Rana Plaza Case
Rana Plaza Case
Rana Plaza Case
The industry that has been making crucial contribution to rebuilding the country
and its economy is none other than the readymade garment (RMG) industry
which is now the single biggest export earner for Bangladesh. The sector
accounts for 83% of total export earnings of the country. When our only major
export earner "the jute industry" started losing its golden days, it is the RMG
sector that replaced it, and then, to overtake it.The apparel industry of
Bangladesh started its journey in the 1980s and has come to the position it is in
today. The late Nurool Quader Khan was the pioneer of the readymade garment
industry in Bangladesh. He had a vision of how to transform the country. In 1978,
he sent 130 trainees to South Korea where they learned how to produce
readymade garments. With those trainees, he set up the first factory "Desh
Garments" toproduce garments for export. At the same time, the late Akhter
Mohammad Musa of Bond Garments, the late Mohammad Reazuddin of Reaz
Garments, MdHumayun of Paris Garments, Engineer Mohammad Fazlul Azim of
Azim Group, Major (Retd) Abdul Mannan of Sunman Group, M Shamsur
Rahman of Stylecraft Limited, the first President of BGMEA, AM Subid Ali of
Aristocrat Limited also came forward and established some of the first garment
factories in Bangladesh. Following their footsteps, other prudent and hardworking
entrepreneurs started RMG factories in the country. Since then, Bangladeshi
garment industry did not need to look behind. Despite many difficulties faced by
the sector over the past years, it has carved a niche in world market and kept
continuing to show robust performance.
Since the early days, different sources of impetus have contributed to the
development and maturity of the industry at various stages. We learned about
child-labour in 1994, and successfully made the industry free from child labour in
1995.The MFA-quota was a blessing to our industry to take root, gradually
develop and mature. While the quota was approaching to an end in 2004, it was
predicted by many that the phase-out would incur a massive upset in our
export.However, the post-MFA era is another story of success. Proving all the
predictions wrong, we conquered the post-MFA challenges. Now the apparel
industry is Bangladesh s biggest export earner with value of over $30.61 billion of
exports in 2017-18 financial year. The Ready Made Garments industry of
Bangladesh has expanded dramatically over the last three decades. The history
of the Readymade Garments Sector in Bangladesh is a fairly recent one.
Nonetheless, it is a rich and varied tale.
The recent struggle to realize Workers’ Rights adds an important episode to the
story.The RMG industry of Bangladesh has expanded dramatically over the last
three decades. Traditionally, the jute industry dominated the industrial sector of
the country until the 1970s. Since the early 1980s, the RMG industry has
emerged as an important player in the economy of the country and has gradually
replaced the jute industry. Although Bangladesh is not developed in industry, it
has been enriched in Garment industries in the recent past years. In the field of
Industrialization garment industry is a promising step. The sector now dominates
the modern economy in export earnings, secondary impact and employment
generated. It has given the opportunity of employment to millions of unemployed,
especially innumerable uneducated women of the country. It is making a
significant contribution in the field of our export income. Bangladesh exports 35
types of garment products to about 31 countries around the world. The RMG
sector is a 100% export-oriented industry.
On 24 April 2013, the collapse of the Rana Plaza building in Dhaka, Bangladesh,
which housed five garment factories, killed at least 1,132 people and injured
more than 2,500. Only five months earlier, at least 112 workers had lost their
lives in another tragic accident, trapped inside the burning Tazreen Fashions
factory on the outskirts of Dhaka. These disasters, among the worst industrial
accidents on record, awoke the world to the poor labour conditions faced by
workers in the ready-made garment sector in Bangladesh. For some of the
lowest wages of the world, millions of people, most of them girls and women, are
exposed every day to an unsafe work environment with a high incidence of work-
related accidents and deaths, as well as occupational diseases. Most of the
factories do not meet standards required by building and construction legislation.
As a result, deaths from fire incidents and building collapses are frequent.
Since the Rana Plaza disaster, no fewer than 109 accidents have occurred.
Among these, at least 35 were textile factory incidents in which 491 workers were
injured and 27 lost their lives. In the absence of a well-functioning labour
inspection system and of appropriate enforcement mechanisms, decent work and
life in dignity are still far from reality for the vast majority of workers in the
garment industry and their families.Given the hazardous working conditions and
the high risk of exposure to employment injury in this sector, the provision of
adequate benefits is of critical importance in compensating injured workers for
the loss of earnings they are likely to suffer, and to ensure that they have access
to the medical and associated care required by their condition. Access to some
form of financial compensation or support for dependent family members who
lose their breadwinner can also make the difference between life in dire poverty,
where children and older people are forced to work to survive, and life at or just
above subsistence level. At present, the only form of financial protection
available to workers and their dependants is set out in the labour code, which
requires employers, when liable, to provide specified payments to injured
workers or survivors.Access to some form of financial compensation or support
for dependent family members who lose their breadwinner can also make the
difference between life in dire poverty, where children and older people are
forced to work to survive, and life at or just above subsistence level. At present,
the only form of financial protection available to workers and their dependants is
set out in the labour code, which requires employers, when liable, to provide
specified payments to injured workers or survivors.A recent amendment to the
labour code requires employers to insure themselves against liability, but no such
obligation was in force at the time Tazreen caught fire, or when Rana Plaza
collapsed. The amounts of compensation envisaged are also very low and take
the form of lump sums, offering inadequate protection to beneficiaries against ill
health and poverty in the medium and long term. The system is also plagued by
major practical application issues (e.g. evasion, lack of proper enforcement,
absence of effective recourse), with the result that legal entitlements very rarely
materialize. Despite the magnitude of the losses suffered by the victims of the
Tazreen and Rana Plaza accidents and their survivors, no compensation was
paid in application of the labour code provisions on employer liability. A small
number of global buyers and local players made some payments to victims in the
months following the disasters, albeit on a voluntary basis.
Same kinds of incidents happened in west the CTV building. The CTV building’s
collapse was one of several investigated by the Canterbury Earthquakes Royal
Commission which reported in June 2012. The Royal Commission found that the
building’s design relied ‘on the north wall complex and the south coupled shear
wall to resist the lateral loads generated by earthquakes’. Defects including a
lack of ductility (ability to stretch or deform under tensile stress) in areas such as
joint zones, columns and drag bars ‘meant that these two walls were not able to
function as the designer intended in the strong shaking generated by the
February earthquake’. It noted inadequacies and deficiencies in the engineering
design, construction and post-2010 earthquake inspection of the building. In
September 2014 the New Zealand Police confirmed that they would proceed with
a criminal investigation into the collapse. In December 2015 this investigation
was still in progress; only once it was completed would the police ‘be in a position
to make final decisions regarding any criminal culpability. The report of the
Canterbury Earthquakes Royal Commission contains biographies of those who
died in the CTV building as a result of the earthquake. Another tragedic incident
happened in ISTANBUL. An unlicensed fireworks factory here exploded
accidentally, leaving at least 22 people dead and at least 100 injured, Turkish
officials said Thursday. The building that housed the unlicensed factory, in
Davutpasa, an industrial neighborhood, partly collapsed. The factory was in a
multistory workshop complex it shared with manufacturers of paint, socks and
textiles, the Istanbul governor, Muammer Guler, said in a statement. Many
victims were crushed to death when some floors collapsed. The explosion
originated with a fire on the building’s fourth floor, Guler said. Several of those
killed were bystanders in the street watching the blaze. There were more than
130 workshops and offices in the building complex where the blast occurred. At
least six of the 20 dead had been pulled out of the rubble from the building that
partially collapsed under the force of the blast, Guler said, adding that nobody
alive remained under the debris.
Inadequate workplace safety has been blamed on lenient enforcement,
inceptions and training. Industrial accidents have killed and injuried thousands in
Eastern world these recent years. Workplace safety has been an everlasting
issue here. Another incident is an explosion has ripped through a chemical plant
in south-eastern China's Fujian province, sparking a major fire. The blast
occurred on Monday evening at the plant in Zhangzhou. Six people were taken to
hospital, say officials. State news agency Xinhua said 177 fire engines and more
than 800 firefighters were sent to the blaze, which is now under control. The plant
produces the chemical paraxylene (PX), in a process many in China feel creates
harmful pollution. PX is a flammable chemical used in polyester and plastics
manufacturing. Construction of PX plants has sparked protests, including violent
demonstrations last year in Guangdong province. Seventeen people were killed
and 20 injured in a series, the blast was occurred around 9.30 am at the Fuwa
Engineering Manufacturing plant while a large number of workers were inside.
Probably there were three blasts as the plants roof was blown off and windows
shattered. The windows of factories around were also shattered in the blasts up
to 100 meter away. The factory has been closed down with several fire trucks at
that moment. The injured workers have been sent to three local hospitals for
treatment. The Lahore Sunder Industrial Estate which buried at least 21 workers
and wounded many others has revealed an important reality about the shabby
state of Pakistans manufacturing economy. It is horrifying that the factory which
produced polythene bags employed a workforce consisting largely of children.
Equally shocking is the fact that the factory owners can build structures that are
dangerous structurally or vulnerable to fires or which follows lenient safety
standards that can cause boilers to explode.
In Pakistan again another incident occurred in KARACHI where more than 190
people are now known to have died in a fire at a garment factory in the southern
Pakistan city of Karachi, police have told the BBC. The blaze broke out on
Tuesday evening. Many other people were injured, including some who jumped
from the burning building. Now need to understand which kind of steps should be
taken for this kind incidents. Specially country like Bangladesh there are so many
problems regarding thois issue. Garments worker are not very educated so they
don’t knoe about the rights and safety initiatives. So there are some initiatives
that they need to be trained for their own safety.After RANA PLAZA fall criminal
bodies of evidence have been recorded against the proprietors of the building
and the proprietors of 5 articles of clothing production lines housed in the
building. Bangladesh labour law 2006 are now impleting by the government.
Bangladesh enjoys the lowest wages in clothing sector in the world, but cost of
living has been increasing gradually; most likely at significantly higher rate in the
world. Thus; demand of increasing monthly wages is obvious, creating labor
unrest. The second factor is wages discrimination; top-level employees draw
more than 100 times monthly salaries than low-level employees, plus other
company’s benefits in the hierarchy. This in turn develops non-motivation among
the fellow workers; create jealousness among them, consequently less
productivity of worker by unrest in the production environment.
Environment Analysis Tool
(PESTLE)
It is understood that Garments industry of Bangladesh has drawn a special
attention to the mass people in the world because of being both cost leader and
quality leader at the same time. The purpose of this research paper is to analyze
the garments industry in Bangladesh, which is going to be an emerging tiger in
the world economy. It also aims to assess the impact of macro-environmental
factors affecting the industry by PESTLE analysis. Again, five forces model has
been analyzed to assess the impacts of competitive external factors on the
Garments industry in Bangladesh. Furthermore, Garments sector competitive
responses to the primary issues affecting the industry have been evaluated here.
It also outlines the primary external influences to which this industry is subject. In
this case, SWOT analysis has been conducted to assess the competitive position
of this industry in comparison with the global perspective. The study suggests
that total export is highly correlated with the exports of garments. It also finds that
there is severe lacking in the safety and security compliance, wages and
compensations and code of conduct of the current organizations. Moreover, GSP
facility withdrawn can affect severely on the readymade garments of Bangladesh
to compete with price in the international market with China, India and Vietnam
etc. The readymade garments sector of Bangladesh is enjoying cost leadership
as a source of completive advantage because of cheap labor. Finally, the study
would like to recommend for further improvement of garment sector in
Bangladesh.
Also there are some key points which shows this should be PESTLE anlaysis-
PESTLE is more appropriate because Rana Plaza building has different
companies of same industry, which focuses on macro environment.
Therefore, we thought PESTLE analysis would be more appropriate for
rana plaza.
Mission Statement
What are the steps that the managerial authorities of RMG companies and the
government take together to ensure workplace healthy and safety, preventing
any further loss of human lives or industry reputation, leading to an economic
struggle for the whole industry?
Pestle Analysis
Political
In spite of having favorable business environment for RMG sector with having
low labor cost, duty-free export facilities to 27 European Union countries and 10
developed countries, this sector is facing negative impact in business operations
due to unstable political state. The eight-stored Rana Plaza building came
crashing down on 24 April demonstrating the ugly politics of Bangladesh. The US
duty-free trade privileges order suspends Bangladesh’s under the terms of a
trade program called the (GSP), designed to promote economic growth in
developing countries suspecting Bangladesh was not taking steps to afford
internationally recognized rights to its workers.
A country’s development largely depends on the country’s smooth and stable
political system. Democratic government, fiscal policy, monetary policy helps to
gain economic growth. Bangladesh is appearing as a new emerging tiger by the
help of its readymade garments and textile sector. But in recent times a black
shadow is appearing in the sky of Bangladesh because of political unrest, strike,
conflicts, labour unrest etc. The most noticeable and important features of
political system are as follows -
Absence of proper democratic system
Absence of rule of law
Corruption and terrorism
Absence of democratic practice among political parties
Pressure from the Islamist
Confrontational situation among political parties
Though the problems, stated above, exist in Bangladesh, the government has
taken many positive steps and initiative in favor of garments sector. Foreign
investments are welcomed. Favorable policy, tax holiday, export-import policies,
investments incentives, reduced import duties on capital machinery and spares
are some important initiative helping the garments sector.
In the year 2011 and 2012 the corporate tax rate, company tax rate and general
tax rate had declined which ultimately had an influence on the growth of service
revenues. This unexpected growth in earnings will eventually increase the
charitable activities in Canada in order to enhance the image of Rana Plaza and
to promote themselves in an ethical way.
Economical
Garments sector is currently contributing about 10% to GDP1 and it is the
highest single contributor of Bangladesh economy. About 20 million people are
directly or indirectly involved in this sector. And about 78% of the employees are
women who are playing a pivotal role in decision making, poverty alleviation in
their family. A platform for 2.8 million women to engage in new productive role
has been created by this industry. Besides, this industry is accelerating the
industrial growth and employment opportunities for the unemployed people in
Bangladesh. Banks are making a lot of profit only from this sector by export and
import services.
The collapse of Rana Plaza has received vast international attention and strong
criticism. Nevertheless, the almost immediate strengthening of labour rights and
the wholesale reform undertaken on all sides of the supply chain, evidence a
move of all local and foreign stakeholders towards greater compliance and taking
of precautionary steps for prevention of further disasters. The tragedy that Rana
Plaza embodies served as a much-needed epiphany for the soaring RMG Sector
of Bangladesh. Prompt co-operation on the part of all stakeholders and
regulatory bodies now show a move towards sustainable development, which
further ensures safeguarding against any future irregularities and pave the way
for steady economic growth.
The recent economic trend of Bangladesh is rather satisfying. In 2007-08 while
US was facing turnover in economic growth, subsequently in 2010-11 quite a few
countries of Europe were in the same state, Bangladesh was having
comparatively steady and stable situation. According to BBS (Bangladesh
Bureau of Statistics) in 2010-11 the rate of economic growth was 6.7%, in 2011-
12 was 6.3% and in 2012-13 it will be 6.03%.
The recent digester of Rana Plaza boosted the garment worker’s anger
and frustration and creating negative impact on Garment Industry.
China is also stepping back From RMG sector.
Bangladesh began its new struggle for achieving economic emancipation
and leading the country try to prosperity with its limited resources.
Economically they are improving day by day as they are learning from the
past experience.
The upcoming trend of using technologies in RMG production questions
future economic growth.
Social
Bangladesh is a country of about 160 million people and a large number of her
people are unemployed. Women are the most unused labor force in our economy
and those who are working are not getting well compensation packages as
compared to men (Bhuiyan, 2012). And it is garments that have helped them to
engage in the mainstream of the economy. About 78% of total garments worker
are woman who are significantly contributing to their families living in slums and
villages. Hence, they are participating in decision making of families. From this
point of view, the social impacts of garments are as follows.
Woman empowerment has been achieved in private and public sector.
They are contributing to increase savings.
They are interested population control.
Economic solvency of woman has been achieved.
Their Children are getting educated more.
Awareness about Health care has been increased
Standard of living is increasing day by day.
Society and culture is an important factor that must be given emphasis by any
business, specifically those who are operating in the global area. It is important
that any industry must operate in compliance with the social systems in order to
gain good reputation and effective public image. On the other hand, cultural
aspects is equally essential, in order to understand the various needs of different
individuals that belongs to different cultures
Population growth rate
Age distribution
Career attitudes
Consumer behavior
Religion and culture itself.
Although Consumer Rights Movement, enforcement of government regulations
and a structured view regarding the economic importance of Social responsibility
are not yet so widespread in the corporate world in Bangladesh. , business
organizations can thereby have an inclusive financial, commercial and social
approach, leading to a long term strategy minimizing risks linked to uncertainty.
This is an investment, not a cost, much like quality management.
Technological
Bangladesh is not technologically so developed as compared to other big giants
in the international markets. It is still using obsolete technologies because they
have to pay a high amount of money to acquire ultra-modern technology.
Although, government has given duty free import of technology and machinery
for garments, it is increasing the fixed and operational cost. If they could
purchase it from the local market, it would be a blessing for the garments industry
of Bangladesh. China, Vietnam, Taiwan etc are more advanced in technological
advantage.
The manufacturing technology of garment production has been changing from
labor-intensive to more sophisticated and capital-intensive production. This
change creates dissatisfaction for the lower skilled workers because of their
inability to adapt to the new manufacturing process. Work dissatisfaction reduces
the performance of workers and, in turn, company performance is negatively
affected. On the other hand, the positive relationships to technological change
include improvement of task significance, salary increase, improvement of the
quality of supervision, improved co-workers relations and increase benefits, in
addition, if skilled technicians are available to instruct, prearranged garment is an
option because labor and energy cost are inexpensive here. Concluding remarks
and recommendations: There are some opportunities that prevailed in the
industry are given below –
Good reputation of product quality in outside world will increase more
option of export.
Strong rise of knitting sector.
Very good quality yarn is now producing.
More options of new employments.
Great pricing capability.
Attracting new buyers by establishing new buying houses.
Encouraging new joint venture projects.
Change in Governments attitude towards RMG sector
Advances in the preparation of base raw materials are one area that can benefit
hugely from technology contributing to the whole sustainability of the garment
supply chain. A simple cotton t-shirt requires some 700 gallons of water to grow,
produce, and transport with more water being used in the dyeing process.
Systems that allow the efficient growing and harvesting of crops, monitoring
water usage, and minimizing the use of fertilizers and pesticides are increasing in
number globally, and are endorsed by a number of international institutions,
including the Better Cotton Initiative (BCI). But technology can take Bangladesh
further still.
Environmental
Environmental impacts of garments on the environment are not well enough to
describe because of poor waste management. The improper drainage system is
mainly responsible for it. Besides, government is not taking enough steps for
waste management in Dhaka city. Sound and air pollution are the outcome of this
industry. Sustainability in RMG business operation is an evolving issue for
Bangladeshi entrepreneurs Rana Plaza incidents. Bangladesh RMG industry, the
main catalyst for the country’s economy, is blamed by the buyer for lack
implementation of sustainability issues in the factories. Environmental
sustainability is the most important and emerging issue at the present phase of
industrialization, which is considered as a burning issue. The goals of sustainable
developments are –Cleaner water and sanitation, Affordable and clean energy,
Industry innovation infrastructure, Climate action and responsible consumption
and production.
Environmental sustainability consists of energy usage, water usage and chemical
storage and handling. The apparel industry has various impacts to
the environment. It is polluting the environment in many ways. Environmental
pollutions are wastewater discharge, solid and hazardous discharge, air emission
and nuisances. Bangladesh RMG industry owners are very much concern about
business sustainability. Compliance factories are implementing a numbers of
best practices to improve their efficiency and sustainability. Some best practices
are:
Rain water harvesting
Reduce, Reuse, Recycle (3R) of water
Cogeneration
Condensate recovery boiler
Water efficient dyes and chemicals
Use of renewable energy (solar panel)
Prismatic skylight
T5 and LED light
Sustainability reporting and etc.
Management Agenda
1. Statement: Ensure national and international certification of safety in the
workplace to safeguard the reputation of the company and to circumvent
probable losses.
3. Statement: Conduct training programs for workers of all levels and make
them strictly adhere to safety policies within the organizations to minimize
losses in cases of emergencies.
Why it needs to be solved? Lobbying with the foreign government can help
reduce value added requirements for expert.
Who is going to solve it? BGMEA should responsible for taking the matter to
the government.
When is it going to be solved? This will be a long process that might take even
years to be solve, this must be initiated immediately.
Recommendation & Implementation-2
What is the problem? The worker working in the RMG sector are not aware of
proper techniques to minimize risks in the workplaces.
What is the solution? The solution is to conduct proper training sessions for all
level workers to ensure they are safely handling equipments.
Why it needs to be solved? This has to be done to make the RMG sector safe
and sustainable industry.
How it needs to be solved? This can be done hiring professional agencies for
T&D.
Who is going to solve it? Management for respective RMG factories should be
responsible.
What is the solution? The solution can be safety program which can help focus
the efforts improving the work environment.
Why it needs to be solved? Safe and healthy workplace will encourage the
employees involvement to achieve the goal.
How it needs to be solved? Make sure employees have the right tools and
have regular equipment inspections and also implementing safety protocols from
the beginning.
Who is going to solve it? The government and RMG sectors should work for
the workplace safety program.
When is it going to be solved? It might take some time to rechecking the tools
and equipments they are using which will ultimately going to be helpful for
ensuringsafe and healthy workplace.
Recommendation & Implementation-4
What is the solution? The solution is to start showing the concern about the
safety of the infrastructures and start working on it by hiring qualified engineers
who would do his job correctly.
How it needs to be solved? They can hire engineers and expertise from abroad
and also change the education system, so that the future engineers are aware of
the technologies.
Who is going to solve it? RMG sectors should be aware hiring the right
candidate.
When is it going to be solved? It might take some time for screening the
existing employees and recruiting the new ones.
Recommendation & Implementation-5
What is the problem? The buildings of RMG sectors is taken for commercial
purposes but are used for industrial purposes.
What is the solution? Officials from the government sectors should go for
verification and the rules should be stricter.
Why it needs to be solved? So that the buildings are properly analyzed which
will eventually create a safer workplace for all.
Who is going to solve it? The government officials as well as the engineers
should work together to solve it.