Cloud Computing Adoption at Higher Education Insti
Cloud Computing Adoption at Higher Education Insti
Cloud Computing Adoption at Higher Education Insti
net/publication/315591077
CITATIONS READS
15 883
3 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Alexeis Garcia-Perez on 18 April 2017.
which enabled these colleges and universities to reduce their Oman, Sharma, Al-Badi, Govindaluri, & Al-Kharusi [20]
IT expenses by eliminating the requirements of software were able to show that job opportunities have a strong
updating and licensing [12]. One study by Mircea & positive relationship with the adoption of cloud computing at
Andreescu [13] argued that about 70% of IT leaders in higher the individual level. The same study has concluded that other
education recommended cloud computing over traditional factors such as perceived usefulness, self-efficacy and trust
computer technologies, stating that improving IT services is positively influence the adoption of cloud computing
the most crucial factor in their decision. In addition, it is technology.
estimated that using cloud computing technology at any According to Truong, Pham, Thoai, & Dustdar [17],
institution may reduce the total operational cost by 25 to 30 education institutions in developing countries mainly focus
percent [14]. on teaching and learning activities. Although some
Cloud computing technology provides a serious step universities in developing countries are considered as
across the educational industry and an important opportunity research-oriented institutions, these institutions are smaller
to improve structural efficiency, stimulate innovation, than teaching-oriented universities. The same authors argued
decrease spending on technology, and increase agility [15], that universities in developing countries face many
16]. Furthermore, cloud computing promises to provide challenges, which can be characterized as following:
almost unlimited computational power at low cost [7]. Such Universities in developing countries suffer from limited
cloud computing benefits may solve the challenge of resources compared with population rate. Therefore,
resource limitations and the lack of advanced technology students also experience a high level of competition
availability in developing countries [17]. between each other for securing a seat in these
The importance of cloud computing in higher education universities.
has increased rapidly with the passage of time, and it is High-quality resources are not available due to cost. As a
obvious that its use and its importance will continue to grow result, technology resources in developing countries
in the future [13], [18]. This is mainly due to its benefits in universities cannot process complicated and advanced
teaching and learning, among other aspects [4]. scientific projects.
The Laboratory facilities are not available out of class
hours. Therefore, the students are restricted in when they
III. CLOUD COMPUTING AT UNIVERSITIES IN DEVELOPING can use university facilities.
COUNTRIES The lack of communication and knowledge sharing
According to Stein et al. [5], cloud computing can increase between lectures and students outside the classroom.
education efficiency, improve quality, and reduce the overall In theory, cloud-computing resources can be used in the
IT costs. For example, several education institutions in East developing countries with the same approach as in developed
Africa (e.g. the University of Nairobi, the Kigali Institute for countries [21]. However, the educational environment,
Education, and Kenyan Methodist University) have culture, and resources are different. For example, utilizing
collaborated with Google to gain significant benefits from cloud computing services effectively needs well-prepared
Google cloud applications for both students and lectures [2]. infrastructure such as internet upload and download speed,
Furthermore, in Ethiopia, Microsoft has supported which still not available in most of developing countries [2].
education institutions by rolling out 250,000 laptops for In developing countries, there are several barriers to the
lectures, which all run Windows Azure, which is mainly adoption of cloud computing in universities. These barriers
based on the platform as a service [18]. Windows Azure is an include the cost and payment method [17], lack of electric
operating system that depends on cloud computing power stability and poor broadband infrastructure [22], lack
technology, and lectures in Ethiopia use it to upload and of awareness [23], security and privacy concerns [21], and
download curriculum and securely transfer students’ records lack of cloud computing technical experts [17].
into the education system. This process prevents the Cost and payment method: even though cloud computing
education institutions in Ethiopia from having to invest reduces the cost of IT through reducing the physical
heavily in datacenters as well as hardware and software for infrastructure, it is still expensive for universities in
connecting this huge number of transactions. developing countries. In addition, cloud computing
In a large longitudinal study, Shirazi, Gholami, & Higón service providers usually accept electronic payment by
[19] investigated the impact of information technology on the credit or debit cards. This payment method is a problem in
economy of 11 countries in the Middle East (Jordan, Oman, developing countries, which still prefer traditional
Yemen, Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Syria, United Arab Emirates, payment methods rather than online banking because of
Bahrain, Iran, Kuwait and Lebanon). The findings of this limitations in online banking services. Therefore, the lack
study argued that there is a positive and strong link between of online payment services may hinder the adoption of
economic growth and the utilization of ICT. In addition, it cloud computing in higher education institutions.
showed that countries with higher education attainment such Lack of electric power stability and poor broadband
as Jordan, Kuwait and Bahrain were able to gain more infrastructure: In many developing countries such as India,
benefits from ICT, whereas other countries such as Iran and Africa, Jordan, Syria, and Iraq the electricity can shut
Syria were less advantaged by ICT because of government down unexpectedly from the power supplier. Such
constraints and policies, which prevent the growth of ICT instability of electricity may destroy the process of upload
infrastructure. and download, especially if there is a large amount of data
In their excellent study of cloud computing adoption in that depends on automatic tasks (e.g. schedule backup of
922
International Journal of Information and Education Technology, Vol. 7, No. 12, December 2017
923
International Journal of Information and Education Technology, Vol. 7, No. 12, December 2017
924
International Journal of Information and Education Technology, Vol. 7, No. 12, December 2017
F. Centralization and team level services. For example, Google docs, which is
One of the cloud computing benefits is its decentralized a simple application based on cloud technology, enables the
technology, which makes it usable anywhere, despite the user to share the same documents and to edit the same file,
geographical location. Most of the interviewees argued that providing the full details about each user edition such as time
the centralization of several applications prevented them of edit, user permissions, content before and after each user
from providing a better performance and thought that such editing, and review sharing mode” (TE6).
applications could be accessed only inside the institution To summarise, it is clear that cloud computing technology
using the intranet. has the ability to increase the sharing knowledge level among
“The centralization of in-house applications is a big students. Therefore, this factor is considered as an enabler of
challenge for us. For security purposes, we cannot enable cloud computing technology adoption at higher education
the users in our institution to use critical applications institutions in developing countries.
through the internet. However, we are studying to transfer
these applications to cloud computing. Thus we may improve
the performance of lecturers, as they can work outside the VI. INTEGRATING DIFFUSION OF INNOVATION THEORY (DOI)
institution at any time they prefer” (TE9). WITH CLOUD COMPUTING ADOPTION AT HIGHER EDUCATION
In the same context, one of the senior lecturers added: INSTITUTION
“The centralization of using different applications DOI theory, developed by Everett Roger [24], [27], [28],
prevents us from traveling all the time. For example, we must has been widely used in innovation adoption studies. The
stay in the campus in the exam periods because of the main aim of DOI theory is to help both organizations and
examination grading software, which we cannot use outside individuals, whether in accepting or rejecting innovations
the university campus”. [29]. Fig. 2 shows Roger’s five steps for adopting an
In brief, the geographical independence in using cloud innovation. This study suggested DOI theory for
computing services through the decentralization ability to implementing cloud computing technology at higher
access technology may be considered as an enabler of cloud education institutions. The knowledge, which means
computing technology adoption. awareness, in this study is the first step in adopting cloud
computing. The main aim of this step is to increase the
G. Management Support
awareness level of cloud computing technology benefits and
The final decision of cloud computing adoption needs the limitations in general.
top management support. This factor could be neither The second step is to find out the benefits of cloud
enabler nor barrier of cloud computing adoption. If the top computing technology in more detail such as compatibility
management is aware of the benefits and limitations of cloud with in-house technology, relative advantages, cost benefits,
computing this may be an enabler to adopt this technology. and increasing sharing knowledge level between students and
Otherwise, the top management might consider such lecturers behind classrooms. Such step followed by the initial
technology useless and then this factor will be a barrier to decision regarding the cloud computing adoption at higher
cloud adoption. education institution. This step may divide to accept the
In this context, one of the senior engineers (TE7) declared adoption or reject it. There is two type of rejections, the
that: rejection caused by reasons, which may handle by cloud
“Our top management has the power to make the final computing serveries providers, and the rejection without any
decision regarding the adoption of cloud computing. logical reasons based on policies and regulations of any
However, they are not aware of the technology benefits. institution. However, this decision still initials based on the
Therefore, cloud technology would not be adopted in the reason of rejection and the continuity of accepting or
near future, unless the top managers learn the excellence of rejecting cloud technology. The fourth step considered the
this technology.” full implementation of cloud technology based on initial
As a result, this factor varies from one management to acceptance of adoption. Finally, the confirmation of keep
another based on the awareness level of the institution’s top using cloud technology for the long term period.
management.
H. Knowledge Sharing
The findings show that cloud computing would positively
increase the sharing of knowledge among students. Almost
all interviewees agreed that IT, in general, improves the
sharing of knowledge. In addition, one of the IT experts
argues that the cloud computing concept is based on sharing
knowledge as it provides the ability to share content with
specific permissions for each user.
“We believe that cloud computing would absolutely
improve the level of sharing knowledge. It enables a group of Fig. 2. Innovation–decisions process model [27].
users to share the same applications, content, and services”
(TE10).
“Cloud computing applications support both individual VII. CONCLUSION
925
International Journal of Information and Education Technology, Vol. 7, No. 12, December 2017
This paper investigates the main factors that affect the [16] M. Stieninger, D. Nedbal, W. Wetzlinger, G. Wagner, and M. A.
Erskine, "Impacts on the organizational adoption of cloud computing:
adoption of cloud computing at universities in developing A reconceptualization of influencing factors," Procedia Technology,
countries from both academic and technical perspectives. vol. 16, pp. 85-93, 2014.
Semi-structured interviews were conducted with participants [17] H. Truong, T. Pham, N. Thoai, and S. Dustdar, "Cloud computing for
including professors in IT and technical experts in IT. Since education and research in developing countries," Cloud Computing for
Teaching and Learning: Strategies for Design and Implementation, pp.
this study employed an interpretive approach using 64-80, 2012.
qualitative methodology, all interviews were recorded after [18] N. Sultan, "Cloud computing for education: A new dawn?" Int. J. Inf.
gaining the ethical approval from participants. In addition, Manage., vol. 30, pp. 109-116, 2010.
[19] F. Shirazi, R. Gholami, and D. A. Higón, "The impact of information
the researchers have applied the Nvivo program for
and communication technology (ICT), education and regulation on
transcribing, coding, and finally generating the study’s economic freedom in Islamic Middle Eastern countries," Information &
conceptual framework. Management, vol. 46, pp. 426-433, 2009.
The finding suggests that the adoption of cloud computing [20] S. K. Sharma, A. H. Al-Badi, S. M. Govindaluri, and M. H. Al-Kharusi,
"Predicting motivators of cloud computing adoption: A developing
at educational institutions in developing countries is strongly country perspective," Comput. Hum. Behav., vol. 62, pp. 61-69, 2016.
recommended by academic experts as well as technical [21] H. M. Sabi, F. E. Uzoka, K. Langmia, and F. N. Njeh, "Conceptualizing
professionals. The cloud computing adoption is supported by a model for adoption of cloud computing in education," Int. J. Inf.
several enablers such as cost effectiveness, ease of use, Manage., vol. 36, pp. 183-191, 2016.
[22] S. Greengard, "Cloud computing and developing nations," Commun
improving the level of sharing knowledge, compatibility with ACM, vol. 53, pp. 18-20, 2010.
devices and software, and geographical decentralization [23] B. Scholtz and D. Atukwase, "An analysis of the perceived benefits and
ability to use cloud applications. However, some concerns drawbacks of cloud ERP systems: A South African study," in
Information Technology in Environmental Engineering, Anonymous
have arisen as barriers for adopting this technology, such as Springer, 2016, pp. 75-87.
security and privacy, awareness of top management about [24] E. M. Rogers, Diffusion of Innovations, New York: Free Press: 2003.
this technology’s benefits and limitations, compatibility of [25] N. Alkhater, G. Wills, and R. Walters, "Factors influencing an
cloud with in-house technology in case of migration, and organisation's intention to adopt cloud computing in saudi arabia," in
Proc 2014 IEEE 6th International Conference on Cloud Computing
resistance to using new technology. Technology and Science (CloudCom), 2014, pp. 1040-1044.
Further research on the adoption of cloud computing may [26] L. S. Gilbert, K. Jackson, and S. di Gregorio, "Tools for analyzing
focus on developing a framework for cloud computing qualitative data: The history and relevance of qualitative data analysis
software," Handbook of Research on Educational Communications
adoption at universities in developing countries. Though and Technology, Anonymous Springer, 2014, pp. 221-236.
cloud computing is a new technology, especially in [27] M. Rogers Everett, "Diffusion of innovations," New York, pp. 12, 1995.
developing nations, further studies in this domain would help [28] E. M. Rogers, Diffusion of Innovations, Simon and Schuster, 2010.
academic institutions to understand the benefits, weaknesses, [29] M. H. Fagan, "Global information technology transfer: A framework
for analysis," Journal of Global Information Technology Management,
and challenges of adopting this technology. vol. 4, pp. 5-26, 2001.
926
International Journal of Information and Education Technology, Vol. 7, No. 12, December 2017
He took his first degree at Aston University, followed by a PhD and research order to control a robot hand directly from his neural signals, across the
post at Imperial College London. He held positions at Oxford, Newcastle, Atlantic Ocean.
Warwick and Reading Universities before joining Coventry. He has been awarded higher doctorates (DSc) by Imperial College and the
Kevin is a chartered engineer who has published over 600 research papers. Czech Academy of Sciences, Prague. Kevin has also been awarded Honorary
His experiments into implant technology led to him being featured as the Doctorates by 8 UK Universities and one from Saints Cyril & Methodius
cover story on the US magazine, ‘Wired’. He achieved the world’s first direct University, Skopje. He received The IEE Senior Achievement Medal, the
electronic communication between two human nervous systems, the basis for IET Mountbatten Medal and the Ellison-Cliffe Medal from the Royal Society
thought communication. Another project extended human sensory input to of Medicine. In 2000 Kevin presented the Royal Institution Christmas
include ultrasonics. He also linked his nervous system with the internet in Lectures.
927