12/10/2020 Covid vaccine side effects: What it's like in Pfizer, Moderna trials


HEALT H AND SCIEN CE

The FDA says Pfizer’s Covid vaccine is safe and

effective. But trial participants warn of intense
symptoms after second shot
PUBLISHED TUE, DEC 8 2020•3:31 PM EST U P DAT E D T U E , D E C 8 2 0 2 0 • 8 : 4 0 P M E S T

MacKenzie Sigalos
@ K E N Z I E S I G A LO S

SHARE    

Under the Pfizer-BioNtech deal, the 27 EU countries could buy 200 million doses, and have an option to purchase another
100 million.
NurPhoto | Getty Images

KEY POINTS
The FDA said data from Pfizer’s Covid vaccine trials show that side effects are

common, though there are
“no specific safety concerns  identified that would 
MARKETS CNBC TV WATCHLIST MENU

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/12/08/pfizer-moderna-covid-vaccine-side-effects-trials.html 1/9
12/10/2020 Covid vaccine side effects: What it's like in Pfizer, Moderna trials

preclude issuance of an” emergency use authorization.


Trial participants in the Moderna and Pfizer studies told CNBC they developed
more significant symptoms following the second dose.

The Pfizer-BioNTech coronavirus vaccine is both safe and effective, according to the
U.S. Food and Drug Administration. In a report released Tuesday morning, the FDA
indicated that it could greenlight the country’s first Covid-19 inoculation within
days.

If Pfizer’s shot is granted an emergency use authorization, or EUA, the

immunizations — which are administered in two doses about three weeks apart —
could start as soon as next week.

Many people are now wondering whether this will be just like getting the flu vaccine.

The short answer is: No, not really.

VIDEO 02:02

FDA report finds Pfizer Covid vaccine safe and effective

One Pfizer trial participant told CNBC that after the second shot, he woke up with
chills, shaking so hard he cracked a tooth. “It hurt to even just lay in my bed sheet,”
he said.

MARKETS

CNBC TV

WATCHLIST

MENU

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/12/08/pfizer-moderna-covid-vaccine-side-effects-trials.html 2/9
12/10/2020 Covid vaccine side effects: What it's like in Pfizer, Moderna trials

Others experienced headaches and fatigue.


The FDA said that while side effects of the Pfizer vaccine are common, there are “no
specific safety concerns identified that would preclude issuance of an EUA.”

Be prepared for the second shot

The Pfizer vaccine is one of four U.S.-backed candidates in phase three trials. Next
up is one from U.S. biotech firm Moderna, which has also submitted its EUA
application.

Both companies have said that taking their vaccines could result in side effects
similar to mild Covid symptoms. Think muscle pain, chills and a headache.

Source: Yasir Batalvi

When trial participant Yasir Batalvi first read Moderna’s 22-page consent form
warning of side effects ranging from nothing at all to death, he felt pretty worried, he
told CNBC.

“You have to keep in mind, I joined the trial when we didn’t know it was going to be a
safe vaccine,” said Batalvi, a recent college graduate living in Boston.


MARKETS

CNBC TV

WATCHLIST

MENU

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/12/08/pfizer-moderna-covid-vaccine-side-effects-trials.html 3/9
12/10/2020 Covid vaccine side effects: What it's like in Pfizer, Moderna trials

The 24-year-old said that when he got the first injection in mid-October, it felt just

like a flu shot. “I experienced stiffness and pain in my left arm where I had gotten the
shot, but it was mild,” he explained. “By that evening, I didn’t want to move my arm
above my shoulder, but it was localized, and it disappeared by the next day.”

The second dose was a different story.

“After the injection, I had the same side effects as the first: localized pain and
stiffness, but it was a little bit worse. My arm got sore faster, and by the time I got
home, I started feeling fatigued and like anyone would feel if they were coming
down with the flu,” said Batalvi.

More significant symptoms presented that evening. “I developed a low-grade fever

and had chills,” he said. “That evening was rough.”

After a restless night, he called the study doctors, who reassured him it was a normal
reaction and no cause for concern. By that afternoon, Batalvi said, he felt like himself
again.

Moderna stopped testing the highest dose of its vaccine during the trial because of
the number of reports of severe adverse reactions.

As for any long-term effects, Batalvi isn’t giving it much thought. “I’m not too
concerned,” he said. “We know from vaccination trials that any adverse events
mostly show up in the first couple of months.”

How an mRNA vaccine works

Front-runners Pfizer and Moderna built their candidates with a new kind of
technology that’s never before been licensed in the U.S.


MARKETS

CNBC TV

WATCHLIST

MENU

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/12/08/pfizer-moderna-covid-vaccine-side-effects-trials.html 4/9
12/10/2020 Covid vaccine side effects: What it's like in Pfizer, Moderna trials

Messenger RNA vaccines, called mRNA for short, aren’t like your normal flu vaccine.

Typically, a vaccine puts a weakened or inactivated virus into our bodies to trigger an
immune response, which then produces antibodies. Those antibodies are what
ultimately protect us from getting infected if we ever encounter the real thing.

An mRNA vaccine, on the other hand, is essentially just a piece of genetic code that
contains instructions for our body. The mRNA tells our cells to make a protein — the
same protein that is the spike on top of the actual coronavirus. This is what triggers
the immune response in these types of vaccines.

So even though some trial participants reported Covid-like symptoms, it is

impossible to contract the coronavirus from the vaccine, because the mRNA
vaccines that Pfizer and Moderna are making don’t use the live virus.

Source: Yasir Batalvi

Dr. Hana El Sahly, who oversees a clinical trial for Moderna’s vaccine candidate, said
one major benefit of the mRNA technology is how fast it is to make. “The
attractiveness of it is the speed with which it can be manufactured once we know the
sequence of the virus,” said El Sahly.

With the traditional flu vaccine, you have to first grow the virus in an egg, then

deactivate
MARKETS
put it into vaccine vials with
the virus, and finally,
CNBC TV
 either mRNA or
WATCHLIST

MENU

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/12/08/pfizer-moderna-covid-vaccine-side-effects-trials.html 5/9
12/10/2020 Covid vaccine side effects: What it's like in Pfizer, Moderna trials

recombinant DNA technology, explained El Sahly.


The Covid vaccine’s faster manufacturing timeline is key, as distributors look to
expedite distribution to the U.S. population.

Paying for the vaccine

Also key to widespread vaccination is making sure governments around the world
have enough money to buy the vaccines.

Moderna said in August it is charging between $32 and $37 per dose for its
vaccine and would perhaps offer a discount if it is bought in bulk. Pfizer’s, on the
other hand, is more affordable. It is reportedly $20 per dose.

The U.S. has secured 100 million doses of the Pfizer vaccine, which is enough to
vaccinate 50 million people.

But to achieve herd immunity, experts say, roughly 70% of the population needs to
be vaccinated or have natural antibodies. That’s about 462 million doses for herd
immunity and an estimated 660 million doses for everyone in the country.

Pfizer board member Dr. Scott Gottlieb told CNBC on Tuesday that President
Donald Trump declined the company’s offer to buy additional doses.

A debate over unblinding the control group

Both Pfizer and Moderna are conducting double-blind trials, which means that half
the participants receive a placebo and the other half receive the actual vaccine.
Because the trials are ongoing, it also means that patients don’t know which group
they are in.

There is a debate raging among experts about whether to give the control group the
vaccine.

The FDA isn’t too keen on the idea of dosing the placebo group, while some scientists
are making the case that they should be moved higher on the prioritization list as a
thanks for their service.

But this kind of break in trial protocol would interfere with the integrity of the trial,
so

MARKETS

for now, participants suchCNBC
as Batalvi
TV remain in the dark

as to whether they’re
WATCHLIST

MENU

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/12/08/pfizer-moderna-covid-vaccine-side-effects-trials.html 6/9
12/10/2020 Covid vaccine side effects: What it's like in Pfizer, Moderna trials

actually protected against the virus. A person can still present symptoms, as Batalvi

did, even if they are in the control group. It’s the “placebo effect.”

But either way, Batalvi said he’s glad he had the opportunity to participate in an
effort to protect the world against the pandemic.

VIDEO 14:03
TRENDING
How to get NOW
a Covid-19 vaccine to everyone in the U.S.

17 states tell Supreme Court they support Texas bid to reverse Biden win

Brace yourself for intense symptoms after the second shot of the Covid
vaccine, trial participants warn
2

Airbnb sells shares at $68 in IPO, pricing above range

Elon Musk on the problem with corporate America: ‘Too many MBAs’

Joe Biden’s son Hunter Biden under federal investigation for tax case

5

MARKETS

CNBC TV

WATCHLIST

MENU

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/12/08/pfizer-moderna-covid-vaccine-side-effects-trials.html 7/9
12/10/2020 Covid vaccine side effects: What it's like in Pfizer, Moderna trials

Subscribe to CNBC PRO Licensing & Reprints

CNBC Councils Supply Chain Values
CNBC on Peacock Advertise With Us
Join the CNBC Panel Digital Products
News Releases Closed Captioning
Corrections About CNBC
Internships Site Map
Ad Choices Careers
Help Contact

      

News Tips
Got a confidential news tip? We want to hear from you.

GET IN TOUCH

 CNBC Newsletters
Sign up for free newsletters and get more CNBC delivered to your inbox

SIGN UP NOW

Get this delivered to your inbox, and more info about our products and services. 

Privacy Policy
Do Not Sell My Personal Information
CA Notice
Terms of Service

MARKETS

CNBC TV

WATCHLIST

MENU

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/12/08/pfizer-moderna-covid-vaccine-side-effects-trials.html 8/9
12/10/2020 Covid vaccine side effects: What it's like in Pfizer, Moderna trials
© 2020 CNBC LLC. All Rights Reserved. A Division of NBCUniversal


Data is a real-time snapshot *Data is delayed at least 15 minutes. Global Business and Financial News, Stock Quotes, and Market Data and
Analysis.

Market Data Terms of Use and Disclaimers

Data also provided by


MARKETS

CNBC TV

WATCHLIST

MENU

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/12/08/pfizer-moderna-covid-vaccine-side-effects-trials.html 9/9