Materials Chemistry C: Journal of
Materials Chemistry C: Journal of
Materials Chemistry C: Journal of
View Journal
Journal of
Materials Chemistry C
Materials for optical, magnetic and electronic devices
Accepted Manuscript
This article can be cited before page numbers have been issued, to do this please use: T. Sun, P. Wang,
R. Fan, W. Chen, S. Hao and Y. Yang, J. Mater. Chem. C, 2019, DOI: 10.1039/C8TC05968C.
Volume 4 Number 1 7 January 2016 Pages 1–224 This is an Accepted Manuscript, which has been through the
Royal Society of Chemistry peer review process and has been
Journal of accepted for publication.
Materials Chemistry C Accepted Manuscripts are published online shortly after
Materials for optical, magnetic and electronic devices
www.rsc.org/MaterialsC
rsc.li/materials-c
Page 1 of 9 Journal
Please of
doMaterials Chemistry
not adjust marginsC
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 20xx J. Name., 2013, 00, 1-3 | 1
_
such as the preparation method of probes, concentration and crystallize in triclinic system P1 space group. The structure of 3-
instrument parameters.34-36 Therefore, the sensing of small Eu is introduced in detail as a representative (Fig. 1). The
molecules/ions through ratios of relative emission intensities in crystallographically independent Eu3+ ion in the asymmetric
multi-fluorescent centers Ln-MOFs is more reliable and structural unit is coordinated with nine oxygen atoms (seven
accurate. Moreover, in order to effectively distinguish various from four different completely deprotonated DPON 3- ligands,
molecules or ions, complex fluorescent signal combinations and two from coordinated water molecules), and forms a
generated by multi-fluorescent centers are needed. twisted tri-capped triangular prismatic geometry. The bond
Furthermore, the extensive sensing functions make multi- lengths of Eu–O bond range from 2.373(4) to 2.684(4) Å, typical
emission Ln-MOFs an important role in the club of “smart values of Eu(III)–carboxyl complexes.
materials”.22,37,38 The high surface areas result from the ordered The completely deprotonated DPON3- coordinate with four
pore structure can be utilized to preconcentrate analytes to Eu3+ ions through μ4- ƞ1: ƞ1: ƞ1: ƞ2: ƞ1: ƞ1 -bridging mode and the
realize efficient fluorescence recognition. Complex multi- dihedral angle between benzene ring and pyridine ring is
fluorescent outputs are also helpful for the construction of 77.119° (Fig. S1†). Two adjacent Eu3+ ions in the structure are
advanced logic circuits. With the more cost‐effective and facile connected by six carboxyl groups to form [Eu2(COO)6] secondary
operation process than DNA modification, Ln-MOFs molecular building units (SBUs). The [Eu2(COO)6] SBUs are linked to form
system becomes a promising candidate for logical devices. We one-dimensional chains along crystallographic a axis and b axis
believe that it will effectively combine analytes recognition and through carboxyl groups, respectively (Fig. S2†). Then the 2D
logic operation in the near future. framework is further constructed with a one-dimensional
Here, we report a series of Ln-MOFs channel (8.972×8.576 Å2) along the a axis (Fig. 1d). The 2D
{[Ln(DPON)(H2O)2]·(H2O)}n (Ln = Nd (1-Nd), Sm (2-Sm), Eu (3- framework can be simplified to a 3, 6-connected kgd network
Eu), Gd (4-Gd), Tb (5-Tb) and Dy (6-Dy)) and a microscale (Fig. 1c) and the final 3D structure are formed through C1-
heterometallic white light Ln-MOF (Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON) H1B⋯π (2.898 Å) hydrogen bonding interactions (Fig. S3†).
that constructed of flexible ligand H 3DPON. Based on the highly Crystallographic data for Ln-MOFs are listed in Table S1†. Part
guests-depend emission of three emission centers (ligand: of the bond angles and bond lengths are listed in Table S2~S7†.
B415, Tb3+: G544, and Eu3+: R616) in Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON, Furthermore, the results of FT-IR spectra, TG analysis and PXRD
it is fabricated to serve as a fluorescent platform for various patterns (Fig. S4, S5 and S6†) are in good agreement with the
toxic solvent molecules, cations and anions. With open metal results of single-crystal X-ray diffraction analysis.
sites and suitable channel, the Ln-MOF can not only efficiently
recognize formol in aqueous solution within 2 min (limit of
detection (LOD) is 0.0193 vol %), but achieve low-concentration
(1.592 mg/m3) formol detection in vapor. The first Ln-MOF
fluorescent probe for detecting VO43- is also constructed based
on the weak interaction between the guest anion and the
framework (LOD: 0.42 μM). The excellent fluorescence material
can effectively sense different solvent molecules and metal ions
through three-dimensional (3D) readouts by combining
different ratiometric emission intensities of three emission
centers. The outstanding specific surface area result from
micron size also improves detection efficiency. Moreover,
based on the fluorescence turn-on or quenching effect of
several contaminating ions (Fe3+, VO43-, and S2−) on the tri‐
emission fluorescence material, multicomponent recognition
has been achieved through a Boolean logic operation (Scheme Fig. 1. Crystal structure of 3-Eu. (a) asymmetric unit of 3-Eu with hydrogen atoms being
1). Compared to traditional single‐output logic circuits, the omitted for clarity. (b) The 2D framework of 3-Eu, where Eu3+ is represented as a
multiple outputs in our system can produce different logic polyhedron. (c) The view of the 2-D kgd network with {43}2{46·66·83} topology in 3-Eu
(Octahedron represents 6-connected [Eu2(COO)6] SUBs and triangle represents 3-
operations by the same analytes inputting, which can enlarge
connected ligands). (d) The 1D channel of the framework.
the information content in logic library and further improve the
2 | J. Name., 2012, 00, 1-3 This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 20xx
Fig.3. SEM images of Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON, (a) quadrilateral and (b) hexagonal. Scale
bar = 1 μm. (c) PXRD patterns of 1-Nd ~ 6-Dy and Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON. (d) Dynamic Fig. 4. Fluorescence response of Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON toward (a) formol and (b) VO43-
light scattering (DLS) characterization of Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON. , Fe3+ and S2− (1 mM).
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 20xx J. Name., 2013, 00, 1-3 | 3
orbitals (LUMO) of donor and acceptor, and the LUMO energy level Similar with Fe3+, VO43- has also became the important factor
View Article of
Online
of donor should be higher than that of acceptor when PET act as the water pollution due to its wide application inDOI: 10.1039/C8TC05968C
the industries. Different
luminescence quenching mechanism.40 However, an opposite result to the quenching effect, the unique emission spectra of VO43- treated
is obtained from LUMO energy levels of ligand (donor) and formol Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON attracted our attention. The emission
(acceptor) calculated by DFT at the B3LYP/6-31 G* level (Fig. 5b and intensities of the ligand and Tb3+ abruptly decreased and even
absence of the interaction between formol and ligand is confirmed Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON caused by VO43- is also investigated in
by the above results. Moreover, as formol has available functional detail. Firstly, the framework integrity is evidenced by the same PXRD
group (=C=O), the binding energy of Ln3+ reduced in the X‐ray patterns of Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON before and after treated by
photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) spectra with the present of formol VO43-. Then, as the characteristic emission intensity of Eu3+ relies on
as expected (Fig. S12†), indicating the interaction between formol the efficiency of “antenna effect”.44 Hence, the mechanism of
and Ln3+. Therefore, the fluorescence quench of Ln3+ attributes to its fluorescence enhancement at 616 nm may be proposed that VO 43-
interaction with carbonyl in formol. Considering the unchanged can facilitate the efficiency of energy transfer from ligand to Eu3+.
fluorescence lifetime of Ln3+ (Table S11†), the fluorescent quenching However, the absence of available functional groups in ligand
process belongs to a static mechanism.11 excludes the possibility of the interaction of VO43- and ligand.
It is known to all that Fe3+ ion plays an important role in both In addition, considering the situation of energy transfer directly
industrial process and biological systems. However, a lower or higher from VO43- to Eu3+,45-47 the possibility of the interaction of VO43- and
concentration of Fe3+ can seriously affect human health and Ln3+ is investigated. As the XPS spectra shows (Fig. S12†), the Ln3d
environmental safety.41-43 Therefore, the detection of Fe3+ is an bonding energy make an obvious decrease after treated by VO43- ion.
important part of water monitoring. As Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON (1 Therefore, a coordination effect between VO 43- and Ln3+ can be
mg) was treated with into Fe3+ aqueous solution (1 mM), the speculated. The significant changes in fluorescence lifetime of Eu3+
emissions of Eu3+, Tb3+ and ligand are all quenched (Fig. 4b). and Tb3+ also prove this interaction. In order to find out the reason
The first, after treated by Fe3+, the PXRD pattern of for different effects on Eu3+ and Tb3+ caused by VO43-, the excited-
Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON is consistent with the original one, which state energy of ligand and VO43- are discussed. From the perspective
deny the possibility of Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON framework collapse of energy level, the emission bond 3-Gd at 77K has an apparent
(Fig. S6†). Secondly, the framework integrity (Fig. S6†) and short bathochromic shift (from 475 to 515 nm) after treated by VO 43- (Fig.
response time (about 30s) deny the occurrence of ion exchange S14†) and the new triplet excited-state energy (T1) of VO43- is
between Fe3+ and Ln3+.15 The last, as Fe3+ has strong absorption calculated to be 19417 cm-1, which lies between 5D4 level of Tb3+
capacity in the ultraviolet region, a competitive energy absorption (20500 cm-1) and 5D0 level of Eu3+ (17300 cm-1). As the energy level
process between Fe3+ and organic ligand can be speculated. By diagram (Fig. 5a) shows, the VO43- T1 level is suitable for Eu3+ rather
comparing the absorption performance of Fe3+ and than Tb3+. Moreover, the fluorescence lifetime and intensity
Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON, we find an obvious spectral overlap reduction of Tb3+ can be attributed to the competitive absorption
between the UV-vis absorption spectra of Fe3+ and between VO43- and Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON that proved by the
Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON (Fig. S11†). Therefore, excited energy obvious overlap of their UV-vis absorption spectrum (Fig. S11†).
effectively absorbed by Fe3+ leads to the decrease efficiency of Similarly, the lower π* energy level of VO43- than ligand also can be
“antenna effect” and finally cause the fluorescent quenching.15 proved by UV-vis absorption spectrum (Fig. S10 and S11†) (375 nm
of VO43- compared to 329 nm of ligand). As a result, the energy
transfer from VO43- to Eu3+ cause the turn-on fluorescence response
at 616 nm and the competitive absorption ability of VO43- quench the
emission of Tb3+.
As for S2-, being an important anion for biologically and
environmentally, it is widely used in industry. However, because of
its toxicity to human body, and corrosiveness to construction, S2-
becomes an important analyte for water monitoring.56 Similar with
formol, S2- induced the quenching effect on both Eu3+ and Tb3+, while
the emission of ligand remains (Fig. 4b). Seen from the PXRD patterns
(Fig. S6†), the diffraction peak of Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON
disappears and the crystallinity decreases after treated by S2-, the
framework collapse of Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON induced by S2- can
Fig. 5. Sensing mechanism of VO43- and formol. (a) Simplied schematic diagram of
competitive absorption process between VO43- and ligand. (b) Schematic representation
be confirmed.
of electronic cloud orbit distributions of ligand H 3DPON, formol, acetaldehyde and Fluorescent probe detection for formol
acetone. (c) The schematic illustration of the mechanism of VO43- and formol sensing by In view of the serious harm of formol to human, the detection of
Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON. formol is meaningful for water monitoring. As formol contains
4 | J. Name., 2012, 00, 1-3 This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 20xx
carbonyl group that could induce fluorescent response through host- View Article Online
guest interactions, it is feasible to develop Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON DOI: 10.1039/C8TC05968C
as a fluorescence probe for formol.
Formol was diluted into aqueous solution of different contents
(vol %) and soaked with Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON. Taking the
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 20xx J. Name., 2013, 00, 1-3 | 5
within the range of 0 − 0.2 mM: I616/I544 = 0.85871 + 4.55968 cNa3VO4 The selectivity to the VO43- is also investigated. Take metal
View ArticleNa as
Online
(R2 = 0.99863). The LOD toward VO43- is calculated to be 0.42 μM an example, 11 kinds of sodium metal saltsDOI: (1 10.1039/C8TC05968C
mM) with different
(Table S13†) through the equation: LOD = k × σ/S. Where k is the anions were added into Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON aqueous solution,
confidence level parameter and k = 3 at the 99% confidence level, σ respectively. According their emission spectra recorded in Fig. 7e,
is the standard deviation for five times repeated detections of blank except for very few anions, most anions exhibit weak impact on the
that Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON shows a short response time of 1.5 overlap with other cationic regions (Fig. S23†), which implies that it
min (Fig. 7c), which endow Ln-MOF the possibility for convenient is accurate to determine the cation with 3D coordinates.
practical application. In the cycle experiment (Fig. 7d and S22†), we Furthermore, in order to utilize the Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON into
find that the ratio of I616/I544 always stay above 10 in the presence of VO43- detection practically, the influence of several competing anions
VO43- (2 mM) during the five times cycling process. Every time after on the fluorescence responses for VO43- ion was evaluated (Fig. S24).
detection of VO43-, suspensions are centrifuged and washed several As shown in Fig. 7f, the recognition and sensing properties for VO 43-
times with ethanol as well as distilled water under ultrasonic. And ion still remains in the presence of different anions and even 3, 5, 7
the ratio of I616/I544 drops back to around 0.9 through the simple and 9 kinds of interference anions, which indicates the high
process of ultrasonic washing. This apparent change of I616/I544 still selectivity of Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON.
remains after five continuous cycles. Meanwhile, the unchanged Construction of boolean logic operation and water monitoring
PXRD patterns of the finally recycled Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON
reveals its well retained framework (Fig. S6†). High selectivity, fast Based on the selective analysis performance of Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-
response and recyclability together endow Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON DPON toward Fe3+, VO43-, and S2-, we design a fluorescence logic
turn-on ratiometric probe with promising practical applications. system to achieve the multiplexed analysis of the two and even three
ions. In the Boolean logic operation, Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON serve
as gate, while the analyzed substances (Fe3+, VO43- or S2-) and
fluorescence emission intensities at 415 nm (B415), 544 nm (G544)
and 616 nm (R616) are set as inputs and outputs, respectively. The
input is “on” (i.e., 1) when the analyzed substances exist, otherwise
it is “off” (i.e., 0). The output is defined by comparing with a threshold
value (B415: 0.5, G544: 1 and R616: 1.5) which depends on the
fluorescence intensities of different emission centers, higher than
the threshold value outputs 1, while lower outputs 0. So, based on
this logic operation, three outputs could be obtained with two or
three inputs. Subsequently, we construct a series of logic operations
(NOR, IMP, NOT) driven by two inputs (Fe3+ + VO43-, Fe3+ + S2-, and
VO43- + S2-).
6 | J. Name., 2012, 00, 1-3 This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 20xx
third ions as input to logical system and two new logical Viewoperations
Article Online
(XOR, INH) generated based on a new threshold DOI: 10.1039/C8TC05968C
(B415: 0.5, G544: 1
and R616: 2) value. The corresponding emission spectra are also
shown in Fig. 4b and S25†. A XOR logic operation outputs 1 at 1/0 or
0/1 input, while INH logic operation has the turn‐on output only at
ions, only the 0/0/0 input could produce 1 input. As for emission at
616 nm (R616), after the NOT logic operation, the Fe3+ input is
integrated into the next XOR logic operation with S 2- input.
Moreover, in the presence of all three inputs (1/1/1), Fe3+ lost its
function through excess connection with VO43- and S2-, while the
remaining VO43- and S2- make their own effects on
Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON, resulting in the 1/0/1 output. The
integration of complex logic evolution network with three inputs
(Fe3+, VO43- and S2-) and three outputs (B415, G544, and R616) is
revealed in Fig. 9d, which exhibits the powerful molecular
recognition ability of Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON fluorescence system.
Fig. 9. (a) Column diagram of fluorescence intensities of B415, G544, and R616:
The above logic operations mainly described the functions of each
the dashed lines show the thresholds (B415: 0.5, G544: 1 and R616: 2). (b) input and their interactions, do not take their order into
Electronic equivalent circuitry of the three inputs Boolean logic gate. (c) Truth
table of the three inputs Boolean logic gate. (d) Compound logic circuit with three consideration. Then the varied orders of three inputs (Fe3+, VO43- and
inputs and two outputs fluorescence signal (blue shadow represents the
fluorescence of B415 and red shadow represents the fluorescence of R616). (e) S2-) were complied to obtain different inputs (Fig. S26†). As S2- takes
Column diagram of fluorescence intensities of B415, G544, and R616: the dashed
lines show the thresholds (R616: 2 and B415: 0.5). (f) The password lock security some time to destroy the framework, each operation lasts for 3 hours
system with different input sequences. (A, B and C represent Fe 3+, VO43-, and S2−,
respectively). before proceeding with other operations to ensure that they make
fully effect on Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON. As shown in Fig. 9e, the
As we all know, NOR logic operation produces an output of 1 only emission at 415 nm outputs 1 in A (Fe3+), B (VO43-), C (S2-) and B, A, C
when all inputs are 0. As demonstrated in Fig. 8b, 8e and 8h, the sequence. Only the A, C, B sequence make the turn-on output of
fluorescence intensities at 544 nm exceeded threshold (G544: 1) only R616 since the connection of Fe3+ and S2- retain the complete
in the absence of Fe3+, VO43- and S2-, otherwise it outputs 0. Similarly, framework. The sequence-depend output characteristics inspired us
identical NOR logic operation can be also implemented on the B415 to develop the logic operation into a simple password lock (Fig. 9f).
output of Fe3+ + VO43- double inputs logic gate and the R616 output Blue (B415) and red (R616) emissions are defined as alarm and
of Fe3+ + S2- logic gate (Fig. 8b and 8e). The R616 output of Fe3+ + VO43- unlock, respectively, while the 0/0/0 output represents the lock.
double inputs logic gate belongs to the binary IMP logic operation Obviously, in addition to the correct password (A, C, B), other
which produces 0 output only at one particular input (1/0). When passwords can not open the lock, and even some wrong passwords
Fe3+ added alone, it exhibits great quenching effect on the emission (A, B, C and B, A, C) will trigger an alarm, which greatly enhances the
at 616 nm, while on the addition of VO43- (input: 1/1), most Fe3+ are security of the password lock.
combined to form a precipitate (Equation 1) and the remaining VO43-
are reactive.
Fe3+ + VO43- → FeVO4 ↓ (1) Conclusions
As shown in Fig. 8h, IMP logic operation can also be implemented on In summary, we have developed a “smart” tri‐emission white
B415 output when VO43- + S2- act as double inputs. This is because fluorescence material‐Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON based on the
the framework collapse mechanism of S2-, which makes the VO43- live facile and cost‐effective method of in-situ Ln3+ heterometallic.
in silence when added together. Moreover, as Fe2S3 is also a Based on the specific fluorescence enhancement and quenching
precipitated substance (Equation 2), Fe3+ will greatly limit the response of VO43- and formol, respectively, we achieved fast
function of S2- in Fe3+ + S2- logic gate and form a NOT logic operation quantitative fluorescence detection of formol (LOD: 0.0193 vol
between Fe3+ input and B415 output. %) and VO43- (LOD: 0.42 μM) in aqueous solution. Also,
Fe3+ + S2- → Fe2S3 ↓ (2) detection of formol at low concentration (1.592 mg/m3) in air is
NOT logic operation also exist in VO43- + S2- logic gate. With the realized by using a designed device. Moreover, a novel 3D
addition of S2-, the characteristic emission of Eu3+ disappears and decoded map has been designed that can effectively and
thus R616 outputs 0. The corresponding fluorescence emission reliably distinguish different solvent molecules and metal ions
spectra of each logic gate are given in Fig. 4b and S25†. in aqueous solution. Finally, we constructed a Boolean logic
The aforementioned double input logic gate showed that operation based on the different fluorescence responses of the
Eu0.059Tb0.051Gd0.89-DPON, Fe3+, VO43- and S2- can self‐assemble and three illuminating centers to the contaminated ions (Fe3+, VO43-
interact with each other in aqueous solution. Then, we introduce the and S2-) in water, and thus realized the analysis of multi-
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 20xx J. Name., 2013, 00, 1-3 | 7
components, which provides more opportunities for the 27 J. Zhou, H. Li, H. Zhang, H. Li, W. Shi and P. Cheng, Adv. Mater.
View Article Online
development of artificial intelligence in water quality monitor. , 2015, 27, 7072. DOI: 10.1039/C8TC05968C
28 F.-Y. Yi, R. Zhang, H. Wang, L.-F. Chen, L. Han, H.-L. Jiang and
Q. Xu, Small Methods, 2017, 1, 1700187.
29 B. B. Chen, Y. Yang, F. Zapata, G. Lin, G. Qian and E. B.
Conflicts of interest Lobkovsky, Adv. Mater., 2007, 19, 1693.
8 | J. Name., 2012, 00, 1-3 This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 20xx
Tiancheng Sun, Ping Wang, Ruiqing Fan*, Wei Chen, Sue Hao and Yulin Yang*