Inventing Music 1 648526 PDF
Inventing Music 1 648526 PDF
Inventing Music 1 648526 PDF
Inventing
Music Ebook reissue
Australian Music Centre
2015
MUSIC
Andrew Ford
Illustrations by Rocco Fazzari
.....
Sounds Australian,* Sydney, Australia
* Sounds Australian was the trading name of the Australian Music Centre in 1989-2000.
1. Inventing Music
The text for this work was developed by Sounds Australian with
funding from the Commonwealth Curriculum Centre under its
Projects of National Significance program.
Australia
ISSN 1036-1766
ISBN 0 646 03 060 4
Published in 1991 by
Sounds Australian
Foreword v
Introduction vi
What is Composition? 1
Improvisation 6
Sound 12
Rhythm and Time 22
Timbre 26
Notation 28
Form in Music 31
Composing with a Tape Recorder 37
Words and Music 40
Style 42
Bibliography 47
Discography 49
Andrew Ford holds dual Australian/UK citizenship and lives, with his
wife, in Sydney. He continues to teach at the University of Wollongong
and has recently become known as a writer and broadcaster on music.
Inventing Music is the first of seven resource kits dealing with the creation of
music in Australia. Whereas Inventing Music guides secondary school students
and teachers in composing their own music, the subsequent kits in the series
show examples of the work of other Australian creative musicians and composers.
Each kit covers one stylistic area: Australian classical music, Australian popular
music, jazz, folk music, world music in Australia, and it is hoped, traditional
Aboriginal music and dance.
Additional copies
Additional copies of this text are available at greatly reduced prices if purchased
in multiples. ·
Supplementary materials
A great many of the Australian works mentioned in the listening lists or
resource lists are available from Sounds Australian in recording and/ or score.
Sounds Australian attempts to make available every recording or publication of
an Australian work, whether made here or overseas.
Copying
Sounds Australian does not object to copying of excerpts from the printed
materials, under normalprovisions of the copyright act. However, copying of
recordings or substantial parts of the text is illegal.
Important
Please ensure that resources on Australian music such as these continue to be
available to high schools, by purchasing additional copies of materials as you
need them.
If materials are illegally copied instead of purchased, it will not be possible for
Sounds Australian to continue to produce these special resources for schools.
Richard Letts
Sounds Australian
It goes without saying that composition is the single most important activity in
the field of music. Without it all the other activities would cease or, at best,
become little more than of antiquarian interest.
Traditionally, however, composition has been considered an inappropriate
activity for the classroom, either too difficultto approach (often for students and
teachers alike) or1 worse still, the province of an elite body of gifted men (sic),.
in touch, somehow, with a divine inspirational force. At least this is the all too
common conception of the Classical composer. Other areas of music have their
own cliches and stereotypes. And yet in most non-Western cultures this
attitude would seem faintly ridiculous and, as the following chapter describes,
the basic business of composition is something which we all do every day.
This resource kit makes little or no distinction between composition (which,
after all, is only notated improvisation) and improvisation (which is spontaneous
composition). When the word "compose" is used, "or improvise" should be
understood. The techniques of good improvisation are discussed in the chapter
devoted to that, and similarly with many approaches to notation, but as far as
making an effective piece of music goes, the skills and techniques involved in
improvisation and composition are much the same.
Given that musical composition (as distinct from harmony and counterpoint
and other exercises in pastiche) has generally not been taught in our schools, it
has been left up to tertiary institutions to carry outthe task. This has traditionally
occurred in the manner of an apprentice scheme (master and pupil). We may
question whether this is. desirable. Nevertheless in all the arts role models are
important. In musical composition: it is even more the case. For young
Australians, particularly females, such figures have often been difficult to find.
In this kit many of the examples and activities provided are of and by Australian
musicians. The kit aims to be a practical one. Students are not asked to sit back
and admire but to be involved and creative. If there is one single message it is
that music may be composed by anyone and that we all have the basic skills
required as of birth.
The kit is divided into chapters which deal with the fundamental building
blocks of any type ofmusic: sound, rhythm, form etc. It is arranged in terms
of Text and Activities. The Activity sections are in Bold type.
The kit has been designed to deal with archetypes rather than specifics,
although the final chapter, which discusses the concept of Style, concludes with
a non-compositional activity involving a study of contrasting stylistic approaches.
-The Activities
There are over forty separate Activities described in the kit. All may be
undertaken precisely as outlined here, but it is hoped that teachers will want to
adapt them and even combine elements of them to develop their own activities.
Most of those described are extremely flexible and have been used before in a
range ofsituations.. They work with young children and professional musicians,
(although, from experience, younger children frequently come up with more
elegant and imaginative solutions!)
The Activities aim.to break down conventional, style-bound notions of what is
music. Ifthisissuccessfultheimaginationmayoften beliberatedfor~reativity....
Liberation from conventionality, however, does not, on its own, produce a
creative frame of mind. Students must feel they have a clear structure in which
to work, otherwise they may lack the confidence and trust to be creative; As
mentioned in the chapter on improvisation, it is often the simplest and most
restricted activities which unleash the greatest amount of creativity.
-Where to begin
The activities are not graded in the text. However they are intended to be used,
within a particular chapter, in the order in which they appear. Teachers may
wish to employ the early Activities in each chapter with Years 7 or 8. Alternatively
some of these early Activities may be deemed too basic for more senior students.
Inevitably this will vary from school to school and from one group of students
to another.
-Equipment
Very little special equipment is required for this kit. A tape recorder is about the
only essential item. The more thatstudents.can hear their compositions, the
more they ,are encouraged.to be self-critical about their work and to evolve -a
critical vocabulary for discussing it. Tape recording activities also, in our high-
tech, product orientated world, somehow legitimises the process. (Nevertheless,
as every enlightened teacher knows, it is the process, rather than the product,
which is of greater educational value). Finally, and most importantly, listening
to playbacks of composition activities will encourage more acute listening
during those activities. And, after all, composers' most important pieces of
equipment are their ears.
viii
This eBook is licensed for 1 copy to Angela Pryce. 26 Feb 2016.
What is Musical
Composition?
Mter all, practically everybody writes words fairly often. Even if we have not
written a book we can imagine quite easily how novelists go about their work.
Similarly everyone has painted a picture, as a small child if not recently. We
all know the sensation of making marks on paper, of doodling. And when we
visit an exhibition of new art it is quite likely that we will overhear a remark
such as "Oh, I could do better than that."
Is the composition of music really so different? So removed from our own every
day experiences of life?
1. Pitch- that is to say the changing highness and lowness of sounds. These
changes are one of music's most notable features, they give rise to
melodies and harmonies. Admittedly, a composer like Sarah Hopkins can
work with one pitch for a very long time. But even in these works pitch
is important - through the absence of change.
7. Silence- this is a very important part of music. For instance, a pause in the
middle of a piece of music can be very expressive.
All of these musical elements are a natural part of our process of communication.
Take pitch for example. We all use pitch every day of our lives. We use it when
we speak, to give our words meaning., In some. Asian languages, such as
Mandarin and Cantonese, a particular phoneme (that is to say, a single sound)
can have many different meanings according to how it is pitched. Think of how
this might happen in English.
Activity
Take the word "Yes".
2. Each pair takes it in tum to change places, walking past each other. and
saying Hello" - just "Hello", no other words - as they pass.
11
i) A and B barely know each other but meet at the bus stop
each morning;
ii) in a dark ally A is afraid of being mugged by B;
iii) B owes A money;
iv) A fancies B;
v) A has just left a restaurant and is still wearing a large white
napkin;
vi) B thinks A is an old, old friend (A isn't!);
vii) A and B are old, old friends who haven't met in ages but
both are in a great hurry;
viii) A and B had a huge and violent argument the previous
day.
And so on. You will be able to thinkof many more scenarios like these. The
teacher should ideally make a list before starting the game and set each scene
just before A and B walk towards each other, keeping the meeting as
spontaneous as possible. If it is possible to tape or video the game it is worth
doing so. It will help analysis of the pitch changes afterwards.
Once again pitch is vitally important in giving the word ''Hello" its meaning.
But it must by now have become apparent that other factors, especially
dynamics (loudness) and tempo (speed) are almost equally important. And, in
complex sentences, rhythm, timbre, articulation (emphasis) and the use of
pauses become essential.
In actual speech, when we are making up the words as well as speaking them
other factors come into play. The use of recurring patterns (what we call
sequences in music), repetition of certain sounds to lend emphasis. All done in
the spirit of communication, of making our ideas and our feelings clear.
Activity
Listen to a politician making a speech~ What we call rhetoric, the politician's
use of dramatic devices which make us pay attention to the message and
possibly want to agree with it, is really nothing more nor less than musical
composition. Which of the politicians you listen to are the most effective
speakers? Why?
The tools which a public speaker uses are exactly the same as those used by a
composer: pitch, rhythm, dynamics, tempo, articulation, pauses, repetition.
Even timbre, that is to say tone colour, the actual quality of the sound, is
important if one is trying to convey a particular "image" - and politicians
usually are!
Activity
Listen to comedians, evangelists, people in television and radio advertisements.
How are they using musical techniques in their speech?
We have seen then that using .the· tools of composition is a very natural. and
spontaneous part of everybody's lives. And yet it is so natural and spontaneous
that most people are unaware of it.
Activity
Listen to the way your family, friends, teachers speak. What are the characteristic
musical sounds they make?
In a medium such as music it is very hard to make a specific point unless words
are used in addition to sounds or unless the sounds used have a particular
meaning outside the music- the sounds might themselves be linked to words
(if a piece of music quotes the tune of Advance Australia Fair even without the
words we might be forgiven for having patriotic or antipatriotic thoughts); if
the sounds are familiar (police sirens, church bells, flowing water) then once
again we might receive a specific meaning; if the style of the music is well
known (a Viennese waltz, a Jolksong,. rock 'n' roll) we might fine!_ familiar
feelings stirring within us.
But this whole question is enormously complex and might be better asked when
we have listened to and composed music a little more ourselves.
For this exercise, the most important limitation is to restrict players to making
"single sounds". That is to say even as many as two notes next to each other are
wrong for the purposes of this exercise. With each new limitation the possibilities
are reduced and paradoxically this will make the players more imaginative. H
they can only play single sounds they must experiment with long and short
sounds, loud and quiet sounds. They will also have to listen harder and
listening is the basis of any improvisation. The suggested stages of improvisation
are outlined below.
It is extremely useful if you are able to record each attempt. It will encourage
players to be self-critical and will heighten their listening powers.
1. Decide only what instruments to use and improvise freely. Let the
improvisation run for about five minutes before bringing it to a close.
Listen to a playback and discuss the strengths and weaknesses - what
was there too much of, too little of?
[N.B. This stage will inevitably be a bit of a ''free for all" and it is important
to move on to stages 2 and 3 as soon as possible so that students do not become
discouraged. Stage 1 is, nevertheless, an important starting point since it
allows students to gauge their development.]
2. Limit players to single sounds only. They may make a range of sounds
but only one at a time. A single sound is anything which is less than
two distinct sounds (you might consider a glissando as a single sound
because it is continuous, even though a large number of pitches may be
covered). Play back and discuss - were there enough pauses, enough
highs and lows?
6. By this stage improvisations should begin and end under their own
steam. Begin with a period of silence and let the players break it with
the first sounds -nothing should be prearranged, someone will begin!
As the players become better listeners they will also intuitively know
when an improvisation is finished. This ability will probably have to
be worked on. There is always someone in a group who wants to keep
playing when all others have ceased•. Try this stage a few times, play
back and discuss the ending of the improvisation.
Probably at this point the participants will want to find a way of preserving the
improvisation, of notating it in some form so that it can be repeated. See chapter
on Notation.
The danger is always that students may revert to dealing in musical cliches
(scales, arpeggios etc.) and that the imaginative ground gained will be lost.
Teachers should always be aware of this possibility and, depending on the
maturity of a class, the matter might be raised as a discussion point.
Generally students seem to find the notion of cliches a difficult one to grasp.
However if the experience of the initial stages of improvisation has been
positive, effective and stimulating it may be possible to channel some of the
benefits into dealing with rhythm and melody.
Beginning after stage 7 (above) introduce the concept of each player evolving
an individual rhythm, perhaps based on their names. Players should
initially be quite independent of one another and should vary speeds and
attacks. Perhaps at a preordained point (or maybe this can happen in a less
contrived way) players should begin to bring their rhythms into
synchronisation with each other. By the end of the improvisation there
should be virtual rhythmic unity.
The next stage is to allow considerably greater freedom. The aim is not now
that everyone should end up playing the same rhythm, but that there should
be a 11Sense" of unanimity. In other words the players begin by being
"individuals" and move towards playing as a group.
What can be done for rhythm can equally be done for pitch. The following
activity works best with a large number of people -the more, the better.
Activity
1. Take or write a short poem, comprising a number of short lines of
unequal length. Some of the lines might just contain one word.
Allocate each line a number from one to ten- you may repeat numbers
and should use more large numbers than small. This represents how
many times each line should be sung.
4. Singers may move slowly around the space, from time to time, though
when they are standing still they should have their eyes closed.
5. When each singer reaches the last repetition of a line, the pitch may be
altered and the singers should adopt the pitch being sung by a person
nearby. As the piece progresses, then, the number of different pitches
in use will gradually diminish and, if the piece goes on long enough, a
6. When all lines of the poem have been sung the requisite number of
times, each singer should hum the note they have arrived at ten or more
times.
The above activity can be extremely powerful and can be prolonged for half an
hour or more. Clearly the longer it lasts the more likely it is that a unison will
be obtained. However it would be a:shame' to··see the goal of the piece asthe
search for a unison. As with the rhythmicimprovisation above, the aim is really
to establish a point of rest, of resolution.
Almost the opposite of this pitch improvisation is a simple melodic one. Any
melody might be used, preferably one which is well known and does not
involve a large number of pitches. The opening line or two of Advance
Australia Fair might serve.
Activity
1. One singer begins by slowly singing a short, simple melody (with or
without words, although words will give the piece a more interesting
texture). The melody is repeated over and over. Other singers
gradually pick out the pitches in the melody and prolong them, humming,
building up a chord based on the pitches in the theme.
2. When each singer has firmly established one· of these pitches, they can
begin to sing the melody themselves using their pitch as the starting,
point. Do not try to synchronise rhythmically with anyone else.
All the above improvisations are tried and true and all have worked with
students of different ages, from primary to tertiary. They can often be combined
in various ways and should be regarded with the utmost flexibility. The
These activities should be undertaken on a regular basis. The early stages of the
first one might be omitted as students become more practiced. But "practice"
is indeed the key word here. Good improvisation is a skill and like any other
will improve with regular work.
After frequent participation in these activities students should:
2. feed off the ideas of other participants and therefore enjoy a constructive
and cooperative environment
We tend to group sounds into the categories "pleasant'' and "unpleasant''. Bird
song is good, traffic noise is bad. Note the terms used to describe each. Singing
is a fine thing but noise is an irritant. This "pleasantness" or "unpleasantness"
is extremely subjective.
Sound
Activity
Make a list of the sounds you can hear from:
a) the classroom
b) the playground
c) your bedroom
12for 1 copy to Angela Pryce. 26 Feb 2016.
This eBook is licensed
1. Describe the sounds in words. What do they consist of?
2. Try to draw the sounds. How can you best represent them visually?
5. Now tell the other people what the actual sounds were and ask them to
perform themaga~ How.do·their·performances change?;. - . .
Scientifically, the term "noise'' is used to describe more complex sounds. When
a bow is drawn across a violin string it produces two sounds- the tone produced
by the bowing and the "noise" of the bow itself on the string. The tone is a
relatively pure sound, on an oscilloscope (which measures vibrations) it would
produce a regular pattern, but the noise of the bow would produce an irregular
pattern.
In the following examples, the relatively "pure" tone of an instrument such as
Tone
'Noise'
Activity
1. Take a wire coat hanger.
2. Tie a length of cotton (about a metre) to the coat hanger, so that you can
suspend it with the hook hanging down.
3. Place the cotton over the top of your head and push the cotton into your
ears with your fingers.
Activity
Speak to your Science or Physics Department. They will have experiments
which you can do to demonstrate how these vibrations occur.
The purest sound of all is a sine wave. All other sounds are made up of many
sine waves.
H someone in your class plays a stringed instrument ask them to demonstrate
the harmonics on each string. These harmonics are very similar to sine waves
(though they are not quite as pure).
The following line represents one of the strings of a violin (or any other stringed
instrument, including a guitar or a piano). The wavy lines are its vibrations.
When we touch the string at its halfway point, we reveal the lowest and simplest
of the harmonics which go to make up the tone produced by bowing or plucking
the open string. This harmonic is· one octave above that tone. We call the tone
itself the fundamental.
H we touch the string one third of the way along its length we reveal the next
harmonic. This is one octave and a fifth above the fundamental.
II
., 0
e- etc
"fundamental"
Activity
Try calling your friend's name across a distance. If you are intent on making
contact you will not scream or shout the name but sing it and you will
inevitably sing one particular interval, the falling minor 3rd.
This is true in virtually every culture in the world and there is a reason for it.
The reason is the Harmonic Series.
The minor third or "calling interval" is so natural to us because the pitches of
which it consists are the first two notes of the harmonic series which are not C
-namely G and E (where Cis the fundamental).
If we add in the next different harmonic;. A, we end up with the pitches which
constitute that international playground favourite:
Activity
Use a pentatonic scale [say, C-D- F- G- A] to create a pitched improvisation.
Tuned percussion creates an attractive sound and presents no intonation
problems, but any combination of instruments and voices may be used.
It will help if a simple rhythm is used (once again this might be based on
people's names- use surnames as well as first names). Once the rhythm is
established add to it, embellish it, change it.
The pitches can be used randomly but what you are now producing are
simple melodies.
The next stage is to attempt to repeat the melodies you are producing. Which
sound the best? Try to notate them with their rhythms.
Similar activities can be undertaken with other scales.
Activity
1. Take four pitches which are very close together - they might be four
consecutive chromatic pitches.
4. Develop. patterns and, once again, notate the most effective ones.
Activity
This is for more advanced students.
1. Write the names of the twelve chromatic pitches on small pieces of
paper (each pitch should appear twice- ie. there should be twenty-four
pieces of paper).
2. Draw five or six out of a hat. You might have one or two notes repeated.
3. You must use the pitches in the order in which they appeared from the
hat and repeat none until the others have been used.
Pitches as we have seen can be ordered into groups or scales. Besides the
familiar pentatonic, chromatic, major and minor scales there are many others.
Here are some examples.
u {e)
O II e
0 II
II e
e fe
II
e e II
e
II II
II II
e
Activity
1. Make up a scale using the intervals of a semitone, whole tone and minor
third.
Example.
.. j~ct e
e ., fe II
3. Are any of the notes in the scale more important than others? Can you
say why?
4. With the whole tone scale (above) you can start on any note and the scale
will sound the same. What happens to the scales you have invented
when you play them from different starting points?
Activity
1. Use one of your scales. to' make a piece of music. Use only th~ notes of.
your scale.
3. Is there a sense in which any of the notes in the scale seem like a 11tonic"
or home note? Is there a musical 11centre of gravity"?
If we take drawing as perhaps the best example, it is quite clear that the pencil
or pen can be used to create single lines- continuous or fragmented. The Swiss
artist Paul Klee spoke of "taking a line for a walk"- that is, he would put his pen
on the page and then allow it to wander around without leaving contact with
the paper. But a pen can also be used to shade an area of paper, producing a
larger mass or block.
Look at some of the work of the artist Brett Whiteley. His paintings are an
especially good example of the differing uses of blocks and lines.
2. Now make a movement for every sound you hear. This exercise can be
carried out with a variety of different styles and moods of music. If you
can find a way of anchoring the paper you can also use a pencil in each
hand (if they are of different colours you will be able to see what you
have done better when the music stops and you open your eyes).
3. Does this activity bring. you ·closer to the music to which you are
listening?
4. Can you see the link between the block and the line in the music and on
the page?
5. Are there any other links between what you heard and what you drew?
Mood, for example?
NB. THIS ACTIVITY IS BEST CARRIED OUT ON THE FLOOR WITH THE
LARGEST PIECE OF PAPER POSSIBLE. EVEN SO IT IS RECOMMENDED
THAT THE FLOOR IS FIRST STREWN WITH NEWSPAPER, OTHERWISE
WHENYOURUNOVERTHEEDGEOFYOURPAGE~CHYOUALMOST
CERTAINLY WILL) YOU WILL BE DRAWING ON THE FLOOR!
Activity
1. Listen to a wide range .of. pieces, of music (different styles, different
genres). [Ex. a piece by Ros Bandt, a short movement from John Antill's
Corroboree, a song from Arnhem 'Land, by Don Burrows.]
3. [For older students] Is there any such thing as truly nonharmonic music
or does even a monody carry an 11implict harmony"?
Activity
1. Compose (improvise) a piece of music which makes use of the distinction
between 11block" and 111ine". The blocks should be dense accumulations
of sound and fairly static (you might use repetition, fewer pitches,
rhythmic unison etc.). The lines should involve a certain independence
on the part of the instruments or voices taking part.
•••
0
8Jo
Once again, this is only an example. Dense, black areas might indicate loud
sounds or they might simply imply many instruments or voices. Black dots
might refer to small 11explosions" of sound, pauses, unisons, anything... It
is important that students devise their own notation and also provide a Key
to the symbols used.
After working through these activities students should be able to:
1. analyse and describe sounds
2. begin to be able to manipulate pitches, melodically and harmonically
3. have a strong feeling for musical texture and a sense of "where a piece is
going''
4. be more self-critical and. more articulate in terms of the. music they
compose.
They should also be more attuned to connections between sounds and visual
signs. In other words the last Activities .in this chapter should enable students
to go beyond the level of associating a piece of music with a particular mental
picture. Instead they may begin to grasp connections between musical and
visual shapes, colours and textures.
These concepts can be difficult (and rather sophisticated to explain) and so,
instead, these Activities will help students to experience them.
This should be an invaluable aid to working not only on further aspects of
composition (especially notation), but also an aid to more advanced and critical
listening. It could even provoke a more innovative and imaginative approach
to the area of musicology, prompting an interest, for example, in works of visual
art, contemporary with musical works studied.
Rhythm is quite a hard word to define although we probably all think we know
what it means. It should not, for instance, be confused with pulse or metre.
Pulse is the underlying unit of tempo (time), metre describes the groupings of
pulse into which the music falls.
In the following example the tempo is allegro (fast), the pulse is crotchets, and
the metre is three crotchets to the· bar~
Allegro
So, what is rhythm? The rhythm of this example is the "rate of change" of the
pitches. We hear this as a pattern, formed by the sound durations.
Rhythm is a very important part of our every day speech (see Chapter 1: What
is Musical Composition?)
Activity
Find the rhythm of your name as you speak it. Clap it. Different names have
different rhythms.
Example.
.["l.
Ro - bert
JDa J
vid
r==:Jco - JIa
Ni -
3
J
Cyn -
~
thi - a
J
) r==:J J
E - li - za - beth
Now try putting together the names of your friends and yourself. Put them
end to end, overlap them, superimpose them. Speak or clap them.
Activity
What are our endogenous rhythms?
Breathing, pulse and heart beat, walking
etc. What do these rhythms have in common?
One person begins to walk, slowly but evenly. Another person walks a little
faster, but also evenly.
Listen to the two pulses. When do they coincide? After how many 11beats"?
Now each 11Walker'' should put a stress on their right foot, but keep the pulse
of their steps absolutely steady - still one 11Walker'' faster than the other.
One half of the class ~ight clap with one 11Walker", the other half with the
other. You must be very precise.
Activity
Time your breathing. Keep it as natural as possible (difficult when you are
concentrating on it). How many seconds does it take to complete a cycle (in
and out)?
Activity
Someone with a watch should clap a beat every five seconds.
Everyone else, with eyes shut, should attempt to clap with them.
Then the interval should be increased to ten seconds, fifteen, twenty, even
thirty.
Activity
1. Take a scale (see pp.17 and 18). Begin with two players each with a
metronome.
4. Each player uses the scale to improvise at one of the two speeds. (It
might be a good idea if the two players have become used to their
respective pulses separately, prior to putting them together. It might
also be wise to place the.playersat opposite ends of the room so that they ..
can concentrate better on their individual pulses.)
.5. The players should not simply play one note for each beat, but use the
pulses as a basis and subdivide as much as they like.
6. Later on you might try more players and more pulses and/or metronome
speeds which are more complex (e.g. 60 against 69, 80 against 90). Here
there is little or no relation between the pulses and so each voice will
retain its independence - at least at one level. However, does the
listener, perhaps, attempt to find connections between the different
musical lines? Can the listener's perceptions be altered by using
instruments/voices which blend or do not blend? [See next chapter on
Timbre.]
What can you tell about the different layers of sound? Do they blend? Would
you say that the music makes a great use of rhythm? Can you walk to this
music? Can you dance to it? Does it make you want to tap your foot?
Can you perceive a strong and regular sense of meter? If not, how does the
composer or performer use meter? Are there many changes?
After these activities have been worked through, students should have developed
a strong sense of:
1. endogenous time
2. endogenous rhythm
3. pulse
4. tempo
Activity
1. Compare the sounds of all the instruments and voices you have available.
3. What are the ranges of each voice and each instrument in your group?
Activity
1. Try pairing the instruments - have them play together.
2. Which instruments blend? Which don't? Why? Try to put into words
the similarities and differences of character of these voices/instruments
as they are paired.
Activity
Compose a short piece of music for one or more instruments and try to take
the characteristics of each one into account.
For example a flute can play from middle C to the D three octaves higher, but
A flute can however produce a relatively long note whereas, as we have said,
a guitar cannot. But even a flute player has to breathe and the note must stop .
eventually. A violinist, on the other hand. can (theoretically) keep going for
ever. All that might hinder a continuous sound is the player's ability to make
even bow changes and risk Repetitive Strain Injury!
Try to take as many of these factors into account in your music. If you play
an instrument yourself, compose your piece for someone else. You will need
to ask the player a lot of questions: about their instrument and what they can
and cannot do on it. -
Probably after they have played your piece, you will also need to make some
alterations. It's a bit like being a tailor fitting a suit.
These activities aim to make students more sensitive to timbre and instrumentation
in general. After working on them, students should be able to:
1. recognise and describe the timbres of various instruments
2. combine instrumental timbres in imaginative ways.
Most music is not written down. Aboriginal music, folk music, the blues, jazz,
the classical music of India, African drumming, Indonesian gamelan, rock 'n'
roll - all have tended to belong to oral traditions. The music, like the skills
required to perform it, has been passed on from player to player, or from
generation to generation, by imitation and by word of mouth. And since the
invention of the sound recording there has been even less reason to write music
down.
The Western classical tradition, of course, is different. It has always existed on
paper. It is not alone. The Chinese, for instance, were notating music at least
two thousand years ago. The reasons for this important difference, between
broadly "classical" and "folk" musics will be discussed in the chapter on Style.
What concerns us here is the enormous range of possibilities connected with the
notation of music and the almost equally large range of potential meanings
which those notations have.
Why notate? Well if you have already worked through some of the activities
described on the earlier pages, you will almost certainly have found the need to
evolve some form of shorthand means of writing down some of the music you
have invented.
Really, all musical notation is shorthand of one sort or another. To notate a piece
of music precisely is, ultimately, impossible. To attempt it would require more
space in the score than would be sensible or indeed practical. If we take what,
on the face it, seems to be a fairly straightforward piece of notation, the
pizzicato, we will begin to see the problem.
In most Western classical music the plucking (as opposed to bowing) of a string
is notated by putting the abbreviation "pizz." above the note to be plucked. But
what exactly does this mean? Plucked how? With the finger nail? The pad of
the finger? And which finger? And plucked in what direction?
The notation of Chinese lute music tells us all this; it also has distinct symbols
for twenty-six different types of vibrato. In the Western classical tradition,
vibrato is either not notated at all or simply represented by the abbreviation
"vib" or a wiggly line over the note.
Of course it all depends on what you need to notate. Western music has
traditionally been less concerned with the quality or type of sound than with its
actual pitch. Whether or not music is notated, and, if it is, how it is notated,
depends upon the musical traditions of a particular culture. As dance has
developed over the centuries and become more complex (particularly in ballet
This eBook is licensed28
for 1 copy to Angela Pryce. 26 Feb 2016.
and its related areas) many people have attempted to notate steps and gestures.
We still have no single, unified system for dance notation.
Activity
With a partner, try to write down as many features of a particular sound as
possible. One person might play or sing a sound, the other person tries to
record all its aspects.
What about articulation? How does the sound begin, how is it 11attacked"?
Activity
Try to find appropriate ways of notating sounds around you.
In pairs, give each other sounds to notate (eg. dropping a saucepan lid, tearing
paper, snapping fingers, clapping hands, etc.)
Activity
1. Divide into two groups working quite independently.
3. How can you record it on paper so that the other group can play it? If you
want it repeated as exactly as possible (and you do!) what will be
essential to notate?
4. Once you have decided on that, the problem becomes one of finding the
clearest means of notation. In some ways words are always the clearest.
This eBook is licensed for 1 copy to Angela Pryce. 26 Feb 2016.
29
to invent signs which would produce the required meanings? Don't
forget that if the signs are invented, rather than borrowed from another
source they will have to be explained in words, otherwise they will not
be understood at all.
5. You might use colours, pictures, words, diagrams or anything at all. But
in order to produce the best perfomance from the other players who,
after all, do not have the advantage of having heard the tape, the score
you give them must be clear and simple.
NB. These activities should be undertaken with reference to the section on graphic
notation beginning on p.19 (Block and Line).
These activities are designed to enable~students to make connections betwen
sounds and signs. At the end of these activities students should be able to:
1. invent appropriate notations for the music they create
2. interpret creatively notations which are presented to them by other
students.
Eflat
If musical composition is the organising of sound, the form into which these
sounds are arranged is obviously very important.
Contrary to what many text books say, there are no rules governing form .. To
read certain authorities is to learn that, for example, Sonata Form was handed
down to composers on a stone tablet. In fact, as with any other successful
musical structure,. it arose quite: naturally' out of the musical,,Ianguage .of the,,., ..
eighteenth century;~ a harmonic tendency to oscillate between the twin .poles of
the tonic and dominant created a musical form whose very existence depends
upon that type of polarity.
The concept of a section of music which remains the same on each appearance
and punctuates the rest of the music, which is changing, is extremely basic and
relates to what we might call the "fixed" and the "free". In all art it is possible
to analyse works in terms of what is fixed and unchanging and what is free and
constantly developing. It is very rare to find a piece of music or a painting in
which nothing is repeated.
Activity
Take a scale and, using the principles ofblock and line (see p.19), treatitfirst
horizontally (one note: after: another) and then vertically (several notes. at
once). The appearances of the vertical blocks should remain the same each
time, but allow the horizontal line to change fractionally.
In the above activity the blocks form a kind of chorus responding to the lines.
We might say that the lines are the verses.
It is possible to represent the music you have composed in the following way:
A - B - A - Bl - A - B2 - A - etc.
This kind of verse and refrain form is extremely common in all manner of
musical styles, from rock music to opera. But it is certainly most common in
"folk-related" music.
An extension of the form also occurs in classical music. This is the Rondo. Here
Activity
Take two contrasting scales. Use one for the refrain and one for the verses.
Invent a short, repetitious melody for the refrain and find a way of using the
other scale for the verses so thatit begins on a. different pitch each time. Aim,
also, to give the verse a different rhythmic shape on each appearance.
Activity
(The examples provided are only illustrations. Students should find their own
scale and invent their own transformations).
Take a scale.
e e
II
e fe
~ • • • • • #• • • •
• • •
This eBook is licensed32
for 1 copy to Angela Pryce. 26 Feb 2016.
Find a rhythm which is appropriate to your pitch order. In doing this you
will need to consider which of your pitches are more important than others.
Where are the points of maximum tension and relaxation as you hear them?
Is it possible further to increase the effect of your melodic line by the use of
Octave Displacement? In other words, does it help to move certain pitches
out of the octave to increase their potency?
What about speed and dynamics and articulation? You can alter the 11meaning''
of your melodic line quite a lot by varying these elements.
>
f ===- pp f :::::>- -== f L- 3
..J
::::::==- p -==== mf = - PP
II
f ::::::- mp
If you are composing a melodic line you may well know from the beginning that
you want it to be very quiet, or to begin fast and then slow down. You might also
have an idea of the shape of the melody before you decide on the pitches to be
used.
It is often the case that a melodic line will grow in a rather "organic'' way, from
note to note.
Activity
(As before, examples are only illustrations).
Give it a shape.
/P ---=========
How can you make the shape clearer?
$1J J
> ~---------
Jp
fp f
or shorten it,
or lengthen it,
I
> .._.... - - - - - - -
p 1===-P I P--
>
=
..__...
I P --=========== I
f p =f p --======== f
All music has form, large scale and small scale. It is the principle by which the
sounds are organised and given meaning.
When we compose we analyse the form ofthe music we are writing. Obviously
we do not generally do so in quite as clinical a way as we have in the previous
two activities. But even if the process is largely subconscious or even instinctive,.
the decision which governs what note to compose next is basically an analytical
one.
At the end of these activities students will have a knowledge of some of the
various means of allowing a simple musical idea to proliferate and grow into a
more elaborate one.
In this section we have spoken of form as though it is related only to pitch and,
specifically, to melody. But form can arise from any aspect of music. Density
of sound, dynamics, timbre, rhythm .., all are capable of defining form.
Throughout this book you will have been recording your improvisations and
compositions in order to help you criticise your work.
Sound recording revolutionised music. At the touch of a button we can hear
practically any music we want~4essthan a·hundred years ago listening to music
was a far more difficult business unless you played or sang it yourself.
But the tape recorder has done more than change people's listening habits, ithas
also made a big impact on the composition of music. Besides commercial
considerations (ie. it is now possible to make an enormous amount of money
from composition if enough people buy your recording) the technical resources
of the composer have been greatly expanded.
Activity
You will ideally need tape editing facilities or two tape recorders, one of
which has four or eight tracks. However if neither of these facilities is
available two or more single track tape recorders will do (the more, the
better).
3. Will these be prerecorded and a part of the tape or will they be played
live in performance, alongside the tape part?
4. Will the sounds of the instruments blend with the other sounds? If so
how?
5. Are you going to select instruments and voices because they blend or
because they don't?
If you want a sound to repeat continuously you might consider setting up-:-a
tape loop. This is easy to do. You:.will only need a milk bottle and a tape
recorder, although obviously you will need a reel to reel model and not a
cassette player!
1. Take the sound you want to have repeated and edit it off the tape- even
if you don't have editing equipment you can make a rough edit with a
pair of scissors.
2. You now have a loose length of tape. Make it into a loop with a small
piece of editing tape and thread it through the heads of the tape recorder
with the neck of a standing milk bottle taking up the slack.
4. Once you have managed to create your loop with its repeating sound or
sounds, how can it be used most effectively? In other words, what
5. If you are fortunate enough to have more than one tape recorder, try
setting up a number of loops of different lengths. Some will repeat
more frequently than others.
Activity
Even if your school does: not have a reel to reel tape recorder, you can still
achieve excellenhresults .with: as few as· two· cassette recorders,. recording , .
sounds from one to the other. As you do this some of the earliest recorded
sounds will deteriorate in quality, but this in itself can be interesting.
Try something like this yourself. You will be surprised how noisy is the
room in which you are sitting.
These activities will give the student a great deal of flexibility and control in
ordering and arranging sounds. Particularly important is this element of
control.
But also one should not under-estimate the degree of "instantaneous gratification"
-that is to say that the results can be heard almost immediately. This should not
only instil confidence into the student; quick results will also make for effective ..
teaching.
Finally, the exercise is useful in that students will have created a piece of music
which will sound identical each time it is played, and this makes it easier for
them to hone their powers of self-criticism.
Setting words to music is, therefore, a very basic function of composition. How
isit done?
Activity
1. Take or write a short poem.
3. Read it aloud.
A poem will have its own rhythm, in a sense its own music. Certain words are
more important than others, both in meaning and in terms of that rhythm. As
we have seen, we use pitch all the time when we speak and when you read
When we sing words we often take more time than if we had spoken them. We
can, for instance, give two or three (or more) pitches to one syllable. The tune
will usually have a life of its own, even if it has been inspired by the words. The
words occasionally have to be made to fit the tune.
Activity
1. Take the song you wrote or write another or take any other song.
2. Can you find instances where the words have been made to fit the
music?
3. And the other way round? Are there places where the music has been
changed to fit the words?
Music can be used in order to give words extra meaning, to make them clear or
to illustrate them. It can even say the opposite of what the words appear to
mean. Think of Midnight Oil's songs. Very often the words are extremely
angry, even depressing or lacking hope - but the music is uplifting and
optimistic.
In some songs the music actually paints pictures or imitates the meaning of the
words. If, for instance, the words of a song suggest someone ascending stairs,
the melodic line might also move upwards. This example is very simple, but the
device can be extremely effective.
Activity
1. Try to make your music match your words. Think of the meaning of the
words you are using and find some musical counterparts to them.
3. Do they describe any particular images which have sounds built into
them (eg. bells, water, wind etc.)?
These activities will help students to combine words and music with sensitivity.
The students will need to think about the words and the way in which the music
fits them.
This eBook is licensed 41
for 1 copy to Angela Pryce. 26 Feb 2016.
Style
"Style" is a word which we tend to use quite a lot in our everyday life. We might
say that someone "dresses stylishly'' or even that they '1ive stylishly". Things
"come into style" and go out again. We are generally talking about outward
appearance and about what is fashionable.
But we can also say that something is "really not my style"- meaning that it does
not fit in with our preferences;,our likesandcdislikes;the way we live our own
life.
In a sense both of these meanings can be attached to the use of the word "style"
when we are talking about music. If, for the sake of argument, Peter Sculthorpe
were to compose a country and western song, the music would be in that
particular style - it would have the outward appearance of a country and
western tune. But, almost inevitably, it would also have another kind of style
-Peter Sculthorpe's own style.
In fact Sculthorpe has provided us with quite a few real examples of precisely
this distinction. His piece Koto Music, for piano, is based on the music of that
Japanese instrument, Sun Music III and Tabuh Tabuhan use musical ideas
from Bali, his orchestral piece Kakadu uses some melodic ideas from the music
of the Aboriginal people in that area. But all of this music is recognisable as
Sculthorpe. It bears the stylistic traces of the composer, rather like musical
finger prints.
A better analogy for "personal musical style" might be a "voice print''. If you
have ever tried to disguise your voice
on the ,telephone, you will know
how difficult this is to do. The
friend on the other end of the phone
usually sees through the disguise
almost immediately. We can try to
sound like someone else and adopt
some of their vocal characteristics
and mannerisms, but there will
always be elements of our own voice
remaining.
Music which lives as an oral tradition, which is not generally written down
obviously requires a very strong sense of 11generic style". An extreme example
of this would be the music of Aboriginal Australians.
Of course there are many types of music amongst the Aboriginal peoples. A
great deal of it has specific functions. It is often associated, for instance, with
particular rituals (the same could be argued of most other kinds of music, but
that discussion can wait).
Therefore, in the twentieth century, many music scholars and performers have
been attempting to uncover the equivalent of an oral tradition surrounding this
music. They have gone to paintings of the period and noticed the size and lay
out of orchestras. They have consulted writings by composers and performers
of the day and discovered details about instrument design of two and three
hundred years ago and about performing practices, such as the use of
ornamentation in melodic lines.
Activity
Spend some time turning the dial on your radio. Listen to the different types
of music you hear and try to categorise them.
Folk? Which country does it come from? Is it a love song, a protest song or
what?
Pop? Is that rock 'n' roll? Or soul? Or reggae? Do you think the musicians
are black or white?
This eBook is licensed 43
for 1 copy to Angela Pryce. 26 Feb 2016.
Oassical? Do you mean baroque? Or romantic? Or twentieth century? Can
you tell which country the music comes from? Or even which composer?
Each time ask yourself, #How do I know? What is it that tells me?" And try
to write down the characteristics of the music which lead you to your
conclusion.
We said earlier that Aboriginal music often has a function, that it is often part
of a ritual. But there is also a strong element of ritual associated with many
other types of music.
For example, when people go to a concert of classical music they often dress up.
Even if they do notthe musicians almost always do. The audience generally sits
in silence and anyone, who .claps between .movements will be hushed by. th~
others. In other words there is a whole pattern of behaviour which is regarded
as "normal" in the concert hall, but which would be seen as quite bizarre, say,
at a disco.
Activity
Make a list of the kinds of ritual behaviour which you might notice and be
expected to follow in the following situations.
1. A symphony concert
2. A rock concert
Can you find any connections between these. patterns of behaviour and the
music itself?
Jazz however has a far more recent history. And, whilst there has been music
which we might describe as "popular" for as long as there has been a sheet
music business and a recording industry, rock music is very recent indeed. We
can point to the roots of rock music in the blues and in country & western music.
We can go further back and discover connections in the drumming and vocal
music of West Africa and the dances of Europe. But rock music itself really
began sometime in the 1950s.
Because of its relative youth and the fact that the twelve bar blues provides an
extremely strong model for much of rock music, there have not been changes in
Activity
Listen to a range of rock music from the fifties, sixties, seventies and eighties.
Try to find accompanying photographs or videos of the performers.
We have begun to see, then, that the style of a piece of music, at least its "generic
style", is related to its social function and this is true whichever culture's music
you look at. In Indian classical music, for example, a particular Raga (a partly
improvised piece based on a certain scale) is associated with a certain time of
day. To perform anearly.morning raga in the evening would be the equivalent
of serving Weetbix at a dinner party.
It follows that there are many concepts which are important in one type of music
which are quite unimportant in others. The idea, for instance, of having a
''beautiful" voice- so important in Western operatic music- would not be
understood in parts of Africa. To be sure, there are singers in African
communities who are widely regarded and revered for their singing ability, but
this is much more connected to how they sing than it is to the quality of their
voices. Indeed this is just one example of the Mrican influence on rock music.
Activity
Collect, with reference to the other kits in this series, examples of Aboriginal,
folk, classical, popular, ethnic and jazz music. A couple of examples of each
will do.
3. Is timbre important in this music? Can you say how it's important?
4. How many layers of sound can you detect? Are the pieces of music with
most layers more complex?
5. What do you think is the function of this music? What is its point?
There is any number of books on the subject of composition many of which are
just a little dubious and full of value judgements - one type of music is better
than another. Below is an extremely select bibliography which is largely
technical rather than inspirational. For further reading teachers are referred to
the other Sounds Australian kits on Aboriginal, Ethnic, Jazz, Popular, Folk and
Classical music, each of which. contains compositional exercises in particular
styles and each·otwhich has• its~ own bibliography.
This is a select discography. of music which will be of use for listening and
discussioninrelationtotheprecedingchapters. Aswithanydiscographyitwill
be out of date within weeks of publication. New recordings will have been
released which should be included and some of those mentioned below will
have inevitably been deleted- such is the "shelf-life" of recordings. Nevertheless
all items listed are good quality recordings and all contain several works of
interest. All will be of use with other AMC Resource Kits.
What Is Composition?
Mann The Rationales NMATAPES 5, NMA Publications
Nagorcka Atom Bomb (excerpt) NMATAPES 2, NMA
Publications
Improvisation
Bandt Genesis MD 3075 CD and cassette, OZM2006
Stargazer: Car Park Pieces Move Records MS 3075
LP, MC 3075 cassette, MD 3075 CD
Sound
Burt Music for Tuning Forks Scarlet Aardvark Tapes
SAT-TFI
Hykes Hearing Solar Winds
Rhythm
Antill Corroboree TCOASD7603
Smetanin Ladder of Escape Attacca Babel 8365-4
Wesley-Smith For Bass Clarinet & Tape·Attacca Babel8365-4
Various Australian Percussion Music Vol.l/Michael Askill
Southern Cross SCCD 1021, LP or CD, includes
Westlake's Omphalo Centric Lecture (also Wesley-
Smith's White Knight & Beaver, Sculthorpe's How
the stars were made and Edwards' Marimba Dances)
Timbre
Australian Percussion Music and Sculthorpe as above
Notation
Bauld One Pearl OZM2005 cassette
Lumsdaine Kangaroo Hunt OZM2004 cassette
Meale Corruscations RCA VRLl-0083 LP
Form
Smetanin and Sculthorpe as above
Sculthorpe Sun Music I-IV OASD7604 LP and cassette
Style
There are some suggestions made in the chapter itself but it is best to make your
own, varied selection. A good starting point, however, might be the compact
disc/ cassette mentioned below which contains five very different orchestral.
pieces.