Marketing in the World of Hi-Tech &

Innovation (MWHTI)
Course Outline 2018-20 PGP Term IV, IIM
Bangalore

Prakash Bagri

0
 Background

The high technology (hi-tech) world is characterized by a chaotic environment in which the
products, players and users are constantly changing. Profitable and well-differentiated products
segments could suddenly face commoditization pressures at the entry segment, or even
disruptive technologies at the high end eating into their business. Technology innovation could
lead to blurring of boundaries between different product segments. Newer distribution or
ownership models could lead to need for re-education of consumers and integration of
services. Even the role of different players in distribution chain could evolve as each tries to
move up in value with increasing deliverables.

This constant churn and ever-changing industry dynamics has fundamental implications for
marketing. Today’s technology marketers face challenges across the marketing mix, starting
with the need to provide clear differentiation, positioning, better integration across offerings
and newer and more effective ways of providing value to the customer.

Despite such complexities, the hi-tech world continues to provide exciting and newer business
opportunities. Whereas in traditional and mature markets a new entrant or small player is
unlikely to compete effectively with established leaders, the hi-tech world offers tremendous
prospects for innovation and entrepreneurship, both for established companies as well as new
players.

Such opportunities are pursued by multiple aspirants with exciting new technologies, and the
winner is usually the one with the strongest market model. Success amidst this dynamic and
turbulent environment calls for diverse skills, an understanding of a wide range of capabilities
and an approach beyond the traditional gamut of marketing management.

Given the dynamic environments and fast paced nature of hi-tech industries, they provide
great context for appreciating long-term business strategy in general and for managing and
marketing innovation in particular.

1
 Course Overview

“Marketing in the World of Hi-Tech & Innovation (MWHTI)” is intended to address some of
the earlier outlined challenges and consequent marketing dynamics.

This course will focus on the application of basic business framework in the hi-tech context
while including those concepts unique to this world. It will build understanding on specifics of
high technology business and its difference from regular businesses. It will subsequently
introduce tools and techniques for more effectively developing strategic market models and
marketing plans for hi-tech products and services. The focus will be in guiding business persons
and marketers on how to adapt, modify and prioritize the basic tenets of marketing, while
incorporating the unique and specific hi-tech aspects.

Given the context, the course will not focus on some adjacent topics. Specifically, it will not
focus on (1) how to employ technology as a marketing tool (digital marketing), (2) identifying
“hot technologies” of today or the future, (3) overall organizational technology strategy and (4)
organizational culture and climate in technology companies. Nonetheless, some of these
subjects will find mention or will appear in discussions, without being the key concern for the
sessions.

The course will attempt to explore a range and diversity of industries and contexts within hi-
tech, but based on the available and published pedagogy, a significant focus will emerge on
information technology. However, given their specific characteristics these illustrations and
lessons will be very relevant to all new age businesses and industries and those that are now
emerging or just starting-up.

This course is intended for students preparing for a sustained career in the hi-tech industry or
for those planning to join start-ups or to become entrepreneurs. Students seeking roles in
sales, marketing and business or product development in hardware or software, newer &
emerging technologies, around the internet as well as in companies providing B2B or B2C
services & solutions will find the tenets of this course relevant for their career goals.

2
 Course Text & Readings

The following book will serve as the primary text for the course:

Marketing of High Technology Products and Innovations

Authors: Jakki J. Mohr, Sanjit Sengupta, Stanley F. Slater

The course pack distributed along with contains a wide selection of readings which are being
provided as a precursor to class discussions.

Recommended readings are outlined in the Session Plan, with supplementary bibliography
appended as Annexure I. Readings should be completed prior to the respective sessions. Class
material will supplement the texts and will be made available after sessions.

Additionally, a selection of global media articles and thought-leader perspectives are curated
by the instructor on Flipboard as follows.

Understanding Innovation & Technology

by Prakash Bagri

http://flip.it/X0ufj

Students are welcome to subscribe, contribute and interact therein, if they wish to stay abreast
of current developments and cross-link those with course learnings.

3
 Course Objectives

This course will explore the following with reference to hi-tech and innovation businesses:

1. Defining characteristics and major forces of differentiation

2. Types of innovations and implications for business
3. Strategic market planning tools & techniques
4. Business model development
5. Adaptations to the marketing mix

Pedagogy & Evaluation

This course will use a mixture of different learning and teaching techniques including lectures,
real-life examples, expert opinions, case discussions and articles from academic and business
journals along with and project work.

The students will be graded as follows on each of the segments for the final evaluation:

End-term Examination (Open Book): 20%

Project Work: 25%
Class Assignments (Case, Articles etc.): 25%
Mid-term Examination (Closed Book): 30%

A document titled Achieving the Course Objectives will be provided with this Course Outline.
It details expectations (including time-lines, submission guidelines and grading particulars)
around each of the components of Class lectures, articles & readings, case analysis and group
project work. Students are advised to review the same and seek clarifications during the
initial sessions itself.

4
5
Session Plan (Indicative)

Session Coverage (Student Activity) Compulsory Readings Suggested Readings

1 Hi-Tech Introduction  Mohr, Ch 1 Case Analysis Questions (Class Discussion Only)
 Why High Tech & Innovation Marketing? The Value of Networks by Farris, Pfeifer & 1. What as per your analysis should Praxim do? Why?
2. Which strategic model/s did you use to analyze the situation?
 Defining Characteristics Johnson
3. How has the PC industry evolved since 1998?
 Network Effects
Case of the Profitless PC by Blackburn,
Halprin & Veloria (1998)  Clockspeed: Winning Industry Control in the Age
of Temporary Advantage by Fine
2 Understanding Innovation Types of Innovation: Several Types on Henderson, R. M., & Clark, K. B. (1990). Architectural
 Nature of Innovation Many Fronts by Harvard Business Essentials innovation: The reconfiguration of existing product
 Contingency Model for Hi-Tech Marketing (Chapter 1) technologies and the failure of established firms.
Administrative science quarterly, 9-30.

3 Technology Cycles Performance Provided etc by Christensen  The Innovator's Dilemma: When New Tech Cause
 Technology S Curves & Life Cycle Reinventing Your Business Model by Great Firms to Fail by Christensen
 Dominant Design & Industry Standards Johnson, Christensen & Kagermann
 Competitive Volatility & Business Models Anderson, P., & Tushman, M. L. (1990). Technological
discontinuities & dominant designs: A cyclical model of tech
change. Administrative science quarterly, 604-33.
4 Strategic Market Planning - I  Mohr, Ch 2  Value Migration: How to Think Several Moves
 Competitive Advantage in Technology  How to Anticipate Value Migration by Ahead of the Competition by Slywotzky
 Value Migration Slywotzky Case Discussion Questions (Group Discussion*)
 Strategic Planning Models Overview # Case of the Profitless PC continued 4. With which of the experts’ analysis do you agree?
(Expert Commentary) by Dubinsky, Keeley, 5. Are there learnings from the case relevant for some other tech
Ward, Quesnelle, Pifer & Moore# industries?

# Will be handed over in Class after Session 1 (Not to be included in Course Binder)

Session plan above is indicative and subject to change. They will be continuously updated as the course progresses, including reshuffling if required.

6
Session Coverage (Student Activity) Compulsory Readings Suggested Readings
5 **Case Discussion (Group Presentation) Study Questions:
1. Examine the major shifts in Netflix’s strategy, and causes for the same.
2. Did Netflix do the same jobs for consumers as Blockbuster did? How did it evolve over time?
Netflix
3. Compare Blockbuster & Netflix’s value networks and business models. How does it affect their respective strategies?
by Willy Shih, Stephen P. Kaufman, David Spinola 4. Of the options available in front of Hastings, which one would you recommend and why?
HBR Case Study ( 2007)
6 Strategic Market Planning –II From value chain to value network by  Innovator's Solution: Creating and Sustaining
 Deliberate vs. Emergent Strategy Formation Peppard & Rylander Successful Growth by Clayton M. Christensen, Michael
 Strategic Fit & Value Network E. Raynor
 Strategic Dissonance Burgelman, R. A., & Grove, A. S. (1996). Strategic
dissonance. California management review, 38(2), 8-28.
7 Partnerships & Alliances  Mohr, Ch 5  The Death of Competition: Leadership and
 Role of Business Ecosystem Ecosystem Advantage: How to successfully Strategy in the Age of Business Ecosystems by James
 Types of partnerships & alliances etc. by Williamson & De Meyer F. Moore
 Co-optition Art of Standards Wars by Shapiro & Varian
The Right Game: Use Game Theory etc by
Brandenburger & Nalebuff

8 Understanding Technology Customers – I  Mohr, Ch 7  Crossing the Chasm: Marketing and Selling High-
 Diffusion of Innovation Models Technology Products to Mainstream Customers by
 Technology Adoption Life Cycle Geoffrey A. Moore
 Crossing the Chasm  Diffusion of Innovations by Everett M. Rogers

7
Session Coverage (Student Activity) Compulsory Readings Suggested Readings
9 **Case Discussion (Group Presentation) Study Questions:
1. Analyse Second Life’s position w.r.t. it’s industry and it’s ecosystem.
2. What strategic options does Second Life have? How can it Cross the Chasm into the mainstream?
Linden Lab: Crossing the Chasm
3. Propose a comprehensive Bowling Alley approach to market development including choice of beachhead segment as well
by Thomas R. Eisenmann; Alison Berkley Wagonfeld as whole product development.
HBS, 2009
10 Understanding Technology Customers - II  Living on the Fault Line by Moore  Inside the Tornado: Marketing Strategies from
 Technology Adoption Life Cycle (contd/-) Silicon Valley's Cutting Edge by Geoffrey A. Moore
 Rogers Five Factors (Product Differences)
 Bass Model of Diffusion

11 Technology Business Models & Multi-Sided Markets Every Product’s a Platform by Sviokla & Paoni What Airbnb, Uber, and Alibaba Have in Common by Libert,
Strategies for Two-Sided Markets by Beck, Fenley & Wind
 Business Models Perspective Eisenmann, Parker & Van Alstyne
 Two-sided Market Characteristics Staged Solution to the Catch-22 by Hagiu &
Eisenmann
 Factors to Success

12 Linking Customer Approach to Product Development  Mohr, Ch 6 Chandrasekaran, D., & Tellis, G. J. (2007). A critical
 Design Thinking review of marketing research on diffusion of new products.
 Research Techniques In Review of marketing research (pp. 39-80). Emerald Group
 Feature Fatigue Publishing Limited.
Thompson, D. V., Hamilton, R. W., & Rust, R. T. (2005).
Feature fatigue: When product capabilities become too
much of a good thing. Journal of marketing research, 42(4),
431-442.

8
Session Coverage (Student Activity) Compulsory Readings Suggested Readings
13 Technology Asset Management  Mohr, Ch 7 Product Strategy for High Technology Companies by
 Technology Mapping  Building the Foundation: Product Michael E. Mcgrath
 Modularity Platform Strategy by McGrath
 Platforms & Derivatives Managing in an Age of Modularity by
Baldwin & Clark

14 **Case Discussion (Group Presentation) Study Questions:

1. Analyse the structural attractiveness of the console industry in 2008 and over time
2. What has been the basis of innovation in the videogame console industry across generations?
Responding to the Wii? 3. How did Sony manage to regain leadership across two successive generations of consoles?
by Andrei Hagiu & Hanna Halaburda 4. Why was Microsoft unsuccessful in replicating its PC industry-like arrangement here?
Harvard Business School, 2010 5. Of the strategic options available to Sony, which one would you recommend and why?

15 Pricing & Supply Chain  Mohr, Chs 9 & 10

 Technology Pricing Paradox Competing Against Free by Bryce, Dyer &
 Harmonized, Integrated & Multi-channels Hatch
 Mapping Supply Chain to Innovation Versioning: The Smart Way to Sell
Information by Shapiro & Varian
 New Perspectives Aligning Supply Chains Strategies with
Product Uncertainties by Lee
16 Branding & Marketing Communications in Hi-Tech  Mohr, Chs 11 & 12
 Integrated Marketing Communications
 Strategic Brand Considerations
 Ingredient Branding

9
Session Coverage (Student Activity) Compulsory Readings Suggested Readings
17 **Case Discussion (Group Presentation) Study Questions:
1. What factors accounted for i-mode’s overwhelming success in Japan?
2. Describe the i-mode value proposition from the perspective of the various parties in its value network.
NTT DoCoMo: Marketing i-mode, 3. Describe i-mode’s customer base. How has it changed over time?
by Youngme Moon 4. How did i-mode ensure business profitability?
Harvard Business School, 2002 5. What are the prospects for DoCoMo’s 3G(FOMA) service? How would you market it?

18 Managing Innovation Case: Synthes by Gourville (2002) Case Analysis Question

 Innovation Success (Group Discussion) Are "bioresorbable implants" worth the risk for Synthes? Take a
stance and defend it.
 Putting it Together

19

PROJECT PRESENTATIONS
20 & COURSE WRAP UP

10
Annexure: Recommended Readings

The Innovator's Dilemma: When New Technologies Cause Great Firms

to Fail (2013)
Authors: Clayton M. Christensen
ISBN: 0875845851 or 978-0875845852

Marketing of High Technology Products and Innovations (2010) –

Authors: Jakki J. Mohr, Sanjit Sengupta, Stanley F. Slater
ISBN: 9788131761076

Clockspeed: Winning Industry Control in the Age of Temporary

Advantage (1999)
Author: Charles H. Fine
ISBN: 0738201537 or 978-0738201535

Value Migration: How to Think Several Moves Ahead of the

Competition (1995)
Author: Adrian J. Slywotzky
ISBN: 0875846327 or 978-0875846323

Innovator's Solution: Creating and Sustaining Successful Growth

(2013)
Authors: Clayton M. Christensen, Michael E. Raynor
ISBN: 1422196577 or 978-1422196571

11
Annexure I: Recommended Readings continued

Crossing the Chasm: Marketing and Selling High-Technology Products

to Mainstream Customers (2014)
Author: Geoffrey A. Moore
ISBN: 0066620023 or 978-0066620022

Inside the Tornado: Marketing Strategies from Silicon Valley's Cutting

Edge (2013)
Author: Geoffrey A. Moore
ISBN: 0887308244 or 978-0887308246

The Death of Competition: Leadership and Strategy in the Age of

Business Ecosystems (1999)
Author: James F. Moore
ISBN: 0887308503 or 978-0887308505

Product Strategy for High Technology Companies (2000)

Author: Michael E. Mcgrath
ISBN: 0071362460 or 978-007136246

12