Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 51 views

    Sevcenko Tomb-Isaak-Komnenos

    Uploaded by

    adashik
    The document summarizes the tomb of Isaak Komnenos located at Pherrai, Greece. Some key details: 1) Isaak Komnenos was a Byzantine prince who fell out with his brother the Emperor in 1122 and spent years in exile before being recalled in 1136. He founded a monastery dedicated to the Virgin Mary at Pherrai. 2) Isaak's tomb at the original location in Constantinople's Monastery of Chora is described, including marble slabs, bronze railings, and icons of his parents. He insisted that his portrait remain at Chora. 3) At Pherrai, Isaak's tomb was to be located in an "

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Sevcenko Tomb-Isaak-Komnenos

    Uploaded by

    adashik
    51 views6 pages
    The document summarizes the tomb of Isaak Komnenos located at Pherrai, Greece. Some key details: 1) Isaak Komnenos was a Byzantine prince who fell out with his brother the Emperor in 1122 and spent years in exile before being recalled in 1136. He founded a monastery dedicated to the Virgin Mary at Pherrai. 2) Isaak's tomb at the original location in Constantinople's Monastery of Chora is described, including marble slabs, bronze railings, and icons of his parents. He insisted that his portrait remain at Chora. 3) At Pherrai, Isaak's tomb was to be located in an "

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    The document summarizes the tomb of Isaak Komnenos located at Pherrai, Greece. Some key details: 1) Isaak Komnenos was a Byzantine prince who fell out with his brother the Emperor in 1122 and spent years in exile before being recalled in 1136. He founded a monastery dedicated to the Virgin Mary at Pherrai. 2) Isaak's tomb at the original location in Constantinople's Monastery of Chora is described, including marble slabs, bronze railings, and icons of his parents. He insisted that his portrait remain at Chora. 3) At Pherrai, Isaak's tomb was to be located in an "

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    51 views6 pages

    Sevcenko Tomb-Isaak-Komnenos

    Uploaded by

    adashik
    The document summarizes the tomb of Isaak Komnenos located at Pherrai, Greece. Some key details: 1) Isaak Komnenos was a Byzantine prince who fell out with his brother the Emperor in 1122 and spent years in exile before being recalled in 1136. He founded a monastery dedicated to the Virgin Mary at Pherrai. 2) Isaak's tomb at the original location in Constantinople's Monastery of Chora is described, including marble slabs, bronze railings, and icons of his parents. He insisted that his portrait remain at Chora. 3) At Pherrai, Isaak's tomb was to be located in an "

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    of 6

    THE TOMB OF ISAAK KOMNENOS AT

    PHERRAI

    Nancy P. Sevöenko

    THE SEBASTOKRATOR Isaak Komnenos was born in 1093; he was


    the son of the Emperor Alexios I, the younger brother of Anna
    Komnene and of the Emperor John II, and father of Andronikos I.
    We hear of him in various contexts: as the man who may have com-
    missioned the Octateuch of the Seraglio and as the probable author
    of both Homeric and theological treatises, a man praised for his literary
    and charitable activités by Theodore Pródromos but condemned for
    sedition by contemporary historians. He fell out with his brother John
    in 1122, and for the next fourteen years wandered, stirring up insur-
    rection, in the Holy Land and among the Seljuk Turks. Though recon-
    ciled with his brother in 1136, he was apparently again in exile at the
    time of John's death in 1143, when he was recalled by his nephew,
    Manuel I.1 In 1152, embittered, and in poor health, he began to com-
    pose a rather disorderly Typikon for a monastery dedicated to the Virgin
    Kosmosoteira, located at a place called Βήρα; this monastery he himself
    had founded, and in it he wished to be buried.2 Βήρα has been iden-
    For the biography of Isaak, and his literary and artistic endeavors, cf. Th. Uspen-
    skij, "Konstantinopol'skij seral'skij kodeks vosmikhniZija." Izvestija russkago arx-
    eologiceskago Instituía ν Konsíaníinopole, 12 (1907), 1-33; Ed. Kurtz, "Unedierte Tex-
    te aus der Zeit des Kaisers Johannes Komnenos," Byzantinische Zeitschrift, 16 (1907),
    esp. 101-19; O. Jurewicz, Andronikos I Komnenos (Amsterdam, 1970), pp. 28-38; P.
    Schreiner, Die byzantinische Kleinchroniken, 1 (Vienna, 1975), p. 55 (for the date of
    Isaak's birth); J.F. Kindstrand, Isaac Porphyrogeniíus, Praefatio inHomerum( = Acta
    Universitatis Upsaliensis, Studia Graeca Upsaliensia, 14) (Uppsala, 1979), pp. 13-20 (at-
    tributes the treatises to this Isaak, rather than to the Isaak who was brother of Alexios
    I); J.C. Anderson, "The Seraglio Octateuch and the Kokkinobaphos Master," Dum-
    barton Oaks Papers, 36 (1982), esp. 84-86.
    2
    L. Petit, "Typikon du monastère de la Kosmosotira près d'Aenos," Izvestija
    russkago arxeologiöeskago Instituía ν Konstant inopoie, 13 (1908) 17-75.1 am preparing
    an English translation of this Typikon for a volume of translations of Typika to be
    published by Dumbarton Oaks. The Typikon, though started in 1152, was by no means
    dictated all at one time. Issak, for example, does not refer to his tomb at all until Sec­
    tion 89 of the Typikon; he must have decided to have it moved from Chora only when
    he saw the monastery close to completion. There is other evidence in the later sections

    135
    136 Nancy Sevcenko

    tified with Pherrai, a town in Greek Thrace not far from Alexan-
    droupolis and the Turkish border. In the town of Pherrai there stands
    today a large church of the Komnenian period, in plan a modified cross-
    in-square, adorned with frescoes of the twelfth century (Fig. 1). This
    church is presumed to have been the katholikon of Isaak's monastery
    of the Kosmosoteira.3
    During his happier years at the court of Constantinople, Isaak ap­
    parently erected a tomb for himself in the Monastery of Chora, for
    in the Typikon he requests that various elements of the structure at
    Chora be removed and shipped to his new foundation.4 His anxiety
    over this move led him to set forth his instructions in some detail; he
    thus furnishes us with precious information about what constituted a
    princely tomb of the first half of the twelfth century.
    Isaak speaks first of transferring the marble slabs which were to
    house his remains: his tomb then was probably not a hollowed-out sar-
    cophagos but was composed of several pieces of marble fitted together.
    He speaks, too, of a cast bronze railing, of an icon stand, and of images
    (the word used is στήλαι) of his parents, i.e. Alexios and Irene, all of
    which had apparently already been set up in Chora. There was also an
    image of himself there, which he insists be not removed.5 Incidentally,
    Isaak later gives special orders that there be no image made of him
    anywhere at all in the new monastery.6
    Isaak goes on to say that in the middle of the lid of the tomb "I

    of the Typikon of changes in plan occuring as construction progressed (e.g. in the loca­
    tion of icons and in the burial places of his close associates). Despite his poor health,
    then, Isaak must have lived on for quite some time after 1152, and have continued to
    add new instructions to the Typikon.
    3
    The identification was first made by Uspenskij (cf. note 1 above). Petit proposed
    another church nearer the sea, the Παναγία Σκαλωτή (cf. note 2 above, p. 19), but
    Uspenskij's identification has been generally accepted. A. Orlandos, "Τα Βυζαντινά
    μνημεία της Βήρας," Θρακικά 4 (1933) 3-44; Nancy Patterson (Sevòenko), "Byzantine
    Frescoes at Pherrai " (M.A. Thesis, Columbia University, 1964); D. Mouriki, "Stylistic
    Trends in Monumental Painting of Greece during the Eleventh and Twelfth Centuries,"
    Dumbarion Oaks Papers 34/35 (1982) 103-05, figs. 45-49.
    4
    Section 89, Petit, p. 63. The date of the tomb at Chora is unknown. It seems hard
    to believe that Isaak was planning his tomb before 1122, i.e. while still in his 20s. The
    portrait of himself which he says was done in "the vanity of youth," must date before
    1122, since when Isaak returned to Constantinople from exile, he was already forty-three
    years old. But the tomb project itself may date from this later period, and have merely
    incorporated an early portrait into its design.
    5
    A portrait of Isaak as a donor forms part of the early fourteenth century mosaic
    decoration at Chora commissioned by Theodore Metochites, a later benefactor of the
    church, P. Underwood, The Kariye Djami (Bollingen Series, N.Y., 1966), 1 pp. 11-13,
    45-48; 2, Plates pp. 36 and 37.
    6
    Section 77, Petit, p. 59. The passage indicates that such commemorative portraiture
    must have been considered routine.
    The Tomb of Isaak Komnenos 137

    want my enkolpion [of] the Theotokos to be fastened (literally "en­


    graved") in a prone position in [a setting of] silver work; it has been
    readied and handed over, and I have just now deposited it in the
    treasury."7 The passage is somewhat puzzling, but I take it to mean
    that his own enkolpion is to be set in silver into the marble lid of the
    tomb. We know of silver sheathing for tombs, but I am not aware of
    parallels for this sort of silver insert. The "prone position" of the Virgin
    suggests that she was depicted on the enkolpion standing up, so that
    when placed on the flat lid, she would of course appear to be lying
    down. It is, however, conceivable that Isaak means that a replica of
    his enkolpion is to be made in silver and placed on the lid, as a sort
    of revetment.
    The most precious adornment of his tomb, according to Isaak, will
    be the mosaic icon he owns of the Virgin Kosmosoteira, which came
    to him, he says, by an act of God from Rhaidestos (modern Tekirdag
    in Turkish Thrace). The icon must have been originally in Chora, as
    he speaks of transferring its stand from there, but he has apparently
    had it with him from the time the monastery dedicated to the
    Kosmosoteira was founded. He has provided the icon with a decora­
    tion of gold and silver (κόσμον περιεθέμην χρυσού και αργύρου, pro­
    bably a silver-gilt frame),8 and he requests that the icon be affixed to
    one end of the tomb, along with the one of Christ which is of the same
    size.9 The icon type, the Virgin Kosmosoteira, incidentally, is other­
    wise unattested. In the Typikon, he makes provision for proper lighting
    of these icons, and even for their conservation; when they fall into
    disrepair, he says, they should be removed from their wooden backing
    and reset by a first-rate technician onto good elm boards.10
    Περί δέ γε το πτώμα μέσον του τάφου έγκολαφθηναι την Θεοτόκον το έμον
    έγκόλπιον έν ύπτίω τω σχήματι βούλομαι δια του αργυρού δργου, δπερ εύθειασ-
    θέν τώ σκευοφυλακίω ετέθη τήν σήμερον και παραδέδοται. Section 89, Petit,
    p. 63.*
    The term κόσμος could equally well mean a revetment, rather than a frame, but
    surviving mosaic icons often have silver or gold frames and rarely any revetment. Cf.
    the eleventh-century mosaic icon of Saint Nicholas on Patmos, M. Chatzedakes, Είκό-
    νες της Πάτμου (Athens, 1977), 1, pp. 44-45 and PI. 1. Cf. also A. Grabar, Les revêie-
    menís en or eí en argení des icônes byzaníines du moyen âge ( = Bibliothèque de
    Γ Institut hellénique d'études byzantines et post-byzantines de Venise, 7) (Venice,
    1975).
    9
    Sections 1, 9, 89, 90, Petit, pp. 19, 23-24, 63-64. While in exile Isaak composed a
    poem to the Virgin with an appeal for salvation, Ed. Kurtz, "Ein Gedicht des
    Sebastokrator Isaakios Komnenos," Byzantinisch-Neugriechische Jahrbücher, 5 (1926-27)
    44-46. The poem would seem to be addressed to an image of the Virgin and Child. It
    should be noted that Isaak donated a book containing some of his own "ekphraseis"
    to the monastery library, Section 106, Petit, p. 69. Section 9 of the Typikon (Petit, p.
    24), which concerns the icon of the Kosmosoteira, itself reads a little like an ekphrasis.
    10
    Section 109, Petit, p. 71.
    138 Nancy Sevcenko

    The tomb was to be located in the left part of the narthex, there
    where, he says, "I made an extension (παρεκβολή) to the building for
    11
    my tomb." This brings up another puzzle: What sort of space did
    the tomb occupy? Was Isaak talking about a separate structure, a real
    tomb chamber attached to the narthex, or about something smaller,
    an arcosolium niche, for example, at one end of it?
    Turning back to the Typikon, we find that Isaak says that the rail­
    ing to be brought from Chora should separate the tomb from "the
    whole of the narthex." And in it should be an entrance-way so that
    the monks can go in after Vespers and recite the Trisagion before the
    two icons, plus forty Kyrie Eleisons for the repose of his soul before
    they retire to their cells.12 Now the monastery was designed to have at
    least fifty "singing" monks,13 and unless we assume they filed in one
    by one, we should probably reconstruct Isaak's tomb as a separate
    chamber large enough to accomodate at least a portion of them.
    Turning for confirmation to the evidence provided by the structures
    surviving at Pherrai, we discover to our regret that, though there are
    paving stones visible to the West of the present West wall of the church,
    no narthex has been preserved—neither esonarthex nor exonarthex, both
    of which are mentioned in the Typikon. However, the small domed
    NW and SW corner bays of the cross-in-square church each have a very
    tall recess 2.70m. long and .80m. deep in their Western wall. Robert
    Ousterhout has recently suggested that the tomb could have been located
    in one of these.14
    There are two difficulties with this intriguing proposal which make
    me at present somewhat hesitant to accept it. We would have to assume
    1) that Isaak would term this Western bay of his cross-in-square church
    "the narthex," and 2) that he would use the word παρεκβολή, an "ex­
    tension," with reference to such a recess. This word, it seems to me,
    would more aptly describe a structure like the little burial chamber
    attached to the North wall of the Παναγία των Χαλκέων,
    Thessalonike.15 But Professor Ousterhout is undertaking a new study
    of the church architecture, and only when his observations on the ac­
    tual remains become available, can the issue begin to be settled.
    11
    Section 89, Petit, p. 63.
    12
    Sections 7, 90, Petit, pp. 22-23, 64.
    13
    Sections 3, Petit, p. 21. There were also to be 24 monks serving the needs of these 50.
    14
    "The Architecture of the Kariye Camii in Istanbul,'* PhD thesis, University of Il­
    linois at Urbana/Champaign, 1982, p. 113.
    15
    D.E. Evangelides, Ή Παναγία των Χαλκέων (Thessalonike, 1954) figs. 1-2, PI. 5b.
    Uspenskij's photograph of the church from the West (cf. note 1 above, PI. 2) shows a struc­
    ture adjoining its NW corner (no longer extant). Orlandos' plan indicates a door in the
    North wall of the church (now blocked by a buttress) which probably communicated with
    this structure (cf. note 3 above, fig. 6). But neither author gives us any indication of date.
    The Tomb of Isaak Komnenos 139

    In the meantime, the Typikon is the sole evidence we have con­


    cerning the appearance of the tomb. Accessible from the narthex
    through a bronze grill, the tomb chamber would have contained a mar­
    ble coffin with some silver inlay or revetment, icon stands carrying two
    mosaic icons in fancy frames, panels with the portraits of Alexios and
    Irene, lamp stands, and still enough space for a good number of monks
    to assemble for a final prayer.
    Was Isaak's tomb ever actually built? All we know for sure is that
    Isaak was buried in his monastery: Choniates reports that in 1183 An-
    dronikos I rode by with a royal hunting party and visited his father's
    grave.16 And in the church was found a broken marble slab, inscribed
    with what are evidently the seven final lines of an epitaph; the very
    last of these lines mentions a δεσπότης—not a sebastokrator, to be
    sure, but close enough, given theflowerylanguage of the inscription,
    to warrant the assumption that the slab once adorned Isaak's tomb.17
    But whether the monks at Chora ever really consented to hand over
    the crucial parts of his tomb, and whether it was ever reassembled as
    and where Isaak envisioned it, we simply cannot tell.
    ,6
    Niketas Choniates, Historia, De Andr. I Comn., p. 280: 30-39, ed. Van Dieten
    (Berlin, 1975).
    17
    Uspenskij, "Konstantinopol'skij serai'skij Kodeks vosmikhntëija" (note 1 above),
    p. 26 and PI. 6; Orlandos, "Τα Βυζαντινά μνημεία της Βήρας," pp. 27-28, fig. 19.
    1. Pherrai: View of the church of the Virgin Kosmosoteira from the Southwest (Photo: N. SevCenko)

    You might also like