Compressor Calculations - Rigorous Using Equation of State Vs Shortcut Method - Campbell Tip of The Month
Compressor Calculations - Rigorous Using Equation of State Vs Shortcut Method - Campbell Tip of The Month
Compressor Calculations - Rigorous Using Equation of State Vs Shortcut Method - Campbell Tip of The Month
May 2020
April 2020
where mass flow rate and h is specific enthalpy.
March 2020
From a calculation viewpoint alone, the power calculation is particularly sensitive to the specification of flow rate, inlet
temperature and pressure, and outlet pressure. Gas composition is important but a small error here is less important February 2020
providing it does not involve the erroneous exclusion of corrosive components. A compressor is going to operate under January 2020
varying values of the variables affecting its performance. Thus the most difficult part of a compressor calculation is
specification of a reasonable range for each variable and not the calculation itself. Reference [1] emphasizes that using a December 2019
single value for each variable is not the correct way to evaluate a compression system.
November 2019
Normally, the thermodynamic calculations are performed for an ideal (reversible process). The results of a reversible
process are then adapted to the real world through the use of an efficiency. In the compression process there are three October 2019
ideal processes that can be visualized: 1) an isothermal process, 2) an isentropic process and 3) a polytropic process. Any September 2019
one of these processes can be used suitably as a basis for evaluating compression power requirements by either hand or
computer calculation. The isothermal process, however, is seldom used as a basis because the normal industrial August 2019
compression process is not even approximately carried out at constant temperature.
July 2019
For an isentropic (reversible and adiabatic) process, equation 1 can be written as:
June 2019
May 2019
April 2019
March 2019
February 2019
and based on the polytropic process:
January 2019
December 2018
November 2018
October 2018
September 2018
The isentropic head is calculated by equation 3A:
August 2018
July 2018
June 2018
May 2018
April 2018
Similarly, the polytropic head is calculated by equation 3B: March 2018
February 2018
January 2018
December 2017
November 2017
The actual discharge temperature based on the isentropic path is calculated by equation 4A.
October 2017
September 2017
August 2017
July 2017
June 2017
May 2017
April 2017
March 2017
The actual discharge temperature based on the polytropic is calculated by equation 4B.
February 2017
January 2017
December 2016
November 2016
where η and ηP are the isentropic (or adiabatic) and polytropic efficiency, respectively, P1 suction pressure, P2 discharge
October 2016
pressure, T1 and T2 arethe suction and discharge temperatures, respectively, q is gas volume flow rate at standard September 2016
condition of PS and TS, Za average gas compressibility factor, k heat capacity ratio, R the gas constant, and n is the
polytropic path exponent. Equations 1 and 2 are equally correct theoretically. The practical choice depends on the August 2016
available data, although it is somewhat arbitrary. The power calculation should be made per stage of compression and July 2016
www.jmcampbell.com/tip-of-the-month/2011/11/compressor-calculations-rigorous-using-equation-of-state-vs-shortcut-method/ 1/7
05/08/2020 Compressor Calculations: Rigorous Using Equation of State vs Shortcut Method | Campbell Tip of the Month
then summed for all stages connected to a single driver. For general planning purposes the graphical solutions shown in June 2016
reference [2] produce results comparable to these equations.
May 2016
Equation of State (EOS)
April 2016
The heart of any commercial process flow simulation software is an equation of state. Due to their simplicity and relative
accuracy, normally a cubic EOS such as Soave Redlich-Kwong (SRK) [3] or Peng-Robinson [4] is used. These equations March 2016
are used to calculate phase behavior, enthalpy, and entropy. With proper binary interaction coefficients, the process
simulation results of these two equations are practically the same. Therefore, only the SRK was used in this work. February 2016
Step-by-Step Computer Solution
January 2016
December 2015
For known gas rate, pressure (P1), temperature (T1), and composition at the inlet condition and discharge pressure (P2),
computation of compressor power requirement is based on an EOS using a computer and involves two steps: November 2015
1. Determination of the ideal or isentropic (reversible and adiabatic) enthalpy change of the compression process. October 2015
The ideal work requirement is obtained by multiplying mass rate by the isentropic enthalpy change.
2. Adjustment of the ideal work requirement for compressor efficiency.
September 2015
The step-by-step calculation based an EOS is outlined below. August 2015
a. Assume steady state, i.e. and the feed composition remain unchanged. July 2015
b. Assume isentropic process, i.e. adiabatic and reversible
c. Calculate enthalpy h1=f(P1, T1, and composition) and suction entropy s1=f(P1, T1, and composition) at the June 2015
suction condition by EOS May 2015
d. For the isentropic process . Note the * April 2015
represents ideal value.
March 2015
e. Calculate the ideal enthalpy ( ) at outlet condition for known composition, P2 and .
February 2015
f. The ideal work is January 2015
December 2014
www.jmcampbell.com/tip-of-the-month/2011/11/compressor-calculations-rigorous-using-equation-of-state-vs-shortcut-method/ 2/7
05/08/2020 Compressor Calculations: Rigorous Using Equation of State vs Shortcut Method | Campbell Tip of the Month
April 2011
March 2011
February 2011
January 2011
December 2010
November 2010
October 2010
September 2010
August 2010
July 2010
June 2010
May 2010
April 2010
March 2010
Figure 1. Compressor polytropic head and best efficiency point
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
Figure 2. Compressor polytropic efficiency December 2008
Results and Discussions
November 2008
October 2008
SRK (Rigorous Method): The feed composition, temperature, pressure, volumetric flow rate at standard condition along
with the compressor polytropic head and efficiency curves data were entered into the ProMax software [5] to perform the September 2008
rigorous calculations based on the SRK EOS. The program calculated polytropic and isentropic efficiencies, heads,
compression ratio (discharge pressure), discharge temperature and power. For the actual gas flow rate at the inlet August 2008
condition, the polytropic efficiency is close to the compressor best efficiency point (BEP). The program also calculated the
gas relative density, heat capacity ratio (k), and polytropic exponent (n). These calculated results are presented in the SRK
July 2008
columns of Table 2 (bold numbers with white background). June 2008
Table 2. Summary of the rigorous and shortcut calculated results May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
The bold numbers with white background are the calculated values December 2006
November 2006
Short-1 (Shortcut Method): In this method, we used equations 2 through 4 to calculate the polytropic and isentropic October 2006
heads, the discharge temperature and power. We used the ProMax calculated polytropic and isentropic efficiencies,
compression ratio (P2/P1), heat capacity ratio (k) and polytropic exponent (n) to calculate head, power, and the discharge September 2006
temperature. The results are presented in the short-1 columns of Table 2. Note the short-1 results (discharge temperature, August 2006
adiabatic and polytropic heads and power) are very close to the SRK values. The calculated actual discharge temperature
by equation 4A (isentropic path: 265.3˚F=129.6˚C) was slightly lower than by equation 4B (polytropic path: 265.9 ˚F=129.9 July 2006
˚C).
June 2006
Short-2 (Shortcut Method): Similar to short-1 method, we used equations 2 through 4 to calculate the polytropic and
isentropic heads, the actual discharge temperature and power. We used only the ProMax calculated values of polytropic May 2006
efficiency (nP), compression ratio (P2/P1), and relative density (y). The heat capacity ratio (k) was estimated by equation 5: April 2006
March 2006
www.jmcampbell.com/tip-of-the-month/2011/11/compressor-calculations-rigorous-using-equation-of-state-vs-shortcut-method/ 3/7
05/08/2020 Compressor Calculations: Rigorous Using Equation of State vs Shortcut Method | Campbell Tip of the Month
February 2006
January 2006
The polytropic exponent (n) was estimated by equation 6.
December 2005
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
The isentropic (adiabatic) efficiency () was estimated by equation 7.
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
Complete Archives
Free Subscription
Topics
The results for this method are presented in the short-2 columns of Table 2. The calculated discharge temperature by
equation 4A (isentropic path) was exactly the same as by equation 4B (polytropic). Note the short-2 results (discharge
Gas Processing
temperature, adiabatic and polytropic heads and power) are deviated from the SRK values. Mechanical
The results in Table 2 indicate that an increase of 2.2% in k (from 1.224 to 1.251) results in power increase of 1.42%. The Pipeline
polytropic exponent (n) increased by 3% and isentropic efficiency ( ) decreased by 0.5 %. The difference in the actual Process Facilities
discharge temperatures of the SRK and short-2 values is 17.5 ˚F (9.7˚C).
Process Safety
With the exception of actual discharge temperature, these differences between the SRK and short-2 methods results for
facilities calculations and planning purposes are negligible. Note that the accuracy of the shortcut method is dependent on Refining
the values of k and n. In Short-1 method in which we used the k and n values from the SRK method the results were
identical to those of SRK method. Reliability Engineering
To learn more about similar cases and how to minimize operational problems, we suggest attending the John M. Campbell Supply Chain
courses; G4 (Gas Conditioning and Processing), and G5 (Gas Conditioning and Processing-Special). Management
John M. Campbell Consulting (JMCC) offers consulting expertise on this subject and many others. For more information Uncategorized
about the services JMCC provides, visit our website at www.jmcampbellconsulting.com, or email your consulting needs
to [email protected].
Water and Corrosion
1. Maddox, R. N. and L. L. Lilly, “Gas conditioning and processing, Volume 3: Advanced Techniques and Register
Applications,” John M. Campbell and Company, 2nd Ed., Norman, Oklahoma, USA, 1990.
Log in
2. Campbell, J. M., “Gas Conditioning and Processing, Vol. 2, the Equipment Modules, 8th Ed., Campbell Petroleum
Series, Norman, Oklahoma, 2001 Entries RSS
3. Soave, G., Chem. Eng. Sci., Vol. 27, pp. 1197-1203, 1972.
4. Peng, D. Y., and Robinson, D. B., Ind. Eng. Chem. Fundam., Vol. 15, p. 59, 1976. Comments RSS
5. ProMax 3.2, Bryan Research and Engineering, Inc, Bryan, Texas, 2011.
WordPress.org
36 comments
« Previous post
Next Post »
Compressor
Could you please advise whether the values of ‘k’ used in the two methods were based on the Cv=Cp-R (Ideal
Gas) relationship or ‘real’ values of Cv calculated directly from the EoS? This can have a significant impact on the
www.jmcampbell.com/tip-of-the-month/2011/11/compressor-calculations-rigorous-using-equation-of-state-vs-shortcut-method/ 4/7
05/08/2020 Compressor Calculations: Rigorous Using Equation of State vs Shortcut Method | Campbell Tip of the Month
results, e.g. incorporating ‘real’ values of ‘k’ (from HYSYS) into the API equations for relief valve sizing can over-
estimate the capacity of a given orifice.
Joe,
1. What is the basis of eqn 5? Did you make a linear best fit in excel in between the dependent variable k and
independent variable y and arrived at the eqn.?
2. When heat capacity ratio (k) is meant, is it Cp/Cv or Cp/(Cp-R) (i.e., an ideal gas heat capacity ratio)?
Thanks,
Rahul Mukherjee
[email protected]
Rahul,
1. Equation 5 is purely empirical, based on typical natural gases that contain no substantial quantities of
non-hydrocarbons and whose relative density does not exceed one.
Dr Mahmood
I just want to calculate efficiency and head for air compressor having the several points of suction pressure vs
flowrate in m3/h. Please help..
Thank you
Please Sir,how do i find d expression for entropy for a soave-redlich kwong equation of state ?
6. Reza says:
June 21, 2012 at 6:08 am
Dear Mahmood:
One important question in my mind. How can one calculate discharge temperature in oil injected compressor in
Hysys or any other process software?
I have written a procedure for measurement flow of a CNG compressor in refueling station. Is it possible for me to
send the procedure for you to check if that is correct or not?
Thank you
Interesting Material. My question is about the change in calculations when applied to a stream of Acid Gas
containing CO2/H2S with trace of Hydrocarbons?
How about the case with Flue gas compression?
www.jmcampbell.com/tip-of-the-month/2011/11/compressor-calculations-rigorous-using-equation-of-state-vs-shortcut-method/ 5/7
05/08/2020 Compressor Calculations: Rigorous Using Equation of State vs Shortcut Method | Campbell Tip of the Month
11. Helmuth says:
November 11, 2014 at 11:30 am
Hi Doc,thanks for the nice educating post.My question is;Are equations 2A,2B,3A,3B,4A and 4B applicable to real
gases?
Dr. Thanks for the nice writeup. How do we estimate the k value and gamma value when we inject known
volumetric flows of wash oil or water to cracked gas compressor stages to mitigate fouling due to polymerization?.
This has been the challenge. Please help.
Thanks
Venkat
hello
i wonder if anyone can help me , i need to find the adiabatic efficiency of a compressor we are prototyping. i am by
no means a mathematician and all these equations are really confusing me. if someone could explain to me what
all the letters stood for it would be a great help
many thanks
Adamson:
Method 1:
1. Knowing gas molecular weight (MW) estimate, gas relative density or Specific Gravity by SG=MW/29
2. Plug in SG (the Greek letter gamma) into equation 5 to estimate k (ratio of specific heats at the ideal gas
conditions).
3. Knowing compressor polytropic efficiency provided by the vendor calculate n by equation 6 (the 2nd one on the
right hand side. n= polytropic exponent.
4. Use equation 7 to estimate the adiabatic efficiency (the Greek letter, mu). P1 and P2 are the suction and
discharge pressures, respectively.
Note: All T’s and P’s are absolute value
If the polytropic efficiency is not available, one can use use the following procedure for a working compressor:
Method 2:
1. Measure suction pressure (P1), suction temperature (T1), and discharge pressure (P2), discharge temperature
(T2).
2. Calculate compression ratio = R = P2/P1
3. Raise compression ratio to power of (k-1)/k or CR=(P2/P1)^[(k-1)/k]
4. Estimate adiabatic efficiency = T1(CR-1)/(T2-T1). This rearrangement of equation 4A.
Note: All T’s and P’s are absolute value
Method 3:
1. Measure suction pressure (P1), suction temperature (T1), and discharge pressure (P2), discharge temperature
(T2).
2. Use a Pressure-Enthalpy-diagram for your gas or a computer program to calculate: Suction enthalpy (H1) at P1
and T1, discharge enthalpy H2 at P2 and T2, discharge isentropic enthalpy H2ise.
3. Estimate adiabatic (isentropic) efficiency by:
Adiabatic efficiency = (H2ise – H1)/(H2-H1)
The detail of this topic is covered in our G4 (Gas Processing and Conditioning) course.
I hope this helps.
Dear Sir,
Can you please tell me any relation between Steam Enthalpy and RPM of a Steam Turbine. How they affect each
other?
DreamProxies.com – least expensive top-notch private proxies with 50% low cost! Professional quality,
Unrestricted proxies, Very speed along with Cheapest price ranges – simply $0.25 for every proxy! Finest
individual proxies just from DreamProxies.com
Merely wanna tell that this is very useful, Thanks for taking your time to write this.
Hello sir,
Can the polytropic efficiency of compression be greater than unity,when n is less than k (i.e 1<n<k).
since using the polytropic efficience [(k-1)/k]/[(n-1)/n] will be greater than 1.
www.jmcampbell.com/tip-of-the-month/2011/11/compressor-calculations-rigorous-using-equation-of-state-vs-shortcut-method/ 6/7
05/08/2020 Compressor Calculations: Rigorous Using Equation of State vs Shortcut Method | Campbell Tip of the Month
DreamProxies.com — least expensive top-notch private proxies with 50% low cost! Elite quality, Limitless proxies,
Very speed and Cheapest prices : only $0.25 for each proxy! Best non-public proxies just on DreamProxies.com
Guys who of you play Pokemon GO? Incredible game, finally Lickitung has been caught
using pokebusterbot. With this bot you can catch pokemons on autopilot!
how should calculate polytropic efficiency of single stage compressor with suction and discharge pressure and
temperature and gas composition
Panos says:
January 1, 2017 at 4:44 pm
https://www.degruyter.com/view/j/tjj.ahead-of-print/tjj-2016-0029/tjj-2016-0029.xml
For low pressures and relatively high temperatures, you can also use the ideal gas law instead of cubic
equations of state ..
Where is the use of compressibility factor while calculating discharge temp T2 in adiabatic compression for non-
ideal gas?
Dr. Mahmood,
I had put up a query about how to use compressibility factor for calculating adiabatic discharge
temperature? Whenever z defers significantly from 1 for example for ethylene at pressure of 100 bar, how
to use Z for calculating adiabatic discharge temperature. Request help.
What is the formula to calculate compressor number? if there is given compression rartio or somethimg like that.
I am looking for a vendor that publishes isentropic compressor efficiencies as a sales point…akin to COP for a
refrigerator. Can you provide vendor that does such? Nice web page, thanks.
Would these equation work for an oil injected twin rotary screw compressor?
Calculate the power required to overcome the internal losses in an electrically driven turbo compressor operating
under the following conditions: Suction volume : 1140 m^2/min Temperature : 27 ˚C Pressure : 0.85bar (abs)
Deliver temperature : 104 ˚C Pressure : 6.5bar (abs) Motor load : 5850 w
Work done = n/( n-1)(P_2 V_2-P_1 V_1)
Interesting forum
www.jmcampbell.com/tip-of-the-month/2011/11/compressor-calculations-rigorous-using-equation-of-state-vs-shortcut-method/ 7/7