Effect of Different Substrate Alone and in Combination On The Sporophore Production of Elm Oyster Mushroom Hypsizygus Ulmarius
Effect of Different Substrate Alone and in Combination On The Sporophore Production of Elm Oyster Mushroom Hypsizygus Ulmarius
Effect of Different Substrate Alone and in Combination On The Sporophore Production of Elm Oyster Mushroom Hypsizygus Ulmarius
E-ISSN: 2278-4136
P-ISSN: 2349-8234
JPP 2019; 8(3): 3167-3171
Received: 25-03-2019
Effect of different substrate alone and in
Accepted: 27-04-2019 combination on the sporophore production of elm
Sutha Raja Kumar R oyster mushroom Hypsizygus ulmarius
Department of Plant Pathology,
Faculty of Agriculture
Annamalai University, Sutha Raja Kumar R, Eswaran A, Darwin Christdhas Henry, L Kannan C
Annamalai Nagar, Tamil Nadu,
India
and Jaiganesh V
Eswaran A Abstract
Department of Plant Pathology, Studies were conducted to assess the efficacy of different substrates, viz., banana leaves, casuarina needle,
Faculty of Agriculture coir pith, ground nut shell, paddy straw, sugarcane trash, sugarcane bagasse, saw dust and water hyacinth
Annamalai University, and supplements on the sporophore production. Among the different substrate paddy straw (489.6g bed-1)
Annamalai Nagar, Tamil Nadu was most efficient in enhancing the yield of H. ulmarius. Followed by water hyacinth (474.4g bed-1) and
India,
sugarcane trash (472.7g bed-1). Among the six different methods of sterilization tested, the chemical
Darwin Christdhas Henry
sterilization by soaking in 500 ppm formalin plus 75ppm carbendazim solution and autoclaving for 30 min.
Department of Plant Pathology, was observed to be the most efficient method of substrate sterilization which not only prevented
Faculty of Agriculture contamination by competitive fungi but also enhanced the yield of the mushrooms (489.5g bed-1). Among
Annamalai University, the different supplements, horse gram powder recorded the maximum sporophore yield and biological
Annamalai Nagar, Tamil Nadu, efficiency (498.6g bed-1 and 99.7%, respectively). Among the various agro wastes paddy straw plus water
India hyacinth recorded the maximum sporophore yield (498.9g bed-1) and biological efficiency (99.8%).
~ 3168 ~
Journal of Pharmacognosy and Phytochemistry
Table 1: Effect of bed substrate on the growth and sporophore yield of H. ulmarius
Spawn run Total yield Biological efficiency
Tr. No. Substrates Pinhead formation (days) Total duration No of sporophore bed-1
(days) (g bed-1) (%)
1 Banana leaves 18.9d 23.2c 49.5c 109.6c 437.1d 87.4
2 Coir pith 23.4h 28.9f 57.8f 54.3g 247.2g 49.4
f d d e
3 Casuarina needle 20.2 24.8 52.3 94.9 375.9e 75.2
4 Groundnut shell 18. 4c 22.8c 48.4c 112.5c 458.3c 91.7
5 Saw dust 20.7g 25.1e 54.7e 82.2f 326.8f 65.4
6 Sugarcane bagasse 19.4e 23.7c 51.2d 101.8d 401.5d 80.3
7 Sugarcane trash 17.9b 22.3b 47.8b 115.4b 472.7b 94.5
8 Water hyacinth 17.8b 21.9b 47.6b 115.6b 474.4b 94.9
9 Paddy straw 17.2a 21.1a 47.1a 119.6a 489.6a 97.9
Values not sharing a common superscript differ significantly at P<0.05 (DMRT)
The variations in the growth and yield parameters of the followed by soaking straw substrate in 0.1 per cent
different mushrooms may be due to the biological structure of carbendazim solution for 16 h. and boiling of presoaked straw
the substrate (Mahbuba, 2010) [13]. Mandeel et al. (2005) [14] for 30 min., recorded a contamination percentage of (6.4%,
reported that mushroom grows in a wide variety of 9.2%, 12.4%) and an yield of 472.7g, 454.9g and 449.7g bed-1,
lignocellulosic residues comprising 40-60 per cent cellulose, respectively whereas, the substrate without any sterilization
20-30 per cent hemicellulose and 15-30 per cent lignin. Cereal treatment recorded complete contamination by weed moulds
straws are rich in cellulose, hemicelluloses and lignin from (Table 2).
which the mushroom derives the nutrition (Biswas and Biswas, Sterilization of bed substrate is a must for reducing the
2015) [3]. The enhanced yield observed in paddy straw contamination from competitive fungi and increasing the yield
substrates could be due to the presence of favourable nutrients of mushrooms (Zadrazil and Grabbe, 1983) [31]. Singh and
that are better utilized by the fungus. Pleurotus spp. has the Singh (1991) [22] reported that soybean straw was best sterilized
capacity to degrade cellulose, hemicelluloses and lignin and to by steeping in a solution of formaldehyde at 500 ppm and
produce fruiting bodies. The poor growth and yield observed carbendazim at 75 ppm for 18 h. Pleurotus sp. was able to
with coir pith and saw dust substrate could be attributed to the tolerate higher levels of carbendazim (75-200ppm) during
rich lignin content in them and poor ability of H. ulmarius to chemical sterilization of paddy straw substrate (Nallathambi
degrade lignin like substances. and Marimuthu, 1992) [17]. Earanna and Shetty (1994) found
that when compared to steam sterilization method, the formalin
Evaluation of different methods of substrate pasteurization drench method was more effective in sterilizing paddy straw
for the cultivation of H. ulmarius substrate. Likewise, the yields of Pleurotus spp. were the
Among the six different methods of sterilization tested, the highest on paddy straw pre-treated with carbendazim (75 ppm)
chemical sterilization by soaking in 500 ppm formalin plus 75 plus formaldehyde (500ppm) (Nallathambi and Marimuthu,
ppm carbendazim solution and autoclaving for 30 min. was 1994) [18] and soaking of paddy straw for 20 min. in hot water
observed to be the most efficient method of substrate followed by 10 min. dip in 500 ppm solution of carbendazim
sterilization which not only prevented contamination by resulted in the maximum yield and was free from any
competitive fungi but also enhanced the yield of the contamination (Singh et al., 1997) [23] whereas, Eswaran and
mushrooms (489.5g bed-1) which was on par with chemical Ramabadran (1997) obtained maximum yield of Pleurotus sp.
sterilization alone by soaking in 500 ppm formalin plus 75 ppm from beds treated with carbendazim @ 25ppm and formalin @
carbendazim solution with nil contamination and an yield of 200ppm.
480.2g bed-1. Autoclaving pre-soaked straw for 30 min.
Table 2: Evaluation of different methods of substrate pasteurization for the cultivation of H. ulmarius
Tr. Spawn run Pinhead Total yield Biological
Methods of pasteurization Contamination (%)
No. (days) formation (days) (g bed-1) efficiency (%)
1 Boiling pre- soaked straw for 30 min. 12.4 18.5c 5.3b 449.7d 89.9
d c
2 Steaming pre- soaked straw for 30 min. 18.4 18.9 6.1 368.2e 73.6
3 Autoclaving pre- soaked straw for 30 min. 6.4 17.6b 4.2a 472.7c 94.5
4 Soaking straw in carbendazim 0.1% for 16 h. 2.1 24.1e 8.2d 354.9e 70.9
Soaking straw in carbendazim 0.01% 75 ppm +
5 0.0 17.2a 4.4a 480.2a 96.0
formalin 500 ppm for 16 h.
Soaking straw in carbendazim 0.01% 75 ppm +
6 0.0 17.3a 4.3a 489.5a 96.3
formalin 500 ppm for 16 h. + autoclaving for 30 min.
7 Control 81.3 21.4e 5.4b 116.3f 23.3
Values not sharing a common superscript differ significantly at P<0.05 (DMRT)
Effect of various organic additives to bed substrate on sporophore yield and biological efficiency (498.6g bed-1 and
sporophore production of H. ulmarius 99.7%, respectively) followed by red gram powder (492.2 g
From the data presented in table 3, all other supplements tested bed-1 and 98.4%, respectively) and calcium carbonate (486.1 g
except gypsum and black gram flour recorded increased yield bed-1 and 97.2% respectively). Paddy straw devoid of any
when compared to control. The supplements viz., horse gram, supplements served as control and recorded a sporophore yield
red gram powder and calcium carbonate Significantly of 481.3g bed-1 and 96.3 per cent biological efficiency.
enhanced the yield than all other treatments. Among the Estrada et al. (2009) [6] opined that supplementation is an
supplements, horse gram powder recorded the maximum important step in enhancing oyster mushroom production.
~ 3169 ~
Journal of Pharmacognosy and Phytochemistry
However, the supplement ratio should not be high due to the There is a direct correlation between the enhanced production
possibility of yield reduction (Fanadzo et al., 2010) [8], of different enzymes viz., cellulose(s), hemicellulose(s), and
possibility of contamination (Yildiz et al., 2002) [30], increase laccase, which degrades cellulose, hemicelluloses and lignin,
in the bed temp. and possibility of mycelium inhibition respectively which is induced by supplementing gram powder.
(Upadhyay et al., 2002) [28]. In the present study, The various organic and inorganic additives mostly influence
supplementation of horse gram and red gram powder recorded the production of enzymes by the mushroom fungi
a significant increase in the yield. Efficient utilization of (Arunprasad, 2004) [1]. Enzyme production by the fungal
lignocellulolytic substrates by mushroom fungi largely mycelium is of paramount importance in the colonization
depends on the activity of extracellular enzymes. In the beds process and also an important determinant of mushroom yield
supplemented with gram powder, an increased rate of (Ferdinandi et al., 2014) [9]. It is appropriate that the enhanced
decomposition was observed in the present study. Jaganathan yield observed in the present study might be attributed to the
(1972) [10] also observed increased rate of decomposition of increased enzyme activity due to the supplementation of gram
straw beds that were treated with amendments. This revealed powder (Munoz et al., 1997) [16] which would have triggered
that the enzymes are possible weapons for substrate quicker degradation of substrates lead to the release of nutrients
decomposition and yield enhancement. which were utilized by the fungus resulting in yield
enhancement.
Table 3; Effect of various organic additives to bed substrate on sporophore production of H. ulmarius
Additives Pinhead formation
Tr. No. Spawn run (days) Total duration Sporophore yield (g bed-1) Biological efficiency (%)
(@ 2 % bed-1) (days)
c c
1 Calcium carbonate 17.2 5.4 48.0d 486.1c 97.2
c c b
2 Corn flour 17.0 4.9 47.8 482.4c 96.5
3 Black gram flour 18.1d 6.2e 48.7c 447.5d 89.5
4 Gypsum 18.9e 7.4f 49.2e 426.8e 85.4
5 Horse gram flour 15.8a 3.9a 46.2a 498.6a 99.7
6 Rice flour 17.2c 5.7d 48.2c 482.9c 96.6
7 Red gram flour 16.3b 4.0b 46.5a 492.2b 98.4
8 Sorghum flour 16.6b 4.3b 47.3b 484.8c 96.9
9 Control 17.4c 5.6d 47.2b 481.3c 96.3
Values not sharing a common superscript differ significantly at P<0.05 (DMRT)
Effect of different combination of bed substrates on the paddy straw plus Sugarcane trash combination recording
yield of H. ulmarius (489.3g bed-1 and 97.9% respectively) while paddy straw alone
Among the various agro wastes viz., banana leaves, coconut recorded 482.6g bed-1 of sporophore yield and 96.5 per cent
leaves, cotton wastes, water hyacinth, groundnut shell and biological efficiency. The minimum biological efficiency
sugarcane trash, in combination with paddy straw, paddy straw (77.3%) and sporophore yield (386.4g bed-1) was recorded with
plus water hyacinth recorded the maximum sporophore yield the combination of paddy straw plus coconut leaves (Table 4).
(498.9g bed-1) and biological efficiency (99.8%) followed by
Table 4: Effect of different combination of bed substrates on the sporophore yield of H. ulmarius
Yield
Tr. No. Substrate combination (1:1) Spawn run (days) Pinhead formation (days) Total duration Biological efficiency (%)
(g bed-1)
1 Paddy straw + Banana leaves 17.3b 6.1d 48.9e 432.7 d 86.5
2 Paddy straw + Coconut leaves 19.2e 7.7e 49.9f 386.4e 77.3
3 Paddy straw + Cotton waste 18.3d 5.3c 48.1d 480.9c 96.2
c
4 Paddy straw + Groundnut shell 17.9 4.8b 47.6c 483.9c 96.8
5 Paddy straw + Sugarcane trash 17.0b 4.2a 46.0b 489.3b 97.9
6 Paddy straw + Water hyacinth 16.7a 4.0a 45.7a 498.9a 99.8
b
7 Paddy straw 17.4 4.7b 46.5b 482.6c 96.5
Values not sharing a common superscript differ significantly at P<0.05 (DMRT)
Paddy straw substrate was reported to be superior for (Shah et al., 2011) [21]. Besides, addition of water hyacinth
cultivation of oyster mushroom (Karthika and Murugesan, along with paddy straw (1:1) will therefore, reduce the
2015) [11], whereas in the present study maximum yield could mushroom production cost and would also help in recycle the
be obtained by using water hyacinth (WH) in combination with nuisance weed (water hyacinth) in an eco-friendly way.
the paddy straw. The significant enhancement in the yield
observed in the present study with paddy straw in combination References
with water hyacinth might be due to the supplementation of 1. Arunprasad M. Studies on potentiality of Lentinus
nutritional requirement of H. ulmarius being mitigated through conatus. For bio conservation of sugarcane trash
water hyacinth and paddy straw. Moreover, the spongy tissues Saccharum officinarum into potential bio-manure. Tamil
of water hyacinth might have also provided better aeration and Nadu. M.Sc. Ag. Thesis, Tamil Nadu Agricultural
water retention capacity to the beds which in combination with University, Madurai, India, 2004.
paddy straw substrate facilitated increased sporophore 2. Baysal E, Peker H, Yalinkilic MK, Temiz A. Cultivation
production. Besides, rapid degradation of complex of oyster mushroom on waste paper with some added
lignocellulosic components in water hyacinth leads to earlier supplementary materials. Bioresour Technol. 2003; 89:95-
mobilization of simple substances for initial mycelia growth 97.
~ 3170 ~
Journal of Pharmacognosy and Phytochemistry
3. Biswas MK, Biswas SM. Recycling of ligno-cellulosic mushroom yield, 2002. http://www.mushworld.com/tech
waste materials through oyster mushroom cultivation for /view.asp. cata_id=1120&vid=5136
sustainable food production. Int. J Env. Sci. 2015; 21. Shah F, Khan SS, Khan M, Tanveer A. Cultivation of
9(3):655-659. Pleurotus sajor-caju on wheat straw, water hyacinth and
4. Curvetto N, Figlas D, Delmastro S. Sunflower seed hulls their combinations. Indian J Fund. Appl. Life Sci. 2011;
as substrate for the cultivation of shiitake mushrooms. 1:56-59.
Hort. Technol. 2002; 12:652-655. 22. Singh A, Singh A. Studies on the utilization of soya bean
5. Earanna N, Shetty KS. Formalin control of brown spot straw for the production of Pleurotus sajor-caju. In: Proc.
disease on oyster mushroom substrate. In: Abs. Natl. Natl. Symp. Mush. Thiruvananthapuram, India, 1991; 90-
Symp. Mush. NCMRT Solan, India, 1994. 93.
6. Estrada AER, Jimenez-Gasco MD, Royse DJ. 23. Singh VK, Kumar M, Kumar H. Pink Mushroom: A new
Improvement of yield of Pleurotus eryngii var eryngii by oyster Mushroom suitable for North Bihar Agro climatic
substrate supplementation and use of a casing overlay. conditions. In: Abs. Indian Mushroom Conference ’97,
Biores. Biotechnol. 2009; 100:5270-5276. Sep, 10-12, 1997, NCMRT, Solan, India, 1997. (Abs. No.
7. Eswaran A, Ramabadran R. Studies on some 1.04).
physiological, cultural and postharvest aspects of oyster 24. Sivaprakasam K. Studies on oyster mushroom Pleurotus
mushroom, Pleurotus ostreatus. Trop. Agric. Res. 2000; sajor-caju Fr. Singer. Ph.D. Thesis, Tamil Nadu
12:360-374. Agricultural University, India, 1980.
8. Fanadzo M, Zireva DT, Dube E, Mashingaidze AB. 25. Tewari RP, Pandey M. Hindu Survey of Indian
Evaluation of various substrates and supplements for Agriculture, 2002; 165-167.
biological efficiency of Pleurotus sajor-caju and 26. Tshinyangu KK, Hennebert GL. Effect of synthetic
Pleurotus ostreatus. Afr. J Biotechnol. 2010; 9:2756- nutrient carriers on the fruiting of Pleurotus ostreatus var.
2761. Columbinus. World J Microbiol Bio technol. 1995;
9. Ferdinandi P, Godliving YSM, Anthony MM, Amelia KK. 54:249-254.
Ligninolytic enzymes activities of Pleurotus sapidus P969 27. Tsuchiya Y, Suzuki S, Inaba K, Sakaguchi T, Baba S,
during vegetative growth and fruit development on Miwa M. Impact of endothelin-1 on microcirculatory
sugarcane residues-based substrates. Int. J Biotechnol. disturbance after partial heaptectomy under
2014; 3(4):58-71. ischemia/reperfusion in thioacetamide-induced cirrhotic
10. Jaganathan G. Studies on certain mutants of Volvariella rats. Journal of Surgical Research. 2003; 111:100-108.
diplasia. M.Sc. Ag. Thesis, Annamalai University, 28. Upadhyay RC, Verma RN, Singh SK, Yadav MC. Effect
Annamalai Nagar, Tamil Nadu, India, 1972; 242. of organic nitrogen supplementation in Pleurotus species.
11. Karthika k, Murugesan S. Cultivation and determination Mush. Biol. Mush. Prod, 2002;
of nutritional value on edible mushroom Pleurotus 225-232.
ulmarius. Int. J Emerg. Res. Manag. Techonol. 2015; 29. Xing ZT, Cheng JH, Tan Q, Pan YJ. Effect of nutritional
4(2):29-36. parameters on laccasse production by the culinary and
12. Lelley JJ, Jan Ben A. Productivity improvement of oyster medicinal mushroom, Grifola frondosa. World J
mushroom substrate with a controlled release of nutrient. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 2006; 22:799-806.
Mush. News. 1993; 41:6-13. 30. Yildiz S, Yildiz UC, Gezer ED, Temiz A. Some
13. Mahbuba M, Nazim Uddin M, Saleh A, Nasrat JS, lignocellulosic wastes used as raw material in cultivation
Asaduzzaman K. Cultivation of different strains of king of the Pleurotus ostreatus culture mushroom. Process
oyster mushroom Pleurotus eryngii on saw dust and rice Biochem. 2002; 38:301-106.
straw in Bangladesh. Saudi J. Biol. Sci. 2010; 17:341-345. 31. Zadrazil F, Grabbe K. Edible mushrooms. In:
14. Mandeel QA, Al-Laith AA, Mohamed SA. Cultivation of Biotechnology a comprehensive treatise. H. Dellweg ed.
oyster mushrooms Pleurotus spp. on various lingo Verlag Chemie, Weinhum. 1983; 3:145-187.
cellulosic wastes. World J Micr. Biotec. 2005; 21:601-607.
15. Mukhopadhyay R, Chatterjee PB, Guha AK. Biochemical
changes during fermentation of edible mushroom
Pleurotus sajor-caju in whey. Process Biochem. 2002;
38:723-725.
16. Munoz Guillen F, Martinez AT, Martinez MJ. Induction
and characterization of laccase in the lingo lytic fungus
Pleurotus eryingii. Curr. Microbiol. 1997; 34:1-5.
17. Nallathambi P, Marimuthu T. Development of
carbendazim resistance in Pleurotus citrinopileatus.
Mush. Res. 1992; 1:123-125.
18. Nallathambi P, Marimuthu T. Effect of various substrate
treatments on enzyme activities of Pleurotus spp. in
correlation with yield. Indian J Mycol. Pl. Pathol. 1994;
24:167-171.
19. Ragunathan R, Gurusamy R, Palaniswamy M,
Swaminathan K. Cultivation of Pleurotus spp. on various
agro-residues. Food Chem. 1996; 33:139-144.
20. Royse DJ. Vacuum soaking of wood chip shiitake
Lentinula edodes logs to reduce soak time and stimulate
~ 3171 ~