Introduction To Budgets and Preparing The Master Budget: Coverage of Learning Objectives
Introduction To Budgets and Preparing The Master Budget: Coverage of Learning Objectives
Introduction To Budgets and Preparing The Master Budget: Coverage of Learning Objectives
CRITICAL CASES,
FUNDA- THINKING EXCEL,
MENTAL EXERCISES COLLAB. &
ASSIGNMENT AND INTERNET
LEARNING OBJECTIVE MATERIAL EXERCISES PROBLEMS EXERCISES
LO1: Explain how budgets A1,B1
facilitate planning and
coordination.
LO2: Anticipate possible 25 40
human relations problems
caused by budgets.
LO3: Explain potentially 22 39, 40
dysfunctional incentives in
the budget process.
LO4: Explain the difficulties 23 42 49
of sales forecasting.
LO5: Explain the major A1,B1 24,26 39
features and advantages of a
master budget.
LO6: Follow the principal A1,B1 29 40 43,45
steps in preparing a master
budget.
LO7: Prepare the operating A1,B1 28,29,30,31 40 43,45,46,48
budget and the supporting
schedules.
LO8: Prepare the financial A1,B1 27,29,32,33, 36,37,38 43,44,47,48
budget. 34,35
LO9: Use a spreadsheet to 41,42
develop a budget (Appendix
7).
1. Exhibit I
GREATBUY ELECTRONICS STORE
Budgeted Income Statement
For the Three Months Ending August 31, 20X8
Sales $580,000
Cost of goods sold (.63 × $580,000) 365,400
Gross profit $214,600
Operating expenses:
Salaries, wages, commissions $139,200
Other expenses 17,400
Depreciation 3,000
Rent, taxes and other fixed expenses 27,000 186,600
Income from operations $ 28,000
Interest expense* 1,219
Net income $ 26,781
2. This is an example of the classic short-term, self-liquidating loan. The need for such a
loan often arises because of the seasonal nature of a business. The basic source of cash is
proceeds from sales to customers. In times of peak sales, there is a lag between the sale
and the collection of the cash, yet the payroll and suppliers must be paid in cash right
away. When the cash is collected, it in turn may be used to repay the loan. The amount
of the loan and the timing of the repayment are heavily dependent on the credit terms
that pertain to both the purchasing and selling functions of the business.
2. The cash budget and balance sheet clearly show the benefits of moving to just-in-
time purchasing (though the transition would rarely be accomplished as easily as
this example suggests). However, the company would be no better off if it left
much of its capital tied up in cash -- it has merely substituted one asset for another.
At a minimum, the excess cash should be in an interest bearing account -- the
interest earned or forgone is one of the costs of inventory.
Schedule a: Sales Budget January February March
Total sales (100% on credit) $378,000 $413,000 $273,000
7-3 Strategic planning covers no specific time period, is quite general, and often is not
built around financial statements. Long-range planning usually has a 5- or 10-year horizon
and consists of financial statements without much detail. Budgeting usually has a horizon of
one year or less, and consists of financial statements with much detail.
7-4 Continuous budgets add a month (or quarter) in the future as the month (or quarter)
just ended is dropped. Therefore, the continuous budget provides a continually updated
budget looking twelve months ahead. When the new month (or quarter) is added, the budget
for the remainder of the current year may also be revised. When companies revise the
budgets for the remainder of the current year, they usually compare subsequent results to the
original budget (a fixed target) in addition to comparing them to the latest revised budget.
7-5 If the measures used to reward employees in the performance evaluation system are
not aligned with the goals of the company, the incentives from the evaluation system may
lead employees to take actions that conflict with the interests of the company.
7-6 Lower-level managers bias their forecasts to create budgetary slack or padding.
Upper-level managers adjust for this bias in creating a revised budget. Therefore, lower-
level managers introduce additional bias to compensate for the adjustment that will be made
by upper-level managers, and upper-level managers introduce additional adjustments for the
additional bias. This cycle can quickly destroy the potential benefits of budgets.
7-7 A manager may make short-run decisions to increase profits that are not in the
company’s best long-run interests, such as offering customers excessively favorable credit
terms or cutting discretionary expenditures such as R&D and advertising, trading future sales
for current profits. In the extreme, the manager might choose to falsely report inflated
profits.
7-8 First, by moving this year's sales into next year or moving next year's expenses into
this year, the manager ensures a higher level of reported profit (and probably a higher bonus)
next year. Second, by decreasing this year's income, the manager avoids ratcheting up of
performance expectations in setting the bonus target for the next year.
7-9 Budgeted performance is better than past performance as a basis for judging current
performance because the budget contains no hidden inefficiencies and can be founded on
current rather than past economic conditions.
7-11 No. When budgeting in done correctly, it is an important aid to managers. Managers
need time to plan and coordinate their various activities. Budgeting forces them to take time
from the day-to-day problems and focus on longer-term issues.
7-12 The sales forecast is the starting point for budgeting because all other operating
activities of the company are affected by the volume of sales.
7-13 The sales forecast is influenced by past patterns of sales, estimates made by the sales
force, general economic conditions, competitors' actions, changes in prices, market research
studies, and advertising and sales promotion plans.
7-14 An operating budget is used as a guide for production and sales and it focuses on the
income statement. A financial budget is used to control the receipt and disbursement of
funds and it focuses on the statement of cash receipts and disbursements.
7-15 Operating expenses are costs charged to the income statement in a particular period.
Some operating expenses may be associated with the sales of the period, and others may be
costs of being in business for the period. Cash disbursements for these operating expenses
may fall in a previous period (assets purchased in one period and depreciated over future
periods) or in a future period (wages accrued in a period but paid in the next period), as well
as during the period.
7-16 A cash budget is an attempt to monitor and regulate the flow of cash in optimum
fashion.
7-17 Budgeting will be effective only if it is accepted by those managers who are
responsible for controlling costs. Since their performance will be measured against the
budget, they must be educated in the assumptions underlying the budget and convinced of its
objectivity and relevance.
7-19 No. Financial planning models are mathematical statements of the relationships in
the organization among all the operating and financial activities and of other major internal
and external factors that may affect the financial results of decisions. But financial planning
models are only as good as the assumptions and inputs used to build them. Managers must
understand the models to provide appropriate assumptions and inputs. If managers do not
understand budgeting, using financial planning models can result in GIGO (garbage in,
garbage out).
7-20 Setting up the master budget on a spreadsheet is time-consuming -- the first time.
However, if it is done properly, with maximum flexibility, then the ease of subsequent use
probably will more than offset that initial cost. Ultimately, though, the master budget
system must meet the cost-benefit test. Improved budgeting systems are only worthwhile if
they offer net benefits. Preparing and revising the master budget of a large company just
would not be feasible without the aid of a computer.
7-22 Budgets that are used primarily for limiting spending provide incentives for “game
playing.” Accurate forecasts and estimates give way to strategies designed to avoid budget
cuts or to justify increased budgets. Budgets should have a much larger role in the effective
and efficient management of an organization. A budget should be a decision tool. It helps
managers project the results of their decisions, thereby aiding them in making the right
decisions. It also provides a base for adapting to change. Anything that results in loss of
budget accuracy will limit the decision usefulness of the budget.
7-24 The planning that comes through a good budget process is important to all segments
of an organization. Segments with both revenues and expenses can show a budgeted profit.
Other segments that have only expenses, such as a research and development department,
still have to plan their operations. It is important to predict the resources needed to meet the
segment’s objectives so that required resources can be obtained. Budgeting provides a
formal channel for communication between the segment and top management about what
activities the segment is to undertake.
7-25 A key to employee acceptance of a budget is participation. Budgets created with the
active participation of all affected employees are generally more effective than budgets
imposed on subordinates. If a budget is to help direct future activities, employees must
accept the budget. Acceptance means believing that the budget reflects a desired future path
for the organization. If a manager has been a participant in determining the future path –
that is, helped develop the budget – he or she is more likely to accept it as a desirable
objective.
7-26 (5 min.)
Movie Mastery will be using cash until the beginning of 20X9, at which time cash receipts
will begin to exceed cash disbursements. Therefore, the following amount of venture capital
is needed to carry the firm to the beginning of 20X9:
Initial capital investment in 20X7 $380,000
Cash outflow during 20X7 (12 × $35,000) 420,000
Cash outflow during 20X8 [12 × ($35,000 - $30,000)] 60,000
Total $860,000
7-31 (15-25 min.) This problem is slightly more complex than 7-30. All amounts are in
thousands of Japanese yen.
Collections from:
January sales: $370,000 × 15% $ 55,500
February sales: $420,000 × 15% × 98% 61,740
February sales: $420,000 × 10% 42,000
March sales: $460,000 × 55% × 97% 245,410
Total cash collections $404,650
2. LEIMERSHEIM GMBH
Purchases and Disbursements Budgets
CARLSON COMPANY
Cash Budget
For the Month Ended June 30, 20X4
(in thousands)
*$24,000 = 20% of May sales, 10% of which or half the remainder will be collected
in June. All of April's remaining sales will be collected in June.
1. The Intercontinental’s monthly cash budget is shown on Exhibit 7-38 on the two
following pages.
2. Increase in revenues:
6 months × .05 × 300 rooms × $250 × 30 days × .98 collected $661,500
Increase in costs:
6 months × .05 × 300 rooms × $30 × 30 days 81,000
Increase in profit $580,500
2. Regardless of what methods are selected to achieve cost savings, the activity-
based budget seems to be a better starting point. The traditional budget does not
show how changes in activities might affect costs, whereas the activity-based
budget does.
1 and 2. See Exhibit 7-41A on the following two pages. This spreadsheet is
constructed so that only formulas are entered in the disbursements and operating
income schedules. You can compare the total operating income figures at the bottom
of each spreadsheet to assess the effects of each scenario.
1. See Exhibit 7-42A on the following two pages. The spreadsheet below contains data from
the problem in the top of the spreadsheet space. Computations of operating expenses are
accomplished with formulas that reference the table. Comparing the summary calculations of
operating expenses (labeled TOTAL OPERATING EXPENSE) allows the user to assess the
effects of alternate scenarios.
OPERATING EXPENSES
Components Assembly Packaging Shipping Total
October $1,428,000 $ 385,600 $ 36,800 $ 19,400 $ 1,869,800
November 1,071,000 299,200 29,600 15,800 1,415,600
December 2,499,000 644,800 58,400 30,200 3,232,400
January 1,428,000 385,600 36,800 19,400 1,869,800
February 1,428,000 385,600 36,800 19,400 1,869,800
March 1,071,000 299,200 29,600 15,800 1,415,600
OPERATING EXPENSES
OPERATING EXPENSES
1. HIGHLINE HOSPITAL
Budgeted Cash Receipts
For the Quarter Ending September 30, 20X7
(in thousands)
2. (a) (b)
10% revenue increase 10% revenue decrease
Revenue $22,948 $18,776
Cost of Sales 12,621 10,327
Gross Margin $10,327 $ 8,449
S&A Expense 6,693 6,693
Income before income taxes $ 3,634 $ 1,756
Income tax expense 909 439
Net income $ 2,725 $ 1,317
In part 1, where all costs are variable, net income increases or decreases in proportion to
the change in revenue. In part 2, where S&A costs are fixed, net income increases or
decreases by more than the proportional change in revenue.
3. (a) (b)
Gross Margin Gross Margin
46% 44%
Revenue $20,862 $20,862
Cost of Sales 11,265 11,683
Gross Margin $ 9,597 $ 9,179
S&A Expense 6,693 6,693
Income before income taxes $ 2,904 $ 2,486
Income tax expense 726 622
Net income $ 2,178 $ 1,865
Note how a small percentage change in gross margin translates into a large percentage
change in net income.
1. The first month that cash receipts exceed cash expenditures in January 20X9.
2 & 3. Expenditures before January 20X9 total $1,220,000. Venture capital of only
$860,000 is required because there will be cash receipts of $360,000 in 20X8.
7-49 (30-45 min.) NOTE TO INSTRUCTOR. This solution is based on the 2011 10-
K, which was the most recent set of annual results available on the web site in late 2012
when the book went to press. Be sure to examine the current web site before assigning
this problem, as the information there may have changed.
1. There are 10 brand lines under the corporation shell. They are Carnival Cruise
Lines, Holland America Line, Princess Cruises and Seabourn in North America;
P&O Cruises and Cunard Line in the United Kingdom; AIDA in Germany; Costa
Cruises in Southern Europe; Ibero cruceros in Spain; and P&O Cruises in
Australia.
Each of the lines focuses on a different part of the world or offers a different class
of cruise. Different names allow for the association or branding of a particular
line with a particular type of cruise. For instance, Cunard focuses on the
traditional ocean liner experience while Carnival focuses on more of a festive
atmosphere on board ship – that is, fun times. The corporation also operates
several tour companies.
2. Total revenues in fiscal 2011 were $15.793 billion. The occupancy percentage
was 106.2%, which is given in the Management’s Discussion and Analysis
section of the report. How can one explain occupancy greater than 100%? For
Carnival, it means that capacity is defined as two persons per room, yet many
rooms have capacity of three or more persons, so when more than two persons
occupy a room capacity utilization is greater than 100%.
4. The prices for cruises of the same length to the same location are not all the same.
They differ according to when the cruise dates are – high season or low season –
and also according to the level of capacity utilization that the particular cruise has
achieved. The firm’s goal is to have the maximum capacity utilization possible
for each cruise. If demand is high for a particular cruise, then the firm will be
able to command a higher price and still fill the cabins. Since much of the cost of
the cruise is likely to be fixed in nature, the firm will incur the cost even if they
don’t fill the cabins. Thus, a price that covers variable cost and contributes to
fixed costs will be preferred to an empty cabin. Destinations or dates that are less
popular are cheaper because once the company schedules and commits to a cruise,
it is in its best interests to fill as many cabins as possible as long as the price is
above the variable costs. Last-minute deals can be especially cheap if a particular
cruise is likely to have excess capacity.