PROYECTO COZUMEL Fotovoltaica
PROYECTO COZUMEL Fotovoltaica
PROYECTO COZUMEL Fotovoltaica
Contents
List of tables........................................................................................................................ ii
List of figures....................................................................................................................... ii
Abstract............................................................................................................................... iii
1. Introduction.................................................................................................................. 1
1.1 Energy system security.........................................................................................1
1.2 Actual situation of the energy system supply in Mexico.........................................1
1.3 Project challenges.................................................................................................4
1.4 Project perspective................................................................................................5
1.5 Structure of the report...........................................................................................6
2. Plant Location.............................................................................................................. 7
2.1 Justification of geographical location.....................................................................7
2.2 Map of the location..............................................................................................10
3. Design........................................................................................................................ 11
3.1 Energy Demand..................................................................................................11
3.2 Weather................................................................................................................... 11
3.3 Geology................................................................................................................... 12
3.4 Legal, environmental, and social framework............................................................13
3.5 Design objectives, assumptions, and specifications of the project......................14
3.5.1 Wind farm.......................................................................................................... 14
3.5.2 Solar farm.......................................................................................................... 15
3.5.3 Tesla Powerpack...............................................................................................15
3.6 Market study.......................................................................................................15
3.7 Business Model...................................................................................................18
3.7.1 Economic Viability...........................................................................................18
3.7.2 Founding Strategy.................................................................................................22
3.8 Hybrid electrical supply of the Cozumel island....................................................23
3.9 Hybrid electrical supply of the Cozumel island configuration alternatives............24
3.10 Comparison of alternatives..................................................................................26
3.10.1 Solar Farm...................................................................................................26
3.10.2 Wind Farm...................................................................................................27
3.11 Mass and energy balance...................................................................................28
4 Conclusion.................................................................................................................28
6.Bibliography................................................................................................................... 30
i
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
4 Annexes..................................................................................................................... 31
4.1 Gantt Chart......................................................................................................... 31
4.2 Other relevant side information...........................................................................31
List of tables
Table 1. Business Model CANVAS. (The authors)...................................................................18
Table 2. Economic Viability Farm 1 (Energy,2020)..................................................................18
Table 3.Economic Viability Farm 2 (Gonzalez,2017)...............................................................20
Table 4. Founding Strategy. (The authors)................................................................................22
Table 5. Selection of equipment solar plant. (The authors).....................................................27
Table 6. Selection of equipment wind farm. (The authors)......................................................27
List of figures
Figure 1. Map of SEN 9 regions. (PRODESEN, 2018)........................................................2
Figure 2. Diagram of SEN "Peninsular" region. (PRODESEN, 2018)..................................2
Figure 3.Diagram of the TL that supply Cozumel. (PRODESEN, 2018)..............................3
Figure 4. Energy System of HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel. (The authors)............................5
Figure 5. Workflow Diagram. (The authors).........................................................................6
Figure 6. Map of Solar energy potential. (AZEL, 2020)........................................................7
Figure 7. Map of Wind Energy potential of Cozumel Island. (AZEL, 2020)..........................7
Figure 8. Map of Urban Biomass Energy potential of Cozumel Island (green). (AZEL,
2020)................................................................................................................................... 8
Figure 9. Maps of incidence of Hurricanes from face 1 to 5. (AZEL, 2020)..........................8
Figure 10. Location of the project. (AZEL, 2020).................................................................9
Figure 11. Map of the principal roads in Cozumel. (AZEL, 2020)......................................10
Figure 12. Cozumel Island's maximum power demand. (Mendoza, 2016)........................11
Figure 13. Geomorphology of the island. (MPG Cozumel, 2012)......................................12
Figure 14. Natural protected areas (red), Federal (pink), RAMSAR areas (purple). (AZEL,
2020)................................................................................................................................. 13
Figure 15. Graphic of Electrical demand 2000 to 2050. (The authors)..............................16
Figure 16. Graphic of total pollutant emission of CO 2e (KTon) 2000 to 2050. (The authors)
.......................................................................................................................................... 17
Figure 17. Graphic of increasing cost in Electrical Centrals in SEN ("Peninsular" central
Examples). (PRODESEN, 2018).......................................................................................17
Figure 18. Horizontal Solar Radiation in Meta, Colombia. (IDEAM ATLAS,2020)..............19
Figure 19. Horizontal Solar Radiation in Cozumel (AZEL,2020)........................................19
Figure 20. Wind specifications in Cozumel (AZEL,2020)...................................................21
Figure 21. Wind specifications Libres,Puebla (AZEL,2020)...............................................22
Figure 22.Hybrid electric supply of the Cozumel Island. (The authors)..............................24
Figure 23. Process Synthesis Centralize System in the electrical substation. (The authors).
.......................................................................................................................................... 25
Figure 24. Process Synthesis, Independent solar farms. (The authors)............................26
Figure 25. Energy Balance of the HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel........................................28
Figure 26. 3D model scale of the HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel. (The authors).................29
ii
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
Abstract
HUNAB KU Hybrid Electric Supply System (HESS) is a project designed for the Cozumel
island.
Cozumel island is a well-known touristic place in the south east of Mexico for its beaches
and tropical landscapes.
With an energy consumption of 240 GWh/yr and a pick load of 45MWh/yr, the island
presents an electric problem. It has a lack of electric stability presenting blackouts of
250h/yr during the months of July to September, when there is an overload usually of
3000h/yr in the electric demand.
These blackouts do not only affect the tourism but also the habitants of Cozumel. This
added to the high prices of the energy that go from $68USD/MWh to $450USDMW/h, lead
to a poor energy system.
In order to provide clean, efficient, stable and low-cost energy, HUNAB KU HESS project
will use wind and solar energy to generate 40MW to the island with the support of a
powerpack system with a price of $68USDMW/h.
This project will not only ensure the energy in the island, but also will be able to reduce the
CO2 emissions from the energy generation by 52kTons/yr. The aim of this project is not
only to provide cleaner, cheaper, and more stable energy but also make the island self-
efficient.
Key words: Cozumel island; Solar energy; Wind energy; Clean energy
iii
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
1. Introduction
1.1 Energy system security
The energy transition is one of the most important aspects in the fight against climate
change, and in the energy security of communities, regions, and countries. However, the
proposed energy transition in developed countries does not necessarily apply to
underdeveloped countries, since they have different environmental, social, and economic
contexts. On the other hand, this does not mean that the energy transition is not
necessary, only that it is necessary to have a different approach and it is necessary to
apply evaluations and designs of congruent systems to the regions studied. Mexico is one
of the Latin American countries that has the third most potential for renewable
energy[ CITATION IRE20 \l 2058 ], since it has wind power with a potential of
70,000MW[ CITATION Reb20 \l 2058 ], solar with a potential of 25,000MW[ CITATION Jua19 \l
2058 ], geothermal with a potential of 10,000 MW[ CITATION Car10 \l 2058 ], biomass with a
potential of 3000 MW[ CITATION Pau14 \l 2058 ], hydro with a potential of 12,642
MW[ CITATION Izc17 \l 2058 ], and tidal with a potential of 7000 MW[ CITATION Uni20 \l 2058 ]
. Obtaining a tentative potential to exploit from 127.6 GW. Nevertheless, the current
government's approach, which is betting on re-enabling and rescuing the Mexican oil
industry, puts the development of renewable energies in a neglect situation. In addition,
the experience of renewable energies in Mexico has fallen into massive installations that
on certain occasions have lacked an approach to growth and coordination with the
Mexican electric power control centers. This phenomenon caused that in 15 th May of 2020
an adjustment1 had to be made to the regulations of the electric industry law and the
interconnection manuals, raising the standards and activities that generating plants and
large consumers must comply with[ CITATION DOF20 \l 2058 ]. Which are now responsible
for being in continuous coordination with CENACE2 and providing the technical information
related to the generation and consumption of energy. Recent events generate a more
difficult scenario for the development of renewable energies, but it does not mean that this
is something negative since the main objective of this change is to ensure the supply,
quality and viability of electricity supply in Mexico.
1
ACUERDO “por el que se emite la Política de Confiabilidad, Seguridad, Continuidad y Calidad en
el Sistema Eléctrico Nacional”.
2
Centro Nacional de Control de Energía, whose function is to exercise the Operational Control of
the National Electric System, Operation of the Wholesale Electricity Market, and guarantee
impartiality in access to the National Transmission Network
3
Sistema Eléctrico Nacional, integrated system that serves 128 million Mexicans, who live in two
million square kilometers, and which has reached 98.7% service coverage.
1/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
However, the most vulnerable region is the “Peninsular” region, which only has one main
distribution line, which generates overloads in the system, causing energy losses, low
quality of energy, and in extreme cases black outs. Apart from that, the “Peninsular” region
does not have the capacity to supply itself as the demand for energy is greater than the
generation capacity of the region, this can be observed in Figure 2. Diagram of SEN
"Peninsular" region. On the other hand, the main economic activity in this region is
tourism, so the demand for energy fluctuates depending on the intensity of tourists who
visit these areas, being the months of June to September the ones with more tourism in
that region[ CITATION Jav16 \l 2058 ]. Having an average annual consumption of 12,465
GW[ CITATION PRO18 \l 2058 ]. The areas furthest from the interconnections of the
“Peninsular” region to SEN are found in the Caribbean in which a group of islands are
found, the island of Cozumel is one of these.
2/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
The island of Cozumel has similar problems if we compare it with the “Peninsular” region,
however it is in a region that already has these problems at the SEN level, so the security
and quality of the supply is even more vulnerable (Figure 3.Diagram of the TL that supply
Cozumel.). Furthermore, the participation of renewable energy on the island is
imperceptible since the island's supply depends on a combined cycle (525MW) plant
located in Valladolid (172Km away from Cozumel Island) and on three “Turbogas” 4
generating plants (C.T.G Cozumel Plants and Chankanaab) two of this plant was an
installed power of 14MW and third one has a power of 30 MW located in Cozumel, two of
which is only used during power peaks (14MW) and the other in the event of a supply cut
from the SEN “Peninsular” region caused by an overload of the system or a natural
disaster[ CITATION PRO18 \l 2058 ].
The prevailing overloads in the Cancun area occur in a range of 3000h/year that exceed
the transmission limit of the TL (825MWh / h). This phenomenon causes low-efficiency and
high-cost auxiliary plants to operate to level the synchronization of loads. In cases of
blackout, there are 250h/year in which 80MW load effects are observed, which cannot be
supplied[ CITATION PRO18 \l 2058 ].
4
Motor turbomachine, the working fluid of which is a gas.
3/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
kTons CO2e using two renewable energy sources, wind and solar and a smart grid
monitoring system to interconnect the generation farms with the Cozumel load bus. The
challenges that arise to achieve this objective lie in knowing the potential of the different
types of renewable energy that exist on the island, using as a reference that the
generation of energy must be interconnected with the Transmission Lines (TL) of
Cozumel. In addition, to know what the technical state of the electrical supply of the island
of Cozumel and its consumption graphs is, in addition to the configuration of the TL of
Cozumel with the components of power systems. Also, we need to know the economic
viability of the project which will be investigated using as a reference the price fluctuations
of the MEM and the consumption curves of the island of Cozumel.
4/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
Enriomenta l
regulations Environmental System Social System
Energy demand
Energy Law: Reduce costs
Reduction
Resurces Hunab Ku HESS Cenace
CO2e e missions Solar Costs:
Wind Cozumel -MEM
MEM
Regulations SEN
Smartgrid
5/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
START
YES
YES Generate Alternatives Screen For Feasibility DONE
Approved
Find Place
Iterate NO
Approved APPROVED
YES
NO
Define: costumers.
Define GO BACK TO
Market study Preducts/services CORRECT THE
Bounderies PROCESS SYNTHESIS TECNOLOGY
Suppliers.
SPECIFIC LOOP
PROCESS YES
Screen For
NO Viable UBICATION
Feasibility
YES
YES YES
PLANT/S
NO CONFIGURATIONS DOCUMENT
CANVAS
BUSINESS MODEL
PLANT/S
INSTALATION
NO APPROVED APPROVED
NO
On this report the main topics to be addressed will be the plants location in which all the
advantages, disadvantages and the justification of the place´s selection will be explained
including its energy potential and access to the zone. The design of the project including
market study, business model, design objectives, specifications and assumptions, relevant
data about the zone like the climate, demography, ecological, social, and legal
frameworks.
Alternatives of the project will be also presented analyzing different technologies and
configurations available for the project.
Finally, the conclusion where the main results will be analyzed along with future work that
can be done to continue the improvement of the project.
2. Plant Location
2.1 Justification of geographical location
For this project, the Cozumel island has been chosen. It is located 23km east of Playa del
Carmen and it is part of the Quintana Roo state. The population of Cozumel island is 86
415 habitants. The island has three potential renewables energies, the first one is the solar
6/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
energy with a solar potential of (5500-5749) Wh/m2 per day as an average of whole year, it
shown in Figure 6. The second one is the wind energy with the intensity of (6-7.5) m/s as
shown in Figure 7. Third one is urban biomass with the potential of 4.02-63.01TJ/a shown
in Figure 8.
7/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
Figure 8. Map of Urban Biomass Energy potential of Cozumel Island (green). (AZEL, 2020).
The climate of the island is tropical, hot humid, with abundant rains in summer.
The average temperature of the coldest month (January) is of 23.2 °C (74 °F), that of the
warmest month (August) is of 28.2 °C (83 °F). On average, there are around
2,510 sunshine hours per year which is nearly 7.5 hours per day. The average hourly wind
speed in Cozumel experiences mild seasonal variation over the course of the year.
The windier part of the year lasts for 7.9 months, from October 20 to June 17, with average
wind speeds of more than 8.2 miles per hour. The windiest day of the year is March 15,
with an average hourly wind speed of 9.3 miles per hour. The calmer time of year lasts
for 4.1 months, from June 17 to October 20. The calmest day of the year is August 25, with
an average hourly wind speed of 7.0 miles per hour. From June to November (but with a
higher probability from August to October), there is the risk of hurricanes the Figure 9,
describes the different intensity phases of hurricanes. (Cozumel Weather Atlas, 2020)
8/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
The access to the island is a criterion that was taken into consideration for the planning of
this project. The access to the island is by plane or by ferry from Playa del Carmen. As for
the roads that already exist inside the island, they surround the south and center part of it
as Figure 11 shows.
The advantage of having the roads already makes the project economic and
environmental viable because there will be no need to invest on the access to the wind
and solar farm from its construction until it starts up and the negative impact that the
construction of roads may involve will not be made.
9/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
3. Design
3.1 Energy Demand
The activity of electricity consumption on the island of Cozumel varies according to the
time of year, with high consumption seasons being the months of July to September the
highest for energy demand with a maximum ceiling of 45 MW of load demand. However,
the average consumption of the island is around 27 MW of load[ CITATION Jav16 \l 2058 ].
This can be seen in the following Figure 12. Cozumel Island's maximum power demand.
10/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
With a population of 86 415 habitants (INEGI, 2015), the island is one of the most popular
truistic locations of Mexico, therefore, Figure 12 shows, the hotter months of the year (as
mentioned on chapter 3) in Cozumel (from May to August), according to the Secretaría de
Turismo (2013), are also the ones when they receive more tourists. The increase of people
on the island added to the use of electricity for example, on air conditioners due to the hot
and humid climate, elevates the power demand. On these cases, the probability of having
an overload increase.
3.2 Weather
The weather plays an important role when designing the plant considering the main energy
resources are the sun and wind.
According to the Köppen classification the climate is a Am(f) hot humid with rain during
summer (Gobierno de Cozumel, 2011). As it was already mentioned in Chapter 3: Plants
location, the island has a high wind potential (6-7.5 m/s), but it is located on a zone where
hurricanes can take place from June to November. Therefore, this weather condition is
being considered on the selection of the wind turbines in order to avoid the damage or loss
of any of them.
On the other hand, for the solar farm, considering Cozumel island has on average 7.5
sunshine hours per day and an energy potential of 5500-5749 Wh/m 2 (Chapter 3). These
weather conditions make the use of solar panels viable, considering a panel needs in
average 5 hours of sun a day (SOLEN, 2019).
3.3 Geology
The geology of the island is similar to the one found in the Yucatan´s Peninsula, being the
limestone the most abundant rock on the island. According to the Mohs´ scale, it has a
hardness of 3 being 1 the softest and 10 the hardest (Moreno e Ibáñez, s.f.).
11/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
Besides the geology of the island another aspect is the geomorphology. In this case, a
previous study states that Cozumel is part of the geomorphological unit of the Caribbean
plains, being a practically flat relief reaching coasts, in its central part it barely exceeds 20
meters above sea level (MPG Cozumel, 2012).
Within the island, five large geomorphological units can be distinguished:
Sandy laces
Sandy beaches
Rocky low shore
Plains in the central area of the island
Low flood plains
Slightly sloping transitional plains into the central plain and low-lying floodplains.
As Figure 13 shows, the location of the project corresponds to plains.
The information about the geology and geomorphology supports the wind and solar farm
project because the ground it is not rocky, therefore the perforations and constructions
made on the island will not require extra work from heavy machinery. Also, the fact that the
location is plain makes the construction of the farm easier thus it is not necessary to invest
much time nor money on making the terrain even.
12/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
Figure 14. Natural protected areas (red), Federal (pink), RAMSAR areas (purple). (AZEL, 2020)
Although the wind and solar farm will not be built on the natural reserved area it is
important to follow the law. In order to do that, a permission will be needed from CONANP
(Comisión de Áreas Naturales Protegidas) and SEMARNAT. Also, a municipal permission
for construction is needed along with an environmental feasibility.
For the wind farm and the solar farm, a permission from SENER is also needed for the
construction of high voltage lines, connection to the network, an authorization to generate
electricity and a license to participate as a generator from the MEM (Susena, 2013).
Once all the permissions are given, the principal NOMs (Normas Oficiales Mexicanas) that
will be considered for this project are the following.
For the environmental aspect, the NOM-059-SEMARNAT-2010. On this NOM the main
purpose is the conservation of the flora and wildlife on the island. Then there is NOM-138-
SEMARNAT/SSA1-2012 which will be considered to avoid contamination in the island.
The NOM-045-SEMARNAT-2017, goes along with NOM-041-SEMARNAT-2015, being
considered for the transport of the material. All the vehicles will be checked prior to its use
and will be also checked during the time they are being use for the project.
Then for the electrical substation, the NOMs that will be considered are NOM-002-SEDE-
2010, before selecting the transformers, this NOM will be verified in order to meet all the
requirements. There is also NOM-001-SEDE-2012, in this one all the technical
specifications of the electrical installation can be found.
Because the wind turbines generate noise, the NOM-081-SEMARNAT-1994 specifies all
the maximum noise data that must be considered so the wind farm does not affect the
people nor wildlife. Also, for the workers the NOM-011-STPS-2001 is about all the security
conditions the workers need to have when working on a noisy place.
Also, the NOM-009-STPS-Vigente.This NOM mentions all the security measures when
working on high places, this applies to the wind farm.
13/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
Continuing with some of the NOMs that are obligatory to follow in Mexico NOM-017-STPS-
2008, this NOM is about the personal protection equipment that will be needed. There is
also NOM-002-STPS-2010, which is about the prevention and protection in case of a fire.
For the solar farm, all the NOMs mentioned above will be also considered except the
NOM-081-SEMARNAT-1994 and NOM-009-STPS-Vigente.
14/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
As it was already mentioned, it is planned to install nine wind turbines. The number of
turbines was selected not only to fulfill half of the energy demand on the island but to have
an extra energy supply of 3MW in case one wind turbine gets damaged or needs
maintenance.
The wind farm will occupy 4.5 hectares, the number of hectares were selected taking into
consideration the nine turbines, the diameter of each one that is 114m and a distance
between each wind turbine of 1 km.
5
SENER: “Secretaria de Energia” It is the office of the federal executive power in charge of the
administration and regulation of the country's energy resources.
6
The Global Bank With 189 member countries, staff from more than 170 countries, and offices in
over 130 locations, the World Bank Group is a unique global partnership: five institutions working for
sustainable solutions that reduce poverty and build shared prosperity in developing countries.
7
ESMAP is a partnership between the World Bank and 18 partners to help low and middle-income
countries reduce poverty and boost growth through sustainable energy solutions.
15/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
Cozumel. The third source is the PRODESEN 2019-2033 what is the program for the
development of the national electrical system.
It´s estimated that the electricity demand of the island of Cozumel will increase annual
growth rate of 4.34% (2000-2050) according to the economic growth and the increase in
tourism in the area this can be seen in Figure 15. Graphic of Electrical demand 2000 to
2050[ CITATION Jav16 \l 2058 ].
1200
Electrcal Demand GWh
1000
800
600
400
200
0
1990 2000 2010 2020 2030 2040 2050 2060
Year
In addition, it was found that CO2e emotions will continue to increase at annual rate of
7.77% between 2000 and 2050, this can be observed in the Figure 16. Graphic of total
pollutant emission of CO2e (KTon) 2000 to 2050. As mentioned above, the safety and
quality of the supply in the “Peninsular” region is in a state of emergency, for this reason
the final generation costs of $USD/GWh are up to 7 times higher than in the other sectors
of the SEN in the MEM [ CITATION PRO18 \l 2058 ]. For this, a graph has been found that
shows the increase and the difference in the cost of $ USD / GWh that each plant has in
SEN and thy revel the specific central that operates in Cancún zone (Figure 16. Graphic of
total pollutant emission of CO2e (KTon) 2000 to 2050.).
8
TRACE The Tool for Rapid Assessment of City Energy (TRACE) is a decision-support system
designed to help cities quickly identify and harness EE opportunities.
16/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
Figure 16. Graphic of total pollutant emission of CO2e (KTon) 2000 to 2050. (The authors)
Figure 17. Graphic of increasing cost in Electrical Centrals in SEN ("Peninsular" central Examples).
(PRODESEN, 2018)
17/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
Key Partne rs Key Activitie s Value Propositions Custome r Relat ionships Custome r s egments
Tec hnology
Sma rt Grid Mana gment the Sma rt grid Provide e nergy se curity to - Sma rt grid CFE
ETAP - Tec hnica l s pe cs (Qua lity the is la nd of Cozume l us ing -High s ecurity supply.
Bus ines s of the cha rge s yste m) rena wa ble e nergies a nd a -High quality Efficie ncy.
- Inves tors - Meteorologica l bac k up stora ge s ystem . - Low cost of ene rgy
-85 % The Global Ba nk. conditions. - Envirom entaly
-15 % Priva t e inves tors . - Economical spec s (Offe r res ponsible .
Gove rnme nt and s oc ial a nd dema nd MEM) - Ba ck up s ys te m.
res ponsibilities - Ge nerator Pla n (Type C)
- SENER
- CFE Key Re suorces Channels
- CENACE
- MEM Wind re surces CFE
-SMN Sola r res urce s - MEM
Ke y suppliers Stora ge bac k up sys t em - CENACE
- SIEMENS GAMESA Big da ta of the sys tem
- TESLA Méxic o Meteorologica l Ce nte r
- SHARP Mé xico
18/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
To calculate the economic viability of Farm 1, a solar project that aims to generate the
same amount of MWh that is wanted to achieve in this project was taken as a reference,
said solar farm is located in the eastern plains of Colombia and not in Mexico , due to the
fact that a project with viable economic data was not achieved within the national territory,
that is why it was decided to use a Colombian project, located in the Meta municipality
since it not only has similar technical characteristics but also the horizontal solar irradiation
on This area is very similar to that of the island of Cozumel, which is why it was decided to
collect the technical-economic data to blend it with ours.
As can be seen, the general radiation of the Meta municipality is approximately 5-5.5
KWh/m2, which is very similar to the different radiations per month that the island of
Cozumel has, having a general average horizontal solar radiation of 5.45 KWh/m 2 , making
it possible for us to take this foreign project as a reference.
19/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
TESLA Megapack(3MW)
Installed capacity 270MWh
Power Capacity (MW) 27
Number modules 90
Total, Investment (USD) 54,000,000
With respect to tables 2, 3 and 4, the budgets and established profits are calculated based
on 68 USD per MWh. For the case of Table 2, the generation calculations are taken based
on 8 hours of average sun per day and for Table 3, with 12 hours of potential wind per day.
Tables 2 and 3 have a budget against natural or industrial disasters of 50% of the value of
each farm (percentage agreed by consensus) with which it will be dealt with in the event of
unforeseen claims. This fund, which represents almost 22,000,000 USD, will be created
from an initial 5,000,000 USD which will be submitted to an investment fund of 7% with
monthly capitalization, in order to obtain the desired budget in 22 months.
Table 5.Investment Fund for Disaster Budget. (The authors).
20/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
8,029,299 7
8,591,349 8
9,192,743 9
9,836,235 10
10,524,771 11
11,261,504 12
12,049,809 13
12,893,295 14
13,795,834 15
14,761,542 16
15,794,849 17
16,900,488 18
18,083,522 19
19,349,368 20
20,703,823 21
22,153,090 22
To obtain data from Farm 2, a Mexican project was sought that would use the same
2.6MW wind turbines that we are proposing for our project, this project on which we rely is
much more ambitious and aims to supply the electricity demand of a recognized brewery
in the country, the location of the model project is in the municipality of Libres, Puebla.
As can be seen in the figures below, the wind characteristics in both places are very
similar, although Cozumel, as it is at sea level, will always receive higher wind speeds, but
for the economic purposes that are needed, this project works at perfect for collecting this
kind of data.
21/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
FOUNDING STRATEGY
FINANCIN QUANTIF INTERES SINGLE ANNUAL PAYBAC
G% Y (USD) T PAYMEN PAYMEN K
RATE(%) T (USD) T FOR 14 PERIOD
YEARS (YEARS)
(USD)
GREEN 85 87,406,39 3.5 3,059,223 At the
BONDS 9 end of
the work
PRIVATE 15 15,424,65 15 2,313,698 6.7
INVESTM 8
ET
Investor 3 3,084,931 3 462,739 6.7
#1
Investor 3 3,084,931 3 462,739 6.7
#2
Investor 3 3,084,931 3 462,739 6.7
#3
Investor 3 3,084,931 462,739 6.7
#4 3
Investor 3 3,084,931 3 462, 6.7
#5 739
22/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
The total investment assumes the investment price of the Tesla Powerpacks, the
investment cost of Farm 1 and 2 (not counting the disaster budget) and the 5,000,000
USD needed to grow the investment fund.
The strategy selected to finance the two energy farms will consist of the distribution of
percentages under two main schemes: The first, called "Green Bonds" which are credit
titles issued by public or private institutions that are qualified to handle them, that is, they
are liquid and fixed-income assets that seek to finance sustainable green projects to
ultimately return the return on their investment [ CITATION Her15 \l 2058 ]. The purposes that
can be given to these bonds can be public or private, that is, a state can issue green
bonds as a strategy to achieve the nation's energy transition objectives, supporting with
resources projects that contribute to Energy. Country mix. And, on the other hand, the
private financier only seeks a real economic interest, to make a capital investment based
on interest and royalties.
This project seeks to finance 85% of the total investment through a “Bono Verde
Soberano” from the Secretary of Finance and Public Credit of the Mexican state, where we
will obtain a total of 87,406,399 USD with an approximate interest rate of 3.5% [ CITATION
Gia19 \l 2058 ]. The interest rate must be paid upon completion of the work and the
borrowed money must be justified month after month to the Secretary of the Treasury on
its use and investment. Finally, the remaining 15% will be obtained from private investors,
with which it is expected to obtain 15,424,658 USD from 5 capital contributors, with whom
an annual economic remuneration for 14 years of 15% will be agreed (distributed among
the 5 investors ) on the estimated annual income of the project that represents 10,071,398
USD, that is, for an investment of 3,084,931 USD after 14 years they will have obtained a
return of two times the invested value and managing to recover their money in
approximately 6.7 years after the implementation of the project.
23/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
O.C
C.F
Cozumel
Storage energy
POWER Electrical ACc (34.5kV) Electrical Grid
system SMARTGRID P
SYSTEMS P Subestation Load: 27MW-
1GWh- 45MW
45MW
M&C
G.F
M&C
C.F
G.P
O.P
M&C
24/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
M&C
Operative conditions
MONITORING &
Generation profiles M&C
CONTROL CENTER
5500-5749 Wh/m2
POWER
Solar panels DCc SMARTGRID S
SYSTEMS S
M&C
Correction Factors
ACc
ACc
Electrical Cozumel
ACc (34.5kV)
Subestation Electrical Grid
Correction factors
POWER
Wind Turbines ACc SMARTGRID W
SYSTEMS W
8-10.5m/s
M&C
Generation profiles
Operative conditions M&C
M&C
ACc
ACc
ACc
Figure 23. Process Synthesis Centralize System in the electrical substation. (The authors).
The third configuration is the independent system. In this system the wind farm and the
storage system are separated but connected in the same node (electrical substation), but
the solar plant can be separated in parts and can be installed in the roof of the biggest
buildings and free areas in Cozumel island and each solar arrangement will have a
storage system. Each Building would be a G.D and can sell the excess of electricity to the
CFE and consume electricity. The solar plans will have an installed power no greater than
0.5 MW in order to enter in the schemes of “New Net Metering” 9. The monitoring and
control of the solar system will be made by the control center. This process synthesis can
b observe in the next Figure 24.
9
It is part of the three low-power interconnection schemes for G.D less than 0.5MW, precedent in
the CRE regulations [ CITATION Jon18 \l 2058 ]
25/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
M&C
Correction factors
MONITORING &
POWER Big data base
Wind Turbines ACc SMARTGRID W CONTROL CENTER
SYSTEMS W
8-10.5m/s
Generation profiles
Operative conditions M&C
M&C
ACc
ACc Electrical Cozumel
ACc (34.5kV)
Subestation Electrical Grid
DCc ACc
M&C
M&C M&C
ACc
Operative conditions
M&C
Generation profiles
5500-5749 Wh/m2
Correction Factors ACc
M&C
26/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
27/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
28/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
Also is present the power curve of the wind turbine with the change of wind speed in the next
Figure 25.Datasheet of SG 2.1-114 Power Curve (Siemens Gamesa).
10
Wind clases defned by an International Electotechnical Commissions Stardard (IEC 61400-1) IEC
II 5o years gust 59.5m/s.
29/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
30/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
G.P
Solar panels
58.4GWeh/yr POWER
DCc SMARTGRID S
5500-5749 Wh/m2 SYSTEMS S
2920h/yr M&C
M&C
C.F
O.C Acc
C.F 58.4GWh/yr
Cozumel
Storage energy ACc (34.5kV)
POWER Acc Electrical Electrical Grid
system SMARTGRID P 160.9Wh/yr
SYSTEMS P 160.9gWh/yr Subestation Load: 27MW-
1GWh- 45MW 20-45MW
45MW
M&C
G.F ACc
102.5GWh/yr
M&C
C.F
Wind Turbines
102.5G Wh/yr POWER
ACc SMARTGRID W
8-10.5m/s SYSTEMS W
4380h/yr
G.P
O.P
M&C
Plant Layout
For this project, the ISO certification will be applied considering the diagram shown on Figure 27.
Iso 50001 diagram application
31/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
-Energy
- Maps of Ducument
efficiency of -EnPIs
Activities. Energy -Table of
the systems E.B*system
- Chain Policy O&T
-E.B. -SEUs
comand ISO 50001
1- General requirements
Scope:
- Wind and Solar Farm. 2-Managment 3-Energy Policy 4-Energy Planning
- Megapack. responsibility Energy consumption of
- Control center. TopMang: Improve the operative the system.
Wind team: efficiency of the systems SEUs: Action plans
- Maintenance labors.
Solar Team: of electricity generation - Wind turbines.
Boundaries: Hunab Ku HESS Megapack Team: and maximize the - Megapack.
plant. Control center Team: storage of energy. - Control Center.
- Energy-
Efficiency - Energy
Check List -E.B Communications Training Team
- Change in Channels matrix plan - Energy
EnPIs Champion
General requirement
Breve description del HESS
Provide 40MW/h to Cozumel locality with a solar and wind farm along with a Tesla power package.
Management responsibility
In order to divide the responsibilities of the project, there will be a strategic council which will be
formed by four main teams: wind team, solar team, megapack team and control center team.
The wind team will be in charge of the wind farm and therefore, responsible of all the activities
related to the wind turbines going from performance to maintenance.
The solar team will be in charge of the solar farm, taking part on the solar panels´ supervision.
The megapack team will take care of the backup while the control center team will be in the
control center all the time attending all the needs of the plant in general.
Because someone has to supervise all of the teams, a top manager will be selected along with a
manager for each team.
32/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
Energy Policy
Stablish a stable electrical supply to the island of Cozumel with renewable energy and conserve the integrity
and the longevity of the plant. Improving with the operative efficiency of the systems of electricity
generation and maximize the storage of energy.
NOMS
NMX
For the project, the NOMs (Normas Oficiales Mexicanas) that will be considered for this
project are the following.
For the environmental aspect, the NOM-059-SEMARNAT-2010. On this NOM the main
purpose is the conservation of the flora and wildlife on the island. Then there is NOM-138-
SEMARNAT/SSA1-2012 which will be considered to avoid contamination in the island.
The NOM-045-SEMARNAT-2017, goes along with NOM-041-SEMARNAT-2015, being
considered for the transport of the material. All the vehicles will be checked prior to its use
and will be also checked during the time they are being use for the project.
Then for the electrical substation, the NOMs that will be considered are NOM-002-SEDE-
2010, before selecting the transformers, this NOM will be verified in order to meet all the
requirements. There is also NOM-001-SEDE-2012, in this one all the technical
specifications of the electrical installation can be found.
Because the wind turbines generate noise, the NOM-081-SEMARNAT-1994 specifies all
the maximum noise data that must be considered so the wind farm does not affect the
people nor wildlife. Also, for the workers the NOM-011-STPS-2001 is about all the security
conditions the workers need to have when working on a noisy place.
Also, the NOM-009-STPS-Vigente.This NOM mentions all the security measures when
working on high places, this applies to the wind farm.
Continuing with some of the NOMs that are obligatory to follow in Mexico NOM-017-STPS-
2008, this NOM is about the personal protection equipment that will be needed. There is
also NOM-002-STPS-2010, which is about the prevention and protection in case of a fire.
For the solar farm, all the NOMs mentioned above will be also considered except the
NOM-081-SEMARNAT-1994 and NOM-009-STPS-Vigente.
Energy Planning
SEUs
- Wind Turbines: orientation of the edge of attack and rotation of the blades.
- Clean Solar panels.
- Megapack: Refrigeration.
- Control Center refrigeration, computer equipment and illumination:
33/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
Objectives
- Improve the interaction between the generator plants the storage system and the
Cozumel demand in order to maximize the efficiency of Hunan Ku HESS.
- Maximize the energy storage in the Megapack to have a biggest reserve for eventualities.
- Record, process analyze, the data of the Hunab Ku HESS 24/365/yr.
o Weather conditions.
o Generate conditions of wind and solar plants.
o Energy demand of Cozumel.
o Megapack storage conditions capacity.
Targets
- Elevate the time of 800 hours of a stable system, providing a power supply of 40MW(+-5MW).
- Have the always 50% of the storage capacity and have a 100% near to hours of not energy
generation.
Actions Plants
- Energy Balance of the Energy (EB) systems and report them (day cuts, and week reports).
- Electric cars and share ride with workers, (control charge of the cars).
- Thermal buildings, Close doors and windows.
- Turn off equipment and lights.
- Respect the schedules.
- Elaborate check list.
34/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
Checking Performance
- Evaluate the weekly reports of the EB and compare the EnPIs.
- Identify the critical success factors CSFs.
Management Review
- Weeky meeting with the energy team and the energy champion.
- Energy team audit (mensual).
- Energy champion Audit (spontaneous).
- Feedback.
o Correction to the O&T or add new ones.
4 Conclusion
The main goal was to supply electricity by increasing the quality and energy security for
Cozumel island. Current electric consumption of the island was 240 (GWh/yr) with the
carbon emissions of 125 (MtonCO2e). Our objective is intended to generate 102 GWh/yr to
reduce 52 kTons CO2e using two renewable energy sources, wind and solar and a smart
grid monitoring system to interconnect the generation farms with the Cozumel load bus.
Cozumel island is abundant in wind potential and the average wind intensity ranges
between (6-7) m/s with an estimated wind of 12 h/day. whereas the solar potential ranges
between (5500-5749) Wh/m2 with an estimation of 7.5 of sunshine per day.
Electric consumption demand varies mostly in the months of July to September which is
high like 45 MW of load demand. Other than that, on average the demand is 27 MW of
load. Considering an error factor of 30%, the result is 35.1 MWh, but to have a bigger
storage when the peak demand is presented, the energy the project will provide is 40MW.
The technology and size of the farms were decided to fulfill this energy demand of the
island. Therefore, the solar and wind farm will generate 40MW, 20MW each farm. The
area will take 55 hectares considering the wind farm will take 4.5
hectares, the powerpack 1 hectare and the solar farm 40 hectares.
An onshore wind turbine provided by SIEMENS GAMESA using the model SG 2.6 114 is
used in order to generate 20MW, nine turbines will be installed on the wind farm. On the
other hand, to provide the remaining 20MW, a solar farm will be built with 50,000 panels
provided by SHARP Mexico. For the backup system, a Tesla Powerpack was selected.
Each powerpack has a capacity of 3MWh, therefore, 90 modules will be used with
a capacity of 270 MWh and a maximum power of 27 MW (Figure 28).
The economic organization of the project provides a successful panorama in the
generation, financing, and sale of the energy to be produced. The Tesla Powerpacks are a
fundamental piece in the economic generation scheme, since it will be possible to sell
100% of the load produced regardless of the time of day it is required for distribution, this
not only represents technical efficiency but also a total economic efficiency, since the eight
hours a day will be fully productive.
35/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
On the other hand, taking into account all the costs of implementation, technology and
applied engineering for this project, a real way of financing it has been found from the
growing energy awareness of the countries in the world, the so-called "green bonds" we
They will allow obtaining 85% of the necessary investment in exchange for a small
percentage of scheduled interest, the remaining 15% will be obtained through a private
investment model with a very lucrative return on investment that can be paid as soon as it
is started the project.
Figure 28. 3D model scale of the HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel. (The authors).
6.Bibliography
AZEL. (2016). Atlas Nacional de Energias Renovables. Obtenido de SENER:
https://dgel.energia.gob.mx/azel/mapa.html?lang=es
Carlino, H. (8 de junio de 2015). Finanzas Carbono. Obtenido de
https://web.archive.org/web/20160304085231/http://finanzascarbono.org/noticias/b
onos-verdes-una-fuente-de-recursos-en-rapida-expansion-para-el-financiamiento-
climatico/
DOF. (15 de may de 2020). ACUERDO por el que se emite la Política de Confiabilidad,
Seguridad, Continuidad y Calidad en el Sistema Eléctrico Nacional. Obtenido de
https://dof.gob.mx/nota_detalle.php?codigo=5593425&fecha=15/05/2020
Energy, N. (2020 de octubre de 2020). naturaenergy.net. Obtenido de
https://naturaenergy.net/2020/10/13/trina-solar-inaugura-en-colombia-una-de-tres-
plantas-fotovoltaicas-de-20-mw/
36/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
https://www.weather-mx.com/en/mexico/cozumel-climate#:~:text=The%20warmest
%20month%20(with%20the,December%20(28.6%C2%B0C).&text=The%20month
%20with%20the%20highest,June%20(23.8%C2%B0C).
38/32
HUNAB KU Team HUNAB KU HESS, Cozumel LIY4101
4 Annexes
4.1 Gantt Chart
32/32