Project Proposal - Fiscal Transparency
Project Proposal - Fiscal Transparency
SUMMARY PAGE
Applicant organization CLADHO (Collectif des Ligues et Associations de
Défense des Droits de l’Homme au Rwanda)
3060 Kigali /Rwanda, www.cladho.org.rw
Contact person (applicant name) Me Emmanuel SAFARI, Executive Secretary of
CLADHO
Cell: (+250)788488022
Email: [email protected]
[email protected]
Date of submission (proposal 28/05/2018
date)
Project title Strengthening the capacity of Civil Society
Organizations and Rwandan Citizens to actively engage
in Government budget process and advocate for
improved fiscal transparency
Geographical coverage of the Gisagara- Ruhango, Muhanga, Rusizi - Rutsiro and
project Rubavu districts
Duration of the project (proposed Two (2) years starting from 1st September,2018 to 30
dates) August,2020
Project budget US$ 248,079.61
Beneficiaries Civil Society Organizations, Community Based
Organizations, Joint Action Development Forums,
Media and Citizens
Purpose of the project The overall objective or goal of this project is to
strengthen and engage CSOs to advocate for more civic
space in budget preparation process and improved fiscal
transparency, engage citizens in budget preparation
process and provide an enabling environment to become
more effective in influencing national public policy
formulation and implementation including budget
preparation and general budget monitoring as a result,
GoR increases its engagement with them, and is better
prepared to receive their inputs and avail detailed
budget information for public consideration.
1
2. Proposal summary
The action which is strongly anchored locally responds to several key priorities of the Rwandan
Vision 2020, National Strategy for Transformation One (NST1) and to the US Embassy and
builds on the good results and lessons learnt from CLADHO’s interventions in government
planning and budget preparation process since 2008. It indeed addresses several challenges
faced by Civil Society Organization (CSOs), Community Based Organizations (CBOs), Media
and Citizen which now have an improved access to accountability fora in the country but are still
struggling to actively participate in planning and budget preparation process. This project will
strengthen the capacity of Civil Society Organizations, Media, Community Based
Organizations and Joint Action Development Forums in technical budgetary knowledge
(planning and budget preparation process), communication and advocacy skills, to
enthusiastically engage in influencing budget process, monitoring its execution and holding
government accountable. This will help to better link the national budget to the population's
priorities, needs and human rights through informed analysis and contributions to budget
proposals, monitoring and tracking public revenues and expenditures, and supporting
citizens' budget literacy. CSO active engagement will ensure a more needs-responsive and
inclusive policy-making fostering a stronger governance and improving public authorities’
accountability and fiscal transparency. This will help to mobilize, bring together and work
with civil society stakeholders from the sector level, community level, and district level to
the national level in order to institutionalize budget preparation process that embraces public
accountability, effectiveness and gender responsiveness. An improved collaborative approach
between the CSOs and the media, will contribute to an enhanced domestic accountability at
local and national levels as it will guarantee a better timely accessibility to information both in
terms of content and visibility. Strengthening community participation in budget preparation
and tracking processes will help to ensure that government guarantees a full engagement of
citizens in budget process and fiscal transparency. Citizens in the following 6 districts will
closely benefit from the project operations; these are Gisagara, Ruhango, Muhanga, Rusizi,
Rutsiro and Rubavu districts and at national level with the CSOs and Media.
CLADHO is a strong observatory member of the African Union human rights commission. It is one of the
potential member organizations of the Rwanda Civil Society Platform (RCSP) and is also affiliated to
F.I.D.H (Federation International des Droits de l’Homme) and to U.I.D.H (Union InterAfricaine des
Droits de l’Homme).
CLADHO in an attempt to promote human rights and citizens participation in matters of national
importance, works and cooperates cordially with all the Civil Society Organizations including her 12
umbrella organizations, members of Rwanda Civil Society Platform and other CSOs in the country. It also
has close working relations with Faith Based Organizations, Community Based Organizations, and Media
associations. These networks and partnerships have fast-tracked immensely implementation of all projects
that CLADHO implemented and others that is currently implementing.
CLADHO is managed by the General assembly comprised of all members of the supreme organ, board of
directors, audit committee and in terms of daily management; CLADHO has the Executive secretariat lead
by the Executive Secretary assisted by qualified staff in different fields.
2
3.2. CLADHO’s key achievements since its inception in 1993 in the fields of social economic
rights and citizen participation in planning and budget preparation process.
CLADHO remains the pioneer of social economic and budget advocacy work in Rwanda and has
championed the work of monitoring the country’s compliancy with international instruments such as
instrument of the United Nations that Rwanda ratified, instruments of the African union the country signed
and other regional framework instruments.
CLADHO initiated various national legal reforms, such as amendment of the national constitution,
abolition of death penalties, amendment of provisions in the law on punishment and preventing gender-
based violence, amendment of the law regulating non-governmental organizations, among others.
CLADHO has motivated writing of position papers on the most cross-cutting issues such as civil society
position paper on law related to sex workers, civil society position paper on expropriation law, position
paper on detention conditions, and position paper on labor mobility in EAC member states among others.
CLADHO has experience in government policies tracking and monitoring, initiated studies and surveys on
the national budget process, and contributed to the historical background of the Rwandan scoring rate on
the International Budget Partnership (IBP)
Achievements in terms of strengthening Civil Society Organizations and citizen participation in planning
and budget preparation process, CLADHO is the only Civil Society Organization in Rwanda that has a
Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with the Rwandan Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning to
support the Ministry in improving budget transparency and accountability through citizen participation in
the budget cycle. Through this MoU, CLADHO analyses policy documents introduced by the Government
of Rwanda through the Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning and submits a position paper for
consideration to the Ministry of Finance, Parliament and to other concerned Government agencies. The
Government through the Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning now approves initiatives from the
Civil Society Organizations under the lead of CLADHO to contribute effectively to the preparation of the
Budget Framework Paper (BFP). CLADHO’s budget analysis also contributes to the preparation of the
draft finance law that is presented to the Parliamentary budget commission for consideration during
budget consultations and on the other hand, it provides a picture to the Parliamentarians of what the
citizens want to be considered but is missing in the presented BFP. During parliamentary budget hearings,
CLADHO on behalf of all Civil Society Organizations in Rwanda is invited to present to the
parliamentarians and other invited Ministries its analysis on Budget Framework Paper. Issues raised in the
analysis of the Budget Framework Paper are submitted to MINECOFIN and to the Parliament (budget
committee) for consideration in the national budget before its approval by the Parliament.
CLADHO analyzed the National Strategy for Transformation One (NST1) and provided inputs and
advocated for their consideration and 90% of them were addressed by the Ministry of Finance and
Economic Planning in the revised NST1 document. CLADHO also organizes and conducts pre-budget
hearings where it engages citizens with their leaders to agree on next year’s priorities for resource
allocation. These pre-budget hearings are organized and conducted by CLADHO at the district level
before issuance of the ceilings by the Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning. CLADHO also
participates in the preparation and dissemination of Citizens Guide to Budget in all districts of Rwanda.
Since 2016, under the financial support of European Union, CLADHO is implementing a 3 years project
called “strengthening CSOs capacity in promoting sustainable agriculture policies and citizen
participatory budgeting in Rwanda” with the aim of supporting and enhancing engagement of CSOs in
agriculture policy shaping, implementation and public accountability towards sustainable food security in
Rwanda. CLADHO has a tangible experience in project management of more than 24 years. Since 1993,
CLADHO has and is still working in the fields of human rights, focusing so much on economic, social and
governance rights which caused partnerships with multilateral and bilateral organizations such as the
3
World Bank, European Union, DFID, UNDP, SIDA, OXFAM, ActionAid, Christian Aid, GIZ,
KinderNotHilfe ,NPA, PLAN INTERNATIONAL Rwanda, UNWOMEN, Save the Children and the
USAID. The past and current projects under CLADHO’s implementation helped different stakeholders
such as academics, government, CSOs among others to design and implement informed policies for the
betterment of the community a current case in point is the National Strategy for Transformation One
(NST1).
4. Problem statement
Transparency and accountability across all institutions and individuals is a key ingredient to
Transformational Governance Pillar as enshrined in the National Strategy for Transformation One (NST1)
and vision 2050 where increased citizen participation, engagement and partnerships in development are
cemented. They emphasize citizen participation as a way of ensuring ownership and feedback for
efficiency and sustainability. It also focuses on increased citizen participation, strengthening partnerships
between Government institutions, private sector, citizens, Civil Society Organizations (CSOs) and Faith
Based Organizations (FBOs) to fast track national development and people centered prosperity as a way of
ensuring ownership and feedback for efficiency and sustainability. However, citizens do to a small extent
participate in planning and budget preparation processes at 7%, 12% and 29% as respectively published in
RGB’s Citizen Report Card of 2015, 2016 and 2017. Citizen engagement in the budget preparation
process is low. They do not access draft budget information before its final approval by parliament.
Besides this, approved budget information is also not made available to all citizens at the glass root level.
Even for the few ones who have managed to participate, it becomes difficult for them to scrutinize
whether what they proposed for inclusion in the national budget was considered or not and if not why it
was excluded. This unfortunately, makes the budget unable to address comprehensively citizens’ specific
needs and challenges since no timely feedback is made available before its final approval and ultimately
the budget ends up becoming non-citizen centered. Citizens and CSOs members have little or no
information about government budget process and this becomes an impediment to PFM compliance thus
making, monitoring budget execution and accountability cumbersome.
Citizen participation in budget preparation process is necessary in fast tracking the implementation of
sector strategies plans (SSPs) and district development strategies (DDS).
There is also a visible need to strengthen the capacity of CSOs, Community Based Organizations, and
Faith Based Organizations to promote citizen participation in budget process, its transparency, hold their
leaders accountable, promote citizen engagement in prioritization and allocation of resources, budget
tracking, and above all improve fiscal transparency. Therefore, Civil Society Organizations need to be
fully equipped with information pertaining to budget process so that they can be better positioned to
advocate for citizen engagement in government budget process and advocate for improved fiscal
transparency.
There is an urgent need to address these bottlenecks to hasten citizen engagement in government budget
process. This necessitates capacitating and skilling CSOs’ members in budget preparation cycle to enable
them raise timely public awareness on government budget process and skillfully engage citizens, their
councillors and leaders in budget preparation process and above all, help to ameliorate fiscal transparency
through availability of timely reliable, adequate budget proposals and availability of approved government
4
budget information for public consumption on time. From the above highlighted facts, this project is
highly needed.
5. Geographical coverage
This project will cover six (6) districts namely; Gisagara, Ruhango, Muhanga, Rusizi, Rutsiro and
Rubavu. These districts are lagging behind in terms of citizens’ participation in planning and budgeting
according to the 2017 Rwanda Governance Board’s Citizen Report Card. Citizens in these districts need to
be supported through a number of identified project initiatives so to have their needed priorities heard and
considered by the districts in the national budget. In terms of Engaging CSOs and Government through
advocacy, the project will operate at National level.
7. Expected results/impacts
6.1. Result 1 - CSOs and, CBOs understand the whole process of budget formulation and general budget
monitoring framework, their roles in engaging citizen in budget cycle and budget related technical
capacities in supporting long term engagement with public authorities are strengthened.
Atleast 200 people from CSOs and CBOs will be trained on budget process, ELBAG
(Economic Literacy & Budget Accountability for Governance), HRBA (Human Rights Based
Approach), Gender Budget Statement, budget monitoring skills/methods and expenditures tracking
using Public Expenditures Tracking Survey (PETs);
At least 200 people from CSOs and CBOs will be benefit from awareness workshops on national
planning and budget process and country development agenda.
1 public dialogue on the role of CSOs and Citizen in budget process is organized.
Live radio and TV programs using community and national radio stations are organized
Public awareness campaign and community dialogues on sources of own revenues, spending and
public investment will be organized in all districts of interventions using community dialogues.
Organization of consultative meetings between local authorities and citizen to inform budget
formulation.
5
Produce and disseminate district citizens guides to budget.
6.2. Results 2: JADF members are empowered in the budget cycle and in the general budget monitoring.
6.3. Result 3- CSOs and media capacity to increase and improve budget information and knowledge
visibility and accessibility to the public, local, national and regional stakeholders and raise public
awareness on budget process and fiscal transparency.
Thus result 3 will empower the activities of CSOs and media organizations’ actions by holding
accountable the public authorities, and enhancing transparency around budget planning and fiscal
transparency. Also the capacity of the CSOs and media houses to improve visibility and accessibility to
budget information and knowledge will be strengthened.
The above action will support CSOs to disseminate the results of their analysis on national budget
spending and to share these findings at a national level during dialogues. This will require improved
capacity to collect stories of change, to engage the media, to report on budget related information, to
simplify this information in order to reach a wider public, and to improve their communication on their
websites and social media. Sharing learning from their analysis will thus contribute to raising awareness
among the Rwandan population on national budget and fiscal transparency.
Journalists of national media will be sensitized and trained on budget process and finance laws so that they
can better record the different challenges and evolutions in that area. Bringing matters related to national
budget and spending, fiscal transparency in national media programs will advance the national debate on
improving public participatory mechanisms in budget planning, implementation and monitoring.
7. Project Activities
7.1. Preparatory Activities:
7.1.1. Internal start-up workshop.
A start-up workshop will be attended by CLADHO staff specifically those involved in the project with the
aim of strengthening the capacity of the staff involved in the project covering partnership management,
compliance with Donor (US Embassy) rules and regulations, Monitoring and Evaluation and
Communication.
Public Hearings:
A public hearing is a tool where people discuss their development needs in a public forum which is
presided over by an independent bench. Usually local officials are also present and are asked to respond to
the queries from the community. A report of the outcomes with plans for future action is prepared and
shared with the concerned ministry and parliament and a follow-up for report consideration is done.
Logic model
O
U Short term Long term
Activities Outputs
T
C
O
Consistent, complete and
Budget information is M
transparent budget
PETS available Einformation
s
Engagement of CSOs,
media and accelerate Causes timely feedback,
Public awareness
citizen participation in ownership, accountability
on government
budget preparation and sustainability of the
budget process
process project impacts.
9
9. Proposed project schedule, Location of planned activities areas and Timeline
This project is proposed to be implemented in 24 months from September 2018 to August 2020.
NO ACTIVITY LOCATION TIMELINE/QUARTER
YEAR 1 YEAR 2
(September,2018- (September,2019-
September,2019) August,2020)
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
1 Preparatory activities
2. Activities in Result 1.
2.2 Training of CSOs and CBOs on Economic Literacy Budget Accountability for Governance
(ELBAG) on Human Rights Based Approaches (HRBA)
2.3 Training of CSOs and CBOs on budget making process, Gender Budget Statement and on Public
Expenditure Tracking Survey (PETs)
2.4 Training of CSOs and CBOs on advocacy for budget issues and fiscal transparency
2.7 Support CSOs and CBOs to hold a consultation session with parliamentarians and conduct a
public dialogue on budget issues
2.8 Conduct public awareness campaign and community dialogues on sources of own revenues
2.10 Support Citizen to conduct community score card on citizen participation in planning and budget
10
process.
3.Activities in Result 2
3.2 Training of local and opinion leaders on participatory planning, budget preparation process,
monitoring and evaluation of priority implementation.
4.Activities in Result 3
4.1 Sensitization and training of media houses on budget preparation and budget monitoring
4.5 Support districts and CSOs to strengthen their websites and social media skills
11
10. Key personnel
The following are the key personnel from CLADHO who will contribute in implementing this
project
No Names Title in Qualifications Tasks within the Time to
CLADHO project be spent
Apart from the above mentioned staff who will contribute in project implementation, full time
project officer and field officers at the district level will be recruited.
CLADHO will be responsible for the overall technical and financial monitoring of project interventions and
their follow-up. The project team will implement and monitor daily activities, including project roll out,
prepare and submit monthly and quarterly reports and also assess qualitative changes that are taking place
in communities, authorities and CSOs. CLADHO’s Communication Officer will support the project’s
documentation.
Participatory review and reflection processes (PRRP) will be conducted every 12 months, with strategic
partners, project beneficiaries, CSOs/CBOs, local and national government representatives (as appropriate).
The PRRP involves a review and reflection on completed activities and agree on the way forward
to remedy situations, strengthen what has been achieved and plan for the next period.
Periodical joint field visits will be organized and conducted by CLADHO in partnership with
the project sponsors to evaluate the project progress in the districts of interventions.
14
Page 15 of 15