"Know Thy Self" - Socrates: Chapter 1: Philosophical Perspective of The Self
"Know Thy Self" - Socrates: Chapter 1: Philosophical Perspective of The Self
eternal truths.
Physical appetite – biological
CHAPTER 1: PHILOSOPHICAL PERSPECTIVE OF needs (e.g. hunger, thirst, sexual
THE SELF desire)
Spirit or passion – basic
“Know thy self” –Socrates emotions (e.g. love, anger,
SOCRATES (468-399 BCE) ambition, aggressiveness, and
empathy)
“An unexamined life is not worth living” Reason can sort things out and exert
More concern of the problem of the self control, restoring harmonious
Engage in systematic questioning about relationship when conflict occurs
the self If man lives in accordance to his nature,
Priority is knowing thy self then he is giving justice to his existence
Every human possesses an immortal Theory of forms of the two worlds:
soul World of forms (nonphysical ideas)
Man is dualistic: body and soul – real and permanent
Two dichotomous realms of reality: World of sense ( reality) –
Physical realm (body) – temporary and only a replica of the
changeable, transient, and ideal world
imperfect If the souls will not work harmoniously,
Ideal realm (soul) –unchanging, human justice will not be served.
eternal, immortal, truth,
goodness and beauty ANCIENT TIMES
The essence of self is soul which is Idealism Dualism 1. Moral
immortal and virtue is
Live an examined life and a life with idealism rooted in
purpose and value the intellect
Meaningful and happy life and lead to
Becomes virtuous and knows happiness.
the value of himself through
2.Wisdom
incessant searching
and
Introspection – Socratic method that knowledge
means carefully examining one’s
thoughts and emotions to gain self- ARISTOTLE
knowledge.
The soul is the essence of the self
ANCIENT TIMES
Does not consider the body and soul as
idealism Socratic 1. Knowledge is separate entities
Philosophy the
Anything with life has a soul
personification
of good while Self-realization is attained by fulfilling
the ignorance man’s threefold nature/three kinds of
is evil. soul:
Vegetative soul – physical body that
2. Self- can grow
knowledge is Sentient soul – sensual desires,
the ultimate feelings, and emotions
virtue. Rational soul (what makes man
human) – intellect that allows man
PLATO (428-347 BC) to know and understand things
– Characterized by moral
“The ideal self, the perfect self” virtues such as justice and courage
The self is an immortal soul Rational nature of the self is to lead a
Self-knowledge and purification of the good, flourishing, and fulfilling life (self-
soul actualization)
Three part soul/self:
Reason – enables us to think DAVID HUMES
deeply, make wise choices,
“The self is the bundle theory of mind” and outer
“Self is a simple bundle of perceptions” self
There is no self
He believes that the self is nothing but a
collection of interconnected and RENE DESCARTES
continually changing perceptions
passing through the theater of our mind “cogito ergo sum” or “I think therefore, I
Knowledge is possible if it is sensed or am”
experienced Father of Modern Philosophy
Distinct entities: The self is the thinking thing, distinct
Impressions – basic sensations of from the body
people’s experience (e.g. hate, love, If to think is infallible, then it can be false
joy, grief, pain, cold and heat) One cannot doubt in the existence of self
– Core of the thoughts The act of thinking about the self, of
makes it lively because of the direct being self-conscious, is in itself a proof
experience that there is a self
Ideas – thoughts and images from 2 distinct:
impressions are less lively and vivid Cogito – a thing that thinks
– You cannot feel it Extenza – the extension of mind
RENAISSANCE which is the body
Empiricist Skeptical All A body is nothing else but a machine that
(expression knowledge is attached to the mid
of doubt) passes Thinking entity as the essence of a
philosophy through the human self:
senses Comprehends
Understands
IMMANUEL KANT (1724-1804) Doubts
Analyzes
“Respect for self” Questions
“The self is not about what gives one his Reasons
personality, it is also the seat of Two dimensions of a human self:
knowledge, acquisition for all human Thinking self (soul) – non-material,
persons” immortal, conscious being,
We construct the self independent of the physical laws of
Everything starts in perceptions and the universe.
impressions Physical body – material, mortal,
There must be a mind that controls or non-thinking entity, fully governed
organizes the impression that men get by the physical laws of nature.
from external world The soul and the body are independent
Time and space are ideas that one of one another, and each can exist
cannot find, there must be an actively without the other.
engage intelligence
The self is the product of reason and a RENAISSANCE
regulative principle Rationalist Mind-body 1. The mind
The self transcends experience dualism and soul can
Rationality – able to understand exist without
abstract ideas with no physical object or the body
sensory experience
2. distinction
RENAISSANCE of soul from
the body can
Empiricist Metaphysics 1. Reason is
make people
of the self the final
believe in
authority of
the afterlife
morality
and soul’s
immortality
2. There is
inner self
(includes JOHN LOCKE (d.1632, d.1704)
reasoning)
“Personal identity”
Human mind at birth is Tabula rasa or a
blank slate 2. Only the
The self is consciousness pure in heart
Conscious awareness (thinking, can see God
reasoning, reflecting identity) and
3. Love of
memory of previous experiences are
God, faith in
the keys to understanding the self
him and
Self-consciousness – a coherent understanding
personal (self) identity or knowledge of his Gospel will
the self as a person ultimately
Consciousness – makes identity of a lead to
person similar in different situations happiness
Knowledge – based on a careful
observations of experiences
Reason – figure out the significance of GILBERT RYLE ( August 19, 1900 – October 6,
sense of experience and to reach 1976)
intelligent conclusions
Reason and introspection enables to “I act therefore, I am”
achieve accurate conclusions about self The self is the way people behave
(or personal identity) Behaviorist
Mind and body can be intrinsically
RENAISSANCE linked in complex and intimate ways
Empiricist Theory of Consciousness Self is the same as bodily behavior
Personal alone is Mind expresses the entire system of
identity where thoughts, emotions and actions that
personal make up the human self
identity or the “Nothing else matters but the behavior
self is found,
of man”
not on the
substance of
either the MODERN TIMES
body or soul. Empiricist The 1. The mind
concept of is the seat
ST. AUGUSTINE (354-430) mind of self. It is
not
separated, it
“You have made us for yourself, O Lord is a parallel
and our hearts are restless until they rest thing to our
in you.” body
“I am doubting, therefore I am”
The self has an immortal soul 2. The mind
Physical body is radically different from is the
and inferior to its inhabitant, the categorical
immortal soul mistake
Body as “spouse” of the soul, both brought
about by
attached to one another by “natural
habitual use
appetite”
through the
Soul is what governs and defines man external
From his work Confessions, humankind world.
is created in the image and likeness of
God MAURICE MERLOU-PONTY (1908-1961)
The self is only known through God
The self seeks to be united with God The self is embodied subjectivity
through faith and reason “Mind and body are intertwined” which
“knowledge can only come by seeing the means it is inseparable
truth that dwells within us.” Knowledge of self is based on a
MIDDLE AGES phenomena of experience
Platonism Neoplatonism 1. All From his book, Phenomenology of
knowledge Perception, everything that people are
leads to God aware of is within consciousness
Consciousness – is responsible for “Being entirely honest with oneself is a
actively structuring conscious ideas and good exercise”
physical behavior The self is multilayered
Self consists of three layers:
MODERN TIMES
Empiricist Phenomenology 1. Both Conscious self or ego (reality
of Perception empiricism principle)- Usually takes into
and account the realistic demands of
intellectualism the situation, the consequences of
are flawed in various actions and the overriding
nature “we
need of balance
are bodies”
Unconscious self or ID (pleasure
2. Experiences principle- basic instinctual drives
do not detach including sexuality, aggressiveness,
on the subject and self-destruction, traumatic
memories, unfulfilled wishes and
PATRICIA CHURCHLAND ( JULY 16, 1943) childhood fantasies, thoughts and
feelings
“Brains are not magical; they are casual Preconscious/subconscious self or
machines” super-ego – not threatening and
Contributed to the fields of philosophy easily brought to mind
of neuroscience, philosophy of the – Located between the
mind, and neuro ethics conscious and the unconscious part
Her research centered between of self
neuroscience and philosophy, with a
current focus on the association of
morality and social brain
MODERN TIMES
Empiricist Neurophilosophy 1. A fully
matured
neuroscience
will
eliminate the
need for
beliefs since
“they are not
real”
2. The
physical
brain gives
us the sense
of self