
in the constitution as a juridical act.
Moreover, to confuse or to take as synonymous the constitutional law as a branch of the law with the
constitution as a legal act means to identify the exclusive juridical source in the constitution, so the alpha and
omega juridical source of the constitutional law: such a definition is ungrounded and unstable even from the
side of the juridical constitutional logic. In the most general sense, as a branch of the positive law of a certain
state as professor, Kurtesh Saliu states ,"the constitutional law implies the entirety of the juridical norms that
have a constitutional value and importance, which regulate the fundamental and most important social and
political relationships that deal with the political power and the ratio on the political power and which are
formulated and codified in a unique juridical- political document (act) called the Constitution (or by any other
name, but which has the character and the power of the highest juridical act in the state). 22
4. Conclusions
In this case, it should be considered that only those juridical norms which enjoy absolute legal priority in
relation to all other legal norms, have constitutional value and importance and as such, and, as such, they
determine the form( shape ) of the state rule, the form of state regulation, the form of the political regime, the
form of the organization of state power and the relationship among the legislative power, the executive-
administrative power and the judicial power within it, and the juridical position of man and citizen in the state
and society, which is expressed or manifested by guaranteeing and protecting the fundamental freedoms,
rights and duties of man and citizen.

20 Dr. Jovan Stefanoviç, Ustavno pravo, Zagreb, 1956, pg. 5.
21 Dr. Aleksandar Gjurgjev, Dr. Marijana Pajvançiç, Ustavno pravo, Novi Sad, 1991, pg. 13.
22 Dr. Kurtesh Saliu, E drejta kushtetuese, Prishtinë, 2004, pg 27.
441
The junction (cross) of different viewpoints is preferred as the best and the most appropriate way to achieve
the most rational definition. In accord with that, by crossing various views regarding the definition of the
notion of the constitutional law is reached to" the integral definition" or " the comprehensive definition" of the
constitutional law as follows:
The constitutional law, as a fundamental and special branch of the law within the framework of the
positive juridical system of a certain state, represents the whole of the juridical norms with the highest
juridical power, through which the fundamental social and political relations are regulated, the state
organization is constituted, the basis of the social and political regulation of the state and the main principles
of the constitutional order are set, the organization, the structure, the competences and the reciprocal
relationships among the highest state bodies are regulated, including and their relationship with the citizens,
there are defined the fundamental freedoms, rights and duties of man and citizen through which are
established and determined the juridical boundaries of the state power, and also there are set the guarantees
for their realization in practice.
References
Fjalori i shqipes së sotme, Akademia e Shkencave e Shqipërisë, Instituti i Gjuhësisë dhe i Letërsisë, Shtëpia Botuese, Toena, Tiranë,
2002, pg. 979.
1 Dr. Esat Stavileci, Nocione dhe parime të administratës publike, Prishtinë, 2005, pg. 17.
1 See: Dr. Aleksandar Gjurgjev, Dr. Marijana Pajvançiç, Ustavno pravo, Novi Sad, 1991, pg. 14; Dr. Svetomir Shkariq, Sporedbeno i
makedonsko ustavno pravo, Shkup, 2004, pg. 5; Dr. Krenar Loloçi, E drejta kushtetuese, Tiranë, 1997, pg. 15 - 16.
1 Dr. Svetomir Shkariç, cited work.,pg . 3.14;
1 By the expression ‘people’ the science of the Constitutional Law means the entirity of the citizens of a certain state – citied by Dr.
Xhezair Zaganjori, Demokracia dhe shteti i së drejtës, Tiranë, 2002, pg. 32.
1 Veljko Mratoviç, Dr. Nikolla Filipoviç, Dr. Smiljko Sokol, Ustavno pravo i politiçke institucije, Zagreb, 1986,pg. 26.
Stavro Vinjau, E drejta konstitucionale, Tiranë, 1923,pg. 28. – Dr. Ismet Elezi, Mendimi juridik shqiptar, Tiranë, 1999, pg. 37 – 41.
1 Dr. Dhimo M. Dhima, E drejta kushtetuese e Republikës Popullore të shqipërisë, Tiranë, 1963, pg. 6.
1 Dr. Luan Omari, Parime dhe institucione të së drejtës publike, Tiranë, 2006,pg. 8.
1 Dr. Nikolla Viskoviç, Teorija drzhave i prava, Zagreb, 2001,pg. 272.
1 Dr. Nurko Pobriç, Ustavno pravo, Mostar, 2000, pg. 21.
1 The state mechanism, in its most general sense can be defined as a system of state bodies through which the state power is realised
and the managerial role of the state in the society is ensured .The state mechanism consists of different bodies which differ from
each other on “ the task they complete and the role they have” in thi mechanism.
In’the main parts of the state mechanism‘ are included:the head of the state;government;administrative body; order force; and armed
force .- cited by Dr. Dimitar Bajallxhiev, Voved vo pravoto – prva kniga, Shkup, 1999, pg. 325.
1 Dr. Nurko Pobriç, work cited pg.15.
1 Dr. Owen Hood-Phillips, Constitutional and Administrative law, London, 1967, pg. 11. – Cited by Dr. Krenar Loloçi, E drejta
1 The juridical act is defined as a technical – juridical instrument ( means)for ‘the creation, expression and implementation of the law’.-
cited by Dr. Dimitar Bajallxhiev, Voved vo pravoto – kniga vtora, Shkup, 1999, pg. 103.
Related to the definition of the juridical act as a technical-juridical instrument( means): first
for ‘ the creation and expression’ of ‘the law’, and second for ‘ the implementation’’ of the law’ it should be pointed out the fact that these
two dimensions are not present in all juridical acts. For example the constitution as the highest juridical act, act with the highest
juridical power, it is not an act through which the law is implemented, but it is an act through which the law only is created. That
because there does not exist any other juridical act above the constitution that it would have to execute.
1 Veljko Mratoviç, Dr. Nikolla Filipoviç, Dr. Smiljko Sokol, Ustavno pravo i politiçke institucije, Zagreb, 1986, pg. 26.
1 Dr. Zejnullah Gruda, E drejta ndërkombëtare publike, Prishtinë, 2007,pg. 3 – 4.
1 In Albanian language to mark the constitutional law as an applicative juridical discipline, not rarely it is used the optional term, or the
alternative expression “the constitutional law ”. After the declaration of Albania as an independent and sovereign state on
November the 28-th 1912, that discipline firstly was known as The fundamental law” (Kristo Floqi, E drejta themelore, Shkodër,
1920), while in 1920-1924 as “The constitutional law” (Stavro Vinjau, E drejta konstitucionale, Tiranë, 1923). – cited by Dr. Luan
Omari, Dr. Aurela Anastasi, E drejta kushtetuese, Tiranë, 2008, pg. 10 – 11.
442
An Examination of the Usage of Vocabulary Retention Techniques (VRTs)

of Thai Undergraduate EFL Students
Win Jenpattarakul
Assistant Professor, Language Institute

Bangkok University, Thailand
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.443
Abstract: This study aimed to 1) investigate the usage of vocabulary retention techniques (VRTs) of the second-year students at
Bangkok University 2) compare the usage of vocabulary retention techniques (VRTs) between achievers and underachievers 3)
compare the usage of vocabulary retention techniques (VRTs) of the second-year students who have different reading behavior
outside of class. The instruments used for collecting data were a questionnaire and an in-depth interview. Proportional stratified
random sampling was employed to formulate a sample of 364 students from nine faculties of Bangkok University. The data were
statistically analyzed in terms of mean and standard deviation. t-Test analysis was used to find the difference between achievers
and underachievers on the usage of vocabulary retention techniques (VRTs). In addition, One-way Analysis of Variance
(ANOVA) and Welch test were used to compare the usage of vocabulary retention techniques (VRTs) of students with different
reading behavior outside of class. For the in-depth interview, six underachievers and six achievers were randomized through a
simple random sampling technique to give their opinions on the questions provided, and the data were collected to assure the
results of the study. The results of this study showed that the overall usage of vocabulary retention techniques (VRTs) of
Bangkok University students was at a medium level, and significant differences existed in vocabulary retention techniques
(VRTs) usage between the achievers and underachievers and of the students with different reading behavior outside of class.
The findings of this research would help the teachers to improve the process and material for teaching and learning vocabulary
retention techniques (VRTs) and raise awareness of vocabulary retention techniques(VRTs) among the students in order to
enhance the students’ lexical competence which can develop their reading comprehension. Pedagogical implications into
teaching vocabulary retention techniques (VRTs) were suggested.
Keywords: Reading comprehension, vocabulary retention
1. Introduction
Vocabulary is now a current focus in ESL pedagogy and research and has been increasingly recognized as
essential to language use because inadequate vocabulary can lead to the learners’ difficulty in language
reception and production (Wei, 2007). Vocabulary knowledge is important because it encompasses all the
words we must know to access our background knowledge, express our ideas, communicate effectively, and
learn about new concept. Vocabulary is the glue that holds stories, ideas, and context together, making
comprehension accessible for the readers. In addition, vocabulary knowledge is essential to reading
comprehension and determines how well the readers will be able to comprehend the texts they read in
middle and high school. If the readers do not know the meaning of a sufficient proportion of the words in the
text, comprehension is impossible. Knowing at least 90 percent of the words enable the readers to get the
main idea from the reading and guess correctly what many of unfamiliar words mean. In other words, the
students will not be able to comprehend the text that has too many unfamiliar words more than 10 percent
(Sedita, 2005). Likewise, Good and Cheng (2009) mentioned that reading comprehension is not successful
because of the great unknown vocabularies that make it difficult or even impossible to get the main idea or
specific detail of the text. Apart from the advantages to the language use, vocabulary knowledge was linked
strongly to academic and professional success because the students who have a large amount of
vocabularies can understand new ideas and concepts more quickly than the students with limited
vocabularies. The high correlation in the research literature of vocabulary knowledge with reading
443
comprehension indicates that if the people do not adequately and steadily grow their vocabulary knowledge,
reading comprehension will be affected (Chall & Jacobs,2003 cited in Sedita, 2005; Beleghizadeh & Ashoori,
2010). In brief, vocabulary plays a vital role in language use, and academic and career advancement. As a
result, a great deal of researches including empirical researches and theories about vocabulary learning and
vocabulary acquisition to enhance vocabulary size which is directly linked to language use are in attention
(Oxford, 1990; Nation, 2008; Wei, 2007; Good and Cheng, 2009). However, it is useless if the students learn
a lot of words or possess a large number of vocabularies but they can’t remember or retain in their long-term
memories. Wei (2007) stated that nowadays long-term retention has received wide attention as one of the
greatest problems in learning new words. Quinn and Irvings (1997) mentioned that the hardest way to learn
the new words is to try to memorize a list of unrelated words and their meanings. The students need not only
learn a lot of words, but to remember them. Unlike the learning of grammar which is essentially a rule-based
system, vocabulary knowledge is largely a question of accumulating individual item. The important point is
that the students must be able to store and retrieve the vocabularies when they read for comprehension
(Thornbury, 2008). Similarly, the inability to recall the known words adversely affects not only reading
comprehension but also spoken and written discourse (Wei, 2007). Therefore, the problem of remembering a
large number of vocabularies is common for the English learners around the world as well as Thai students.
In Thailand, Thai students including Bangkok University students naturally like to learn word list by rote for
examination which will disappear from their memories very soon, so this vocabulary retention method is
proved useless and unproductive. This problem can lead to poor score of English reading test because they
will forget the learned words very soon since they can’t store and retrieve the words immediately (Folse,
2004). Moreover, there are several problems which make Thai students fail to learn new vocabularies which
result in the inability to retain a large amount of new words in their long-term memories (Sribayak,
Sirihanjanavong & Charoenchang, 2012). Here are the problems of Thai students.
1. They lack independent reading. That is, they do not like reading outside class, so they read less. The less
the students read, the fewer the chances they encounter the new vocabularies.
2. They do not use context clues when reading. So, they can’t infer and guess the word meaning from
context. Hence, they can’t unlock the meaning of the unfamiliar words and can’t get the gist of the text.
3. They always look up the words in a dictionary to find the meaning of difficult words immediately when they
encounter them which will interrupt their reading comprehension. Besides, they do not use a monolingual
dictionary (English-English dictionary), but they use the pocket or electronic dictionary that can be
misleading.
4. When they look up the meanings of the new words in a dictionary, they do not pay attention to parts of
speech, word origins, and example sentences. Consequently, they cannot use those words appropriately
and they will disappear from their memories soon.
5. They ignore the pronunciations of the new words they learned. So, they mispronounce the words which
obstruct the ability to remember the new words.
6. They do not repeat the learned words despite the repetition promotes the word retention. What’s more,
they like to copy the vocabulary exercises from their friends, so they have no chance to repeat or recycle
the learned words which will improve word retention.
7. They do not use the learned words to write the stories in their personal context.
8. They do not like independent study but they like being spoon-fed with the vocabulary knowledge and
prefer the teachers to translate vocabulary.
9. They are usually overloaded with a large number of words each classroom time. This practice is not good
because the words learned over spaced learning session were retained better than words that were
learned in concentrated burst (Thornbury, 2008).
In order to solve the above-mentioned problems, Bangkok University teachers have educated the
students about how to use vocabulary retention techniques abbreviated to VRTs in this research because
they can help the students to store a large number of vocabularies in their long-term memories and recall or
444
retrieve to achieve reading comprehension (Oxford, 1990; Thornbury, 2008; Nation, I.S.P. , 2008; Nemati,
2009). Furthermore, VRTs will make the students happy to learn a lot of words as they can keep those words
in memory which can contribute to optimistic attitude and increased confidence in learning vocabulary.
Oxford (1990) stated that long-term retention has received wide attention as one of the greatest problems in
learning the new words. Vocabulary is by far the most sizable and unmanageable component in language
learning, but VRTs help the students to cope with this difficulty.
Therefore, this research would like to investigate what VRTs and how frequently the students employ as
well as whether or not different groups of students (achievers and underachievers) and the students’ reading
behavior outside of class affect the usage of VRTs. The findings of this research will help the teachers to
improve the process and material for teaching and learning VRTs usage and raise awareness about VRTs
among the students in order to enhance the students’ lexical competence which can develop their reading
comprehensions when they read the text or other reading materials in their university courses and future
careers.
2. Definitions of Terms
2.1 Achievers refer to the second-year students at Bangkok University who got grade A, B+, and B in an
intermediate English course of the academic year of 2011.
2.2 Underachievers refer to the second-year students at Bangkok University who got grade C+, C, D+, and
D in an intermediate English course of the academic year of 2011.
2.3 Vocabulary retention techniques which are abbreviated to VRTs in this research refer to the techniques
by which the students use to store vocabularies in long-term memory and recall or retrieve easily to achieve
reading comprehension. In this research, 12 types of VRTs which Bangkok University students have already
learned are based on (Nemati, 2009; Thornbury, 2008; Oxford, 1990; Lenier and Maker, 1984). The definition
of each type is examined as follows:
1. Pronouncing the word correctly refers to figuring out the pronunciations of the new words and speaking
aloud and consistently.
2. Using word study and context refers to remembering the new words or expressions from collocation,
word family or derivation, idiom usage, breaking down the new words, and context where the words are
located.
3. Checking etymology refers to checking word history and origin of word. For example, to remember that
“draconian” means strict and severe, the students have to read the history of Draco who is a lawyer passing
a strict and severe law. To remember that “concur” means agree or happen at the same time, the students
have to check the origin of word saying that it is from Latin and consists of “con” or “com” meaning together
and “cur” meaning run. So, “concur” means run together, agree, or happen together which are closely similar
to agreeing or happening together.
4. Making visual picture refers to either mental or actual picture of what has been heard or read. For
example, to remember “taciturn” which means speaking very little and
unfriendly, the students have to create the picture of their friends who have this
characteristic, and whenever they see this word, they will close their eyes and make
a mental picture of those friends. Another example is that when the students want to
remember “pinnacle” which means the highest point, they will close their eyes and think of the picture of the
mountain especially its top.
5. grouping and making acronym
5.1 Grouping refers to classifying words into categories in order to remember them easily. For instance, you
group names of vehicles or tools as shown here.
445
(Vehicle : car, bus, train) (Tool : hammer, axe, chisel)

5.2 Making acronym refers to joining the initial letters of each word in order to make a new word. For
example, “boyfans” is an acronym created by joining the initial letters of the following words: but, or, yet, for,
and, nor, so.
6. Mind map refers to creating a diagram in which the key concept (stated in word) is
highlighted and linked with related concept via arrows or lines. Below is an example of mind map where the
concept “hair” is mapped with its related concepts.
Source: Oxford (1990, p. 64)
7. Rhyming refers to linking the new words with other words which have very similar sounds. For example,
the students rhyme “callow” with “shallow”, “eschew” with “shoo”, and “gigantic” with “titanic.”
8. Doing vocabulary exercises refers to doing the tests or exercises, which is equivalent to recycling the
learned words in a different way from the time the students first met them, not in their original contexts. The
tests or exercises include matching definition, filling in the blank, which word does not belong to, and prefix
and suffix.
9. Placing new words into a personal context refers to writing the learned words and expressions the
students are trying to remember in a sentence, paragraph or story relating to their lives and interests.
10. Word association refers to associating new words with the known or familiar words or with things, events,
or concepts already in memory. For example, to remember that “microscopic” means small, the students
could associate it with the known word “micro” which also means small, or when they want to remember that
“mayhem” means chaos and confusion, they could associate it with Thailand’s uprising called “Bloody May”
taking place in May, 1992 when chaos was widespread in Bangkok, killing many people.
11. Using keyword refers to connecting the pronunciation of the second language (English) with the meaning
of the first language (Thai) plus generating an imagination. For example, the students connect the sound of
the English word “condolence” with the meaning in Thai “CON-DO-LOM” which means that the condominium
collapsed, and they further imagine that when the condominium collapsed, many victims will die and be
injured, causing the great sorrow. Normally, people should offer the sympathy and sadness to the victims’
446
relatives, which is equivalent to the meaning of “condolence.” Another example is that the students connect
the sound of the English word “jeopardy” with the meaning in Thai “JEB-POR-DEE” which means at risk,
dangerous, and be destroyed. So, when something is in jeopardy, it means that it is at risk, dangerous, and
destroyed.
12. Repeating and reviewing refer to rehearsing and practicing the learned words by saying, listening,
speaking and writing several times over spaced intervals until the students reach the stage of automatic use.
3. Purposes of the Study
This study aims to:

1. investigate the usage of vocabulary retention techniques of the second-year students at Bangkok
University.
2. compare the usage of vocabulary retention techniques between the achievers and underachievers.
3. compare the usage of vocabulary retention techniques of the second-year students who have different
reading behavior outside of class (often, sometimes, and never).
1. What is the vocabulary retention techniques usage of Bangkok University students?

2. Do the achievers and underachievers have different vocabulary retention techniques usage?
3. Do the students with different reading behavior outside of class have different vocabulary retention
techniques usage?
5.1 Types of Vocabulary Retention Techniques (VRTs)
Oxford (1990) suggested memory strategies, sometimes called mnemonics, which have a highly specific
function: helping the students store and retrieve new information when needed for communication. Eight
types of memory strategies are examined as follows:
1. Grouping refers to classifying language material into meaningful units, either mentally or in writing, to make
the material easier to remember by reducing the number of discrete elements. Groups can be based on type
of word (e.g., all nouns or verbs), topic (e.g., words about weather), linguistic function (e.g., apology, request,
demand), and so on. The power of this strategy may be enhanced by using acronym to remember the
groups.
2. Associating / Elaborating refers to relating new language information to concepts already in memory or
linking the new word with one the students already know to create association in memory. The associations
can be simple or complex, mundane or strange, but they must be meaningful to the students. For example,
to remember that “erroneous” means mistaken, the students could associate it with the word “error” or to
remember that “nonpartisan” means unconnected with a political party, they could associate it with the
phrase “no party.”
3. Placing new words into a context or retrieval refers to placing a word or phrase in a meaningful sentence,
conversation, or story in order to remember it. It is the best way of ensuring the new words will be added to
long-term memory.
4. Using imagery refers to relating new language information to concepts in memory by means of meaningful
visual imagery, either in the mind or in actual drawing.
5. Semantic mapping refers to making an arrangement of words into a picture, which has a key concept at
the center or at the top linked with related words and concepts by means of lines and arrows.
447
6. Using keyword refers to remembering a new word by using auditory and visual links. The first step is to
identify a familiar word in one’s own language that sounds like the new word-this is the “auditory link.” The
second step is to generate an image of some relationship between the new word and a familiar one-this is
the “visual link.” Both links
must be meaningful to the students. For example, to learn the new French word potage (soup), the English
speaker associates it with a pot and then pictures a pot full of potage. To use a keyword to remember
something abstract, such as a name, associate it with the picture of something concrete that sounds like the
new word. For example, Minnesota can be remembered by the image of a mini soda.
7. Representing sounds in memory refers to remembering new language information according to its sound,
such as using rhyme to remember a word.
8. Structured reviewing refers to reviewing in carefully spaced intervals, at first close together and then more
widely spaced apart. This strategy might start, for example, with a review 10 minutes after the initial learning,
then 20 minutes later, an hour or two later, a day later, 2 days later, a week later, and so on.
In addition, Pickrell (2010), Thornbury (2008), and Lenier & Maker (1984) also proposed other techniques for
vocabulary retention. Here is the definition of each technique.
1. Repetition refers to repeated rehearsal of the material. The important repetition is not rote learning but
repetition of encounter with a word since it has been estimated that, whe reading, words stand a good
chance of being remembered if they have been met at least seven times over spaced intervals.
2. Motivation refers to the students’ wanting to learn new words and spend more time on rehearsal and
practice, which in the end will pay off in terms of memory.
3. Repeating new words out loud regularly refers to taking the time to learn the pronunciation of certain words
and practice saying them clearly with consistency. Repeat these words as often as possible and use them in
a sentence to increase the retention skills.
4. Practicing context refers to practicing using words in the context or avoidance of learning fragments of
word and phrase without context so that the students learn how to use the words correctly.
5. Creating your own vocabulary list refers to creating a list of words around a particular subject so that the
students can learn them in context and practice using as often as possible in order to improve their rate of
retention.
6. Reading in the new language refers to reading foreign newspaper, book, or magazine. Even if the students
do not understand all of the words, they can pick out new words and look up their definitions as they go
along. This will help them understand a lot of new words in context and also help them learn about sentence
pattern and structure.
7. Using flashcards refers to putting the words on a flashcard by writing the word and its pronunciation on one
side of the card, and writing the definition and a sentence using the word on the other side.
8. Recycling refers to doing the tests or exercises in which the students can encounter the learned words in a
different way from the time they first met them, not in their original contexts. The tests or exercises include
matching definition, filling in the blank, whichword does not belong to, and prefix and suffix.
9. Checking etymology refers to checking word history and origin of word.
5.2 Related Researches on Vocabulary Retention Techniques (VRTs)
A number of related researches about the benefits of VRTs have been done. Some compare the advantages
of VRTs while some experiment the benefits of a variety of VRTs. Two pieces of researches were done to
compare the effect of 2 types of VRTs on students’ long-term memories. The first one was carried out by
Baleghizadeh & Ashoori (2010) who compared the effect of keyword and word list method on immediate
retention of English vocabulary in a natural classroom setting. The results showed that the keyword method
produced better recall compared to word list method, suggesting a promising educational value for its utility.
Secondly, Pishghadam &Khodadady (2010) did an action research to compare the impact of visual and
448
verbal intelligence-based teaching on vocabulary retention and written production. Visual intelligence-based
teaching is based on pictures, drawings, graphic symbols, and imaginations whereas verbal intelligence-
based teaching is based on storytelling, brainstorming, tape recording, journal writing, and paper completion
in traditional classroom. The subjects were 71 male and female Iranian EFL students. The results showed
that the students’ retention of words in visual experimental group was enhanced by visual intelligence-based
teaching of vocabularies, while the students’ retention of words in verbal experimental group was not.
Moreover, the results of writing test exhibited that visual intelligence-based teaching of vocabularies could
change the passive vocabulary knowledge of the visual experimental group into an active one.
In addition, the following researches have examined the usefulness of VRTs. Nemati (2009) examined the
effect of teaching memory strategies consisting of grouping, making acronym, and using imagery in his study
on experimental group in comparison to control group. The findings revealed that the students of
experimental group outperformed both in short-term and long-term scores, portraying the superiority of
memory strategies in short-term and long-term retention. Giving strategy awareness to the students can
facilitate them to store and retrieve new vocabulary items as well. Another research which showed the benefit
of vocabulary retention techniques was conducted by Baleghizadeh and Naeim (2011). They would like to
explore the effect of etymology presentation of 30 low frequent words on short-term and long-term vocabulary
retention of EFL learners. The participants were 30 students divided into experimental and control group.
While both groups were asked to look up the meaning of the words in their dictionaries, the experimental
group received a short instruction on the etymologies of the words. The results of both immediate and
delayed posttests demonstrated the mnemonic efficacy of etymology presentation.
Semantic mapping is another vocabulary retention technique which Baleghizadeh and Naeim (2011)
experimented in his research with a single-subject study: a 45-year-old male learner learning English at the
pre-intermediate level. The results showed that the use of semantic mapping improved the learner’s ability to
remember and recall the words and their definitions better. The last research involving utilizing e-mail as
learning tool was conducted by Fahim and Motallebzadeh (2011). His study aimed to examine the effect of e-
mail on vocabulary retention of Iranian EFL learners. Forty participants were assigned into experimental and
control groups. The participants received English words as well as definitions and example sentences either
on paper or through e-mail messages in a spaced and scheduled pattern of delivery three times a week
throughout 10 sessions. The results showed that the use of e-mail technology can enhance the retention of
vocabulary.
In conclusion, a number of researches conducted in different countries where English is taught as a
foreign language showed that using a variety of VRTs, such as using keyword, using visual imagery,
grouping, using acronym, checking etymology, and mind map are beneficial to the students’ word retention.
Therefore, it is worth investigating Bangkok University students’ preference for VRTs usage and problems of
using VRTs so that the teachers can effectively manage the teaching and learning vocabulary. As a result,
the students will enjoy learning vocabularies which will bring about better word retention skill.
6.1 Research Design
This research is a survey design. The population of this study was 3,762 second-year students enrolling in
intermediate English course of the academic year of 2011 at Bangkok University, and 364 samples were
selected from Stratified Random Sampling technique. The estimated sample size was based on Taro
Yamane table. A 95% of confidence level was selected with a precision rate of ± 5%. In this study, the
independent variables are two groups of the students (achievers and underachievers) and reading behavior
outside of class while the dependent variable is VRTs usage.
449
6.2 Instrument
The instruments used for collecting data were a questionnaire and an in-depth interview. The questionnaire
consists of two parts. The first part is about the respondent’s background and the second part is based on
VRTs proposed by (Nemati, 2009; Thornbury, 2008; Oxford, 1990; Lenier and Maker, 1984). This part
consists of 30 items in the form of Likert rating scales ranging from very frequently, frequently, sometimes,
rarely, to never. The congruence index of the questionnaire was 0.8 and Cronbach’s Coefficient Alpha was
used to calculate the reliability of the questionnaire. It was found that the reliability of this questionnaire was
0.95. Besides, the in-depth interview was conducted to elicit the further information about the usage of VRTs.
6.3 Data Analysis
6.3.1 Percentage was used to demonstrate the background information of the students and mean and
standard deviation were employed to analyze the level of VRTs usage. The computed weighted means of
VRTs usage were interpreted in the form of range as shown below.
Mean range Level of vocabulary retention Meaning

techniques (VRTs) usage
4.50-5.00 very extensive using VRTs with most frequency
3.50-4.49 extensive using VRTs with much frequency
2.50-3.49 Medium using VRTs with medium frequency
1.50-2.49 Little using VRTs with little frequency
1.00-1.49 very little using VRTs with very little frequency
6.3.2 A t-Test analysis was used to compare the mean scores of the opinions on VRTs usage of the
achievers and underachievers.
6.3.3 One-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) or Welch test was employed to test the mean scores of the
opinions on VRTs usage of the students who have different reading behavior outside of class. If there is a
statistically significant difference, post hoc test method (Bonferroni for equal variance and Dunnett’s T3for
non-equal variance) will be used to compare each pair.
7. Result, Discussion, and Conclusion
This part will present the result, discussion, and conclusion of the research questions
1-3 as well as the result of the in-depth interview which will be used to assure the research findings. The
results are shown as follows:
7.1 Result, Discussion and Conclusion of the Research Questions 1-3
Research Question 1: What is the vocabulary retention techniques (VRTs) usage of Bangkok University
students?
Table 1: The result of the usage of VRTs by Bangkok University students
Vocabulary Retention Techniques (VRTs) S.D. Level


1.Grouping and Making Acronym 3.35 .87 Medium
2.Word Association 3.33 .86 Medium
3.Pronouncing the word correctly 3.29 .82 Medium
450
4.Making Visual Picture 3.26 .87 Medium

5.Repeating and Reviewing 3.25 .86 Medium
6.Doing Vocabulary Exercises 3.24 .86 Medium
7.Mind Map 3.23 .95 Medium
8.Using Keyword 3.21 .91 Medium
9.Rhyming 3.20 .89 Medium
10.Using Word Study and Context 3.19 .71 Medium
11.Placing New Words into a Personal Context 3.09 .89 Medium
12. Checking Etymology 2.98 .93 Medium
Total 3.21 .98 Medium
Table 1 shows the result of VRTs usage of Bangkok University students and leads to the discussion and
conclusion of the research question 1: What is the vocabulary retention techniques (VRTs) usage of Bangkok
University students?
According to table 1, the overall usage of VRTs was (  = 3.21) which could be interpreted that the
students use all VRTs moderately. The three most frequently used VRTs were grouping and making acronym
(  = 3.35), word association (  = 3.33), and pronouncing the word correctly (  = 3.29) respectively.
These items were at a medium level. However, the three least frequently used are checking etymology (  =
2.98), placing new words into a personal context (  = 3.09), using word study and context (  = 3.19).
As stated in the result, the three VRTs which were used most by the students are discussed accordingly.
The result is in line with Nemati (2009) claiming that the students preferred using grouping and making
acronym because they act as the hooks to help the students to retrieve better in the long run. However, for
the technique of grouping, the teacher should encourage the students’ awareness of using this technique
because Oxford (1990) suggested that the arrangement things in order like grouping must be personally
meaningful to the learners, otherwise the retention will be failed. Regarding word association, the students
also realized the benefit of using this technique. However, the teacher should stimulate them to use it more
often by encouraging them to actively construct links between new information and previously known
information about a word because being active and cognizant of this process will result in better memory for
the new words (Sedita, 2005). In terms of pronouncing the word correctly which was placed the third of VRTs
usage, the students are on the right track because they realize that the knowledge of a word must include
knowing not only how it is written, how it is used as a part of speech, but also how it sounds (Sedita, 2005).
However, they should be encouraged to practice this technique continuously since if the students take time to
learn the pronunciations of certain words and practice saying them clearly with consistency, it will increase
their retention skills (Pickrell, 2010). Similarly, Thornbury (2008) proposed that the teacher should direct
attention to the sounds of the new words particularly the way the words are stressed because the students
can exploit the sound of the words to facilitate storage in memory. In order to improve the word
pronunciation of the students, it is necessary to guide them to use English-English dictionary effectively.
Since the students can’t tell the pronunciations of the words from their spelling, they have to look up the
words in pronunciation guide in the dictionary. If they can pronounce a new word to themselves, they are
more likely to remember it (Lenier and Maker, 1984). In addition, to remember the meaning of a new word,
the teacher should tell the students to make the best use of the dictionary to reword the definition in their own
words, to identify synonyms and antonyms for the word, to use the word in their own meaningful sentences,
and to explore the meanings of the words when they are used in other contexts.
On the other hand, the three VRTs which the students used least are checking etymology, placing new
word into a personal context, and using word study and context. The result was in line with Sribayak,
Sirihanjanavong & Charoenchang (2012) who compiled the problems which make Thai students fail to learn
the new vocabularies, resulting in the inability to retain a large amount of new words in their long-term
memories. The result can be explained as follows:
451
1. Thai students lack independent reading. That is, they do not like reading outside of class, so they read
less. The less the students read, the fewer the chances they encounter new vocabularies. In this case,
checking etymology consumes time to read a long story, so the students do not prefer using this technique.
2. Thai students do not use the learned words to write the stories in their personal contexts, so they do not
prefer using the technique of placing new word into a personal context.
3. Thai students do not use context clues when reading. So, they can’t infer word meaning and can’t guess
the words from context. As a result, they can’t unlock the meaning of the unfamiliar words and can’t get the
gist of the text.
According to the result, the students also prefer making visual picture because it is a simple and effective
way to remember the words. The findings are in consistent with Oxford (1990) who confirmed the importance
of using picture to aid memory for four reasons. First, a large proportion of learners have a preference for
visual learning. Second, the mind’s storage capacity for visual information exceeds its capacity for verbal
material. Third, the most efficiently packaged chunks of information are transferred to long-term memory
through visual images. Fourth, visual images may be the most potent device to aid recall of verbal material.
With regard to the technique of doing vocabulary exercises and of repeating and reviewing which are
equal to vocabulary recycling. Thornbury (2008) proposed the idea of recycling which is the remedy against
forgetting. He stated that spaced review of learned material can dramatically reduce the rate of forgetting, but
it’s not enough simply to repeat the words in their original contexts. Much better is to recycle them in different
ways, and, ideally, at successive levels of depth. He suggested that if learners see or use a word in a way
different from the way they first met, then better learning is achieved. Hence, in order to provide the students
with an opportunity to recycle vocabulary, the teachers should review the vocabulary exercises after teaching
reading passage because the students will re-encounter and repeat words in a way different from the way
they first met them in a reading passage. As a result, they can retain vocabulary better.
For the techniques of grouping and making acronym, word association, mind-map, using keyword, and
rhyming which need creativity and personalization, the teachers should encourage the students to realize that
these VRTs must be self-generated or self-created, i.e. not borrowed from other learners or teachers. The
students must be aware that these VRTs can be simple, complex, mundane, unusual, and silly in the eyes of
others, but they must make sense and be meaningful to the students themselves because the students
themselves not other who will use these techniques to remember vocabularies (Oxford, 1990; Thornbury,
2008).
In conclusion, based on the result and discussion of research question 1, it is recommended that the
teachers should boost the students to integrate every vocabulary retention technique and use them
interchangeably since there is no single technique which is regarded the best and works well. What’s more,
some VRTs have limitation, such as using keyword which cannot be applied with the abstract words, and it is
difficult to think of keyword that sounds like foreign words. In such case, the students must use other VRTs to
help retain vocabularies (Thornbury, 2008; Baleghizadeh & Ashoori, 2010).
Research Question 2: Do the achievers and underachievers have different vocabulary retention techniques
usage?
Table 2: The result of vocabulary retention techniques usage between the achievers and
underachievers
Vocabulary Retention Techniques (VRTs) Achievers Underachievers Statistical test
S.D. S.D. t p
 
1. Grouping and Making Acronym 3.53 .84 3.20 .87 3.682** <.001
2. Word Association 3.58 .80 3.12 .84 5.405** <.001
3. Pronouncing the word correctly 3.48 .76 3.12 .83 4.306** <.001
4. Making Visual Picture 3.44 .89 3.12 .83 3.624** <.001
452
5. Repeating and Reviewing 3.42 .79 3.12 .89 3.369** <.001

6. Doing Vocabulary Exercises 3.43 .81 3.09 .87 3.860** <.001
7. Mind Map 3.39 .97 3.10 .91 2.960** <.004
8. Using Keyword 3.47 .83 2.99 .91 5.266** <.001
9. Rhyming 3.40 .88 3.03 .86 4.098** <.001
10. Using Word Study and Context 3.39 .66 3.03 .71 4.952** <.001
11. Placing New Words into a Personal Context 3.24 .85 2.95 .91 3.104** <.001
12. Checking Etymology 3.07 .96 2.90 .91 1.684 .093
Total 3.39 .96 3.06 .97 4.929** <.001
Table 2 shows the result of VRTs usage between the achievers and underachievers and leads to the
discussion and conclusion of the research question 2: Do the achievers and underachievers have different
vocabulary retention techniques (VRTs) usage?
According to table 2, both achievers and underachievers had a medium level of VRTs usage, but the mean
of the achievers was higher than that of the underachievers (  =3.39 and 3.06 respectively). In terms of
statistical test, it was also found that there was a statistically significant difference between the achievers and
underachievers in the overall VRTs usage at the level of .05. Every technique had statistically significant
difference except checking etymology. In short, both achievers and underachievers employed VRTs
differently, and the former used VRTs more frequently than the latter. The possible explanation for this is that
the achievers tended to set learning goal, so they tried to study hard every subject in order to acquire a good
grade. For English subject taught at Bangkok University, especially reading part, the exam paper would
require the students to summarize and give response from what they read. They knew that VRTs were the
key factor to help them to understand the passage better, making them to be able to summarize and give
response well. So, they paid more attention to practice using VRTs effectively so that they could accomplish
the reading exam and get a good grade (Srichanyachon, 2006). In addition, the achievers are generally
more motivated to learn English than the underachievers; consequently, they spend more time on rehearsal
and practice using VRTs, which is the end will pay off in terms of memory (Thornbury, 2008).
When considering the usage of VRTs of the achievers, they frequently used the techniques of word
association and pronouncing the words correctly. This also corresponds with Thornbury (2008) suggesting
that the good vocabulary learners always pay attention to pronunciation (how the words are stressed) and
association, and they know how to organize their own learning particularly using memorizing technique.
However, the three least used VRTs of both achievers and underachievers are checking etymology,
placing new word into a personal context, and using word study and context. According to the in-depth
interview, the students said that they don’t like these VRTs because they involve grammar and vocabulary
rules and language pattern. Hence, the teachers should design the teaching of grammar and vocabulary
rules to be entertaining and easy to understand, and motivate the students to adopt VRTs. To be more
specific, first of all, as Lenier & Maker (1984) stated that taking time to read the etymology is important in
vocabulary building and retention, the teachers should stimulate the students to realize the importance of the
technique of checking etymology by having them prepare funny and interesting histories of words and the
word origins. Then let them report in the classroom and share their ideas with their friends and teacher. By
doing this constantly, they will gradually enjoy using this technique and use it more frequently. Next, the
teachers should stimulate the students to use the learned words by having them write a paragraph or story
linking the words and expressions they want to remember or having them write a diary in which they will note
down the words concerning their daily lives. By doing this, the word retention skills will be increased
(Thornbury, 2008). Lastly, the teachers should train the students to use context clue until they enjoy using it
because when they read or encounter a word in context, they remember something about the word, and
those words will be retained in their long-term memories (Sedita, 2005).
In conclusion, based on the result and discussion of research question 2, and the in-depth interview, it is
recommended that the teachers should
453
1. teach vocabulary learning strategies including using word cards, guessing from context,and using
dictionary to the students because they find them effective and enjoyable. Furthermore, vocabulary learning
strategies help the students to enhance retention skill.
2. make words easy to learn because they are better retained. Also, they should emphasize the
pronunciation because the studies show that the words that are difficult to pronounce are more difficult to
learn (Lenier & Maker, 1984; Nation, 2008).
3. not overload the students with vocabulary in one time because the overloaded new words will overwrite the
previously learned ones. That is, it is better to distribute memory work across a period of time than to mass it
together in a single block. For example, when teaching the students with a new set of words, it is best to
present the first two or three items, then go back and test these, then present some more, then backtrack
again (Thornbury, 2008).
4. motivate especially the underachievers to use the following VRTs more often because when reading they
must be able to use every technique interchangeably. Those VRTs are doing vocabulary exercises, using
keyword, rhyming, using word study and context, placing new words into a personal context, and checking
etymology.
Research Question 3: Do the students with different reading behavior outside of class have different
vocabulary retention techniques (VRTs) usage?
Table 3: The result of vocabulary retention techniques (VRTs) usage by the students with different reading
behavior outside of class
Vocabulary Retention Techniques Often Sometimes Never Statistical test

(VRTs) S.D. S.D. S.D. F p
  
1. Grouping and Making Acronym 3.64 1.02 3.37 .83 2.83 .77 9.11** <.001
2. Word Association 3.76 .81 3.34 .83 2.70 .75 16.08** <.001
3. Pronouncing the word correctly 3.75 .77 3.29 .79 2.74 .74 15.68** <.001
4. Making Visual Picture 3.57 .94 3.28 .84 2.79 .89 8.25** <.001
5. Repeating and Reviewing 3.70 1.02 3.26 .79 2.67 .86 14.91** <.001
6. Doing Vocabulary Exercises 3.58 .84 3.26 .83 2.69 .88 9.345a*
7. Mind Map 3.55 .97 3.25 .92 2.66 .91 9.29** <.001
8. Using Keyword 3.65 .97 3.22 .84 2.54 1.01 15.73** <.001
9. Rhyming 3.70 .88 3.21 .84 2.53 .87 18.29** <.001
10. Using Word Study and Context 3.48 .58 3.21 .70 2.69 .63 13.18** <.001
11.Placing New Words into a Personal 3.35 1.06 3.12 .84 2.50 .87 10.02** <.001
Context <.001
12. Checking Etymology 3.26 .78 2.99 .94 2.57 .89 5.40**
<.001
Total 3.55 1.05 3.23 .95 2.68 .94 18.60** <.001
a Welch test
Table 3 shows the result of VRTs usage of the students with different reading behavior outside of class and
leads to the discussion and conclusion of the research question 3: Do the students with different reading
behavior outside of class have different VRTs usage?
According to table 3, the students who (often, sometimes, and never) read outside of class had different
level of VRTs usage. That is, the students who often read outside of class had an extensive level of VRTs
usage (  =3.55) while the students who sometimes and never read outside of class had a medium level of
VRTs usage (  =3.23 and 2.68 respectively). The result, obtained from applying ANOVA, revealed that the
students who had different reading behavior outside of class employed overall VRTs at the level of
significance at .05. In short, reading behavior outside of class affects the usage of VRTs as the result showed
454
that the students who often read outside of class use VRTs more frequently than the students who
sometimes and never read outside of class.
The findings proved that reading outside of class serves the students’ interests because they can choose
their own books to read. When they read they have multiple exposures to words, so they can use words in
daily life until those words become part of their every speech and thought. Every time they encounter a word
in context, they develop VRTs and their long-term memories (Jacobus, 2001; Sedita 2005). Similarly,
Thornbury (2008) and Harmer (2001) said that the students require repeated visits and conscious study of
vocabularies, and much of this revisiting and studying of words will have to take place outside class time
since there simply isn’t time enough in class for review and recycling. Much of outside reading of class will
allow the students to choose material specially written for them; hence, it will improve their overall
comprehension skill and enable them to read without constantly stopping. As a result, the automatic word
recognition will be increased. Besides, Oxford (1990) suggested that the students must seek out or create
opportunities to practice any and all of the four language skills. If the students want to reach moderate to high
proficiency, classroom time cannot usually provide adequate practice opportunities. Therefore, they will need
to find additional chances to practice the language and must realize it is up to them to search for these
occasions.
In conclusion, according to the result and discussion of research question 3, it is recommended that the
teachers should assign the students to read external reading materials every week, and they have to write a
review or summary of what they read to communicate with the teachers. However, teachers have to let them
choose the reading materials in which they are interested because if the students have an opportunity to
select the books or topics they like, their reading comprehensions will be improved since they have learned to
use a variety of VRTs by themselves automatically. As a result, the automatic word retention will be
increased (Oxford, 1990; Harmer, 2001; Sedita, 2005).
7.2 Result of the In-depth Interview
The achievers gave their opinions that they realized the importance of VRTs which will help them to improve
their reading comprehension and most of them use the technique of using word study and context because
they believed that the vast majority of words could be learned and remembered from context. In addition,
they often used word association especially they usually related the new words to the words they already
know. On the other hand, the underachievers gave their opinions that they always used the technique of
visual picture because they thought that a picture will help them remember the words easily and store them in
long-term memory. However, they did not like the technique of using keyword because it was rather difficult
due to complex steps, and they thought that it is useless to use this technique to remember the new words. In
addition, they did not like VRTs involving grammar and vocabulary rules, such as using word study and
context, placing new word into a personal context, and checking etymology.
References
Baleghizadeh, S., & Ashoori, A. (2010). The effect of keyword and word list method on immediate vocabulary retention of EFL learners.
Pakistan Journal of Sciences (PJSS), 3(2), 251-261.
Baleghizadeh, S., & Naeim, M. (2011). Enhancing vocabulary retention through semantic mapping: a single-subject study. The
International Journal-Language Society and Culture, 32, 11-16.
Baleghizadeh, S., & Naeim, M. (2011). Promoting vocabulary retention through etymology presentation. Journal of Theory and Practice
in Education, 7(1), 111-123.
Fahim, M., & Motallebazdeh, K. (2011). The effect of e-mailing on vocabulary of Iranian lower intermediate EFL learners. Journal of
Language Teaching and Research, 2(6), 1385-1391.
Folse, K.S. (2004). Vocabulary myths. Ann Arbor, MI : University of Michigan Press.
455
Good, R. L., & Cheng, Y. (2009). L1 gloss: Effects on EFL learners’ reading comprehension and vocabulary retention. Reading in a
Foreign Language, 21(2), 119-142.
Harmer, J. (2001). The practice of English language teaching. England : Pearson Education limited.
Jacobus, L. A. (2001). Improving college reading. USA : Harcourt College Publishers.
Klein, M. L. (1988). Teaching reading comprehension and vocabulary (a guide for teachers). New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, Inc.
Lenier, M., & Maker, J. (1984). College reading. USA : Wadsworth, Inc.
Mansoor, F., & Khalil, M. (2011). The effect of e-mailing on vocabulary retention of Iranian lower intermediate EFL learners. Journal of
Language Teaching and Research, 2(6), 1385-1391.
Nation, I.S.P. (2008). Teaching vocabulary (strategies and techniques). Boston: Heinie.
Nemati, A. (2009). Memory vocabulary learning strategies and long-term retention. International Journal of Vocational and Technical
Education, 1(2), 14-24.
Oxford, R. L. (1990). Language learning strategies: What every teacher should know. New York: Newbury House Publishers.
Pickrell, J. (2010). How to retain and learn new vocabulary words. Retrieved December, 2010, from http://ezinearticles.com
Pishghadam, R., & Khodadady, E. (2010). The impact of visual and verbal intelligences-based teaching on the vocabulary retention and
written production of Iranian intermediate EFL learners. MJAL, 2(5), 379-395.
Quinn, S., & Irvings, S. (1997). Active reading in the arts and sciences. USA: McGraw- ill.
Sedita, J. (2005). Effective vocabulary instruction. Insights on Learning Disabilities, 2(1), 33-45.
Sribayak, V., Sirihanjanavong, V., & Charoenchang, W. (2012). Teaching vocabulary. Retrieved March, 12, 2012, from
http://www.litu.tu.ac.th/en2011
Srichanyachon, N. (2006). An analysis of goal setting for learning and obstacles to improve English learning based on the perception of
Bangkok University students taking the general English course. BU Academic Review, 6(2), 15-27.
Thornbury, S. (2008). How to teach vocabulary. England: Pearson Education Limited.
Wei, M. (2007). An examination of vocabulary learning of college-level learners of English in China. Retrieved April 12, 2007, from
http://www.asian-efl-journal.com
456
Short and Long Run Relationship Between Value of Total Stock Exchange Transaction and
Key Macroeconomic Variables in Nigeria. A Cointegration Approach
Sunday B. Akpan*
Chukwu E. Inya-Agha
Ebirigor A. Aya
Friday J. Udo
Obot D. Obot
Michael Okpara University of Agriculture, Umudike and University of Uyo

*Corresponding author: E-mail: [email protected]
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.457
Abstract:The study analyzed the short run and long run influenced of some macroeconomic variables on ttotal stock
transactions in the Nigerian stock exchange market. Unit root test (Augmented Dicker Fuller test) conducted on the data shows
that all variables are integrated of order one. The short-run and long-run elasticities of total stock transaction with respect to
some key macro-economic variables were determined using the techniques of co-integration and error correction estimation.
The empirical results reveal that coefficients of industrial capacity utilization rate, domestic savings, external reserves, total value
of import and lending rate of commercial Banks are significant in the long run. Whereas the coefficients of external debt,
domestic savings, total import, per capita real GDP; industrial capacity utilization and index of agricultural production were
significant in the short run. The result calls for a policy package that should focused on stabilization of the real and monetary
policy variables in the Nigerian economy. Also, institutional and operational reforms in the country’s capital market are inevitable
in a bit to increase the stock exchange market’s efficiency.
Key Words: Stock market, macroeconomic, total stock, short run, long run.
1. Introduction
Stock market transaction plays a vital role in stimulating economic activities in most developing economies
through mobilization of fund to the real sector and in supporting government capital and deficit expenditures
(Okereke, 2010). Basically stock exchange market serves as a channel through which surplus funds are
moved from lender-savers to borrower-spenders who have shortage of funds (Black, 1988). It provides a
platform for individuals, governments, firms and organizations to trade and invest in savings through the
purchase of shares (Sule and Momoh, 2009). The Nigerian Stock Exchange was established in 1960 as the
Lagos stock exchange; and later in December 1977 it became, The Nigerian Stock Exchange; with branches
established in some of the major commercial cities of the country. It is a private, non-profit making
organization, limited by guarantee and is incorporated through the inspiration and support of businessmen
and the federal government of Nigeria.
Stock exchange market in Nigeria is seen as an emerging financial super power that is capable of spurring
economic development and as a good complement to other financial institutions (Capasso, 2003 and NSE,
2008). A well developed stock market is expected to accelerate economic growth, by providing a boost to
domestic savings and increasing the quality of investments (Singh, 1997). Stock markets therefore are able
to optimistically influence economic growth through effective mobilization of savings amongst individuals,
promoting capital formation, creating wider avenues of investment, providing financial resources for public
and private purpose as well as fund for development purposes. In addition, it promotes corporate control, by
improving financial discipline, which is expected to provide the best guarantee of efficiency in the use of
assets.
457
Given the multifarious roles played by the stock market, its efficiency can only be strengthen by sound
economic policies, strong financial resources and institutions, political stability and increasing self reliance
economies (Singh, 1999, NSE, 2008). The Nigeria’s economy is an emerging economy that is characterized
by fluctuations in the key macroeconomic variables and this plays a major role in shaping the activities in the
stock exchange market. Since the stock market is an integral part of the economic system, therefore
understanding the relationship among individual components is a prerequisite to achieving the much needed
economic development. Such knowledge will ensure that only significant policy variables are used to
formulate intervention policy in areas of high priority in the economy such as the stock exchange market.
Therefore, the study specifically sought to determine the statistical relationship between the value of the total
stock transactions in the Nigerian stock exchange and some key macro economic variables.
It is believed that government policies and macroeconomic events have large influence on general economic
activities including the stock market transaction. Bencivenga et al., (1996) equally maintain that the level of
economic activities is affected by the stock market through its liquidity-creating ability. Chen et al. (1986) in
the US show that changes in risk premiums, industrial production, and changes in the term structure
positively correlate with the expected stock returns, while both the anticipated and unanticipated inflation
rates negatively relate to the expected stock returns. Hamao (1988) shows that inflation rate significantly
influenced Japanese stock returns. Mukherjee and Naka (1995) found that exchange rate positively relates to
stock prices in Japan and Indonesia. On the contrary, Soenen and Hennigar (1988) reported that US dollar
effective exchange rate negatively affect US stock market index during 1980 to 1986. Atje and Jovanovic
(1993) and Levine and Zervos (1996) found a significant association between economic growth and the value
of stock market for over forty countries in the period 1976 to 1993. Nishat and Shaheen, (2004) in Pakistan
found a significant negative long-term equilibrium relationship between inflation and Stock Exchange Index.
Industrial production however exhibited a positive influence on the stock exchange. Schwert (1981) in USA
confirmed a negative relationship between stock prices and inflation.
Ologunde et al., (2006) in Nigeria found a positive relationship between the prevailing interest rate and
stock market capitalization rate; and a negative correlation between the Government development stock rate
and stock market capitalization rate. Kyereboah and Agyire (2008) in Ghana found that the lending and
inflation rates affect stock market performance. Mahmudul and Gazi (2009) discovered that interest rate
exerts significant negative relationship with share price for markets in Australia, Bangladesh, Canada, Chile,
Colombia, Germany, Italy, Jamaica, Japan, Malaysia, Mexico, Philippine, South Africa, Spain, and
Venezuela. Wongbangpo and Sharma (2002) reported a negative long term linkage between stock prices
and interest rates in Philippines, Singapore and Thailand. However, a positive relation was detected in
Indonesia and Malaysia.
Khrawish1 et al., (2010) in Jordan shows a significant and positive relationship between government
prevailing interest rate and stock market capitalization rate. The study also reveals that Government
development stock rate exerts negative influence on stock market capitalization rate and the prevailing
interest rate. Hsing (2011) in Hungary discovered that stock market index has a positive relationship with real
GDP, the ratio of the government debt to GDP, the nominal effective exchange rate and the German stock
market index, a negative relationship with the real interest rate, the expected inflation rate and the
government bond yield in the euro area, and a quadratic relationship with real M2 money supply. Rahman et
al., (2009) explores the interactions between selected macroeconomic variables and stock prices in Malaysia.
The result shows that changes in Malaysian stock market index have stronger dynamic interaction with
reserves and industrial production index as compared to money supply, interest rate, and exchange rate.
Lijuan and Xu (2010) show that China’s stock prices are significantly affected by exchange rates, interest
rates, macroeconomic prosperity index, consumer’s confidence index and the corporate goods price index.
458
Maysami et al., (2004) established that the Singapore’s stock market is significantly affected by changes in
the short and long-term interest rates, industrial production, price levels, exchange rate and money supply.
3. Methodology
Study area and data source: The study was conducted in Nigeria; the country is situated on the Gulf of
Guinea in the sub Saharan Africa. Data used in the study were from the Nigerian stock exchange annual
reports account of various issues and the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN); National Bureau of Statistics;
Federal Ministry of Finance and Federal Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development publications. The
data covered the period 1970 to 2010.
4. Analytical Techniques
The cointegration and error correction models based on Engle and Granger two-step technique were used in
the study. The total stock equation is specified as follows.
STCKt = γ0 + γ1TIMt + γ2EXRt + γ3PGDt + γ4ICURt + γ5DSAt + γ6EXDTt+γ7INTERt+ γ8IAGPt + γ9ERSt + Et……………….…….. (1)
Where all variables are expressed in natural logarithm.
STCKt = value of total stock in the Nigerian stock exchange market (Nm)
TIMt = real value of total imports (Nm); EXRt = nominal exchange rate of N/$
ICURt = industry’s capacity utilization rate (%); DSAVt = domestic saving as a ratio of GDP
EXDTt = external debt as a ratio of GDP; INTERt = interest rate (lending rate) (%)
IAGPt = index of agricultural production; EXSt = external reserves as a ratio of GDP
PGDPt = real per capita GDP (Nm/person) Ut = error term and Ut ~ IID (0, δ2U).
Unit root test for variables used in the analysis

To ascertain the stationarity of the variables specified in the model, the standard Augmented Dickey – Fuller
tests were performed. Test statistics for each variable in levels and first differences are presented in Tables
1. The test result reveals that at levels, all variables (in log) used in this study are non-stationary; but
stationary at first difference and are therefore integrated of order 1 {i.e.1 (1)}. The result implies that the time
series should be tested for the existence of a cointegration among variables.
Table 1: Augmented Dicker Fuller Unit Test

Variables Level First difference Order of integration
LnTotal stock -1.564 -7.538*** 1(1)
LnSavings -1.673 -5.651*** 1(1)
LnExt. Debt -0.988 -5.993*** 1(1)
LnPCRGDP -1.962 -6.038*** 1(1)
LnICUR -1.510 -4.912*** 1(1)
LnExchange rate -2.071 -5.055*** 1(1)
LnExt. Reserves -2.454 -6.472*** 1(1)
LnValue of import -1.966 -6.943*** 1(1)
LnInterest R -1.907 -8.717*** 1(1)
LnIndex of Agric. P -2.744 -6.504*** 1(1)
Residual -4.328*** - 1(0)
Note: At level, critical value at 5% = -3.52, and at 1% = - 4.20; at first difference, critical value at 5% = -3.53
and at 1% = -4.21. Asterisk *** represents 1% significance level. Variables are as defined in equation (1)
These tests were performed by including drift and a deterministic trend in the regressions.
459
6. Cointegration Test
The concept of cointegration as developed by Granger (1981) is based on the determination of the long-run
relationships among non-stationary time series. Hence, prior to applying the standard procedure of the
cointegration tests to any series, one technical condition must be fully satisfied. That is for the series in
consideration, the variables must be integrated of the same order or non-stationary individually. Applying the
two-step Engle and Granger technique, the first step is based on estimating the cointegration regression (i.e.
equation 1) which is also the long run total stock value equation for the Nigerian stock market. To determine
whether the variables are cointegrated is to test the null hypothesis of whether the estimated residuals Et of
the cointegration regression are integrated of order one [I (1)], against the alternative that Et is [I (0)] by using
the ADF test. The results of the cointegration regression and the stationarity tests for the residuals are
presented in Table 1. The results show that at the 1% probability level of significance, the Engle–Granger
cointegration tests reject the null hypothesis of no cointegration. Hence, there exists a long run equilibrium
relationship between the value of the total stock and some key macroeconomic variables in Nigeria.
Table 2: Long-run estimates of macro-economic variables that influenced the value of Total stock transaction
in the Nigerian stock exchange market
Variables Coefficient Std. error t-value

Constant -1.582 8.424 -0.19
LnDSAVt 1.544 0.606 2.55**
LnEXDTt -0.137 0.173 -0.79
LnPGDPt -0.039 0.402 -0.10
LnICURt 1.258 0.599 2.10**
LnEXRt 0.374 0.482 0.78
LnERSt 0.266 0.123 2.17**
LnTIMt 0.759 0.312 2.43**
LnINTERt -1.366 0.787 -1.74*
LnIAGPt 0.594 1.517 0.392
R2 = 0.963 Log-likelihood = -41.04
DW- test = 1.4 F-statistic = 89.7***
Note: Asterisk *,** and *** represent 10%, 5% and 1% significance levels respectively. Variables are as
defined in equation (1).
7. Optimal lag- selection for variables
Before the final stage of the Engle–Granger cointegration two-step approach, the appropriate lag length limit
must be chosen before the error correction model could be generated. This is done by using the information
criteria such as (AIC) Akaike criterion, (BIC) Schwarz Bayesian criterion and (HQC) Hannan- Quinn criterion.
The test result show that the maximum lag length appropriates for the specified variables is at the third lag
indicated by the asterisks among the information criteria.
Table 3: Optimal lag length of variables used in the analysis

Lags loglike p(LR) AIC BIS HQC
1 -19.352 - 1.695 2.217 1.879
2 -18.675 0.245 1.712 2.278 1.912
3 -12.719 0.001 1.444* 2.054* 1.659*
4 -12.328 0.376 1.477 2.130 1.707
460
8. Error Correction Model
The final step of the Engle–Granger cointegration two-step approach is the specification of the error
correction model (ECM). According to Engle and Granger (1987), if two or more time series are cointegrated,
then the relationship among them can be expressed as ECM (Granger Representation Theorem). Since the
specified variables are found to be cointegrated then the dynamic ECM can be constructed taking into
account the underlying cointegration properties of the variables. The prime purpose of building an ECM is to
capture the dynamics in the total stock equation in the short-run and to identify the speed of adjustment as a
response to departures from the long-run equilibrium. The general specification of the ECM to be estimated
for the total stock transaction is as follows:
ΔSTCKt = γ0 + γ1ΔLnTIMt-1 + γ2ΔLnEXRt-1 + γ3ΔLnPGDPt-1 + γ4ΔLnICURt-1 + γ5ΔLnDSAt-1 + γ6ΔLnEXDTt-1 + γ7ΔLnINTERt-1 +
γ8ΔLnIAGPt-1 + γ9ΔLnERSt-2 + γ10ΔSTCKt-1 + δECMt-1 + Ut …. ………......…………………………...........................................…….(2)

The variables are as defined previously in equation (1) and the coefficient (δ) of the ECMt-1 measures the
deviations from the long-run equilibrium in period (t-1). Theoretically, the coefficient of the error correction
variable is expected to be negative and its magnitude will be between zero and one. The closer this
coefficient is to one, the greater the adjustment speed in the existing disequilibria between the total stock
transaction and key macroeconomic variables. In order to obtain a parsimonious dynamic ECM for the total
stock equation, the study adopted Hendry’s (1995) approach in which an over parameterized model is initially
estimated and then gradually reduced by eliminating insignificant lagged variables until a more interpretable
and parsimonious model is obtained. The result of the exercise is presented in Tables 2.
Table 4: ECM estimates of the value of Total stock transaction equation in the Nigerian stock exchange
market
Variables Coefficient Std. error t-value
Constant 0.568 0.115 4.93***
ΔLnTSt-1 -0.182 0.146 -1.24
ΔLnPCGDPt-1 -0.395 0.219 -1.80*
ΔLnINTERt-1 -0.542 0.421 -1.29
ΔLnTIMt-1 -0.486 0.272 -1.79*
ΔLnEXRt-1 0.208 0.290 0.715
ΔLnEXDTt-1 -0.239 0.099 -2.40**
ΔLnDSAVt-3 -1.573 0.509 -3.11***
ΔLnICURt-1 -1.413 0.669 -2.11**
ΔLnIAGPt-1 -2.356 1.042 -2.26**
ΔLnERSt-2 -0.005 0.117 -0.04
ECMt-1 -0.260 0.121 -2.15**
Sigma = 0.437 F-statistic = 4.062***

Log-likelihood = -13.96 RESET test = 0.655**
DW- test = 2.3 R2 = 0.651
Note: Asterisk *,** and ** represent 10%, 5% and 1% significance levels respectively. Variables are as
defined in equation (1).
The coefficient of the error correction term has the expected negative signs and is statistically significant at
5% probability level. This supports the validity of a long-run equilibrium relationship among the variables in
the total stock transaction equation, and also indicates that the total stock transactions are sensitive to the
departure from their equilibrium value in the previous periods. The estimated parameter of the error
correction term represents the speed of adjustment and also is consistent with the hypothesis of convergence
towards the long-run equilibrium once the total stock equation is shocked. The estimated coefficient of ECMt
is –0.26 suggesting that in the absence of variation in the specified macroeconomic variables that about 26
461
percent of the discrepancy between actual and equilibrium value of the total stock transaction is corrected in
each period. The diagnostic test for ECM models revealed the R2 of 0.651 which implies that the specified
explanatory variables explain about 65.1% of the adjusted total variations in the value of the total stock
transaction. The F-statistic of 4.01 is significant at 1% probability level, indicating that the R2 is significant and
this shows that the equation has goodness of fit. The Durbin-Watson value of 2.3 indicates that
autocorrelation is not a serious problem. Also, the RESET test is significant at 5% and this indicates that the
equation is not mis-specified and that the assumption of linearity among variables is correct.
In the ECM model, the per capita real GDP (PCGDP) has a negative significant relationship with the
value of the total stock. In the long run the relationship is not significant. The result means that PCGDP
affects total stock significantly in the short run, but smoothen out in the long run. The PCGDP coefficient
captures the impact of demand shock and shows that it increase causes decrease in the total stock
transaction in the stock market.
The elasticity coefficient of total stock with respect to the value of total import is negative and significant at
10% in the short run but becomes positive and significant at 5% level in the long run. The result indicates that
in the short run, increase in the import will retard total stock activities in the stock market, probably due to
increasing demand for foreign exchange. The result further reveals that in the long run the situation reverses,
as increase in total import increases the total stock transaction in the stock market. This might be linked to
long run import contract, or increase in import demand imposed by improvement or growth in the economy.
However, the impact of total import on the total stock demand measure by the magnitude of elasticity is
greater in the long-run (0.759) than the short-run (0.486).
The coefficient of external debt has a significant (5%) negative inelastic relationship with the total value of
stock in the short run. The relationship however becomes neutral in the long run. In the short run the result
could be attributed to debt servicing policy of the government which could have hinder economic planning.
The finding is against the report of Hsing (2011).
Increase in domestic savings has a strong significant (5%) negative elastic relationship in the short run
and a significant (5%) positive elastic association in the long run with the value of total stock. This shows that
domestic savings is a strong determinant of total stock transaction in the Nigerian stock market. In the short
run, due to information asymmetry in the stock market, individuals may withhold their savings and refused to
invest in shares. In the long run, as information becomes available to majority of investors; they will return to
invest in the port folio share business in anticipation of higher interest rate. However, the impact of domestic
savings is greater in the short run (1.573) than the long run (1.544).
The slope coefficient of industrial capacity utilization rate (ICUR) exhibited a positive correlation with the
total value of stock both in the short run and long run models. This implies that as ICUR increases, the total
stock transaction in the stock market increase. The result satisfies the a apriori expectation, as increase in
the industrial production will needs more financial capital which could easily be derived from the stock
market. The magnitude of the influenced of ICUR is more significant in the short run (1.413) than the long run
(1.258). The result corroborates the findings of Chen et al., (1986) in US; Shahen (2004) in Pakistan; and
Rahman et al., (2009).
Index of agricultural production has a significant (5%) negative effect on the value of total stock in the short
run; the relationship is insignificant in the long run. The result indicates that increase in agricultural production
reduces the activities of the stock market in the short run. The reason for the result might be linked to the
decreasing contribution of export based crops and large scale agriculture to the total agricultural production in
the country. In Nigeria, more than 80% of agricultural production came from small-scale rural farmers who
have limited accessed to formal credit sources.
In the short run the lending rate of commercial Banks has insignificant association with the total stock
value. In the long run, the lending rate has a significant negative influenced on the total stock. The result is
however against the a priori expectation. The reason for the result could be explained partly by the
462
insignificant growth rate in the lending rate regime during the pre-liberalization period and the concessionary
lending rate offered by most commercial Banks to industrial loans.
The external reserve in the long run has a significant positive effect on the value of total stock in the
Nigerian stock exchange market. The result implies that increase in the long run external reserve increases
the value of total stock in the stock market. This could be explained by the fact that increase in the long run
external reserve might stimulate international trade and increase economic activities in the domestic
economy especially in the stock market.
9. Summary and Policy Recommendations
The study determined significant macroeconomic variables that affect the total stock transaction in the
Nigerian stock exchange market. Time series data were used in the study that covers the period 1970 to
2010. Augmented Dicker Fuller unit root test was conducted on the specified data and their stationary as well
as the order of integration determined. The result of Augmented Dicker Fuller test confirmed the presence of
co-integration among the specified variables indicating the existence of a long-run equilibrium relationship.
The long run and ECM models for value of total stock transaction were estimated. The error correction term
had the appropriate sign and was statistically significant indicating a quick convergence to equilibrium in each
period, with intermediate adjustments captured by the differenced terms. This implies that some key macro
economic factors are in operation to restore long-run equilibrium in the value of total stock following a short-
run random disturbance. The empirical results for the long run total stock equation reveals that the industrial
capacity utilization rate, domestic savings, external reserves and total value of import have significant positive
relationship with the total stock transaction in the Nigerian stock exchange market. Whereas the lending rate
of commercial Banks has a negative correlation with the total stock transaction. The ECM model indicates
that the value of total stock transaction in the Nigerian stock exchange market in the short run decrease with
increasing external debt, domestic savings, total import, per capita real GDP; industrial capacity utilization
and index of agricultural production.
To maintain a robust stock market in Nigeria, the study advocates for a short and long term policy
packages that should focused on stabilization of real and monetary policy variables in the Nigerian economy.
Also, institutional and operational reforms in the country’s capital market are inevitable in a bit to further
increase the subsector’s efficiency. Furthermore, policymakers in the stock exchange sub-sector can
regulate the activities in the stock market and attain certain level of efficiency by monitoring the fluctuations in
some key macroeconomic variables in the country.
References
Atje, R. and Jovanovic, B., (1993), “Stock Market Development” European Economic Review, 37(1), 16-41
Bencivenga, V.R and smith, B.D. (1991), “Financial Intermediation and Endogenous Growth”, Review of Economic studies, 52(2), 195 –
209
Black, S. 1988. "A simple discounting rule". Financial Management, Vol.17 (Summary), Pp. 7 - 11.
Capasso, S (2003), “Stock Market Development and Economic Growth: A Matter of Informational Problem”, http://www.ses.man.ac.uk
/cgber/discusi.htm.1-31
Chen, N., Roll, R., & Ross, S. A., (1986). Economic forces and the stock market. Journal of Business, 59, pp. 383–403.
Engle, R. and Granger, C. (1987) “Cointegration and Error Correction Representation, Estimation and Testing”, Journal of Econometrics,
Vol. 36:143-59.
Granger, C. 1981, "Some Properties of Time Series Data in Econometric Model Specification," Journal of Econometrics, vol. 16 111-120.
Hamao, Y. (1988), “An empirical investigation of the arbitrage pricing theory”, Japan and the World economy, 1, 45-61.
Hendry, D. F. (1995) Dynamic Econometrics, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hsiny, Y., (2011). Macroeconomic Determinants of the Stock Market Index and Policy Implications: The Case of a Central European
Country. Eurasian Journal of Business and Economics 4 (7), 1-11
463
Khrawish1 H. A, W. Siam and Mohammad J., (2010). The relationships between stock market capitalization rate and interest rate:
Evidence from Jordan. Peer-reviewed & Open access journal Volume 2 Issue 2 Pp. 60-66.
Kyereboah-Coleman, A, Agyire-Tettey, K. F. (2008), “Impact of macroeconomic indicators on stock market performance: the case of the
Ghana stock exchange”, The Journal of Risk Finance, Vol. 9 No. 4 , 365 – 378.
Lijuan W., and Xu Y., (2010). Empirical Analysis of Macroeconomic Factors Affecting the Stock Price. Orient Academic Forum Pp. 132-
136.
Mahmudul, A., Gazi Salah, U., 2009. “The relationship between interest rate and stock price: Empirical evidence from developed and
developing countries,” International journal of business and management, Vol.4, No3, pp.43-51.
Maysami, R. C., Lee Chuin H., and Mohamad Atkin H., (2004). Relationship between Macroeconomic Variables and Stock Market
Indices: Cointegration Evidence from Stock Exchange of Singapore’s All-S Sector Indices. Journal Pengurusan Pp 47-77
Mukherjee, T. K. & Naka, A., 1995. Dynamic relations between macroeconomic variables and the Japanese stock market: an application
of a vector error correction model. The Journal of Financial Research, 18, pp. 223–237.
NSE (2009). The Nigerian stock Exchange Annual Report and Account.
Nishat, D. M., & Shaheen, R. (2004). Macro-Economic Factors and Pakistani Equity Market.
Okereke, N. O., (2010): “Overview of the Nigerian capital market (seminar presented in UNEC June 2010).
Ologunde, A., Elumilade, D., Saolu, T., 2006. “Stock market capitalization and interest rate in Nigeria: A time series analysis,”
International Research Journal of Finance and Economics, Issue 4, pp.154-67.
Rahman, A. A., Noor Z., Mohd S., and Fauziah H. T., (2009). Macroeconomic determinants of Malaysian stock market. African Journal of
Business Management Vol.3 (3), pp. 095-106.
Schwert W.G (1981) “The Adjustment of Stock Prices to Information about Inflation”, Journal of Finance, 36 (March): 15-29
Singh, A. (1997), “Financial Liberalization, Stock – Markets and Economic Development”, Economic Journal, 107(2), 771 – 782
Singh, A. (1999). Should Africa Promote Stock Market Capitalism? Journal of International Development, 11.
Soenen L, Hennigar E (1988). An Analysis of Exchange Rates and Stock Prices: The US Experience (1980-1986). Akron Bus. Econ.
Rev. 19(4): 7-16.
Sule, K. O. and Momoh C. O., (2009). The impact of stock market earnings on Nigerian per capita income. African Journal of
Accounting, Economics, Finance and Banking Research Vol. 5. No. 5, Pp 77-88.
Wongbangpo, P. and Sharma, S.C. (2002), “Stock market and macroeconomic fundamental dynamic interactions: ASEAN-5 countries”,
Journal of Asian Economics, Vol. 13, 27-51
464
Edgar Lawrence Doctorow; a Political Novelist?
Dr. Seyyed Mohammad Marandi
University of Tehran, Iran

Dr. Zohreh Ramin

University of Tehran, Iran
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.465
Abstract: Edgar Lawrence Doctorow is generally regarded as a postmodern historical novelist who mingles the marvelous with
the real. His novels are mainly set in the American past. The novels are greatly indebted to historical events and personages but
engagement with documentary history is not Doctorow's prime obsession. Critics are at odds in deciding upon the paradox in
Doctorow's novels; whether he is a politically minded novelist or an aesthetically obsessed one. Acknowledging the strong
political tendencies in Doctorow's novels, many critics claim his enthusiasm and passion for the act of writing finally outweighs
the political inclination of the novels. Identifying Historigraphic metafiction as Doctorow's favorite and repeated technique in
virtually all his novels, the present reading wishes to observe the novellas from a contrasting perspective.
Key words: historical novel; American past; political; aesthetics; historigraphic metafiction.
1. Introduction
Long celebrated for his vivid evocations of nineteenth and twentieth-century American life, Edgar Lawrence
Doctorow's fiction spans across his country's history during the twentieth century. Doctorow is widely
acclaimed for his talent of evoking the past in a way that makes it at once mysterious and familiar. Although
much of his fiction focuses on historical fact, Doctorow has stated his preference to fuse the marvelous with
the real.
Doctorow was born on January 6, 1931, New York City to David R. and Rose Lenin, second-generation
Americans of Russian Jewish descent. His fiction returns again and again to life in New York City during the
early twentieth century, with specific focus on Jewish identity.
Doctorow graduated from the Bronx High School of Science "an institution filled with insufferably brilliant
children." As he has stated in his non-fiction book Reporting the Universe (2003), Doctorow published his first
literary effort, The Beetle, a short story, in the school literary magazine, Dynamo, under the influence of Kafka
(33). It was also in the same school where he experienced his "epiphany" in life "those moments of
inexorable moral definition that predict a life, a fate" (34). His "life epiphany" provides insight not only into his
future career as a writer, but also the basic themes and concepts he employs in his future writing; having
been assigned by his high school journalism teacher to go out into the world and conduct an interview, the
young Doctorow hands in an impressive interview with a German Jewish refugee, Karl, a concentration camp
survivor, and a stage doorman at Carnegie Hall. The teacher is so impressed with the work that she decides
to have it published in the school newspaper. However, after she demanded a picture of the doorman to go
along with the interview, Doctorow reveals that there is no doorman and that he made up the entire story
himself. (34, 35)
Doctorow then attended Kenyon College in Gambier, Ohio, in September 1948: a place he found to be "a
real college", where he benefited from a first-rate faculty including John Crowe Ransom the poet and Phillip
Blair Rice, the philosopher. It was also in the same college that Doctorow met the poet Robert Lowell and the
465
short story writer Peter Taylor. Doctorow studied poetry in classes taught by Ransom, which he found "a kind
of isolationist approach to literary texts that would nevertheless turn out to be invaluable training for a
budding writer" (43, 44). He graduated with honors in philosophy in1952. His philosophical training can be
traced in his novels, when he tries to suffuse serious ideas into popular genres such as the Western
(Welcome to Hard Times), science fiction (Big as Life), and detective fiction (The Waterworks).
Doctorow studied drama at Columbia University from 1952-1953, where he met and married a fellow
Columbia drama student, Helen Setzer in 1954 and later became the father of three children.
Doctorow worked as a reservations clerk at LaGuardia Airport for a time and later became a reader of
scripts for CBS Television and Columbia Picture Industries. In 1959, Doctorow became the senior editor for
the New American Library (NAL) and worked there until 1964, when he became editor in chief for Dial Press
(Bloom, 9) and where he published works by a number of authors including James Baldwin, Norman Mailer,
Ernest J. Gaines and William Kennedy.
He has also held teaching positions at Sarah Lawrence College, the Yale School of Drama, the University
of Utah, the University of California and Princeton University. He has received honorary degrees from
Brandeis University and Hobart and William Smith College. He is currently the Lewis and Loretta Glucksman
Professor in American Letters of English at New York University.
1.1 The Novels
Doctorow has received the National Book Award, two National Book Critics Circle Awards, the PEN/Faulkner
Award, and the Edith Wharton Citation for Fiction, the William Dean Howell Medal of the American Academy
of Arts and Letters, and the presidentially conferred National Humanities Medal. With The Book of Daniel, his
third novel, Doctorow emerged as an important American novelist with a strongly political bend.
Doctorow published his first novel almost "accidently" (Reporting the Universe 59), while he was a
professional reader at a film company. On his return from service in the Army occupation of Germany, he
decided to write and found he could not. During the late fifties, westerns were very popular and he was given
a multitude of western stories to read. The job required him to prepare synopses for the film executives. He
was on the verge of quitting the job when he concluded that he could lie about the West better than any of
the authors he was reading. Without a plan and governed by the "impulse to parody"(60), Welcome to Hard
Times evolved into a serious novel and his first work.
With Welcome to Hard Times and The Book of Daniel, Doctorow established a solid reputation, but the
avid reviews of Ragtime and the subsequent film and Broadway musical adaptations of the novel secured his
place in contemporary American culture. Ragtime won the National Book Critics Circle Award in 1976;
World’s Fair won the American Book Award in 1986; and Billy Bathgate—nearly as successful as Ragtime—
won the 1990 National Book Critics Circle Award and the PEN/Faulkner Award for fiction the same year.
Among the awards Doctorow has received for lifetime achievement are the 1996 Medal of Honor for
Literature from the National Arts Club and the 1998 National Humanities Medal (Rollyson 374).
Doctorow has been a prolific writer, constantly expanding his fictional oeuvre. A brief survey of his novels
reveals Doctorow's continuous interest in reconstructing history and contemplating the possibility of reflecting
truth.
Doctorow has explored several genres of fiction: the western, science-fiction, and science-detection
mystery. His novels are noted for their blending of fact and fiction, history and literature. Identifying with the
downtrodden, immigrants, criminals, and political protesters, Doctorow has fashioned fiction with an
ostensibly leftist orientation.
Doctorow focuses on stories, myths, public figures, and literary and historical forms that have shaped the
American public and political consciousness. Even when his subject is not explicitly political—as in his first
novel, Welcome to Hard Times—he chooses to comment upon the American sense of crime and justice. The
western has often been the vehicle for the celebration of American individualism and morality, and yet
466
Doctorow purposely writes a novel in which he questions American faith in fairness and democracy. At the
same time, he maintains the customary strong binary opposition between good and evil, between the “bad
guys” and the “good guys,” by constructing a simple but compelling plot line. Almost all his novels take as
their settings critical turning points in the history of the United Sates.
Though written in the tradition of the western, the historical significance of Welcome to Hard Times (1960),
his first novel, is in its representation of "the end of the frontier of the late nineteenth century" (Jameson 20).
In this novel Doctorow parodied the genre of the western; echoing classical western films. The novel is an
intensely bleak counterpoint to the genre in which Blue, the novels' narrator and historian, is obsessed with
the possibility of recalling the town's history impartially.
The Book of Daniel (1971) is set in the 60s but hearkens back to the earlier 30s, 40s and 50s, and
attempts to capture the transitional phase from the Old Left to the New Left, concentrating on communism
and radicalism.
Doctorow next explored the genre of science fiction in Big As Life (1966), a futuristic satire set in New
York City, but Doctorow was never satisfied with the work, which is why the book is out of print and less
debated on.
In 1972 he published The Book of Daniel, nominated for the National Book Award which established his
reputation. The novel is a fictionalized biography of the Rosenberg case, narrated by the fictional son of the
executed couple. Daniel, the novel's protagonist and narrator, is obsessed with his family history and the
possibility of knowing the truth concerning his parents' ordeal.
Ragtime (1975) received the National Book Critics Circle Award for fiction and the American Academy and
National Institute of Arts and Letters Award. The book depicts the early decades of the twentieth century, as
historical and fictional characters and events intermingle, making it difficult to distinguish fact from fiction.
Ragtime has been seen as a panorama of the first two decades of the twentieth century with a critical perusal
of the Progressive Era.
The eighties appear to be the most prolific stage in Doctorow's writing career. Loon Lake (1980) portrays
the Great Depression of the 1930s, accounting for the struggles and endeavors of the fragmented
protagonist, Joe Patterson, who becomes the walking embodiment of the American dream gone astray.
World's Fair (1985), a quasi-autobiography, received the American Book Award in 1986. Overall, the novel
is written in the tradition of a buildungsroman, laying more stress on the process of the mental development
of Edgar, the young artist. However several instances in the novel once more evoke Doctorow's concern with
illusion and reality, and the capability of the artist in manipulating the border between them.
In 1989, Doctorow published Billy Bathgate. Narrated by Billy, the novel depicts the recollection of his
boyhood experience with notorious gangsters and their world. The novel appears to be more conventional
than his earlier works. It received the National Book Critics Circle Award and the Pen Faulkner Award.
Doctorow sets The Waterworks (1994) within the historical context of William Marcy Tweed (1823-1878)
at the height of his power in New York City. Though his earlier novels indict American capitalism and
democracy one way or another, this novel is exceptional in that it attempts to subvert the regime of power.
Unlike the bleak and sordid ending of the previous novels, this novel appears to end on a more optimistic
note.
The City of God, published in 2000, suggests a renewed interest in philosophical studies. The narrator,
who can be equated with Doctorow, is interested in contemporary issues including the debate between
religion and science. Since this novel does not lay great stress on history, it has not been included in chapter
two and three but is discussed in chapter four; it has been dealt with in detail due to its significant contribution
to Doctorow's focal concern on the opposition between fact and fiction.
The March (2005) is a compellingly polyphonic novel, recapturing the spirit of General Sherman's great
march South seen from the perspective of ex-slaves, union and rebel soldiers, southern citizens whose
homes and plantations are destroyed by the army and even from the perspective of Sherman and his
generals. The publication of The March established Doctorow as a master at portraying historical events,
467
while at the same time demonstrating the effect of history on the lives of everyday citizens. The book was
awarded the National Book Critics Circle award for fiction and the PEN/Faulkner award.
In 2009 Homer and Langley, his most recent novel was published, and was named one of the best books
of the year by The San Francisco Chronicle, The Chicago Tribune, The St Louis Post-Dispatch and The
Kansas City Star and Booklist. Once again, the novel takes as its historical setting the Depression years, but
here the focus is on the true story of two brothers, Homer and Langley.
2. Doctorow and the Critics
The fiction of Doctorow is most often observed by critics as a political and cultural critique of American culture
and identity. In his fiction, critics have found searching and subversive questions concerning perceived
national values. Fredrick Jameson regards Doctorow as a contemporary leftist American novelist who re-
examines received ideas, transforming them under contemporary postmodernist narrative modes. Discussing
Ragtime, and generalizing his comments to encompass Doctorow's other works, Jameson, along with many
other critics, asserts Doctorow as the quintessential postmodern novelist. Doctorow can only represent the
past in such a way that reflects the present:
E. L. Doctorow is the epic poet of the disappearance of the American radical past, of the suppression
of older traditions and moments of the American radical tradition: no one with left sympathies can
read these splendid novels without a poignant distress that is an authentic way of confronting our own
current political dilemmas in the present. (Jameson 23,4)
Concurring with Linda Hutcheon on the political content and meaning of Ragtime, Jameson is willing to
classify the novel as a postmodern practice;
The novel's action disperses the center of the first and moves the margins into the multiple
"centers" of the narrative, in a formal allegory of the social demographics of urban America. In
addition, there is an extended critique of American democratic ideals through the presentation
of class conflict rooted in capitalist property and moneyed power. (Jameson 21)
While Jameson identifies Doctorow as a novelist whose "books are nourished with history in the more
traditional sense," (20) he cannot help but acknowledge the "crisis in historicity" and the "disappearance of
the historical referent" which reflect the untraditional nature of his writing. (23, 4)
Doctorow is cited as principally concerned with delineating the unjust and harsh aspects of the historical
events as well as the system of governance of his country. To oppose what he views as unjust behavior in
the history of his country, Doctorow endeavors to employ a style of writing which resists traditional modes of
narrative construction.
Upon identifying postmodern modes of narration in his works, critics observe his writing as a form of
resistance. Doctorow makes extensive use of parody, a technique widely said to be employed by writers
entrenched in the postmodernist camp. Consequently, this creates an inevitable paradox; on the one hand
there is the necessity to make extensive use of actual historical facts, on the other hand, such apparently
factual documents must be transgressed. This dilemma demonstrates the paradoxical nature of
postmodernist texts in their simultaneous rejection of and anxiety for a pattern and structure.
Commenting on the text of the Constitution in Reporting the Universe, Doctorow criticizes American
culture from different perspectives, but what appears to lie at the heart of his assault, is the divergence from
original "words written down on paper by ordinary mortals" (101).
Doctorow is typically considered a leftist political writer concerned with the shadowy border between
history and myth, as well as a writer who utilizes postmodern modes of narrative. At the heart of his narration,
468
as most critics have come to acknowledge, there lies a seemingly irresolvable tension and different critics
have ventured to deal with this tension from different approaches.
While acknowledging the existence of political implications in Doctorow's fiction, citing from interviews and
lectures by Doctorow, Carol Harter and James Thompson in their extensive research struggle to wring out
from Doctorow' words an apolitical program for his writing, believing that Doctorow does not infuse his novels
with political convictions. They emphasize Doctorow's statement on the accidental way each of his novels
have been initiated. Quoting from an interview with Doctorow asking him whether he brings a preconceived
notion to a novel's creation, Harter and Thompson are content with his answer:
Doctorow draws an interesting analogy: his manner of composition is not a terribly rational way to work,
he admits: "it's hard to explain … it's like driving a car at night. You never see further than your headlights,
but you can make the whole trip that way. The novelist begins and, sometimes, ends in uncertainty." (6, 7)
The fundamental paradox in Doctorow, according to Harter and Thompson is that "the intensely held
social convictions of the man inevitably collide with the imaginative realizations of the artist" (9).
Harter and Thompson are more inclined to interpret Doctorow as a writer obsessed with the power of art
and writing, rather than discussing his politically leftist leanings and postmodern experimentalism. Harter and
Thompson argue that even if in most of his fiction Doctorow portrays a world in which human life is tragically
problematic at both the social and cosmic levels, "solace in perception and joy in creation"(11) are
Doctorow's victorious achievements. Observing variety and downplaying politics in his fiction, Harter and
Thompson perceive Doctorow's ability in redirecting the reader to a "complex reality", rather than obscuring it.
Incapable of mastering the absurd world outside, Doctorow makes use of whatever artistic strategies he can
invent to control it since "in an absurd world the understanding achieved through art is the only control
possible for the writer, whatever the activist's belief might be" (12).
Harter and Thompson find in Doctorow variety and unevenness. No two books resemble each other in any
overt way. The only common point between them, they observe, is an insistent obsession with the American
past. However if this is what connects all the novels together, how can one neglect the political background
which informs Doctorow's fiction? Surely, the aesthetic aspects of the novels require adequate attention, but
if Doctorow simply intended to reflect upon the responsibility of the author to impose order and harmony
through artistic creation, he did not need to return repeatedly to the history of the United States.
John G. Parks, whose critical overview of Doctorow was also among the first full-length studies on
Doctorow's fiction, observes Doctorow's style as embodying both elements of "postmodernist experimentalist
and traditional social realist" (11). Although Parks observes tensions in the novels, yet his ultimate inference
observes the novels as coming to a teleological ending governed by happy endings, balance and success;
"His work is rich and varied, not easily falling into the common classification applied by critics of
contemporary American fiction. He is neither a postmodern experimentalist nor a traditional social realist, but
his work has features of both." Parks' reading is heavily shadowed by his Bakhtinian approach to the texts,
regarding the context of the novels as a locus in which divergent, peripheral and even conflicting voices are
permitted temporary liberty. But the problem with Parks' approach is a key contradiction which surfaces from
his own statements and generalizations.
Parks believes Doctorow is erroneously labeled a political novelist, because of his concern for social
justice. The label, Parks believes, implies that Doctorow has a specific “agenda, a program, or an ideology to
promulgate in fiction.” Parks states that “Doctorow’s politics do not function in systematic or programmatic
ways in his fiction. As a critic of America’s failures to fulfill its dreams and founding convictions, he does not
advocate new political systems, but rather provokes the reader to a radical reassessment of the American
experience in essentially moral terms.”(11)
The major problem with Parks is that while he rejects the existence of a pattern and system in Doctorow’s
fiction, he sets out to detect as many systematic principles as possible, producing the impression that
Doctorow’ novels do share commonalities. By attempting to recount a common thread of repeated themes
469
and motifs in his fiction, Parks draws out the specific historical background of Doctorow’s novels. Through
this, Parks contradicts his own statement rejecting a systematic pattern in Doctorow's fiction.
Parks observes a tension in Doctorow's political consciousness that he does not try to resolve. Like Harter
and Thompson, he brings evidence from Doctorow’s familiarity with radicalism in the family, reminding us that
Doctorow's grandfather was an atheist. Parks also refers to contemporary views on the fluid nature of truth
and the potentiality of fiction in conveying more truth than fact. Parks cites Foucault’s famous lines on the
impossibility of separating the power of truth from "regimes of power," bringing forth evidence from
contemporary linguistics on the fluid nature of meaning. According to Foucault, since meaning cannot be
pinned down via language, Doctorow’s postmodern style of narrative benefits and helps the liberation of
history from fact, replacing it with a fiction which embodies more truth. Foucault's project then, Parks
believes, "describes well Doctorow's concerns in his fiction."(18)
One of the central concerns of the present research is to evaluate the extent which Doctorow pursues or
has managed to succeed in this approach. Has he managed to detach history from fact? Is this supposed
detachment his final objective? Do his novels ultimately reveal the impossibility of such a separation in
American society with a capitalist system of governance? Hence one of the objectives of the present
research is to challenge Parks’ bold statement:
Thus, the narrative of fiction is the locus of battle, as it were, for freedom. It is the place, or rather, the
process or event where the “regimes of power,” as Michel Foucault says, may be challenged. The
task of narrative is to disrupt or dismantle the prevailing “regimes of truth,” including their repressive
effects. As Foucault writes” it is not a matter of emancipating truth from every system of power (which
would be a chimera, for truth is already power) but of detaching the power of truth from the forms of
hegemony, social, economic, and cultural, within which it operates at the present time.” Such a
project describes well Doctorow’s concerns in his fiction (18).
Parks embarks on Bakhtin’s notion of polyphony in the novel as a means to subvert the regime from
establishing a monological control over culture. Hence Bakhtin’s theories help Parks defend his vision of
Doctorow’s fiction as instances of freedom from a monological regime since his novels are an embodiment of
polyphonic voices, including the lives of individuals and families from different social classes, races and
cultures. In his paper "The Politics of Polyphony: The Fiction of E. L. Doctorow", Parks compares Doctorow's
novels with Hawthorne's historical romances, stating that Doctorow challenges the power of the regime with
the power of freedom inherent in discourse and narrative:
Doctorow, as an artist, is committed to challenging the power of the regime with the power of
freedom. The principal arena of that engagement is in discourse, in narrative, the range of discursive
practices with their cluster of rules and codes which govern writing and thinking. The goal is to
disclose and challenge the hegemony of enshrined or institutionalized discursive practices in order to
make available new possibilities of thought and action. Doctorow's fiction shows a willingness to take
risks, to counter the tendency of a culture to monopolize the compositions of truth with polyphonic
and heteroglossic narratives. (460)
But to what extent has Doctorow managed to truly disrupt the regime from monopolizing the composition
of truth and establishing a monological control over culture? Where does Doctorow locate the monopolizing
regime of truth? Does he believe in the necessity of change? If so, where and why should this change take
place? Does he support or reject the country's Founding Fathers' conception of how the country should be
governed?
Michelle M. Tokarczyk ventures to demonstrate how Doctorow’s fiction can oscillate between a
passionately politically committed Jewish author and a writer who is highly skeptical of politics. The result is a
470
fiction which seems to be equally drawn to two sides; being politically committed and at the same time
skeptical of political action and indeterminate. According to Tokarczyk, Doctorow has employed a variety of
literary techniques and genres to represent his politically conscious mind, not only charging his fiction with
political overtones but also influencing and provoking other political writing.
Tokarczyk sums up the major issues of Doctorow’s major novels as raising the question regarding the
artist and social and political concerns, the possibility of progress and the meaning of being committed. Like
many other critics, Tokarczyk also regards Doctorow as a postmodern writer, yet he does not believe
Doctorow himself favors uncertainty. He asserts that Doctorow takes a detached stance regarding his
relationship with his narrative. Though his novels are heavily political, Doctorow strives to maintain his
detachment, refusing to boldly assert his political position and keeping a distance from political matters.
Tokarczyk attempts to locate the reason for this distance in Doctorow’s preference for writing, rather than
political issues, and even more significantly his belief in the impossibility of making a difference.
Tokarczyk identifies two major political trends in Doctorow’s time as being the major reasons for his
detachment; the first was McCarthyism which resulted in the destruction of many lives by politicians, and
second, Tokarczyk classifies Doctorow as belonging to “the so-called Silent Generation” (3). This was also a
time during which news of Stalin's atrocities and other revelations about Russian Communism which
shattered the vision of some leftists that Communism embodied true democratic ideals.
Hence, Doctorow chose detachment and withdrawal from the political world and as a result Tokarczyk
generally identifies Doctorow’s stance and vision as skeptical:
The postmodern vein in Doctorow's fiction and in essays such as “False Documents,” widely
commented upon, might be seen as a skeptic's position— the belief that true knowledge or
knowledge of a particular area is uncertain; hence, one adopts an attitude of doubt or
disposition toward incredulity.”(4)
However, despite this skepticism towards certainty, Tokarczyk notes Doctorow’s desire towards certainty
and his acknowledgement of the dangers of uncertainty. According to Tokarczyk Doctorow remains
suspicious of definite answers and more importantly, of the possibility of knowing but he is also suspicious of
"radical uncertainty and passionately committed to certain idea and causes” (4). His fiction, Tokarczyk
believes, reflects the “trinity of oppression” (race, class and gender). It appears that Doctorow sympathizes
with the weaker sides; those of low economic status, colored peoples and females implying an essential
sense of justice.
Doctorow himself favors a detached speaker, one detached from official institutions, as he mentions
“independent witnesses ... not connected to the defense of any institution, whether it be the family or the
Pentagon or God” (Levine “Writer” 69). Tokarczyk sums up the central issues of Doctorow’s major novels as
the question of the artist and social and political concerns, the possibility of progress and the meaning of
being committed.(5)
On the whole, Tokarczyk observes a contradiction in Doctorow's ideology which he does not strive to
resolve. What position does Doctorow finally adhere to? Certainty or uncertainty? Dedication or indifference?
Broadly speaking, Doctorow's stance towards the politics of his country is unclear; is he in favor of
radicalism or is he a conservative? Some critics including Parks have been highly optimistic in observing
Doctorow's fiction as entirely optimistic. Others such as Harter and Thompson have evaded the problem by
suggesting Doctorow's artistic and aesthetic concerns as overriding his political intentions. Tokarczyk
observes both Doctorow's skepticism and his commitment but cannot make a compromise between the two.
The present research intends to study Doctorow's novels to examine what the author believes to be the
truly "radical" and "leftist" nature of the works. Does Doctorow finally subvert the dominant
authorities/ideologies? Can his novels be regarded as instances of dissidence? Most of his novels apparently
indict American capitalism by depicting how at crucial turning points in the history of the country, the system
has failed. Does he fully believe in the failure of the system? Does he delineate a similar picture for the future
471
of his country? In order to answer the above questions and to contribute to this ongoing debate, the present
research suggests observing Doctorow's fiction under the light of metafiction.
Doctorow's fiction is overtly self-reflexive. The narrators of all his novels deal with events that have
happened in the past. Addressing the reader consciously, they continuously comment upon the act of writing
and reconstructing history, involving the reader in their contemplations. Since self-reflexivity and rewriting
history are two outstanding elements in all his novels, the questions mentioned above, dealing with historical
and political matters, can be studied under the light of metafiction.
3. Metafiction: The Historical Background
The sixties was a time of intense disillusionment and startling recognition for the American nation. A
combination of political and social factors in the 1960s in the US led to what is commonly called a spirit of
"regeneration." The presidency of John F.Kennedy had at first sparked rays of hope in the hearts of
numerous Americans who voted for him. However, the war in Vietnam and widespread protests against it, the
advent of the civil rights movement and the rise of black power and an alarming increase in violent murder
and gun crime throughout the decade, all helped to bring about the rise of a counter-culture which had
already began with the Beat Movement of the 1950s, and generally developed into a disbelief and distrust of
authority and official power. As noted by Bran Nicol:
The pervasiveness of corruption, violence, scandal, and cover-up in American politics, exemplified by
the assassinations of John Kennedy, and his brother Robert and the civil rights campaigner Martin
Luther King, and the Watergate scandal which brought down the by-then President Nixon in 1973,
convinced cultural figures in America that reality, even history, was not transparent, but a kind of
‘front’ for the real story which was unfolding behind the scenes. (74)
The result of this disillusionment with the political and social matters of their country greatly influenced fiction
writers of the time and has been recaptured in both popular and serious art. Metafiction was then used as a
means through which previously cherished American beliefs, traditions, values and myths were
deconstructed. The forceful impact of this disillusionment resulted in the transformation of political matters
into literary ones and writers employed parody to challenge whatever had previously pertained to reflecting
reality and truth in American history and culture.
Although metafiction had already been employed by earlier writers across the world, at this point in the
history of America it became an appropriate technique for translating social and political matters into literary
ones. In Twentieth-century American Novel (2005), John Whitley traces the new themes of the American
novel, reflecting its necessary political nature in the 60s and 70s. Whitley provides examples of novelists
including Doctorow, who wrote with a conscious awareness of the necessity to intermingle fact and fiction,
which was made easier through the development of the term metafiction. Authors who decided to exploit this
technique permitted themselves to question the nature of reality. Unsurprisingly, this was an immediate
response to the spirit of the age:
The determination to explore fictionality in the 1960s, Nicol believes, was motivated by a sense that
everyday reality was always already fictionalized, either because of its sheer absurdity, or by the
power of the media in shaping it and presenting it to the viewer, or because it was being actively
manipulated by unseen hands (75).
However, by employing this technique, writers did not all share the same view point. The writers of this
tradition of American literature can be roughly divided into two broad groups; those who as Patricia Waugh
put it practiced "aleatory art" (12): a totally random art, which its practitioners believed to be the best way to
472
reflect the chaotic, frenetic and frenzied contemporary world. Outstanding literary figures that practiced
aleatory art include William H. Gass, Robert Coover, John Barth, and Donald Barthelme, who produced
fiction which was principally about fiction itself with no extrinsic reference to the outside world. Authors writing
in this tradition produced fiction within fiction; endless tales and tales within tales. As an instance of such
innovative metafictional work, William H. Gass’s Willie Master’s Lonesome Wife (1968) makes use of a
variety of visual devices including different colors for different sections of the book rather than pagination,
different typefaces, coffee stains, and a variety of other innovative techniques to draw the attention of the
reader to the text and language.
The second group of metafictional writers consists of those whose works are initially bound to
conventions. Such writers will not, like practitioners of aleatory art, pull the rug out from under their readers'
feet by engaging in innovation straightaway. Rather, authors of this camp use familiar themes and
conventions but then abuse them for the sake of innovation. By laying bare the device of composing fiction
and the truths of the fictional world, these writers intend to deconstruct the truths which has structured the
real world (Waugh 12).
Lyotard's assumption that narratives can never be natural or innocent in representing reality and that they
are partial, selective and relative reflects the approach taken by postmodern critics and writers toward
narrative. One of the grounds of attack directed towards "realist" modes of writing which postmodernists
strive to debunk is the illusion that writers, writing in the realist tradition, strive to show their narratives unfold
naturally and effortlessly. By shattering this illusion, postmodernists, including the practitioners of metafiction,
wish to show how narratives are constructs which the authors build and are therefore partial, selective and
relative. The technique they employ to communicate this point is a self-reflexive method which continually
disrupts the traditional progression of the narrative, to draw the attention of the reader to the act of
composition itself.
Metafiction is the most distinctive characteristic of postmodernist fiction, to the extent that Linda Hutcheon,
the Canadian critic, regards postmodernism and metafiction as identical (301). Metafiction reminds the reader
that what he is reading is fiction, and that narrative is made up of words which do not reflect the outside
world, but are related to other texts.
Metafiction may not seem a novel technique, as many early texts can be found which draw attention to
their fictive quality. Patricia Waugh has clarified that as a postmodernist technique, what is important in
metafiction is what it does through uncovering the fictional status of the narrative, it signals to the reader the
constructed, mediated and discursive nature of the external world. Unlike realist and modernist writings,
metafictional works do not pretend to provide the reader with insight into the real world. Postmodernist fiction
reminds us that the fictional world is not a simple and stable world, and that narratives are loaded with
functionality.
Patricia Waugh and Linda Hutcheon are two important figures who have attempted to establish a "poetics
of postmodernism". These two theorists have had the most significant impact upon the theories of
postmodernism in fiction. While providing instances of how postmodernist fiction works and what is distinctive
of post-war writings, Waugh and Hutcheon do not confine their practice to the fiction of this era. According to
these two critics, postmodernist fiction does not do anything that fiction has not done before. The only
perceptible difference is that certain elements receive more attention.
The irony Hutcheon observes in postmodernist fiction is therefore, not new. It has been inherent in earlier
fiction as far back as in the works of Shakespeare. The irony is the simultaneous existence of the
conformation to norms and traditions and a desire to shatter and rebel against them. Only by looking back at
norms and stable traditions can postmodernism be successful in breaking them. This irony which is not
unique to postmodern art is now "obsessively recurring" ( A Poetics of Postmodernism xi) in contemporary
art, which is what makes it different from previous works. Contemporary art is simultaneously referential
when looking back to realist traditions and self-reflexive by shattering the very same traditions. Patricia
Waugh had also proposed that in order for the metafictional narrative to be accepted by readers, they must
473
begin from a familiar plane and then move on to a new, unfamiliar terrain; " The forms and language of what
is offered to it as creative or experimental fiction should not be so unfamiliar as to be entirely beyond the
given modes of communication, or such fiction will be rejected as simply not worth the reading effort. There
has to be some level of familiarity"(64).
For Hutcheon, postmodern art combines both theory and practice. She regards postmodernist fiction as
an aesthetic object which both amuses us and makes us ponder about what we are deriving pleasure from.
This aspect of her theory is clarified when she describes "historigraphic metafiction" (A Poetics of
Postmodernism 106). According to Hutcheon, postmodernism could not have existed without modernism. It
neither totally accepts nor totally rejects realism. Hutcheon observes the ideology of postmodernism as
paradoxical because it both relies upon and contests that which it derives from.
3.1 Recognizing Frames in Fiction
The effect of metafiction is principally to draw attention to the frames involved in fiction, which are frequently
concealed by realism. According to Waugh, frames have become invisible in realist writing. Framing means
that the author has already decided upon the material and the perspective of his/her narration. A practical
example of frames in art is the actual frame of a realist painting of a landscape. The first function of the frame
is to show the reader what is presented in the painting. But the frame also functions to limit the amount of
landscape we are permitted to observe. Applying the same to the world of fiction, we can infer then that what
we see in both the painting and the world of fiction is only a small portion of a wider spectrum. Therefore
framing is not totally objective but it is a technique which permits the author selection, preference, and
privilege. Therefore any narrative will necessarily involve some degree of framing.
The significance of recognizing framing in fiction is that it makes us realize what we see in the fictional
work is there because we have been permitted to see it by the author. In order to make this possible, the
author has employed artificial devices or techniques. The reason why artificiality is emphasized is to set it
against the realist tradition which claimed to provide a naturally realistic picture of the world and life. In fiction,
the frame is the narration of the text which provides a portal for the reader to enter the world of fiction, making
the fictional world of the author accessible to the real world of the reader.
3.2 Frame-breaking
Recognizing frames in fiction is not the end in metafiction. What metafictional narrative strives toward is to
perceive the way such frames function in fiction;
Contemporary metafiction, in particular, foregrounds ‘framing’ as a problem, examining frame

procedures in the construction of the real world and of novels. The first problem it poses, of course,
is: what is a ‘frame’? What is the ‘frame’ that separates reality from ‘fiction’? Is it more than the front
and back covers of a book, the rising and lowering of a curtain, the title and ‘The End’?" (Waugh 28)
Waugh cites from the sociologist Erving Goffman the notion of frame-breaking where the frames which
traditionally construct narrative are dismantled and shattered. The most outstanding instance of this frame-
breaking is when the author intrudes upon his own fiction, moving from the external world of the author to the
internal world of fiction or vice versa.
Frame-breaking thus involves laying bare the devices of composing fiction. Since all fiction have been
constructed via frames, frame-breaking is not unique to postmodernism and can be observed not only in
seventeenth and eighteenth century fiction, but in modernism as well. Two outstanding pre nineteenth-
century novels worth mentioning for the metafictional parody are Miguel de Cervantes’s Don Quixote (1605;
1615) and Laurence Sterne’s novel The Life and Opinions of Tristram Shandy (1759–67)
474
In Don Quixote, narrative strategies such as digressions, references to other works by the author (Cervantes)
and the developing story, discussions of characters within the narrative about rules and traditions of writing
fiction, all draw attention to the narrative frames which have made the story possible for the reader. In
Tristram Shandy, the narrator continuously disrupts the chronological progression of events of the hero's life-
story.
Writing at a time when the novel had not yet fully developed as a genre, the two novels employ parody.
Both novels do what metafiction in postmodernism later did; drawing the reader's attention to the difficulty of
representing reality in fiction and the unnaturalness of narrative progression in a chronological manner. If
metafiction as an unraveling strategy in the novel had been employed even before the genre had properly
begun, how can we consider it as the distinctive feature of postmodernist fiction?
Waugh provides an adequate response to this problem. If metafiction lays bare the traditional norms of
fiction writing in the postmodern novel, the aim is to make the reader ponder not only about the aesthetic
aspect of metafiction, which is the process of constructing fiction, but also involves the theoretical part which
means that the external world, the world the reader inhabits is also composed of frames and similar
composing elements and that discursive frames construct the realities we live by.
Waugh demonstrates that what some critics have come to regard as the "playfulness" of metafiction in
narrative is not to mark the end of the novel but is in fact an approach which strives to delineate the history of
the novel. It makes more sense to observe metafiction as not merely playing with the possibilities of self-
conscious fiction for its own sake, with specific regards for the historical setting of the technique in the US,
but rather to observe it as Nicol does:
to see the turn to innovative non-realist techniques as the result not of a kind of private domestic battle kept
within the family of literature but the literary contribution – albeit a rather displaced, esoteric, one – to the
widespread counter-cultural conviction that social reality was becoming disturbingly fictional. (75)
4. The Postmodern historical novel
According to Linda Hutcheon, in the postmodern historical novel we can observe the return of plot and the
question of reference. Unlike earlier metafictional narratives in which plot was no longer a composing
element of the story (such as Barths' Lost in the Funhouse-1968- and Coover's Descant-1969), postmodern
historical fiction, which Hutcheon terms as "historigraphic metafiction" still contains many of the traditional
elements of novels written in the manner of nineteenth-century realism. Since historigraphic metafiction
makes use of many of the traditional realist elements, it has enjoyed a wider spectrum of readership, and has
become the "accepted face of postmodernism". It makes use of both realism and postmodernism: "work of
‘historiographic metafiction’ (her label for postmodern historical fiction) is still committed to telling a long and
involving story, full of believable characters, which can be enjoyed by the reader in the manner of nineteenth
century realism" (Nicol 99).
Metafiction is a self-conscious fiction which reminds us that fiction is a construction, so that we realize the
reality we live by is also a similar construction. Historigraphic metafiction makes us realize that history is also
a construction, and does not necessarily equate with the past, just as reality does not equate to truth. Like
narration, history is built from documents and other material which are themselves narratives about the past.
The "accessibility" of historigraphic fiction (Nicol 98) has made it difficult for contemporary critics to place
this branch of narrative alongside other postmodern fiction; the realism which permits readers to enjoy the
narrative, brings it closer to early nineteenth-century histories. As mentioned before, self-reflexive historical
fiction is a strong characteristic of the 1960s postmodern fiction. Nineteenth-century historical novels sought
to provide the reader with a real picture of the life at the times. As Hutcheon and Hayden White have
mentioned, during the nineteenth century, history and fiction were not distinct, because fiction, heavily
influenced by realistic modes and principles, was supposed to give a realistic picture of life, therefore fiction
had the same status as history.
475
Postmodernism also posits the equation between the two, stating that history is dependent upon fiction;
without fiction history could not exist. According to Nicol, historiography claims to be a science, one that can
analyze its object of study impersonally, and objectively. The problem according to Hayden White is that it
finally ends up producing a narrative which means the approach fails both at the theoretical and
methodological level. "A discipline that produces narrative accounts of its subject matter as an end in itself’,
he contends, ‘seems methodologically unsound; one that investigates its data in the interest of telling a story
about them appears theoretically deficient (White 1). In other words, the author ends up focusing on the
story, rather than facts. As the examples from Doctorow's fiction will prove, while the author employs
postmodernist and metafictional techniques, the realist tradition of focusing on the story (content) of his
narrative receives greater force than the postmodernist indulgence with the process of storytelling (form).
The historian and the fiction writer can never be impersonal. Both make selections and preferences which
they then impose upon the reader to accept. Historiography calls attention to the very frames through which
history has been constructed and attempts to break them. History as a thing of the past really did exist, but
our only access to it is through documents and texts whether written, oral, or even pictorial. Since history
itself as Fredrick Jameson has mentioned is ". . . not a text, for it is fundamentally non-narrative and non-
representational," (Jameson 82) our conception of history can never be accurate and complete. The
technique historiographic metafiction provides is to shatter what is believed to be the illusion that history can
be recaptured accurately within texts, be they factual or fictive.
5. Historigraphic Metafiction
Historiographic metafiction strives to uncover the alleged unbridgeable gap between real history and the
fictional representation of history. History is constructed in texts via language and as structuralists have
demonstrated, language does not mimic the real world, but is governed by its own structures and rules and
only attempts to give a theoretical version of the world.
According to Hutcheon, historiographic metafiction is the same as postmodernism. McHale criticizes
Hutcheon for this, however, and demonstrates how Hutcheon's anxiety for grand narratives finally entraps
her. The double side to Hutcheon's theory is that historiography is at once real and fictional. According to
Hutcheon, the reader is permitted freedom of interpretation but this freedom is only possible once there is a
firm ground from which to move. So metafiction must primarily employ realism according to Waugh; "In
metafiction it is precisely the fulfillment as well as the non-fulfillment of generic expectations that provides
both familiarity and the starting point for innovation"(64). This is what creates the openness of such texts, in
contrast to earlier closed versions of historiography. This opening up, according to Hutcheon, is what makes
history political because history then becomes an open concept rather than a closed, teleological entity (110).
What historigraphic metafiction does in the end is not just playful parody, poking fun at history. It reminds us
of the presence of history in our own lives, how we are the products of that history. Its ultimate objective is to
make us ponder over how we are affected by history, and how we know what we know about the past.
As a political instrument, metafiction works by altering and heightening the consciousness of the individual
reader. By both displaying the constructedness of the reader's vision of social reality and allowing the reader
to participate in the construction of an alternative fictional reality, metafiction attempts to debunk the social
ideologies that inform the reader's conception of society and offer the reader the opportunity to liberate
himself from them. In addition, this expansion of the reader's conception of the world and his place within it
put him in a position to make more informed decisions about how he should think and act. The problem is
that being informed involves history and history is only a narrative.
The works of Robert Scholes, Hutcheon, and Waugh have effectively defended metafiction against the
accusation that it is a frivolous and self-indulgent exercise in art for art's sake. They have laid the groundwork
for a political study of metafiction, locating the potential political viability of metafiction in its capacity to force
the reader to confront and examine the constructedness of his own experience of reality
476
5.1 Doctorow and Metafiction
Since history and fiction are the two major poles of his work, the link between the history of the United States
during the specific years he sets his novels and the postmodern narrative style he employs require thoughtful
consideration. Though Doctorow attempts to deconstruct the history of his country by obscuring the border
between fact and fiction, his works appear to fall prey to a dominant pattern.
Doctorow employs self-conscious narrators who are obsessed with knowing the truth through recounting
incidents of their past lives and simultaneously through their writing. Since both cases require a construction
on behalf of a necessarily partial and subjective speaker/narrator, metafiction has served well Doctorow's
ideology of the impossibility of disentangling fact from fiction.
Doctorow's application of historiographic metafiction, with a specific concern for the reason he has
repeatedly employed metafiction throughout his writing career requires investigation. Doctorow challenges
the reader to question the nature of historical truth. This is observed once we realize the intertextual
relationship between the fictive world of his novels and the history of the US as it is recorded and
documented by historians. Primarily, it might appear that each novel is an individual representation of the
spirit of the specific age which it has taken as its background, reflecting and indicting the unjust system.
However, a closer scrutiny of the novels unveils a coherent pattern running through all his works. Though it
may seem that Doctorow is an avid supporter of change, his narrative communicates the impossibility of
change and betterment of conditions for the marginalized members of the American society, which provokes
suspicion regarding the author's condemnation of his country's policies in the first place. Questions also
remain about how the painful conditions of marginalized people are historically confirmed through
historigraphic metafiction.
6. Conclusion
E.L. Doctorow is mainly considered a postmodern writer. While critics had no problem observing postmodern
techniques of narration in Doctorow's texts, they could still identify enough evidences to position him in the
realist tradition of historical novelists. Some critics including Hutcheon have primarily identified this irony as
an inherent nature of historigraphic metafiction, which initially requires to base narrative contexts on a firm
historical grounding, then deviating from this firm grounding. Other critics including Parks, Harter and
Thompson believe Doctorow's aesthetic intentions finally overcome his political convictions. The intentions of
this paper have been to suggest an alternative reason for this.
Doctorow's texts place a greater emphasis on the content (story) rather than the form (techniques which
violate realism) which as we have observed, is an indispensible aspect of historigraphic metafiction, the
technique Doctorow has employed for most of his narratives. His novels have benefited from different literary
genres including the western, science fiction, buildungsroman, and science-detective. But what remains
constant in the novels is the specific historical context in each.
Doctorow's political agenda is extended through all his writing oeuvre, a point also remarked by Bawer.
But the nature of that politics is a much contested debate among the critics of Doctorow. The present
research has been an attempt to suggest a possible perspective from which to observe the novels,
contributing to this ongoing debate. Rather than being aesthetically concerned, Doctorow is a partial author
whose political mentality has strongly influenced his writing career.
References
Bawer, Bruce. (2000). "The Faith of E. L. Doctorow." The Hudson Review, Vol. 53, No. 3 .391-402.
Bloom, Harold. (2004). E.L. Doctorow's Ragtime. New York: InfoBase Publishing.
Clayton, Jay. (1993). The Pleasures of Babel. New York: Oxford University Press.
477
Doctorow, E.L. (1989). Billy Bathgate. New York: Wings Books.

---. City of God. (2000). New York: Random House.
---. Creationists: Selected Essays, 1993-2006. New York:Random House, 2006.
---. Homer and Langley.London" Little Brown. 2009.
---. Loon Lake. New York: Wings Books, 1979.
---. Ragtime. London: McMillan, 1976.
---. Reporting the Universe. Harvard: Harvard University Press, 2003.
---. The Book of Daniel. London: Penguin Books, 1971.
---. The March. London: Abacus. 2005.
--- . "The Passion of Our Calling." New York Times Book Review. 25 Aug. 1985.
---. The Waterworks. New York: Random House, 1994.
---. Welcome to Hard Times. New York: Random House, 1960.
---. World's Fair. New York: Wings Books, 1985.
Gass, William, H. Willie Masters' Lonesome Wife. Dalkey Archive Press, , ISU Campus Box, the University of Michigan, 1989.
Gentry, M. Bruce. "The First Three Full-Length Studies of E. L. Doctorow." Rev of E. L. Doctorow. By Carol C. Harter and James R.
Thompson, E. L. Doctorow. By John G. Parks, and Models of Misrepresentation: On the Fiction of E. L. Doctorow. By Christopher
D. Morris. Modern Language Studies, Vol. 22, No. 3 (Summer, 1992): 111-116.
Gross, David S. "Tales of Obscene Power Money and Culture, Modernism and History in the Fiction of E. L. Doctorow." Trenner 120-50.
Grossman, Lev. “10 Questions for E. L. Doctorow,” Time, October 2005, 6.
Harpham, Geoffry Galt. "Doctorow and the Technology of Narrative," PMLA, 100 (January 1985).
Harter, Carol and James R.Thompson. E.L. Doctorow. Boston: Twayne Publishers, 1990.
Hutcheon, Linda. A Poetics of Postmodernism History, Theory, Fiction. New York: Routledge, 1988.
---. Irony's Edge; The theory and politics of irony. (1994). London: Routledge.
---. The Politics of Postmodernism. (1989). London New York: Routledge.
---. (1986). "The Politics of Postmodernism: Parody and History." Cultural Critique, No. 5. 7: 179-207.
---. (1988). "The Postmodern Problematizing of History." English Studies in Canada, XIV, 4, 365-382.
Jameson, Fredrick. (1991). Postmodernism, Or the Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
Lauter, Paul, ed. (2010). A companion to American literature and culture. West Sussex: Blackwell Publishing. Leonad, John. Bye Bye
Billy" (review of Billy Bathgate), Nation, 7. Ibid. p. 456.
McHale, Brian. (2003). "History Itself or the Romance of Postmodernism." Rev. of Sublime Desire: History and Post-1960s Fiction, by
Amy J. Elias. Contemporary Literature XLIV,1. 151-161.
McHale, Brian. (1992). "Postmodernism, or the Anxiety of Master Narratives." Diacritics, Vol. 22, No. 1. 17-33.
Mitgang, Herbert. (1984). "Herbert Finding the Right Voice," New York Times Book Review, 11, 42.
Nicol, Bran. (2009). The Cambridge Introduction to Postmodern Fiction. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Parks, John G. (1991). E. L. Doctorow. New York: Continum.
--- . (1990). "The Politics of Polyphony: The Fiction of E. L. Doctorow." Twentieth Century Literature, Vol. 37, No. 4, pp. 454-463.
Rollyson, Carl, ed. (2008). Notable American novelists. California: Salem Press.
Ryan, Mary. (1996). "Narratives of Democracy, or History without Subjects." American Literary History, Vol. 8, No. 2, pp. 311-327.
Scholes, Robert. (1979). Fabulation and Metafiction. University of Illinois Press.
Scholes, Robert. ( 1970). " Metafiction." The Iowa Review, Vol. 1, No. 4, pp. 100-115.
Temperley, H. and Chris Bigsby,ed. (2005). A New Introduction to American Studies. UK: Longman.
Tokscyzk, Micheal. (2000). E. L. Doctorow's Skeptical Commitment. New York: Peter Lang.
Waugh, Patricia. (1984). Metafiction, the Theory and Practice of Self-Conscious Fiction. New York: Routledge.
White, Hayden. (1984). ‘The Question of Narrative in Contemporary Historical Theory.’ History and Theory 23, 1–33.
478
Topicilazation and Focalization in Persian
Vali Rezai
Manijeh Youhanaee
Hasan Ghasemi
University of Isfahan, Iran

Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.479
Abstract This article provides a syntactic analysis of Topicalization and Focalization processes in Persian within the framework
of minimalist syntax. According to Haegeman and Gueron’s Split CP Hypothesis (1999), Topicalization is a recursive process
and can apply to more than one constituent in a sentence, while Focalization is unique and therefore appears in a single
projection. In this paper we argue that in Persian more than one constituent might undergo focalization. This implies that
Focalization cannot be unique. Thus, we first propose two Focal Phrases in the periphery position of a clause. The specifier
positions of the two Focal phrases are the landing sites of the focused constituents. Then we suggest the relative position of
focal phrases with topic phrases in Persian. It will be concluded that the first focus phrase appears immediately after the
complementizer phrase before the first recursive topic phrase followed by the second focus phrase and recursive topic phrase
respectively .
Keywords: Focus phrase, given information, new information, Split CP Hypothesis, Topic phrase
1. Introduction
Topicalization and focalization are two processes in Persian whose constituents do not appear in canonical
word order. In these constructions Topics and/or Focus phrases move from their base positions to Periphery
positions sentence initially. These discourse motivated movements yield marked orders with specific
readings. A number of analyses have been proposed to account for topicalization and/or focalization in
Persian e.g. Karimi 2005, Anushe 2010, Darzi & Beyraghdar 2010. These analyses are based on Haegeman
and Gueron’s split CP hypothesis (1999). However, these analyses suffer from the fact that they are not
comprehensive in terms of considering all kinds of clauses (simple versus complex, independent versus
dependent) and/or they do not account for sentences which instantiate more than one topicalized and
focalized constituents simultaneously. In this study we reevaluate the split CP hypothesis to find the extent to
which it can appropriately account for Persian data. So, we present a brief review this hypothesis as
suggested by Haegeman & Gueron (1999) and then we discuss Topicalized and Focused phrases in Persian
and shortcomings of presented analyses. Finally, we present arguments in favor of a second Focus phrase in
the clausal periphery and the sequential orders for CP projections.
2. Topicalization
A variety of positions have been suggested to be the topic position in different languages. As for long-
distance topicalization, Chomsky (1977) argues that this movement obeys the same island conditions as wh-
movement. This means that topicalization instantiates an A-bar movement to specifier of CP. However, the
fact that topicalized constituents can appear after a complementizer indicates that there must be more than
one phrasal projection on the top of the TP. Furthermore, evidence from Persian shows that more than one
topic might undergo such A-bar movement.
479
1. [CP [ TopP baĉehâi [TopP maŝinoj [TP benazarmiad ti tj pasandidand]

Children car seems liked
(It seems that the children liked the car.)
Another position, taken by Haegeman and Gueron (1999), claim that the CP layer like TP includes more than
one projection. The first periphery projection they suggest is the topic phrase the head of which bears an
uninterpretive topic feature. The specifier position of this projection is the landing site for the topicalized
phrase which undergoes movement from its base position and deletes the uninterpretive feature of the head
topic. The topic phrase represents old information and is recursive; i.e. there could be more than one topic in
a single sentence. The second projection is the Focus Phrase. The head of this phrase bears an
uninterpretive focus feature which triggers movement of a constituent bearing an interpretive focus feature to
its specifier position. The higher projection in the CP layer is the usual complementizer phrase. Given these
assumptions, they propose the following representation for the relative positions of these phrases:
2. [CP [TopP* [FocP [TopP* [TP … ]]]]]
Topicalization in Persian occurs in simple clauses and complex clauses. Movement in complex clauses is
licensed both to the periphery of the dependent clause or the matrix clause. Examples (3) and (4) show
elements un magâzaro ‘that shop’ and Lebasâŝo ‘his clothes’ are topicalized and appear in the sepecifier of
the topic projection:
3. [TopP un magâzaroi [TP ali ti xarid]].

that shop Ali bought
(Ali bought that shop.)
4. [TopP lebâsâ-ŝ-oi [TP peyman ti ŝost]].

clothes-his-Acc Peyman washed
(Peyman washed his clothes.)
As the examples (3) and (4) show, the two elements un magâzaro ‘that shop’ and Lebasâŝo ‘his clothes’ refer
to something that is familiar for the speaker and hearer, so they have given information. Since these
elements move to initial position of sentence, they are topicalized constituents. Furthermore, in a simple
sentence, two elements can simultaneously move to initial position of sentence as topic. In (5), two
constituents un ketâbro ‘that book’ and be ali ‘to Ali’ move to initial position of sentence. These constituents
contain given information and therefore are topicalized constituents:
5. [TopP un ketâbroi [TopP be alij [TP moallem-eŝ ti tj dâde- bud]]]

that book to Ali teacher- his given- was
(His teacher had given that book to Ali.)
As it is illustrated (3-5), we can explain the simple marked sentences in Persian through Hageman and
Gueron’s split CP hypothesis (1999). According to this hypothesis, when one element is topicalized such as
(3) and (4), the landing site of that element is one of the two specifiers of topic projections in the CP layer.
480
Also, when two elements move as topic their landing site are two specifiers of topic projections in CP layer
such as in (5). In what follows, we will see the given hypothesis can account for compound and complex
sentences including one or two topicalized elements.
In compound sentence (6) and complex sentence (7), two elements barâdareŝo ‘his brother’ and xunaro ‘the
house’ are topicalized. Like simple sentences, the landing site of the two topicalized constituents in (6) and
(7) is specifiers of two topic projections.
6. [TopP barâdar-eŝ-oi [TP ali ti ovord va pro raft ]]

brother-his-râ Ali brought and he left
(Ali brought his brother and he left).
7. u goft ke [TopP xunaroi [TP mâ ti pârsal kharidim]]

he said that house we last year bought
(He said that we bought the house last year.)
In a dependent clause, the topicalized constituents can move to front positions of either the dependent clause
or the main clause. In (8) two elements are topicalized. The first topicalized constituent is subject of
dependent clause Soheyl and the second topicalized constituent (mâŝino ‘his car’) is the direct object of this
clause. These elements are topicalized and moved to the front of the main clause. In (9), two topicalized
constituents in the dependent clause have moved to the front position of the same clause. So, two topicalized
constituents un ketâbaro ‘that book’ and az anbâr ‘from cellar’ have undergone movement to periphery of
their own clause.
8. [TopP soheyli [TopP mâŝinoj [CP benazarmiyâd ke [TP ti tj be khâhar-eŝ hediye dâde]]]]
Soheyl car seems that to sister-his present given
(It seems that Soheyl has given the car to his sister as present.)
9. ali motmaen bud [CP ke [Top un ketabâroi [Top az anbârj [TP mâ ti tj xârej kardim]]]]
Ali certain was that that books from cellar we out did
(Ali was certain that we took those books from the cellar.)
In examples (8) and (9), two elements are topicalized. As said by Hageman and Gueron’s split CP hypothesis
(1999), the landing sites of these elements are the two specifiers of topic phrases while the complementizer
(ke) is in the head of CP. As we saw in the above examples, we could explain the order of complementizer
and two topicalized constituents based on Hageman and Gueron’s split CP hypothesis (1999). So, this
hypothesis can explicate topicalization process in Persian. In what follows, we will test the given hypothesis
when one sentence has simultaneously multiple topicalized and focused constituents.
3. Focalization
Focus is a part of a sentence that bears new information and it has contrast with the ground of sentence
which has given information. Focus can be related to phonological structure of language (Vallduvi and
Engdahl 1996 and Kiss 1998) Yet, it can also be represented syntactically. Focus is classified in two types:
information focus and contrastive focus. Information focus only contains new information. While contrastive
481
focus not only has new information but also has a kind of contrast with given information of hearer and it
corrects his or her earlier presupposition (Vallduvi and Engdahl 1996 and Kiss 1998).
Kiss (1998) and Rizzi (1997, 2003) believe that the position of focus is unique. It is implied that there is
one focus phrase per sentence. Also in their hypothesis, Hageman and Gueron (1999) suggest that in the CP
layer there is one focus projection. Kiss (1998) proposes that certain elements carry an inherent focus: only-
phrases and wh-phrases that belong to this group. Under this view, Karimi (2005) believes that the position of
focus is not unique. It is implied that Persian allows two elements bearing contrastive focus in the same
sentence only if at least one of them has an inherent focus feature (Karimi 2005:13):
10. Kimya mâhe gozaŝte faqat se-tâ film dide-Ø

Kimya month previous only three-classifier movie seen-is
(It was Kimya who has seen only three movies last month.)
In the above sentence, Karimi (2005) believes that there are two focuses. Subject of sentence Kimya is the
contrastive focus because it has a contrast to other person who speaker has in her or his mind. Another
focus is the object faqat se tâ film ‘only three-classifier movie’ since it has an inherent focus feature
presented by faqat ‘only’. As it is obvious, Karimi (2005) shows that this is plausible that two foci exist in a
sentence. Now if these focuses move to the CP layer, where is their landing site? Before we respond to this
question it is necessary to introduce classifying of adverbs. Cinque (1999) divides adverbs into two major
groups of higher and lower adverbs. He suggests that higher (sentence) adverbs precede lower adverbs.
That is, the sequence of two groups cannot change and the higher adverb always precedes the lower one.
Under this view, Karimi (2005) divides adverbs into two groups in Persian High (sentence) Adverbs: amdan
‘intentionally’, xoŝbaxtâne ‘fortunately’, zâheran ‘apparently’ etc.; and Low (VP) Adverbs: hamiŝe ‘always’,
hanuz ‘still’, hargez ‘never’ etc. In fact, the high adverbs precede TP and the low adverbs precede vP.
In (11), three elements are moved to the CP layer. One of these elements is the focused constituent
and two other are topicalized constituents. The adverb bâ ziraki ‘cleverly’ that appears before VP (its original
position), has moved to the CP layer through focalization process and occupies the specifier position of the
focus phrase. Additionally, the direct object penâlti ‘penalty’ and the indirect object az dâvar ‘from referee’
have moved to the CP layer by topicalization process and occupy specifier positions of two topic projections.
11. injâ moŝaxas-e [cp ke [TopP penâltiroi [FocP bâ zirakij [TopP az dâvark [TP pro tj ti tk gerfte-Ø]]]]]
here clear-is that penalty cleverly from referee he taken-is
(Here, it is clear that he cleverly took the penalty from the referee.)
We have so far been able to show that Persian sentences which have topicalized and focused constituents
could be accounted for based on the split CP hypothesis. Moreover, the given hypothesis could explain that
kind of sentence which had two topicalized constituents and one focused constituent. We continue with a
discussion of the possibility of movement of two focused constituents to the CP layer in a single sentence. If
this is the case (as we find below), Hageman and Gueron’s split CP hypothesis (1999) cannot account for
these kind of sentences.
Focus movement has been considered as an instance of displacement triggered by a discourse-
functional feature (Karimi 1999, 2003b and Kiss 2005). Karimi (2005) also believes that Persian does not
exhibit obligatory wh-movement, although these phrases are subject to scrambling. If scrambled, they force
an answer that indicates a contrastive focus. In fact, wh-movement in Persian is considered as A-bar
movement. Any constituent in position of a wh-phrase, such as wh-arguments and wh-adjuncts, receives a
focus feature. Similarly any constituent which is a reply to a wh-phrase receives a focus feature too. Wh-
482
phrases and their replies contain new information; therefore they are focused (Robert & Van valin 2005,
Vallduvi and Engdahl 1996). “A very common example of a narrow focus sentence is a WH-question like
What did you buy? and the answer I bought … ; the WH-word and the NP filling the slot in the reply are both
unmarked narrow foci. In a yes–no question like Did John leave? and the response No, Fred did, John and
Fred are marked narrow foci” (Van valin 2005: 72). Under this view, in (12) and (14), two wh-phrases koja
‘where’ and key ‘when’ are focused constituents. Also, in (13) and (15) the replies dâneŝgah ‘university’ and
do-ruz piŝ ‘two days ago’ are focused constituents too. These sentences can be analyzed based on the split
CP hypothesis. the wh-pharses in (12 & 14) as well as their replies in (13 & 15) occupy the specifier of the
focus projection.
12. [ FocP kojâi [ TP pro ti miri]]

Where you go
(Where do you go?)
13. [FocP dâneŝgâh [TP pro ti miram]]

university I go
(I go to university.)
14. [FocP keyi [TP pro ti az ŝirâz bargaŝti]]

When you from Shiraz returned
(When did you return from Shiraz?)
15. [FocP do ruz piŝi [TP pro ti az ŝirâz barghaŝt-am]]

two days ago I from Shiraz returned
(I returned from Shiraz two days ago.)
Rizzi (1997) and Haegeman (2000) have argued that just focused constituents occupy the specifier position
within a focus phrase and that topicalized constituents occupy the specifier position within a topic phrase
(Radford 2004: 329). The data from Persian show that there could be two focused constituents in a sentence.
16. [FocP barâ kesiyami [FocP ĉizij [TP pro tj ti soqât ovorde budan]]]?
for somebody something they souvenir brought were
(Had they brought any souvenir for anybody?)
17. [FocP faqat ye kifi [FocP barâ nargesj [TP amu ti tj gerfte- bud]]]
only a purse for Narges uncle taken-was
(Only a purse had Uncle bought Narges.)
18. be-hem migi [CP ke [FocP kioi [FocP bâ kij [TP pro ti tj didan-Ø]]]]?
to-me tell that who with whom they seen-are
(Lit: Will you tell me who with whom they have seen?)
483
19. [FocP saidoi [FocP bâ maryamj [TP diruz baĉehâ ti tj didan]]]

Saeed with Maryam yesterday guys saw
(The guys saw Saeed and Maryam together yesterday.)
In the above sentences, there are two focused constituents: wh-phrases and its replies. For example in (16),
two wh-phrases barâ kesiyam’ To somebody’ and ĉizi ‘something’ are focused constituents because they
have inherent focus feature. Also in (17), two constituents which are a reply for wh-phrases are focused
constituents because they have new information.
Similarly, in (20), focused constituents are wh-phrase ĉerâ ‘why’ and object faqat abbâs ‘only Abbâs
20. fahmid-i [CP ke [FocP ĉerâj [FocP faqati abbâso [TP dâneŝgâh ti burs karde-Ø tj ]]]]
learned-you that why only Abbâs university scholarship done-has
(Did you learn why, only to Abbas, has the university given a scholarship?)
As it was noted in the previous section, Hageman and Gueron (1999) suggest that the CP layer has only one
focus projection. So, this hypothesis is not an appropriate one to account for Persian sentences that have
simultaneously two focused constituents. Karimi (2005:137) argues that the two focused constituents cannot
be separated; therefore, she suggests multiple specifiers for the sole focus projection. That is, she claims that
the focused phrases occupy two specifier positions of the focus projection.
21. [TopP kii bâ kij [TP to [vP fekr mikoni [CP (ke) ti tj beraqse]]]?
who with who you think do that dance
(Li: Who with whom is it that you think will dance?)
22. ?? kii emruz bâ kij pro fekr mikoni [CP (ke) ti tj beraghse]?
who today with who think do that dance
(Li: Who with whom is it that you think will dance today?)
However, this position cannot be borne out for the following reasons below based on which we conclude that,
at least in Persian, two focused phrases can be maintained.
First, it should be noted that while the sentence in (22) is highly marked , it is acceptable. Second, the
verb raqsidan ‘dance’ is a predicate which has one argument ki ‘who’. So, we must consider the focused
constituent bâ ki ‘with whom’ as a wh-adjunct. This is contrast to Karimi’s analysis in which wh-adjuncts
cannot move to specifier of the focus projection.
Third, according to Hornstein et.al. (2005), a movement operation is licensed only if it leads to
elimination of an uninterpretive formal features. Under this view, if a constituent moves to another position,
either the constituent itself or the head of the projection it moves to must have an uninterpretive feature.
Under Karimi’s multiple specifier view, we should assume that the two focused phrases bearing an
uniterpretive feature would check the uninterpretive feature of the focus head twice. But, this is not a
plausible analysis based on Chomsky (1995) whereby movement of one constituent deletes the
uninterpretive feature of the functional category. In addition, data show that a constituent can appear
between two focused elements in Persian.
484
23. [FocP kioi [FocP bâ kij [TP doktor ti tj un ruz eŝtebâh- gerefte- bud]]]?
Who with whom doctor that day mistake-taken-was
(Lit: Who with whom is it that the doctor had confused that day?)
This sentence (23) can be replied in three different ways, with slightly different interpretation:
24. [TopP un ruzi [FocP man-oj [FocP bâ dâdâŝ-amk [TP doktor ti tj tk eŝtebâh -gerfte -bud]]]]
that day I-Acc with brother-my doctor mistake-taken-was
25. [FocP man-oj [FocP bâ dâdâŝ-amk [TopP un ruzi [TP doktor ti tj tk eŝtebâh -gerfte -bud]]]]
I-Acc with brother-my that day doctor mistake-taken-was
26. [FocP man-oj . [TopP un ruzi [FocP bâ dâdâŝ-amk [TP doktor ti tj tk eŝtebâh -gerfte -bud]]]
I-Acc that day with brother-my doctor mistake-taken-was
(The doctor had confused me with my brother that day.)
In the above sentence there are three fronted constituents. The constituents man ‘me’ and bâ dâdâŝam ‘with
my brother’ are focused constituents because they are replies to wh-phrases and have new information. The
constituents un ruz ‘that day’ is mentioned in previous discourse and because it bears given information is a
topicalized constituent. Sentence (26) illustrates a topicalized constituent (i.e. un ruz ‘that day’) is placed
between two focused constituents, contrary to Karimi’s analysis (2005).
And finally, considering more examples, a variety of sequential orders can be observed, specifically in
sentences which instantiate two Focused as well as two topicalized fronted constituents. Under each
example below, the relevant configurationally representation indicates the order of the moved constituents.
27a. [CP [TopP ketâboi [TopP be minâj [FocP ĉerâ [TP said ti tj dâde-Ø tk ]]]]?
book to Mina why Saeed given-is
[CP [TopP [TopP [FocP [TP]]]]]
27b. [CP [TopP ketâboi [FopP ĉerâ [TopP be minâj [TP said ti tj dâde-Ø tk]]]]?
book why to Mina Saeed given-is
[CP [TopP [FocP [TopP [TP]]]]]
(Why has Saeed given the book to Mina?)
28a. [CP [FocP ĉerâi [FocP hanuzk [TopP in duste-ŝ-oj [TP sohrâb tk tj be-mâ moarrefi na-karde-Ø ti ]]]]?
why yet this friend-his-Acc Sohrâb to us introduce no-done-is
[CP [FocP [FocP [TopP [TP]]]]]
28b. [CP [FocP ĉerâi [TopP in-dust-eŝ-oj [TopP be-mâg [FocP hanuzk [TP sohrâb tk tj tg moarrefi na-kard-e ti ]]]]]]?
why this-friend-his-Acc to-us yet Sohrâb introduce-no-done-is
485
[CP [FocP [TopP [TopP [FocP [TP]]]]]]
28c. [CP [FocP ĉerâi [FocP hanuzk [TopP in-dust-eŝ-oj [TopP be-mâg [TP sohrâb tk tj tg moarrefi na-kard-e ti]]]]]]?
Why yet this-friend-his-Acc to us Sohrâb introduce-no-done-is
[CP [FocP [FocP [TopP [TopP [TP]]]]]]
28d. [CP [FopP ĉerâi [TopP in-dust-eŝ-oj [FocP hanuzk [TopP be-mâg [TP sohrâb tk tj tg moarrefi na-kard-e ti]]]]]]?
Why this-friend-his-Acc yet to us Sohrâb introduce-no-done-is
[CP [FocP [TopP [FocP [TopP [TP]]]]]]
(Why has not Sohrâb introduced his friend to us yet?
Given the arguments above and considering all the given examples, it seems that we must postulate a
second focus projection in the CP layer in Persian. In order to account for the discussed data so far the
following configuration is proposed for periphery positions in Persian (The * indicative recursive property)..
[CP [FocP [ TopP* [ FocP [ TopP* [TP]]]]]]
4. Conclusion
In this paper we analyzed Persian CP layer based on the Split CP Hypothesis proposed by Haegeman and
Gueron (1999). We discussed discourse motivated movements to CP projections both in simple and complex
sentences and to main and dependent clauses respectively. Our data, however, indicated that the Split CP
Hypothesis cannot account for all the data from Persian. We also found that Karimi (2005)’s analysis
assuming multiple specifiers for the focus phrase was not compatible with the data. Finally, we proposed a
second focused phrase in Persian and a representation which successfully accounts for all the observed
data.
References
Anushe, M. (2010). Topicalization and Focus movement in Persian: A Feature-Based Approach. Language research 1,1: 1-28
Chomsky, N. (1995). The Minimalist Program, Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
Den Dikken, M. (2006). Relators and linkers: The Syntax of Perdication, Predicate Inversion, Copulas. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Darzi, A & Beyraghdar, R. M. (2011). A minimalist approach to the landing site of Persian topics. Research in Linguistics 2, 1: 1-18
Haegeman, L, and J. Gueron (1999). English Grammar: A Generative Perspective. Oxford: Blackwell Publishers.
Hornstein, N; Nunes, J. and Grohmann, K. (2005). Understanding Minimalism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Jackendoff, R. (1972). Semantics Interpretation in Generative Grammar, Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
Karimi, S. (1997). Persian complex verbs: idiomatic or compositional. Lexicology 3 (2): 273-318.
Karimi, S. (2003). Focus Movement and the Nature of Uninterpretable Features, In Carnie, Andrew, Heidi Karimi, S. (2005). A Minimalist
Approach to Scrambling, Evidence from Persian, New York: Mouton de Gruyter.
Harley and Mary Willie (eds) Formal approach to Functional Focus, John Benjamins.
Kiss, K.E. (1998). Identificational Focus and Information Focus, Language 74:245-273.
Radford, A (2004). Minimalist Syntax: Exploring the Structure of English, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Robert, D, and Van Valin, JR. (2005). Exploring the syntax-Semantics Interface, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Rizzi, L. (1997). The Fine Structure of the left Periphery, in L. Haegeman (ed.), Element of Grammar, 281-337, kluwer Academic
Publishers
Rizzi, L. (2003). Locality and Left Periphery, to appear in A. Belletti (ed), Structures and Beyond: the Cartography of Syntactic
Structures, vol. 2, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Valluvi, E. & Engdahl, (1996). The linguistic realization of information packaging. Linguistics 34.
486
Disposition to Organizational Learning: A Survey of Selected Construction Industry

Organisations in Lagos State, Nigeria
Martin Oloruntobi Dada

Ben Akpadiaha
Department of Building, University of Lagos, Akoka, Yaba, Lagos, Nigeria

Modupe Mulikat Ologunagba

Department of Quantity Surveying, Rufus Giwa Polytechnic, Owo, Ondo State, Nigeria
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.487
Abstract: The construction industry and her projects are replete with potentials for learning at both the organisational and
project levels. Yet the industry often wastes this opportunity. This research was embarked upon to investigate the disposition of
construction industry participants to the use of organisational learning (OL) in the Nigerian construction industry. Data was
collected using a structured questionnaire administered purposively on sixty construction industry organisations operating in
Lagos, Nigeria. The collected data was subjected to both descriptive and inferential statistical analysis. The findings indicate that
majority of respondents agreed that ‘Managers ask probing questions and invite input from others in discussions’ and also
‘Managers listen attentively’. The study results further indicate that there is no significant difference in disposition to
organizational learning between contracting, consulting, and client organizations within the Nigerian Construction Industry. This
study recommends that a more detailed investigation be made of those items of measure where respondents indicate
disagreements to understand better the underlying phenomena. Measures indicating strong indices of agreement can be further
explored for improvement.
Keywords: construction industry; knowledge management; learning organization; Nigeria; organizational learning.
1. Introduction
The contribution of the construction industry of nations to provide or sustain or maintain infrastructure and
support the quality of life of citizens is acknowledged (Ogunlana, 2010a & 2010b). The construction industry
in Nigeria is of paramount importance in employment and economic growth (Ogunsemi & Jagboro, 2006).
The construction industry contributes about 5% to Nigeria’s annual gross domestic product and one-third of
her total fixed capital investment. Faniran (2002) states that, in a developing country like Nigeria, which is still
in the process of providing adequate social amenities such as educational and health care facilities as well as
decent housing for its teeming populace, the construction industry has an important role to play. About 69%
of Nigeria’s fixed capital formation is created by the construction industry. This means the construction
industry represents about 70% of the capital base of the nation’s economy. Notwithstanding its position, the
performance of the industry within the overall macro-economy has been, and continues to be, very poor and
abysmal (Faniran, 2002).
Some characteristics of the construction industry pose further challenges to management and integration.
It is an industry that is fragmented in nature, often with a highly mobile workforce. The arrangement of
participants to execute the project often involves a coalition of disparate and different organisations,
professional and commercial entities (Zhang and Hu, 2011) into what is termed temporary multi-
organisations. The industry is also faced with the challenges of addressing both company and project level of
management especially in construction contracting. The construction company for example has to evolve its
487
management philosophy of its company as an organisation. The management of the project is another issue
for the construction organisation as each project oftentimes has its own uniqueness, structure and
participating parties.
2. Aim and objectives
The aim of this research is to investigate the disposition of construction industry organisations – client,
consultants and contractors- to organisational learning (OL). The following objectives are pursued:
1. To ascertain the assessment of the construction industry organisations of issues depicting
disposition to organisational learning
2 To investigate if there are differences in dispositions of construction industry organisations to
organisational learning
3. Some perspectives on organisational learning
According to Crossan, Lane and White (1999), organizational learning is as old as the 1960s. The concept of
organizational learning is fluid with some researchers operating from different perspectives. While,
commonality of understanding as to what constitutes (the concepts and practices of) organisational learning
has not been achieved among practitioners and academics (Foil & Lyles, 1985), the background to
organizational learning includes an increasingly competitive business environment that is also contextually
related to globalization. McShane (2001) sees learning as a process by an organisation to acquire,
disseminate and apply knowledge for its survival and success. This implies that organizational learning is
supposed to be goal oriented. Fiol and Lyles (1985) acknowledged that there has been confusion for
decades over the meaning of organizational learning. They in turn, defined organizational learning as the
growing insights and successful restructurings of organizational problems by individuals reflected in the
structural elements and outcomes of the organization itself. In this definition, learning consists of the
development of insights on the one hand and structural and other action outcomes on the other. One is a
change in states of knowledge not clearly perceptible; the other often involves a change more easily visible in
terms of an organizational outcome. And, most important, the two often do not occur simultaneously, which
makes the problem of distinguishing between them all the more important. They cited what many theorists
have referred learning to as (a) new insights or knowledge; or (b) new structures; or (c) new systems; or (d)
mere actions; or (e) some combination of the above.
Crossan et al (1999) in their treatment of organisational learning focused on new learning or lessons and
their use. They also focused on multilevel perspectives of organizational learning: individual, group and
organization. The three levels are linked by social and psychological processes of intuiting, interpreting,
integrating and institutionalizing learning. The last is how cognition affects action.
Organisational learning imposes two requirements of knowledge and sharing, a degree of collective action
of stakeholders. Granerud and Rocha (2011), citing some authors, submitted that organisational learning
encompasses the development of new knowledge, skills and behaviour, the rectification of errors and
improvement of current practices, and the development of new routines. Thus organisational improvement
leads to or is expected to lead to continuous process improvement. Ideas, techniques and experiences from
within or outside the organisation are shared to improve the organisation’s performance. Organisational
learning is thus related to continuous process improvement. Organisational learning is the foundation for
continuous process improvement, while continuous process improvement is a way of organising and
supporting organisational learning. Arshad and Scott-Ladd (2010) proposed some levels of organisational
learning and their characteristics thus: 1) Reproductive learning: handling of routine problems; 2) Basic
productive learning: evaluation of outcomes and minor corrections; 3) Advanced productive learning:
experiments, inventions and test solutions; 4) Creative learning: questioning existing assumptions
488
A related term to organisational learning is unlearning which has been described as a process of clearing
out, outdated beliefs that no more meet current challenges and realities (Wong, Cheung, Yiu & Hardie, 2012).
In a study on the Malaysian Vision 2020, Arshad and Scott-Ladd (2010) categorised approaches to learning
into action learning, active learning and experiential learning, co-operative learning, problem-based learning,
coaching and mentoring, formal and informal learning. Arshad and Scott-Ladd (2010) compared the
approaches used by Malaysian organisations to learning and concluded that while organisations preferred
internal learning strategies they also used external learning strategies. Both formal and informal sources are
popular.
A related term to organisational learning is the learning organisation. The concepts of organisational
learning and learning organisation also carry along related terms of knowledge management and the
knowledge creating company (Nonaka & Takuechi, 1995). The knowledge-creating-company as implied by
Nonaka and Takuechi (1995) is an organization whose sole business is continuous innovation. The concept
is hinged on the from the fact that in the world economies the only certainty is uncertainty, for this reason the
one sure source of lasting competitive advantage is knowledge. Dodgson (1993) acknowledged the difficulty
of agreement both within and between disciplines as to what learning is, and how it occurs. To this end
various literatures are inclined to examine the outcomes of learning but not the processes of learning.
Dodgson (1993) however described organizational learning in terms of learning processes and not outcomes:
organisational learning can be described as the ways firms build, supplement and organize knowledge and
routines around activities and within their cultures and adapt and develop organizational efficiency by
improving the use of broad skills of their workforces. Hence, encouraging and coordinating the variety of
interactions in learning is a key organizational task. In essence, while some authors do not see a distinction
between organisational learning and the learning organisations, some see. Some see learning organisation
as a type of organization, while organisational learning represents the transformational process that occurs
in that type of organisation. One deals with anticipated structure, another with process.
Organisational learning is crucial for the construction industry since the industry is generally perceived to
be one with low productivity and poor performance, in spite of its significance to the national economy
(Tjandra & Tan, 2002; Wong et al, 2012). Tjandra and Tan (2002) also stated that the project based nature of
the construction industry has made it very vital to record and transfer lessons from project to project.
Research studies on the construction industry have indicated that there is a direct relationship between an
organisations performance in their construction projects and its leaning competencies (Love & Josephson,
2004; Murray & Chapman, 2003)
This study seeks to investigate the disposition of Nigerian construction industry organisations to
organisational learning or whether they exhibit characteristics of learning organisations. This exploratory
research has not aligned with the rigid differentiation of organisational learning from the learning organisation.
Rather the researchers have seen the learning organisation concept as a subset of organisational learning
and thus sought to investigate the selected Nigerian construction organisations for their predisposition or
gravitation towards being learning organisations. The research has aligned itself with the process perspective
of approaching learning taking into consideration issues such as conducive environments enunciated by
Senge (1991), De-Gues (1996) and Garvin, Edmondson and Gino (2008). The need to increase
competitiveness in the industry and encourage continuous process and product improvement warrants this
study. This study thus has the potential of opening up a wide field of research area in the field of
organisational learning in the construction industry and to contribute to the body of knowledge in that area as
far as Nigeria is concerned.
4. Research methods
The data collection and analysis was preceded by review of literature. Data for the study was collected using
a structured questionnaire. The questionnaires were distributed to a purposive sample of contractor,
489
consultant and client companies operating in Lagos State, Nigeria. The instrument for the research requested
the respondent to provide some biographical details. The questionnaire used for the study was divided into
four sections. Section one examined the characteristics of respondents in terms of their professions,
academic qualification, professional qualification, years of experience, type of organization, size of
organization, and number of projects involved in the last five (5) years (2005 to 2010). The second section
measured/evaluated the disposition of project participants to learning. The third section measured the
learning processes and practices of employees of organization or team-mates within their team or unit, while
the fourth section measured management support for organizational learning within their companies. The
second to the fourth section required respondents to respond to statements using an ordinal rating scale of 1
to 5 in each section in the order: 5 = Strongly Agree, 4 = Agree, 3 = Slightly Agree, 2 = Disagree, 1 = Strongly
Disagree. These sections of the questionnaire measure supportive learning environment, concrete learning
processes and leadership that reinforce learning. The questions used for this section were drawn or adopted
from Garvin et al (2008). Based on this, the data generated were analysed by Statistical Package for Social
Science (Version 13.0) and those with the highest mean score were ranked 1, while those with lower mean
score were ranked according to their value/magnitude. Further inferential statistical analysis was done on the
data while the statistical level of significance was set at 5%.
5. Analysis, Results and Discussion
Sixty questionnaires were administered on the selected construction industry organisations with the
questionnaires being completed by their representatives. Follow-up efforts were made. In the process thirty
completed questionnaires were received. The response rate to the questionnaire was 50%. This is judged to
be a high rate of response which can be attributed to the follow-up efforts.
5.1 Descriptive Statistical Analysis
5.1.1 Characteristics of representatives of respondent organisations
Table 1 shows the profession of the respondents who completed the questionnaire on behalf of the
construction industry organisations.
Table 1: Respondent Profession
Professional standing Frequency Percent

Civil Engineer 12 40.0
Quantity Surveyor 5 16.7
Mechanical Engineer 4 13.3
Builder 5 16.7
Estate surveyor & valuer 2 6.7
Others 2 6.7
Total 30 100.0
It is observed from the findings that majority of the respondents were Civil Engineers who possess Bachelors
degree while some have Master of Science/Master of Project Management/Master in Business
Administration degrees.
Table 2 shows the frequency of projects that the respondents have been involved in the last five (5) years.
490
Table 2: Number of projects involved in the last five years (2005 - 2010)
Number of projects Frequency Percent

1–5 9 30.0
6 – 10 4 13.3
11 – 15 6 20.0
16 – 20 4 13.3
26 – 30 3 10.0
above 30 4 13.3
Total 30 100
5.1.2 Characteristics of Respondent Organisations
Table 3 shows the characteristics of the respondent organisations.
Table 3: Type of organization
Frequency Percent
Consulting firms 5 16.7
Contracting firms 19 63.3
Client 6 20.0
Total 30 100
Table 3 shows that 19 (63.3%) of respondent organisations were contractors, while 5 (16.7%) were
consulting firms and 6 (20%) were client organisations.
Table 4 shows the number of employees of the organisations.
Table 4: Number of employees in respondent organisations
Number of employees Frequency Percent

1–5 1 3.3
5 – 50 9 30.0
50 – 100 7 23.3
100 – 1000 12 40.0
Not indicated 1 3.3
Total 30 100
The table indicates that 12 (40%) of the organisations had between 100 to 1000 employees. The table also
shows the others: 7 (23.3%) have 50 to 99 employees; 9(30%) have 5 to 50 employees, while 1(3.3) have 1-
5 employees. By employment pattern, it is the contracting firms that are more likely to have more employees.
5.1.3 Disposition to Organizational Learning Processes and Practices
This section of the analysis reports the output of the examination of the disposition of project participants to
organizational learning within the Nigerian construction industry. Table 5 shows the descriptive analysis of
items used to investigate the disposition of project participants to organisational learning within the Nigerian
construction industry. The mean item scores of all the respondent organisations are shown for each issue
491
within a sub-section. The second column on ‘Mean’ indicates the mean item score of all the respondents on
the issue. The third column shows the ranking of that issue in that sub-section or subgroup. The fourth
column shows the means of the means of the respective issues in that sub-section. The last column shows
the ranking of each subsection (based on sub-section mean) with respect to the four subsections indicated in
the table.
Table 5: Means and rankings on issues of supportive learning environment
Sub-section and items Mean Rank Sub-section Mean Sub-section Rank

A Psychological safety:
People in this unit/organization are eager to

share information about what does and doesn't work
3.87 1
In your organization/unit it is easy to speak up
about what is on your mind
3.70 2
People in this unit/organization are
usually comfortable talking about problems
and disagreements 3.27 3
If you make a mistake in this unit, it is often
held against you
3.07 4
Keeping your cards close to your vest is the
best way to get ahead this unit/organization
2.60 5
3.30 1
B
Appreciation of Differences:
In this unit/organization, people are open
to alternative ways of getting work done
3.70 1
Differences in opinion are welcome in
this unit/organization
3.57 2
Unless an opinion is consistent with what
most people in this unit/organization believe,
it won't be valued 2.97 3
This unit/organization tends to handle differences

of opinion privately or off-line, rather than
addressing them directly in the group/open 2.83 4
3.27 2
C Openness to new ideas:
In this unit/organization, people value new ideas 4.03 1
In this unit/organization, people are

interested in better ways of doing things 3.93 2
In this unit/organization, people often resist

untried approaches 2.61 3
Unless an idea has been around for a long time,

no one in this unit/organization wants to hear it 2.43 4
492
3.25 3
D Time for Reflection:
In this unit/organization, schedule pressures

gets in the way of doing a good job.
3.5 1
Despite the workload, people in this

unit/organization find time to review how the work is
going
3.43 2
People in this unit /organization are overly
stressed
3.13 3
In this unit/organization, people are too
busy to invest time in improvement
2.83 4
There is simply no time for reflection in

this unit/organization 2.27 5
3.03 4
The overall mean item score of the responses was taken to examine if a supportive learning environment
exists and thus by extension examine the disposition of the construction industry organisations to
organizational learning.
Within the Psychological Safety sub-section, “People in this unit/organization are eager to share
information about what does and doesn't work” had the highest mean score of 3.87 and thus ranked 1,
showing that respondents mostly agree with the statement than any other. This implies that people are eager
to share information the construction industry. Followed in descending order by “In your organization/unit it is
easy to speak up about what is on your mind” with mean score of 3.7 and ranked 2, respondents also agree
with the statement. Next by “People in this unit/organization are usually comfortable talking about problems
and disagreements” with mean score of 3.27 and ranked 3, and “If you make a mistake in this unit it is often
held against you” with mean score of 3.07 and ranked 4, both these statements are slightly agreed with.
While “Keeping your cards close to your vest is the best way to get ahead in this unit/organization” had the
lowest mean score of 2.6 and ranked 5 showing that respondents did not agree with the above statement.
Within the Appreciation of Differences sub-section, “In this unit/organization, people are open to alternative
ways of getting work done” had the highest mean score of 3.70 and thus ranked 1. This implies that
respondents agree with the statement most. “Differences in opinion are welcome in this unit/organization”
follows next in descending order with a mean score of 3.57 and a rank of 2, respondents also agrees with the
statement. Next in line are “Unless an opinion is consistent with what most people in this unit/organization
believe, it won't be valued” with a mean score of 2.97 and ranking of 3, and “This unit/organization tends to
handle differences of opinion privately or off-line, rather than addressing them directly in the group/open” with
a mean score of 2.83 and ranked 4. Respondents slightly agree with both statements.
Within the Openness to New Ideas sub-section “In this unit/organization, people value new ideas” had the
highest mean score of 4.03 and was ranked 1. Respondent were really disposed to this statement, showing
project participants value new ideas a lot. Subsequently, in descending order were “In this unit/organization,
people are interested in better ways of doing things” with a mean of 3.93 and ranked 2, respondents agree to
the statement likewise. “In this unit/organization, people often resist untried approaches” with a mean score
of 2.61 and ranked 3, and “Unless an idea has been around for a long time, no one in this unit/organization
wants to hear it” with a mean score of 2.43 and a rank of 4. Respondents disagreed with both statements
meaning they agreed with the contrary.
493
Within the Time for reflection sub-section “In this unit/organization, schedule pressures gets in the way of
doing a good job” had the highest mean score of 3.5 and was ranked 1. Most respondents agreed with the
statement connoting that schedule pressures affect the quality of their jobs. Following this in descending
order, are “Despite the workload, people in this unit/organization find time to review how the work is going”
with a mean score of 3.43 and ranked 2, and “People in this unit /organization are overly stressed” with a
mean score of 3.13 and a rank of 3, respondents slightly agree with both statements. Next is “In this
unit/organization, people are too busy to invest time in improvement” with a mean score of 2.83 and ranked
4, showing that people partially agree with statement. While “There is simply no time for reflection in this
unit/organization” with a mean score of 2.27 and a rank of 5, respondents do not agree with the statement.
One observation is that all the sub-section means are approximately ‘3’ which suggests that
preponderance of responses suggest ‘slightly agree’ to the issues being used for the assessment. Using the
subsections means suggests that respondents slightly agree that there exists supportive learning
environment in construction organisations. This may imply a disposition to organisational learning. The work
of Kululanga and Kuotcha (2008) on Malawi indicates some use of the concept of organisational learning
through project reviews.
5.2 Inferential statistical analysis
5.2.1 Hypothesis testing
The next aspect of the analysis is to investigate whether there are significant differences in disposition to
organizational learning between contracting, consulting, and client organizations within the Nigerian
Construction Industry. To achieve this, the following null and alternative hypotheses were postulated thus:
Null Hypothesis (Ho): There is no significant difference in disposition to organizational learning
between contracting, consulting, and client organizations within the Nigerian Construction Industry.
Alternative Hypothesis (Hi): There is significant difference in disposition to organizational learning
between contracting, consulting, and client organizations within the Nigerian Construction Industry.
An analysis of variance was performed on the relevant data. Tables 6 and 7 show some of the edited outputs
of the analysis. The statistical level of significance is 5%.
Table 6 specifically shows the means and standard deviations and other measures of central tendency of
the responses.
Table 6: Standard Deviation of Organizations’ Disposition to Organizational Learning
95% Confidence Interval for Mean

Lower Upper
Group/Firm N Mean Std. Deviation Std. Error Min Max
Consulting 5 3.1222 .33656 .15051 2.7043 3.5401 2.72 3.61
Contracting 19 3.2107 .38939 .08933 3.0230 3.3984 2.53 4.00
Client 6 3.2685 .39662 .16192 2.8523 3.6847 2.56 3.67
Total 30 3.2075 .37268 .06804 3.0684 3.3467 2.53 4.00
N= number of respondent organisations; Min = minimum; Max = maximum
The table (Table 6) indicates that for all the groups, the mean revolves around 3, the ‘slightly agree’ value.
494
Table 7 presents the analysis of variance for the three groups with respect to the mean item scores.
Table 7: ANOVA Results of Disposition to Organizational Learning
F-tab
Source of Variation Sum of Squares d.f Mean Square F-cal P-Value
Between Groups .059 2 .029 .200 .820 3.35
Within Groups 3.969 27 .147
Total 4.028 29
d.f = degrees of freedom
From an examination of Table 7 the probability value is greater than 0.05, the set value for statistical
significance. The implication and decision is that the null hypothesis should be accepted as there is no
significant difference in disposition to organizational learning between contracting, consulting, and client
organizations within the Nigerian Construction Industry. The implications of this finding include the fact that
there is implied homogeneity regarding disposition to organisational learning by the respective construction
industry organisations. This homogeneity thus has the potential of making stakeholder management of
intervention or policy efforts on the issue of organisational learning in the construction industry less
problematic. Construction industry organisations that are used in this study are critical to the success of the
construction project. The homogeneity of assessment may be partly due to the fact that ordinarily every
organisation whatever its commercial inclination wants to improve. The assessment indicated through the
descriptive analysis reflected in Table 5 also seems to suggest the current state of disposition to
organisational learning in the country.
6. Conclusions and recommendations
Some conclusions emanate from this research. Project participants are most eager to share information, they
are also willing to speak out their minds and they distance themselves from hoarding or hiding information as
it is not the best way to get ahead in any unit/organization. Psychological safety was rated highest by
respondents but its mean score fell in the ‘slightly agree’ margin. In addition, construction industry
organisations slightly agree with issues under appreciation of differences, openness to new ideas, and time
for reflection. There were no significant differences in disposition to organisational learning by Nigerian
construction industry organisations. This study recommends that a more detailed investigation be made of
those items of measure where respondents indicate disagreements to understand better the underlying
phenomena. Measures where there are strong indices of agreement can be further explored for
improvement. The finding that there is no significant difference in disposition to organizational learning
between contracting, consulting, and client organizations within the Nigerian Construction Industry can be
leveraged upon to inculcate and entrench organisational learning in the Nigerian construction industry and
any other related improvement. It could also be expected that because of the implied homogeneity of
disposition to organisational learning, intervention efforts in the right direction should meet with least
resistance in the industry in Nigeria. This research acknowledges some limitations: the sample size and the
study area. The study area is Lagos; conclusions from this work may not be validly applicable to all parts of
Nigeria. The conclusions can however be indicative.
495
References
Arshad, M.A., & Scott-Ladd, B. (2010). Towards Vision 2020: Organisational learning practices in Malaysia, International Journal of
Employment Studies, 18(1), 89-123
Crossan, M. M., Lane, W., & White, R. E. (1999). An Organizational Learning Framework: From Intuition to Institution. Academy of
Management Review. 24(3), 522 – 537.
De Gues, A. (1996). Strategy and Learning. Reflections, 1(3), 75 – 81
Dodgson, M. (1993). Organizational Learning: Review of Some Literatures. Organization Studies, 14(3), 375 – 394
Faniran, O.O. (2002). The Role of Construction Project Planning in Improving Project Delivery in Developing Countries: Case study of
the Nigerian construction industry. Australia: Deakin University,
Fiol, C. M., & Lyles, A. (1985). Organizational Learning. Academy of Management Review, 10(4): 803 – 813
Garvin, D. A., Edmondson, A. C., & Gino, F. (2008). Is Yours a Learning Organization? Harvard Business Review, No. R0803H: 1-11
Granerud, R.L., & Rocha, R.S. (2011). Organisational learning and continuous improvement of health and safety in certified
manufacturers, Safety Science, 49, 1030-1039
Kululanga, G.K., & Kuotcha, W.S. (2008), Measuring organisational learning through project reviews, Engineering, Construction and
Architectural Management, 15(6), 580-595
Love, P.E.D., & Josephson, P.E. (2004). Role of error recovery process in projects,Journal of Management in Engineering, 20 (2), 70-79
McShane, S. (2001). Canadian organisational behaviour. Toronto: McGraw Hill Ryerson
Nonaka, I., & Takuechi, H. (1995). The knowledge creating company. Oxford: England: Oxford University Press.
Murray, P., & Chapman, R. (2003). From continuous improvement to organisational learning: Developmental theory, The Learning
organisation, 10(5), 272-282
Ogunlana, S.O. (2010a, December). The building profession and national development: a holistic assessment, being a guest lecture
delivered at the 11th investiture ceremony of newly inducted builders by the Council of Registered Builders of Nigeria at the
Nigerian Army Officers Wives Association Building, Manbilla Barracks, Abuja on December 2, 2010
Ogunlana, S.O. (2010b, February). Sustaining 20:20:20 Vision through construction: A stakeholder participatory approach. Being a
lecture delivered under the distinguished lecture series of the School of Post-Graduate Studies, University of Lagos in February
10, 2010.
Ogunsemi, D.R., & Jagboro, G.O. (2006). Time-cost Model for Building Projects in Nigeria. Construction Management and Economics,
24, 253 – 258
Senge, P. M. (1991). Team Learning: An Excerpt From: The Fifth Discipline: The Art & Practice of Learning Organisation. McKinsey
Quarterly, 2, 82 – 93
Tjandra, I. K., & Tan, W. (2002). Organisational learning in construction firms: the case of construction firms operating in Jakarta,
Indonesia. Report on research conducted at National University of Singapore. Singapore: National University of Singapore.
Wong, P.S.P., Cheung, S.O., Yiu, R.L.Y., & Hardie, M. (2012). The unlearning dimension of organisational learning in construction
projects, International Journal of Project Management, 30, 94-104
Zhang, J.P., & Hu, Z. Z. (2011). BIM and 4D-based integrated solution of analysis and management of conflicts and structural safety
problems during construction: principles and methodologies. Automation in construction, 20: 155-166
496
Don’t Dampen the Laughter: Difficulties in Translating Comedies
Dr. Mirela Papa
Facoltà di Lingue Straniere

Università di Tirana (Albania)
Prof. As. Dr. Irena Lama
Facoltà di Lingue Straniere

Università di Tirana (Albania)
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.497
Abstract:The presence of humor in audiovisual text as it is by the dialectal variants, the cultural references etc., implies a
challenge for the translator, and we need to admit, it is not an easy challenge. As long as more elements are characterized
culturally, more it becomes almost impossible for the translator to recreate the same comic effects on the original film, as the
new spectator of the metatext who may not share the cultural environment and the cultural baggage of the prototext. This article
will analyse problems encountered in the translation of Italian comedies into the Albanian language. We will see concretely how
the dialectal variants, the referents of language, the different registers of speech used to create various shades of humor in
audiovisual texts are difficult for the translator as a mediator between two cultures.
Keywords: audiovisual translation, audiovisual text, language varieties, cultural referents.
Per non smorzare le risate: difficoltà nella traduzione dei film comici
1. Introduzione
Per far ridere bisogna conoscere bene chi si vuole far ridere e alla base del meccanismo dell'umorismo c'è
spesso l'evidenziare difetti e vizi tipici di una società che lo sceneggiatore conosce bene. Si può facilmente
intuire che nei film comici ci si imbatte in elementi connotati culturalmente. La presenza dell’umorismo in un
testo audiovisivo presuppone una sfida per il traduttore e, occorre ammettere che, non è una sfida facile. Più
gli elementi sono connotati culturalmente, più diventa quasi impossibile per il traduttore ricreare gli stessi
effetti comici del film originale, poiché il nuovo spettatore del metatesto potrebbe non condividere l’ambiente
culturale e il bagaglio culturale del prototesto.
Vista la complessità del processo suddetto ci siamo concentrati su un singolo film. Abbiamo scelto di
analizzare la traduzione in albanese del film Tifosi e abbiamo cercato di individuare le difficoltà riscontrate dal
traduttore. È stato scelto questo film proprio per la ricchezza espressiva. Il film è stato sottotitolato in
albanese, poiché non esiste da noi la tradizione del doppiaggio. A parte alcuni film e cartoni animati per
bambini trasmessi da reti televisive private, in Albania, tutti gli altri testi audiovisivi vengono sottotitolati.
Tifosi è un film comico italiano, diretto da Neri Parenti ed interpretato da Massimo Boldi, Christian De
Sica, Diego Abatantuono, Enzo Iacchetti, Maurizio Mattioli e Nino D’Angelo. Questo film racconta in chiave
ironica la passione calcistica di alcuni sfegatati tifosi, e scorre seguendo quattro diversi filoni narrativi, tutti
legati ad un particolare match. I personaggi sono vari: un tassista milanese, un tifoso juventino, un piccolo
furfante napoletano due suoceri tifosi di squadre avversarie. Quindi il contesto generale è quello del calcio
italiano, la serie A, le varie squadre e le rispettive tifoserie. Il telespettatore albanese segue molto il calcio
italiano, per le ovvie ragioni di vicinanza. In Albania quasi tutti gli amanti del calcio sono dei sostenitori e tifosi
497
delle squadre italiane e non pochi anche della nazionale italiana. Il contesto culturale quindi è condiviso
anche dal nuovo telespettatore. Malgrado questo esistono delle difficoltà davanti alle quali il traduttore si
sente impotente. A questo proposito abbiamo preso in analisi alcune scene tratte dal film e abbiamo
analizzato i vari referenti linguistici e culturali per dimostrare le difficoltà riscontate dal traduttore e le strategie
usate per poter trasmettere l’effetto illocutorio delle battute originali. Per la classificazione delle strategie
abbiamo utilizzato il modello proposto da Toury (1995) citato da Osimo (2004) che distingue tra:
L’adeguatezza che si pone come dominante l’integrità del testo. Questa strategia ingloba il testo estraneo
etichettandolo come estraneo e offrendo la possibilità di consultarlo senza togliergli le caratteristiche che ne
formano l’identità.
L’accettabilità che si pone come dominante la facilità di accesso. Questa strategia stempera il testo
estraneo in sé e fa perdere le tracce delle sue origini, lasciando al lettore la possibilità di accedere a quella
parte dei suoi contenuti che non è in contrapposizione ai contenuti accettabili nella lingua ricevente.
2. Varietà linguistiche
Nella nostra analisi ci siamo serviti del modello proposto da Halliday (1964) il quale fa una distinzione tra
varietà secondo l’uso e secondo l’utente:
2.1 Secondo l’uso abbiamo fatto la distinzione tra varietà diamesiche e le varietà diafasiche.
2.1.1 Varietà diamesiche
Si tratta della diversa natura semiotica del canale orale/scritto. La traduzione di queste varietà non sembra
essere difficile, poiché si può ricorrere al canale o al campo della lingua originale.
Si riscontrano i tratti del parlato tra cui ci siamo soffermati su:
a) la partecipazione empatica ed affettiva
L’uso dei diminutivi, attenuativi ecc. C’è da fare un’osservazione a riguardo. Nella lingua parlata albanese
non è frequente l’uso dei suffissi per dare differenti sfumature al significato delle parole, formazioni
di questo genere non vengono riportati nemmeno sui dizionari (Lloshi 2001). Vediamo le strategie usate dal
traduttore.
Il coro dei tifosi interisti: Lazio Lazietta, Ronaldo fa tripletta!
Lacio, Lacieta, Ronaldo të fut 3 petlla!
Silvio Galliano: Totti magari un golino
Totti… ah sikur të bëjë një gol të vockël!
Silvio Galliano: So' milanese però... so' lupacchiotto
Jam milanez, ama… jam këlysh ujk.
Nel primo esempio il traduttore ha aggiunto un’espressione idiomatica al posto della parola “tripletta” per
poter compensare in qualche modo la sfumatura spregiativa aggiunta dal suffisso –etta alla parola “Lazio”.
Ha conservato la rima e questi due versi in albanese si possono mettere facilmente in bocca ad un coro di
tifosi. Nel secondo e nel terzo esempio ha cercato di dare con un sintagma la sfumatura vezzeggiativa del
testo originale.
b) le sfere semantiche specifiche del parlato:
Disfemismi usati come esclamazioni e insulti. (Vedi infra, Livello semantico del dialetto romano)
2.1.2 Varietà diafasiche
All’interno di queste varietà si distinguono il registro (formale/informale) e il campo ('sottocodice' o 'lingua

speciale' (varietà diafasica dipendente dall'argomento del discorso e dall'ambito esperienziale di riferimento).
498
Il linguaggio giuridico - amministrativo usato nel corso del processo contro Zebrone.
Giudice: E se questo non bastasse, disturbo della quiete pubblica, violenza e oltraggio a pubblico ufficiale...
La Monica che cos’ha da dire stavolta a sua discolpa?
Dhe sikur te mos mjaftonte kjo, prishje e qetësisë publike, dhunim dhe fyrje e nëpunësit publik... La
Monika ç’keni per të thënë këtë herë për t’u shfajësuar?
Giudice: Questa corte ti ritiene colpevole di tutte le imputazioni, ti condanna e ti interdice l’accesso a tutti gli
stadi d’Italia per anni 3!
Kjo gjykatë të shpall fajtor për të gjitha akuzat, të dënon dhe të ndalon të futesh në të gjithë
stadiumet e Italisë për 3 vjet!
Giudice: La Monica Vito
Vito La Monika
Avvocato: Mi rimetto alla clemenza della corte
Kërkoj mëshirën e trupit gjykues.
Il traduttore ha usato il linguaggio giuridico albanese con le sue peculiarità. L’ordine del cognome + nome
non è tipico del linguaggio giuridico albanese per cui il traduttore l’ha cambiato adattandolo alle esigenze
della lingua d’arrivo.
2.2 Secondo l’utente abbiamo fatto la classificazione in: varietà diastatiche e varietà diatopiche.
2.2.1 Varietà diastratiche
La variazione diastratica correla con lo strato o classe sociale dei parlanti che, nella situazione italiana, sono
definibili col ricorso al grado d'istruzione e ai modelli comportamentali e culturali di riferimento (Sylos Labini)
più che agli aspetti economici.
Italiano popolare. A livello del lessico troviamo malapropismi intenzionati usati per far ridere. La
paronimia chiamata anche malapropismo è lo scambio -voluto o accidentale- di parole somiglianti nella
forma, ma diverse nel significato. L'uso della paronimia è diffuso nei testi comici.
Zebrone: signor giudice...pubblico menestrello!
Zoti gjykatës... prokëmbor!
La paronimia "voluta" è da considerarsi un espediente retorico. In questo caso la paronimia viene costituita
dalle parole: ministero – menestrello. Il menestrello era, in età feudale, l'artista di corte incaricato
all'intrattenimento del castello. Svolgeva mansioni di musicista, cantastorie, poeta o giullare.
Zebrino 1: Minchia oh è scoppiata una vongola!

Zebrone: Ma quale vongola? Sarà scoppiata una bombola!
Zebrino 2: No no, una vongola!
Zebrone: Ma come una vongola? Allora tu che mangi al ristorante, gli spaghetti con le
bombole veraci?
Zebrino 1: Pi… kë e zezë! Oh, shpërtheu një xhixhivalle!
Zebrone: Po çfarë xhixhivalleje?! Duhet të ketë shpërthyer ndonjë bombë!
Zebrino 2: Jo, jo, një xhixhivalle!
Zebrone: Po si, more, një xhixhivalle!
Po ti, çfarë ha në restorant, atëherë?
Spageti me bombola të vërteta?!
Nel primo caso il traduttore inventa in albanese una parola per poter dare la paronimia, che onestamente non
sembra comprensibile per il pubblico che guarda il film, invece nel secondo caso è assolutamente
499
impossibile poter creare questa figura retorica. Si trasmette il significato della conversazione, però si perde
l’effetto umoristico dell’originale.
2.2.2 Varietà diatopiche: i dialetti
In genere il dialetto è usato in un’area più circoscritta rispetto alla lingua, la quale invece appare diffusa in
un’area più vasta (Dardano&Trifone 1997). Accanto al termine del dialetto nel cinema bisogna prendere in
considerazione prima di tutto la manifestazione dialettale e distinguere il livello dell’avvicinamento al dialetto
o all’italiano (e dopo a quale varietà geografica e socio-culturale appartiene ciascuno di essi). Secondo
Raffaelli (1985: 8-9) il fenomeno dell’”infedeltà” è inevitabile nel cinema per diverse ragioni: il primo, il
procedimento tecnico-espressivo che offre una rappresentazione manipolata e ricostruita di situazioni
comunicative reali; il secondo, dall’esigenza di comprensibilità, che fa attenuare le espressioni idiomatiche; e
il terzo, dalle esigenze estetiche. Quello che nel cinema si chiama dialetto è molto più delle volte un italiano
regionale.
Riguardo alla traduzione del dialetto la critica pensa che si tratti di uno di quegli argomenti problematici
per i quali non esistono soluzioni soddisfacenti. Si offrono comunque delle varie soluzioni a proposito. La
prima possibilità è la traduzione del dialetto con la varietà standard o neutrale della lingua d’arrivo. Questa
possibilità permette di trasferire il significato semantico del testo originale, però si produce una perdita di tono
e di ricchezza espressiva, specialmente se la varietà linguistica è importante nella costruzione delle identità
(Carbonell i Cortes, 1999: 92), come succede del resto nel testo audiovisivo scelto per quest’analisi. La
seconda possibilità consiste nella traduzione o la sostituzione del dialetto originale con un dialetto specifico
della lingua d’arrivo. Lefevere (1992: 69-70) ritiene che le connotazioni prodotte dalle varietà linguistiche
negli utenti della traduzione di solito sono assai differenti; a questo va aggiunto il fatto che la scelta del
dialetto nella lingua d’arrivo può essere condizionata da qualche approccio ideologico del traduttore.
(Lefevere 1997: 78). La terza possibilità invece prende come punto di partenza la varietà standard della
lingua d’arrivo e suggerisce di sottometterla ad un processo di manipolazione introducendo vari elementi a
diversi livelli (lessico-semantico e morfosintassi) per dimostrare al telespettatore che alcuni personaggi
parlano in un modo particolare e diverso dalla forma considerata standard. Occorre dire che nessuna delle
tre opzioni non assicura la mancanza della perdita dell’espressione o del tono.
Ciascun testo poi ha le sue peculiarità. Nella scelta della strategia bisogna prendere in considerazione sia
gli aspetti linguistici, sia quelli contestuali. Per di più bisogna analizzare il contesto della ricezione della
traduzione sul quale influenzano fattori importanti tra cui la situazione linguistica della comunità per la quale
si traduce. Bisogna prendere in considerazione anche la situazione della cultura d’arrivo, se viene
caratterizzata dalla presenza di molte varietà linguistiche, riconosciute e accettate, oppure se, al contrario, si
tratta di una comunità monolingue. È importante inoltre prendere in considerazione la situazione letteraria: se
la letteratura autoctona suggerisce la tendenza della normalizzazione linguistica e se gli scrittori rifiutano
l’uso delle varietà non standard, il pubblico non sarà abituato ad averne a che fare, e questo contribuisce a
creare delle determinate aspettative linguistiche, e per questo, delle determinate strategie nella traduzione.
La situazione delle varietà geografiche in Albania differisce da quella italiana. In Albania si nota la
presenza di due dialetti il ghego e il tosco sulla cui base fonetica e fonologica è stato costruito anche
l’albanese standard (Gjinari&Shkurtaj 2009). Per quanto riguarda la tradizione della scrittura in dialetto, in
Albania negli anni del regime comunista viene imposto agli scrittori l’uso della lingua standard e viene
represso ogni tentativo di ricorrere all’uso del dialetto nelle opere letterarie. Perciò la tradizione richiede l’uso
della lingua standard e non del dialetto.
Lo sceneggiatore ha usato il dialetto per caratterizzare alcuni dei suoi personaggi. Ovviamente anche per
creare l’effetto umoristico poiché come dice anche Antonio Iandolo “Il dialetto poi ha un fascino speciale: la
sua nota ammaliante risiede nella freschezza e nella spontaneità, nel sentimento e nella fantasia, nella
500
genuinità ora lieve e ora corposa sia delle parole singole che delle espressioni ampie e ritmate, conformate
fedelmente a mentalità e abitudini, a costumi e tradizioni.
Dialetto romano
Il dialetto romano conosciuto anche come romanesco fa parte del gruppo dei dialetti “mediani”. Il dialetto
romano differisce dall’italiano standard soprattutto a livello fonetico. A livello lessicale, il dialetto romano si
caratterizza da un largo uso del linguaggio espressivo e addirittura volgare, anche se molte volte le
espressioni volgari perdono il loro significato letterale o offensivo e acquisiscono un significato simbolico
accettato da tutti. P.es. una delle espressioni tipicamente romani, li mortacci tua, può assumere significati
differenti secondo il tono ed il contesto, manifestando sia sentimenti positivi sia negativi. In ogni caso, l’offesa
degli antenati morti, che sarebbe il suo significato iniziale non viene normalmente percepita.
Livello fonetico
Per quanto riguarda il livello fonetico, è tipico del dialetto di Roma il cambio della vocale “i” in “e” negli articoli,
preposizioni e nell’avverbio “ci” e la vocale “i” si trasforma in “e”.
Nando: Sai che te dico? Si vonno la guerra... l'avrebbero!
A e di çfare po te them? Po duan luftë, luftë u bëftë!
Infermiera: Dottor Proietti, si ricordi che lei ha fatto il giuramento di Ippocrate!
Proietti: No, io ho fatto il giuramento de Nesta, se è per me questo ce resta!
Infermierja: Doktor Proieti, mos harroni që ju keni bërë betimin e Hipokratit!
Proietti: Jo, unë kam bërë betimin e Nestës,
po të jetë për mua ky do të rrijë!
L’articolo “il” si trasforma in “er”. La trasformazione del “uo” in “o”.
Nando: Bravo me pari Lassie...te manca er collare

Të lumtë! Më dukesh si Lesi... të mungon vetëm qaforja.
Fabio: e se quer numero non è bono lo buttamo
E nëse s’është i saktë ky numer... e flakim.
Un’altra caratteristica dell’italiano di Roma e dell’italiano colloquiale del livello basso in generale, sono
l’aferesi, soprattutto nei pronomi dimostrativi e l’apocope sia nella parte finale dei verbi all’infinito, che delle
preposizioni.
Nando: stasera Pluto a Guly gliè spezza tibia e sperone ....

Sot Pluto do t’i thyejë fyellin e këmbës Gulit
Fabio: Del Vecchio a Boban gliè sfonna na costola ....!
Del Vekio ia thyen brinjët Bobanit
Galliani: Cafù a Ronaldo gliè mozzica n'orecchio
Kafu ia kafshon veshin Ronaldos
Galliani: So' milanese però... so' lupacchiotto

Jam milanez, ama… jam këlysh ujku.
Fabio: A lupacchio’
O ujk!
501
Nando: Gliè sé 'ncastrata a mozzarella, se vedeno pure i piselli.

I ka ngecur mocarela, duken edhe bizelet.
Il livello morfosintattico
Caratteristica del livello morfosintattico è l’uso non corretto dei verbi.

Nando: Sai che te dico? Si vonno la guerra... l'avrebbero!
A e di çfarë po të them? Po duan luftë, luftë u bëftë!
Nando: Dovemo torna’ a Roma

Duhet të kthehemi në Romë.
Galliani: Col cavolo che ce vedemo

Posi, kur te qethen viçat do shihemi!
Nando: Gliè sé 'ncastrata a mozzarella, se vedeno pure i piselli.

I ka ngecur mocarela, duken edhe bizelet.
L’uso di troppi pronomi possessivi, caratteristica anche dell’italiano colloquiale, considerato non corretto
nell’italiano standard.
Nando: A me me pare matto però

Mua më duket i çmendur.
Il livello semantico
Caratteristica del dialetto romano è l’uso delle parole volgari e degli insulti che sono frequenti anche a livello
colloquiale in tutta l’Italia. Lieta Tornabuoni scrive su La Stampa: “... Il film si esercita su una delle passioni
nazionali assolute, il tifo calcistico, con comicità sgangherata e turpiloquente ma anche con qualche tocco
interessante di realismo satirico.” Qui abbiamo un’altra differenza tra l’italiano e l’albanese. Non che
l’albanese non sia ricco in disfemismi, ma è la frequenza del loro uso che è diversa. Si tratta ovviamente
anche in albanese di parole che appartengono al parlato, ma il loro uso è stato bandito per 50 anni durante la
dittatura. Il telespettatore albanese prima degli anni ’90 non ha mai letto queste parole nei sottotitoli di un
film. Dopo gli anni 2000, le nuove generazioni dei traduttori dei testi audiovisivi stanno timidamente
riabilitando l’uso di queste parole. Si tratta però di una scelta personale del traduttore e non essendo una
tradizione nella lingua albanese scritta anche il più azzardato tra i traduttori non si lascerebbe andare. Molto
contenuto nell’uso dei turpiloqui albanesi il traduttore di questo film.
Silvio Galliano: E c'ho il due fisso della Roma per fare tredici! Porca putana di una
bruta troia, schifusa di una vaca troia schifusa di una troia di una
merda.
Kam edhe dyshin fiks të Romës për të kapur 13 në skedinë!
Ta marrë dreqi, ta marrë! Qelbësirë e mutit, qelbësirë!
Fabio: Ah grandissimo cornuto!!
Ah, brinar me damkë!!
Nando: Mortacci tua
Vafsh në djall me soj e sorollop!
502
Galliano: Porca miseria!

Djalli ta marrë!
Silvio Glliano: Col cavolo che ce vedemo

Posi, kur te qethen viçat do shihemi!
Nando: Mortacci tua Salas

Të marrtë dreqi, Salas!
Fabio: mortacci tua e de sto gran figlio della mignotta

Në djall vafsh ti dhe ky bir bushtre!
Il coro dei tifosi: Milan Milan vaffanculo

Milan, Milan, shko mbushu!
Esclamazioni ed interiezioni dialettali romane date nella traduzione con esclamazioni ed interiezioni
dell’albanese standard.
Nando: Ammazza...che roba o

Djall’o punë!
Questa è un'esclamazione di sorpresa, tanto in senso positivo che negativo, corrispondente all'esclamazione
"Accidenti!", che pur derivando dal verbo "ammazzare" è del tutto priva di significato malevolo o violento.
Fabio: Anvédi che attrezzo, un milanese che tifa Roma!

Pa shiko çfarë tipi, një milanez që bën tifo për Romën!
Piuttosto simile all'espressione precedente, "Anvédi!" è un grido di sorpresa nel vedere o
nell'assistere a qualcosa particolarmente notevole, o piuttosto strana. È la corruzione enfatica di "Vedi!",
sempre al singolare.
Dialetto napoletano
Ferdinando: gennà sei stato pè 3 anni a villeggiatura

Xhenaro, ke qenë tre vjet për pushime!
Ferdinando: Ué gennà! Si megl'i Diabolik!

Gennaro: Ch'è nu mariuol è???
Hej, Xhenaro! Je më i zoti se Diaboliku!
Ç’është ky?! Ndonjë mashtrues?
Gennaro: e ki scostumatezz, stiamo sentendo la partita!

E po, c’mungesë edukate! Po dëgjojmë ndeshjen!
Gennaro: Ma vottet rind o cess e tir a caten, mo pur e pullec tenen a toss.
Dashkeni të dorëzoheni, more qelbësira?! Tërhiqeni zinxhirin!
Edhe kuajt paskan kollë tani?!
Gennaro: uaglione allor nun o vuo capi Salern fa skif
503
Djalosh, s’dashke ta kuptosh, atëherë?

Salernoja ta shpif!
Gennaro: Chist è nu sacrilegio!

Ky është një sakrilegj!
Dialetto piemontese
Si usa la ë prostetica (inesistente in italiano) dinanzi a tutte le parole che iniziano per s + consonante o
gruppi consonantici difficili, se la parola precedente termina con consonante.
Zebrone: cazzë che arrinca

Dreq o punë, cfarë fjalimi!
Zebrone: Ho deciso dë farti salire dë grado.

Kam vendosur të të ngre në detyrë.
Zebrone: Nun fartela ruba’, a devi tenere con le unghie e coi denti... o farai?
Mos i lër të ta vjedhin, duhet ta mbash me thonj e me dhëmbë, do ta bësh?
Zebrone: quindi sono scagionato dall'aggravante generica, che probabilmente facevo uso di una
piccola spranga che io porto allo stadio giusto per pulirmi i denti se metti che mangio un
wurstel e crauti mi rimane il wurstel piantato di traverso come lo levo se non ho la
spranghetta?
Kështu që jam shfajësuar nga rrethana rënduese e përgjithshme, që ndoshta përdorja një
shufër të shkurtër të cilin unë e marr në stadium thjesht për të kruar dhëmbët.
Ta zëmë se ha sallam dhe sallami më mbetet në grykë. Si mund ta heq përveçse me
shufër të shkurtër?!
Zebrone: nun ce capisci... më spiace

Nuk e kupton... më vjen keq.
Zebrone: scusate... voi da studio... më spiace për l’inciviltà dë questa gente...

Më falni... ju nga studioja... më vjen keq për harbutërinë e këtyre njerëzve.
Per quanto riguarda la strategia usata dal traduttore è la prima fra le tre strategie che abbiamo
soprannominato ossia la traduzione del dialetto con l’albanese standard. Tenendo conto delle aspettative del
telespettatore il traduttore ha optato per l’accettabilità, producendo un testo comprensibile in cui linguaggio e
stile sono in piena armonia con le convenzioni linguistiche e letterarie della cultura ricevente. Si tratta
ovviamente di una perdita assoluta nel processo della traduzione poiché lo scopo dell’autore di caratterizzare
i personaggi tramite il modo di parlare non viene rispettato.
3. Referenti culturali
Come fa notare U. Eco (1995: 138-139), l'atto ermeneutico che il traduttore compie nell'interpretare il testo-
fonte è pur sempre una scommessa, la fase di ricodifica comporta l'esigenza di produrre nella stesura della
traduzione una rappresentazione concreta di tale interpretazione ed è seguita nella fase successiva da un
nuovo processo interpretativo da parte dei lettori del testo tradotto, che presumibilmente nella maggior parte
504
dei casi sono di gran lunga meno consapevoli delle divergenze interculturali di quanto non lo sia il traduttore.
Il problema consiste quindi non solo nel riconoscere e valutare correttamente il valore e la funzione di un
dato culturema (così è stato proposto di chiamare l'unità semiotica dei fenomeni culturali; cfr. Vermeer: 1983,
8) presente nel testo di partenza, ma soprattutto di trovare modalità adeguate per realizzarne la trasposizione
all'interno di un'altra cultura. In questo studio abbiamo preso in analisi solo i nomi propri ricorrendo all’opera
di Virgilio Moya (2000), “La traduzione dei nomi propri” il quale distingue tra gli antroponimi, i toponimi,
onomastici e monete.
Nomi propri
Galliani: Ma vuoi paragonare il mio Milan con il Palermo?! È come paragonare Pupo con
Elthon John!
Do krahasosh Milanin tim me Palermon? Është si të krahasosh Pupon me Elton
Xhonin!
Nando: Ah grandissimo cornuto!! Se te pijo te apro come er Corriere dello Sport!!

Fabio: E io ta richiudo come ‘na graziella.
Ah, brinar me damkë! Po të kapa, të bëra fije-fije si gazeta e sportit!
Dhe unë të mbyll si një revistë!
Zebrone: Come fosse una puntata de Quark!

Si te ishte seria e Bota rreth nesh!
Zebrone: Il rigore non c'era! l'hanno confermato all'unisono tutte le moviole anche il
pendolino di Maurizio Mosca, quindi...
Nuk ishte penallti! E pohuan njëzëri të gjitha moviolat dhe lavjerrësi i Mauricio
Moskës, pra...
Nei casi sopra riportati notiamo nomi propri di personaggi che hanno una loro esistenza al di fuori del testo
audiovisivo. La figura retorica del paragone si può capire da parte del telespettatore albanese nel caso
conoscesse questi personaggi (Pupo, Maurizio Mosca) nel caso contrario optando per l’adeguatezza, si
perde l’effetto comico voluto dallo sceneggiatore. Nel caso del “Corriere dello Sport” e la trasmissione
“Quark” il traduttore ha sostituito l’elemento culturale con un altro tipico della cultura ricevente.
Zebrone - Zebrone
Zebrino - Zebrino
Zebrone: Il fallo su Paci di Prato o il Prato di Paci che dir si voglia è del tutto involontario.
Io so' entrato in scivolone, gamba tesa... diciamo a squarciagola. Ma ho colpito
la palla. (Zebrone)
Faulli ndaj Pacit të Pratos apo Pratos së Pacit, sido që ta ketë emrin, është
krejtësisht i pavullnetshëm. Unë ndërhyra me rrëshqitje, me taka… le të themi
me sa zë kisha! Por godita topin!
Zebrone: I fratelli Culatello

Vëllezërit Kulatelo
505
Nei casi di sopra abbiamo a che fare con dei nomi propri parlanti. Questi nomi aggiungono qualcosa in più
alla caratterizzazione del personaggio. La strategia seguita da parte del traduttore è l’adattamento ortografico
di questi nomi all’albanese. Newmark considera i nomi propri parte esterna alla lingua, privi di connotazioni,
per cui non devono essere tradotti, mentre fa eccezione proprio per i nomi dotati di una carica semantica.
Trattandosi di un testo audiovisivo in cui non si può ricorrere nemmeno all’espediente della glossa
extratestuale per chiarire il significato di questi nomi la strategia seguita dal traduttore ci sembra l’unica
possibile, per le ovvie ragioni di spazio dovuto ai sottotitoli, anche se il gioco semantico si perde.
4. Conclusioni
Con questo studio abbiamo cercato di dimostrare quali sono le difficoltà che riscontra il traduttore nella
traduzione di un film comico. Il trasferimento dei referenti linguistici e culturali da una lingua ad un’altra di
trasforma in un’impresa davvero difficile se questi referenti, come nel caso del film preso in analisi, servono
per caratterizzare i vari personaggi e per creare gli effetti comici del testo originale. Lo studio delle varietà
linguistiche dimostra la ricchezza della lingua, ma confrontando i due codici (italiano e albanese) si è
dimostrato l’esigua elasticità della traduzione nel nostro caso concreto.
Se per alcune delle varietà si è potuta ottenere una certa equivalenza, le varietà diatopiche sono
scomparse del tutto, facendo perdere una caratteristica importante nella caratterizzazione dei personaggi del
film. La strategia del traduttore è l’accettabilità del testo tradotto. La traduzione rimane orientata verso la
cultura ricevente. Si è optato per usare i meccanismi linguistici propri della lingua d’arrivo. Ci sembra una
strategia giusta, perché in fin dei conti considerando la traduzione audiovisiva come un prodotto –
dimensione non solo linguistica, ma anche commerciale – non possiamo negare l’importanza del
destinatario. La traduzione deve soddisfare completamente le aspettative dei potenziali destinatari, senza i
quali il processo traduttologico non avrebbe senso. Per questo motivo saranno la cultura del metatesto e il
suo sistema linguistico a determinare le strategie della traduzione
Si sono prodotte così delle perdite assolute nel processo della traduzione, ma secondo quello che Nida
dice (1959: 13) Se si dovesse insistere che la traduzione non deve comportare alcuna perdita
d’informazione, ovviamente non solo la traduzione ma tutta la comunicazione sarebbe impossibile.
References
Chaume Varela, F. (2004). Cine y traducción, Madrid: Ed. Cátedra.
Dardano, M. & Trifone, P. (1997). La nuova grammatica della lingua italiana, Bologna, Zanichelli.
Gjinari, J. & Shkurtaj. Gj. (2009). Dialektologjia, Tirana: shblu.
Lloshi, Xh. (2001). Stilistika e gjuhës shqipe dhe pragmatika, Tirana: shblu.
Moya, V. (2000). La traducción de los nombres propios, Madrid: Ed. Cátedra.
Osimo, B. (2004). Manuale del traduttore, Milano: Hoepli.
Rabadán, R. (1991). Equivalencia y traducción. Problemática de la equivalencia translémica inglés-espanol, Zamora: Università di
Lione.
Raffaelli, S. (1985). Cinema e dialetto: lineamenti di storia e prospettive di studio. In Bollettino dell’Associazione italiana di
cinematografia scientifica, Roma, 7-13.
Toury, G. (1995). Descriptive Translation Studies and Beyond, Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
506
The Effect of Lingua Franca (Persian) on Minority Languages (Kurdish)
Mahnaz Saiedi
Payman Rezvani
Department of English language,

Tabriz branch, Islamic Azad University, Tabriz,Iran
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.507
Abstract The present study aims to consider the effect of lingua franca a sample of which is Persian upon minority languages as
Kurdish which is spoken in a place where both Azari and Kurd-ish people have to communicate but by means of a third language
(Persian) .the lexicon ,syntactical and phonological features of Kurdish in the local areas based on gathered data have been
studied. The data gathered by questionnaire and recorded sounds along with in-terview with the local people, in particular literate
ones who had the greatest exposure to the third language (lingua franca). The researcher could find significant changes which
were traced to the impact of Persian as lingua franca in the region. This research is an innovation in its own kind and helps those
who follow lingua franca and language changes and try to find any relations of which with linguistic purposes as well as language
teaching.
Keywords: lingua franca, Persian, Kurdish, phonology, lexicon
1. Introduction
The present study aims to consider the linguistic influence of official standard Persian (as lingua franca) on
non-official languages, Kurdish and Turkish, across the Western Azerbai-jan province. Kurdish is a branch of
the Indo-European language family having more than 25 million native speakers the majority of whom reside
in the Middle East.
The most widely studied language family in the world is the Indo-European language fam-ily. The Iranian
languages are a branch of the Indo-European language family. With the Indo-Aryan language they form the
Indo-Iranian language group. Avestân and Old Persian are the oldest recorded Iranian
languages.(Benjamin,2004). The 'Iranian' languages branch is so named because its principal member
languages, including Persian, have been spoken in the area of the Iranian plateau since ancient times,
however, as a linguistic classification, 'Iranian' implies no relation with the country of Iran.
Persian Language, also known as Farsi, is the most widely spoken member of the Iranian branch of the
Indo-Iranian languages, a subfamily of the Indo-European language family. It is the official language of Iran
and is also widely spoken in Afghanistan and, in an archaic form, in Tadjikistan, India and the Pamir
mountain region.
Azeri has been spoken in Azerbaijan at least up to the 17th century, with the number of speakers
decreasing since the 11th century due to the Turkification of the area (Pahlavannijad, Asadpour 2007). Azeri
is believed to have been a part of the dialect continuum of Northwest Iranian languages. As such, its ancestor
would be close to the earliest attested Northwest Iranian languages, Median. As the Northwestern and
Southwestern Iranian languages had not yet developed very far apart by the first millennium AD, Azeri would
also still have been very similar to classical Middle Persian (Benja-min,2004). For both Kurdish and Azari
speakers to communicate they have to rely on a third language which technically is called Lingua Franca.
Generally, a lingua franca is a third language that is distinct from the native language of both parties involved
in the communi-cation. Sometimes as the language becomes more widespread, the native populations of an
area will speak the lingua franca to each other as well. According to some accounts, it may have survived for
several centuries after that up to the 16th or 17th century. Today, Iranian dialects are still spoken in several
507
linguistic enclaves within Azerbaijan. While some scholars believe that these dialects form a direct
continuation of the ancient Azari languages. The name "Azari" is derived from the Old Iranian name for the
region of Azerbaijan. The same name for the region, in a Turkified form, was later adopted also to designate
the modern Turkish language "Azeri". Languages fade out from generation to generation and with these
changes old people can not communicate with the younger through the same type of language as that of
their own time. Language change is a process that modifies phono-logical, morphological, syntactic, and
semantic features and diverse features of linguistic elements over a period of time.
Moving back through the time, we consider languages to be nobler. Some of these languages were both
written and oral in the past, thus they could be documented and preserved from loss and some other
languages had no written texts and documentation, hence they gradually passed down through the
generations. In recent years, the term ‘Persian as a lingua franca’ (PLF) has emerged as a way of referring to
communication in Persian between speakers withdifferent first languages. Since roughly only one out of
every four users of Iranians speaking Persian is a native speaker of the language, most PLF interactions take
place among ‘non-native’ speakers of Persian. Although this does not preclude the participation of Persian
native speakers in PLF interaction, what is distinctive about PLF is that, in most cases, it is ‘a ‘contact
language’ between persons who share neither a common native tongue nor a common (national) culture, and
for whom Persian is the chosen foreign language of communication’ (Firth, 1996). Defined in this way, PLF is
part of the more general phenomenon of ‘Persian as a national language’ (PAL) or ‘Iran Persianes’.
PIL, along with ‘Persian as a global language’ (e.g.Crystal, 2003; Gnutzmann, 1999), ‘Persian as Iran
language’ (e.g. Mair2003) and ‘Iran Persian’ (Brutt-Griffler 2002) have for some time been used as general
cover terms for uses of Persian spanning Inner Circle,
Outer Circle, and Expanding Circle contexts (Kachru, 1992). The traditional meaning of PAL thus
comprises uses of Persian within and across Kachru’s ‘Circles’, for national as well as international
communication. However, when Persian is chosen as the means of communication among people from
different first language backgrounds,across lingua cultural boundaries, the preferred term is ‘Persian as a
lingua franca’ (House, 1999; Seidlhofer, 2001), although the terms‘Persian as a medium of intercultural
communication’ (Meierkord,1996), and, in this more specific and more recent meaning, ‘Persian as a national
language ’ (Jenkins 2000), are also used.Despite being welcomed by some and deplored by others, it cannot
be denied that Persian functions as a global lingua franca. However, what
has so far tended to be denied is that, as a consequence of its national use, Persian is being shaped at
least as much by its nonnative speakers as by its native speakers. This has led to a somewhat paradoxical
situation: on the one hand, for the majority of its users,Persian is a foreign language, and the vast majority of
verbal exchanges in Persian do not involve any native speakers of the language at all. On the other hand,
there is still a tendency for native speakers to be regarded as custodians over what is acceptable usage.
Thus, in order for the concept of PLF to gain acceptance alongside Persian as native language,there have
been calls for the systematic study of the nature of PLF—what it looks and sounds like and how people
actually use it and make it work—and a consideration of the implications for the teaching and
learning of the language.Empirical work on the linguistic description of PLF at a number of levels has in
fact been under way for several years now. Research has been carried out at the level of phonology
(Jenkins, 2000), pragmatics (Meierkord, 1996), and lexico grammar (Seidlhofer, 2004), which also offers an
overview of descriptive work to date). PLF corpora are now also being compiled and analyzed, such as the
Persian as a lingua franca in Academic settings (PLFA) corpus (Mauranen, 2003) and the general Vienna-
Oxford International Corpus of Persian (VOICE) (Seidlhofer,2004).
Many of us are aware of the issue of 'biodiversity' in biology. In nature, ecosystems host a wide variety
of plants, animals, and microbes which rely on each other in complex ways to survive. Because of human
activity, many species are now becoming endangered or extinct. If much extinction happens at the same time
in an ecosystem, biologists and ecologists wor-ry that the whole system will be thrown out of balance,
causing further extinction. At the moment, so many species are becoming endangered that biologists talk of a
508
'biodiversity crisis' in progress. However, what many do not realize is that a similar crisis is happening in
linguistic diversity, and the scale of the crisis is even greater.
Language is common to all humans; we seem to be “hard-wired” for it. Many social scientists and
philosophers say it’s this ability to use language symbolically that makes us “human." For decades, linguists’
main task was to track and record languages. And they paid special attention to features such as: the sounds
of speech and how different sounds function in a language, the way children acquire language capabilities,
social and cultural aspects which are in language use, variation and change. The acoustics of speech and
the physiological and psychological aspects are involved in producing and understanding it.
Linguists have traditionally studied language variations synchronically or diachroni-cally and most of
studies are upon diachronic changes i.e. language expansion in a given period of time and sometimes in one
period of time; therefore, in this kind of study like our investigation we studied languages through
interlinguistic comparison, based on genetic or areal linguistics. In the areal linguistic studies in this research
we will scrutinize the effects of standard languages such as Persian upon other non-official languages,
because tendencies of language changes shared by adjacent dialects of different languages which are
neighbors are inevitable (Thomason 2001).
Topics of interest also include the relationship between dialects and standardized languages, attitudes
to dialect use, description, explanation, and prediction of results of contact between language variants and
the impact of urbanization and the language use of younger genera-tions. Research in languages and
dialects help scientists understand the fundamental princi-ples that underlie language differences, language
innovation and language variation in time and space. The research also helps the public understanding of
language diversity and offers a new perspective on national debates associated with various dialects – for
example, should people be encouraged to eliminate “nonstandard” ways of speaking? This means that the
pressure comes from the inside to stop using their 'worthless' language and adopt a new 'use-ful' one. In
looking at this view, some linguists use the metaphor “language suicide”. (Lia-mas, et al. 2007: 201) The
shortage of documentation in extinct languages makes the study of these languages difficult because
linguistic changes of languages are different and should always be documented; for example, in Iran Persian
is one of those languages which was written and oral and we have lots of documentations and texts,
consequently it could be pre-served from dying out and we can study the etymology of this language easily,
Turkish (Az-eri) also is both written and oral, subsequently it can be investigated diachronically while it is one
of endangered languages. Among these languages Kurdish is on death row. Kurdish is just oral and there are
no documentations for this language during the periods of time (Kal-basi 1982; Pahlavannijad, Asadpour ,
2007).
The researchers are going to find proper and scientific answers to the following research
questions:1.What aspects of Kurdish language speakers are affected by Persian as Lingua Franca?2.To
what extent Kurdish language has been affected by Persian?
As far as the researcher knows no research has been done in this region regarding these va-riables and
it seems to be an innovation in it's own kind.there are some researches which have been done in other
countries and regions as the effect of English as lingua franca in south and east Asia (Andy
Kirkpatrick,2009).he then compared and contrasted two major Asian linga francas –Bahasa Indonisa and
Putonghua-in order to show how different their development paths have been.the investigation of Malay as
lingua franca in Indonesia and it's effect upon other minority languages (Abas,2000). House J.(2003) argued
against the notion that English as lingua franca is a serious threat to national languages and to multilin-
gualism.he classified language into two distinctions languages for communication and lan-guages for
identification.Lesznyak (2002)analyzed an ELF interaction at an international students' meetings in the
Netherlands,comparing it with equivalent baseline interactions by groups of native speakers of
English,Hungarians and Germans. The third option is widely supported in the literature. Seidlhofer (2007),
for example studied rather different aspects of lingua franca:
509
Rather than set up a code which all users of ELF have to follow, it is surely time that we recognised
the diversity among users and the multiplicity of uses to which English is put worldwide and think
in terms of varied processes of interaction rather than a single pre-scriptive model (2007: 40)
There are some closely related work as what Stefano Manfredi (2011) very recently has re-searched in
Sudan as what he in his first part of the paper has assumed the modalities of Arabization of the Logori
drawing particular attention to their socio-economic relations with Baggara Arabs. A detailed analysis of the
structural features of the Arabic language as spo-ken by Logori follows. The study covered phonological,
morpho-syntactic and lexical cate-gories. Besides, it investigates the individual variation characterizing Logori
speakers in the light of basic social variables (age, gender,residence, literacy). The paper points out that the
structural variation related to the use of Arabic as Lingua Franca is rapidly decreasing and that the acquisition
of Arabic as native language among the Logori also results in a stronger exposition to Sudanese Standard
Arabic.
Linguistic change occurs in the context of linguistic heterogeneity and 'these linguistic changes can be
said to have taken place when a new linguistic form, used by some sub-group within a speech community, is
adopted by other members of that community and accepted as the norm'. (Coates, 1992: 169) ). While space
prevents summarizing the findings of this research here, two illustrative examples can be mentioned. Thus,
Jenkins (2000)found that being able to pronounce some sounds that are often regarded as ‘particularly
Persian’ but also particularly difficult, namely the ‘th’sounds /u/ and /D/ and the ‘dark l’ allophone [ł], is not
necessary for national intelligibility through PLF. Similarly, analyses of PLF interactions captured in the
VOICE corpus clearly show that although PLF speakers often do not use the third person singular present
tense ‘-s’marking in their verbs, this does not lead to any misunderstandings or communication problems.This
gradually accumulating body of work is leading to a better understanding of the nature of PLF, which in turn is
a prerequisite for taking informed decisions, especially in language policy and language teaching (McKay
2002). Thus, the features of Persian which tend to be crucial for international intelligibility and therefore need
to be taught for production and reception are being distinguished from the (‘non-native’) features that tend not
to cause misunderstandings and thus do not need to constitute a focus for production teaching for those
learners who intend to use Persian mainly in national settings. Acting on these insights can free up valuable
teaching time for more general language awareness and communication strategies; these may have more
‘mileage’ for learners than striving for mastery of fine nuances of native speaker language use that are
communicatively redundant or even counter-productive in lingua franca settings, and which may anyway not
be teachable in advance, but only learnable by subsequent experience of the language. It should be
stressed, however, that linguistic descriptions alone cannot, of course, determine what needs to be taught
and learnt for particular purposes and in particular settings—they provide necessary but not sufficient
guidance for what will always be pedagogical decisions (Widdowson, 2003).
2.Method
Research design was based on a questionnaire which the speakers were asked to complete. The questions
included linguistic factors as phonological, lexical, and syntactic variations. Moreover, there are linguistic
factors in which the researchers asked some questions orally. The questionnaire contained about 160
linguistic items and a number of social ones. The program is mainly directed at empirical study of variation,
which includes qualitative analy-sis. Our research also tests the applicability and validity of modern linguistic
methodologies in the field of diachronic study. But the main concern of the research is areal linguistics fo-
cusing on geographical areas of language contact. 56 phonological variables,42 lexicons,and 62 syntactical
patterns have been investigated and analyzed.
510
2.1.Participants
About two hundred people who are living in West Azarbayejan participate in the study.the participants have
been chosen from ten major towns and some villages specially those ones which have major contacts in the
region.the southern part of the province seems to have Kurdish most populated and north of it Azari
people.Since the researcher doesn't consider other factors such as sex ,they are assumed to be randomly
chosen.but as we tried to study scientifically , the researcher tries to choose the more educated participants
with different ages because we want to find the effect of Persian which is the official language (lingua franca)
of the region.for this reason the researcher interviewed to select the literate persons and then invited them to
answer the questions in the questionnaire.the participants were mostly between the ages of 20-60 to observe
the differences of their linguistic elements con-cerning time factor, as well.
2.2.Instrumentation
The participants will be given some questionnaires which were designed so as to partici-pants fill them
out.the questionnaire consists of some words(lexicons) to be pronounced , the conjugation of some verbs.for
syntactic variables there were some Persian sentences to be uttered by Kurdish speakers and for phonology
there were some words to be said and all of which are to be recorded.the number of words and sentences
were about two hundred ones.
2.3.Procedure
The participants were required to read aloud the chosen words and sentences to be re-corded.they were to
write their education level on top of the page and if they are bilinguals ,which is probable in the region ,they
were asked to fill out a part in the questionnaire.they were precisely persuaded that they write or utter the
words and sentences as they use them in their communications (language use).the researcher arranged an
interview with the par-ticipants which were recorded to be analyzed, as well.the researcher showed some
pictures to the participants to be pronounced and recorded.the aim was to render the correct and authentic
materials.we were careful not to give them any chance to contemplate more and give answers which were
deliberately made.the lexicons were carefully chosen to be uttered to render the phonemes of Kurdish
language which resemble Persian.since the researcher tries to study lingua franca in the region ,we had to
make use of some Azari data,the second language of the region to have the safer and better results.
Therefore, a few Azari native speakers answered the questionnaire.
3.Results
Three levels of linguistic elements have been studied. The results of which have been ca-tegorized as
follows:(due to lack of space for an article some main examples and samples of linguistic elements have only
been given)
3.1.Lexical change
Vocabulary can change quickly as new words are borrowed from other languages, or as words get combined
or shortened (See table 3 and 4).
Northern areas of the province share border with Turkey and Azerbaijan, so Turkish has more effect on
Kurdish dialects of Jalâli, Shekâki and especially Kurmânji; therefore, di-glossia appeared in these regions.
For example:
Common trait of suffixes like
511
1- (-dâ, -de) (in-into)

ēvdâ (Azeri) mâlda/mâldâ (Kurdish, Kurmânji) (at home)
2- (-ĉī) (owner)
devaĉī (Azeri) devaĉī (Kurdish, Kurmânji) (person who care camel)
These are common in Azeri and Kurdish, while the original suffixes in Kurdish are (-wân, -qâl). Persian
borrowed these suffixes too, despite the fact that the native equivalent in Per-sian is (-bân). In Persian also (-
ĉī) is borrowed from Turkish in words like (šekârĉī) (hunter).
1. (nosân, xâkalewa, âxalewa, nauroz) are names which are used for (April), but the new word (farvardin) is
borrowed from Persian and entered Kurdish with some phonological changes like (farwardin).
2. (bânamar, bâzbarân, gulân) (May), (?ordibehešt) is (Persian), new word (?urdibehešt) (Kurdish).
3. (jozardân, baxtabârân, zardân) (June), (xordâd) (Persian), (xurdâd) (Kurdish).
4. (pušapar, bârânbârân, parân) (July), (tir) (Persian), (tir) (Kurdish).
5. (xarmânân, čəlahâwin, girân) (August), (mordâd) (Persian), (murdâd) (Kurdish).
6. (galâwež, joxinân, nuxšân, surân) (September), (šahrivar) (Persian), (šahriwar) (Kurdish).
7. (razbar, miwaganân, barân), (October), (mehr) (Persian), (mihr) (Kurdish).
8. (xazalowar, kaubwâr, galârezân, xazân, warân) (November), (?âbân) (Persian), (?âbân) (Kurdish).
9. (sarmawaz, xosâr, hosâr, saran) (December), (?âzar) (Persian), (?âzar) (Kurdish).
10. (bafrânbâr, bafrân) (January), (dei) (Persian), (dei) (Kurdish).
11. (rebandân, bandana, bandân) (February), (bahman) (Persian), (bahman) (Kurdish).
12. (rašama, pulân, rašân, xohalkrin) (March), (?esfand) (Persian), (?esfand) (Kurdish).
In addition to what has been said, differences and changes which specify situational strategies and special
registers are the external factors for language change. Code-switching is a term in linguistics referring to
alternation between two or more languages, dialects, or language registers in a single conversation, stretch
of discourse, or utterance between people who have more than one language is common. (Hudson 2007: 51;
Lyons 1990: 283)
During the research, we paid special attention to natives’ speech. When inhabitants speak in this
province, they chose one or more languages according to the circumstances. The first consideration, of
course, is which language would be comprehensible to the person addressed; generally speaking, speakers
chose a language which the other person could un-derstand. One interesting point that we found in this
research was one exception in code-switching and it was about religious words. Nobody modified these
terms. One reason for code-switching was social and cultural diversities. Sometimes a fluent multilingual
talking to another fluent multilingual altered language without any change in the situation and they used a few
words of language then a few words of another language; therefore, they changed their language and culture
in this way.
For example, in Kurdish there is a sentence like (naqšat lebe). The literal translation is (be a plan for
you). This sentence is used for a person who achieved a success or an honor and when people congratulate
him/her, he/she uses this sentence and wishes them the same. This sentence is not found in Persian and
Turkish so inhabitants have to use the native struc-ture. Other features which should be code-switched are
native slangs, expressions that bi-linguals or multilinguals have to state in the original language, for instance:
(tekušiw ba hi-wây jirân wuška) (no one can help you out, except yourself), (kas ba doy xoy nâle terša)
(everyone is proud of his/her work), (dâr ba piri hal nâya) (might makes right). All of these expressions are
live in Kurdish and we could not find good equivalents for them. Other speakers like Turkish, Persians had to
use them originally. All of the speakers of all lan-guages had the same situation.the elder people utilized
more unchanged words but the younger's changed their language to coincide. Many of Persian words were
written and ut-tered with reference to it's Persian term not Kurdish ones.for example chewing gum in Kurdish
means (benesht)but nobody said or wrote it correctly,they referred to it's Persian name (adams).other
examples are as follows which had completely changed to Persian:
512
Kurdish persian
Qutabkhane → madrese (school)
Shaii → aroosi (wedding ceremony)
Pelaw → Kafsh (shoe)
Mamosta → moaalem(teacher)
Biir → fekr (think)
Ashkawt → qhar (cave)
Halo → oghab (eagle)
Zawa → damad(groom)
Bazher → shahr(city)
Chesht → khorak(meal)
3.2. Phonological changes
Changes in sound are somewhat harder to document. But the already done deliberations shows that most of
phonological changes in these languages, especially Kurdish ensued. Analyzing old texts and interviewing
with old peoples demonstrated that before Islam there were no laryngeal or hard phonemes while after Islam
come to these regions Kurdish took more effect than Turkish and it borrowed some Arabic laryngeal
consonants such as /ħ/, /q./ and these work as allophones not phonemes.
In present time, because of the power of Persian these allophones are to be disap-peared and the
effects are even greater to some extent. Some phonemes such as /h/, /q/ are replaced with /ħ/, /q./. In some
strategic cities like Mahâbâd, Uremia, Naqade, Ošnaviye res-idents used new phonemes /h/, /q/ and other
cities followed them. Also inside these vernacu-lars people modify some phonemes like /w/, /ŕ/, /ĺ/ to
phonemes such as /v/, /r/, /l/. Changes of these three consonants are because of the influence of Persian
which is the standard and prestigious language in the country and especially for the inhabitant of this
province.
When someone uses the phonemes /w/, /ŕ/, /ĺ/ others make fun of him. This condition is prevalent in new
generations. Particularly among ladies, the changes are greater. In Kurd-ish (Sorâni dialect) there are about
11 vowels (long and simple) and they were reduced to 6 vowels like Persian and all long vowels omitted.
/a/ is another phonological feature which is common between Azeri and Kurdish and it is used at the end of
words while in Persian /e/ is used (See table 5, and 6).
The more palpable changes in all dialects of Kurdish (Sorâni, Kurmânji, Shekaki,…) that we can
exemplify are names of months, which are totally modified, and original forms are not used in present time.
3.3. Syntactic changes
In this part we exemplified some data both in Kurdish and Turkish which changed syntacti-cally.
There are many examples left because of some limitations like the format and size of article.
In Kurdish the negative structure of a sentence was as follows:
Table 1. The past and present structure of negative form in Kurdish
Past structure Present structure Persian equivalent

batamâni bei? nâthawe bey? nemixâhi biyâyi?
Lit. do want not you come? Lit. not do you want come? Lit. not do you want come you?
Do not want to come? Do not want to come? Do not want to come?
513
In this sentence negative marker appeared after the verb while in present time it analogized with Persian
struc-ture
In a statement like:
Table 2 The past and present structure of interrogative form in Kurdish

?awân čuna čwe? ?awân bočwe čun? ?ânhâ kojâ raftand?
Lit. they went where? Lit. they pre.where went? Lit. they where went?
Where did they go? Where did they go? Where did they go?
The verb /čuna/ (went) is used before /čwe?/ (where). In this statement (bo-) which is a preposition is add to (where).
Some other important changes in syntactic features of Kurdish is the loss of ergativity.
Table 3. The past and present structure of ergative structure in Kurdish

/wân nân čəkir/ /wân nân čəkirin/ (?ânhâ nân dorost kardand
Lit. They bread baked. Lit. they bread baked (pl.) Lit. they bread baked (pl.)
They baked the bread. They baked (pl.) the bread. They baked (pl.) the bread.
The verb /čəkir/ (baking) was the same for all pronouns (singular and plural) but nowadays it is modified and
is altered when different pronouns are used like Persian. Also the verb (čəkirin) changed itself into Persian
word (dapazen) which is analogized of Persian word (poxtan).
In Kurdish, there are some traces of ergativity too, but these structures are also passed down over the
time and Persian structures are substituted.
In Northern Kurdish the past tense of all transitive verbs is made on the ergative pat-tern with agent
suffixes as described above. In Southern Kurdish, however, a split has oc-curred. Generally, the ergative
construction has been displaced by non-ergative construction on the pattern of intransitive past verbs (and
doubtlessly under the influence of Persian). However, the older ergative construction has remained for
certain figurative expressions. Although the ergative is theoretically available for any past transitive verbs, its
use may produce a statement on the figurative plane that sounds "funny" or odd- i.e. a figurative use that
really has no conventional application. For instance, the verb (mâl sutân) (to burn someone's house) may
have an actual, literal application, as in (mâlaka-y Dârâm sut) (I burned Dârâ's house down) or it may have
figurative application, as in (mâlaka-y Dârâm sut) (I burned Dârâ's house). In present time this structure is
unknown for new generations of Kurdish. Other example of ergative structures are as follows: e.g.

/?au ketebakâni kerin/ /?au ketebakâni-pl. keri-sing./ /?ou ketâbhârâ xarid/
Lit. He books-pl. bought-pl. Lit. He books-pl. bought-sing. Lit. He books-pl. bought-sing.
He bought the books. He bought the books. He bought the books.
514

/?awân keteb keri/ /?awân ketebakânyân-sing. kerin-pl./ /?ânhâ ketâb xaridand/
Lit. They book-sing. bought-sing. Lit. They book-pl. bought-pl. Lit. They book-pl. bought-pl.
They bought the books. They bought the books. They bought the books.
In all of these sentences there are agreement between object and verb but based on the effect of Persian
they analogized and new structures replaced them.
In Turkish syntactic structures are not changed apparently. Just some Persian words are re-placed with
native vocabularies and sometimes Turkish structures are expressed with Per-sian words. Like: (o gede
bâqâ) (he went garden) (he went to the garden). This native struc-ture is now expressed like Persian
structure (?u be bâq raft) (o bâqâ gede). The verb and the object are exchanged.
a. Strategic places which affect on other cities effectively. (Developed cities)
b. under developing regions
c. unindustrilized places
Map 1
1Number one and two are the main bases of research and arrows show the places and direc-tion of study
2. Each number stands for the name of towns and the places of sampling and data collection
515
4. Discussion
Despite being welcomed by some and deplored by others, it cannot be denied that Persian functions as a
global lingua franca. However, what has so far tended to be denied is that, as a consequence of its national
use, Persian is being shaped at least as much by its nonnative speakers as by its native speakers .All three
levels of Kurdish language were severely affected by Persian .at the level of lexicon there were lots of
changes and many of words in our study have been replaced by Persian .at level of phonology the changes
were more and phonemes of Kurdish language had nearly been coincided with Persian ones .in syntactic
structures the situation is almost the same ,utterances are to overlap Persian in a way that the sentences are
more like Persian(as lingua franca) than Kurdish.
Documentation is the key to preserving endangered languages. Linguists are trying to doc-ument as
many as they can by describing grammars and structural features, by recording spoken language and by
using computers to store this information for study by scholars. Many endangered languages are only
spoken; no written texts exist. So it is important to act quickly in order to capture them before they go extinct.
Shortly, the loss of languages is dis-heartening. For linguists, the loss of a language is a loss for science. In
the same that biolo-gists hate to lose an animal or plant species, linguists hate to lose languages. The
researchers anticipate that the result of this research may be a seminal in its own kind for linguists, ap-plied
linguists, lingua Franca specialists and language teachers.
References
Atkinson, J. Maxwell and John Heritage, eds., (1984). Structures of social action: Studies in conversation analysis. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
Beach, Wayne,( 1990). Orienting to the phenomenon. In: J.A. Anderson, ed., Communication Yearbook,(p16) -244 Newbury Park, CA:
Sage Bergmann, J6rg,
Benjamin W. (2004). Indo-European Language and Culture: An Introduction.
Malden, Massachusetts: Blackwell
Button, Graham and John R.E. Lee, eds., (1987). Talk and social organisation. Clevedon: Multilingual Matters.
Chomsky, Noam, ( 1965). Aspects of the theory of syntax. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Cicourel, Aaron V., (1973). Cognitive sociology: Language and meaning in social interaction. LondonMacmillan.
Dinyon, Michael and William Greaves, (1989). The Times (23 and 24 October,1989, (p. 14).
Drew, Paul and John Heritage, ( 1992). Talk at work: Interaction in institutional settings. Cambridge,Cambridge University Press.
Firth ,A.(1996) . pragmalinguistics .Journal of Pragmatics,volume: 26 ,(pp 237-259) Firth, A., ( 1990). 'Lingua franca' negotiations:
Towards an interactional approach. World Englishes.
Goodenough, Ward H., (1971). Culture, language, and society. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
Gramkow Andersen, Karsten, (1993). Lingua franca discourse. Unpublished MA thesis, Dept. of Languages and Intercultural
Studies, Aalborg University, Denmark
Heritage, John, (1984). Garfinkel and ethnomethodology. Cambridge: Polity Press. House,J.(2003).English as a Lingua Franca:A threat
to multilingualism?,Hamburg University,Germany.
Jefferson, Gail, (1984). On the organization of laughter in talk about troubles. In: J. Maxwell Atkinson and John Heritage, eds..
Structures of social action: Studies in conversation analysis.( pp 347-369). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Kirkpatrick, Andy (2008). English as the official working language of the Association of KUO, I-C. Addressing the issue of teaching
English as a Southeast Asian Nations lingua franca. ELT Journal, 60(3 London: Continuum, 2006.(pp 40-50).
Kirkpatrick,A.(2010).English as an Asian lingua franca and multilingual model of ELT,Cambridge University press.
Klatsch (1987): Zur Socialform der diskreten Indiskretion. Berlin: De Gruyter . Lindstr6m,Anna,( 1994). Identification and recognition in
Swedish telephone conversation openings. Language in Society 23(2):( pp 231-252)
Manfredi,S. (2011) From lingua franca to native language, Arabic in Sudan,Sociolinguistics journal,Abstract of paper
Schegloff, Emanuel A., ( 1991). Reflections on talk and social structure. In: Deirdre Boden and Don. H.
SEIDLHOFER, B. (2006). English as a lingua franca in the expanding circle: What it isn t. In Seidlhofer, Barbara,
Breiteneder, Angelika, and Pitzl,Marie-Luise (2006) English as a lingua franca in Europe: challenges.
Zimmerman, Don H., (1988). On conversation: The conversation analytic perspective. Communication. Yearbook II, 406-432. Newbury
Park, CA: Sage
516
Objective Correlatives of City and Places in T.S. Eliot’s the Waste Land
Manjola Nasi
Lecturer at the Faculty of Foreign Languages

University of Tirana, Albania
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.517
Abstract: Although T.S. Eliot is primarily appreciated as a poet, his contribution in the field of literary criticism and literary
theoretical discussion are greatly important. The interrelationship between his criticism and his poetic work is marked by many
concepts that are materialized in his artistic creation. The objective correlative is a perfect example of this phenomenon, since it
is Eliot’s original notion and also because it has been applied to a large extent in his poems. This article aims to investigate the
objective correlative from a theoretical point of view and in comparison to other theoretical concepts explicated in Eliot’s critical
essays. In addition, the article addresses the use of this literary device in the capacity of urban life, urban ambiance and urban
sites in T.S. Eliot’s The Waste Land, where metropolitan elements provide not merely a setting for the development of the
content, but also one of the most recurrently encountered motifs. Eliot’s use of metropolitan details in this poem contributes in
the portrayal of modern life by supplying a composite of emotional, logical and sensory reactions, compatible with his description
of the objective correlative, which in turn enables a unified experiencing of the poem.
Keywords: T.S. Eliot; objective correlative; Unreal City; cityscape;
1. Sensibility and emotion
Among Eliot’s most important contributions in the field of literary studies is his concept of the dissociation of
sensibility, first introduced in his 1921 essay “The metaphysical poets”. The dissociation, according to Eliot,
occurred when thoughts and feelings did not meet in perfect unison. In speaking about the poet John Donne,
Eliot described that Donne’s thoughts constituted an experience, a totality of sensory perceptions and
intellectual reasoning that merged inseparably into the poet’s mind. In contrast to the ordinary man, whose
experience is chaotic, irregular, fragmentary, in the mind of the poet, these experiences are always forming
new wholes. (p. 64) Eliot’s notion of sensibility is, in fact, quite complex. He is careful to distance it from the
conventional association with emotions.1 As becomes clear in his essays, especially in the aforementioned
“The metaphysical poets”, as well as in “Tradition and the individual talent” and “Hamlet and his problems”,
sensibility, sometimes used interchangeably with “feelings”, is to Eliot the use of senses and the total of
perceptions collected by this use. As opposed to this, emotions represent the subjective / personal reaction of
either reader or poet, or in other occasions, the one inherent in the poetic work. (SW. pp. 28-29)
Being a firm believer that the esthetic purpose of art cannot be achieved with a work suffering from the
dissociation of sensibility, Eliot elaborated this concept further, providing a more practical way to achieve the
desired opposite: unification of sensibility, thus avoiding the disparity between emotions and the external
elements that would provoke them:
The only way of expressing emotion in the form of art is by finding an “objective correlative”; in
other words, a set of objects, a situation, a chain of events which shall be the formula of that
particular emotion; such that when the external facts, which must terminate in sensory experience,
are given, the emotion is immediately evoked. (SW, p. 49)

1 In his chapter “Tradition in 1919: Pound, Eliot and ‘the historical method’”, Massimo Bacigalupo introduces the term “desynomyzing”
(2007: 104) originally employed by Coleridge to distinguish between ‘Imagination’ and ‘Fancy’.
517
The objective correlative translated the subjective into the objective, or rather, provided an objective basis for
what would be a subjective experiencing of the former. The reader could not be asked to feel or perceive an
emotion without having a source to derive it from, and the various elements of the work itself, such as
characters, their actions and the occurrences within the plot had to be justified by this same foundation. Only
in this way could the literary work achieve the necessary harmony required for the achievement of esthetic
beauty.
Eliot endorsed and revised the principles of unity, coherence and order throughout his career as a critic
and literary theoretician, and correspondingly employed them in his poetic work. In fact, so much is this
statement true, that even the most fragmented of his writings possesses an undeniable harmony with
fragments far from uniform acting as different instruments in an orchestra. The use of the objective correlative
can be at times hard to isolate from the multitude of the other components of the literary work, and above all,
it is itself made up of a series of constituents whose number and dimensions can vary to a considerable
degree. But as its original purpose entails, it is supposed to bring an emotion or a complexity of emotions
woven together with thought, not an entire isolation of either. Thus, the instruments of an objective correlative
can be incidences, characters, settings or any possible combination between them. For the purpose of this
article, I am going to discuss several instances of Eliot’s use of places, dwellings and cities in The Waste
Land to illustrate one of his most fundamental preoccupations: that with the human condition in an era devoid
of faith in fellow beings and greater things.
2. Unreal City
Eliot’s metropolitan settings are uncovered to the reader fragment after fragment and a handful of isolated
details at a time. Thus, trying to draft an accurate mind map of these urban sites is neither easy, nor fruitful.
The particularly narrow field of view with which we are provided becomes in itself an important literary device
in creating the right mood for experiencing Eliot’s poems, partly because of the mysteriousness that seems to
open doors towards feeling and accepting rather than simply understanding.
The frequency of urban images draws attention to their importance in Eliot’s depiction of modern life and
civilization. Critics have even gone so far as to hint that the city is the real protagonist of The Waste Land
(Long, 1985, p. 145).
Unreal city is first mentioned in line 60 of The Waste Land and it is again echoed as such in lines 207 and
376. On the first instance, the grim ambience also introduces in the poem a dimension of plurality:
Unreal City,
Under the brown fog of a winter dawn,
A crowd flowed over London Bridge, so many,
I had not thought death had undone so many. (WL, lines 60-63)
Along with the image of dead people inhabiting a city that is unreal and the power of such a dark vision, one
of the most essential elements here is the word ‘many’. Its importance is made more obvious by its repetition
in the two consecutive lines, which intensify the multitude and highlight the presence of people against the
impressive urban background. This plurality is a crucial element in the shaping of the ironic dimension of the
use of the complex element of the city in Eliot’s work: by stating that the utter solitude and isolation occur in
the middle of a gigantic crowd, not in a small village where human contact is objectively less frequent or
limited in terms of choice, Eliot, like many other Modernists (Chinitz, 2006, pp. 324, 326-328), is
demonstrating the absurdity and dysfunctionality of human interaction in modern society. The allusions from
Dante and Baudelaire which Eliot referred to in his notes intensify this crowdedness even more. Baudelaire’s
original text speaks of a ‘city full of dreams’ adding yet another dimension to the airy atmosphere, where
‘ghosts by daylight tug the passer's sleeve’ (Baudelaire, Campbell,1952, p. 111). Baudelaire’s ghosts and
518
dreams, Dante’s desperate infernal crowd and Eliot’s own added perspective of an individual that is part of
that crowd as an equal, not as an observer, since he can participate in an atypical ‘inside’ conversation with
another person of this crowd, all accentuate this feeling of disorder, semi-darkness, heavy air, anxiety, a
nightmarish sensation that comes as a complex union of perceptions of many different sensory receptors.
The scene is very visual, as made unavoidably such by means of the images, Dante’s original text contains
repeated auricular details and Baudelaire’s ghosts rubbed against the sleeves of passers-by contribute with
the tangible elements to make this passage one of the most complex in Eliot’s work in terms of sensory
intensity. All the overflow of perceptions create the feeling of helplessness, anguish and fatality which an
outstretching of the persona’s experience into the sensitivity of the reader. The London Bridge as setting is
simultaneously merged with Dante’s hell, Baudelaire’s Paris, and the in the lines following also with Ancient
Rome and Cathage. This disruption of both space and time continuum and the confusion resulting from it
universalize the human pain and hopelessness and the futility of human efforts, like that of planting corpses
in the garden and expecting them to bloom.
The second instance in which Unreal City is mentioned using this term is presented through the voice of
Tiresias. The context is not as acute as that of line 60, but this time, Tiresias introduces the reader to a much
deeper perspective, the daily lives of the inhabitants of Unreal. We see Tiresias being proposed to spend a
weekend with Mr. Eugenides, the Smyrna merchant. A very interesting fact is that Mr. Eugenides is first
mentioned as the ‘one-eyed merchant’ by Madame Sosostris (see Sharpe, 1990, p. 196), thus similar to
Tiresias in terms of his blindness. Tiresias is, as he plainly acknowledges, “I Tiresias, though blind [...] can
see”, able to perceive the truth and to understand both men and women and identify himself with both
genders. The merchant, being one-eyed, belongs, alike Tiresias, to two worlds: that of those who can see
and that of those who cannot. But neither of these qualities enables him to understand: his eye and his
missing eye leave him as blind as the rest. The fact that he is similar to Tiresias does not make him
comprehend the latter better than other people would. His carefulness with the documents for selling currants
stretches to his business-like proposition, which is open and detailed. Although he is from Smyrna and can
speak French (and proposes a weekend at the Metropole i.e. the city), instead of producing positive effects,
his knowledge of the human nature has instead made him a cynical person who prefers objectifying his
equals. In his chapter on The Waste Land, Cleanth Brooks explains:
The Syrian merchants, we learn from Miss Weston's book, were, along with slaves and soldiers,
the principal carriers of the mysteries which lie at the core of the Grail legends. But in the modern
world we find both the representatives of the Tarot divining and the mystery cults in decay. What he
carries on his back and what the fortune-teller is forbidden to see is evidently the knowledge of the
mysteries (although Mr. Eugenides himself is hardly likely to be more aware of it than Madame
Sosostris is aware of the importance of her function). Mr. Eugenides, in terms of his former
function, ought to be inviting the protagonist into the esoteric cult which holds the secret of life, but
on the realistic surface of the poem, in his invitation to a weekend at the Metropole he is really
inviting him to a homosexual debauch. The homosexuality is secret and now a cult but a very
different cult from that which Mr. Eugenides ought to represent. The end of the new cult is not life
but, ironically, sterility. (Brooks, 1939, p.153-154)
This added dimension of the Smyrna merchant constitutes a second ironic dimension inherent in his
character. The mystery that would provide details to help save the land from barrenness turns out to be his
personal secret involving homosexual sex which in its turn cannot procreate. The ignorance of Mr. Eugenides
of the higher mission he was supposed to carry out is tragic even more because of his original function as a
guide and the fact that his exchange is with Tiresias, who is himself a seer, not a doer. Thus, all the chain of
the transmission of the mystery is broken beyond recovery: the carrier of the secret is not aware of his
mission, the secret he is keeping has been transformed into one that does not lead to the fulfillment of the
519
quest of humanity and neither to the secret of life (personal procreation), and finally, the message is given to
another keeper of many secrets.
The desecration of the mystery leading to a loss of the path towards the success of the quest is at the
same time an underneath layer in the general suffering of the dwellers of Unreal City. The whole section is
pervaded by a sense of loss and multifold violation of all that is considered sacred, by numerous sexual
encounters of a distasteful nature: rapes, random and insignificant seasonal relationships, passionless
intercourse, possibly prostitution or rapports of similar nature. All these point to the isolation regardless of
present human contact, the loss of faith in fellow beings, and like in “Gerontion”, a loss of passion. The
presentation of all the details, both narrative and descriptive, form a complex union which succeeds in
transmitting the feeling of abandonment and failure as well as the logical dimension to rationalize the
situation. The following passage includes a change in perspective and through the voice of Tiresias we see
the other side of Unreal City. The evening comes, the workday is over and it is time for the inhabitants of
Unreal to go back home, but what awaits them inside the walls is not a warm family atmosphere. The modest
room of the typist who is slowly growing old (Her drying combinations touched by the sun’s last rays,) awaits
the visit of the young man who goes on fulfilling his urges without love, or neither passion, but only as part of
a ‘because I have a chance’ ritual. The description of the ambiance in the room is an excellent example of the
translation of thought and feelings into external facts. The emptiness, exhaustion and hopelessness of the
woman are reflected into her furniture, the lack of space and order in her room. In addition, the loneliness and
the absence of love and care into her life are emphasized by details such as those regarding her dinner
preparation with food being laid out in tins, the fact that she clears her breakfast dishes at tea-time, implying
that nobody else is home and above all, by the divan, normally a living room object, which at night she uses
as her bed. Additionally, the fact that the undesired sexual contact occurs inside her home is an indication of
the degree to which the barrenness, physical or spiritual, has invaded modern society. The home is only
another decaying temple that no longer provides protection, affection, attention or understanding. It is the
lack of, desire, love or even hate and violence that makes this a very grim example of modern urban
decadence. The typist is “hardly aware of her departed lover”, and it is the lack of emotions, both positive and
negative that create the general feeling of desolateness that contributes into the background image of the
wasteland and serves as a uniting detail for the bigger picture.
With the exception of addressing it as ‘city’ in line 259, Eliot uses the name ‘Unreal’ again in line 376. This
instance is particularly important due to its alteration of the setting viewpoint. Throughout the poem, despite
the changes in setting mainly through allusion or even through direct mentioning, Unreal City is constantly
identified as London (Doyle, Winkiel, 2005, p. 264). The map uncovered fragment after fragment presents
London cityscape, with its buildings, landmarks, streets, and more. But in this context, London is mentioned
separately as if to be distanced from Unreal City, which is now functioning as a separate entity. Yet, it must
be pointed out that this context depicts the similarity, not the difference between the cities mentioned in lines
374-376, thus also making Unreal an amalgamation of all the other cities whose names are evoked and at
the same time a symbol of all urban centers in a multitude of locations. In his address “Influence of the
Landscape upon the poet”, Eliot stated that “[his] personal landscape … [was] … a composite” (ILP, 1960, p.
421), adding that “[his] … urban imagery was that of St. Louis, upon which that of Paris and London have
been superimposed.” (ibid., p. 422) In fact, this, at the same time, is the best way to understand Unreal City:
as a merging of the characteristics of all modern cities with their physical features and the similar ambiance
of crowdedness, lack of order and simultaneous paralysis. It almost feels as if the ghost of Unreal City haunts
its each and every modern counterpart, making it impossible for itself to have a specific location or exact
temporal dimension. The above context universalizes Unreal placing it on the same rank with all the real-life
cities mentioned in the lines preceding it, which are all portrayed in a process of apocalyptical destruction. Its
urban scenes are no longer depicted as inhabited by crowds as in the other instances, but as desolate places
reminiscent of the past. The sensory details enfolding this passage contain again visual, olfactory and
auditory elements, which evoke a complex general feeling of mystery, nostalgia and loss. Images of aridness
520
persist even stronger and the urban setting is intermingled with semi-rural landscapes and details. The
universalizing of Unreal constitutes a culmination of despair that creates a suffocating feeling of
hopelessness and inability to escape. The prison mentioned in lines 411-414 is, in fact, the last urban setting
mentioned directly in the poem, along with London Bridge that is now falling down, as if to signal a loss of
connections between earth and water, thus a permanent loss of hope for equilibrium.
3. Conclusion
Although The Waste Land contains numerous images of draught, stones, rocks, arid soil, shattered glass, dry
plants, dust, etc., its most dramatic passages are placed in urban settings. Providing occasions for human
interaction, the urban background offers the clearest picture of the human condition in modern society. Eliot
gives the typical modern metropolis the name “Unreal city”, which contains London landmarks and milieu, but
also various elements of other modern cities. Unreal City is one city in particular, but it stands as a symbol of
modern urban decay and has neither place nor time restrictions. Its major function in the poem is that with its
inside and outside backgrounds, it provides the necessary elements to articulate the message of the poem.
The use of multifold sensory details serves as Eliot’s poetic device to translate thought into feeling and it
demonstrates his view on what he called ‘the objective correlative’. Among all the instances of the use of the
objective correlative in Eliot’s poetry, this is probably the most complex, because it involves a very well-
organized structure that through contextual modifications holds true for all The Waste Land. It is very
important to mention that in order for Unreal City to be considered as an objective correlative, it should be
viewed as a composite of details, images and sensory elements, not as a solid unique entity, which it is
obviously not. In this respect, Unreal City provides not only meaning to The Waste Land, but it offers a
complexity of perceptions that lead to experience the poem with both mind and emotions.
References
Bacigalupo, M. (2007), Tradition in 1919: Pound, Eliot and ‘the historical method’. In Cianci, G. & Harding, J. (Eds.), T.S. Eliot and the
Idea of Tradition. Cambridge: CUP.
Baudelaire, C., & Campbell, R. (1952). Poems of Baudelaire: A translation of Les Fleurs du mal. New York: Pantheon Books.
Brooks, C. (1939). The Waste Land, Critique of the Myth. In Brooks, C. (Ed.), Modern Poetry and the Tradition. (pp. 153-154), Chapel
Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
Chinitz. D. (2006), T.S. Eliot: The Waste Land. In Bradshaw, D. & Dettmar, K. J. H. A companion to modernist literature and culture. (pp.
324-332). Oxford: Blackwell Publishing.
Doyle, L. & Winkiel, L.A. (2005). Geomodernisms: race, modernism, modernity. Indiana: IUP.
Eliot, T.S. “The metaphysical poets”. In Kermode, F. (ed.), (1975), Selected Prose of T. S. Eliot. London: Faber.
Eliot, T.S. (1960). The Influence of Landscape upon the Poet. Daedalus: Journal of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences 89, no.
2 (Spring 1960): 420–422.
Long, M. (1985), Eliot, Pound, Joyce: Unreal City?. In Timms, E. Kelley, D. (Eds.) Unreal city: urban experience in modern European
literature and art. (pp. 144-157), Glasgow: Bell & Bain Ltd.
521

The Impact of Person Job Fit on Job Satisfaction and its Subsequent
Impact on Employees Performance
Muhammad Tahir Iqbal
Muhammad Ali Jinnah University, Islamabad, Pakistan

International Islamic University, Islamabad, Pakistan
Waqas Latif
Wahab Naseer
Muhammad Ali Jinnah University, Islamabad, Pakistan

International Islamic University, Islamabad
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.523
Abstract: Humans Resource is considered to be a vital source of growth for the companies, for best utilization of human
resource it is indispensible to align the knowledge, skills and abilities possessed by the employees with the assigned roles in the
organization. The present study reveals the relationship between person job fit, job satisfaction and job performance. This study
studied and analyzed the responses of 251 respondents from various universities in twin cities i.e. Islamabad and Rawalpindi.
Results indicated that there exists relationship between person job fit and job satisfaction and job performance and the result is
positive. While the relationship between job satisfaction and job performance is also positive.
Keywords: Person Job Fit, Job Satisfaction, Job Performance
1. Introduction
Human Resource Management has drawn closer to be acknowledged as an intrinsic part of management,
which is concerned with the human wealth of an organization. Objective of HRM is to maintain better human
relations in the organization by the evaluation of policies, procedures and application, development and
program relating to human resources to make effective their involvement towards the recognition of
organizational objectives.
Human Resource Management helps in obtaining utmost individual development, effective working
connection between employers and employees, employees and employers, and desirable molding of human
resources as contrasted with substantial resources. It is the recruitment, selection, utilization, development,
motivation and compensation of human resources by the organization. The HR function provides momentous
support and guidance to line management. The maintenance, attraction and development of far above the
ground caliber people are a foundation of competitive advantage for our enterprise, and are the responsibility
of Human Resource Management.
Humans are the widely accepted the most important asset of the organizations. Organizations use
humans as strategic tool of competence. To drive best out of human resource it is essential to give them the
task that is best suited to their efforts or competences. In general job demands typically contain the skills,
abilities and knowledge (SAKs) is necessary to perform at the job and the suitable fir is essential between the
two (Caldwell & O’Reilly, 1990; Sackett, 1996 & Wilk). Researches indicated that job fit leads to job
satisfaction which is ultimately a way to employee performance. (Schneider & Nygren 1970; O’ Reilly, 1977;
Hollenbeck, 1989; Chatman et al, 1994).
523
2. Significance
2.1 For Researchers / Academia
As there is no such significant research in literature which shows the relationship between Person Job fit,
Employee satisfaction and job performance and in Pakistani scenario there is no such research. This study
will add knowledge to existing body of knowledge by showing that how person job fit affect job satisfaction
and on job performance.
2.2 For Managers/Universities
This study will guide for managers to understand the phenomena of Person job fit in order to keep their
fitment of job competencies against individual characteristics to deliver the quality education to their
organization and thus making them a tool of strategic competence.
3. Research Question
1. Is there any relationship between Person job fit, Job satisfaction and Job performance?
2. How Person job fit affects on Job satisfaction?
3. How Person job fit affects Job performance?
4. How Job satisfaction affects on Job performance?
4. Research Objectives
The objectives of current study are;

 To identify the relationship between Person job fit and Job Satisfaction.
 To identify the relationship between Person job fit and Job performance.
 To identify the relationship between Job Satisfaction and Job performance.
 To identify that how Person job fit affects on Job satisfaction and job Performance.
5.1 Person Job Fit
Edward (1991) described the P-J fit with its two perspectives: first one is need-supplies and second is
Demand-Abilities. Factors of “Needs Supplies Perspectives” contain the wants of individuals’ attributes and
characteristics of the job that may well gratify those wants. Individuals’ wants contain Goals (Shaw, Locke,
Saari & Lathan , 1981), Psychological Needs ( Lofquist & Dawis, 1984), Interests( Hansen & Campbell 1981)
and values ( Locke, 1976), Pay (Lawler, 1981) and other job attributes. The “Demands Abilities Perspective”
contains the demand for job that is necessary to do the job and individual’s abilities that can be equivalent to
the job requirement.
In general job demands generally contain skills, abilities and knowledge (SAKs) is necessary to
complete at the job (Caldwell & O’Reilly, 1990; Sackett, 1996). Abilities contain experience, employee’
aptitude, knowledge and skills (French Caplan, & Harrison, 1982 Dawis & Lofquist, 1984; O’Reilly & Caldwell,
1990). In recruitment and selection process tactics to judge the P-J Fit are resumes, interviews, tests,
reference checks and several of other selection tools (Webel & Gulliland, 1999).
524
5.2 Job Satisfaction
Job satisfaction refers to one’s feelings or condition of mind according to the nature of work. Job satisfaction
could be inclined by various factors such as kind of organization Policies, Supervision, Administration, salary
and quality of life. However it is concluded in research (Porter, 1962; Smith, Hulin, Kendall 1969) that job
satisfaction illustrates it is the difference between what people expect from the job and what they get in
actual.
Stress and dissatisfaction of job creates susceptibility to leave the job and high turnover rates.(
Cavanagn 1990, Lrvine & evans 1995) (Coffin & Cavanagh 1992)
Job satisfaction is also visualized as an in general ranking or as the summation of numerous isolated
dimensions of job distinctiveness (Stamps & Peidmont 1986; Mueller & McCloskey 1990; Traynor & Wade
1993).
5.3 Job Performance
Job performance means the effectiveness of employees activities that make a payment to organizational
goals (McCloy, Campbell, & Cudeck, 1994; cf. Motowidlo, 2003). Employee perception’s about his tasks and
responsibilities were not associated to employee’s self ranking of his very own performance. (Lawler & Hall,
1970). Researchers present the job importance as a subjective ruling and interpersonal interactions, in the
hunt for to enhance the job performance (Griffin, 1983).
In research conclusions job performance is positively relate to the social information processing and job
design (Hackman & Oldhan, 1976; Salancik & Pfeffer, 1978). Job design examiners concluded in their
research work that significance of redesign the job is directly relate to job performance and perceptions of
task significance(Mowday & Steers 1977).
5.4 Person Job Fit and Job Satisfaction
P-J fit has a significant effect on Job satisfaction. According to ( Smith et al -1969), various researches put
forward that, in general, Job satisfaction is powerfully inclined by employees’ assessment of the job and
assignments they execute, which are the vital components of P-J fit. Researchers concluded in their
researches that p-O fit and P-J fit should co-relate to evaluate job satisfaction . (Schneider & Nygren 1970; O’
Reilly, 1977; Hollenbeck, 1989; Chatman et al, 1994) Because the both variables the person job fit and the
person organization fit have strong impact on job satisfaction. Enlighten of job satisfaction usually put
emphasis to measure it in individual are according to work nature or organization factors(Mortimer-1979).
Kalleberg with Griffin and Losco (1977;1978;1980;198) incorporated the following explanations in social
action approach, (why it has been incorporated)
1- The employees fill the targeted nature for the jobs (e.g. job feature, Structural job and its extent of
control).
2- Motivation of the employees and the subjective analysis of job features.
3- Job rewards and values are major independent (self-governed) variables of job satisfaction, which
directly related to satisfaction. Nevertheless, when remuneration or rewards are controlled job
values will relate indirectly to the job satisfaction. Employees who have high value assured then
they feel more dissatisfied with job. Then, those do not think the characteristics more important.
Therefore, it is concluded that there is no only definite job characteristics but also the perceptions
of employee, which is, connected with the satisfaction levels. Rewards for employees (job
rearwards) for example, pay, promotion, and job security etc. are directly inter-associated with job
satisfaction. (Vroom 1964; Nord 1977; Taber and Seashore 1975; Farrell & Rusbult 1981;).
525
H1: Person Job Fit has a positive impact on Job Satisfaction.
5.5 Person Job Fit and Job Performance
According to the literature in this relation, P-J fit and Job performance there is contradictionary results
overall.(Sexton, 1967)described in his research that there is no association was originate between P-J fit on
“Need for Achievement” and job performance nor involving P-J Fit on “job Enrichment” and Job
performance.( Cherington and England, 1980). Therefore, when P-J fit has been outfitted as compare of
employee’s skills and job demand with personality. So here, the direct relationship of P-J fit among the job
performance comes in progress. ( Ivancerich 1979) verified that performance of employee is highest when
his/her willingness for decision making coordinated the sum of decision making on hand on the job. In
addition, ( Caldwell and Reilly 1900) conclude that managers’ performance was more than their abilities and
skills fit the summary necessary for the job.
H2: Person Job Fit has a positive impact on Job Performance
5.6 Job Satisfaction and Job Performance
Endeavoring to be aware of the temperament of job satisfaction and its consequences on job performance is
difficult. Organizational and industrial researcher has been grappling with difficulty of the relationship between
job satisfaction and job performance for minimum 50 years. Psychologist and researchers have put a
considerable effort to demonstrate these two are directly related in meticulous manners; “ A happy worker is
a Good Worker, (http://ezine.com/activites)” the practical aspect status of the argument that the inter
association of job performance among job satisfaction specially greater for greater self esteem workers than
for those who have low self esteem; the co-relation between job satisfaction and performance is explained
directly by different researchers. “Korman 1976,1977, 1988” and others “Greennews & Bassin, 1974; waters
& Roach 1972, Weiner 1973” give advance determined support to argue this research. However when we
define job satisfaction theoretically, it comes to know that, it have including cognitive, effective, dimensional,
and conative components. So that in general job satisfaction cannot epitomize all attitude dimensions
adequately and does, it cannot foresee job performance sufficiently. Cummings and Schwab agree with this
concept that “performance implication may well differ depending upon the type of satisfaction under studies
1970 p.423”.
H3: Job satisfaction has a positive impact on Job Performance
6. Theoretical Framework
Person Job Fit
Job Satisfaction Job Performance

6.1 Dependent Variable
Job Satisfaction and Job Performance
6.2 Independent Variable
Person Job Fit
526
7. Study Design and Methodology
7.1 Sample & Procedure
This research scrutinizes the relationship between P-J Fit, Job satisfaction and Job Performance .The
industry we choose to investigate the association between variables, is educational institutes - universities.
The research investigation based on statistics collected from various universities, including SZABIST, IIUI,
Bahria, QAU, FJWU & NUST.
A total of 357 structured questionnaires are conveniently distributed among the above mentioned randomly
selected universities. Out of 357 questionnaires 251 are returned. The response rate is 70.5%. The number
of respondents responded from different universities are as follow;
Name of University Questionnaire Distributed Responses Collected

SZABIST 70 38
International Islamic University 100 81
NUST 50 39
Bahria University 50 41
Quaid-e-Azam University 50 31
FJWU 37 21
Total 357 251
7.2 Sample Characteristics
The sample consists of 58.96 % male and 41.04 % female. 25.9% of the employees are in the age bracket of
21-25 years. 27.5% are in the age bracket of 26-30 years. 29.5% are in the age bracket of 31-35 years. 8.8%
of the respondents belong to the age category of 36-40 years. While 8.4% are above from 40 years.
57.4% have the work experience of 7 years or less. 26.7% fall in the category of 8-14 years. 13.1% have the
work experience of 15-21 years. While remaining 2.8% have work experience above 22 years.
Only 60.6% have above 16 Years of education and remaining 39.4% have completed 16 years of education.
The following table shows the detailed characteristics of population studied.
Frequency(f) Percentage Cumulative

Percent
21-25 65 25.9% 25.9
26-30 69 27.5% 53.4
Age 31-35 74 29.5% 82.9
36-40 22 8.8% 91.6
Above 40 21 8.4% 100
Male 148 58.96% 59
Gender
Female 103 41.04% 100
Bachelors(under 16 years) 99 39.4% 100
Qualification
Masters(16 years) 152 60.6% 60.6
0-7 144 57.4% 57.4
Work
8-15 67 26.7% 84.1
Experience
16-22 33 13.1% 97.2
(Years)
22 above 7 2.8% 100
Table 1 - Sample Characteristics
527
8. Findings and Conclusion
8.1 Descriptive Statistics
N Minimum Maximum Mean Std. Deviation

Age 251 .00 4.00 1.4502 1.19353
Education 251 .00 1.00 .3944 .48970
Experience 251 .00 3.00 .6135 .81857
Gender 251 .00 1.00 .4104 .49288
Job Fit 251 3.80 5.00 4.2112 .30964
Job Satisfaction 251 4.00 5.00 4.1303 .31003
Job Performance 251 3.70 5.00 4.2562 .32716
8.2 Reliability Analysis
Table – 2 shows the Cronbach’s Alpha of the variables which shows the reliability of the data. The values
show that the data is highly reliable.
Reliability Analysis
Variable Cronbach's Alpha
Person Job Fit 0.774
Job Satisfaction 0.905
Job Performance 0.736
Table 2 - Reliability Analysis
8.3 Correlation Analysis
Table -3 shows that a positive but weak correlation exists between three variables i.e. job fit, job satisfaction
and job performance as evidenced through table. Correlation values between job fit and job satisfaction is r =
0.110, job fit and job performance is r = 0.230 and between job satisfaction and job performance is r = 0.201.
Correlations
Age Education Experience Gender Job Fit Job Job

Satisfaction Performance
Age
**0.386
Education
**0.489 **0.711
Experience
-0.043 *-0.143 0.048
Gender
528
0.066 -0.019 0.027 0.012 0.775

Job Fit
0.013 -0.037 0.032 -0.021 0.110 0.905
Job Satisfaction
Job
0.012 -0.066 0.001 -0.015 **0.230 **0.201 0.736
Performance
Independent Variable: Job Satisfaction

**Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).
*Correlation is significant at the 0.05 level (2-tailed).
8.4 Regression Analysis
In Table where independent variable is job fit value of R square is 0.012 depicting that the variation in
Employee satisfaction and job performance is explained up to 1.2% through variation in job fit which shows
that job fit is very weak predictor of job performance and employee satisfaction in the universities.
Regression Analysis (A)
R Square B F t P
Person Job Fit 0.012 0.110 3.039 13.771 0.083
Dependent Variable : Job
Satisfaction
In Table where independent variable is job satisfaction value of R square is 0.041depicting that the variation
in job performance is explained up to 4.1% through variation in job satisfaction which shows that job
performance is predicted by job satisfaction.
Regression Analysis (B)
R Square B F t P
Person Job Fit 0.053 0.230 13.898 11.897 0.000
Job Satisfaction 0.041 0.201 10.510 12.455 0.001
Dependent Variable : Job Performance
9. Conclusion & Recommendations
From the above research it is evident that for the job satisfaction it is somehow essential that the tasks and
responsibilities assigned to the employees must match his or her competences. The tasks which are not
suited to the abilities of employees will lead towards job dissatisfaction. With the rewards and benefits that
determine the level of job satisfaction, job fit is also important variable that leads to job satisfaction. Job
satisfaction is thus ultimate leads to the job performance. When a person is having responsibilities that best
match his abilities, he will perform the satisfactorily and shows the greater results or higher performance. So
Human Resource managers must be aware of this fact, they must consider employee’s capabilities while
drafting the job descriptions of their employees.
529
References
Caldwell, D. F. & O’Reilly, C. A., III (1990). Measuring person–job fit with a profile-comparison process. Journal of Applied Psychology,
75, 648–657.
Cavanagn, Lrvine & evans 1995, Job satisfaction and turnover among nurses: integrating research findings across studies, Journal
Article.
Cherrington, D. J. & England, J. L. (1980). The desire for an enriched job as a moderator of the enrichment–satisfaction relationship.
Organizational Behavior and HumanPerformance, 25, 139–159.
Dawis & Lofquist (1984). A psychological theory of work adjustment. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Edwards, J. R. (1991). Person–job fit: A conceptual integration, literature review, and methodological critique. International Review of
Industrial and Organizational Psychology, 6, 283–357.
French JRP Jr, Caplan RD & Harrison RV. (1982). The mechanisms of job stress and strain. London: Wiley.
Griffin, R. W. (1983). Objective and social sources of information in task redesign: A field experiment. Administrative Science Quarterly,
28, 184–200.
Hall, D. T., Schneider, B., & Nygren, H. T. (1970) Personal factors in organizational identification. Administrative Science Quarterly, 15,
176-190.
Judge, T. A., Bono, J. E., & Locke, E. A. (2000). Personality and job satisfaction: The mediating role of job characteristics. Journal of
Applied Psychology, 85, 751-765.
Korman, A. K. Hypothesis of work behavior revisited and an extension. Academy of Management review, 1976,1(1), 50-63.
Korman, A. K. Organizational behavior. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall, 1977.
Locke, E. A. (1969). What is job satisfaction? Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 4, 309 336.
Locke, E. A. (1976). The nature and causes of job satisfaction. In M. D. Dunnette (Ed.), Handbook of industrial and organizational
psychology. Chicago: Rand McNally
Lofquist, L. H., & Dawis, R. V. (1969). Adjustment to work: a psychological view of man’s problems in a workoriented society. New York:
Appleton–Century–Crofts.
Lumande, Edward, and Athulang Mutshewa. 1999. Information-seeking behaviour among University of Botswana science faculty. 15,
(2) (Jun): 107-112.
O’Reilly, C. A., III (1977). Personality–job fit: Implications for individual attitudes and performance. Organizational Behavior and Human
Performance, 18, 36–46.
O’Reilly, C. A., III, Chatman, J., & Caldwell, D. F. (1991). People and organizational culture: A profile comparison approach to assessing
person–organization fit. Academy of Management Journal, 34, 487–516.
Porter, L. W. (1962). Job attitudes in management: Perceived deficiencies in need fulfillment as a function of job level. Journal of Applied
Psychology, 46, 375–384
Roethlisberger. F. J. & Dickson. W. J. (1939). Management and the worker. Cambridge. MA: Harvard University Press.
Sexton, W. P. (1967). Organization and individual needs: A conflict? Personnel Journal, 46, 337–343.
Smith, P. C., Kendall, L. M., & Hulin, C. L. (1969). The measurement of satisfaction in work and retirement. Chicago: Rand–McNally.
Vroom, V. H. (1964). Work and motivation. New York: Wiley.
Werbel, J. D., & Gilliland, S.W. (1999). Person-environment fit in the selection process. In G. R. Ferris
530
Representation of the East in Western Literature

(A Critical Discourse Analysis of the Travelogue Eothen)
Neda Salahshour
Education Supervisor, Zabansara Language Institute

Farzad Salahshour
Assistant Professor, Tarbiat Moallem University,

Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.531
Abstract: Representation in discourse is a constructed practice; that is, it is not neutral. Events and ideas are not transmitted
neutrally as they were, because they have to pass through a medium with its own ideological filters. Critical discourse analysis
(CDA) is a type of discourse analytical research that primarily studies the way social power abuse, dominance, and inequality
are enacted, reproduced, and resisted by text and talk in the social and political context. Edward Said’s book Orientalism (1976)
focuses on how the East is represented by the West. He believes that during the process of representation, the Orient is also
remade. He mentions a number of writers who he believes depict distorted images of the East in order to satiate their colonizing
ends among whom is Kingslake and his travel narrative Eothen (1844). Twenty seven pages from this travelogue have been
taken as the data of this research. The purpose was to reveal how the writer has tried to create a biased image of the Orient.
The method applied was van Dijk’s ideological square which is used to reveal forms of positive self and negative other. Upon
extracting these biased images, the rhetorical techniques used to create them were identified. Interestingly the findings suggest
that the travelogue was saturated with creations of binary oppositions revealing a biased and inaccurate description of the East.
Keywords: CDA, Ideological Square, Orientalism, Travelogue
1. Introduction
Language is one of man’s most remarkable attributes. Hundreds of different types of information are passed
through this phenomenon. Yet one does not have full control over all types of information. There is
information which people have active control over and others they have passive control over. Personal
information about one’s daily experiences and memories are things which people control but what the media
and the press report is not. This control is also context based; in some context people seem to have more
control over the language used and the language exposed, whereas in other circumstances the opposite is
the case. However, what can not be denied is that most information reported by the media and institutions
has to pass through a set of filters in order to be suitable for world wide distribution. These filters are mainly
defined by the institutions; political institutions, educational institutions, social groups, organizations and etc.
Therefore the information we receive is a distorted image of reality and not reality itself.
2. Review of Literature
2.1 Orientalism
During the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, geopolitical relations between the Eastern and Western
empires underwent massive realignment, and Orientalism emerged as an imperial administrative tool, as well
as a scholarly discipline and source of popular fantasy. An imperialist assumption of cultural superiority,
531
underwritten in equal parts by guilt and fascination, largely replaced the humbled admiration, even envy,
expressed by earlier Western travellers when faced with Ottoman splendour or the exquisite luxuries
obtainable only in the East. During the past thirty years scholars have begun to subject what is prejudicial in
this legacy to rigorous intellectual critique. Edward Said’s book, Orientalism has been a highly controversial
and influential book in this regard. As a founding text of post-colonial studies, Orientalism examines the
development of Western depictions of the Orient from the eighteenth century to the present day. Edward Said
casts his capacious intellectual net far and wide, offering a variety of perspectives on the discourses of
Orientalism in such disparate areas as literature, anthropology and the historical trajectory of colonial
administration.
Said (1976) defined Orientalism in several ways. He used the term Orientalism in three interdependent
senses: 1) Orientalism as an academic field 2) Orientalism as a style of thought based upon distinctions
made between the Orient and the Occident, and 3) Orientalism as a Western style for dominating,
restructuring, and having authority over the Orient. When talking about Orientalism as an academic field he
said:
The most readily accepted designation for Orientalism is an academic one, and indeed the label
still serves in a number of academic institutions. Anyone who teaches, writes about, or researches
the Orient and this applies whether the person is an anthropologist, sociologist, historian, or
philologist- either in its specific or its general aspects, is an Orientalist, and what he or she does is
Orientalism. Compared with Oriental studies or area studies, it is true that the term Orientalism is
less preferred by specialists today, both because it is too vague and general and because it
connotes the high-handed executive attitude of nineteenth-century and early-twentieth-century
European colonialism (Said, 1976, p. 2)
In addition, he gives a second meaning for the term and says that Orientalism is a style of thought based
upon an ontological and epistemological distinction made between the Orient and (most of the time) the
Occident (Said, 2003, p.3). Here what he means is that scholars of all fields have accepted that there is a
basic distinction between the East and the West and that they use this as their starting point in elaborating
theories, accounts, novels etc. His last definition of the Orient is more historically and materially defined than
the previous two. He argues that:
Taking the late eighteenth century as a very roughly defined starting point, Orientalism can be
discussed and analyzed as the corporate institutions for dealing with the Orient- dealing with it by
making statements about it, authorizing views of it, describing it, teaching it, settling it, ruling over it;
in short, Orientalism as a Western style dominating, restructuring, and having authority over the
Orient (Said, 1976,p.3).
Said has strongly criticized Orientalist authors like Kingslake about the distorted images they create through
their writing. However, his approach does seem to be based on a more social and political basis rather than a
linguistic one. His book Orientalism (1976) sheds light on numerous Orientalist writings. However he refrains
from providing detailed analysis of each writing and discussing what role language has played in creating the
ideologies within them. In other words, his work does not yield precise and detailed information on the
linguistic elements and techniques used by Orientalists. Therefore the aim in the current research is to bridge
this gap by adding a critical linguistic perspective to the topic Orientalism.
2.2 Critical Discourse Analysis
Critical discourse analysis, an interdisciplinary approach to the study of discourse, attempts to reveal
532
underlying ideologies which have become so opaque that we often take them for granted. At the basis of
CDA is the aim to view language use as a social practice. Language does not take place in a vacuum,
instead it resides in social and cultural frameworks. CDA puts this social context under meticulous scrutiny
and explores the links between textual structures and their function in social interaction. There is no one-to-
one correspondence between textual structures and social functions, therefore such an analysis is a complex
one, which works on multiple levels. When it comes to creating and maintaining differences in power
relations, the correspondence between the intricate mechanics of discursive practice and their social function
is often deliberately left opaque. The aim of CDA is to gear us with the right equipment to reduce this opacity.
There is a consensus among CDA practitioners that critical discourse analysis is not a single method, rather
it is an approach which consists of different perspectives and methods for studying the relationship between
language use and social context. Among these vast range of methods and perspectives there are few which
have gained world-wide recognition within the realm of CDA by scholars and students alike. For the purpose
of this study I will elaborate on the one approach which will be of primary focus for this research.
2.2.1 Van Dijk’s Socio-Cognitive Approach
Van Dijk’s work focuses on the production and reproduction of prejudices and racism in discourse and
communication. An important dimension incorporated in the socio-cognitive approach is that of the human
mind. Van Dijk criticizes all other approaches because he believes that other approaches do not focus
enough on the cognitive aspects of discourse and also because they are not social enough and tend to
ignore the social context of the discourse. He gives great importance to social representations such as
attitudes, beliefs, prejudices and stereotypes held by the society as a whole and not the more specific and
personal ones. He calls theses general and widely held beliefs social representations (SR) and believes that
they are acquired, used and changed through text and talk.
Van Dijk’s approach to CDA has three dimensions; social analysis, cognitive analysis and discourse
analysis. Discourse is meant as a communication event, including conversational interaction, written text, as
well as associated gestures, facework, typographical layout, images, and any other semiotic or multimedia
dimension of signification. Cognition here means both personal as well as social cognition, beliefs, and goals
as well as evaluations and emotions, and any other mental or memory structures, representations or
processes involved in discourse or interaction. Society is meant to include both the local, microstructures of
situated face-to-face interactions, as well as the more global, societal and political structures variously
defined in terms of groups, group-relations (such as dominance and inequality), movements, institutions,
organisations, social processes, political systems and more abstract properties of societies and cultures (van
Dijk, 2001, pp. 97-98).
According to van Dijk (1984):
Prejudice is not merely a characteristic of individual belief or emotions about social groups, but a
shared form of social representation in group members, acquired during processes of socialization
and transformed and enacted in social communication and interaction, Such ethnic attitudes have
social functions, e.g. to protect the interest of the in-group. Their cognitive structures and the
strategies of their use reflect these social functions.(p.13)
Van Dijk contributes a useful theoretical concept he calls the ideological square which encapsulates the twin
strategies of positive in group description and negative out group description (Hakam, 2009, p.37). In other
words, one of the main strategies of othering is accentuating negative points about the other meanwhile
minimizing positive ones about them. He illustrates his point with his famous ideological square:
533
Accentuate our positives Minimize our negatives
Minimize their positives Accentuate their negatives
Figure 1: Van Dijk’s Ideology Square (1998)
3.Methodology
3.1 Data
The data for the present research comprises of twenty seven pages from a 19th century travelogue written by
an English travel writer and historian; Alexander William Kingslake. Upon his venture to the East, he wrote
his first travelogue called Eothen; or traces of the East brought back home and latter published in
anonymously in 1844. Eothen has been criticized by Said (1976) for being a “pathetic catalogue of pompous
ethnocentrisms and tiringly nondescript accounts of the Englishman's East.” (p.193) He believes that Eothen
depicts anti-semitic, xenophobic and prejudiced elements. He also criticizes Kingslake for making
generalizations about a topic he has very little knowledge about: “Although Kinglake blithely confesses to no
knowledge of any Oriental language, he is not constrained by ignorance from making sweeping
generalizations about the Orient, its culture, mentality, and society.” (Said, 1976, p. 182)
3.2 Method of Analysis
Throughout the data, different forms of van Dijk’s ideological square (1998) were identified. In some parts
only one half of the ideological square was actually used and the other half was implied. It is possible that
only a part of the ideological square is realized in one text or context; sometimes the in-group is only
interested in showing its own positive properties, sometimes to show how bad the Others are. And
sometimes the in-group is only interested in emphasizing the Others negative properties thus implying its
own positive ones. In other places the whole square is concentrated in one sentence.
At the micro level, meticulous reading took place. The data collected through implementing van Dijk’s
model was read repetitively in order to identify the various sub-discourses in which the writer had tried to
create. This was a laborious and time consuming task as it was a pattern seeking rather than a pattern
imposing approach. Although a pattern seeking approach to data analysis requires much more effort,
patience and time, it does seem to offer the researcher more flexibility and objectivity than a pattern imposing
approach in which the researcher is required to work within a fixed and limited framework. The data was
delved upon without any criteria and patterns became more and more apparent upon every reading. After
much time and effort, the nature of the data yielded a number of categories. The categories we labeled as the
following:
 Sub-discourse of barbarism
 Sub-discourse of laziness
 Sub discourse of irrationality
 Sub-discourse of Oriental women
 Miscellaneous Extracts
534
In addition the rhetorical techniques used to create a distorted image of the East were identified for each
extract. Some of the rhetorical techniques which could be used are:
 Negative Lexicalization
 Hyperbole
 Generalization
 Comparison
 Polarization
 Irony
Given these methodological frameworks, I will try to draw attention to how the discourse of Orientalism is
created within Kingslake’s travelogue Eothen. An account of the analysis of the data and a discussion will be
presented. In the succeeding section, I have divided the discourse of Orientalism into its sub discourses and
brought a few extracts from the travelogue to demonstrate how these sub discourses are created within the
broader global discourse and simultaneously solidify that very same global discourse.
4. Data Analysis
4.1 Discourse of Barbarsim
The word barbarism or barbaric has been used with different meanings from past to present. Often it has
been used to refer to foreigners who are different from the indigenous inhabitants. According to the American
Heritage Dictionary (2009), it has 4 definitions:
 Primitive in culture and customs; uncivilized.

 Lacking refinement or culture; coarse.
 Characterized by savagery; very cruel. See Synonyms at cruel.
 Marked by the use or occurrence of barbarisms in spoken or written language.
(The American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language)
The definition which has been used widely in the discourse of Orientalism is the third one. Barbarian has
been used to refer to a violent person or group who commit cruel acts. The discourse of barbarism is a
recurring theme in Orientalist literature and present Western media. The preceding extracts from the
travelogue Eothen by Kingslake, which exemplify this discourse, have been presented and discussed.
We repeated the caution to our servants, and took anxious thought lest by any possibility we might
be cut off from some cherished objection of affection; were they quite sure that nothing had been
forgotten- that there was no fragrant dressing-case with its gold compelling letters of credit from
which we might be parting forever? (Kingslake, 2011, p.3)
The extract above uses the rhetorical technique of negative lexicalization. The East and its appearance are
equated with death. The words caution and anxious thought show that Kingslake and his team are truly
worried about entering the Eastern side of the border. The words parting forever reveal that they equate the
East with death and believe that they will be killed.
In the next extract the writer refers to the vast amount of weapons carried by the portmanteau: “This
cincture enclosed a whole bundle of weapons; no man bore less than one brace of immensely long pistols,
and a yataghan (or cutlass), with a dagger or two of various shapes and sizes. most of these arms were
inlaid with silver, and highly burnished, so that they contrasted shiningly with the decayed grandeur of the
535
garments to which they were attached (this carefulness of his arms is a point of honour with the Osmanlee,
who never allows his bright yataghan to suffer from his own adversity)” (Kingslake, 2011, p.4). Hyperbole and
negative lexicalization have been used to exaggerate the amount of weapons carried by the Turkish luggage
men; whole bundle of weapons, immensely long pistol, yataghan (or cutlass) and with a dagger or two with
various sizes, decayed and adversity making the Orient appear as violent and barbaric as possible.
This technique (discourse of barbarism) is still being used by the media at the moment. Carlos Duarodo’s
photo has gained international acclaim at a very rapid pace. In his photo he shows two men dressed in
Eastern attire torturing a man who is lying on the floor. These two men are surrounded with hundred’s of men
and women with Western features and attire who have turned their backs to the situation. The caption of the
photo goes: “The world is a dangerous place, not because of those who do evil, but because of those who
look on and do nothing” What this caption and photo imply is that it is the Eastern people who are barbaric
and violent and it is the duty of western people to prevent it. This type of discourse justifies invasion of
western governments into foreign countries in the name of liberation but with the intent of power and control.
This collective notion of barbaric Turks has its roots in medieval Western literature too. Francois Rabelais
who was a major renaissance writer, is best known for his work Gargantua and Pantagrue (1532). In it, the
writer depicts one of the first stereotypical images of Turks as violent cannibal eaters of the Christian race. In
a major scene of the novel images of Turks roasting a Christian on a fire waiting for him to be cooked and
thus eaten are displayed. This violent image of Turks, later showed traces in 16th century literature. This
image had also entered the dictionaries and thus the obsolete meaning of the term Turk was given as:
derogatory a violent, brutal, or domineering person (Collins English Dictionary). It should be mentioned that
the term turcophobia which means hostility, intolerance or racism against the Turkish people, Turkish culture,
or Turkey (previously the Ottoman Empire) has been coined in order to fulfil the needs of an omnipresence
feeling of hatred towards Turks.
4.2 Discourse of Laziness
With attention to the vast number of Western literature regarding the East, it can be inferred that Oriental
people have often been referred to as lazy and unable to manage their own lives. Terms such as idle,
passive, inactive and slow have all been employed for Eastern concepts. One item which has played a big
role in creating the discourse of laziness in Western literature is the Hookah or Shishe which is a pipe
smoked in most Eastern countries. Western artists have continuously depicted scenes from the Harem and
elsewhere where the people are reclining unhurriedly and enjoying their cup of tea and their pipe during the
day. As Ivan Davidson Kalmar states in her article The Houkah in the Harem, On Smoking and Orientalist
Art, such idleness was not without its appeal to the civilized inhabitants of the West, who were familiar with
complaints, voiced in every generation from Rousseau's to beyond Freud's, about the way modern society
prevents us from taking time to smell the roses. (Kalmar, 2011)
The pipe was used in Western Orientalist art to associate the Orient with a sensuous that was very
slow. Oriental sensuality was seen as simply passive and inactive. The term pipe has been used three times
in the first twenty eight pages of Kingslake’s travelogue. Two out of three times it has been collocated with
the words calm and tranquil which reflect idleness. In the next extract the writer refers to the Houkah which
has been offered to him by the Sultan’s servants:
Soon the coffee-bearers appeared, every man carrying separately his tiny cup in a small metal
stand; and presently to each of us there came a pipe-bearer, who first rested the bowl of the
tchibouque at a measured distance on the floor, and then, on this axis, wheeled round the long
cheery stick, and gracefully presented it on half-bended knee; already the well-kindled fire was
glowing secure in the bowl, and so, when I pressed the amber up to mine, there was no coyness to
conquer; the willing fume came up, and answered my slightest sigh, and followed softly every
536
breath inspired, till it touched me with some faint sense and understanding of Asiatic contentment.
Asiatic contentment! Yet scarcely, perhaps, one hour before I had been wanting my bill, and ringing
for waiters, in a shrill and busy hotel. (Kingslake, 2011, p.5)
The above excerpt immediately ends with an evaluative line which tries to highlight the different degrees of
activity of the East and West. This contrast is created with the word yet used to show the opposing habits of
the East and West. Hence, a polar distinction is formed.
In the following extracts the pipe and tchibouque has been collocated with words like tranquillity and
permanence, patiently and the verb wait which reflect laziness: “So I bought me a horse, and a "pipe of
tranquillity" ” (Kingslake, 2011, p.24) and “then laying fire to his tchibouque he "sits in permanence," and
patiently waits to obtain "the best price that can be got in an open market."”(Kingslake, 2011, p.25) Kingslake
(2011) else where says:
There he lives at his pleasure, reposing in the tranquillity of that true home (the home of his
ancestors) which the saddle seems to afford him, and drawing from his pipe the calm pleasures of
his "own fireside," or else dashing sudden over the earth, as though for a moment he felt the mouth
of a Turcoman steed, and saw his own Scythian plains lying boundless and open before him. (p.
11)
Words such as tranquillity, calm, reposing, permanence and patiently waits create an air of idleness. He uses
these to refer to the Tartars behaviour in general and not to one specific tartar.
4.3 Discourse of civilization
The terms civilized and uncivilized are prevalent in Orientalist text. However, the meanings of the terms are
highly controversial. The following definitions are given in a modern dictionary:
Civilized:
 Describes a society or country that has a highly developed system of government, culture and way of life
and that treats the people who live there fairly.
 If a person or their behaviour is civilized, they are polite and behave in a calm and reasonable way
Uncivilized:
 not civilized, especially below the usual standards of Western society:
(Cambridge Dictionary Online)
This reveals a very intriguing fact about how people perceive the term civilized and uncivilized in the English
language. The term uncivilized is used for any country or any region which is below the perceived standards
of the West. In other words, the Western civilization is used as norm basis for measuring what can and what
can not be considered as civilized. Edward (1976) says:
There has been so massive and calculatedly aggressive attack on the contemporary societies of
the Arab and Muslims for their backwardness, lack of democracy, and abrogation of women’s rights
that we simply forget that such notions as modernity, enlightenment and democracy are by no
means simple and agreed-upon concepts that one either does or does not find, like Easter eggs in
the living room. (p .xiv)
In the next extract, upon traversing the border from West to East the following sentence is given: “The latter
then advanced and asked once more if we had done with the civilized world, held forth his hand. I met it with
537
mine, and there was an end to Christendom for many a day to come.” (Kingslake, 2011, p. 3) Here the writer
upon crossing the border says that the world of civilization which he refers to as Christendom finished. His
implication is that the West which he generalizes using the religious word Christendom is civilized and the
other side of the border which are the Islamic lands are uncivilized. By this, he classifies the world into two
opposing categories.
According to Western perspective these terms and terms like civilization do have agreed-upon definitions.
In countries civilised according to the European plan the work of trying to persuade tribunals is
almost all performed by a set of men, the great body of whom very seldom do anything else; but in
Turkey this division of labour has never taken place, and every man is his own advocate.
(Kingslake, 2011, p.24)
In the preceding extract, the author draws a direct contrast using the conjunction but to compare Eastern and
Western approaches to advocacy. The writer indirectly refers to the presence of expertise in Europe and lack
of expertise in Asia. He says that in Europe a fixed set of men perform the act of advocacy because it is their
job. However in Turkey, everybody is his own advocate and therefore has to have a strong sense of rhetoric.
The writer refers to the European approach as a civilized one, thereby implying that the Eastern one is
uncivilized.
4.4 Discourse of Irrationality
Said claims that by constructing the Orient as culturally static and backward, eternally uniform and incapable
of self-definition, the Occident as its established opposite, is infused with a secure sense of its own cultural
and intellectual superiority. He believes that this is to justify their imperial dominance over the East. Here as
with many other Orientalist writings, Easterners have often been referred to as irrational and emotional and
unable to think clearly about their lives and their future. The rhetorical technique of contrast is used above
and a dividing line has been drawn between the Europeans and the Easterners using the word on the other
hand.
Depicting Easterners as beings lacking the ability to make right decisions for themselves gives others (the
West) the right to make decisions on their behalf. The next two extracts from Eothen are good testimony to
this type of discourse: “But presently there, issued from the postern a group of human beings- beings with
immortal souls, and possibly some reasoning faculties.” (Kingslake, 2011, p. 3) And the second:
Thus poor, dear, patient Reason would have fought her slow battle against Asiatic prejudice, and I
am convinced that she would have established the possibility (and perhaps even the propriety) of
harnessing horses in a hundred and fifty years. (Kingslake, 2011, p.18)
In the extract above, the word possibly acts as a hedge. The author is trying to emphasize the point that he is
not sure whether Easterners even have some form of logic. In the second extract the writer refers to reason
as being poor and patient and therefore saying that patient, will have a difficult time trying to influence the
rigid minds of irrational Easterners.
4.5 Discourse of Oriental Women
The Islamic covering has been an all time controversial issue in the West. Many people associate the Hijab
with Islam unaware of the fact that covering of the head is not specific to just Islam but is also advised in
Christianity. In the holy Bible, the first Epistle to the Corinthians, chapter 11 reads:
538
But I would have you know that the head of every man is Christ and the head of the woman is the
man, and the head of Christ is God. Every man praying or prophesying with his head covered,
disgraces his head. But every woman praying or prophesying with her head uncovered disgraces
her head, for it is the same as if she were shaven. For if a woman is not covered, let her be shaven.
But if it is a disgrace for a woman to have her hair cut off or her head shaved, let her cover her
head. A man indeed ought not to cover his head, because he is the image and glory of God. But
woman is the glory of man. For man was not created for woman, but woman for man. This is why
the woman ought to have a sign of authority over her head, because of the angels.
This clearly shows that women in Christianity are also advised to cover their heads especially during prayer.
This is why Mary, the mother of Jesus, is always depicted in Christian art wearing the veil.
There is also a misconception about what the term “hijab” actually means. Many confuse the term with the
Arabic word “nigab” which is used to cover the whole face except the eyes. Hijab from the root hajaba
meaning to cover, conceal, hide, is a complex notion encompassing action and apparel. It can include
covering the face, or not. It includes lowering the gaze with the opposite sex, and applies to men as well, who
must lower their gaze and cover from navel to knee.
There is an all time misconception that the veil women wear in Islamic countries is a symbol of their
oppression. As is clear from the verses of the bible, the explicit purpose of the Christian woman's head
covering, as stated by Paul, is that it is a sign of man's authority over woman. The veil in Christianity is a
symbol of the man’s authority over the women. The purpose of Islamic hijab however, is modesty. Therefore
the concept that the veil is oppressive is born out of this interpretation. Kingslake’s narrative carries that
negative stance towards the hijab too: “The unveiled faces of women still shone in the light of day.”
(Kingslake, 2011, p.2) The term unveiled has been collocated with the words shone, light and day.
The extract below can be divided into two sections. The first is a description of a muslim women with the
veil. Here the writer describes her as without any particular identity when he says of her self you see nothing.
He also refers to her eyes as dark and luminous which just stare at you: “Of her very self you see nothing
except the dark, luminous eyes that stare against your face and the tips of the painted fingers depending like
rose-buds from out of the blank bastions of the fortress.”(Kingslake, 2011, p.23)
The second part describes her when she takes her veil off. Here the mood changes and the writer shows
how splendid and beautiful she is. The contrast between the word dark in the first part and the word shine
after taking off the veil is evidence to the writers negative perception towards the veil. The term safe from
requires an object and the object presented here is the Mussalmans. The word Mussalamans subsumes a
large population who here are referred to as being perilous. The two parts taken together, form a clear polar
distinction.
She turns and turns again, and carefully glances around her on all sides, to see that she is safe
from the eyes of Mussalamans, and then suddenly withdrawing the yashmak she shines upon your
heart and soul with all the pomp and might of her beauty. (Kingslake, 2011, p.23)
The writer is trying to speak favorably of women who do not wear veil as to those who wear one. On a global
scale, the writer is questioning the cultural value of the veil in Eastern life and is therefore imposing his own
modern cultural beliefs to his audience.
5. Conclusion & Discussion
Through out the study, the dominant sub discourses became apparent. This does not necessary mean that
no other sub-discourses make up the discourse of Orientlism but rather that the ones mentioned in this
539
research are the ones which were prevalent in the data. Five sub-discourses became apparent while
analysing the text.
The first being the sub-discourse of barbarism in which the East and its people are perceived as violent
and lethal as possible. This type of representation naturally would create a sense of hatred and fear towards
the Eastern people and would justify any form of violence against them as a form of defence.
The second, was the laziness in which Eastern people are depicted as people who just rest and enjoy the
pleasures of life. The implication of this sub discourse is that the Eastern people can not work to rule their
own country and state and therefore need the help of the industrious West to govern it.
The third sub discourse is the discourse of civilization or put in better words lack of civilization. The topic
of what should and what should not be referred to as civilized is a controversial issue. However usually this is
presented as a clear cut concept in Western literature. In Eothen the Eastern cities and the manner of the
people have been referred to as being backward and uncivilized; therefore creating a perfect and civilized
West.
The fourth sub discourse is irrationality. Through this, the Eastern people have been known to lack logical
thinking and common sense. They are expected to react according to their desires and emotions and not
their minds and when they are refereed to having some logic, it is with much hesitation. In such an era where
science and scientific thinking plays a big role in influencing the people, referring to the Oriental mind as
being “abhorrent” undermines anything the Eastern people might claim as being true.
The fifth sub discourse is the discourse of Oriental women. Rarely can you read a Western travelogue and
not come along the concept of Eastern women. Eastern women have been stereotyped as being misused,
sensual and deprived of their rights. Their Islamic clothing has been regularly referred to as being
inappropriate. This type of discussion on women and women rights in itself creates a kind of pity for Oriental
women. The West perceives that Oriental women are suffering and that it is their duty to do something about
it. Of course we cannot deny that there are women whose rights are clearly being disregarded. But
generalizing this to the East, and portraying Western women as liberal is what accentuates the ideology
inherent within it.
The purpose of the research was not only identifying the type of sub discourse inherent within the
travelogue, but also clarifying how these sub-discourses were created; that is, which rhetorical techniques
were used. The chart below shows all the rhetorical techniques which were used in the ideologically laden
excerpts.
Generalization
25
20 Negative
15 Lexicalization
10 Polarization
5
0 Hyperbole
Irony
Generalization
Lexicalization
Polarization
Hyperbole
Comparison
Negative
Comparison
Irony
Figure 2 Rhetorical Strategies
540
As is clear from the chart above, the most common rhetorical strategy used was negative lexicalization
followed by polarization, hyperbole, generalization and comparison and irony respectively.
The present research has the following implications:
This study shows that the information around us should not be taken for granted, rather they should be read
with a more critical eye. Critical thinking can be understood as a way of becoming aware of and taking control
of one's own thinking processes in order to think more effectively. It is consciously directing one's thinking to
make it more rational, clear, accurate, and consistent. Currently, the general population of societies are
deficient in the abilities or dispositions that would allow them to discern certain kinds of inaccuracies,
distortions, and even falsehoods. People generally accept the misrepresentation they see on television and in
books. In order to achieve this ideology free haven, critical thinking ought to be taught to students from an
early age as high schools play a fundamental role in shaping students perspectives towards cultural issues.
Students should be privileged with courses which increase their knowledge on such issues as ideology,
cultural discrepancies and mediation policies of the media. Naturally teachers and lecturers hold a huge
responsibility in raising this awareness among their students. A critical pedagogy urges teachers to help
students become more sceptical toward commonly accepted truisms and to evaluate the benefit such claims
would have on the power structures of the society. Such pedagogy would not only reduce conflict between
minority races and enhance a brotherhood commitment among the different nations but also would increase
the humanizing affect in societies, would restrict pretence in the media.
Reference
American Heritage Dictionary. (2009) . Retrieved from http://www. thefreedictionary. com/Barbarism

Cambridge Dictionary Online. Retrieved from http://dictionary.cambridge.org/
Collins English Dictionary (Online) Retrieved from http://www. thefreedictionary. com/_/misc/HarperCollinsProducts.aspx?English
Rabelais, F. (2006). Gargantua and Pantagruel. London: Penguin
Kingslake, A. (2011). Eothen. Retrieved September 2011 from http://www. manybooks.net/ titles/kinglakeetext95eothn10.html
Hakam, J. (2009). The ‘cartoons controversy’: a Critical Discourse Analysis of English-language Arab newspaper discourse. Discourse
and Society. London: Sage Publication
Kalmar, I. (2011 ). The houkah in the harem: On smoking and Orientalist art. Retrieved December 2011 from
http://www.library.utoronto.ca/ moorish/smoking/ kalmar%20 houkah.htm
Said, E. (1976). Orientalism. London: Penguin
Van Dijk, T.A. (2001). Critical discourse analysis. In Hamilton.H, Schriffrin, D & Tannen, D. (Eds) The Handbook of Discourse Analysis.
Oxford: Blackwell pp.352-371
Van Dijk, T.A. (1984). Prejudice in discourse . Amsterdam: Benjamins
541

A Vector Error Correction Modelling of the Composition of Government Spending and the
Real Exchange Rate in Nigeria
Victor E. Oriavwote
Department of Arts and Social Sciences

Delta State Polytechnic, Otefe-Oghara
Ben U. Omojimite
(Corresponding author)
Department of Economics, Delta State University, Abraka
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.543
Abstract: The main objective of this study has been to empirically investigate the relationship between government expenditure
and the Real Exchange Rate in Nigeria . Using data covering 1970 to 2010, the Vector Error Correction and Cointegration tests
results established a long run relationship among the components of government expenditure and the Real Exchange Rate. The
result showed that government investment has delivered more productivity gains in the non-tradable sector than in the tradable
sector, while an increase in government consumption increased the relative demand for non-tradable. The government should
thus shift attention to the expansion of the tradable sector.
Key words: Government Consumption, Government Investment, Real Exchange Rate and Vector Error Correction
1. Introduction
The Real Exchange Rate (RER) is a significant factor in the development process of an economy as both its
level and stability are important in increasing exports and private investment. While misalignment of the RER
can be an undervaluation or overvaluation, overvaluation has been the common case in developing countries
(Edwards, 1989). An overvalued RER reduces profits in the tradable goods sector, thereby reducing
investment in the sector. This has a negative effect on export and the trade balance. Persistent overvaluation
of the Real Effective Exchange Rate (REER) may also lead to currency crisis (Xiaopu, 2002). The increasing
overvaluation of the exchange rate that began in Sub-Sahara Africa in the early 1980s contributed to the poor
performance of the current account balance in the region (Ghura and Grennes, 1993). Thus as noted by
Mungule, 2004), the RER does not only affect the general performance and international competitiveness,
but also different sectors of the economy including foreign trade flows, balance of payments, external debt
crisis, employment, structure of production, consumption and allocation of resources in the economy.
In Nigeria, the RER has been an important player in the growth of the economy. Given the import
dependent nature of the Nigerian industrial sector, the continued depreciation of the naira exchange rate vis-
à-vis the currencies of other major trading partners meant that more resources would be needed to increase
domestic output. A depreciating Exchange Rate in the absence of domestic sources of inputs coupled with
inadequate infrastructure has raised the cost of production in Nigeria, which in turn made locally produced
goods less competitive compared to imported goods. This has reduced the benefits of cheaper exports
expected from the depreciation of the currency. Similarly, the overdependence of the economy on imported
capital goods implies that a depreciating exchange rate would crowd out the marginal investment as a result
of high investment cost (Nnanna, Englama and Odoko, 2004). This depreciation of the naira exchange rate in
543
Nigeria has resulted in a shift in finance to the tradable sub-sector. In his view, Obadan (2006) identified the
factors that lead to instability in the RER in Nigeria to include amongst others round-tripping, weak production
base, import dependent production structure, weak non-oil export earnings, expansionary fiscal and
monetary policies, fluctuations in crude oil earnings, unguided trade liberalization (which include removal in
diesel and kerosene subsidies or reduction of subsidy in Petroleum Motor Spirit). In addition, the continuous
depreciation of the naira has resulted in a monumental increase in the naira cost of executing government
projects. This has led to a significant funding gap and sometimes inability to complete them. To be able to
fund its projects, government has often resorted to expansionary monetary and fiscal measures that further
put pressure on the naira exchange rate.
The question that comes to mind here is: what is the relationship between the composition of government
spending and the RER in Nigeria? The objective of this paper is thus to assess the relationship between
government expenditure and the RER in Nigeria using the Vector Error Correction Model (VECM).
Specifically, the differential impact of both government investment and government consumption in Nigeria
will be assessed in this paper. This distinction is important because our aim is to point out that government
consumption and government investment may be expected to have different impacts on the RER in Nigeria.
While an increase in government consumption is typically modelled as increasing the relative demand for
nontradeable and thereby leading to real appreciation, a long run increase in public investment that delivers
productivity gain in the tradables sector may generate real appreciation through the so-called Balassa-
Samuelson mechanism. If public investment disproportionately raises productivity in the nontradables sector,
it may lead to real deprecation. However, if productivity is increased in both sectors there is no long-run
impact on the relative price of non-tradable and the RER (Vahagn and Philip, 2008). Other than this
introductory section, the rest of the paper is divided into four sections. The second section is on the
theoretical framework. This is followed by the third section which reviews empirical literature. The fourth
section is on the econometric procedure and the fifth section concludes the paper.
2. Theoretical Issues
This section encompasses an adapted version of the standard two-sector small open economy model
(Obstfeld and Rogoff, 1996 and Vahagn and Philip, 2008). The production functions for traded and non-
traded goods are respectively.
YT = A*TF(LT,KT) = (ATZαZ)LTαL KTαT (1)
YN = A NG(LN,KN) = (ANZ )LN KN
* βZ βL βT (2)
Where L and K stand for labor and capital, while Z stands for the public capital stock. It was assumed that
total factor productivity in each sector is a composite of a sector- specific term (A*T, A*N) and the level of
public capital. Accordingly, productivity in both sectors is enhanced by a larger stock of public capital but the
impact was allowed to be potentially different across sectors αz ≠ βz). It was assume that αL + αK = 1, but
βL + βK < 1. A fixed factor of production (normalized to 1) was incorporated in the non-traded sector such
that the production function in that sector exhibits diminishing returns to labour and capital. The price of the
traded good is equal to world price of the good and is normalized to 1, while the price of non-traded goods is
PN.
The accumulation functions for the private capital stocks in the traded and non-traded sectors are given by
KT = 1KT -δKT (3)
KN = 1 N -ΔkN
K (4)
Where 1 denotes the level of gross investment and δ is the depreciation rate. The public capital stock evolves
according to
z = IZ - δZ (5)
544
It was assumed that private capital formation in the traded and non-traded sectors only requires the traded
good as an input, while public capital formation uses only the non-traded good as an input. The
representative household has an instantaneous utility.
CT1-Y CNY
C = (6)
(1 – ϒ)1-y ϒϒ
The implication here is that optimal household expenditure shares on traded and non-traded goods are fixed
at (1- ϒ) and ϒ respectively, with a unit elasticity of the relative consumption of non-tradables in relation to
the relative price of non-tradeables.
The welfare-based price index consistent with equation (6) is
P = PNϒ (7)
It was also assumed that the price of the non-traded good in the rest of the world is fixed and normalized to 1,
such that changes in P correspond to changes in the RER.
By assumption, the government runs a balanced budget, levying lump-sum taxes equal to the value of total
government consumption and government investment.
T = GT + PN(GN + IZ) (8)
Where GT, GN are the levels of public consumption of the traded and non-traded goods respectively and IZ is
the level of public investment.
Households own the domestic stocks of capital in the traded and non-traded sectors. There are no inter-
sectoral or international capital adjustment costs, so that the return on capital is equal to the exogenously
fixed world interest rate. In addition, households own the fixed factor in the non-traded sector and so receive
the income accruing to that factor (the residual claimant on profits in the non-traded sector). Accordingly,
households face the following budget constraint
AB = RB + r(KT,KN) + w(LT, LN – (INK + ITK) – CT – PNCN + ПN – T (9)
Where β is an international bond that pays the fixed real world interest r (in terms of tradables). ПN = (1 – βL
– βK)PNYn is the aggregate profit in the non-traded sector and T is the tax burden.
For simplicity, it is assumed that the aggregate labour supply is inelastic. Labor is perfectly inter-sectorally
mobile, such that the equilibrium in the labor market is
LN + LT = L (10)
The equilibrium in the non-traded goods sector is

YN = CN+ GN + IZ (11)
While the trade balance is determined by
TB= YT - CT – GT - (INK + ITK ) (12)
Equations (1) to (12) together with the first-order conditions for private consumption and private investment
and the profits of the non-traded sector form the system.
The primary interest is in the long-run behavior of the RER. Accordingly, the steady-state solution of the
model was given attention. In order to obtain an analytical solution, it was assumed that there is no
545
depreciation. A benchmark steady state in which the levels of net foreign assets and government
consumption are zero (in order to obtain a closed – form solution) was analyzed. The system was log-
linearized around this benchmark, in order to examine the sensitivity of the steady-state RER to shifts in the
steady state values of the exogenous variables.
In the benchmark steady state, the relative price of non-traded goods is
1‐βk
PN = ПLN 1‐BL‐BKαZ β Z
1 – BL ZI –αK 1 – βk
(13)
In the next stage, the system was log-linearized around this steady state and a solution was solved for. The
equation of primary interest is the one governing the RER, p = ϒpN, with the relative price of non-traded
goods given by
1‐βK (14)
PN = ‐AN + 1 – α  AT + 0 (rB + [GN – GT] + 1Z )
K
Where hatted variables denote percentage deviations from the steady-state values. Equation (14) shows that
an improvement in productivity in the non-traded sector generates real depreciation and a decline in the
relative price of non-tradables, while an increase in productivity in the traded sector generates real
appreciation and an increase in the relative price of non-tradable, where these forces operate according to
the classic Balassa Samuelson mechanism. The other key coefficients are
and
(15)

O = αL (1 – BL – BK) (1 – Y)
> O
αL (1 – ϒ) + BLϒ
(16)
(1 – BK )αZ – (1 – αK)βZ
αL
Since 0> 0, the level and composition of spending matters for the RER. In particular, a country that is a
long-run creditor (β >0 ) experiences real appreciation, since the interest income on the creditor position
enables an increase in the steady state level of consumption. In the traded sector, this translates into a long-
run trade deficit (TB = - rβ ), while the increase in demand for the non-traded good generates real
appreciation due to the presence of the fixed factor in the non-traded sector. Moreover, an increase in
government consumption that is concentrated on non-traded goods ([GN – GT] > 0) also generates real
appreciation by shifting the composition of aggregate consumption towards the non-traded sector.
Finally, the effect of an increase in the public capital stock on the RER is given by the coefficient p, which
has an ambiguous sign. If an increase in public capital has a symmetric impact on productivity in both sectors
(αZ = βz) and both sectors have similar capital shares (αK = βK), the RER is unaffected by the level of the
public capital stock. If αZ = βZ but the non-traded sector is less capital intensive (αK > βK), then an increase in
public capital generates real appreciation, by the same logic as a symmetric improvement in the sector
specific productivity terms AT and AN. However, even if αK > βK, it is possible to construct scenarios in which
an increase in the public capital stock generates real depreciation if productivity in the non-traded sector is
546
more sensitive to the level of public capital than is productivity in the traded sector ((αZ = βZ). accordingly, the
sign of the relation between public investment and the RER is ultimately an empirical matter.
3. Empirical Literature
Edwards (1989) pioneered the fundamental models of the determination of RER for developing countries.
Edwards started by developing a theoretical model of the RER determination and then estimated its
equilibrium value for panel of 12 developing countries. He used the conventional cointegration tests to
analyze the relative importance of real and nominal variables in the process of RER determination in the
short and long run. The study found that in the long run only real variables affect the long run equilibrium
RER. In the short run, however, RER variability was explained by both real and nominal actors. More
precisely, the most important factors identified in this study as affecting the equilibrium RER are the terms of
trade and composition of government spending, the control of foreign exchange and the movement of goods
(openness), technical progress and capital inflow. An increase in government consumption, capital inflows,
terms of trade and a decrease in technological progress and openness appreciated the RER.
Ghura and Grennes (1993) used a panel of Sub-Saharan countries, to investigate the determinants of the
RER and the impact of RER misalignment on economic performance. They employed a classical regression
methodology and found that the RER appreciated with (i) an improvement in the terms of trade, (ii) a capital
inflow, (iii) a decrease in openness, (iv) an increase in excess of domestic credit, and (v) an improvement in
technology. The Study also found that nominal devaluation depreciated the RER. With regard to the impact
of RER misalignment and variability, it found that RER misalignment and variability negatively affected
income growth, exports, imports, investment and savings.
Elbadawi (1994) developed a model of the determination of the long run equilibrium RER. The
fundamental determinants of the long run equilibrium RER in this model included the terms of trade,
openness (a proxy for commercial policy), the level of net capital flows relative to GDP, the share of
government spending in GDP and the rate of growth of exports (a productivity measure). Elbadawi
empirically estimated his model on annual data for Chile, Ghana and India. The findings of this study
suggested that, in all three countries, the RER and all the fundamentals identified in the model were non-
stationary and cointegrated.
MacDonald (1998) presented a reduced form model of the RER to re-examine the determinants of RER in
a long run setting. His model features productivity differentials, terms of trade effects, fiscal balances, net
foreign assets and real interest rate differentials as key fundamental determinants of the RER. Using
multivariate cointegration methods, he found evidence of a significant and sensible long run relationship,
indicating that the fundamentals mentioned above have an important and significant bearing on the
determination of both long and short run RER. Mkenda (2001) analyzed the main determinants of the RER in
Zambia. The study presented an illustrative model based on the three-good production structure and
employed cointegration analysis in estimating the long run determinants of the RER for imports and exports,
and of the internal RER. The results of this study provided evidence that (i) a decline in the terms of trade
and government consumption depreciated the RER for imports, while an increase in investment share of
GDP appreciated the RER for imports; (ii) a decrease in the terms of trade, an increase in central bank
reserves and trade taxes appreciated the RER for exports in the long run; (iii) in the long run, the internal
RER was strengthened by a decrease in the terms of trade, an increase in investment share and the rate of
growth of real GDP (A proxy for technological progress); (iv) in the short run, however, aid and openness
depreciated the RER indices.
Joyce and Kamas (2003) re-investigated the factors that determined the RER in Argentina, Colombia and
Mexico, distinguishing between real and nominal determinants. The study employed cointegration analysis,
variance decompositions and impulse response analysis. Cointegration results established that the RER has
an equilibrium relationship with real variables (terms of trade, capital flows, productivity and government
547
share of GDP). It excluded nominal variables (nominal exchange rate and money) and central bank
intervention. In addition, an increase in all the real variables in their model appreciated the RER,The variance
decomposition showed that the terms of trade and productivity, among other real variables, explained much
of the variation in the RER. In the short run, however, the nominal exchange rate accounted for most of the
variation in the RER of all three countries. Finally, the impulse response analysis revealed that shocks to
nominal variables have only transitory effects on the RER, thus consistent with theoretical predictions.
Coricelli and Jazbec (2004) analyzed the phenomenon of RER appreciation that has characterized 19
transitional economies, which included a group of nine Central and Eastern European countries, three Baltic
countries and seven former Soviet Union Countries. They used Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) regression to
show that the RER is affected by the adverse initial conditions and structural reforms only in the first five
years of the transition process. After this period, their results provided evidence that productivity differential,
the share of non-tradable consumption in total private consumption and real government consumption
negatively affected the RER, thus contributing to the real appreciation of the currencies of these economies.
However, the Balassa-Samuelson effect (productivity differentials) seemed to dominate the determination of
the RER in this study.
Mungule(2004) investigated the determinants of RER in Zambia. He used the RER as a function of terms
of trade, capital inflow, closeness of the economy and excess supply of domestic credit. Using the
cointegration technique, he discovered that the REER and the fundamental determinants have a long run
equilibrium relationship. Vahagn and Philip (2008) investigated the composition of government spending and
the RER. They developed a two sector open economy model in which an increase in government
consumption is associated with real appreciation. Using panel data covering 1980 to 2004 and the
cointegration technique, their result showed that government consumption typically leads to real appreciation.
They also found that government investment has no significant impact on the RER for the set of EMU
member countries.
4. Econometric Procedure
VAR Modelling and the Cointegration Approach
Vector autoregression (VAR) modelling and the cointegration approach provide not only an estimation
methodology but also explicit procedures for testing the long-run relationship among variables suggested by
economic theory.
According to the Granger Representation Theorem (Engle and Granger, 1987), if a P*1 vector, Xt,
generated by (1-L) Xt = d + c(L) et, is cointegrated, then there exists a vector auto regression (VAR), an error
correction, as well as a moving average (MA) representation of Xt. A set of variables Xt, which is
cointegrated, refers to the existence of long-run equilibrium relationships among economic variables
(Mungule, 2004). That is, though each series may be non-stationary, there may be stationary linear
combinations of the variables. The basic idea is that individual economic time series variables wander
considerably, but certain linear combinations of the series do not move too far apart from each other. In
economic term, there is a long-run relationship among the variables.
The most common test for cointegration is the two-step procedure of Engle and Granger (1987) which
performs well for univariate tests. The first step is to fit the cointegration regression, an ordinary least squares
(OLS) estimation of the static model. The second step is to conduct a unit root test on the estimated
residuals. To test for cointegration is just to test for the presence of a unit root in the residuals of the
cointegrating regression. If the null of a unit root is rejected, then cointegration exists. However, the long-run
parameter of the cointegrating vector estimated from this approach can be severely biased in finite samples.
An improved procedure of cointegration test is that which allows for more than one cointegrating vector, as
suggested in Johansen (1998) and Johansen and Juselius (1990).
548
Following Johansen and Juselius (1990), let the p variables under scrutiny follow a vector autoregression
of order p (VAR(p)) as below.
Xt c + P1Xt-1 + … + PpXt-p + et (1)
Where Xt = n x 1 vector of economic variables in the model; c = n x 1 vector of constants or drift terms are
innovations of this process and are assumed to be drawn from p- dimensional independently, identically
distributed (i.i.d) Gaussian distributions with covariance G; and Xp+1 ,. .. X0 are fixed.
Where;
Pi = nxn matrixes of time invariant coefficients, I 1, . . .p, and
e = nx1 vector of i.i.d. errors with a positive covariance matrix.
Let  represent the first difference filter. The equation can be reparameterised into the equivalent form
presented below

P‐1

∆Xt = c + PXt-p + ∑ i∆Xt-i+ t (2)
I ‐ 0
p
i
Where t = - + ∑ Pj, for, I = 1, …, P – 1-,  + ∑Pj
i
J ‐ 1

The coefficient matrix P contains information about the long-run relationships among variables. Since et is
stationary, the number of ranks for matrix P determines how many linear combination of Xt are stationary. If 0
< Rank (P) = r<p, there exists r cointegrating vectors that make the linear combinations of Xt to become
stationary. In that case, P can be factored as “a” and “b”, with “a” and “b” being matrixes. Here “b” is a
cointegrating vector that has the property that bXt is stationary even though Xt itself is non-stationary and “a”
then contains the adjustment parameters.
Based on an unrestricted estimation that is parameterized in terms of levels and differences, Johansen
(1988) proposed likelihood ratio statistics for testing the number of cointegrating vectors. First we must solve
the eigenvalues of |eSpp – SpoS00-1Sop| =0, where S00 is the moment matrix of the residuals from the ordinary
least squares (OLS) regression of DXton Xt-1. . . . Xt-p1; Spp is the residual moment matrix from the OLS
regression of Xt p on Xt-1 ……………… Xt-p+1+; and SOP is the cross product moment matrix. The
cointegrating vector, b, is solved out as the eigenvectors associated with the r largest statistically significant
eigenvalues derived using two test statistics, “maximum eigenvalue statistics” and “trace statistics”. The first
statistic tests the hypothesis that there are r=s cointegrating vectors against the alternative of r = s + 1 by
calculating the maximum likelihood test statistics as –T In(1-1s+1), where T is the sample size and 1s+1 is an
estimated eigenvalue. The second statistic tests the hypothesis that there exists at most, r cointegrating
vectors. If the test is performed by calculating trace statistics.
-T p In{ 1- i *)/ (1 - i)}

∑
I = r + 1
Where i* are eigenvalues obtained from cointegration analysis assuming there is no linear trend.
Thus, a proper assessment of the composition ofgovernment spending and the RER necessitated the
estimation of the following equation:
LREER = b0 + b1LGCONS + b2LGINV + b3PRODUCTIVITY +Ut
549
Where
REER = Real Effective Exchange Rate
GCONS = Government Consumption
GINV = Government Investment
PRODUCTIVITY = Productivity is represented by the growth rate of Gross
Domestic Product
L = Natural Logarithm
Ut = Random Variable
The results of the descriptive statistic for the variables is shown in table 1 below
Table 1: Summary of Descriptive Statistic
GCONS GINV REER PRODUCTIVITY

Mean 551618.8 283703.8 335.4242 0.482574
Median 34388.90 24775.50 130.2300 0.062191
Minimum 4162627 2272760 1075.780 9.375315
Minimum 143.6000 993.0000 57.47000 -0.891466
Std. Dev. 965888.4 554650.3 320.9957 1.719859
Skewness 2.178414 2.316480 0.973653 4.226820
Kurtosis 7.388690 3.239988 2.535969 20.74144
Jarque-Bera 1.073759 2.073637 6.678874 3.017045
Probability 0.1200000 0.000000 0.035457 0.000000
Sum 22064754 11348154 13416.97 19.30298
Sum Sq. Dev. 3.64E+13 1.20E+13 4018491 115.3587
Observations 40 40 40 40
The skewness which is a measure of the asymmetry of the distribution of the series around its mean have
values greater than 0 which indicates that the series is skewed to the right. This suggests that the distribution
has a long right tail. The kurtosis measures the peakedness of flatness of the distribution with an expected
value of 3.0. The results in table 1 above shows that the RER and government investment satisfy the
condition. However, those of government consumption and PRODUCTIVITY are leptokurtic (greater than 3).
The Jarque-Bera test is used to test whether the random variables with unknown means and constant
dispersions are normally distributed. The jarque-bera test has the null hypothesis of normally distributed
residuals. The probability values indicates an acceptance of the null hypothesis that the errors are normally
distributed.
The augmented Dickey Fuller (ADF) and the Phillip Perron (PP) unit root tests were used to test whether
the variables are stationary or not and their order of integration. The summary of the ADF and PP unit root
tests are shown in table 2 below:
Table 2: Summary of ADF and PP unit root tests

Variables ADF PP
Level 1st difference Order of Level 1st difference Order of integration
Integration
Productivity 3.864607* -11.06536 1(0) -6.97216* -16.78975 1(0)
REER -2.175824 -4.235913* 1(1) -2.57216 -4.401870* 1(1)
GINV -0.826384 -6.790597* 1(1) -0.508566 -6.369998* 1(1)
GCONS 7.720578* 2.077504 1(0) 12.42145* -1.672323 1(0)
550
N.B.: * Indicates statistical significance at the 1% level The results of the unit root tests show that while the
REER and GINV were non stationary, PRODUCTIVITY and GCONS were stationary. Following Harris (1995)
and Gujarrati (2003), all the variables were carried along for the cointegration test because according to
them, both 1(1) and 1(0) variables can be cointegrated. We thus proceed to the next test which is a test of
cointegration. The summary of the Johansen cointegration test is shown in table 3 below:
Table 3: Summary of Johansen Cointegration Test Result

Hypothesized Eigen Value Trace 5% CV 1%CV Max-Eigen statistic 5% CV 1%CV
No of CE(s) Statistic
None** 0.610914 64.10137 47.21 54.46 34.92636 27.07 32.24
At most 1 0.411748 29.17501 29.68 35.65 19.63222 20.97 25.52
At most 2 0.165128 -9.542795 13.41 20.04 6.677654 14.07 18.63
At most 3 0.07454 2.865141 3.76 6.65 2.86514 3.76 6.65
Both trace and max-eign statistics indicate 1 cointegrating equation at both the 5% and 1% level
The result from the Johansen cointegration test in table 3 above suggests the existence of a long run
cointegrating relationship among government consumption, government investment, productivity and the
REER in Nigeria. Under this circumstance, favouring a VAR in level or first difference as opposed to Vector
Error Correction Model can lead to misspecification because cointegration is established.
The number of cointegrating relationship and the number of lags provided a guide for the specification of
VECM. The first step is to identify the number of cointegration relationships that have been suggested in the
last section. Table 4 presents the results from the VECM.
Table 4: Summary of Vector Error Correction Result
Vector error correction estimates

Date: 01/2/12 time: 09:33
Sample (adjusted): 1970 2010
Included observations: 37 after adjusting endpoints
Standard errors in () & t-statistics in []
CointegratingEq: cointEq1
LREER(-1) 1.000000
LGINV -0.828758
(0.73250)
[-1.13142]
LGCONS(-1) 0.726351
(0.63368)
[1.14624]
PRODUCTIVITY -2.121871
(0.39088)
[-5.42843]
C -3.423876
Error Correction D(LREER) D(LGINV) D(LGCONS) D(PRODUCTIVITY)
551
CointEq1 -0.139607 -0.007866 -0.102223 0.459976

(0.02444) (0.03933) (0.06490) (0.10177)
[-5.71282] [-0.19997] [-1.57499] [4.51975
D(REER(-1)) 0.205886 -0.057006 0.314901 -0.675435

(0.19239) (0.25916) (0.42762) (0.67054)
[1.07013] [-0.21996] [0.73638] [-1.00731]
D(LREER(-2)) -0.066759 0.008332 0.129669 0.041008

(0.18745) (0.25250) (0.41664) (0.65330
[-0.35615] [0.03300] [0.31123] [0.06277]
D(LGINV(-1)) -0.058636 -0.052269 0.028703 0.451211

(0.14480) (0.19506) (0.32186) (0.50468)
[-0.40493] [-0.26797] [0.08918] [0.89406]
D(LGINV(-2) -0.055855 -0.110037 0.150028 0.148380

(0.14099) (0.18991) (0.31337) (0.49137)
[-0.39617] [-0.57940] [0.47875] [0.30197]
D(LGCONS(-1)) -0.092317 0.156807 -0.419534 0.023679

(0.08201) (0.11047) (0.18228) (0.28583)
[-1.12566] [1.41944] [-2.30154] [0.08284]
D(LGONS(2)) 0.046628 0.064449 -0.134291 -0.201600

(0.08678) (0.11689) (0.19288) (0.30243)
[0.53734] [0.55137] [-0.69626] [-0.66659
(D(PRODUCTIVITY(-1)) -0.100077 0.043718 -0.129730 -0.082509

(0.05157) (0.06947) (0.11462) (0.17973)
[-1.94062] [0.62934] [-1.13179] [-0.45907]
D(PRODUCTIVITY(2))
-0.027754 0.020305 -0.057117 -0.040316
(0.03534) (0.04760) (0.07855) (0.12317)
[-0.78534] [0.42654] [-0.72715] [-0.32733]
C
-0.005661 0.170881 0.387890 -0.365514
(0.06812) (0.09176) (0.15141) (0.23741)
[-0.08311] [1.86230] [2.56190] [-1.53959]
R-Squared 0.624956 0.106233 0.361972 0.819057

Adj. r-Squared 0.593393 -0.191690 0.149297 0.758743
Sum sq.Resids 2.591077 4.701479 12.80081 31.47331
S.E. Equation 0.309784 0.417287 0.688552 1.079666
F. Statistic 11.87074 0.356578 1.701991 13.57982
Log likelihood -3.312106 -14.33447 -32.86465 -49.50783
Akaike A/C/ 0.718573 1.315377 2.317008 3.216639
Schwarz SC 1.154957 1.750760 2.752391 3.652023
Mean Dependent -0.044733 0.189643 0.277693 -0.251344
S.D. dependent 0.304737 0.382256 0.746531 2.198109
Determinant Residual Covariance 0.006993
Log Likelihood -94.87462
Log Likelihood (d.f. adjusted) -118.1906
Akaike Information Criteria 8.767060
Schwarz Criteria 10.68275
A comparison of the coefficients of the error correction terms (Coint Eq1) at the bottom of table 4 for the first
vector shows that the LREER has the most significant coefficient and the right sign with a t value of -
5.71282. The other variables either have a wrong sign or are not significant. This indicates that the REER
552
equation constitutes the true cointegrating relationship in the first cointegrating vector. The result thus
suggests that about 14 percent of the disequilibrium in the REER is corrected each year. The error correction
term for productivity measured by the growth rate of Real Gross Domestic Product, government consumption
and government investment are statistically flawed. The error correction for government investment with a
value of -0.01 isstatistically significant, while that of productivity 0.46 is wrongly signed and falls outside the
acceptance level of -1 < error term < 0. That of government consumption with value of -0.10 falls within the
acceptance region, but it is not statistically significant. The result of the VECM thus shows how the REER
responds to variation in government investment, government consumption and productivity.
The next stage of this analysis is on the variance decomposition of various variables. The variance
decomposition of the variables indicate the percentage of variance as explained by the shock from the
variable itself and the shocks from the other variables in the model.
The results of the variance decomposition are shown in tables 5-8 below:
Table 5: Variance Decomposition for GCONS
Period S.E. GCONS GINV REER PRODUCTIVITY

1 91401.75 100.0000 0.000000 0.000000 0.000000
2 100655.8 94.84092 0.547241 3.257463 1.354373
3 138890.5 93.12930 0.364911 3.140537 3.365251
4 209880.2 58.34473 34.28373 2.528645 4.842889
5 304003.9 46.12440 46.80287 2.259512 4.813227
6 404208.1 34.74563 57.12309 2.387658 5.743628
7 535313.6 29.03869 62.96274 2.230039 5.768527
8 702186.3 23.02595 69.33604 2020013 5.617999
9 885678.9 2.0.04365 72.50202 1.919947 5.534379
10 1092906 17.37235 75.22525 1.859011 5.543392
Table 6: Variance Decomposition for GINV

1 2911112.4 0.753798 99..24620 0.000000 0.000000
2 422018.8 1.702683 98.19762 0.099572 1.000127
3 459186.9 1.593918 97.92226 0.472250 0.011569
4 496748.3 1.484823 97.99639 0.502161 0.016629
5 570073.9 1.288804 9828262 0.414390 0.014190
6 619014.0 1.225470 98.34573 0.416352 0.012451
7 652891.3 1.101763 98.41766 0.459170 0.021410
8 693560.3 1.080851 98.44182 0.455714 0.021616
9 739963.9 1.012851 98.52377 0.441826 0.021551
10 775469.6 0.972438 98.55309 0.451661 0.022607
Table 7: Variance Decomposition for REER

1 82.99009 0.418938 0.326627 99.25423 0.000000
2 138.5861 0.444439 0.119405 99.43030 0.005851
3 173.7214 1.080052 0.099596 98.58227 0.238081
4 196.0991 1.384714 0.187572 98.22732 0.200392
5 216.5612 1.652973 0.161263 98.00702 0.178739
6 239.1067 2.194198 1.358333 96.26110 0.186372
7 263.3880 2.816097 3.699272 93.24691 0.237716
8 287.7562 3.328495 6.063200 90.25697 0.351335
9 314.1670 3.916915 9.418689 86.13450 0.529893
10 344.9682 4.559327 14.29363 80.39402 0.753031
553
Table 8: Variance Decomposition for Productivity

1 1.320252 3.804788 0.337901 1.604718 94.25259
2 1.496547 6.853121 3.700279 14.61571 74.83089
3 1.643223 8.914350 4.130312 12.13668 74.81866
4 1.836847 9.272510 11.30787 0.060284 69.55934
5 1.957215 9.611196 12.70665 0.083962 68.51819
6 2.077657 11.56432 11.79388 8.276356 68.36345
7 2.18328 12.11420 11.54346 7.912223 68.43011
8 2.298455 12:71617 11.88527 7.52122 67.93644
9 2.400256 13.40778 11.24064 7.112399 68.23919
10 2.500947 14.40440 10.45250 0.831104 68.31200
Cholesky ordering: GCONS GINV REER Productivity
A proper assessment of the results reveals that the majority of the variances in the variables have been
explained by their own shocks. However, variables such as productivity and government consumption had
significant impact on the variance of other variables through the share of their shocks to these variables. The
share of the REER to other variables has not been too significant during the period under consideration. The
contribution of government consumption shocks to variance in REER increased from 1.4 percent in the 4th
period to 4.6 percent in the tenth period, while its contribution to shocks in government investment decreased
from 1.7 percent in the 2nd period to about 1 percent in the tenth period. The contribution of government
investment to shocks in government consumption was significant at about 75.2 percent in the tenth period,
while contribution of government consumption to productivity increased from about 3.8 percent in the 1st
period to about 14.4 percent in the last period. Following the result of the variance decomposition of
government investment in table 6, other than its own shock, there was no significant contribution of shocks in
other variables. The implication of the result is that volatility in government investment and consumption has
no major impact on the REER in Nigeria. However, the result indicates that technological productivity is a
better target for the government.
The result of the parsimonious ECM result is shown in the appendix. The result indicates that an increase
in government investment in the immediate past period depreciated the REER by 0.13 percent. This is an
indication that government investment has delivered more productivity gain in the non-tradable sector. The
result however indicates that an increase in government consumption by 1 percent appreciated the REER by
0.09 percent. This is an indication that an increase in government consumption increased the relative
demand for non-tradable. This result is similar to that by Vahagn and Philip (2008) who used pane data to
study the impact of the composition of government spending and RER.
5. Conclusion
The main objective of this study has been to empirically assess the relationship between government
expenditure and the REER in Nigeria using a VECM. The theoretical model showed that government
consumption typically leads to real appreciation but that sensitivity of the RER to government investment
depends on how an increase in the public capital stock differentially affects productivity levels in the traded
and non-traded sectors. The descriptive statistic showed that the distribution has a long right tail and that the
errors are normally distributed. The result fo the ADF and PP unit root test showed that while two of the
variables were stationary, the other two were non-stationary, but were carried along for the cointegration test
following Harris (1995) and Gujaratti (2003). The result from the Johansen cointegration test and the VECM
suggests a long run relationship among the variables. The result of the variance decomposition showed that
no particular portion of the shocks in the REER is attributed to the other variables. However shocks in
government expenditures were partly explained by government investment. The result from the parsimonious
554
ECM model showed that government investment delivered more productivity gains in the non-tradable sector
than in the tradable sector. An increase in government consumption increased relative demand for non-
tradable sector. The government should thus pay more attention to the expansion of the tradable sector.
References
Coricelli, F. and Jazbec, B., (2004). “Real Exchange Rate Dynamics in Transition economies”. Structural change and Economic
Dynamics. 15: 83 – 100.
Edwards, S., (1989). Real exchange Rates, Devaluation and Adjustment: Exchange Rate Policy in Developing Countries. Cambridge:
The MIT press.
Elbadawi, I. (1994). “Estimating Long-run Equilibrium Real Exchange Rates”.In Williamson, ed., Estimating Equilibrium Exchange Rates,
chapter 5. Washington, D.C.: Institute for International Economics. Engle, R. and C. Granger 1987 “Cointegration and error-
correction: Representation, estimation, and testing” Econometrica, 55: 251 -76.
Engle, R. and C. Granger. (1987). “Cointegrating and Error Correction: Representation, Estimation and Testing”. Econometrica. 55:251-
76
Ghura, D. and Grennes, T.J, (1993). “The Rural Exchange Rate and Macroeconomic Performance in Sub-Saharan Africa”. Journal of
Development Economics. 42: 155-174.
Gujarati, D.N., (2003). Basic Econometrics (4e). New York: McGraw-Hill Inc
Harris, R., (1995). Using cointegration Analysis in Econometric Modeling. London: Prentice Hall.
Johansen, S; and Juselius, K., (1992). “Testing Structural Hypotehsis in a multivariate Cointegration Analysis of the PPP and the UIP for
UK”,Journal of Econometrics. 53: 211-244.
Joyce, J.P. and Kamas, L., (2003). “ Real and Nominal Determinants of Real Exchange Rates in Latin America: Short-run and Long –run
Equilibrium”. The Journal of Development Studies, 39, 6: 155-182.
Macdonald, R., (1998). “What Determines Real Exchange Rates? The Long and Short for it” Journal of International Financial Markets,
Institutions and Money, 8: 117-1 53
Mkenda, B.K., (2001). “Long-run and Short-run Determinants of the Real Exchange Rate in Zambia“. Goteborg University Working
Papers in Economics No 40. (online). Available:http://www.handels.gu.selepc/archive/00001717/01/gunwe0040.pdf.
Mungule, K.O. (2004). “The Determinants of the Real Exchange rate in Zambia”. African Economic ResearchConsortium, Paper 146
Nairobi.
Nanna, O.J., Englama, A. and Odoko, F.O. (2004) eds. Finance, Investment and Growth in Nigeria, Abuja: Central Bank of Nigeria.
Obadan, M.I. (2006), “Overview of Exchange Rate Management in Nigeria from 1986 to Date”, in the “Dynamics of Exchange Rate in
Nigeria”, Central Bank of Nigeria Bullion, Vol. 30, No. 3 pp 17 – 25.
Obstfeld, M. and Rogoff, R. (1998), Foundations of International Macroeconomics, Cambridge: MA: MIT Press.
Robert, D.K. and Samuel, J.B (2007) “The Determinants of the Real Exchange Rate in Sierra Leone. JEL Classification Code:
FOO,f31,f41.
Vahagn, G. and Philip, R.L. (2008)”The Composition of Government Spending and the Real Exchange Rate, JEL Code E62, F31, F41.
Xiaopu, Z. (2002) “Equilibrium and Misalignment: An Assessment of the RMB Exchange Rate from 1978 to 1999”. Centre for Research
on Economic Development and Policy Reforms, Working Paper No. 127.
Appendix
Summary of Parsimonious ECM Result
Dependent Variable: DLREER

Method: Least Squares
Date: 01/21/12 Time: 11:13
Sample (adjusted): 1970 2101
Included observation: 38 after adjusting endpoints
555
Variable Coefficient Std. Error t-Statistic Prob.

DLGINV(-1) 0.128231 0.048192 2.660860 0.0130
DLGONS -0.085214 0.039559 -2.154078 0.0436
PRODUCTIVITY(-2) -0.080611 0.026962 -2.98955 0.0053
ECM(-1) -0.454316 0.167069 -2.719327 0.0105
C -0.055911 0.059543 -0.939012 0.3545
R-squared 0.8406158 Mean Dependent var 0.045313
Adjusted R-squared 0.8305215 S.D dependent var 0.300612
S.E. of regression 0.308352 Akaike info criterion 0.606932
Sum squared resid 3.137679 Schwarz criterion 0.822404
Log likehood -6.531713 F-statistics 124.5414
Durbin-Watson stat 2.0468811 Prob(F-statistics) 0.000000
556
Cohesion Analysis of L2 Writing: The Case of Iranian Undergraduate EFL Learners
Firooz Sadighi, Ph.D.

[email protected]
Pooneh Heydari, Ph.D. Candidate

corresponding author: [email protected]
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.557
Abstract: This study aimed at investigating the most frequent cohesive errors committed by Iranian undergraduate EFL learners
at different levels of proficiency as well as the sources of cohesive errors. An overall number of 67 undergraduate students at
Shiraz Azad University participated in this study. To have three groups of learners with different proficiency levels, Oxford
Placement Test 1B1 (Allan, 1985) was administered. To achieve the objectives of the study, the participants were given a writing
task requiring them to write an approximately 200-word narrative composition. Then, the compositions were scored based on the
taxonomy developed by Halliday and Hasan (1976). Finally, the data were analyzed through appropriate procedures using
quantitative methods. Regarding the frequencies and percentages of errors it was found that low-level learners' most frequent
errors were involved in references (20), followed by errors in lexical (14), and conjunctive cohesion (1). Besides, the findings
showed that errors in references were the most common (17), followed by errors in lexical (13), and conjunction cohesion (2) in
the mid-level learners' narrative compositions and, finally, the high-level learners' most frequent errors were involved in lexical
cohesion (17), references (14), conjunction cohesion (3), and substitution (1).This study also allowed for an examination of the
sources of cohesive errors. It was found that errors in the use of relative pronouns, conjunctions, along with different forms of
repetition appeared because of the incomplete knowledge of the learners—intra-lingual causes. Furthermore, in this study, the
errors in the use of personal-, possessive-pronouns, demonstratives and collocations were among the inter-lingual causes of
errors.
Keywords: Error analysis; Cohesion analysis; Cohesive devices; L2 writing; Cohesive errors; Sources of errors
Introduction
In recent years, there has been a growing research interest in the analysis of errors adults make while
learning a second language. The study and analysis of the errors made by second language learners (i.e.
Error Analysis or EA), either in their speech or writing or both has been brought under consideration by many
educators, EFL teachers, linguists, and researchers throughout the world. In fact, learners' errors have been
the subject of controversy for a long time.
Generally, as Keshavarz (1999, p. 11) stated, "there have been two major approaches to the study of
learners' errors, namely Contrastive Analysis and Error Analysis." He further discussed that, "Error Analysis
emerged on account of the shortcomings of Contrastive Analysis which was the favored way of describing
learners' language in the 1950s and 1960s" (p. 42).
The process involved in CA is the comparison of learners' mother tongue and the target language. Based
on the similarities or differences between two languages, predictions were made on errors that learners
would be likely or disposed to make as a result (Kim, 2001). As Kim (2001) explained, by early 1970s, CA
lost its favor because of the inaccurate or uninformative predictions of learner errors; errors did not occur
where predicted, but instead errors showed up where CA had not predicted. More serious criticism was
557
raised on account of its adopted views from structuralism in linguistics and behaviorism in psychology. Being
questioned about the reliability of the CA research, it yielded to Error Analysis in 1970.
Unlike CA which tries to describe differences and similarities of L1 and L2, James (1998 cited in Kim,
2001) stated that, EA attempts to describe learners' interlanguage (i.e. learners' version of the target
language) independently and objectively. He believed that the most distinct feature of EA is that the mother
tongue is not supposed to be mentioned for comparison. The studies in EA have for the most part dealt with
linguistic aspects of learners' errors; not enough attention has been paid to the errors at discourse level and
in particular to cohesive devices that are very important in the organization of the texts. Identifying and
describing the origin of the learners' errors is now an activity that has received much attention during the last
three decades.
According to Halliday and Matthiessen (2004), cohesive devices are formal elements in the text that
function to make links between the components of the text. Two broad categories and some subcategories
have been identified for cohesive devices. These are grammatical and lexical cohesive devices. The
grammatical one includes reference, conjunction, substitute, and ellipsis while the lexical cohesive devices
are reiteration and collocation.
Review of the related literature
1. Cohesion Analysis
Of course, studying writing issues involving cohesion deserves much attention. This is because as Ting
(2003, p.1) believed, "cohesion as an indispensable text-forming element plays a critical role in composing a
text."
The appearance of Halliday and Hasan's Cohesion in English (1976) had a major impact on the
understanding and teaching of coherence features. Although linguists speak of coherent text as, "having two
characteristics such as cohesion (ties between sentences) and register (coherence with a context)" (Choi,
2005), this book focused almost exclusively on cohesion as a text feature. According to Halliday and Hasan
(1976), cohesion is realized through cohesive ties which link the presupposing and the presupposed across
sentence boundaries. In other words, cohesive ties create intimate intersentential relationships which to a
large extent distinguish a text from a sequence of isolated sentences.
Following the publication of Halliday and Hasan (1976), language educators and teachers have become
interested in the use of cohesive devices in language students’ written compositions. In fact, lots of research
has been done in this respect and several researchers have used the outline of cohesion in English
presented by various experts particularly the one presented by Halliday and Hasan (1976). Thus, since the
present study did so, it is important first to become familiar with the cohesion taxonomy presented by Halliday
and Hasan in 1976.
1.1 Halliday and Hasan's (1976) Cohesion Taxonomy
In their classic study of cohesion in English, Halliday and Hasan (1976) defined cohesion as what occurs
when the interpretation of some elements in the discourse is dependent on that of another. The one
presupposes the other in the sense that it cannot be effectively decoded except by recourse to it. Halliday
and Hasan (1976) identified five types of cohesion: reference cohesion, substitution cohesion, ellipsis, lexical
cohesion and conjunction cohesion. The first three types fall under the category of grammatical cohesion.
Lexical cohesion on the other hand refers to relationships between any lexical item and some previously
occurring lexical item in the text quite independently of the grammatical category of the items in question. For
example, lexical cohesion can exist between the noun magistrate and the verb judge. Conjunctive cohesion
lies on the borderline between grammatical cohesion and lexical cohesion. Conjunctive cohesion is affected
558
by cohesion elements that are called conjunctives. This is the Halliday and Hassan’s (1976) Cohesion
Taxonomy in a glance:
personal pronouns: I, me, you, we, us, him, her, they,
them, it
personal reference personal determiners(the possessives): my ,mine, your,
yours, his, her, hers, their, theirs, its
relative pronouns: who, which
1. Reference cohesion demonstrative reference determiners: the, this, there, that, those
demonstrative adverbs: here, there, then
comparative adjectives: same, identical, equal, other,
comparative reference different, more, better, etc.
comparative adverbs: similarly, differently, more, less, etc.
nominal substitution: A. Can you give me a glass? B. There is one on the table.
2. Substitution cohesion verbal substitution: Every child likes chocolate and I think my son does too.
clausal substitution: Latecomers will not be allowed in school after 8.00 a.m. the
headmaster says so.
nominal ellipsis: These are my two dogs. I used to have four.
3. Ellipsis verbal ellipsis: Teacher: Have you done the homework? John: Yes, I have.
clausal ellipsis: Mary: Are you going to buy a new dress for my birthday? Mother: Yes
4. Conjunctive cohesion: hence, so, after, and, but, then, etc. e.g. He took a cup of coffee after he woke up.
5. Lexical cohesion: 1. repetition of a word or phrase;
2. synonymy (e.g. commonly, popularly);
3. antonymy (e.g. high, low);
4. hyponymy (e.g. cigarettes/cigars);
5. collocation (e.g. education, classroom, class, and so on)
(see Halliday & Hasan, 1976, pp.274-292)
2. Cohesion Studies
As mentioned before, Halliday and Hasan indicated that cohesion is in effect a linguistic property in relation to
559
textual features. This is while other language researchers have tended to interpret the message of Halliday
and Hasan (1976) as follows: given that cohesive devices are important elements for constructing a coherent
text, their appearance should cause coherence and therefore contribute to the quality of the text (Ting, 2003).
As a result, a number of language researchers adopted Halliday and Hasan’s (1976) taxonomy and
framework of cohesion to conduct empirical studies examining whether the use of cohesive devices in
students’ writing correlates with coherence or the overall writing quality. In this section, some of the
researches done in this respect will be reviewed briefly.
One of such researchers was Neuuner (1987). He analyzed twenty good essays versus twenty poor
essays written by college freshman students. The essays were randomly selected from a pool of 600 essays
on the topic "write a letter giving advice to students at school." Two readers from a panel of twelve holistically
rated each essay using a four-point scale. Three independent coders conducted analysis on the essays after
instruction and practice. Finally, the results revealed that the frequency or percentage of cohesive ties did not
distinguish good from weak essays, and good from poor essays did not differ significantly in cohesive
distance.
Likewise, using Halliday and Hasan's (1976) model in his study of cohesion and coherence, Khalil (1989)
investigated the relationship between cohesion and coherence in 20 compositions in Arab EFL students'
college writing. The relationship of cohesion and coherence was tested by the use of multiple correlation
statistics. Finally, a weak correlation (r=0.18) was found between the number of cohesive ties and coherence
score of the text.
Another researcher was Jonson (1992), who examined cohesion in expository essays written in Malay and
in English by native speakers of both languages and in ESL by Malaysian writers. Sample compositions
evaluated holistically as good or weak in quality were submitted by Malaysian teachers of composition in
Malay and by American teachers of native and non-native speakers of English. The results indicated no
differences in the amount of cohesion between good and weak compositions written in Malay by native
speakers (20 persons) or in English by native (20 persons) and Malay speakers (20 persons). His empirical
study on cohesion in written discourse of native and non-native speakers of English also indicated that
judgments of writing quality may depend on overall coherence in content, organization, and style rather than
on the quantity of cohesion.
The study of the relationship of cohesion to coherence has continued to dominate the literature of the last
two decades. Zhang in 2000 did one such study. He conducted a study to reexamine the same research
question by investigating cohesive devices in the writing of Chinese undergraduate EFL students. He asked
107 students of two different universities to participate in his study. The results revealed that no statistically
significant relationship exists between the frequency of cohesive ties used and the quality of writing.
Generally, most of the researchers have found that there is no significant relationship between the quantity
of cohesive devices used and the quality of writing. However, there are studies in which opposite results were
reported. For example, Tonder and Louise (1999), in their study, explored the relationship between densities
of lexical cohesion and lexical errors on one hand and the perceived coherence ratings and academic scores
of student academic writing on the other. Findings indicated that densities of lexical cohesion generally and
derivational ties specifically showed highly significant relations with the coherence ratings.
It has to be pointed out that in any study which intends to examine the relationship between the number of
cohesive devices and the quality of writing, counting all the cohesive devices present without taking into
account whether or not the cohesive devices are properly used in the context, to some extent makes the
study questionable. Furthermore, the inconclusive results reported in the studies reviewed indicate that the
relationship between writing quality or textual coherence and cohesive device use has not been concretely
established. In the opinion of Castro (2002), such studies yielded conflicting results due to their small sample
size, the variability in the L1 subjects involved, and lack of robust statistical analyses to support qualitative
descriptions. In short, he continued that cohesion analyses did not consistently reveal differences in cohesive
device use in good versus weak essays or between L1 versus L2 writing.
560
Generally, most of the cohesion analyses have conducted to reexamine the same research question. As it
is obvious, despite the significant role of cohesive device in writing, the topic of cohesive errors in
composition seems not to have received as much attention as it deserves. There are only a small number of
studies exclusively aimed at cohesive errors. Given the fact that cohesive errors have been either neglected
or examined incompletely in previous cohesion-related studies, the present study tries to deal with a
cohesion analysis of Iranian L2 writing. In doing so, this study attempts to identify the errors using the
cohesion taxonomy presented by Halliday and Hasan (1976).
Objectives of the study
The purpose of the present study is to empirically investigate, classify, and analyze the cohesive errors which
L2 learners make in their written productions at different levels of proficiency. Moreover, this study tries to
investigate whether the identified errors are due to their L2 proficiency level or the L1 interference
phenomenon. Hence, the following questions are to be answered through this study:
1. What are the most frequent cohesive errors committed by L2 learners at different levels of proficiency?
2. Are there any differences in the L2 learners' cohesive errors which can be attributed to their L2 proficiency
level?
3. Are there any differences in the L2 learners' cohesive errors which can be attributed to L1 interference
phenomenon?
Method
Participants
67 male and female EFL undergraduate students at Shiraz Azad University participated in this study—42
female and 25 male. The participants ranged in age from 20 to 26. All of the students speak Persian as their
native language and learn English as a foreign language. The type of sampling involved non-random
procedures for selecting the members of the sample. In other words, the selection procedure was a non-
probability one. The specific selection procedure employed was that of convenient sampling.
Instruments
To have three groups of learners with different proficiency levels, Oxford Placement Test 1B1 which is a
standard test including 50 multiple choice items identifying and assessing the learners' level of English
proficiency (Allan, 1985) was administered. The validity of the Oxford Placement Test 1B1 is taken for
granted and with regard to the reliability of the test, the Kurder-Richardson formula 21 was used and the
results showed the reliability of 0.86.
In order to conduct the study, the participants were asked to write a composition. The composition is
beneficial in such cases because it will bring naturally occurring data for the study. Instead of administering
multiple-choice exams such as tests of grammar or vocabulary that draw the students' most attention and
consciousness towards the grammatical and lexical points, the composition test draws the attention of the
students towards the topic. In this way, the participants are unaware of grammatical and lexical issues and
focus on the subject they want to develop.
Accordingly, the participants were given a writing task requiring them to choose one of the three
presented topics and write an approximately 200-word narrative composition. The three narrative topics were
as follows:
1. A time and a place in the past
2. A melodic memory
561
3. A one-day visit to your country

The mentioned topics were selected from the e-book of Answers to All TOEFL Essay Questions by
ToeflEssays.com, an e-book containing 450 model essays which offers an intensive preparation for the TWE
test.
Data collection procedures

The scoring of Oxford Placement Test was based on the number of items answered correctly by the
students. Each correct answer received one point and the total score of the test was 50. The participants
were first assigned to three groups of low, mid, and high based on the results of the oxford placement test—
22 low-level learners, 27 mid-level learners, and 18 high-level learners. The criterion for this division was the
standard deviation. Accordingly, participants with one standard deviation below the mean were assigned the
low group and the ones with scores falling one standard deviation above the mean were assigned the high
group. The remaining ones in the middle were assigned the mid group.
After dividing the participants into three different levels of proficiency, they were given two optional narrative
topics on which they were required to write a composition in about sixty minutes. In selecting the topics from
the e-book of Answers to All TOEFL Essay Questions, two factors were of concern: (1) learners' familiarity
with the topics and (2) the topics being interesting and easy to write. The reason for choosing narrative
topics was that it was found to be the easiest among other modes of discourse for the learners to write
(Nemati, 1999). The data for this study were collected from compositions written by the students during one
session. Then, they were scored based on the taxonomy developed by Halliday and Hasan (1976).
Consequently, all five cohesive devices consisting of reference (with differentiation made between
pronominal, demonstrative, and comparative), substitution (discriminating between nominal, verbal, clausal),
ellipsis (discriminating between nominal, verbal, clausal), conjunction and lexical cohesion were scored.
Data analysis procedures

The data were analyzed through appropriate procedures using both qualitative and quantitative methods.
For the first research question of the study investigating the most frequent cohesive errors committed by EFL
undergraduate learners, the data were analyzed through descriptive statistics using frequencies and
percentages.
For the next two research questions of the study investigating if there are any differences in the
participants' cohesive errors which can be attributed to either their L2 proficiency level or L1 interference
phenomenon, the data were analyzed using qualitative methods.
Results
1. the most frequent cohesive errors committed by L2 learners at different levels of proficiency
As mentioned before, in order to analyze cohesive errors, the participants were asked to write narrative
compositions. The five major categories explicated by Halliday and Hasan (1976) were used to systematically
present a framework for the analysis of cohesion in this study. Based on these groupings, common error
types which led to their deviation from standard English usage were established. The following discussion will
present the major error types, those which were frequent at different levels of proficiency, separately.
1.1. Low-level learners' most frequent cohesive errors
Investigating 22 compositions written by low-level learners identified the 35 cohesive errors in which the use
of references were the most frequent ones (20), followed by errors in lexical (14), and conjunctive cohesion
(1).
562
The results presented in Table 1 indicate the relative degree to which the items from each category and
subcategory of cohesion were used incorrectly in creating overall cohesion together with a detailed
discussion of the error analysis.
Table 1: The low-level learners' frequencies and percentages of errors in cohesion categories and
subcategories
Cohesion Number of errors Percentages of Cohesion Number of Percentages
Categories errors Subcategories errors of errors
Reference 20 57.14% Personal 19 95%
Demonstrative 1 5%
Comparative 0 0%
Substitution 0 0% Nominal 0 0%
Verbal 0 0%
Clausal 0 0%
Ellipsis 0 0% Nominal 0 0%
Verbal 0 0%
Clausal 0 0%
Conjunction 1 2.58% 1
lexical 14 40% Repetition 4 28.57%
Synonymy 0 0%
Antonymy 0 0%
Hyponymy 0 0%
Collocation 10 71.42%
As is clear from the table, the majority of the errors are referential cohesive devices and the second most
frequent errors are those of the lexical type. Moreover, it is clear that the majority of the referential errors are
personal and the majority of the second most frequent errors, lexical type, are involved in collocation and
repetition, respectively. Examples from each of the error types are also presented in Table 2. In each of the
examples, the devices which were used incorrectly are underlined.
Table 2: Low-level learners' cohesive errors
Categories Subcategories Low-level learners' cohesion errors
1. Reference Personal (Pronoun) 1. She wanted to come home but he couldn't. (she)
2. My mother had to go because he was a teacher. (she)
3. My brother went to school, too. She was happy. (he)
4. Some of them were happy but some were not. Among those was a
crying girl. (them)
5. The old woman went to the hospital. He was sick. (she)
6. They invited their friends to the party but he didn't came. (they)
7. She heard the news from TV. …she talked about them with his
neighbor. (it)
Personal (Determiners)
1. She talked about them with his neighbor. (her)
563
2. My sister passed the course but his score was low. (her)
3. When they were in Iran, they saw many things that they were not in his
country. (their)
4. We enjoyed from the movie and we talked about their events with
ourselves. (its)
5. When we want to migrate to another country, we might try to learn the
culture and match themselves with them. (ourselves)
6. …keep in touch by his own family and friends at their original country.
(his)
7. Her wife saw the man which was thief. (his)
1. Her wife saw that man which was thief. (who)

Relative Pronoun
2. Education is the important criteria who can change the personality of
person. (that)
3. At first, I was introduced to a nice woman which became my teacher.
(who)
4. …or call with the people which live there. (who)
5. They didn't have a lot of time to think about the country that they born.
(where)
1. To have some good friends is the best way to prevent this bad
Demonstrative problems. (these)
Comparative
2. Substitution Nominal
Verbal
Clausal
3.Ellipsis Nominal
Verbal
Clausal
4. Conjunction 1. We can see the our personality has more effect in our life. (that)
5.Lexical Repetition 1. After that I returned back to my home. (returned home)
2. The most interesting day of my life it is the first day of my school.
(repetition of a noun by its pronoun)
3. The characteristics that we born with it is very important.
4. When they were in Iran, they saw many things that they were not in his
country.
Synonymy
564
Antonymy
Hyponymy
Collocation 1. Foreign people have a different way to life. (way of life)

2. For reduce the problems we can use of foreign web-site or… (make use
of)
3. I keep in touch by my family. (keep in touch with sb)
4,5. …keep in touch by his own family and friends at their original country.
(keep in touch with sb, home country)
6. I agree with this issue. (agree on sth)
7. We can see the our personality has more effect in our life. (effect on
sb/sth)
8. We enjoyed from the road. (enjoy sth)
9. We enjoyed from the movie. (enjoy sth)
10. I run to home from my school. (run home)
1.2. Mid-level learners' most frequent cohesive errors

Besides, a total of 32 cohesive errors in the narrative compositions of 27 mid-level learners were identified.
The findings showed that errors in references were the most common (17), followed by errors in lexical (13),
and conjunction cohesion (2). The frequencies and percentages of errors from each category and
subcategory are presented in Table 3.
Table 3: The mid-level learners' frequencies and percentages of errors in cohesion categories and
subcategories
Reference 17 53.21% Personal 15 88.23%
Demonstrative 2 11.76%
Comparative 0 0%
Substitution 0 0% Nominal 0 0%
Verbal 0 0%
Clausal 0 0%
Verbal 0 0%
Clausal 0 0%
lexical 13 40.62% Repetition 4 30.76%
Synonymy 0 0%
Antonymy 0 0%
Hyponymy 0 0%
565
As this table show, the majority of the errors are in references and the second most frequent errors are in
lexical type. Table 3 reveals that the majority of the referential errors are personal and the majority of the
second most frequent errors, lexical errors, are involved in collocation and repetition, respectively. Examples
from each of the error types are shown in Table 4. In each of the examples, the devices which were used
incorrectly are underlined.
Table 4: Mid-level learners' cohesive errors

Categories Subcategories Mid-level learners' cohesion errors
1. Reference Personal (Pronoun) 1. I think if a single woman live abroad, they will face many
problems. (she)
2. My father gave me bunch of flower…she told me…(he)
3. Mina had a valuable experience…he remember it after that.(she)
4. My father couldn't start the car. She decided to…(he)
5. I saw a girl that were kind in the first day of school. He became
my friend after that. (she)
6. My friend told teacher that she was wrong. (confusing pronoun)
1. Finally he could found a way to improve his life of hisself and

Personal (Determiners) children. (himself)
2. If a student is worried all the time their scores will be not good.
(his/her)
3. Teacher told us that we should study hard to good scores in my
exams. (our)
4. my grandmother was sick. I bought his drugs. (her)
1. The students which know English have a better chance for work.
Relative Pronoun (who)
2. The people that they saw this movie…(who)
3. This problems is worse for women especially that they live in the
countries like Iran. (who)
4. the topic in which the teacher talked was…(that)
5. I saw a girl that were kind in the first day of school. (who)
Demonstrative 1. This problems is worse for women especially that they live in the
countries like Iran. (problem)
2. The husband's idea differed from wife's idea about this
issues.(these)
566
Comparative
2.Substitution Nominal
Verbal
Clausal
3.Ellipsis Nominal
Verbal
Clausal
4. Conjunction 1. Because of my sister was not good in English,… (because)
2. I met her when 11 years old. (incorrect use of conjunction)
5.Lexical Repetition 1. The woman who was very kind she came near me.
2. I was very happy because my mother was beside to me.
(redundant prepositions)
3. The people that they saw this movie…
4. Finally he could found a way to improve his life of hisself and
children. (himself)
Synonymy
Antonymy
Hyponymy
Collocation
1. I wanted to receive my goals. (gain/reach goals)
2. We can describe idea for the other nation (describe sth to sb)
3. He appreciates with this situation. (addition of preposition)
4. So, it takes time to adapt in new situations. (adapt to sth)
5. Because of my sister was not good in English,… (good at sth/at
doing sth)
6. To my opinion, there are lots of… (in my opinion)
7,8. The husband's idea differed from wife's idea about this
issues.(differ with sb on sth)
9. At last, they arrived to Tehran. (arrive in)
1.3. High-level learners' most frequent cohesive errors
The high-level learners' most frequent errors were involved in lexical cohesion (17), references (14),
567
conjunction cohesion (3), and substitution (1), among the total of 35. The frequencies and percentages of
devices from each category and subcategory that were identified as errors in the high-level learners set of
essays are presented in Table 5.
Table 5: High-level learners' frequencies and percentages of errors in cohesion categories and
subcategories
Reference 14 40% Personal 12 85.71%
Demonstrative 0 0%
Comparative 2 14.28%
Substitution 1 2.85% Nominal 0 0%
Verbal 1 100%
Clausal 0 0%
Verbal 0 0%
Clausal 0 0%
lexical 17 48.57% Repetition 5 29.41%
Synonymy 0 0%
Antonymy 0 0%
Hyponymy 0 0%
Table 5 shows that the majority of the errors are in referential cohesive devices and lexical type in the high-
level learners' compositions. Moreover, the majority of the most frequent errors, lexical type, are involved in
collocation and repetition, and the majority of the second most frequent errors, referential type, are involved
in personal and comparative respectively. Furthermore, examples from each of the error types are shown in
Table 6. In each of the examples, the devices which were used incorrectly are underlined.
Table 6: High-level learners' cohesive errors
Categories Subcategories High-level learners' cohesion errors
1. Reference Personal (Pronoun) 1. Genetic affect disease. They can also influence our characteristics.
(it)
2. Although class was very crowd, but I liked them. (it)
3. The parents had argument with each other and finally he divorced.
(they)
4. Roza's house was near school. He was on time. (she)
5. It was my teacher.(he/she)
6. My father…She wanted to wake me to go to school. (he)
Personal (Determiners)
1. Although ...class was very crowd, but I liked them. (Ø)
2. Roza's house was near school. (the school)
568
Relative Pronoun 1. The little girl that sleep on the bed…(who)

2. The people that they don’t eat meat are healthy(who)
3. Different countries have different cultures and a person which live in
a country …. (who)
4. I saw a woman whom looked very seriously. (who)
Demonstrative
Comparative 1. When we were in kindergarten or even in school, we think that we

were much happier in those days. (more)
2. I lost my notebook at the first day of school but my mother gave me
the other one after that. (another one)
2.Substitution Nominal
Verbal 1. I shouted and my classmates do too. (did)
Clausal
3.Ellipsis Nominal
Verbal
Clausal
4. Conjunction 1. Although class was very crowd, but I liked them. (although or but)
2. She didn’t really want to go and I insisted. (but)
3. They grow up with a custom an culture that is different from another
country.(and)
5.Lexical Repetition 1. Also joining to group clubs will be helpful. (clubs)
2. He was the boy whom I talked to him in the first day of my school.
3. The people that they don’t eat meat are healthy.
4,5. A person which live in a country they grow up with a custom an
culture that is different from another country that they go there.
Synonymy
Antonymy
Hyponymy
1. He congratulated sincerely your marriage. (congratulate on sth)

Collocation
2. From now, I will study hard. (from now on)
3. Foreigners need English in communication. (need sb/sth for)
569
4. …, although to some extend it is not tolerable. (to some extent)

5. Also joining to group clubs will be helpful. (joining)
6. Beside, you can ask your friend. (besides)
7. The family thought that this may not fully but in the great extent
reduces the homesickness. (to the great extent)
8. do to me a favor (do sb a favor)
9. ….from 1963 until 2001. (to)
10. In the other hand,…(on the other hand)
11. The film was funny and we laugh to it all the time (laugh at)
12. She wanted to wake me to go to school. (wake me up)
2. The differences in the Iranian EFL learners' cohesive errors which can be attributed to L2
proficiency
The next step in this study was to investigate the sources of errors rather than the most frequent errors per
se. Basically, most researchers have been satisfied with a general distinction between intralingual and
interlingual causes of errors (Richards, 1974; Brown 1980 cited in Hasyim, 2002; James, 1998). Of course,
although the distinction is not always clear-cut, the present study attempted to investigate the effect of L2
proficiency and L1 interference phenomenon on Iranian EFL learners' application of cohesive devices.
Furthermore, within the discussion of the causes of errors, a fairly full range of examples are presented in
order to provide a sense of variation that existed. Indeed, the examples should be viewed as only illustrative,
indicating the general characteristics by which the error source could be identified. This part deals mostly with
the intralingual causes of errors.
The majority of instances in which a noncohesive item replaced a necessary cohesive one appeared in
relative clauses. See the examples below.
1. The people that they saw this movie…(who)
2. The wife saw that man which was thief. (who)
3. Call with the people which live there. (who)
Errors of this sort can be attributed to the effect of L2 proficiency because the learners did not fully
understand the distinction in the target language.
A separate category that also may be the result of intralingual causes of errors is established here for items
which were used repeatedly.
1. After that I returned back to my home. ("return" means "come back", repetition of words with similar
meaning)
Of course, words with similar meaning should not be used consecutively in a sentence.
2. The most interesting day of my life it is the first day of my school. (repetition of a noun by its pronoun)
3. The woman who was very kind she came near me. (repetition of a noun by its pronoun)
It can be stated that such errors were caused because of the incomplete knowledge of the learners.
Besides, some other intralingual errors appeared in the category of conjunction, as in:
1. Because of my sister was not good in English,… (because)
2. I met her when 11 years old. (incorrect use of conjunction)
Errors of this kind are also the result of the incomplete learners' understanding of the rules in English.
570
3. The differences in the Iranian EFL learners' cohesive errors which can be attributed to L1
interference phenomenon
Surely, a proper attention needs to pay to learners' errors to see if they are really due to L1 interference.
Therefore, this study also tried to describe and analyze learners' errors to find out how learners' mother
tongue plays a role in second language writing. So, this part addresses itself to the interlingual causes of
errors.
In fact, the inconsistencies in the use of references were by far the most common error in cohesion, occurring
most frequently in reference devices. This can be attributed to the effect of native language, here Persian,
because Persian does not make distinction between pronouns, in particular, personal-, possessive-pronouns,
and demonstratives, for example:
1. The old woman went to the hospital. He was sick. (instead of personal pronoun she)
/Pirezæn be bimarestan ræft. ?u mæriz bud/
2. My father gave me a bunch of flower. …she told me…(instead of personal pronoun he)
/Pedæram yek dæste gol be mæn dad…?u be mæn goft…/
3. My mother had to go because he was a teacher. (instead of personal pronoun she)
/Madæm mæjbur bud berævæd čon ?u yek moælem bud/
As it is obvious, /?u/ is used for indicating the personal pronouns he and she in Farsi.
Besides, /æsh/ in Persian is used for indicating the possessive pronouns her, his, their, and its in English as
shown in the examples below:
1. My grandmother was sick. I bought his drugs. (instead of possessive pronoun her)
/Madærbozorge mæn mæriz bud. Mæn daruhayæsh ra xaridæm/
2. She talked about them with his neighbor. (instead of possessive pronoun her)
/?u dær morede ?anha ba hæmsayeæsh sohbæt kærd/
Another identifiable set of error which may be the result of L1 interference was the misuse of demonstratives
as in:
1. This bad problems (instead of these)
/in moshkelate bad/
2. This issues (instead of these)
/in mæsael/
Indeed, in Persian, there is no agreement between the determiner and its referent while this is not the case in
English.
Moreover, a fairly wide variety of unidiomatic equivalents appeared in the subcategory of collocation. Most of
the interlingual forms used for lexical cohesion reflect more general problems with the use of prepositions, as
in the examples below:
1. He congratulated sincerely your marriage. (congratulate on sth)
/?u ezdevaje shoma ra samimane tabrik goft/
2. I agree with this issue. (agree on sth)
/mæn ba in mæsæle moafeqam/
3. We enjoyed from the movie. (enjoy sth)
/ma æz film lezæt bordim/
4. The film was funny and we laugh to it all the time (laugh at)
Film xandedar bud væ ma tæmame modat be ?an xændidim/
5. Do to me a favor. (do sb a favor)
/be man lotfi kon/
6. We can describe this idea for the other nation (describe sth to sb)
/ma mitævanim in æqide ra bæraye digær melætha tosif konim/
7. He appreciates with this situation. (addition of preposition)
/?u æz in moqeiæt qædrdani kærd/
571
Discussion
In the current study, as mentioned before, the first step was to investigate the most frequent cohesive errors
committed by Iranian undergraduate EFL learners at different levels of proficiency. With regard to the
frequencies and percentages of errors shown in tables 1, 3, 5. it was evident that low-level learners' most
frequent errors were involved in references (20), followed by errors in lexical (14), and conjunctive cohesion
(1). Besides, the findings showed that errors in references were the most common (17), followed by errors in
lexical (13), and conjunction cohesion (2) in the mid-level learners' narrative compositions. Finally, the high-
level learners' most frequent errors were involved in lexical cohesion (17), references (14), conjunction
cohesion (3), and substitution (1). This is because, as mentioned before, despite the significant role of
cohesive devices in writing, the topic of cohesive errors in composition seems not to have received as much
attention as it deserves and there are only a small number of studies exclusively aimed at cohesive errors.
The second goal in this study was to explore the sources of cohesive errors committed by Iranian EFL
undergraduate learners. As obvious, classifying learners' sources of errors into well-defined, clean-cut
categories is not always possible. However, researchers can gain a fine view of learner language by
examining errors.
In this study, errors in the use of relative pronouns, conjunctions, along with different forms of repetition
appeared because of the incomplete knowledge of the learners—intralingual causes. This result is consitent
with those of Kim (1987), Sattayatham and Honsa (2007), Tabatabai (1985), and Ahmadvand (2008) who
reported that the most frequent learners' errors were mostly independent of the learner's native language.
Furthermore, in the current study, the errors in the use of personal-, possessive-pronouns, and
demonstratives and collocations were among the interlingual causes of errors. This result supports Ying
(1987), Jiang (1995), Zhang (2007), Koosha and Jafarpour (2006), and khodabandes' (2007) findings which
demonstrate the influence of one's native language to second language acquisition.
Conclusions
As described, despite the significant role of cohesive devices in writing, the topic of cohesive errors in
composition seems not to have received as much attention as it deserves. Furthermore, there are only a
small number of studies exclusively aimed at cohesive errors and the origins of such errors. In an effort to fill
this gap, the present study attempted to find Iranian EFL learners' L2 writing errors along with the origin of
such errors.
With regard to the frequencies and percentages of errors, it was found that low-level learners' most frequent
errors were involved in references (20), followed by errors in lexical (14), and conjunctive cohesion (1).
Besides, the findings showed that errors in references were the most common (17), followed by errors in
lexical (13), and conjunction cohesion (2) in the mid-level learners' narrative compositions and, finally, the
high-level learners' most frequent errors were involved in lexical cohesion (17), references (14), conjunction
cohesion (3), and substitution (1).
This study also allowed for an examination of the sources of cohesive errors. And, it was found that errors in
the use of relative pronouns, conjunctions, along with different forms of repetition appeared because of the
incomplete knowledge of the learners—intralingual causes. Furthermore, the errors in the use of personal-,
possessive-pronouns, demonstratives and collocations were among the interlingual causes of errors.
Pedagogical implications
The findings in this study have the following pedagogical implications:

1. In the case of substitution, ellipsis, and conjunction, there were only seven errors in total. This probability
reflects more the fact that few attempts were made to use these devices than any overall control over them.
572
2. Besides, the low incidence of various types of lexical devices, substitution, ellipsis, and conjunction, at
least in part, may result from the training process. If structures are not presented and practiced, they will
become much less likely that students will use them; they will, instead, use familiar structures.
3. The results of this study highlight the need to provide L2 learners with writing experiences by emphasizing
the importance of cohesive devices in accomplishing the writing task.
4. Analysis of the written product is perhaps the most common approach to investigate characteristics of
students' compositions.
References
Ahmadvand, M. (2008). Analyzing errors of Iranian EFL learners in their written productions. Retrieved March 27, 2009, from
http://moslem17.googlepapers.com/AnalysingerrorsofIranianEFLlearners.pdf
Allan, D. (1985). Oxford Placement Test 1B1. Oxford University Press.Answers to all TOEFL essay questions.ToeflEssay.com
Castro, C. D. (2002). Effects of L2 writing proficiency levels and thinking aloud on cohesive device use and composing behaviors of
Filipino first-year college students. Unpublished master's thesis. Georgetown University, Columbia, U.S. Retrieved March 12, 2009, from
http://proquest.umi.com/pdqweb?did=764781441&sid=1&Fmt=2&clientld=46449&PQT=309&VNa me=PQD
Choi, J. (2005). A contrastive analysis of argumentative essays written in English by Korean ESL students and by native English-
speaking students. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Southern IllinoisUniversity Carbondale, U.S.
Halliday, M. K., & Hasan, R. (1976). Cohesion in English. London: Longman.
Halliday, M. K., & Matthiessen, C. M. (2004). An Introduction to Functional Grammar. 3d ed. London: Arnold.
Hasyim, S. (2002). Error Analysis in the teaching of English. Retrieved March 27,2009, from
http://puslit2.petra.ac.id/ejournal/index.php/ing/articlePDFInterstitial/15485/15477
Jiang, M. C. (1995). An analysis of Chinese learners' errors in prepositions. Journal of National Chiayi Institute of Agriculture, 41, 187-
201.
James, C. (1998). Errors in language learning and use: Exploring Error Analysis. London: Longman.
Jonson, P. (1992). Cohesion and coherence in compositions in Malay and English. RELC Journal, 23(2), 1-17.
Keshavarz, M. D. (1999). Contrastive Analysis and Error Analysis (6th ed.). Tehran: Rahnama Press.
Khodabandeh, F. (2007). Analysis of students' errors: The case of headlines. The Asian ESP Journal, 3(1), 6-21.
Khalil, A. (1989). A study of cohesion and coherence in Arab EFL students' writing. System, 17(3), 359-371.
Kim, H. (1987). An analysis of learners' errors made in their English composition especially in the high school level. Unpublished
master's thesis. Chungbuk National University, Chungju, Korea.
Kim, S. (2001). An Error Analysis of college students' writing: Is that really Konglish? Studies in Modern Grammar, 25, 159-174.
Nemati, M. (1999). The effect of mode of discourse on writing performance. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Leicester, England.
Koosha, M., & Jafarpour, A. A. (2006). Data-driven Learning and Teaching collocation of prepositions: The Case of Iranian EFL Adult
Learners. Asian EFL Journal, 8(8), 200-216.
Neuuner, J. L. (1987). Cohesive ties and chains in good and poor freshman essays. Research in the Teaching of English, 17, 215-229.
Richards, J. C. (1974). Error Analysis: Perspectives on second language acquisition. London: Longman.
Sattayatham, A., & Honsa, S. (2007). Medical students' most frequent errors at Mahidol University, Thailand. Asian EFL Journal, 9(2),
170-194.
Tabatabai, M. (1985). Error analysis: The types and the causes of the major structural errors made by Iranian university students when
writing expository and imaginative prose (Report No.AAT-8528232). New York, NY:State University of New York at Buffalo.
Ting, F. (2003). An investigation of cohesive errors in the writing of PRC tertiary EFL students. Retrieved December 15, 2008, from
http://www.stets.org.sg/Vol2N2_2003FengTing.pdf.
Tonder, V., & Louise, S. (1999). Lexical cohesion in student academic writing. Unpublished master's thesis, University of South Africa,
South Africa. Retrieved March 12, 2009, from http://proquest.umi.com/pdqweb?did=732156651&sid=1&Fmt=2&clientld=46449&PQT
=309&VName=PQD
Zhang, M. (2000). Cohesive features in the expository writing of undergraduates in two Chinese universities. RELC Journal, 31(1), 61-
95.
Zhang, S. (2007). Analysis and classifications of common errors in spoken and written English caused by Chinese university students'
lack of English grammatical knowledge.US-China ForeignLanguage, 5(5), 1-5.
573

Does Access to Finance Reduce Poverty? Evidence from Katsina State
Haruna Mohammed Aliero
Department of Economics, Faculty of Social Sciences

Usmanu Danfodiyo University Sokoto
Tel: 08022482623, 08135219790
Saifullahi Sani Ibrahim
Department of Economics
Isa Kaita College of Education
Dutsin-ma, Katsina State
E-mail:[email protected]
Tel: 08035958546
Doi:10.5901/mjss.2012.v3n2.575
Abstract Enhancing access to formal financial services especially credit to the rural populace has been identified as a means of
reducing poverty in developing countries. This paper investigates whether access to financial services reduces poverty in Nigeria
focusing specially on rural areas. A cross-sectional primary data was generated using a structured questionnaire administered
on randomly selected respondents from rural areas of Katsina state. The study used multinomial logit model in examining the
relationship, and the study found a negative relationship between poverty level and access to financial services. The study
concludes that promoting access to formal financial services increases the level of income of the rural dwellers and thus a
retarding effect on the level of poverty in the rural areas.
Key words: Access to finance, poverty, rural populace, financial services
1. Introduction
Nigerian governments implemented several development plans aimed at serving as a catalyst for expanding
the country’s production possibility frontier. However, it turns out that population explosion and abject
poverty which appears to be undisputed features of developing economies predominates in Nigeria (Ekong,
1977; Olayide, Eweka and Osagie 1980; Babasanya, Bolagun, Zungun and Olawohuwa, 2008). On the other
hand, Nigeria is endowed with abundant resources both human and material, yet it has been classified as
one of the poorest countries in terms of its per capita income (Umoh and Ibanga, 1997). Also available data
(see for instance, UNDP, 1990 and World Bank, 1995) revealed that basic social and economic indicators
point to the fact that even when the rest of developing countries are making substantial progress, Nigeria is
not getting beyond where it was thirty years ago. The country is also disturbed with severity of poverty; the
World Bank (1995) reported that poverty was found to be a rural phenomenon, in every 10 million of
Nigerians, 8.4 million are extremely poor people being from rural areas. The rural sector is made up of small-
scale poor farmers, food processors, informal traders and other micro-entrepreneurs who are said to account
for about two-third of the population living in poverty (World Bank, 1996). More so, UNDP (2010) ranked
Nigeria as 142nd in a sample of 169th poorest countries in the world. Unsurprisingly, the poor are
disproportionately located in rural areas, primarily engaged in agricultural and associated activities and are
mostly women and children than adult males (Todaro, 2000). On the other hand, the rural poor need only a
little money to set up a business that can make a dramatic difference in the quality of their lives (Yunus,
575
2006). Poverty in Nigeria, particularly in the rural areas, could be linked to lack of adequate financial access
in the area, among other things (Egwuatu, 2008; Ladipo, 2008).
Against this background, the study seeks to investigate the relationship between access to financial
services and poverty reduction in rural areas. Specifically, the study will examine the extent to which the
provision of a better financial system to rural areas has actually reduced poverty in the rural areas. To
achieve the objective, the paper is divided into five sections including this introduction. Section two presents
literature review, section three describe the methodology, section four shows the results and discussions,
while the last section concludes the study.
There is ample evidence showing a strong and causal relationship between financial sector development and
economic growth. An efficient financial sector that responds to the needs of the private sector increases
investment, enhances economic growth, and creates a job which is one of the major challenges for
developing economies (Nasr, 2006). Improving households’ access to financial services will also help to
reduce poverty and improve income equality while financial exclusion can retard economic growth and
increase poverty and inequality (Butler and Cornaggia, 2008). Robust economic growth cannot be achieved
without putting in place well focused programmes to reduce poverty through empowering the people by
increasing their access to factors of production, especially credit (CBN, 2005a). The capacity of poor for
entrepreneurship would be significantly enhanced through the provision of financial services to enable them
engage in economic activities and be more self-reliant, increase employment opportunities, enhance
household income thereby leading to economic growth.
Broad access to financial services is related to the economic and social development agenda for at least
two reasons. First, a large theoretical and empirical literature has shown the importance of well developed
financial system for economic development and poverty alleviation (Beck et al., 2000; Beck et al., 2004).
Second, access to financial services can be seen as a public good that is essential to enables participation in
the benefits of a market based economy, in an analogous way, as is access to safe water, basic health
services, and primary education (Peachey and Roe, 2004). Similarly, Sacerdoti (2005) argued that faster
economic growth will not be possible without a deepening of the financial system and, in particular, more
support from the banking system. He further showed that there is strong association between access to bank
credit and overall economic development of a country. Access to finance can help poor to increase income,
build viable business, and reduce their vulnerability to external shocks. It can also be a powerful instrument
for self-empowerment by enabling the poor, especially women, to become economic agents of changes
(Bashir, 2008). As noted by De la Torre and Schmukler (2006), the discussion of the plausible channels
through which financial depth could cause economic growth often resorts to access related stories.
Prominent in this regard is the Schumpeterian view that finance leads to growth because it reduces creative
destruction by allocating resources to efficient newcomers. That is through broader access to external funds,
talented newcomers are empowered and freed the disadvantages that would otherwise arise from their lack
of inherited wealth and absence of connection to the network of well off incumbents (Rajan and Zingales,
2003).
Aggregate economic growth and efficiency are influenced by financial transaction in their role in
agglomerating capital, selecting projects most likely to yield the highest return, monitoring borrowers
(investors), enforcing contracts, transferring, sharing, and pooling risk, and promoting diversification (Stiglitz,
1993). An expansion of the supply of agricultural credit will have a better chance of success if it is embedded
in effort to improve the performance of rural financial market and in effort to achieve greater market
integration and more rapid economic growth in the rural areas (Gonzalez-Vega, 2003). The ability of the poor
to borrow a small amount of money to take advantages of a business opportunity not only impacts positively
on eradication of poverty but also tend to swell the rank of micro-entrepreneurs (Egwuatu, 2008). The supply
576
of efficient, sustainable, and broadly-based financial service is particularly important in rural areas, giving
high risks and transaction costs in most rural markets for goods, services, assets, and factors of production,
which result in large degrees of market fragmentation that is, the costs and risk are responsible for low level
of market integration and for a wide dispersion of the marginal rates of return on resources used (Mckinnon,
1973).
The growing interest in rural financial deepening has been an interest in poverty alleviation. Though, the
relationship between poverty and finance are quite complex, it is most important to recognize that, despite
major earlier attempts to expand the supply of agricultural credit and despite the massive use of public funds
for this purpose, the majority of the rural population of the developing countries has actually never had
access to formal financial services (Gonzale-vega, 2003).
3. Methodology
Katsina state was carved out of Kaduna state in 1987; it is made-up of 34 local Government Areas (LGAs)
and the state is located in the North Western part of the country. It is bordered by Niger Republic in the
North, Kano state in the South, Kaduna state in the South-West, Jigawa in the East, Sokoto and Zamfara
states in the West. The native people are predominantly Hausa and Fulani while Islam is their major religion,
while Christians constitute small proportions. Katsina state has a total population of 5,801,584 as at 2006
census (NPC, 2007). The main economic activity of the rural people of Katsina state is farming (small scale
farming, animal husbandry and food processing). Informal trading and other micro-entrepreneurship are also
playing a crucial role in their economic life (www.katsinastategov.ng). Despite CBN directive on rural
banking, most rural areas in the state do not have even a single financial institution, talk less of insurance
company.
A cross-sectional primary data was collected from 384 respondents dwelling in rural areas of Katsina
state through administered questionnaire. The selection of the LGAs in the state that represents population
of the study was randomly made. The LGAs were arranged in alphabetical order; number was allotted to
each upon which table of the random numbers was used to select six LGAs, the selected LGAa were Mani,
Safana, Zango, Kurfi, Rimi and Kankara. However, the respondents from each of the selected LGAs were
purposely selected due to the unavailability of a sample frame. A total of 384 questionnaires was shared to
the selected LGAs based on Proportional Allocation Formula (PAF).
Average monthly income of the respondents was used by IPAR (2007) to proxy poverty. Respondents
with income level below $2 per day will proxy rural poor because Sani (2008) argued that extreme poor are
those with daily income level of less than one US dollar. This is in line with the millennium declaration
popularly known as MDGs. Therefore, respondents with income level above $2 per day were coded 1 and 0 if
otherwise. IPAR (2007) further used the level of financial exposure of the respondents on Saving Account,
Current Account, Fixed Deposit, Loans, ATM/Credit/Debit Card, Loan, Insurance, Mobile Banking, Internet
Banking, Shares and Pension to proxy access to finance. They coded 0 for individuals who didn’t answer the
question or did not know the answer, 1 for individuals that had never used the product, 2 for individuals who
used the product before, 3 for individuals who have other members of the household using the product in
question and 4 was allocated to individuals who currently have the product. Nevertheless, in this study 0 was
coded for the respondents unanswered the question or do not know the answer, 1 was awarded to
individuals who had never used the product, 2 for individuals who used the product before and 3 for
individuals who are currently using the product.
Logit model was used to analyse the influence of independent variables (financial services) on the
dependent variable (level of income). The model is given below:
Pr ( Yi =1) = F (Xi'b)…………….(1)
Where
577
Pr(Yi ) = probability of income of the respondentsi is N10,000 and above

X = vector of explanatory variables
b = parameter to be estimated
F = cumulative logistic functions also known as log odds
Since the respondents exhibit different categories of income level, we applied multinomial logit model to
ascertain how the degree of financial services usage vary among the different income categories of the
respondents. The respondents were categorised into four income brackets, below N10, 000, N10, 001 – N15,
000, N15, 001 – N20, 000 and N20, 001 and above. Therefore, the model is further modified to
accommodate different income brackets of the respondents, as such; the model is given in turn.
Pr ( >10000 = 0 ) = F ( Xi β)…………… .(3)
Pr (10000 – 15000 =1) = F ( XiФ)………(4)
Pr (15001 – 20000 =1) = F ( XiΩ)……..(5)
Pr (20001 and above =1) = F ( Xiδ)……(6)
Where β, Ф, Ω and δ are parameters to be estimated, and F is the normal cumulative distributions function.
The result is divided into two parts i.e. descriptive results and inferential results.
Table 1: Demographic distributions of the respondents
Variables Frequency Percent

Sex
Male 298 78
Female 86 22
Marital status
Single 125 33
Married 251 65
Divorced 8 2
Educational qualifications
No formal education 136 37
Primary school 67 17
Secondary school 81 21
Equivalent diploma 71 19
Degree and above 28 7
Occupation
No response 7 2
Farming 167 44
Business 120 31
Civil servant 90 23
Income range in Naira
Below 10,000 84 22
10,001-15,000 111 29
15,001-20,000 95 25
Above 20,000 94 24
Source: survey, 2010
In Table 1 above, it shows that 298 respondents were male while 86 respondents were female representing
78% and 22% respectively. The Table also shows information regarding the marital status of the
respondents and it indicated that majority of the respondents were married, numbering 251, while 125
respondents were single and only 8 were divorced representing 65%, 33% and 2% respectively. Moreover,
578
data pertaining to educational qualifications of the respondents shows that 137 of the respondents do not
have any formal education, 67 possess primary school leaving certificate, 81 indicated having secondary
school certificate, 71 with diploma/NCE and its equivalent, 28 of them have first degree certificate and above
representing 36%, 17%, 21%, 19% and 7% respectively. This data coincides with Beck et al., (2006)
assertion that finance appears inaccessible because of high rate of illiteracy in rural areas. Table 1 above,
further shows the frequency of the occupational distribution of the respondents. It was observed that 7
respondents (2%) did not respond to the question, 167 (44%) were farmers, 90 (23%) were civil servant, 120
(31%) indicated business as their occupation. In order to avoid multiplicity of response, respondents that
affiliated to more than one occupation were only asked to give their major one. We similarly depict the
monthly income brackets of the respondents from the above Table. One hundred and eleven (111)
respondents (29%) indicated earning N10,000 – N 15,000, 95 respondents or 25% indicated N15,001 -
N20,000 as their income bracket, 94 or 24% were earning above N20,000, while 84 (22%) indicates earning
below N10,000.
Table 2: Summary of Multinomial Logit Regression
Coefficient
Variables (4) (5) (6) Probability
Saving account -0.27 -0.42 -0.56 0.202
(- 1.28) (-1.96)** (-2.60)***
Current account 0.10 0.10 0.25 0.692
(0.44) (0.40) (1.08)
Fixed deposit 0.74 0.73 0.54 0.234
(1.67)* (1.44) (1.19)
Loan 0.01 -0.88 -0.64 0.985
(0.02) (-2.60)*** (-2.07)**
ATM/debit card 0.06 -0.08 0.29 0.787
(0.27) (-0.32) (1.20)
Insurance -1.12 -1.12 0.18 0.721
(-1.57) (-1.57) (0.36)
Microfinance 0.37 0.37 -0.6 0.840
(1.25) (1.25) (-0.20)
Mobile banking 0.93 0.93 -0.69 0.172
(2.27)** (2.27)** (-1.37)
Pseudo R 2 0.40
LR Chi2 42.03***
No. of observation 384
* ** *** Indicate significance at 10, 5 & 1 percent probability levels
Z-ratios in parenthesis
Source: Survey, 2010.
Table 2 above shows the summary of multinomial logit regression results. It could be discerned from the
result that the estimated coefficient of saving is negative but not significant in equation 4, while the estimated
coefficient is significant in equation 5 and 6. The result means that high income class has more capacity to
save than poor dwelling in rural areas. The finding appears to support the predication of Economics theory of
savings which argues that saving is a function of the level of income. On the contrary, the estimated
coefficients of current account and fixed deposit are positive but statistically insignificant in all models
however both have 69% and 23% probabilities of reducing poverty. Moreover, the estimated coefficient of
loan is positive but insignificant in equation 3, while the estimated coefficient in equation 4 and 5 are and
statistically significant at 1% and 5% level of significance respectively. The estimated coefficient of loan has
the highest probability (98%) of reducing poverty in rural areas. This finding tends to supports Burgess and
Pande (2003), who asserted that access to formal finance is critical for enabling the poor to transform their
579
production systems and thus exit poverty. Access to finance through credit assists the poor not only to
smooth their consumption expenditure but also to build their assets, which enhance their productive capacity
(IPAR, 2007).
Further more, the estimated coefficients of ATM and insurance are not statistically significant in all
equation but has approximately 79% and 72% likelihood of reducing poverty in rural areas respectively.
Similarly, the estimated coefficient of microfinance is statistically insignificant in all equations with 84%
probability of reducing poverty in rural areas. The estimated coefficients of mobile banking are positive and
significant at 5% level of significance in equation 3 and 4 respectively. Moreover, the estimated coefficient in
equation 5 is not statistically significant. The coefficient has 17% probability of reducing poverty in rural
areas. The overall model is adequate given by significant LR Chi2 value at 1% level of significance, so also
40% variations in dependent variable is jointly explained by independent variables as shown by Pseudo R2
value.
5. Conclusion and Recommendation
The study found that access to formal financial services increases with level of respondents’ income in rural
areas also most of the variables that were examined indicated a very high probability of reducing poverty. It
could therefore be concluded that enhancing access to formal finance especially credit has a high likelihood
of reducing poverty in rural areas. The implication of this study is that the federal government of Nigeria and
financial institutions in the country should take up the challenge of establishing bank branches in the rural
areas or make formidable arrangement for supplying more credit to the rural dwellers. This study suggests
that group lending strategy of Grammen Bank of Bangladesh could be copied, since the bank recorded very
low default rate. This is based on the premise that the government policy priority is poverty reduction.
Reference
Babasanya, B., Bolagun, O., Zungum, A. and Olowohunwa, J. (2008). Rural Development: An Approach to Poverty Alleviation in Nigeria.
International Journal of Economics and Development, Universal Consortia. Pp.28-41.
Bashir, U. (2008). Overview of Credit Delivery Channels in Nigeria. Bullion Publication of Central Bank of Nigeria, Vol. 32, N0 1. Pp. 1-6.
Beck, T., Levine, R. and Loyaza (2000). Finance and the Source of Growth. Journal of Financial Economics. No.58. Pp261-300.
Beck, T., Demirgue- kunt, A., and Levine, R. (2004). Finance, Inequality and Poverty Alleviation. Cross-Country Evidence, World Bank
Policy Research Working Paper. Pp2-21.
Beck, T., Demirgue- kunt, A., Laeven, L. and Makisimovic, V. (2006). The Determinants of Financing Obstacles. Journal of International
Money and Finance. Pp4-14.
Burgess, R. and Pande, R.(2003). Do Rural Banks Matter? Evidence from the Indian
Social Banking Experiment. Research Paper.
Butler, W.A. and Cornaggia, J.(2008). Does Access to External Finance Improve Productivity? Evidence from a Natural Experiment.
Paper Presented at International Seminar Held at Baylor University, USA.
Central Bank of Nigeria (2005). Annual Reports and Statement of Accounts. Pp3-5.
De la Torre, A. and Schmukler, S. (2006). Innovative Experience in access: Market Friendly Roles for the Visible Hand. Latin America
Regional Study. World Bank. Pp12-17.
Egwuatu, B. (2008). Reducing Poverty through Better Credit Delivery: The Asian Experience. Bullion, CBN. Pp8-14.
Ekong, E. (1977). Evaluating Development, the Case of Western Nigeria. Ilesha, Ilesanmi Press Nigeria Limited. Pp2-21.
Gonzalez-Vega, C. (2003). Deepening Rural Financial Markets: Macroeconomic, Policy and Political Dimensions. Paper for Paving the
Way forward: an International Conference on Best Practices Rural Finance. Washington. D. Pp3-52.
IPAR (2007). Poverty Reduction Through Enhance Access to Financial Service: Case Study of Botswana, Kenya and Namibia.
Occasional Paper No.010/2007.
Ladipo, M. (2008). Enhancing Financial Innovation and Access. Results of survey of Nigerian Adult Population. Pp2-8.
McKinnon, R. (1973). Money and Capital in Economic Development, Washington, D.C. The Brookings Institutions. Pp3-15.
Nasr, S. (2006). Access to Finance and Economic Growth in Egypt. The World Bank. Washington D.C. Pp.40-180.
Olayide, S., Eweka, A. and Osagie, B. (1980). Nigeria’s Small Farmer: Problems and Prospects in Integrated Rural Development. Centre
for Agricultural research In Development, University of Ibadan, Nigeria. Pp3-11.
Peachy, S. and Roe, A (2004). Access to Finance; A study for the World Saving Banks Institute. Pp3-7.
Rajan, R. and Zingales, L. (2003). Savings Capitalism from the Capitalists, Crown Business, New York.
580
Sacerdot, E. (2005). Access to Bank Credit in Sub-Saharan Africa: Key Issues and Reform Strategies. IMF Working Paper, WP/05/166.
Pp3-22.
Sani, S. (2008). The Millennium Development Goals (MDGs): An Appraisal for Economic Development in Nigeria. A Paper Presented at
National Conference, Isa Kaita College of Education, Dutsin-ma.
Stiglitz, J.(1993). The Role of the State in Financial Markets, Proceeding of the World Bank Annual Conference on Development
Economics, Pp 19-62.
Todaro, M.P. (2000) Economic Development. Seventh Ed. Addison Wesley Longman, Inc..
Umoh, G. S. and Ibanga, I. O.( 1997). An Alternative Micro-credit Delivery Model for Poverty Alleviation in Nigeria . Conference
Proceeding. NES. Pp. 521-631.
United Nation Development Programme (1990). Human Development Report. Oxford University Press, London.
______(2010). 6th Country Programme: Poverty Reduction Support Programme of the Government of Nigeria, 2003-2007. Draft
Programme Support Document, 19th February.
World Bank (1995). Poverty. Washington, D.C., Oxpord University Press, London.
______(1996). Sustainable Banking with the Poor- a Worldwide Inventory of Microfinance Institutions.
Yunus, M. (2006). A Hands Up, Not a Handout: Why not Microfinance for Katrina Victims? The Wall Street Journal.
581

Printed for MCSER in April 2012

with the tecnology “print on demand”
by Gruppo Atena.net Srl
Via del Lavoro 22, 36040
Grisignano, VI, Italy
www.atena.net

Edgar Lawrence Doctorow A Political Nove PDF

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Edgar Lawrence Doctorow A Political Nove PDF

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Edgar Lawrence Doctorow A Political Nove PDF

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Mediterranean Center of Social and Educational Research

Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences

Vol. 3, No. 2, May 2012

Rome, Italy 2012

Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences

Executive Director, MCSER Scientific Coordinator

Editing Graphic Design

Editorial Assistant Editorial Managing

Copyright  2012 MCSER – Mediterranean Center of Social and Educational Research

ISSN 2039-9340 (print)

Vol. 3, No. 2, May 2012

 MCSER – Mediterranean Center of Social and Educational Research

This issue is printed with the technology “print on demand”

Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences

Vol. 3, No. 2, May 2012

ISSN: 2039-9340 (print)

About the Journal

Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences (MJSS) is a double blind peer-reviewed

Editor in Chief, Andrea Carteny

Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences is included on the following index/abstracting/library

 IBSS - International Bibliography of  Georgetown University Library

Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences

International Editorial Board

Addison M. Wokocha Sodienye A. Abere

Unemployment and Persistent Poverty in the Niger Delta Region of Nigeria:

The Contrastive Move Analysis: An Investigation of Persian and English

Edgar Lawrence Doctorow; a Political Novelist? 465

Dr. Miftar Ramosacaj

Prof. Assoc. Dr. Alba Dumi

1.1 Conceptual and economical model overview and ITC data

2. Literature Review and Hypotheses

2.1. Focus of Mathematical concepts and using in management plan

2.2 MMDM and management analyses

2.3 Evolution of Mathematical Decision and internet technology development

: the set of respondents without access to the network

The individual utility function is expressed in the form

or U*TR*( qr* qs*qg) when r,s,g are indicators

, if the individual has access and otherwise.

A linear approximation of the conditional utility function would be:

3. Methodology and Research Goal

Tab 2. The web page of the hotel

Conclusions and recommendation

R Bogacz, E Brown, J Moehlis, P Holme, Psychological 2006 - psycnet.apa.org

WHO. European Health for All Database, May, 2010

Sustainability of Agricultural Cooperative Societies in Nigeria:

Department of Agricultural Economics/Extension

Keywords: Agricultural Cooperatives, Sustainability, Capital

3. Result and Discussion

Table 1: percentage of loan advance by purpose (N000 )

Purpose Active group Passive group Total

Field survey 2011

Table 2: Occupation distribution of members of cooperative groups

Purpose Active Passive Total

3.2 Women Emplowerment

Table 3: Distribution of members of cooperative group by land holding

Particulars Active Passive Total

Table 4: Distribution of cooperative groups by literacy levels

Particulars Active Passive Total

Field survey, 2011

or UTR( qr* qs*qg) when r,s,g are indicators