Module Overview-Research Methods
Module Overview-Research Methods
Introduction
This module provides students with an introduction to research methods and to the types of skills
necessary for the planning, data gathering and dissemination stages of business-related research.
Research Design;
Methods of Data Collection;
Approaches to Analysing Data and Writing a Research Proposal.
Objectives
To equip students with a basic understanding of the underlying principles of quantitative and
qualitative research and the links between the two
To introduce students to the key data generation methods of current use in public health and
health-related research
To enable students to choose the most appropriate research method to address a particular
research question
To enable students to gain a basic overview of a range of quantitative and qualitative
approaches to analysis
To provide students with the knowledge and skill to undertake the design of a health-related
research proposal
Learning Outcomes
Describe a range of quantitative and qualitative research designs used in health research and
identify the advantages and disadvantages associated with these designs.
Design an appropriate mixed-method research study to answer a health-related research
question.
Choose appropriate quantitative or qualitative method to collect data.
Write a research proposal suitable for submission to a research funding body.
Topics to be covered
1. Introduction
Introduction to the research, research process
2. Designing a Research Project
creating a conceptual framework, the research statement/ question/ hypothesis, research aim
and objectives, methodology and method rationale.
3. Developing a Theoretical Framework
Writing a literature review Research Methodology, quantitative qualitative and mixed
methods approach - designing an appropriate methodological framework
1
4. Data Analysis
Developing analytical frameworks, describing and interpreting data, the role of theory in data
analysis
Teaching Methods
This is a distance learning module. The teaching methods include guided independent study and
facilitated discussions with constructive feedback. Online resources, including reading, audio/visual
materials and self-assessment exercises, will be used to provoke critical thinking.
Research in common language refers to a search for knowledge. The Oxford learners dictionary
defines research as “a careful study of a subject, especially in order to discover new facts or
information about it” while the Marriam Webster dictionary refers to research as “studious inquiry or
examination; especially: investigation or experimentation aimed at the discovery and interpretation
of facts, revision of accepted theories or laws in the light of new facts, or practical application of
such new or revised theories or laws”
It has also been defined as a scientific and systematic search for valid information on a specific topic.
In fact, research is an art of scientific investigation. From the academic side the term research is used
in a technical sense which depicts the activities involved in the process of undertaking. Such
activities include defining and redefining problems, formulating hypothesis or suggested solutions;
collecting, organizing and evaluating data; making deductions and reaching conclusions; and at last
carefully testing the conclusions to determine whether they fit the formulating hypothesis.
Management research is conducted either to expand knowledge about a particular aspect or to find a
solution to a particular problem. Business research studies can be classified into two categories—
basic research and applied research.
However, the results of the study may have implications for a new theory of learning. In the same
way, a scientist who is conducting basic research to test a theory of learning may discover results that
can be applied in the classroom.
Applied research is intended to answer practical questions or solve practical problems. Research
studies intended to answer theoretical questions or gather knowledge simply for the sake of new
knowledge are classified as basic research.
2
Basic research refers to a focused, systematic study or investigation undertaken to discover new
knowledge or interpretations and establish facts or principles in a particular field. In other words, it is
a research aimed primarily at gaining knowledge rather than solving a pragmatic problem. The
underlying motive is to increase knowledge about particular phenomena by testing, refining and
elaborating theory without concern for practical application.
Applied research refers to investigation undertaken to discover the applications and uses of theories,
knowledge and principles in actual work or in solving problems. In other words, it is any research
that is used to answer a specific question, determine why something failed or succeeded, solve a
specific, pragmatic problem, or to gain better understanding.
Therefore, research that is directed toward solving practical problems is often classified as applied
research; in contrast, studies that are intended to solve theoretical issues are classified as basic
research. Although these different kinds of research begin with different goals, they are both
legitimate sources of research ideas and, occasionally, they can overlap. For example, the HR
department of a company may initiate an applied study to find out if there is a significant difference
between employee performance between female and male employees.
Although the purpose of these two research forms varies, there is not much difference in the research
methods and tools used for their conduct. Both these research forms use scientific methods in various
stages of the research process. The scientific method refers to a systematic approach towards
observing phenomena, drawing conclusions and testing hypotheses. Scientific methods involve
systematic analysis and logical interpretation of empirical evidence to establish facts or to prove a
theory.
In basic research, first the hypothesis is tested through experimentation and observation. Then,
logical interpretations and conclusions are made about a particular phenomenon. These conclusions
lead to the formation of general laws about that phenomenon. However, applied research involves
developing alternatives to a particular problem and finding the best alternative among them.
Research involves a careful consideration of study regarding a particular concern or a problem using
scientific methods. It is a well-structured systematic inquiry to describe, explain, predict and control
the observed phenomenon. There are various definitions of research. They include the following:
‘The systematic investigation into and study of materials and sources in order to establish
facts and reach new conclusions.’ (OED 2011)
‘The systematic gathering and interpretation of information about individuals or organisations
using the statistical and analytical methods and techniques of the applied sciences to gain
insight or support decision making.’ (Definition of market research, including social and
opinion research, ESOMAR 2013)
‘a systematic process to solve real-world problems.’ (Gray 2009)
‘systematic investigation to find things out. It is the process by which we produce evidence or
knowledge.’ (McGivern 2006)
3
‘Systematic study and investigation.’ (Robson 2011)
‘The systematic collection and interpretation of information with a clear purpose, to find
things out.’ (Saunders et al. 2012)
‘An organised, systematic, critical, scientific inquiry or investigation into a specific problem,
undertaken with the objective of finding answers or solutions thereto.’ (Sekaran and Bougie
2010)
CHARACTERISTICS OF RESEARCH
1. Research follows a systematic approach. Rules and procedures are an integral part of research
that set the objective of a research process. Researchers need to practice ethics and code of
conduct while making observations or drawing conclusions.
2. Research is based on logical reasoning.
3. The data or knowledge that is derived is in real time, actual observations in the natural
settings.
4. There is an in-depth analysis of all the data collected from research so that there are no
anomalies associated with it.
5. Research creates a path for generating new questions. More research opportunity can be
generated from existing research.
6. Research is analytical in nature. It makes use of all the available data so that there is no
ambiguity in inference.
7. Accuracy is one of the important character of research, the information that is obtained while
conducting the research should be accurate and true to its nature. For example, research
conducted in a controlled environment like a laboratory. Here accuracy is measured of
instruments used, calibrations, and the final result of the experiment.
OBJECTIVES OF RESEARCH
The purpose of research is to discover answers to questions through the application of scientific
procedures. The main aim of research is to find out the truth which is hidden and which has not been
discovered as yet. Though each research study has its own specific purpose, we may think of
research objectives as falling into a number of following broad groupings:
1. To gain familiarity with a phenomenon or to achieve new insights into it (studies with this
object in view are termed as exploratory or formulative research studies);
2. To portray accurately the characteristics of a particular individual, situation or a group
(studies with this object in view are known as descriptive research studies);
3. To determine the frequency with which something occurs or with which it is associated with
something else (studies with this object in view are known as diagnostic research studies);
4. To test a hypothesis of a causal relationship between variables (such studies are known as
hypothesis-testing research studies).
MOTIVATION IN RESEARCH
What makes people to undertake research? This is a question of fundamental importance. The
possible motives for doing research may be either one or more of the following:
4
2. Desire to face the challenge in solving the unsolved problems, i.e., concern over practical
problems initiates research;
3. Desire to get intellectual joy of doing some creative work;
4. Desire to be of service to society;
5. Desire to get respectability.
However, this is not an exhaustive list of factors motivating people to undertake research studies.
Many more factors such as directives of government, employment conditions, curiosity about new
things, desire to understand causal relationships, social thinking and awakening, and the like may as
well motivate (or at times compel) people to perform research operations.
The process of planning and conducting a research study involves using the scientific method to
address a specific question. During this process, the researcher moves from a general idea to actual
data collection and interpretation of the results. There are different models of the stages in the
research process. In this lesson, we focus on the simplified stage process. The model identifies the
principle activities involved in undertaking research project. The following are the details of the
steps involved in conducting research.
The first step in the research process is to find a research idea. This task typically involves two parts:
Selecting a general topic area (such as human development, perception, social interaction,
and so on).
Reviewing the literature in that area to identify the relevant variables and find an unanswered
question.
It is important to define the problem in a precise manner. A well-defined problem gives the
researcher a proper direction for carrying out investigation. It also helps in utilizing the resources
provided for the research effectively. A researcher can focus his efforts on collecting relevant
information, if the problem is defined properly.
A research design is a framework or blueprint for conducting the marketing research project. It
details the procedures necessary for obtaining the information needed to structure or solve research
problems. The process of research design start once the problem identification and definition stage is
complete. Planning the research design is a crucial step in the research design process. A research
design is the actual framework of a research that provides specific features about the process to be
followed in undertaking the research. The research designed is based on the objectives formulated
during the problem identification and definition phases of the research. It includes all the details
concerning the research such as;
A research design method is selected based on the objectives of the study, the costs involved in
conducting the research, the availability of the data and finally the importance and urgency of the
decision. There are four basic methods of conducting a research study—secondary data studies,
surveys, experiments and observation. There are several research designs for a research to select
from and researcher are expected to exercise caution in the choice of research design. There are
numerous alternative research designs that can satisfy research objectives, but the key is to create a
design that boosts the value of the information obtained, whilst optimising the costs of obtaining it.
The appropriateness of a particular method for the study must also be judged on the its ability to
deliver the envisaged research results.
Once the researcher selects a research method that is most appropriate for the research, the next steps
to develop a sampling procedure. A sample is a group representing a target population. Sampling is a
method of studying a few selected items as opposed to the entire population, to draw conclusions
regarding the whole population. Therefore, the design of the sampling process starts by defining the
population of the study. A properly defined sample would bear the same characteristics as the study
population.
5. Data collection
Having prepared a suitable sample, the researcher collects the data from the units in this sample,
from which inferences and conclusions about the study problem can be drawn. Just are there are
several research techniques, several data collection methods also exist. Based on the research design,
a researcher may collect data through interviews, survey questionnaires, nominal/focus group
discussions or through observations.
6. Data evaluation/analysis
Once the data have been collected, the next important phase in the research process is evaluating the
data. The most important aspect of data evaluation is to convert the data collected into a format
which will facilitate the drawing conclusions. The reason for analysing the data is to obtain research
results and to prepare the research report. Several mathematical and statistical models are used to
evaluate the data. Evaluation of data normally starts with editing and coding of the data. The way
you analyse the information you collected largely depends upon two things: the type of information
(descriptive, quantitative, qualitative or attitudinal); and the way you want to communicate your
findings to your readers.
7. Data evaluation/analysis
Writing the report is the last and, for many, the most difficult step of the research process. The report
informs the world what you have done, what you have discovered and what conclusions you have
drawn from your findings. The report should be written in an academic style and be divided into
different chapters and/or sections based upon the main themes of your study.
6
The video below explains a seven-step research process.
the use of the words how and what essentially summarizes what research is. It is an investigation of
finding solutions to scientific and social problems through objective and systematic analysis. It is a
search for knowledge, that is, a discovery of hidden truths. Here knowledge means information
about matters. The information might be collected from different sources like experience, human
beings, books, journals, nature, etc.
A research can lead to new contributions to the existing knowledge. Only through research is it
possible to make progress in a field. Research is indeed civilization and determines the economic,
social and political development of a nation. The results of scientific research very often force a
change in the philosophical view of problems which extend far beyond the restricted domain of
science itself.
Research is not confined to science and technology only. There are vast areas of research in other
disciplines such as languages, literature, history and sociology. Whatever might be the subject,
research has to be an active, diligent and systematic process of inquiry in order to discover, interpret
or revise facts, events, behaviours and theories. Applying the outcome of research for the refinement
of knowledge in other subjects, or in enhancing the quality of human life also becomes a kind of
research and development.
study,
experiment,
observation,
analysis,
comparison and
How did we know all these? We became aware of all this information only through research. More
precisely, it seeks predictions of events, explanations, relationships and theories for them. As stated
7
by Gerald Milburn Scientific research is a chaotic business, stumbling along amidst red herrings,
errors and truly, creative insights. Great scientific breakthroughs are rarely the work of a single
researchers plodding slowly by inexorably towards some final goal.
The crucial idea behind the breakthrough may surface a number of times, in different places, only to
sink again beneath the babble of an endless scientific discourse.
(3) to analyse an event or process or phenomenon to identify the cause and effect relationship
(4) to develop new scientific tools, concepts and theories to solve and understand scientific and non
scientific problems
(5) to find solutions to scientific, non scientific and social problems and
This is a fundamentally important question. No person would like to do research unless
there are some motivating factors. Some of the motivations are the following:
(1) to get a research degree along with its benefits like better employment, promotion,
increment in salary, etc.
(2) to get a research degree and then to get a teaching position in a college or university or
become a scientist in a research institution
(3) to get a research position in countries like U.S.A., Canada, Germany, England, Japan,
(8) curiosity to find out the unknown facts of an event
8
(9) curiosity to find new things
Some students undertake research without any aim possibly because of not being able to
think of anything else to do. Such students can also become good researchers by motivating
themselves toward a respectable goal. Even if you work in a company or run a company, a
mind inclined towards research would do better than a mind not trained for it and it was
like the story of the hare and the tortoise. If you have a mind trained for research, you will
be the tortoise – the climb would be slow and steady, but eventually you would win the
race.
Research is important both in scientific and non-scientific fields. In our life new problems,
events, phenomena and processes occur every day. Practically, implementable solutions and
suggestions are required for tackling new problems that arise. Scientists have to undertake
research on them and find their causes, solutions, explanations and applications. Precisely,
research assists us to understand nature and natural phenomena.
(1) A research problem refers to a difficulty which a researcher or a scientific community or
an industry or a government organization or a society experiences. It may be a theoretical
or a practical situation. It calls for a thorough understanding and possible solution.
(2) Research on existing theories and concepts help us identify the range and applications of
them.
(3) It is the fountain of knowledge and provide guidelines for solving problems.
(4) Research provides basis for many government policies. For example, research on the
needs and desires of the people and on the availability of revenues to meet the needs helps
a government to prepare a budget.
(5) It is important in industry and business for higher gain and productivity and to improve
the quality of products.
(6) Mathematical and logical research on business and industry optimizes the problems in
them.
(7) It leads to the identification and characterization of new materials, new living things,
new stars, etc.
(8) Only through research inventions can be made; for example, new and novel phenomena
and processes such as superconductivity and cloning have been discovered only through
research.
(9) Social research helps find answers to social problems. They explain social phenomena
and seek solution to social problems.
9
(10) Research leads to a new style of life and makes it delightful and glorious. Emphasizing
the importance of research Louis Pasteur said: I beseech you to take interest in these sacred
domains called laboratories. Ask that there be more and that they be adorned for these are
the temples of the future, wealth and well-being. It is here that humanity will learn to read
progress and individual harmony in the works of nature, while humanity’s own works are all
too often those of barbarism, fanaticism and destruction. (Louis Paster –article by S.
Mahanti, Dream 2047, p.29–34 (May 2003)).
Research methods
are the various procedures, schemes and algorithms used in All the methods used by
a researcher during a research study are termed as research methods. They are
essentially planned, scientific and value-neutral. They include theoretical procedures,
experimental studies, numerical schemes, statistical approaches, etc.
Research methods help us collect samples, data and find a solution to a Particularly,
scientific research methods call for explanations based on collected facts,
measurements and observations and not on reasoning alone. They accept only those
explanations which can be verified by experiments.
Research methodology
Research methodology is a systematic way to solve a It is a science of studying how
research is to be carried out. Essentially, the procedures by which researchers go
about their work of describing, explaining and predicting phenomena are called
research methodology. It is also defined as the study of methods by which knowledge
is gained. Its aim is to give the work plan of research.
It is necessary for a researcher to design a methodology for the problem One should
note that even if the method considered in two problems are same the methodology
may be different. It is important for the researcher to know not only the research
methods necessary for the research under taken but also the methodology. For
example, a researcher not only needs to know how to calculate mean, variance and
distribution function for a set of data, how to find a solution of a physical system
described by mathematical model, how to determine the roots of algebraic equations
and how to apply a particular method but also need to know
(ii) what is the order of accuracy of the result of a method?,
10
(iii) what is the efficiency of the method?
and so on. Consideration of these aspects constitute a research methodology.
More precisely, research methods help us get a solution to a problem. On the other hand,
research methodology is concerned with the explanation of the following:
(5) Why was a particular technique of analysis of data used?
The study of research methods gives training to apply them to a problem. The study of
research methodology provides us the necessary training in choosing methods, materials,
scientific tools and training in techniques relevant for the problem chosen.
But it is original or basic in character. It provides a systematic and deep insight into a problem and
facilitates extraction of scientific and logical explanation and conclusion on it. It helps build new
frontiers of knowledge. The outcomes of basic research form the basis for many applied
research. Researchers working on applied research have to make use of the outcomes of
basic research and explore the utility of them.
Research on improving a theory or a method is also referred as fundamental research. For
example, suppose a theory is applicable to a system provided the system satisfies certain
specific conditions. Modifying the theory to apply it to a general situation is a basic research.
Attempts to find answers to the following questions actually form basic research.
11
Why are materials like that?
What are they?
How does a crystal melt?
Why is sound produced when water is heated?
Why do we feel difficult when walking on seashore?
Why are birds arrange them in ‘>’ shape when flying in a group?
Fundamental research leads to a new theory or a new property of matter or even the
existence of a new matter, the knowledge of which has not been known or reported earlier.
For example, fundamental research on
(1) astronomy may leads to identification of new planets or stars in our galaxy,
(3) complex functions may leads to new patterns or new properties associated with them,
(4) differential equations results in new types of solutions or new properties of solutions not
known so far,
(5) chemical reactions leads to development of new compounds, new properties of
chemicals, mechanism of chemicals reactions, etc.,
(6) medicinal chemistry leads to an understanding of physiological action of various
chemicals and drugs,
(7) structure, contents and functioning of various parts of human body helps us identify the
basis for certain diseases.
12
Studies individual or specific cases without
the objective to generalize
Seeks generalization
It is numerical, non-descriptive, applies statistics or mathematics and uses numbers.
It is an iterative process whereby evidence is evaluated.
The results are often presented in tables and graphs.
It is conclusive.
It investigates the what , where and when of decision making.
Statistics is the most widely used branch of mathematics in quantitative research. It finds
applications not only in physical sciences but also in economics, social sciences and biology.
13
Quantitative research using statistical methods often begins with the collection of data based
on a theory or hypothesis or experiment followed by the application of descriptive or
inferential statistical methods.
Qualitative research is concerned with qualitative phenomenon involving quality. Some of the
characteristics of qualitative research/method are:
We measure and weigh things in the study of substance or structure. Can we measure or
weigh patterns? We cannot measure or weigh patterns. But to study patterns we must map a
configuration of relationships. That is, structures involve quantities whereas patterns involve
qualities. If one wishes to investigate why certain data are random then it is a qualitative
research. If the aim is to study how random the data is, what is the mean, variance and
distribution function then it becomes quantitative. Explaining how digestion of food takes
place in our body is a qualitative description. It does not involve any numbers or data and
quantities.
The detection of a particular compound is a qualitative analysis. This can be done by
carrying out physical or chemical tests. Determination of exact amount of a particular
compound present in a volume is essentially quantitative analysis. This can be done by
volumetric, gravimetric and colorimetric methods or instrumental methods. Experimental and
simulation studies are generally quantitative research. In fact, qualitative methods can be used
to understand the meaning of the numbers obtained by quantitative methods.
Other types of research include action research (fact findings to improve the quality of
action in the social world), explanatory research (searching explanations for events and
phenomena, for example finding answer to the question why are the things like what they
are?), exploratory research (getting more information on a topic) and comparative research
(obtaining similarities and differences between events, methods, techniques, etc.).
Exercise 4.1-2
Assignment:
1. List out at least 10 theoretical and applied methods which you have learned and write
their features in two or three
2. Write at least 20 questions in your subject the investigation of which forms basic research.
Then point out how many of them have already been solved and how many were found in
14
3. Distinguish between theory and Write a note on importance of theory in basic and applied
In the following sections the above mentioned various stages of research are discussed in
detail.
There are many ways to do research as there are scientists. The choice of a thesis research
area has always been a very subjective process. Identifying a suitable topic for work is one
of the most difficult parts of a research. Before choosing a research topic and a problem the
young researchers should keep the following points in mind.
15
Topic should be suitable for research.
The researcher should have interest in it.
Topic should not be chosen by compulsion from some one else.
Topic and problem can be fixed in consultation with the research supervisor. In our country
often research supervisors suggest a topic and state a problem in broad view. The researcher
has to narrow it and define it in an operational form.
Some sources of identification of a research topic and problems are the following:
Suppose one is interested in the theory of nonlinear differential equations or quasicrystals or
fullerenes. Then he can find a research guide who is working in this field or interested to
work in this field and then choose a problem for research. Our daily experiences and day to
affairs have rich openings on various aspects such as the daunting tasks of AIDS, consumer
perception, air pollution, afforestation and deforestation, child labor, problems of aged
citizens, etc.
Technology in various branches of science, business and marketing changes rapidly. For
example, in the early years, computers were built in larger size with vacuum tubes. Then
evolution in electronic technology replaced them by integrated circuits. Recently, scientists
have developed quantum dots. Now the interest is in developing efficient, super-fast and
miniaturized computing machine made up of material whose particle size of the order of
nano (10−9) meter or even smaller. Similarly, another fascinating topic namely, thin film has
multiple fields of applications. Recent research on fullerenes resulted in many practical
applications.
Choosing a topic of current interest or recent trends provides bright and promising
opportunities for young researchers to get post-doctoral fellowship, position in leading
institutions in our nation and abroad. In each subject there are several topics which are not
explored in detail even though the topic was considered by scientists long time ago. For
example, string theory, quantum computing, nano-particles, quantum cloning and quantum
cryptography and gene immunology are fascinating topics and are in preliminary stages.
The supervisors and experts are working on one or few fields over a long time and they
are the specialists in the field considered and well versed with the development and current
status of the field. Therefore, a young researcher can make use of their expertise in knowing
16
various possible problems in the topic the solving of which provide better opportunities in
all aspects.
Don’t choose a topic simply because it is fascinating. In choosing a topic one should take
care of the possibility of data collection, quantity of gain, breadth of the topic and so on.
The topic should not be too narrow. For example, the study of social status and sexual life
of married couples of same sex (man-man marriage and woman-woman marriage) is
interesting and of social relevance. But the intricate problem here is that we do not find
enough number of such couples to study. This is a very narrow topic at the same time we
will not get enough data to analyse. On the other hand, the changes in the social life of
aravanis in recent times is a valuable social problem and one can collect enough data.
Further, one has to study advanced level text books and latest research articles to identify
problems. Is it necessary to know all the methods, techniques, concepts in a research topic
before identifying a problem for investigation? This is not necessary. After learning some
fundamental concepts, recent developments and current trends of a topic, one can identify a
problem for research. Then he can learn the tools necessary to solve it
State the problem in questionnaire form or in an equivalent form
Specify the problem in detail and in precise terms
List the assumptions made
Remove the ambiguities, if any, in the statement of the problem
Examine the feasibility of a particular solution
Defining the problem is more important than its solution. It is a crucial part of the research
study and should not be defined in hurry.
A problem in its first definition may not be appealing. It may require redefinition in order
to make it a good problem. That is, by suitably rewording or reformulating the chosen
problem, it can be made to meet the criteria of a good problem. This is also important to
solve the problem successfully. To this end a researcher can ask a series of questions on
the problem. Some are:
(1) Is the problem really interesting to him and to the scientific community?
(2) Is the problem significant to the present status of the topic?
(4) Can the problem be solved in the required time frame?
17
(5) Are the necessary equipment, adequate library and computational facilities, etc. available?
If the answers to these questions are satisfactory, then the researcher can initiate work on
the chosen problem. In addition, discuss the problem with the current students who are
studying higher degrees than yourself and obtain the scope of the problem and other related
aspects.
The researcher should be interested on the problem for the reasons mentioned above. The
problem should also be interesting to the supervisor so that the researcher can get the
necessary guidance from him. Otherwise sometimes the researcher may find it very difficult
to convince the supervisor on the importance and significance of the results obtained. More
importantly, the problem must be of interest to scientific community and society. If not then
the researcher will find great difficulty to publish his findings in reputed journals and
convince the funding agency.
Next, the status of the problem, particularly the importance of finding its solution should
match with the current status of the field. But, if the problem investigated is of not much
interest to science and society then publications will become useless to him in his research
career. A researcher needs proper guidance and encouragement from the supervisor regularly.
This is important for keeping the research in right track, to overcome the difficulties which
come at various states of research and also to have moral support.
Finally, the researcher must make sure that the necessary experimental setup and materials
to perform the actual research work are available in the department where research work is
to be carried out. Without these, if the researcher initiated the work and has gone through
certain stages of work or spent one or two years in the problem then in order to complete
the task he would be forced to buy the materials and instruments from his personal savings.
(1) the journals which publish abstracts of papers published in various journals,
18
(4) advanced level books on the chosen topic,
(6) reprint/preprint collections available with the supervisor and nearby experts working on
the topic chosen and
(7) Internet.
No research shall be complete unless we make use of the knowledge available in books,
journals and internet. Review of the literature in the area of research is a preliminary step
before attempting to plan the study.
(1) sharpen the problem, reformulate it or even leads to defining other closely related
problems,
(3) acquire proper theoretical and practical knowledge to investigate the problem,
(4) show how the problem under study relates to the previous research studies and
(5) know whether the proposed problem had already been solved.
Through survey one can collect relevant information about the problem. Clarity of ideas can
be acquired through study of literature. Apart from literature directly connected with the
problem, the literature that is connected with similar problems is also useful. It helps
formulate the problem in a clear-cut way. A review on past work helps us know the
outcome of those investigations where similar problems were solved. It can help us design
methodology for the present work. We can also explore the vital links with the various trends
and phases in the chosen topic and familiarize with characteristic precepts, concepts and
interpretations. Further, it can help us formulate a satisfactory structure of the research proposal.
Because a Ph.D. thesis or MSc or B. Sc dissertation is a study in depth aiming contribution to
knowledge, a careful check should be made to ensure that the proposed study has not
previously been performed and reported. The earlier studies which are relevant to the
problem chosen should be carefully studied. Ignorance of prior studies may lead to a
researcher duplicating a work already carried out by another researcher. A good library will
be of great help to a researcher at this stage. One can visit nearby research institutions and
avail the library facility.
Electronic mail, e-journal, online submission of articles to journals, online focus groups, online
video conferencing and online questionary are some of the latest tools opened-up by the
internet. We note that thousands of books and other print publications have been made
available online that would be extremely difficult to locate otherwise, including out-of-print
books, and classic literature and textbooks that would be much less accessible in their
printed form.
Some of the scientific research information available on the internet are:
In general, academic research that has been commercially published is not freely available
on the internet.
Some of the features of conducting research through internet are:
While the internet contains a virtually-unlimited wealth of information not found in
traditional resources, this abundance also may hinder academic research. The following are
some of the new challenges for the researcher:
A major way to find whether an online source is credible is to determine how popular and
authoritative the source is. If the site has a well-respected offline counterpart such as the
New York Times the site will be as credible as the original. For websites and authors
which have little popularity, one must consider the credentials of the source–if those are
available and valid. Even though a website may be written in a professional or academic
20
manner, the lack of central body to determine its credibility may be a prohibitive factor for
serious research.
The important source of reference collection is the journal called Current Contents. This
comes once in a week. It is available in hard copy and also in floppy diskette. Almost all
the universities and research institutions buy this document. It contains the table of content
of research journals and magazines in various subjects. It provides title of articles, names of
the authors, date of publication, volume number, starting page number of the articles and
address of the author from whom one can get the reprint of the article. If the title of the
article indicates that the paper is in the topic of one’s interest then he can take a copy of
the article if the journal is available in the local library.
One can obtain a research article on paying the charge fixed by the INFLIBNET provided
the particular journal is available in it. Articles can also be purchased from the publishers
on payment. Alternatively, reprint of the article can be had from the author by sending a
letter/card/e-mail to the author. The references from current contents or from journals can be
noted on a separate card or sheet with the names of authors and the title of the paper/book,
etc. For a research paper, its title, journal name, volume number, starting and ending pages
of it and year of publication should be noted. For a book, publisher’s name, place of
publication and year of publication must be written down. The references can be classified.
For example, sources dealing with theory, dealing with experimental techniques, concerned
with numerical methods, etc. can be grouped separately. The copies of the research articles
can also be classified and bounded. Cross references (that is research articles or books
referred or cited in a research report) should also be collected and classified. These also
provide useful information.
Reference collection and keeping the collected materials have to be systematic. Unless they
are organized with utmost care and discipline, one would end up in chaos. One may not be
able to retrieve the required research article or any other collected material when it needed.
Materials can be classified as facts, ideas, views and opinions, expert comments, new
breakthroughs, quotes, journal papers, review articles, etc. It is better to have multiple copies
of important materials. At various stages of research one may refer to numerous journal
articles, books and web sites. Obviously, all of them are not going to find a place in the
thesis or research reports. Based on the present work and future plan one has to select the
relevant materials from the available collection.
21
Generally, it is not difficult to know the current status of research work in a specific topic.
The current status of the chosen topic can be identified by reading the relevant journals and
the recent papers, discussions in conferences, seminars and workshops. One can perform
inquiries at several important places known for research on proposed topic. A study of the
current literature in the chosen topic explores the current status of it. More importantly,
review articles point out not only to the basic aspects and features of the topic concerned
but also give a brief account of its present status. For this purpose, one can survey the
journals, Review Letters, Reviews, Current journals, seminars and conferences, etc.
Rapid communication and Letter sections of international journals publish articles which are
very important and fall in recent trends category. There are several areas in internet where
the papers just submitted to journals are placed. One can download such articles free of
cost. These articles indicate the recent trends in a particular topic. Some relevant web sites
are listed below.
http://arxiv.org/
http://www.ams.org/global-preprints/
http://front.math.ucdavis.edu/math.AG/
http://www.ma.utexas.edu/mp−arc/
http://www.clifford.org/anonftp/clf-alg/
They are often stated in terms of if-then sentences in certain logical forms. A hypothesis
should provide what we expect to find in the chosen research problem. That is, the expected
or proposed solutions based on available data and tentative explanations constitute the
hypothesis. Hypothesizing is done only after survey of relevant literature and learning the
present status of the field of research. It can be formulated based on previous research and
observation. To formulate a hypothesis the researcher should acquire enough knowledge in
the topic of research and a reasonably deep insight about the problem. In formulating a
hypothesis construct operational definitions of variables in the research problem. Hypothesis
is due to an intelligent guess or for inspiration which is to be tested in the research work
rigorously through appropriate methodology. Testing of hypothesis leads to explanation of the
associated phenomenon or event.
What are the criteria of a good hypothesis? An hypothesis should have conceptual clarity
and a theoretical orientation. Further, it should be testable. It should be stated in a suitable
22
way so that it can be tested by investigation. A hypothesis made initially may become
incorrect when the data obtained are analysed. In this case it has to be revised. It is
important to state the hypothesis of a research problem in a research report. We note that if
a hypothesis withstands the experiments and provides the required facts to make it
acceptable, not only to the researchers performing the experiments but to others doing other
experiments then when sufficiently reinforced by continual verification the hypothesis may
become a theory.
Discussion with the supervisor, experts and colleagues about the research work,
particularly, the problem and its origin, objectives and difficulties faced in the
execution of the
Reading of the latest research papers, relevant theories and possible application to the
present problem and to overcome the difficulties
Review of the work reported on the similar
Theoretical calculations, setting-up of an experimental setup, numerical calculations,
computer programs, preparation of graphs, tables and other relevant work related to
the research should be done by a new researcher by himself without assistance from
others.
Have a practice of periodically writing the work done, results obtained and steps
followed in a This is important because sometime we may think that a particular
aspect will be a center piece of the problem under investigation. But once we make
a write-up of it, this aspect or part of it may turn out to be only of marginal
importance. In fact, writing of the progress of the work will help us better understand
our work and forms a solid basis for further progress. It also points out the gaps in
our work.
Participation and presentation of research findings in national and international
These regular practices provide useful information like new ideas and can help the researcher
Independent Research
Absolute honesty, patience, stamina, precision and devotion to the subject of matter together
with imagination and analytical ability are among the requirements for scientific research.
Each and every bit of task related to the research work has to be done by the researcher. A
young researcher should not do the entire work in collaboration with others. A young
researcher should have the ability to do all by himself. In this connection Beasley and Jones
[1] wrote: In reality collaborations are commonplace, often necessary–to get samples, to
make all the desired measurements or to perform a complete analysis.
But such collaborations generally arise naturally in the course of the research and define
and limit themselves naturally. A true sense of camaraderie often develops, and students do
not lose that sense of having made major contributions on their own. The researcher is
advised to perform all the works starting from identification of the problem to report
24
preparation by himself under the guidance of supervisor. Particularly, collaboration work with
experts and senior researcher may be avoided. (However, he can discuss his problems with
them).
(3) training
Part of the dissertation should demonstrate the researcher’s originality. The dissertation should
reflect the efforts of a single researcher. Keeping this in mind one should avoid
collaboration as far as possible in the young stage. Eugene Wigner, a Nobel laureate said:
One does not have the satisfaction which creative work provides, if one’s activities are too
closely directed by others.
Doubt
A researcher should provide new information to the supervisor and avoid getting information
from the supervisor. This remarkable growth has to come through nothing but his hard work.
There is no shortcut to success. He should learn and collect many information related to his
work. The Nobel Laureate Richard Feynman said: I had no fear of doubt and uncertainty. I
don’t feel frightened by not knowing things, by being lost in a mysterious universe without
any purpose. It doesn’t frighten me. Doubt is motivation. It leads to discovery and the
pleasure of finding things out.
Complete Focus
Francis Bacon said: If a man will begin with certainties, he shall end in doubts. But if he
will be content to begin with doubts, he will end in certainties. During the course of
research, one should focus the mind mainly on the research work. Don’t allow the personal
life to interfere with research. Our life is mixed with happiness, sorrows, problems and
difficulties. At any stage of life how much happiness we had depends on how much
problems we faced and how we approached each one of them, how we solved them and so
on. Most of the achievements have been made by scientists only after struggles.
A researcher must be clear in his thoughts. He should know what he has to find out. In
order to perform the work successfully the researcher should acquire proper training in the
techniques of research. The training equips the researcher with the requirements of the task.
Further, he should be clear about his task and possess intellectual insight. Then only he is
able to find out the facts that would help him in his task. Make your research a part of
your every day life. Think about your research work in background mode, ideas will come
out even when you are seeing a movie, traveling to a place, sight-seeing and shopping
Maintaining Ties
A good relationship with the supervisor is essential for several reasons. It will greatly
influence the quality and progress of your work. Remember that maintaining an excellent
25
relationship with another person and working closely for a long period is not easy. You
have to maintain a fine relation with the supervisor and also with your seniors and
colleagues throughout your period of association. Backbiting and unwholesome arguments on
academic matters, research work and other matters should be avoided. The supervisor will
have a thorough knowledge of the subject of research, however, at one stage you may feel
that you have acquired more knowledge than him in certain topics. But this is no reason to
show-off.
You have to maintain politeness and courtesy. Professional etiquette has to be followed. If
your are consulting another expert on some aspect of your work, it should be necessarily be
with the knowledge of your supervisor. You should also take the supervisor’s criticism in
the right spirit and respond appropriately; there should be no reason for emotional outbursts.
third priority. The attributes of a good research scholar may be summarized as:
Self-confidence
Dedication
Concentration
Determination
Analytical mind
Scientific discipline
Global outlook
Innovative approach
Originality
Intellectual curiosity
Freedom from the obsessions of clock and calendar
Flexibility
Keen observation
Intelligence
Passion for knowledge
Questioning attitude
Spirit of enquiry
Insight
Precision and accuracy
Resilience to withstand temporary setbacks
Persistence
Patience
Social skills
Presentation skills
Writing skills
To distinguish one from another we can use various quantities. Like-wise, to identify the
best from among the available, one can use various quantities to measure the quality of
them. For example, to identify a best research the quality of the one’s research publications,
number of citations of his publications, projects completed, books published, contribution
made to the science and society, etc. can be considered.
Research work
(2) cited by other researchers working in the same or similar topic and
(3) which added new information to the existing knowledge on a topic are generally
considered as good .
(3) Over-generalization
(9) Mystification
27
There are two indispensable rules of modern research. The freedom of creative imagination
necessarily subjected to rigorous experimentation. In the beginning any experimental research
on a specific subject, imagination should give wings to the thought. At the time of
concluding and interpreting the facts that were collected observation, the imagination should
be dominated and prevailed over by concrete results of experiments. We should analyse
cause and effect. We should pay attention to minute details also.
In fact keenness in observation is the hallmark of any scientific research. Proper
interpretations of the results must be made. Interpretation refers to the task of drawing
inferences from the actual research work . It also means drawing of conclusion. Conclusion
is based on the study performed. It would bring out relations and processes that underlie the
findings. The utility of the outcome of the research greatly lie on proper interpretations and
is the hardest part of solving a scientific problem. Interpretation of results is important
because it
(3) opens new avenues of intellectual adventure and stimulates the quest for more
knowledge,
(4) makes others understand the significance of the research findings and
The basic rule in preparing results and conclusion is to give all the evidences relevant to
the research problem and its solution. A bare statement of the findings are not enough.
Their implications must be pointed out. Discuss your answers to the following questions
with experts:
(1) Are the supporting evidences sufficient?, and if not, What to do?
(2) How many pieces of evidence are required? Instead of producing all, is it possible to
restrict to one or two pieces of evidence? If so, what are they? and
Such directions can help us minimize work and the quantity of presentation of the report.
Do not rely on a bogus evidence which would increase the chances of errors. The
investigator has to give suggestions. These should be practical and based on logic, reasoning
and fact. The suggestions should be such that they can be actually implemented. The
researcher should not be in hurry while preparing the results and conclusion. After preparing
them the researcher may ask the following questions:
(1) Are the quantitative and qualitative analysis performed adequate for the conclusion
drawn?
28
(3) Are the results and conclusion valid only for the particular situation considered in the
present work?
(4) Is the conclusion too broad considering the analysis performed?
The results and conclusion prepared can be revised based on the answers to the above
questions. Each and every statement made in the results and conclusion sections must be
based on evidence obtained from theoretical or experimental analysis. Baseless statements
should never be made. While doing research particularly experiments, one may land up with
an unexpected result or a finding contrary to the underlying theory. Such an observation
should not be ignored blindly. It may be pursued to some extent to check whether it yields
some useful result.
As noted by Warrier [2001], the history of science records such fortuitous breaks that led to
many classic discoveries. Never yield to the temptation of fabrication of results and
interpretation. Plagiarism in the form of copying data or findings from others’ report without
acknowledging the source will make you in trouble. Don’t attempt to report the already
reported findings of others as yours. Citing the original sources actually enhances the
credibility of your work. One should note that the observations, claims and the conclusions
drawn in a research report are subjected to a criticism by the experts in the concerned field.
Therefore, the researchers have to think twice before presenting the outcomes of the research
in a journal and in a scientific meeting.
Exercise 9.1-2
For each of the following topics write at least two questions, the answers to which must be
available in the respective topics. For example, for the topic, introduction, a relevant
question is Why am I doing it?.
(i) Introduction,
(iii) Methodology,
(v) Results,
(vii) Conclusion.
29
Lesson 10.1 What is an oral report and why is
it important
Presentation of one’s research work in a scientific meeting is an oral report . Scientific
meetings include conference, seminar, symposium, workshop, departmental weekly seminar,
etc. Researchers in certain research institutions not only discuss their own work but also have
discussions on very recently reported work of other scientists.
An oral report provides a bridge between the researcher and audience and offers greater scope
to the researcher for explaining the actual work performed, its outcome and significance. It
also leads to a better understanding of the findings and their implications. In an oral report,
the researcher can present the results and interpretations which are not clearly understood by
him and may request the experts in the audience to give their opinions and suggestions. Oral
reporting at a conference or a seminar requires more elaborate preparation than the written report.
For a long time, report, that is, 45–60-minute presentation, one may have enough time to
30
Consequently, these aspects can be prepared in detail.
For a 15–30 minute, oral presentation one cannot find enough time to discuss complete
details of the work. In this case less informative materials must be dropped. Methods and
techniques used can be presented very briefly without going into technical details. Much
time should be reserved for results, conclusion and further directions.
Prepare a write-up of the oral presentation. It is a good and very helpful practice to write
the talk before presenting it orally. Then evaluate the written material. Ask:
Revise the presentation until you get convincing answer to the above two questions. Make
sure that your objective would convince the audience that you have done your job well,
your methodology is sound and the findings are useful. The success of a presentation lies in
making it long enough to cover the topic and short enough to arouse curiosity . Oral
presentation can be made effective and attractive by using modern visual devises, power-
points, slides and transparency sheets.
Title of the report, author’s name, plan of the presentation, very important content of it and
conclusion can be printed in the slides or sheets possibly point by point with bold and sufficiently
large size letters. Merely reading out measured or computed data will never catch the attention of the
audience. They may be displayed in the form of histograms. Important formulas, equations,
tables, figures and photographs can be prepared using transparency sheets or slides. Slides
and transparency sheets should not contain running matters. Researcher should not simply
read the content in the sheets. That is, the descriptive portion of the report should not be
prepared on the sheets.
An abstract or a short write-up of the presentation may be circulated to the participants of
the meeting. Sophisticated softwares developed for preparing the text on transparency
sheets/slides are available in internet and can be freely downloaded. In order to make the
presentation, more lively, the researcher could use multimedia. Nowadays, the use of power-
point of Microsoft Windows is common. It is an easy and compact utility software
especially for preparing classroom presentations.
One could use the audio aspects also to facilitate his presentation in a better way. While
presenting the topic, the researcher should strictly follow the class room teaching
methodology. For example, one should allow interaction; don’t forget to modulate the voice
as and when required and don’t violate the time frame. Logical continuity is another key
aspect. Move from the simple to the complex, from the known to the unknown. Your
statements should sound sensible and reasonable. Do not speak too fast and compromise on
31
clarity, or speak too slowly and bore the audience. Make the session interactive by posing
questions.
As pointed out by Warrier, there is a dictum to be followed in good speeches: First tell
them what you are going to tell. Next, you tell them. Then tell them what you told them.
The most crucial part is the actual presentation in front of the listeners. Stage fright is the
bane of most presenters. There is no shortcut to overcome this fear. One has to practice,
practice and practice. You can improve your presentation skill by getting the feedback after
you have spoken. Avoid repeated use of words or phrases such as “well”, “your see”, “you
know”, “I mean”, “I think”, “that is” and “basically”. You should also concentrate on your
body language.
Smooth movements of limbs, an occasional smile and pleasing manners would endear us to
the listeners. Look relaxed and comfortable. Eye contact should be maintained with the
audience. Let your eyes move uniformly around the entire audience and not focus on any
particular person or a particular part of the audience. One or two rehearsals of the report in
the presence of colleagues, supervisor and collaborators can be exercised in order to
During a long presentation, the speaker can stop the presentation at various stages, seek
comments and questions from the audience and then proceed. This will make the
presentation attractive, interesting and also allow the audience to clarify their doubts so that
they can follow the work. Your clarifications should be clear and convincing. Never go into
arguments. Your confidence gets boosted, if you approach the situation with a feeling that the
expert panel is there to help you. An important point is to consider the tone to adopt so
that you sound genuine.
https://www.slideshare.net/effectworks/10-commandments-for-great-presentations (Links to an
external site.)
32
Exercise 12.3
Pick a topic of your choice and prepare a PowerPoint presentation of not more than 15 slides
33