Power Loss Imminent (PLI) Technology

Introduction
In recent years, there have been major shifts in weather patterns. Inclement
extremes have become the norm with heavy snow storms, hurricanes, flash
flooding, and ominous thunder and lightning storms, all of which can interrupt
electrical power. Additionally, our nation’s power grid and substations are at risk
of terrorist attacks seeking to cause havoc and disruption. Whether an act of
nature or of evil, our daily lives and the critical data we rely on to run
governments, corporations, banks, local businesses, schools, and households are
impacted by power loss events. It’s imperative to protect critical data, and to
protect the integrity of the data at risk due to power loss events.
Data centers and their administrators are responsible
for the thousands of storage drives at risk in a power
loss event, and whether the last operation prior to the
power outage was completed. One of the newest
technologies embedded in a Solid-State Storage device
is Power Loss Imminent (PLI) technology. PLI
technology significantly reduces the possibility of losing
data during a power loss event. The PLI technology feature in a Solid-State Drive
(SSD) continuously prepares for unexpected power loss, thereby protecting the
data from corruption and destruction.

The Storage Power Loss Problem

During a clean shutdown, most host systems initiate the ATA “STANDBY
IMMEDIATE” command to the SSD, signaling it to prepare for shutdown. In preparing for shutdown, the SSD
saves any data in transition or in flight (in temporary buffers) to the non-volatile NAND Flash media.
However, during an unsafe or unexpected loss of power, the SSD abruptly loses power before the host system
can initiate the ATA “STANDBY IMMEDIATE” command, or mid-way through the command. An unexpected
loss of power can mean that the data in the SSD controller’s temporary buffers will not be saved to the non-
volatile NAND Flash media, which often results in data corruption or loss due to incomplete or partial writes.

PLI Technology Details

Not all SSDs contain PLI technology. SSDs with PLI technology contain energy storing
capacitors. The energy storing capacitors provide enough energy (power) to complete
any commands in progress and to make sure that any data in the temporary buffers is
committed to the non-volatile NAND Flash media. These capacitors act as backup
batteries for the drive.
Figure 1 highlights (yellow box) a PLI capacitor in an SSD. The SSD supply voltage
detector circuit constantly monitors the drive’s supply voltage. If voltage falls
below a predefined level, indicating a power loss event is imminent, the SSD Figure 1: 1 of 2 PLI Capacitors
will use the backup energy in the capacitors to write any data in temporary shown from Intel® SSD DC 3700
buffers to the NAND Flash media. After power is restored, the PLI capacitors Series Product
will be charged again, ready for a future power loss event.

330275-001US Technology Brief 1

 Power Loss Imminent (PLI) Technology
Figure 2 illustrates the switching sequence that engages the PLI capacitors to the SSD controller during a
power loss event. As shown, switch 1 (SW1) is closed, connecting the capacitor energy to the SSD ASIC
Controller, and switch 2 (SW2) is opened, disengaging the host power supply source. The energy stored in the
PLI capacitors will be used to finish transferring any data in the buffer to the non-volatile NAND Flash media.
When power is restored the PLI capacitors will be charged up again and ready for a future power loss event.

(SW1)

(SW2)

Figure 2: PLI Capacitor Engagement Sequence During Power Loss Event

Architecting and Implementing PLI Technology Solution into

a Solid-State Drive
Designing PLI technology into an SSD is quite involved. The design process requires intricate architectural
integration into the whole SSD’s operation, from enumeration to a proper shut down. A critical PLI feature is
the ability to anticipate needs of the system administrators, and to monitor the health, performance and
usage count of the PLI circuitry. PLI architecture incorporates the SMART command and functionality
necessary to periodically verify the PLI circuitry continues to function properly over the life of the SSD.
Additionally, the PLI capacitor chemistry choice needs to be carefully selected for reliability over the lifetime
of the product. This capacitor choice is key and, depending on the capacitor type used, will dictate supporting
circuits and firmware which provide storage robustness through power loss events.

PLI Technology Architecture

Monitoring SSD health and reliability, meeting
and anticipating system administrator needs,
all while balancing the financial and
performance cost of restoring an entire data
center after a power loss event, provides
additional challenges in defining a good
architecture. The architecture of the Intel® SSD
DC S3700 Series and S3500 Series has taken
these needs into account. Figure 3 shows an
operational architectural diagram depicting the
key PLI components, the SSD voltage detector,
Figure 3: Intel® Solid-State Drive PLI Architecture
the charge storing capacitor bank, and the
SMART (Self-Monitoring Analysis and Monitoring Technology) attribute extraction module.
The SSD voltage detector circuit constantly monitors the drive’s supply voltage. If the voltage falls below a
predefined level, indicating a power loss event is imminent, the SSD will use the backup energy supply from
the capacitor bank to write any data in temporary buffers to the NAND Flash media. After the power is
restored, the PLI capacitors will be charged up again and ready for a future power loss event. The SMART
attribute extraction module provides system administrators with specific health information and status of the
PLI capacitors, which is the heart of the PLI technology. Since the Intel® SSD DC S3700 Series and S3500
Series support SMART attributes and have specific PLI SMART attributes, the system administrator can
retrieve the drive’s PLI SMART attribute reported values.

330275-001US Technology Brief 2

 Power Loss Imminent (PLI) Technology
Charge (Energy) Storing Capacitors for PLI
The selection of PLI energy storing
capacitors is a very critical component
choice. Accurate selection of components
is crucial to the PLI technology and the
architectural implementation essentially
revolves around this choice. There are
many critical decision points and trade-
offs regarding this selection including cost,
capacitance offerings, energy storing
efficiency, form factor, operating
temperature range, capacitor use life, and
its endurance.
Examining the capacitor family tree in
Figure 4, there are a variety of choices for
each solution and application. For the
Intel® SSD DC S3700 Series and S3500
Series, Aluminum Electrolytic (Wet) Figure 4: Fixed Capacitor Technology Tree
capacitors were chosen for their specific
attributes:
 Wide Capacitive Size Offerings: 0.1 to 68,000 µF
 Suitable form factor
 Economical cost
 Rated Voltage Range of 6.3 Volts to 450 Volts
 Good Endurance: Up to 5 years at 80 ˚C
 Wide Operating Temperature Range: -40 to 105 ˚C

The family of electrostatic capacitors was not considered because of their DC bias characteristic phenomenon
wherein the effective electrostatic capacitance decreases when a DC voltage is applied. With the need for PLI
capacitors to constantly be ready to discharge, this capacitance degrade is not acceptable nor is the resulting
varied energy source caused by the degrading capacitance. The other good electrolytic capacitors, Tantalum
and Niobium, were not chosen because they are more costly, as shown in Table 1, below.
Table 1: Sample Fixed Capacitor Pricing

Rated Price#
Capacitor Type Supplier Part Number Capacitance
Voltage (Quantity of 100)
Electrolytic Aluminum Wet Nichion UKL1V101KPDANA 100 µF 35 V $0.225
Electrolytic Tantalum Wet Vishay 138D107X9035F2 100 µF 35 V $0.401
Niobium Oxide AVX NOJD1D7M010RWB 100 µF 10 V $1.27

330275-001US Technology Brief 3

 Power Loss Imminent (PLI) Technology

SMART (Self-Monitoring Analysis, and Reporting Technology)

Integrating SMART technology into the PLI architecture is essential. Providing the ability for system
administrators to periodically check the health of the SSD and the health of the PLI technology, particularly
after a power loss event, is crucial.
Intel® SSD DC S3700 Series and S3500 Series have SMART technology incorporated into their PLI
architecture. The Intel SSD DC S3700 Series and S3500 Series provide two convenient SMART attributes for
the system administrators with key data on power loss events as well as the SSD PLI circuitry health. The
SMART power loss and PLI attributes are summarized in the table below.
Table 2: Intel SSD DC S3700 Series and S3500 Series PLI SMART Attribute Descriptions

SMART ID SMART Attribute

Unexpected Power Loss

Raw value reports number of unclean shutdowns cumulative over the life of the SSD. An
AEh unclean shutdown is the removal of the SSD’s power without the host issuing a “STANDBY
IMMEDIATE” as the last command (regardless of PLI activity using capacitor power). The
normalized value, which is a percentage value, always is a 100.
Power Loss Protection Failure
Last test result of PLI (Provides 3 Health Check Report Out Values)
1. “Microseconds to Discharge Capacitors” (Bytes 0-1): The SSD provides a self-test
where the backup energy storing PLI capacitors are partially discharged to make
sure they are able to release and sustain their energy as designed; to write any
in flight, committed data in the SSD controller storage buffers to NAND Flash
memory. In the case of the Intel® SSD S3700 Series and S3500 Series, it should meet
its minimum 25 µS.
2. “Minutes since last test saturates at max value” (Bytes 2-3): SSD also keeps track in
minutes since the last PLI capacitor test was done by the SSD. So if the system
AFh administrator wanted to know when the last test was done, that value, in minutes
will be reported up to the maximum recording time of 2 bytes of data (1111,1111,
1111,1111) recording bits, in minutes, or 65,535 minutes or 2,730 days.
3. Lifetime number of tests, not incremented on power cycle, saturates at max value.
(Normalized value: set to a “1” on test failure or a “11” if the capacitor has been
tested in an excessive temperature condition, otherwise 100 (Bytes 4-5):
a) Cumulatively tracks the number PLI test, not counting power on cycling of the
drive.
b) Reports a “1” if there is a PLI test failure that signals some more investigative or
diagnostic work is required.
c) Reports a “11” if the PLI capacitor was done in an excessive temperature,
beyond SSD specified operating temperatures in the product specification.

330275-001US Technology Brief 4

 Power Loss Imminent (PLI) Technology

The red arrows in Figure 5 point to examples of reading the SMART attributes through the Intel® SSD
Toolbox. The report from the Intel SSD Toolbox clearly show power loss, “AEh”, result of 8, indicating that 8
unclean shutdown have occurred since the drive was put into service. Additionally, the SSD Toolbox shows
the PLI Loss Protection Failure, “AFh”; the last PLI capacitor discharge test result was 678 which exceeds the
minimum 25 µS specification; the last PLI test was done 1 minute ago; and the number of tests done was 1. To
the system administrator, this is valuable statistical data to determine if any action is needed. As an added
capability, the Intel® SSD DC S3700 Series and DC S3500 Series also support the SMART Command Transport
(SCT). The SCT allows the administrator to issue commands with which they can manually invoke a new
capacitor test, or set the capacitor test intervals as needed.

Figure 5: Intel® SSD Toolbox Reporting Sample PLI SMART Attributes on the Intel® SSD DC S3500 Series

The SMART attribute data report from the Intel SSD Toolbox provides power loss event statistics and the PLI
technology health log data, which is very useful to the system administrator. With the normalized values from
AF SMART Attribute, the system administrator can take necessary actions to replace the drive before data is
compromised by a power loss.

330275-001US Technology Brief 5

 Power Loss Imminent (PLI) Technology
Validating Solid-State Drives with PLI
Validating the PLI technology in an SSD involves
verifying that the PLI circuitry and its switch timing
are working properly; meaning always ready to
supply the energy required to complete the write of
the SSD controller’s temporary buffer data into the
NAND Flash in the SSD. Additional power loss
validation cases include some rare but plausible
scenarios, such as a power loss event during the
drive’s firmware update, or a secure erase that will
not brick (kill) the drive. One of the key validation
deliverables of any PLI-enabled SSD is that the drive
is stable upon power up, enumerates after 15
seconds, and any commands acknowledged as
complete encountered no data loss.

Figure 6 : PLI Validation Process Flow

Performing data integrity checks is absolutely essential but challenging because of the many scenarios of in-
flight data. The two power loss write scenarios of typical concern are the shorn writes of unaligned data and
unserialized writes. Intel takes these power loss scenarios into consideration when validating the Intel® SSD
DC S3700 Series and DC S3500 Series of products.

Power Loss Scenario of Shorn Writes with Unaligned Data

When attempting to complete a file or data write, depending on which operating system was used to deploy
the Solid-State Drive, the associated file system may not align its data to certain transfer size(s). Misalignment
could cause data fragmentation during transfer across the SATA bus to the SSD. In this fragmented state, the
data is unaligned, so if a shorn write were to occur during this stream of data, a data integrity transfer failure
could possibly happen. The best way to mitigate and minimize this fragmented state of data transfers is to use
an operating system such as the newer Windows* server operating system, which will lay down the file
system aligned to 4KB. For users of Linux* OS, there are commands to confirm 4KB alignment.
Validation flows can include the shorn writes with both aligned and unaligned data and compare the success
rates. Intel utilizes its own software tool to analyze and track the stream of data transmitted across the SATA
bus so when power is removed (by unplugging the drive) during the test, Intel SSDs can record, then verify
that upon drive re-insertion, all the right LBA’s of data were indeed written.

Power Loss Scenario of Unserialized Writes

Unserialized writes occur in an SSD when the SSD writes cached data in order to optimize write throughput
and efficiency. When unserialized writes caching occurs, either at the drive or file system level, this data is
vulnerable to being lost, depending on where it is temporarily stored. So, how susceptible are SSDs to
unserialized writes during a power loss event? Is it possible to determine if a PLI-enabled SSD is able to solve
this particular scenario? Unserialized write failures are difficult to validate because file systems may reorder
write sequences. This makes it difficult to validate and predict susceptibilities of unserialized writes.
Regardless, because Intel SSDs do not consolidate writes, therefore unserialized writes will not occur.

330275-001US Technology Brief 6

 Power Loss Imminent (PLI) Technology
What Do PLI-Enabled SSDs Do for Me?
PLI technology significantly improves data integrity during power loss events whether from acts of nature,
careless mistakes, or even inadvertent hot removal of the SSD storage device. Improved data integrity can
help speed the data center recovery after a power loss event with fewer data path checks and validation.
Bringing the data center back online as fast as possible will minimize users’ delayed access to their data,
media, or web materials.

Do I Need PLI in My Storage Device Platforms?

PLI technology offers many advantages by adding higher levels of integrity to data storage environments.
Before deciding, it is critical to evaluate the geographical location and its susceptibility to power outages. In
addition, evaluate the robustness of the data center regarding power outage risks and mitigating the loss of
critical data. Another critical factor in deciding if PLI is the right data center choice is evaluating the workload.
If it is more write than read intensive, what is the mix? Is the nature of the data being read or written more
random or sequential? If it data is long sequential writes, how long are they? What file system is deployed and
does it coalesce the writes? Obviously there is a lot to analyze and consider, including whether the cost of
time to rebuild backup data is less than the cost of buying a drive with PLI technology. Down time is lost time,
and will impact the total cost of ownership of the entire data center.

Featured Intel® SSD Products with PLI Technology

The Intel® SSD DC S3700 Series and S3500 Series with SATA 3.0 interface contain enabled PLI Technology
hardware and the firmware to manage the SSD through the power loss event.

#References:

Sample Pricing: As of February 28, 2014

Nichion Electrolytic Aluminum Wet:
http://www.mouser.com/ProductDetail/Nichicon/UKL1V101KPDANA/?qs=d7wrpMys%2fBuKyOHCoT5fmw%3d%3d

Vishay Tantalum Wet:

http://www.mouser.com/ProductDetail/Vishay/138D107X9035F2/?qs=pEtYqTnH3INJqCnQ3SzcqQ%3d%3d

AVX Niobium Oxide:

http://www.mouser.com/Passive-Components/Capacitors/Niobium-Oxide-Capacitors/_/N-5g8e?P=1z0wrkmZ1z0x8hf

330275-001US Technology Brief 7

 Power Loss Imminent (PLI) Technology

INFORMATION IN THIS DOCUMENT IS PROVIDED IN CONNECTION WITH INTEL PRODUCTS. NO LICENSE, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, BY ESTOPPEL OR
OTHERWISE, TO ANY INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS IS GRANTED BY THIS DOCUMENT. EXCEPT AS PROVIDED IN INTEL'S TERMS AND CONDITIONS
OF SALE FOR SUCH PRODUCTS, INTEL ASSUMES NO LIABILITY WHATSOEVER AND INTEL DISCLAIMS ANY EXPRESS OR IMPLIED WARRANTY, RELATING
TO SALE AND/OR USE OF INTEL PRODUCTS INCLUDING LIABILITY OR WARRANTIES RELATING TO FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE,
MERCHANTABILITY, OR INFRINGEMENT OF ANY PATENT, COPYRIGHT OR OTHER INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHT.

A "Mission Critical Application" is any application in which failure of the Intel Product could result, directly or indirectly, in personal injury or death.
SHOULD YOU PURCHASE OR USE INTEL'S PRODUCTS FOR ANY SUCH MISSION CRITICAL APPLICATION, YOU SHALL INDEMNIFY AND HOLD INTEL AND ITS
SUBSIDIARIES, SUBCONTRACTORS AND AFFILIATES, AND THE DIRECTORS, OFFICERS, AND EMPLOYEES OF EACH, HARMLESS AGAINST ALL CLAIMS
COSTS, DAMAGES, AND EXPENSES AND REASONABLE ATTORNEYS' FEES ARISING OUT OF, DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY, ANY CLAIM OF PRODUCT
LIABILITY, PERSONAL INJURY, OR DEATH ARISING IN ANY WAY OUT OF SUCH MISSION CRITICAL APPLICATION, WHETHER OR NOT INTEL OR ITS
SUBCONTRACTOR WAS NEGLIGENT IN THE DESIGN, MANUFACTURE, OR WARNING OF THE INTEL PRODUCT OR ANY OF ITS PARTS.

Intel may make changes to specifications and product descriptions at any time, without notice. Designers must not rely on the absence or characteristics of
any features or instructions marked "reserved" or "undefined". Intel reserves these for future definition and shall have no responsibility whatsoever for
conflicts or incompatibilities arising from future changes to them. The information here is subject to change without notice. Do not finalize a design with this
information.

The products described in this document may contain design defects or errors known as errata which may cause the product to deviate from published
specifications. Current characterized errata are available on request.

Contact your local Intel sales office or your distributor to obtain the latest specifications and before placing your product order.

Copies of documents which have an order number and are referenced in this document, or other Intel literature, may be obtained by calling 1-800-548-4725,
or go to: http://www.intel.com/design/literature.htm

Intel and the Intel logo are trademarks of Intel Corporation in the U.S. and/or other countries.

*Other names and brands may be claimed as the property of others.

Copyright © 2014 Intel Corporation. All rights reserved.

330275-001US Technology Brief 8