Ponnaiyar - Palar Intra-State Link Project EIA
Ponnaiyar - Palar Intra-State Link Project EIA
Ponnaiyar - Palar Intra-State Link Project EIA
10.0 General
The Ponnaiyar (Nedungal) - Palar Intra-state link project envisages annual
diversion of 86 Mm3 of flood waters of Ponnaiyar river to the Palar basin to stabilize the
existing command area of about 9850 ha. Since the command area contemplated to be
benefitted is below 10000 ha the project falls under Category B as per the relevant EIA
notifications. The State Environmental Impact Assessment Authority (SEIAA) of Tamil Nadu
is the authority to approve Terms of Reference (ToR) for carrying out the Comprehensive
Environmental Impact Assessment (CEIA) study and Socio-economic study of the project.
After completion of the CEIA study by the project proponent, the findings and
recommendations there from would be suitably incorporated in the DPR of the project at a
later date. Meanwhile, baseline information from secondary sources on various environment
related issues are discussed briefly in the present chapter along with a tentative
Environmental Management Plan (EMP).
176
wells by recharging the ground water. The link canal is proposed to feed the enroute
system tanks for irrigation and recharging ground water enroute the link canal in Krishnagiri
and Vellore districts as well as Vaniyambadi taluka in Palar basin at tail end for stabilising the
existing ayacut of 9850 ha annually, besides providing 3.882 Mm3 of drinking water supply to
the enroute villages benefiting 1.52 lakh human population.
The total length of link canal is 54.150 km off-takes at FSL of 434.450 m from
the left flank of the existing Nedungal Anicut across the Ponnaiyar river near Peruhalli village
and out falls into Kal Ar river near Karuppanur village. No new reservoirs are contemplated
under the project. The flood waters spilling down the existing Krishnagiri dam will be
regulated to Ponnaiyar (Nedungal) – Palar link canal through existing Nedungal Anicut
located about 16 km downstream of Krishnagiri dam on Ponnaiyar river. This link canal
crosses a number of streams/ rivulets/existing feeder canals and several roads including a
railway line for which 6 Canal syphons, 6 Aqueducts, 2 Super passages, 34 Road bridges, 5
Under tunnels and 1 Elevated pipe/trough have been proposed. One Head regulator, one
Cross regulator cum canal escape, 8 Canal outlets and one Outfall structure have also been
provided for canal regulation.
177
availability of ground water for future irrigation development being almost nil, especially in
Vaniyambadi taluka of Vellore district in Palar basin. Annual ground water extraction is
almost twice the annual replenishable ground water. A large population in the vicinity of the
proposed project in Krishnagiri and Pochampalli talukas of Krishnagiri district and Tirupattur
and Vaniyambadi talukas of Vellore district experience acute shortage of water for irrigation
and drinking water. It is in this context the proposed Ponnaiyar (Nedungal) - Palar link has
been conceived.
In light of the above scenario the Ponnaiyar (Nedungal) - Palar link project is
proposed to divert the flood water from Ponnaiyar river to enable recharging the ground
water for utilisation in Palar basin in Vaniyambadi taluka of Vellore district, besides feeding
enroute tanks in Krishnagiri and Vellore districts for drinking water supply as well as to
stabilise the existing command area under these tanks. No new command areas are
identified in the vicinity of the link canal.
The Palar river which is also an inter-state river originates in Kolar district of
Karnataka state near Kaivara village at an altitude of 900 m. The catchment area of the
basin lies in Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu States.
Presently, the main source of irrigation in the command area under the
Ponnaiyar (Nedungal) - Palar Link Project is only ground water through bore wells and open
wells. Tank irrigation by harvesting rainwater also practiced to some extent. The open wells
account for more than 90% of the area being irrigated in the vicinity of the proposed link
project. Besides irrigation use, for domestic use also ground water is the only source in
Krishnagiri and Vellore districts of Tamil Nadu in the vicinity of Ponnaiyar (Nedungal) - Palar
178
link project. Further, the ground water assessment made by Central Ground Water Board
(CGWB) indicates that the ground water usage increased above 100% (between 142% and
201%) in all the blocks lying especially in Vaniyambadi taluka of Vellore district and the
same have been categorized as over-exploited for future ground water development. ground
water exploitation is almost twice the annual replenishable ground water. Further, it has
been observed that during monsoon periods, the Ponnaiyar river is in spate while the Palar
river mostly remains dry. Hence, in light of the above scenario and due to non-availability of
canal irrigation facilities in the existing command area in the vicinity of the proposed project,
where the farmers mainly depend on rainfall and ground water for irrigation and other
domestic needs, the Ponnaiyar (Nedungal)- Palar Link Project has been planned to divert the
flood water available at Krishnagiri dam in the project will stabilise the irrigation over an
area of 7950 ha presently being irrigated under tanks/open wells/bore wells by recharging
the ground water potential.
Apart from above, the enroute command area of 1900 ha identified under the
link project in Krishnagiri and Pochampalli talukas of Krishnagiri district and Tirupattur taluka
of Vellore district will also be stabilised by feeding the enroute existing system tanks (Eris).
The project will bring economic prosperity to the drought-prone area lying in
the vicinity of the link project through stabilisation of the irrigation facility in the existing
irrigated area.
179
2. Cross drainage / Cross masonry works are proposed along the link canal.
The impact of the link canal on account of land acquisition for execution of
the canal is very less as the link canal passes through rural areas. However, the issues
related with land acquisition are to be dealt amicably while acquiring the land for the canal
way.
180
organisations/ departments. In addition, pre-environmental clearance is required to be
obtained from concerned designated authority.
10.5.2 Meteorology
Climatologically, the Ponnaiyar(Nedungal)-Palar link project area has four
distinct seasons viz., dry period from January to February, hot period from March to May,
south-west monsoon from June to September and north-east monsoon from October to
181
December. The climate is cold from December to February followed by hot season from
March to May.
The average annual rainfall of Krishnagiri district varies from 750 to 900 mm.
During monsoon the average rainfall is about 706 mm. Maximum rainfall occurs in the
month of September and minimum rainfall in the month of July. The average annual rainfall
in Krishnagiri region which is very close to the head works of the link Project is 882 mm, of
which 706 mm is during monsoon. The annual normal rainfall of Vellore district is about
1023 mm and during monsoon it is about 748 mm. The mean annual rainfall of Vaniyambadi
station where maximum command area is proposed under the link canal is about 800 mm,
of which monsoon rainfall is about 668 mm. The mean annual rainfall of Tirupattur, which is
located closer to the canal outfall point is about 878 mm, of which 724 mm is during
monsoon. As per the IMD observatory of Dharmapuri which is located nearer to the link
Project, the daily maximum and minimum temperatures recorded are 37.1O C in April and
17.2O C in January. The mean monthly wind speed observed as per IMD data is 6.7 kmph.
The latest data for the period from 2009 to 2013 on laboratory test results of
the water samples of Krishnagiri reservoir have been collected and the averages of results of
the samples during the months of October, November and December which have already
been furnished in Table - 4.3 are reproduced in Table-10.1 below.
182
Table-10.1
Statement of Test Results of Water Samples from Krishnagiri Dam
Sl. Parameter Average of observed Values Limits as per
No IS 10500 -1991
for drinking
Oct Nov Dec and domestic
uses
(ii) The levels of total dissolved salts are well below the permissible limit of 500mg/l,
ranging from 439.5 to 480 mg/l during October to November months and indicate that
the water is suitable for drinking and domestic uses. The total hardness of the water
ranged from 255 to 273.75 mg/l, which is well below the permissible limit of 600 mg/l
specified for drinking and domestic uses.
183
(iii) The calcium hardness level ranged from 51.2 to 64.5 mg/l which is well within the
permissible limit of 200 mg/l specified for drinking water.
(iv) The concentration of Sulphate is in the range of 21.1 to 23.04 mg/l which is within the
permissible limit of 400 mg/l.
(v) The concentration of chlorides is within the range of 136.48 to 152.43 mg/l which is
within the permissible limit of 1000 mg/l as per IS 10500-1991 for drinking water
quality standards.
(vi) The lime content as CaCO3 in the above water samples is well within the permissible
limit of 600 mg/l ranging from 246.25 to 272.5 mg/l.
(vii) The conductivity of water which is less than 1000 micro mhos/cm indicates that the
water is ‘Excellent To Good-Class-1’ for irrigation purpose.
(viii) As the levels of total dissolved salts in various samples collected are well below the
permissible limits of less than 700 ppm, the same is ‘Excellent to Good-Class-1’ for
irrigation.
(ix) The range of Chlorides in the water of less than 175 ppm indicates as ‘Excellent to
Good-Class-1’ for irrigation.
(x) Also, the other parameters such as Carbonate / Bi-carbonate alkalinity, total hardness,
Calcium/Magnesium/including Sulphates are within the limits for irrigation water.
Hence, the water proposed for diversion through the link canal is suitable for irrigation
purpose.
184
district is NaCl with mixed CaMgCl. The presence of excessive Na and Cl is observed in the
groundwater, in general in Krishnagiri district areas. The type of water is CaHCo3, NaHCo3,
and Nacl in the zones of Krishnagiri district. In the zones of Vellore district, the ground water
study on quality of water indicates that the presence of chemical constituents of CACo3, Cl
and No3, are more than permissible limits. Vellore is surrounded by many leather industries
and their effluents are discharged into the Palar river causing impact on the quality of the
groundwater. The quality is deteriorating. All the parameters such as TDS, electrical
conductivity, chloride, hardness and salinity is found to be very high. Hence proper
treatment is warranted. The type of water is CaHCo3, NaCl and CaCl.
However, the hazards of water logging and salinization are not anticipated
due to the proposed project.
Table-10.2
Long-term Annual Water Level Trend in the Command Area
Sl. Annual water level trend (m/year)
District
No Rise Fall
Source: District Ground water Brochure, Jan-2009, Krishnagiri and Vellore Districts, CGWB.
185
As per the ground water study by CGWB the pre-monsoon depth and post-
monsoon depth to water levels were measured in Krishnagiri and Vellore districts in May
2006 and January 2007 respectively. The results are furnished in Table 10.3.
Table 10.3
Pre-Monsoon and Post-Monsoon Depths to Water Levels in the Command Area
Water level (m)
Sl.
District Pre-monsoon Post-monsoon
No
(May,2006) (Jan,2007)
Source: District Ground water Brochure, Jan-2009, Krishnagiri and Vellore Districts, CGWB.
Table-10.4
Dynamic Ground Water Resources in the Command Area
(As on 31.03.2011)
District
Sl.
Details
No Krishnagiri Vellore
3
1. Annual net ground water availability (Mm ) 354.94 592.80
2. Total annual ground water draft for all purposes (Mm3) 471.44 621.44
186
10.5.4 Land Environment
10.5.4.1 Land Use
The present land use and land cover information of the proposed project area
has already been discussed in Chapter-8, Irrigation Planning and Command Area.
However, the land use and land cover is expected to change due to the developmental
activities of the project.
187
In Krishnagiri district, the predominant geological formations are Recent Alluvium,
Upper Proterozoic, Lower Proterozoic and Archaeons, whereas Alluvium, Granite gneisses
and Charnockite are the predominant geological formations in most parts of Vellore district.
Soil surveys were not conducted in the vicinity of project area. However,
based on the particulars contained in the Hydro-geological Atlas of Tamil Nadu, brought out
by the Central Ground water Board, the soils in the vicinity of the project in Krishnagiri and
Vellore districts are grouped as - mainly (i) Red sandy clay loam soils (ii) Brown clay loam
(iii) Recent old alluvium soils and (iv) Rock outcrops with loamy sand soils in Krishnagiri
district and (i) Brown clay loam soils (ii) Rock outcrops with loamy sand soils in Vellore
district.
The red sandy clay loam soils are partly matured soils and they are shallow to
deep, possessing good drainage characteristics. These soils are suitable for cultivation of
large variety of crops including ragi, bajra, jowar, paddy, etc., both under irrigated and rain-
fed conditions.
The Brown clay loamy soils are moderately well drained and have rapid to
moderately rapid permeability. Crops like cotton, jowar, pulses, chillies, onion, groundnut
etc., are cultivable in these soils.
The recent/old Alluvial soils are generally fertile and respond well to
management practices and are suitable for cultivation of crops like paddy, sugarcane, jowar,
groundnut, chillies, pulses etc.,
The rock outcrops with loamy sand soils respond well to irrigation, manuring
and other management practices. The crops grown under rain-fed cultivation are ragi,
jowar, millets, pulses and oil seeds. Under irrigation crops like ragi, jowar, groundnut and
pulses are grown.
188
10.5.7 Public Health
10.5.7.1 Medical and Health Facilities in the Project Command Area
The major portion of the command area to be benefited from the Ponnaiyar
(Nedungal) - Palar link project lies in Vellore district. The existing public health facilities in
Vellore district are good as indicated in Table-10.5.
Table-10.5
Medical Health Facilities Available
Sl.
Particulars Vellore District
No
1 Allopathic Hospitals 13
Dispensaries 8 (ESI)
PHC 76
Sub Centre 454
2 Indian Medicine Hospitals: 12
Dispensaries 2
PHC 13
3 Homeopathic Dispensaries 3
4 No. Of Doctors
Allopathic 384
Other Medicines 23
189
Lack of proper sanitary facilities and sanitary waste disposal in the rural area
are the root causes of many diseases. In this project too, the rural areas are lacking in
drainage system. Even in the semi-urban areas open drainage systems exist, which expose
the sewage to the disease transmitting organisms like flies, insects, germs etc. These
organisms contaminate the water and food to be consumed by the people leading to water
borne diseases like diarrhoea, ameobiasis, gastroenteritis etc. depending upon the type of
infecting organism. Open air defecation is still a predominant practice in all the villages in
project area which is a potential hazard for spreading of diseases in the area.
As per the ground water study in the vicinity of the project area which have
been conducted jointly by CGWB and State Ground water Resources and Data Centre, PWD,
WRO, Govt. of Tamil Nadu as on 31st March, 2004, it was observed that the ground water is
suitable for drinking and domestic uses in respect of all the constituents except total
hardness, chloride and nitrate. In about 42% of samples, nitrate concentration is above
permissible limits of 100 mg/l. The incidence of high total hardness is attributed to the
composition of litho units constituting the aquifers in these district areas, whereas nitrate
pollution is most likely due to use of fertilisers and other improper waste disposal.
190
10.5.7.5 Nutrition
Many children in the rural areas suffer from malnutrition due to under
nourishment. Non availability of balanced food at affordable prices to feed the children
adequately, improper cooking habits, low crop yields and persistent worm infestations due
to lack of proper sanitation are also acting synergistically leading to nutritional problem.
Malnutrition is by and large the result of poverty, ignorance, illiteracy, lack of proper
knowledge of nutrition value of different foods and larger family size in these areas.
Malnutrition leads to recurrence of infections thereby reducing the full working capacity of
the people.
191
The EIA and EMP and Socio Economic aspects in respect of Ponnaiyar
(Nedungal) - Palar link Project are to be carried out by the project proponent through the
specialist consultancy Agencies, separately, as discussed at para 10.0 above. However,
these aspects are discussed briefly in general terms in the following paras.
(ii) Fugitive Emissions from Various Sources: During construction phase, lot of
construction material like sand, fine aggregate is to be stored at various sites. Normally, due
to blowing of winds, especially when the environment is dry, some of the stored material
can get entrained in the atmosphere. However, such impacts are visible only in and around
the storage sites. The impacts on this account are generally, insignificant in nature.
(b) Operation Phase: No major impacts are envisaged during operation phase.
192
(b) Operation Phase: No major impacts are expected during operation phase.
193
(ii) Impact on Existing Projects/Water Bodies Upstream of
Krishnagiri Dam
The water resources of existing projects/water bodies upstream of the
proposed diversion point/Krishnagiri dam will not be diverted for the link canal supplies.
Therefore, this project will not have impact on the water resources of upstream existing
projects/water bodies.
194
Palar river because of which many villages in Vaniyambadi and Tirupattur talukas of Vellore
district will be benefitted due to more ground water recharge possibility.
195
(iv) Soil Erosion
Possibilities of soil erosion and hence degradation of land environment due to
construction of colonies/temporary houses/toilet blocks etc. are anticipated for which
suitable remedial measures are to be adopted.
(viii) Roads
There is a well developed wide network of National High Ways (NH), State
High Ways (SH) and District and village roads in the Project area. Only cart-tracks will have
to be improved and new approach roads to quarry sites, labour colony, construction sites
and Material and equipment stores will have to be constructed. Therefore, no adverse
impact of land in this aspect is anticipated.
196
which the link canal is proposed for diversion of water from the Ponnaiyar river is an acute
drought-prone zone and almost dry. Therefore, no water-logging, salinity and flooding
problems of serious nature is anticipated in the command area during operation phase.
197
10.6.5.1 Impact Matrix
An impact matrix indicating the beneficial / adverse impacts relating to
physical, biological, financial and socio-economic conditions are given in Table 10.6.
Table 10.6
Impact Matrix
Sl. Impact Ponnaiyar (Nedungal) – Palar link
No. Project
A Physical Impacts
i) Sedimentation No siltation, as no new reservoirs are
proposed
198
Sl. Impact Ponnaiyar (Nedungal) – Palar link
No. Project
B Biological Impacts
199
• Unnecessary idling of construction vehicles to be prohibited.
• Effective traffic management to be undertaken to avoid significant delays in and
around the project area.
• Prompt repair and maintenance of roads.
• Location of DG sets and other emission generating equipment should be decided
keeping in view the predominant wind direction and stack height of DG sets to be
kept in accordance with CPCB norms.
200
(ii) Noise Generation from Controlled Blasting Operations
• Controlled blasting will be done as per the provisions of Indian Explosives Act.
• Blasting will not be undertaken in night hours.
• Workers at blasting sites will be provided with proper earplugs and helmets.
• Explosives used for controlled blasting will be kept in safest custody under lock and
key as per the provisions of Indian Explosives Act.
(i) Major contribution of the Surface water to Ponnaiyar basin is from regeneration water
from the Bengaluru city located in the upper reaches. Since the spills of flood water
during monsoon is proposed for diversion, quality of the water is much better. The
parameters such as pH, temperature, electrical conductivity, turbidity, total hardness,
total dissolved solids, DO, BOD, COD, Ca, Mg, chlorides, sulphates, nitrates, iron and
zinc are being analyses by the Krishnagiri dam authorities as a measure for testing the
quality of water for domestic and Irrigation uses from time to time, based on which the
quality of water is found to be within limits for domestic/irrigation uses. However, the
surface water quality needs to be monitored since the Krishnagiri reservoir is a hyper -
eutrophicated reservoir. Maintaining aquatic ecology is essential to make the aquatic
fauna flourish.
(ii) Sewage generated from various labour camps during project construction phase shall be
treated in a sewage treatment plant prior to disposal.
(iii) The effluent generated from the crushers will have high-suspended solids and needs to
be treated before disposal. Settling tanks of appropriate size for treatment of effluent
from various crushers should be provided. The sludge from the various settling tanks
can be collected once in 15 days and disposed at the site designed for disposal of
municipal solid wastes from the labour camps. The sludge after drying could also be
used as cover material for landfill disposal site.
201
10.7.2.2 Ground Water Quality
(i) The pollution from tanneries has caused irrevocable deterioration of quality of ground
water and soil in vast areas. There is an urgent need to arrest/prevent further
deterioration of ground water and soil quality through a comprehensive plan by
providing common effluent treatment plant (CETP) and adoption of environment friendly
technologies for tanning and safe disposal of waste water in the area.
(ii) The link canal is proposed as unlined for increasing the ground water potential enroute,
due to seepage. Highly polluted condition of ground water in the vicinity of the Kal Ar
and Palar rivers and Vaniyambadi taluka by the effluents let in to the river by existing
tanneries and other industries will be considerably improved due to the diverted water.
(iii) A number of piezometers at close spacing need to be established in entire study area to
monitor the changes in water levels and quality. The data on water fluctuations and
quality would be collected for both pre and post project. However, the hazards of water
logging and salinisation are not anticipated due to the project.
(iv) Studies have been carried out to find the Chromium (Cr) contamination level and the
ecology of heavy metal tolerance of the native bacterial flora. Chromium tolerant strains
were isolated from contaminated sediments, water and effluents of various tanneries.
The tolerance of soil bacteria to heavy metals has been proposed as an indicator of
potential toxicity of metals to other forms of life. These high chromium tolerant bacteria
confirmed the chromium contamination in Palar river in Vellore District. Micro organisms
with the ability to tolerate and reduce Chromium can be used for detoxification of
environments, contaminated with Chromium.
(v) The data on water fluctuations and its quality would be collected and verified for both
pre and post project.
202
excavated material of the canal in deep-cut reaches can be used in filling the embankment
reaches and balance muck/excavated material requires to be suitably disposed off in
disposal sites in the project area to be suitably identified in such a manner to occupy least
space. This is to be dumped along the streams/river course and in low-lying areas by taking
precautionary measures in scientific manner without creating hazards to the environment.
The fine aggregates (sand) required for the project is proposed to be met
from Palar river and crushed sand from one of the identified rock quarry sites in Krishnagiri
district. The quarrying operations are semi-mechanized in nature. Quarrying is normally done
by cutting a face of the hill. A permanent scar is likely to be left, once quarrying activities are
over. With the passage of time, the rock from the exposed face of the quarry under the
action of wind and other erosion forces get slowly weathered and after some time they
become a potential source of landslide. Thus, it is necessary to implement appropriate slope
stabilization measures to prevent the possibility of soil erosion and landslides in the quarry
sites. After excavation of the required material these quarry sites will be restored by
adopting appropriate engineering, bio-engineering and biological measures.
203
No land development works or drainage system is required in the above
proposed command area. Since, the vicinity area of the Project is water deficit and drought
prone area with overexploited ground water, no chances of stagnation of water and thereby
water logging is anticipated in the command area.
Though the fauna easily adopt and/or migrate temporarily during the harsh
conditions or disturbances, they again rehabilitates back when the conditions become
favourable.
Hence, no management of the flora and fauna along the link canal including
action plan for alternate breeding grounds is needed.
204
10.7.3.7 Earthquake Management
No new dams/reservoirs are involved in the present study, since the existing
dam and anicut are planned as ‘controlling structures’ for diversion of water. The link canal
of about 54 km with enroute CD/CM structures are the only proposed structures in the
project execution. However, the Ponnaiyar (Nedungal) – Palar link Project falls under Seismic
Zone-II in Krishnagiri and Vellore districts of Tamil Nadu state with moderate seismic hazard
zone. Therefore, in view of only canal is involved, no earthquake management measures are
required.
205
Table 10.7
Cost for Implementing Environmental Management Plan (EMP)
Total 500.00
However, the actual cost will be considered in the estimate after carrying out
EIA & EMP study of the link project by the project proponent through the reputed
consultant.
206