11 Supplement - 5 175
11 Supplement - 5 175
11 Supplement - 5 175
Alex Lopata
Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, University of Melbourne,
Royal Women's Hospital, 132 Grattan Street, Carlton, Victoria 3053,
For information on the growth of the early human embryo in the genital tract
we still depend on the specimens collected by Hertig et al. (1956). In these
classical studies embryos were obtained from the uterus or Fallopian tubes, after
hysterectomies performed at estimated times following ovulation and conception
times based on recorded coital dates. On about day 3 after ovulation a 12-cell
embryo, possibly 60-72 h of age and described as a morula, was recovered from
the uterus. By day 4 after presumed ovulation an early blastocyst, containing 53
trophoblastic and five embryonic cells was obtained. While by day 4.5 .after
inferred ovulation, a zona-free blastocyst, containing 99 trophoblastic and eight
embryonic cells, was recovered from the uterus (Hertig et al., 1956). In these
and earlier studies the time of ovulation was estimated from menstrual cycle
data as well as endometrial and corpus luteum morphology (Hertig et al., 1954).
More recently, collecting embryos and ova from the uterus by non-surgical
procedures, after more precise detection of the expected times of ovulation, was
reported by two groups (Croxatto et al., 1972; Buster et ai., 1985). Croxatto
et al. used urinary luteinizing hormone (LH) and pregnanediol assays, and other
parameters, to predict ovulation which, in many cases, was also assumed to
correspond to the time of fertilization. In one woman they found a l2-16-cell
morula 4 days after the LH peak and 3 days after coitus, and in a second case a
16-cell morula which was considered to be 4-5 days old. They also recovered
an expanded zonal blastocyst, containing at least 186 cells, which was considered
to be 5 days or slightly older. Buster et al. (1985) used serum LH assays and
artificial inseminations to estimate ovulation and fertilization times. Embryos
were collected by non-surgical uterine lavages performed 5 days after the LH
peak. Five zona-enclosed blastocysts, with an estimated age ranging from
102.5-117 h, were recovered. However, embryos ranging from 2-16-cell stages
were also obtained during a similar time interval. The latter findings suggest that
delayed and arrested embryonic development, which is commonly observed
in vitro, also occurs following in-vivo fertilization and attempted in-situ growth.
Human Reproduction Volume 11 Supplement 1 1996 © European Society for Human Reproduction and Embryology 175
A.Lopata
176
Implantation of the human embryo
Corpus Luteum I
Oestrogen + Progesterone
... '.
Stromal Inner Cell
Cells " '"
Laminin .'. Mass
Figure 1. Interaction of tissues at implantation. In the embryonic compartment. shown in the box on the
right. the inner cell mass and trophectoderm probably influence each other through paracrine and contact
mechanisms. The polar trophectoderm interacts with uterine epithelium in primates through released signals
such as cytokines and eicosanoids as well as via the components of the glycocalyx and cell-cell attachments.
[ntegrins on the surface of the implanting trophectoderm are subsequently involved in the penetration process
by binding to laminin. fibronectin and other compounds in the epithelial basement membrane and the matrix
of the decidual stroma. The cellular and molecular composition of the stromal compartment. and the capacity
of the epithelium to induce decidualization. arc powerfully influenced by the sex steroids secreted by the
developing corpus luteum. Bidirectional arrows indicate feedback interactions between cellular and matrix
compartments.
Figure 2. The uterine epithelium appears to be an obligatory intermediate in inducing stromal transformation
(decidualization) during implantation. The epithelium is regarded as being an essential transducer that
delivers the deciduogenic signal(s) to the stroma. The nature of the transmitted epithelial signal(s) are not
known. Physiologically, the initial stimulus arises from the blastocyst, although decidualization can be
induced in the absence of an embryo. The three classes of inductive stimuli from the blastocyst are
illustrated by the arrows. The transformed stroma, in turn, directs cytodifferentiation and function of the
epithelium in contact with it (represented by the paracrine, endocrine and matrix feedback arrows). The sex
steroids have a critical priming role during these tissue interactions.
in the human. If the window of implantation lasts from 4-8 days, beginning on
about day 19 of the cycle, all normal embryos will have formed blastocysts that
have hatched during the receptive interval. Is it possible, therefore, to have
embryo--endometrial asynchrony in women who have an implantation window
spanning 4-8 days? As far as I am aware, there are no studies that correlate the
likelihood of implantation with morphological findings on embryos and uterine
epithelium, within transfer cycles, either at the light or electron microscopic
level. So at present we cannot define normal embryonic and endometrial
morphology, particularly between stimulated cycles, let alone the possible
abnormalities.
It is clear that good quality embryos need to be produced for successful
implantation. Virtually all patients can produce a good endometrium if levels of
oestrogen and progesterone are sufficient without being too high. It follows,
therefore, that any type of ovarian stimulation will produce an epithelium that
will be effective, providing the blastocysts are of sufficiently good quality.
Receptivity can only be induced at the site of the blastocyst within the uterine
cavity. In the absence of an embryo, there is no other way of defining receptivity.
Apart from my belief that the epithelium plays a passive role during blastocyst
penetration, I also consider that there is lack of strong evidence showing that
blastocysts firmly attach to the apical surface of the uterine epithelium. If they
do so, it is a very transitory process, since the blastocyst is very mobile.
In effect, perhaps one of the main roles of the uterine epithelium is to transmit
signals from the blastocyst to induce the decidual cell reaction (Figure 2). A
blastocyst would implant even if uterine epithelium was removed, but it would
not induce a decidual response which is the function of the epithelium. The
implanting blastocyst produces signals, perhaps prostaglandins, leucotrienes,
179
A.Lopata
Lam-Rec
iii'
:::il
. . . . . .L - - -1-
Laminin
---,
J
I:
Figure 3. Trophoblast invasion of decidua. Endometrial stromal cells that undergo decidual transformation
acquire the capacity to synthesize and secrete basement membrane proteins, such as laminin, fibronectin and
collagen type IV. The invasive trophoblast of the implanting embryo also expresses and releases some of
these proteins as well as surface receptors (e.g. integrins) for various matrix proteins. Invasive trophoblast
cells have also been found to produce plasminogen activator (u-PA), a serine proteinase that converts
plasminogen to plasmin. High affinity cell slllt'ace receptors (uPA-R) and binding sites for plasminogen and
plasmin serve to localize proteolytic activation to the pericellular area. The plasmin generated is able to
degrade extracellular components and to activate latent metalloproteinases, such as procollagenase. The
proteolytic activity of plasmin is regulated by PA inhibitors (PAI-I and PAI-2) and other proteinase
inhibitors. The events illustrated bring together adhesive and proteolytic interactions during implantation.
E1 = oestradiol:
P4 = progesterone.
The marmoset is a very suitable experimental model for human implantation. Its
reproductive cycle, which is normally 28 days, can be controlled by administering
a prostaglandin F2u analogue during the mid-luteal phase or early pregnancy, to
begin a new cycle (Summers et at., 1985). The marmoset ovulates about 8-9
1995), so we had cDNA available for both subunits. From these sequences, we
obtained riboprobes for the a- and ~-subunits, producing both sense and antisense
probes, which were labelled with digoxygenin for in-situ hybridization. Analyses
involving in-situ hybridization were then carried out on marmoset blastocysts
invading Matrigel4 days after hatching (Lopata et aI., 1995), i.e. early implantation
stages. As a positive control we used marmoset trophoblastic vesicles, which are
known to secrete bioactive CG in tissue culture (Summers et al., 1987; Simula
et al., 1995). Uterus, kidney and liver were used as negative controls.
The mRNA for CG-~ was predominantly expressed over the polar trophoblast
region. Some signals were found in mural trophoblast, but far fewer. Inner cell
mass had a low level of activity of the message for CG-~ in some cells, and
there was virtually no activity in the endoderm.
With the CG-a subunit anti-sense riboprobe, hybridization also occurred over
the polar trophoblast, but not as heavily. The transcript was uniformly distributed
both in polar and mural trophoblast, with some a-subunit activity showing up
distinctly in the inner cell mass. It appears that in the marmoset blastocyst, CG
activity is located predominantly in the area where the trophoblast is attaching
and implanting, whereas in differentiating tissues such as inner cell mass and
endoderm, the genes for the gonadotrophin are probably being inactivated.
182
Implantation of the human embryo
References
Alecozay, A. A. , Harper, M.J.K., Schenken, R.S. and Hanahan, D.J. (1991) Paracrine interactions
between platelet-activating factor and prostaglandins in hormonally-treated human luteal phase
endometrium in vitro. 1. Reprod. Fertil., 91, 301-312.
Bolton, V.N., Wren, M.E. and Parsons, J.H. (1991) Pregnancies after in vitro fertilization and
transfer of human blastocysts. Ferti!. Steril., 55, 830-832.
183
A.Lopata
Menezo , Y, Hazout, A., Dumont, M. et al. (1992) Co-culture of embryos on Vero cells and
transfer of blastocysts in humans. Hum. Reprod., 7 (Suppl. I), 101-106.
Navot. D., Anderson. T.L., Droesch, K. et al. (1989) Hormonal manipulation of endometrial
maturation. 1. Ciin. Endocrinol. Metab., 68, 801-807.
Olivenncs, F., Hazout, A., Lelaidier, C. et al. (1994) Four indications for embryo transfer at the
blastocyst stage. Hum. Reprod., 9, 2367-2373.
Rock, 1. and Hertig, A., T. (1948) The human conceptus during the first two weeks of gestation.
Am. 1. Obstet. Gynecol., 55, 6-17.
184